What I find hilarious is that if you guys were wearing bjj gi and presenting this without the context of kata, I doubt anyone would bat an eye. But since it’s karate, people immediately make absolute braindead comments like “stop the bs! Teaching this will get people killed!” Karate and realistic kata analysis/application can be highly efficient. It’s about how it’s learned, trained and applied.
Thank you for sharing, sir! I'm not trying to call anyone's teacher wrong or disagree with senior practitioners, just trying to show what this could do in a violent encounter where anything goes. Our organization's formal bunkai says this is jumping away from a sword swing to the legs. It's an answer, but I'm pretty confident that isn't the best answer.
Somebody watched this and accused me if doing "high level Judo," which I found funny. But yes, there's a ton of overlap. Thanks for the comment and watch! 😁
That's not where I thought you were going with that comment, but I agree. All the founders were interested in progress and efficacy from what I can tell!
Seems...like a lot of hoops to jump through. Why don't you just elbow him in the face with the same hand you're using to defend his punch? You can actually beat him to the punch if you react as soon as he grabs (you have two free hands, throw a straight and hook). You can also just parry with your other side hand and throw an upper cut with the same side hand. You can also just bring your hands up to defend punches and knee him in the groin.
You're right, there are a lot of options. But this is specifically about showing how the movements of the kata can help you to gain a dominant position quickly. With a couple steps, I've broken his balance, gotten a joint lock, moved behind him, and set him up for a knee to the spine and a broken shoulder. It's not the only one even the most efficient option. It's about unpacking the kata.
Your options operate on the assumption that you can beat them to the punch/es. Self defense assumes you may have already began receiving punches. The opponent having control of your garment is the issue. Even if you can raise your hands to defend, they can jostle you around to break your defense or change your orientation- nullifying your defense. That is why you have to take it into grappling into a finish- not a stand-up game. The kata shows a way to gain control of their back, not clinch in return and start doing Muay Thai.
Hi! We're north of Boston in Peabody, Massachusetts. Authentic Karate Training Center is the name of the dojo. It's not my school, but I do teach there. If you're in the area, come visit and meet my teacher!
Peut être. Et puis vous continuez à vous battre et ils ont perdu leur emprise. Je ne pense pas qu'un attaquant qui a l'intention de vous assommer en frappant encore et encore sacrifiera sa prise parce que vous commencez à vous déplacer d'une manière à laquelle il ne s'attend pas. Une fois le verrou enclenché, il est de toute façon trop tard pour lâcher prise. Merci d'avoir regardé!
The chances of a violent encounter working like this long sequence of the kata over multiple steps is slim to none. That said, each piece is valid and has potential. People have asked "but why not just hammer fist him until he spits teeth once you tie him up?" Sure, that's an option. People have said "I don't think he's going to let you twist the arm like that." Sure, maybe it doesn't work or the guy slips out of it as it comes on. As I understand it, that's true of anything. I don't know about movie name. Do you have title ideas?
@@andrewobrienkarate actually yes. It would be the flinstones I believe. And what you don’t see or say is that someone might actually believe this crap and get him or herself injured or even much worse. That’s what’s wrong with showing the load Iof BS. Keep on With your martial art philosophy. The only person your fooling is yourself oh wise one
@@andrewobrienkarate the first reply was polite but since you decided sarcasm was the way I I decided truth would be the best option. This would never work on any normal angry semi healthy person
@della1731 Sir, you came in here asking what movie I'd be in. Now you're calling me sarcastic and implying I'm disrespectful because I'm quoting YOU. Also you: "That's what's wrong with showing the load lof BS." "The only person your fooling is yourself oh wise one." I'm open to having a real conversation. You're the one insulting a stranger on the internet without offering evidence. Let's unpack the moves you're calling "crap," "BS," and saying are "never going to work on a normal angry semi healthy person." I'd like help understanding what's wrong with them. -An Americana arm bar. -A hand hook on the face. -A knee strike.
Actually, I wanted to, but all the big guys I have access to have bad shoulders. I'm okay with accidental chiropractic adjustments, but anything worse is a deal breaker in a demo partner.
