well the robot being able to move an a x and y axis is actually a really good idea like he said and if he actually wanted to "invent" robots with practical uses or something i feel like he's fully capable of it. but youre right its Michael hes not gonna do that
@@temanor I know about Michael but not a full ton so gotta ask: how does it usually go? I know that he's a mad scientist of RUclips esp with his beer piss robot dog that's for sure but still, what usually happens exactly? And how come Michael doesn't fully invent robots with practical uses like what's stopping him frfom doing so? Like it'd be cool to have a RUclipsr Tony Stark so how come he isn't doing it then?
To be fair, the dude started making some good points about how to improve it, but then just went into good old goblin mode, i guess You can't make significant advancements in both medícine and robótics in 6weeks for a haha RUclips video
yes the patience, because i believe 100% he could do something way better, but is not the objective, and who are we lying to? if it was a real surgery robot and none of the jokes, he would not be his channel
@@DavidHindin I think any surgery robot would necessarily have the ability to "attack the patient" if used ineptly or maliciously. You are manipulating and cutting into flesh, arteries, and vital organs.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
I just wonder if he did the work or other people idd it for him........ seriously when he was trying to get the head off i was wondering if he would be needing a surgery robot when it chopped his arm off....... well or cut it pretty bad. Cringe watching him be so unsafe
Michael Reeves is like the Chaotic Evil of science RUclipsrs and I'm so happy to see a surgeon react to him because when I first saw this video like a year ago, I thought it was hilarious. Thanks Dr Hindin!
The most chaotic science and engineering youtubers. Michael Reeves, Electroboom, Styropyro, nile red and Explosions and fire. Maybe not the most chaotic but I love them nonetheless
Pointing out the positives on the engineering part and understanding the chaotic and dark humor of someone combined with actual interesting information made this video a well spend moment on RUclips for me. Thnx for that.
I feel like this video was the perfect mixture of talking about the serious and educational part of the process and at the same time understanding and appreciating the joke, great reaction
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Mot an electronics "expert", but as a hobbyist 3d printer/cnc guy and professional IT guy I can confirm what he said about the motors is true. A regular brushless DC motor can run real fast, but is unable to tell how much it has rotated due to the fact its a rather "dumb" piece of electronics. it's just some magnets and copper wire. Adding a driver board that can measure how much it turns is how you make servo motors, which are motors that can tell how much they have rotated using additional electronics. It's an old trick for DIY CNC mills if you don't want to shell thousands of dollars for a high quality servo motor ecosystem.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Michael Reeves represents why I went into engineering and he continues to be an inspiration for me and all of my engineering friends. The man is brilliant and like any true engineer has the skills and the determination to bring any and all of his ideas, no matter how dumb or ill-conceived, into the real world. And once he makes his dreams a reality, the chaotic gremlin of a human being does whatever the fuck he wants with them. We could all take a page out of Michael's book.
The funniest thing is he actually envisioned a genuine improvement from the ground up for surgical robots even if he turned it into a meme at the end lol
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
to be fair, a hand tracker will never surpass physical controllers because it cannot give tactile feedback, which is incredibly important for precise movements
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
Funny enough, he's not formally trained like.... at all. Pretty much everything he knows he learned from RUclips and personal research. Smart as hell, no filter, and entertaining for days.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
@aiapihud4344 he said in an interview he attended a bunch of college lectures (snuck into the lecture halls) and learned as much as he could without having to buy the degree paper. So unofficially speaking, I guess you're right in a way 😆
15:26 As an undergrad I worked on this laparoscopic AR system, it was totally running late, the phd student whose thesis it was was stressed out and depressed, and then we had some surgeon come in to test it. The surgeon loved it! He was most impressed with some feature that got thrown in as a gimmick, where you could see the percentage of the liver volume left if you removed a piece using the ultrasound probe as a virtual knife. He said he'd use that immediately. Definitely always test it with the actual user, not just developers.
That sounds really cool. How were you able to get the liver volume to begin with? Was it input to your machine from separate tests done prior to the surgery? How did you measure the removed piece of liver?
@Nell S We had the surface of the liver along with its internal vascular system that were segmented out of a crt or mri scan which would have been done prior to the surgery.
@Nell S the volume was computed based on the 3d model and the ultrasound probe was tracked live in 3d for the AR features already, where the ultrasound image was rendered into the view too. You can imagine the tool and the ultrasound image looking a bit like a giant key. Extend the ultrasound image into an infinite plane, use that to "cut" the virtual liver in two, then compute the volume of one of the pieces and display that to the surgeon.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
You could actually use Michaels machine as a mount for the Da Vinci robot which would solve the range problem and also make it easier to move if something goes wrong. Michael only needs to make it a bit more precised, for example making it so you could input the coordinates to where C.U.M would be located.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text
I'm loving this sub genre of RUclips, where actual professionals in a field watch RUclipsrs and their videos about it. My introduction to it was an economist and small business owner reacting to Brian David Gilbert's video about making $20,000 dollars a month which, spoiler alert, was a horror sketch based off of a modern adaptation of Dorian Grey. I can't wait to see this sub genre evolve and adapt.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
The thing that separates good "x reacts" videos from bad ones is how much insight the professionals can give. I love how you were able to find interesting talking points and ways to educate about robotic surgery. Excellent job!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
goodness this was hilarious chaos. I had never heard of him, but Michael is brilliant! (though not gonna lie, I spent half of the video terrified that the knife was gonna accidentally impale someone and the fake blood was not my thing.) I'm not normally into reaction videos but yours are great--offering interesting info but letting things just be funny, too. and also: your hoodie at the end--- thanks. I'd appreciate seeing it any time but especially this week
@@thehwguy4293 An outsider who's never seen michael before would be so confused at these comments 🤣 "soo.. he's like a nerdy robotics specialist... But he also does boxing? And.. he's clearly very funny.. Who *IS* this guy?"
