There's plenty more to unpack with the history and modern reception of the character of Zwarte Piet - seeing as that wasn't the point of this video, I figured it was best to avoid the tangent. But interestingly enough, Dutch culture is currently reimagining the character to be less... well, less of a deliberately racist caricature. New interpretations include "Rainbow Pete" and "Sooty Pete", and they have their own nuances and difficulties as well - but it's worth the investigation if you're curious, because it really is fascinating to see cultural innovation in real time! This is the stuff we talk about happening hundreds of years ago, but this one is happening now!! Anyway Merry Crimbis and stuff, don't get punched by a saint. -B
And please take into consideration that there are many.. many!! More views about zwarte Piet then being a racist leftover of colonial past! I lived all around the wordt but only in the US the Media outrage was considering it racist to black people. Then it spread to the eu and worldwide As a European I’m truly shocked about the “political” wrong and disinformed statements come from the USA
In Germany we have a card game called Schwarzer Peter meaning exactly the same as Zwarte Piet (Black Pete), which is about avoiding being the last player to have the Black Pete card in your hand. Old versions of the game depict Black Pete as a stereotypical black person, but it has since shifted toward depicting him as a chimney sweep. I wonder if there's some kind of larger identity to Black Pete?
Thank you for including that note! If you ask most people who grew up with Zwarte Piet, they'll tell you that they never thought he was actually black, because as children, we're told stories that Black Pete comes through the chimney, ending up being completely covered in soot, but that doesn't take away the fact that he looks quite literally like a deliberate racist caricature, nor the fact that he first appears in Dutch children's literature around 1850 as an actual black man; it just means that over the years, adults have changed the explanation that they give to their children about why Black Pete is so dark (as far as I can tell, it was probably because the black makeup used for Zwarte Piet was much darker than the natural skin colour of actual black people. Even though the makeup became lighter later, the explanation stayed). It's a tradition that is thankfully changing now.
The words "stealth charity" make me think of someone creeping up on a homeless person and dropping a bag of money at his/her feet, with a vaguely threatening note saying, "Here's a thousand dollars-- take it or else." 😀
@@BennyLlama39 Now I'm just imagining a dude who looks like Joe Pesci, well-dressed yet still sinister, visiting the homeless to deliver food and clothing with genuine kindness at heart, while accompanied by a number of hulking, scowling, scarred-up thug types who clean their fingernails with switchblades while making uncomfortably prolonged eye contact.
And then Saint Nicolas and Odin did the fusion dance, but due to their vastly different power level, the result of the transformation came out weird and thus Santa was born.
Sidenote, St. Nick in his original form is celebrated on December 6th in most predominantly catholic countries. In Austria (and Bavaria) he is in the company of not-black-face devil "Krampus" to also judge who's naughty and who's nice. Funnily enough, even though we were never protestant here, in Austria Jesus himself is bringing the presents, while in Germany you got Santa Claus (although often called Weihnachtsmann with no specific name given, although it has of course started to get mixed up with the American Santa Claus so... full circe)
In Poland, also, Saint Nicholas (Święty Mikołaj) is celebrated on December 6th, and on that day he brings candy to children. December 6th is also the name day for people named "Mikołaj" (a name day is the veneration day for the Saint after which the person is named, often connected to the date they were martyred, or held to have been martyred in Catholic & Orthodox tradition). This particular name day happens to fall on the same date for Orthodox & Catholics (they often differ, and some Saints in one have no counterpart in the other). I know all this since I'm a Nicholas born in Greece and living in Poland ;-)
Was about to add this in my own comment, as it's one of the few "old world" holidays I know about. My Oma was Lutheran (mostly?) but she absolutely adored St. Nicholas day, which for her always involved making up a huge batch of thumbprint cookies - something she ONLY ever did for this holiday. She'd talk about all the winter festivals from back in Germany too, sometimes telling various Christmas stories that she'd picked up when living in southern Germany. So, 6 December is a day with lots of good memories for me, and St. Nicholas is a figure that I knew a tiny bit about already, hehe Fascinating to learn more from this!
Edit: I really should know better by now than to interact with comments before finishing the video. Revised: While the name Christkind stuck and thus confusingly still implies it being Baby Jesus, Luther et al. quickly changed it to officially being an (at least nowadays usually blond and feminine) angel. It is the height of irony that the Christkind survived in majority Catholic regions, while otherwise fiercely anti-saints majority Protestant countries moved St. Nicholas to Christmas (and then popularized this around the globe through the power of US consumerism). And the saints traditionally in charge of delivering presents to children in Orthodox Christianity as well as Iberia and thus Hispanic countries are the Three Wise Men/Kings on Epiphany on January 6. As for your description of Austria, yes, the Christkind delivers presents on Christmas (Eve), with many people endlessly whining about the growing popularity of the Weihnachtsmann due to US media. But children still get sweets and (small) presents on St. Nicholas's, complete with (usually) men dressed up like him (and Krampus, but he's often cut now as being too scary) visiting elementary schools. And up until a few decades ago, they got as much on December 6th or even more than on the 24th. (This shift is also mirrored in birthdays replacing name days in importance for tangentially related reasons.) Also, we absolutely were Protestant. The Reformation spread across Austria like wildfire until it got brutally beaten back by the Catholic Counter-Reformation.
@@rnanni1048 Because no matter how much we've modernized the context it doesn't change that the old make-up looks like an old offensive stereotype. So happy we're moving on from that.
The best story of Santa Claus that I found out recently is that he apparently delivers a lump of coal personally to Darkseid from the DC universe each year. Just walks straight up to Darkseid, tells him he has been naughty, hands him the coal, and laughs as he evades all of their defenses.
Living close to the dutch border, we have -St. Nicholas on dec 6th, -the mentioned before baby jesus that brings presents on christmas eve, -AND, due to media-globalisation, the Americanised version of Santa that we literally call "christmas man". Really looking forward to explain that mess to my children in a couple of years.
as someone from the Netherlands, I see sinterklaasavond as the time for gift giving and being with close famliy/freinds, and christmas as the time for being with and eating with the whole family (aunts, uncles, cousins etc). Both are really fun
sinterklaas is for het gezin, parents and kids, maybe grandparents, while christmas is for the whole family. (it's so odd that english doesn't have a word for gezin)
Same here. Presents are for Sinterklaas, family and eating are for Christmas. As a child I was always confused and didn’t get why Sinterklaas came to America on Christmas and not December 5th. Only later I realised they are two different characters
It's nice to see that something meant to be a children's story character did truly have humble origins to inspire people to be selfless. After the past two years, it is still good to remember that people can still do good. (Even with our memeable shortcomings like punching a heretic in the face) Merry Christmas/Happy Holidays to all! 🎄
Exactly. All joking aside, that is actually a really good thing to keep in mind for Christmas: - Instead of just decorating and giving gifts to family members, do some charity work for those in need. Or better yet, call distant and close friends that have nowhere to go and invite them to celebrate with you. One of the best gifts you can give someone is a helping hand and some kindness. - Also remember, if you pull away some of the G-rated stuff, Jesus's birth is not a pretty story: an unwed, pregnant teen travels by donkey with her spouse 90 miles to complete a census that will not help them but will just allow the imperial government to control them better. When they finally get there, she goes into labor and yet every single establishment cannot to house them. So, they are offered to rest and give birth in a stable, which is not at all sanitary. And when The Son of Man finally arrives, He is placed where animals eat. Imagine being so poor that you can't even afford a bed for your baby. Then, He is not visited by a Pharisee or Zealot, but by three astrologers from faraway lands and shepherds, who were seen as outcasts and also would not be welcomed in town. So, even though it is still a Holiday full of cheer and gift-giving and decorating, it should also be a holiday of action against the cruelty of the world around us.
Here in Belgium they would have a guy disguised in Saint Nicholas and come in schools to give oranges, candy, and speculoos (and actual gifts if you're lucky). Speculoos are biscuits and often people give Saint Nicholas shaped speculoos to kids. Speculoos are delicious
@@sogghartha ye speculoos is the brand idd, but I also mess it up despite being flemish (I'm sure the company picked that name on purpouse xD) and an accurate transulation/explanation to english seems to be spiced bisquit
Same here in Germany, although instead of Speculaas, I think nuts, specifically peanuts, are more common alongside chocolate and oranges/tangerines. Also yeah, Speculaas are delicious, especially the spicy ones.
@@sogghartha Iirc 'Speculoos' and 'Speculaas' are very similar, but different products. 'Speculaas' is more common in the Netherlands, as it is made with 'speculaas'-spices (colonialism ahoy), hence the name. Belgium didn't really have a steady supply of those, so over time making something that tastes similar, but doesn't contain the spices, they created speculoos (basically, 'speculaas-loos', as in without speculaas-spices). That spread is a fairly recent Belgian invention based on speculoos-biscuits.
