Stumbled on this via diamonds and rust by Joan Baez. I saw Hurricane performed in London in the late seventies. Scarlet blew us all away that night, but I have to say the intensity of this version is killing. Bob has done so much, it's hard when you try to comment on a genius. We know. But on this recording we feel every word. The rhythm is all Bob a the back beat and bass threading pistol shots in the dark. What a song, at last about something real. A mans life rotting in. prison cell for something he didn't do. Racism in its most profound form. Bless you Bob and bless you kind people for liking this and appreciating the art and the humanity. I heard it recently with Tracey Chapman on the Grammy's. The power of a simple song told powerfully. Respect.
He delivered for sure. But I always wonder if given a choice in that circumstance if he might have wanted to do Billie Holliday song to truly pay his respects to John Hammond.
The audience was with him 100%...I loved the pre song clapping as much as the post song clapping. Oh Krishna. The magnificence of America's Bob. He is a heart throb. Dylan, Always willin To create for our heart's desire, A tale, a melody on fire. Long life to you, Bobby the bard of song Long long long may your songs be heard. Play on and paint Paint and sing into the night to bring the light. American beautiful laureate glorious For spacious art notorious. 🍓💐☺️🎨🖌️🎬🪑🎸🎹
My dad used to listen to Bob Dylan. On weekends my Dad would play Bob Dylan on the huge console stereo that was nested in the corner of our living groom. I would lay down in front of the speakers and sing along with words my 5 year old self thought Bob was singing. (Come lay across my bumble glass bread)🫤 As an adult I’m thrilled to have stumbled upon Dylan again. I’m obsessed.
i met rubin carter, it was christmas 1988, at a convention for wrongly convicted in seattle. he told me quite convincingly if not for bob dylans record he wouldve struggled getting justice. RIP rubin
The fact that Dylan chose this 8 minute song to perform live on a major PBS special - one of the most searing and unfiltered indictments of the racist penal justice system in the United States by a "popular" artist - is a testament to the man's courage and convictions.
One of Dylan's best songs.. complex, thoughtful, intellectual, interesting, great beat, melody. It's 2022 and we do not see any musicians able to write a complex, complete 9 minute song that is so innovative and thought provoking.. America- start educating your youth !!!!!!
@@bellakrinkle9381 plus, hard, hard, hard work... nothing comes easy without work. Beatles ?? - hard work... U2 ?? -- hard work.. Moody Blues. ?? -- hard work.. Tom Brady ?? - hard work.. Lee Trevino ?? - hard work.
Not entirely true. Watch Taylor Swift's 10 min song "All Too Well", live on SNL version. It's pretty incredible and genius in it's own right, it made me a closet Swifty that's coming out! And yeah, this Dylan song is topnotch.
Rubin "Hurricane" Carter was freed by Canadian activists and lawyers after working hard to find the truth. Carter died in Toronto, Canada. Hope his soul rests in peace.
I read the biography of Ruben “Hurricane” Carter several years ago and it is an excellent and heartbreaking book. One thing that you realize from the book is how seriously Dylan took the writing of this song, interviewing Carter numerous times in jail and penning a song that is artistically genius and yet also historically very very accurate. There will never be another Bob Dylan
Just another reason why he deserved the Nobel Prize in literature though he was often a bit of a protest singer and anti establishment he was so popular they couldn't stop him like say Mario Savio etc.
@@seanmurphy2302he honestly doesn’t need to. It served its purpose and it resulted in public sentiment turning in Ruben’s favor and FINALLY being freed after decades in prison for a crime he and John Artis NEVER COMMITTED.
My thoughts are with you and your family at this time.Have you ever seen the film about Reuben “the hurricane”Carter with Denzel Washington.Just with this being your Grandmother’s favourite it might help knowing a bit about the man Dylan was singing about.Just a thought,by the way your Grandma must of been awesom.
Writing a timeless masterpiece, but all the lyrics are lies. He's glorifying a homicidal sociopath and defaming the victims. That's why he stopped singing this song after the 2nd trial, after a Black jury also found them guilty.
@@kenmiller7708 Four different eyewitnesses saw Artis and Carter flee the scene of the homicide. Hazel Tanis gave a good description of the killer with the pistol to police. They drew a sketch of her description, and it matches John Artis. She also told her daughter that Artis and Carter were the ones who shot her. Also, Artis and Carter both flunked lie detector tests given to them just hours after the shootings.
June 17, 1966 was the day Rubin Carter was arrested. He was exonerated in 1988. It is quite an amazing story, with his release being made possible with the help of a bunch of Canadians and the great Bobby D. This is a fantastic video and I thank you for posting it.
I'm 64 and I still love this song. Brings back those 70's memories. I love my life and I'm very blessed, but things were simpler then and the music was far, far better than today's stuff.
I'm 65. I can relate. That music era was a great time to be young. The first time I heard this song, it was playing in my local record store right after the album was released. I bought the album on the spot. I was already enamored with Dylan's music, but "Desire" is by far my favorite album of his. There isn't a track on the album that doesn't reach me to the core. Not long after, our local AOR station (KZEW in Dallas) was playing this song. I got to hear him play this song only once in concert, but it's a memory I'll never forget. 1993 at the Cal Expo Amphitheater in Sacramento. Great friends. Backstage passes. Perfect weather. Bob Dylan.
I agree, it's one of the most amazing songs ever written, but there are people online who argue persuasively that Rubin was guilty...very guilty, and Bob got it wrong. Rubin was tried twice and convicted each time. The third time, many years later, he was freed, but not exonerated, by the most liberal judge in the state......Check it out for yourself.....But hey, I would want Bob to write a song about me if I was convicted, falsely or other wise.....
@@CoolhandLukeSkywalkr WOW Really? I did not know that. I still havent seen the movie, so I dont know how its portrayed. But still. all that aside, I really love that song, It's typical of his story telling. And if a few liberties are taken, well. I can live with it. Thats a real head twister though. So he really did do it huh?
@@henryshockem9242 The killers sped off in a white dodge polara. Hurricane Carter was stopped by police driving away from the scene of the crime in his white Dodge Polara. It's not a common car. Eyewitnesses saw Hurricane and Artis and IDd them. Also, once in police custody hours after the shooting, Artis and Carter didn't have matching stories about what they had just been doing that night. They were given lie detector tests, and they both flunked them. Hurricane Carter himself has given three or four different versions of the story of what supposedly went down tha4 night. After he was freed, he claimed that the police planted fake bodies in the bar, and nobody was actually even killed. Does that version of the story sound at all plausible to anyone? The killers used an unusual caliber of bullets. .32 caliber bullets in the pistol they used. Hurricane's white polara had .32 caliber pistol bullets strewn on the floor of the car when police arrested them. It's not exactly rocket science..32 caliber isn't even in the top 15 of bullet sizes. It's quite rare. They hid the guns and got rid of them, but they missed some bullets they dropped on the floor of Hurricane's car. Why isn't any of that in the song or the movie? Instead, there is a completely make-believe story about unhinged police officers who framed him. None of that stuff actually happened in real life, and the incriminating things Hurricane Carter did, like having 4 or 5 very different versions of his story about what he was doing that night. None of the stuff that makes Hurricane Carter look guilty is mentioned in the song or the film. Between his first and second trials, he beat up a black bail bonds lady so badly that she almost died. She didn't press charges and so police decided not to persue it. They could at least have shown that. Bob Dylan hasn't performed this song live since the 2nd trial when a Black jury found Artis and Carter guilty, and after everyone knew Carter beat up that bail bonds lady so badly, he put her in the hospital.
@@henryshockem9242 More than a few liberties were taken. Police pulled him over, fleeing the scene of the crime, mere blocks away from the bar. Or as Bob Dylan put it "on the other side of town." Every single part of the song is fictitious and based on lies the killer told.
