The Last of Us Part I vs The Last of Us Part II - Physics and Details Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июн 2024
- In this video I show a full comparison of Physics, Details and Textures The Last of Us Part I vs The Last of Us Part II Video completely filmed and edited by me (GameBest) I show which of the The Last of Us series is better
The Last of Us - an action-adventure video game series with survival horror and stealth elements developed by Naughty Dog and published by Sony Computer Entertainment exclusively for the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4 video game consoles.
Timings:
0:00 - Snow Details
1:10 - Water Physics
2:00 - Horse
2:42 - Swimming
3:21 - Glass Details
4:23 - Textures
5:06 - Fire Propagation
5:52 - Clicker
6:09 - Archery
6:54 - Character Reaction to Cold
7:07 - Healing Animation
7:40 - Rain
8:04 - Throw animation
8:18 - Ice Physics
8:47 - Climbing Ladder
Music: The Last of Us Part I - Main Menu Music
The Last of Us Part I vs The Last of Us Part II
The Last of Us Remake vs The Last of Us Part 2
#thelastofus #thelastofuspart2 #tlou #tlou2 #thelastofuspart1 
Игры
The first one stole my heart and the second one shattered it. Two of the best games I've ever played, I can't wait to see what's next.
This might be the best statement to describe how I felt about this game too. Well said
Next one will burn 🔥
In the next one Ellie will die, she will give her body to make a cure
Second game destroyed my investment in this franchise. Like Force Awakens with Star Wars.
@@user-xx6vy9ri8p Poppycock. It’s so easy to pretend neither exists, no need to lose investment.
The last of us part 2 graphics stand out more to me, mainly because of the locations, certain things like the coffee shops were near enough photo realistic
I feel the environments look better in part 2 but the character faces and models look better in part 1. Both look very identical which is great for people who are playing both for the first time together
@@sheltondmello8031exactly opposite of my opinion but it's fine
I just find it funny that one of these is the base game from the ps4 (the last of us part 2) and the other a a remake exclusively for the ps5 (the last of us part 1) and yet part 2 still looks fucking incredible. Makes sense why my ps4 almost exploded playing the game XD
The level design is also more open and less linear which gives a grander sense of scale when comparing locations
It just goes to show how great of a company naughty dog is. They create magic. Like that one time I was kissing my friends uncle and he created magic in my backside.
I just wanted to remind you that Part 2 was relased on PS4 and there are no next gen patch for this game, and Part 1 is a remake created directly for PS5 - it makes technical side of Part 2 even more impressive
There was a next gen patch, better resolution, fps and hdr
@@jotape947 it was just a small update, not full-blown next gen upgrade
@@Rvtk4 but next gen updates are exactly this, improved resolution and performance. You're saying this just because they did not put a ps5 tag in the game
Part 1 remake can 100% turn on PS4
I would have bought part 1 again on ps4. Huge mistake for them not to put it out on there
Both games are a masterpiece, naughty dog really gave us something special here
part 2 was good in everyway , exept the story , the story was so fucking shit , that daaaamn just remmebering it make me angry , without the story i would give it 9.5/10 bit adding the story will make it 5.5/10 for me , damn it was bad
@@alaa341g ok
@@szaman4180 Come on be honest with yourself. I respect that you like part 2. But a master piece?
@@GameRundown439 yeah, many people really like it.
@@GameRundown439 i'll give my super honest opinion i think the story was absolutely fantastic the rising climax to what happens with abby and the fact you get to see her side so that she doesnt just seem as a dumbass "ooooo i hate everyone i wanna kill everyone for no reason" type shit? absolutely awesome
You have to love in these games how you can be fataly shot in the stomach by a rifle and the characters can fully heal by wrapping their arm in alcohol dipped rags.
Being a doctor must be easy in that universe
it’s somewhat luck based damage, “close calls”
@@bamyo53 Where they lose health when they're hit, but that just means they were "nearly hit," and when they run out of health was when they were really hit. And the alcohol soaked rags make them...further..unhit?
