Mitchell and Webb - Stalin Vs Hitler (arguing the moral toss)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 янв 2025

Комментарии • 64

  • @RadioRudie
    @RadioRudie 5 лет назад +7

    That's it, that's every internet argument ever.

  • @fritspas
    @fritspas 14 лет назад +38

    I agree with Mary.

    • @romainsavioz5466
      @romainsavioz5466 4 года назад +2

      What did she say I wasn't listening

    • @fritspas
      @fritspas 4 года назад +2

      @@romainsavioz5466 Sorry, can't answer now, I'm rather tired.

  • @cesc819
    @cesc819 11 лет назад +62

    This is all arguments on the internet

    • @fds7476
      @fds7476 8 лет назад +7

      Spoken like a true fascist!
      Why don't you just drive down an Autobahn in your Volkswagen while you're at it?!

    • @najeyrifai1134
      @najeyrifai1134 7 лет назад +5

      I'm very tired.

    • @ThreadBomb
      @ThreadBomb 7 лет назад +1

      I think this sketch is actually more reasonable than most youtube comment threads.

  • @tris421
    @tris421 7 лет назад +55

    wow this really sums up the political climate right now

    • @AnEnemySpy456
      @AnEnemySpy456 7 лет назад +12

      A Communist like you would say that.

    • @John_McDonnell
      @John_McDonnell 7 лет назад +16

      Only a Nazi would call someone a Communist.

    • @ThreadBomb
      @ThreadBomb 7 лет назад +2

      Taking care of your children for free, like a filthy Commie!

    • @thebackofdoctormanhattanshead
      @thebackofdoctormanhattanshead 4 года назад

      Not adressing his arguments, instead using insults; typical behaviour of a radical socialist.

    • @MannyFlanders
      @MannyFlanders 4 года назад

      or right now (oct 2020)

  • @Pining_for_the_fjords
    @Pining_for_the_fjords 8 лет назад +38

    This is actually the level of argument some politicians are resorting to about the EU referendum.

  • @adzug
    @adzug 14 лет назад +5

    this is exactly what passes for real debate in america.

    • @drido
      @drido 2 года назад +2

      Yep, can confirm that. And its worse now.

  • @STho205
    @STho205 6 лет назад +13

    I'm with Mary.
    This is EXACTLY how any two extremes in any middle road normal democracy debate. Mary is the rational middle. Mary is very tired.

  • @TheBlackwaterDemon
    @TheBlackwaterDemon 15 лет назад +1

    Oh man, that was hilarious - thanks for posting!

  • @SIngli6
    @SIngli6 13 лет назад +3

    I think that the right to present Mitchell and Webb radio sketches on RUclips is one of the greatest expressions of democracy, and frankly denying it would but us in a situation not dissimilar from SOPA's America!

  • @tigs73
    @tigs73 15 лет назад +1

    Surprisingly many discussions on the internet go that way.

  • @squamish4244
    @squamish4244 12 лет назад +1

    "I feel very tired."

  • @martinverran5
    @martinverran5 2 года назад

    Shooting distributors sounds a bit like killing the messenger when he delivers bad news.

  • @whade62000
    @whade62000 3 года назад

    Would be funny if I didn't meet people who argue like this regularly.

  • @squamish4244
    @squamish4244 13 лет назад

    it's really bizarre how so many internet arguments quickly degenerate into one or both participants comparing the other to the biggest assholes in history.

  • @DannyPhantomBeast
    @DannyPhantomBeast 13 лет назад

    4 people feel very tired.

  • @handsomebrick
    @handsomebrick 12 лет назад

    oh, you were serious.

  • @MazingMania
    @MazingMania 7 лет назад +1

    Fry and Laurie reference?

  • @DoctorRhys
    @DoctorRhys 4 года назад +1

    Twitter in a nutshell...

  • @SaintSwithinsDay
    @SaintSwithinsDay 13 лет назад

    "This one is dedicated to the force for epic stupidity that is ben stein ("darwin leads to hitler")."
    Actually, it's a parody of a Radio 4 programme called "The Moral Maze," hosted by Michael Burke, who used to stand next to starving Ethiopians looking sad, but now sits next to Claire Fox and Melanie Phillips and sounds cranky.

  • @TheDoctorWholigan
    @TheDoctorWholigan 13 лет назад

    @sheepwshotguns thats try as hell having argument with christen fundamentalist it went straight to hitler

  • @pithie84
    @pithie84 14 лет назад

    @Kington99 , ahhh a fan of QI? love that show too

  • @GENERALJOHNNYREBEL
    @GENERALJOHNNYREBEL 12 лет назад

    Although it hasn’t happened yet, we have similar laws here in Texas. We don’t have the "Stand your ground law" like Florida has (that’s what George Zimmerman's defense is), but we have laws that allow us to shot dead threatening people in our front yards, in our homes, & even in the street if they are approaching your property in a threatening manner. Plus, our cars are considered to be the same as our homes, so we can carry guns in our vehicles too. I LOVE OUR GUN CULTURE......

