Geopolitical Rumble in the East | Exploring India's Stand Against China's Economic Empire!"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Join Dr. David Oualaalou, an international geopolitical consultant, in a riveting discussion with Pravin Sawhney, Editor of Force Magazine, as they delve deep into India's solitary stand against China's economic empire. The video explores India's decision to turn down 5G Huawei, the importance of China in global supply chains, and the challenges of managing alliances with Quad, BRICS, and SCO. With insights into the evolving geopolitical landscape, India's military affairs, and trade relations with other countries, this thought-provoking episode offers a comprehensive analysis of India's strategic decisions and its economic outlook amidst China's dominance. Don't miss this insightful exploration of East Asia's dynamic geopolitical dynamics!
Just by looking at how India clamped down and/or suppressed Chinese companies, like Huawei, Tikrok, Alibaba, Wechat, MG Motor, Xiaomi, Vivo, Oppo.....and more recently BYD, we know India has a very very strong sino-phobia. It is a regret that India takes the side of the West, especially the US, in their efforts to counter and contain China and misses the opportunities that China may offer.
If you want india china good relationship then ask china to maintain peace sanctity & pre April 2020 situation in the border
@@vinodkaka5225 It takes two hands to clap. India should shoulder part of the responsibility for the conflict. The Chinese companies are private entities, but the Indian government is seemingly venting its anger on them. Many also have the perception that the Indian government is just using the border conflict as a pretext to seize the assets of the Chinese companies. This perception is rife among Chinese investors now. They have learnt a nasty lesson and are turning away from India, and venturing into Southeast Asia and Latin America instead. Who stands to lose?
Moreover, the bureaucracy and infrastructure in India are not conducive to foreign investments.
@@engsudatta276 So far we have been a developing country if it takes some more time for us to remain developing then so be it as it's not going to be big thing for us to worry about since post covid pendmic period & with the increasing Chinese assertiveness n bullying arrogant & confrontist vis a vis Taiwan Japan in SCS & with india in the LAC since then America & European led theirs initiatives of diversification of supply chain which in the West known as democratization of supply chain in which apart from Asean nations among others nations india is also Getting attraction in this new ventures so if we are not getting Chinese investment both public or private it's not matter of concern for us but what more important for us is our sovereignty which Chinese PLA under the behest of their political leadership most precisely Xi Xingping trying to encroach upon our land every know & then as if india is another Tajikistan or Kyrgyzstan to easily push over and if china really want to have progressive economic & cooperative relationship with india then what's the point in border clashes now & then as india on it's part has always been sensitive & Accomdative to Chinese concerns on every issues which are touchy for the Chinese but what we got in return regular veto & hold on our efforts in UN security Council whenever we mooted proposal to banned Pakistan origin terrorist & if it's not enough for the Chinese they started Regular cross border incursions form PLA & in Galwan china crossed all it's limits & it was the watershed moment for us & since July 2020 there's has been 21 rounds of talks on military level happened on the same border clashes issues where china is not relanting an inch on india demand for the disengagement from the border & restoration of Pre April 2020 situation on the LAC which china refusing to accept therefore what's a point on having cooperative relationship when there's clear visible signs about Chinese intention are opposite to what they speak & what they act. Hence if Chinese really want india not to be in the Western camp then they have to respect indian sensitivities on the border if Chinese didn't keep the pot boiling on the border there was no way india could have gone so much close to the US but the bitter truth is that Chinese wishes to take alot from india but offers nothing to give in return to addressed India's concerns even some of Chinese leaders in various interviews wishing for the same & wanting to address india concerns but one man personal ambitious stopping them for doing this & he is no other than Chinese president Xii Xingping himself
@@vinodkaka5225 The borders between India and China was arbitrarily drawn by the British colonist government of India without the knowledge and approval of the Chinese Qing government and so remain a source of controversy. it is left for the two governments to resolve.
But geopolitically, who first stoked the fire in the Taiwan strait, in North Asia, in South China Sea and south Pacific Ocean. Weren't they the US who sent aircraft carriers, nuclear, submarines, watships, reconnaissance planes to these parts of the world to carry out drills to demostrate military might (even India participated). The target is obvious Besidrs, the US formed the Five Eyes, the Aukus, the Quod (including India and the upcoming alliance of the US, Japan and Korea s pseudo-Nato in the Esst. And the US has just set up a military supplies base in Papua New Guinea. All these are blatant acts aimed at encircling, containing, suppressing China, in line with what Blinken said: " The US will continue to say and do what China dislikes" This is a clear expression of US hegemony and bullying. Do you think China will go down on knees to kowtow to the US?
