In Vietnam, which returned to French colonial rule, 700 to 800 Japanese soldiers remained and weapons such as aircraft and tanks remained, and the Kwangai Army Junior High School was established in 1946 during the Vietnam Independence War. Military education was conducted by former Japanese Army officers and non-commissioned officers at several military schools. Some of the former Japanese soldiers who died in the Vietnam Independence War have been honored at the Martyr's Cemetery. Some Japanese soldiers who returned to Japan were later awarded a medal by Vietnam. In addition, we will continue the friendly relations between the two countries by establishing organizations such as the Japan-Vietnam Trade Association and the Japan-Vietnam Friendship Association.
Those Japanese soldiers had families in Vietnam and sired Vietnamese-Japanese children. However, as the US became involved in the region, Japanese government ordered them all to withdrew and abandoned their families in Vietnam. The wives and the children weren’t even allowed to say goodbye. In his visit to Vietnam, Emperor Akihito met with the families and expressed his condolences for the hardships they had went through. A trip was then organised for the representatives of the families to visit their fatherland and if possible, pay respect to their father’s graves. Some even had the opportunity to meet with their Japanese half-siblings and received memento from their father.
There were thousands of Japanese soldiers in the South who surrendered to the Allies and were later used by them to fight the Vietminh too. Do you know that?
I once read that some Japanese soldiers were sympathized with Vietnamese so some of them who had missions to keep order for British and French deliberately ignored resistance action by Vietminh.
"Sympathized with" is rather a great underestimation of what good deeds the Japanese have greatly done for the Viet Minh. The Japanese weren't only sympathized with the Viet Minh, but they were also the one who laid the foundation for the organization, the core tactic, and the modernization of the Viet Minh and Vietnamese army as a whole. Driven by past guilt, hatred for the Allies, fear of condemnation or even a purpose for life, as many as thousand of Japanese soldiers ( Including some from the notorious Kempeitai ) decided to join the ranks of the Viet Minh, Ho Chi Minh would later granted Vietnamese citizenships with made up native names for these wandering soldiers and certified them as the "New Vietnamese", which made them completely immune to Allied intervention. All the camouflages, the booby traps, the small and elaborated trench digging and the guerilla tactics, the Viet Minh were able to perfected with the Japanese experiences and guidance. Japanese officers were appointed to strategists, military teachers and even generals. Old Japanese warfare textbooks were translated from Japanese to French by various Japanese officers for the benefits of the Viet Minh. Without the Japanese support and collaboration, i don't think the Viet Minh and later on the NVA wouldn't have been able to achieved what they had achieved in our timeline.
@@deskywallington2844 Some Viet Minh units were commanded by Germans or Austrians. The most famous was Ernst Frey who commended a V.M. Regiment. Some others directed the propaganda, they published a paper called "Waffen Brueder" (Brother in Arms) aimed at recruiting French Foreign Legion Germans. Some French also joined the V.M., many former French resistants, who fought the Germans during the French Occupation. After WWII, Europe was completely destroyed, for many, going to Asia was an opportunity: a roof, food, a work, some money. There is a youtube doc in German :Deutsche Legionäre im Indochinakrieg Doku Deutsch über Legionäre im Indochinakrieg" where German veterans who fought with/against the French retell their memories. Some specialized units pretended to be French units and attacked French remote forts from inside. At the difference of the US, French send colonial soldiers to fight in Vietnam: only officers and NCO were French natives. Most of the French infantry was African (West and East Africa), Algerian, Moroccan (the Tabors), and Tunisian.
Actually, your governments have cheated you and all your country's residents. They invaded my country, and then they killed many people. Your relatives were also taken advantage. I really love your residents, your national custom, national food. However, i hate your President
The people of Vietnam did not deserve what the Americans brought upon their shores. In order to make things right, the Americans and the French should pay reparations for 100 years!
@Tuphut Let me share w/you: I was a kid during the Vietnam War, missing the draft by one year. A few years ago I picked an old Time-Life picture book about SE Asia in which a picture of Ho appears. In the b&w picture, Ho is dressed in a black jacket. His left hand cups a cigarrette; he is looking to his left: The picture is cropped at the waist. Ho's hair and beard are wispy white, his eyes alert, world-weary, intelligent. cont....
