Yes everyone knows that no one can beat the original, but the fact that these people can reach a note like that for that duration is absolutely incredible and takes a lot to do
For real though! Like of course no one can top the original, but we are not gonna use that excuse to gloss over the fact that these people are hitting these crazy notes.
Yeah! She’s the queen of belting for me💫 I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
The difference between Celine and those other artists: she delivers the note with passion nobody can replicate. Most singers can hit F5 easily, but without the growl, cry, pain, and longing Celine does.
So true, masters of their craft! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Can we focus on talent and not race? That’s so childish. I know the media has brainwashed you to behave that way but it needs to stop. This isn’t the 1800’s.
@@sohyangworld1544 she has a fantastic headvoice tbf she never uses it in her own music much so it’s refreshing to hear in something like this where she belts/mixes well
As I appreciate Celine Dion’s original, I also appreciate the amazing vocals that everyone else gave and that’s on realizing that singing is a beautiful way to express emotions and impact others (instead of a competition or comparison game)
The original? Eric Carmen released it in 1975. The verse was even based on classical music: the second movement of Sergei Rachmaninoff's circa 1900-1901 Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Opus 18. Here's Eric Carmen live: ruclips.net/video/iW8BgwqSFTI/видео.html
People who doesn´t know about music or has a shitty perspective about it, thinks that just because you can hit certain note, you are automatically a good singer. Just like guitarist when they think playing fast is being a good guitarist or have musicality, when has nothing to do with it. Basically Celine has something to say with that note, and the other are just copying, so achievement? sure I gues, but they are just copying and using that note as self validation when nobody gives a fuck, everybody wants to hear the original because it has way more meaning. Not to mention this video and channel also contributes with that shitty mindset of looking at music as a way of competition instead of a way of expressing yourself using the techniques and vocabulary that you feel natural for you.
If she's the one I'm thinking of, some songs aren't meant to sing with a lot of vibrato. Covering them means to get the feeling of the artist you have to adjust the amount of vibrato you use, it's not opera. Just one person's opinion (given from instructors). Wonderful voice though.
@@saifiqbal9913 well Celine is a soprano(thr hugest voice), Leona is alto(the lowest femalo voice), her E5 is more impressive then Celine’s F5, speaking purely about atonomy of the vocal chords.
She’s Celine Dion! She always outdoes herself. I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
@@nomadic294 Well yeah. Live TV performances, interviews, and hundreds of performances every day let alone her Monday through Friday Las Vegas show back then... no one is going to ruin their vocal chords singing F5s every week all year.
@@drarrej actually celine herself told in the interview the producer raise the key of the recording. And celine herself said "how could you do this this is not what we agreed i cannot do this live" go watch the interview if u dont believe me lol
Okay but Celine does it with ease and with passion. All the others seem to be concentrating on reaching the note rather than feeling the emotion. She is artistry and craft and extraordinary talent. Alchemy, really.
Indeed. She can toe to toe with anybody, and still slay. For sure . Which is doing already. All others are quite pale to me and i just lack of interest. End of discussion;)🌹
that's not an easy note even for celine, she even complained to David about it being too high. also those other singers were singing the song live, celine admits lip syncing in her concerts.
It is!! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
As a Filipino, I'm tired of all the screeching. They don't even have control over their tone. It's Regine's fault I think. Now everyone thinks screeching till your lungs give out is cool.
Don’t know who Jennie Lenna is but she killed it. People aren’t talking about her in the comments bc they mostly just rep the singers they already know. Respect where respect is due.
Agree, their voices were so powerful! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
So true, they’re incredibly talented! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Respect to most of the singers in this video as most did a great job BUT nothing and nobody touches the original. Celine's tone and power is unmatched. Thats why she is know as Queen
Completely agree! Celine has so much passion and emotion in her voice, her notes sound very impactful. I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Well thats because she recirded it ina recording studio and has autotune. She can't do it live and has to sing 2 NOTES down, for her to make it. These other women sing it live, in the original key, something Celine frankly can't do
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 even if they sang it on a studio. They still go to the safest vowel. ANYMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH only Céline can do the hardest vowel. David Foster did an amazing job picking Céline to sing this song. No one can ever do that high belted with raspy tone.
Very true! There’s so much emotion in her singing! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
I'm a huge fan of Celine Dion but I must admit I've never seen her attempting this iconic note live. These girls on the other hand have done a great job.
You can clearly hear they are afraid to bend slowly to the f5, that gives power to the moment, Celine does that very slowly and that slow transition is what make it sow iconic
There may be perfecter notes than Celine’s but Celine’s is perfectly imperfect. Please pay attention to how everyone else is so focused on hitting the note while Celine is emoting it. We all know she can hit a note with perfect clarity. I actually hate that F5 when that rasp Celine adds is missing.
