Why Cacturne was Banned

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 апр 2024
  • ●. Enjoy the video? Subscribe! bit.ly/PokeaimMD .●
    Why Cacturne was banned in generation 3 OU
    [BG Music] ROUTE 225: 8-Bit Remix by Zame:
    • ROUTE 225: 8-Bit Remix...
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 753

  • @Nadid_Dhrabb
    @Nadid_Dhrabb Месяц назад +2669

    People on their way to berate the OU council for not banning Kingambit and Gholdengo instead of Cacturne in gen 3 OU

    • @Fanimati0n
      @Fanimati0n Месяц назад +75

      I feel that Gholdengo & Kingambit aren't quite banworthy at the moment. I think menaces like Espathra & Annihilape that worked their way to ubers are the real bs ones, though I'd say that Kingambit & Gholdengo are just barely *not* oubl worthy

    • @downtownraw2676
      @downtownraw2676 Месяц назад +199

      @@Fanimati0n OHH BROTHER STHAAAPPPP Gholdengo and Kingambit are literaly the most brain dead mons with busted abilities in the meta atm. They litteraly flip the script whenever they are in stage

    • @austinlundahl5349
      @austinlundahl5349 Месяц назад +77

      Tbf they didn’t ban cacturne they banned sandveil which is cacturnes only ability. You can still use gligar because it has another ability in hyper cutter. I learned all of this from the insane gamer jimothy cool

    • @samp_txt
      @samp_txt Месяц назад +43

      @@downtownraw2676 brother is still complaining about Ghold after a year and a half of it existing in the metagame. Can guarantee that you just straight up have not interacted with the competitive scene in a minute if you think Ghold is in anyway shape or form broken in its current state.

    • @underbandit2372
      @underbandit2372 Месяц назад +24

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@downtownraw2676I agree that Kingambit is still brain dead, but Gholdengo is not that crazy anymore. He is countered by at least half of OU based on type matchups alone since OU is infested with heavy hitting ground and fire types like Volc, Heatran, Gliscor, etc. Not to mention how most of these mons are faster than Ghold (BST wise) like Samurott-H and Great Tusk. In fact, Gholdengo is best at deterring stall strats since Bliss and Corv barely have counters against it, or just chipping away at enemy health with make it rain. Gholdengo is not a balanced Mon, but I don’t think it should be banned either.

  • @TheSpektrum1989
    @TheSpektrum1989 Месяц назад +1757

    "I hate sand. It's coarse and it gets everywhere." - The Council probably

    • @watersensei1
      @watersensei1 Месяц назад +23

      and rough and irritating

    • @acekechi
      @acekechi Месяц назад +33

      To Cacturn -
      "You are on this council, but we do not grant you the rank of master"

    • @sleekntears9467
      @sleekntears9467 Месяц назад +4

      That’s why competitive pokemon is a joke. Something is strong? Ban it

    • @lucasgreer1736
      @lucasgreer1736 Месяц назад +9

      @@sleekntears9467 pretty much every other competitive game also bans unbalanced stuff

    • @sleekntears9467
      @sleekntears9467 Месяц назад

      @@lucasgreer1736 Usually bans occur before each match and are decided by the players

  • @echogaia1708
    @echogaia1708 Месяц назад +1146

    "Cacturne unique typing in that generation" Shiftry : Am i a joke to you?

    • @minecraftoverlord4212
      @minecraftoverlord4212 Месяц назад +179

      Yes, actually.

    • @rifasclub
      @rifasclub Месяц назад +38

      Well, sun is not as good as sandstorm.

    • @TheSandwhichman108
      @TheSandwhichman108 Месяц назад +50

      Sorry Shiftry…But carturn is better than you in practically every way until the gen 4 physical/special split.

    • @sheepisfortheweak6164
      @sheepisfortheweak6164 Месяц назад

      Yes, you are. Away with you, you worthless tengu.

    • @BigAutisticDaddy
      @BigAutisticDaddy Месяц назад

      sorry Shiftry, but T-taur doesn't bring the sun.

  • @ZBB415
    @ZBB415 Месяц назад +168

    They banned cacturne because he was out standing in his field

    • @Pepesmall
      @Pepesmall Месяц назад +8

      Brilliant

    • @phellowshipstar8756
      @phellowshipstar8756 23 дня назад +4

      This is the only good comment in this entire comment section

    • @nathanrice8778
      @nathanrice8778 9 дней назад +1

      Exactly what I was thinking. Like boohoo ur Tyranitar can’t beat a fuckin cactus💀fuckin get over it 😂

  • @CountGremlin
    @CountGremlin Месяц назад +341

    "Those damn Smogon bureaucrats!!" -Cactune after the ban 😂

    • @rjagad
      @rjagad Месяц назад +2

      Literally China CPC moment.