Why did Vietnam turn to communism in the first place. Must ask the nice colonial master that only exploited but didn’t think about developing the country they take over.
@@alexandrecolomer3807 So if you steal something from somebody else, you have to be pro that person to give that stolen thing back?! What kind of stupid logic is that?!
its just like what the americans did with the taliban they supplied them with weps to fight the soviets and now the americans fight the taliban and like what they said in this documentary about americans supplying arms to the vietminh
I have come to know-well, the life & death difference between 'how' I come to understand something, and 'why' I come to understand that it is Right. Or wrong.
người việt luân yêu chuộng hòa bình người việt sẵn sàng gác lại quá khứ nhưng không quyên để luân đấu tranh cho hòa bình .và không bao giờ hận thù chỉ cần mỗi con người bất kể màu da đều được sống đều có quyền nhu cầu hạnh phúc
AS A U. S. MARINE THAT WOULD FIGHTING IN VIET NAM 1968 - 1969, L CO. 3/3, 3RD MARDIV, 0311. THEN SPEND 20 YRS IN CORPS. HERES WHAT I KNOW, AND 90% OF ALL VIET NAM VETS KNOW, WE SHOULD HAVE NEVER BACKED THE CHICKEN SHIT FRENCH, AND NEVER BEEN AT WAR WITH VIET NAM. A TERRIBLE MISTAKE ON THE U. S. PART. BIG MISTAKE. I APOLOGISE VIET NAMEESE PEOPLE.
Exactly. Ho Chi Minh said patriotism first. Socialism second. Vietnamese at the time didn’t care about communism or capitalism. They just wanted to be freed from the French.
Vietnamese lost about 2 million lives in their war and known as a glorious struggle for independent in history, and Cambodian the neighboring lost about the same amount of lives during The Khmer Rough or Pot Pol regime known as the Killing Field, the Cambodian killed its Cambodian, and considered such as a shameless losses, while only a little know that The Khmer Rough had spent ages with the Vietnamese Communist to fight with Republic government backed by the US in Cambodia. Cambodian or Khmer historically known as one of the foolish and innocent nation in Southeast Asia, and for the Vietnamese is well-known in their tactic of spy and undermining even the US couldn't beat them with this, that's why I had always thought about the involvement of The Vietnamese in the Killing of Two million Cambodia in just 4 years of Khmer Rough occupation.
We Viets beat ALL our enemies, including FIVE WORLD SUPERPOWERS. So yes, we Viets have the world's BEST military. I hate the commies, but all the accomplishments are due to the great efforts of our Viet people thru out the ages.
Its not full of lies. You just have a different version. How can japanese give independance to people who are living in their own country. That just provez the fact of japanese imperialism in vietnam.
Bạn nói đúng. Nhật đánh Pháp ra khỏi Việt Nam, sau đó Mỹ thả hai trái bom nguyên tử Nhật đầu hàng và ra khỏi Việt Nam, lúc này Nhật trả lại độc lập hoàn toàn cho Việt Nam dưới quyền vua Bảo Đại. Vua Bảo Đại chọn Trần Trọng Kim lập chính phủ quân chủ lập hiến, chưa có quân đội... Hồ từ trong rừng nhảy ra cướp chánh quyền của Trần Trọng Kim... Các đảng phái và tổ chức phê quốc gia và quân chủ lập hiến... chống lại Hồ và Việt Minh. Hồ yếu thế nên bí mật qua Tây ký hiệp ước công nhận Pháp trở lại VN và kêu gọi người VN đứng lên đánh Pháp.... sau đó Pháp quay lại liên minh với Vua Bảo Đại và các đảng phái phe quốc gia chống lại Hồ....
In Vietnam, which returned to French colonial rule, 700 to 800 Japanese soldiers remained and weapons such as aircraft and tanks remained, and the Kwangai Army Junior High School was established in 1946 during the Vietnam Independence War. Military education was conducted by former Japanese Army officers and non-commissioned officers at several military schools. Some of the former Japanese soldiers who died in the Vietnam Independence War have been honored at the Martyr's Cemetery. Some Japanese soldiers who returned to Japan were later awarded a medal by Vietnam. In addition, we will continue the friendly relations between the two countries by establishing organizations such as the Japan-Vietnam Trade Association and the Japan-Vietnam Friendship Association.