@@henryshockem9242 I know it's one of his best songs. I still listen to it. I still listen to his songs glorifying John Wesley Harding and George Jackson. But I know what he's doing. He's always glorified killers to cash in on the racial demographics of the US. I'm a fellow Jew, I see what he's doing with this song. Pitting the different gentile races against each other and race-baiting to make a quick buck for himself. It doesn't reflect well on the Jewish race. He shouldn't be out there manipulating gentiles in exchange for fame and financial gain.
@@silvermediastudioReuben hurricane was a real middleweight boxer who was wrongfully imprisoned for 20 years. Very moving movie about it called hurricane.
@@silvermediastudio also heard that he was guilty. The real story is that, he indeed was put in prison for something that he didn't do. Here Dylan says the truth. But to say that the man was innocent is not true, and here I agree. Hurricane definitely was not a saint, and he had done some bad things.
@@bsnf-5 Nope, Dylan's lyrics was an output of Operation Mockingbird and activists seeking to divide and destabilize. Classic information operations that prey on the gullible, useful idiots.
Wow. This is just pure hard working musically gifted people. No fancy lights, stage acts, dance moves, mega screens, synthetic sound or special effects. Just pure artistry in action. How incredibly humbling to our current music industry. Puts the new generation to frigging shame. This song is beautiful and terrifying all at once.
Agree. Just raw gifted music. And they even wore their clothes. Am so proud to be a part of this generation. Nothing like the natural wonders of talent. Wouldn't trade it for anything.
Well he wrote the lines so they mean something to him so the words come natural. And he doesnt phrase it the same every time. He and most musicians start to vary their rhythmical phrasing after their initial recording of the song after repetitive performances of it to keep it sounding fresh.
@subg8858 quite often he doesn't, lol. Seen him more than 20 times and most of the time he's rarely really on point. Much better writer than preformer and he'd probably agree.
I’m in my 70s and BOB, bless him, takes me back to the good old days. So grateful to have lived in those times. A life saver in these disturbing times. Love you BOB.❤️
Everything is so perfect here. A moment thankfully captured on film. This is history. Also it shows what a great rhythm section can do to make a minimal ensemble sound huge without overpowering the singer. Howie Wyeth's snare just snaps and crackles with authority.
Youre right this is both rare and awesome!! When Dylan took this on the road originally he had a huge band the rolling thunder review. This stripped down band is just awesome!
This song is one of Bobs greatest freedom songs , where he stood against the world with his message of truth , already then the evil of corruption and tyranny was shown, but people went sleeping again, dreaming into slavery, and thought it was easy to lean on the same people which destroyed societies then, they still do today, its time they leave, enough is enough. Listen to Bob and take charge of your life and those of the others and innocent and stand for freedom, light . Blessings and grace to Bob and those other freedom fighters who never stopped ! Remember the newspaper (media ) went along with the ride...... never trust media, science trust your own eyes
He very literally might have the most endurance of any performer who has ever lived. Doing shows consistently for *60* fucking years. SIX-ZERO. It's wild. "Best" is basically meaningless though. I love his voice.
@@octagonseventynine1253 They don't understand music. Period. Not even a conversation worth having for those who understand. Music is not some bizarre art of scientific perfection??
Alweer "a timeless masterpiece". Alweer een sublieme Bob Dylan compositie... die door diverse anderen mooi & knap werden gezongen....met vaak een rijker en mooiklinkend arrangement... B D is een verdiende Nobelprijswinnaar van Literatuur... veel van zijn songs zijn gebalde romans... ongelooflijk knap... met hele knappe vondsten erin! Te bewonderen! Blij dat ik kan genieten van het "uitzonderlijk knappe" in heel wat Dylan songs... Knappe performance
I have been to 2 Dylan konserts. One was great but the other was horrible. He was to drunk to perform. Asked for refunds but never got it. But I got one great konsert.
This is by far Dylan's best song ever. I've never been a Dylan fan although I have been around through his many years. He combines his story telling with a true story, real people, social justice....it has it all. With excellent music, and highlights his playing. It certainly made me more aware of not just Carter, but our sad sad legal system.
For me, Dylan's oeuvre is more about the story and songwriting than the musicality. This man is the prime example that you can play simple chords with an amazing story and still make one of the best songs ever. He's done this multiple times, including this song. I mean look at Times They Are A Changin', Like a Rolling Stone, Blowin' in the Wind, Tangled Up in Blue & A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall. I'm positive there are more examples, but these are just the ones I came up with off the top of my head.
I love everything that Bob has done,but this is my favorite song by far,and this live version is such a class performance.The violin,the bass and Bob on guitar and harmonica are awesome! Thanks for posting this!!
got to see Dylan live with Petty and McGuinn, tour in 1987. IMO, this version of Hurricane is one of his best live performances of his entire career. and OMG that violin is incredible
I got to hang with him in his small motel room after-party with several other glitterati of the era, all of us on the floor, back in 1972. Damn! I understood my privilege every single second in that moment.
@@Kinkle_Z The only celebrity I can think of that I really could have had access to was Peter Fonda, as his yacht was moored across from our trimaran at the Ala Wai Harbor in Hawaii. He used to come out in the Summers and go on cruises with friends. I didn't get up the nerve, because he was so well known, and I figured just being a harbor rat, they wouldn't want me annoying them. I think I was wrong though, as actually he was a nice guy.
How ... how ... does he remember all these words? ... I don't care if he wrote them, just try it sometime. (ask Patti Smith trying to remember "A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall").
Outstanding. The only word I can use to describe this performance. The musicians, the vocals make this possibly the most complete live performance ever..... And I've been around 75 years and have seen a lot.
I've been listening to Bob Dylan all my life. His voice is great for a folk singer. I think he is the one of the most influential artists that ever came out of our country. a true American and gentleman.
I've never seen a look of such great seriousness on his face as here in the moments before he begins to sing. The way it looks, he could be a soldier in a pitched and deafening battle, seconds away from charging. It seems to show just how badly he wanted to perform as well as possible. (Either that or he couldn't remember the words.)
I'm 62. Trust me this is one of the best Dylan songs ever. The best live Dylan song done in my opinion. I'm a musician.... guitar vocals... just wow not woke.
Petit français que je suis, petit niveau au niveau musical. Mais Bob Dylan est un Mr !!! Le bonjour de France qui jadis était un beau pays où il faisait bon vivre 😢
God's work. You're doing God's work SP. How many times have I said it? This is so great. "Hurricane" was on the radio in 1975 and it launched my Dylan epiphany and high school obsession. I'd never heard anything like it and still haven't. Love this 4 piece band! ✌😎
I feel the same unexplainable as he himself has told often he can't say where how it comes through I say modern day disciples exist as years before. . I am no religious extraodinare its transcending, nearly biblical, not cult But far and wide his fan base is driven by his intellect, his connections of people, place, time, history, art, music, rhyme, parable, lyrical, and moving, I've been amazed by this man all my life, he is consistent, for ever changing and in tune with our changing times as a great historian as precarious and straight to the point as he is he keeps the social sciences on a time-line. No doubt
like in 'Hattie Carroll,' Bob doesn't glibly deal in platitudes or pop movements, he goes right to the human story that exposes us all. Thanks so much SP
Many thanks for this upload, and your explanation. Scarlet also said that Dylan changed the key just before they started, so that she would have to concentrate on the music instead of her nervousnress. Rob Stoner has confirmed this recently.
Yeah it looks like he has a capo on the first fret before the song starts, and takes it off just before he starts strumming and switches the harmonica too.
The accompaniment, Dylan's phrasing and rhythm such a powerful moving force. He's added so much to the lexicon, to poetry; a wondrous gift for the interpretation of the world, that Nobel Prize was deserved.