    • @lazypaladin
      @lazypaladin Месяц назад +1

      _Smogon Bureaucrats_ I love it 😂👌

    • @snakyYT
      @snakyYT Месяц назад +1

      Damn smogon you allow stall teams. BRING BACK EVASION(ONLY FOR ABILITIES)

  • @cinder8154
    @cinder8154 Месяц назад +434

    It’s so cool to me that older generations still get some competitive play even today

    • @ianr.navahuber2195
      @ianr.navahuber2195 Месяц назад +3

      i wonder how that happens. they use emulator or official games?

    • @cinder8154
      @cinder8154 Месяц назад

      good question

    • @fabiangrandez2957
      @fabiangrandez2957 Месяц назад

      @@ianr.navahuber2195 they use pokemon showdown

    • @nd1095
      @nd1095 Месяц назад

      @@ianr.navahuber2195 it's mostly played on pokemon showdown

    • @ruludos1977
      @ruludos1977 Месяц назад

      @@ianr.navahuber2195 pokemon showdown mostly, it's an online simulator

  • @FiresBZ
    @FiresBZ Месяц назад +210

    It's funny because it's not banned in UU because Tyranitar isn't there to set up sandstorm

    • @Fuhuhu
      @Fuhuhu Месяц назад +3

      But if sand veil is banned from OU, is it not also banned from UU ?

    • @Oscarus4250
      @Oscarus4250 Месяц назад +13

      @@Fuhuhu No, because sand isn't nearly as prevalent there (if it is even slightly present in the first place...)
      In Gen 3, only three Pokemon total had weather inducing Abilities - Groudon with Drought, Kyogre with Drizzle, and Tyranitar with Sand Stream. Since legends are Uber-bound and pseudolegend is OU's #1, they are clearly out of UU's boundaries.
      And activating weather with a move isn't as good as with an ability. Still, when it comes to activating weather with a move, Sunny Day and Rain Dance are more likely to be seen than Sandstorm due to them being, I believe, slighty better in UU, as there aren't that many Pokemon in UU which could benefit from sandstorm; you have Cradily, Gligar, Sandslash, maybe Quagsire too... and that's it.

  • @yoalexdanoob4177
    @yoalexdanoob4177 Месяц назад +112

    He's outstanding in his field

    • @hps362
      @hps362 Месяц назад +7

      folks...

    • @Draytherion
      @Draytherion Месяц назад +3

      Underrated comment 😂😂😂

    • @kaloncpu57
      @kaloncpu57 25 дней назад +1

      There's the comment I was looking for

  • @tysondennis1016
    @tysondennis1016 27 дней назад +33

    Cacturne is what happens when a desert plant becomes terminally addicted to gambling.

    • @ItsJustKaya
      @ItsJustKaya 23 дня назад +2

      Feel like its JJK reference but also could be darktype joke

    • @tysondennis1016
      @tysondennis1016 23 дня назад +1

      @@ItsJustKaya It's because its Sand Veil turns matchups against it into games where luck matters more than skill.

    • @hansbloodsmith
      @hansbloodsmith 21 день назад

      Cacturne never acquired Evasion Boosting technique...
      But...
      The evasion overflowing due to Cacturne's Sand Veil caused his body to reflectively dodge every incoming attacks....
      In other words....
      In the 4:11 following a Sandstorm, Cacturne is effectively INVINCIBLE...

  • @naturalharmoniagropius4486
    @naturalharmoniagropius4486 Месяц назад +436

    I remember that. Cacturne's only ability is Sand Veil, and since Sand is just defines Gen 3 OU due to Tyranitar, they decide to just ban Cacturne entirely.

    • @mage3659
      @mage3659 Месяц назад +105

      Its almost as if he said all that in the video lol

    • @Kai............
      @Kai............ Месяц назад +91

      I remember that too. Cacturne’s unique typing allowed it to set up spikes against claydol, the premier rapid spinner in adv ou

    • @AizakkuAdoman
      @AizakkuAdoman Месяц назад +27

      Ironic for all the complains of too much water in gen 3, sand is the broken weather in the format

    • @why3994
      @why3994 Месяц назад +38

      @@Kai............ Did you know that it is immune to psychic, and also resists earthquake?

