People complaining about demo lyrics 💀💀💀 he literally could be singing about a potato salad recipe the point of a demo is so you get an idea of the melody of the song
Fun fact: this song was originally meant for shinee but they ended up recording view instead, and f(x) recorded 4 walls but they were meant to record view.
These are professional writers writing to brief for Korea and knowing the lyrics will be changed. Provided they like the song and the title they'll take it no matter what they're singing about, sometimes you just make up lyrics that flow well to be quicker. As it doesn't matter anyway.
That was never an option because this song was composed for f(x) by LDN on SM's premises and Tay & Adrian happened to write and sing the guide. You can see in the picture the area they're in is Itaewon
if this didn’t become a kpop song and these guys kept it and released it as their own i bet it would be released as a single and eventually end up as a tiktok song
the fact that they do make their own tracks and its dope but ended up only used in teaser or somekind like that and its not related to the main track,or even the album lol XD
I think you got it wrong lol SM paid these people to write this beautiful song actually. They started it by making a demo of it so f(x) can easily sing along to it with their own korean lyrics ^^ Hopefully this clears up :)
sounds like it would play in H&M. Wow! So many Likes😳😳I am flattered!😍😍 And stupid RUclips didn't think abt noticing me of it but recommending me videos I am not interested.😑
[Unpopular Opinion] In this version the lyrics are telling a story and make sense. In the F(x) version it doesn’t make sense at all, they just wanted to sing this song in korean and peaked sentences that worked with the bass.
@@user-fp3hq6rl5g well not really...I mean at least in english they don't make so much sense and the mv? Aesthetic as heaven but not a clue about what they were trying to pass on to their viewers...
that doesn't apply tho only in kpop song translations. That goes as well with all the songs translated in another language. and also I hate to break it to you buddy but you'll hardly ever find a kpop song where the lyrics aren't bubbly and not meaningful.
Elissavet Argiriou i speak both languages, and honestly, I think they both make sense in their own way? The english og version does tell a direct story but the kor. Ver has more of an ambiguous element into it, hence, the aesthetic mv haha. I do agree that the kor. Has a lot of parts that seems to fill in the blanks (the eng parts).but hey, they both sound lit af.
The lyrics were just to direct the singers f(X) on how to they should sing it they just threw together some lyrics to show them how it should sound it is a demo
원래 가사는 사랑은 네 개의 벽에 갇힌거 같다고 해서 여자가 계속 남자한테 철벽쳐서 남자가 괴로워하는 내용이에요 ㅎㅎ 계속 나오는 'friend zone'이라는 가사가 여자가 계속 남자를 친구로 취급하는 것, 즉 철벽을 친다는 뜻이에요. 그건 그렇고 에프엑스 10주년인데 컴백 좀 하자....하....
Tay Jasper and Adrian are just physically unable to write bad songs! WayV's entire discography is basically made by them and that's probably one of the reasons why every single song of them is a bop lol
the instrumental sounds a lot lower and deeper than in the f(x) version, this is why i like it more, especially that more recognisable western house sounding synth at 2:00
데모랑 원곡이랑 느낌, 결이 다른데 너무 에펙 곡 깎아내리는 사람들이 많네.. 데모곡은 좀 더 팝적인 비트가 도드라지는 반면 에펙은 몽환적인 느낌 살리려고 창법도 공기 많이 섞고 맨 마지막 싸비 비트도 느낌을 더 가볍게 살려놨음 그니까 비교 그만하세요 약간 다른 장르니까
@official regina what sounds stupid is how black people aint getting recognition for handing over demos to our fave songs and still be discriminated against in Korea
@@Sesamsesam59 you people really must not know that most lyrics that get retranslated arent gonna make sense due to certain words we just dont have that korean does.
