Theres a stranger interaction with a blind man you can help him later on while you meet him he says stuff like "I sense bad energy from you get away! Loyalty will blind you and will become a burden"
@Don Dann So what? That means we can't be inspired by them and cry and laugh with them? Just because a character isn't real doesn't mean we always have to act like they're not real. It's the same thing with movie and book characters. For example, Tony Stark was a fictional character, but plenty of people, myself included, cried when he died. In conclusion, kindly fuck off.
this is what i repeat myself everyday, i am a ghost in society. Even my friends don't want anything to do with me. Just because i see the truth in stuff
Unbelievable. I did the exact same thing. I only bought a PS4 just to play it. What an amazing experience. I haven't stop playing and I can't get enough of it
Yes, it's wonderfully animated. His eyes are slightly glazed as though he's holding back tears, the way they dart around a little more than usual. I've never seen an animated face convey more emotion than in that moment.
Me to afraid i have tb. Nobody care me. Well i just trying to move on lets see how my ends come. But i not break anyone heart i trying always even i have depression
Timmah also considering all the characters we could play (most likely those that don’t get out of blackwater) we are probably gunna cry as much as we did for arthur
@@ilhandaanish2381 that much is obvious, however the real question is, is it gonna be as good as RDR2 or was RDR2 just so good it is impossible to make another one this good without making a copy of RDR2 which in the end would still be bad... Yep lets just hope that Rockstar doesnt end up at the same path as almost every other game developer ever in existance and that they actualy make another exellent game and realize that making huge proffits in game industry is not by micro transactions or expensive dlc's but instead making a game that people will never forget and will be considered an EPIC and will propably be repressenting video games in museums in far future.
@@yaro42 Well I did play the first RDR but at first I was okay with arthur, but when I had reached the point In which you start to play as john, I didnt want to do so anymore. I miss arthur
Here's a funny fact. Roger Clark, the performance capture and voice actor of Arthur, did the performance capture (skin tight suit with pingpong balls) for Mary Gillis when she was crying at Arthur's grave, because she wasn't in studio that day. Arthur shed tears at his own grave
At the end when Dutch says “who’s with me and who’s betraying me?” He was so blinded that he didn’t realize that he was the one betraying Arthur and John
@@samgardner4667 yes he was. According to the actor playing Dutch's role. 😉 He said he really wanted to do the good choices.but hosea died, and Dutch "lost his mind", didn't know who he could trust or not.....and Micah saw an opportunity. In the end of the game, Dutch kills him cause he saw what Micah really was. 😉😊
Abigail: you'd risk all this? For what? For Micah? John: all this? All this wouldn't exist if It weren't for Arthur... Man, this really touches me deeply
It's not just a game. It's a masterpiece, it's an example of how a "bad man" is the best in the world, and a "good man" is the worst traitor that can exist. Rest in peace Arthur Morgan❤️.
@@shahidkarimm oh, the original comment was saying that Arthur was technically a "Bad man" in the eyes of society/the law, because hes protecting a gang of criminals, even though he is morally much better than the "Good guy" Micah who was ratting the criminals out, while indeed being the one with the worst morals in the entire game. Arthur was a good man, truly.
I honestly feel Arthur is a bad man with some goodness in him. After all the things he did, there is no way he is a good man. But that’s what the game is, It’s about a bad man.
Remember when days was good? Lenny and Arthur partying in the bar, Micah in jail, horses were frolicking and not dying, pinkertons were nowhere to be seen, there was a severe lack of tuberculosis, and Karen was sober. Sean was alive. Hosea and Arthur went bear hunting. Mary Beth and Arthur danced. It was good.
Arthur: "That's all I am, a fighter, a killer .. A crazy man." Reverend Swanson: "So be it, you lived your way, you'll die your way." One of the most iconic lines of dialect in this experience of Red Dead Redemption 2
“I’m sorry, ma’am...” “I know I ruined your life, I suffer for it everyday...” The pain in his voice, the look in his eyes, the expression that he has when he says those things.. He truly wanted to be a decent human. Fuck, man, I had tears in my eyes when I saw those two scenes and it just made me think of how much pain Arthur has gone through in his life.
A good man is one who does good things. Arthur Morgan was a killer who got weary of seeing his family and friends die over and over. He was no good man but he had a good heart and cared for the ones he loved. He sacrificed himself so everybody else could live the life he couldn't live. His death completed the story, there's no greater thing to die for than freedom for your beloved ones.
@@jesus4lyfe00 arthur in comparison to every other character was infact the purest... .. i said "he was purest man" .. which when put into a comparative context should make it obvious
He was a bad man in a way, he did bad things to lots of people but he tried to do better. That’s what matters. I’ve known people who claimed they were bad people but you can tell there was good in them. There’s so much weight on their shoulders and demons that they fight they they think they can’t change who they are. Some accept it and continue to do bad but others do something about it and try to change. Those who have the will to overcome their darkest demons is admirable
@@WanderingLoner1 you never had that thought that everything you do on the interwebs is being watched by a FBI man? Even if you havent its kind of a joke.
The last moments where you chose to help John escape I knew that was it. I knew Author was going to die. I was silently screaming come at me mother fuckers. I honestly thought he was going to die at that moment buying John time to get away. Only for Micah to fuck that up.
