Napaka galing niyo talaga Sir! Palagi akong nakakasagot sa mga tanong sa klase kasi lahat ng info nabibigay mo. Natututunan ko talaga lalo na mahilig ako mag advance study. Salamat sir, galing niyo po!
Thank you Sir! May debate kami sa Monday, ang side namin ay anti- Retraction. Pinanood ko muna yung Pro- retraction, sana mairaos namin 'to HAHHAHAHAHAHA. Salamat po sa mga video nyo natututo po ako😊
Very intriguing topic, kudos sir. Naalala ko sa class ni ma’am Rag Sak nagdebate kami about this fliptop style, it was so cringey (my performance)😅 btw so sad when I learned how Rizal was buried. More power to your channel sir 😊
Hi sir. May I ask if you could make a video on the updated list of the Presidents of the Republic of the Philippines and discuss them? It would mean so much. I really love your videos. Thank you very much.
Thank you sir for this very informative discussion ❤️ it helps a lot. But still I keep on questioning myself: Which among the accounts or analyses is considered the most convincing and reliable?
this makes sense. sir, if u were the one to be asked po? what is your decision? let's say po na 'till now ay laman parin ito ng mga debates pero lahat naman po tayo ay may pinapanigan. this is not to invalidate po the other side, did rizal really retracted?
Sa ngayon I cannot really make a decision since for me, lacking pa rn ang evidence to prove or disprove. Although if we would base it s cuerpo report, may possibility tlga ng retraction.
good afternoon po, pwede po bang makahingi nung analysis po ni rafael palma, need ko lang po kasi malaman yung date kung kailan po nila ginawa pati po kay pascual po tapos kay runes, thank you po.
Hi Sir! I really find this material very beneficial to our class. Can we have a copy of your materials regarding Rizal's burial? We need resources po kasi. Thank you so much po!
Hi sir, I really support your channel po. I am from private school but I really do spent some time watching your videos, mas natututo po ako sainyo kaysa sa Prof ko.. sir sana sa next video about po sa Treaty of paris 1898. Thank youuu
Hello sir, Thank you for this enlightenment it really helps a lot. If it's okay, can I ask the sources that you used in this video? because I badly need it po for our position paper. Thank you, sir
Local history is very helpful in making history closer to us and relatable. Local history promotes the place or local town wherein people live thus helping us know more about ourselves and more proud to be a member of the community
Hello po may i ask if sino po ang nakakita na si rizal ay nalibing sa paco cemetery and hindi sya nakalagay sa mismong day ng pagkamatay nya ? Sana po mareplayan
Hi! Ang nakahanap po sa kanyang labi sa Paco cemetery ay si Narcisa. Nilibot nya ang mga sementeryo sa Maynila para maghanap at nagkataon daw na may nakita itong guwardya sibil na papaalis galing Paco cemetery. Sa loob ay may nakita siya na bagong hukay na libingan. Sinuhulan niya ang sepulturero para mailagay ang krus at marker sa puntod. Matapos mapaalis ang Philippine revolution, naipahukay nila ang labi ni Rizal at nakumpirma na siya nga ito dahil sa kanyang damit at sapatos na suot. May mga sulat pa daw ito na nakaipit sa kanyang sapatos at bulsa pero dahil sa pagkakabaon sa lupa ay hindi na ito mabasa.
I think its too late in a sense that it wouldn't matter nowadays whether he did it or not. I think the retraction does not change the fact that Rizal has a big contribution in the formation of nationalistic ideals.
Kindly explain and elaborate po this title "The conversion of doctor Jose Rizal and his own handwritten retraction of errors and profession of catholic faith" . It if its okay with you po sir. Thank you poo 😇🤍
Up until now I cant really make a decision because both sides presents a strong case. We really need to have the original retraction document resurface and be scrutinized using modern technology to make a sound conclusion and finally close the debate on this issue.
Sir, thank you sa detalyado po ninyong content pero may isa po akong tanong: Kung sakaling peke o gawa-gawa lang ang retraction letter ni Dr. Rizal ano po ang pinagtatakpan ng simbahang katoliko kung sa gayon?
Ayaw lang nila sa mga isiniwalat ni Rizal na gawain ng mga kastilang prayle. Sila ang tinutuligsa ni Rizal at hindi ang simbahan. Marami sa mga gawain nila ang pinakita sa 2 nobela ni Rizal at sa mga iba pang sinulat nito.
This is from the video description on its video counterpart References: Batis: Sources in Philippine History by Jose Victor Torres englishkyoto-seas.org/2019/12... nhcp.gov.ph/the-rizal-retract... varsitarian.net/news/20111004...
