Haunted Mansion vs. Phantom Manor: differences between attractions
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июл 2024
- The 1969 original Haunted Mansion compared to the 1992 Phantom Manor variation. Their owners, origins, concept art, ghosts, rooms and more are compared bit by bit to determine which of the both attractions is the better one.
Video sources:
All Phantom Manor POV's (DLP Welcome, subscribe to his channel!): • [4K-Extreme Low Light]...
Certain Haunted Mansion POV's (LGM Vids): • [2021] Haunted Mansion...
Haunted Mansion cool close ups with awesome edits (4K Theme Park Videos): • Disneyland - The Haunt...
Haunted Mansion Holiday footage (LGM Vids): • [2021] Haunted Mansion...
1970's Haunted Mansion video (HBVideos): • Haunted Manison Ride F...
1969 Haunted Mansion video (Disney History Institute): • Disneyland History 196...
Osmonds Special Video: • HAUNTED MANSION - Visi...
Tony Baxter interview: • Tony Baxter Backstage ...
Subscribe to all of these awesome channels! 
Развлечения
We're only 41 subscribers away from the 900 Happy Haunts! Subscribe and be part of this Haunted Community!
Hey there!Can you do a video about PickWick?Just as a suggestion!
Phantom Manor is way better than your Haunted Mansion 🟦⬜🟥🇫🇷
Lol there's actually bust in the new corridor of Phantom Manor. This one is not Moving and located futher away. You didn't see it 😆 6:50
You really need 999 ghosts 🖤
The Haunted Mansion is my favorite ride along with the Pirate Ride........when I saw the fan videos of the Phantom Manor Ride and I loved the story behind it.
I find Phantom Manor to be superior to the Haunted Mansion. It’s has an official backstory, recurring characters and gothic feel to the attraction.
Our French Phantom Manor has more disturbing backstory. The owner of Manor is also the same person who runs Big Thunder Mountain Company
Most likely the Whole Frontierland Thunder Mesa is connected to Phantom Manor
Tony Baxter ensured French Haunted Mansion had to be more scarier and creepier than the California one
Y’all wouldn’t have Phantom Manor if it weren’t for our original Haunted Mansion
I agree on that…😉
I agree on the part that it has more consistency on it's theming, story and characters but disagree on the superior part, maybe it might just simply be due to how iconic the mansion and the characters are but I prefer the Haunted Mansion.
The ending scene is the biggest improvement over the original. The town scene in Thunder Mesa is absolutely phenomenal
Phantom Manors My Favorite for the Story As soon as I learned about it and saw videos and such I fell in love, Because there’s so much you can build upon it.
Like just story ideas like that Henry is keeping Melanie somewhat young so that she continues to wait and wait and he can torment her for her commitment to waiting as she slowly looses it. (Idk if it makes sense but I like the idea).
Also from fan art I’ve seen of Melanie she’s a very pretty girl I’ll just say and I feel bad for her!
But seriously Disney needs like a Disney+ series or something about Phantom Manor just for more people to learn about it and give it some love.
Our Phantom Manor needs it's own movie. The Storytelling is so drama. 🇫🇷😈
To sum up the backstory of Phantom Manor, Henry Ravenswood is so Overprotective Father to Melanie. He thinks none of the 4 suitors who wanted to ask her daughter's hand are not good enough for her.
He led them upon their demise
I seen the haunted mansion movie
I wish there was a phantom manor movie
As French. Been wishing for years they will make a Phantom Manor Movie. Hopefully as Sequel
I saw the Haunted Mansion movie. It was okay. The Main Villain the Hat Box is not scary
@@christophermichaelclarence6003 also his character and role in the movie was a blatant ripoff of the phantom
I love both for different reasons. I love haunted mansion for being so iconic and being both dark and dark humored while I love phantom manor for having a way better story and soundtrack
there should be a movie about phantom manor 😊
I'd definitely watch that!
@@storiesfromthemansion4387There's Haunted Mansion movie coming up soon, but not the Phantom Manor.