Red Dead Redemption is a godamn experience, not just a game, and Arthur is not just a character, he is what a real human would be in those times, he really feels, feeling fear like he does its just what a human feels, Arthur is my favorite character of the videogames
This game tells such a beautiful story. I was able to learn a lot about how to live and give back, I was in a very bad motorcycle accident when I was 21 shattered pelvis, split tailbone, 3 cracked vertebrae, punctured blatter, my right leg was dislocated and my left foot was 3 days away from amputation. I was in the hospital for 27 days and went through multiple surgeries. I thought my life was over I was engaged at the time but I was ready to die i couldn’t see a life after that. But I played a lot of video games to pass time and I learned from this game that you don’t need your physical strength to give back to the world, I’m 23 and I’m married to an amazing woman who helped me more than I can ever give back and I’m still living in constant pain but I’ve had the best couple years just showing people how beautiful life is and how you can give so much back even when you’re broken and in pain. I’m always looking to help people and there’s no shame in living just for that reason. If anyone takes time to go through this just know you don’t have to be all macho and quiet about your struggles. sharing your story and listening to others can really help you make sense of this world.
I read your story, you touched my heart so much, you are an inspiration and and honorable man a real life Arthur Morgan, God Bless you, be well always ♥
I'm replaying it and I kept the first horse Arhur got and I'm planning on having that horse to the very end to when Arthur says "thank you" it'll actually mean something to me because players don't always keep the same horse from the beginning.
It was the gamers choice if Arthur was loyal or not. The whole game through I loved Arthur. I never had such a bond, With a protagonist. It was like Arthur was my best friend and someone I couldn't live without. It made me learn how to change and how to become a good person.
Iain Hamilton He basically taught us that no matter how horrible life gets, always look at the bright side. He taught me that no matter how bad of a person i feel like i am, i can be better. it’s been over a year since i’ve finished the game, and i couldnt express to you how many times i’ve cried after replaying the game again.
when he says he’s afraid... it’s the way he says it and his facial expression that just makes me sad, you can see he’s afraid and it just makes me sad.
Pinkertons were doing their job. Even Milton gave many chances for the gang, to run away and live a normal life by handing over Dutch. Gang’s loyalty for Dutch was their downfall. Dutch was like a mad fire and Micah was the fuel. They both destroyed the gang. Arthur died being loyal. So Pinkertons were just doing their job. Milton too. But on the other hand Ross was a piece of shit.
I just finished the story and for me, its the best game i have ever played hands down. Im 45 and i have played quite alot of story-driven games through the years. The only game that has got me this attached emotionally would be The last of us (the first game when Joels daughter dies hit me very hard too) But Im just blown away of how good this game was, story, characters, scenery, sound etc. This is a masterpiece in my opinion and thats one reason im not surprised that games now makes more money than the movie-industry. Sorry for rambling, Cheers and stay safe everyone!
Arthur Morgan rip bro, I’ll cya in the other side, lmao for some reason I think in heaven in a coincidence I think somebody will be named Arthur Morgan and everybody will swarm around them 😂
The final talk between Arthur and John really tears me apart because you can tell John knows it will be the last time he will see Arthur, last time he will see his brother...
Don Dann Man shut up people are free to think whatever they want and this game was a masterpiece. Just because you don’t like the way some people think doesn’t mean that you have to be a complete asshole to them keep it to yourself. But I can see that you are a coward who hides behind a screen and you think that gives you the freedom to insult whoever you want. And just try to be more understanding in the future ok?
Arthur goes through the extreme struggle to survive in this world as a man. In a world where men are treated as inhumanly as possible just because they are stronger. To this day there are a lot of good men who are labeled monsters. Because this media have degraded men. Arthur is what a man should be.
"Im afraid" gets me everytime because really after taking a good look at myself and life I never understood how afraid of death and being old and alone I really was
After Arthur died :( I figured John was gunna get revenge on Micah soon so was waiting for that time...and when that time came I went up the hills waited til that cut scene was over and shot every bullet into Micahs balls
RDR changed us on so many levels. From our understanding of loyalty to the bitterness of betrayal all leading up to the final moment in life. We learned trust. Respect. Heartbreak. Sadness. And love. I ain't saying Arthur wasn't a bad man. But he tried to be good. And just like john says " no telling what he really was in the end "
Get the hell out of here and be a god damn man ! Reminds me of the line from Tom Hanks "Earn this" Arthur became the man Dutch dreams he could, and Arthur wanted John to live the life he wished he could have. when I think of John I think of the qoute "before you begin a journey of revenge, dig two graves "
If they would've given Arthur and the rest of the gang that had passed away an Assassin's Creed Black Flag send off at John's Wedding, I would've cried like a baby, more than I already had. The lost members of the gang standing around drinking, clanking mugs together and dancing, and as John said his vows they all stop, and watch, and smile. John walks off because he had the vision of them, he's alone overlooking the plains in the distance and Arthur approaches him and stands next to him and John says "I tried Arthur" with tears in his eyes, and Arthur smiles and puts his hand on John's shoulder and says "We all did, Son, we all did." John wipes his eyes, and Arthur is gone. Abigail approaches him and kisses him on the cheek and asks "What's wrong?" and John smiles and says "Just remembering an old friend." As a lone deer/coyote/eagle flies/stands out into the distance. And the screen fades to "Red Dead Redemption 2"
Dude he ran in a gang spilt blood robbed looted corps and shot people and killed a lot of people don't get ur emotions mixed he was a bad man sure he tried to redeem himself but he's still a bad man man u Arthur fans sure are something huh
@@DeadX2 you must be the school nerd that no one likes you. You know if someone truly regret something he will go to heaven right?? Thats what god sayed Edit : because i want you to feel like you accomplished something I'll press a like to your comment
Honestly, all Red Dead main characters are awesome! Red Harlow was the classical bounty hunter: cold, of few words, with a tragical past; but still honorable and a great warrior who reached justice and revenge. John Marston was a man who made the impossible to support his family, but they didn't let him put his past away... Arthur Morgan, a man in a continuous struggle with himself for the things that are right and the people he was loyal to. Thanks y'all for your stories!
