You mean that people have to be miserable and in pain to sing Linkin Park songs? You sound like a sad, depressing person. I'd prefer a happy person singing the songs...and they all look pretty happy!
@@musikmixxerkb how is it related? The author of the comment meant that Chester had experience, sang those songs emotionally, he knew what was he singing about.
No es comparacion xq chester es inigualable pero hubieran puesto a una persona que cante bien no este ma.mar.racho falta de respeto a todos los fans la verdafv
@@filipmatatko6228 a new band name can still perform OG song live.. if you cant find a good enough replacement.. dont replace it.. and immortalize Chester and Mike with LP.. dont muddy the water with something less then.. she can sing but her screams is just one tone.. when he screams you can hear him still singing.. she only fails in live shows.. as the studio can touch up just a pinch to make it really good.. im down for all of it with her and everything.. just the name thing is hard to swallow.. maybe, i just still miss him..
It's like any good rock/metal singer. I have heard solid covers, but you can tell which covers really feel that emotional attachment vs those who don't
@@Sua_Sponte_RSTB It's normal. Why would she be connected to a song that isn't close to her feelings? Chester felt the lyrics much more because well, he dealt with depression.
@@MultiKamil97 If it isn't close to her feelings, that's even more reason to leave it be. Just going through the motions is disrespectful and minimizes the reasons behind writing the song
I think Chester, he just seems more natural he’s singing from his soul. Emily seems she’s singing to not mess up and to give a decent performance, her eyes don’t close, she doesn’t tense up.. just does her job. Both are great voices but I love the rawness of Chester..
@@nsl4570 Why can't we compare? If I make one dish and it's great, then the same dish and it's now bad people should be able to tell me. She sings with no passion, she doesn't sound good. My opinion, my comparison. Don't like it that's fine but we're 100000% allowed to compare them.
@@RandomUserYTisFailing as OP said, comparison is just a way to not enjoy something. She sings greatly, and Chester sang greatly as well. Both are great, but they arent the same. She never was meant to replace him, but she sings any LP song with quality (even though I dont like when bands change the musics tone). Their new album is awesome. And I know a lot of people will be there to criticize, because thats what most annoying fans do. Or do you really think that no one was trash talking about Chester as well?
Nadie puede compararse con Chester sus canciones y su voz era todo desde lo más profundo de su corazón y su ser para mi el es único y nadie lo reemplazará .😢
When Emily comes to do her own songs, she'll be showing the emotions that Chester was giving... you can't compare the two- she's got her own strengths just as Chester had his - both incredible vocalists
So much pain in Chester's voice. Chic's voice is too synthetic to me, no heart behind it... now Chester, on the other hand... his pain is legendary!!! R.I.P. My brotha!!! ✨️🙏✨️
So lets make it clear. My body reacts immediately when the Chesters part comes. Like Goosebumps instantly!! With Emily nothing happens, it’s emotionless. You can feel Chesters pain, it comes from deep inside and performance wise it simply can’t and will never be able to be surpassed. RIP legend!
I think really all Emily does is show how hard the song really is. She is a professional singer and still had a voice break on this part… such a hard fuckin song
Chester Forever !!!! Im sorry, not compared but they need to give her songs made for her , stop using the old ones, those belongs to him, he made those songs
Emilie sounds like she’s loosing her voice, Chester you could feel it when he sings! You feel Chester’s pain, heartache his trauma. No comparison!! I can’t listen to Emilie sing songs that’s Chester has sang, it makes me sad that he’s not here anymore and wants me to play it w/ him singing. To me Linkin Park IS Chester Bennington.
It's not even question of strength and weaknesses, it's about Chester using normal vocal distribution and a new vocalist using only fry scream, they just choses the wrong vocalist, Wich don't know how to use distribution, she could learn it, but the question is the same, why did they choused her instead of someone better, who can use extreme vocals properly, there are so much extreme vocalists, who can do better than her
@@gitarbro2175 fair point. I guess, they answer that in their late interviews. For LP, it's not about having the best vocalist but rather the vibe of the person. If you compare LP with any other band, you will see they are rather all friends and the friendship is more important for them.