For a bit of context on the zwarte Piet/black Pete thing: The original explanation for them painted them as enslaved Moor (ethnicity from south Marocco) sailors which saint Nick had help free in the past; depending on the version of the story you're dealing with, they were either so thankful that they swore to aid him in all his endavours henceforth or Nick realised that, if freed, they would soon be recaptured and thus decided to employ them all on the spot. As their job involved going up and down chimneys to delived gifts, the story goes on to say the soot covered them from head to toe, turning them black (colour not race). Some speculate that this may be a reference to either Odin's or Wodan's ravens. The most common depicting of zwarte Piet was originally just people who were covered in soot or dirt, although rarer depictions as african people did also exist. This state lasted until about the 50s, when the holiday got more commercialised and companies figured selling products depicting dirty people would be harder than those featuring black people. The frizzy hair, bright red lips, golden earrings and silly suit are also all the invention of these companies. A few years back the semblance to slavery was first called out and lead to a yearly controversy... until covid hit. An after effect of this was the replacement of black Pete by white Pete, rainbow Petes, or soot-smear Pete (which people funnily enough thought to be an amazing and new middle ground) in many, but not all places.
The thing is the lips and the accessories play so hard to the racist depictions that it’s hard for an outsider like me to see something other. Maybe they should go back to soot and make that clearer
@@elif6908 They already have. When people dress up nowadays they put black smears across the face rather than completely painting it. It's kinda weird how the story that was told and the aesthetic were always strangely disconnected in this way.
no, this is false. zwarte piet was a black person right from the start, old poems explicitly describe him as a n*gro. the whole idea that he was an evolution of the ravens of odin, or that it had to do with soot, was made up after black Dutch people started being more vocal against blackface.
I'm glad someone else brought up the fact that wasn't blackface. I love a lot of what Red and Blue do, but they really need to stop projecting their American Left sensibilities onto other cultures. Not everyone wants to deal with the Yank's politics...
“The giver of every good and perfect gift has called upon us to mimic His giving, by grace, through faith, and this is not of ourselves.” ― St. Nicholas of Myra
"As we celebrate the year-end holiday of Saturnalia - wait, no - Yule! Agh no come on which one is it - Christmas? CHRISTMAS, that one - they all just blend together." It's okay, Blue, all immortal beings who have been around for over two hundred years slip up sometimes.
imagine being an immortal historian being in an argument with a fellow scholar trying barely holding in your identity and weighing if proving the other person wrong is worth outing yourself (the answer is yes).
@@gohanr1271 Reminds me of a scene from Speaker for the Dead (sequel to Ender's game) where Ender is still alive about a thousand years later thanks to traveling by their version of hyperspeed and is currently working as a school teacher. He is teaching about himself and the Formics (aliens that he and humanity killed) and is forced to deal with a bunch of brats that talk about how much of a monster he was and that they would have of course loved the Formics and made peace with them. It seems to have gotten lost in history that the Formics had already invaded Earth twice and humanity had no way of knowing that the Formics weren't planning a third (they realized they were attacking fellow sentient beings and were horrified at what they had done) when humanity launched a counterstrike.
As someone who lives in The Netherlands and loves the Sinterklaas festivals, I’m happy to see it getting some attention! The whole vibe around Sinterklaas is simply amazing and even a bit magical. It always make me happy to see hundreds and hundreds of children gathered at the port so see the old man arrive. Heck, we even have a special program that reports on the daily life of Sinterklaas and it’s…. eh, it makes some weird decisions sometimes. Oh and for anyone wondering how it went this year: they basically scared the crap out of 1.6 million children. Pretty funny. Anyway, I love Sinterklaas and the whole (not questionable and controversial) part of the festival and 5 December is always a good day here. If anyone in the comment has any questions about the festival and it’s old man on a horse, just ask! I will answer gladly.
How do you all feel about Zwarte Piet? An old dutch friend, felt deeply uncomfortable about him. I'm genuinely wondering how he reads overall as Black European.
@@Firegen1 most people i know dont feel any shame at all... the stort we learn here is the’re black because they Climb through the chimny. Its American media that is playing the racist card on them, Sadly.... and uninformed...
St. Nicholas is one of the most beloved saints of Orthodoxy! St. Nicholas Day is sometimes more popular than Christmas from what I’ve experienced. Thanks for the video!
The (Orthodox) church I grew up in would have St. Nicholas (in full bishop's garb) visit on his feast day every year. Kids would then bring up toys to give to the local shelter.
Shoves all winter religious festivals into a blender. Sprinkles on flakes of Late Stage Capitalism, and proceeds to slurps the slurry we call... Christmas! 🎄
Minus the Late Stage Capitalism, which is abhorrent, that was the typical Eastern Christian way of doing things for a millennia. Rather than looking to destroy local cultures, most Christian evangelists in that time tried to tie in the local cultural heritage of their audience to show that Christ, being the True Wisdom, was the completion of the worldly wisdoms and religions that already existed. A much cooler approach to the later approaches by the Catholics (Latinize everything) or the Protestants (colonialism), from my biased perspective.
@@adamkimara6919 *happy nordic noises* Colonialism or not, we kept most of the good traditions, frankly ending slavery and human sacrifice uh...seems like a pretty progressive thing, then again...nordic... 🥳
@@Elenrai I meant more of the phenomena of Western European Protestants trying to spread the religion through the colonizing of other countries, particularly in Africa and Southeast Asia. Though in hindsight the way I wrote was likely a bit more polemical than I should have haha. I love all the Nordic Christmas traditions I’ve seen!
I still love how varied Saint Nicholas' entourage is depending on where you go - in the Netherlands he's accompanied by black caricatures, in the southern Germanic-speaking areas he's got a demon who eats naughty children at his beck and call.... and in North Germany he's accompanied by a dude who'll beat you with a rod.
Now I'm imagining a man enjoying Christmas with his family. The joy interrupted by the sound of breaking glass. Next to a broken window they see a brick with a note tied to it. "Merry Christmas," it says. The brick is solid gold.
Imagine of this video was a collab between OSP and Puppet Hisyory considering the latter did a Saint Nicholas episode back in 2020 of I remember correctly
"Here's a secret for you: I don't care." Not a secret, Blue. Also, my third sold story was about how a guy with the same name and the same area is thought to be Santa, and some idiots try to break into his workshop/stash. He's not, and his wife (and the reason he's still alive a thousand years later) is a fay ice queen. Big mistake...
yes and no its more likely part the god Wodan but Wodan and Odin are mostly the same god with most of the differences coming from where they were worshipped
The only part that is dubious is the Odin part imo, since Odin's horse Sleipnir couldn't fly, and there's established stories separate from anything related to paganism (mostly fairy tales made in the medieval to early modern period) that have Saint Nicholas ride a reindeer that flies.
One of Odin's epithets (divine titles) was 'Jolnir' which could mean 'the Yule one' and the Yule festival of the Germanic peoples did provide much of the aesthetics we commonly associate with Christmas so there's that
*Come join us at OSP! In this one video about Santa, we have:* -St Nick being tortured -Santa punching an alleged heretic in the face (it's a meme, you had to be there) -Martin Luther (debatably) being a killjoy -Very unjolly Black Face -Santa helping the troops end slavery in the Civil War *I mean what else could you ask for? This is the true spirit of Christmas right here!*
A note about "Blackface Piet" in the Netherlands Sinterklaas celebration, the last few years there has been a shift happening as we shift away from the black Piet to a Piet with colourful (blue/red/yellow/etc) face paint or a few smudges of brown/soot (as in the story Piet comes down chimneys). This shift is happening slowly but as far as i know, the national arival of Sinterklaas, his arrival in all major cities and also his arrival in almost all villages is now done with a soot or colorpaint piet, there are still black piet around but it becomes less and less every year. (But as you can see from the expected replies it is still a somewhat contentious topic under certain groups)
Not gonna work in the long run. The pure black made them unrecognisable to kids, now it's clearly just your aunt with some smudges on her. Better to reinvent the character entirely in that case.
Kinda, the story about the soot Piets is that it is the everyday man/woman who volunteers to help sinterklaas and the soot is gained from them training. So them being recognizable somewhat makes sense.
Only state sponsored politically correct one on TV. Everywhere else in the country the tradition (rightfully) remains. Don't mess with things you do not understand, especially not things as sacred as your own culture passed down to you from your ancestors. If you ARE going to mess with it, you better know exactly all the ins and outs and hows and whys.
@@Lilliathi Black pete has always been sootblack. What he wasn't always, was an African. I'm all about going back to just a black face and some wild animal skins and chains and bells and a rod. Make him look like a bear or a wolf or something.
Darn. I was hoping for a summary of The Nutcracker. Not the ballet, the actual story the ballet is based on. Seems perfect for Red's treatment. And then Blue could have done a vid on Hoffman. Oh well, there will be other years, and this is a good pick for Christmas, too.
Hiya! I just wanted to say that OSP got me this year to actually appreciate christmas. I never got into the cynical capitalist viewpoint, but I do have the SAD thing. It angered me that I felt obligated to be happy when I was not; it felt artificial, fake, forced. But you guys helped me changing that perspective. I've never felt like a part of my family and always felt really alone in these days. But this time I'll just be happy for the heck of it. I'll celebrate being with my family, as fractured as it is , and as not-so-understanding as they are. My mom and dad at least is trying to, and that is enough for me this year. So, thank you OSP. I am excited and feel more festive. Thank you for helping me, literally, understand christmas. Thank you so much.
