EDH VS cEDH | Magic the Gathering Commander Comedy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024
- I make a bear token with Bearscape.
Need gaming supplies? Use my affiliate links for Dragon Shield to support the channel!
North America: www.dragonshie...
Europe: www.dragonshie...
Follow me on Twitter! @Dave8th / dave8th
And also Instagram! / 8thplacedave
If you would like to support the channel, my Patreon is here: / 8thplacedave
Come join my discord server here: / discord
For inquiries, send emails to: dave8thcontact@gmail.com
#mtg #edh #comedy #magic #commander #cedh
Music:
Silly Fun by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons... 
Игры
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HiCxoDeo0hc/mqdefault.jpg)
Aside from the accuracy, what makes this spectacular is your choice to win on turn 0 WHEN IT'S NOT YOUR TURN. lmao
Right the power of #flash
@@raalo7136 flash is banned
@@fenixmeaney6170 Yeah but thats why it's banned.
Leyline of Anticipation gives all of your spells Flash
@@nintendo917 Flash the card, not the keyword in this case ;)
Doesn't dig deep enough with Ad Naus to get counterspell back-up and gets his Consultation countered by Mental Misstep.
The heart of the cards will guide me through this. I don't need counterspells when I have friends!
You're right, really big misplay. Turn 0 Ad Naus? No reason not to go until you're at 9. Save 2 life to cast misstep, 1 for FoW, 2 for probe, and 4 spare incase opponents have gut shot. Then your consult/probe are protected from multiple missteps.
@@SporeGalacticCreator I need to get better at this.
@@SporeGalacticCreator No reason to not go until you're at 4, to be honest. Gotta believe in the heart of the cards. If you hit your Peer, well, the cards did not love you
@@8thPlaceDave Jokes on you, there are no friends in cEDH
The lack of Humility made me laugh loud enough to wake the neighbors!
You know he's a casual cedhEr though, he didn't name abandon hope
Now we say “You Are Already Dead”
@@zertamtg1334 Soon we can name You are Already Dead ;3
Balance is good card name. But it is baned.
Moderation would have been a good name here also.
I freaking love they did all that in response to their opponent's first land.
Also, don't know if this was on purpose, but love the fact the cEDH player essentially said they don't have any humility.
It was on purpose ;)
Actually didn’t have priority there *
@@johnweinhandl8890 If you want to get technical, both players had not agreed to move past the first player's upkeep. That's why the combo player had to stop their opponent from assuming it was okay to play a land.
@@8thPlaceDave Necessary for the bit but I think Leyline counts as a pre-game action so in normal circumstances people would know what's up.
Also really can't think of a cEDH deck that would play Leyline of Anticipation for any reason other than the joke.
Also missed opportunity for force of negation on Gitaxian probe into implied tableflip endcut.
@@GrimoireM It would have had to be a force of negation into 1 mana removal spell - and then the joke would not be funny anymore.
"Totally worth refinancing my house so I can build this deck" LMAO
;)
Whew boy Dave, you really poked the bears nest with this one.
I poked the Bearscape and a 2/2 bear token came out.
The cEDH part reminds me of the time at the LGS when somebody triggered an infinite combo and then proceeded to spend the next 20 mins iterating through it while everyone else left the table to do something more productive🤣
Happened at the LGS this week in casual pod vs the guy with “extra turn tribal”
The only inaccurate part is that the casual player would probably be the one flexing its expensive cards and the cedh player using a bunch of proxies 🤣
Nah it's fine, he refinanced his home so he could get the real deal cards.
Excellent XD humility is not in this deck XD
I like that part too :P
I'm not sure what I'd enjoy more. Playing the first game, or watching the second.
yeah, but how many times would it be interesting to see the same win con play?
Playing the first game would be it for me. The rushes of adrenaline that happen between a good commander game versus just watching someone destroy the table with their absolutely insane deck and luck really hits only once. Now, in a "true" cEDH game, things would go very different because of free counterspells, so.