The fact that half of the "original note" singers are FILIPINOS..🇵🇭🥰 This makes me proud as a Philippine citizen 🇵🇭 who loves to sing till our hearts content
Very true! Using chest dominant mixed voice we can sound a little bit close to Celine’s version! But again, she’s unbeatable. I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
And it depends on each person's timbre as well. Not to mention that a cover is not supposed to copy the original, I don't think the others try impersonating Celine.
Celine is and will be the best, nobody can beat her. All By Myself is my favorite of all times, especially the one from her Boston concert. It hits me everytime😪💙
Agree so much! She’s the best I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Very true! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
The problem with most of these covers is that these beautiful songs become nothing but a race to get to the high notes. You can't really put your finger on it but for some reason they leave you cold. That's because these singers possess all of the dramatics yet the most important ingredient is missing and that is the intense emotion that the original artist had. Listen to Celine and you can hear the pain and struggle in her voice. Part of it is her actually struggling to sing the note because they raised the key when she came to studio that day but it makes it perfect because that's what the song is all about, especially that part lyrically and climax wise. The producer did this on purpose, of course, to bring that emotion out of the artist and Celine delivered. So, yes, while it is very impressive that you can sing that note in the original key, have perfect pitch and not strain because your breath support is flawless, you are missing the point. Since you have the technique down and you know it, how about you use it to make the right artistic choices and honour the integrity of the song? Leave your ego to your practice sessions and sing for the song or just don't touch it. Sorry, I don't mean to be salty. Most of these singers are very talented but it is a great pet peeve of mine when singers sing songs by Mariah, Whitney or Celine and they think that just by nailing the high notes they possess the magic that the vocal trinity had/have. See, none of the members of the trinity are concerned with the high notes, they are concerned with the songs themselves and the stories they tell, especially Mariah who writes her material.
I beg to disagree with your claim. The reason why celine ended up with a straining sound while is because it was done INTENTIONALLY, it was decided to make it sound straining to fully emphasis on the emotion that the singer (which is Celine) wants to tell us listeners. Try to fully understand the lyrics. It totally tells about longing, sadness, despair and desperation (Don't want to live all by myself anymore) Sustained f5 is already hard, how much more adding strain to it. Singers can practice till they perfect the f5 note, but none of them dared to include the straining sound,(because it's vocally tasking). Celine can actually do this in a very clean and Crystal clear way but then that will remove her own touch to it, which separates her from others who managed to attempt it.
If you don't agree with me, how about you listen to her other songs. Specifically THINK TWICE and WITH THIS TEARS. Both of which possess a straining sound at its climax. Think twice, if you try to understand the lyrics, tells us about a woman, wanting her lover to stop and think twice before leaving. To simply put it, it's a song about breaking up between two lovers, but with the woman still holding on, hence why the peak lyrics are BABYYYYYYY NO! NO! NO! NO! with straining sound to it. It gives us the feeling with the straining added to it, that the woman is extremely desperate and a bit of anguish and anger mixed into it. Same thing with her song WITH THIS TEARS, as the title suggest, is about a sorrowful song about longing to be touched. Now for their similarities With this tears All by myself Think twice Are songs that expresses Desperation, sorrow and pain! Without the straining touch to it, it wouldn't be as impactful as it is when you listen to it all the time
@@jhoneltumampocfashion2008 I'm sorry but technically speaking, how can singers intentionally strain their upper belts like that, especially when it's a sustained F5 belt? Not a hater, I'm just curious to know
@@mohaimenbheer9816 I also sing. Had some experience participating in singing contests before. I just want to say that Strain can sometimes be achieved just like how some singers can add flavors by adding vocal breaks. Celine mentioned in one of her interviews that she admires singers who smoke and get scratchy sound when they sing because she finds it great, she also said that when she gets sick and her voice has this straining sound to it, she loves to sing with it. Maybe that's the reason why we can hear her rock type song like "That's just a woman in me". She really utilized her strain here to sound rock. Celine is know to use her voice for different ways, she can mimic guitars, and other instruments too. Adding strain to her belts is no longer an issue for her. David also mentioned Celine sang the final note 7 times in the studio too.
Well, she's a musical singer after almost 20 years of stage presence. Also played the role of elphaba for over 7 years, which is a very hard role. Belting at the edge of your voice 8 times a week for 7 years is probably hard for your vocal cords^^
this was excellent, no one does it like Celine but most of these were excellent renditions. i came from another one of these and with the compilation one was pitchy, another was flat. i only heard one here that seemed like it was a bit of a struggle but still the overall integrity of the voice remained.
Agree! I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
SAME! their voices are just so powerful and impactful in my opinion. I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
for me it's Pia, Jake, Katrina and Regine that did it..yes they've sung beautiful but ofcourse no one is sounded like Celine the legend and none of them surpass CELINE DION..no hate just stating the fact
Well, they all do, since Celine can't actually hit it. When she sings it live she sings it 2 notes down to be able to hit it. And you are comparing a studio recording with autotune, to live performances.
