@@tatarchan5212 Taiwan has Japan on their side though. Even if biden would let China take Taiwan he wouldn't let them take Japan. He'll be out in 3 years anyways and we'll likely get someone like desantis who will take a hard stance on china.
@@E0572-e1n desantis? That anti vaxxer delusional fascist? He can't even take on Cuba properly, both Trump and Biden does far better job than him and that's saying something. Also China don't need Japan, they want only Taiwan because they're still in civil war after 70 years of barking at each other and both prepared to become the one real China. Victory over Taiwan is like victory over confederate in China which every leader eager to succeed at doing so. Imagine if confederate still exist would US president want to put an end to this forever war?
That could not be any more true. Also to add more coincidence the previous generation preceding saw trauma of which the world changed. Pre-boomers saw the horrors of WWII Millennials saw the horrors of 9/11
How many Americans know that HCM actually reached out for USA after WW1 to help him win independence for Vietnam, and he was not a communist back then? He repeated his attempts several time but was shunned back. How many Americans know that CASTRO tried the same thing with the US to win the same thing for his Cuban people, but was also Shunned? Same with the Soviets they also tried to be friends with the west after WW2, but were actually shunned back. The ruling elite/ bankers of the USA were always ready to deceive their own American people and hide the real story, for the benefit of the industrial complex. The only 2 presidents that actually tried to warn Americabs about it and tried to stop those proxy wars were Isenhower and JFK.
They pushed Vietnam toward communism, then send troops there to reverse it. They liberated Afghanistan from Taliban just to give it back to them later together with billions dollars worth of equipment. unnecessary bloodshed everywhere. It is just stupid.
HCM has been a communist since the final years of the 1910s, he was a member of the French Social Party, and voted in favor of the establishment of the French Communist Party. The Soviets after WW2 were aggressively trying to make the whole world communist, this is evident in the fact that puppet communist governments were systematically founded in Eastern Europe, in the countries that was unfortunate enough to be "liberated" by the USSR. They were not "shunned", they were wolves pretending to be harmless sheep, and they got what they deserve.
BULLSHIT!! The Communists were hell bent on taking over the world and these supposed attempt to reach out to the US were simply attempts to get Aiden support from us before they killed us and made us communist too. Lenin said that the capitalists would sell them the rope they would use to hang them with. Whenever we did try to be friendly with them it came back to haunt us in the end. Castro and Ho Chi Minh were Soviet loyalists who had no intention of long-term friendly relations with the us. Their intentions were to make their own areas and eventually the rest of the world communist and take all our rights away.
Well you mean the North Vietnamese people. Seems to me if soon as the US pulled out 3 years before the southern Vietnamese were looking for a reason to fold like a cheap tent. That's one of the reasons why the US pulled out because of corruption and they weren't willing to fight hard enough for their own freedom. If you want it bad enough you'll do anything to get it, one side obviously wanted it more than the other.
@@Sandhill1988 South Vietnam was a brutal regime in its own right, where the tiny Catholic minority imposed its will on the Buddhist majority; no wonder it folded.
South Vietnamese Republic (1949-1975) 💛🚩 Coalition forces supported by the United States North Vietnamese Democratic Republic (1955-1976) 🔴🚩 Communist forces supported by the Soviet Union Socialist Republic of Vietnam (1976-present) 🇻🇳 The born of Southeast Asian power supported by own members of ASEAN
@@chickenpuddingstudio4730 it doesn't matter now who was right or wrong. History can't be changed. Still, the desire to find out the truth is a big one.
My parents are both from the North of Vietnam. They were still kids in 1975 and my mom always told me how happy it was back then when she didnt have to hide herself under the basement to avoid the bombing after the reunification. My mum had an uncle who had left the big family to go South with his small family in 1954 promising to be back in 1956 but it turned out he only saw them again 19 years later and his dad had died in 1965. He refused to flee from Vietnam in 1975 because he wanted to see them again. Then he took all his big family to the South including my mum and gave them shelter, helped everyone find a job and found school for my mum. Unfortunately, he died tragically in a car accident while riding his other niece to find a job in 1979. His small family are all in Germany and America now but all of us back in Vietnam always appreciate his generosity and great support. If there was no reunification in 1975, I wouldnt have been born on earth. The war brought a lot of pain to most family. There are people suffering because of the incident happened in 1975 but there were families like ours getting a lot better after it. I hope all the pain heals in the end and there will be no war like this ever happens again.
@babafoodle9624 We experience economic downturn this year. I don't think the situation is good because we suffer from so many lockdowns back in 2020 and 2021. But I guess there is still a chance for growth and I'm seeking it as well.
Very interesting life story with all the ups and downs. I can only imagine how so many years of war brought pain and mischief to so many. I was lucky to visit some of your beautiful country and get to meet very nice people in Hanoi area mostly. I would like to visit again sometime soon and get to see the rest of the country starting in HCM City upwards. Hope you are well and keep the spirits high, Im sure you will be fine and so will your contry. Cheers from Argentina!
@@agustinenzoa4447 Thank you for your kind words. Ho Chi Minh City and the nearby provinces such as Da Lat, Phan Thiet are also very interesting to visit. Hope you will have a great trip next time.
Who knows what will happen, Taliban has hardly captured any major city and districts are changing hands every day, there is no certainty when the conflict will be over
That first scene is NOT the US Embassy, but an apartment building on 22 Gia Long Street, now 22 Lý Tự Trọng Street, where CIA and others where stationed.
He he he the important, it is seen the almighty amerikan army running away with its tail between its legs, or as Richard Watergate Nixon said, a peace with honor! Eh eh eh eh eh eh eh eh
@@mattstephens6137 The United States Embassy in Saigon was first established in June 1952, and moved into a new building in 1967 and eventually closed in 1975. The embassy was the scene of a number of significant events of the Vietnam War, most notably the Viet Cong attack during the Tet Offensive which helped turn American public opinion against the war, and the helicopter evacuation during the Fall of Saigon after which the embassy closed permanently.
Do any locals really call it ho chi minh city? I've heard that everyone, regular folks in every day life, have always called it Saigon. It's a much better name anyway. Washington DC, or just DC, sounds better than The District of Columbia George Winifred Washington City LOL
@@HavanaSyndrome69 of course shorter name, why not ? it not like the goverment ban the people to call that name anyway. But on paper and id stuffs well HCM city as alway.
I was on my last hitch in the USN and just before I retired from active service in 2004 at NAWS China Lake, CA and one of my junior Petty Officers was a younger man of Vietnamese birth. He was one of the sharpest, most professional, proficient and respectful I have ever known. I kept track of his career thereafter and was very pleased to have seen him advance up the ranks. He spent so many years in those refugee camps and on the wrong side of the wire in Bataan Province, Philippines and had every reason to be bitter, angry or depressed, however, once he finally had the opportunity to join the USN he was 100% All In. Anh Le you are a True Inspiration to me.
You will never know how helpful and inspiring your comment is to me at this moment. I was laying back in my chair, depressed about life, and your account of Anh Le has just jolted me into focus and optimism. And more. Thank you. Folks should never forget how an inspiring account about someone can help a total stranger.
...in the late 80's, there was a small restaurant on Queen Street East in Toronto. It had photos of end-of-war Vietnam on the wall. The owner was previously a press photographer, and had gotten out of Saigon on one of the very last helicopters...
There's a lot of ARVN vets still here, at least as of a few years ago when they had a reunion - in uniform - in Toronto's Mel Lastman Square. And the RVN flag still flies down the street from me here for some reason.
@@fumotized8210 ...long gone, I imagine, the neighbourhood's getting gentrified...it was just down the street from the watering hole that James Earl Ray quenched his thirst at, when he was still on the lam...that was earlier on tho'..
@@flowersstaringback9234 Everything they had on the banners screamed Communism. What is the Hammer and Sickle? Go ahead, call it White. Marx & Lenin were.
My beloved grandfather was one of the communists coming to Saigon these days. As a teenager who joined the army, he left his family in the north of VN (Hai Phong) when my mother was just a very little kid, bumped into the war when no one could say when it ends and whether he lived or died. Luckily, he could see me growing up as a teenager for almost 20 years. And so am I. He passed away 6 years ago. Whenever I miss him, I think I will find this video and see how fabulous his youth is. Stop telling it is the same as Kabul. Any war is meanless and we - Vietnamese with yellow skin will fight till our last breathe to keep our freedom and independence.
@@chrisryaninchoco324 why you call he bad guy? Imaging people you loved were raped and then killed, you have to stand up, although you have no idea of when it ends, but you have to fight for your family at first. War has no meaning. We fight for our own freedom and peace. I'm so proud of my grandfather. When he left the army, he was dioxin toxin positive (I want to say more but my english is just like that) and after that my grand mother misscarriaged again and again. Thank for the American gift.
@@nhuphamthuy6749 you should learn to love your people and not the government!! Yeah sure your country is now happy and prosperous but lack of freedom!!!!😡😡😡😡😡
@@chrisryaninchoco324 the gov do good comrade Tell me what freedom shit we don’t have kid When you guy get raped so hard by covid out there we’re drinking beer and talk shit about our government We got free speak after all The only shit you can’t say shit about is out national hero like Ho Chi Minh,.. So you west stop the shitty thing you talk about our Vietnam if you are not Vietnamese That look stupid are shit man Ah yes With the kind of you about to say we brainwashed or some shit like that after all How pathetic
western war thirsty monsters are now heading to South China sea for another potential war the whole world should boycott, sanction and if possible just nuke the sh*t out murica to achieve the eternal peace
I am Vietnamese, in addition to domestic information, I want to learn more about what the world thinks about our fight and I am proud that the world supports us.
The world doesn't support you and that's kind of absurd for you to think so. A lot of people feel how I feel that North Vietnam was a expansionist and oppressive Nation that forcefully occupied the legitimate government of the South then invaded without caus Laos and Cambodia. Vietnam is a one-party State dictatorship who oppresses minorities and operational groups to this day. I will never support your shithole country.
Probably the most deserved military victory in modern human history. I understand people's sympathy for those who feared the Communists, but under the South Vietnamese government they were the ones torturing, murdering and turning in their neighbours to the police. It's hypocritical to only value a Vietnamese life when they aren't a "communist." Ultimately these people chose America over an indigenous national liberation movement that had fought for Vietnam's sovereignty against the Japanese and the French before that. They must be among the most committed people in any army there's ever been. Simply put: they wanted it more because it was theirs.It's also an impressively orderly victory in which no pointless massacres or chaos occurred. You can tell that it was important to them not to tarnish something so many of their people had died for and the discipline was real.
As outsider, I agree in general of your view. North Vietnam was leading to fight for Vietnam sovereignty and independency with utter determination regardless of cost and lives.
@shiishani3302 you call this propaganda because it doesn’t fit your belief. Instead of calling a vid propaganda,maybe you should pay Vietnam a visit to see if facts fit your belief . And stop coping with government lies,we don’t execute people for fun .
I well remember listening to the news on my car radio during this time and realizing to my amazement that the Vietnam War, which had caused immense upheavals in the USA and had been such an inescapable part of much of my life, was now really and finally ending.
I was a Vietnam/Draft resistor. I remember these scenes on TV For some reason, it brought no sense of relief b/c I realized I was witnessing an American defeat that was demoralizing. Imagine the families of those 60000 who were lost there. I was anti-war...not anti-American
@@BOB-wx3fq What that means is you think more with your **** than the brain in between your ears. And you had special training to master that. I'm sure your fellow unibrows are very proud of you.
@@topgeardel ok sure, the chechyan rebels disarmed the tankers, took apart their AK's, disassembled the bolt carrier groups, removed the firing pins, reassembled the rifles and gave it back to the tankers That makes so much sense
Vietnamese army in this time was a strong army in the world .Because they won 3 wars : 1 with French from 1858 to 1954 and 2 with English in South Viet nam from 1946 to 1954 . 3 with American ,Australian,South Korean and New Zealander from 1961 to March,1973 .They won the war in 30/4/1975 .In their history,they had many wars with Chinese for 1,800 years,many battles with Japanese,Qing (china), Mongolian,Thailand people,Laos,Cambodian,Dutch and Spanish .But they love PEACE very much .