Hopefully as a sequel
There's supposed to be a Big Thunder Mountain movie coming up; depending on whether the Thunder Mesa (Disneyland Paris) version of Big Thunder will be the setting of that one, a Phantom Manor movie would be the next logical step really; perhaps it'll even be mentioned already?
Since I never visited Disneyland or Disneyland Paris, I watched videos of both places and I find that I like the Phantom Manor better after watching the video of the ride. It has a story that goes with the house. It makes you feel sorry for young Melanie Ravenswood who is waiting by the window on the grand staircase for her fiancee to come back and not knowing that her fiancee is already dead.
I don't understand why one has to be "better" than the other. Phantom Manor has a story that's part of the larger Thunder Mesa universe which is it's own thing, whereas the classic Haunted Mansion is more open-ended, in that you are a visitor checking out a potential "retirement" option for the afterlife - where you're guaranteed to have a "swingin' wake" with other creepy, but friendly, ghosts.
Our Phantom Manor 🇫🇷 is most likely a Drama vibe and Death bodies and Squeletons
I’ve only been on the haunted mansion, but tbh after studying the lore of both extensively I think phantom manor has a better story. That being said, I am annoyed that they got rid of every reference to Jake. They really went “References to hanging are too dark. We should remove them. Anyway, one of Melanie’s suitors got sliced in half by a buzzsaw.”
I am absolutely obsessed with the look of the phantom manor. I’d have loved to see even more innovation on the inside!
Im going on Phantom Manor next year, I cant wait!
Wise choice
Fun fact both haunted mansion and phantom manor according to disney are both family friendly attractions 👪 because they are the same house with different stories and I like it that way. Both versions are awesome
The Phantom Manor was more and deeper scary. The ride itself is much more Darker, pitch black in the original version 1992
love taking the kiddos to see a skeletal serial killer
Classic, original Disneyland Anaheim CA all the way! 💚. Each has their own style which is good too!!
Phantom Manor cannot be topped. No other ride comes close. If you’ve never been but get the opportunity, I highly recommend.
MOST DEFINITELY, Phantom Manor.
Henry Ravenswood’s the type to wear one of those cringe shirts for dads that says “gUns dOn’T kiLl pEoPlE, dAdS wiTh pReTtY dAuGhTeRs dO”
Wrong. I'd say he's more like. "No a single man deserve and worthy enough to ask my daughter to marry"
He's overprotective father.
Both rides are amazing in their own rights. By heavy bias PM is my favorite version. But I respect and love HM a lot, it is the original after all and comparing the two feels unfair. They are just two completely different rides to me. Different tones, different themes and vibes. PM feels like the older, edgy brother to HM even though HM is the older one.
It just depends on what a guest is looking for in a spooky ride. Want some scary fun with weird settings, ideas and characters without much plot? HM is your true pick. Want something macabre, gothic, lore heavy and foreboding? PM is the one for you:)
The Storytelling of Phantom Manor is better than Haunted Mansion.
More disturbing and dramatic which takes place in Wild War West.
Basically, The Whole Frontierland is linked with the backstory Phantom Manor. One of the most highlight
Those 2 have different story
Buzz Lightyear Astro Blasters vs. Buzz Lightyear Laser Blast: differences between rides. Pirates of the Caribbean vs. Pirates of the Caribbean: differences between rides.
Haunted mansion is liked to the land of New Orleans square. If you know New Orleans and it’s paranormal history, you would understand.
Phantom Manor at Disneyland Paris is better because Phantom Manor has Phantom Henry Ravenswood.
I like that your reasoning is just “better because skeleton man :)”
In my opinion that makes it worse
The names of Melanie's fiancés allude to their deaths.
Barry Claude was eaten by bears
Rowan D. Falls got caught in a river current and went over a waterfall
Sawyer Bottom was cut in two by an industrial saw
And Ignatius Knight got blown up by dynamite
Phantom manor is better because Jake Evans is a very cool guy if I do say so myself. Also he has big big muscles and infinite rizz
I liked the original stretch room from Phantom Manor where all the things were happening to Melonie better. How come Disney never came up with a movie about Phantom Manor?