@@azvrias im half-korean and understand korean 100%... i can confirmed that f(x)'s 4 walls doesnt make any sense. I can say that im confused at first but thats kpop.. especially idols song, they just want to have singable/catchy song and literally put no effort on the lyric... but still, its a bop.. cant be mad at that lol
See it doesn't take to much before some feelings start to form Everything began so perfect wasn't tryna get involved but the way you looked at me girl I just knew you wanted more Oh you fooled me If I knew what I knew now (wouldn't ever loved ya) Girl ya heart so cold its blue Got a soul as black as night Lead me on, lead me on, let me loose Now these 4 walls Got me in a friend zone, friend zone Now these 4 walls Got me in a friend zone Taking a backseat to being your lover Gave you my heart girl you threw in the gutter So imma need answers Would've sworn we had something but you look at me like its nothing Oh you gone get repercussions, don't think that I'm bluffing Quit tryna put me in the friend zone, I thought we had something to stand on Girl look how you doing the mans wrong Took it personal I opened up you give me the cold shoulder Girl what was that for Always teasing me So special every time you had me over But tell me goodnight If I knew what I knew now (wouldn't ever loved ya) Girl ya heart so cold its blue Got a soul as black as night Lead me on, lead me on, let me loose Oh, dont do it some me girl You let me take you out You let me buy you things I never asked for much You turned your back on me Why go and change it up All of a suddenly Fuck that baby If I knew what I knew now (wouldn't ever loved ya) Girl ya heart so cold its blue (you so blue~) Got a soul as black as night Lead me on, lead me on, let me loose (let me loose) Now these 4 walls Got me in a friend zone, friend zone Now these 4 walls (our friend zone~~) Got me in a friend zone, friend zone
Sarodja Govindin regardless of it being a demo, it had the potential of becoming a hit in the us. let’s be honest, had they kept the rights to 4 walls, this song would have probably done well in the charts and with the overall pop culture of the us
ミルクティーMilkTea well, because thats not the content to the video... there are a lot of things i like about f(x)s version - the choreo, lunas vocals, and the lyrics make more sense. But we wont stop you from liking f(x)s version more either. Its all up to personal preference!
So many producers have no interest in releasing things for themselves. They enjoy the stability of a regularly paying job that doesn’t hinge on public approval of their personalities. They don’t have to worry about the lack of privacy and constant backlash that comes with fame. They simply enjoy making music and know they’re good at it and want to get paid for their work, they don’t want to go on exhausting world tours or be hypervisible public figures. Producing is an entirely different art form from performing. Just like there are people who would rather be music teachers than singers, there are people who would rather be producers than celebrities. Not everyone wants some big grand life in the public eye, many people just want a calm job they enjoy doing.
been here since fx 4 walls was released. there were rumour about this demo in twitter so i also listened alot around 2014.. currently this demo become popular again..
human The Demo is what the official song is based off of. So technically this is is the original song then it was picked up or sold to F(x). Just like how Sia writes music for other artist and she’ll make a demo as a guideline for the actual song so they can hear what it’s SUPPOSED to be.
This demo gave me another reason to love Adrian McKinnon and Tay Jasper. And seriously, did we need another? I love these guys! Thank you for contributing so much to kpop and SM music. There is till date no song in which Adrian has participated that I didn't like( most of them are my favourites) Shout-out to Umu from ReacttotheK for interviewing these guys and helping us to know about them!
I love the final version but I wish f(x) had kept more of the grittier/louder synths, especially at the end. The released version of "4 Walls" is just slightly too polished, but still one of my faves. Props to these guys for formulating a great demo!
damn, they managed to make such iconic song, and f(x) popularized it so much that this style even inspired other kpop songs such as GWSN - Puzzle Moon (and other gwsn song too, pinky star, red sun, and like it hot), ILLIT - Magnetic, AB6IX - Breathe
"Now these 4 walls..." I heard "nariz for walls" Nariz means nose in Spanish... anyone else heard that? it's ok if I'm the only one haha Thanks for sharing 😊
These guys shoulda kept the song. They would've made it big and become huge. Though, with a record this big it could easily overshadow them as artists. I can also see Justin Bieber releasing it with the lyrics tweaked here and there. Anyway, glad f(x) released it, but I would really like it if they ever released an English version. They did record the song in Japanese after all.... I'm sure it'd be a piece of cake for Krystal and Amber to write English lyrics.
Producers and songwriters probably make more (guaranteed) money by sending the song to a big company. It was a choice between them releasing the song on their own, as relatively unknown artists, and hoping it made it big; or giving it to SM so they could use it for an idol group with a guaranteed fanbase.