As a random person on the internet, I wish that the happiness will last and return again and again where needed, for both you and your loved ones. Happy holidays, and may the new year bring good tidings.
Here where I live Santa is a rather recent addition. We have the Three Wise Men/Kings who bring presents on the 6th of January. And for Christmas itself we have the "Tió de Nadal" (Christmas Log), which is a log with a face painted one and sometimes legs that comes to your house at the start of December. You feed it everyday until Christmas and then the children hit its back with sticks to have it poop out presents, traditionally sweets.
about the blackface character, he's called Black Pete and the current story is that he was supposed to be a slave that Sinterklaas bought to free, but pete wanted to stay with him and help out. Why there are multiples is a mystery, but I guess saint nick is the patron saint of cloning tech. Before that there was a lineage of various black-faced bogeymen that was the punishing side to the festival's charity and further back the blackness was just a part of throwing all kinds of shit on yourself like soot, chains, bells, furs, and whatnot to scare children. A different permutation of the same character ended up as Krampus, but generally the modern audience has a more negative response to a blackface character as opposed to an edgy furry.
Or like something that belongs on a death metal album cover. I will always think of Krampus with this exchange in the Venture Brothers Christmas episode: Dr. Venture: "What the hell kind of kinky Christmas spirit is that?!" Dr. Orpheus: "Well, it is Germanic in origin."
The slave part simply isn't true. The bells and soot definitely is. In its current form yes, black pete is dressed up as an African, but not a slave. He is a Moor! However originally this was not the case. It was, as you said, just a completely sooted face, some cowbells and chains and a rod to spank the girls with. Nothing to do with Africans as the tradition predates our first interaction with Africans.
That dedication at the end hit me right in the heart, especially as I also had a grandfather I truly admired that was named after Saint Nicholas. Hope your Yule was lovely, and may good fortune come your way in 2023!
I feel like this was a missed opportunity to spawn a new series called "Christmas-Makers" that would magically find its way into our notifications every year =p Great video though!
“Does that make Luther a killjoy?” Yes. I knew that the Protestant Reformation did do things like outlaw plays, but I didn’t know that it did outlaw the St. Nick in Christmas.
Sinterklaas actually doesn't have much to do with Christmas besides being celebrated in December. Festivities usually start in November and end on the evening of December fifth. Christmas comes afterwards on the twenty-fifth and twenty-sixth with less focus on gifts and more on family.
@@willemketelaars4342 Except that the video is insisting that St Nicholas and Christmas being associated with one another has it's origins in Europe while it is actuallyh a completely novel modern American only invention.
The reason behind the pieten (black assistants) was one legend of him saving several coloured children from slavery and giving them jobs, which was then translated into 'He saves people from slavery who assist him out of gratitude/as a job' during the 1800's if I remember correctly
My family is basically half catholic, half protestant, so on Christmas Eve my parents told me that both Santa Claus and baby Jesus (“Christkind”) were coming, basically working together. Here in Germany we have also have „Nikolaustag” on December the 6., and usually kids will get like a small present as well as a stocking full of nuts, sweets and fruit (often mandarins).
In Greece instead of St Nicholas, it is St Basil the Great of Caesaria who brings gifts to children on St Basil's day at the 1st of January. A devout philanthropist, he donated all of his fortune to the poor and built a city, Basileiad, which was used as a poorhouse, hospital, and hospice. It is traditional on St Basil's Day to serve vasilopita, a rich bread baked with a coin inside. The tradition is attributed to St. Basil, who when a bishop, wanted to distribute money to the poor and commissioned some women to bake sweetened bread, in which he arranged to place gold coins. Thus the families in cutting the bread were pleasantly surprised to find the coins. St Basil the great truly was great!
YESSSS!!! Dutch history made it into one of your video's!!!! I'm so happy! Belgium and the Netherlands are some of the most interesting countries in Europe, but not many people outside the dutch-speaking world seem to know. As for why we have Zwarte Piet (now usually Roetveegpiet): we've begun questioning it as well. It's one of those angry political debates that comes around each year around november/december.
I have a question, because I want to learn more about Dutch speaking areas. Do they speak Dutch or French in Belgium, or something else? And are there any good source books available in English in US that one can find to learn more about the history?
@@Levsa399 Hahaha, oh boy... Belgium is the most complicated country in the world. I live there and I barely understand how it works. What I can say is that Belgium consists of a few different parts. The northern half is called Flanders, that's where I live. In Flanders, we only speak (our version of) Dutch. We're pretty good at English and, supposedly, French, but Flemings hate French for numerous reasons that are hard to explain in a RUclips comment. The southern half of the country is called Wallonia (I think). Most people there speak French, but there's a little German-speaking community in the very east that we "acquired" in the aftermath of one of the two World Wars. Our capital city, Brussels, is bilingual in name, but nearly every language known to man is spoken there and the lingua franca is French. With 20+ languages, 4 governments and 19 mayors, Brussels is by far the most complicated city I have ever heard of. I'm actually not familiar with the English literature on Dutch and Belgian history, but I suspect it won't be hard to find a good starting point via Wikipedia or Google. I'm super glad you're interested! Are you familiar with/interested in the language? Or do you primarily enjoy the historical aspect?
Resident Dutchman here! Very much appreciating the little tangent about Sinterklaas. That's a thing honestly deserving its own video. On the note of the blackface thing: they were originally meant to be soot stains from jumping down and climbing up a bunch of chimneys to deliver all those gifts. Somewhere along the lines that got turned into "just paint the whole face black" however. Probably because it was easier and more recognizable on TV than some spots. The connection with blackface is (at least in my experience) a more recent connection that some people have latched onto in protest. A lot of these people take it too far however and call for just ditching the celebration in its entirety over this. We're quickly transitioning Black Pete over into Pete with soot stains however, so the whole thing is becoming a non-issue. Sinterklaas also has dope candy. I mean, chocolate letters yo! Look em up, they're excellent. Also, Slash is Sinterklaas and one of our parents in disguise.
I married a Byzantine Catholic, and for them St. Nick is kinda a huge deal. I did have a priest once insist that as a baby St. Nick refused to breastfeed during Lent because it was dairy. 😶
Blue I don't know how to tell you this but Sinterklaas is celebrated dec 5th- so as much as I appreciate the "merry Sinterklaasfeest" I do feel the need to point that out 8'D Does this mean the Netherlands gets _two_ holidays featuring different incarnations of the same guy? Yes. Yes it does.
As someone from Belgium, aka one of the low countries where we celebrate Sinterklaas I can gladly tell you that after a lot of anoying "but our traditions" from certain parts of the population the whole blackface thing was replaced with just some smears of soot on the faces of the helpers, supposedly from coming down the chimney.
It's still receiving a lot of pushback, unfortunately, with such totally not in bad faith arguments such as 'they got their blackface, makeup and golden jewelry from going down the chimney' and 'but it's for kids so it's ok to teach them that black people are servants who will kidnap them if they're naughty'.
@@r31n0ut Dat komt omdat het zwarte gezicht juist één der oudste delen van de traditie is. De oorbellen, kroeshaar, rode lippen en het stomme pakje, NIET. Of anders gezegd, het zwarte gezicht heeft VAN OORSPRONG geen donder te maken met Afrikanen. Dus zou liever zien dat het zwarte gezicht blijft en alle andere onzin weggaat. Verder is het van oorsprong ook helemaal geen kinderfeest. De kinderen werd juist de stuipen op 't lijf gejaagd door de zwarte pieten. En in alleroudste vorm waren het jonge ongetrouwde mannen die in de nacht jonge ongetrouwde meiden achterna gingen.
Great video as always, I'm happy to see someone dispel, even indirectly, the common urban legend that our modern image of Santa Claus was codified by Coca-Cola. Bearded fat man in red was already established canon by then!!
@@Karak-_- I know his colors did vary for some time, but by the 1930s depictions of Santa in advertising and illustration overwhelmingly used red. Seeing as some of the most famous pre-30s Santa's were shown in red, ie Nast's cartoons and Baum's children's novel, I feel confident saying that coca cola's ads were much more reactions to existing trends than they were trendsetters.
Happy to see a history on a bit of Dutch culture of one of the few feast we have over here. Sinterklaas may not be celebrated by all but I'm still happy that its there for us all here in the small land of the Nederland's. Wish you all people a warm merry Christmas.
As someone from Belgium, very happy to see representation of a tradition of ours! Luckily, the whole "blackface" thing is being slowly erased out. Currently, the compromise is that they just have dirty smears from chimney ashes xD Still, a magical tradition I'm happy to see in one of your videos!
Happy holidays you guys!! Hope everyone in the rainbow family is safe and healthy and has a great time spending time with family and friends and history textbooks lol
My favorite story about Santa is lesser known tale about when a freak meteor hit Santa's sleigh, splitting in in two. In that moment he turned to his helper Elfin Skywalker and uttered his famous phrase: "Not to worry! We are still flying half a sleigh!" He then carried on delivering presents with a jolly laugh, greeting the good people with a "Ho Ho Ho There!" I just find this story so relatable for some odd reason. Perhaps is the impressive beard? Or maybe it's Santa indisputable dominion over the (latitudinal) High Ground in the North Pole? Who can really say...