oh wow, I didn't even know that Michael kinda knows his stuff, I thought he was just making a funny video but now I realized he's highlighting legit problems and suggesting some solutions for them although still not usable but at least it's a good start to a brainstorming process that could actually bring a potential usable solution! Totally EPIC !
@@kareemelabkary7611 He is part of a content creator group known as Offline TV, They did a challenge to build a boat there were three teams with three people in each.. They placed michael in his own team for fear that he could create a working nuclear powered aircraft carrier with help..
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
I love seeing people watching Micheal Reeves for the first time. It always starts with "oh that's cool, I wonder how he's gunna make it better" and then he attaches tasers or knives to it
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
I like that he’s able to see the funny and comedic side of Michael and then also see the genuine improvements he’s tried to show in the video, w surgeon
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
This is a really great video and I'm glad you didn't take it seriously and shared your opinion and knowledge knowing what it was all about. I'm surprised you don't have more subscribers than the other people I've seen doing videos like this.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
FDA on cigarettes, which are basically 100% guaranteed to kill you via several different methods due to the thousands of various toxins and carcinogens in cigarette smoke: "Yeah, not a huge deal. Just make sure people are 18, let people know they may get cancer, but allow them to make their own choices on whether or not they think it's worth the risk." FDA on vaping, which exponentially reduces the amount of chemicals people are exposed to, is clinically proven to reduce a smokers reliance on much more dangerous combustible tobacco, and the 3 main chemical components have been used and studied in both the medical industry and food industry for 70+ years: "Oh my god, regulate EVERYTHING. Don't even give people a choice. Ban flavors, make entering the market prohibitively expensive and so complicated that only wealthy corporations can afford it, smear the reputation of innovative and even safer devices with flawed and biased testing methodologies to crucify them in the public eye. Do everything you can to get this stuff off the streets, it is the downfall of humanity and all that is good!" Yeah, FDA is literal clown-shoes and their constant multifaceted attack on the vaping industry is a perfect example that their credibility and motives are extremely questionable.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
From an engineering point of view, a major portion of the cost of a robot like the DaVinci is how much time and effort they've put into making the controls and the machine's articulations match with the hand motions surgeons already know. Which is great for letting existing surgeons work remotely without adding too much additional training to their already busy schedules. At the same time though, a robot which departs from that can also depart from the limitations of the human hand. You can see this in some of the industrial robots now in use, where they have multiple articulations that can bend and move in ways that a hand never could and so can do things which an unassisted human would have severe trouble with. The next level evolution of the technology will be to go from replicating the performance of a surgeon at the table to improving upon it. Ever wish you had an extra hand? You could. There's probably a place for "canned cycles" as well, where the surgeon lines it up and then lets the machine do one, routine thing while continuing on with the bits that require human judgement. This, however would require training and developing one's surgical skills on the machine specifically, which reduces flexibility later. The visual hand tracking has some advantages, but... I'm hardly a surgeon, but I've sutured a wound or two in my life (mostly on animals), and I really, really wouldn't want to attempt it robotically without some amount of tactile feedback. There are technologies on the horizon that can do that via ultrasound, but they're so expensive as to totally defeat the purpose of trying to build a cheaper robot.
Considering in addition to the HMI that the requirement that everything in an operating theater has to be able to be sterilized and medical equipment engineering (like nuclear engineering and aviation engineering) requires the most strict levels of failure mode analysis and design: $2,000,000 seems reasonable and almost cheap given the amount of investment required and market size.
@@cholesterol6703 Although, I'll tell you from my experience with the insulin pump industry that it's fairly likely that a bunch of that probably just goes to an expensive insurance policy to cover the liability of a failure, rather than into actual engineering to prevent failures.
In order to use the unit in a hospital setting the surgeon is required to pass extensive training in order to be approved! There are surgeons who have not able to complete that training and pass the tests!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
16:20 That is a pretty good line. But also, I'm not a medical pro, but I've heard from EMTs and first-aid trainers that if you have a knife or arrow (or other penetrator) in the body, you leave it in so the hole stays somewhat plugged-up. This helps prevent bleed-out while the patient is waiting for surgery to fix the hole.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
the best part of anyone reacting to micheal is the slow slow breakdown realizing its not a serious project but the attempts of the reactor to keep believing hes serious knowing he isnt
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
At 11:46 he says "oh no" and thats when the video turned around lol Michael is super funny and talented I liked the reactions to it and the doctors aspect of what could be useful features.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Youre a breath of fresh air. A lot of doctors reacts to this video by bullying or taking it too seriously that they fail to see the genius behind michael’s “robot”. Obviously the video is satyr but it shows how smart the guy is. Thanks so much doc for being chill and actually providing insights.