India of course is playing the game by siding with the West and going against China to gain economic and military benefits from them. Everyone knows that. By the way, India is also not condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine as it wants to import crude oil from Russia at substantial discounts as well as makes huge profits by exporting the crude to the West. Everyone knows how "shrewd" the Indian government can be. As said, the Chinese businessmen and others had learnt their invaluable lessons and they have formed a hardened perception about India, its government and even some of it citizens. What perception is it? It is up for your guess?
@@engsudatta276 What's US doing everywhere in the world is not india fault neither American are doing this on indian behest as such india has nothing to do with that but having said that whatever US is doing in South China Sea & china is doing in the South China is or I Asia Pacific is up to the China & US Rather we have concerns related to just our borders with china and these so called dispute are not emerged in the 2020 as you rightly mentioned it was started with its roots in the British colonial period when india was also not independent so was china was also not present with its troops deployed in the Tibetan plateau & not just that same Mac Mohan boundry line ➖〰between india & china which has been a bone of contention between the two countries the very same Mac mohan boundry line➖ 〰 extended eastern wards towards Myanmar as well & creating a border between china & Myanmar but there you will never see china do the same precisely what it does in the border with india so if china can Applied restraint in the Myanmar border why can't it can do the same with indian border & one more thing here to note about the very same Mac mohan line boundry dispute was there since century now if we kept aside 2 border skirmishes wars 1962 & 67 aside as an exception then there's has been always peace in the sino indo border therefore then what's proscribed china to keep the temperature boiling with indian border as we know on April 2020 in the midst of the covid pendmic lock down period in the world back then therefore india is not asking china to withdraw from Chinese land but from the Bufferzones which according to 1993 & 2003 peace and transquility agreement between the both sides neither side can occupy even if both side troops comes face to face with each other they will be mutual withdrawal & both sides will come back to their own original backside camps without firing Or physically hurting each other so that to maintain peace transquility & sanctity of the border & both sides should resolve the differences diplomatically & peacefully that's what agreed upon in the Agreements signed in 1993 & 2002 treaty that's what india requesting china to honour the agreement & peace treaty & start mutual troops disengagement & withdraw troops back to the April 2020 location & restoration of pre April 2020 situation on the border which was agreed upon between the two sides even with Differences of opinion & perception so what's stopping china from not honouring agreed treaties with india where as I see china as being a one of superpower nation so definitely no one can dictate china for not improving relationship with india so china have to take call but for that china have to be honest with the peace agreements it has signed with india then unilaterally changing the status quo on the border will not help the matters to solve rather it will have ripples effects on others sectors as well
Mr Pravin speaks objectivrly, very Very true. Mr Pravin is a wise, intellegent and knowledgeable man.
From Singapore.
You both are genius humble and real analyst, always talk truth with Great experience and knowledge,
Only indian Army officer to even Pakistanis Pakistan wait to listen and respect from heart.Wish we have such a thoughtful Officers in our Army.Salute to Sir Perveen,doesnt shy away speaking truth and reality about challenges india is going to face in future and gives a clear picture
David, thank you for bringing such a prominent analyst like Mr Pravin, his knowledge and insight into the world politics and specially about China, India and Pakistan is unmatchable. I have never heard anyone who have such a deep knowledge and understanding in these kind of issues which you guys just discussed. Great job David 👍.
Prominent 😂😂😂😂
@@χσχσ-ν3χ Yes, Mr Pravin is highly prominent analyst. Do you have any doubt on his expertise and analysis? No one in world who watches his videos and read his books or magazines would dare to challenge his analysis.
Bravo, David for bringing on Pravin for an insightful dialogue 👏 👌 👍
G7 delivered nothing for the betterment of the world, whereas two countries alone, China and Russia, have brought more countries together for developement and created more peace around the world.
Lol
@chuekaothao6329 Agree absolutely
India seems to be recalcitrant in any organizations like SCO, BRICS, etc including QUAD. Eg. by playing down SCO summit to please the west and against a BRICS common currency with many demands and concessions....just like RCEP, BRI, etc.
Best to move on with or without India. Let India know that it isnt the world or a major economy which the rest of the world couldn't live without. Couldn't say the same for the unwise India tho, at least for now or near future.😊
Even I could easily debunked many of the news from Wionn or Firstpost. Just like CNA (Singapore based) are many of the regional media setup to disseminated someone's agendas or manipulation of false opinions with their professionalism/reporting observed. Unless you have read more, you can be easily misled by their stories/reporting or even videos/photos.
Maintaining status quo is the G7 agenda while China and Russia wants to unite the world and have a global peace and inclusive development
G7 is set up for coordinate their exploitation on the world.
