This is just appalling these crew members are professional sailors and have lost friends and have just experienced a life changing event. Shame on the public who expresses such horrific racism!
Is any far left( communist) country liberal?? Is any Islamic country liberal?? Do they have Free speech?? But in all democracies these two ideologies join hands together and call themselves’ leftist liberals’😅 No left( communist) country tolerates Islamists and no Islamic country tolerates Leftists! That’s the irony which many people do not realise n fall for the one sided narrative! Type’ left n Islamists alliance’ n understand the deeper geopolitics!!
@@zeeefaaa9979 both piloted by local crew as required by international law. Baltimore piloted by American pilot and evergreen piloted by Egyptian pilot.
as a former American Merchant Seaman we used the term Brotherhood of the Sea meaning all sailors are equal....It offends me that some ignorant fools take great joy in insulting a ships crew....
@@alphapredmass people knows what you says, but there are few people who does and they do it repeatedly such behaviours because nobody held them accountable for their inappropriate behaviours and this is like a virus which is spreading rapidly everywhere these days
They saved countless lives!! You can actually see on the video that the vehicles had stopped coming onto the bridge just seconds before the collapse!! All because of their fast reactions
I saw the video again, after reading your message, yes, I saw a few cars plying and suddenly all has stopped, just seconds before. That was a close call for many people.
@@zeeefaaa9979 List hundred bad deeds by India in last 100 years. I will list you a million bad deeds of others. I can list many many good deeds of India or Indians around the world.. no matter how much you pile the hate against India, we will keep doing good for the world. That has been our way for thousands of years. We thrived despite adversity. We will continue to do so.. more so, and more assertively.
While I do agree the video is racist and unfortunate, your comment is way off the mark. Indians are not "beating out" American professionals. They are just the cheap labor de jur, to be replaced by the next easily exploitable group to come down the pike.
@@TheSayKular Yes, my suspicion is that they are funded by, or themselves are, an odd group of characters - as exist in every country today including in India.
Unless we develop our own country and proudly promote our own culture and history there is no chance to escape from this racist mongers. Time has come for us to develop our own country
Is any far left( communist) country liberal?? Is any Islamic country liberal?? Do they have Free speech?? But in all democracies these two ideologies join hands together and call themselves’ leftist liberals’😅 No left( communist) country tolerates Islamists and no Islamic country tolerates Leftists! That’s the irony which many people do not realise n fall for the one sided narrative! Type’ left n Islamists alliance’ n understand the deeper geopolitics!!
@@jeetlahkar894 lol you are funny. go to pakistan. its a very united country by religion. We do not need mindset like your here. "too divided" is never an excuse. We hit 8.3 percent groth so whats your point?
I'm from North Carolina USA & a MAGA Repubilcan, I work in Engineering at a world renowned electrical connector manufacturing Co. Some of My head Engineers are from India & they are some of the smartest, most hardworking, & humble Engineers I have had the honor of working with in my 40-year career ! Who ever made that cartoon/meme is about sick as fk ! Please don't categorize all Americans as having those values, Far Right or Far Left because they do not !
We know that but sadly their numbers are increasing by the day. Few Indians were killed in the US in the last couple of months. In one case a white guy stabbed him in the head in a gym. I think western media or social media algorithms are pushing hard to promote a negetive image about India.
Here in North Carolina, USA. We are blessed to also have some of the smartest Dr.'s in the world who are from India ! And you are so correct , our media here loves to antagonize and pit one faction against another. It instigates more incidents for future stories !@@aritrachatterjee363
I say this.....I'm a American veteran and I don't agree with what's going on with this heartless people who do this...I love all people. Don't judge all Americans by the few.
Well-spoken. And being a person of Indian origin, I can vouch for the fact that there is an equivalent proportion of reactive, thoughtless, jingoist Indians also! Especially, on social media!
We love Americans. Except some extreme left people who lives in delusion. But they are in every country. It's the American government we cannot stand at times with a lot of hypocrisy. I am proud of your service to the nation. My father was also in the army. 🫡
But the Majority are in fact racist, I didn't hear anyone stepping in, Americans love joining in to participate, I served in the Marine Corps and there are some racist mfers in our ranks.
I condemn racism. But I also advise you to don’t remain in false knowledge. India hasn’t become a power in one continent Asia (if you know the countries in Asia and their economy). Forget about the world.
they are good in hording jobs in foreign land , is that wild that entire crew was indian on international ship, here in Canada, our ceo hire 1 indian exec now 90% of staff is indian as they kicked out locals and replaced them with imported indians , Indians are the most racist ppl i have seen
It was an Indian Captain and all Indian crew and there was a local pilot as that is the norm when you're entering and exiting a port. But both the captain & the pilot were on the bridge and ultimately captain is the leader so u can't just blame the pilot simply because he was american and u wanna blame them, not the Indian crew. But that would be when it was the fault of the crew, right now leading theory is that the ship lost propulsion, they tried to stop the ship and even dropped the anchor but couldnt change course and did issue warnings before it hit the bridge. That doesn't sound like incompetence to me
@nishn111Anchors don't pivot the ship, not these giant container ships, maybe it might work on sailing vessels . And no offense but all the expert sailors and captains with decades of experience are now saying that this is the right approach in these situations and i don't think u have even sailed a day in your life, taking a boat ride on a lake doesn't count. It takes years to become an expert so u really shouldn't discount the opinion of experts with decades of experience especially when u don't know anything about the topic at hand
Recently there was a “What’s wrong with India” trend. We Indians stood united and turned the negativity into positivity. We can deal with this racist nonsense too! Some racist people cannot stand that Indians are inherently street-smart. We are more exposed to tricky situations on streets and public places on a daily basis. An average American’s jaw will drop if he sees an Indian ride a bike through traffic. Our reactions and reflexes to such situations are at a much higher level than average Americans or Europeans. That conditioning somehow helped this crew too, to have the presence of mind to call the bridge authorities
no body cares, every one understand now that Indians have army of social media agents doing misinformation, rest of the world is not idiot , just answer why on this international ship all crew was indians, indians hire indians and they usually replace non indians from workforce if they get hired on controlling position so common here
The real blame here lies with ship owners economizing on maintenance of the ship's machinery. (This is a nice way of phrasing it). Unless there was sabotage, crew members are not to blame.