Justice is still a game, things haven't changed at all in nearly 50 years. Ya gots the $ then u have half a chance, regardless of whether u r guilty or not. Just ask our old mate the trumpster
I remember this. It completely blew me away. My favorite version of this song as well; indeed, one of my all-time favorite Dylan songs. "All the criminals in their coats and their ties are free to drink martinis and watch the sun rise." Indeed. Thanks for uploading this.
'Cept it's all bullshit..Dylan was in a very drunk period (the Rolling Thunder tour) and this otherwise catchy tune gets it wrong in EVERY single verse...look for yourself..www.graphicwitness.com/carter/song.html
@@shotarodeniet3301 Huh? Look, Carter was COMPLETELY guilty, and Dylan was COMPLETELY misled in his song. Every single verse is dead wrong. The "point" of the song?
@@wehaveasituation history proved you wrong. Carter was exonerated. Innocent and lived out the remainder of his life a free man, accepting an invitation to move to Canada from supporters who helped him fight for justice. Read Lazarus and the Hurricane to discover the truth.
It's Bob's passionate mastery of the extensive lyrics, the driving backbeat and the sublime but melancholy tones of Scarlet Rivera's violin that, for me, make this a stand out track. Great top see this rare and original recording, thank you so much!
I have always hear of Bob Dylan before, but I never listened to any of his music. It just wasn't my thing. But then this video pops up in my RUclips feed and damn did slap me in my face! It is an amazing song but an awful story that could have happened still today and probably has happened many times between now and when this was recorded. Just epic.
Terrific cut. Intimate stage. A new sound that night with Scarlet cutting through. Apparently, they played through Hurricane twice - at the beginning and end of the short set. But this is enough! Intense, driven and lucid. A bit spicy for PBS
i was fortunate enough to meet and speak to the man Bob is singing about. Ruben "hurricane" Carter. He was doing motivational speeches/testimonial for some insurance company. Whatever the reason was, it was really cool getting to meet him. i couldn't imagine how horrible it must have been to rot in prison for that many years while he was in his prime and such a great boxer, only to finally get out when he was too old to box any more. He died in 2014. I loved the movie with Denzel Washington, and i have always loved this song.
He did it! No doubt about. I think *three* separate juries convicted him! Read the case. he was not innocent. Every time he was convicted...a white judge sprung him. Motivational speaker? LOL Just a con man.
Not one of his songs is complete. They're all works in progress, I love how Bob is always trying new things with the same songs, adding tweaks here and there. No one performance is the same.
It doesn’t even matter how many times I have listened to this or watched it. The entire time I have full body chills for the entire song. This is such a powerful song. Musically and lyrically. It’s also still so relevant. It’s unfortunate actually that things haven’t really changed all that much.
Haven't changed? The U.S. elected its first minority president. More minorities are educated, serve in government and are heads of corporations than at anytime in American history.
it is a great performance indeed and it is so revealing the injustice in our world and corrupt judges that don't even try to hide their racism.And how he could fit all that in a song and make. it entertainment and at the same time make people think a little further than their noses
@@lifeisstr4nge :: It was about the version he has ever heard, not you. And Dazed and Confuses audio was surely mixed and remixed, processed and reprocessed. This one is purely natural magic.
Brilliant live performance. The violin 🎻 is brilliant- you can feel the anguish …The subtle bass and drums pulling it all together. Bob Dylan is a genius
Such a powerful performance. Dylan was such a genius. This song always gave me goosebumps. I remember hearing this song for the first time in high school and immediately bought the Desire album. He is one of our great storytellers made only stronger and more impactful in the form of song.
My God, even with such legendary status, it is nearly believable that one man alone penned SO many brilliant works. As for his stage voice and delivery, my absolute favorite of all HAS to be the whole of Side 5 from The Concert For Bangladesh! Give them 5 or 6(?) songs a listen asap. TOTALLY changed me to a Dylan fan instantly. Give them a listen, really.
To know that you have chosen to be an unconventional singer but to have a conviction to keep sticking to it needs some confidence in yourself. His sense of rhythm dynamics is extraordinary. Lyrics out of the world, of course.
Yep Internet has made us not bothered drips. Everyone is too bothered about videoing themselves or watching videos of others than to fight for what still STILL going on ....What's changed?????? You tell me !!! We've been dumbed down bribed corrupted by Internet.. so we don't make the world a better place we too busy *fixing our face*
If everyone just did one thing rebelled against one rule stood up for a purpose thst is dear to them at least we can say we didn't do nothing. Let's not do nothing let's keep Bob's passion our passion alive!!
Back in the early 60s I wasn’t a real Dylan fan , did not like his voice . But my friends all listen to him so I had to , then one Stoney day I actually listen to him and at that moment I got it . The poet of our time and such a good story teller .
Stoney days…..remember the good times. Now it's nostalgia trips on youtube with a beer or two, aint so bad. Sometimes you get a tear in your eye, you'll know what i mean Mike.
My mother always used to say who is that man voice you always play Everyday I always loved him and that was from day one and it's lasted all these years
You never do get it quite like that first time that you get it. And isn’t it strange how easy it is to forget it, until you hear that song and are transported back to that one time that you had it..
I know I'm missing plenty but Elvis, Bob, John lennon, BB King, Bowie, Sinatra, Hendrix, Clapton, McCartney etc . We will never see the likes of these again
I’m with you, and these were all legends that gave us the music of our lives. Pretty sure our parents said the same about all the legends from their youth and the big band sound of Glen Miller, Duke Ellington and Tommy Dorsey as well. Our kids and grandkids will all have their favourite artists as well, and life goes on. We all love the music we grew up on.
I bought this album just for this song...Hurricane Rubin Carter who was framed and his old life was taken away for a long stint in the New Jersey state prison..listen to the lyrics.. Great job & A great song for the Hurricane persevered Hurricane the song gave Rubins case publicity and helped on the road to freedom..thank you Bob for giving us this song❤
I remember sitting up on a Saturday night right around this time, calling up the only radio station that would play the full version, to request it. Amazing song and cause. Not much has changed as a result in close to 50 years, unfortunately...
Justice is alive and well in the USA as well as in 219 other nations and counties. Justice gas never left or changed regardless of games of many, won a very long time ago.
As shown in the conviction of Derek Chauvin for the manslaughter, unintentional murder and murder of George Floyd who actually died of a drug’s overdose and first said I can’t breathe after swallowing fentanyl before he was even touched. The first autopsy said it was a drug OD and if he had been found dead in a house then it wouldn’t have been suspicious but the Quincy was leaned on, threatened and changed the autopsy report.
Wow... first I heard. I recall buying the LP back in the day and Hurricane became a quick favorite, but the whole LP is awesome. Thanks for posting this, amazing after all these years. Along side Neil Young, Dylan is my favorite song writer/performer.
It’s sort of hard to believe this actually happened. Amazing. Never realized the Disco influences on this song before. Performed live it really makes you want to move. Bob rules.
![Bob Dylan - Oh, Sister (Live on PBS, 1975) [RESTORED FOOTAGE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/smb86Il2sgA/mqdefault.jpg)
![ARGENTINA vs. PERÚ [1-0] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 12](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xtI25ENDDSY/mqdefault.jpg)
Stumbled on this via diamonds and rust by Joan Baez. I saw Hurricane performed in London in the late seventies. Scarlet blew us all away that night, but I have to say the intensity of this version is killing. Bob has done so much, it's hard when you try to comment on a genius. We know. But on this recording we feel every word. The rhythm is all Bob a the back beat and bass threading pistol shots in the dark. What a song, at last about something real. A mans life rotting in. prison cell for something he didn't do. Racism in its most profound form. Bless you Bob and bless you kind people for liking this and appreciating the art and the humanity. I heard it recently with Tracey Chapman on the Grammy's. The power of a simple song told powerfully. Respect.
He delivered for sure. But I always wonder if given a choice in that circumstance if he might have wanted to do Billie Holliday song to truly pay his respects to John Hammond.