Obviously a lot needs to be fine tuned, but from what a father of my friend, who has been working in different surgery jobs (I don't know specifics, I'm sure he told me at some point, lol) for about 40 years, said after seeing this, if you added two more points of movement it could actually work as a prototype for a serious surgery robot.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Well the thing about the way he steers the robot is that light-based sensors obviously can bug/misread and even the smallest misread can move say a scalpel a millimeter or centimeter into a direction it shouldn't go. Also with the controls of the DaVinci robot, if you aren't moving the control interface, the thing isn't going to move and you can be methodical about things. But the motion sensor activates as soon as it gets a read and then doesn't stop reading and controlling the arm until it doesn't have a read anymore. That could be changed, but just due to the clear advantage in reliability and precision the controller of the davinci robot is better for the task.
As a trauma surgeon, I can't imagine what you were thinking while he was climbing into the path of the high speed motion controlled kitchen knife. "See you soon", maybe?
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Despite the fact that Michael's design is basically one giant shitpost, you actually gave me quite a bit of insight on this video since I watched it when it came out. Made me realize that, somehow, Michale was actually onto something xD But no seriously, with what little patience he has, it's amazing to see what he managed to create in such a short timespan. I can't help but wonder if his idea, with some more thought and work put into it, could actually be better than what Intuitive made? Idk, just a random insight I had. Great video and great reaction tho!
Given the content of the rest of Michael Reeve's channel (perfect serial killer name) I'm fairly sure we are all witnessing the first draft of him birthing the terminator robots that will kill us all.
What makes you think he doesn't have patience? Have you ever created something like this? It takes patience, and creativity to translate this to the real world! Let alone make it interesting and fun to digest in lay men terms! Wtf u talking about
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
i can see how both the davinci machine and michael's creation can be used together. The 3D vr thing can help with proper wrist movements to the patient where it would have to be more toned to be able to have less latency and such, and having the elevated limbs can help with moving the machine out in cases of emergency. As well as moving the machine to a different part of the patient.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
"Plug the hole with the knife" is honestly an underrated line from this video, it's one of my favorites. Right up there with it is "just a small incision" as he's dragging the impaled pineapple around the table.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
I don't know how I found this video, but as someone who watched everything michael does religiously, watching someone experience his madness for the first time was incredible.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
I watched the original video the day it came out and watching your reaction made it even more enjoyable🤣🥰 I really love to see expert feedback on mechanical systems and appreciated you appreciating his humor. You’ve earned a new subscriber (:
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text //
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
the craziest thing is that with some R&D and improvements on this it could turn out to be an actually pretty good surgical robot. this is like, the skeleton of a good surgical robot, now it just needs to be less jerky and not kill people
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Wrapping up surgical crit care fellowship now! But I’ve been moonlighting as a trauma surgeon at another hospital in the interim. And congrats!!! So excited for you!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
7:30 Doctor: "I'm interested to see what he does, how he improves. Elbow mechanisms are cool and complicated" Me, having already seen the robot: "Oh doctor, you're so innocent"
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text /////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
@@DavidHindin Trust me.. Not once did you overestimate Michael.. He Built this machine as a giant joke. I guarantee he could build something similar and just as safe as a Davinci given enough time
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
I have seen hes robot before and i gotta say its hillarious to se this Surgeon go so in to detail about the ide without knowing how it will turn out in the end.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text /////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text /////
I really like how Dr. Hindin explains things so clearly and concisely. He also has a good sense of humor which makes his videos very enjoyable. Keep making more of them, Doc!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
Reeves video here is one of the most fuckin hilarious things I’ve ever watched in my life . The fuckin knife just flying around is hilarious . But being serious obviously his final product isn’t gonna he what surgeons use but he’s put forth ideas that could absolutely be great in medical advancements in the future
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
My cousins the head surgeon on a haematology ward in a capital city and I absolutely love seeing him every time to hear about new medical science stuff. I even recognise the terms docking he also used to explain how they do things. He says training on a robot is aids. Because a lot of what they’ve learned almost vanishes. I love his so much.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
never seen your channel, I'm a fan of Reeves but you popped up on my recommended. Glad I found you it's cool to hear your perspective on something like that.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
the thing about this robot is that it actually have potential to be great, but then it's made by Michael Reeves and it went to crap the moment he got the knife
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ///
3:42 as an engineer i can confirm you that all the mobile parts in robot are in general DC motors like this one, maybe with particular voltajes but all the same in the basic.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember. Transitory life.. -is the translated text ////
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
*Got a request for a future reaction video? Lmk!*
First reply?