@@gitarbro2175 Probably because they like her vocals on the new songs, which millions of other people do to. Just because you want to cling onto the past doesn't mean the band has too. They want to move forward with new music and a new singer, drummer. They have every right to do so, and to cover their old material that they own at the same time. Apologies that it's not up to your demanding standards....
Full support to Emily, she's really good. Comparing could be good but it can't help to get any conclusion 'cause nobody can't beat Chester in his own songs
Stop comparing *She's one of the reasons* why we see LP on stage back again. Just like the old times if u knew what I mean, Emily is Something I could tell.
It wouldn’t have hurt to start a new band idk why else they would want to keep the linkin park name other than keeping the popularity that comes with the name but he being who he is in the rock industry would’ve successfully been able to start a new band
parece una persona afónica ..por dolor de garganta Emily ... chester es otro leveel su forma de cantar despierta un sentimiento de ira y una sensación muy fuerte..
Chester se expresaba con el alma en cada una de sus canciones, como lo hacia Yutaka Ozaki. Busquen Yutaka Ozaki - Forget-me-not live. Diferente género musical pero misma vibra.
That’s the thing, he’s emotional to the point of being an animal almost a beast. She’s singing it to match his vocals, so it’ll be off. Also she’s probably not feeling it. But the original songs she’s made with the rest of Linkin Park defiantly hit.
it's just not fair to compare her first performance to one of chester's best ones ever! To go out and perform this song on their first concert shows some big balls!! Kudos to her 🙌🏼
Does anyone know which recorded performance of Given Up was Chester’s earliest? It would be interesting to use that for his side of the comparison, when he didn’t have as much experience singing it either. Not gonna lie, I still expect him to be superior, but it would be a fairer test.
@@magnet8185 weird defensive behaviour, she was chosen not to be chester 2 but to be a new direction for the band in the future She isn't trying to usurp anything
I'm trying really hard to give this gal a chance...but goshdangit, I can't stand it!!! I'll keep circling back and sampling to see if something changes for me...until then, it's old Linkin Park all day every day for me, hands down. Sorry ❣️
If your not rocking with it your not rocking with it. No need to try to please the rest of the fan base I personally will only listen to the old songs but I’m happy for them that they started making music again
@c0rxpseb0i13 Yes that right there! I'm happy for them, support their decision, wish them all the best, but what drew me in just isn't there anymore. Chester put into words what I could not, such a beautiful tortured soul. What's your favorite LP song? Mine is Given Up, that scream is EPIC ❣️
@@leahsummer5852 I love given up as well I love point of authority,faint,numb and numb/encore with you pretty much every song on meteora and hybrid theory and the one more light album those are my favorites the other 2 albums are ok too I also love minutes to midnight too if that’s what it’s called I forgot
@@leahsummer5852 I also love the scream on given up first time I heard it I was blown away. Idk if you heard the z trip song with Chester it’s called walking dead I recommend listening to that it’s pretty fire
Incomparabile, Chester rimarrà imbattibile lei non è neanche lontanamente paragonabile! I Linkin Park erano e rimarranno solo quelli in cui era presente Chester mi spiace ma non riesco a farmeli piacere ora! Grande Chester RIP❤❤😢😢
No hay comparación y ella no es mala cantante, simplemente es como si fuera una mala copia de Chester Bennington que fue original 🇺🇲 desde un inicio de la banda. Mejor de vieran reconsiderar regresar por qué es difícil ver a otra persona 🎤cantando en Linkin Park cuando la imagen de Chester Bennington, está cada que tocan una canción 👌👍💯🔥. Es como si a Metallica le quitarán a James Hetfield o a Van ★Halen David Lee-Roth ó Samy Haggar o a Bon★Jovi entrara a cantar una mujer en vez del propio Jon???.🙄🤔🤯🫨😵💫🥸🤡
![Linkin Park: Given Up [Live 4K] (Dallas, Texas - November 8, 2024)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZjHSZzCqHFA/mqdefault.jpg)
She has a good voice but Chester’s comes from pain…no one can beat him on his own songs
Absolutely true
You mean that people have to be miserable and in pain to sing Linkin Park songs? You sound like a sad, depressing person. I'd prefer a happy person singing the songs...and they all look pretty happy!