Yes . Poor maintenance of the vessel could be a ground for this accident . Possible design defect of the bridge could be a factor for its massive failure with a single contact of a vessel when this risk should have been factored in the design and construction. Port approach could still be a problem along with underwater currents changing course . Poor stowage , ballast issues might be a cause . Without investigations apportioning blame on the Indian crew supports the thought of bad application of nicety . Accident can happen anywhere and by anyone’s negligence.
big respect to the Indian and Philippine crews of all those ships and to the latino workers on all these bridges. America would not function without you! thank you.
@zeeefaaa9979 - They were selected by the top management, who noticed their diligence, dedication, hard work, and intelligence, thus superceding several Americans. They never asked to be seated on the throne. Their merit spoke volumes for them, which naturally gets the goat of specimens like you !
no it was not, there were no pilots , all ports have local guide which basically tell captain how and where to park, its always captain responsibility to drive it accordingly, captain was indian and ship lost power, most likely Indian engineer plug the wrong wire lol , same stuff happens with ever green the most famous ship wreck of this decades and all were indian
@@stormtrooper8420 yeah crazy that people from a developing country outcompete and outperform people who've had every privilege and top notch education their whole life 🤡
According to local port authorities local captain pull in and pull out the ship from the Harbours . No Indian captain was controlling the ship at the time of accident
Pilot or not, the captain is still legally responsible for his ship. The pilot is an advisor and is often given effective command of the ship but is not the final authority aboard.
@@willythemailboy2 my point is East Indian crew is no reasonable for this incident . It is on the social media ppl. are accused Indian crew . The Navigation equipment are fully controlled by local port Authoritie’s designated pilots
@@raichandkulkarni4011 As stated, even with a pilot aboard the captain is the final authority and responsibility on the ship. The captain is required to have a pilot aboard the ship, he is not required to allow the pilot to control the ship directly. Of course, if he ignores the pilot and something happens, he's responsible for that as well. There's no reason to blame the Indian crew or the American pilots at this point because there's no indication human error was involved. It was a mechanical failure of some sort.
Wake up Indians.... As good as America is, you can see there exists a lot of Indian haters. We don't need to make enemies or get angry..... just double down on your strengths of hard + smart work individual and team work, and make India a Great country !
That surely happening American are just bunch Immigrant from EU, North America, Africa,Mexico they live on DEAD body's of Native American. How can they Now what sovereignty means ? Or Feels like to be united and secured as we Indian are we Show the World No Matter what religion you practice your are AN Indian . Except the Extremist 😅😢.
dont worry about racism madam...how minorities and dalits are treated in India, it is good to get taste of own medicine sometimes. it makes you humble in the long run
Why do you care about this topic, you're neither Indian nor American? Your loyalties lie with Canada, go drive your taxis there and leave us alone. And before accusing anyone else of discrimination, remember the discrimination in Punjab against Ramdasiyas, Mazhabis, Sehajdharis, women, deras and most importantly Hindu Bihari labor. It's not necessary to have Punjab in India. For example, the Turks did not originally live in Today's turkey. They migrated from what is today known as Russian territory. Google 'Tartar loyalists.' You can have your Sikh-ruled in Canada and dit wouldn't be without historical precedence. They have a lot of land to give. You were never a majority in Indian Punjab. Even today you barely are. If India did not accept you after the partition, you wouldn't be a majority in Indian Punjab either. A large influential part of the Sikhs were already in talks with Jinnah over that. Even today many have bought into the idea of a religious(Sikh) theocracy, which was the idea behind Pakistan. In your Sikh state, it isn't hard to fathom how minorities would be treated and what would ultimately become of them, we've all had parents who lived during 1990s Punjab. It was only the demographic realities that caused the Sikhs to join India in the first place. This is the historical reality that cannot be ignored, even acknowledged by Sikh leaders at the time. This is why the Akali Dal which is one of the most religious parties in India keeps winning in Sikh-majority Punjab.
Oye Paaji People like you r the reason why westerners tend to make jokes on Indians and think that we would take it lightly... No time has changed... castism and reservation is proportional to each other now and minorities which minority r u talking about haa??? Say it clearly if can't then shut up
Yes, they are treated so badly that they get jobs &admission in universities by scoring less then 50% while a General category student struggles with even 95%. So tragic🙃
Indian seafaring officers are one of the best and more educated and qualified for their jobs. It's the major ship owners and companies that have avoided paying for maintenance and costs affecting their own vessels and a poor seafarer is at the receiving end as always.
Indians should have made a cartoon with the ship colliding with the towers and pasty, fat Americans falling out of it, titled "American Engineering:- Planned Obsolescence in Action, but they didn't plan forr that"
Think Indians should be alert cause first you have these students being killed for no reason and now this. Pure jealously it seems and therefore being targeted ?
I am an Indian and i agree that those crew members or pilot or whoever alerted the authorities did a good job. Otherwise, we could have have another 50 or more casualties on that bridge. But if i heard right, this ship had had problems before this. The shipping company running this ship should be held accountable for not maintaining it properly.