Now you're making me imagine a Star Wars planet based on the Netherlands where Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piet have lightsabers based on the former's bishop staff, and the latter's collection of thin sticks.
Now that you brought it up, I’d love to see a video on the translation of saintly relics. As someone who wrote about it for their undergrad dissertation (with Saint Nicholas of Myra as a key figure of study at that) I think it’s a subject right up the alley of this channel!
5:39 it’s supposed to be ash from going down the chimney but recently theyv’e changement it to coloured paint to avoid the people protesting against it
Saint Nicolas is the patron of my hometown, so around December many festivités are dedicated to him. It’s so cool, it’s like you have double Santa for the end of the year
On the way to a Passover Seder the night before Easter with my interfaith family. My 5 year old daughter: "Is this the one where all the babies die or the one where they nail the guy to wood?" Me: "Um... never thought of it like that. But this is the one where the babies die. Tomorrow they nail the guy to wood."
"A Visit from St. Nicholas" was originally published anonymously in the upstate NY newspaper The Troy Sentinel. The newspaper doesn't exist anymore, but the building still has a plaque outside memorializing the poem.
I like that you mentioned that there's elements of the Wild Hunt in the Santa mythos. This is actually something I first realized while watching Red's Halloween video on the Wild Hunt a couple years ago.
in greece we use the modern imagery of santa claus, we call him Αη Βασιλή which is Basil of Caesarea. I don't remember the story by heart, but he was supposedly very generous and gave as gifts things that were donating to him or something like that. I will let someone else say the correct answer as an answer, because I am a lazy hack.
I always did wonder how my brother’s namesake did become the face of Coca-Cola in December, and now I know why! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to all!
5:30. The simple explanation is ashes and soot. These helpers klimbed through the chimney of houses and (apparently) they did not see fit to clean up afterwards. We changed it up now, witch is nice.
My condolences for your grandfather Blue. It sounds like he was a good man. Side note, isn't it odd how some people who were named after Saints end up taking saintly characteristics? My name is actually Joel, and I'm a little afraid of it, since Joel was the one who prophesied the plagues. Don't let me preach doom and gloom! And merry Christmas to all!
5:40 because it was convenient, the story of them being like that from being covered in soot was a perfect way to make kids not question it and avoid them coming to the realisation that the pragmatic reason behind it was to disguise the fact that their gift bringing visitor was, in fact, their neighbour/uncle/family friend.
1) Sorry to hear about your grandfather, I hope you are okay. 2) After all this time we spent as Byzantines making the Sailor Protector (Queen Beryl will never return, why is there no rabbit in the story?) really really important (any greek based empire will be maritime), why do Greek Orthodox have St. Basil deliver gifts on January 1st? 3) And starting on 2021, the dutch can enjoy the best Santa Claus permutation so far: Vader Johan.
As a Dutchie, I picked up some interesting trivia about the Sinterklaas tradition through this video. Cool to see it covered! Kudos for your pronounciation of the name, by the way, I was all too prepared to see you stumble through it but the quality is there as much as it has always has been - Shouldn't have expected otherwise.
How does Odin even fit into the inspiration for Santa Claus? Sure, there is the sled/deer/horse thing, but the wildhunt has nothing to do with Christmas as far as I know. Saint Nicholas fits more for the inspiration with his giving of gifts.
I remember la fête de St. Nicolas at my French preschool. We all went into the gymnasium and a guy dressed as St. Nicolas gave us all oranges. It was bizarre.
That has been part of the sinterklaas celebration in the Netherlands as well but nowadays it is mostly "Kruidnoten" & "Chocolate letter", look it up if you want, they are great.
While Sinterklaas is the most popular gift giving saint in the Low countries, there are a few parts of Flanders who celebrate Saint Martin (a dude who allegedly cut his own cloak in half so he could give it to a freezing beggar) instead. The feast is held in early november instead of december and the kids go around singing and receiving gifts.
There is a reason why Sinterklaas is on the 5th of December in the Netherlands and in Belgium the 6th. So that he has a night to travel to Belgium after his night of giving gifts to kids.
There's plenty more to unpack with the history and modern reception of the character of Zwarte Piet - seeing as that wasn't the point of this video, I figured it was best to avoid the tangent.
But interestingly enough, Dutch culture is currently reimagining the character to be less... well, less of a deliberately racist caricature. New interpretations include "Rainbow Pete" and "Sooty Pete", and they have their own nuances and difficulties as well - but it's worth the investigation if you're curious, because it really is fascinating to see cultural innovation in real time! This is the stuff we talk about happening hundreds of years ago, but this one is happening now!!
Anyway Merry Crimbis and stuff, don't get punched by a saint.
-B
And please take into consideration that there are many.. many!! More views about zwarte Piet then being a racist leftover of colonial past! I lived all around the wordt but only in the US the Media outrage was considering it racist to black people. Then it spread to the eu and worldwide
As a European I’m truly shocked about the “political” wrong and disinformed statements come from the USA
What if the Saint punching is consensual and reciprocal
Merry Hogswatch Red, Blue, Cyan, Indigo and all other color related family
In Germany we have a card game called Schwarzer Peter meaning exactly the same as Zwarte Piet (Black Pete), which is about avoiding being the last player to have the Black Pete card in your hand. Old versions of the game depict Black Pete as a stereotypical black person, but it has since shifted toward depicting him as a chimney sweep. I wonder if there's some kind of larger identity to Black Pete?
Thank you for including that note! If you ask most people who grew up with Zwarte Piet, they'll tell you that they never thought he was actually black, because as children, we're told stories that Black Pete comes through the chimney, ending up being completely covered in soot, but that doesn't take away the fact that he looks quite literally like a deliberate racist caricature, nor the fact that he first appears in Dutch children's literature around 1850 as an actual black man; it just means that over the years, adults have changed the explanation that they give to their children about why Black Pete is so dark (as far as I can tell, it was probably because the black makeup used for Zwarte Piet was much darker than the natural skin colour of actual black people. Even though the makeup became lighter later, the explanation stayed). It's a tradition that is thankfully changing now.
‘Stealth charity’ is probably one of the most threatening ways I’ve heard anyone describe Santa while still remaining somewhat wholesome
The words "stealth charity" make me think of someone creeping up on a homeless person and dropping a bag of money at his/her feet, with a vaguely threatening note saying, "Here's a thousand dollars-- take it or else." 😀
@@BennyLlama39 Now I'm just imagining a dude who looks like Joe Pesci, well-dressed yet still sinister, visiting the homeless to deliver food and clothing with genuine kindness at heart, while accompanied by a number of hulking, scowling, scarred-up thug types who clean their fingernails with switchblades while making uncomfortably prolonged eye contact.
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND Now I'm imagining Solid Snake with a cardboard box full of presents.
@@louisduarte8763 there was a freeware game from a long time ago called Merry Gear Solid that you might like.
Could also consider it an "anonymous donation", which isn't technically far off if we consider Santa a pseudonym.
Remember, kids: When throwing gifts of gold through the window, be sure not to smack the recipient in the face. Gold is _heavy,_ that sh*t hurts.
Unless they're a non-trinitarian, then go wild.
Remember: _gold is about 20 times denser than duck._
@@widmo206 Which means it’s not a witch
If you can dodge a sack of gold. . .
Yup
And then Saint Nicolas and Odin did the fusion dance, but due to their vastly different power level, the result of the transformation came out weird and thus Santa was born.
You're out of line but you're not wrong
I both hate and love this.
But I think it's more if a potara fusion. (their clothes also fused)
Is there an actual historical source for this/
@@stephengray1344 yeah i was there
Yes Odin couldn't dream to match THE POWER OF GOD.
Sidenote, St. Nick in his original form is celebrated on December 6th in most predominantly catholic countries. In Austria (and Bavaria) he is in the company of not-black-face devil "Krampus" to also judge who's naughty and who's nice. Funnily enough, even though we were never protestant here, in Austria Jesus himself is bringing the presents, while in Germany you got Santa Claus (although often called Weihnachtsmann with no specific name given, although it has of course started to get mixed up with the American Santa Claus so... full circe)
In Poland, also, Saint Nicholas (Święty Mikołaj) is celebrated on December 6th, and on that day he brings candy to children. December 6th is also the name day for people named "Mikołaj" (a name day is the veneration day for the Saint after which the person is named, often connected to the date they were martyred, or held to have been martyred in Catholic & Orthodox tradition). This particular name day happens to fall on the same date for Orthodox & Catholics (they often differ, and some Saints in one have no counterpart in the other). I know all this since I'm a Nicholas born in Greece and living in Poland ;-)
And in the Netherlands Sinterklaas is celebrated on Saint Nick's Eve (which, like many such Eves is the evening before the day, aka Dec 5th)
Was about to add this in my own comment, as it's one of the few "old world" holidays I know about. My Oma was Lutheran (mostly?) but she absolutely adored St. Nicholas day, which for her always involved making up a huge batch of thumbprint cookies - something she ONLY ever did for this holiday. She'd talk about all the winter festivals from back in Germany too, sometimes telling various Christmas stories that she'd picked up when living in southern Germany. So, 6 December is a day with lots of good memories for me, and St. Nicholas is a figure that I knew a tiny bit about already, hehe
Fascinating to learn more from this!