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 Autotune didn't even exist when Celine hit that note lololol. Imagine being such a good singer that haters think its autotune. Every legend wannabe should strive to be that good.
anyways, what I really mean here guys is just that you can easily determine it's Celine Dion singing when it's soft, an angelic voice and full of emotions not just hitting those notes higher but also hitting them right.. and in singing it isn't all about hitting those higher notes, it's all about giving your best and the emotion that you feel.
I absolutely adored Charice Pempengco's (Jake Zyrus) voice. With so much power, control and talent, she was a breath of fresh air when she joined Glee.
@@SuperPianogirl123 They absolutely did. Definitely not knocking them. Adding Sunshine''s character though created a nice story arc that was far too short. Everyone on Glee was a powerhouse in their own way.
@@RomonicaDiGregory I'm not talking about Jake though as Jake's version wasn't included in the video (unless I'm not remembering it) When you look up Charice Pempengco on RUclips(or Google) that is who pops up in the suggestions, not Jake. I think IMDB is the only site that automatically redirects to Jake.
The fact that they reach the note and HOLD it for so long! Jesus Christ, this people deserve an award!! (I’ve tried, believe me, it’s not as easy as it looks!!)
Agree so much! They sound so powerful. I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
This and Whitney Houston's "I will always love you", are two songs that singers should never sing. The originals are vocal and emotional masterpieces. No one will ever be able to replicate or out do the originals.
Did you consider that people sing these songs because it would be fun and enjoyable? I hardly doubt that any of these singers sang these songs because they were trying to “out do” the artists. Maybe replicate, but replicate in the sense of singing the same notes, the way the song is supposed to be sung.
Again, nobody gave the note the pure chest Celine did. Nobody did the full on chesty growled scratchy belt Celine did. And most importantly, nobody emoted like Celine. All were concentrated on hitting the note, while Celine delivered a whole wave of emotions that noone could approach.
Celine: often imitated, never duplicated. No one meets or exceeds her execution of that note. And not a single one brings the emotion to their performance that she does. Her tone is unmatched as well. The others sound like long-tailed cats in a room full of rocking chairs. 😱 In other words, who prefers faux leather when the original and the best is the genuine stuff?
Celine struggled SO much hitting it in the studio, and the reason you like hers better is because there is autotune on it. Celine never does it live because she can't do it. All of these women can hit it better than her, since she frankly can't do it. Live she always sings it 2 notes down. So don't diss on these amazing women when they do it better than Celine!
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 If ever there was a singer who DOESN’T need autotune, it’s Celine, heifer. Which explains, in part, why she’s a living legend and none of these women are. To say the least. And if you actually believe any of them sing that note better than Celine, I just have one question: exactly how long have you been stone deaf?
Celine? GOAT. I'm all for the vocalists after her (cause they all slayed it) but the feeling you feel in your gut when you hear Celine "Dion the shit out of it" is just... there's just nothing like it. She grabs you in the chest and grips your soul so hard and doesn't let go and you're left wanting her to do it again. It's breathtaking. The OG is just a WONDER and we are all lucky to have lived in the era of her vocal dominance and blessed to be graced by her talent... but YO! Pia and Perrie did that SEATED... I mean, dang. And Jake really captures the essence of the emotion in the lyric and instrumentation backing him. The feeling from him was the closest to the original for me. But to each their own, of course.
Yes everyone knows that no one can beat the original, but the fact that these people can reach a note like that for that duration is absolutely incredible and takes a lot to do
Exactly
I hate the comments
“Nobody did it as good as the original”
Like can we just still appreciate how good these people did
For real though! Like of course no one can top the original, but we are not gonna use that excuse to gloss over the fact that these people are hitting these crazy notes.
Exactly
I heard in a video of Celine that her voice went high than the F5 and had to come down,yes these ladies can hit the note but no higher her the celine
I think Morissette Amon did it the best. Even compared to original.
The First Lady after celine was so good. Managed to stay in control and full of power
True. She was the only one I liked
She is very amazing
she sounded a bit strained to me. was great nonetheless. what do ya think?
Yesss
Ikr.. I thought no one would come close to Celine.. Saw the second one and was like damnnn
Celine's ressonance is increbible and unique.
Yeah! She’s the queen of belting for me💫
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
1:30 redone ears
Sung live not in an MV.
The video is then of poor quality to hear all the frequencies of his voice
🤷🏻♂️😱🤷🏻♂️
@@brunodemarchis4533 come on, who sings live in a mv like that?
@@GamingWithEric2508 in mv nobody sings live.
and celine is no exception.🤷♀️
@@TheCosmicNote nah I’m good
The last singer made me realize that even when it's lower than the original, it can sound really good as a result of the vocal quality
YESSS!!! This!!!
Limitless!
Yeah I was gonna comment, that Eb5 was beautiful.
Just a short question am I dumb or is e flat just 1 tone under f
@@ouroborus6951 you are NOT dumb at all
Why is no one talking about the amazing Pia?! So good! 😁
So true, I was looking for comments complimenting her until I found yours
i liked her note, tone and inflection the best. much richer textures than celine.