More likely the Singaporean management company being negligent with maintenance of the ship. Everything I've seen indicates an equipment failure rather than human error.
Two American Pilots were in charge of the ship! Find out who they were. I think they were inebriated. That's why there is silence on who they were! The Indian crew took a stand against the inebriated American Pilots and warned and dropped anchor. Too late!
That was really not necessary actually, the pilot could not do anything but we found somebody who can be blamed because of the racist comments about Indians.
Then why hell going US like dogs running for bone..one can see people throng at US consulate for visa, que is more than enough proof.. Cry for "boycott US".. Not a single bhrahmin will support.. Bhrahmins 2nd home native is US.. This humiliation will not care bhrahmins in US.. Only rest of indians cry of this humiliation.😂😂😂..
Many people are ignorant to the fact that, when a ship comes near it's destination port, a local pilot will board the ship and takes control of it for the safe embarkation at the port. Same way when the ship depart the port, it will be boarded and steered by the local pilot, until the ship reaches the open sea. So in the Baltimore incident no one can blame Indian Captain or crew. Also in this particular case the local pilot cannot be blamed either, because the ship lost power and lost control.
Pilot or not, the captain is still legally responsible for his ship. The pilot is an advisor and is often given effective command of the ship but is not the final authority aboard. But you are correct about the equipment failure being the issue and not human error.
@@edwardrichardson5567 Yes, even when the pilot is on board. The captain is still responsible because while the pilot knows the harbor, the captain knows the ship.
The unsettling aspect is that if you confront them, they will show the screenshot of the Wiki article on ethnic joke to claim that they are humorous. The Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs complained about such jokes to the US State Department in the 1970s, according to the same Wiki article. Because they reinforce ethnic stereotypes and sometimes lead to calls for violence.
I don't know why They Tease all Indians if 22 Members are on that Ship and When these people travel out of India should also know that They Will not receive the same amount of Support as Indians living and Prospering in India get, Hence they should Be ready to fend of for themselves as India Should inly care fir those Innocents who Unnecessarily Using Racism
They are getting a reality check right now, most European countries and America are virtually bankrupt, and that's why they don't want gold to be the way to evaluate currencies soon. The major powers like Russia, China and more than half the countries are in the process of bringing back gold to set the value of currency mot petrol dollar.
Yes , You are right ,West Indians are different than East Indians. West Indians are Hybrid of Dalits(Untouchables) people of East India (indentured workers exported from India by British to West Indies) and African Slaves those who were brought by British in West Indies.
The same thing the ship's crew was doing: not a whole hell of a lot, because without power they didn't have the means of controlling the ship. No engine, no rudder, no bow thruster. Dropping the anchor was all they could do, and if they'd had another mile or two it might have mattered. As for tugs, it's actually extremely dangerous for the tugs in that situation. Instead of one tragedy in 50 years, we'd incidents of tugs getting capsized and 4-6 crewmen dead at least once a year.
Please dont say "western society is ignorant'. That's a blanket statement. Be fair jusr as you ask us to know that not all indians are alike, not all westerns are alike. I absolutely have heard some things from my western compadres that place them in the ignorant category. Im not a fan of them either 😊
I'll also hold social media sites accountable. Even if you report the postings, the Silicon Valley corporations and their community handles never take any action despite the widespread sharing of such materials. However, when other nationalities are targeted, these businesses act pro-actively. Considering that the US State Department often meddles in India's domestic affairs. For once, I would like MEA to discuss the issue with their US colleagues and include the CEOs of the major social media companies in the discussion.
So-called 'professionals' built that Baltimore bridge right??? Well, Look what happened to it by just a kiss from that ship. 😂 Poor USA. Gotta find someone to blame. Yeah! India as always. 🤣
lol there were guide not pilots, ship always driven by captain and captain is responsible of it, all most all port have local guide as per law, nice way of blaming loss of power to guide, it highly likely Indian engineer in mechanical room plug the wrong wire for ship to lose power
Another anti India toolkit member is spotted. 😂😂😂😂😂. Minorities in India are sitting government cabinet to Manager at factories in India. RSS is a social group not an political party and what about Terror sponsored group called PFI??????
Actually we are in a Era of Self Drive Cars, why don't we use it in shipping. Moreover when the Titanic ship collided with the iceberg and sunk, after that they invented a technology radar & sonar with GPS.
That's a hell of a leap. Radar capable of detecting an iceberg like that wouldn't be developed for at least 25 years after the Titanic sank, sonar even later than that, and GPS nearly 70 years after.
Each of us Indians face this bias and discrimination But God knows how we put up with it. We immigrants are third class citizens. Is there a kickback for the Insurance company. Need to be a detective instead of diverting attention on our lungi or turban. Or was it AI taking control of vehicles
Racism has been around for a long time. During the British Raj, Indians were barred from clubs, one of them bore the sign: ;Indians and dogs not allowed'. The only Indian member was the Aga Khan.
Prejudicial people are everywhere, perhaps more in US! Then again, they probably are least world-wise and ignorant in many things in the world! We can only feel sorry for them!
It was the American pilot, not the captain, nor any crew members who alerted the authorities about the power failure. That was his responsibility. The ship should not have been cleared to leave port because there were power failures whilst it was being prepared to sail, according to the man who worked on the HVAC. The investigation will uncover what went wrong.
Question is, if the crew had performed all due maintenance appropriately or were there deficiencies and unmanaged oversights leading to ship losing power, which led to the disaster.
What is the EAM DOING ABOUT THE IMAGE OF INDIAN Sea FARERS. Absolutely disgraceful to see Indian ministry silent on this even the shipping ministry accepts this image
It's funny in a way, the cargo ship is owned by one Asian country, the crew is from another Asian country while the ship is being run and managed by a German international ship company, big name company!!!!!