In Germany you also have baby Jesus bringing presents, I think it's a regional thing ^^
Edit: I really should know better by now than to interact with comments before finishing the video. Revised:
While the name Christkind stuck and thus confusingly still implies it being Baby Jesus, Luther et al. quickly changed it to officially being an (at least nowadays usually blond and feminine) angel. It is the height of irony that the Christkind survived in majority Catholic regions, while otherwise fiercely anti-saints majority Protestant countries moved St. Nicholas to Christmas (and then popularized this around the globe through the power of US consumerism). And the saints traditionally in charge of delivering presents to children in Orthodox Christianity as well as Iberia and thus Hispanic countries are the Three Wise Men/Kings on Epiphany on January 6.
As for your description of Austria, yes, the Christkind delivers presents on Christmas (Eve), with many people endlessly whining about the growing popularity of the Weihnachtsmann due to US media. But children still get sweets and (small) presents on St. Nicholas's, complete with (usually) men dressed up like him (and Krampus, but he's often cut now as being too scary) visiting elementary schools. And up until a few decades ago, they got as much on December 6th or even more than on the 24th. (This shift is also mirrored in birthdays replacing name days in importance for tangentially related reasons.)
Also, we absolutely were Protestant. The Reformation spread across Austria like wildfire until it got brutally beaten back by the Catholic Counter-Reformation.
My favourite version of the St. Nick punching a heretic legend has him beat the guy so hard that Mary and Gabriel had to come down to restrain him.
"NICK HE'S DOWN, YOU MADE YOUR POINT! CHILL DUDE! YOU WON!" - Gabriel attempting to restrain St. Nicholas
@@gasmasker7409 "Nah there's 3 rounds in a boxing match just like there's 3 aspects in 1 trinity! Get up you heretic!"
Nicholas: "Tag in Krampus!'
Krampus: hops the rope and proceeds to execute a German suplex on heretic
And thus was Boxing Day added to the Christmas festivities, in honour of that crazy trinitarian Bishop
Stealth charity sounds like a skill check for a paladin/rogue class combo, which I believe sums up St Nick
Which fits, since, among other things, he is the patron Saint of repentant thieves.
I'm now imagining the smite as burning coal
This was quite interesting and I liked how you included Sinterklaas
who knew that throwing gold in poeples homes is now throwing (pepernoten in engels) on the streets
At least there was a shot of the non-blackface Pieten
@@Rutgerman95 why are you happy about that? Truly interrested!
@@rnanni1048 He is being positive.
@@rnanni1048 Because no matter how much we've modernized the context it doesn't change that the old make-up looks like an old offensive stereotype. So happy we're moving on from that.
"our favorite sleigh-riding home intruder" LOVE IT!
That time of year when a jolly prowler breaks into your house, and leaves gifts. Like a genie.
The best story of Santa Claus that I found out recently is that he apparently delivers a lump of coal personally to Darkseid from the DC universe each year. Just walks straight up to Darkseid, tells him he has been naughty, hands him the coal, and laughs as he evades all of their defenses.
Good grief.
I’m a Catholic, so while I grew up with all the standard Santa Clause iconography, I also was told of Saint Nicholas.
Best of both worlds
Same here! I always love telling people who said that "Santa isn't real" and pointing out about Saint Nicholas. Merry Christmas, my guy.
Bonus points if your parents put stuff in your shoes on Saint Nick’s day
Did you also had the story of the wizard kings who visited jesus?
Living close to the dutch border, we have
-St. Nicholas on dec 6th,
-the mentioned before baby jesus that brings presents on christmas eve,
-AND, due to media-globalisation, the Americanised version of Santa that we literally call "christmas man".
Really looking forward to explain that mess to my children in a couple of years.
Where I am from they are seperat entities too
as someone from the Netherlands, I see sinterklaasavond as the time for gift giving and being with close famliy/freinds, and christmas as the time for being with and eating with the whole family (aunts, uncles, cousins etc). Both are really fun
Same thing here!
sinterklaas is for het gezin, parents and kids, maybe grandparents, while christmas is for the whole family.
(it's so odd that english doesn't have a word for gezin)
@@vinx.9099 im guessing but i think we use "immediate family" for that
Same here. Presents are for Sinterklaas, family and eating are for Christmas.
As a child I was always confused and didn’t get why Sinterklaas came to America on Christmas and not December 5th. Only later I realised they are two different characters
@@vinx.9099 I dunno, it seems to be in the translation dictionary. They define it as "household," that is, your immediate family that you live with.
It's nice to see that something meant to be a children's story character did truly have humble origins to inspire people to be selfless.
After the past two years, it is still good to remember that people can still do good.
(Even with our memeable shortcomings like punching a heretic in the face)
Merry Christmas/Happy Holidays to all! 🎄
Punching a heretic in the face isn't a bug, it's a feature! :)
You too!
A joyous yuletide to you, as well!
Exactly. All joking aside, that is actually a really good thing to keep in mind for Christmas:
- Instead of just decorating and giving gifts to family members, do some charity work for those in need. Or better yet, call distant and close friends that have nowhere to go and invite them to celebrate with you. One of the best gifts you can give someone is a helping hand and some kindness.
- Also remember, if you pull away some of the G-rated stuff, Jesus's birth is not a pretty story: an unwed, pregnant teen travels by donkey with her spouse 90 miles to complete a census that will not help them but will just allow the imperial government to control them better. When they finally get there, she goes into labor and yet every single establishment cannot to house them. So, they are offered to rest and give birth in a stable, which is not at all sanitary. And when The Son of Man finally arrives, He is placed where animals eat. Imagine being so poor that you can't even afford a bed for your baby. Then, He is not visited by a Pharisee or Zealot, but by three astrologers from faraway lands and shepherds, who were seen as outcasts and also would not be welcomed in town. So, even though it is still a Holiday full of cheer and gift-giving and decorating, it should also be a holiday of action against the cruelty of the world around us.
He has a list, he's checking it twice, he knows who's been naughty and nice, and he's coming to town. Wait I'm thinking of Sulla.
Nice
Here in Belgium they would have a guy disguised in Saint Nicholas and come in schools to give oranges, candy, and speculoos (and actual gifts if you're lucky). Speculoos are biscuits and often people give Saint Nicholas shaped speculoos to kids. Speculoos are delicious
speculoos? you mean speculaas? speculoos is a brand name for a spread for on bread that is made to taste like speculaas.
@@sogghartha ye speculoos is the brand idd, but I also mess it up despite being flemish (I'm sure the company picked that name on purpouse xD)
and an accurate transulation/explanation to english seems to be spiced bisquit
Same here in Germany, although instead of Speculaas, I think nuts, specifically peanuts, are more common alongside chocolate and oranges/tangerines.
Also yeah, Speculaas are delicious, especially the spicy ones.
@@sogghartha Iirc 'Speculoos' and 'Speculaas' are very similar, but different products. 'Speculaas' is more common in the Netherlands, as it is made with 'speculaas'-spices (colonialism ahoy), hence the name. Belgium didn't really have a steady supply of those, so over time making something that tastes similar, but doesn't contain the spices, they created speculoos (basically, 'speculaas-loos', as in without speculaas-spices).
That spread is a fairly recent Belgian invention based on speculoos-biscuits.
All my speculaas is gone by now, I must not have had a lot of sesfcontrole
For a bit of context on the zwarte Piet/black Pete thing:
The original explanation for them painted them as enslaved Moor (ethnicity from south Marocco) sailors which saint Nick had help free in the past; depending on the version of the story you're dealing with, they were either so thankful that they swore to aid him in all his endavours henceforth or Nick realised that, if freed, they would soon be recaptured and thus decided to employ them all on the spot.
As their job involved going up and down chimneys to delived gifts, the story goes on to say the soot covered them from head to toe, turning them black (colour not race). Some speculate that this may be a reference to either Odin's or Wodan's ravens.
The most common depicting of zwarte Piet was originally just people who were covered in soot or dirt, although rarer depictions as african people did also exist. This state lasted until about the 50s, when the holiday got more commercialised and companies figured selling products depicting dirty people would be harder than those featuring black people. The frizzy hair, bright red lips, golden earrings and silly suit are also all the invention of these companies.
A few years back the semblance to slavery was first called out and lead to a yearly controversy... until covid hit. An after effect of this was the replacement of black Pete by white Pete, rainbow Petes, or soot-smear Pete (which people funnily enough thought to be an amazing and new middle ground) in many, but not all places.
The thing is the lips and the accessories play so hard to the racist depictions that it’s hard for an outsider like me to see something other. Maybe they should go back to soot and make that clearer
@@elif6908 They already have. When people dress up nowadays they put black smears across the face rather than completely painting it. It's kinda weird how the story that was told and the aesthetic were always strangely disconnected in this way.
no, this is false. zwarte piet was a black person right from the start, old poems explicitly describe him as a n*gro. the whole idea that he was an evolution of the ravens of odin, or that it had to do with soot, was made up after black Dutch people started being more vocal against blackface.
