DJI Mavic Mini vs. DJI Spark - Is It an Upgrade?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2019
- Mavic Mini & Spark raw images:
drive.google.com/drive/folder...
Mavic Mini Specs: click.dji.com/AEt1mNjCsoksx2n...
Spark Specs: click.dji.com/ALUKNpQx0fgbUnR...
DJI Mavic Mini:
click.dji.com/AChWS1WpFhYB2gJ...
moment.8ocm68.net/d1qXQ
Mavic Mini Playlist:
• DJI Mavic Mini
My Gear:
DJI Inspire 2: click.dji.com/AHazYHMipEZHQQF...
DJI Zenmuse X4S: click.dji.com/AI0GIu5CtMwhY-n...
DJI Mavic 2 Pro: click.dji.com/AIBborbeJjpPUHV...
M2P ND Filters: amzn.to/2EA2T4V
Camera Bag: amzn.to/2tR7ivi
Sony a7 III: amzn.to/2SMLpHA
Sony GM 16-35: amzn.to/2NHwfmE
Shotgun Mic: amzn.to/2JWnDaG
ALL GEAR:
www.amazon.com/shop/billykyle
Check out my podcast:
/ flighttimecast
Study to become a commercially certified drone pilot in the US, with the help of the Drone Pilot Ground School:
learn.uavcoach.com/a/aff_95hf...
Use code "BILLYKYLE50" for $50 off!
Get your drone repaired by experienced technicians:
djidroneservice.com
Use code "BKFAN10" for 10% off!
FOLLOW ME:
/ billykyle
/ billykyle
/ billykyle
/ billiamkyle
/ billykyle
billykyle.net
Outro music:
Super Duper - Far From Falling 
Наука
Just a note on the comparison footage: The Mavic Mini seems to lack dynamic range, blowing out a lot of the highlight areas. I expect this will be fixed by DJI when the Fly app comes out of beta with the first big update the drone receives.
Would underexposing the footage and bringing it out post process help?
I been flying my spark Since they came out and I put it through hell I still like this spark for what it does I also have the Mavic pro I live in the Philippines thanks for the video Billy
Hopefully they’ll add some manual control for video. I wish they would up the 40mbs bit rate but then like you said it’s in M air territory. Not sure if I would use it for paid work, but as I said on Bill and others channels is that I think it’s the perfect addition to a travel kit of my Sony RX100 V, and a iPad Pro. I was going to pull the “impulse” purchase on release day but they just pre released it. I think I will buy it though. I’m always amazed at how convenient and the video quality is on my RX100. Hope you’re well Billy and enjoy your coming up thanksgiving break.
Not sure if you noticed and chose not to mention it when comparing sizes, but the Mavic Mini actually has the same footprint as the Mavic Air when unfolded. So it's smaller than the Spark when folded, but as big as the Air when unfolded. That's a big deal for it to have such a wide base considering it's light weight.
You can definitely tell the difference in images, obviously with the spark you’re able to control the shutter speed and exposure so the Mavic Mini images look blown out as you said
12:14 That’s the game changer right there. 2x the range, double the flight time and also FAA free for new beginners
thanks
Definitely, technology has improved quite a lot between the years where lightweight drones with advanced technology are a lot more easier to create
The realistic range is actually better on the spark if you use an otg cable, it is also much more interference resiliant
Now people selling the spark cheap to fund the mini. Best time to buy a spark
Ash Zk Lol yeah look at Facebook marketplace you can get the fly more combo for $300
Ash Zk I still say the spark better you get more modes they had me with the mini until I found out it lacked the quick shot modes and active track
No active track! I'm gonna stick with my spark
@@angelogotrice im holding my money just yet for people to further drop the price of their spark. 1 dude offered me a p4a for rm2300( 500dollar in usd).
I got mine with fly more combo and mobile charging station for 240$
Seeing Philly brought a tear to my eye. Damn, I miss home. I loved the Spark. Just ordered the Mini. It looks like it might need some software updates to adjust the color profile a bit.
DJI Spark advantages over the Mavic Mini:
- faster,
- much more manual control and settings,
- very high quality FHD image (easy smooth edit),
- perfect colors out of the box - no need to color grade etc.,
- active track
- front sensors
- more rigid and sturdy body.
