Aston Martin Valkyrie VS Mercedes-AMG One

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 112

  • @THEWINDTUNNEL
    @THEWINDTUNNEL  Год назад +29

    Which one would you take home?

    • @andreademarchi7495
      @andreademarchi7495 Год назад +15

      Aston 100%,V12 N/A and still it have less weight- more power

    • @Nerdybetta
      @Nerdybetta Год назад +2

      Is both an option?

    • @Tire24
      @Tire24 Год назад +3

      I personally prefer cornering/lateral acceleration capability over power, so I like the Aston.

    • @Tire24
      @Tire24 Год назад

      Just one problem though. I live on a dirt road, so neither car would fare very well. I probably couldn't take either one home even if I wanted to 😅😢

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      aston every day, rough old school, cutting edge aero...

  • @vivos71
    @vivos71 Год назад +106

    Given the glorious V12 and that they are actually taking some version of it to Le Mans soon, the Aston has my vote

  • @matsimmo6208
    @matsimmo6208 11 месяцев назад +11

    I’d be interested to see this expanded with like 20 or more “track only” cars. There’s been a bunch over the years would be cool to see them together

  • @erickoffi2715
    @erickoffi2715 Год назад +21

    I’ll take the valkyrie what a sound❤

  • @ipo7596
    @ipo7596 Год назад +32

    500kg damn. Both are made with slightly different principles in mind. I think the AMG One would be faster overall for it's feats, but the main thing I saw right away that could give the AMR the edge is the sheer weight difference despite similar power figures - actually even more power for the AMR. P/w ratio alone gives the AMR the advantage.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +4

      ofc there is weight and power, the amg is less powerful and heavier. the valkyrie have less aerodynamic drag and more downforce. the efficiency of the AMR is just insane, and the AMR PRO is even more.

    • @ipo7596
      @ipo7596 Год назад +1

      @@kinka16 amr pro will join LMH??

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      @@ipo7596 hum yes it will by 2025 but i don't see why you said that

    • @ipo7596
      @ipo7596 Год назад +1

      @@kinka16 i thought they join 2024. Hopefully Bolide also joins. They both look the most beautiful if they join LMH.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      @@ipo7596 not sure about the bolide, they can use thier w16 since it is allowed BUT they have to get the power down to 700hp. in therm of weight saving, the w16 is not optimized with his 400kg (minimal engine weight is 165kg)...the bodywork seems to be out of rules at first sight so the real LMH model would change look wise. if i was bugatti, i wouldn't use the w16

  • @MessyRook09
    @MessyRook09 Год назад +12

    Its funny how they were so evenly matched on the straight, even though the Aston had plenty more powaa

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +4

      it has more downforce !

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад +4

      Only a 70 horsepower difference but the amg one has less drag.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +2

      @@Jesko. no it has more drag and less downforce, on top of being 500kg heavier

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад +2

      @@kinka16 They make roughly the same amount of downforce. Valkyrie makes 800kg and under breaking over a thousand. So it's similar to the senna and the amg one. But no. It makes more drag. And it's 300kg heavier. The valkyrie weighs 1450 kg curb.

    • @K3b1bisLtu
      @K3b1bisLtu 6 месяцев назад +1

      The amg does have active aero, so at high speeds, it's even with the valkyrie.
      But it definitely doesn't make as much downforce as the valkyrie.

  • @pigeonpoo1823
    @pigeonpoo1823 Год назад +9

    The aston was making music every time it downshifted, so won

  • @lotuselisenobel
    @lotuselisenobel Год назад +5

    Tremendous side by side action! 💥

  • @roosevelt21
    @roosevelt21 Год назад +24

    The AMG was in highway mode, giving it less downforce. It would probably do better in race mode where the downforce is increased

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      it also mean slower in the straight and more drag !

    • @Faiz_Azad-Khan
      @Faiz_Azad-Khan Год назад

      The race mode is not street legal I believe might be wrong

    • @impulsemedia2080
      @impulsemedia2080 Год назад

      the AMG is still much slower than the Valkyrie

    • @Faiz_Azad-Khan
      @Faiz_Azad-Khan Год назад

      @@impulsemedia2080 yeah probably true we don’t have much lap times from both of course but the Aston is lighter more power and looks like to have more downforce also but until the Valkyrie doesn’t do a lap around the Nürburgring the amg one will be considered faster because it put a lap down even though we all know who is faster

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад

      @@Faiz_Azad-Khan No it isn't. Amg one was 1 second slower than gt3 pole 2022

  • @CanadaPlayz48
    @CanadaPlayz48 Год назад +11

    Didn't Red Bull contribute a bit to the Valkyrie back when they were sponsored by Aston Martin?