Those Japanese soldiers had families in Vietnam and sired Vietnamese-Japanese children. However, as the US became involved in the region, Japanese government ordered them all to withdrew and abandoned their families in Vietnam. The wives and the children weren’t even allowed to say goodbye. In his visit to Vietnam, Emperor Akihito met with the families and expressed his condolences for the hardships they had went through. A trip was then organised for the representatives of the families to visit their fatherland and if possible, pay respect to their father’s graves. Some even had the opportunity to meet with their Japanese half-siblings and received memento from their father.
There were thousands of Japanese soldiers in the South who surrendered to the Allies and were later used by them to fight the Vietminh too. Do you know that?
mình ở nước ngoài từ nhỏ và xem lịch sử này.. chính phủ pháp thời điểm đó rất là ác...Vietnam chống lại là rất đúng ko bàn cải được. Phim rất hay
I once read that some Japanese soldiers were sympathized with Vietnamese so some of them who had missions to keep order for British and French deliberately ignored resistance action by Vietminh.
"Sympathized with" is rather a great underestimation of what good deeds the Japanese have greatly done for the Viet Minh. The Japanese weren't only sympathized with the Viet Minh, but they were also the one who laid the foundation for the organization, the core tactic, and the modernization of the Viet Minh and Vietnamese army as a whole. Driven by past guilt, hatred for the Allies, fear of condemnation or even a purpose for life, as many as thousand of Japanese soldiers ( Including some from the notorious Kempeitai ) decided to join the ranks of the Viet Minh, Ho Chi Minh would later granted Vietnamese citizenships with made up native names for these wandering soldiers and certified them as the "New Vietnamese", which made them completely immune to Allied intervention. All the camouflages, the booby traps, the small and elaborated trench digging and the guerilla tactics, the Viet Minh were able to perfected with the Japanese experiences and guidance. Japanese officers were appointed to strategists, military teachers and even generals. Old Japanese warfare textbooks were translated from Japanese to French by various Japanese officers for the benefits of the Viet Minh. Without the Japanese support and collaboration, i don't think the Viet Minh and later on the NVA wouldn't have been able to achieved what they had achieved in our timeline.
@@deskywallington2844 Some Viet Minh units were commanded by Germans or Austrians. The most famous was Ernst Frey who commended a V.M. Regiment. Some others directed the propaganda, they published a paper called "Waffen Brueder" (Brother in Arms) aimed at recruiting French Foreign Legion Germans. Some French also joined the V.M., many former French resistants, who fought the Germans during the French Occupation.
After WWII, Europe was completely destroyed, for many, going to Asia was an opportunity: a roof, food, a work, some money. There is a youtube doc in German :Deutsche Legionäre im Indochinakrieg Doku Deutsch über Legionäre im Indochinakrieg" where German veterans who fought with/against the French retell their memories.
Some specialized units pretended to be French units and attacked French remote forts from inside.
At the difference of the US, French send colonial soldiers to fight in Vietnam: only officers and NCO were French natives. Most of the French infantry was African (West and East Africa), Algerian, Moroccan (the Tabors), and Tunisian.
My grandfather's brother remained in Vietnam after the war and was involved in training many Vietnamese soldiers.
Actually, your governments have cheated you and all your country's residents. They invaded my country, and then they killed many people. Your relatives were also taken advantage.
I really love your residents, your national custom, national food. However, i hate your President
Respect
The people of Vietnam did not deserve what the Americans brought upon their shores. In order to make things right, the Americans and the French should pay reparations for 100 years!
Ho Chi Minh is hands down the most fascinating figure of the twentieth century. An endlessly complex man
An interesting man indeed. But there are many people from the 20th century who shaped or contributed to the world we have now...
If we Americans would have dealt with him fairly, we could have avoided needless bloodshed.