I preferred her over everyone else!! 🔥
She was the best. She was sitting too
Wall by myself hanymoreeeeee....
The difference between Celine and those other artists: she delivers the note with passion nobody can replicate. Most singers can hit F5 easily, but without the growl, cry, pain, and longing Celine does.
Truth!
Nobody does it like Celine!!!
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 Whatever floats your boat
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 Why so defensive?
🤣🤣🤣🤷🙉
Celine is singing, through an MV,genie.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
but perrie belting while seating, it’s just amazing
There are not enough people talking her, I'm disappointed
It was all head voice
And I just realized she edited the "Yea" run at the end. Theres a cut..😕
Y’all are big mad
@@sohyangworld1544 that is called heady mixed
@@christoffermillerante1772 yea ik, its not belty like celine.
She leaned way back though
This video just proves how amazing and vocally skilled are Filipinos
So true, masters of their craft!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
It's just sad with that much skills and talents, they're never really famous world-wide.
Can we focus on talent and not race? That’s so childish. I know the media has brainwashed you to behave that way but it needs to stop. This isn’t the 1800’s.
@@KingOfThePirates101 Nah you just only watched them on RUclips where they were singing live in front of crowds.
@@opinionsarentfacts3515 What do you mean?
I was just here for Perrie and WOW she nailed it!!
Same!! ❤️
Pia hitting it while seated, with so much clarity in the power of her voice was amazing. All so much fun to hear.
Perrie sing it while seating down is impressive.
It was mostly head voice though
@@sohyangworld1544 she has a fantastic headvoice tbf she never uses it in her own music much so it’s refreshing to hear in something like this where she belts/mixes well
@@sohyangworld1544 THANK YOU i was looking for this comment
@@sohyangworld1544 it was the echo
Mmn not really, there's a jump-cut at 2:51 which tells me her voice cracked towards the end and edited in that last bit.
No one can ever hit it the way Céline did.
pure truth!
Yeah because Céline did it in Not Tensed Pure Chest Voice Rich F5 tone, straight tone and then vibrato and then fast run
Celine hardly hit the f5 studio recording she can never hit it live!
@@clovervillarta4791 Atleast her live Eb5s are still good
@@clovervillarta4791 maybe watch a video of her vocal range bc she can lit sustain a mixed c6
As I appreciate Celine Dion’s original, I also appreciate the amazing vocals that everyone else gave and that’s on realizing that singing is a beautiful way to express emotions and impact others (instead of a competition or comparison game)
Exactly!!!
This should be pinned as top comment. This is exactly the purpose of this video!
The original wasn’t by Celine Dion.
The original? Eric Carmen released it in 1975. The verse was even based on classical music: the second movement of Sergei Rachmaninoff's circa 1900-1901 Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Opus 18. Here's Eric Carmen live: ruclips.net/video/iW8BgwqSFTI/видео.html
People who doesn´t know about music or has a shitty perspective about it, thinks that just because you can hit certain note, you are automatically a good singer. Just like guitarist when they think playing fast is being a good guitarist or have musicality, when has nothing to do with it. Basically Celine has something to say with that note, and the other are just copying, so achievement? sure I gues, but they are just copying and using that note as self validation when nobody gives a fuck, everybody wants to hear the original because it has way more meaning. Not to mention this video and channel also contributes with that shitty mindset of looking at music as a way of competition instead of a way of expressing yourself using the techniques and vocabulary that you feel natural for you.
is no one gonna talk about Perrie Edwards hitting that F5 while sitting down?? one of the greatest vocalists of our generation!!!
It's throaty. Celine was doing it on her headtone.
@@Jakeylicious7891 not as throaty as the one after Perri. That hurt my ears.
@@Jakeylicious7891what is troaty?
Who??
5th lady was seated too tho.
Perrie's vibrato HOLY SHIT
If she's the one I'm thinking of, some songs aren't meant to sing with a lot of vibrato. Covering them means to get the feeling of the artist you have to adjust the amount of vibrato you use, it's not opera. Just one person's opinion (given from instructors). Wonderful voice though.
I know it's nothing to do with the "anymore" but can we appreciate the falsetto Leona Lewis did after her E5.
It is truly the most beautiful moment in this video 💐
yah!!! it sounded so freaking good !
@@GarageStudio7 After Celine's glorious, eargasmic F5. Ugh it sounded so good!! The best F5 i've ever heard..
Imagine sutaining an E5 and then a C6!
@@saifiqbal9913 well Celine is a soprano(thr hugest voice), Leona is alto(the lowest femalo voice), her E5 is more impressive then Celine’s F5, speaking purely about atonomy of the vocal chords.
Celine blows them all away with that outro A5 and Bb5 improvisation of All by myself ending.
She’s Celine Dion! She always outdoes herself.