The North Vietnamese military was indeed very strong, despite the tendency of outsiders-especially Westerners-to portray it as little more than a scrappy band of rice farmers. Many Vietnamese are justifiably proud of having fielded a professional, highly trained fighting force.
@@dudelebowski8629 --The Vietnamese I know don’t care for the “rice farmers” characterization, nor the David-versus-Goliath metaphor that Westeners, especially, like to use. They take it as a simplistic stereotype, however well-intentioned it may be. (I assume that you didn't mean it this way.) It’s meaningful to mention that among Vietnamese fighters there were doctors, lawyers, accountants, clerks, entertainers, teachers, architects, engineers, and many others who’d never grown a grain of rice in their lives. Together they formed professional, highly trained and seasoned military forces, and labeling them as “rice farmers” isn’t necessarily the compliment it is intended to be.
@@cardinalRG they don't need a compliment, they only won because the American People had mercy on all the soldiers involved. If the American people wanted blood, we would blow up the whole country. We half assed all wars after WW2, we never gave full effort again. Why? Because we have too much mercy, war is too ugly, we don't have conscription, drafts are rarely used etc
It was interesting how Ho Chi Minh worked with the OSS in WW II and invited American officers when he declared independence of Vietnam. He obviously needed US as an ally not Soviet or China. Later, in some interviews, he expressed how he was inspired by American revolution and he was willing to do the same in Vietnam. His work could go as planned if he got US on his side. Unfortunately, US government didn't give any attention to him which led to a huge mess afterwards.
That is sad and might have turned out different had Roosevelt lived or not been pressured into dropping his long time VP (Wallace). Both men were determined to rid the world of colonialism. Truman was picked solely because he had few political enemies and once he had taken office after FDR's passing was persuaded to back France's recapture of control in Vietnam. If Vietnam had become free with the blessing of the USA in 1945 just think what that country might have became by this time. They are on the rise these days and I wish them good fortune.
Charles De Gaulle threatened the Roosevelt Administration that they would join the Soviet Bloc if the US picked Vietnam over France. The French came back to Vietnam in 1945 to retained their colony, the communist force was only around 500 to 1000 men at that time. Later, French got their butts kicked in 1954. All I have to say is history is intertwined and predestinated.
America lost the Vietnam war because the Communists broke their treaty to not continue the war. In Afghanistan, America chose to leave rather than stay forever. It's just that Biden didn't plan it out at all, so everything is chaos.
Vietnam literally is one of the toughest nations of all time, they fought several nonstop, sometimes overlapping wars from 1946 until 1991. No matter which side won, we now see that inevitably Vietnam would become a friend of the USA. And it's an honor to be your friend, I hope to visit one day.
Friends but not allies, Vietnam will stay neutral to avoid being pawned by greater powers, and the Vietnamese never forget American atrocities committed to the land.
You Vietnamese people don't want to be friends with the US. VN can be friendly, but not friend, to the US. US doesn't believe in friendship or loyalty. The Americans only work with partners for mutual benefits. The US is a good, fair partner, and won't screw VN like China. VN needs to be an equal partner, not a beggar, by bringing something good to the table, and the US will stick with VN. Look at Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea. Do not fall in love with the US, or any other countries, especially Russa, and definitely not China. VN needs to realize the days of sharing communist ideology are over. The only people who are friends and loyal to Vietnamese are Vietnamese.
Hundreds of thousands young Americans and Vietnamese lost their lifes for one day of the fall of the southern regime, then the people who were in fear of the regime welcomed and embraced their brothers from the north.
You have seen that very valuable image, in contrast to the smear of the CIA and the puppet government of Saigon. Americans and saigon regime warned: the communist army would "bathe in blood", "pull out the nails", Frank Sneep, a senior CIA official, even wrote "the communist army captured a female Saigon radio announcer, tied her up, cut her tongue ". That's why many people panicked, ran after the army and died at sea.Chaos occurred throughout South Vietnam, so the Saigon government collapsed without any major battles. Even the North was unpredictable.
Saigonese were cunning like the old foxes. They just shot at the communist forces moment ago then when the surrender order came, just ditched their weapons and uniforms , joined the crowds to pretend welcoming the NVA and the NLF. That day was just the beginning of a horrible era for the Vietnamese under communism. Millions people perished in re-education camps, in the unbearable new economic zones, died of hunger and diseases, died of prosecution and in prisons, and others disappeared on the high sea or on land tried to escape. Communism was one of the biggest man made disaster of the 20th century with Stalin, Mao, the Polpot, the Vietnamese communist just murdered their own people for the sake of their ideology.
@Elcollpohorrible the Vietnamese who died for national independence were the ARVN and other South Vietnamese military members. They fought bravely against the Communists even when the odds were hopeless.
People in Saigon back then cheered because that they are not so worry about fighting and being in fear that they are going to be shot and forced to fight their own Vietnamese people. Peace is one thing that we are desired for more than 40 years, more than anyone, we understand how valuable it is. One more thing is that the government of south Vietnam, or the "thing" that they call "republic of Vietnam" totally sucked, with corruptions, evils like banning Buddhism and other religion that have made people in South Vietnam hate the government. Only that cannot stand the pressure of living under Communism decided to turn against their own nation, and become United States 's burden and keep rotting themselves until these days in little Saigon in California, keeping dreaming about their fed-like-animal history
Seeing those little kids crying on the ship makes me sad. it reminds me of that Hey Arnold episode. I didn't realize that it was historically relevant until I learned about Vietnam.
The true horror was the years after this, when many South Vietnamese tried to escape to seek asylum and a way to the U.S (in Thailand, Singapore, Phillipines). They are called "boat people" and although there is no accurate statistic, it is estimated that around 2 millions of them perished on the sea surrounded South Vietnam, in the hand of pirates (killed, raped then throw out of their boat), to hunger and decease in the refugee camps if they managed to reach those forementioned countries.
Long Live Unified Vietnam...I felt greatly happy to learn North Vietnam was finally able to take South Vietnam on April 30 , 1975... I was also mighty relieved to see the US finally pulling out of Vietnam in 1973 - without the least Pride...!!! LONG LIVE VIETNAM... LONG LIVE VIETNAM's LEADERSHIP...!!!
my oldest uncle was one of the NVA got blowed up into more then 100 pieces by bomb from US air fighter during the vietnamwar at the Ho Chi Minh Trail , and then few years later his wife got killed during the US B52 bombing HaNoi , i never see their face in my tire life...
When I was born in 1972 in El Salvador (Central America) my Mom says that my Dad came into the hospital room and the first thing he did was picked me up and looked at the soles of feet, he then jokingly said; "That's my boy, he is not flat-footed, he can go fight in Vietnam when he turns 19". The war as on the news of all newspapers in the world.
Saigon's retreat was well organised compared to the shitshow that is Kabul right now, LOL. The US managed to lose to two groups of warriors fighting in sandals.
North Vietnam was not hostile to any western countries, it only hostiled to foreign forces which stopped them from unify the nation - a wish that had been there since the start of French occupation. It portrayed in the war with China and Cambodia at the border of Vietnam 4 years after the war (1979). The fact that Swedish, Germans still had good contact with NV during the war. And now Vietnam considered the U.S to be its ally, because for 1000 years and until modern time, China has always been Vietnam biggest enemy.
After decades of civil and military involvement in South Vietnam, the fall of Saigon and South Vietnam was a national humiliation for the United States. Quite right, too. The U.S. war in Vietnam was thoroughly unjustified.
The Communist war against the Vietnamese people was totally unjustified. The United States went there to assist the Vietnamese people in fighting the Communists. When the Communists took over nearly 3 million Vietnamese fled the country, the largest Exodus in Southeast Asian history.
@@tedmccarron there might be an alternate reality where Vietnamese could've became like South Korea and West Germany but we live in this reality and I'm glad that the Vietnamese people got what they wanted which was unification, I don't like communists nor do I like capitalists both are bad if taken too far. The United States intervene in Vietnam's internal matters which was liberation from the French and created South Vietnam, they should've never been there in the first place. All the Vietnamese families who suffered from Agent Orange, members with PTSD, being cut down my machine gun fire and all the Americans who were shunned for fighting in a war that they never wanted to be in. The Vietnam War was a tragedy before it even started. Now that Vietnam is unified, the people are happy that they that they themselves didn't ended up like Korea and inequality was kept to a minimal by the state. They still have a long way to go, but this is still better than stuck fighting a war that never ends.
@@dannyzero692 the Vietnamese people didn't "get what they wanted," they got totalitarian communism and lost all their rights by an evil army and government that FORCED it on them. North Vietnam invaded three countries that just wanted to be left alone. Unification is nice but freedom is much more important than unification. To be unified under slavery, mass murder and Terror is not a good thing at all and only an idiot would be in favor of it. Korea is at least half free and the other half is a totalitarian nightmare. I'm sure you would want to see them Unified under North Korean rule so that millions of innocent Koreans could die. That's not a happy outcome, that's a nightmare.
@@tedmccarron bruh, there would be a election for reunification of Vietnam after Geneve but the CIA had to stick their nose in so nope, US didn’t help, they created more killing. People who fled where associated with the Saigon government or US personal.
I have MASSIVE RESPECT for the all of Vietnamese people, they literally just just wanted to be able to have their country reunited in peace and to have the freedom to be able to decide for themselves what route to take to reaching creating a successful destiny and future for their homeland. And isn't that just the desire of every peoples of every country in the world. Communist/Socialist or not, THAT IS THE WILL OF EVERY COUNTRY AND OF EVERY ONE OF THEIR CITIZENS IN THE WORLD, period! And so it should be! The Red terror.... please. I mean, look at the example the Vietnamese people set for the rest of the Communists/ Socialists of the world. They are probably actually the only TRULY SUCCESSFUL Communists countries in the world, they actually did it right and created a Utopian Society.... The people are proud of their country, those who reside in the cities have jobs, food, homes and are provided with all of the things that they need to live and to support their families and those in the countryside also live decently on the land, usually laboring in traditional Vietnamese farming or fishing jobs and sonce that's how their country is, I do believe they don't mind rural living and actually prefer it to the life in the big cities. I gotta give them props, good job VIETNAM!!!!!!!
I am Vietnamese, and I read all comments from all over the world friends, and @devonoylear2415 is talking about us in the right way (at least to myself). My father was in the army and fought in the border war of the Souther (of VN), his elder brother died in a hard 1968 battle against U.S army. My grandfathers had troubles in the 1955s with the new North government's farm revolution, but after all, they didn't mind and kept supporting Uncle Ho's government and sent all their sons to join the army. My brother and I were born after the war, we were raised in our families's arms with love and I did not hear their hatred, my parents worked hard to feed us, and we kept forward to get a more convenient life. My younger brother and in-law-brother joined the Communist party, but I am not but is not different from us under the leadership of one government.
These Vietnamese War Refugees were held in the Philippines since 1975 to 1992 in Palawan and Bataan. As the current, many Vietnamese Refugees was now at Viet Ville Restaurant in Puerto Princesa City was start of our business after the Vietnam War and held us for the saving difference.
It is 30/4/2022 today and I am here - to review these scenes. I would like to say I strongly love and am grateful for people fighting for peace and harmony - Vietnamese heroes. Thank you - Communist Armies.Thank you for your patience; moreover, thank you for your noble sacrifice.Oh my love, oh my pride 🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
@@nguoisaigon526 Who cares dark side??? All the South Vietnamese use strong weapon and also have USA for the economy, and Saigon people cheers for communist
Only a piece of shit communist with no respect for human rights would applaud the Communist takeover of South vietnam. When the Communists took over they not only killed in the prison many innocent people but they took away the rights of all vietnamese. When they took over the Vietnamese people lost their freedom of speech, freedom of religion, Democratic political process, freedom of assembly and freedom of the press. All their rights were taken away and they delved into a Soviet style nightmare state. It was like the east side of the Berlin wall. Nearly 3 million of them fled the country which made it the largest accidents in Southeast Asian history. Only a total control free would be happy about something like that.