The song was never theirs as it happens. Composed at SM by LDN for f(x) and these guys (Tay & Adrian) wrote and sang the lyrics as a melody guide for f(x) :)
JuFro743 maybe something like “these four walls, got me feeling hollow hollow” or “learning how to let go let go” idfk, just anything but friend zone 😅
if this got mixed better & released i think this wouldve charted in the us 😭 like i could see this being popular alongside that rihanna and calvin harris song
This song is such a masterpiece, even as a demo. Feels like it would have been a hit with these guys and the right promotion, but I'm glad f(x) got it, being one of the most artistic kpop groups and probably the best one to handle it
I think the reason this demo sounds very lit is how nice and powerful the vocals flow ,f(x) version is addictive in its own right too with the soothing female vocals and enchanting forest vibes
Hate to admit it but I like this better than f(x) version. 😭 like there’s just this vibe they give to it. Black people really have influenced so much of kpop.
![[Full Album] aespa (에스파) - SYNK : PARALLEL LINE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6vfDbDW_TeI/mqdefault.jpg)
People complaining about demo lyrics 💀💀💀 he literally could be singing about a potato salad recipe the point of a demo is so you get an idea of the melody of the song
FlufftonTail lmao I’m just saying!
omg ahahaha
Love is 4 walls
Mayo in the veg bowl, veg bowl...
Ché Lives exactly it’s not like they going release like that
yea you’re 100% right lol some people really don’t know what a demo is
Fun fact: this song was originally meant for shinee but they ended up recording view instead, and f(x) recorded 4 walls but they were meant to record view.
wow i literally had Shinee vibes while watching this
C A lmao i cant imagine fx singing view. even just dancing to it seems weird
View and 4 walls sound alike🧐 so it’s really just the same
Yeah both view and 4walls have that up tempo cool club sound
I read that Jonghyun composed View, so he made it for F(x)?
I CANT BELIEVE 4WALLS WAS A FRIEND ZONE SONG I'M YODELING
It's not though
What do you mean "was"?
Overcooked Eggs With Worms this song is the demo, it's about being friendzoned
ALL OF US ARE ROLLING ON THE FLOOR
라이언 Lmfao listen to the lyrics
이 사진 웃긴게 간지나는 행님덜이 뉴욕에 있는 스튜디오에서 데모따고 스튜디오 건물 앞에서 찍은 듯 한 사진인데 그냥 대원치과 건너편임ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
외국인줄 알았는데 대원치과보고 현웃ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아씨 지금보니까 정가운데에 있는거 더페이스샵이네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 나 네스카페만 보고 ㄹㅇ 외국인줄 알았는데 아니넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅁㅊ 당연히 외국인줄 ㅜㅜ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
대원치과 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
if this dude didnt get friendzoned we wont b enjoying this song rn so thank god u got friendzoned bruh u made a masterpiece
omg im laughing so hard
😂😂😂😂
L O L
best comment here 👏
i'm like TT JAJAJAAJAJAJAJA
I would have never expected the demo to be a bitter boy singing about the friendzone
LOOOL
lol same XD
loooool
These are professional writers writing to brief for Korea and knowing the lyrics will be changed. Provided they like the song and the title they'll take it no matter what they're singing about, sometimes you just make up lyrics that flow well to be quicker. As it doesn't matter anyway.
+Boss Man for real! hahaha
This is low-key lit.
Il Veritiere Anonimo I think you meant high-key*
Il Veritiere Anonimo High key
highkey lmao
Il Veritiere Anonimo high-key
* Very high key for me.
stop saying this is better than the original. it IS the original
Oooooof
for once , comments like this actually make sense
Literally
sirens that wish they were mesmerizing I was going to write this :v
@Just a Sana Fanboy technically it is lmao
If this was released in America it will be huge am sure
They should do kpop type songs merged with American pop and r&b in the west with western artists
Elizabeth that’s such a clever idea! kpop would then go worldwide and the popularity of it would be crazy.
Nah...
nah it wouldn’t be huge but it’ll probably get some popularity
@em ! no it's their fourth album
If they kept the rights to this song, it would definitely be a hit on the US charts!
so true
agree
That was never an option because this song was composed for f(x) by LDN on SM's premises and Tay & Adrian happened to write and sing the guide. You can see in the picture the area they're in is Itaewon
Ratchet _King are you the guy singing?
it probably would'nt alot of UK artist don't make it big unfortunately
if this didn’t become a kpop song and these guys kept it and released it as their own i bet it would be released as a single and eventually end up as a tiktok song
lmao true tho, i can imagine this song becomes a popular tiktok song
Noooo not tiktok 😭😭
Oh no💀💀💀
This demo is awesome, loving the sick beat
LMAO PLS NOT TIKTOK LOL
too good for a demo holy...