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Which she cant do live.. She did it on the studio but not live... It's always lowered during live performances
@@nomadic294 Well yeah. Live TV performances, interviews, and hundreds of performances every day let alone her Monday through Friday Las Vegas show back then... no one is going to ruin their vocal chords singing F5s every week all year.
Not regine please even celine si the original
I know regine powerful vocal
The original is by far the best one: powerful as hell.
Because it has autotune on it and is done in a studio...
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 1)the song came out before autotune was even invented
2) Celine does it just as well live
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 Autotune did not even existed. There is a live recording of Céline delivering this note.
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 wtf? Auto tune in the 90's? Are you high?
@@drarrej actually celine herself told in the interview the producer raise the key of the recording. And celine herself said "how could you do this this is not what we agreed i cannot do this live" go watch the interview if u dont believe me lol
Chapters:
0:00 intro
0:11 Celine Dion (Original)
0:31 Pia Toscano 0:47 Jake Zyrus
1:06 Katrina Velarde
1:24 Morissette Amon
1:43 Jonalyn Viray
1:59 Regine Velasquez
2:15 Bella Paige
2:36 Perrie Edwards
2:53 Willemijn Verkaik
3:10 Jennie Lenna
3:33 Paullete Cambronero
3:59 Leona Lewis
4:21 Katy Perry
4:35 Julie Anne San Jose
4:53 End Screen
🥰
I’m sorry but I read the 4:53 as Ed Sheeran at first glance 😅
Okay but Celine does it with ease and with passion. All the others seem to be concentrating on reaching the note rather than feeling the emotion.
She is artistry and craft and extraordinary talent. Alchemy, really.
Well said
Indeed. She can toe to toe with anybody, and still slay. For sure . Which is doing already.
All others are quite pale to me and i just lack of interest. End of discussion;)🌹
Celine herself said she struggled with that note
that's not an easy note even for celine, she even complained to David about it being too high. also those other singers were singing the song live, celine admits lip syncing in her concerts.
That's the difference between prerecorded and live vocals, the latter require concentration above showboating
I think being a vocalist is amazing.
i think so too
It is!!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
I agree, I was in a choral before in highschool but stopped now that I'm in college. One of my most treasured experience.
Yes. There are many popular singers out there, but not that many vocalists.
yeah, and it takes training for others.
The Philippine singers just wow.... All of them. Just envy, that's what I feel. Damn their voices.
Most of them are faithful christians and thus active in choir, in choir u can practice singing like that
As a Filipino, I'm tired of all the screeching. They don't even have control over their tone. It's Regine's fault I think. Now everyone thinks screeching till your lungs give out is cool.
@@egalscheie5714not everyone in the Philippines joins a choir
@@egalscheie5714 it’s actually because singing is just a big part of their culture, I don’t think it has much to do with religion
😢
Don’t know who Jennie Lenna is but she killed it. People aren’t talking about her in the comments bc they mostly just rep the singers they already know. Respect where respect is due.
Agreed, she made it look & sound effortless.
I love lenna!
Her version is my favorite here.
You should listen her version of who's loving you as well 👌
Agreed. That was incredible
Perrie Nailed It OMGGGG, lil mix is really the most talented girl group
Celine praised Perrie about her cover
Loved the Perrie Edwards’s part, she hit the note Quite amazing
Only Charice, now Jake Zyrus came close for me they had an absolutely amazing version of the song with just as much passion and vocal ability
Agree, their voices were so powerful!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
*even Perrie Edwards’*
charice and jake zyrus are the same person, jake zyrus is just his true self :)
i think perrie too, even celine praised perrie for the cover
Um Leona
Perrie ❤️ even Celine commented on her video 💕💕💕
No one will ever sing it like Celine, but Perry hitting an F5 while seated is impressive.
so was the first girl
Pia toscano was incredibly amazing 🤩
Philippine singers completed the list I mean💅
Thats true 🤣
Thought the sane
So true, they’re incredibly talented!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
They ate tbh
Because most of them still trapped in the 90's till to this day.
Respect to most of the singers in this video as most did a great job BUT nothing and nobody touches the original. Celine's tone and power is unmatched. Thats why she is know as Queen
Completely agree! Celine has so much passion and emotion in her voice, her notes sound very impactful.
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Erm, hate to break it to you but Celine Dion's version is a cover and not the original.
Only Céline can do the hardest vowel to sing this ANYMOOOOOOOOORE the rest are doing the safe vowel ANYMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
Totally agree, I guess no one noticed that.
Celine is also the queen of close /e/ vowel ! 🔥
Well thats because she recirded it ina recording studio and has autotune. She can't do it live and has to sing 2 NOTES down, for her to make it. These other women sing it live, in the original key, something Celine frankly can't do
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 even if they sang it on a studio. They still go to the safest vowel. ANYMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH only Céline can do the hardest vowel. David Foster did an amazing job picking Céline to sing this song. No one can ever do that high belted with raspy tone.
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 autotune wasn’t invented when the song came out
Dimash sang “All by Myself” at his Bastau and New York concerts (after I Am Singer version of it) and OOF 😩🦋🦋 dude still gives me chills to this day!