Scrubs! 😁
@@pedrovfn if you're in I'm in!! haha :)
@@-Dexr you win! haha
william osman's - Built my own x ray machine after a hospital charged me $69210.32 is one you might find interesting
I love how he actually keeps believing Michael is going to make something reasonable 😂
well the robot being able to move an a x and y axis is actually a really good idea like he said and if he actually wanted to "invent" robots with practical uses or something i feel like he's fully capable of it. but youre right its Michael hes not gonna do that
@@Hoochibaba I also think he is capable, but we all know how it usually goes.
@@temanor yep.
Michael did earn $$$ from a goldfish.
@@temanor I know about Michael but not a full ton so gotta ask: how does it usually go? I know that he's a mad scientist of RUclips esp with his beer piss robot dog that's for sure but still, what usually happens exactly? And how come Michael doesn't fully invent robots with practical uses like what's stopping him frfom doing so? Like it'd be cool to have a RUclipsr Tony Stark so how come he isn't doing it then?
"the arms which we might see later" Sir i think you severely over-estimate the level of Michael's patience when he designs these things.
😂 you’re right, I was unprepared
To be fair, the dude started making some good points about how to improve it, but then just went into good old goblin mode, i guess You can't make significant advancements in both medícine and robótics in 6weeks for a haha RUclips video
It seems you didn't listen Nix, the arms were clearly the design fault from the overpriced DaVinci robot!
@@Niklastard ah shoot he did say that.
yes the patience, because i believe 100% he could do something way better, but is not the objective, and who are we lying to? if it was a real surgery robot and none of the jokes, he would not be his channel
"You never want the robot to be able to attack the patient." Classic. Banger of a video.
haha thank you! So glad you liked it!
@@DavidHindin I think any surgery robot would necessarily have the ability to "attack the patient" if used ineptly or maliciously. You are manipulating and cutting into flesh, arteries, and vital organs.
Meanwhile Michael makes a robot that ONLY attacks the patient XD
he's almost a real life Doofenschmirtz or whatever hahaa
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
It’s at the knife moment this man realizes what’s off and that Michael is an intelligent lunatic. 😂
lol it’s true 😂😂
I just wonder if he did the work or other people idd it for him........ seriously when he was trying to get the head off i was wondering if he would be needing a surgery robot when it chopped his arm off....... well or cut it pretty bad.
Cringe watching him be so unsafe
@@johndorian4078 Nah he does it himself. Have you seen his other videos? I can't name too many where he's being "safe" lol
@@johndorian4078 he does it himself, as for the safety aspect, Michael Reeves is actually on the safer side compared to other channels lmao
@@Dell-ol6hb styropyro has entered the chat
Michael Reeves is like the Chaotic Evil of science RUclipsrs and I'm so happy to see a surgeon react to him because when I first saw this video like a year ago, I thought it was hilarious. Thanks Dr Hindin!
So glad you liked it! And yes - he's brilliant and hilarious
The most chaotic science and engineering youtubers. Michael Reeves, Electroboom, Styropyro, nile red and Explosions and fire.
Maybe not the most chaotic but I love them nonetheless
You know, I'd like to think that Michael is chaotic good... but yeah, he's pretty crazy! XD
I feel like he'd be more chaotic neutral lol, he'd either make a machine than can fix everything or a handheld electric chair, whichever's more fun😂
Ooo
Pointing out the positives on the engineering part and understanding the chaotic and dark humor of someone combined with actual interesting information made this video a well spend moment on RUclips for me.
Thnx for that.
Thank you so much Wilbert - that's one of the nicest comments I've ever received here! :)
@@DavidHindin , you're welcome. Your video showed up on my list for some reason and I think I'll have to stick around for a while. Just in case.
@@DavidHindin I almost never like reaction content; but this video is definitely an exception.
what part of that was dark humor at all stg people just throw those words around
Plug the hole with the knife
So using the DaVinci robot is like you're role-playing as the rat from ratatouille got it
Lol this comment literally blew my mind
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Highly underrated comment!
:DDD
Yeah but reverse... like the guy controling the mouse?
Remy...his name is Remy
I feel like this video was the perfect mixture of talking about the serious and educational part of the process and at the same time understanding and appreciating the joke, great reaction
You should watch Dr Mike asap!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
Mot an electronics "expert", but as a hobbyist 3d printer/cnc guy and professional IT guy I can confirm what he said about the motors is true. A regular brushless DC motor can run real fast, but is unable to tell how much it has rotated due to the fact its a rather "dumb" piece of electronics. it's just some magnets and copper wire. Adding a driver board that can measure how much it turns is how you make servo motors, which are motors that can tell how much they have rotated using additional electronics. It's an old trick for DIY CNC mills if you don't want to shell thousands of dollars for a high quality servo motor ecosystem.
Really interesting- thanks so much for explaining this Jared!
"Freaking magnets, how do I work?" -Brushless Motors, probably
I have no idea what you just said but I'm gonna like your comment anyway
@@Thenoobestgirl agreed ☺️
that's what stepper motors are for...
I like how he starts the reaction kinda taking Michael seriously and then it slowly settles in that the whole thing is just an over-engineered meme.