@Tuphut Let me share w/you:
I was a kid during the Vietnam War, missing the draft by one year. A few years ago I picked an old Time-Life picture book about SE Asia in which a picture of Ho appears. In the b&w picture, Ho is dressed in a black jacket. His left hand cups a cigarrette; he is looking to his left: The picture is cropped at the waist. Ho's hair and beard are wispy white, his eyes alert, world-weary, intelligent.
cont....
Indochina, the "pearl of the empire", which we French loved and for which we fought with honor against communism
Why did Vietnam turn to communism in the first place. Must ask the nice colonial master that only exploited but didn’t think about developing the country they take over.
@@wattpad3094the Viet Minh, Viet Cong, and PAVN exploited, tortured, and killed many, many more Vietnamese than the French ever did.
only if the french gave them independence without hesitance.
They were not all pro ho chi min mate
@@alexandrecolomer3807 So if you steal something from somebody else, you have to be pro that person to give that stolen thing back?! What kind of stupid logic is that?!
good document,thanks
I would love to have a conversation with ho chi such a wise and interesting character
Pay attention to Vo Nguyen Giap, French and American had turned him from a little active funny kid to a great and honor General.
its just like what the americans did with the taliban they supplied them with weps to fight the soviets and now the americans fight the taliban and like what they said in this documentary about americans supplying arms to the vietminh
Hay quá tư liêuk thâtk bổ ich lần đầu đc xem phim tài liệu màu ma lại net thế nay
Ho chi minh was a hero
Had the American supported Vietnamese independence from the start then we could have evaded all the wars and communist rule
at 2:28, the person in question is NOT vo nguyen giap, but truong chinh. you've lost credibility.
you are right..they do look similar..he is Truong Trinh not Vo Nguyen Giap..at 2:48 he is Vo Nguyen Giap right next to Hochiminh.
Wiktory..
North Vietnam without communist friends?
vietnam que huong toi !!!
Como resivir la narración en español
1945年にベトナムは日本が独立させています。
まるでフランスと日本が同じような扱いは偏向報道以外のなにものでもない。
まぁ、ディスカバリーチャンネルは欧米の衛生放送だから、アジア関連の話で偏向報道になるのも無理はない。だけどベトミンに戦術を教えたのも、ベトナムに初の士官学校を建てたのも日本軍人だと言う事実ぐらいは報道して欲しかった。しかし、それを報道すると欧米にとっても共産党にとっても都合が悪くなるから口が裂けても報道しないと思う。
@@ヤマト八咫烏 戦略は戦略、日本軍の罪がベトナムに与えた被害も言えないぐらいだ！
@@conghao163 言ってごらんよ 世界中の人が見てくれるかもよ
@@コスパ厨で原価厨 200萬越南人被日本軍弄死
日本軍の功績もベトナム飢饉を起こした罪には勝らないと思うんだけどな。
ホーチミン氏自ら日本はフランスと並ぶ敵と名指しで言っている。
I have come to know-well, the life & death difference between 'how' I come to understand something, and 'why' I come to understand that it is Right. Or wrong.
Việt nam muôn năm
1:37 y la traduccion?
He saved people
Yeah
They the people kicked the French from Vietnam and Mexico.
Amen, GOD help VIETCONG to OVERRUN VIETNAM CONGHOA
Dont god help us, we help us
Sat Cong
Why ask God to help the Viet Cong? Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese were Communists. Hence, "Religion is the Opium of the Masses".
Ho Chi Minh Muôn Năm .
ベトナムの皆さんごめんなさい。一日本人
Đến khi nào người Nhật Bản mới dám đứng lên đánh đuổi kẻ xâm lược Mỹ để giành lại chủ quyền đất nước ...?