Mr. Pravin is absolutely right. India can't play this double game. India must decide which camp it belongs to. It's in India's best interest to cooperate with China and Russia. The US wants world domination and doesn't tolerate any countries, especially large countries, to challenge US hegemony. Think the US loves India? Think again. Having seen how hostile the US is toward the great power Russia and China, why would the US treat India any differently when India becomes a superpower?
How about china behaving with india in last 60 years?
Only betrayal 😂😂😂
Let us be clear here - China today has become so powerful because of the enormous benefits given by the US to it since the early 1970s. It is only now that the US has started seeing China as a threat when its economy is close to the size of the US economy. Do you think China will help any country like that ? Obviously not.
While the US and the western world is declining, they still have a lot to offer to India and Indians. They are open societies. The same cannot be said of China. Moreover if India became part of the China camp, it will lose all benefits of the western world which China has explored merrily for its rise, and it will have to play second fiddle to China. So thanks but no thanks. We are happy where we are.
@@zzzzz653 Playing second fiddle to China is better than forever playing third fiddle to China and to your
master's voice the US.
@@stevewang2 India is not going to be anybody’s slave, God willing. We have a large enough country that can become a global behemoth. You better worry about Pakistan which can never expect to match upto to India and has always played the slave’s role to US & China.
@@HiteshChaudhari74you don’t know history at all eh 😂 go and check real history, not ani or Wion lol
Both of speakers are straightforward with their words. So glad to see both together.
Thank you, and I hope you bring back your guest. He is one of the very few analysts who is logical and critical, not emotionally like a lot of Indian politicians.
He doesn't know anything.... He is talking rubbish.... He just share he own false viewpoint which have nothing to do with reality..
@@SamratDutta-ki1mlChina would beat India in 3 days and disintegrate India within month
@@SamratDutta-ki1ml😅😂
Only the thug politicians of the ruling BJP. BTW, many of them educate their children abroad and own trading firms with China dealings. Liars to the core, they won't believe their own words--emotions and sentiments mean nothing to the. They are NOT Hindu nationalists but caste imperialists who cater to the global Hindu caste diaspora
@@SamratDutta-ki1mlYou are so emotional already, being patriotic of India doesn't mean you have to side with India blindly without a clear mind. Ask one question, do you follow the other side of the story fully (Chinese English media, or scholars like Jeff Sach, Martin Jacques, Cyrus Jansen, Kishore Mahbubani, etc ) or just from the western or particularly Chinese bashing media/propaganda machines. For instance, Chinese's debt trap nonsense, sensational and curry flavored. Have you heard directly from data released by their central banks, scholars ' studies, and actual interests rates as compared to western financials, even from IMF, world bank. After hearing the whole stories, you dun be surprised that our opinions are being manipulated or misleaded by the half stories told. That's the power of media,
thanks to Mr Pravin from Germany- one of the few sane minds, which should be heard in India/Bharat.
I am a person of Chinese descent. I greatly admire Pravin's rationality and pragmaticism. So many other Indian
politicians always portrait India as a great power, on par with China, and refused to consider a diplomatic
solution on disputes with China and Pakistan.
Stop worrying about our problem, take care of your regional affairs, we have many problems on our plate. Do not tell us what we should do or what is bad and good for us. keep your hatred opinion to yourself. Let's see how you plan to unite Taiwan
@@shelenwangnao8659 The problem with Indians is that they refused to listen to constructive criticism,
only wanted to listen to sweet words, even if those sweet words is not based on truth from facts. No ability
to self-reflect. Infected with "Colonialism of the Mind".
@@shelenwangnao8659He wasn't worried about India. Here we are with the traditional Indian attitude. You are not on China's level. That parody was past in 1990 and India was left well behind the dust. You folks are the ones constantly TALKING ABOUT CHINA- Palki Sharma with her lies of China constantly as one example.
@@timothychung4811lmao just saw scores of Chinese crossing Mexico border into USA, so much for so called economic power china 😂
@@shelenwangnao8659
Why are you using a Chinese name instead of your Indian name?
Mr Swahney is probably aware of Deng Xiaoping's famous dictum: “Hide your strength, bide your time.” Which GEOPOLITICAL arena does this apply - neighborhood or across the Pacific? Should Bharath be ready for a CENTURY OF HUMILIATION?
I am Pakistan and listening to Parveen for 2 years . He is very objective Analysis
@@tarapadasarkar3108absolutely correct.
The problem for Modi is if he would leave the West for China the West would start criticising BJP Modi’s domestic policies against the minorities of India especially towards the Indian’s Muslims therefore for the BJP this is more important than anything anything else.