The audience was with him 100%...I loved the pre song clapping as much as the post song clapping.
Oh Krishna.
The magnificence of America's Bob.
He is a heart throb.
Dylan,
Always willin
To create for our heart's desire,
A tale, a melody on fire.
Long life to you, Bobby the bard of song
Long long long may your songs be heard.
Play on and paint
Paint and sing into the night to bring the light.
American beautiful laureate glorious
For spacious art notorious.
🍓💐☺️🎨🖌️🎬🪑🎸🎹
Vous êtes un génie monsieur Dylan merci ❤
Wow,,,, such nice and true ... talk ..
My dad used to listen to Bob Dylan. On weekends my Dad would play Bob Dylan on the huge console stereo that was nested in the corner of our living groom. I would lay down in front of the speakers and sing along with words my 5 year old self thought Bob was singing. (Come lay across my bumble glass bread)🫤
As an adult I’m thrilled to have stumbled upon Dylan again. I’m obsessed.
I was the same but What line did you think was bumble glass bread?
Congrats, my dad loved the Eagles... I had to hear that crap lol
@@Charles37400 big brass bed i imagine
@@riderwestgate6368 yeah but what song?
@@Charles37400 Lay lady lay
i met rubin carter, it was christmas 1988, at a convention for wrongly convicted in seattle. he told me quite convincingly if not for bob dylans record he wouldve struggled getting justice. RIP rubin
Justice? He was a violent thug.
The fact that Dylan chose this 8 minute song to perform live on a major PBS special - one of the most searing and unfiltered indictments of the racist penal justice system in the United States by a "popular" artist - is a testament to the man's courage and convictions.
What makes you think he thought about it.?
@jeffreyschaper6126, Amen!!
@@danocable do you think?
You are right about the justice system, but was Bob Dylan right about Hurricane?
@@Daniel-sh3os Do you know the time and Era that took place??
Then you should know Bob was right.
One of Dylan's best songs.. complex, thoughtful, intellectual, interesting, great beat, melody. It's 2022 and we do not see any musicians able to write a complex, complete 9 minute song that is so innovative and thought provoking.. America- start educating your youth !!!!!!
You are vso right, nobody can do this now
a work of greatness.
Innate talent and musical intuition.
@@bellakrinkle9381 plus, hard, hard, hard work... nothing comes easy without work. Beatles ?? - hard work... U2 ?? -- hard work.. Moody Blues. ?? -- hard work.. Tom Brady ?? - hard work.. Lee Trevino ?? - hard work.
Not entirely true. Watch Taylor Swift's 10 min song "All Too Well", live on SNL version. It's pretty incredible and genius in it's own right, it made me a closet Swifty that's coming out! And yeah, this Dylan song is topnotch.
The absolute genius to use Scarlet's violin as the lead instrument! Amazing Album!!
Till she pokes out someone’s eye.
@@alexbowman7582 🤣
👍👌❤️💜👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Rubin "Hurricane" Carter was freed by Canadian activists and lawyers after working hard to find the truth. Carter died in Toronto, Canada. Hope his soul rests in peace.
zappa was doing this years before
I read the biography of Ruben “Hurricane” Carter several years ago and it is an excellent and heartbreaking book. One thing that you realize from the book is how seriously Dylan took the writing of this song, interviewing Carter numerous times in jail and penning a song that is artistically genius and yet also historically very very accurate. There will never be another Bob Dylan
Just another reason why he deserved the Nobel Prize in literature though he was often a bit of a protest singer and anti establishment he was so popular they couldn't stop him like say Mario Savio etc.
Nice write up . Thank you.
He wont perform this song anymore. Hasn't in 45ish years?
@@seanmurphy2302he honestly doesn’t need to. It served its purpose and it resulted in public sentiment turning in Ruben’s favor and FINALLY being freed after decades in prison for a crime he and John Artis NEVER COMMITTED.
@@EFunkRock OK. You think that's why Bob doesn't perform it anymore?
This was my 84 year old grandmothers favorite song. We played it at her funeral this morning
My condolences, your grandmother must have been awesome!!!
My condolences. Obviously a special lady!
Bittersweet-hard to think of a better song for the occasion-best wishes
My thoughts are with you and your family at this time.Have you ever seen the film about Reuben “the hurricane”Carter with Denzel Washington.Just with this being your Grandmother’s favourite it might help knowing a bit about the man Dylan was singing about.Just a thought,by the way your Grandma must of been awesom.
she knows good music
Absolute masterpiece. From Bob to Scarlet to bass and drums to the sound engineers. It does not get any better than this
agreed..a masterpiece.
Brilliant!!!!❤️❤️
Writing a timeless masterpiece, but all the lyrics are lies. He's glorifying a homicidal sociopath and defaming the victims. That's why he stopped singing this song after the 2nd trial, after a Black jury also found them guilty.
@@CoolhandLukeSkywalkr eye witness says you are wrong
@@kenmiller7708 Four different eyewitnesses saw Artis and Carter flee the scene of the homicide. Hazel Tanis gave a good description of the killer with the pistol to police. They drew a sketch of her description, and it matches John Artis. She also told her daughter that Artis and Carter were the ones who shot her. Also, Artis and Carter both flunked lie detector tests given to them just hours after the shootings.
June 17, 1966 was the day Rubin Carter was arrested. He was exonerated in 1988. It is quite an amazing story, with his release being made possible with the help of a bunch of Canadians and the great Bobby D. This is a fantastic video and I thank you for posting it.
I'm not sure if he was exonerated but he was guilty.
20yrs down the drain for nothing other than Racism.
I did time with Rubin in Trenton State Prison. His co-defendant, John Artis, pled guilty.
@@charlesmonroe8288 And they were together in the car?
@@seanmurphy2302 away from the actual crime scene? Yes they were.
I'm 64 and I still love this song. Brings back those 70's memories. I love my life and I'm very blessed, but things were simpler then and the music was far, far better than today's stuff.
I'm 65. I can relate. That music era was a great time to be young.
The first time I heard this song, it was playing in my local record store right after the album was released. I bought the album on the spot.
I was already enamored with Dylan's music, but "Desire" is by far my favorite album of his. There isn't a track on the album that doesn't reach me to the core.
Not long after, our local AOR station (KZEW in Dallas) was playing this song.
I got to hear him play this song only once in concert, but it's a memory I'll never forget. 1993 at the Cal Expo Amphitheater in Sacramento. Great friends. Backstage passes. Perfect weather. Bob Dylan.
Music is subjective
Every era thinks their era was the best.
@christopherwhittaker2620 True. Safe to say that music is a part of us all.
66, I concur !
Absolutely.
Right?This is pretty good quality for the era
No one comes close to Bob Dylan ...Absolute Genius.
Some of the verses in this song give me the cold shivers. Dylan is a genius.
Examples?
@@TheFbiFilesRepeat Are you deaf as well as dumb?
@@TheFbiFilesRepeat music tip: listen to it then think for yourself. Stimulates brain activity.
I agree, it's one of the most amazing songs ever written, but there are people online who argue persuasively that Rubin was guilty...very guilty, and Bob got it wrong. Rubin was tried twice and convicted each time. The third time, many years later, he was freed, but not exonerated, by the most liberal judge in the state......Check it out for yourself.....But hey, I would want Bob to write a song about me if I was convicted, falsely or other wise.....
Ditto.
This song blows me away every time. I never get tired of it after all these years. Much Respect!
But it's important to note that the lyrics are vicious lies, and Hurricane actually did do the murders in cold blood.
@@CoolhandLukeSkywalkr WOW Really? I did not know that. I still havent seen the movie, so I dont know how its portrayed. But still. all that aside, I really love that song, It's typical of his story telling. And if a few liberties are taken, well. I can live with it. Thats a real head twister though. So he really did do it huh?