Hi Abbie332 ...... I was commenting on this page, when I came across yours and all what you just said in your comment is great and amazing sunshine I will like us to be friends, This is my Gmail...... mch78789@gmail.com you can text me okay.! Sorry for comment on Public stuff.
A man we can relate to. A man living in a hard world. A man trying to be good when he was raised a thief. A man trying to find redemption. This story really was something, this just wasn't a plain game it was a breathtaking adventure. After the last of us this game takes 2nd place, untill maybe the last of us part 2 drops, but you will be in ly top 3 friends 💗
This is the most beautiful tribute to a man who did bad things but through repentance, loyalty, honor, sacrifice and love found redemption in the end. RIP Arthur.thanks for sharing this awesome video ❤❤❤❤
This is the best game i have ever played in my whole life, the experience was incredible, breathtaking and incredibly fun and sad. Ive never cried of a videogame but A.Morgan got me. I have never connected so much with a fictional chracter so much. Both emotionally and spiritually.
Thank you Rockstar, thank you Roger Clark for creating and giving life to the best character ever... RIP Arthur...we all love you❤️. Beautiful video thank you for sharing it.
Its like the one time rockstar may have accidentally made the best protagonist in gaming history, they're like: ahh shit we accidentally made a genuinely phenomenal character, but we can't have them only shitty ones are allowed to live. You know what, Hey boss how did your mother pass away again. Yeah exactly Tuberculosis. Thanks boss. First john. Then Arthur. Wtf is wrong rockstar. By the way, how many people actually replayed the game till chapter 4 and stopped just to be able to play as Arthur.
What edit would you like to see next about Red Dead and which character would you guys prefer I make it on. Any suggestions ?
Sadie
Hosea!!
Jack marston
arthur is the best :,)
Dutch
Honestly, RDR 2 wasn't a game... It was an experience.
Just like The Last of Us
Its art
Taran MVP Is a masterpiece
Yes ... :"v
Or why not? "both"
Arthur Morgan = shows you cannot run from your past
John Marston = shows you cannot forget your past
This is so much more than just a game...
this is just rockstar. What a company
Its a life lesson
"...Because those were the stories that stuck with you, even if you were too little to understand why." -Samwise Gamgee.
I feel like they're switched actually.
Eh, more like "John Marston = also shows you cannot run from the past"
Jack: What killed Uncle Arthur pa?
John: Loyalty...
Theres a stranger interaction with a blind man you can help him later on while you meet him he says stuff like "I sense bad energy from you get away! Loyalty will blind you and will become a burden"
Loyal people always die first
national socialist because they’re the easiest to betray
@@yeeyee6122 yep
Thats why i dont trust someone easily but i am still loyal only to good friends not to friends or family that i dont care about
national socialist big facts. I’ve been stabbed in the back to many times to trust anymore
I always wear the arthur's hat as John, for Arthur's honor.
Same
Same and I always tear up and what I do the horses I had for aurther I got back as john
When I was doing the last mission has John. I wear Arthur hat
No matter what outfit I make John or Arthur wear, the only hat they will ever wear is Arthur's signature hat
So do i
Arthur: "Get the hell outta here and be a god damn man"
John: "You're my brother"
Arthur: "I know"
😭😭💔
Best scene
"I'll hold 'em off."
It will mean a lot to me
@Don Dann So what? That means we can't be inspired by them and cry and laugh with them? Just because a character isn't real doesn't mean we always have to act like they're not real. It's the same thing with movie and book characters. For example, Tony Stark was a fictional character, but plenty of people, myself included, cried when he died. In conclusion, kindly fuck off.
@Don Dann wtf
_"This whole thing is pretty much done. We're more ghosts than people"_
*-A.Morgan*
Love this 😭😭
You should smell my fart right now, smells like rotten 🥚
@@linusbirgersson what tf? Get outta here, troll.
this is what i repeat myself everyday, i am a ghost in society. Even my friends don't want anything to do with me. Just because i see the truth in stuff
@@davy-johanab8231 they're no true "friends" if they don't even (at least) consider your pov. Period.
This game was beautifully done, I bought a ps4 just to play it. Hadn’t touched a video game in 20 years. It was unbelievable.
Unbelievable. I did the exact same thing. I only bought a PS4 just to play it. What an amazing experience. I haven't stop playing and I can't get enough of it
There's alot of great games your missing out on, you should play the Last of us it's a good game.
I'm saving for one. I only need about 70 more dollars.
Edit: Just got the PS4 Pro and RDR2 and I regret nothing.
I am imagining your reaction when it came out on pc
@@djkong2309 save for the ps5 man, youll regret it if u get the ps4 now, also, you can play ps4 games on the ps5.
when he say "I'm afraid".... his face, broke my heart....
Yes, it's wonderfully animated. His eyes are slightly glazed as though he's holding back tears, the way they dart around a little more than usual. I've never seen an animated face convey more emotion than in that moment.
What about at 2:15 when he said "I'm sorry ma'am" his eyes look very real and he looked very sad
@@UrMom-ol8mj here he looks like Puss in Boots from the Shrek.
Yess
Me to afraid i have tb. Nobody care me. Well i just trying to move on lets see how my ends come. But i not break anyone heart i trying always even i have depression
I’m afraid too
Afraid that we won’t get another game like this in a longgg time
Vetnurselife ....if ever. Seriously this is the single best game I’ve ever played. Now I play other games and they all suck in comparison.
Timmah they are definitely going to make another game considering this games success
Timmah also considering all the characters we could play (most likely those that don’t get out of blackwater) we are probably gunna cry as much as we did for arthur
@@ilhandaanish2381 that much is obvious, however the real question is, is it gonna be as good as RDR2 or was RDR2 just so good it is impossible to make another one this good without making a copy of RDR2 which in the end would still be bad...