The first girl killed it 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
That'll be Celine 😅
Perrie nailed it!!!!
They still can't beat the way celine combined the growl and the perfect note
The passion, the intensity, the magic: Queen Celine 👑 no one beats the original!!!
Very true! There’s so much emotion in her singing!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Jesus! This is like a superpower. Hats off to you ladies👍
So much entertainment to watch these gifted singers reach this goal. Wished I had a singing voice!
Leona Lewis' tone is the most gorgeous, what a difference it makes.
Yes cause its lower
Bec. its auto tone.,hahaha
@@abarcangel713 its not leonas tone is angelic af lmao
Yes and the run she did with the note was amazing
@@xia1494 omg i know, a vocal dream come true, so stunning!
I'm a huge fan of Celine Dion but I must admit I've never seen her attempting this iconic note live. These girls on the other hand have done a great job.
Pretty sure she did a Vegas show, there and heaps of videos of her doing this live
She's done it several times during the Taking Chances World Tour and even on the tours after that
@@sougeshthondeeofficial2409 Not in the original key
then you are not such a good fan xd shes done that note live several times xd
@@javieracostabotello9973 Not in the original key. My 300 Celine Dion items collection says I'm her #1 fan.
You can clearly hear they are afraid to bend slowly to the f5, that gives power to the moment, Celine does that very slowly and that slow transition is what make it sow iconic
they’re all so talented, i could never 😭
🤯 literal chills. They're all goddamn amazing.
There may be perfecter notes than Celine’s but Celine’s is perfectly imperfect. Please pay attention to how everyone else is so focused on hitting the note while Celine is emoting it. We all know she can hit a note with perfect clarity. I actually hate that F5 when that rasp Celine adds is missing.
Agreed. It becomes flat, cold, and harsh. The opposite of passionate.
Yeah🤨I noticed that raspy strain at the ending belt
U can feel the pain of the song in her voice
*perrie’s always gives me goosebumps though*
Damnnn Perrie!♥
Everyone of these are incredible
The fact that half of the "original note" singers are FILIPINOS..🇵🇭🥰
This makes me proud as a Philippine citizen 🇵🇭 who loves to sing till our hearts content
Bcoz Filipino love to sing any occasion public to private house to live band
and there are others not in this video with also amazing talent
I think it depends on the technique. A full chest sustained F5 is way harder than a more heady/mixed F5. And ofc it doesn't sound the same.
Very true! Using chest dominant mixed voice we can sound a little bit close to Celine’s version! But again, she’s unbeatable.
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
You mean chest dominant. There's no such thing as full chest F5. Still mixed.
@@michaliskossyfas5862 Yeah yeah, chest dominant. If someone could ever done a full chest F5 let me know ASAP. 🤣🤣🤣
And it depends on each person's timbre as well. Not to mention that a cover is not supposed to copy the original, I don't think the others try impersonating Celine.
@@alejandrotassone7826 most of them did a chest dominant mixed lol
Celine is and will be the best, nobody can beat her. All By Myself is my favorite of all times, especially the one from her Boston concert. It hits me everytime😪💙
Agree so much! She’s the best
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
1:47 The drums made that 10x better.
Thank you for not using Jake's dead name. Ik it's the bare minimum but it's just so tiring to see people give so much hate to him.
Facts. The transphobia in this coments makes me sick
So few can get that high for so long while still sounding good. Impressive stuff some of these. Awesome!
3:12 Jeninne didn’t even do the lead into it just jumped right up there. Props
Shes snapped. One of my favourites
Perrie 💕💕💕💕
Regine always does it so effortless, power, resonance ,tone all on point
Very true!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
the first one gave me goosebumps!.
the eb5 at the end is so pretty in my opinion its the best one
The problem with most of these covers is that these beautiful songs become nothing but a race to get to the high notes. You can't really put your finger on it but for some reason they leave you cold. That's because these singers possess all of the dramatics yet the most important ingredient is missing and that is the intense emotion that the original artist had. Listen to Celine and you can hear the pain and struggle in her voice. Part of it is her actually struggling to sing the note because they raised the key when she came to studio that day but it makes it perfect because that's what the song is all about, especially that part lyrically and climax wise. The producer did this on purpose, of course, to bring that emotion out of the artist and Celine delivered. So, yes, while it is very impressive that you can sing that note in the original key, have perfect pitch and not strain because your breath support is flawless, you are missing the point. Since you have the technique down and you know it, how about you use it to make the right artistic choices and honour the integrity of the song? Leave your ego to your practice sessions and sing for the song or just don't touch it. Sorry, I don't mean to be salty. Most of these singers are very talented but it is a great pet peeve of mine when singers sing songs by Mariah, Whitney or Celine and they think that just by nailing the high notes they possess the magic that the vocal trinity had/have. See, none of the members of the trinity are concerned with the high notes, they are concerned with the songs themselves and the stories they tell, especially Mariah who writes her material.