    • @Cryptic-çi
      @Cryptic-çi Год назад +6

      Yup, and a hell of a lot more than a bit.

    • @Tire24
      @Tire24 Год назад +1

      Now Verstappen has one of his own.

    • @Decypha77
      @Decypha77 11 месяцев назад +2

      The car is actually Adrian Newey's take on a street legal car. It started as his and he developed it with Aston Martin who then also helped it look like an Aston Martin as much as possible within the constraints of Adrian's initial concept.

  • @GG-bi2jz
    @GG-bi2jz Год назад +5

    AMG One:1700kg 0-100kph:2.9s
    Aston Martin :1100kg 0-100kph:2.6s ハイダウンフォース
    もっと差が出るはず

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад +3

      The valkyrie weighs 1450 kg curb Aston Martin failed there weight tseget

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад +2

      Also the amg one as electric power. So it makes sense that it accelerates faster.

    • @Decypha77
      @Decypha77 11 месяцев назад

      The Valkyrie also has electric power though. @@Jesko.

  • @Nerdybetta
    @Nerdybetta Год назад +3

    The Valkyrie was litteraly made by Adrian Newey

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      yes and no, he started the project but an other guy finishes it. btw it nearly bankcrupt aston !

  • @Not_HelmutMarko
    @Not_HelmutMarko Год назад

    Yesss... I've been waiting for this...

  • @jann1k_MSC47
    @jann1k_MSC47 Год назад +1

    Love both but Valk ❤❤❤

  • @ArenderBros
    @ArenderBros 10 месяцев назад

    We need the 4wd Valkyrie

  • @carburetor77
    @carburetor77 Год назад +2

    Wow Red Bull is even fastest on the streets!

  • @ranchius
    @ranchius 6 месяцев назад

    Considering the AMG weighs 410 KG more and has 67 less horsepower, I'm surprised it did that well against the Aston.

  • @sirafoxtron1701
    @sirafoxtron1701 Год назад

    These 2 brands shares the common
    The gorgeous engine sound.

  • @scharahorst374
    @scharahorst374 Год назад

    Bugatti Bolide vs. Valkyrie AMR Pro please!!!

  • @deltas4764
    @deltas4764 Год назад

    That's what I call wheel to wheel racing

  • @muhammadbayuajimunggaran
    @muhammadbayuajimunggaran Год назад

    Its the genius way of the big team to develop the f1 engine without even touching the budget of the team.

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  Год назад +2

      Ferrari has their Hypercar
      Red Bull is working on a road car
      Mercedes has the AMG One
      Aston Martin has the Valkyrie
      Alpine has their LMDh
      Williams has Williams Advanced Engineering
      Alfa Romeo has Sauber Technologies
      Mclaren has an IndyCar and FE team
      Haas has a NASCAR team
      What budget cap? 😂

  • @ihsanjayadi88
    @ihsanjayadi88 Год назад +7

    I'd rather take the AMG One, it has a much bigger historical significance and it looks better when it's in full track mode imo. Why is the AMG One not in track mode here?

    • @mr8I7
      @mr8I7 Год назад +2

      How? It has no racing pedigree whereas the Aston will race at Le Mans.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      ​@@mr8I7what ???? bro you never heard about Mercedes in F1 ????? btw the powertrain comes from thier F1 and btw merc also did le mans...man, this is the time to learn !

  • @manufaustino316
    @manufaustino316 Год назад

    "F1 Cars for the road" but only rich roads holy f*ck

  • @onlycars-et6ti
    @onlycars-et6ti 9 месяцев назад

    Can you give me the mod of both of them?

  • @Universejurassic
    @Universejurassic Месяц назад

    Pov AMG one no activo el modo Attack 💀

  • @xnotasweatx
    @xnotasweatx Год назад +5

    Is the AMG slowed down by the spoiler not deploying?

    • @infinitetk4165
      @infinitetk4165 Год назад +3

      Yes

    • @xnotasweatx
      @xnotasweatx Год назад +5

      @@infinitetk4165 I find it odd that the mod is not accurate because it doesn’t look like it works here

    • @v0ldy54
      @v0ldy54 Год назад

      @@xnotasweatx every mod of those cars sucks ass

    • @houseking9211
      @houseking9211 Год назад

      @@xnotasweatx probably not, the car would be no faster if the wings went up, you can see by the way it was acting in corners, more rear wing would've just added understeer, and it could be just not showing visually. Especially awd cars don't need nearly as much rear downforce as rwd

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      what ? with the spoiler it would be even slower since a spoiler the car produce more downforce and more drag, its good for turns but not for straights

  • @flavioschrenk2425
    @flavioschrenk2425 Год назад

    big difference is that the amg is road legal, or am i wrong?