There would be no problems. There are 195 countries, and only 40 or so that would as they are the US's vassals. China and Russia are going through that right now, so what more would happen? Modi wants to be a demagogue because he is not that great.
Parvin is what India needs as a leader.
Mr. Parvin, I've been watching your videos for a couple of years now... Keep up the great work, Mr. Parvin!
Pravin, I request you to never stop speaking your mind...You are a very important voice in Indian strategic community.
An year ago i used to be your critic but now i have come to accept your views on many issues.
I hope there will be more converted Indians like you.
*Pravin*,if only the high chair of India has your SENSE & human spirituality... lots of ❤ to David and Pravin and the 🌏🌍🌎💕
What disappoints me about India is the decision to grant the US permission to put a military hub in their country? How is that going to benefit India? What positives are going to be coming out of that? I personally don't see any; all I see is negativity.
It's the era of economic coercion it seems.
It is their new master, the daughter of their first master.
If 100 years from now India as a united nation seized to exist, this policy will be marked as the beginning of India's decension as world power if they had one.
Do Indian leaders believe US will earnestly help India to develop into the next China? If not, then what do they expect to get from the US, and if so, why do they think Washington would help create a great power with ambition of being the hegemon of the IOR (and displace the US)?
litmus test. modiji has asked usa to help create semiconductors ecosystem in india. if usa allows that , then its worth having usa as a trusted partner
@@pioneerpremiere2267 Foreign companies learn at their expense that India seized their assets, saying they didn't respect the Indian law. Foxconn, Wistron and Xiaomi who share their technology with Indian companies leave India for the con scheme disguised in incentive economic policy of India. So, giving India hi-tech technology isn't wise. The U.S. Administration will learn that at its expense.
@@pioneerpremiere2267 early 2021 covid kill india in mass, india ask usa for vaccine when they hoarding it, usa refuse
at first.... how can you call that a trusted partner when your people die in huge number and usa not even step up to help?
case 2: Japan econnomy in the 80s-90 they start overt take usa in many area, what happen Usa put sanction and destroy their economy.
case 3: just China just like japan on the rise, Usa start sanction. NOW if india rise to China level USA will start sanction them too. this india have not figure out yet.
by the way Usa will never help india in semi conductor, they do not want another going to challenge them in the future and eat a slice of their cake.....just like china now.
@@user-ne6xw1sv4ucry harder
Russia had no problem resolving border issues with China and established a partnership to the benefits of both countries. India could do the same, but the West played a game which will not serve the internet of India in the long run. You are not going to see massive western investment in China shifted to India. Cooperation among the global south countries is the key to the strengthening of the Indian economy through make in India policy.
“To be an enemy of America can be dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal.” Henry Kissinger
India must wake up from the dream they are dreaming now.
- Henry Kissinger
Most leaders love to take their desires for reality, thinking they could do better than their former leaders.
I think it is you Pakistanis who have to wake up to the reality. Inspite of US pressure India has stood with Russia and strengthened its relationship by buying lots of oil. Do you think that was possible if Modi was under US control ? Think before you talk rubbish.
HEAR HEAR and LISTEN carefully😇👀👂
@@zzzzz653 Modi is flip-flop man. None can trust such character. Keep on sleeping:"zzzzz". 🤣🤣🤣
India knows its own interest, will get tech from US, will get cheap oil from Russia. I
geopolitics is shifting towards east Asia and Asia but the western countries will stifle this shift by using india.
Their chowgidar and chai walla.
OK beggar nation
sure mulla you are a great geopolitical analyst I'm sure. Mullas want to ride the coattails of India to power. They've been western henchmen for ages. India is just making sure multipolarity is allowed to flourish without all these western mulla parasites. Adding all the terrorist in the OIC to BRICS will destroy BRICS. That is why India brought up the terror issue.
Excellent conversation with objectivity ..... always enjoyed Parween speaking on the geo-politics with it's military dimensions and have learned a lot on this subject from Parween's youtube channel FORCE.
Thanks Parween from Lahore.
I like listening to Mr Pravin he give unbiased views on geo politics 👍🏼
Pravin Swahney your interview with David is perhaps one of the most informative one that I have watched for a long time. Normally I would change channel if an interview is more than 15 minutes long but in this instance I was glued to your thought provoking arguments without realising it was an hour long. I sincerely hope the bigwigs of your government will watch the interview and take note of where India should stand in terms of world's geopolitics as opposed to blindly follow the outdated world order. Also the Ukraine war has laid bare the West’s hypocracy of Democracy. They have closed ranks against Russia and will do so against India too if need arises. India shares a long border with China and Pakistan therefore all energies should be channeled to normalise relation with them.