I beg to disagree with your claim. The reason why celine ended up with a straining sound while is because it was done INTENTIONALLY, it was decided to make it sound straining to fully emphasis on the emotion that the singer (which is Celine) wants to tell us listeners. Try to fully understand the lyrics. It totally tells about longing, sadness, despair and desperation (Don't want to live all by myself anymore) Sustained f5 is already hard, how much more adding strain to it. Singers can practice till they perfect the f5 note, but none of them dared to include the straining sound,(because it's vocally tasking). Celine can actually do this in a very clean and Crystal clear way but then that will remove her own touch to it, which separates her from others who managed to attempt it.
If you don't agree with me, how about you listen to her other songs. Specifically THINK TWICE and WITH THIS TEARS. Both of which possess a straining sound at its climax. Think twice, if you try to understand the lyrics, tells us about a woman, wanting her lover to stop and think twice before leaving. To simply put it, it's a song about breaking up between two lovers, but with the woman still holding on, hence why the peak lyrics are BABYYYYYYY NO! NO! NO! NO! with straining sound to it. It gives us the feeling with the straining added to it, that the woman is extremely desperate and a bit of anguish and anger mixed into it. Same thing with her song WITH THIS TEARS, as the title suggest, is about a sorrowful song about longing to be touched.
Now for their similarities
With this tears
All by myself
Think twice
Are songs that expresses Desperation, sorrow and pain! Without the straining touch to it, it wouldn't be as impactful as it is when you listen to it all the time
True
@@jhoneltumampocfashion2008 I'm sorry but technically speaking, how can singers intentionally strain their upper belts like that, especially when it's a sustained F5 belt? Not a hater, I'm just curious to know
@@mohaimenbheer9816 I also sing. Had some experience participating in singing contests before. I just want to say that Strain can sometimes be achieved just like how some singers can add flavors by adding vocal breaks. Celine mentioned in one of her interviews that she admires singers who smoke and get scratchy sound when they sing because she finds it great, she also said that when she gets sick and her voice has this straining sound to it, she loves to sing with it. Maybe that's the reason why we can hear her rock type song like "That's just a woman in me". She really utilized her strain here to sound rock. Celine is know to use her voice for different ways, she can mimic guitars, and other instruments too. Adding strain to her belts is no longer an issue for her. David also mentioned Celine sang the final note 7 times in the studio too.
Perrie of course.
Well, The Philippines won the list. Singing there is just a sports for them.
I’m more impressed by the run after the sustained high note. Amazing
I love that they almost all hit that little trill at the very end too.
Omg got emotional 😭 on some of them. Beautiful voices
They all did really well
Well done ladies👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Celine's version is the one and only, I can't explain why, but it's so comfortable and enjoyable.
Even though Dimash is not included here...I say he is legend
1:07 im in love
All are superior but Celine did it with so much passion and emotion which makes her the best of the best. No one hits the note like her like ever.
02:53 Not that I can even belt a note like that, but this was hard to listen to =(
i know, not devaluating her work at all, i can't even sing paris hilton songs in tune lmao. It just sounded a little nasal for me
Well, she's a musical singer after almost 20 years of stage presence.
Also played the role of elphaba for over 7 years, which is a very hard role.
Belting at the edge of your voice 8 times a week for 7 years is probably hard for your vocal cords^^
this was excellent, no one does it like Celine but most of these were excellent renditions. i came from another one of these and with the compilation one was pitchy, another was flat. i only heard one here that seemed like it was a bit of a struggle but still the overall integrity of the voice remained.
Agree!
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Perrie's sounds more nasal, which reminds me of a Celine's
1:30 - best air raid alert ringtone
The Filipino queens and kings killin it! Lol
Celine Dion and Morissette are my HUGE FAVES!
SAME! their voices are just so powerful and impactful in my opinion.
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
Philippines really is the land of singers!
Great video! The use of Jake Zyrus' name is well appreciated
Celine just does it effortlessly, while everyone does it like it was the end of the world.
3:34 Paullete Camronero that was so exciting to hear!
for me it's Pia, Jake, Katrina and Regine that did it..yes they've sung beautiful but ofcourse no one is sounded like Celine the legend and none of them surpass CELINE DION..no hate just stating the fact
Well, they all do, since Celine can't actually hit it. When she sings it live she sings it 2 notes down to be able to hit it. And you are comparing a studio recording with autotune, to live performances.
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 Autotune didn't even exist when Celine hit that note lololol. Imagine being such a good singer that haters think its autotune. Every legend wannabe should strive to be that good.
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 and anyways I'm not comparing them read it again carefully🥴
@@saifiqbal9913 I agree😊
anyways, what I really mean here guys is just that you can easily determine it's Celine Dion singing when it's soft, an angelic voice and full of emotions not just hitting those notes higher but also hitting them right.. and in singing it isn't all about hitting those higher notes, it's all about giving your best and the emotion that you feel.