@@henryshockem9242 The killers sped off in a white dodge polara. Hurricane Carter was stopped by police driving away from the scene of the crime in his white Dodge Polara. It's not a common car. Eyewitnesses saw Hurricane and Artis and IDd them. Also, once in police custody hours after the shooting, Artis and Carter didn't have matching stories about what they had just been doing that night. They were given lie detector tests, and they both flunked them. Hurricane Carter himself has given three or four different versions of the story of what supposedly went down tha4 night. After he was freed, he claimed that the police planted fake bodies in the bar, and nobody was actually even killed. Does that version of the story sound at all plausible to anyone?
The killers used an unusual caliber of bullets. .32 caliber bullets in the pistol they used. Hurricane's white polara had .32 caliber pistol bullets strewn on the floor of the car when police arrested them. It's not exactly rocket science..32 caliber isn't even in the top 15 of bullet sizes. It's quite rare. They hid the guns and got rid of them, but they missed some bullets they dropped on the floor of Hurricane's car. Why isn't any of that in the song or the movie? Instead, there is a completely make-believe story about unhinged police officers who framed him. None of that stuff actually happened in real life, and the incriminating things Hurricane Carter did, like having 4 or 5 very different versions of his story about what he was doing that night. None of the stuff that makes Hurricane Carter look guilty is mentioned in the song or the film. Between his first and second trials, he beat up a black bail bonds lady so badly that she almost died. She didn't press charges and so police decided not to persue it. They could at least have shown that. Bob Dylan hasn't performed this song live since the 2nd trial when a Black jury found Artis and Carter guilty, and after everyone knew Carter beat up that bail bonds lady so badly, he put her in the hospital.
@@henryshockem9242 More than a few liberties were taken. Police pulled him over, fleeing the scene of the crime, mere blocks away from the bar. Or as Bob Dylan put it "on the other side of town." Every single part of the song is fictitious and based on lies the killer told.
@@henryshockem9242 I know it's one of his best songs. I still listen to it. I still listen to his songs glorifying John Wesley Harding and George Jackson. But I know what he's doing. He's always glorified killers to cash in on the racial demographics of the US. I'm a fellow Jew, I see what he's doing with this song. Pitting the different gentile races against each other and race-baiting to make a quick buck for himself. It doesn't reflect well on the Jewish race. He shouldn't be out there manipulating gentiles in exchange for fame and financial gain.
Bravo he's on his game here ... He's 35 years old here in the prime of his life and he's spot on just like we'd expect him to be ... Another gem ....
No one can sing a story like Bob.
It was propaganda to raise money. Definitely a "story."
@@silvermediastudioReuben hurricane was a real middleweight boxer who was wrongfully imprisoned for 20 years. Very moving movie about it called hurricane.
@@samuelmitchellskate You get your facts from movies and songs 🤣 dude was guilty as hell.
@@silvermediastudio also heard that he was guilty. The real story is that, he indeed was put in prison for something that he didn't do. Here Dylan says the truth.
But to say that the man was innocent is not true, and here I agree. Hurricane definitely was not a saint, and he had done some bad things.
@@bsnf-5 Nope, Dylan's lyrics was an output of Operation Mockingbird and activists seeking to divide and destabilize. Classic information operations that prey on the gullible, useful idiots.
Wow. This is just pure hard working musically gifted people. No fancy lights, stage acts, dance moves, mega screens, synthetic sound or special effects. Just pure artistry in action. How incredibly humbling to our current music industry. Puts the new generation to frigging shame. This song is beautiful and terrifying all at once.
pure artistry can still involve all of these things. let us not limit ourselves
Agree. Just raw gifted music. And they even wore their clothes. Am so proud to be a part of this generation. Nothing like the natural wonders of talent. Wouldn't trade it for anything.
@@deborahlauterbach6156Amen God Bobby Happy late birthday 🎉
Good music's always being made. You just need to open your mind to listen to it.
I can imagine this song is extremely difficult to sing let alone remember each line and then phrase it perfectly..unique and genius
👍🏻
Well he wrote the lines so they mean something to him so the words come natural. And he doesnt phrase it the same every time. He and most musicians start to vary their rhythmical phrasing after their initial recording of the song after repetitive performances of it to keep it sounding fresh.
It amazes me the amount pf lyrics Dylan has to remember for each concert
It amazes me the amount pf lyrics Dylan has to remember for each concert
@subg8858 quite often he doesn't, lol. Seen him more than 20 times and most of the time he's rarely really on point. Much better writer than preformer and he'd probably agree.
Who else could produce such musical poetry? We are so fortunate to have witnessed his incredible talent.
There are no words to describe this song and performance but absolutely brilliant....lifelong fan of Bob Dylan and his music and lyrics.
Spot on there. It pulls you to understand his brilliance does this live recording. Brilliant. A truly one off.
how come he brings out the best in situations
when others would crumble?
he’s fearless
its the bob
He’s a meat popsicle
No, absolutely not, it's his talent.
I believe "A hard rains a gonna fall" is the most important song of all time. What context. And our boy delivers.
hes high on coke. its 1975 int he video. or do you think hes sweating like that cause its warm in there?
This is one of my absolute favourite Bob Dylan performances. Great song, great lyrics, great band, great arrangement, great Bob!
Try-hard troubadour. Sorry but the age of the knight in shining arms finished a long time a go.
@@zootsoot2006 Great songs, great lyrics and great performances are ageless.
You know Carter was retried and found guilty again right?
@@KaiserBlade Some understand art and some don`t. Right?
@@KaiserBlade it is a white men's world!!! Hipocricy at worst, in a country where "all men are created equal" , if you are white, that is!!
I’m in my 70s and BOB, bless him, takes me back to the good old days. So grateful to have lived in those times. A life saver in these disturbing times. Love you BOB.❤️
Hello, how are you doing?
Now times are 10 times worse.
Hah I'm the same.Saw him first at the Isle of Wight and loved him ever since
Lucky.what a good first one..
Kids these days are living in disturbing times with narry a bob dylan in sight.sad..
Absolutely love the ghostly alluring Scarlet Rivera's violinship. Adds a touch of serenity to the vitriol of the lyrics,.
Her playing really makes the song, on an instrumental level.
Serenity? I think it adds real edge to the lyrics.
i don't feel any serenity in her playing! sounds like weeping to me, the anguish of the injustice. it's perfect
@@theodoreconstantini2548 Agreed. The guy doing guitar and vocals is pretty good too, but loving that violin.
A violin never hurts any arrangement. It is without a doubt my favorite instrument.
I love that he performed THIS song on live television. The the band and Dylan’s voice sound beautiful.
To all the people who think Dylan can't sing in tune. They are just not nuanced enough.
one of the few times he did this song live, he quickly stopped when he realised the truth. Absolute masterpiece of propaganda.
My favorite performer ever!!! Dylan the Hurricane!!?❤❤❤❤❤
He is high as fuck.lol😂
Hard r on live tv.def a ballsy move for those times.l
Back when pure talent wasnt manufactured but recognized
Best Dylan song ever....
@@fredsalter1915 Eh, IMO that is Simple Twist of Fate
Nothing manufactured can be pure. The clue is in the word
Really well said!! Thank you Mr. Dylan for all the great, inspirational music!!
Everything is so perfect here. A moment thankfully captured on film. This is history. Also it shows what a great rhythm section can do to make a minimal ensemble sound huge without overpowering the singer. Howie Wyeth's snare just snaps and crackles with authority.
Was the version on the "Hard Rain" live recording dubed over?
Great post. I don't know music but I appreciate good writing.
Amen,Brother/Sister.
Not sure which is more wow that this piece is in the Library of Congress or that Dylan was gjven the Nobel literary prize
And the violinist... So spot-on
they sure don't make them like they used to...this song is a masterpiece...this live version never heard before but Dylans phrasing is top notch!!
Truth! I love his voice and the way his lyrics erupt from him.