Both India and the US are embarking on the wrong policies vis-a-vis China and a multi-polar world. Parvin is certainly very well versed with the geopolitics of the Indian sub-continent and China. David and Parvin complement each other and it is so good to hear then discuss. Please invite Parvin back for his take after the BRICS meet in South Africa,
Pravin Sawhney is dispassionately focused and imbued with the courage of his analytical convictions! Excellent conversation!
I have been an admirer and follower of Praveen on Force Magazine for a very long time. He has a brilliant incisive mind. His analysis of India-China-Pakistan is so correct that one can only admire his brilliance. I live in USA and Pakistan though I am from South East Asia with its unique cultural background. I follow David regularly also though at times I have difficulty comprehending some of his analysis as being off course occasionally. This though does not detract me from admiring his tenacity in forcefully putting his viewpoints across.
India too tried hard to have a good relation with Pak... forget terror groups, even Army betrayed India when Bajpayee went to Lahore. Parliament attack, Mumbai attack... India gave up. Having good relation is what every Indian want. But that's not possible until Pak stops India-Hindu hatred from its text books
@@nirmalbhel3231 Since its separation from India, the Pak Army has maintained a vicious grip on the running of the country and controlled the politicians in one way or another. Hyping up tensions with India is the preferred way to control the narrative. Though Modi has surged India and porpelled it into an economic powerhouse, the RSS controlling in the background is detrimental to creating harmony amongst the various ethnic communities and is a very major problem. Modi is a strong leader, unlike the other major Congress party. I am placing high hopes on Kejir Agarwal of the AAM ADMI party for the future of India.
@@ahmedsoorma All muslims in India needs to join RSS atleast for a month then decide whether RSS is good for India or not. There are a few but there are Muslims in RSS too. Main idea of RSS is to build a good citizen just like Boys Scout of America. It is not a political but many politician were a RSS students. There are many RSS guys in Cong too. RSS/Modi is anti-Muslim! this is a narrative created by Cong, few non-secular partirs Muslim League, AIMQM and few wester media who don't want a strong leader in India. Many RSS leaders have mentioned several times that India will be incomplete without Muslims. Kejriwal AAP has spoiled Delhi and Punjab. He can fight like Mamata but can't do good geverence.
Whatever Pak Army is doing is choice of Pak people too. They respect Army chief more than PM. Every citizen of Pak will celbrate if Pak Army attacks India again
If Modi comes back in 2024 then India will become 5 trillion economy by end is third term.
Parveen is really intellect.
Mr.Pravin is a Realist.
A genuinely honest person.
Pravin talks immense sense. Good man! 👍🏻
when i see talking india and china comparison......it is like compare between kenya with s.korea.
india should be comparing from bangladesh , pakistan and afghinistan.
It is because of Corrupt Elite class that's why Pakistan is behind and Indians get chance to mock Pakistan always. Otherwise Pakistan CAN get Ahead of India in All terms.
with 3.5 trillion dollar nominal gdp india is the worlds 5th largest economy .with 11.5 trillion dollar economy in terms of the purchasing power parity indias gdp is the worlds 3rd largest gdp according to the purchasing power parity .srilanka is mostly living on indian aids .According to the prime minister of the srilanka Ranil Wickramasinghe srilanka can fight the war for the next day because of only india .india have large contribution in the economic development of the bangladesh.During the last visit of pm modi bangladesh recives help worth of 20 billion dollars in the form of financial aid and soft loan.Amount twice bigger than the defence budget of the pakistan
india have gifted 60000 tonnes of wheat to afghanistan at free of cost.projecs worth of 3 billion dollars are running under the taliban regim
@@amalchakrabarti2357 Yes, it is true. However please be honest, how much is the average annual income of each person in India? $2000/year. That is what an average person makes in a week in the West or it is possible by a average person. India does not have that kind of luxury. So being 5th economy does not help average Indians.
In fact, Bangladesh has a higher per capita income than India even though India has a much bigger influence over its neighbours. Bangladesh is a poor country by any means.
Thank sir for inviting Mr Parvin... his thoughts on the subject is very refreshing... hope to hear from him again on your show...
For india to overtake usa as second largest economy, india need to work with China. Usa will look to india as a threat if india come close to overtaking usa. This will take decades in the making if india ever replace usa.
TOTALLY TRUE
You are the smartest man, but all Indians do not understand this and try not to make India a pawn of the United States🙃🙃
never ever trust the west never.