I'm glad someone else brought up the fact that wasn't blackface. I love a lot of what Red and Blue do, but they really need to stop projecting their American Left sensibilities onto other cultures. Not everyone wants to deal with the Yank's politics...
@@sogghartha You do realize "negro" isn't a bad word, right? It literally just means black in many languages.
“The giver of every good and perfect gift has called upon us to mimic
His giving, by grace, through faith, and this is not of ourselves.”
― St. Nicholas of Myra
Philosophy that even the Addams Family abides by.
"As we celebrate the year-end holiday of Saturnalia - wait, no - Yule! Agh no come on which one is it - Christmas? CHRISTMAS, that one - they all just blend together."
It's okay, Blue, all immortal beings who have been around for over two hundred years slip up sometimes.
imagine being an immortal historian being in an argument with a fellow scholar trying barely holding in your identity and weighing if proving the other person wrong is worth outing yourself (the answer is yes).
@@gohanr1271 Reminds me of a scene from Speaker for the Dead (sequel to Ender's game) where Ender is still alive about a thousand years later thanks to traveling by their version of hyperspeed and is currently working as a school teacher. He is teaching about himself and the Formics (aliens that he and humanity killed) and is forced to deal with a bunch of brats that talk about how much of a monster he was and that they would have of course loved the Formics and made peace with them. It seems to have gotten lost in history that the Formics had already invaded Earth twice and humanity had no way of knowing that the Formics weren't planning a third (they realized they were attacking fellow sentient beings and were horrified at what they had done) when humanity launched a counterstrike.
St Nicholas celebration are long over though, it is celebrated on the 5th or 6th of december and does not have anything to do with Christmas.
As someone who lives in The Netherlands and loves the Sinterklaas festivals, I’m happy to see it getting some attention! The whole vibe around Sinterklaas is simply amazing and even a bit magical. It always make me happy to see hundreds and hundreds of children gathered at the port so see the old man arrive. Heck, we even have a special program that reports on the daily life of Sinterklaas and it’s…. eh, it makes some weird decisions sometimes.
Oh and for anyone wondering how it went this year: they basically scared the crap out of 1.6 million children. Pretty funny.
Anyway, I love Sinterklaas and the whole (not questionable and controversial) part of the festival and 5 December is always a good day here. If anyone in the comment has any questions about the festival and it’s old man on a horse, just ask! I will answer gladly.
Hehe, as another Dutch person. I agree. Ask away! As long as its not asking about the rage we tossed on half the picture
Sinterklaasjournaal is amazing, the trauma they dispense builds character
How do you all feel about Zwarte Piet? An old dutch friend, felt deeply uncomfortable about him. I'm genuinely wondering how he reads overall as Black European.
@@Firegen1 he's a subject that's being phased out and we can move on from since we have Roetveeg Piet now
@@Firegen1 most people i know dont feel any shame at all... the stort we learn here is the’re black because they Climb through the chimny. Its American media that is playing the racist card on them, Sadly.... and uninformed...
St. Nicholas is one of the most beloved saints of Orthodoxy! St. Nicholas Day is sometimes more popular than Christmas from what I’ve experienced. Thanks for the video!
The (Orthodox) church I grew up in would have St. Nicholas (in full bishop's garb) visit on his feast day every year. Kids would then bring up toys to give to the local shelter.
@@cloudkitt Haha, my home parish does something similar as well! :)
Shoves all winter religious festivals into a blender. Sprinkles on flakes of Late Stage Capitalism, and proceeds to slurps the slurry we call... Christmas! 🎄
Minus the Late Stage Capitalism, which is abhorrent, that was the typical Eastern Christian way of doing things for a millennia. Rather than looking to destroy local cultures, most Christian evangelists in that time tried to tie in the local cultural heritage of their audience to show that Christ, being the True Wisdom, was the completion of the worldly wisdoms and religions that already existed. A much cooler approach to the later approaches by the Catholics (Latinize everything) or the Protestants (colonialism), from my biased perspective.
The Capitalism part was all America's fault. Curse you Coca Cola!!!
@@adamkimara6919 *happy nordic noises*
Colonialism or not, we kept most of the good traditions, frankly ending slavery and human sacrifice uh...seems like a pretty progressive thing, then again...nordic... 🥳
@@Elenrai I meant more of the phenomena of Western European Protestants trying to spread the religion through the colonizing of other countries, particularly in Africa and Southeast Asia. Though in hindsight the way I wrote was likely a bit more polemical than I should have haha. I love all the Nordic Christmas traditions I’ve seen!
In short: Americanized
I so hope there would be an episode on the monsters of Christmas(Krampus, Yule cat, etc)
_Krampus wants to know your location_
I still love how varied Saint Nicholas' entourage is depending on where you go - in the Netherlands he's accompanied by black caricatures, in the southern Germanic-speaking areas he's got a demon who eats naughty children at his beck and call.... and in North Germany he's accompanied by a dude who'll beat you with a rod.
@@TitanDarwin ... North Germany has no concept of chill, does it?
@@simonschnedl *Krampus already knows your location*
Krampus isn't actually assicated with Christmas. Only to Americans.
Now I'm imagining a man enjoying Christmas with his family. The joy interrupted by the sound of breaking glass. Next to a broken window they see a brick with a note tied to it. "Merry Christmas," it says. The brick is solid gold.
Imagine of this video was a collab between OSP and Puppet Hisyory considering the latter did a Saint Nicholas episode back in 2020 of I remember correctly
saint nicholas killed--i mean saved--the pickle boys!
An OSP/Puppet History collab would be amazing
Thanks Blue, Merry Christmas to you too!
"Here's a secret for you: I don't care." Not a secret, Blue.
Also, my third sold story was about how a guy with the same name and the same area is thought to be Santa, and some idiots try to break into his workshop/stash. He's not, and his wife (and the reason he's still alive a thousand years later) is a fay ice queen. Big mistake...
Sinterklaas being part Odin was not the information I expected but I'm here for it
yes and no
its more likely part the god Wodan but Wodan and Odin are mostly the same god with most of the differences coming from where they were worshipped
The only part that is dubious is the Odin part imo, since Odin's horse Sleipnir couldn't fly, and there's established stories separate from anything related to paganism (mostly fairy tales made in the medieval to early modern period) that have Saint Nicholas ride a reindeer that flies.
@@Kristiano100 yes but later germanic mythology places Odin/Wodan as the leader of the flying Wild Hunt, as mentioned in the video
One of Odin's epithets (divine titles) was 'Jolnir' which could mean 'the Yule one' and the Yule festival of the Germanic peoples did provide much of the aesthetics we commonly associate with Christmas so there's that
@@manmoy4104 Do you have any evidence that any of our current Christmas aesthetics actually come from Yule?
*Come join us at OSP! In this one video about Santa, we have:*
-St Nick being tortured
-Santa punching an alleged heretic in the face (it's a meme, you had to be there)
-Martin Luther (debatably) being a killjoy
-Very unjolly Black Face
-Santa helping the troops end slavery in the Civil War
*I mean what else could you ask for? This is the true spirit of Christmas right here!*
Hello there
A note about "Blackface Piet" in the Netherlands Sinterklaas celebration, the last few years there has been a shift happening as we shift away from the black Piet to a Piet with colourful (blue/red/yellow/etc) face paint or a few smudges of brown/soot (as in the story Piet comes down chimneys).
This shift is happening slowly but as far as i know, the national arival of Sinterklaas, his arrival in all major cities and also his arrival in almost all villages is now done with a soot or colorpaint piet, there are still black piet around but it becomes less and less every year.
(But as you can see from the expected replies it is still a somewhat contentious topic under certain groups)
Not gonna work in the long run. The pure black made them unrecognisable to kids, now it's clearly just your aunt with some smudges on her. Better to reinvent the character entirely in that case.
Kinda, the story about the soot Piets is that it is the everyday man/woman who volunteers to help sinterklaas and the soot is gained from them training.
So them being recognizable somewhat makes sense.
Only state sponsored politically correct one on TV. Everywhere else in the country the tradition (rightfully) remains.
Don't mess with things you do not understand, especially not things as sacred as your own culture passed down to you from your ancestors.
If you ARE going to mess with it, you better know exactly all the ins and outs and hows and whys.
@@Lilliathi Black pete has always been sootblack. What he wasn't always, was an African. I'm all about going back to just a black face and some wild animal skins and chains and bells and a rod. Make him look like a bear or a wolf or something.
Darn. I was hoping for a summary of The Nutcracker. Not the ballet, the actual story the ballet is based on. Seems perfect for Red's treatment. And then Blue could have done a vid on Hoffman. Oh well, there will be other years, and this is a good pick for Christmas, too.
Yes please!
Hiya! I just wanted to say that OSP got me this year to actually appreciate christmas. I never got into the cynical capitalist viewpoint, but I do have the SAD thing. It angered me that I felt obligated to be happy when I was not; it felt artificial, fake, forced. But you guys helped me changing that perspective.
I've never felt like a part of my family and always felt really alone in these days. But this time I'll just be happy for the heck of it. I'll celebrate being with my family, as fractured as it is , and as not-so-understanding as they are. My mom and dad at least is trying to, and that is enough for me this year.