Vietnamese love peace! But history is too fierce for our country. We fight because we must to fight! For independence! For our people! Long live Vietnam! Long live HoChiMinh!
Almost everything you said is wrong. The Vietnam nation is a shit hole. Vietnam is an expansionist and oppressive warlike people who do nothing but pick fights and invade Nations around them and pick fights that day themselves cannot win and a beg for foreign political help. How did the invasion of Cambodia work out? How did that border conflict with China work out for you guys? LOL. Ho chi Minh was a tyrant who did nothing meaningful in his life and was nothing but a loser. And also you're so called Independence meant years of being nothing but being a Soviet puppet.
@Livin Vids Happened before the US even fully withdrew. At least the South Vietnamese held on (kinda) on their own for a couple years. Not to mention the hubris from the US leadership saying how the ANA had 300,000 troops and there was hardly a chance they would fall to the Taliban.
@Livin Vids i’ll tell you why. The US was desperately trying to get the fuck out of Vietnam and their people support it. They got out with a bunch of orphans with them and the war was over. The end. But Afghanistan situation is different. Now that they haven’t got out yet and their troops were still dying from terrorist attacks, Afghanistan will surely become a sanctuary for ISIS and Al Qaeda ver 2.0. There’ll be 10/11, 11/11, 12/11... attacks on the US soil by these groups of terrorists. The war in Afghanistan is now widely open with more potential civil war and uprising.
HCM never wanted war. He wanted peace for his country only. When no one listens and you’ve been betrayed then you take action. Some say worthless war and I’m sure HCM would agree because he tried to avoid it from the beginning. It was just a proxy war and the Vietnamese and surrounding countries suffered because of it.
You are SO WRONG--HCM was a dedicated bloodthirsty Communist, educated in Marxism in Paris in the post WWI period, and later in Communist imperialism in the USSR. He cared nothing for the loss of life if it served his Russian Communist masters and led to the reunification if North and South Vietnam at the point of a gun.
16:59 Saigon had luck that the regular forces ot the north lead the war in this phase. Some wanted to settle their own old scores. In Phnom Penh the kids soldiers of the Khmer Rouge behaved like psychopathic killers.
Well we Vietnam kind of help the new Cambodia and eliminate those psychopathic after 1975 war. Although many of my people gone starve between the war with Cambodia while America superiority of "Embargo". We still managed to survive, wipe out Khmer Rouge for doing war crime on it own people and my people, and see the error of our socialism way and change for the better for our people. Now here we are, freedom with economy grow even in the middle of the pandemic.
I was 17 years old when I got to Vietnam-1966 through 1969 (My mom had to sign a waiver for me), I grew up fast and learned a lot, good and bad. (I am now 73 and still learning). I was stationed on the USS Providence and also stationed in Country at a place called "Monkey Mountain" close to DaNang,. I spent 3 tours of duty in and around Vietnam. 3 of my high school friends were killed in Vietnam, I was spared. I participated in the TET Offensive in Feb 1968, that was bad. Somewhere along the way I was exposed to Agent Orange (Nasty Stuff) I am now on disability for the effects of agent orange. When I was discharged and came home to the States we arrived in San Francisco, and there were a lot of protesters spitting on us and throwing rocks and eggs and called us baby killers. That was our welcome home. I tell you this to say to you, that whatever your position is or was on the Vietnam war, it was not the veteran who got us into the war, most of us went because we were patriots and loved our country. Blame the politicians, yes, but not the veteran. To all Vietnam Vets out there, you are not forgotten. As a previous combat Vet myself, I salute you my friend.
I guess now to avoid those attrocities being victims of war, people must consider what does this mean being patriots ? , if it can be easily manipulated by lies from our own politicians to get us into war after war, endless wars policy. If i may say, after Vietnam war, US copied the "Vietnam all over again" to Iraq, Afga, Yugoslovia, Serbia,...and many indirect wars, now the rhetoric of Ukraine war. Talking about US intervention to foreign countries, i remember history of US came to Philippines, senator of the US wrote at the time " it was true that the rulers of philippines oppressed and killed its people, but once we came in to liberate those poor people, the number of philippinos we killed in 2 months even more than what they have been killing during 13 years". At the end, i think being patriots meant to love, be loyal to your own country, to your people AND also to love and treat other people in other countries the same way as your people not your enemy, Once we take arms come all a long way to other countries to kill others, we have to ask ourselves what the outcome of killing others and who benefit it ?
As a Vietnamese, I understand that very well, we don't blame the American soldier who was young and did not know much at that time. I born in Hanoi, my granddad is a Veteran too, he's fought the France, manage to save a whole squadron, and I think he was bad ass enough because later he got caught the France sent him on an island prison Côn Đảo (very far away). Luckily he survived and still live well, he is 94 years old right now😂
I was on a ship headed for cold weather training at Mt. Fuji when the gulf of Ton kin incident happened our ships took a left turn and we spent nearly 3 months floating off shore... Later on land for 13 months. What younger people don't think about is that we were born (1946) in the shadow of the WWII veterans, all the big parades on many holidays and just the way the country felt about veterans in the 50s. I remember thinking (also at 17) that if there was a war maybe we could become something to be proud of as well.
Afghans had 20 years to clear the country of Taliban. All people in power there are corrupt. They will flee and take their money with them. No matter who wins the average Afghani is worse for it. What's even worse is that for 20 years Pentagon has been milking $$$ out of the American taxpayer and got away with it. There are counteless scrap yards of perfectly serviceable equipment that was scrapped so that people's pockets could be greased. This is all public knowledge but no one has balls to do anything about it.
My uncle had been in the army marching for half a year to go to the South for liberation, now he is an average 2/4 wounded and still has 4 shrapnel in his lungs, he has 4 children, the latter 2 are infected with Agent Orange. Uncle lost a close friend from the same neighborhood when he joined the army that year, that close friend has not been found until now.
The last American helicopter landed at 8:06 AM atop the American Embassy. There were 11 American Marines that got aboard. Juan Valdez was the last to get on the helicopter. Unlike other reports Ambassador Graham Martin was not the last American to leave Saigon.
Our country regained its independence from the hands of Americans and their henchmen. We are the whole country, not just "North Vietnam", but include forces in the South. The truth is that without the war on the Southwest border, the Northern border and the US embargo (until 1995), our country would have been much more developed. We have continued the tradition of driving out the foreigners. We saved the Cambodian people from genocide from Ponpot. But the world still owes Vietnam an apology and an acknowledgment of the historical values we bring to world peace. Because we have gained independence since 1945, repelled the French colonialists in 1954. Because of that, colonial countries around the world have carried out revolutions to gain independence. Be careful, events in the Taliban and Vietnam may be similar in some ways. But the nature and origin of the two forces are completely different. This is the internet age, be careful when comparing and judging.
North Vietnam was not a reactionary religious extremests like Talies. How US during Soviet-Afghan war mainly aided Hekmatyar, who eventually ended up cheering for Al Qaeda and Taliban who were arch nemesis to his own Mujahedeens, instead of more nuanced and revolutionary Ahmad Shah Masoud, shows you how dumb and clueless US foreign intervention tactic is. The louder one to shout "commies are bad" gets US dollars.
My grandfather lived 18 miles from Sai Gon at that time, he was scared that the Communist will treat the Sai Gon people, its officers and politicians like what the revolution in China did. It was a relived that they only took his family money away.
The United States built two undercarriages of helicopters, in addition to the purpose of taking off and landing, also for another purpose, to let the team of henchmen selling water hang around to run away. Shame on those who sell the country.
@@attorneyreel1181 when I say money I mean anything valuable. He lost jewelry, gold bars, etc... the south's money were useless. The funny thing is some North Vietnamese soldiers bring lots of food with them. The propoganda ran deep and they though the South was poor, and people living like they were in the French colonial rules. They were quite surprised when they found out about Pizza, can foods.
1:43 You can see an ARVN (south Vietnamese) officer board the ship, and at 1:50 you can spot an ARVN officer at the top of the ship staircase, you can also see an ARVN infantry soldier at the top of the entrance to the ship, which indicates that ARVN troops were still in the city still trying to escape.
To be precise, NVA and NLF (aka Vietcong) were far different from Taliban. They behaved like regular human beings, and all they have wanted were unification. Taliban, on the contrary, well...
Lmao, as if the NVA and NLF didn't commit their share of atrocities. Both treated their POWs brutally, conducted terror attacks, and sent hundreds of thousands of re-education camps where many were tortured and killed. You can say literally the same about the Taliban, all they wanted was reunification of their country since the invasion of the Soviets and its collapse into Civil War thereafter.
@@taoliu3949 and your proof is? Lol people such as yourself wont ever understand that life in the re education camp had been much better than daily lives that day
@@dat_toonieProof? Hundreds of thousands of civilians were killed by the NVA and VC during the war through deliberate terror attacks. Hundreds of thousands of people sent to re-education camps have provided testimonies. Oh yes, "better than daily lives" equates to being imprisoned, beatened, tortured, etc. The Vietnamese government even tried to justify their actions by labeling these people as "prisoners". That said, where is YOUR proof that the Taliban did everything you claimed they have done?
@@spookyperson7096 Lol, Mao was infamous for his ability to incite fighting between the classes, his entire period of rule could basically be characterized as him destroying his political rivals through successful persecutions of various people. First you had the "land reforms" which where the peasantry was goaded to attack and kill the landowners. Then you had persecutions of the KMT post 1949 which resulted in 700k+ people executions. There were also several anti campaigns that were aimed at businessmen, intellectuals, and members of the CCP who was claimed to be corrupt resulting in millions of deaths. The Cultural revolution was also an incitation of the students to attack their superiors, but also effectively annihilating many of his own political rivals within the party.
Đây mới là phim tài liệu về chiến tranh ở Việt Nam chân thật nhất, đúng đắn nhất, thế hiện đúng bản chất vấn đề về chiến tranh Việt Nam. Cảm ơn kênh youtube của bạn đã phản ánh đúng sự thật ❤🇻🇳 đến từ Việt Nam.
@mistermodified1 us was so brutal it managed after 20 years of war managed to unite the whole country behind the Taliban, even groups they'd previously oppressed, because the us was worse
It's extremely funny when people still screaming capitalism good communism bad or vice-versa although we Vietnamese just trying to get over the pandemic. And for some reason Vietnam do not having a PS5 shortage, I seeing millions of advertising post on social media all day.
13:39 "Nothing is more valuable than independence and freedom" Do we Vietnamese have independence and freedom? Yes But I am afraid for those in Afghanistan now living in the terrorist regime not having the same things we have.
Initially, we were there because we needed Frances' help in Berlin. FDR advocated for independence for the French colonies. After he died, Truman needed France's help in Berlin to counter the Soviets, so when France sought to assert their dominance over their former colonies, Truman looked the other way. When Vietnam fought France for its independence, the U.S. was paying up to 70% of France's war cost. After France's defeat, the UN divided Vietnam at the 17th Parallel, with the Communists getting the Northern half and the U.S.-backed Ngo Dinh Diem regime getting the southern half. There was a UN requirement to hold elections in two years. But the Catholic and anti-communist Diem stated that the South hadn't signed the Geneva Accords, so they weren't bound by them. Diem also felt it was impossible to hold free elections in the North, so the national election was never held. The U.S. also felt that Diem could not defeat Ho Chi Minh in a federal election, so they also supported the election cancellation. Diem was a corrupt Catholic autocrat in a country full of Buddhists, and he was only interested in maintaining power for himself and his family. He was overthrown in a coup on Nov 1st, 1963. So, I guess you could say we backed the wrong horse...