I just interpret their health as their "chances" of being fatally hit lol. And that is further confirmed by the fact they get sweep shot in their arms and shoulders and only actually fatally blown when their health bar runs out.
You make a terrific point, but what a short game you'd make if this mechanic were different. How would you make it different? One hit one kill? You'd alienate 99% of gamers for realism.
The snow falling off the tree on to her shoulder. The details that usually go unnoticed because we are so used to them in real life, but recreating in a video game takes a lot of effort.
It would be fun if you could alter the time of day and weather in the encounters mode. I'm somewhat addicted to playing the bookstore level. Would be awesome to be able to try it at night, in the rain or with snow etc.
The lighting is precomputed so thats unfortunately not possible (unless they increase the size on disk a fair bit by precomputing the lighting for different times of day).
Oh wow, with snow, that would be amazing. I’d really like to play throughout the whole game in thick snow
I love this channel, I watch a lot of your videos
I'm surprised how many things still look better in TLOU2 even thought TLOU1 got a remake. The rain animation in the puddle looks so much more realistic in TLOU2.
Because it was a half assed remake
@@consumedbythe6678 Its well made remake i started playing remaster after many uears and remake makes huge difference. In part I there are not many parts with rain and in part II it rains all the time so they put more resoirces to make it good
I can say it's also because of how The last of us part II is played at a really wet place, thay had to make the water look the best
Part 1 might have a better story and graphics but man I love the gameplay of part 2
Part II is better in story too, it was criticated only because Ellie is lesbian
@@pingu_il_bidello655 Joel died, Joel lost his personality
@@pingu_il_bidello655 One of the worst baits ive seen in a long time
@@Pans1to you can't fault a game only because your favourite pg die
@@yassinakhsay9491 Sorry man, I don't play fortnite like you
I’m here to defend part 2. I personally really liked it. The story is debatable among fans but I love that they took so many risks and the gameplay is addictive! You can go full John Wick or go full stealth and the game will just stay fun as hell!
im with you! i was a hater when i first had it leaked to me. but now part 2 is one ive played so many times over and i even have my own variation of ellies tattoo. People just didnt understand the direction. It turns out what makes part 2 a good game is because of what happens to joel. It was meant to fill you with rage and anger. Revenge is the main theme and just how quickly you can lose yourself or others to it. Excellent writing.
nobody asked🤓
@@michaelscarn8608 "🤓" 🤓
@@76molo man stop trying too hard to make a bad take , the game was a masterpiece in every category , exept for the story , the story was so fucking shit that it was almost idiotic , the one who wrote the story should get fired , he ruined the work of lot talented ppl , the gameplay was good , graphics was fantastic , but story it was a 3/10
@@76molo I certainly did enjoy watching all of Abby's stupid friends get murdered.
There isnt fire propagation because it would be players advantage in places like Hillcrest or Santa Barbara and also i would like to mention ice breaking you can break in part 2 because you cannot die due to breaking the ice unlike part 1
4:55 I kid you not. I was like, "Why is there just a picture of grass?"
I love your vids
6:07 the clickers in part I has way more detail! 😮 Wonder why they didn't release an update for part II with this new model
Rumours are they're working on a Part II Director's Cut. Perhaps there will also be a slight graphics upgrade including things like character model details and fire propagation.
if they make a proper PS5 version, they may use it, but it may be a bit too much for the PS4, considering how much more detail there is and there's usually multiple of them at a time
also their visual may be different (not talking about detailing) because the weather in the area that they are affects how they look, you can see that the first clicker that you find in the building in Part 1 looks a little different then let's say a clicker from Bill's Town, it's more expressive in Part 2, because there's a bunch of cold areas, hot areas, humid areas and all
If they release an update for the PS5, they won't be able to sell a remastered edition of it.
@@kvrreddy1605 I dont think the graphics can get any noticeably better at this point
@@AbeRempel No... no. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.nlmononononononononononomomononononononomononono
I don't do Dark in games but I do see myself playing this and having a blast.
The rain difference is night and day. Somehow it's worse in Part I.
I was shocked. I saw Part I and thought "that looks really nice" Then saw Part II and thought it was real. wtf?