@@musikmixxerkb how is it related? The author of the comment meant that Chester had experience, sang those songs emotionally, he knew what was he singing about.
It's not her song anyway. And i think it's wrong to compare between these 2
@@musikmixxerkbyour an idiot
Stop the comparisons. Chester was a freak of nature
And Emily is just nature
No es comparacion xq chester es inigualable pero hubieran puesto a una persona que cante bien no este ma.mar.racho falta de respeto a todos los fans la verdafv
then don't sing his song!
@@coldbattery well there are still ppl who want to hear it live, and this is sufficient
@@filipmatatko6228 a new band name can still perform OG song live..
if you cant find a good enough replacement.. dont replace it.. and
immortalize Chester and Mike with LP.. dont muddy the water with something less then.. she can sing but her screams is just one tone..
when he screams you can hear him still singing..
she only fails in live shows.. as the studio can touch up just a pinch to make it really good..
im down for all of it with her and everything.. just the name thing is hard to swallow..
maybe, i just still miss him..
Chester's voice gives me chills, I feel anguish and sadness, I don't know how to explain it, he was a different talent
Everything you said, I 100% agree!❤
Yep doesn’t matter how many times I hear Chester. I get chills every time
It's like any good rock/metal singer. I have heard solid covers, but you can tell which covers really feel that emotional attachment vs those who don't
@@Nlzinhaedit his singing voice was really great indeed
There is most definitely raw emotion in his vocals. You can certainly feel it
She sings it. He feels it. The difference is unmistakable.
She yells
@@Mcs983 Yeah. She just feels disconnected from the song imo. I feel like certain songs need to be left to him out of respect, and this is one of them
@@Sua_Sponte_RSTB It's normal. Why would she be connected to a song that isn't close to her feelings? Chester felt the lyrics much more because well, he dealt with depression.
@@MultiKamil97 If it isn't close to her feelings, that's even more reason to leave it be. Just going through the motions is disrespectful and minimizes the reasons behind writing the song
She's actually using the same yelling technique as Chester, she just has a different voice.@@Mcs983
I think Chester, he just seems more natural he’s singing from his soul. Emily seems she’s singing to not mess up and to give a decent performance, her eyes don’t close, she doesn’t tense up.. just does her job. Both are great voices but I love the rawness of Chester..
Different people give different expressions.
Comparison is the thief of joy
So is listening to Emily try to sing
@@ChadAV69 idk. emptiness machine goes hard.
@@ChadAV69she is awesome, you're just comparing and making the comment's statement true
@@nsl4570 Why can't we compare?
If I make one dish and it's great, then the same dish and it's now bad people should be able to tell me.
She sings with no passion, she doesn't sound good. My opinion, my comparison. Don't like it that's fine but we're 100000% allowed to compare them.
@@RandomUserYTisFailing as OP said, comparison is just a way to not enjoy something.
She sings greatly, and Chester sang greatly as well. Both are great, but they arent the same. She never was meant to replace him, but she sings any LP song with quality (even though I dont like when bands change the musics tone). Their new album is awesome.
And I know a lot of people will be there to criticize, because thats what most annoying fans do. Or do you really think that no one was trash talking about Chester as well?
Shes just singing a song. Chester is speaking the truth direct from his soul.
Ye but chester is dead, so she is what we got now.
@@Ken-Mortenbut Chester is better
@@thiagocastro6744 but that makes no difference since he's gone now.
I’m also pretty sure Mike wrote this one.
She doesn't even sing. She just yells
In my opinion, Emily is just screaming, while Chester is putting his heart into it.
This is not an opinion, but a fact!
You can hear Emil, but you can feel Chester. No comparison.
No, I can hear emily, and I can feel my ears bleed because it's that bad
@@ChickenThug55Who are you?
@@MrLumbago I'm batman, go tell all your friends about me
Exactly...."you can feel Chester".....that's the word.....
@@ChickenThug55 you cant be batman because im Batman
There is no comparison.