Mavic Mini Advantages over the Spark:
- slightly higher output 2.7k vs FHD (not as much difference as you might think thou!) still a bit more details
- longer flight time on one battery (30min vs 14 min) - twice much
- 249g. vs 300g for some it might be advantage
- 3 axis gimbal compared to 2 axis + 1 axis digital
(not so much of a difference if you are not panning too often) still 3ax always bit better than two axis gimbal) - said that
Spark footage is also buttery smoth Spark is like 7/10 while Mavic Mini is 9/10.
Similarities:
Both very small
Both great footage
Both similarily priced
Both similar distance and connectivity althou Spark can be modified with app to CE and FCC mode.
If you have Spark I wouldn't consider Mavic Mini as a upgrade. I would rather keep the spark or sold it and get Mavic 2 Pro / Air / Zoom.. or even old Mavic Pro 1.
ummm .. while i tried to buy spark this mini came so i do alot of comparison over utube videos and reviews...but the flight time and 2.k and the 50fps shooting mode is convincing me to go for mini...hope i am not wrong and hope dji will updates the firmware of this beta mavic mini soon enough
@@35mm_g_master70 i agree.. i think i will go for mavic mini.. thx for opinion..
I'm planning to sell my spark too and get the mavic mini
Crash test?
I have to disagree. Unless the 60fps is absolutely necessary i think the spark is a better value. Spark has more Sensors, faster, tougher, more controls on remote and more options for active track etc.
Plus it's honestly like a tank. This thing is tough i've crashed mine twice and all it's ever needed was a prop change which can be done in 5 seconds with no tools.
Love my mini, I’m a licensed pilot with a Mavic 2 pro but I’ll still bring this thing everywhere
I appreciate that the Mavic Mini unfolds. The different model for Europe and UK is frustrating.
I bought the Spark in May of this year and been using it during my out-of-town trips and uploaded on my channel. Thanks for this review coz I didn’t have to regret of buying the Spark! Haha. Thanks!
Great comparison review. I just bought the mini. I have had the pro and really love the size of the mini and the flight time. It flys exceptionally and seems like a bigger drone. I will have it with me wherever I go. You do a great job billy. thanks for the review.
On a phone screen the footage is similar. But the longer flight time makes it a no brainer in my opinion
Think I will keep my spark and save for the Mavic Pro
exactly same conclusion.. Mavic Pro Original is similarly priced (100usd more) than DJI Mavic Mini in my country.. so I probabily go for Occusync.. and just the pro version..
I have both. The range is nice on the Mavic Pro but the Mini actually shoots better video despite being 2.7K vs 4K. The Mavic Pro always had micro-stuttering issues when panning and the Mini is a lot smoother. I think a better upgrade when it comes to video quality would be from Spark to Mavic Air.
Why don't u buy dji mavic air 2
Pieter deli ho I am now. At the time it wasn’t out
@@BrouilletteLuke ok got it
Thanks for the comparison but I love my spark
Thanks for the comparison, Billy! Just what I needed to see to help me decide if I should upgrade from the Spark.
I'm keeping my Spark. They both do their own things, Spark fly's in colder weather and is a beast at fast maneuvering like a fighter plane. Not to mention the panoramas.
After 3 years, DJI Spark is still the best "Mini Sefie Drone" in the world with the ability to control by hand gesture without take time to connect it with smartphone or controller. 😁👏
Thanks Billy...
Exceptionally good video! Precise and to the point!
Thank you..
Phil
Kentucky
Thank you for providing raw images!
Thank your for the review and hopefully I can save some money to buy one for my Goalkeeping videos.
I spoke to a dji rep and he said that the Mavic Mini is not an upgrade to the Spark but it was designed as a new sun 250g drone.
Thanks for this video. I ordered the mini right after watching your video.
I really want to thank you for this great video. After watching this I canceled my order for the Mini Fly More. I searched for and found an awesome deal (less than the Mini Fly More) on a little used, virtually new Spark with many accessories. So far it has been very easy to learn how to use. It is really a great drone.
are you going to review the skydio2?
Was it me or did the Spark's images/video look so much better than the Mini's?
Absolutely. Thats what I thought
👍🏽
I saw the opposite. In the waterfall, the Spark's video is noticeably worse, almost to the point where it actually looks bad. Though in photos, it did have more dynamic range!