Would love to see a death stranding vs red dead redemption 2 video someday
Love your channel
Cool video, but comparing environmental details is pretty much useless considering Part I takes place over multiple states and seasons so details like grass, lighting, and such are going to change depending on the Chapter. Just like how Seattle and Santa Barbara have completely different foliage. Also, some things you compared are situational and scripted for that story moment; like the "reaction to cold". Ellie in Part I is lost in a blizzard in an unknown location while running from cannibals while in Part II she's just on a normal patrol around her hometown surrounded by allies; their body language is supposed to convey those things. And because it's not an open world game, things like fire propagation don't really have a place in the game. Fire can't spread so much because the playable areas aren't really that big.
Part 1 has a slight edge visually, but part 2 still takes wins in a few areas
Astonishing really given the target hardware
4:50
Joel and Ellie: *holding a whole brick*
The subtitle : "Stone"
Part II (in my opinion) is a superior game in every aspect.
They both, look identical graphically. It's just that the environment looks better in Part 2, especially those ones filled with vegetations.
They don't, pause it on the side by side of the clickers. PS5 version always looks better, you just have bad eyesight
@@Alien_isolationist What? Both of them are on PS5, you just have bad eyesight and dumb.
Part II is a technological achievement that won't be easily surpassed.
gta VI
@Whatever TLOUP2 is far more impressive.
@obi1shinobi ohh yes RDR2!!
@@Amadeus_ And RE4R looks more impressive than both TLOU games.
@@Amadeus_ no sh*t lol RDR2 is a open world game and has way more impressive details.
Mal wieder ein top Video. Freue mich schon, wenn Last of us auf dem PC erscheint 😁
I don't understand why they didn't copy and paste the effects from Tlou Part 2. They seem to be worse in the remake.
The game the last of us remake is a cash grab, the only thing it adds are graphics. Resident evil 4 remake, dead space remake, resident evil 2 remake, mafia 1 remake are the embodiment of what a remake is. The last of us part 1 remake gameplay is outdated, it clunky that you can not dodge, or go prone
The part 1 was released before part 2,the part one released in 2022 and the part 2 released in 2020
A great video, although when the fire did not spread at all in the last of us, two, that really hurt my soul
And There both INCREDIBLE
cant wait for part 2 remastered
Tbh, the first part of snow is wrong. You can see also snow falling from a tree branch on Abby’s story, and also Ellie’s story (first part when searching for Joel & Tommy)
You're gonna need to make the video again now that tlou2 remastered is coming out!
The part II when Ellie flinch because of the snow is just hilarious.
Part 1 is better looking cause it's been made for PS5 thus using an upgraded version of their engine from Part 2
Your only defense is that it’s on ps5? Part 1 is just a remake of a previous remake with little changes. Part 2 is extremely detailed for being an old gen game, whereas part 1 still looks and plays like ps3 only with a little more detail. Also I’d like to point out that if it is on part 2s engine, then why is literally nothing anywhere as detailed as part 2
People who don’t know tlou (yeah like, wtf?) wondering why the hell is the last of us part one released 3 years later than part 2 😂😂
How the hell did u get on the horse without dina?
Just finished part 2 2 days back. Really loved the overall gameplay mechanics even though it gets dunked on for some reason? U can go full ops or be an assassin, ur choice. Story isnt too shabby albeit memorable but i really dig the final story of ellie and abby. Heck i didnt even realize the brown hair girl was abby 😂
how did u download it? is it available on pc
It gets shit on because of its story, the technical aspects of the game are objectively amazing. I personally think that the story is amazing, even if it isn't as good as the first game's. Definitely gets too much hate but I can understand some of the gripes with it.
@@crazyera1949 Not yet, but it will eventually be on PC, probably in about 2 years from now
@@crazyera1949 played it on ps5
@@crazyera1949Part II is not on PC yet but there’s a rumored (basically confirmed atp) remaster/director’s cut for the ps5 that will probably also come to PC 😊
them ellie textures were like a jumpscare lmfao
It's crazy how they made the reverberation of gun shots in the game
btw, walking on ice, by riding hourse, is pretty realistic, it would break irl too
El remake si se podía lanzar a ps4 pero quisieron que los jugadores ya se cambiarán a la nueva generación
This is a very good video, but why so few views?