I didn't realise that until I read the comments.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
I think it was halfway through when I realized he actually expected an actual surgery robot.
He still addresses legit issues, and the doctor recognized that.
im high so i just realized when i read your comment lol
@@un1qu3n4m3 I did realize when I read his comment too. But Im not high im dumb
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
Michael Reeves represents why I went into engineering and he continues to be an inspiration for me and all of my engineering friends. The man is brilliant and like any true engineer has the skills and the determination to bring any and all of his ideas, no matter how dumb or ill-conceived, into the real world. And once he makes his dreams a reality, the chaotic gremlin of a human being does whatever the fuck he wants with them. We could all take a page out of Michael's book.
Love this.
If he’s so smart he should have a better vocabulary.
@@sophiabeatty3270 that's a very interesting view on intelligence.
@@sophiabeatty3270 that’s the same as “if Stephen Hawkins is so smart, he should just invent something to stand up”
@@sophiabeatty3270 you do get that Michel is doing funny videos for mostly teenagers right?
The funniest thing is he actually envisioned a genuine improvement from the ground up for surgical robots even if he turned it into a meme at the end lol
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
This video was like 10 times funnier having a surgeon react to it i actually died watching this
lol glad you enjoyed it and sorry to hear you have passed away 💀 😂
@@DavidHindin imfao
F
I'd recommend a surgeon if it isn't too late to save ya. Dr. Hindin, you got some time?
@@johnathanpetreman6701 I think at this point, we're well beyond the realms of medicine.
got any necromancers on speed-dial?
Absolutely loving that he takes it seriously for so long
lol I may have missed the memo 😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
Bro did this all in 2 months by himself, basically not possible for anyone else tbh. Very few people could achieve this in that amount of time.
he’s seriously brilliant
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
"you never want the robot to be able to attack the patient" oh hes not prepared for michael
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
"I'm interested to see whether this way of controlling it is going to be even more intuitive and easy to use"
Yeah, about that....
Lol I was unprepared for what was to come 😂
@@DavidHindin Don't worry.. None of us are, when it comes to Michael Reeves videos..
to be fair, a hand tracker will never surpass physical controllers because it cannot give tactile feedback, which is incredibly important for precise movements
Maybe he should have used suped up wiimotes
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
Funny enough, he's not formally trained like.... at all. Pretty much everything he knows he learned from RUclips and personal research. Smart as hell, no filter, and entertaining for days.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
@@Liex09 what are you on about? What did that have to do with anything? 😆
@@Liex09hold my sleep drug😂
Im p-sure he actually got a bachelors in programming
@aiapihud4344 he said in an interview he attended a bunch of college lectures (snuck into the lecture halls) and learned as much as he could without having to buy the degree paper. So unofficially speaking, I guess you're right in a way 😆
15:26 As an undergrad I worked on this laparoscopic AR system, it was totally running late, the phd student whose thesis it was was stressed out and depressed, and then we had some surgeon come in to test it. The surgeon loved it! He was most impressed with some feature that got thrown in as a gimmick, where you could see the percentage of the liver volume left if you removed a piece using the ultrasound probe as a virtual knife. He said he'd use that immediately. Definitely always test it with the actual user, not just developers.
That sounds really cool. How were you able to get the liver volume to begin with? Was it input to your machine from separate tests done prior to the surgery? How did you measure the removed piece of liver?
@Nell S We had the surface of the liver along with its internal vascular system that were segmented out of a crt or mri scan which would have been done prior to the surgery.
@Nell S the volume was computed based on the 3d model and the ultrasound probe was tracked live in 3d for the AR features already, where the ultrasound image was rendered into the view too. You can imagine the tool and the ultrasound image looking a bit like a giant key. Extend the ultrasound image into an infinite plane, use that to "cut" the virtual liver in two, then compute the volume of one of the pieces and display that to the surgeon.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I love how he keeps treating Micheal like he’s actually making a useable surgery robot
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
You could actually use Michaels machine as a mount for the Da Vinci robot which would solve the range problem and also make it easier to move if something goes wrong.
Michael only needs to make it a bit more precised, for example making it so you could input the coordinates to where C.U.M would be located.
i mean it looks like it uses coords when he was using the mouse so i dont imagine its hard to do
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text
I'm loving this sub genre of RUclips, where actual professionals in a field watch RUclipsrs and their videos about it. My introduction to it was an economist and small business owner reacting to Brian David Gilbert's video about making $20,000 dollars a month which, spoiler alert, was a horror sketch based off of a modern adaptation of Dorian Grey. I can't wait to see this sub genre evolve and adapt.
So glad you liked it - thx Conner!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
The thing that separates good "x reacts" videos from bad ones is how much insight the professionals can give. I love how you were able to find interesting talking points and ways to educate about robotic surgery.
Excellent job!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I really enjoyed how you kept trying to bring Michael's ideas back to reality even though he hasn't visited reality in years.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
OMG this guy is amazing! How clever is he! Great reaction video. Hope more vids are coming soon! 😊
Totally - he’s brilliant. And thanks so much! Working on more as I write this☺️
Oh god, your name...truly unfortunate it starts with an H 😅
@@yay292 ?