Yep lets just hope that Rockstar doesnt end up at the same path as almost every other game developer ever in existance and that they actualy make another exellent game and realize that making huge proffits in game industry is not by micro transactions or expensive dlc's but instead making a game that people will never forget and will be considered an EPIC and will propably be repressenting video games in museums in far future.
I’m 100% positive the next game is gonna have jack as the main antagonist
Beginning of RDR2: I want to play as John.
End of RDR2: I want to keep playing as Authur.
That is so true
Never wanted to play as john tbh
@@mark.082 ah again one of those who didn't play rdr
@@yaro42 Well I did play the first RDR but at first I was okay with arthur, but when I had reached the point In which you start to play as john, I didnt want to do so anymore. I miss arthur
Thats so fucking true man
Here's a funny fact. Roger Clark, the performance capture and voice actor of Arthur, did the performance capture (skin tight suit with pingpong balls) for Mary Gillis when she was crying at Arthur's grave, because she wasn't in studio that day.
Arthur shed tears at his own grave
Really?
Yeah
He said it himself
Hate to be that guy, but it's Mary Linton
duuuuuuuuude!!!!
“We can’t change what’s done, We can only move on.”
- Arthur Morgan
At the end when Dutch says “who’s with me and who’s betraying me?” He was so blinded that he didn’t realize that he was the one betraying Arthur and John
silly goose He wasn’t blind at all. He was manipulative. There’s a huge difference
I still don’t get why Dutch would choose Micah over Arthur since Micah was met bye Dutch 6 months ago Arthur was in the gang for 20 years
*micah shoots miss grimshaw “WhO Is WiTh Me AnD WhO iS aGaInSt Me
@@samgardner4667 yes he was.
According to the actor playing Dutch's role. 😉
He said he really wanted to do the good choices.but hosea died, and Dutch "lost his mind", didn't know who he could trust or not.....and Micah saw an opportunity.
In the end of the game, Dutch kills him cause he saw what Micah really was. 😉😊
i think it's because michah boosted his ego. arthur questioned him. micah pushed him every step of the way, and made dutch's decisions feel verified
Abigail: you'd risk all this? For what? For Micah?
John: all this? All this wouldn't exist if It weren't for Arthur...
Man, this really touches me deeply
And Arthur said not to look back
And that’s what killed John. Revenge is a fools game
Yes true dude I love Arthur Morgan .Rest In Peace Legend
Me too brother
If I was John I wouldn’t have done it Arthur always said “ Revenge is a fools game”
First time Im feeling so connected to a video game character...
Gros chef bandit ikr im lowkey hella sad
Dude I was actually kinda depressed for the rest of the day
Me 2 I cried
I connected more to Pearson, I cried when he cried
Me too man
It's not just a game. It's a masterpiece, it's an example of how a "bad man" is the best in the world, and a "good man" is the worst traitor that can exist. Rest in peace Arthur Morgan❤️.
thats a really scary analogy tbh
I'm not quite sure that's what they were trying to say through the story but uh ok
@@shahidkarimm oh, the original comment was saying that Arthur was technically a "Bad man" in the eyes of society/the law, because hes protecting a gang of criminals, even though he is morally much better than the "Good guy" Micah who was ratting the criminals out, while indeed being the one with the worst morals in the entire game. Arthur was a good man, truly.
I honestly feel Arthur is a bad man with some goodness in him. After all the things he did, there is no way he is a good man. But that’s what the game is, It’s about a bad man.
I’m dead ass crying over a virtual character rockstar how
Yeah the same question rises in my mind
That really shows that what kind of protagonist Arthur Morgan was...😭😭
Bruh same I just got finished with my 20th playthrough and still cried
Its not just pixels. Its a story like every other, books, movies, life
Janys dont mean to rain on your parade but those stories and movies are also fiction
Remember when days was good? Lenny and Arthur partying in the bar, Micah in jail, horses were frolicking and not dying, pinkertons were nowhere to be seen, there was a severe lack of tuberculosis, and Karen was sober. Sean was alive. Hosea and Arthur went bear hunting. Mary Beth and Arthur danced. It was good.
Damn. Im getting reeeaaal nostalgic right now
Hollotom 02 I’m replaying the game and I didt know how much I missed it
Good old times 😢
It passed so quickly... You're gonna make me cry ;-;
My name is Sean I literally started crying when Arthur died and when Sean died, Hosea, Lenny, and Micah was in jail those were the good times 😭😢😢
*when the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back..*
😭
*I gave you all I had..*
I did ...
John made it, he's the only one😟
@Sam Johnson yep I know, but I love that line so much 🤩
@Sam Johnson Yeah lol
I see you in every comment section 😆😆
Arthur: "That's all I am, a fighter, a killer .. A crazy man."
Reverend Swanson: "So be it, you lived your way, you'll die your way." One of the most iconic lines of dialect in this experience of Red Dead Redemption 2
Yes is a shame that or you get this dialogue or the nun dialogue, both are so perfect
@@robfus There is also high honour with Reverend.
@@John-996 I honestly prefer the low honour Reverend scene.
@@robfustrue
“I’m sorry, ma’am...”
“I know I ruined your life, I suffer for it everyday...”
The pain in his voice, the look in his eyes, the expression that he has when he says those things.. He truly wanted to be a decent human. Fuck, man, I had tears in my eyes when I saw those two scenes and it just made me think of how much pain Arthur has gone through in his life.