Love the 2nd game, Just reshuffle and tru again. The first game feels like a drag to me
i love it when the pod is still ramping while im already set to go off..no kitchentable tricks and all business
If it really was cEDH that dude would need to have had counters for at least three Force of Wills
Haha, thats true because its easy to stop the co- (recordscratch) wait, three?
@@aldenret Force of will, Force of Negation, Mental Misstep for sol ring and if some1 plays mono blue they could throw in a foil^^
Oh yeah, i had forgotten about mental misstep. For a moment i was like... Pact of negation? but then you lose! Unless.... (rewatches video)
@@aldenretPact of Negation!!
on my upkeep, with pact of Negation Delayed trigger on the stack: Elvish Spirit Guide, simian Spirit guide, Manamorphose for white black. Cast Angel's Grace
@@moersertrupp you have to have that super secret tech ready you know!
TBH, I would turn 0 'Pact of Negation' his Ad Nauseum just to watch him suffer. Even if I lost the round on my next turn.
Worth it
That is called a "spite play" and is frowned upon in the cEDH community
@@angelagrace8499 Listen, if someone turn 1 gets Mana Crypt, Mana Vault, Sol Ring, Mox Opal, and near unlimited card draw, you have permission to engage "kamikaze mode".
@@HeckaLives in EDH yes, but cEDH is a competetive environment, so no
@@angelagrace8499 screw the cedh community, I have green hair.
As someone who runs a bear tribal, I love you.
Bear Force One!
Gotta have the Forebear's Blade, it's for bears
I would've named Weakness with the Demonic Consultation and say "Weakness does not exist in my deck."
Edit: NO! Even better: Name Fear and say “FEAR DOES NOT EXIST IN THIS DOJO!”
There is a card named "You are already dead" in the new Kamigawa, and it demands to be named.
@@nwstormraider818 The best cards to name are the schemes from Archenemy, which are technically legal card names.
Choice picks include "Dance, Pathetic Marionette", "All Shall Smolder in My Wake", and "My Genius Knows No Bounds"
@@EliteMasterEric The most ironic one would definitely be "My Genius Knows No Bounds" as this is neither an unexpected nor genius T1/T0 win for cEDH. In fact, it's basically super cookie cutter, which makes it even better!
Balance is good name too.
My grandfather's deck doesn't contain weakness, Kaiba!
Morality : be a bear, not a maniac.
What about doing the same but on steroids? Yes, i play sliver. feel free to hate me. I refuse to play inf combo's though...cause those arnt needed.
😏 Can't I be a bear and a maniac simultaneously?
This reminds me too much of my first roomate in college...
Yes, he got me into magic, Yes, he's been playing longer than me, Yes, he's a dungeon master, Yes, he's a GM of a Taco Bell now and Yes, he made multiple "casual decks" like Darevi, Daretti, Feather, AND Animar...
He owns a seven hundred dollar Tuvasa deck...
Green: turn 50? Time flies, I guess.
Blue: Turn 2? What the hell?! This game is too long!
Definitely sending this to my friends 😄 Dude really had to hard flex at turn 0 like there was no tomorrow 😆
I'm sure it's not even the only turn 0 win possible either
This is literally every CEDH gameplay show I've ever watched. Fantastic.
The advantage of winning turn0 is, it's technically not your turn -> Force of Negation is online!
A pub in the next town over hosted commander nights on thursdays, me and my friends didnt know they had commander nights since they had a board game cafe next door and i only had some precons with me and some guy did the Mana Crypt, Sol Ring, Mana Vault, Dimir Signet, Watery Grave first turn
love the vid. Though i feel every edh deck drifts closer and closer to the cEDH event horizon eventually. you could even do a video about an edh player slowly becoming what they hate lol. it happened to me, so im sure its happened to everyone else. that cool Zirda equipment deck becoming artifact combo was inevitable... but its okay because its not tier 1.