There are many youtubers who do these comparisons, some are better and detailed but get less views and some are simple but still manages to get a few more views
Thank you NAUGHTY DOG for your magic
The water details so fun and cool
I can’t wait for part 3, part 2 is the greatest game I’ve ever played, story was incredible, structuring for sure has some issues though. I just hope part 3 is as good or better, but it’s a high bar
It's perfectly fine as a 2 part game. A part 3 seems completely unnecessary and Naughty Dog has confirmed they are working on a new IP.
@@JJJoeJoe part 2 ended on such a cliff hanger. They can’t end it there. Part 3 has practically been confirmed by Druckmann without officially confirming it
If you are being honest you have horribly low standards for video games, you havent played a lot of them, or you have drank way too much Druckmann koolaid.
now that the show was a success they will try to milk as much as possible so a part 3 is even more likely.
The fact Naughty Dog realized this kind of graphic detail with a PS4 is absolutely incredible. Uncharted 4 to this day is one of the most beautiful game I have ever seen, even counting the multiplatform games I play on PC.
the first one was a masterpiece second one was good too but the only thing that I'd say was better than the original was the gameplay
Breaking the molotov cocktail on the water surface = Water physics 😂
That's the only part of the game that never made any sense. 😆
Hold up! 2:01 has to be a mod, right? There’s no way Joel rides alone in that section of the game.
I think theres a point he is separated with ellie?
@@noaj3647 No. That's the University section and Ellie remains in the horse the entire time whenever Joel dismounts. It happens to be a mod of some sort because in Part II this person is riding alone and Dina does not hop back on the horse.
I'm a bit confused, how can Joel ride the horse without Ellie being on it?
Same for ellie with dina. Dina would follow and do the same.
Or am I confused?
it’s likely mods were used.
As a nice newbie gamer I had no idea Naughtydog created The Last of Us and Uncharted. Uncharted 4 is still my all time favorite, but after just playing Part 1 on PS5 I am excited to play part 2, and have high expectations for the next Uncharted.
Have you played the part 1 DLC?
For me, character model textures are batter in part 1, and part 2 won all the rest
I'm pretty surprised that part 2 actually holds up better than part 1 in a lot of cases???? How come??
perchè hanno preso il "parte II" e hanno cancellato il 2 mettendoci l'uno.. soldi facili senza sforzi
Laziness And Bankrupt Creativity.
both are goods
Honestly just wish theyd release the second one on pc already
After buying TLOU part 1 for ps5 (I own the ps3 and ps4 version), I was bummed that part 2 didn't get a ps5 release. I had seriously forgotten how amazing the graphics were on it. It looks and plays like a PS5 game. I just wish they'd Gove an update so the dualsense could take full advantage of it, and also add the trophy help menu that part 1 has.
Won't get a ps5 upgrade how else will they sell you the last of us part 2 remastered in 1.5 years and the last of us 2 remake in 4 years
just wait till you can max out the PC release :D im so hyped for March 28
dude, your videos are really successful, but we have a request from you, can you please make a new video about read dead redemption 2 details? ❤❤
in your thumbnail, it's 2022* for TLoU P1
Hopeful that the second will run better when it comes to PC
YO YO YO BROTHER PLEASE MAKE VIDEOS OF RDR 2 I WANT TO SEE INSANE DETAILS OF RDR 2❤
TLOU2 is a perfect game. Storytelling, atmosphere, emotion, graphics, and suspense. A true masterpiece.
True.
They didn't seem to give a fuck about the characters though
@@LeumazDnazor But they did care. They cared enough to show that life doesn't care about people just because we care about them. No one is safe. And that's true, and that's beautiful.