@@wenoyang6571 EXACTLY
Im BRAZILIAN AND I SAY TO INDIAN"S PEOPLE : BE CAREFUL
NEVER TRUST USA
THEY WILL USE YOU LIKE HANDKERCHIEF
THEY WILL THROW UP YOU
THEY WILL BETRAYE YOU
NEVER FORGET 1971 WHEN THEY THREATED YOU WITH NUCLEAR SUBMARINES BEFORE RUSSIA INTERVENTION IN SUPPORT OF INDIA
But i think this advice should be given to China because when india said against non cooperating with china in any field rather it's china which is playing dual tactics with india by keeping the pot boiling in the border while seeking cooperation & friendship with india in economic & trade matters which is not possible to make relationship good & cooperative in such circumstances
(IMF)’s GDP database shows that the world GDP crossed $100 trillion, in current US dollars, in 2022: it was for the first time ever. US and China have added GDP of $4.08 trillion and $3.76 trillion respectively in these three years. At the same time, India could add only $0.55 trillion. India’s GDP gap with the US and China widening uncomfortably. The truth is India is not catching up, but the GDP gap is only widening.
Fascinating interview and brilliant analysis from both, thank you so much Sir for sharing this information
SALUTE TO THESE TWO GENTLEMEN WHO AR GUIDING INDIA VERY RIGHTLY.
Refusal to cooperate is suicidal to India economy .
According to the estimates usa is facing all most 500 billion dollar losses per year because of the espionage .Number is twice than the total gdp of the pakistan.china have already penetrated evry nuke and corner of american socity trough the chineese investors and corporate companies.Even president bidens son is facing the charge of reciving unaccounted money from the chineese sources
Refusal to cooperate will be suicidal for China !
@@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i😂😂😂
Irans should replace India
Your ass is burning apply burnal.
Best analysis always Pravin Sawhney,, best wishes for you sir jee
India should be working closer with China ! Win win for both countries 👍🏼because eventually India will surpass the US economy and the US doesn’t like that !
US also has deep pockets. But they will fund only in wars to maintain the status quo. While China is investing in development world wide. That should dictate us which side to be in for our national interests.
India is making a historical mistake by not having a friendly relation with China.
I know it helps their domestic political interest but severely hampers their national interests.
as chinese, i have never seen a indian indegenous expoert with such insightul and ratinoal mind..but his opinion for sure will not be popular among the current indian political environment. like Kishore Mahbubani once said , the indian policitians act on emotion not on rantionale, which is same with most indian people..that's sad.
Check out Jayant Bandari as well.
I have been watching your show for many years. It is an excellent geopolitical show and, in my view, is one of the best. I always feel that there is one element "missing" in your geopolitical model. The missing link is x-factors emotions. I believe Indians are very emotional people. Tell an Indian that he can outrun an African; defeats a Chinese in King Fu with one of his hands tied behind his back; a better lover than an Italian and smarter than a jew; you can get an Indian to do everything for you. He had already delivered India to Britain, and now Modi is going to deliver India again to the USA.
If you guys don’t poking India then india would be your friend like Russia. So please look inward 😊
India is not missing the x-factor which is too emotional. It is that they have one too many x-factor which is too emotional.
No man can serve two masters, India is trying to accomplish this feat with BRICS and G7. How will this end?
Says a African slave
Brilliant U R, Pravin, always brilliant
And what does Pravin have to say " India must understand that China is in a wholly separate Geo political category". Message delivered, Sir, Indians are quaking in their shoes...
Don't be defensive. All he is saying is that you basically can't match China... They are too far ahead.
So why are your policies based on "competing"? When, by definition there is no competition at all.
China is 5x of India is all major national power indices.
I don't see anything wrong with what Mr Pravin Sawhney said.
@@sabtaingopinath9652PRIDE and he knows the truth which is killing him as his nation is not unified. With China and Russia, that can be achieved. They will get education, opportunities which they have to make the best of. The most important thing is being freed from the shackles of the elites of the West.
Great minds work alike in speaking the truth of Geopolitics, it will always echoes in our ears, even for those who doesn't want to hear the truth. If only India will join the neighbors China and Russia and join venture to excel their economics for the benefits of their citizens.
When USA says they will help they mean military base, Naval base, fighter jet. They don't say about roads development, educational institution, Infrastructure development. I am slowly hating USA
Col Praveen Sawhney is just superb. A great truth seeker!
The Truth Seeker says “Pakistan never lost a war”. In 1971 war although Pakistan “won” the war they were gracious and created Bangladesh. Pakistan captured 90,000 Indian soldiers as prisoners of war and it was not India!