Arthur Morgan - “GET OUTTA THE GODDAMN WAY! “
R.I.P - 1899
yer okay boyyy - Arthur Morgan 1899
You sir are a fish -Arthur Morgan
R.I.P-1899
“Well I better get going” - Arthur Morgan
*after being told Micah is captured and they plan to hang him*
“We can only hope” - Arthur Morgan
Do I just jump on the train or wha - arthur Morgan
I cried an UGLY CRY from the time he rode to camp and the song played to his dying breathe! He was a good man!
No... he was the best
And before starting his ride he took the cap from His saddle and wore... It was like he was about to clear and end all the things today
A good man is one who does good things. Arthur Morgan was a killer who got weary of seeing his family and friends die over and over. He was no good man but he had a good heart and cared for the ones he loved. He sacrificed himself so everybody else could live the life he couldn't live. His death completed the story, there's no greater thing to die for than freedom for your beloved ones.
@@wernherv.b.928 he was a good man in the end Dutch made him bad
I keep coming back to this video, and every single time it feels like the first time 😭 I love this game 😭😭
Agreed, best game i have ever played hands down. No other game except this and the first The last of us has got me like this
never cried over a video and a video game character until i finished red dead 2
this game is the best ive ever played rip Aurther Morgan
BigBoyCrispy damn can’t even spell his name right
Adi Da Gamer solid 1 view on your stream
Same here
I have recommend to you play a Hellblade senua's sacrifice. That game is a emocional tsunami.
Same
When he said he's afraid, that broke my heart.
Because I can clearly remember my father saying that , knowing that he dies ,just like Arthur.
I am sorry
😭
Im sorry i dont know why i cry its just a game but WHYYYYYYYYY MicHA WhY WaaAaaaa
Sorry.💔
😔
I like the sister. "Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act!" Words of wisdom.
When he thanked his horse at the end.....😭😭😭😭
Yeah its sad but i was like “brooo revive him i have horse cure” lol☹️
I had the water in my eyes, my ex girlfriend started balling when Silky Clipclop Whisperteen was felled. He was a good boah, just like Arthur
When he thanked his horse and cried, it was most humane thing is gaming history.
I felt when he said thanks to his horse this was his last moment
Rest in peace arthur
For me probably the saddest moment in the whole game. It broke me
Rockstar did a better job than the guys finishing GoT
GoT has always been devoid of logic,so I'm not surprised.
Game of Thrones didn't have good storytelling or writing, the show ran on it's shock factor.
@@SomeGuyXD65 I think that sums it up nicely.
@@SomeGuyXD65 Shitty take. The first 4 seasons is some of the most brilliantly written television out there.
@@deathbyslipknot Maybe in terms of World Building and lore sure, there isn't exactly a high bar for writing in Television either.
Aurther kept saying he was a bad man.. but he was the purest man in the whole game
I respectfully disagree he defeintly was a “bad” man but in the he tried, and he was reedemed
Smh Arthur was not a good man..stop allowing your emotions to disregard logic...Morgan even said he wasn't a good man over and over smh
@@jesus4lyfe00 true
@@jesus4lyfe00 arthur in comparison to every other character was infact the purest... .. i said "he was purest man" .. which when put into a comparative context should make it obvious
He was a bad man in a way, he did bad things to lots of people but he tried to do better. That’s what matters. I’ve known people who claimed they were bad people but you can tell there was good in them. There’s so much weight on their shoulders and demons that they fight they they think they can’t change who they are. Some accept it and continue to do bad but others do something about it and try to change. Those who have the will to overcome their darkest demons is admirable
“We’re thieves in a world that don’t want us no more”
- Arthur Morgan
You may be a thief Arthur and the world may not want you, but we do
Parodies & more yes 😭😭
one of the best❤️😭
Arthur you are maybe a game character but we love you😍
Only thing he’s guilty of is stealing my heart.
they are thieves today.. politic.. mafians... agents.. police.. etc.. =( i am a good man like arthur and i have hard live in today age...
*"I ain't changed...I'm still a bad man"*
- Arthur Morgan 1899
Arthur is not dead, in our hearts we admire a man we have never seen and met...
RIP ; like if Arthur Morgan is a legend
Damn right, he made John Marston who he is now.
@@bryanmendoza7630 what sucks is that I just sets up the line for rdr 1 and doesn't change anything
MR E Arthur morgen was legend
Most important he was a hero
Arthur Morgan was far more than a legend 'cause he was real damnit and he was a fucking hero
"We ain't both gonna make it"
(Gives hat to john)
Literally had to pause the game cause I started to cry
I pause the game after every good dialogue and repeat it by myself
OMG THAT MOMENT HAD ME CRYYYYY
Same
I have this shot framed on my wall
I would say softie but I have no reason to
You were a bad man, but you died a good man Arthur Morgan.
Amen
Omen
Umen
Oomen
Loumen
Lenny in heaven: Arthur?
Arthur in heaven: Haha found you Lenny!!
Dang thanks for the likes (the most I’ve had ever)
@@heydani6678 stop being cectic
That comment made me cry harder
ynnel
Oh LEEEENNNNY!!!!
They're sure as hell not in Heaven
I miss him so Damn much man he deserved so much better
Me: *crying*
FBI man: "I feel you"
Lmao
Okay... But what does it have to do with a FBI man?
@@WanderingLoner1 you never had that thought that everything you do on the interwebs is being watched by a FBI man? Even if you havent its kind of a joke.
NSA
@@dailysandwich4838 he is watching you play?
He was never a bad man he was good💔
Yep killing cops who are just doing their job
Cate Butler I’m not a good man I’m an outlaw there’s nothing good about that
Arthur Morgan But in the end he became a good man
Cate Butler ur gay mate
@@whatareyou4830 what's your problem man?
Only 2 games made me cry, Metal Gear Solid 4 and Red Dead Redemption 2.
this game is perfection.