I’ve ensured my teenage children know and appreciate the master that is Bob Dylan.
@@quinn3974 well done !! smart move
i smelled burned flash and toxic air ......axaxaxaxaxax feel good man HAHAHAHHAHAAHHAHAAHAH burn forever
The first song after he sold his sole to the devil .....
1
@@beyondalpha1072 gg
Bob Dylan in his prime lyrically and vocally.
A true artist in every sense of the word. Such a timeless song, relevent to this day.
Always will be relevant.
Except Hurricane did it. As usual, the narrative is bullshit.
Most of Dylan's lyrics are as relevant today as ever
Oh sure so long as injustice is relevant Carters story will be too. He moved to Toronto after release to help others.
@@annalisavajda252 “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” - George Santayana
Scarlet Rivera just great on the violin. This is really a very rare and unique performance. Even better when I saw him live in "75" do it. 👏👏👏
It's because he wrote it breliante ray
If you've seen him like I hy you'd know he composes everything ray
Youre right this is both rare and awesome!! When Dylan took this on the road originally he had a huge band the rolling thunder review. This stripped down band is just awesome!
Thank God for Bob Dylan and his music and life 🌹💞🎸
This song is one of Bobs greatest freedom songs , where he stood against the world with his message of truth , already then the evil of corruption and tyranny was shown, but people went sleeping again, dreaming into slavery, and thought it was easy to lean on the same people which destroyed societies then, they still do today, its time they leave, enough is enough. Listen to Bob and take charge of your life and those of the others and innocent and stand for freedom, light . Blessings and grace to Bob and those other freedom fighters who never stopped ! Remember the newspaper (media ) went along with the ride...... never trust media, science trust your own eyes
Excellent (from France).
Hurricane Carter was a monster who killed multiple people. I guess "truth" in this case is subjective ?
Yeah we all need to remember that in the next pandemic
People dog on his voice. But here’s the thing, he’s one of the best performers ever. Everything is so on point wow.
Yeah man he is one of the best singers of all time. People who say he can’t sing only like pretty voices, they don’t understand blues.
I feel like people gave up dogging on his voice 30 years ago.
He very literally might have the most endurance of any performer who has ever lived. Doing shows consistently for *60* fucking years. SIX-ZERO. It's wild. "Best" is basically meaningless though. I love his voice.
His voice was fantastic. His voice was suited to what he sang. He sang like a wildcat. He was possessed. He meant what he said.
@@octagonseventynine1253 They don't understand music. Period. Not even a conversation worth having for those who understand. Music is not some bizarre art of scientific perfection??
Alweer "a timeless masterpiece". Alweer een sublieme Bob Dylan compositie... die door diverse anderen mooi & knap werden gezongen....met vaak een rijker en mooiklinkend arrangement... B D is een verdiende Nobelprijswinnaar van Literatuur... veel van zijn songs zijn gebalde romans... ongelooflijk knap... met hele knappe vondsten erin! Te bewonderen! Blij dat ik kan genieten van het "uitzonderlijk knappe" in heel wat Dylan songs... Knappe performance
I'm a 63 year old man and that song pulls tears out of me every time. GOD BLESS Rubin.
crybaby
Who cares who you are. It's simply a great song even for 1000 year genderless alien.
It's happening to me now.
There simply is no one better than Bob Dylan. The king of music, lyrics, melody, poetry and performance.
The king of >>> the american folk music....🎼🎸🎼
Also John prine
@@jamesdeaton7235 Prine is amazing but Dylan has done so much more, imo
I have been to 2 Dylan konserts. One was great but the other was horrible. He was to drunk to perform. Asked for refunds but never got it. But I got one great konsert.
@@jamesdeaton7235 Also Joni Mitchell...
Already had a great day and now I have this gem to watch.
This is by far Dylan's best song ever. I've never been a Dylan fan although I have been around through his many years. He combines his story telling with a true story, real people, social justice....it has it all. With excellent music, and highlights his playing.
It certainly made me more aware of not just Carter, but our sad sad legal system.
For me, Dylan's oeuvre is more about the story and songwriting than the musicality. This man is the prime example that you can play simple chords with an amazing story and still make one of the best songs ever. He's done this multiple times, including this song. I mean look at Times They Are A Changin', Like a Rolling Stone, Blowin' in the Wind, Tangled Up in Blue & A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall. I'm positive there are more examples, but these are just the ones I came up with off the top of my head.
Close. Only "It's Alright Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)" tops this.
Carter was guilty, the legal system worked perfectly well…
@@johneeeemarry34 Another NPC
GREATEST SONG EVER???? ARE YOU CRAZY???
I love everything that Bob has done,but this is my favorite song by far,and this live version is such a class performance.The violin,the bass and Bob on guitar and harmonica are awesome! Thanks for posting this!!
Hattie Carrol is another such writing well done
Thanks so much for the tears of truth,Mr. Dylan.If there has ever been any cooler,I don't know about it.Sold his soul to the devil? Come on,man...
@@davidstevens-py1vw Then what exactly was he telling Ed Bradley??
Scarlet-Rumor has it that they met at 5.00am on broadway as she was heading to a rehersal session at JULLIARD -FACT OR FICTION IT TELLS ALL
and this is why I love Bob Dylan; damn what a performance; just remembering all those lyrics! GREAT post
ive said that several times over the years on some of them songs, just to remember the lyrics seams a gift itself
She's an outstanding violinist. I don't know who she is but she deserves kudos. Her music is part of the song.
❤ yep
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarlet_Rivera
is it actually her@@certifiedfancypants
Album Desire will tell ya.
It is the song,she’s playing lead..
got to see Dylan live with Petty and McGuinn, tour in 1987. IMO, this version of Hurricane is one of his best live performances of his entire career. and OMG that violin is incredible
Yes, and Scarlet's playing is as gorgeous as she is.
I got to hang with him in his small motel room after-party with several other glitterati of the era, all of us on the floor, back in 1972. Damn! I understood my privilege every single second in that moment.
I got to see Rolling Thunder, it was touring when this track was recorded.
@@Kinkle_Z The only celebrity I can think of that I really could have had access to was Peter Fonda, as his yacht was moored across from our trimaran at the Ala Wai Harbor in Hawaii. He used to come out in the Summers and go on cruises with friends. I didn't get up the nerve, because he was so well known, and I figured just being a harbor rat, they wouldn't want me annoying them. I think I was wrong though, as actually he was a nice guy.
Just love the violin and guitar together. You can see the poetry in his face.
You can see the sketch in his face too. The poetry, the sketch, and lots more besides: it's all in there.
I absolutely agree 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
I absolutely agree 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
How ... how ... does he remember all these words? ... I don't care if he wrote them, just try it sometime. (ask Patti Smith trying to remember "A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall").
Yes! I want to discribe the violin as "terrible" ...Not in it's playing, but it seems to perfectly capture the underlying injustice of the story.
Outstanding. The only word I can use to describe this performance. The musicians, the vocals make this possibly the most complete live performance ever..... And I've been around 75 years and have seen a lot.
I've been listening to Bob Dylan all my life. His voice is great for a folk singer. I think he is the one of the most influential artists that ever came out of our country. a true American and gentleman.
Just finally saw him live about 7 years ago in Ohio I guess that was a lifetime dream!
not just America, one of the most influential ever.
Gentlemen ? Sorry but that's complete crap !
@Enzo James the word Gentleman is not him though. He might have influenced thousands - to become Pete Seger - but he's not a Gentleman !
@@hazard3020 i would say it's not what you mean by that word.
absolutely legendary performance
I've never seen a look of such great seriousness on his face as here in the moments before he begins to sing. The way it looks, he could be a soldier in a pitched and deafening battle, seconds away from charging.
It seems to show just how badly he wanted to perform as well as possible.
(Either that or he couldn't remember the words.)