@@rdouglas747 America REALLY should have back uncle Ho instead. The alternative history will be interesting, Viet is tough in military and economic and became an asia dragon, to this time it will be a good team to balance the China rising 😂
Now here I am watching Americans exit Afghanistan all the while Taliban reclaiming all territory now at 85%. History always repeats itself. Iraq war veteran.
@@abdullahmsa7027 "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." - writer and philosopher *George Santayana* Read and think about it.
False. The truth is that Vietnam is an oppressive and expansionist Communist dictatorship who by Force occupy their neighbors and oppress minority groups to this day.
The Vietnamese fought the Japanese, then the French, and the Americans. They won all the wars against colonialists and invaders. Why Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon fought them - only they could answer, or at least try to.
My granduncle left the North to the South as an adopted child of a relative sometime around 1954. He lost connection with his family then. After that, he joined the Army in the South, while my grandfather and his other brother fought for the North. I don’t think they met in the battlefield but the brothers literally fought each other in this war.
@@Elephantsss that "South" was not Vietnamese people, there was Americans and pro-Americans. "Vietcong" or Viet Minh was from the South and been founded by the real South side just so you know.
My father was in South Vietnam in 1968 and part of 1969. He made friends with a Vietnamese woman who assisted the signal corps. Her husband had been killed by the Communists. When he left she gave him an antique Vietnamese fishing boat. I remember playing with it as a kid. It was sad because I think I wore it down playing with it as a kid.
For people here that want to compare Vietnam to Afghan they are no where the same. Only thing that was similar was there would be less casualty if American didn't get involve in the civil war. For the Afghan people I hope you have a peaceful transfer and not a long and protracted civil war.
Sao giống nhau chiến tranh vn thuộc chiến tranh thế giới của các cường quốc và những nước nhỏ chống lại sự bành tướng và ách thống trị và cuộc chiến giữa hai nền dân chủ và cộng sản mà mĩ sợ cộng sản bá quyền thế giới nên ví giống Nhau là điều ko thể
@@rdouglas747 and only focusing on the fact that US was supposedly "beaten". Taliban are just right wing religious extremists. US intervention should have been limited to Afghan and Afghan only without dipping their feet into Iraq, and even then, prolonged US occupation would have given more excuse for Taliban to terrorize its own population which is precisely what happened.
I had no idea the fall of Saigon itself was this bloodless. The only casualties of that event seemed to be self-inflicted. Years from now, will the fall of Kabul be looked upon similarly?
At this day I boarded a Royal Air Lao Flight (DC 4) from Vientiane to Saigon. Over Pakse, about halfway, the Airplane returned to Vientiane and we ve been told that the Airport of Saigon is closed.
@@capncake8837 the South lost because they were shitty at fighting, when the NVA found the US supplies for the South inside Long Binh Post in 1975, there were still more than enough weapons and equipments for us to fight 2 more wars with the Khmer Rogue in 1979 & Chinese (1979-1989), even some of them lasted till these days
RUclips algorithm has united us all once again.
Ain’t that the truth.
Absolutely🤣
Do you not see why?
History repeat itself once again ladies and gentlemen 👏 👏👏 American army coward Army
Yep...
History never repeats itself, but it does often rhyme.” - Mark Twain
USA can never be trusted. They fly you up and left u all alone mid air to fall.
@@racetoria3069 sweat in Taiwan, flame of red dragon in the horizon shine bright while Eagle screech has turned in to Covid cough.
Next will be taiwan?! I hope not!
@@tatarchan5212 Taiwan has Japan on their side though. Even if biden would let China take Taiwan he wouldn't let them take Japan. He'll be out in 3 years anyways and we'll likely get someone like desantis who will take a hard stance on china.
@@E0572-e1n desantis? That anti vaxxer delusional fascist? He can't even take on Cuba properly, both Trump and Biden does far better job than him and that's saying something.
Also China don't need Japan, they want only Taiwan because they're still in civil war after 70 years of barking at each other and both prepared to become the one real China. Victory over Taiwan is like victory over confederate in China which every leader eager to succeed at doing so.
Imagine if confederate still exist would US president want to put an end to this forever war?
Boomers saw Fall of Saigon
Zoomers saw Fall of Kabul
That could not be any more true. Also to add more coincidence the previous generation preceding saw trauma of which the world changed.
Pre-boomers saw the horrors of WWII
Millennials saw the horrors of 9/11
Its all part of the plan.
Alphas won't see Fall of Taipei
@@souvik43209 Betas would
@@sooryan_1018 XD
And now we're allowed to visit Vietnam and they treat us kindly. That's an amazing people.
Vietnam is independent and equal so you are treated like that .
As a Vietnamese yes, you guys ain't the dummies in US government who start Vietnam War so you guys have nothing to do with us
How many Americans know that HCM actually reached out for USA after WW1 to help him win independence for Vietnam, and he was not a communist back then? He repeated his attempts several time but was shunned back. How many Americans know that CASTRO tried the same thing with the US to win the same thing for his Cuban people, but was also Shunned? Same with the Soviets they also tried to be friends with the west after WW2, but were actually shunned back. The ruling elite/ bankers of the USA were always ready to deceive their own American people and hide the real story, for the benefit of the industrial complex. The only 2 presidents that actually tried to warn Americabs about it and tried to stop those proxy wars were Isenhower and JFK.
They pushed Vietnam toward communism, then send troops there to reverse it. They liberated Afghanistan from Taliban just to give it back to them later together with billions dollars worth of equipment. unnecessary bloodshed everywhere. It is just stupid.
So true
HCM has been a communist since the final years of the 1910s, he was a member of the French Social Party, and voted in favor of the establishment of the French Communist Party. The Soviets after WW2 were aggressively trying to make the whole world communist, this is evident in the fact that puppet communist governments were systematically founded in Eastern Europe, in the countries that was unfortunate enough to be "liberated" by the USSR. They were not "shunned", they were wolves pretending to be harmless sheep, and they got what they deserve.
BULLSHIT!! The Communists were hell bent on taking over the world and these supposed attempt to reach out to the US were simply attempts to get Aiden support from us before they killed us and made us communist too. Lenin said that the capitalists would sell them the rope they would use to hang them with. Whenever we did try to be friendly with them it came back to haunt us in the end. Castro and Ho Chi Minh were Soviet loyalists who had no intention of long-term friendly relations with the us. Their intentions were to make their own areas and eventually the rest of the world communist and take all our rights away.
The Declaration of Independence of then Democratic Republic of Vietnam literally has a quote from the US Declaration of Independence. Look it up.
From French colonialism to American occupation, the strength of the Vietnamese people has to be admired
Well you mean the North Vietnamese people. Seems to me if soon as the US pulled out 3 years before the southern Vietnamese were looking for a reason to fold like a cheap tent. That's one of the reasons why the US pulled out because of corruption and they weren't willing to fight hard enough for their own freedom. If you want it bad enough you'll do anything to get it, one side obviously wanted it more than the other.
@@Sandhill1988 South Vietnam was a brutal regime in its own right, where the tiny Catholic minority imposed its will on the Buddhist majority; no wonder it folded.
@@Sandhill1988 gringo go home
@@Carolina-uu5ji
@@Carolina-uu5ji the truth hurts doesn't it.
The Vietnam War is still alive and raging today......in this comment section.
it's all about US
South Vietnamese Republic
(1949-1975)
💛🚩
Coalition forces supported by the United States
North Vietnamese Democratic Republic
(1955-1976)
🔴🚩
Communist forces supported by the Soviet Union
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
(1976-present)
🇻🇳
The born of Southeast Asian power supported by own members of ASEAN
It's true i wish video like this stop being political
@@chickenpuddingstudio4730 it doesn't matter now who was right or wrong. History can't be changed. Still, the desire to find out the truth is a big one.
@@quananginh9446 vietnamese?
My parents are both from the North of Vietnam. They were still kids in 1975 and my mom always told me how happy it was back then when she didnt have to hide herself under the basement to avoid the bombing after the reunification. My mum had an uncle who had left the big family to go South with his small family in 1954 promising to be back in 1956 but it turned out he only saw them again 19 years later and his dad had died in 1965. He refused to flee from Vietnam in 1975 because he wanted to see them again. Then he took all his big family to the South including my mum and gave them shelter, helped everyone find a job and found school for my mum. Unfortunately, he died tragically in a car accident while riding his other niece to find a job in 1979. His small family are all in Germany and America now but all of us back in Vietnam always appreciate his generosity and great support. If there was no reunification in 1975, I wouldnt have been born on earth. The war brought a lot of pain to most family. There are people suffering because of the incident happened in 1975 but there were families like ours getting a lot better after it. I hope all the pain heals in the end and there will be no war like this ever happens again.
@babafoodle9624 We experience economic downturn this year. I don't think the situation is good because we suffer from so many lockdowns back in 2020 and 2021. But I guess there is still a chance for growth and I'm seeking it as well.
@@ngthoangyen wise man always say "shit happens"
@babafoodle9624 I am from America and want to move to Thailand
Very interesting life story with all the ups and downs. I can only imagine how so many years of war brought pain and mischief to so many. I was lucky to visit some of your beautiful country and get to meet very nice people in Hanoi area mostly. I would like to visit again sometime soon and get to see the rest of the country starting in HCM City upwards. Hope you are well and keep the spirits high, Im sure you will be fine and so will your contry. Cheers from Argentina!
@@agustinenzoa4447 Thank you for your kind words. Ho Chi Minh City and the nearby provinces such as Da Lat, Phan Thiet are also very interesting to visit. Hope you will have a great trip next time.
Next: we going to see *The Fall Of Kabul* 2022.
Edited:
As of today Sun Aug 15 2021 Taliban Captures Kabul, spoke too soon 😌
Yeah baby!
I can hardly wait for it
Who knows what will happen, Taliban has hardly captured any major city and districts are changing hands every day, there is no certainty when the conflict will be over
it could end sooner. it might be the end of 2021.
Not the fall of Kabul... The liberation of Kabul, liberated by the Afghan people.
AP has a twisted sense of humor, recommending this during the Saigon 2.0 incident recently.
RUclips did it. The resemblance is strange though
*laughs out loud*
its not "sense of humor", it is an obviously relevant story 🙄
@@ar2042 The resemblance is quite natural of any desperate evacuation. Those in charge f*** it up again.
@@ivanarciniegas7324 almost same, for example is north Vietnam soldier and Taliban use M16 😂
That first scene is NOT the US Embassy, but an apartment building on 22 Gia Long Street, now 22 Lý Tự Trọng Street, where CIA and others where stationed.
Yes it is still there and so is the ladder..
Can you help me understand what you mean? Was that some sort of capstone event? Lol
He he he the important, it is seen the almighty amerikan army running away with its tail between its legs, or as Richard Watergate Nixon said, a peace with honor! Eh eh eh eh eh eh eh eh
@@mattstephens6137 The United States Embassy in Saigon was first established in June 1952, and moved into a new building in 1967 and eventually closed in 1975. The embassy was the scene of a number of significant events of the Vietnam War, most notably the Viet Cong attack during the Tet Offensive which helped turn American public opinion against the war, and the helicopter evacuation during the Fall of Saigon after which the embassy closed permanently.
@@mattstephens6137 US embassy in Saigon was the first US embassy in the world to be attacked, Tet Offensive 1968
I went on a vacation to Hanoi and Saigon. It was very interesting. Beautiful country. Friendly people. Great food.
Great heroin out there I tell ya, great heroin.
Do any locals really call it ho chi minh city? I've heard that everyone, regular folks in every day life, have always called it Saigon. It's a much better name anyway. Washington DC, or just DC, sounds better than The District of Columbia George Winifred Washington City LOL
@@HavanaSyndrome69 As a northerner, we casually call HCM city "Saigon" but the official now is Ho Chi Minh City.