@@glowiedetector Ever heard of Amber Heard?
@@yay292 i thought you were talking to dr hindin so i was confused hahaha didnt see she was called amber h
goodness this was hilarious chaos. I had never heard of him, but Michael is brilliant! (though not gonna lie, I spent half of the video terrified that the knife was gonna accidentally impale someone and the fake blood was not my thing.) I'm not normally into reaction videos but yours are great--offering interesting info but letting things just be funny, too.
and also: your hoodie at the end--- thanks. I'd appreciate seeing it any time but especially this week
He's got some other great videos that you should check out too
You should also check out his boxing ability.
@@thehwguy4293 An outsider who's never seen michael before would be so confused at these comments 🤣 "soo.. he's like a nerdy robotics specialist... But he also does boxing? And.. he's clearly very funny.. Who *IS* this guy?"
He made a dog piss beer too!
That man knows no fear man, he tased himself and his friends so many times its unbelievable how he has a social life
oh wow, I didn't even know that Michael kinda knows his stuff, I thought he was just making a funny video but now I realized he's highlighting legit problems and suggesting some solutions for them although still not usable but at least it's a good start to a brainstorming process that could actually bring a potential usable solution!
Totally EPIC !
Trust me bro. If he wanted to he could make something better than the Da Vinci.. I am 100% serious. People should fear this man
@@SysKeyJS I know right!
not to mention the fact that he's doing all this on a low budget!
@@kareemelabkary7611 He is part of a content creator group known as Offline TV, They did a challenge to build a boat there were three teams with three people in each.. They placed michael in his own team for fear that he could create a working nuclear powered aircraft carrier with help..
@@SysKeyJS lol it's a legitimate concern 😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I love seeing people watching Micheal Reeves for the first time. It always starts with "oh that's cool, I wonder how he's gunna make it better" and then he attaches tasers or knives to it
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
0:15 you don't find Michael Reeves...he finds you
"I'm curious how he'll make it even better."
At this point I was like "Michael doesn't do better. He does more chaotic." ^^
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I like that he’s able to see the funny and comedic side of Michael and then also see the genuine improvements he’s tried to show in the video, w surgeon
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
This is a really great video and I'm glad you didn't take it seriously and shared your opinion and knowledge knowing what it was all about. I'm surprised you don't have more subscribers than the other people I've seen doing videos like this.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I think my favorite part is
"You may be wondering, is it FDA approved?
"
probbaly is considering dangerous shit allowed and safe shit not.
FDA on cigarettes, which are basically 100% guaranteed to kill you via several different methods due to the thousands of various toxins and carcinogens in cigarette smoke: "Yeah, not a huge deal. Just make sure people are 18, let people know they may get cancer, but allow them to make their own choices on whether or not they think it's worth the risk."
FDA on vaping, which exponentially reduces the amount of chemicals people are exposed to, is clinically proven to reduce a smokers reliance on much more dangerous combustible tobacco, and the 3 main chemical components have been used and studied in both the medical industry and food industry for 70+ years: "Oh my god, regulate EVERYTHING. Don't even give people a choice. Ban flavors, make entering the market prohibitively expensive and so complicated that only wealthy corporations can afford it, smear the reputation of innovative and even safer devices with flawed and biased testing methodologies to crucify them in the public eye. Do everything you can to get this stuff off the streets, it is the downfall of humanity and all that is good!"
Yeah, FDA is literal clown-shoes and their constant multifaceted attack on the vaping industry is a perfect example that their credibility and motives are extremely questionable.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
From an engineering point of view, a major portion of the cost of a robot like the DaVinci is how much time and effort they've put into making the controls and the machine's articulations match with the hand motions surgeons already know.
Which is great for letting existing surgeons work remotely without adding too much additional training to their already busy schedules.
At the same time though, a robot which departs from that can also depart from the limitations of the human hand. You can see this in some of the industrial robots now in use, where they have multiple articulations that can bend and move in ways that a hand never could and so can do things which an unassisted human would have severe trouble with.
The next level evolution of the technology will be to go from replicating the performance of a surgeon at the table to improving upon it. Ever wish you had an extra hand? You could. There's probably a place for "canned cycles" as well, where the surgeon lines it up and then lets the machine do one, routine thing while continuing on with the bits that require human judgement.
This, however would require training and developing one's surgical skills on the machine specifically, which reduces flexibility later.
The visual hand tracking has some advantages, but... I'm hardly a surgeon, but I've sutured a wound or two in my life (mostly on animals), and I really, really wouldn't want to attempt it robotically without some amount of tactile feedback. There are technologies on the horizon that can do that via ultrasound, but they're so expensive as to totally defeat the purpose of trying to build a cheaper robot.
Considering in addition to the HMI that the requirement that everything in an operating theater has to be able to be sterilized and medical equipment engineering (like nuclear engineering and aviation engineering) requires the most strict levels of failure mode analysis and design: $2,000,000 seems reasonable and almost cheap given the amount of investment required and market size.