@@dixonpinfold2582 that made me laugh. I think it was the former though :-)
watch his performance at The Concert for Bangladesh.
Kermit , ‘the Fud’ 😂 that’s a Scottish word! U Scottish?
@@asmith9040 He's a fud!
I'm 62. Trust me this is one of the best Dylan songs ever. The best live Dylan song done in my opinion. I'm a musician.... guitar vocals... just wow not woke.
Petit français que je suis, petit niveau au niveau musical.
Mais Bob Dylan est un Mr !!!
Le bonjour de France qui jadis était un beau pays où il faisait bon vivre 😢
Yes. I agree.
I'm 63. Trust me, this song sucks fr 🗣🗣
This doesn't hold a candle to anything on Highway 61 or Blonde on Blonde. Not even close, man.
@@xs-1b415 shut yo goofy ass up bruh 🤦♂🤦♂
God's work. You're doing God's work SP. How many times have I said it? This is so great. "Hurricane" was on the radio in 1975 and it launched my Dylan epiphany and high school obsession. I'd never heard anything like it and still haven't. Love this 4 piece band! ✌😎
I feel the same unexplainable as he himself has told often he can't say where how it comes through I say modern day disciples exist as years before. . I am no religious extraodinare its transcending, nearly biblical, not cult But far and wide his fan base is driven by his intellect, his connections of people, place, time, history, art, music, rhyme, parable, lyrical, and moving, I've been amazed by this man all my life, he is consistent, for ever changing and in tune with our changing times as a great historian as precarious and straight to the point as he is he keeps the social sciences on a time-line. No doubt
like in 'Hattie Carroll,' Bob doesn't glibly deal in platitudes or pop movements, he goes right to the human story that exposes us all. Thanks so much SP
Except it's all bullshit. Carter was completely guilty--and Dylan got every verse wrong!...www.graphicwitness.com/carter/
@@wehaveasituation wtf
@@wehaveasituation Correct. Hattie Carroll was full of bullshit also.
I
No, Bob has always been a hollow chameleon...as for the hideous murderer Carter...www.graphicwitness.com/carter/song.html
@@jerrypeters2095 no. He took the words from the newspaper when writing The Lonesome Death of Hattie Caroll.
One of the most powerful ballads ever written, a masterpiece. This is slightly different from the final version.
His phrasing is completely different what do you mean?
It's a pretty easy sentence to understand. It's obviously not "completely different". The final version is just more refined.@@aboynamedsue1933
Many thanks for this upload, and your explanation. Scarlet also said that Dylan changed the key just before they started, so that she would have to concentrate on the music instead of her nervousnress. Rob Stoner has confirmed this recently.
Heard her say that too. You can see it in her eyes. I think Bob was saying something about the importance of this performance.
Yeah it looks like he has a capo on the first fret before the song starts, and takes it off just before he starts strumming and switches the harmonica too.
And Howie on drums is just like... key change? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
The accompaniment, Dylan's phrasing and rhythm such a powerful moving force. He's added so much to the lexicon, to poetry; a wondrous gift for the interpretation of the world, that Nobel Prize was deserved.
Justice is still a game, things haven't changed at all in nearly 50 years. Ya gots the $ then u have half a chance, regardless of whether u r guilty or not. Just ask our old mate the trumpster
13 th ...slavery
Trump IS guilty. Pay attention to the facts. Turn off Trump's lying voice.
👍😁
I remember this. It completely blew me away. My favorite version of this song as well; indeed, one of my all-time favorite Dylan songs. "All the criminals in their coats and their ties are free to drink martinis and watch the sun rise." Indeed. Thanks for uploading this.
'Cept it's all bullshit..Dylan was in a very drunk period (the Rolling Thunder tour) and this otherwise catchy tune gets it wrong in EVERY single verse...look for yourself..www.graphicwitness.com/carter/song.html
@@wehaveasituation you are aware that the artist is free to tweek his own work right? My god, do you miss the point of the song
@@shotarodeniet3301 Huh? Look, Carter was COMPLETELY guilty, and Dylan was COMPLETELY misled in his song. Every single verse is dead wrong. The "point" of the song?
No change there then.
@@wehaveasituation history proved you wrong. Carter was exonerated. Innocent and lived out the remainder of his life a free man, accepting an invitation to move to Canada from supporters who helped him fight for justice. Read Lazarus and the Hurricane to discover the truth.
It's Bob's passionate mastery of the extensive lyrics, the driving backbeat and the sublime but melancholy tones of Scarlet Rivera's violin that, for me, make this a stand out track. Great top see this rare and original recording, thank you so much!
HELL not a bad rhythm guitar on dylans behalf 👍
I have always hear of Bob Dylan before, but I never listened to any of his music. It just wasn't my thing. But then this video pops up in my RUclips feed and damn did slap me in my face! It is an amazing song but an awful story that could have happened still today and probably has happened many times between now and when this was recorded. Just epic.
I agree with others who say the violin adds so much to the song,... dylan has the unique ability to evoke emotion in lyrics and music.
Terrific cut. Intimate stage. A new sound that night with Scarlet cutting through. Apparently, they played through Hurricane twice - at the beginning and end of the short set. But this is enough! Intense, driven and lucid. A bit spicy for PBS
I wonder if playing it again had something to do with deviation from the original lyrics. I noticed a lot of differences.
Right…. Not sure you could get away with even “ass” or “son-of-a-bitch” then…
@@jewelsandbinoculars1 He uses the language ordinary people speak - probably quite restrained for the racist police officers!
There's a reason he's the best song writer of our time,he can spin a tale and have you on edge of your seat the whole time
Wow what a song this is. I couldn’t imagine the scenes when this released in 1976. It’s still a masterclass today.
Good music, RUclips and other distractions (usually entertainment or sports) getting me through the pandemic. Thanks again, Bob.
The fact that he was willing to perform this song in those times is hella respectable. Even more respect for his music now
i was fortunate enough to meet and speak to the man Bob is singing about. Ruben "hurricane" Carter. He was doing motivational speeches/testimonial for some insurance company. Whatever the reason was, it was really cool getting to meet him. i couldn't imagine how horrible it must have been to rot in prison for that many years while he was in his prime and such a great boxer, only to finally get out when he was too old to box any more. He died in 2014. I loved the movie with Denzel Washington, and i have always loved this song.
He did it! No doubt about. I think *three* separate juries convicted him! Read the case. he was not innocent. Every time he was convicted...a white judge sprung him. Motivational speaker? LOL Just a con man.
I had the pleasure of watching Bob singing this song on the river in little Rock Arkansas ❤
Omg what an experience. Love this song & meeting Rueben "Hurricane" Carter would have been awesome. A history lession in a meeting.
@@robnero52 He was found guilty TWICE. The evidence, even his own attorney admitted, was overwhelming. He participated in a mass murder of white ppl.
I got to shake the hand of the judge set him free.
Not one of his songs is complete. They're all works in progress, I love how Bob is always trying new things with the same songs, adding tweaks here and there. No one performance is the same.
Because to Dylan, doing a song the same way night after night is boring
listened to this many times and only just noticed dylan emphasize "eye-dentify" the guilty man.
We'll keep you thafe from tereees lol.
Just mind blowing. Great song by a great man. Love the arrangement and the vocals and phrasing = exquisite.
unbelievable how good this sounds, drums guitar violin bass. as good as on record. dylan what a legend
This is simply TOTAL brilliance. The song is unbelievably good, Dylan's vocal performance is as good as it gets. Amazing. Downunder, South Australia
It doesn’t even matter how many times I have listened to this or watched it. The entire time I have full body chills for the entire song. This is such a powerful song. Musically and lyrically. It’s also still so relevant. It’s unfortunate actually that things haven’t really changed all that much.
Haven't changed? The U.S. elected its first minority president. More minorities are educated, serve in government and are heads of corporations than at anytime in American history.