@@chander3338 Instead of being sarcastic, just listen to what Col Sawhney said, "except in Bangladesh theatre". Bangladesh surrounded with Indian territory from three sides, and all Bangladeshis up against, Pakistani army had no alternative left. Besides, it was Sikh general who was commanding in eastern sector who did this quickly. Had there been any Hindu general, Indian Army would have suffered considerably.
@@ASHKUM-uw2qg I should thank Allah for converting self loathing Hindus to Muslims and creating Pakistan. The reward of 72 virgins waiting in heaven was too tempting. Keep it up!
It's worth listening. Thank you David n Parvin, an objective analyst.
The best and most neutral analyst in India - well done Pravin, well done. objective discussions and not subjective!
India should leave SCO and BRICS. We don't need India as a saboteur.
Indian government rejection of BYD EV investment could have been influenced by the Japanese who have plan to matket its hydrogen powered cars in India.
To be an enemy of the US is dangerous but to be a friend is fatal. India's current approach is highly dangerous and it may suffer the same fate as Ukraine as it may end up o0n the wrong side of history.
Awesome ! both are talking real true facts.
Excellent, lucid wise analysis
Pravin is a pragmatic analyst👍
God bless Indian
Leadership with... Sanity and Wisdom.
.
India had better get its act together or get left behind. also, Inda has made themselves venerable to other countries that surround them. brics, China can do without India,.
As always, respect for Sawhney Sb. from Lahore. We need more men of peace on both sides.
The smile on his face when mr. David mentioned Rawal Pindi was priceless, his ancestral place if i am not mistaken.
Unfortunately the mindset of the Indian rulers, especially the current dispensation is against any kind diplomatic negotiations with either Pakistan or China. We are unable to have amicable ties any of our neighbors. The latest casualty is the Maldives. We have lost Nepal and Sri Lanka to China, the next to slip out will be Bhutan, who are in their final stages of establishing diplomatic relations with the PRC. Our ties with Bangladesh are tenuous at best. The way our Muslims and other minorities are being hounded by the BJP is going to come back to bite us. The BJP games in the North Eastern States is a policy fraught with dire consequences.
Absolutely agree
To become a super power, India is still many centuries away and still a very, very distant pipe dream. India sud continue dreaming
Envy cause india downfall.
better cooperate.
Even china must do it with usa .
Both usa / china need each other to move faster in today light speed Internet online economy
Why don't India leave SCO organization and BRICS.
America's complaint: "Oh, why can't China's leadership be more like India's leadership?"
Pravin Sawhney 👍🏻👍👍🏼
中国只想和美国欧洲日本比，学习他们的优点，避开他们犯的错，让自己更好，至于印度，我们尊重。
Why is china supporting pakistan
If it needs to fight India it can declare its intent in public
He is learned person
Cheers to Dr David's viewers
Mr. Pervin is rightly said "Every nation including India have won political interest in mind".
But India should also apply the same principle to all the smaller countries around her.
> So for the security & sustainable regional interests of India, they should take the policy for not to be the friend of a specific political party or community. Rather she should respect the desire /opinion and try to win the hearts of the people of the neighboring countries.
Bring Praveen back, so thankful you found him and not the clown you had on once ( not your fault, he gets around until people figure him out). Very good program and guest
Keep up your good work, David.
India, should either full heartedly join BRICKS or move out. Cannot play games in this age of time.
I think every 100 yrs a person like praveen is born, with his head screwed on tight, a true analyst.
I wish he was heading the Indian government.
I Admire your Instinct Regarding India 🇮🇳 🐍
Thumbs 👍 👍 up
❤😂🎉😅😊
.
We should nominate Pravin for prime minister. He’s one to resolve problems over the negotiation table rather than through means of hostility. Modi is appreciated in the country cuz he qualifies as the Donald Trump of India.
.
Excellent excellent discussion. What a great program..to listen a real discussion.
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
David, your broadcast is invaluable to us Indians, and full of information not available to us.
But please don’t let your microphone pick up the sounds from your speakers, as you become unintelligible . Get some professional pointers about how to conduct a flawless podcast, and we’ll enjoy listening to you even more. Thanks.
Thanks for a very interesting and informative discussion. In my humble opinion Mr Sawhney is the best defense analyst in the world today.
best defense analyst in the world today for India.
David, your sound system is having echoing due to you microphone having voice feedback from your speakers back into your microphone.
It's hard to hear clearly due to the echoing.