Definitivamente 👌
Absolutely not. RIP Chester….
Emily:pure yelling
Chester:pure 100% pain and anger
Its not yelling its screaming and there is roughness in her screams which is an expression of feelings
She doesn't know how to do the chester scream LoL it's 2 different screams and hers sucks.
@@1xAer0x1 chester did it in 2 screams very often too
This girl doesn't do it badly but no voice can supplant Chester's voice, he was unique, his songs will never be forgotten.
Chester the best
Chester came from another planet. RIP Legend!
Only Chester
Nadie puede compararse con Chester sus canciones y su voz era todo desde lo más profundo de su corazón y su ser para mi el es único y nadie lo reemplazará .😢
si
Chester wins
When Emily comes to do her own songs, she'll be showing the emotions that Chester was giving... you can't compare the two- she's got her own strengths just as Chester had his - both incredible vocalists
So much pain in Chester's voice. Chic's voice is too synthetic to me, no heart behind it... now Chester, on the other hand... his pain is legendary!!! R.I.P. My brotha!!! ✨️🙏✨️
His pain is so legendary that it killed him. Now everybody is happy, how painful he sounded
Que comparación más absurda....Descanse en paz Chester 🙏
So lets make it clear. My body reacts immediately when the Chesters part comes. Like Goosebumps instantly!! With Emily nothing happens, it’s emotionless.
You can feel Chesters pain, it comes from deep inside and performance wise it simply can’t and will never be able to be surpassed. RIP legend!
I don’t know. I connect with Emily’s screaming; I feel a lot of rage bubbling through.
Replacing Chester with a woman to try to stop the back lash is wild..... Linkin Park died with Chester Bennington....
RIP
Naw they finally got a good singer
CHESTER IS REAL 😢
Emily just singing for us ....but chester tell us the true story
No emotion in her voice. No one can replace Chester
No one compares to Chester, sorry.
His voice is a lot stronger
emily is good but chester is another level
Chester is another level and emily is bad
@@rubiagomes3584emily isnt bad
@@Even_N.D. I have the right to have my opinião.
They tried to find someone that can sing like Chester but no one will be able to match the emotion he put in every performance
I think really all Emily does is show how hard the song really is. She is a professional singer and still had a voice break on this part… such a hard fuckin song
Chester forever the best
No one ever ever compares with Chester.
R.I.P. LEGEND....
She will NEVER replace Chester!
Chester é incomparável 🇧🇷❤️
A.I trying not to mess up vrs Ultra legend
Além da diferença na potência e extensão vocal, a Emily você ouve, já o Chester você sente.
Однозначно Честер лучший некто не заменит его
Так никто и не пытался.
100000 %Chester ❤❤❤❤❤
Definitivamente así es él es y seguirá siendo el único.
999999999999999999% chester❤❤❤
Chester the goat
Chester Forever !!!!
Im sorry, not compared but they need to give her songs made for her , stop using the old ones, those belongs to him, he made those songs
Yeah I agree she has to play her stuff otherwise it sucks for everybody involved including us
Finally someone who understands and doesn’t non stop glaze emily
Well actually him AND mike.why people always forget about him and his influence,especially when it comes to the lyrics.
Absolutely agree!
@@thekidsarentalright410well, Mike wasn’t emotions and voice of songs but Chester was
Emilie sounds like she’s loosing her voice, Chester you could feel it when he sings! You feel Chester’s pain, heartache his trauma. No comparison!! I can’t listen to Emilie sing songs that’s Chester has sang, it makes me sad that he’s not here anymore and wants me to play it w/ him singing. To me Linkin Park IS Chester Bennington.
Agree with every single word.
No contest
Obviosly chester is the best 😅
Extraño a Chester 😢
What's with these comparison videos? This new chick is nowhere near to Chester.
Every vocalist has his/her strengths and weaknesses and so any comparison with Chester is unfair on Emily. Also, Chester is one of the all time great!