That's a pretty good idea ;)
@@8thPlaceDave equipment are artifacts, better pick up a mox opal... well, in for an opal, in for a monolith.
I know what you mean.. My rograkh&ardenn is just close to cedh without the hatebears and mox...
Same with chatterfang, protean hulk line, craterhoof and triumph of the horde. Im just shy to buy earthcraft 😂
This happened with mono black for me, i just loved the deck and kept on tweeking it, and now im just made to feel guilty for playing it.
This is so true. One of my favorite decks is Meren (because Golgari is cool and reanimating Big Stupid Green Things is fun), but I've had it for so long and modified it so much that I now occasionally lock the rest of the table out from having cards in their hand by turn 3 without even trying. Oops...
This is one of the funniest videos I’ve seen in awhile. You definitely deserve a like and subscribe
Thanks, I'm glad you liked it :)
Totally worth refinancing my house!! XD
More like "Casual EDH 2014 vs. 'Casual' EDH 2022"
the fact that this is actually possible just makes me laugh
Ok that gave me a good d laugh, thank you!
"Totally worth refinancing my house..."
hyperbolic yet oddly accurate. not to mention funny. nice job.
Thanks :)
Now you can add that new bearscape secret lair to this deck you winner.
The best thing about this video is that the pain doesn't make it any less funny. Good job, sir.
Thanks ;)
That moment when you get a wincon on someone’s stack 😂😂😂
Man this really makes me want to play CEDH...
Discard a land, not exile :P OMG the last line killed me 🤣🤣🤣🤣
i'm gonna need the decklist on this one, captain.
Came here from reddit. Love your content! Keep up the awesome work!
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it. There is more on the way.
No real cedh player would disagree lol.
Can't argue facts.
the "REPEAT THIS PROCESS" kills me lol
;)
I love that you choose to name "humility" haha the extra layer of irony
Honestly when I play cedh...I just sit back and say: " it looks like you spent alot of time on this and honestly I'm just honored to be apart"
They don’t really spend a lot of time on it. They run the meta
@@jamesgratz4771 the cEDH meta is constantly evolving and people are trying new things all the time, especially if it's a pod and not a blind meta.
The difference between the creativity in cEDH vs EDH isnt any less, it just looks different. Like Turbo AdNaus Sisay Jegantha is super odd but it keeps up with the 'meta' decks
It's a super great format, and the community around it is super chill and helpful
I like that you used all the right cards for it, except you know, nobody plays leyline but its needed for the bit :)
Well now I want the deck list for my life project
It's sad that at my LGS where we play casually I have totally seen some people bring their close to CEDH decks and end up comboing on turn 4 while the rest of us are barely playing our commanders. Anytime I see someone has a Mana Crypt, I know it's gonna be one of those games.
The trick is to say "wow, good win for you. Now, please leave the table, so the rest of us can finish up this game". Nothing better than them waiting for hours until the next game
Lighten up people this is pretty funny!
Had someone literally do this with Emry, Lady of the Loch. Was not having fun -.-
This is literally the local game store I work at.
Would have been funny to see a free counter spell war.
ok but that's like. a dream starting hand
Godo player exiles simian spirit guide, casts lighting bolt
I've played not, and this is pretty damn accurate. Even if it's a total hyperbole.
You forgot the arguments during the EDH game about deck power levels
I like cEDH, because the pods tend to be super chill. But I also like EDH because it satisfies my desire to play a more complicated format. As long as no one tries to jump in a casual pod with a cEDH deck, I'm pretty happy playing commander!
Absolutely zero humidity.
CEDH is fine for those that enjoy it. It's appeal is apparent even to me, tho I could never leave my beloved jank.
Well, you can say that night Himility... was off the table
I'm having fun just *looking* at that turn ??? board state. Is that 6/6 BALDUVIAN BEARS? Oh yeah, it's all coming together.