Every call of duty keyboard warrior has an opinion on things when they don't even train. That said, the jump away with leg raise, was initially created as an evasive defense against an attack to one's lead leg with a weapon: sword, oar, spear, etc or a round house kick aimed at one's knee. Pre-WW2 Okinawan ryu kara te was developed during a time when Okinawans had to defend themselves from armed pirates, military invasions and criminals so we see weapon awareness in Uechi Ryu PanghaiNoon, Goju Ryu and Shorin Ryu. I'm glad you're keeping traditional Uechi Ryu alive. Peace be with you.
Trolling is a popular form of fishing. In ANY self defense situation, any technique is only 50/50% chance of success. Personally I prefer technique that is based on Kata. Easer to remember. Nice video ⛩
![J.P., NLE Choppa - Bad Bitty (Remix) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rBDa6BCvw10/mqdefault.jpg)
What I find hilarious is that if you guys were wearing bjj gi and presenting this without the context of kata, I doubt anyone would bat an eye. But since it’s karate, people immediately make absolute braindead comments like “stop the bs! Teaching this will get people killed!” Karate and realistic kata analysis/application can be highly efficient. It’s about how it’s learned, trained and applied.
Maximum agreement!
Interesting, Sensi Tsuneo Shimabukuro teach's it as a round house block in to in to a elbow. History wise Sensi says it's a jump away from a spear.
Thank you for sharing, sir! I'm not trying to call anyone's teacher wrong or disagree with senior practitioners, just trying to show what this could do in a violent encounter where anything goes. Our organization's formal bunkai says this is jumping away from a sword swing to the legs. It's an answer, but I'm pretty confident that isn't the best answer.
Your instruction style and snake forms remind me of my old kenpo instructor
That's good, right? 😅
Всегда исходить из того что если вас схватили за одежду то следом ударят в лицо....😂😂😂😂😂
Need more bunkai!!!
Do you want me to make more, or are you saying this video isn't good enough?
I love practical bunkai! One can find Jujitsu/Judo and Aikido principles in the kata.
Somebody watched this and accused me if doing "high level Judo," which I found funny. But yes, there's a ton of overlap. Thanks for the comment and watch! 😁
I like it. Very aikido-like technique minus the execution
Thanks! I'm definitely not an Aikido-ka, so that's likely why. 😁
Master Kiyohide shinjo's demonstration is pretty good too.
I'll have to check it out! Thanks for the tip.
Kiohyde sensei is brutal. Be careful 😅😅😅😅😅
Nice
Thanks, and thanks for watching! 😁
👍👍👍🌟
😊😁🙏
Imagine if Kanbun Uechi saw this.
He would be happy with the proliferation of his art
That's not where I thought you were going with that comment, but I agree. All the founders were interested in progress and efficacy from what I can tell!
Totally not
@@Oddr396 Why not?
@@andrewobrienkarate Porque eso jamás ha sido uechi ryu. El verdadero Uechi Ryu es el la escuela Shubukai, dirigida por Kuno Sensei
@@Oddr396 The one true Uechi!
Seems...like a lot of hoops to jump through. Why don't you just elbow him in the face with the same hand you're using to defend his punch?
You can actually beat him to the punch if you react as soon as he grabs (you have two free hands, throw a straight and hook).
You can also just parry with your other side hand and throw an upper cut with the same side hand.
You can also just bring your hands up to defend punches and knee him in the groin.
You're right, there are a lot of options. But this is specifically about showing how the movements of the kata can help you to gain a dominant position quickly. With a couple steps, I've broken his balance, gotten a joint lock, moved behind him, and set him up for a knee to the spine and a broken shoulder. It's not the only one even the most efficient option. It's about unpacking the kata.
Your options operate on the assumption that you can beat them to the punch/es. Self defense assumes you may have already began receiving punches.
The opponent having control of your garment is the issue. Even if you can raise your hands to defend, they can jostle you around to break your defense or change your orientation- nullifying your defense. That is why you have to take it into grappling into a finish- not a stand-up game.
The kata shows a way to gain control of their back, not clinch in return and start doing Muay Thai.
