I am really at a loss to understand how these two sublime artists could have ever been compared. Tebaldi had a ravishing vocal endowment and she was a wonderfully disciplined artist. No reason whatsoever to compare her and Maria Callas. Both had different attributes, sought different artistic goals, and really specialized in their own respective repertoires. Tebaldi was a modern Twentieth Century soprano whose repertoire was rooted in Puccini and the verismo composers, as well as a few Verdi roles. Ms Tebaldi’s voice is bright and girlish and dark and angry and hopeful and playful, as -I think- the voice of Choi Choi in Madame Butterfly should sound. Callas' art was rooted in a much earlier period (bel canto) and she had a three octave range which enabled her to undertake everything. Callas did perhaps not have the vocal velvet of Tebaldi. She was a different artist altogether. Bashing one against the other is stupid and shows an innate ignorance about music. Two different artistic approaches COMPLETELY. Both divas defined a period in Italian opera that we will not likely encounter again.
❤❤❤❤❤Extraordinario tu comentario, al fin alguien habla sensatamente. Tebaldi y Callas eran dos artistas con calidades diferentes que las hacían únicas. Dudo mucho que en esta generación escuchemos algo parecido. Un saludo cordial y felices fiestas.
I don't think the contrast issue should be one pertaining to music. What makes Mme Callas unique in her time is the fact that she always used her vocality in the service of acting, producing a profound synthesis. This approach was, though divergent in starting point, similar to the way that the great actor and countertenor Christopher Robson aimed at pure theatre. A balance between ego, technique and dramatic necessity is the grail of any artist, or certainly should be.
Callas is much better! Lower body fat %, she was exercising every day probably. Tebaldi definitely needed ABS training... and a few pounds off. Why would anybody compare them?!!!😀
@@car5car5 For some reason, excess weight favours the voice - think Tetrazzini, Pavarotti, Jessye Norman. And after Maria Callas slimmed down, she might have become one of the most glamorous women in the world, but her voice suffered perceptibly, as comparison of her recordings sadly demonstrates. But she is still one of the greatest artists of all time.
I heard her sing ‘la Vergine’ in a 1966 concert here in Vancouver. She also sang the Easter Hymn from Cavalleria, l’altra notte and Desdemona’s willow song and prayer.
I've got to add that. I listened to the vinyl lp dozens and dozens of times but seeing her perform it in person in this filming 60 years later is a real thrill.
~Tebaldi is in superb voice here. 1960 is often said to be the very last year of her prime, ( not coincidentally, it was the year in which she lost her beloved mother.) But she certainly doesn't sound like she is at the end of anything here...
Una stupenda Tebaldi...quando con la Callas...divideva i più grandi palcoscenici del mondo...la voce di Renata è magnificata dalla sua arte assoluta.🙏👏👏👏👏👏❤
Splendida possente voce, la potenza e la interpretazione che dava ai suoi personaggi la rendevano riconoscibile. Non me ne voglia alcuno, ...come lo era Maria Callas la qui voce univa anch'essa profonda potenza interpretativa e dava profonde emozioni. Due grandi soprano che hanno calcato magistralmente i teatri lirici senza nulla togliere ad altre grandi come la più delicata interpretazione di Renata Scotto, che ebbi la possibilità di ascoltare a Lecce o Raina Kabaivanska con una superba lirica voce e la profondità di Monserrat Caballe' ..... oh sì si sono un pochino perdute le grandi interpreti...
So eine Stimme, so voluminös, so schön und ausdrucksstark hat es nach ihr nicht mehr gegeben. Ich hatte das Glück, sie in den 60ziger Jahren noch live zu erleben und wusste damals schon, so eine Stimme wirst du nie wieder hören. Und so war es auch! Zum Glück gibt es viele wunderbare Aufnahmen von ihr.
Heute klingen die meisten Stimmen leider ähnlich. Man scheint einem einheitlichen Schönheitsideal zu folgen. In der Tat: Das ist eine mustergültige Interpretation!
I take it you are Russian? Please stop opening your mouth or using your pen. Everytime you do so there will be just lies. Start pestering your own kind but don't get involved in a cvil debate between people that take world 🎁peace seriously.