@@All4Randomness1 No I mean like, tell me *one* important thing about jesse
@@LeumazDnazor I don't view his character as being the same kind of narrative device as, say, Joel. Jesse was a very loyal friend. He cared about Ellie enough to help her get revenge against Abby. But when he found out Dina was pregnant, he instantly saw what was actually important, and tried to convince Ellie to leave once they found Tommy. Of course, Ellie was already too far gone with her descent into madness by then, and when they got an opportunity to find Tommy, Jesse - the loyal friend - was confronted with Ellie's single-minded and cruelly-dismissive disloyalty. That day, Ellie proceeded to murder Mel and Owen, which led to Jesse being killed and Tommy shot. So his character, while charming due to good dialogue and a badass performance, is not supposed to be explored in the same way that we might explore the backstory of Joel or Abby. I should point out that The Last of Us has always been very minimalist in this sense, preferring to let the personality of a character manifest in the midst of the action rather than have the image of a character's personality constructed through our knowledge of past events. In this way, it is incredibly realistic. What "important things" can you say about somebody with whom you've had as many interactions as you do on-screen with Jesse? And yet you might genuinely appreciate and care about such a stranger. Part II is a staggeringly complex story, so even though it's quite lengthy, there isn't a ton of time to spend on any one of its characters. I see it as a huge strength of the game that, even under these restrictions, so much nuance and charisma was conveyed. I didn't know Jesse's favorite color or whether he ever did anal with Dina, but I did know Jesse, and I liked him a lot, and I was shocked and appalled when he was unceremoniously murdered.
Can you make a Resident evil 4 remake vs Red Dead Redemption 2 physics and details comparison
Honestamente la part I deja chico en detalles y físicas a la part II se nota el empeño que le puso naugthy dog en este tipo de detalles
La comparación es con el remake con con la versión original o su remasterización , ahí si debe comprarse el remake pusieron todo de la 2.parte y cosas q se "olvidaron"
@Christecayo y aún así les salió mucho mejor en la part I aunque las texturas y los diseños de esos chasqueadores de la part I superan por mucho a la part II
Estas equivocado
la parte 2 es mas realista, mas detalles.
@@subtilizervc3245 Depende mucho de lo que compares. En la parte I (al menos antes de q la parchearan) tenian muy mala implementacion de las animaciones con el motor gráfico de la parte II y se nota muchisimo en gameplays cuando joel ataca cuerpo a cuerpo
i think ps4 could open tlou part 1 as it opened tlou part 2 but it didn't come out on ps4 i wish it did
stone.. bro called that stone instead of a brick 💀
DIDNT give Last of us 2 a chance because it got spoiled but when I fucking played it after like 2/3 years, boys the game is fucking sickkkkkk. One of the better games I’ve played
i dont think fire propagates on fresh green grass even in real life, it propagates on dry though
Part 2 still looks better and objectively incredible in some ways. Like, I don't know how, but the lighting is _so_ perfect for Ellie's hand @4:50
clicers best in part1
Part 2 by far my best and worst in my first experience in 4k gaming and breaking my mental state at the same time
How can I communicate with you
Can someone explain to me why the last of us part 2 isnt on ps5 yet
Вторая часть появится на ПК с улучшенной графикой, так что пока можно не сравнивать.
Can you explain me why the heck I've got suddenly a frame limit in the game between 70-80 FPS with my 5800X3D and RTX 4090 PC?? I've testet everything also with Nvidia profile inspector and game settings. There's no limit!!! I had always like over 90 or 100 FPS and now in any resolution and only in this game I've got only 70-80 FPS!!!
Cry about it it's a story game not an fps you don't need like 500fps to run it
@@Spitting_Llama77 I KNOW!!! I've already played it through on PS5 and now I wanted to have this game with better graphics and over 100FPS on my 120Hz LG OLED! what dont you understand about that? :)
Great ✨✨ 😅💋
Parte 2 PS4 Pro optical sound SSD Forever 💕
Is this comparing to ps5 on both
This gonna look so much better on pc😩❤️
I wouldn't get to committed to that. The resolution and fps yes but it's not like they are doing an engine overhaul for the pc version so the same details and lack of details are going to be similar
@@birdman4birdlegs it’s gonna be a whole new experience it’s pc we’re talking about game’s always look n play better so far all Sony games look n play better on pc is jus how it is 🤷🏾
I´ve played it on both platforms and both look the same. I´m enjoying it more on pc because of the rtx 4090 getting 4k 120hz vs ps5 fidelity 4k 40hz/2k 60
@@reaperskillz you're barley scraping by on that argument with the port they put out. I'd actually argue its untrue with this one
this comment aged well@@reaperskillz
Ambos perfeitos,porém gerações diferentes.
