Minecraft: The List - Episode 2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 окт 2024
- The List is a weekly comprehensive series that explores a variety of ideas I have regarding Minecraft accumulated over the last several years. This list is presented as I came up with the list and contains over 100 ideas that I feel are worthy of consideration for adding to Minecraft. Some ideas are big, some ideas are small but they each contribute to making Minecraft a more interesting and fulfilling game. If you missed episode one check it out here: • Minecraft: The List - ...
► Twitter: / cubfan135
Follow me on Twitter so you never miss a video!
Wanting more Minecraft ideas? Check out my Minecraft Opportunities series for a in-depth look at some potential Minecraft features: • Minecraft Opportunities
#minecraft #Cubfan135 #TheList
Phantoms in the end is one of the ideas people toss around a lot. But if you try it out using mods, it's even worse. They'd have to be localized to end cities or some other structure. Phantoms attacking while bridging across the void is the worst.
what abould some smaller islands are phantom breading grounds. so they spawn there
Maybe they could add a flag in the programming where it checks to see if you have Elytra equipped before it spawns a phantom on you. Cub's idea was to have scalable difficulty. The longer you're in the End, the more likely phantoms would spawn, and chances are you'd have found an Elytra by then.
@@ramonruijgt4532 phantom nest structure
nah, having a bit of a challenge for bridging would be welcome imo
Also, it makes it so that in multiplayer, the people who are not bridging have something to do: protect the bridger from phantoms
@@deimon451plus the end is literally the game's endgame. It makes sense if it were more difficult
Something I would change with your coral Idea is that bonemealing them makes no sense, they're animals rather than plants, so I would say that you should be able to place any cobble next to a coral block and the coral should then be able to spread the same way grass does to dirt 😊
Ah, they are animals, we can use bread then or Golden Carrots.🙃
@@InsipidAppl 😂 bread might go a bit soggy underwater 😜
All fantastic ideas, I'd add the hammer to the list of items that create reverberations making the dripstone fall!
The Red Nether Brick Block is the most underrated and underused block in Minecraft. Having a warped variant would be awesome, but something tells me that it wouldn't be blue enough for Scar, lol.
No, it’s not quite blue enough to be properly blue, but I bet it’d look really good alongside the purplish hue of Blackstone.
Phantoms being in the end makes sense from a lore standpoint as well, as phantom membranes repair elytras
OK, I hadn't thought of that when I said in my comment that they don't make sense in the End.
They also kinda look like flying Endermen.
Phantom idea sounds cool, but I’d rather not be terrified when bridgebuildng between the end islands.😅 The phantoms would definitely not be more likable if moved to the end dimension.
you basically only bridge across the end once, then you'll be using elytra
I don't use elytra@@JazzManhattan
Maybe they just spawn in the cities to avoid this issue?
Just sleep before going in, and you have a while before they spawn
@@The_PokeNerdthat was my thought as well to keep it balanced
Great list! I agree with all of them. The one I've thought the most of in the past was the Coral blocks. Bonemealing them is a cool idea, but I'd be happy if you could just take 4x Coral Fans and craft a block with them. It would take a lot longer to get a good supply, but it would be super easy to implement.
Absolutely love the MS Paint explanatory diagram. You missed a calling from the technical graphics industry 😁
Loving this series
What about... putting the fletching table functionality in the mineshaft dirt room?
The problem I see with moving the phantom to the end is getting to the first elytra. People need to bridge a lot in the end, for them to get to the first elytra, being than attacked by phantoms will be increadibly difficult to deal with, when on a narrow bridge.
It SHOULD be hard to get an Elytra. I also think they should remove mending from the Elytra
then bridge wider.
Cub was talking about the insomnia mechanic still working in the end, and since you cant sleep, you'd have a 3-day window to find an end city before they even start spawning. It makes it so that the longer you stay, the harder time you'll have
3:42 Beacon material should also definitely determine the range of the beacon. Iron blocks 50 block radius
Netherite should be the furthest reaching beacon
Agreed, I'm currently using a resource pack to hide beacon beams because i built a grid lf them to provide speed, haste, jump boost, and regen across my base/spawn town. That many beams is honestly just ugly.
Plus its a practical incentive to build more expensive beacons for resource mining areas.