The thing is that all these Indian sailors see every day thousands of China outbound and inbound containers. These Americans may have the perception that the Indian crew want to decouple China from US by crashing on the pier
I am an Indian seafarer ...All the companies has Indian seafarers on all ships...and seriously challenging Indian brains...it's a laughable content..pilot has the ultimate control of ship in local waters..
This is just appalling these crew members are professional sailors and have lost friends and have just experienced a life changing event. Shame on the public who expresses such horrific racism!
whats common with ever green and dali crash, indian crew and indian captian.....
Captain was Ukrainian@@zeeefaaa9979
@@zeeefaaa9979 get out if here
Is any far left( communist) country liberal?? Is any Islamic country liberal?? Do they have Free speech?? But in all democracies these two ideologies join hands together and call themselves’ leftist liberals’😅
No left( communist) country tolerates Islamists and no Islamic country tolerates Leftists! That’s the irony which many people do not realise n fall for the one sided narrative!
Type’ left n Islamists alliance’ n understand the deeper geopolitics!!
@@zeeefaaa9979 both piloted by local crew as required by international law. Baltimore piloted by American pilot and evergreen piloted by Egyptian pilot.
as a former American Merchant Seaman we used the term Brotherhood of the Sea meaning all sailors are equal....It offends me that some ignorant fools take great joy in insulting a ships crew....
Now if you can only educate the masses about the Moors.
@@alphapredmass people knows what you says, but there are few people who does and they do it repeatedly such behaviours because nobody held them accountable for their inappropriate behaviours and this is like a virus which is spreading rapidly everywhere these days
@@Robin-kv5vh hmm
@@alphapred who is talking endians??
The most ignorant people on the planet
They saved countless lives!! You can actually see on the video that the vehicles had stopped coming onto the bridge just seconds before the collapse!! All because of their fast reactions
I saw the video again, after reading your message, yes, I saw a few cars plying and suddenly all has stopped, just seconds before. That was a close call for many people.
@@zeeefaaa9979 List hundred bad deeds by India in last 100 years. I will list you a million bad deeds of others. I can list many many good deeds of India or Indians around the world.. no matter how much you pile the hate against India, we will keep doing good for the world. That has been our way for thousands of years. We thrived despite adversity. We will continue to do so.. more so, and more assertively.
@@krishnaats7141 india does bad deeds within the country. You are too weak to do bad deeds outside lol
@@zeeefaaa9979
U r a biased m crack,it seems... longing for an opportunity very long to abuse.... pitiable insect.😊
One of the evil and criminal thing is caste system low caste and spreading hatred in religion @@krishnaats7141
The cartoon shows the inner frustration of Americans loosing out to Indian professionals in many areas....in future Bharat will show the way
Did you check who are foxford comics people? Can they be funded by Pakistan?
But India is still a poor and third world country.The truth hurts and yet many Indian boast it is a superpower country which I cannot take it
While I do agree the video is racist and unfortunate, your comment is way off the mark. Indians are not "beating out" American professionals. They are just the cheap labor de jur, to be replaced by the next easily exploitable group to come down the pike.
Show which way? Fake democracy? TRUE democracy? Barbaric culture? Civilised culture? Cross-border terrorism,........
@@TheSayKular Yes, my suspicion is that they are funded by, or themselves are, an odd group of characters - as exist in every country today including in India.
Unless we develop our own country and proudly promote our own culture and history there is no chance to escape from this racist mongers. Time has come for us to develop our own country
Never happen. We are too divided by language caste and religion
which is why there's women , lgb, indian, black , etc Month
Is any far left( communist) country liberal?? Is any Islamic country liberal?? Do they have Free speech?? But in all democracies these two ideologies join hands together and call themselves’ leftist liberals’😅
No left( communist) country tolerates Islamists and no Islamic country tolerates Leftists! That’s the irony which many people do not realise n fall for the one sided narrative!
Type’ left n Islamists alliance’ n understand the deeper geopolitics!!
@@jeetlahkar894 lol you are funny. go to pakistan. its a very united country by religion. We do not need mindset like your here. "too divided" is never an excuse. We hit 8.3 percent groth so whats your point?
Not going to happen,You are too busy check what China is doing 24/7.
I'm from North Carolina USA & a MAGA Repubilcan, I work in Engineering at a world renowned electrical connector manufacturing Co. Some of My head Engineers are from India & they are some of the smartest, most hardworking, & humble Engineers I have had the honor of working with in my 40-year career ! Who ever made that cartoon/meme is about sick as fk ! Please don't categorize all Americans as having those values, Far Right or Far Left because they do not !
We know that but sadly their numbers are increasing by the day. Few Indians were killed in the US in the last couple of months. In one case a white guy stabbed him in the head in a gym. I think western media or social media algorithms are pushing hard to promote a negetive image about India.
Here in North Carolina, USA. We are blessed to also have some of the smartest Dr.'s in the world who are from India ! And you are so correct , our media here loves to antagonize and pit one faction against another. It instigates more incidents for future stories !@@aritrachatterjee363
Come to India and experience
As a Filipino, I respect Indians’ achievements and their contributions to my country. And Indian cuisine is awesome.
what is it going to do with cuisine?
Yes Philippine and india both are huge competetor in Open defecation. 🇮🇳🇵🇭
I say this.....I'm a American veteran and I don't agree with what's going on with this heartless people who do this...I love all people. Don't judge all Americans by the few.
Well-spoken. And being a person of Indian origin, I can vouch for the fact that there is an equivalent proportion of reactive, thoughtless, jingoist Indians also! Especially, on social media!