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  Год назад

      Both are road legal. The Valkyrie has a track-only version too.

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  Год назад

      Both are road legal. The Valkyrie has a track-only version too.

  • @notoriousl.a.d2427
    @notoriousl.a.d2427 3 месяца назад

    Not fair AMG wasn't in there full downforce setting

  • @ZedNinetySix_
    @ZedNinetySix_ Год назад

    That 2 seat Mercedes made from carbon and doesn't even have cupholders is nearly 1,800kg....💀
    Wtf lol

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  Год назад

      Yeah, the new AMG GT weights 2000 kg, same for the C63... I don't know what are they doing.

  • @OscarZheng50
    @OscarZheng50 Год назад +3

    the AMG's rear wing and active areo wasnt even deployed bruh

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      would change nothing

    • @OscarZheng50
      @OscarZheng50 Год назад

      @@kinka16 mate it'll make the car corner 50% better and keep the same speed on the straight as the one in the video

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      @@OscarZheng50 how the straight line speed would be better ? explaind to me. and btw, this track is more mechanical grip related rather than aero. only the fast right turn after the straight line is aero-related. so the valkyrie would have win anyway due to the low weight

    • @OscarZheng50
      @OscarZheng50 Год назад

      @@kinka16 straight line would be the same as in the video but the rear wing plus the pop out flaps in the front produce like a good chunk of downforce and you say that only mechanical grip was needed, if the Mercedes had its active areo it would be able to do the fast right hander out of the long straight a lot faster and would've been able to hold off the valkyrie, that was really the valkyrie's only overtaking opportunity as it got aero vs no aero on the Mercedes. the Mercedes was in front off the line and defending position is easier than overtaking a position. the valkyrie has some sophisticated ground effect areo going on underneath and front spoiler and rear wing. isn't really fair coming a car with aero to a car without areo. only thing the Mercedes had going for it was the 4wd launch off the line then it was pretty much defensive the whole time

  • @adamsteinmetz3223
    @adamsteinmetz3223 Год назад +3

    Am looks better, sounds better, and is an actual racecar, the choice is easy folks

  • @fransergiodelgado
    @fransergiodelgado Год назад

    Valkyrie is not an F1. AMG One is.
    But I prefer the V12.

    • @ZedNinetySix_
      @ZedNinetySix_ Год назад

      The lead designer of AMR is Adrian Newey.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      a f1 with a poor aero and heavy weight but ok

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад

      @@kinka16 It doesn't have poor aero. It makes 800 kg of downforce with active aero tf you on about?

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад +1

      @@Jesko. i didn't mean it has a bad aero, it just have a less effective one. if 2 cars produce the exact same 500kg of downforce at the exact same speed, if one have a higher drag coefficient, this one will have a slower top speed, less fuel efficiency and it will require more power to be accelerate.
      it has a poor aero in comparaison to the valkyrie. btw active aero does not mean good aero.
      (the guy on top said it is a "f1")

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад

      @@kinka16 Active aero is impressive. And a car that has it can not be considered to have poor aero. And what your saying is still wrong. F1 cars have some of the wordy aero efficiency there is. Because they're open wheel and open cockpit cars. The amg one is more aero efficient. Far more than an F1 car and is stil more aero efficient than the Valkyrie. Down the straight it will activate active aero and produce less drag. Active aero does mean good aero. But I guess that and it's F1 engine made it overweight.

  • @rafale-fg8eo
    @rafale-fg8eo Год назад

    It was an evidence

  • @adamsteinmetz3223
    @adamsteinmetz3223 Год назад

    Also you should’ve used the AMR Pro

    • @Jesko.
      @Jesko. Год назад +5

      What? Why compare a track only car to a road legal car? Of course not.

    • @kinka16
      @kinka16 Год назад

      nahhh the amr pro is not road legal and it would have destory even more the amg one

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  11 месяцев назад

      It's not road legal

  • @spanishcarguy2810
    @spanishcarguy2810 Год назад +2

    AMG One, sorry.

  • @VW-Gaming18
    @VW-Gaming18 Год назад

    Where mclaren f1