I would have iron & emerald both do 50 blocks since they are so cheap. (Even without a raid farm). Then following the progression of gold, diamond, netherite boost it by 50 blocks each tier.
Although a full netherite is such a grind i could see having it be even further depending on how a 200block square radius beacon feels in game.
@@jasonreed7522 I see it as this
Iron 50
Gold 100
Emerald 150
Diamond 200
Netherite 500
@@Greesher actual numbers are definitely subject to balancing, but personally i would put emerald below gold since they are easier to get in large amounts. (Not even considering a raid farm, villager powered potato farm -> sell taters for emeralds -> profit. Especially if you cure the villagers first, and thats just 1 pathway.)
@@jasonreed7522 I guess I see it my way because I personally get a headache when dealing with villagers and there’s no village near me in my world. That and I have a giga gold farm so I just value it less than emeralds
Netherite Beacons shouldn't have a gameplay advantage but varying the rest is fine I think.
0:30 Shout-out to Wordpad, which Microsoft recently announced would be removed from Windows. It's like software development poetry. Writing the script about a Microsoft product development on a product they are deprecating. I see you cub. Well done.
I love the coral idea that's really smart, like coral saplings
Coral aren't plants though 😂
But Minecraft doesn’t need to be realistic.@@asteria4279
We have normal Nether Wart that makes Nether Wart Blocks but no Warped Wart to make Warped Wart Blocks. 12:07 Instead of changing the recipe they should just add Warped Nether Wart and rename Nether Wart to "Crimson Nether Wart." Then we'd have Crimson Nether Bricks and Warped Nether Bricks that way.
Nether wart is critical for potion brewing. It doesn't really need additional functionality.
These lists have been extremely well considered. Even if I might not agree 100% with every one, they are all very legit with good rationale, and would all be a legit way to solve real exigent issues.
Put TNT in the mineshaft rooms. Thanks for the cool ideas Cub
Gotta love the Captain Disillusion reference !!! 🤣
OMG yes, Cub is a real one, for sure 👍
When was that?
@@bell2023 13:10 his outro spiel
I’m down with the coral idea, but i just figure it should be at least a lil bit harder. Maybe give it a low chance to grow. Enough that sometimes, a block just refuses to grow and in general, takes 10-18 bonemeal. Perhaps alongside a condition that it must be on another coral block.
Even though coral does have real world efforts to preserve them, and it could be possible to represent that in the game, making it too renewable removes the feeling of it being threatened.
10:23 I think a system like the skulk has would work really well too. Instead of little ghost particles flowing out of a Catalyst, have dust particles flow from an explosion to drip stone within a certain radius as a sort of quake to knock some loose.
By putting Phantoms in the end, you're removing a way to kill phantoms; by sleeping. Also, you're dramatically increasing traversal difficulty in the end, particularly for those without means of faster travel.
What if phantoms only spawn on the main island with no ender dragon instead? Like if you linger there for a few days, and aren't under a ceiling etc. I do think they could introduce something like the respawn anchor or another item that'd let you reset your "insomnia" in the end as well.
So? Raiding end cities should be hard, the end should be, you know, end/late game content
@@drefk1973 The end is not just about raid cities. Getting to them is a big part of the battle, and not a lot of real estate to work with at times.
@@KBroly And getting there should be hard
I think what Minecraft needs most is a continuity update. Corals being bonemealed to large corals, adding missing stone variants (like andesite bricks or chiseled diorite), and just generally making mechanics and block crafting make more sense in the context of similar blocks and mechanics
The crimson nether brick is a good start, and the recipe could even remain the same, since 1 crimson block is made from nether wart. But what they really need to address is the red nether brick blocks being so limited -- we need red nether brick fences and chiseled red nether bricks too!
I think phantom which drop repair items for elytras and also potion ingredient for slow fall make them more well suited to the End. I love the crimson brick/nether brick blocks but maybe instead of changing the recipe we could have warped wart. Coral should be fed something to grow like baby cows/chickens/etc since they are an animal. The MSPaint section was my favorite. I loved it. It was informative and adorable and made me want to squish it with cute aggression.