So, thank you OSP. I am excited and feel more festive. Thank you for helping me, literally, understand christmas. Thank you so much.
As a random person on the internet, I wish that the happiness will last and return again and again where needed, for both you and your loved ones.
Happy holidays, and may the new year bring good tidings.
_"Here's a secret for you: _*_I don't care!"_*
This is why I love this channel.
Sorry for your loss, Blue. May his memory be a blessing. Thanks for the rad video.
Merry Christmas Blue, and Happy Hanukkah (and Christmas) to you Red!
The story of St. Nick resurcting the dead children is sort of metal, and a favorite.
Here where I live Santa is a rather recent addition. We have the Three Wise Men/Kings who bring presents on the 6th of January. And for Christmas itself we have the "Tió de Nadal" (Christmas Log), which is a log with a face painted one and sometimes legs that comes to your house at the start of December. You feed it everyday until Christmas and then the children hit its back with sticks to have it poop out presents, traditionally sweets.
about the blackface character, he's called Black Pete and the current story is that he was supposed to be a slave that Sinterklaas bought to free, but pete wanted to stay with him and help out. Why there are multiples is a mystery, but I guess saint nick is the patron saint of cloning tech. Before that there was a lineage of various black-faced bogeymen that was the punishing side to the festival's charity and further back the blackness was just a part of throwing all kinds of shit on yourself like soot, chains, bells, furs, and whatnot to scare children. A different permutation of the same character ended up as Krampus, but generally the modern audience has a more negative response to a blackface character as opposed to an edgy furry.
I was told he looks that way cause he's covered in soot from chimneys
@@GraveyardMaiden yeah that is much more common now, but I'm unsure if it is regarded as the "official" story just yet.
Krampus as Edgy Furry made my day.
Or like something that belongs on a death metal album cover. I will always think of Krampus with this exchange in the Venture Brothers Christmas episode:
Dr. Venture: "What the hell kind of kinky Christmas spirit is that?!"
Dr. Orpheus: "Well, it is Germanic in origin."
The slave part simply isn't true. The bells and soot definitely is. In its current form yes, black pete is dressed up as an African, but not a slave. He is a Moor!
However originally this was not the case. It was, as you said, just a completely sooted face, some cowbells and chains and a rod to spank the girls with. Nothing to do with Africans as the tradition predates our first interaction with Africans.
That dedication at the end hit me right in the heart, especially as I also had a grandfather I truly admired that was named after Saint Nicholas. Hope your Yule was lovely, and may good fortune come your way in 2023!
0:58 and suddenly blue is now my favorite person to exist
I feel like this was a missed opportunity to spawn a new series called "Christmas-Makers" that would magically find its way into our notifications every year =p
Great video though!
“Does that make Luther a killjoy?”
Yes.
I knew that the Protestant Reformation did do things like outlaw plays, but I didn’t know that it did outlaw the St. Nick in Christmas.
St Nick wasn't really associated with Christmas until the 19th century.
Christmas is about giving. Giving what? You may ask. Giving out gold and these hands.
As a nontrinitarian, may I express my deepest thanks to you all for not including the face punch in the holiday tradition😂
👊
You've set yourself up for this now
In celebration of the season, I will fight you, Kyle.
Isaiah 9:6 dude.
Santa Claus punching you: “What the FUCK is up Kyle?”
Sinterklaas actually doesn't have much to do with Christmas besides being celebrated in December. Festivities usually start in November and end on the evening of December fifth. Christmas comes afterwards on the twenty-fifth and twenty-sixth with less focus on gifts and more on family.
Sinterklaas was included because the american santa originated from sinterklaas.
christmas and yule are also not on the same date, doesn't mean they're not related.
This is only true on a surface level.
@@willemketelaars4342 Except that the video is insisting that St Nicholas and Christmas being associated with one another has it's origins in Europe while it is actuallyh a completely novel modern American only invention.
@@Quetzietse is the UK part of north america now?
"All roads lead to Odin, apparently" -Red, The Wild Hunt
The reason behind the pieten (black assistants) was one legend of him saving several coloured children from slavery and giving them jobs, which was then translated into 'He saves people from slavery who assist him out of gratitude/as a job' during the 1800's if I remember correctly
My family is basically half catholic, half protestant, so on Christmas Eve my parents told me that both Santa Claus and baby Jesus (“Christkind”) were coming, basically working together.
Here in Germany we have also have „Nikolaustag” on December the 6., and usually kids will get like a small present as well as a stocking full of nuts, sweets and fruit (often mandarins).
In Greece instead of St Nicholas, it is St Basil the Great of Caesaria who brings gifts to children on St Basil's day at the 1st of January. A devout philanthropist, he donated all of his fortune to the poor and built a city, Basileiad, which was used as a poorhouse, hospital, and hospice. It is traditional on St Basil's Day to serve vasilopita, a rich bread baked with a coin inside. The tradition is attributed to St. Basil, who when a bishop, wanted to distribute money to the poor and commissioned some women to bake sweetened bread, in which he arranged to place gold coins. Thus the families in cutting the bread were pleasantly surprised to find the coins. St Basil the great truly was great!
YESSSS!!! Dutch history made it into one of your video's!!!! I'm so happy! Belgium and the Netherlands are some of the most interesting countries in Europe, but not many people outside the dutch-speaking world seem to know. As for why we have Zwarte Piet (now usually Roetveegpiet): we've begun questioning it as well. It's one of those angry political debates that comes around each year around november/december.
I have a question, because I want to learn more about Dutch speaking areas. Do they speak Dutch or French in Belgium, or something else? And are there any good source books available in English in US that one can find to learn more about the history?
@@Levsa399 In Fleming, the Northern side of the country they speak Dutch, while Wallonia, the southern side of Belgium the people speak French.
@@Levsa399 Hahaha, oh boy... Belgium is the most complicated country in the world. I live there and I barely understand how it works. What I can say is that Belgium consists of a few different parts. The northern half is called Flanders, that's where I live. In Flanders, we only speak (our version of) Dutch. We're pretty good at English and, supposedly, French, but Flemings hate French for numerous reasons that are hard to explain in a RUclips comment. The southern half of the country is called Wallonia (I think). Most people there speak French, but there's a little German-speaking community in the very east that we "acquired" in the aftermath of one of the two World Wars. Our capital city, Brussels, is bilingual in name, but nearly every language known to man is spoken there and the lingua franca is French. With 20+ languages, 4 governments and 19 mayors, Brussels is by far the most complicated city I have ever heard of.
I'm actually not familiar with the English literature on Dutch and Belgian history, but I suspect it won't be hard to find a good starting point via Wikipedia or Google. I'm super glad you're interested! Are you familiar with/interested in the language? Or do you primarily enjoy the historical aspect?
@@CarlosMagnussen thank you! I’m actually writing a historical fantasy and one of my characters is Dutch, so I wanted to be respectful and accurate.
@@Levsa399 That's so cool! Good luck!
Resident Dutchman here! Very much appreciating the little tangent about Sinterklaas. That's a thing honestly deserving its own video.
On the note of the blackface thing: they were originally meant to be soot stains from jumping down and climbing up a bunch of chimneys to deliver all those gifts. Somewhere along the lines that got turned into "just paint the whole face black" however. Probably because it was easier and more recognizable on TV than some spots. The connection with blackface is (at least in my experience) a more recent connection that some people have latched onto in protest. A lot of these people take it too far however and call for just ditching the celebration in its entirety over this. We're quickly transitioning Black Pete over into Pete with soot stains however, so the whole thing is becoming a non-issue.
Sinterklaas also has dope candy. I mean, chocolate letters yo! Look em up, they're excellent.
Also, Slash is Sinterklaas and one of our parents in disguise.
I married a Byzantine Catholic, and for them St. Nick is kinda a huge deal. I did have a priest once insist that as a baby St. Nick refused to breastfeed during Lent because it was dairy. 😶
Sounds obvious.
It is more hilarious to think that St. Nicholas showed up uninvited to the Council of Nicaea solely to sucker punch Arius.
Blue I don't know how to tell you this but Sinterklaas is celebrated dec 5th- so as much as I appreciate the "merry Sinterklaasfeest" I do feel the need to point that out 8'D
Does this mean the Netherlands gets _two_ holidays featuring different incarnations of the same guy? Yes. Yes it does.
Thank you for another year of excellent informative art, osp crew. We hope y'all have wonderful holidays and an even better new year after this one!
That was cool. Bit surprised you didn’t link to Red’s Wild Hunt video onscreen, but that’s a good synopsis of the original Nick.
As someone from Belgium, aka one of the low countries where we celebrate Sinterklaas I can gladly tell you that after a lot of anoying "but our traditions" from certain parts of the population the whole blackface thing was replaced with just some smears of soot on the faces of the helpers, supposedly from coming down the chimney.
It's still receiving a lot of pushback, unfortunately, with such totally not in bad faith arguments such as 'they got their blackface, makeup and golden jewelry from going down the chimney' and 'but it's for kids so it's ok to teach them that black people are servants who will kidnap them if they're naughty'.