Yeah gotta watch out for that balduvian bear
Thats hilarious and i would laugh if that actually happened in
a game
Me too :)
ive seen it happen ONCE on turn zero. usually they do it turn 1. I basically just built a deck just like this >.>
based bearscape chad
dude your twiiter bot is just saying random words now
These days, the best way to win with Demonic Consultation is to name Omae Wah Mou Shindeiru
"Humility is not in my library." 🤣
The mythical double digit turn!
Smh my head, didn’t use Thassa’s Oracle. Suboptimal line. Don’t you know that Labman’s an outdated combo piece?
(I’m completely joking this video is gold)
That last line makes me laugh every time
my guy refinanced his house instead of buying a printer 💀
It was easier than trying to get the printer to reliably print
Cedh is just yugioh in magic
That is no banlist cEDH not actual cEDH, everyone is playing to much interaction and is limited by a resource system to actually turn 1 like this
"Humility is NOT in my library!" *SMACK*
Years ago they called me a fool, for using laboratory maniac in ehd.
“But… I didn’t even get to play…”😢
If you want to have some real fun, keep this quiet! Leveler and glimpse of tomorrow; every time I play it some one loses their crap lol.
this is so good! i would definitiv play again!
Thanks :)
I play Pact of Slaughter on your Maniac before Probe Resolves.
Omg bear deck thats awesome
It's one of my favourite decks :)
@@8thPlaceDave could you please share your decklist?
@@gradis13 Sure, maybe I will do a deck tech for it :)
@@gradis13 Here you go again :P Sorry I reuploaded the video ruclips.net/video/GH1DIGZdx9s/видео.html
man youre lucky the opponent didnt have Endurance in their opening hand
Absolutely beautiful!
One is 5 hours and the other is 5 minutes. I wish there was more in between 😭
There kinda is. cEDH with stax decks or being only 90% fine tuned
Inaccurate, doesn't get mental misstepped or force of willed
Ah, a good old turn 0 win. Truly magic as richard garfield intended.
Damn I'm being called out...
Every Edh game is Cedh to me. Daddy didn't come here to have fun, Daddy came here to win!
This was fucking good mate.
Leyline 😬 otherwise pretty accurate lmfao
Need it for the turn 0 though I think
8thPlaceDave you just need a gemstone cavern + crop rotation for emergence zone + simian spirit guide
Then it’s like Necro, activate Necro, let them play out their turn, win in end step
he does deserve to win opening the nuts draw like that and noone having no counters, id call a judge on bribery for that luck
The only thing more powerful then a turn 1 sol ring... a turn 0 sol ring!
nowadays Lab Maniac win con is just done with Thassa's Oracle.
Cheaper overall and wins on the ETB trigger of Thoracle.
And my friends say my decks are bad. Mwha wait until I build my NEW fun deck!
refinance? nah bro just proxy everything. best way to play
Me, a non MTG player: Yes, I get the humor.
I don't think I have ever seen blue layline in a cedh deck
I love the idea of cEDH even though I'll never have the money to invest in it.
this sums up what I hate about Commander either way
fair & casual: Standard
unfair & broken: Modern
REPEAT. THIS. PROCESS.
The best part about "you win" cards in Commander is that player gets to put away his cards and everyone gets to keep playing like he never existed.
Isn't that..... inherently a dick move? "Oh, you played a card I don't like? You don't exist anymore."
This feels incredibly toxic.
@@Frostgiantbutsmall How is it a dick move when the person themselves chooses take themselves out
@@Frostgiantbutsmall I mean, it's incredibly more toxic to crash a casual Commander game with 6+ people with this. You're essentially expecting the other players to restart the game for you and let you in on the next game so you can do it all over again. If you say "oh, I'm gonna switch decks," well then why did you play it in the first place? All you're gonna do is draw the ire of the whole table and be killed off early if you ever try to play with them again.