@@HavanaSyndrome69 of course shorter name, why not ? it not like the goverment ban the people to call that name anyway. But on paper and id stuffs well HCM city as alway.
Ho chi minh city
I was on my last hitch in the USN and just before I retired from active service in 2004 at NAWS China Lake, CA and one of my junior Petty Officers was a younger man of Vietnamese birth. He was one of the sharpest, most professional, proficient and respectful I have ever known. I kept track of his career thereafter and was very pleased to have seen him advance up the ranks. He spent so many years in those refugee camps and on the wrong side of the wire in Bataan Province, Philippines and had every reason to be bitter, angry or depressed, however, once he finally had the opportunity to join the USN he was 100% All In. Anh Le you are a True Inspiration to me.
You will never know how helpful and inspiring your comment is to me at this moment. I was laying back in my chair, depressed about life, and your account of Anh Le has just jolted me into focus and optimism. And more. Thank you.
Folks should never forget how an inspiring account about someone can help a total stranger.
...in the late 80's, there was a small restaurant on Queen Street East in Toronto. It had photos of end-of-war Vietnam on the wall. The owner was previously a press photographer, and had gotten out of Saigon on one of the very last helicopters...
Wow
There's a lot of ARVN vets still here, at least as of a few years ago when they had a reunion - in uniform - in Toronto's Mel Lastman Square. And the RVN flag still flies down the street from me here for some reason.
is the restaurant still around?
@@fumotized8210 Yes
@@fumotized8210 ...long gone, I imagine, the neighbourhood's getting gentrified...it was just down the street from the watering hole that James Earl Ray quenched his thirst at, when he was still on the lam...that was earlier on tho'..
Meanwhile, 200 km of them (in Phnom Penh), the genocide was begun by khmer rouge.
And the VPA kill them too .
Communism, brings death. Poor Cambodia for example,and Ukrain. At least there was no Genocide in Vietnam, as far as i know.
They we're not communist they we're mad men with racist ideology.
@@ksmythe1532 oof if only you knew history a d werent closed minded. i raise you stalin pretty easy example
@@flowersstaringback9234 Everything they had on the banners screamed Communism. What is the Hammer and Sickle? Go ahead, call it White. Marx & Lenin were.
My beloved grandfather was one of the communists coming to Saigon these days. As a teenager who joined the army, he left his family in the north of VN (Hai Phong) when my mother was just a very little kid, bumped into the war when no one could say when it ends and whether he lived or died.
Luckily, he could see me growing up as a teenager for almost 20 years. And so am I.
He passed away 6 years ago. Whenever I miss him, I think I will find this video and see how fabulous his youth is.
Stop telling it is the same as Kabul. Any war is meanless and we - Vietnamese with yellow skin will fight till our last breathe to keep our freedom and independence.
Then your one of the bad guys!!!!😡😡😡😡
@@chrisryaninchoco324 why you call he bad guy? Imaging people you loved were raped and then killed, you have to stand up, although you have no idea of when it ends, but you have to fight for your family at first. War has no meaning. We fight for our own freedom and peace. I'm so proud of my grandfather. When he left the army, he was dioxin toxin positive (I want to say more but my english is just like that) and after that my grand mother misscarriaged again and again. Thank for the American gift.
@@nhuphamthuy6749 you should learn to love your people and not the government!! Yeah sure your country is now happy and prosperous but lack of freedom!!!!😡😡😡😡😡
@@chrisryaninchoco324 stop telling as if you live next to my door 😏. You don't even live in Hanoi. Shut up about trash
@@chrisryaninchoco324 the gov do good comrade
Tell me what freedom shit we don’t have kid
When you guy get raped so hard by covid out there we’re drinking beer and talk shit about our government
We got free speak after all
The only shit you can’t say shit about is out national hero like Ho Chi Minh,..
So you west stop the shitty thing you talk about our Vietnam if you are not Vietnamese
That look stupid are shit man
Ah yes
With the kind of you about to say we brainwashed or some shit like that after all
How pathetic
US: "Ok that's it! It's over! We're done, never happened again!"
Taliban: "Hmmm"
US: "What?"
Taliban: *"You wouldn't get it"*
US must learn about what they did, because it's already happened Twice (but lil bit different)
Well there is lesson says lightning never strikes twice in 1 place. *WRONG!* . It hit like twice to the US mental power now
western war thirsty monsters are now heading to South China sea for another potential war
the whole world should boycott, sanction and if possible just nuke the sh*t out murica to achieve the eternal peace
@mistermodified1 your mom's bedroom
I do get it, the brutal things which is not funny
I am Vietnamese, in addition to domestic information, I want to learn more about what the world thinks about our fight and I am proud that the world supports us.
The world doesn't support you and that's kind of absurd for you to think so. A lot of people feel how I feel that North Vietnam was a expansionist and oppressive Nation that forcefully occupied the legitimate government of the South then invaded without caus Laos and Cambodia. Vietnam is a one-party State dictatorship who oppresses minorities and operational groups to this day. I will never support your shithole country.
Probably the most deserved military victory in modern human history. I understand people's sympathy for those who feared the Communists, but under the South Vietnamese government they were the ones torturing, murdering and turning in their neighbours to the police. It's hypocritical to only value a Vietnamese life when they aren't a "communist." Ultimately these people chose America over an indigenous national liberation movement that had fought for Vietnam's sovereignty against the Japanese and the French before that. They must be among the most committed people in any army there's ever been. Simply put: they wanted it more because it was theirs.It's also an impressively orderly victory in which no pointless massacres or chaos occurred. You can tell that it was important to them not to tarnish something so many of their people had died for and the discipline was real.
Communists did the exact same thing
As outsider, I agree in general of your view. North Vietnam was leading to fight for Vietnam sovereignty and independency with utter determination regardless of cost and lives.
@@agoodchow respect NVN too
The communists sent a bunch of people to camps afterwards
@@kittycatwithinternetaccess2356 But at least they fought for the Vietnamese, not for outsiders.
Damn reports really used to be relatively objective instead of filled up with cheap propaganda...
Still propaganda but yeah they had integrity to tell a story and not a narrative
@@myview5840 How is this propaganda? I thought it was very balanced and fair.
@@myview5840 how is this propaganda, it is obviously fact and truth. You can go to Saigon and see, all Vietnamese here will agree this.
@shiishani3302 you call this propaganda because it doesn’t fit your belief. Instead of calling a vid propaganda,maybe you should pay Vietnam a visit to see if facts fit your belief . And stop coping with government lies,we don’t execute people for fun .
@@asdf3568 he says nowadays' reports are filled with cheap propaganda. This report is a cool one
This doesn’t look like the fall of a city
It looks like a liberation of one
Indeed!
Liberation, yes!
wrong, the communists sent people to concentration camps, as well as also torturing and killing people
that's the one, Vietnam does not like to be the same like Korea
Liberation to single party dictatorship?
I well remember listening to the news on my car radio during this time and realizing to my amazement that the Vietnam War, which had caused immense upheavals in the USA and had been such an inescapable part of much of my life, was now really and finally ending.
hebneh Were you in nam.
I was a Vietnam/Draft resistor. I remember these scenes on TV For some reason, it brought no sense of relief b/c I realized I was witnessing an American defeat that was demoralizing. Imagine the families of those 60000 who were lost there. I was anti-war...not anti-American
@@topgeardel resistor 😂😂
So full of sh*t its coming out of your ears
I'm a Navy seal resistor
@@BOB-wx3fq What that means is you think more with your **** than the brain in between your ears. And you had special training to master that. I'm sure your fellow unibrows are very proud of you.
@@topgeardel ok sure, the chechyan rebels disarmed the tankers, took apart their AK's, disassembled the bolt carrier groups, removed the firing pins, reassembled the rifles and gave it back to the tankers
That makes so much sense
Vietnamese army in this time was a strong army in the world .Because they won 3 wars : 1 with French from 1858 to 1954 and 2 with English in South Viet nam from 1946 to 1954 . 3 with American ,Australian,South Korean and New Zealander from 1961 to March,1973 .They won the war in 30/4/1975 .In their history,they had many wars with Chinese for 1,800 years,many battles with Japanese,Qing (china), Mongolian,Thailand people,Laos,Cambodian,Dutch and Spanish .But they love PEACE very much .
The North Vietnamese military was indeed very strong, despite the tendency of outsiders-especially Westerners-to portray it as little more than a scrappy band of rice farmers. Many Vietnamese are justifiably proud of having fielded a professional, highly trained fighting force.
@@cardinalRG i mean it was a bunch a scrappy rice farmers, they were just TOUGH scrappy rice farmers!
@@dudelebowski8629 --The Vietnamese I know don’t care for the “rice farmers” characterization, nor the David-versus-Goliath metaphor that Westeners, especially, like to use. They take it as a simplistic stereotype, however well-intentioned it may be. (I assume that you didn't mean it this way.) It’s meaningful to mention that among Vietnamese fighters there were doctors, lawyers, accountants, clerks, entertainers, teachers, architects, engineers, and many others who’d never grown a grain of rice in their lives. Together they formed professional, highly trained and seasoned military forces, and labeling them as “rice farmers” isn’t necessarily the compliment it is intended to be.
If it was a strong army then it shouldn’t of needed to fall back entirely onto guerrilla warfare
@@cardinalRG they don't need a compliment, they only won because the American People had mercy on all the soldiers involved. If the American people wanted blood, we would blow up the whole country. We half assed all wars after WW2, we never gave full effort again. Why? Because we have too much mercy, war is too ugly, we don't have conscription, drafts are rarely used etc
God Bless Vietnam 🇻🇳😘
From 🇵🇭
❤❤
Nust
It was interesting how Ho Chi Minh worked with the OSS in WW II and invited American officers when he declared independence of Vietnam. He obviously needed US as an ally not Soviet or China. Later, in some interviews, he expressed how he was inspired by American revolution and he was willing to do the same in Vietnam. His work could go as planned if he got US on his side. Unfortunately, US government didn't give any attention to him which led to a huge mess afterwards.
that is true, if Americant govermen have accopany with HOCHIMINH the Viet nam war no happened
That is sad and might have turned out different had Roosevelt lived or not been pressured into dropping his long time VP (Wallace). Both men were determined to rid the world of colonialism. Truman was picked solely because he had few political enemies and once he had taken office after FDR's passing was persuaded to back France's recapture of control in Vietnam.
If Vietnam had become free with the blessing of the USA in 1945 just think what that country might have became by this time. They are on the rise these days and I wish them good fortune.
He was a very intelligent man. Definitely dedicated to his country. He was well educated. It all could have and should have been different .
Tôi đồng ý với bạn
Charles De Gaulle threatened the Roosevelt Administration that they would join the Soviet Bloc if the US picked Vietnam over France. The French came back to Vietnam in 1945 to retained their colony, the communist force was only around 500 to 1000 men at that time. Later, French got their butts kicked in 1954. All I have to say is history is intertwined and predestinated.
We are reliving this day today except instead of April 30, 1975 it is August 15, 2021. Instead of the fall of Saigon it is the Fall of Kabul.
America lost the Vietnam war because the Communists broke their treaty to not continue the war. In Afghanistan, America chose to leave rather than stay forever. It's just that Biden didn't plan it out at all, so everything is chaos.
Yea we know.
@@earlysda everything about Biden is chaos
@@earlysda What's your point? A loss is a loss.
@@jake8855 Jake, the point is --- don't ever trust a Communist to do as they say.
Vietnam literally is one of the toughest nations of all time, they fought several nonstop, sometimes overlapping wars from 1946 until 1991. No matter which side won, we now see that inevitably Vietnam would become a friend of the USA. And it's an honor to be your friend, I hope to visit one day.
Friends but not allies, Vietnam will stay neutral to avoid being pawned by greater powers, and the Vietnamese never forget American atrocities committed to the land.