    • @SassyLoverBoy
      @SassyLoverBoy 3 года назад

      OMG, I love killing without consequence as well!

  • @JakeLucGoodman
    @JakeLucGoodman 14 лет назад

    this is genius

  • @t.v.fjordland558
    @t.v.fjordland558 2 года назад

    Sounded just like American Politics through the Media Filter at the time Now life mirrors art ...

  • @MediumRareOpinions
    @MediumRareOpinions 12 лет назад +3

    everybody should watch QI, just my humble opinion, but i think many would agree

  • @paulbottomley42
    @paulbottomley42 14 лет назад

    @Kington99
    With, of course, the caveat, "unless the argument in question is actually about Nazi Germany"
    :)

  • @sheepwshotguns
    @sheepwshotguns 15 лет назад

    reminds me of godwin's law

  • @CarloCanovaccio
    @CarloCanovaccio 13 лет назад +1

    Prussia vs Russia ft.England and America
    aka, Hetalia brought me here xD

  • @lelouch3
    @lelouch3 14 лет назад

    @kinggod654 Indeed.

  • @masteroftheobvious86
    @masteroftheobvious86 15 лет назад

    @666satanification666
    And they then immediately lose by doing so, as Godwin's Law states

  • @SaintSwithinsDay
    @SaintSwithinsDay 13 лет назад

    Actually, all of those statements are more sensible than anything Melanie Phillips has ever said. Satire pales in comparison.

  • @Lawh
    @Lawh 14 лет назад

    @Kington99 Unless, you are actually talking about Hitler. Hitler had other thoughts and deeds outside of his mass murdering racist tendencies. Comparing Stalin to Hitler, for example. Comparing Hitlers painting skills to someone else. Comparing Hitler's other political view points to someone else. There are many things about Hitler which one can discuss, but it helps if the topic is actually Hitler. In a moral discussion, one can also be as cold as Hitler, but to accuse someone is another issue.

  • @fudge1monkey
    @fudge1monkey 15 лет назад

    scared the crap out of me when he said "angus" my name, caught me unawares. i wonder when i will get desensitized to hearing my own name...

  • @Lawh
    @Lawh 14 лет назад

    @adzug Sadly

  • @sevret313
    @sevret313 12 лет назад

    Except for the fact that they got a warning letter. You should watch QI.

  • @Xezlec
    @Xezlec 13 лет назад

    I actually don't think it's that strange. History is how we learn what is and isn't a good idea. Of course the biggest moral failures of the past will figure large in any discussion of modern morality.

  • @Jcolinsol
    @Jcolinsol 12 лет назад +1

    I wasn't invoking Godwin's Law, I was just saying that the intolerance that rises in the gorge during the act of debate, is the exact same impulse that made hitler spew his vitriol.
    The urge and act of debate makes us all as bad as hitler on some level, that's all I was trying to say.

    • @ThreadBomb
      @ThreadBomb 7 лет назад

      Misusing the word "debate". Debate is a reasoned exchange of views. Schools and universities have debating clubs, so members can practice public speaking and logical argument.

  • @Weazla-
    @Weazla- 3 года назад +1

    Funny that people still compare the worst man in history to the man that beat him

  • @Jcolinsol
    @Jcolinsol 12 лет назад

    Only no one mentioned communism.
    So, I'm curious, what about my comment offended you?

  • @kurdtpage
    @kurdtpage 11 лет назад +2

    Hmm, videos not working for me, can only hear the audio

    • @henrywiltcher
      @henrywiltcher 6 лет назад +4

      That's a shame, I can both hear and see the audio.

  • @leirgauk
    @leirgauk 9 лет назад

    Lol spot on

  • @Lawh
    @Lawh 14 лет назад

    I would think godwins law has it's basis on Hitler being a universal worse case scenario.It's universally accepted as being hard to top for being the worse. So the law might be that when the unprofessional debaters are going further and further away from common ground, it might, from a personal perspective seem that the other is metaphorically as far as Hitler to them. Also, as an argument goes far enough, people wil start admitting into things they have not thought of out of defencive stance.

  • @AndyAce83
    @AndyAce83 10 лет назад +1

    "This one is dedicated to the force for epic stupidity that is ben stein ("darwin leads to hitler")."
    *Darwinism* leads to nazism or other horrible "survival of the fittest" socities, not Darwin. Evolution in itself does not lead to anything. Its what follows when people try make it out to be more than just science. Get it?
    But funny skit though.

  • @cmur078
    @cmur078 11 лет назад

    well that's just the level of argument that we've come to expect from the fascists...
    ;)

  • @mattyarden2484
    @mattyarden2484 10 лет назад

    i feel it should be the other way around, with the pro-gun side on the right.

  • @Truthiness231
    @Truthiness231 12 лет назад

    Typical communist dribble...