We love Americans. Except some extreme left people who lives in delusion. But they are in every country. It's the American government we cannot stand at times with a lot of hypocrisy. I am proud of your service to the nation. My father was also in the army. 🫡
You may be a select few but we all know that Americans are the most racist people on the earth and not just racist but with no scruples either .
But the few keeps increasing daily 😏
But the Majority are in fact racist, I didn't hear anyone stepping in, Americans love joining in to participate, I served in the Marine Corps and there are some racist mfers in our ranks.
Mam we Indians should stand united, these things surely tell India is becoming a world power, let's face it with strength and confidence.
I condemn racism. But I also advise you to don’t remain in false knowledge. India hasn’t become a power in one continent Asia (if you know the countries in Asia and their economy). Forget about the world.
@@Frc278 😄🤣
they are good in hording jobs in foreign land , is that wild that entire crew was indian on international ship, here in Canada, our ceo hire 1 indian exec now 90% of staff is indian as they kicked out locals and replaced them with imported indians , Indians are the most racist ppl i have seen
World power. Really and indians can not respect their poor and women.
@@Frc278 so quick to hate always…Wait 20 years …if you can :)
Great response. Can't expect much from people who are confused with their own gender identity. 😂😂😂
😜
Then why many indian migration in USA... Stop them bru 😂
They don't worship gender fluid gods like you people
Do not redeem saar
@@nostro1940 did your ego get hurt?
This accident has got more to do with the “mental health issues of American captain steering the ship ” than incompetence of Indian crew members.
Do you know that Captain or any of the circumstance around the accident? You seem more knowledgeable that the US NTSB!!
captain was indian, there were two local guide but they were not steering the ship its always captain responsibility and he was indian
Captain was Ukrainian.@@zeeefaaa9979
It was an Indian Captain and all Indian crew and there was a local pilot as that is the norm when you're entering and exiting a port. But both the captain & the pilot were on the bridge and ultimately captain is the leader so u can't just blame the pilot simply because he was american and u wanna blame them, not the Indian crew. But that would be when it was the fault of the crew, right now leading theory is that the ship lost propulsion, they tried to stop the ship and even dropped the anchor but couldnt change course and did issue warnings before it hit the bridge. That doesn't sound like incompetence to me
@nishn111Anchors don't pivot the ship, not these giant container ships, maybe it might work on sailing vessels .
And no offense but all the expert sailors and captains with decades of experience are now saying that this is the right approach in these situations and i don't think u have even sailed a day in your life, taking a boat ride on a lake doesn't count. It takes years to become an expert so u really shouldn't discount the opinion of experts with decades of experience especially when u don't know anything about the topic at hand
It calls itself democrats, advices other countries, but it's not for them,first practice and then preach
So close so true
Endians are the most racist people in the world
You get what you preach
Francis key wrote the national anthem on an Indian made ship captured by American from the British
Recently there was a “What’s wrong with India” trend. We Indians stood united and turned the negativity into positivity. We can deal with this racist nonsense too! Some racist people cannot stand that Indians are inherently street-smart. We are more exposed to tricky situations on streets and public places on a daily basis. An average American’s jaw will drop if he sees an Indian ride a bike through traffic. Our reactions and reflexes to such situations are at a much higher level than average Americans or Europeans. That conditioning somehow helped this crew too, to have the presence of mind to call the bridge authorities
no body cares, every one understand now that Indians have army of social media agents doing misinformation, rest of the world is not idiot , just answer why on this international ship all crew was indians, indians hire indians and they usually replace non indians from workforce if they get hired on controlling position so common here
If this news becomes more widespread then Indian hackers will hack that comedy website. Don’t underestimate Desi Jugaad.
😂
@@stormtrooper8420 that did happen to canada
Indians are funny 😂
The real blame here lies with ship owners economizing on maintenance of the ship's machinery. (This is a nice way of phrasing it). Unless there was sabotage, crew members are not to blame.
Bro pilot and co pilot are Americans
Agree wholeheartedly with you @user-ts4fo9ol9x
Yes . Poor maintenance of the vessel could be a ground for this accident . Possible design defect of the bridge could be a factor for its massive failure with a single contact of a vessel when this risk should have been factored in the design and construction. Port approach could still be a problem along with underwater currents changing course . Poor stowage , ballast issues might be a cause . Without investigations apportioning blame on the Indian crew supports the thought of bad application of nicety . Accident can happen anywhere and by anyone’s negligence.
big respect to the Indian and Philippine crews of all those ships and to the latino workers on all these bridges. America would not function without you! thank you.
Nice comment. Highly appreciated. Thank you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
so why u come here in hordes, why not google ceo or MS ceo created the company in India, why you cant get success in india.
@zeeefaaa9979 - They were selected by the top management, who noticed their diligence, dedication, hard work, and intelligence, thus superceding several Americans. They never asked to be seated on the throne. Their merit spoke volumes for them, which naturally gets the goat of specimens like you !
@@zeeefaaa9979
Ur identity has come out now,
u nasty element... coward in hiding..😅
@@haripadmanabhan1095 don't need to reply to these clowns bro
What will they say when very soon after American investigation will prove it was the 2 American pilot responsible.
no it was not, there were no pilots , all ports have local guide which basically tell captain how and where to park, its always captain responsibility to drive it accordingly, captain was indian and ship lost power, most likely Indian engineer plug the wrong wire lol , same stuff happens with ever green the most famous ship wreck of this decades and all were indian
@@zeeefaaa9979 N a cartoon like u " knows it all " Let the experts investigate n inform us. Keep yr 2c opinion to yrself.