    • @naturalharmoniagropius4486
      @naturalharmoniagropius4486 Месяц назад

      @@mage3659 not everyone has the attention span like yours, bro

  • @adnagapot
    @adnagapot Месяц назад +34

    Some people went so far as to use cacnea as a cacturn lite

  • @flameacegaming
    @flameacegaming Месяц назад +114

    This also means my boy Sandslash was also banned :(

    • @KusogeMan
      @KusogeMan Месяц назад +4

      was it? for real?

    • @airymems
      @airymems Месяц назад +4

      Didn't sandslash have the one that boosted speed?

    • @flameacegaming
      @flameacegaming Месяц назад +10

      @@airymems As a Hidden Abbility, but those were introduced post-Gen 3

    • @flameacegaming
      @flameacegaming Месяц назад

      @@KusogeMan Yeah

  • @rorozoro182
    @rorozoro182 Месяц назад +21

    Encountering a swords dance + sucker punch cacturne in showdown randoms is scary

  • @gregorymirabella1423
    @gregorymirabella1423 Месяц назад +37

    Similar thing happened to garchomp, it was only unbanned in gen 5 once it got rough skin.

  • @mistermisfortune13
    @mistermisfortune13 Месяц назад +6

    PSA: Sand Veil evasion is equivalent to using Double Team a single time

    • @foxshinehiyaa3933
      @foxshinehiyaa3933 27 дней назад +4

      And PSA for the PSA : the sandstorm is infinite when the ability sand stream activates in gen 3 so sand veil is a evasion version of the ability intrepid sword

    • @mistermisfortune13
      @mistermisfortune13 27 дней назад +2

      @@foxshinehiyaa3933 very true

  • @miketacos9034
    @miketacos9034 12 часов назад +3

    “He’s just standing there… menacingly!”

  • @cobalt7248
    @cobalt7248 Месяц назад +26

    Cacturne mentioned 🍻 (I'm the one existing Cacturne fan)

    • @yosh9192
      @yosh9192 Месяц назад +7

      It’s honestly so sick, absolutely deserves a crossgen evo or a mega

    • @SillyBones420
      @SillyBones420 8 дней назад

      Cacturne gang rise up, I've loved him ever since his debut, I always use him anytime I play through gen 3

  • @Regiultima
    @Regiultima Месяц назад +15

    Just like Articuno being banned from BDSP OU pre-Home since you could only get Snow Cloak Articuno in BDSP.

    • @stetsonherrick8090
      @stetsonherrick8090 Месяц назад

      Wouldn’t that also mean Glaceon got shafted by proxy since Snow Cloak has been the only Non Dream World ability it has?

  • @cinderblockgamingweresolid5731
    @cinderblockgamingweresolid5731 Месяц назад +4

    The editing on these short is always so pleasing to look at

  • @noble0155
    @noble0155 Месяц назад +12

    this pokemon killed friendships and caused divorces

    • @hyoroemongaming569
      @hyoroemongaming569 Месяц назад +1

      Only for smogonscrub

    • @yosh9192
      @yosh9192 Месяц назад +1

      @@hyoroemongaming569
      We get it, you suck at battling and probably unironically struggled with Cynthia past the age of 14

    • @BrokenValentine-333
      @BrokenValentine-333 Месяц назад

      He just like me fr fr 😤

  • @CursedGaming31
    @CursedGaming31 Месяц назад +19

    We need a Cacturne live/video fam 😭
    One of my favorite mons of all time, carried me through a whole gen 6 tournament
    Shotouts to Sorriso (it means "smile"), the PU demon

  • @echogaia1708
    @echogaia1708 Месяц назад +11

    Cacnea Sandslash and Sandshrew are banned too, at least Gligar can use Hyper Cutter

  • @tsyumamatsuthehavenofguard32
    @tsyumamatsuthehavenofguard32 Месяц назад +5

    Sandstorm is probably the best way to beat the battle frontier

    • @yosh9192
      @yosh9192 Месяц назад +2

      I always run something that knows Sandstorm in the Battle Arena for the sole purpose of completely shutting down Greta’s Brightpowder Shedinja, even if I’d never use it otherwise

  • @kekistani_meme_farmer7242
    @kekistani_meme_farmer7242 27 дней назад +4

    They should make swift do more damage the higher the opponents evasiveness is and the lower your accuracy is.

    • @Jesse110
      @Jesse110 5 дней назад

      that is one of the best balance ideas I have ever heard for Pokemon

  • @_Rhatsody
    @_Rhatsody Месяц назад +30

    This is why everyone hates Justy in Pokémon colosseum

    • @forsetimaster0689
      @forsetimaster0689 Месяц назад +2

      I just wrapped up my playthrough and I absolutely can confirm.