Mine was this and mgs 3 with the Boss at the end. That salute :(
@@sindelmybelle2215 I've only cried at twdg s1 and rdr1 and rdr2-
Metal Gear Solid 3 and RDR 2 made me Cry.
Boss and Arthur 4ever in my heart!
Same here bro, two masterpieces
The last moments where you chose to help John escape I knew that was it. I knew Author was going to die. I was silently screaming come at me mother fuckers. I honestly thought he was going to die at that moment buying John time to get away. Only for Micah to fuck that up.
I'm gonna name my future son Arthur because of this...
That's cool man!
Actually, I genuinely might too one day. As nerdy as this sounds, this character and game in general means a lot to me.
me too!!!
This game is getting out of hand smh
Maybe me too
Is it here the Red Dead Depression support group?
I need to talk.
Me to bro
Lane Rich really 😭😭
I can't see Arthur face without crying XD
i get sad everytime i think about both arthur and john they feel so real wtf
Red Dead Redemption is a godamn experience, not just a game, and Arthur is not just a character, he is what a real human would be in those times, he really feels, feeling fear like he does its just what a human feels, Arthur is my favorite character of the videogames
This game tells such a beautiful story. I was able to learn a lot about how to live and give back, I was in a very bad motorcycle accident when I was 21 shattered pelvis, split tailbone, 3 cracked vertebrae, punctured blatter, my right leg was dislocated and my left foot was 3 days away from amputation. I was in the hospital for 27 days and went through multiple surgeries. I thought my life was over I was engaged at the time but I was ready to die i couldn’t see a life after that. But I played a lot of video games to pass time and I learned from this game that you don’t need your physical strength to give back to the world, I’m 23 and I’m married to an amazing woman who helped me more than I can ever give back and I’m still living in constant pain but I’ve had the best couple years just showing people how beautiful life is and how you can give so much back even when you’re broken and in pain. I’m always looking to help people and there’s no shame in living just for that reason. If anyone takes time to go through this just know you don’t have to be all macho and quiet about your struggles. sharing your story and listening to others can really help you make sense of this world.
I was moved by your story bro, really inspiring & so true. I wish you & ur wife a lifetime of joy and happiness 🌹
I read your story, you touched my heart so much, you are an inspiration and and honorable man a real life Arthur Morgan, God Bless you, be well always ♥
Arthur definitely has changed my life, and is the man/character I would like to become.
I got so attached to my horse and Arthur but when I saw them both die I broke
icemaan777365 Same! I’m replaying it with the first horse Arthur ever got and I’m just not ready to watch that sad scene just yet 😭😭😭
@@waywardoutlaw1518 I don't know if I can replay it
Same
I'm replaying it and I kept the first horse Arhur got and I'm planning on having that horse to the very end to when Arthur says "thank you" it'll actually mean something to me because players don't always keep the same horse from the beginning.
Me too
Who the hell is cutting onions in my house right now
Those damn onion ninjas.
Its Pearson making the stew.
Let just be honeat with our self we crying our eyes out right now
Im not crying youre crying
What are your onions doing in my house ?!
We need more of Arthur Morgan. We will pay for it. Just make a prequel or something.
I was hoping to play as Zombie Arthur when they release Undead Nightmare 2
I want that vampire arthur for undead nightmare 2 SO BAD!
It was the gamers choice if Arthur was loyal or not.
The whole game through I loved Arthur. I never had such a bond, With a protagonist. It was like Arthur was my best friend and someone I couldn't live without. It made me learn how to change and how to become a good person.
Arthur's journey made me want to be a better man than I was.
That’s exactly how I felt. He’s more then just a game character he’s an inspiration to me and making me want to be a better man.
Iain Hamilton He basically taught us that no matter how horrible life gets, always look at the bright side. He taught me that no matter how bad of a person i feel like i am, i can be better. it’s been over a year since i’ve finished the game, and i couldnt express to you how many times i’ve cried after replaying the game again.
It made me so sad that I won’t even say a god damm thing about your avatar and why are you Zero two
"Im afraid"
😭😭
“Of the insist couple”
U were a good man everyone knows that
"He insist" huh He Insist
This is beautifully edited. Really captures Arthur’s life and internal conflict. Had me crying life a baby.
Thank you!
AxSProductions yer okay boyy
when he says he’s afraid... it’s the way he says it and his facial expression that just makes me sad, you can see he’s afraid and it just makes me sad.
The 155 dislikes are all Pinkerton’s and One of them is Micah
London Batehead And Molly.
@@johnmarston3024 let's go kill Micah the rat
Pinkertons were doing their job. Even Milton gave many chances for the gang, to run away and live a normal life by handing over Dutch. Gang’s loyalty for Dutch was their downfall. Dutch was like a mad fire and Micah was the fuel. They both destroyed the gang. Arthur died being loyal.
So Pinkertons were just doing their job. Milton too.
But on the other hand Ross was a piece of shit.
Manoj Gagan fuck the Pinkertons Milton kidnapped Abigail
@@manojgagan9454 so your saying the pinkertones were good guys
I will always remeber you Arthur
Hello scarface
Thank
Hello walking deadman btw Pinkertons betray u everybody told u this
This is the best comment section ever
@@micahbell8941 what the hell are u doing in the comment section
Be gone
Theres a good man within you Arthur, but he’s wrestling with a giant, and the giant wins time after time. 💔
That is so we'll said
Mary...did u know. In the end, he won. He beat it good.
In the end, when it mattered, Arthur kicked that giant where it hurts. He finally beat it. Rest his soul.