@@simlamaharaj1695😂🤜🤛
@zeeefaaa9979 no any port in the world to come to port and get out is the job of the pilot and here there was 2 American pilot so stop denying.
Lunatic zee needs to grow a brain else she / he / others ..may land in the loony bin
I'm disappointed that my fellow Americans would be so unkind. I admire Indian people. They are brilliant, kind and trustworthy. Regards from 🇺🇲
300million people 3 assholes post this shit and you blame all Americans.
@@TheUnknownVideographer This bot got more sense and knowledge than you !!
baughahahahahahahaha you forget a racist caste system
@@alphapred bro 🤡 is american by birth lives under CNN
@@alphapred What do you know about caste system?
Funny how we Indians cannot take this.... Because we are experts at hurling abuses and name calling each other in politics back here in India
Its nothing but pure jealousy.
But India is still a poor and third world country.The truth hurts and yet many Indian boast it is a superpower country which I cannot take it
Jealous of what exactly 😅
@@stormtrooper8420skill and intelligence
@@skandy6847 🤣🤣
Yeah endia definitely looks like a country filled with skilled and intelligent people.
You can literally smell it when you land their
@@stormtrooper8420 yeah crazy that people from a developing country outcompete and outperform people who've had every privilege and top notch education their whole life 🤡
According to local port authorities local captain pull in and pull out the ship from the Harbours . No Indian captain was controlling the ship at the time of accident
Pilot or not, the captain is still legally responsible for his ship. The pilot is an advisor and is often given effective command of the ship but is not the final authority aboard.
@@willythemailboy2 my point is East Indian crew is no reasonable for this incident . It is on the social media ppl. are accused Indian crew . The Navigation equipment are fully controlled by local port Authoritie’s designated pilots
@@raichandkulkarni4011 As stated, even with a pilot aboard the captain is the final authority and responsibility on the ship. The captain is required to have a pilot aboard the ship, he is not required to allow the pilot to control the ship directly. Of course, if he ignores the pilot and something happens, he's responsible for that as well.
There's no reason to blame the Indian crew or the American pilots at this point because there's no indication human error was involved. It was a mechanical failure of some sort.
@@willythemailboy2 social media full of cartoons
@@raichandkulkarni4011 People are stupid and uneducated. Why are you surprised by this?
The pilots were American.
Black and Brown people were developing mathematics and philosophy while they crawled in caves.
So why are the black and brown people begging the western nations now.
good joke all inventions from Asia and Africa take some tranquilisers 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Only Indians were advanced .Yes whiteys were living in caves.
what did Europe create pre renaissance? some aquaducts? Africans had to teach Europe how to bathe and brush teeth. @@SoldierofGod-ft9mz
@@SoldierofGod-ft9mz woah ! Great time to search for next carpenter 🤣
Making baseless mockery out of the tragedy is pure evil.
Wake up Indians.... As good as America is, you can see there exists a lot of Indian haters. We don't need to make enemies or get angry..... just double down on your strengths of hard + smart work individual and team work, and make India a Great country !
That surely happening American are just bunch Immigrant from EU, North America, Africa,Mexico they live on DEAD body's of Native American.
How can they Now what sovereignty means ? Or Feels like to be united and secured as we Indian are we Show the World No Matter what religion you practice your are AN Indian .
Except the Extremist 😅😢.
Well said 🫡
Given the same exact scenario, IF this was a Chinese or Russian ship, would the government & MSM response would be the same?
Nope
remember evergreen, all crew was indian, a most famous ship mishaps and next day Indians IT cell start blaming others as usual, same is happening here
@@zeeefaaa9979 good point
@@zeeefaaa9979the pilot was American.. so don't put your own blame on others to hide your mistakes
@@zeeefaaa9979 who was the pilot??... that's the point...
dont worry about racism madam...how minorities and dalits are treated in India, it is good to get taste of own medicine sometimes. it makes you humble in the long run
Yes ask your Jatt Sikhs in Punjab .. half the population embraced christianity
Why do you care about this topic, you're neither Indian nor American? Your loyalties lie with Canada, go drive your taxis there and leave us alone. And before accusing anyone else of discrimination, remember the discrimination in Punjab against Ramdasiyas, Mazhabis, Sehajdharis, women, deras and most importantly Hindu Bihari labor.
It's not necessary to have Punjab in India. For example, the Turks did not originally live in Today's turkey. They migrated from what is today known as Russian territory. Google 'Tartar loyalists.' You can have your Sikh-ruled in Canada and dit wouldn't be without historical precedence. They have a lot of land to give.
You were never a majority in Indian Punjab. Even today you barely are. If India did not accept you after the partition, you wouldn't be a majority in Indian Punjab either. A large influential part of the Sikhs were already in talks with Jinnah over that. Even today many have bought into the idea of a religious(Sikh) theocracy, which was the idea behind Pakistan. In your Sikh state, it isn't hard to fathom how minorities would be treated and what would ultimately become of them, we've all had parents who lived during 1990s Punjab.
It was only the demographic realities that caused the Sikhs to join India in the first place. This is the historical reality that cannot be ignored, even acknowledged by Sikh leaders at the time. This is why the Akali Dal which is one of the most religious parties in India keeps winning in Sikh-majority Punjab.
Oye Paaji
People like you r the reason why westerners tend to make jokes on Indians and think that we would take it lightly...
No time has changed... castism and reservation is proportional to each other now and minorities which minority r u talking about haa??? Say it clearly if can't then shut up
Very well said..
Yes, they are treated so badly that they get jobs &admission in universities by scoring less then 50% while a General category student struggles with even 95%.
So tragic🙃
Indian seafaring officers are one of the best and more educated and qualified for their jobs.