Did you watch the comparison on a small 1080P monitor laptop screen? I saw it on a 43" 4K screen on my Desktop computer and the Mini was much better on Video and camera images were the same.
Not only you. But spark actually way better than mini
Thanks Billy. Informative and precise as usual. I honestly cannot see much difference in the photos or videos taken on either device but you are a skilled pilot who knows how to get the best out of the Spark. I have learned to fly my Spark taking account of the limitations of the 2 axis gimble and the video looks smooth now. I also feel some loyalty to Sparky because it has survived some serious crashes and I may be wrong here but the Mini looks flimsy and that gimble is vulnerable and replacing the props is a pain.
Anyway, a great review so many thanks.
I agree prop replacement will be a pain, now you have to worry about eight screw threads that might strip.
Awesome review and comparison. Thank you! You gained a subscriber :)
Great review comparison test. Great little drone the mini, but still love my Spark. Cheers :)
i think spark looks better
Thanks for that great video brother, much appreciated. Mavic Mini it is for me then and going to buy one.
Another great video. I think I still like most of the Spark photos and videos better! The on video that the Mavic Mini seemed better at was where you were on the river/lake flying sideways. The video seemed smoother and had more detail on the Mini.
I have spark and im gonna keep it. I thought about changing it but no. Thanks for this video
I swear from what I see... the spark looked better in pics and video from your examples
I agree
I thought so too!
I agree with both the comments, be nice for Billy to come back on this as he said there wasn't that much in it, but I can see a difference and a mainly use my drone for images. Maybe it needs a bit more processing or like mentioned earlier the dynamic range upgrading after beta testing, the highlights were extra bright which wasn't pleasing to the eye. The Spark had more depth in its images in my opinion.
To my eyes, the mini video is MUCH better!
I watched on my S10e and I had it on zoom to fit (hiding the bottom left) and I thought for sure the 2nd of each example looked better. What a surprise.
Superb video, full of good information. Thanks Billy.
Very well constructed video. Ty sir
I’m actually glad that I can store the mavic mini buttons within the controller itself for easier carrying
7:00, yeah its called the mavic
I was thinking the exact same thing. Throw in bigger motors, and sensors etc. And you have a mavic. Haha
Or the Mavic Air.....Shoots 4K and has obstacle avoidance, etc
As one would expect, the real difference was in the video examples. The Mini really shows it's chops there. Thank you for a very concise complete comparison with the Spark and it's successor the Mavic Mini. Well done Billy!
@@MikeKinney8675 If someone gets upset when your flying it, just say its only a toy. Use the term for your own advantage .
If it helps me fly in an inconspicuous manor, I'm fine calling it a toy. 😎
I can't say that the Minis videos were better here as I clearly saw better video quality from the Spark video. The Minis video looked kinda blown out.
Thank you for your video I have two Sparks and I was thinking about a mini however maybe later but for now I love my two sparks. And the reason I two is I go out with my sons and we fly to gather.
100 % without question the Mavic Mini is an upgrade from the spark!
I’ve been flying this thing all day and contemplating taking it on a western hunt tour for the outdoor channel with my inspire 2 instead of the i2 and Mavic 2 pro. It can get into areas and catch some angles that even the Mavic won’t
Careful the state you live in may have restrictions on using a drone during an active hunting season. Where I live in Oregon you cannot use any unmanned vehicle for surveillance or filming in any hunting unit during any active hunting season.
I think it depends on what you want. No Active Track, Gesture Control or ability to control without a remote are deal killers for me as I use my these feature on my Spark and Mavic Air all of the time. It's usually why I decide to leave my Anafi at home. When I am out on the golf course on vacation (or even my home course) and want to shoot some quick video of playing out a hole with my wife and/or buddies, I don't want to pull out a case and start dealing with a remote. Hand launch my Spark within seconds, wave it away from my and it's following me down the fairway and recording the whole thing. That's just not going to happen with the Mini. If I want more control without a remote, I'll bring the Mavic Air. It takes a little more time to get it off the ground but still not fussing with a remote. Without some firmware and software updates, the Mini is just a downgrade FOR MY USE.