I absolutely adored Charice Pempengco's (Jake Zyrus) voice. With so much power, control and talent, she was a breath of fresh air when she joined Glee.
Uhh, Amber Riley, Lea Michele, and Naya Rivera were all on Glee and delivered amazing performances basically every episode
Pretty awkward to deadname and misgender him this entire comment
@@RomonicaDiGregory His “fans” are transphobic as shit towards him. It’s simply terrible
@@SuperPianogirl123 They absolutely did. Definitely not knocking them. Adding Sunshine''s character though created a nice story arc that was far too short. Everyone on Glee was a powerhouse in their own way.
@@RomonicaDiGregory I'm not talking about Jake though as Jake's version wasn't included in the video (unless I'm not remembering it) When you look up Charice Pempengco on RUclips(or Google) that is who pops up in the suggestions, not Jake. I think IMDB is the only site that automatically redirects to Jake.
The fact that they reach the note and HOLD it for so long! Jesus Christ, this people deserve an award!! (I’ve tried, believe me, it’s not as easy as it looks!!)
Perrieeeeeeee amazinggg
Watching singers hit high notes
Me: just sitting down just awkwardly opening my mouth as if I'm actually singing
Pia,regine and charices is the closest one
Agree so much! They sound so powerful.
I tried to cover this wonderful song with all the high notes, it’s nowhere close to Celine or Charice but it would mean the world to me if you heard it!😆✨🎼
I agree especially Regine she seems similar with Celine. Maybe its the “ine” in their names ahah
I love Pia Toscano. She is so good.
SO GOOD 💙💞💕
So amazingly blessed and talented.
One word… PERRIE!
Insanely excited for her upcoming solo material 😝
This and Whitney Houston's "I will always love you", are two songs that singers should never sing. The originals are vocal and emotional masterpieces. No one will ever be able to replicate or out do the originals.
both are covers by the way...
Did you consider that people sing these songs because it would be fun and enjoyable? I hardly doubt that any of these singers sang these songs because they were trying to “out do” the artists. Maybe replicate, but replicate in the sense of singing the same notes, the way the song is supposed to be sung.
If we aren’t even allowed to sing those songs, why were those songs made then? Let us sing what we want.
Perrie Edwards
Again, nobody gave the note the pure chest Celine did. Nobody did the full on chesty growled scratchy belt Celine did. And most importantly, nobody emoted like Celine. All were concentrated on hitting the note, while Celine delivered a whole wave of emotions that noone could approach.
yes that is very true celine did it that nobody did
Did NOT expect to see Willemijn here! Love her sm!
Piaaaa sitting down and hitting this note!!!!!! With suiuuuch resonance and to me it was the best one!
Y'all know Celine didn't sing this first? You realize this song is from the 70s, right? Please god, tell me you know that.
Bro wdym?
@@ulyssecohenner9640 The songwriter and original singer of the song was Eric Carmen, and it was released in the mid-70s. His version hits hardest.
@@ulyssecohenner9640 He literally died within the past month or two. Very recently.
Celine: often imitated, never duplicated. No one meets or exceeds her execution of that note. And not a single one brings the emotion to their performance that she does. Her tone is unmatched as well. The others sound like long-tailed cats in a room full of rocking chairs. 😱 In other words, who prefers faux leather when the original and the best is the genuine stuff?
@Devon Hawkins-Anderson Who?
@Devon Hawkins-Anderson Has she ever had a hit? Or sold any records?
Celine struggled SO much hitting it in the studio, and the reason you like hers better is because there is autotune on it. Celine never does it live because she can't do it. All of these women can hit it better than her, since she frankly can't do it. Live she always sings it 2 notes down. So don't diss on these amazing women when they do it better than Celine!
@@lottarydlandkjelby8917 If ever there was a singer who DOESN’T need autotune, it’s Celine, heifer. Which explains, in part, why she’s a living legend and none of these women are. To say the least. And if you actually believe any of them sing that note better than Celine, I just have one question: exactly how long have you been stone deaf?
Hey! But what makes you think they wanted to sound like Celine?) Do you tink this is the artist's meaning? To sound like other artist???)
Leona Lewis!!!!.The best cover ever ❤❤❤ She added that unbelievable sustained high note, absolutely sublime vocals 💯💯💯👏👏👏😍
Pia toscano though! Sitting down, wow and Perry 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Celine? GOAT. I'm all for the vocalists after her (cause they all slayed it) but the feeling you feel in your gut when you hear Celine "Dion the shit out of it" is just... there's just nothing like it. She grabs you in the chest and grips your soul so hard and doesn't let go and you're left wanting her to do it again. It's breathtaking. The OG is just a WONDER and we are all lucky to have lived in the era of her vocal dominance and blessed to be graced by her talent... but YO! Pia and Perrie did that SEATED... I mean, dang. And Jake really captures the essence of the emotion in the lyric and instrumentation backing him. The feeling from him was the closest to the original for me. But to each their own, of course.