    • @whitedragonzerureusu4480
      @whitedragonzerureusu4480 Месяц назад

      Yep actually one of the hardest or trickiest fights in that game. But i actually kinda like the challenge he brings in

    • @forsetimaster0689
      @forsetimaster0689 Месяц назад +2

      @@whitedragonzerureusu4480 True. Umbreon's Feint Attack made me appreciate moves that never miss a lot more.

  • @luigisilver818_7
    @luigisilver818_7 Месяц назад +17

    I actually used a Sandstorm team in Emerald once. It was a pretty well rounded team, I had Cacturne in it too, but when I went to fight Steven he was immune to my Sandstorm and as a result it became one of my favorite battles in a Pokémon game. When it came down to our last Mon I had Cacturne and Sand Veil kicked it at the right time, if it didn't activate I would've lost, and I won.

  • @HaisaySasaki
    @HaisaySasaki Месяц назад +7

    Nah he was banned for being too cool, the coolest looking mon in the game 😎

  • @BigCaj
    @BigCaj 23 дня назад +21

    god Smogon hates anything that isn’t boring as fuck

    • @nospimi99
      @nospimi99 23 дня назад +3

      While I do agree, I don’t blame them in this case. No one likes evasion boosts. Moves are already “balanced” to incorporate them automatically missing a certain amount of times based on their power or secondary effects. The fact that people can just passively make an opponent’s turn randomly just be skipped is infuriating.

    • @BigCaj
      @BigCaj 23 дня назад +7

      @@nospimi99 never-miss moves (like aerial ace, specifically in this case) exist and the para/sleep/freeze statues conditions are still allowed despite also providing the chance for an opponent to straight up do nothing, so i don’t get what the problem with evasion is. i honestly think it would’ve spiced up the competitive scene with people having to come up with strategies to work around it, rather than just getting rid of it and crushing any niche for underappreciated/underutilized mons

    • @nooooooooo432
      @nooooooooo432 23 дня назад +2

      I promise you sand veil sub is not fun

    • @BigCaj
      @BigCaj 23 дня назад

      @@nooooooooo432 garchomp and ttar go brrrrr

    • @It-Will-All-Be-Okay-I-Promise
      @It-Will-All-Be-Okay-I-Promise 23 дня назад +7

      @@BigCaj Why do people bring up aerial ace type moves like they actually make evasion balanced? It’s a 60 base power nonstab move and a very dead slot vs any team w/o the cactus. The Pokémon that can learn it in ADV OU will just be always worse if they run it outside of this one very specific matchup. If Zapdos or Skarmory or even freaking Metagross have to run Aerial Ace specifically to beat a Pokémon they should already always beat then something is very wrong. I don’t want a metagame revolving around evasion and neither does anybody else, 50 turns of dodging cacti using leech seed and substitute isn’t interesting or fun its mind numbing.
      If you really want evasion strats, play some Power Of Alchemy Muk-Alola teams in VGC, there are a couple of them you can find and they’re pretty powerful, singles and evasion though just do not mix well.

  • @armaggedon390
    @armaggedon390 Месяц назад +28

    Smogon: "This is too OP and over used."
    Also Smogon: "Stealth Rocks, my beloved."

    • @Gich101
      @Gich101 Месяц назад +2

      Depends on the meta

    • @itztaytay2
      @itztaytay2 Месяц назад +4

      Well this is also about gen 3, which didn't have stealth rocks

    • @nd1095
      @nd1095 Месяц назад +2

      stealth rocks actually helps to ensure that stall isn't op so it helps to make a less toxic meta

    • @oscen335
      @oscen335 Месяц назад +5

      Ppl: SMOGON LOVES STALL😠😠
      Also Ppl: WhY Arent St-st-stEaltH rOCks banned!!(stealth rocks wasnt even in gen3)

    • @yosh9192
      @yosh9192 Месяц назад +2

      If you can’t play around stealth rocks, your opinion is invalid

  • @uberfiend2544
    @uberfiend2544 29 дней назад +2

    This made me remember my trickroom sand doubles team.

  • @Boomhandshoot
    @Boomhandshoot Месяц назад +4

    Nah, Cacture is the Find out of Tyranitar's Eff around. It didnt deserve the ban

    • @s1rumbrens.u133
      @s1rumbrens.u133 Месяц назад +2

      yes, he deserve, gain evasion boost and trying to dealt with this is bullshit and uncompetitive

  • @lucasboat
    @lucasboat Месяц назад +4

    Fun fact: they are still allowed in the lower tiers

  • @kingcradi
    @kingcradi Месяц назад +1

    This battle animation you just made is 🔥🔥🔥

  • @matthewmiller1847
    @matthewmiller1847 28 дней назад +6

    Aerial Ace...
    There's literally a never miss move thats super effective against Cacturne. If people used Cacturne because Tyranitar, why couldn't people also adapt with flying types with Aerial Ace? Flying types are also immune to spikes.
    Gligar with sandveil is a different problem.