I just finished the story and for me, its the best game i have ever played hands down. Im 45 and i have played quite alot of story-driven games through the years. The only game that has got me this attached emotionally would be The last of us (the first game when Joels daughter dies hit me very hard too) But Im just blown away of how good this game was, story, characters, scenery, sound etc. This is a masterpiece in my opinion and thats one reason im not surprised that games now makes more money than the movie-industry. Sorry for rambling, Cheers and stay safe everyone!
I honestly never thought i could like another character as much as John. Rockstar nailed it.
Goodbye old friend.
Good-bye
Arthur Morgan rip bro, I’ll cya in the other side, lmao for some reason I think in heaven in a coincidence I think somebody will be named Arthur Morgan and everybody will swarm around them 😂
@@arthurmorgan5262 goodbye,dear friend
@@arthurmorgan5262 say hi to my mother for me 😭👋
I wish u had added the scene where Arthur says "Ride with me!" to Sadie and Charlie. That was epic
Charlie lol
Jajajaj
Or when Arthur says he'd be better off alone and Charles says we ride with you
@@lewisbateman6032 "hello there."
The final talk between Arthur and John really tears me apart because you can tell John knows it will be the last time he will see Arthur, last time he will see his brother...
Never cried over a video game character until i finish RDR2 we will miss you arthur
Don Dann get the hell outta here
Start the game again...
Don Dann Man shut up people are free to think whatever they want and this game was a masterpiece. Just because you don’t like the way some people think doesn’t mean that you have to be a complete asshole to them keep it to yourself. But I can see that you are a coward who hides behind a screen and you think that gives you the freedom to insult whoever you want. And just try to be more understanding in the future ok?
@@zadaron4286 I hate that jackass Don Dan. Everything you said is everything I didn't know how to say to him. Thank you.
@Damned oMg, i Am SuCh A bAdAsS bEcAuSe I dIdN't CrY tO a ViDeO gAmE cHaRcTeR's DeAtH. yOu ArE sUcH a WuSs
I cant express my love for this game. And watching this brought every single emotion back. Best game ever
Arthur goes through the extreme struggle to survive in this world as a man. In a world where men are treated as inhumanly as possible just because they are stronger. To this day there are a lot of good men who are labeled monsters. Because this media have degraded men. Arthur is what a man should be.
Nicely said
👍🤠🐎 fxck civilisation
Nics guy
Bro this is incel as fuck
Never a truer word said my man
"Im afraid" gets me everytime because really after taking a good look at myself and life I never understood how afraid of death and being old and alone I really was
Arthur was the heart and soul of his Game, miss him so much.😞😭 Thank you vor this Beautiful Video
No problem, thanks for watching!
Arthur Morgan: One of the best characters of all Rockstar games, in my opinion the best ... You will always be remembered Arthur .R.I.P.
I don’t know how to describe this game! Don’t Know how to describe this Video! Thank You For making this Video 😢
When he said,
"I am sorry mam, i really am"
My heart broke in 72 pieces😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Who else when they play with John puts on author hat like if you do
I played the whole epilogue wearing it and made sure to use it while killing Micah
@@CesarHernandez1994 game forces you to wear it while killing micah
*Arthur*
@@BrobotDj no it falls off, you have to die once to have it put back on after sadie gets stabbed
Codsworth the robot you can just turn around and pick it up
Micah: shoots grimshaw
Dutch: WhO iS BeTrAyInG mE
Arthur: BOAH
UrBoiJ13 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 it’s funny because it’s true
After Arthur died :( I figured John was gunna get revenge on Micah soon so was waiting for that time...and when that time came I went up the hills waited til that cut scene was over and shot every bullet into Micahs balls
Same haha
Revenge is a fools game
John Grey yes!!!!!
Lol I unloaded my whole clip in his head
@@ambivalentaxe u like Micah?
damn, that "im sorry ma'am, i really am" hit so hard because you know he meant it completely when he said it
Arthur its been a privilege playing with you
I haven't seen that many tributes dedicated to one character since The Witcher 3. Rockstar really is making history.
[*] R.I.P. | Arthur Morgan
Angle down 😢😭
Dude I'm crying soo bad
He's like my older brother
I missed him 💔
RDR changed us on so many levels. From our understanding of loyalty to the bitterness of betrayal all leading up to the final moment in life. We learned trust. Respect. Heartbreak. Sadness. And love. I ain't saying Arthur wasn't a bad man. But he tried to be good. And just like john says " no telling what he really was in the end "
"When the time comes... you had to run, and don't look back"
- Arthur morgan
You gotto run
John: Your my brother
Arthur: I know...
Arthur: Ok, I'll catch you later then
Skiller 2002 ha
unfortunately Death caught him RIP
Funniest line but touching at the sametime
@@SighGuy__2002__ Also Arthur: OUTTA THE DAMN WAY
Damn O'Driscles disliking the video this is an amazing tribute, really sad to lose arthur its so heartbreaking... A bad man with a good heart
B4shar Micah disliked too
“there’s a man within you, arthur” hits different 😔
Without Arthur this game isn't this game anymore man😞
Get the hell out of here and be a god damn man !
Reminds me of the line from Tom Hanks
"Earn this"
Arthur became the man Dutch dreams he could, and Arthur wanted John to live the life he wished he could have.
when I think of John I think of the qoute "before you begin a journey of revenge, dig two graves "
If they would've given Arthur and the rest of the gang that had passed away an Assassin's Creed Black Flag send off at John's Wedding, I would've cried like a baby, more than I already had.
The lost members of the gang standing around drinking, clanking mugs together and dancing, and as John said his vows they all stop, and watch, and smile.
John walks off because he had the vision of them, he's alone overlooking the plains in the distance and Arthur approaches him and stands next to him and John says "I tried Arthur" with tears in his eyes, and Arthur smiles and puts his hand on John's shoulder and says "We all did, Son, we all did." John wipes his eyes, and Arthur is gone.