@@cholesterol6703 Although, I'll tell you from my experience with the insulin pump industry that it's fairly likely that a bunch of that probably just goes to an expensive insurance policy to cover the liability of a failure, rather than into actual engineering to prevent failures.
In order to use the unit in a hospital setting the surgeon is required to pass extensive training in order to be approved! There are surgeons who have not able to complete that training and pass the tests!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
13:23 BRUH HE EDITED OUT THE COMEDIC SILENCE
😂😂🙊🙊😂😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
16:20 That is a pretty good line. But also, I'm not a medical pro, but I've heard from EMTs and first-aid trainers that if you have a knife or arrow (or other penetrator) in the body, you leave it in so the hole stays somewhat plugged-up. This helps prevent bleed-out while the patient is waiting for surgery to fix the hole.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
a genius idea and you can see the precise moment when it descends into madness
🙃😂🙃
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I love the informative side of this video, makes it feel more than just a react video, it's educational. Thank you for the wonderful video
Thank you so much!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
the best part of anyone reacting to micheal is the slow slow breakdown realizing its not a serious project but the attempts of the reactor to keep believing hes serious knowing he isnt
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
At 11:46 he says "oh no" and thats when the video turned around lol Michael is super funny and talented I liked the reactions to it and the doctors aspect of what could be useful features.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
"Small incision above the ear"
*kills patient*
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
Youre a breath of fresh air. A lot of doctors reacts to this video by bullying or taking it too seriously that they fail to see the genius behind michael’s “robot”. Obviously the video is satyr but it shows how smart the guy is. Thanks so much doc for being chill and actually providing insights.
Obviously a lot needs to be fine tuned, but from what a father of my friend, who has been working in different surgery jobs (I don't know specifics, I'm sure he told me at some point, lol) for about 40 years, said after seeing this, if you added two more points of movement it could actually work as a prototype for a serious surgery robot.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
7:10 "what he's talking about is actually a real challenge"
At least someone said it. Thanks doc.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
You're an asset to humanity doc, keep it up!!
That is so incredibly kind of you - thank you!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
Well the thing about the way he steers the robot is that light-based sensors obviously can bug/misread and even the smallest misread can move say a scalpel a millimeter or centimeter into a direction it shouldn't go. Also with the controls of the DaVinci robot, if you aren't moving the control interface, the thing isn't going to move and you can be methodical about things. But the motion sensor activates as soon as it gets a read and then doesn't stop reading and controlling the arm until it doesn't have a read anymore. That could be changed, but just due to the clear advantage in reliability and precision the controller of the davinci robot is better for the task.
As a trauma surgeon, I can't imagine what you were thinking while he was climbing into the path of the high speed motion controlled kitchen knife. "See you soon", maybe?
Sounds about right 😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
7:10 to 7:45 I'm sorry but your words used with his acronym..Chefs kiss👌.. That was gold 😂😂😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
Despite the fact that Michael's design is basically one giant shitpost, you actually gave me quite a bit of insight on this video since I watched it when it came out. Made me realize that, somehow, Michale was actually onto something xD
But no seriously, with what little patience he has, it's amazing to see what he managed to create in such a short timespan. I can't help but wonder if his idea, with some more thought and work put into it, could actually be better than what Intuitive made? Idk, just a random insight I had. Great video and great reaction tho!
Given the content of the rest of Michael Reeve's channel (perfect serial killer name) I'm fairly sure we are all witnessing the first draft of him birthing the terminator robots that will kill us all.
What makes you think he doesn't have patience? Have you ever created something like this? It takes patience, and creativity to translate this to the real world! Let alone make it interesting and fun to digest in lay men terms!
Wtf u talking about
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I like how you actually talk about machines in the medical industry and making connections to Michael's build.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
i can see how both the davinci machine and michael's creation can be used together. The 3D vr thing can help with proper wrist movements to the patient where it would have to be more toned to be able to have less latency and such, and having the elevated limbs can help with moving the machine out in cases of emergency. As well as moving the machine to a different part of the patient.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
The sincerity of this review at all stages is awesome. Thanks for adding your commentary to the original video.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
13:33 I love how medical professionals have the same hand movement
It's the "I've heard too many lectures" move.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
"Plug the hole with the knife" is honestly an underrated line from this video, it's one of my favorites. Right up there with it is "just a small incision" as he's dragging the impaled pineapple around the table.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
7:43 at this point I realized he really hasn’t watched any of Micheal’s vids before.
I don't know how I found this video, but as someone who watched everything michael does religiously, watching someone experience his madness for the first time was incredible.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
@@Liex09 Cringe.
I'm so glad a surgeon with an actual sense of humor has seen this video
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
Its pretty fascinating to see the actual realism behind videos like this, good watch.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
I watched the original video the day it came out and watching your reaction made it even more enjoyable🤣🥰 I really love to see expert feedback on mechanical systems and appreciated you appreciating his humor. You’ve earned a new subscriber (:
so happy to hear that - thanks!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
Michael is such a smart person if he actually wanted to he could probably make a surgery robot that would work really good
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Really good mix of enjoying the chaos and sharing actual information
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text //
Surgeon reacts to a maniac who clearly doesn't understand surgery building a robot. 10/10 hahaha
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
Michael Reeves is an agent of chaos.