@@angkhoanguyen6114 Вьетнамцы самые лучшие воины во всей Азии
@@angkhoanguyen6114 Уважение вьетнамцам
You Vietnamese people don't want to be friends with the US. VN can be friendly, but not friend, to the US. US doesn't believe in friendship or loyalty. The Americans only work with partners for mutual benefits. The US is a good, fair partner, and won't screw VN like China. VN needs to be an equal partner, not a beggar, by bringing something good to the table, and the US will stick with VN. Look at Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea. Do not fall in love with the US, or any other countries, especially Russa, and definitely not China. VN needs to realize the days of sharing communist ideology are over.
The only people who are friends and loyal to Vietnamese are Vietnamese.
@@angkhoanguyen6114 Respectable
Hundreds of thousands young Americans and Vietnamese lost their lifes for one day of the fall of the southern regime, then the people who were in fear of the regime welcomed and embraced their brothers from the north.
You have seen that very valuable image, in contrast to the smear of the CIA and the puppet government of Saigon.
Americans and saigon regime warned: the communist army would "bathe in blood", "pull out the nails", Frank Sneep, a senior CIA official, even wrote "the communist army captured a female Saigon radio announcer, tied her up, cut her tongue ". That's why many people panicked, ran after the army and died at sea.Chaos occurred throughout South Vietnam, so the Saigon government collapsed without any major battles. Even the North was unpredictable.
Saigonese were cunning like the old foxes. They just shot at the communist forces moment ago then when the surrender order came, just ditched their weapons and uniforms , joined the crowds to pretend welcoming the NVA and the NLF. That day was just the beginning of a horrible era for the Vietnamese under communism. Millions people perished in re-education camps, in the unbearable new economic zones, died of hunger and diseases, died of prosecution and in prisons, and others disappeared on the high sea or on land tried to escape.
Communism was one of the biggest man made disaster of the 20th century with Stalin, Mao, the Polpot, the Vietnamese communist just murdered their own people for the sake of their ideology.
vietnamese speak good english!
Oh yeah ? Ok
why can't we?
Congratulations Vietnam that you got your land back. My deepest respect for all the people whom died for national independence.
What are you talking about? Vietnam lost its land to the Communists in 1975.
@@tedmccarron So? You are not making any logical sense
cảm ơn bạn
@Elcollpohorrible the Vietnamese who died for national independence were the ARVN and other South Vietnamese military members. They fought bravely against the Communists even when the odds were hopeless.
@@tedmccarronshut
People in Saigon back then cheered because that they are not so worry about fighting and being in fear that they are going to be shot and forced to fight their own Vietnamese people. Peace is one thing that we are desired for more than 40 years, more than anyone, we understand how valuable it is.
One more thing is that the government of south Vietnam, or the "thing" that they call "republic of Vietnam" totally sucked, with corruptions, evils like banning Buddhism and other religion that have made people in South Vietnam hate the government. Only that cannot stand the pressure of living under Communism decided to turn against their own nation, and become United States 's burden and keep rotting themselves until these days in little Saigon in California, keeping dreaming about their fed-like-animal history
If you support communism!? Then your one of the bad guys!!!!
Agree
It doesn't matter economic prosperity is goimg to the south
Seems like you got some anger issues. But some people believe in the gook way of life. Maybe you and I could smoke some opium together.
@Chiến 2003 🇻🇳 speak english!
one thing i notice from 75 to these days..the city full of trees ! so beautiful..glad im visited this beautiful country..
Seeing those little kids crying on the ship makes me sad. it reminds me of that Hey Arnold episode. I didn't realize that it was historically relevant until I learned about Vietnam.
The true horror was the years after this, when many South Vietnamese tried to escape to seek asylum and a way to the U.S (in Thailand, Singapore, Phillipines). They are called "boat people" and although there is no accurate statistic, it is estimated that around 2 millions of them perished on the sea surrounded South Vietnam, in the hand of pirates (killed, raped then throw out of their boat), to hunger and decease in the refugee camps if they managed to reach those forementioned countries.
@@RagnarNomad And when Vietnam was becoming more developed, they starts to slander the country they abandoned.
Long Live Unified Vietnam...I felt greatly happy to learn North Vietnam was finally able to take South Vietnam on April 30 , 1975...
I was also mighty relieved to see the US finally pulling out of Vietnam in 1973 - without the least Pride...!!!
LONG LIVE VIETNAM...
LONG LIVE VIETNAM's LEADERSHIP...!!!
Huge respects for viet people
Thank you
Respect from Indonesia 🇮🇩🤝🇻🇳
sama - sama berjuang melawan penjajah❤.tidak seperti malaysia pada umumnya
❤❤
And here we are witnessing the fall of Kabul.
my oldest uncle was one of the NVA got blowed up into more then 100 pieces by bomb from US air fighter during the vietnamwar at the Ho Chi Minh Trail , and then few years later his wife got killed during the US B52 bombing HaNoi , i never see their face in my tire life...
Really sorry for your lost.
Thats good to hear SAT CONG
@@PeterNgola huh?
@@taolaai123123 RIP
@@PeterNgola ur mom is gay
When I was born in 1972 in El Salvador (Central America) my Mom says that my Dad came into the hospital room and the first thing he did was picked me up and looked at the soles of feet, he then jokingly said; "That's my boy, he is not flat-footed, he can go fight in Vietnam when he turns 19". The war as on the news of all newspapers in the world.
Saigon's retreat was well organised compared to the shitshow that is Kabul right now, LOL. The US managed to lose to two groups of warriors fighting in sandals.
NORTH vietnamese very welcome westerner my man.Is just not Americans
I mean in the past
North Vietnam was not hostile to any western countries, it only hostiled to foreign forces which stopped them from unify the nation - a wish that had been there since the start of French occupation. It portrayed in the war with China and Cambodia at the border of Vietnam 4 years after the war (1979). The fact that Swedish, Germans still had good contact with NV during the war. And now Vietnam considered the U.S to be its ally, because for 1000 years and until modern time, China has always been Vietnam biggest enemy.
@@molotovtheholy2292 Actually you got no idea how we have been struggling to normalize relation with the USA ever since the 1976
@反共 wtf
@反共 I don't speak alien sorry
After decades of civil and military involvement in South Vietnam, the fall of Saigon and South Vietnam was a national humiliation for the United States. Quite right, too. The U.S. war in Vietnam was thoroughly unjustified.
The Communist war against the Vietnamese people was totally unjustified. The United States went there to assist the Vietnamese people in fighting the Communists. When the Communists took over nearly 3 million Vietnamese fled the country, the largest Exodus in Southeast Asian history.
@@tedmccarron there might be an alternate reality where Vietnamese could've became like South Korea and West Germany but we live in this reality and I'm glad that the Vietnamese people got what they wanted which was unification, I don't like communists nor do I like capitalists both are bad if taken too far.
The United States intervene in Vietnam's internal matters which was liberation from the French and created South Vietnam, they should've never been there in the first place. All the Vietnamese families who suffered from Agent Orange, members with PTSD, being cut down my machine gun fire and all the Americans who were shunned for fighting in a war that they never wanted to be in. The Vietnam War was a tragedy before it even started.
Now that Vietnam is unified, the people are happy that they that they themselves didn't ended up like Korea and inequality was kept to a minimal by the state. They still have a long way to go, but this is still better than stuck fighting a war that never ends.
@@tedmccarron military industrial complex propaganda for breakfast?
@@dannyzero692 the Vietnamese people didn't "get what they wanted," they got totalitarian communism and lost all their rights by an evil army and government that FORCED it on them. North Vietnam invaded three countries that just wanted to be left alone. Unification is nice but freedom is much more important than unification. To be unified under slavery, mass murder and Terror is not a good thing at all and only an idiot would be in favor of it. Korea is at least half free and the other half is a totalitarian nightmare. I'm sure you would want to see them Unified under North Korean rule so that millions of innocent Koreans could die. That's not a happy outcome, that's a nightmare.
@@tedmccarron bruh, there would be a election for reunification of Vietnam after Geneve but the CIA had to stick their nose in so nope, US didn’t help, they created more killing. People who fled where associated with the Saigon government or US personal.
The Fall of Saigon is only a western name. Vietnamese called it the reunification of their country.
That is the true
the same thing with kabul !
I prefer the LIBERATION of Saigon, and now the liberation of Kabul.
@@E001-f8g What's the similarity? Despite assholes who fleed to US, you see how happy people werr when the north troops entered the city?
you mean Communists, not Vietnamese
Thank you for airing. Vital historical document.
I have MASSIVE RESPECT for the all of Vietnamese people, they literally just just wanted to be able to have their country reunited in peace and to have the freedom to be able to decide for themselves what route to take to reaching creating a successful destiny and future for their homeland. And isn't that just the desire of every peoples of every country in the world. Communist/Socialist or not, THAT IS THE WILL OF EVERY COUNTRY AND OF EVERY ONE OF THEIR CITIZENS IN THE WORLD, period! And so it should be! The Red terror.... please. I mean, look at the example the Vietnamese people set for the rest of the Communists/ Socialists of the world. They are probably actually the only TRULY SUCCESSFUL Communists countries in the world, they actually did it right and created a Utopian Society.... The people are proud of their country, those who reside in the cities have jobs, food, homes and are provided with all of the things that they need to live and to support their families and those in the countryside also live decently on the land, usually laboring in traditional Vietnamese farming or fishing jobs and sonce that's how their country is, I do believe they don't mind rural living and actually prefer it to the life in the big cities. I gotta give them props, good job VIETNAM!!!!!!!
❤
cuba too! although u.s. embargo keeps them poor 🇻🇳🇨🇺
Cảm ơn bạn ❤ đến từ Việt Nam
I am Vietnamese, and I read all comments from all over the world friends, and @devonoylear2415 is talking about us in the right way (at least to myself).
My father was in the army and fought in the border war of the Souther (of VN), his elder brother died in a hard 1968 battle against U.S army. My grandfathers had troubles in the 1955s with the new North government's farm revolution, but after all, they didn't mind and kept supporting Uncle Ho's government and sent all their sons to join the army.
My brother and I were born after the war, we were raised in our families's arms with love and I did not hear their hatred, my parents worked hard to feed us, and we kept forward to get a more convenient life.
My younger brother and in-law-brother joined the Communist party, but I am not but is not different from us under the leadership of one government.
These Vietnamese War Refugees were held in the Philippines since 1975 to 1992 in Palawan and Bataan. As the current, many Vietnamese Refugees was now at Viet Ville Restaurant in Puerto Princesa City was start of our business after the Vietnam War and held us for the saving difference.
you look like a spy vietcong dawg
@@nguyenn99527 You sound like a moron " dawg"
I from Vietnam Communist and I think that good. Thanks Philippines for helping those in need and help them get a better life.
@@nguyenn99527 haleluya brother
It is 30/4/2022 today and I am here - to review these scenes. I would like to say I strongly love and am grateful for people fighting for peace and harmony - Vietnamese heroes. Thank you - Communist Armies.Thank you for your patience; moreover, thank you for your noble sacrifice.Oh my love, oh my pride 🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
@@nguoisaigon526 Who cares dark side??? All the South Vietnamese use strong weapon and also have USA for the economy, and Saigon people cheers for communist
Only a piece of shit communist with no respect for human rights would applaud the Communist takeover of South vietnam. When the Communists took over they not only killed in the prison many innocent people but they took away the rights of all vietnamese. When they took over the Vietnamese people lost their freedom of speech, freedom of religion, Democratic political process, freedom of assembly and freedom of the press. All their rights were taken away and they delved into a Soviet style nightmare state. It was like the east side of the Berlin wall. Nearly 3 million of them fled the country which made it the largest accidents in Southeast Asian history. Only a total control free would be happy about something like that.
❤❤
Vietnamese love peace! But history is too fierce for our country. We fight because we must to fight! For independence! For our people!
Long live Vietnam!
Long live HoChiMinh!
Đại tướng Võ Nguyên Giáp Muôn Năm!