    • @crunch4743
      @crunch4743 27 дней назад +6

      Having to run aerial ace for one specific team comp is highly unhealthy to the meta. You force a bad move onto a Pokémon solely to resolve one Pokémon being an issue in the meta.
      Why restrict team building so harshly, when there is a better answer in removing the Pokémon?
      Cacturne brings little value to the meta.

    • @rhouxfang4172
      @rhouxfang4172 15 дней назад +1

      ​@@crunch4743Well here's the issue. If Sandstorm is triggering Sand veil, just stop using a Sandstorm type. It's pretty ridiculous to me that sand veil would get banned just because it shook up the meta.

    • @crunch4743
      @crunch4743 12 дней назад +1

      @@rhouxfang4172 does this not work the other way
      having to remove the far more helpful sandstorm which has a healthy effect on the meta is worse than removing a cactus.

  • @memebrain2177
    @memebrain2177 Месяц назад +1

    Survivability ties to your defense and hp
    Accuracy ties to kills per hour

  • @justindekoning9988
    @justindekoning9988 Месяц назад +3

    Theres a lot going on here with this. It wasn't always banned. But Garchomp in gen 4 got banned and sand veil was the final straw because Chomp quite litteraly had no counters the only thing close was Choice specs Starmie and band Weavile could revenge kill it through a Yache berry but thanks to sand veil even that had a 20% chance to fail. People just argued that it was only broken on Garchomp so in Gen 5 a few players went out of there way to prove that it was sand veil that was broken and they used Cacturne and Cacnea to prove it was sand veil that was broken and it was then banned in every generation and snow cloak eventualy followed years later

  • @dequanandrews8972
    @dequanandrews8972 29 дней назад +5

    This make no sense to ban pokemon or anything for doing there job to well this the real world u do your job to great and they kick u out

  • @austinwilburn1772
    @austinwilburn1772 Месяц назад +1

    I’m a casual Pokémon player but even I can tell that Pokémon sounds really good against the current Pokémon used in tournaments. I did play Yugioh for 13 years and been playing Magic the Gathering for 11 years and one of my favorite card subject is Anti-meta.
    For me when I study a card that is no longer used in tournaments because they have fallen out of favor and it was a anti-meta card, aka a card that was good against what was being used at that point in time, it’s like a flashback, a piece of history that can be used to see how tournaments were in days gone by.

  • @myloveIUxBaeSuzy
    @myloveIUxBaeSuzy Месяц назад +4

    Pretty sure you can still use manual sandstorm + Cacturne in lower ADV tiers if I'm not mistaken? It was only in OU it's banned.

    • @thepedrojay
      @thepedrojay Месяц назад +4

      we did mention this in the longer version on TikTok! Didn't make it to the 60s cut here unfort

  • @Petsinwinter2
    @Petsinwinter2 Месяц назад +1

    You could also count on Sand being up in Gen 3 because Tar is the only one with a weather ability in ADV OU.

  • @deathblowringo4168
    @deathblowringo4168 Месяц назад +1

    That reminds me in Pokemon Colosseum at the Orre Colosseum Lv.100 singles, where Athlete Naga at the round 2 uses a Sandstorm + Sand Veil + Bright powder / Lax Incense strategy just like with Worker Lobel at the 1st battle of the round 2 in XD, and it is even more worse because his Cacturne and Dugtrio have Double Team. As I said, Lax Incense in gen 3 reduces the accuracy of moves targeting the holder by 5% opposed to Bright Powder's 10%.

  • @brett1908
    @brett1908 Месяц назад +3

    I actually did know cacturne was banned thanks to a very cool guy named jimothy.

  • @kw5371
    @kw5371 23 дня назад +7

    Wwwaaahhhhj I can't hit them!!