Felicissimo di aver potuto aggiungere ai video della tebaldi anche quest'ultimo, appena arrivato. È sempre una ricchezza poterla vedere e ascoltare. Di questo concerto già da decenni esisteva l'audio ma da pochi anni si stanno aggiungendo i video.....
La Soprano Renata Tebaldi apodada la Voce D'Angelo la mas grande soprano Lirico Spinto de todos los tiempos y la Cio Cio San de la Madama Butterfly de referencia
The magnificent Tebaldi 💙🌟
I met her in Westchester
A true artist! When I play Madama Butterfly, the vocal elegance of Renata Tebaldi is always a great lesson for me
I am really at a loss to understand how these two sublime artists could have ever been compared. Tebaldi had a ravishing vocal endowment and she was a wonderfully disciplined artist. No reason whatsoever to compare her and Maria Callas. Both had different attributes, sought different artistic goals, and really specialized in their own respective repertoires. Tebaldi was a modern Twentieth Century soprano whose repertoire was rooted in Puccini and the verismo composers, as well as a few Verdi roles. Ms Tebaldi’s voice is bright and girlish and dark and angry and hopeful and playful, as -I think- the voice of Choi Choi in Madame Butterfly should sound. Callas' art was rooted in a much earlier period (bel canto) and she had a three octave range which enabled her to undertake everything. Callas did perhaps not have the vocal velvet of Tebaldi. She was a different artist altogether. Bashing one against the other is stupid and shows an innate ignorance about music. Two different artistic approaches COMPLETELY. Both divas defined a period in Italian opera that we will not likely encounter again.
❤❤❤❤❤Extraordinario tu comentario, al fin alguien habla sensatamente. Tebaldi y Callas eran dos artistas con calidades diferentes que las hacían únicas. Dudo mucho que en esta generación escuchemos algo parecido. Un saludo cordial y felices fiestas.
I don't think the contrast issue should be one pertaining to music. What makes Mme Callas unique in her time is the fact that she always used her vocality in the service of acting, producing a profound synthesis. This approach was, though divergent in starting point, similar to the way that the great actor and countertenor Christopher Robson aimed at pure theatre. A balance between ego, technique and dramatic necessity is the grail of any artist, or certainly should be.
Callas is much better! Lower body fat %, she was exercising every day probably. Tebaldi definitely needed ABS training... and a few pounds off. Why would anybody compare them?!!!😀
@@car5car5 For some reason, excess weight favours the voice - think Tetrazzini, Pavarotti, Jessye Norman. And after Maria Callas slimmed down, she might have become one of the most glamorous women in the world, but her voice suffered perceptibly, as comparison of her recordings sadly demonstrates. But she is still one of the greatest artists of all time.
@@rosemaryallen2128 I am losing weight, now I sing better than Pavarotti, we'll see how I'll sing after losing 20 lb.
How absolutely splendid!
Voce d angelo, ora canti in cielo. Grazie per averci dato la tua arte per tanti anni
Splendida 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Splendida 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Mamma che Voce……… L’attacco più perfetto in Assoluto.
I heard her sing ‘la Vergine’ in a 1966 concert here in Vancouver. She also sang the Easter Hymn from Cavalleria, l’altra notte and Desdemona’s willow song and prayer.
Her voice is just pure gold
Renata singing un bel di was the first opera I was exposed to as a ten year old child. I will never forget the song and her voice and her feelings.
I've got to add that. I listened to the vinyl lp dozens and dozens of times but seeing her perform it in person in this filming 60 years later is a real thrill.
I agree. As a student I stood in line 3 hours to get standing room only ticket. She did not disappoint.
Wunderbar! Ich habe nie eine bessere Butterfly gehört, als die von Frau Tebaldi. Sie ist einfach nur großartig in dieser Rolle!
~Tebaldi is in superb voice here. 1960 is often said to be the very last year of her prime, ( not coincidentally, it was the year in which she lost her beloved mother.) But she certainly doesn't sound like she is at the end of anything here...
She lost her mother in 1957.
Her top notes were not secure
@@sanfordpress8943OK they aren’t fantastic here but the entire aria beyond that is about perfect. Such a full rich tone.