Chúng tôi hòa bình rồi nên mọi thù hận đã kết thúc để hướng đến tương lai
người việt luân yêu chuộng hòa bình người việt sẵn sàng gác lại quá khứ nhưng không quyên để luân đấu tranh cho hòa bình .và không bao giờ hận thù chỉ cần mỗi con người bất kể màu da đều được sống đều có quyền nhu cầu hạnh phúc
バカな、本当に君は日本人か？日本人は、フランスからベトナムを解放し王制にした。フランスがそうしたか？
戦後、ベトナムに残った旧日本兵は、ベトナム人と一緒になって独立戦争に参戦した。だから、今でも天皇がベトナムに定期的に訪問している。欧米のプロパガンダに騙されないようちゃんと勉強したまえ。
Kahit masakit nangyari na eh kaya tingnan nating hinaharap kaysa damhin ang nakaraan
ơ hồi đó vn vẫn dùng hán tự à
AS A U. S. MARINE THAT WOULD FIGHTING IN VIET NAM 1968 - 1969, L CO. 3/3, 3RD MARDIV, 0311. THEN SPEND 20 YRS IN CORPS. HERES WHAT I KNOW, AND 90% OF ALL VIET NAM VETS KNOW, WE SHOULD HAVE NEVER BACKED THE CHICKEN SHIT FRENCH, AND NEVER BEEN AT WAR WITH VIET NAM. A TERRIBLE MISTAKE ON THE U. S. PART. BIG MISTAKE. I APOLOGISE VIET NAMEESE PEOPLE.
Exactly. Ho Chi Minh said patriotism first. Socialism second. Vietnamese at the time didn’t care about communism or capitalism. They just wanted to be freed from the French.
ngày xưa mặc quần xì ngộ ha , như đóng bỉm !
Hình như bạn có vấn đề về quang học và ngoại ngữ thì phải đây là thực dân Pháp
Vietnamese lost about 2 million lives in their war and known as a glorious struggle for independent in history, and Cambodian the neighboring lost about the same amount of lives during The Khmer Rough or Pot Pol regime known as the Killing Field, the Cambodian killed its Cambodian, and considered such as a shameless losses, while only a little know that The Khmer Rough had spent ages with the Vietnamese Communist to fight with Republic government backed by the US in Cambodia. Cambodian or Khmer historically known as one of the foolish and innocent nation in Southeast Asia, and for the Vietnamese is well-known in their tactic of spy and undermining even the US couldn't beat them with this, that's why I had always thought about the involvement of The Vietnamese in the Killing of Two million Cambodia in just 4 years of Khmer Rough occupation.
sorry Vietnam
I didn't wrote about Vietnam 's military pal but about the fact that you blame France whereas you suffered pretty much more from the us
so the american train them before the Vietnam war? lol
and Afghanistan.
Jeneral jihad or g up?i'm very comfuse..
Giap
日本人として恥ずかしい限りだ。日本進駐前のフランスの非道さを知るほど、そこにさらにつけ込んだ日本の愚行も引きたってしまうから。
,OK 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
It’s boss
We Viets beat ALL our enemies, including FIVE WORLD SUPERPOWERS. So yes, we Viets have the world's BEST military. I hate the commies, but all the accomplishments are due to the great efforts of our Viet people thru out the ages.
嘘が多い動画だ。日本軍はベトナム独立。この一点のみで行動したのだ。明号作戦「Operation Bright Moon」
「7・7・7」だ。
Its not full of lies. You just have a different version. How can japanese give independance to people who are living in their own country. That just provez the fact of japanese imperialism in vietnam.
@@hemanag1020 Because the Japanese overthrew the European administration. Self-independence and freedom to all fellow asiatics.
Bạn nói đúng. Nhật đánh Pháp ra khỏi Việt Nam, sau đó Mỹ thả hai trái bom nguyên tử Nhật đầu hàng và ra khỏi Việt Nam, lúc này Nhật trả lại độc lập hoàn toàn cho Việt Nam dưới quyền vua Bảo Đại. Vua Bảo Đại chọn Trần Trọng Kim lập chính phủ quân chủ lập hiến, chưa có quân đội... Hồ từ trong rừng nhảy ra cướp chánh quyền của Trần Trọng Kim... Các đảng phái và tổ chức phê quốc gia và quân chủ lập hiến... chống lại Hồ và Việt Minh. Hồ yếu thế nên bí mật qua Tây ký hiệp ước công nhận Pháp trở lại VN và kêu gọi người VN đứng lên đánh Pháp.... sau đó Pháp quay lại liên minh với Vua Bảo Đại và các đảng phái phe quốc gia chống lại Hồ....
Jeneral jihad or g up?i'm very comfuse..