One of the most insane and funny RUclipsrs I've seen.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Yeah plug the hole with the knife was one of the best quotes of the video!
Seriously!! 😂😳
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
5:20 “never want the robot to attack the patient” man do I have some news for you boss
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
I love reactions that actually add really good and new information. Thank you for your insight! I learned some stuff today
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Just love how calm he is while Michael builds a killing machine
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
the craziest thing is that with some R&D and improvements on this it could turn out to be an actually pretty good surgical robot. this is like, the skeleton of a good surgical robot, now it just needs to be less jerky and not kill people
All I'm thinking while hearing all your amazing insight and genuine curiosity, is the freakin' chaos that is gonna ensue when it is finished.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
One of my favourite videos on this platform! Thank you David! And Michael of course :D
This made my day - thank you!!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
Great reaction video! I like how you continuously provided an expert opinion whilst not being so offended professionally over the ridiculousness
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Didn’t know you did a trauma fellowship! I just graduated and start EM residency in July. Time flies!
Wrapping up surgical crit care fellowship now! But I’ve been moonlighting as a trauma surgeon at another hospital in the interim. And congrats!!! So excited for you!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Us: Are you going to power it with your hand?
Reeves: No idiot. Motor.
Us: So, you'll move it with a controller?
Reeves: No idiot. Hand.
7:30 Doctor: "I'm interested to see what he does, how he improves. Elbow mechanisms are cool and complicated"
Me, having already seen the robot: "Oh doctor, you're so innocent"
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text /////
I like your take in here understanding the joke and the build up for intellectuals and explain it for a bigger audience to understand
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Having seen the original video before, watching this was hilarious seeing you overestimate what Michael will do so much
I somehow never got the michael reeves memo 😂
@@DavidHindin Trust me.. Not once did you overestimate Michael.. He Built this machine as a giant joke. I guarantee he could build something similar and just as safe as a Davinci given enough time
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
I have seen hes robot before and i gotta say its hillarious to se this Surgeon go so in to detail about the ide without knowing how it will turn out in the end.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
The amount of pure JOY this vide brought me .... is beyond compare.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text /////
"I can't speak to the electronics, I'm not an engineer."
Sure doesn't stop anybody else on youtube, lol.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Hilarious. But also nerve recking everytime he reached in while the machine was still on with the knife attached
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
I find it hilarious how he’s taking this machine seriously
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
Literally crying laughing. This guy is brilliant, but this is so funny!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
6:34 "i wonder how he's going to add to it, make it better"
he's going to ducktape a fucking knife
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text /////
I really like how Dr. Hindin explains things so clearly and concisely. He also has a good sense of humor which makes his videos very enjoyable. Keep making more of them, Doc!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
I always love seeing reactions to videos I already enjoy by people who actually know what they're talking about and explain how everything works.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
this is one of the only reaction videos Ive seen that adds something useful to the original video. props to you
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
Reeves video here is one of the most fuckin hilarious things I’ve ever watched in my life . The fuckin knife just flying around is hilarious . But being serious obviously his final product isn’t gonna he what surgeons use but he’s put forth ideas that could absolutely be great in medical advancements in the future
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
This guy looks like the surgeon version of pleasant green. Just an overall chill, wholesome vibe and a knack for storytelling.
This is the best reaction video I’ve ever seen you actually pause the video to talk about the video I love it and Michael Reeves is hilarious
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////
My cousins the head surgeon on a haematology ward in a capital city and I absolutely love seeing him every time to hear about new medical science stuff. I even recognise the terms docking he also used to explain how they do things. He says training on a robot is aids. Because a lot of what they’ve learned almost vanishes. I love his so much.
So funny how you missed the part when he said "Carriage Utility Mechanism" at 7:10 hahahaha you didnt get it 😆
… or maybe I try to keep this channel family-friendly ;)
@@DavidHindin Hahaha I see. Although Michael Reeves is the supreme antithesis of "family friendly" xP
I gotta say, as common as react videos are, your style is original
That means a lot to me - thanks so much!
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
never seen your channel, I'm a fan of Reeves but you popped up on my recommended. Glad I found you it's cool to hear your perspective on something like that.
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
the thing about this robot is that it actually have potential to be great, but then it's made by Michael Reeves and it went to crap the moment he got the knife
I like how he actually expected Michael to make a "real" surgery robot
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ///
what
3:42 as an engineer i can confirm you that all the mobile parts in robot are in general DC motors like this one, maybe with particular voltajes but all the same in the basic.
16:46 [Michael just displayed gory homicide on a dummy patient]
Doctor: Wow this guy is brilliant
HES REALLY GOOD
I absolutely love how he's trying so so so hard to actually take Michael seriously 😂😂
yeah… I somehow didn’t get the memo 😂😂
Everything exists with its opposite, we must remember death so that we can understand the value of life, seek to live life correctly and beautifully and prepare for death in the best way. Sometimes we must remember.
Transitory life..
-is the translated text ////