Coral relies on a symbiotic relationship with zooxanthellae (a type of yellow algae) for its color, so maybe Mojang could add that somehow into the game, but I’d imagine a lot of players would complain about them adding that when its only use may be for growing coral.
(A solution to this would be to make gathering smaller coral and fans harder, also using zooxanthellae instead of bonemeal, and maybe even using zooxanthellae to revive dead coral.)
I think beacon material should affect the beam and it's effect, not just the aesthetics. I would like a larger radius. When you compare a beacon to a conduit, you see how smalle the beacon is. I'd also like other minerals available as materials, like redstone, copper, and amethyst.
For aesthetic changes, maybe use the raw ore block instead of the refined ore block, thus giving another use for Silk Touch.
10/10 thumbnail
This is such a cool series, and i love the way youre putting it together like one of those pld history channel shows. Thanks for the effeort youve put into this project so far, hopefully some of the guys at mojang will keep tabs on this and add some of these ideas. It would also be kind of funny if at some point down the road you did a special edition "the list" subseries or episode with scar to talk about some of the ideas on his infamous scroll
I am going to suggest that Coral needs a rework, but not in the way you suggest; coral is a living animal, not a plant, so the internal logic of bonemealing coral blocks to spread them is not consistent. I would like to suggest a living coral mob, that functions comparably to a Shulker, where it attaches to coral blocks similar to how fan coral generates. Every full moon there is a small chance that the coral reproduces automatically (generating offspring on a hydrated living coral block within a certain radius), and when a coral mob successfully reproduces there is a greater than 50% chance that they die off, leaving behind a coral fan. If coral offspring try to generate on a coral block that is covered in coral fans, it will turn one of these coral fans into a coral block and generate on top of that block.
Something about the intro to this series really does it for me
I think they should change the spawning condition for phantoms, not the location. Instead of spawning due to a lack of sleep, they should spawn due to a guilty conscience. If a villager were to die near you then you would get the Pantom Curse. It doesn't matter who or what killed the villager, it only matters that you feel bad about its death and so now phantoms will haunt you. Maybe there's a twentyfive percent chance that every time you kill a phantom the curse will go away, or you could simply have a bucket of milk.
1:34 well timed witch cackle
The phantom gamerule was added around the same time as the pillager patrol gamerule was. Remember how rough pillager patrols were in 1.14? I'd say that in the modern day that gamerule could be removed, as both the frequency of them has been lessened and their effect isn't forced upon the player, though I prefer having more options.
I think the mineshaft idea is great, especially if the gold blocks are part of the badlands mineshaft while the copper is for Y>0 mineshafts and iron for Y
The other problem with phantom spawning right now is that if you _do_ have the insomnia game rule turned off, it makes it almost impossible to get phantom membranes because literally the only way to obtain them is from a 1 in 31 chance from a cat gift every night, so having some other way of spawning them in would help in this regard. Granted membranes aren't too useful right now, but if they did get more of a use this would definitely be a bigger problem.
(Also turning their spawning off locks you out of 2 advancements, just another minor inconvenience)
Cat gift? what is that?
@@tahsin0097 if you have a tamed cat nearby and sleep in a bed, the cat will sleep with you and upon waking up will drop an item. It's usually something like a feather or raw chicken, but there's a small chance you get a phantom membrane (it's rarer than any other item from this)
the membranes have no use. If you choose those over a mending book you are signing up for way more work than you have to do
never clicked faster
Amen brother
Same
For the Phantom change in the end instead of having them spawn anywhere near the player, have them spawn near end cities with only ships, so non ship end cities dont have the phantoms. and dont removed them from the overworked until something else is displaced for the difficulty, just plain moving them to the end will make dramatic difference for difficulty for the overworld, some players never even go to the end, they probaly will never see the phantoms.
One idea I have had for a few years for Phantoms is that there should be a non undead, passive version of them. If they're undead, they have to be an undead version of *something* right? Just have passive ones flying through the void... maybe they fly towards cities to point the way or something. And as you suggested, the longer you stay in the end, the more likely they are to turn hostile.
The real problem with phantoms is that they require you to sleep. A part of minecraft was lost when we all started sleeping through every night. I miss the danger and thrill of surviving the first night.