Scott Almas
Yeah I see what you’re saying. It would be cool if they added some of that stuff to the mavic mini, especially active track. I feel like gesture control is kind of a gimmick, I used it once and never used it again. But the active track was always really cool to me. I think the mavic mini still has some of the modes like dronie, rocket, circle, and stuff like that though.
Superpope69 thank you. Yes we are well aware of the rules and regs regarding drone use during hunting season. They cannot be used to scout property you’re actively hunting during season and if the drone is flown over said property then it must be a period of not less than 24 hours until you may Hunt the property. We only use them for B-roll production. In no way do we use them to our advantage in a hunting situation.
SquiDragon I am really glad I stuck with gesture in terms of training myself to get used to using it. It has made selfies and short follow me videos much more spontaneous. It felt gimmicky to me also but honestly it was my gateway to the Mavic Air. I already had an Anafi but saw the benefits of hand controls and wanted something of Anafi quality but with hand control.
I’m just getting a spark with an extra battery.
I completely agree that I loved the idea of a "Mavic Mini Plus" - a drone that has the same form factor but ignores the weight restriction. That is something I would be very excited about!
Hey Bill!
Great video, as always ... Thanks! And I agree with you, too!
The main reasons I’m staying with my Spark ..
1.) Can’t use DroneVR app as I do, using my iPhone in VR goggles to fly ‘in my Spark!’
2.) I mostly use the various camera modes (ie Panoramas, etc) which are NOT available, yet on the mini???
Hopefully, they will add the above and then I’d upgrade but for now, why pay for a downgrade???
Hi. If I have to buy the drone starting from zero. What do you suggest? I never used a drone. Thank you.
Federico Maria Achilli I will go for the mavic mini
Nice comparison video, and it's interesting that the two and half year old Spark still has some advantages over the new Mavic Mini.
Very robust, good comparison of these two drones. I love the way you handled this and also sharing a video comparison, and picture comparison. Whewwww- I don't want to just, throw my spark away, but I'm pretty impressed with what I'm hearing about the flying experience from you and others about the new mini. Also having 60fps. is nice and of course the 3 axis gimble. That's a lot of bang for not too many more bucks than what the Spark is right now. This looks like a pretty worthwile drone. Thanks so much for the great comparison. Marc Trainor.
Oh, and I forgot to mention the extra flight time. Marc.
Great comparison video thank you :)
Billy, the one amazing party trick of the spark is becoming a jedi! 'The force is strong with this one' 😂 I guess the mavic mini is on the dark side...
For an adventurous person I think the spark is still the best. Has obstacle avoidance and active track. The mini has neither of these options.
Another point not mentioned in the review is that the Mini in video mode only has e.v. control. The Spark has full control over the camera in video mode. I would think in time the mini will have these as it is a software not hardware issue. I will not be upgrading just yet. I think DJI is going to pull a fast one on us and come up with a Mavic Mini Pro plus which shoots in 4k and uses the full blown software. Time will tell.
@@eddyg1794 true lol...will wait until next year before buying a new drone. It's raining season after all at my place .
@@Ash47ZK agreed winter time I don't plan on flying much anyways so I will be waiting also..
I'd honestly just buy a used air or Mavic pro 1
@@eddyg1794 I'm betting you're right. But I'm still trying to decide I can buy a spark in an unopened Box from a local guy for less money then the Mini so I'm still trying to decide which one to buy.
You are really good man, subbed
I have spark. now one year of age (october).. awesome drones awesome footage.. awesome photos.. (took 360 photo and post on facebook) .. nice smooth footage even only have 2 axis gimbals. (but still can warp stabilize in post)..
The Spark looks like it's been edited while the Mavic Mini looks like it's shooting closer to log
Spark looks great for the money
From DJI Support:
"I suggest you fix your Spark and use it with your travel as it is still a better aircraft than the Mavic Mini."
Hope this might help someone. I got the Spark when it first came out, and travel around the world with a Spark via bicycle. I was really interested in the New Mavic Mini.
(I have only ever used the phone app to control the Spark.)
Billy Boi, great vid. you gotta get those side by sides for us in future tho. always the best to really compare
Great comparison, thanks!
Spark was my favourite but with a 2 minute boot up time and 2 minute gps search and 15% battery remaining you only get about 10 minutes.