Good day sir. i know wala po sa topic ito but can i ask po which is more reliable author about the cry of rebellion. is it Valenzuela or Masangkay? we have our debate po 🥲
Hi! I think you might want to consider the statements of Nakpil and De Jesus. Yu may watch my video discussion about this one here ruclips.net/video/tQ-TxkljzyM/видео.html
@@profnextdoor21 i've watched the video already sir. And our side in the debate is the account of pio. We can't find any evidences po aside from his po. nawawalan na po kami ng hope para madefend yung side namin sir HAHAHA
Napaka galing niyo talaga Sir! Palagi akong nakakasagot sa mga tanong sa klase kasi lahat ng info nabibigay mo. Natututunan ko talaga lalo na mahilig ako mag advance study. Salamat sir, galing niyo po!
MAraming salamat po! Nakakataba ng puso na ako'y nakakatlong sa inyong pag-aaral. Enjoy learning our history! Please share this to your friends!
@@profnextdoor21 I already did po! This really help us saming class reports. Salamat po, more videos to make po!
who is here in 2024?
Thank you Sir! May debate kami sa Monday, ang side namin ay anti- Retraction. Pinanood ko muna yung Pro- retraction, sana mairaos namin 'to HAHHAHAHAHAHA. Salamat po sa mga video nyo natututo po ako😊
Maraming salamat sa panunuod. I wish you all the best with the debate. Just be confident and consistent and everything will follow 😉
Thank you sir part ito ng rereport ko
Very intriguing topic, kudos sir. Naalala ko sa class ni ma’am Rag Sak nagdebate kami about this fliptop style, it was so cringey (my performance)😅 btw so sad when I learned how Rizal was buried.
More power to your channel sir 😊
Thank you so much sa patuloy na pagsuporta!
Hi sir. May I ask if you could make a video on the updated list of the Presidents of the Republic of the Philippines and discuss them? It would mean so much. I really love your videos. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much and I hope that I would be able to do that soon!
Thank you very much and I hope that I would be able to do that soon!
Thank you sir for this very informative discussion ❤️ it helps a lot. But still I keep on questioning myself: Which among the accounts or analyses is considered the most convincing and reliable?
Hi! If you are looking for straight and "trabaho lang" account, go for the cuerpo de vigilancia statement.
baket po wala kayong caption ? ang hirap po kase minsang intindihin ng salita nyo po eh , sorry 😢 pero sobrang galing nyo po 👏🏻
Good day! I would like to ask for some references about this topics.
I think the references are posted in the description box on the Pro Retraction video. You may refer to it 😊
update po, ano na pong side ninyu? pro or anti?
this makes sense. sir, if u were the one to be asked po? what is your decision? let's say po na 'till now ay laman parin ito ng mga debates pero lahat naman po tayo ay may pinapanigan. this is not to invalidate po the other side, did rizal really retracted?
Sa ngayon I cannot really make a decision since for me, lacking pa rn ang evidence to prove or disprove. Although if we would base it s cuerpo report, may possibility tlga ng retraction.
@@profnextdoor21 thank u po sir
good afternoon po, pwede po bang makahingi nung analysis po ni rafael palma, need ko lang po kasi malaman yung date kung kailan po nila ginawa pati po kay pascual po tapos kay runes, thank you po.
Hi Sir! I really find this material very beneficial to our class. Can we have a copy of your materials regarding Rizal's burial? We need resources po kasi. Thank you so much po!
Aside from the pictures that I got from the internet, I only have a powerpoint of pictures I use n my class.
Hi sir, I really support your channel po. I am from private school but I really do spent some time watching your videos, mas natututo po ako sainyo kaysa sa Prof ko.. sir sana sa next video about po sa Treaty of paris 1898. Thank youuu
Thank you for the great support. I sincerely hope I can cover a lot of topics as many as possible. Please share my videos to others!
Annotation of Antonio de Morga's Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas naman po next hehe
Thank you! Hopefully we can do that in the future!
Hello sir, Thank you for this enlightenment it really helps a lot. If it's okay, can I ask the sources that you used in this video? because I badly need it po for our position paper. Thank you, sir
Hi! Check the video description for the reference links. Please share and subscribe!
Thank you so much sir!
Sir what is importance po of local history in the philippine history po?
Local history is very helpful in making history closer to us and relatable. Local history promotes the place or local town wherein people live thus helping us know more about ourselves and more proud to be a member of the community
@@profnextdoor21 Aww, thank you sir!
Welcome! Please subscribe and share!
hello po! mayroon po ba kayo ng original copy ni Rafael Palma? thank you po.