It's the major ship owners and companies that have avoided paying for maintenance and costs affecting their own vessels and a poor seafarer is at the receiving end as always.
Shame on the cartoonist who did that…. Can you Criticize the engineers who built the bridge which is so fragile? Like a cheap glass door!! 😂😂
Indians should have made a cartoon with the ship colliding with the towers and pasty, fat Americans falling out of it, titled "American Engineering:- Planned Obsolescence in Action, but they didn't plan forr that"
@adolft_official cow dung helps to generate electricity unlike you who is good for nothing
@adolft_official At least they are not plane-into-building crashing terror1sts.
American captain and crew tried there best with a powerless ship, it is an accident new vehicles break down also.
Think Indians should be alert cause first you have these students being killed for no reason and now this. Pure jealously it seems and therefore being targeted ?
I am an Indian and i agree that those crew members or pilot or whoever alerted the authorities did a good job. Otherwise, we could have have another 50 or more casualties on that bridge.
But if i heard right, this ship had had problems before this. The shipping company running this ship should be held accountable for not maintaining it properly.
They are trying to hide their own mistakes. And want to divert. The actual culprit is an american pilot.
More likely the Singaporean management company being negligent with maintenance of the ship. Everything I've seen indicates an equipment failure rather than human error.
The Indians crews alerted the US media. That’s what is important
Two American Pilots were in charge of the ship! Find out who they were. I think they were inebriated. That's why there is silence on who they were!
The Indian crew took a stand against the inebriated American Pilots and warned and dropped anchor. Too late!
The amount of racism from Indians directed against the American pilots who called Mayday is unprecedented.
That was really not necessary actually, the pilot could not do anything but we found somebody who can be blamed because of the racist comments about Indians.
DO NOT REDEEM!!!!
Pilot from the port doesn’t have responsibility over this , without power how can he control , that’s the mistake by the crews
GOOD MORNING SAARS 👳♂️👳♂️👳♂️
We are aryans saar
If an American pilot was incharge during the incident then insulting the Indians is clearly a no brainer ! 😢
USA ALWAYS TREATED INDIANS LIKE THAT
Then why hell going US like dogs running for bone..one can see people throng at US consulate for visa,
que is more than enough proof..
Cry for "boycott US"..
Not a single bhrahmin will support..
Bhrahmins 2nd home native is US..
This humiliation will not care bhrahmins in US..
Only rest of indians cry of this humiliation.😂😂😂..
Still we want Green Card
@@jeetlahkar894 ONLY the JOBBIES. RICH PEOPLE ARE GIVING BACK THEIR GREEN CARD LAST 10-15 YEARS
Over 59k Indian got us citizenship last year.
Indians treat their own like true $hit, why complain?
The downside of free expression is that racist and ignorant views can be stated.without censorship.
I replied to that racist lady on X.
Thank you
Im South African Indian, and cant tolerate these racist fools
I'm of West African descent born and raised in the USA. 60% of my doctors / specialist doctors are Indians. Just saying..
They don't like black people lol
The truth is, they treated you in the same way you guys treat untouchables in India...
So?
Many people are ignorant to the fact that, when a ship comes near it's destination port, a local pilot will board the ship and takes control of it for the safe embarkation at the port. Same way when the ship depart the port, it will be boarded and steered by the local pilot, until the ship reaches the open sea. So in the Baltimore incident no one can blame Indian Captain or crew. Also in this particular case the local pilot cannot be blamed either, because the ship lost power and lost control.
Pilot or not, the captain is still legally responsible for his ship. The pilot is an advisor and is often given effective command of the ship but is not the final authority aboard.
But you are correct about the equipment failure being the issue and not human error.
Not when the Local Pilot has command..
@@edwardrichardson5567 Yes, even when the pilot is on board. The captain is still responsible because while the pilot knows the harbor, the captain knows the ship.
Even after this indians want to go to america legally or illegally .
The unsettling aspect is that if you confront them, they will show the screenshot of the Wiki article on ethnic joke to claim that they are humorous. The Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs complained about such jokes to the US State Department in the 1970s, according to the same Wiki article. Because they reinforce ethnic stereotypes and sometimes lead to calls for violence.
If at all congress gets back to power, Mukhtar Ansari will be given ‘Bharat Ratna’ award.😂
Congress, is a British colonial legacy party.... and with the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty bloodline, they are a DISEAAE on India and Indians
I don't know why They Tease all Indians if 22 Members are on that Ship and When these people travel out of India should also know that They Will not receive the same amount of Support as Indians living and Prospering in India get, Hence they should Be ready to fend of for themselves as India Should inly care fir those Innocents who Unnecessarily Using Racism
Paajit is slur for Sikhs and punjabi people
Jeets coping in the comments 😂😂
West will take decades to get a Reality Check
They are getting a reality check right now, most European countries and America are virtually bankrupt, and that's why they don't want gold to be the way to evaluate currencies soon. The major powers like Russia, China and more than half the countries are in the process of bringing back gold to set the value of currency mot petrol dollar.
Im west indian and hate when people think im east indian, we're not the same!!!!
Yes , You are right ,West Indians are different than East Indians. West Indians are Hybrid of Dalits(Untouchables) people of East India (indentured workers exported from India by British to West Indies) and African Slaves those who were brought by British in West Indies.
Now that All the Americans are gone frustrated with the Indians' smartness
yep. how indians can produce babies like assembly line.
Ship was in disrepair! Why was it allowed to be used????
Because Indians inspected it.
I'm surprised that ship had toilets.
This lady has gained my greatest respect
They should blame the bridge not the all indian crew.....😂😂😂......
Isn't funny whatsoever..
What were the 2 American marine piloe doing ?