@@ManhIMT6789 được rồi Tất. Cả muôn năm
Almost everything you said is wrong. The Vietnam nation is a shit hole. Vietnam is an expansionist and oppressive warlike people who do nothing but pick fights and invade Nations around them and pick fights that day themselves cannot win and a beg for foreign political help. How did the invasion of Cambodia work out? How did that border conflict with China work out for you guys? LOL. Ho chi Minh was a tyrant who did nothing meaningful in his life and was nothing but a loser. And also you're so called Independence meant years of being nothing but being a Soviet puppet.
Biden: *This isn't Saigon. C'mooon maaan!*
Kabul: **is also Saigon, only worse**
@Livin Vids Happened before the US even fully withdrew. At least the South Vietnamese held on (kinda) on their own for a couple years. Not to mention the hubris from the US leadership saying how the ANA had 300,000 troops and there was hardly a chance they would fall to the Taliban.
@@jake8855 not kinda. South Vietnam fought longer and harder than Afghanistan ever did.
@Livin Vids i’ll tell you why. The US was desperately trying to get the fuck out of Vietnam and their people support it. They got out with a bunch of orphans with them and the war was over. The end.
But Afghanistan situation is different. Now that they haven’t got out yet and their troops were still dying from terrorist attacks, Afghanistan will surely become a sanctuary for ISIS and Al Qaeda ver 2.0. There’ll be 10/11, 11/11, 12/11... attacks on the US soil by these groups of terrorists. The war in Afghanistan is now widely open with more potential civil war and uprising.
@Livin Vids Well, the Vietnamese communists didn't discriminate against women like the TLB
@@tandung05_nguyen51 - They persecuted all southerners equally.
HCM never wanted war. He wanted peace for his country only. When no one listens and you’ve been betrayed then you take action. Some say worthless war and I’m sure HCM would agree because he tried to avoid it from the beginning. It was just a proxy war and the Vietnamese and surrounding countries suffered because of it.
bạn là người có đánh giá rất chuẩn xác, chính xác nhất trong các commend. bạn là người hiểu mục đích của người Mỹ. xin cảm ơn.
well done ! Redbull 🐄
this is as close to a truth as you get when war happens.
You are SO WRONG--HCM was a dedicated bloodthirsty Communist, educated in Marxism in Paris in the post WWI period, and later in Communist imperialism in the USSR. He cared nothing for the loss of life if it served his Russian Communist masters and led to the reunification if North and South Vietnam at the point of a gun.
@@attorneyreel1181 you’re from /pol/?
16:59 Saigon had luck that the regular forces ot the north lead the war in this phase. Some wanted to settle their own old scores. In Phnom Penh the kids soldiers of the Khmer Rouge behaved like psychopathic killers.
Well, the Khmer Rouge is full of psychopathic killers.
This NVA are the ones who destroyed the psychopathic khmer rouges and polpot
Well we Vietnam kind of help the new Cambodia and eliminate those psychopathic after 1975 war. Although many of my people gone starve between the war with Cambodia while America superiority of "Embargo". We still managed to survive, wipe out Khmer Rouge for doing war crime on it own people and my people, and see the error of our socialism way and change for the better for our people. Now here we are, freedom with economy grow even in the middle of the pandemic.
@@victorbukowsky7496 It's still Socialist, mixed-market Socialist it's simply not a command economy anymore. Lol
while China, Thailand, USA and UN are who behind supported those psychopathics killers
Angelo Castro, Jr. as 30 years old the fall of Saigon in Vietnam
25 years later he was 55 years old Angelo Castro, Jr. anchor of The World Tonight
I was 17 years old when I got to Vietnam-1966 through 1969 (My mom had to sign a waiver for me), I grew up fast and learned a lot, good and bad. (I am now 73 and still learning). I was stationed on the USS Providence and also stationed in Country at a place called "Monkey Mountain" close to DaNang,. I spent 3 tours of duty in and around Vietnam. 3 of my high school friends were killed in Vietnam, I was spared. I participated in the TET Offensive in Feb 1968, that was bad. Somewhere along the way I was exposed to Agent Orange (Nasty Stuff) I am now on disability for the effects of agent orange. When I was discharged and came home to the States we arrived in San Francisco, and there were a lot of protesters spitting on us and throwing rocks and eggs and called us baby killers. That was our welcome home. I tell you this to say to you, that whatever your position is or was on the Vietnam war, it was not the veteran who got us into the war, most of us went because we were patriots and loved our country. Blame the politicians, yes, but not the veteran. To all Vietnam Vets out there, you are not forgotten. As a previous combat Vet myself, I salute you my friend.
you are disgusting.
I guess now to avoid those attrocities being victims of war, people must consider what does this mean being patriots ? , if it can be easily manipulated by lies from our own politicians to get us into war after war, endless wars policy. If i may say, after Vietnam war, US copied the "Vietnam all over again" to Iraq, Afga, Yugoslovia, Serbia,...and many indirect wars, now the rhetoric of Ukraine war. Talking about US intervention to foreign countries, i remember history of US came to Philippines, senator of the US wrote at the time " it was true that the rulers of philippines oppressed and killed its people, but once we came in to liberate those poor people, the number of philippinos we killed in 2 months even more than what they have been killing during 13 years". At the end, i think being patriots meant to love, be loyal to your own country, to your people AND also to love and treat other people in other countries the same way as your people not your enemy, Once we take arms come all a long way to other countries to kill others, we have to ask ourselves what the outcome of killing others and who benefit it ?
No one told you to go fight... You should be mad at the government you have all the pride in the world only to be shitted on from the government
As a Vietnamese, I understand that very well, we don't blame the American soldier who was young and did not know much at that time. I born in Hanoi, my granddad is a Veteran too, he's fought the France, manage to save a whole squadron, and I think he was bad ass enough because later he got caught the France sent him on an island prison Côn Đảo (very far away). Luckily he survived and still live well, he is 94 years old right now😂
I was on a ship headed for cold weather training at Mt. Fuji when the gulf of Ton kin incident happened our ships took a left turn and we spent nearly 3 months floating off shore... Later on land for 13 months.
What younger people don't think about is that we were born (1946) in the shadow of the WWII veterans, all the big parades on many holidays and just the way the country felt about veterans in the 50s.
I remember thinking (also at 17) that if there was a war maybe we could become something to be proud of as well.
Another decade, another Saigoon in the shape of Kabul!!
@Zea Maze for who?
Afghans had 20 years to clear the country of Taliban. All people in power there are corrupt. They will flee and take their money with them. No matter who wins the average Afghani is worse for it. What's even worse is that for 20 years Pentagon has been milking $$$ out of the American taxpayer and got away with it. There are counteless scrap yards of perfectly serviceable equipment that was scrapped so that people's pockets could be greased. This is all public knowledge but no one has balls to do anything about it.
Vietnam Afghanistan Iraq Syria etc etc until Washington learns to mind its own business
Taliban has occupied Kandahar the second largest city, and they on the road to Kabul
@@teukurajahitam8225 its over.
The repeat in Kabul is almost comical.
First as tragedy, then as farce.
well written script by cia but at the end climax changed by isi
@@cat_city2009 This isn't a tragedy, it's a liberation. And ironic that you would quote Marx to call it a tragedy
My uncle had been in the army marching for half a year to go to the South for liberation, now he is an average 2/4 wounded and still has 4 shrapnel in his lungs, he has 4 children, the latter 2 are infected with Agent Orange. Uncle lost a close friend from the same neighborhood when he joined the army that year, that close friend has not been found until now.
got wrecked
Agent Orange. Is that a Orange Grove plantation in Florida?
Good
@@David-vt3hn no, it's chemical warfare that the US used on Vietnamese fighters. It causes genetic defects even in latter generation.
@@David-vt3hn no
The last American helicopter landed at 8:06 AM atop the American Embassy. There were 11 American Marines that got aboard. Juan Valdez was the last to get on the helicopter. Unlike other reports Ambassador Graham Martin was not the last American to leave Saigon.
Because they wouldn't dare give any credit to the Hispanic marine... Especially in those times smh
@sandcastle1417 Exactly and that is a total shame.
Yeah and they actually had forgotten those last marines for a time.
Angloids overshadowing Hispanics as always...
Please learn from history, Afghanistan is facing a similar situation. Pray for Afghanistan 🇦🇫 and it’s future without an oppressive Taliban regime.
The most important thing is that Afghanistan has no more communism, it doesn't matter that now is controlled by some blood-thirsty Islamic regime.
@@UtenZork um yes it does. Trading one evil for another doesn’t make it better at all.
Are prayers plan B when the 20 year war didn't work?
not an evil, and have yet to show themselves being oppressive. They've done nothing of such till now. Don't look at how they were 25 years ago
They are not the same. PAVN and NLF are heroes and protectors.
7:51 Yep, it's such a long time that he has the ability to hug and love his daughter. They haven't met each other for years .War keeps them apart🥺
Đó ko phải con anh ấy đó là cô bé con của đối phương bị bỏ dơi
As a Vietnamese, I am truly moved by the saying "Nothing is more precious than independence and freedom"
Our country regained its independence from the hands of Americans and their henchmen. We are the whole country, not just "North Vietnam", but include forces in the South.
The truth is that without the war on the Southwest border, the Northern border and the US embargo (until 1995), our country would have been much more developed.
We have continued the tradition of driving out the foreigners.
We saved the Cambodian people from genocide from Ponpot. But the world still owes Vietnam an apology and an acknowledgment of the historical values we bring to world peace.
Because we have gained independence since 1945, repelled the French colonialists in 1954. Because of that, colonial countries around the world have carried out revolutions to gain independence.
Be careful, events in the Taliban and Vietnam may be similar in some ways. But the nature and origin of the two forces are completely different.
This is the internet age, be careful when comparing and judging.
Do I give a damn?
@@terrenceescarda8951 u should
Commie fantasies, lol.
Congratulations for your independence.
May more revolutions liberate the world from emperialism and capitalism.
"What is independence if the slaves of today will be the tyrants of tomorrow?" - Jose Rizal
The painful past is over, national healing is the present. The Vietnamese people are always resilient!
Just seeing all those poor innocent kids makes me so sad considering what they’ve been through 🤦🏻♀️
Sadly this very difficult lesson had to be repeated a second time 🇦🇫
We never learn. We should have never been in Vietnam nor Afghanistan
North Vietnam was not a reactionary religious extremests like Talies. How US during Soviet-Afghan war mainly aided Hekmatyar, who eventually ended up cheering for Al Qaeda and Taliban who were arch nemesis to his own Mujahedeens, instead of more nuanced and revolutionary Ahmad Shah Masoud, shows you how dumb and clueless US foreign intervention tactic is. The louder one to shout "commies are bad" gets US dollars.
My grandfather lived 18 miles from Sai Gon at that time, he was scared that the Communist will treat the Sai Gon people, its officers and politicians like what the revolution in China did. It was a relived that they only took his family money away.
Very lucky
The United States built two undercarriages of helicopters, in addition to the purpose of taking off and landing, also for another purpose, to let the team of henchmen selling water hang around to run away. Shame on those who sell the country.
Well, he was right about the officers and politicians. They got sent to re-education camps.
"Only took his money away" that he had spent his life earning to support his family....
@@attorneyreel1181 when I say money I mean anything valuable. He lost jewelry, gold bars, etc... the south's money were useless.
The funny thing is some North Vietnamese soldiers bring lots of food with them. The propoganda ran deep and they though the South was poor, and people living like they were in the French colonial rules. They were quite surprised when they found out about Pizza, can foods.
Our unification work was made by the party and President Ho Chi Minh, so I'm totally proud to be Vietnamese. ❤🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳❤
Уважение вьетнамцам
@@ВячеславРахматов❤❤
1:43 You can see an ARVN (south Vietnamese) officer board the ship, and at 1:50 you can spot an ARVN officer at the top of the ship staircase, you can also see an ARVN infantry soldier at the top of the entrance to the ship, which indicates that ARVN troops were still in the city still trying to escape.
