Breguet all day. They have a unique history and design and real craftmanship. The Patek is a rich kid flex piece and will fall off trend like it already was 10 years ago.
Great review Tim. The flag at the end of the seconds hand is the nautical flag letter B for Breguet. The movement plates are also cut on the rose engine for the deck look.
Design-wise, the Nautalis is king between the two, but charmed by the Breguet's looks on the wrist - it's a handsome watch I'd buy and be proud to wear.
Yea, I think what you're saying makes sense and would probably agree. It makes me think that the Breguet vs Patek comparisons seem appropraite. Maybe a more expensive comparison the new white goal nautilus vs the white gold/blue dialed marine, or the previous generation blue dialed 5711 vs the blue dialed 5817 big date?
@@DirtFather407The Patek Nautilus has a recognizable design but it does not necessarily mean that it looks “better”. I’d argue that most people outside of watch circles would likely prefer the Breguet one just because it looks more like a classic round watch.
The nautilus for sure and that has nothing to do with hype for me. It's simply a vastly superior design and at the end of the day no amount of finishing or haute horology is going to make up for design.
My nautilus was literally the worst purchase Ive made. Immense letdown and something of a tease. Im not impressed by PP anymore and regret spending so much to be allowed to buy something so average. Im fascinated by the Breguet. Had no idea it was titanium and it makes me want one. Ive never given them much thought. Visited a Tourbillon recently while in Montreux and didnt even look at them…. I feel like I need to branch out of my comfort zone. I love my Swatches - Omega and Blancpain - so maybe the Breguet will be familiar but novel too. Thanks
I used to be a nautilus “hater” before I put a 5713 on and it changed my perspective. It is a undisputed icon! The breguet is incredible value and in this comparison the breguet is way better value compared to the insane $300k for the green 5711.
Comparing a 15k watch vs a 300k watch is pretty silly, without a doubt Breguet wins all day due to the value proposition given the watch quality between the two aren’t that far apart, it isn’t like Breguet is an invicta quality watch, it’s all hand finished and uncompromising quality, that stands toe to toe with Patek minus the bullst waitlist / background check to buy one, and cost 20 times less..
130m water resistance from the Patek eh? Wouldn't want to be testing that after recent silliness from Patek. The nautilus is essentially now a dress watch playing make believe. Breguet takes the win here by default.
The Breguet is the nicer watch regardless of price considerations. Entirely subjective of course but I cannot understand how it is possible to like the Nautilus.
Put it up against the old big date Marine and it would make it an even harder choice for me. I have to go green here, its a legend, its an icon and its certainly a peer of the Breguet, which I have to say I would LOVE to own on its own. You can't go wrong with either of these but I have a weakness for that shade of green. The only thing about the Breguet that puts me off is the end link/ first link and how its connected.. It just doesn't look cohesive. Still, minor complaint.
The classic comment from someone with limited means who voices an opinion on the value of this watch or that watch based on their own assets and purchasing capacity. Now step back and think about the actual targeted 1916 clientele (hint, it's not you). Someone who has, for example, access to FP Journe's Black label collection because of their purchase history. They are not watching this video thinking I will make my decision based on needing to save money on a watch because I need the remaining money for something else. I am rich, and I can buy whatever I want and when. So how about you just step back and enjoy Tim's excellent presentation skills (that you are getting for free) and not write one of the most typical cliched responses from the middle class (that has to always compromise when making serious money related decisions) to a VS episode that involves an acknowledged heavy hitter. Deal?
@@davidr2802Someone is mad that one guy on the Internet does not care about his favorite watch brand 😅. Loving watches has little to do with money. There are plenty of millionaires who could buy a Patek but still love watches enough to walk around with a $50 G-Shock.
@@davidr2802Tim compared this two watches and ask which one do you prefer (viewer) and i answers it. if its 300k vs 295k watch then and im not really talking about money. but 300k vs 13k. then 13k seens really a good value for the same category of watches. money is still money. be humble a little bit,its not gonna hurt you.
Ilia kvalito ne estas malsupera al tiuj grandaj luksaj varoj. La fortikeco kaj atento al detaloj rivalas kun la originalaj dezajnistsakoj kaj mi ne povas kredi kiom mi ?paris. ?i estas la perfekta akcesora?o por iu ajn moda knabino! Mi certas, ke mi rea?etos iujn aliajn stilojn kaj kolorojn ? nkuwan por kongrui kun miaj vesta?oj kaj ?uoj!