I propose that phantoms be changed to spawn when you sleep instead of when you don't, this makes sense if they are meant to be a nightmare. If you sleep out in the open you will be attacked by phantoms, woken up and have to fight. That encourages you, to build a structure around your bed, in a game about building your starter house is now useful again, a little tent is a useful structure to build when out exploring.
I've often thought the same thing about beacons .... there's like 0 incentive or reason, other than boredom and "just cos", to use anything other than iron. You should have to use, instead of more layers, more expensive blocks to get the higher tier, or more simaltanious buffs active.
if we were going to reflect minecraft into real life, they should add a grate-like wood block where fan corals can grow. The coral fan will specifically grow on that grate block in warm ocean biome, under y-64 and would take long time (longer than oxidation of copper). As for the blocks, I do agree with bonemeal-ing the coral fan to grow into coral block structure
Man I'm loving this List, Cub! Especially love your dripstone explosion diagram! 😂
Sleeping needs some work, I agree. Not touching on Insomnia itself (I think it needs to be more than a mere phantom on/off button, making it similar to Bad Omen or common gaming implementations of Death's Sting), beds should be sleepable at all times and even in all dimensions. The thing that happens when you sleep in a bed (advancing the night, explosion, etc) should only happen when you exit the bed. If we're going to regard the End as a nightmare to wake up from, then perhaps in the End the bed becomes an emergency exit back to the overworld (no more bedwars with the ender dragon), which would be really handy pre-dragonfight if you forgot something (ie, blocks to bridge around with).
The mineshaft starts out nonsensical, in that the start point doesn't have to connect to anything else (spawner dungeons have to be attached to caves or another open-air space.) Maybe structures need to "snap" to some entrance-point that is then used to invalidate procedural expansion from the start point in that direction (thereby overwriting or crossing through the entryway). Being the startpoint of the mineshaft, perhaps some "furniture"-like creative builds of machinery or just simple-machines inclusions for ore-processing and the like (autosmelters, etc) as a sort of pregenerated starter base/outpost/camp.
I like the red netherbrick change, but I see it as analogous to the 1.9 end changes versus what players now call for (the modern End Update is what I refer to it as). There's no reason to suggest red nether bricks are at all related to the crimson set. I would love to see the crimson/warped idea get more of a mossed texture instead of just being a solid-color variation of the original. Perhaps the original red nether bricks could be shunted over to the dyable group to give them their first complex-texture option (all of the dyable sets, with the exception of the glazed terracotta, are mainly solid-color with only minor elements breaking up the texture--the gleaming specks in glass, the granules in concrete powder, the threads in wool, etc).
Been saying phantoms belong in the end for years! All great ideas cub
Someone hire this man as a game designer asap
Everthing sounds great. Except coral fans. Because Corals are actually small animals called polyps, shaped like miniature sea cucumbers, that can form colonies. These polyps create a shared skeleton, which in some species forms the foundation of a coral reef.
Therefore you cannot bonemeal them.
It would be cool to have a different growing method for them then. I suppose you could do over time, but it'd be cool if you had to craft an artificial coral bed and then use some other means to get them to grow. I don't know how you'd bride their slow growth with something like the sapling style growth cub mentioned but frankly Coral is a primarily aesthetic block anyways so If it's a little slower than just bonemealing it I personally wouldn't mind
Then maybe switch to bonemeal coral fans for more and maybe add the possibilities to do it like for giant spruce tree then, planting 4 coral fans together would make corals growing overtime ?
Bonemeal makes coral not so special and fragile
One caveat about your drip stone cone proposal is that the further below the creeper is from the drip stone ceiling, the larger the area of drip stone would fall. My intuition tells me less drip stone should fall the further the explosion is
I like your thought on beacons, but go another step, the material the base is made from will determine what status effects are available, that or what item is sacrificed to power. For example an iron base gives haste but diamond give regen gold jump boost etc.
The problem I see with that idea is that it will break a lot of beacon setup since you can have all beacon effects in one base if it is big enough. If the block used will determine the power given, that setup will become impossible.
I like the idea of the corals since it is better than just crafting the coral fans to make a block. I always hate non-renewable blocks that you only get by destroying a part of your world. Heck, even dirt is renewable and that's everywhere. Make more non-renewable blocks renewable. ESPECIALLY Sand.