This is the best version I’ve ever heard. Thanks for posting it.
absolutely the best, and the studio mix on 'Desire' is phenomenal
Agreed! Bob's phrasing is immaculate.
it is a great performance indeed and it is so revealing the injustice in our world and corrupt judges that don't even try to hide their racism.And how he could fit all that in a song and make. it entertainment and at the same time make people think a little further than their noses
Go listen to it in Dazed and Confused 1993 before you make a fool of yourself again in public
@@lifeisstr4nge :: It was about the version he has ever heard, not you. And Dazed and Confuses audio was surely mixed and remixed, processed and reprocessed. This one is purely natural magic.
Three pieces--lyric, voice, performance--all collide perfectly.
Brilliant live performance. The violin 🎻 is brilliant- you can feel the anguish …The subtle bass and drums pulling it all together.
Bob Dylan is a genius
It’s a fiddle
Rest In peace bob dylan. A true icon ❤
@@clarebriggs8169 he’s not dead you twat
@@clarebriggs8169 he’s still alive
@@LeahElisheva omg your joking
I've always love this song, but never heard this version. Wonderful and a great story behind it. Wow, what a beautiful genius.
Just brilliant, what can one say. And 47 years ago this was on live TV!
Just WOW. Incredible commitment SP to get this version up...Thank you. 👏
I remember this song on the radio, but this is the first time I ever saw this performance. Much respect.
Boxing While Black.
Such a powerful performance. Dylan was such a genius. This song always gave me goosebumps. I remember hearing this song for the first time in high school and immediately bought the Desire album. He is one of our great storytellers made only stronger and more impactful in the form of song.
Is.
mindblowing..
My God, even with such legendary status, it is nearly believable that one man alone penned SO many brilliant works. As for his stage voice and delivery, my absolute favorite of all HAS to be the whole of Side 5 from The Concert For Bangladesh! Give them 5 or 6(?) songs a listen asap. TOTALLY changed me to a Dylan fan instantly. Give them a listen, really.
If I am remembering correctly this was penned with another writer helping.
To know that you have chosen to be an unconventional singer but to have a conviction to keep sticking to it needs some confidence in yourself. His sense of rhythm dynamics is extraordinary. Lyrics out of the world, of course.
I'll never forget listening to Desire for the first time, I was 12 years old, I wore out the needle and Ginsbergs liner notes! I rest my case,
First Dylan album I bought, in 1978. I was 19. Another 16 Dylan albums followed in the next two years.
Desire is my favorite album.
I can relate....same here...all Bob all the time....
What a great performance of a wonderful song.. I feel privileged to have lived when he wrote and performed.
Bod is one of the greatest storytellers and poets of the 20th century. That is something that will never be forgotten. What a legacy.
"we live in a land where justice is a game" this song should make us as outraged now as it did then!
Great comment
I couldn't have said it better. Especially now with trump and his lawyers,along with a corrupt judge.
I wrote that lyric down, next to my laptop to remind me..
Yep Internet has made us not bothered drips. Everyone is too bothered about videoing themselves or watching videos of others than to fight for what still STILL going on ....What's changed?????? You tell me !!! We've been dumbed down bribed corrupted by Internet.. so we don't make the world a better place we too busy *fixing our face*
If everyone just did one thing rebelled against one rule stood up for a purpose thst is dear to them at least we can say we didn't do nothing. Let's not do nothing let's keep Bob's passion our passion alive!!
Wow! Never saw this performance before. Makes life better on several levels. Thanks for putting this up.
Excellent video of a superb rendition of this song.
Much appreciated.
Back in the early 60s I wasn’t a real Dylan fan , did not like his voice . But my friends all listen to him so I had to , then one Stoney day I actually listen to him and at that moment I got it . The poet of our time and such a good story teller .
Stoney days…..remember the good times. Now it's nostalgia trips on youtube with a beer or two, aint so bad. Sometimes you get a tear in your eye, you'll know what i mean Mike.
My mother always used to say who is that man voice you always play Everyday I always loved him and that was from day one and it's lasted all these years
You never do get it quite like that first time that you get it. And isn’t it strange how easy it is to forget it, until you hear that song and are transported back to that one time that you had it..
I had the same experience in the same period
Dylan is an acquired taste. I didn't get him til I saw him live...
"To live in a land where Justice is a game". Nothing changed here! Thank God for Bob Dylan.
... the champion of the worrrrrrlllllld 😂 (what a strange voice/sound in that point)
Dylan is also a great leader of the band. You can hear how he had the band chill and pick it up in the right moments.
fantastic is all i can say!
I know I'm missing plenty but Elvis, Bob, John lennon, BB King, Bowie, Sinatra, Hendrix, Clapton, McCartney etc . We will never see the likes of these again
I’m with you, and these were all legends that gave us the music of our lives. Pretty sure our parents said the same about all the legends from their youth and the big band sound of Glen Miller, Duke Ellington and Tommy Dorsey as well. Our kids and grandkids will all have their favourite artists as well, and life goes on. We all love the music we grew up on.
We now have taylor swift, the greatest artist of all time(sarcasm if you are wondering)
@@Scoobyoneknobi I'm sure many young people believe that she is. She will certainly be the richest by the time she is done.
Mate....the truth will break your heart about ALL of them...([inverted]
Your a fool mr jones,,,reach and teach our children, don't change them someone taught them even if it was poverty 🎉
A giant, singular and never to be repeated. He stands at the top of themountain of greatest songwriters ever.
Just my opinion, but I put Neil young and George Harrison right up there with him.. but they with Bob, not Bob with them
Top 10
@@JamesJones-cx5pk Agree there's also Bobs friend and genius Phil Ochs!!
Joni Mitchell and Jackson Browne.
There’s Dylan and Cohen on the peak.
The best part was the violin. Loved her playing.
Check Out LONELY TENEMENT
Scarlet Rivera is amazing. The way that violin weaves in ,out and around is beautiful. ✌🏾
I bought this album just for this song...Hurricane Rubin Carter who was framed and his old life was taken away for a long stint in the New Jersey state prison..listen to the lyrics.. Great job & A great song for the Hurricane persevered Hurricane the song gave Rubins case publicity and helped on the road to freedom..thank you Bob for giving us this song❤
I remember sitting up on a Saturday night right around this time, calling up the only radio station that would play the full version, to request it. Amazing song and cause. Not much has changed as a result in close to 50 years, unfortunately...
I called my station and they said no it’s controversial???
"...in a land where justice is a game." Yep.
No change there then.
Holds up today👍
Justice is alive and well in the USA as well as in 219 other nations and counties. Justice gas never left or changed regardless of games of many, won a very long time ago.
No justice. 👎
As shown in the conviction of Derek Chauvin for the manslaughter, unintentional murder and murder of George Floyd who actually died of a drug’s overdose and first said I can’t breathe after swallowing fentanyl before he was even touched. The first autopsy said it was a drug OD and if he had been found dead in a house then it wouldn’t have been suspicious but the Quincy was leaned on, threatened and changed the autopsy report.
Wow... first I heard. I recall buying the LP back in the day and Hurricane became a quick favorite, but the whole LP is awesome. Thanks for posting this, amazing after all these years. Along side Neil Young, Dylan is my favorite song writer/performer.
Dylan showing that he's the master of lyrics. Nothing ever stays the same. A great song with the haunting sounds of Scarlet Rivera.
Robert Hunter was of his echelon.
Dylan’s the best story teller ever there wouldn’t be rock and roll without him! Love this TY for sharing!
Sold his soul to the devil and has to keep up his end of the bargain or...
There wouldn't be any real honest to God history without him. 🇺🇸
Here we go with Bob Dylan’s Hurricane ! Great song ! Really love it ! This is so so fine. :) - John Coolman
It’s sort of hard to believe this actually happened. Amazing. Never realized the Disco influences on this song before. Performed live it really makes you want to move. Bob rules.