Apart from literally having black faces, what exactly does this have in common with minstrel shows from the US? Just curious as a foreigner
@@nonya_bidness The makeup, the clothing, them literally being there as a show, to name a few.
Gladly it's changed in the Netherlands too
@@r31n0ut Dat komt omdat het zwarte gezicht juist één der oudste delen van de traditie is. De oorbellen, kroeshaar, rode lippen en het stomme pakje, NIET.
Of anders gezegd, het zwarte gezicht heeft VAN OORSPRONG geen donder te maken met Afrikanen.
Dus zou liever zien dat het zwarte gezicht blijft en alle andere onzin weggaat.
Verder is het van oorsprong ook helemaal geen kinderfeest. De kinderen werd juist de stuipen op 't lijf gejaagd door de zwarte pieten. En in alleroudste vorm waren het jonge ongetrouwde mannen die in de nacht jonge ongetrouwde meiden achterna gingen.
Great video as always, I'm happy to see someone dispel, even indirectly, the common urban legend that our modern image of Santa Claus was codified by Coca-Cola. Bearded fat man in red was already established canon by then!!
And what about the red?
I've read that before Coca-Cola, his colours would wary.
@@Karak-_- I know his colors did vary for some time, but by the 1930s depictions of Santa in advertising and illustration overwhelmingly used red. Seeing as some of the most famous pre-30s Santa's were shown in red, ie Nast's cartoons and Baum's children's novel, I feel confident saying that coca cola's ads were much more reactions to existing trends than they were trendsetters.
May your grandfather rest in peace, and I hope you have a Happy Christmas and New Year!
Can't wait to watch more OSP in 2023!
As I am currently sick with a cough, a OSP video before Christmas is just what the doctor ordered. To all the OSP team, happy holidays :)
It never fails to make me immensely happy when I get a new OSP video especially one right before the jingliest of holidays
Happy to see a history on a bit of Dutch culture of one of the few feast we have over here.
Sinterklaas may not be celebrated by all but I'm still happy that its there for us all here in the small land of the Nederland's.
Wish you all people a warm merry Christmas.
“The man was just born, give him a minute!” 😂
Honestly I feel like this could be a dual side video
Blue could go over the Historical side of Christmas and Red could handle the Mythical side of it!
As someone from Belgium, very happy to see representation of a tradition of ours!
Luckily, the whole "blackface" thing is being slowly erased out. Currently, the compromise is that they just have dirty smears from chimney ashes xD
Still, a magical tradition I'm happy to see in one of your videos!
Happy holidays you guys!! Hope everyone in the rainbow family is safe and healthy and has a great time spending time with family and friends and history textbooks lol
4:33 As a kid I was told to leave out milk & cookies for Santa Claus and some carrots for the reindeers.
My favorite story about Santa is lesser known tale about when a freak meteor hit Santa's sleigh, splitting in in two. In that moment he turned to his helper Elfin Skywalker and uttered his famous phrase: "Not to worry! We are still flying half a sleigh!"
He then carried on delivering presents with a jolly laugh, greeting the good people with a "Ho Ho Ho There!"
I just find this story so relatable for some odd reason. Perhaps is the impressive beard? Or maybe it's Santa indisputable dominion over the (latitudinal) High Ground in the North Pole? Who can really say...
Now you're making me imagine a Star Wars planet based on the Netherlands where Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piet have lightsabers based on the former's bishop staff, and the latter's collection of thin sticks.
@@jurtheorc8117 Centuries after their good deeds, they would immortalized as significant figures in intergalactic Life Day celebrations.
Now that you brought it up, I’d love to see a video on the translation of saintly relics. As someone who wrote about it for their undergrad dissertation (with Saint Nicholas of Myra as a key figure of study at that) I think it’s a subject right up the alley of this channel!
Always fun to trace the evolution of popular figures. Happy Holidays OSP Crew!
5:39 it’s supposed to be ash from going down the chimney but recently theyv’e changement it to coloured paint to avoid the people protesting against it
I would love to write a story where Mark Twain meets up with Sinterklass being his pilot on his steamship
Saint Nicolas is the patron of my hometown, so around December many festivités are dedicated to him. It’s so cool, it’s like you have double Santa for the end of the year
On the way to a Passover Seder the night before Easter with my interfaith family.
My 5 year old daughter: "Is this the one where all the babies die or the one where they nail the guy to wood?"
Me: "Um... never thought of it like that. But this is the one where the babies die. Tomorrow they nail the guy to wood."
"A Visit from St. Nicholas" was originally published anonymously in the upstate NY newspaper The Troy Sentinel. The newspaper doesn't exist anymore, but the building still has a plaque outside memorializing the poem.
Pity the punching people in the face didnt make it as a Christmas tradition, would really spice things up
Time for the Christmas free-for-all! *rolls up sleeves* WHO'S BEEN A NON-TRINITARIAN HERETIC LATELY?!
Someones halls are getting DECKED
In fact I recall somewhere in italy this is exactly what they do. Massive street fights while Santa Claus looks upon it agreeingly, even eggs them on.
@@moorebear1 YES.
I like that you mentioned that there's elements of the Wild Hunt in the Santa mythos. This is actually something I first realized while watching Red's Halloween video on the Wild Hunt a couple years ago.
in greece we use the modern imagery of santa claus, we call him Αη Βασιλή which is Basil of Caesarea. I don't remember the story by heart, but he was supposedly very generous and gave as gifts things that were donating to him or something like that. I will let someone else say the correct answer as an answer, because I am a lazy hack.
2:30 The daughter in green looks terrified by the mysterious man chucking gold balls at them through their window.
OH MY GOD i was gonna do a video covering how christmas came to be on the day it is but yall already covered it love yall
Your humor is top-notch in that intro!
"stealth-charity" **Jean Valjean has entered the chat**
i like how you included sinterklaas,
much love from the Netherlands and I wish you happy holidays
I always did wonder how my brother’s namesake did become the face of Coca-Cola in December, and now I know why! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to all!
Machi Machi knocks it outta the park to close out our year :D thank you for your art and generosity. it means a lot to us.
OMG this is perfect timing we just watched this creepy stop motion video about Saint Nicholas in French class.
Santa Claus is Coming to Town or The Life & Adventures of Santa Claus?
@@erichfiedler1481 La Legende De Saint Nicolas stop motion
5:30. The simple explanation is ashes and soot. These helpers klimbed through the chimney of houses and (apparently) they did not see fit to clean up afterwards. We changed it up now, witch is nice.
My condolences for your grandfather Blue. It sounds like he was a good man.
Side note, isn't it odd how some people who were named after Saints end up taking saintly characteristics?
My name is actually Joel, and I'm a little afraid of it, since Joel was the one who prophesied the plagues. Don't let me preach doom and gloom! And merry Christmas to all!
5:40 because it was convenient, the story of them being like that from being covered in soot was a perfect way to make kids not question it and avoid them coming to the realisation that the pragmatic reason behind it was to disguise the fact that their gift bringing visitor was, in fact, their neighbour/uncle/family friend.
This was a very fun summary of a LOT of information, thanks for sharing Blue!! Happy whatever the heck you celebrate.
St. Nick hit em with the "Hail Mary, full of grace, punch a heretic in the face"
1) Sorry to hear about your grandfather, I hope you are okay.
2) After all this time we spent as Byzantines making the Sailor Protector (Queen Beryl will never return, why is there no rabbit in the story?) really really important (any greek based empire will be maritime), why do Greek Orthodox have St. Basil deliver gifts on January 1st?
3) And starting on 2021, the dutch can enjoy the best Santa Claus permutation so far: Vader Johan.
As a Dutchie, I picked up some interesting trivia about the Sinterklaas tradition through this video. Cool to see it covered! Kudos for your pronounciation of the name, by the way, I was all too prepared to see you stumble through it but the quality is there as much as it has always has been - Shouldn't have expected otherwise.
How does Odin even fit into the inspiration for Santa Claus? Sure, there is the sled/deer/horse thing, but the wildhunt has nothing to do with Christmas as far as I know. Saint Nicholas fits more for the inspiration with his giving of gifts.
I love how Red drew Santa with twinkling eyes. It’s so subtle but such a wonderful, jolly detail 😊
I remember la fête de St. Nicolas at my French preschool. We all went into the gymnasium and a guy dressed as St. Nicolas gave us all oranges. It was bizarre.
That has been part of the sinterklaas celebration in the Netherlands as well but nowadays it is mostly "Kruidnoten" & "Chocolate letter", look it up if you want, they are great.
While Sinterklaas is the most popular gift giving saint in the Low countries, there are a few parts of Flanders who celebrate Saint Martin (a dude who allegedly cut his own cloak in half so he could give it to a freezing beggar) instead. The feast is held in early november instead of december and the kids go around singing and receiving gifts.
Merry Christmas and Happy new year ppl
Uno Reverse Card
You too!
There is a reason why Sinterklaas is on the 5th of December in the Netherlands and in Belgium the 6th. So that he has a night to travel to Belgium after his night of giving gifts to kids.
Happy Holidays!! Happy Hanukkah, Red
I'm actually going to a Yule party this year, and that first "stumble" was hysterical to me. I love learning the actual history of holidays!!!