  • @LathanFitzpatrick-vx5zp
    @LathanFitzpatrick-vx5zp 11 дней назад

    tbh, I love Cacturne and I never knew it was such a menace, so this makes me happy

  • @mrburrito1096
    @mrburrito1096 Месяц назад +1

    That animation is sick ngl

  • @cuzwynaut7248
    @cuzwynaut7248 27 дней назад +1

    I love your animation

  • @bigboypapaboy
    @bigboypapaboy 7 дней назад

    Some out bans I didn’t even mind them before they were banned. Like when greninja got banned I was surprised because he just seemed like a regular mon

  • @DoinkDeetus
    @DoinkDeetus Месяц назад +1

    Crazy how they made this totally fun and cool event pass to make free to play players wait two weeks

  • @Thrillin_Chillin_Drillin
    @Thrillin_Chillin_Drillin Месяц назад +1

    Mega Cacturne in Legends Z-A 🤞

  • @Lkfttgjtgjr
    @Lkfttgjtgjr 2 дня назад +1

    Also cacturne being a grass dark type means it has a good type matchup agaisnt tyranitar

  • @cellP8
    @cellP8 Месяц назад +1

    They should have given cacturne water absorb
    And the pokemon that lives in the desert doesnt even learn scorching sands…

  • @p0kem0nlvl1
    @p0kem0nlvl1 Месяц назад +2

    Step aside mega rayquaza, catcus is the og

  • @anameyoucantremember
    @anameyoucantremember 8 дней назад

    Cacturne was my most powerful pokemon in Emerald, that was some really god tier thing back in the day lol

  • @doctordoom8875
    @doctordoom8875 Месяц назад +3

    Cacturne still gets to be in UU though LOL

    • @JackieJackJackerJacky
      @JackieJackJackerJacky Месяц назад +4

      Because permanent Sandstorm isn't in ADV UU

    • @sketchydude8431
      @sketchydude8431 Месяц назад +1

      Tyranitaur is the only pokemon with Sand Stream, which sets unlimited sand
      Using a move like Sandstorm only sets sand for a limited amount of turns, meaning OU is the only tier youre going to see sand 100% of the time.

  • @zerokyuuni
    @zerokyuuni 17 дней назад +1

    Smogon is synonymous with skill gap

  • @austinlundahl5349
    @austinlundahl5349 Месяц назад +2

    Joey we need a jimothy cool collab with the boys

  • @glitchyboi-nk1qv
    @glitchyboi-nk1qv Месяц назад +2

    Smogon: the format of endless cope

    • @crescentcrab
      @crescentcrab 12 дней назад

      I've never taken Smogon seriously. They're not Game Freak or Nintendo.

  • @sayvionwashington1939
    @sayvionwashington1939 Месяц назад +1

    "Hey guys, what do you think of Cacturne?"

  • @sansplayer6254
    @sansplayer6254 16 дней назад +1

    Pokemon fans trying not to ban creative strategies (it's literally impossible)

  • @Marcothy_
    @Marcothy_ Месяц назад +2

    This is insane

  • @eightcoins4401
    @eightcoins4401 Месяц назад +1

    Gen 3 OU is the most wacky meta

  • @FlameBinder55
    @FlameBinder55 Месяц назад +2

    So, let me get this straight, and correct me if I'm wrong, they banned a pokemon because it was the perfect counter to the meta?

    • @itztaytay2
      @itztaytay2 Месяц назад +5

      To be exact, they banned the ability and not the mon (just that Cacturne has no other ability), not because it counters the meta but because it is a cheesy rng reliant strat with very sparsely found counterplay because it's only good specifically into Sand Veil stacking teams (which were not common). The actual winrate of these teams were not great since you were relying on consistent 25% rolls, so they can't really be called effectively anti-meta

    • @lucasgreer1736
      @lucasgreer1736 Месяц назад +1

      @@itztaytay2 iirc cacturne teams saw a decent amount of high-level play but I could be misremembering

    • @itztaytay2
      @itztaytay2 Месяц назад +2

      ​@@lucasgreer1736I went back to check cause it has been a long while. The month before the Sand Veil ban Cacturne had 1.457% usage overall and 2.32% on high ladder lol. The thing that really put it on the radar was being brought to tournaments and even there it was quite rare and cheesy

  • @Runictheunic
    @Runictheunic 8 дней назад

    This sounds like a salty Tyr trainer making rules to make his favorite uncontested

  • @reidf96
    @reidf96 25 дней назад +4

    Were there ever any discussions about banning Ttar due to this

    • @Zomgnomnom1
      @Zomgnomnom1 23 дня назад +2

      No. Sand wasn't the issue. Sand Veil was. Cacturne was still allowed to be played in lower tiers, where Sand wasn't a near permanent fixture of the meta game.