Dirt is a great example, there are atleast 2 pathways for fully renewable dirt using either gravel -> course dirt, or moss -> podzol.
And if you aren't in a skyblock world its everywhere. Underground blobs usually have a couple stacks worth each so thats a good source without destroying the surface, and the surface dirt is 4 blocks deep so you can theoretically skim 2-3 layers off without it ruining the look of the area. (Let the grass grow back and don't leave floating trees and stuff, along with blending the edges. But its possible)
Basically dirt has 2 renewable pathways when it technically doesn't need them for normal worlds. And i consider that good game design, we need more pathways to make different blocks renewable in large amounts. (Wandering trader is cool but sells like 5 of an item and comes once every 20min or so which is not an industrial supply of anything.)
I feel like your phantom idea is good, but what better place for the most hated mob than hell itself? You'd think in a unbearably hot, highly deadly, often very dark place where your literally punished for sleeping by being exploded, that a person would wear out psychologically and emotionally, perfect environment to spawn nightmares.
I always thought Phantoms could be much less annoying with just some small tweaks.
Taking quick naps in the day I think would go a long way to addressing that but I also thought it would be good to know when theyre due. Maybe if each painting has a 'pahntom variant' with a phantom hidden somewhere in the painting to tie in with the insomnia theme, while also giving paintings a use beyond decoration.
Also they shouldn't show up at all until after you first visit the end, and they stop coming if you die, until you visit the end again.
You should be on a retainer with Mojang, if you’re not already Cub. Outstanding analysis, as always.
I love the phantom suggestion. One note: They shouldn't spawn between the main island and outer islands.
Forgot to comment last video but this is awesome ! I can’t wait to hear everything, I can imagine doc watching the first one talking about duping, just freaking out haha. Keep it up cub this is great !
You can't convince me that Cub and Coach from Homestar runner aren't the same person.
These ideas are all so well though out, and the editing is amazing!
I disagree with the way you implemented the creeper explosion causing dripstone to drop. With a cone above the creeper, this makes it so that if a creeper was standing next to the dripstone but was out of the blast radius, it wouldn't trigger. The creeper would specifically HAVE to be underneath the dripstone which wouldn't be very accurate imo and not make much sense. Plus drawing a cone bounding box takes more processing than just a simple sphere or box around the creeper that could have a set radius that causes all dripstone within the selection to fall. Could even add a check to make sure that every dripstone doesn't fall that way it isn't a surefire way that the player WILL die XD
love these ideas, cub! and love this series with you sharing your ideas!
Never clicked faster
I just love your speaking voice! I would love to hear a space documentary by you ✨ Excellent ideas on this list! Love your drawings, too 😁
The big finale of this series better be to fix the fletching table. If not I'll have a word with Cub!
Great suggestions. Just don’t call warped wood “blue” around Scar or Bdubs! 😂
The paint drawn thumbnail is peak
Love This already
Is that outro a Captain Disillusion reference? That’s always nice to see. Also funny how it’s a reference to a reference.
For the warped nether brick, I think it would make more sense to add a new nether plant called Warped Wart that can be used to craft them as well as warped wart blocks. It can be found in fortresses that generate in a warped forest and is used in brewing the same way nether wart is. (also maybe rename nether wart to crimson wart)
Once again, I love that I agree with almost the whole list. I'd be pleased if all these things got changed.
I love how well thought out your ideas are! I could wax poetic about all of these!
Different beacon beams for different materials is a cool idea, but how would you handle beacon bases made out of multiple different materials? Since we're trying not to alter the functionality of beacons, we can't just say "a beacon base doesn't work if it's made of more than one material", so we'd need a way to handle beacon beams for mixed material bases.
Can’t you mix ore blocks into beacon pyramids? What would the beam look like with a beacon that uses multiple types of ore blocks?
Also, I have to disagree with the phantom suggestion, as slow falling potions already help fix how broken the Ender dragon’s toss ability is, and, as other commenters mentioned, having phantoms spawn everywhere in the End would make bridging very difficult, and highly risky. (Which it already is with Endermen getting on your void bridges)
You said so much coral in this video I just started hearing the walking dead carl/coralcompilation.