Fr
I love F(x) but this is lit
Agreed!
What's the "but" suppose to mean tho lol
Just Law Facts!!!! I know like i love the f(x) version but the demo is so much better!!! Like im soo hyped
@@nataliawallace6687 i agree
Agree this is lit af
Im still laughing because of that friend zone 😂
SAME
krysicalli so strange to hear,isnt it? hahah
SAME😂😂 i started laughing
SAMEE 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
대원치과 ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 무슨 뉴욕인줄알았는데
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ존나 웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 뒤에 배경 ㅋㅋㅁㅊㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Charming Park ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 저 지금 알았음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 더페이스샵이랑 대원치과 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 님 댓 안봤으면 계속 뉴욕이나 뭐 그런곳인줄ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋ
정보: 지금 보이는 배경은 뉴욕 맨해튼이 아니라 이태원역 4번출구 앞이다
킹원갓과...
obvi 🙄 everyone can see the signs in korean over there tf
@re1ribution they arent being rude they are literally just stating where its at babes
@luv4.sadiee and i was stating everyone already knew "babes" 😘
@re1ribution not everybody knew why are you assuming BABES 😘
this sounds great in english OMG these guys are great
it sucks that sm doesnt produce their own tracks, but im not gonna lie, they always choose the best demos to use for their artists xD
the fact that they do make their own tracks and its dope but ended up only used in teaser or somekind like that and its not related to the main track,or even the album lol XD
right
like the track in the teaser for SNSD's "You Think".... i'm still salty about that not being a full song.
I think only Lead Tracks the other tracks some are of the artist like Amber she have wrote many F(x) song's
I think you got it wrong lol SM paid these people to write this beautiful song actually. They started it by making a demo of it so f(x) can easily sing along to it with their own korean lyrics ^^ Hopefully this clears up :)
sounds like it would play in H&M.
Wow! So many Likes😳😳I am flattered!😍😍
And stupid RUclips didn't think abt noticing me of it but recommending me videos I am not interested.😑
Or ZARA
Yes
Wow i can smell clothes
Lolol ikr this and the beat to dualipa's 'one kiss' are always being played in the H&m store where I live
I'm crying I work at H&M and that's so accurate 🤧😂😂😂😂😂😂
kpop wouldnt be where it is now without their black creatives
yes
don’t point out 😹🙈
@@somegrill7561 'tis true
true
exactly?? 😭
2015 NAH
2016 NAH
2017NAH
2018 NAH
2019 RUclips: LET'S PUT IT IN HER RECOMMENDATION
Kim Bora same. It only showed up now
😭ʙᴜᴛ ᴀᴛ ʟᴇᴀsᴛ ɪᴛ sʜᴏᴡᴇᴅ ᴜᴘ ʟᴏʟ😂👍💟
Kim Bora OMG LITERALLY
The same! 😭
Better late than never I guess lol
Same here
Amber sounds a lil different here doesn’t she
Park Hye Ah
*would you like to get wooooshed?*
@@adosouma JDHFKDJNSNSVSMSB
annyeonghaseyo bitches HAHA LOL
Park Hye Ah this was just a joke LOL 😐
Lmao
와 이 버전도 너무너무너무 좋다... 이거 들으니까 진짜 에프엑스가 가사를 정말 잘 골랐다고 생각함 가사 별로였으면 이 버전이 훨씬 나았을지도...
한줌거리 마자여 포월즈 가사너무이뿜 ㅠㅠㅠ
받고 크리스탈 럽!! 하는부분 추가요~
1:00 fx도 몽환적이고 작사 잘한걸로 유명한 건 알겠는데 이건 진짜 레전드임. 이 이후론 데모곡이 원곡을 찢어버림. 렙 ㅈ되네...