    • @khub5660
      @khub5660 23 дня назад +4

      ​@Zomgnomnom1 so in other words, Sand was in fact the issue but no one wanted to ban Tyranitar due to needing a clear cut difference between the tiers. Makes sense

  • @BakedBaconBoi
    @BakedBaconBoi Месяц назад +3

    Question: Why is it called ADV OU instead of RSE OU or something like that?

    • @emperortoho
      @emperortoho Месяц назад +4

      because fire red, leaf green, and colosseum were the only ways to get some pokemon since rs didn’t have every pokemon
      rs ou is separate from adv ou

    • @callmezeldaonemoartime
      @callmezeldaonemoartime 19 дней назад

      It includes FireRed and LeafGreen

  • @LilZuZu
    @LilZuZu 13 дней назад

    Interesting considering a few generations later they introduced cacturne with secret ability (absorb)

  • @icebearpanda7068
    @icebearpanda7068 11 дней назад

    Substitute and leechseed is evil itself
    I remember doing it on venosaur..

  • @BrawlStars-gs4fi
    @BrawlStars-gs4fi Месяц назад +1

    Shiftry also has Cacturbes typing

    • @OtisCluck
      @OtisCluck Месяц назад

      But it doesn’t have sand veil, which was what got banned

    • @BrawlStars-gs4fi
      @BrawlStars-gs4fi Месяц назад +1

      @@OtisCluck yeah I know but I said it only for the corrction

  • @nathanwaterser8218
    @nathanwaterser8218 19 дней назад +1

    It's like how Sandshrew alola got banned from NU
    They banned Slush Rush and Snow Cloak is banned because of evasion clause
    And since Sandshrew alola only has those 2 abilities it is banned by technicality

  • @optionfinder
    @optionfinder Месяц назад

    One of my fav mons I love this guy

  • @yyopem
    @yyopem 17 дней назад +1

    Playing smogon and their limited pool is the 1st mistake

  • @BruceWilikers
    @BruceWilikers 13 дней назад

    Oh if only there was a flying move that didn’t miss

  • @AmanoLorenzo
    @AmanoLorenzo Месяц назад

    pleaaase MORE SHORTS

  • @1414walla
    @1414walla 4 дня назад

    oh yeah the only time i played online battles.

  • @alexvergara479
    @alexvergara479 Месяц назад

    Please make vedios of battles with this!!

  • @zonkz6947
    @zonkz6947 6 дней назад

    Jesus christ we were never supposed to get so enthralled in old video games like this, japan must be astonished lol

  • @jamtone4492
    @jamtone4492 Месяц назад +2

    Oh, and caturne was so gimicky, people ran cacnea to get another one.

  • @bubalackgaming8892
    @bubalackgaming8892 Месяц назад +1

    Smogon when literally anybody comes up with a strategy they're not used to

    • @foxshinehiyaa3933
      @foxshinehiyaa3933 27 дней назад

      Lmao please stop talking because that stupid asf sand veil is banned because it is braindead and even on trash mons like cacturne it is broken and completely uncompetitive

  • @jacobmiller9527
    @jacobmiller9527 Месяц назад +5

    Really shows how people forget The moves that never miss and just stop evasion builds like Aerial Ace

    • @sharpeylogic2907
      @sharpeylogic2907 Месяц назад +8

      Yeah, like giving up a valuable slot for a 60 BP move to counter a niche strat is worth it. Iirc only Dugtrio runs Aerial Ace in ADV to trap Heracross. What's stopping Cacturne from Substituting on the switch and nailing Dugtrio with Needle Arm?
      It's unrealistic to expect everyone to slap on Aerial Ace and call it a day. It's why Shadow Tag was banned in BW too - forcing every defensive Pokemon to run Shed Shell was unhealthy for the metagame

    • @oscen335
      @oscen335 Месяц назад +1

      Basically a free switch in for mence lol

    • @callmezeldaonemoartime
      @callmezeldaonemoartime 19 дней назад

      Yeah no, Aerial Ace is a wasted slot

  • @nearlawliet4468
    @nearlawliet4468 Месяц назад

    Cacturne was blessed by the sands of time.

  • @yosh9192
    @yosh9192 Месяц назад +5

    I love how you can tell the vast majority of kids in this comments section have never even played or even looked at gen 3 ou.
    “WhY nOt BaN TtAr!!!??1!”
    Read the strategy dex pages. It litera says “basic reading comprehension is required to play this game” on every Pokemon game, please apply this skill to competitive as well.

  • @Somersalsa
    @Somersalsa 7 дней назад

    I got so distracted by that combat animation why isn't there a pokemon game like that yet omg

  • @MattDustyParker
    @MattDustyParker Месяц назад

    Cacturne and gligar are my boys. Never thought to pair them up in gen 3. Maybe this is how i beat the battke frontier finally.