I liked the ideas of Melanie getting into silly little mishaps :) I never liked the artstyle but I miss when the ride revolved around Melanie and her groom and not a bunch of guys with goofy pun names and unserious deaths
Both Spooky, both awesome! 🖤 💀 💜
You forgot to mention that Eleanor Audley voiced Madame Leota (the face is Leota Toombs, though).
6:21 Before Medusa, there is the Flying Dutchman but you didn't quote it
You left out the Endless Hallway. Both rides have one.
i hope do the one for the bday girl but this was good.
I know the Orlando Haunted Mansion.
Phantom manor 4 ever.
Thank you for appreciating our Phantom Manor 🟦⬜🟥🇨🇵😈
This year I made both, and definitely I can say Phantom Manor manos is 1000 times better than Haunted Mansion. In videos looks similar but even you can watch the differences, but on the ride the feeling on Phantom Manor is superior, you can feel nostalgic, melancholic, heartbreak, the pain, and the voice singing in hole attraction made it amazing. The bride at dining room's window is absolutely lovely, and the theme of Phantom Canyon is superior to any other theme. I love Magic Kingdom, bur Phantom Manor in Paris won this time.
And I haven't talked about the cargo area or the entrance hallway and the fact that we enter through the door and not from the side.
Dose that mean, Phantom Manor Wins?
hauted mansion
It’s classic!!
Differences? Phantom Manor is heads and tails better. It's like comparing spago to Burger King
I think they are both amazing, but Phantom Manor did not have to start from scratch as Haunted Mansion did. The fact that one wanted an experiences only and the other wanted a storyline does make Phantom Manor more palatable to today's audiences.
@@storiesfromthemansion4387 I am partial to just the general atmosphere and operatics of phantom manor. The haunted Mansion is Grand but phantom Manor is a little less ham-fisted. It takes itself dead serious and has enough humor as to not be pretentious. I just love the clear and concise storyline the dark ominous atmosphere. It's the Haunted Mansion perfected
@@cafeAmericano That last sentence is exactly what I think of Phantom Manor.
@@storiesfromthemansion4387 As French I got a talk with Tony Baxter famed Disney Imagineer in a Convention back in April 12th.
He said himself that he wanted a better version better version than Haunted Mansion. And it's Phantom Manor
More scary and disturbing backstory.
That link with the Whole Frontierland
@@christophermichaelclarence6003 It definitely feels creepier and has an amazing connection to the rest of the land.
I like a lot about your video except the scoring part. Neither Mansion has to be superior or inferior.
Phantom Manor is fantastic and if I could ride both with no other guests then I'd be hard pressed to pick a favorite, they both are amazing for their own reasons. HOWEVER... I went to Disneyland Paris and Disneyland California last year within months of each other and the guests at Paris are SO RUDE. I couldn't hear anything in the foyer or the stretching room, all the other guests were talking all the time as if they weren't already in the attraction. Then during the attraction half the people in the buggies near me were on their phones with the brightness up, again as if they weren't ON a freakin' ride! In California there was still chatter, but either they have their volume up higher or the guests were more considerate, so I could clearly hear everything, and I only once saw someone open their phone.
I wish I could ride Phantom Manor when the park was empty because it would have been a much better experience. I do love tho that the Mayor of Thunder Mesa (who's tipping his head to you at the start of the town scene) is Paul Frees! I believe they sampled lines from the Haunted Mansion recording to make the dialogue for the Mayor at Phantom Manor =D
As far as I'm concerned, the Hatbox Ghost thrashes the Phantom. I'm not impressed with the Phantom. Other than that, Phantom Manor seems very intriguing and I plan on going sometime.
I visited both. The Phantom Manor is way better than Haunted Mansion when it comes to storytelling and land.
And he probably smells better too. Henry wore way too much cologne
@@phantommanorgroom Dead men don't smell. They stink
haunted mansion is beter than phantor manor💀