Họ không cần trốn họ chỉ cần cởi bộ quân phục ra không ai làm gì họ chúng tôi là anh em
To be precise, NVA and NLF (aka Vietcong) were far different from Taliban. They behaved like regular human beings, and all they have wanted were unification. Taliban, on the contrary, well...
Lmao, as if the NVA and NLF didn't commit their share of atrocities. Both treated their POWs brutally, conducted terror attacks, and sent hundreds of thousands of re-education camps where many were tortured and killed. You can say literally the same about the Taliban, all they wanted was reunification of their country since the invasion of the Soviets and its collapse into Civil War thereafter.
@@taoliu3949 and your proof is? Lol people such as yourself wont ever understand that life in the re education camp had been much better than daily lives that day
@@taoliu3949 Your name sounds Chinese and indeed, China's re-education camps were fucked
@@dat_toonieProof? Hundreds of thousands of civilians were killed by the NVA and VC during the war through deliberate terror attacks. Hundreds of thousands of people sent to re-education camps have provided testimonies. Oh yes, "better than daily lives" equates to being imprisoned, beatened, tortured, etc. The Vietnamese government even tried to justify their actions by labeling these people as "prisoners".
That said, where is YOUR proof that the Taliban did everything you claimed they have done?
@@spookyperson7096 Lol, Mao was infamous for his ability to incite fighting between the classes, his entire period of rule could basically be characterized as him destroying his political rivals through successful persecutions of various people. First you had the "land reforms" which where the peasantry was goaded to attack and kill the landowners. Then you had persecutions of the KMT post 1949 which resulted in 700k+ people executions. There were also several anti campaigns that were aimed at businessmen, intellectuals, and members of the CCP who was claimed to be corrupt resulting in millions of deaths. The Cultural revolution was also an incitation of the students to attack their superiors, but also effectively annihilating many of his own political rivals within the party.
Long Live Ho Chi Minh
It's amazing how the city has changed but you still know where everything is
Đây mới là phim tài liệu về chiến tranh ở Việt Nam chân thật nhất, đúng đắn nhất, thế hiện đúng bản chất vấn đề về chiến tranh Việt Nam. Cảm ơn kênh youtube của bạn đã phản ánh đúng sự thật ❤🇻🇳 đến từ Việt Nam.
Always like the ap Archive footage
America:
*“Ah shit here we go again”*
Gotta make money on a sequel
@mistermodified1 us was so brutal it managed after 20 years of war managed to unite the whole country behind the Taliban, even groups they'd previously oppressed, because the us was worse
This war was a whole waste of life.
True, it all start when America fear the nonsense Domino effect.
Yep niggga
Yep niggga
@@Nhatanh0475If Americans didn't do the same in South Korea, they would have fallen under communism, they wanted to do the same in Vietnam
It's extremely funny when people still screaming capitalism good communism bad or vice-versa although we Vietnamese just trying to get over the pandemic. And for some reason Vietnam do not having a PS5 shortage, I seeing millions of advertising post on social media all day.
BLAME THE POLITICIANS, NOT THE SOLDIERS!
That’s right.
Both Capitalist and communist soldiers are brave.
@@Oline1756 Exactally, and many gave the ultimate sacrifice
Joe_Chill That’s right.
The politicians are the problem
Except the nazi officers who like to torture people
@@upstreamtoast3512 True
Saigon: *Falls
Kabul: WRITE THAT DOWN!
And hold my beer
Every country deserve an INDEPENDENCE
from USA xD American Democracy... lol
@@leisureclub_ Also from Red Star communism LOL
what does this have to do with the video?
We will need to liberate glorious revolutionary humanist socialist people's California from The Party.
How about the South Vietnamese?
13:39 "Nothing is more valuable than independence and freedom"
Do we Vietnamese have independence and freedom? Yes
But I am afraid for those in Afghanistan now living in the terrorist regime not having the same things we have.
I'll rather prefer a communist government than an extremist Islamic group
You have independence, but do you have freedom?
@@capncake8837 freedom is. better than none at all, for example ISIL
@@capncake8837 Vietnamese and American ideals are not the same.
@@capncake8837 well, freedom depends on the people's view. Western standard can't be applied on all countries :v
This will be Kabul but with less hardware and provisional government
7:03
That's why NVA won.
If nvm won, why not keep the communist system? You lost! Communist lost.
@@thhdhn2 Where have I supported communism here?
I prefer NVA than the bloody imperialists of France and USA.
:))) communist of Vietnam still here , where's American in Afghan ???????
@@thhdhn2 Why there always an Internet jerk like you?
Communist still exist and rise and we are the example of it.
@@milokhanh313 oof this is a good one
this comment section is amazing.
earning your independence thru the battlefirld is better than someone giving it to you
What a horribly romanticized view of violence.
an independence giving by someone is not an independence
well said
We backed the wrong horse in Nam. Too many Americans died for Dow Chemical, et al.
Initially, we were there because we needed Frances' help in Berlin. FDR advocated for independence for the French colonies. After he died, Truman needed France's help in Berlin to counter the Soviets, so when France sought to assert their dominance over their former colonies, Truman looked the other way. When Vietnam fought France for its independence, the U.S. was paying up to 70% of France's war cost.
After France's defeat, the UN divided Vietnam at the 17th Parallel, with the Communists getting the Northern half and the U.S.-backed Ngo Dinh Diem regime getting the southern half. There was a UN requirement to hold elections in two years. But the Catholic and anti-communist Diem stated that the South hadn't signed the Geneva Accords, so they weren't bound by them. Diem also felt it was impossible to hold free elections in the North, so the national election was never held. The U.S. also felt that Diem could not defeat Ho Chi Minh in a federal election, so they also supported the election cancellation. Diem was a corrupt Catholic autocrat in a country full of Buddhists, and he was only interested in maintaining power for himself and his family. He was overthrown in a coup on Nov 1st, 1963.
So, I guess you could say we backed the wrong horse...
The interests of the american regimes leaders fit neatly with the interests of colonial france
@@rdouglas747 America REALLY should have back uncle Ho instead. The alternative history will be interesting, Viet is tough in military and economic and became an asia dragon, to this time it will be a good team to balance the China rising 😂
The French died for Michelin and the Bank of Indochine... they didn't even get a free set of tires.
Now here I am watching Americans exit Afghanistan all the while Taliban reclaiming all territory now at 85%. History always repeats itself.
Iraq war veteran.
So your point being?
And by the way, you destroyed Iraq, you shouldn’t be so proud of being a butcher into that mess.
@@abdullahmsa7027 "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." - writer and philosopher *George Santayana*
Read and think about it.
Dis Happah Why is your country always itching for war?
@Duke Tango oh no you mad rug pilot? And bet you wouldn’t say that to his face
@@abdullahmsa7027 Iraq destroyed themselves 🤣🤣🤣🤣 people in Iraq are all rug pilots
The truth is the Vietnamese liberated themselves from the colonialists
False. The truth is that Vietnam is an oppressive and expansionist Communist dictatorship who by Force occupy their neighbors and oppress minority groups to this day.
But still wasn't liberated from communism 🤡
And we call them uncivilised. Not a recorded case of drunkeness, rape or pillage. Outstanding!
Còn những người văn minh thì killing baby,raped women,cut head of civilans
You fell for communist propaganda, kid.
They learned their lessons from Hue and didn’t want a South insurgency
@@7ElevenAlphaCentauri The Hue event created by disorder by south Vietnam republic.
What about political murders?
GOOD ENDING.FINALLY VIETNAM REUNITED.LONG LIVE VIETNAM
They should have reunited under the capitalist system
The Vietnamese fought the Japanese, then the French, and the Americans. They won all the wars against colonialists and invaders. Why Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon fought them - only they could answer, or at least try to.
You Mean the Russian, Chinese, and north Viet Nam
@@thhdhn2 lol :)) ya ain't know sh,t
They just support weapon for us
You missed the Chinese...they invaded after the Americans.
@@robertreynolds580 and before too, a lot.
Kennedy didn’t he was gonna pull out in 1964 and then got killed SF told him we won’t win then Johnson fubar everything , as Democrats Do
My granduncle left the North to the South as an adopted child of a relative sometime around 1954. He lost connection with his family then. After that, he joined the Army in the South, while my grandfather and his other brother fought for the North. I don’t think they met in the battlefield but the brothers literally fought each other in this war.
Like the Civil War, brother vs brother
@@maryroberts2099 the problem is the Vietnam War was never a civil war. More like Resistance against America.
@@angkhoanguyen6114 The South did not want Communist one party state.
@@Elephantsss that "South" was not Vietnamese people, there was Americans and pro-Americans. "Vietcong" or Viet Minh was from the South and been founded by the real South side just so you know.
Long live Vietnam 🇻🇳
And all that good pusszzy!
Who knew this was gonna pop up years later during Saigon 2.0. Thanks Saigon Joe.
Long Live Vietnam! Greeting from Malaysia!
Kau suka ke sokong ideologi Komunis hanat...?? 🤣😂😅
Fuck you communism short live
@@Rich-sm3ho u noob
@@Rich-sm3ho fuck you imperialist, stfu
@@Rich-sm3ho A childish act of ignorance and internet jerk.
Good to know that the RUclips algorithm is keeping abreast of the global geopolitics :)
My father was in South Vietnam in 1968 and part of 1969. He made friends with a Vietnamese woman who assisted the signal corps. Her husband had been killed by the Communists. When he left she gave him an antique Vietnamese fishing boat. I remember playing with it as a kid. It was sad because I think I wore it down playing with it as a kid.
Well my grandfather's all brother got killed by American troops,..
Well Americans troop masscare Vietnamese people in My Lai Masscare
@@partyvietnamcommunist4829 Yeah, Communist massacred Vietnamese people in Hue
@@partyvietnamcommunist4829 people would probably believe you if not for the overt user name and avatar
@@testla3383 I live in Vietnam and I use this name, what is the problem??? Not like some dude ran to USA in 1975
For people here that want to compare Vietnam to Afghan they are no where the same. Only thing that was similar was there would be less casualty if American didn't get involve in the civil war. For the Afghan people I hope you have a peaceful transfer and not a long and protracted civil war.
I believe what people are comparing is the way the U.S. departed in the two wars.
Sao giống nhau chiến tranh vn thuộc chiến tranh thế giới của các cường quốc và những nước nhỏ chống lại sự bành tướng và ách thống trị và cuộc chiến giữa hai nền dân chủ và cộng sản mà mĩ sợ cộng sản bá quyền thế giới nên ví giống Nhau là điều ko thể
@@rdouglas747 and only focusing on the fact that US was supposedly "beaten". Taliban are just right wing religious extremists. US intervention should have been limited to Afghan and Afghan only without dipping their feet into Iraq, and even then, prolonged US occupation would have given more excuse for Taliban to terrorize its own population which is precisely what happened.
It’s not peaceful for women but I guess less lives were lost
I had no idea the fall of Saigon itself was this bloodless. The only casualties of that event seemed to be self-inflicted. Years from now, will the fall of Kabul be looked upon similarly?
We know why we are here
At this day I boarded a Royal Air Lao Flight (DC 4) from Vientiane to Saigon. Over Pakse, about halfway, the Airplane returned to Vientiane and we ve been told that the Airport of Saigon is closed.
My dad was in a USA boot camp at this moment. They didn't hear about it until after their graduation ceremony several weeks later.
@Mr. Sanke Y’know, the South almost survived, but we cut funding to its military, then they lost.
@@capncake8837 why would they do something stupid
@@capncake8837 The South was never going to survive, American help or not.
@@capncake8837 the South lost because they were shitty at fighting, when the NVA found the US supplies for the South inside Long Binh Post in 1975, there were still more than enough weapons and equipments for us to fight 2 more wars with the Khmer Rogue in 1979 & Chinese (1979-1989), even some of them lasted till these days
At the surface, the talibam seems to have learned from the NVA by being nice to the civilians in Kabul.....for now.