THIS IS ART ❤
From the first note ... Extraordinary.
Слушаю эту арию а новогоднюю ночь 2023. И эта музыка, и этот голос Ане времени. Благодарю!
That's a voice that carries and can front an orchestra. Amazing.
Meravigliosa gloria italiana
Una stupenda Tebaldi...quando con la Callas...divideva i più grandi palcoscenici del mondo...la voce di Renata è magnificata dalla sua arte assoluta.🙏👏👏👏👏👏❤
Semplicemente divina :)
I have never listened to Tebaldi's Butterfly before. I've been missing out
I had many recordings of Tebaldi singing this aria - but this is the first time I had seen a video of her singing. Beautiful voice.
An all time great. I saw her on her farewell tour with Franco Corelli. Enormous voices, and they still sounded great.
Una grandissima voce di tutti i tempi.
Нет слов! Хочется слушать снова и снова. Bravissimo, Renata Tebaldi!
@@car5car5
*тебя опять выпустили из Кащенко досрочно?*
@@God-9-9-9-9-9 u tebq, дурака, с юмором напряг?
@@car5car5 *лошуля, ты и юмор? Это оксюморон.*
Голос Ренаты - тёплый луч встающего утра
Canterà in cielo,la sua voce d’angelo è dentro di noi.
Occhi appannati cuore accelerato che dire nessun complimento regge (.DIVINA )
Splendida possente voce, la potenza e la interpretazione che dava ai suoi personaggi la rendevano riconoscibile. Non me ne voglia alcuno, ...come lo era Maria Callas la qui voce univa anch'essa profonda potenza interpretativa e dava profonde emozioni. Due grandi soprano che hanno calcato magistralmente i teatri lirici senza nulla togliere ad altre grandi come la più delicata interpretazione di Renata Scotto, che ebbi la possibilità di ascoltare a Lecce o Raina Kabaivanska con una superba lirica voce e la profondità di Monserrat Caballe' ..... oh sì si sono un pochino perdute le grandi interpreti...
Tolle Stimme, die die Seele zum Klingen bringt
Stupenda esecuzione di questa splendida aria...
Che amore di Renata! ❤❤
Ora ho capito da chi hai preso l'abitudine di cantare sempre con le mani attorcigliate sotto le tette.
So eine Stimme, so voluminös, so schön und ausdrucksstark hat es nach ihr nicht mehr gegeben. Ich hatte das Glück, sie in den 60ziger Jahren noch live zu erleben und wusste damals schon, so eine Stimme wirst du nie wieder hören. Und so war es auch! Zum Glück gibt es viele wunderbare Aufnahmen von ihr.
Heute klingen die meisten Stimmen leider ähnlich. Man scheint einem einheitlichen Schönheitsideal zu folgen. In der Tat: Das ist eine mustergültige Interpretation!
@@geroelze7566 cierto hoy todo suena igual, falta técnica y pasión. Saludos cordiales
Merveilleuse Renata Tebaldi !!!
Voix unique et inégalable !!!
C'est la plus grande soprano lyrico-spinto du monde.
Non, on dirait un chat qui miaule.
Une horreur.
@@ir3356у Вас, простите, плохой вкус.
How I loved her voice. Maybe my all time favorite soprano.
This is öne of the Aria makes me emotional …
Touches your soul
Reneta sings very beautiful 🌺🙏👏
Absolument sublime, pour moi la meilleure interprétation de ce sublime air de Puccini
Philippe
Chills and rapid heartbeat. Renata, you were unmatchable by any other talent or voice.
Oltre alla bellissima voce ha avuto il privilegio degli ingegneri del suono Decca per tutta la carriera.
Registrazioni perfette.
Time had her on the cover. She was great
La voz de ángel
Toscanini tenía toda la razón, es la voz más Bella de esos años, voz de Ángel.
Just beautiful!!!
Великолепно,замечательно это можно слушать не один раз браво!
I take it you are Russian? Please stop opening your mouth or using your pen. Everytime you do so there will be just lies. Start pestering your own kind but don't get involved in a cvil debate between people that take world 🎁peace seriously.
The most beautiful rendition of this great aria.