Mavic Mini also takes forever to GPS lock.
Lately I've had major issues with my Spark and signal connection. It's constantly disconnecting. Anyone else?
I actually think the spark looks like more of a premium drone. for some reason the mini looks like a plasticky toy.
Agreed
I agree I own the spark and the Mavic Air and the air feels very plasticky in comparison. I think DJI is putting profit before quality, always happens as companies grow.
Sure seems that way.
But it has the 3-axis gimbal 😁
David Gilchrist lets not forget it needed to be light...
Great video Billy....keep em comin...👍
Great comparison and information. Thank you!
Hey I’m looking into buying my first drone and I just saw this video for the first time. And what made this video even better is that I was watching it and was like... “Hey!! That’s Philly! I live there too lol!!”
Flight time , range and camera quality can be good reasons to upgrade to mavic mini from spark. But mavic mini cannot take panorama , bracketing or shallow focus which my little sparky does . (my most liked photos are usually panorama photos, sorry little mavic mini) And for the new users, obstacle ovaidance is tooooo important . The obstacle avoidence saved my ass for a lot of times. If i sell my sparky, i can easily buy a mavic mini, but do i? Of course not.
I agree. If you should change your mind, I will buy yours :-)
Good review, excellent explanations, thansk :)
Thansk
Thanks again great videos.
Biggest selling point is the battery time 30min vs 15min
which one has 30 min?
@@NipponKiwi Mavic mini
30 is more loke 23 min ,and spark is 16 so not a lot...
@@danparaschivoiu8620 27-28 min. Don't be bitter that you own the spark ')
Dan Paraschivoiu in reality spark is 9-11 and mini is around 23-25
My experience with the mini vs spark after owning each of them since launch, and with the latest firmware:
Mini: Everything I want out of a drone. Premium, better image/video quality, stable, easy to control, good flight range, VERY good battery life. No Activetrack or obstacle avoidance, but I never used that anyway. This drone is now faster than the in the latest firmware update.
Spark: Has a lot of features I never use. Good video quality, but mini is miles better.
So the mini has better photo and video quality? Don't they have the same sensor? I have the Spark and use it mostly for photos. Wondering if I should switch to mini.
@@joaomarveloso1049 They do, but they have different color science. The Spark has a two axis gimbal, limiting the video resolution to 1080p and causing some photos to end up blurry because the gimbal is shaking to the left and right. The mini has a three axis gimbal, letting you have peace of mind.
Does the missing obstacle avoidance sensor worry you if u want to use the return to home feature?
@@Mental_Alchemist No. I never even used it on my spark.
Sticking to my Spark for compact drone. I also have a Mavic 2 Zoom but the Spark is the "throw in the bag and go" drone.
Nice demo also went back and looked at your flying demo. They put all of this in 249 grams, amazing. Happy Flying
Keeping the spark, no weight rules here in Australia anyway.
We have weight laws in NZ but it's like 25kg before you have get an actual drone licence which all consumer drones are well under
The spark pictures looked better than minis to my eyes . But the minis videos looked better.
Thank you for specifying the price, in my country (Romania) it sells now (29.10.2020) for 456$ and 552$ full combo.
Weird how after one year the price is still bigger then the original USA release.
I've had the spark I have an original mavic pro and I also have the mavic 2 Enterprise dual with the thermal camera and for me flight time is a big factor so I would definitely choose the mini over the spark because the rest of the differences are so similar that flight time is just too big of a difference to ignore.
Less is more?... This is not really an UPgrade. It's a trade off.
Absolutely 👍
NO its not. You get a 3 axis gimbal. Foldable arms. Double flight time. Triple range. Much lower price. Many accessories,(charging base) . Plus you're getting a better app.
O RAFABALL its not what you get its what you lose....hence trade off.
twice the range and flight time.. thats what I care about. Just depends on what you want to use tue drones for and what you think is more important
Djestin de Vries if you have the spark already it is a trade off. If you do not have the spark the mini is the ONLY choice.
yall know what's the biggest bummer of this brilliant little guy?
micro-usb in 2019
Ollie Wayne meh. It has fast charge so I’m not bothered by it.