That last remark about finding disc 13, 13 times was a little too real. We've got so many copies of it on the realm I play on
My new favourite series :D
To everyone saying phantoms should not spawn in the end because it makes early bridging too dangerous: Cub states that they would only start spawning after spending a long time in the end, meaning the player would probably be able to get an elytra beforehand. Also, bridging across end islands is already too easy as there is nothing dangerous as long as you play it safe.
Endermen spawns are incredibly high when bridging. The last point isn’t true.
I like everything except the phantoms in the End. Phantoms don't "fit in" with the End and don't make sense there IMO. Bridging across the Void is already plenty dangerous and scary enough--Adding such a high risk of being knocked into the void is out of proportion to the penalty of permanently losing all your stuff. Endermen can knock you off but that is balanced by the ability to avoid aggro-ing them by not looking at them. Second, you'd want to sleep before entering so you'd have to wait around until night to do that (unless resting in the bed from Episode 1 resets your insomnia clock). Third, there's probably going to be an End update at some point and Mojang will come up with some mob that fits in with better with the End biome. I do like the idea of limiting them to a certain biome or two though.
While I agree having the different beacon materials should do something different, it should be more than just a different appearance of the beam.
Hi cub! Excited for ep 2!!!!
Also, make the coral grow back but very slowly. I think the idea behind coral being non renewable is because of the distraction of the coral reefs at the time and how it's being destroyed faster than it can regrow.
this format is great. mojang listen to this
Phantoms knocking you into the void? Nope
Also coral is not a plant. You can't bone meal it. But I like the idea of having fans grow on artificial reafs. A real artificial reaf with coral structures, in the warm ocean and not just a couple bits of coral to make a farm. I also think instead of adding light to the Amethyst blocks, why not just remove the light from the clusters?
the drip stone falling is kinda cool
I think wart BLOCKS would be a better way to craft crimson & warped bricks. Just easier to obtain in bulk. Maybe both recipes could work?
Truly solid ideas. Im down for all of them!
Phantoms can just spawn on end stone other than the main island in the end to prevent the bridging problem people are bringing up. Doesnt have to be just cities
That animation though!
Could all of your ideas be made into a mod pack? I'm loving all the changes!
Once again I love your ideas.
Very nice touch with the use of MS Paint.
you should be able to hide beacon beams but still get the effect, maybe by adding another beacon on top.
glass would color the beam and another beacon would make in invisible.
I'm loving this series, Cub! 😮😊
Phantoms knocking you into the void = NOOO. PLEASE NO. Not in the end.
Mojang should pay attention!
Oh man, i love this series soonmuch
Great video duuude!
I knew I was going to love this series haha
about the beacons, tinted glass should block the beam with out blocking the effect.
I am strongly against having phantoms in the end. The last thing I want is to be hit by a phantom while bridging over the void after a couple hours of not finding an end city. Even after getting the elytra having to deal with both shulker bullets and phantoms would be so frustrating. And with out the ability to sleep in the end there would be no way to stop phantoms from spawning. I already don't go to the end very often past getting an elytra. This change would make me not want to go at all.
MS paint animation is top notch... No pun intended.. well maybe some pun intended
How is that a pun? Do you know what a pun is?
13 Music disk thats crazy, I also need to get on my research
A better idea for the beacon bases is the different bases increase the range with iron the shortest range and netherite the longest range.
this seiries is awesome
The coral idea is really bad, it's actually very cool that it cannot easily be farmed. If you could bonemeal it, someone would figure out an OP farm and it would ruin a lot of gameplay (e.g. getting the materials to build an underwater breathing thingy would now never be worth it anymore). The current situation creates a lot of opportunities for people to build structures around coral reefs -- for example see Gem's in S10 of HC.
i really like the coral bonemeal idea.
Please don't put phantoms in the end. That's worse than them in the overworld. They will knock you into the void constantly. I'd like the end to be a more viable place to spend your time, not a less viable one. The end shouldn't be a barren wasteland, players have been demanding an end rework for years.
I do like the idea of the dripstone but I don't think Mojang will ever add it because caving is one of the first things new players do and it would make caves too dangerous.
My only issue with the red nether brick change is that nether wart already has too few uses, taking this away makes them just for potions. Minecraft already has enough single use items without taking away uses from some of the few that have a couple.