It's not even question of strength and weaknesses, it's about Chester using normal vocal distribution and a new vocalist using only fry scream, they just choses the wrong vocalist, Wich don't know how to use distribution, she could learn it, but the question is the same, why did they choused her instead of someone better, who can use extreme vocals properly, there are so much extreme vocalists, who can do better than her
@@gitarbro2175 fair point. I guess, they answer that in their late interviews. For LP, it's not about having the best vocalist but rather the vibe of the person. If you compare LP with any other band, you will see they are rather all friends and the friendship is more important for them.
@@gitarbro2175 Probably because they like her vocals on the new songs, which millions of other people do to. Just because you want to cling onto the past doesn't mean the band has too. They want to move forward with new music and a new singer, drummer. They have every right to do so, and to cover their old material that they own at the same time. Apologies that it's not up to your demanding standards....
Many others would do better then her
All time great? Because he's dead?
This is shit. Absolutely no heart. No one, nothing can ever replicate, replace or re-do what Chester did.
He was talent.
Chester grita de um lugar de dor e verdade... A nova vocalista só está interpretando... Não tem comparação.
Full support to Emily, she's really good. Comparing could be good but it can't help to get any conclusion 'cause nobody can't beat Chester in his own songs
Stop comparing *She's one of the reasons* why we see LP on stage back again. Just like the old times if u knew what I mean, Emily is Something I could tell.
Everyone doesn’t have to be happy with the decision it’s ok if you are
Idk wtf Mike was thinking trying to replace Chester. She’s trying so hard to sound like him bruh lol
It wouldn’t have hurt to start a new band idk why else they would want to keep the linkin park name other than keeping the popularity that comes with the name but he being who he is in the rock industry would’ve successfully been able to start a new band
i dunno, shes has a decent voice, but she cant hold a candle to Chester unfortunately...i dont believe her when shes singing like i do Chester.
Emily is amazing but Chester was a frickin genius.
Chester God entregava tudo!
Chester forever ❤😢
parece una persona afónica ..por dolor de garganta Emily ...
chester es otro leveel su forma de cantar despierta un sentimiento de ira y una sensación muy fuerte..
Chester se expresaba con el alma en cada una de sus canciones, como lo hacia Yutaka Ozaki. Busquen Yutaka Ozaki - Forget-me-not live. Diferente género musical pero misma vibra.
R.I.P. Chester
That’s the thing, he’s emotional to the point of being an animal almost a beast. She’s singing it to match his vocals, so it’ll be off. Also she’s probably not feeling it. But the original songs she’s made with the rest of Linkin Park defiantly hit.
Why TF is she even in comparison with CB? Theres no comparison, it's as if I'm trying to compare bb8 to Darth Vader
Sorry does not compute
Love chester🎉🎉🌋🌋😢
Chester's voice just rides the beat so much better.
it's just not fair to compare her first performance to one of chester's best ones ever! To go out and perform this song on their first concert shows some big balls!! Kudos to her 🙌🏼
Emily will never get there 😂
Ναι Σκεψου ομως οτι ο Chester δεν ήξερε οτι θα τον συγκρίνουμε …Ενω αυτη το ξερει….σκεψου ποσο καλύτερος ειναι….
Does anyone know which recorded performance of Given Up was Chester’s earliest? It would be interesting to use that for his side of the comparison, when he didn’t have as much experience singing it either. Not gonna lie, I still expect him to be superior, but it would be a fairer test.
@@MelissaGarrett1980 given up was released in 2007 and this video is from 2007
@@MelissaGarrett1980you also can search for the latest because at the end his screams were pretty weak
Ela é uma ótima vocalista,não vamos fazer comparações galera 😌👏🏽 que tragam bastante novidade pra gente ❤
Put me out of my misery…listening to Armstrong giving a lazy rendition of this battled song.
Oh dear ....
Chester’s screams from his soul and touches your soul, Emily has a great voice but doesn’t have that power and magic
Oh, Emily is SOO bad in this comparison!!!
She doesn't FEEL the song at all...
Sorry, the Emily thing isn't my thing.
Its her worst performance on this. There are way better ones
Chester bennington incomparavel
Chester was a legend and no mily a$$ has a single chance to beat the legend.