LexaPr0 I don’t like the idea of bringing an extra charging cable that should be eliminated long time ago
I was thinking the same thing! All our phones and devices are USB C. It's a pain having to have a seperate micro USB
Outstanding review. My Spark did a flyaway after two sensor failures an hour out of the box. Swore I'd never buy another DJI since they wouldn't honor the warranty. But, based on your review, I'm considering a Mini. Thanks.
Thanks for the vid . . been flying the spark for about a year. . thinking about an upgrade but not ready to drop a grand on a mavic . . . so now imconcerned though hecause for me the big call outs would be the flight time and the range . .
I bought the spark recently and I think it is amazing!
karsten kropat did it come with the remote?
Okpara Clinton I bought the fly more combo so yes
Do u have a licence or smth
I just wish my spark flew straight. I love my spark, but from everything I’ve seen and read, the mini seems to have buttery smooth flight controls. I’m sure the 3-axis gimbal helps out as well.
Thanks for all that info
super helpful...thank you!
Spark image is better, I miss my spark, even compared to my manic air. Wish the spark had a 3 axis as I would not have sold it
I love my Spark!!!
Very well done. Thanks!
Thanks for the cinematic pics of Philly. I moved away 27 years ago.
The mini needed to be light so material isn’t as good
A beginners drone without obstacle avoidance.
That's how u learn
Imho obstacle avoidance is totally unnecessary, have flown drones for years, back in the days of built ones only, and never needed it, something like that shouldn't be relied on... it's called learning to fly properly.
Nice comparison video
Hey Billy, I’m interested in tight POI shots. Do you have any idea how the spark compares to the mini regarding how close to the poi it can be while recording?
I was trying to get some art sculpture shots in poi with my MP2 but I couldn’t get as tight a shot as I needed…thinking the S or M might do better. Any thoughts?
Spark images n vids looks better..sticking with my spark 🤷🏾♂️
You forgot to mention that the gesture control is not existing anymore on the Mini. Even if it was not as perfect on the Spark as on the Mavic Air this seems to be great for family selfies and now I miss this badly.
I can life with 1080, 12 minutes flight time and a 2 axis gimbal but lack of selfies and no manual control on video is really hard to accept.
Hella nice review thanks!
I really like the Mini as a first/basic/entry level drone. I'm more of a land based photographer so the fact that this packs in a small-ish bag with my A7III is the main reason I purchased it. I definitely wish it had some more of those higher end features, especially RAW shooting, but for me the size and weight are paramount. Also, cool sample vids! I definitely wasn't expecting to see Philly when I searched Spark vs Mavic Mini. 😂
You want a Mavic Mini, with the extra clout, that is not restricted by weight.... call it a Mavic Air.
Yea I just said that myself..
@@Honeypot-x9s me too
The Sparks footage looks much better in my opinion
Yeah, great for that "dji mavic mini plus". Imaginne what you can do with that small drone ❤️
Thanks for the video...I think I will still roll with my Phantom 3 a d spark for now...
I sold my spark last week. So you know what i'm coming for
👀
I won't be buying the mini, not an upgrade from the spark imo.
An upgrade to the spark would be Mavic air upwards. Thanks for the comparison though!
A.D.B. Right
In terms of flying time it is an upgrade thou. The price of a used spark fmc and a new mavic mini fmc differs only at usd50 at my country. Still waiting for local flyer rl opinion
@Billy Kyle do you know of any way to logout of your profile in the DJI Fly app? i cannot figure a way out for the iOS app. deleted app and resintalled, prev profile still logged in. so weird. thanks for the vids! my mini should be here on thur!!
Nice video! I already had a spark and considering buying a mavic mini (because of the video quality and flight time) can you use the spark RC when using the mavic mini?
I do believe the Spark does have a slight edge in photos over the mini, but I’m still down with the Mini especially since I’m waiting for mine in the mail! Lol
Mikhail Anderson
I think his settings were just off. You can customize photo settings in the new app, and I think his were a little too bright compared to the spark. I think both drones for photos are about equally good. Video is where the mini excels though for sure.
SquiDragon You are absolutely right, I just assumed the worst. Still excited to receive my mini whenever Dji decides to ship it
I totally agree on a Mavic Mini Pro with 4K and anti collision sensors...
Nice job brother thanks a lot that help me a lot
What's the bottom line? Which one of them you recommend?
And thx about the review!