Una storia che non torna piu❤
Miss Tebaldi, wonderful as usual ! Her beatiful voice is incomparable !
What a wonderful singer Renata was and singing my favourite opera. Thank you.
Wonderful opera singer 👏 !
Magnífica interpretación y una voz maravillosa.
Saluti da acá
She and Corelli. Fabulous Grazie Mille
fenomenal........................de las mas grandes........................
Великолепное выступление.
I loved her when I first encountered her voice in the 1950s and I still love her.
This looks so easy...
Renata!!! Renata!!! Renata!!!
Phenomenal! Brava Renata!👏👏👏
Renata, quelle magnifique voix puissante , limpide et si douce à la fois..bref j adore !bravissimo.
Maravillosa interpretación de Renata Tebaldi, con musicalidad perfecta y su voz excelsa. Armando Nazareno Cerutti-barítono
목소리가 너무나 품위있네요. 고급스럽고.
Hermoso ❤
Forse un bel di tracentomila anni ascolteremo forse un canto cosi grande ❤🎉🎉🎉❤
At 3:34 the conductor reaches out to her after a flawless climactic note and she smiles back at him.
Very beautiful interpretation of this fragment from the famous opera!
Great to see a early video of Renata she was superb all those years ago
Felicissimo di aver potuto aggiungere ai video della tebaldi anche quest'ultimo, appena arrivato. È sempre una ricchezza poterla vedere e ascoltare. Di questo concerto già da decenni esisteva l'audio ma da pochi anni si stanno aggiungendo i video.....
Immensa e unica. Che tempi!!!
Además de potencia tiene gusto cantando es la mejor que he escuchado. En hombres Alfredo Krauss
I met la Signora Tebaldi a lot of time at Café Taveggia in Milan, she, the sweety dog and her secretary. Smailing will be in me forever. Thank you
Superb singing !
Mesmerising
Renata tebaldy Best voice
Love everything she does.
❤❤❤Qué maravilla, madre mía! Si tienen el concierto completo, ruego que lo compartan, por favor. Muchas gracias
Seemingly effortless.
😢😢😢beautiful
Truly, a glorious voice!
Es fabulosa la interpretación de esta cantante fue grandiosa y muy conmovedora.
Certainly one of the greats. 🤗
Une pure merveille
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Gorgeous singing.
❤unica per sempre❤
Bravo!!💯🙏🏽
Che meraviglia!
Divina
Une véritable voix d'ange comme le disait le maestro Arturo Toscanini
One of my favourite's soprano.
Grandi voci....Jaguar Mercury
Me encanta ❤️
DEPOIS DA DIVA MARIA CALLAS, ESSA INTÉRPRETE É A QUE REALMENTE
CANTA A ALTURA ESSA MÚSICA 👏👏👏
I love her! Bravo! 👏👏👏👏👏
Il Soprano pucciniano par excellence!
오 신성한 목소리 테발디의 아리아는 정말 비범하고 아름답습니다.
테발디만의 단단하고 정석적인 발성이 너무 좋네요. 정말 깔끔해요. 칼라스는 좀 과한 느낌.
音色豔麗，如聞天籟。
Perfection on earth
Nessuno cantava e canta tutt'ora quest’opera come la Tebaldi. Superba, magnifica
Велика певица! Адмирации! Брилянтно изпълнение на" Бътерфлай"! Била е конкурент вдаден период от живота на Калас.
Just heard Renata and Maris’s version. Renata’s much more rich, powerful, velvety, while Maria’s thinny, light. Both great sopranos
La más grande soprano de todos los tiempos.
Inigualable.
Desde Cartago Costa Rica
27/11/22
Eccezzionale!!!
Maria callas cantaba su propio requiem. Que en paz descanse. Hermosas palabras
Voce sublime ,con la Callas la mia preferita
Actually extraordinary how the technical side of this aria has changed..Callas... Netrebko..ect..each a different approach..but we'll done
La Soprano Renata Tebaldi apodada la Voce D'Angelo la mas grande soprano Lirico Spinto de todos los tiempos y la Cio Cio San de la Madama Butterfly de referencia
I saw videos of other 2 songs from this concert. This is new for me. Thanks! Are there any other videos from this particular concert?