@@NaturalBornWinner- You can call it underrated, but there's a reason you can purchase a Breguet for less than a Submariner. Breguet as a company has fallen from grace. They haven't tried innovating or changing a single thing in their catalog in who knows how long. They have more history than all other watch brands in the world combined, and they refuse to use it. There are now tons of brands in their segment that make watches of equal quality and finishing with brand cachet to back it up.
Please make more videos on Breguet. The watches are not valued enough
Standalone review coming!
Best,
Tim
I’ve got a blue dial 5517 on rubber and I absolutely love it. I also love the fact that they’re an absolute steal on the second hand market.
Yeah, you can pick them up for peanuts. I have 10.
i like that they sync the seconds hands together when doing the review 👍👍💕💕💕💕
It's not always easy to do when one watch doesn't hack. Fortunately, both do in this case.
Best,
Tim
Breguet all day. They have a unique history and design and real craftmanship. The Patek is a rich kid flex piece and will fall off trend like it already was 10 years ago.
Nah rich kid flex piece is AP and RM. Patek is timeless, so is Breguet. Both are good brands.
Great review Tim. The flag at the end of the seconds hand is the nautical flag letter B for Breguet. The movement plates are also cut on the rose engine for the deck look.
Interesting, I've got the bucherer blue version of the Breguet. It's an incredible watch.
Design-wise, the Nautalis is king between the two, but charmed by the Breguet's looks on the wrist - it's a handsome watch I'd buy and be proud to wear.
Couldn't have said it better. The Breguet has so much character and charm, but the Nautilus is just that good.
It also helps that one is a watch you can actually wear and the other is an investment that will likely sit in a bank safe for the rest of your life 😅
Fascinating review!
Yea, I think what you're saying makes sense and would probably agree. It makes me think that the Breguet vs Patek comparisons seem appropraite. Maybe a more expensive comparison the new white goal nautilus vs the white gold/blue dialed marine, or the previous generation blue dialed 5711 vs the blue dialed 5817 big date?
love how Tim's Royter is just within camera view. Tim's just another client at WB trying on watches and trying to decide. Haha!
He should put it in that little felt lined tray they usually have on the cases. Actually I should get one of those, that would be handy.
It's never far from reach!
Best,
Tim
Very good review, both is really good watch
The Breguet is on another level. I can’t understand the appeal of that Patek. Looks are not its best feature.
“I can’t understand the appeal of the Patek” because it looks better and has a better looking movement? Sounds like you’re trying hard to stand out
@@DirtFather407 nope, apparently many share my opinion. That case shape is ugly AF. Not discussing quality here, they are both incredibly well made.
@@DirtFather407The Patek Nautilus has a recognizable design but it does not necessarily mean that it looks “better”. I’d argue that most people outside of watch circles would likely prefer the Breguet one just because it looks more like a classic round watch.
You’re right - the Nautilus is pig ugly!
@@darrenaquilina1403 "...apparently many share my opinion.." When big men come to you with their opinions, do they also have tears in their eyes.?"
I was fortunate enough to buy this Breguet from the video 😁
Sincerly,this breguet is great,and if you compare the price with the patek its a big diference ,so better to buy a breguet
The nautilus for sure and that has nothing to do with hype for me. It's simply a vastly superior design and at the end of the day no amount of finishing or haute horology is going to make up for design.
I just don’t get the whole Nautilus thing of to be honest the square Genta thing.
Tim should’ve compared the older Marine Grande Date model. I don’t like the design of new generation of Marines at all
Couldn't agree more. Breguet took a lot away from the Marine that made it great, the big date, the old dial and the rotor. Cheapened it out perhaps.
Patex price,,?
I love Breguet but a titanium sports watch with their design language does not speak to me much. It's like a carbon fiber body kit on a 50s SL300
My nautilus was literally the worst purchase Ive made. Immense letdown and something of a tease. Im not impressed by PP anymore and regret spending so much to be allowed to buy something so average. Im fascinated by the Breguet. Had no idea it was titanium and it makes me want one. Ive never given them much thought. Visited a Tourbillon recently while in Montreux and didnt even look at them…. I feel like I need to branch out of my comfort zone. I love my Swatches - Omega and Blancpain - so maybe the Breguet will be familiar but novel too. Thanks
I used to be a nautilus “hater” before I put a 5713 on and it changed my perspective. It is a undisputed icon! The breguet is incredible value and in this comparison the breguet is way better value compared to the insane $300k for the green 5711.
Is the Nautilus nicer? Probably. Is it ten times the price nicer? Not hardly.
Comparing a 15k watch vs a 300k watch is pretty silly, without a doubt Breguet wins all day due to the value proposition given the watch quality between the two aren’t that far apart, it isn’t like Breguet is an invicta quality watch, it’s all hand finished and uncompromising quality, that stands toe to toe with Patek minus the bullst waitlist / background check to buy one, and cost 20 times less..