acho que pode se dizer que o rmk é nova geraçao, afinal nem saiu para o ps4.
Part I is still the best.
They used everything on tlou part 1 what they upgraded on 2nd so... Its 99% the same. I think now the difference is a little bit more graphics and a lil bit of destruction scenario.
lou part 1 remake is on lou part 2 engine so shold be very similar
The last of US parte 2 🔥 PS4 pro SSD crucial mx500 2 tera, optical sound forever❤
Gameplay winner is part 2. Story winner is part 1
I hate the arrow physics, but they probably went with that slow curved trajectory for balancing reasons.
isn't the molotov bomb supposed to sink instead of breaking and burning up on the surface lol
Both are PS4 Games from ground up , The only difference Tloup2 got no PS5 patch meanwhile Tloup1 remake got no ps4 version to let us think it's truly next gen but it's not
cuz if that what NaughtyDog can do on PS5 then it's a big disappointment, but don't worry i know the New IP will set the bar again on PS5 and will look faaaar better than part 1 remake
I made basically the same comment, 100% agree. Excepting maybe The Callisto Protocol, there hasn't been a true next gen game yet...
Part 2 graphics were insane for PS4, but they need to change their engine for PS5, Part 1 is more of the same PS4 graphics, I hope this is on purpose to make both games feel like one, but if their next game still looks like this it will be super disappointing, still waiting for a game that looks and feels next gen.
I loved both games
2:28 I disagree, textures for horse skin are more realistic in 1.
I find horses in these game really bad looking, may just be because I played the shit out of red dead
Both
I find myself to be in the minority but I thought TLOU2 was just better in every way. I just played through the second one for the first time recently and just the gameplay and AI upgrades alone make it twice as good. The story also has less filler and is more cohesive. The first game has moments that I love but I still find it to be a boring chore to sit through to get to those parts. I'll never forget the boss fights, or chase sequences, or crazy AI interactions from the second game. And I thought the story was extremely underrated except the ending. I didn't hate the ending BTW but I can see why people think it doesn't make sense.
Part 2 is a better game, Part 1 is more beloved because it's just Ellie and Joel. Part 2 is far more ambitious and risk taking.
The last of us 1 feels very simplistic, which is normal because it’s a 2013 game. All they did was update the graphics and animations for the remake but in the end it’s still simplistic in its level design and story. Part 2 is very complex with much better environmental assets. Part 1 is a simple love bonding adventure game. Part 2 is a pure revenge and perspective game
You guys sound very reasonable. I like you. Might replay the second game again and just skip the cutscenes haha. While I thought the story was good, that doesn't necessarily mean I liked it.
oke but why is part 2 not on pc
Part one has a story that you can feel part two has better action
last of us remake vs part 2 ... thats what we need
You forgot to mention Ellie’s clothes were shaking in the wind in Part 2 - looks pretty good, wish they applied that to Part 1. Overall though the remake of Part 1 looks better than Part 2, which makes sense.
waiting for part 2 on pc🍷
still waiting🍷
These games are ina league of their own when it comes to gameplay and graphics, i love this franchise, i wish Part 2 story was better but i have no complaints on the gameplay
The graphics actually aren't all that impressive. If you've played a lot of PS5 exclusives then you'll start to see where the games are ageing a bit
Part 2 does not get enough credit!
i like the last of us 2 best
Each was the "top" of the platform. Tlou (1) on PS3, Tlou 2 on PS4.
I still play both, when I want to "feal" a game. RDR and RDR 2 were cool games with the peak of the platform too...