  • @xham-ik9yr
    @xham-ik9yr Месяц назад +11

    ppl who have never played adv: "emmm just use aerial ace" "just ban ttar then" "smogon are crybabies because they banned a niche cheese strat in an old gen"

    • @s1rumbrens.u133
      @s1rumbrens.u133 Месяц назад +3

      literally everybody here thinking that is smart enough to discuss about something that don't even play but ending up just dumb because of this

    • @loganb9697
      @loganb9697 Месяц назад +2

      Or you just didn’t have a good enough counter for it and cried for it to be banned lol

    • @xham-ik9yr
      @xham-ik9yr Месяц назад

      @@loganb9697 post elo

    • @imcarolean
      @imcarolean 23 дня назад +1

      ​@@xham-ik9yr1000

    • @callmezeldaonemoartime
      @callmezeldaonemoartime 19 дней назад

      @@loganb9697you’re exactly what the commenter is talking about.

  • @thebladeofchaos
    @thebladeofchaos 14 дней назад +1

    seems a bit weird that they'll ban pokemon because it upsets the meta rather then embracing the new meta

  • @XKloosyvv
    @XKloosyvv Месяц назад

    Sounds like a big mad move

  • @skhighglitch4217
    @skhighglitch4217 День назад

    Darude is disappointed

  • @frayzure
    @frayzure 8 дней назад

    Lets ban a valid strategy because it’s too good 😂

  • @bakonandsonicfamily2930
    @bakonandsonicfamily2930 Месяц назад

    Now, we have Darkrai with Bad Dreams that’s completely unusable lmao

  • @Looknook1
    @Looknook1 18 дней назад +1

    Wouldn't it be better to simply ban Tryranitar for being the pokemon that was providing free sandstorms? Pretty sure Tryranitars abillity caused other issues during this Gen too.

  • @duhotatoday3277
    @duhotatoday3277 24 дня назад +13

    So it was banned because it made one of the most overpowered Pokémon in Gen 3 less overpowered, so it was not beneficial to every single team?🤔

    • @llamaryder1
      @llamaryder1 22 дня назад +4

      No, it made it more overpowered by supporting a teammate that could scum their way to free wins.

  • @Meetwad
    @Meetwad 13 часов назад

    Gotta love competitive pokemon banning moves or abilities. You know, HOW IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE PLAYED IS CASUALLY.

  • @bluecanine3374
    @bluecanine3374 Месяц назад

    Wonder how effective it would be if it used Double Team amd Sand Attack along with Substitute and Leech Seed. Just pure stall strats and chip damage

  • @Unfaux-compte
    @Unfaux-compte Месяц назад +4

    Banning sand veil is small D energy

  • @Naustrix
    @Naustrix Месяц назад

    That’s crazy man people thought cacturn was tier 3 before now it’s banned (I haven’t played adv in 4 months)

  • @JiisTube
    @JiisTube 29 дней назад +1

    Y'all better be acting like you know what the OU is

  • @Noahloveless1
    @Noahloveless1 17 дней назад

    I didnt understand a single one of those acronyms he used.

  • @ZilNab
    @ZilNab 6 дней назад

    I've never played the games, is there set ups like this worth exploring in game or is it all just PvP stuff?

  • @markusthefirstmartyr9012
    @markusthefirstmartyr9012 16 дней назад +1

    Someone finds something that works against the meta, the people all using the meta: Ban it ban it pleaseeee 😭

  • @Weareonenation303
    @Weareonenation303 Месяц назад +19

    What surprises me was how long sand veil, brightpowder and other lucked based bullshit was allowed in OU.

    • @Fanimati0n
      @Fanimati0n Месяц назад +16

      Tbh, pokemon is luck based in general. You can do all of the preparation in the world, but one errant crit or missed will-o-wisp can make all of that work be worthless.

    • @JohnSmith-ik8nt
      @JohnSmith-ik8nt Месяц назад +3

      Almost as if playing it competitively is dumb

    • @RedBloodedMale777
      @RedBloodedMale777 Месяц назад +10

      @@Fanimati0nthat’s true but the purpose of a competitive game is to remove the unnecessary mechanics that rely too heavily on rng, hence their eventual ban

    • @metareaper8008
      @metareaper8008 Месяц назад +3

      Its almost like random chance is a core mechanic of the entire rpg genre

    • @foxshinehiyaa3933
      @foxshinehiyaa3933 27 дней назад +1

      ​@@JohnSmith-ik8ntyou are not the brightest in your school for sure