Why no standby or escort tugs at the critical area ?
The same thing the ship's crew was doing: not a whole hell of a lot, because without power they didn't have the means of controlling the ship. No engine, no rudder, no bow thruster. Dropping the anchor was all they could do, and if they'd had another mile or two it might have mattered.
As for tugs, it's actually extremely dangerous for the tugs in that situation. Instead of one tragedy in 50 years, we'd incidents of tugs getting capsized and 4-6 crewmen dead at least once a year.
In India where its 100 plus degrees is hot plus a outer robe. This is not the kind of clothes they had on. grow up.
Please dont say "western society is ignorant'. That's a blanket statement. Be fair jusr as you ask us to know that not all indians are alike, not all westerns are alike. I absolutely have heard some things from my western compadres that place them in the ignorant category. Im not a fan of them either 😊
I'll also hold social media sites accountable. Even if you report the postings, the Silicon Valley corporations and their community handles never take any action despite the widespread sharing of such materials. However, when other nationalities are targeted, these businesses act pro-actively. Considering that the US State Department often meddles in India's domestic affairs. For once, I would like MEA to discuss the issue with their US colleagues and include the CEOs of the major social media companies in the discussion.
Captain of the ship was American!!
So-called 'professionals' built that Baltimore bridge right??? Well, Look what happened to it by just a kiss from that ship. 😂 Poor USA. Gotta find someone to blame. Yeah! India as always. 🤣
THEY NEED TO BUILD A BRIDGE AND GET OVER IT ! LOL
Be quiet brown.
Was American piloting the ship wearing a ku klux klan costume😆
😀😆😁😉😊😋
lol there were guide not pilots, ship always driven by captain and captain is responsible of it, all most all port have local guide as per law, nice way of blaming loss of power to guide, it highly likely Indian engineer in mechanical room plug the wrong wire for ship to lose power
@@zeeefaaa9979 You missed the point which is that Americans are not immune to negative stereotypes.
Madam, please also note how RSS treating and making obscene comments about minorities in India.same US right wing persons are making funny of us.
Another anti India toolkit member is spotted. 😂😂😂😂😂. Minorities in India are sitting government cabinet to Manager at factories in India. RSS is a social group not an political party and what about Terror sponsored group called PFI??????
Why don't you talk about ruthless racism in India? You will not talk because you are the so-called upper caste?
Fantastic speech 🎉
Actually we are in a Era of Self Drive Cars, why don't we use it in shipping. Moreover when the Titanic ship collided with the iceberg and sunk, after that they invented a technology radar & sonar with GPS.
That's a hell of a leap. Radar capable of detecting an iceberg like that wouldn't be developed for at least 25 years after the Titanic sank, sonar even later than that, and GPS nearly 70 years after.
The ship started going off course quite a while before it hit the bridge. Why didnt they correct their onset.
The captain of the ship is American. Maybe he was incompetent & on drugs, like most Americans!!
The ship lost power. That means no engine control, no rudder control, no bow thruster. They didn't have the means to correct their course.
Developed country but racisist people sad reality 😢
What about india? Isn't that the most racist country in the world?
Each of us Indians face this bias and discrimination
But God knows how we put up with it. We immigrants are third class citizens. Is there a kickback for the Insurance company. Need to be a detective instead of diverting attention on our lungi or turban. Or was it AI taking control of vehicles
Your home country do the same thing to their fellow citizens ..
@@atheistbanerjee008 fr
Racism has been around for a long time. During the British Raj, Indians were barred from clubs, one of them bore the sign: ;Indians and dogs not allowed'. The only Indian member was the Aga Khan.
Prejudicial people are everywhere, perhaps more in US! Then again, they probably are least world-wise and ignorant in many things in the world! We can only feel sorry for them!
Excellent reporting
Well presented and analysed by news anchor.
It was the American pilot, not the captain, nor any crew members who alerted the authorities about the power failure. That was his responsibility. The ship should not have been cleared to leave port because there were power failures whilst it was being prepared to sail, according to the man who worked on the HVAC. The investigation will uncover what went wrong.
Tis the Season of Sacrifice
Well said. This should be watched by the whole World.
This is totally unfair
Question is, if the crew had performed all due maintenance appropriately or were there deficiencies and unmanaged oversights leading to ship losing power, which led to the disaster.
Why drive the ship when everything wasn’t in check?
What bigger disaster did they even avert when they destroyed a whole bridge?
I like the way the journalist did her job. Finally, someone who can show the truth.
What is the EAM DOING ABOUT THE IMAGE OF INDIAN Sea FARERS. Absolutely disgraceful to see Indian ministry silent on this even the shipping ministry accepts this image
Don't think badly about Indians, remember everything
paradox of racism...having some racism in a country is the lesser of 2 evils when compared to a country with no racism.
Excellent Discourse on this very important matter.
Sending Mayday messages is "heroic"??
Thank God the crew is safe.
Very strong reply...
It's funny in a way, the cargo ship is owned by one Asian country, the crew is from another Asian country while the ship is being run and managed by a German international ship company, big name company!!!!!
Which news published it ?
Great explanation. Just lots of idiots out there passing on disinformation causing more anxiety and sadness to the victims - instead of helping them.
responsibility of accident on American pilot (?) but crew praised for saving the lives...he must have sensed the danger in time and send the alarm
The thing is that all these Indian sailors see every day thousands of China outbound and inbound containers. These Americans may have the perception that the Indian crew want to decouple China from US by crashing on the pier
I am an Indian seafarer ...All the companies has Indian seafarers on all ships...and seriously challenging Indian brains...it's a laughable content..pilot has the ultimate control of ship in local waters..
Its appreciate you are talking straight forward.