Chester : GOAT
Emilie : SUCKS
No
@Even_N.D. yes it's a fact Emilie SUCKS
@Acheron1996 She doesnt. You just have no clue
I hate the New Linkin park linerup
And their new blurry colourful logo.
Chester always!!
Emily is good, but chester voice is from his heart... ❤
setuju akang
Chester wins😢
I felt nothing when she sang..literally nothing..it had no meaning..Chester’s hits every time
I rather listen to Hybrid Theory (the cover band) then new LP.
She sounds like a boy that just started puberty
Love both of them, great vocalists!
Chester All Day
She's not even near his level. Chester is the only one that fits this music.
And she can not come even in the near to chester❤
and she doesn't have to
@michaels.5001 But we will Remember Linkin Park on Chester and his legacy. Not her's. She won't usurp anything. It's all his. Only his. Forever
@@magnet8185 weird defensive behaviour, she was chosen not to be chester 2 but to be a new direction for the band in the future
She isn't trying to usurp anything
@ni9274 oh no she definitely is. but It won't work cause she's not very good at singing.
I'm trying really hard to give this gal a chance...but goshdangit, I can't stand it!!! I'll keep circling back and sampling to see if something changes for me...until then, it's old Linkin Park all day every day for me, hands down. Sorry ❣️
If your not rocking with it your not rocking with it. No need to try to please the rest of the fan base I personally will only listen to the old songs but I’m happy for them that they started making music again
@c0rxpseb0i13 Yes that right there! I'm happy for them, support their decision, wish them all the best, but what drew me in just isn't there anymore. Chester put into words what I could not, such a beautiful tortured soul. What's your favorite LP song? Mine is Given Up, that scream is EPIC ❣️
@@leahsummer5852 I love given up as well I love point of authority,faint,numb and numb/encore with you pretty much every song on meteora and hybrid theory and the one more light album those are my favorites the other 2 albums are ok too I also love minutes to midnight too if that’s what it’s called I forgot
@@leahsummer5852 I also love the scream on given up first time I heard it I was blown away. Idk if you heard the z trip song with Chester it’s called walking dead I recommend listening to that it’s pretty fire
Jesus she’s bad. I don’t think just compared to cheater, just objectively. Which is sad I wanted to like the band update
No comparen amigo, Chester fue unico
She wasn't even close weak
ONE AND ONLY CHESTER!!!
She’s good but she can never replace the legendary Chester Bennington!! #RIPCHESTER!! 🤘🎤🎸
No one can replicate Chester’s 17 sec scream
I saw someone else say Emily screams with anger, Chester screams with sorrow and pain
Emily canta muy bien las canciones de Linkin Park. Pero sin duda alguna Chester grita mejor.
Not even close... Chester was pure talent and Emily is experienced and has good technique but thats just different.
It’s always going to be different..
Chester! No contest!
Chester gives me chills every time no matter how many times I listen to the song 😢 he knew pain
Incomparabile, Chester rimarrà imbattibile lei non è neanche lontanamente paragonabile! I Linkin Park erano e rimarranno solo quelli in cui era presente Chester mi spiace ma non riesco a farmeli piacere ora! Grande Chester RIP❤❤😢😢
She's great BUT.... you can't compare 🤷🏻♂️
Честер незаменим, в любом случае он поет во первых лучше во вторых он поет искренне, от боли
Emily sang it, Chester sang it from his heart. There's a big difference
No comparison Chester was magic and heartbreakingly beautifully real. She is a good singer.
chester so pain, very pain. i feel it
As they say, feel the difference
No hay comparación y ella no es mala cantante, simplemente es como si fuera una mala copia de Chester Bennington que fue original 🇺🇲 desde un inicio de la banda. Mejor de vieran reconsiderar regresar por qué es difícil ver a otra persona 🎤cantando en Linkin Park cuando la imagen de Chester Bennington, está cada que tocan una canción 👌👍💯🔥. Es como si a Metallica le quitarán a James Hetfield o a Van ★Halen David Lee-Roth ó Samy Haggar o a Bon★Jovi entrara a cantar una mujer en vez del propio Jon???.🙄🤔🤯🫨😵💫🥸🤡
Chester was one of a kind. Even himself cannot copy his own.