Professor I’d like to visit your school , where are you located ?
Hi! We're north of Boston in Peabody, Massachusetts. Authentic Karate Training Center is the name of the dojo. It's not my school, but I do teach there. If you're in the area, come visit and meet my teacher!
Le problème c est que par reflex l agresseur lâche le bras
Peut être. Et puis vous continuez à vous battre et ils ont perdu leur emprise. Je ne pense pas qu'un attaquant qui a l'intention de vous assommer en frappant encore et encore sacrifiera sa prise parce que vous commencez à vous déplacer d'une manière à laquelle il ne s'attend pas. Une fois le verrou enclenché, il est de toute façon trop tard pour lâcher prise. Merci d'avoir regardé!
Sooo
In which movie are you doing all of this ?
The chances of a violent encounter working like this long sequence of the kata over multiple steps is slim to none. That said, each piece is valid and has potential. People have asked "but why not just hammer fist him until he spits teeth once you tie him up?" Sure, that's an option. People have said "I don't think he's going to let you twist the arm like that." Sure, maybe it doesn't work or the guy slips out of it as it comes on. As I understand it, that's true of anything.
I don't know about movie name. Do you have title ideas?
@@andrewobrienkarate actually yes.
It would be the flinstones I believe.
And what you don’t see or say is that someone might actually believe this crap and get him or herself injured or even much worse. That’s what’s wrong with showing the load Iof BS.
Keep on With your martial art philosophy.
The only person your fooling is yourself oh wise one
@@della1731 Why is this "crap?"
@@andrewobrienkarate the first reply was polite but since you decided sarcasm was the way I I decided truth would be the best option.
This would never work on any normal angry semi healthy person
@della1731 Sir, you came in here asking what movie I'd be in. Now you're calling me sarcastic and implying I'm disrespectful because I'm quoting YOU.
Also you:
"That's what's wrong with showing the load lof BS."
"The only person your fooling is yourself oh wise one."
I'm open to having a real conversation. You're the one insulting a stranger on the internet without offering evidence.
Let's unpack the moves you're calling "crap," "BS," and saying are "never going to work on a normal angry semi healthy person." I'd like help understanding what's wrong with them.
-An Americana arm bar.
-A hand hook on the face.
-A knee strike.
do jiu jitsu
If you put your hand on his mouth, they are going to bite your hand or fingers
It's better to.pull their Hair
Good point, the bite is something to watch out for.
Why don’t you make a demo with a big guy???
Actually, I wanted to, but all the big guys I have access to have bad shoulders. I'm okay with accidental chiropractic adjustments, but anything worse is a deal breaker in a demo partner.
@@andrewobrienkarate if you do it with a big guy, we guys get more confidence with martial arts...
everyone has a plan until they get punch in the face
-Mike Tyson.
Every call of duty keyboard warrior has an opinion on things when they don't even train.
That said, the jump away with leg raise, was initially created as an evasive defense against an attack to one's lead leg with a weapon: sword, oar, spear, etc or a round house kick aimed at one's knee.
Pre-WW2 Okinawan ryu kara te was developed during a time when Okinawans had to defend themselves from armed pirates, military invasions and criminals so we see weapon awareness in Uechi Ryu PanghaiNoon, Goju Ryu and Shorin Ryu.
I'm glad you're keeping traditional Uechi Ryu alive. Peace be with you.
Luckyli, this style also teaches a punch to the face😃
That's not what it's for.
@@varanid9 Why not?
Other guy thinking, get on with it smart arse
WTF''???
Yes?
That's nice how they play fighting games. Just don't try any of that nonsense in the street kids
Why not?
Trolling is a popular form of fishing. In ANY self defense situation, any technique is only 50/50% chance of success. Personally I prefer technique that is based on Kata. Easer to remember. Nice video ⛩
@lawrencelaird2919 Yeah. Sometimes the trolls respond. It's fun to read. Thank you! 😊
@@andrewobrienkarate If you've ever been in a real fight you know the answer to that question friend.
@@johnreidy2804 But maybe you could explain it so I understand.