Abigail approaches him and kisses him on the cheek and asks "What's wrong?" and John smiles and says "Just remembering an old friend."
As a lone deer/coyote/eagle flies/stands out into the distance.
And the screen fades to "Red Dead Redemption 2"
I agree with the people at the wedding but the looking over the plains part is a bit corny
You made me cry
Captain Rex
I cried reading this too...
@@th31nternet who knew grieving was corny lol
@@syv4192 but you were there with him tho
Death: its time to go
Arthur: was i a bad man
Death: no, i was told you where one of the best man
You mean THE BEST MAN
No I heard you pet a dog after killing somebody
Dude he ran in a gang spilt blood robbed looted corps and shot people and killed a lot of people don't get ur emotions mixed he was a bad man sure he tried to redeem himself but he's still a bad man man u Arthur fans sure are something huh
@@DeadX2 you must be the school nerd that no one likes you. You know if someone truly regret something he will go to heaven right?? Thats what god sayed
Edit : because i want you to feel like you accomplished something I'll press a like to your comment
@@DeadX2 Someone’s really mad, we are aware but he is still a cool character.
I don't wanted to kill Micah i just wanted to save Arthur
Micah can go be frozen and burned in hell
Yeah man.... "it would mean a lot to me"
revenge is a fools game - Arthur Morgan
I would want to do both
I tried from the start to antagonize, ignore every mission, and shoot Micah. Game didn’t let me.... very obvious he was the mole
Honestly, all Red Dead main characters are awesome!
Red Harlow was the classical bounty hunter: cold, of few words, with a tragical past; but still honorable and a great warrior who reached justice and revenge.
John Marston was a man who made the impossible to support his family, but they didn't let him put his past away...
Arthur Morgan, a man in a continuous struggle with himself for the things that are right and the people he was loyal to.
Thanks y'all for your stories!
@Zoinks Scoob Red dead Revolver protagonist.
If your honor is low, your progress is horse shit.
Arthur is a great man❤❤❤
Please say I'm not the only one that loves this game so much I play it over and over again, but I always break into tears when it ends... 😭❤😭
Hi Abbie332 ...... I was commenting on this page, when I came across yours and all what you just said in your comment is great and amazing sunshine I will like us to be friends, This is my Gmail...... mch78789@gmail.com
you can text me okay.! Sorry for comment on Public stuff.
@@williamerichenderson6311 bruh wtf??
I beat this game a while ago and it still hurts me and leaves me empty
Same
I’m scared to end it🤧
A man we can relate to. A man living in a hard world. A man trying to be good when he was raised a thief. A man trying to find redemption.
This story really was something, this just wasn't a plain game it was a breathtaking adventure. After the last of us this game takes 2nd place, untill maybe the last of us part 2 drops, but you will be in ly top 3 friends 💗
For me its my most favourite game
NATE HIGGERS oh yeah yeah
fuck last of us rdr2 is something else
Three dislikes! Agent Milton, Agent Ross and Micah disliked this.
4th one is Dutch
@@bertandokur6914 other 4:
Javier
Bill
That guy who gave Arthur TB
And, that big fella in Valentine
and o, odrescall.
@@dragutintheslav-veliki790 and Strauss
And Angelo bronte and cornwall.
This is the most beautiful tribute to a man who did bad things but through repentance, loyalty, honor, sacrifice and love found redemption in the end. RIP Arthur.thanks for sharing this awesome video ❤❤❤❤
OMG what a Beautiful comment, you captured the message of Arthur's story perfectly.
Csodálatosan megfogalmazott komment, le a kalappal! ;)
Magam sem írhattam volna szebben, pacsi!
This is the best game i have ever played in my whole life, the experience was incredible, breathtaking and incredibly fun and sad. Ive never cried of a videogame but A.Morgan got me. I have never connected so much with a fictional chracter so much. Both emotionally and spiritually.
Yea😭😭
Thank you Rockstar, thank you Roger Clark for creating and giving life to the best character ever... RIP Arthur...we all love you❤️. Beautiful video thank you for sharing it.
It's not just a video game, it's real life lessons and it's a masterpiece...
I miss you Arthur
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 Agreed on Every level.
Anyone read the journal of arthurs when you play as john? His message to mary... 😭
Francois Cobb omg i read them all the time. i feel like he wasn’t talked about enough after his death
I didn't know you could read his journal Shows you how much I've been paying attention
it’s seeing such a strong man be defeated for the first time, it really gets me, i loved arthur and i’ll never forget him
Its like the one time rockstar may have accidentally made the best protagonist in gaming history, they're like: ahh shit we accidentally made a genuinely phenomenal character, but we can't have them only shitty ones are allowed to live. You know what,
Hey boss how did your mother pass away again. Yeah exactly Tuberculosis. Thanks boss.
First john.
Then Arthur.
Wtf is wrong rockstar.
By the way, how many people actually replayed the game till chapter 4 and stopped just to be able to play as Arthur.
I'm working on my 100% (I'm at 95.3%) and then I'm starting over and never going past Chapter 4 ever ... ever !!
I'm replaying it made it to the 2nd chapter I'm drawing this out as long as I can
I just finished but I'm re playing every mission to play as him
Sean Riddle And I finally crafted the legend of the east satchel in chapter 4.
Yep, also I hate Rockstar's fetish for killing their protagonist but enjoy Rockstar itself
2:15 “I’m sorry, ma’am. I really am” Damn, I felt that. You can hear the hurt in his voice.
I love Arthur. Amazing character
Arthur Morgan 😂😂😂
"We're thieves in a world that dont want us no more" -Arthur Morgan
Yes you are a thief, you stole all our hearts 💔