Sir ask lang po, is it 39years or 30 po?
Hello po may i ask if sino po ang nakakita na si rizal ay nalibing sa paco cemetery and hindi sya nakalagay sa mismong day ng pagkamatay nya ? Sana po mareplayan
Hi! Ang nakahanap po sa kanyang labi sa Paco cemetery ay si Narcisa. Nilibot nya ang mga sementeryo sa Maynila para maghanap at nagkataon daw na may nakita itong guwardya sibil na papaalis galing Paco cemetery. Sa loob ay may nakita siya na bagong hukay na libingan. Sinuhulan niya ang sepulturero para mailagay ang krus at marker sa puntod. Matapos mapaalis ang Philippine revolution, naipahukay nila ang labi ni Rizal at nakumpirma na siya nga ito dahil sa kanyang damit at sapatos na suot. May mga sulat pa daw ito na nakaipit sa kanyang sapatos at bulsa pero dahil sa pagkakabaon sa lupa ay hindi na ito mabasa.
Meron ka po ba Yung about sa retraction ni Dr.Rizal according po sa analysis ni Austin coated?
Hi, I have a copy of his analysis but wasn't able to include it in this video. My apologies.
Sana po maupload nyopo, para may basis po ako sa report namin this week. Thankyoupo❤️
@@marielledelacruz5079 maybe I can send a screenshot of the text thru email
Why is it too late to release Jose Rizal's retraction?
I think its too late in a sense that it wouldn't matter nowadays whether he did it or not. I think the retraction does not change the fact that Rizal has a big contribution in the formation of nationalistic ideals.
Hello po. Can I ask sir kung ano po Full name nyo? for my thesis lang po. Thank u 🤗
hello sir! pwede po mahingi yung copy po ng analysis ni Rafael Palma jan po sa retration ni Rizal? thank you po!
@@cjignacio9478 hi i only got these references by going to the library that offers hardcopy
Hi po pwede po maka hingi ng copy plss po eto po kasi yung topic namin for reporting any advice po@@profnextdoor21
Hello po sir. I have questions po, saan po kita pwedi e pm?
Your response is highly appreciated po.
Hello! You are free to post your questions here in the comment section 😊
Kindly explain and elaborate po this title "The conversion of doctor Jose Rizal and his own handwritten retraction of errors and profession of catholic faith" . It if its okay with you po sir.
Thank you poo 😇🤍
Hi may I know if this is a book or an article?
A book po.
Thank you for the uploaded videos prof! 🫶
Welcome! Please share and subscribe!
Yung pahayag din daw ni Trinidad Rizal
If rizal retracted , meron naman palang original text,Bakit po nawala ito for 39yewrs since rizal death?
That is also one of the questions raised by rafael palma. It was not shown to the public even to his family after his death.
Sir para sainyo poba, nag retract poba si Rizal o hindi?
Up until now I cant really make a decision because both sides presents a strong case. We really need to have the original retraction document resurface and be scrutinized using modern technology to make a sound conclusion and finally close the debate on this issue.
nagretract po ba si rizal o hindi?
Sir, pwede po ba mahingi sources nyo?
Hi! Kindly check the video description for the references. Thank you for watching!
Sir, thank you sa detalyado po ninyong content pero may isa po akong tanong:
Kung sakaling peke o gawa-gawa lang ang retraction letter ni Dr. Rizal ano po ang pinagtatakpan ng simbahang katoliko kung sa gayon?
Ayaw lang nila sa mga isiniwalat ni Rizal na gawain ng mga kastilang prayle. Sila ang tinutuligsa ni Rizal at hindi ang simbahan. Marami sa mga gawain nila ang pinakita sa 2 nobela ni Rizal at sa mga iba pang sinulat nito.
Can i have the source sir? Or your ppt po?
This is from the video description on its video counterpart
References:
Batis: Sources in Philippine History by Jose Victor Torres
englishkyoto-seas.org/2019/12...
nhcp.gov.ph/the-rizal-retract...
varsitarian.net/news/20111004...
Good day sir. i know wala po sa topic ito but can i ask po which is more reliable author about the cry of rebellion. is it Valenzuela or Masangkay? we have our debate po 🥲
Hi! I think you might want to consider the statements of Nakpil and De Jesus. Yu may watch my video discussion about this one here ruclips.net/video/tQ-TxkljzyM/видео.html
@@profnextdoor21 i've watched the video already sir. And our side in the debate is the account of pio. We can't find any evidences po aside from his po. nawawalan na po kami ng hope para madefend yung side namin sir HAHAHA