130m water resistance from the Patek eh? Wouldn't want to be testing that after recent silliness from Patek. The nautilus is essentially now a dress watch playing make believe. Breguet takes the win here by default.
Breguet all the way! ❤😊
The Breguet needed to be with waves
The Breguet is the nicer watch regardless of price considerations. Entirely subjective of course but I cannot understand how it is possible to like the Nautilus.
not allowed to sell it then i would have the breguet
Give me the Breguet and a 911 turbo
I would chose an odysseus
The Breguet has a lovely movement, but the rest of the watch is dosed in ugly rays. Patek all the way. 👌
Put it up against the old big date Marine and it would make it an even harder choice for me. I have to go green here, its a legend, its an icon and its certainly a peer of the Breguet, which I have to say I would LOVE to own on its own. You can't go wrong with either of these but I have a weakness for that shade of green. The only thing about the Breguet that puts me off is the end link/ first link and how its connected.. It just doesn't look cohesive. Still, minor complaint.
Breguet ☝️
get 13k watch. and spend another 287k on something else. i love watches but at the end of the day. it just a watch.
The classic comment from someone with limited means who voices an opinion on the value of this watch or that watch based on their own assets and purchasing capacity. Now step back and think about the actual targeted 1916 clientele (hint, it's not you). Someone who has, for example, access to FP Journe's Black label collection because of their purchase history. They are not watching this video thinking I will make my decision based on needing to save money on a watch because I need the remaining money for something else. I am rich, and I can buy whatever I want and when. So how about you just step back and enjoy Tim's excellent presentation skills (that you are getting for free) and not write one of the most typical cliched responses from the middle class (that has to always compromise when making serious money related decisions) to a VS episode that involves an acknowledged heavy hitter. Deal?
@@davidr2802Someone is mad that one guy on the Internet does not care about his favorite watch brand 😅. Loving watches has little to do with money. There are plenty of millionaires who could buy a Patek but still love watches enough to walk around with a $50 G-Shock.
The person buying the 5711 doesn't need the spare 287k.
@@davidr2802Tim compared this two watches and ask which one do you prefer (viewer) and i answers it. if its 300k vs 295k watch then and im not really talking about money. but 300k vs 13k. then 13k seens really a good value for the same category of watches. money is still money. be humble a little bit,its not gonna hurt you.
@@NoahBB do you think 5711 buyer would consider a breguet?
As far as I am concerned it’s a no brainer.I hate tv screen watches .🤢
I thought I’d like the Patek more but that Breguet is incredible
Next up: we compare the rainbow Daytona to a timex.
Which one is the timex in this versus here?
@@Moe90rules The Breguet is the Timex.
There's a reason it costs less than a Submariner when comparing secondary market prices.
@@fj7509 Old man Breguet is spinning in his grave!
Ilia kvalito ne estas malsupera al tiuj grandaj luksaj varoj. La fortikeco kaj atento al detaloj rivalas kun la originalaj dezajnistsakoj kaj mi ne povas kredi kiom mi ?paris. ?i estas la perfekta akcesora?o por iu ajn moda knabino! Mi certas, ke mi rea?etos iujn aliajn stilojn kaj kolorojn ? nkuwan por kongrui kun miaj vesta?oj kaj ?uoj!
I don't even like the Nautilus, but it blows the Breguet out of the water.
The Breguet is an old man's watch that hasn't been updated in 100 years.
I have to disagree, the Breguet blows the patek out of the water all day long. Breguet is an underrated brand that makes fantastic watches.
@@NaturalBornWinner- You can call it underrated, but there's a reason you can purchase a Breguet for less than a Submariner.
Breguet as a company has fallen from grace. They haven't tried innovating or changing a single thing in their catalog in who knows how long. They have more history than all other watch brands in the world combined, and they refuse to use it.
There are now tons of brands in their segment that make watches of equal quality and finishing with brand cachet to back it up.
I disagree but I like your avatar and the Breguet is no AE86. Its not supposed to be.
Coughing baby vs Hydrogen bomb
Breguet have managed to make one of the ugliest three handers known to man. Alpine Eagle for me.
One of the ugliest Marine ever done IMO. The nautilus is stunning in green
PP with a 45hr power reserve is absolutely abysmal 😂
Ah yes the square 60s TV set that is supposed to be a porthole.
Also $300,000 for pinsleeves…come on Patek 🤦
Oh, right, if it had screws you would have two!. I suggest middle class folks like you sit this one out.