The Indians only love to hear from any analysis those who project India as a great power,even if it is not.....😅😅😅😅😅
Cry mf
@PemsShimrey
Absolutely agree
Spot on
They will only hear if you praise them sky high even if it's not the truth
From : Singapore 🇸🇬🤠
> All the neighbouring states of India like Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Maldives and even Hindu dominant Nepal have become anti-India except the current govt.of Bangladesh, who has forcefully perpetuated in power by India going against the public opinion of Bangladesh
> So anti-Indian sentiment inflaming among the common people of Bangladesh.
> In long run it will go against Indian interest to support & assist for one-sided show up election by keeping all the opposition parties out election to ignore the opinion of the people like a autocratic/ Communist country
> The same was done to keep Mamun Abdul Gayoom in power in the Maldives. But current Maldives situation is a living proof of the consequences of going against public opinion.
> If it’s continue whole area will be unstable
> Will it be good for India?
Indian racism gets in the way of understanding China and East Asia
India is sobotaging bricks , Shanghai cooperation..
Pakistan was suppose to be cooperating with India atleast on the economic matters, which they didn't and see where they are economically. India needs to leran this lesson when comes to China.
Cry
Excellent show with Parveen
Modi is hard up to have the superman's suit. Give him one. First he has to bring the price of essentials before embarking on unsolicited wars. Mad fellow.
.
Prahvin should be *NOMINATED* by the Indian masses as Prime Minister of India instead of those weaklings that’s been running the country -weaklings who rode on the coattails of both the UK and the West to get to the top seat in the country.
If Prahvin was calling the shots, my bet is India will have been a STAUNCH PART of Asia and will have PROGRESSED TOGETHER WITH ASIA rather than being a rival to it…
If we’re the case, good chance Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka and India will have merged into a single community and no rivalry would exist today as it does.
But, Indian think they are part of the Neanderthal culture hence look down on everything and everyone Persia right through the subcontinent…
Prahvin and Kishore for PM and for el Presidente! The only two that can make the subcontinent excel through the roof.
.
Pakistan has tried to get on the table at least three times. Irony is the strict Hindu mindset of the Indian government. This mindset has even created a big problem for the Indian Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and other minorities within India. This mindset needs to be changed. Seems difficult with the present RSS mindset of the rulers of India.
Not Hindu, you mean Hindutva. One is a religion and the other is an ideology.
@@HamidRehman100794 well...who r Not Indian...they wont see that difference. Because they deal Indians...not Liberal Indian or Radical ones.
It is upto Indian ppl to Stop rise of Radical Hindus...if not then they r to be blamed
Pakistan back stabbed India by killing 44 soldiers in 2019
Excellent discussion. Modi is weakening India from inside, opening it for foreign players to create conflicts with his Hindu nation push. Economy is worse than when he took power but present government just likes to event manage everything to present a pretty superficial facade. And then our leaders are always focused on elections and usurping power of opposition.
I guess that finally India will leave
B R I C S , AND FOLLOW THE WES . AS , INDIA LEFT ,THE CHAH BAHAR PORT IN IRAN AND AFTER
18 YEARS HAS NOT FINISHED THE PROJECT . I AM SURE IT WILL BE FINISHED BY CHINA .
4:15 most of the indians scared of truth
The British Empire was afraid of a United Asia.
They left a half million bodies in Balaclava to prove their resolve.
The US Empire as overextended as the Limey one before it,
appears to be repeating the same mistakes as the Well Dressed Gents of London,
did previously.
After the British handed the Persian Colony to the US,
the Dulles Bros made as piss poor an example of Colonial leadership,
as any snooty Brit has ever made an impression on Citizens of Iran.....
The US appears to stomp their feet and attempt to issue threats about invasions.
But can the US actually assemble the forces to invade and overcome the Iranian Government?
Is the US now once again spending so much cash,
(this time in Fiat Dollars)
as they did establishing Port Facilities in Vietnam?
The US created the container Traffic that now seems so normal ,
as the attempt to maintain some form of Puppet Government in Saigon.
The Currency Crisis of 1967 appears to have demonstrated that Colonial Empires cost a lot to maintain.
But here we are again......
How are those US Treasury Notes selling today?
Very nice discussions, truly enjoy a lot.
To enable a further exploration of the matter and avert the trap of reality denial don't you think it would be of utmost interest to mention as well a certain number of publications from knowledgeable and renowned Indian scholars such as Pr. Ashoka Mody with his book " India is Broken"?
India shall be left irrelevant with a simple issues by the fully coming on board asap of the United Nations of Africa.UNA with a single currency and unity military and also the ONE leadership in Ethiopia.ARC+++.
Pravin is a brilliant man. Pity he is not in Government.
Mr. Pravin is not emotional and biased.. i agree with his analysis...