@@CamperCarl00 I do this game one and game two I get out the squirrel deck break there brains with all the squirrels
You missed the part where the cEDH player goes "Yeah, this decks like... a 7"
u dont get priority straight after resolving leyline? :D
First one was kind of accurate. Durdling around basically playing 4p solitaire while nothing is of any consequence and there for nothing really has impact.
Second one. There is no cEDH pod on this planet where that's even close to realistically happening. If you apply the idea of "pretend interaction doesn't exist" that is ever-present in a game of "casual" EDH, than most CEDH decks will just walk away with the game.
But nearly every deck is packed with every possible counterspell as well as top end removal, not to mention the vast array of hatebears.
More accurate title would be "Stoned AF EDH" vs "Pubstoming EDH".
PS: Leyline? Lab Man over Oracle?
PPS: I like most cEDH players, love casual EDH as well. Sometimes we want to ye know, play the game though instead of psuedo-RPing for 90 minutes.
Ill force of will ad nauseum.
Now, you don't actually *have* to play Ad Naus, I'm sure there are other decks out there! I mean, there's also Peer, right? That's different!
Funny how this is just a normal Yugioh match.
Truth
not enough searching and shuffling.
My Zur deck plays exactly like the second deck.
cEDH = I'll spend 50x what I could spend to build a deck in order to have LESS fun playing
I really feel like cEDH is more a battle of ego than a TCG game.
Did you give it a try?
@@w4tch0ut10 Yes. I borrowed competitive decks at my LGS back in 2017-2018.
@@MrLoowiz ok :) personally, I like cEDH more. Games are less time consuming and randomnes is limited. I also like cEDH deck building more. I guess, that many people would say the opposite is the case, but to me not having to limit yourself makes for far more creative deck building, where things can actually work the way they are intended (instead of accidentally). And yes, there are auto-includes. But tbf, isn't Sol Ring in every non cEDH deck as well? And truly all kinds of fast mana are not a cEDH issue, but purely a monetary one, with price being the outcome of, not the reason for inclusion. In that regard, I think that cEDH decks aren't nearly as one dimensional as people sometimes make them out to be.
@@w4tch0ut10 Less time consuming seems counter-productive, considering I usually play to spend time having fun. And randomness is what makes Magic fun (which is why I hate tutors, which ironically drag the game on with searching and shuffling. I removed every tutor from my monoB EDH deck). I'd argue that you're limiting yourself on cEDH, which is why you always see the same cards and you know exactly what cards are in someone else's deck. You won't play a different and fun combo, you'll always go for what works. 99% of cards are considered unplayable by cEDH standards, so your arsenal of cards is limited.
In some cEDH matches I've played and seen, people spent more time preparing for the game than actually playing it. It's a battle of no mana counters, combos and people winning out of nowhere. To each their own, but I'd much rather make a fun, jank deck and test different ways to play a commander, or different combos that no one has ever seen before.
Plus, my EDH decks are my own. All the cEDH decks I've seen are either net decked or 99% equal to some optimized list, which takes away any personality the deck could have.
Proxies completely negate your cost argument if it is out of your price range and your tables are understanding human being literal paper and pen is all you need or a printer, also my experience with casual is far worse because all anyone does half the time is actively attempt to prolong the game which is far less enjoyable than actually just you know developing your gameplan and attempting to win like intended. I understand my argument is based in annecdote however, the "casual" community literally bitched about the flash banning which literally was against the ideas of casual and competitive commander because believe it or not the cEDH community is playing commander just as much as everyone else we just prefer to "generally" (some people are in fact just elitist scumbag assholes) play to win without limiting ourselves to playing weaker card options or we prefer higher power level formats. You know playing the game is fun, but playing it for the purpose of just keeping the game going until everyone has a boardstate so large they can't even process all their triggers just defeats the purpose of playing the game, because at the end of the day the general point of a game is to win it, because winning is fun.
SMH, true cedh players don’t run leyline of anticipation, this isn’t even optimal 🙄 /s
This is facts
Idk he did win on turn 1