이런 비트로 랩 들어간 곡 또 없나요ㅜㅠ
The rap in this version sounds better
true
zynbw so true
zynbw everything sounds better in this version
zynbw I WANT *AMBER* TO RAP THISSSSSSS
This song needs a mash up with 4walls
dont tell anyone but i've been listening to this more than the f(x) version
we all have
It be like that
as a f(x) stan.. somehow i relate 😌😌 the demo slaps
Alot of us have, had this in my playlist for over a year and my Fx one hasn't been listened to as much as this one has
i’m gonna tell everyone
데모 들으니까 4walls가 갓곡이 된 데에는 진짜 가사가 한 몫 했다는 게 더 와닿네... 한 편의 시 같은 가사가 포월즈의 몽환적인 분위기를 확 끌어올린듯... 레벨 킹덤검이랑 같은 작사가라는 게 진짜 대박이다. 외쳐 갓스란!!!
[Unpopular Opinion] In this version the lyrics are telling a story and make sense. In the F(x) version it doesn’t make sense at all, they just wanted to sing this song in korean and peaked sentences that worked with the bass.
I know right? I thought I was just dump af
읭 그건 님이 한국어를 잘 이해못해서 그런거 아닐까...에프엑스 버젼 가사가 더 예쁜것같은데
@@user-fp3hq6rl5g well not really...I mean at least in english they don't make so much sense and the mv? Aesthetic as heaven but not a clue about what they were trying to pass on to their viewers...
that doesn't apply tho only in kpop song translations. That goes as well with all the songs translated in another language. and also I hate to break it to you buddy but you'll hardly ever find a kpop song where the lyrics aren't bubbly and not meaningful.
Elissavet Argiriou i speak both languages, and honestly, I think they both make sense in their own way? The english og version does tell a direct story but the kor. Ver has more of an ambiguous element into it, hence, the aesthetic mv haha. I do agree that the kor. Has a lot of parts that seems to fill in the blanks (the eng parts).but hey, they both sound lit af.
"stop trying to put me in the friendzone" 😂😂
Lol I love that f(x) made the song much more serious. Like their version is pure poetry.
lol. ikr? But could you picture them singing, 'The 4 woa ~ woall~~ Got me in a friend zone~' XD
to each their own. in korean its cheesy
exactly.. the English version is cheesy to us but the Korean version is cheesy to Koreans so..
The lyrics were just to direct the singers f(X) on how to they should sing it they just threw together some lyrics to show them how it should sound it is a demo
I know right there's an apparent theme going on and F(x)'s is really ambiguous (for me xD)
So many black writers behind the kpop industry. Our influence is everywhere.
Music Producers not writers*
@@sabrina1380m there are some writers
@@sabrina1380m nope its both and that doesn't change the influence
Yaaaas.
Yeah. Blacks made pop music. But most of Kpop songs are written by Koreans.
Black excellence.
georgea amen
nice avatar
sima likewise.
A TRUTH
Kaito Because black excellence
원래 가사는 사랑은 네 개의 벽에 갇힌거 같다고 해서 여자가 계속 남자한테 철벽쳐서 남자가 괴로워하는 내용이에요 ㅎㅎ 계속 나오는 'friend zone'이라는 가사가 여자가 계속 남자를 친구로 취급하는 것, 즉 철벽을 친다는 뜻이에요. 그건 그렇고 에프엑스 10주년인데 컴백 좀 하자....하....
friendzone = 어장관리 ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
Tay Jasper and Adrian are just physically unable to write bad songs! WayV's entire discography is basically made by them and that's probably one of the reasons why every single song of them is a bop lol
THE WAY I JUST FOUND OUT ABOUT THIS OMFG- THAY MAKES SO MUCH SENSE
THAT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE WTF,, i was wondering how sm treated them like crap yet their discography was so good?
@@worldwidefunnyguy Oh that's 50/50- good songwriting and them just being ridiculously talented and hard working with amazing chemistry
사진 외국인줄 알았는데 대문짝만하게 써져있는 대원치과..
한인타운 가면 저런 한글 간판이 많아요
@@귀엽지-v8k 이태원 대원치과 아닌가여
이태원역 사거리 쪽인디 사진은 해밀턴 호텔 맞은편이고
ㅇㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋ진짜네
와 sm은 가이드곡이 좋다는 소리듣고 왔는데..미쳤네; 온전히 팝일때가 훨씬 곡이 사네ㅜ 한국어버전으로 들었을때도 되게 좋다고 생각은 했는데..가이드가 넘사수준인데 이정도면
역시 가이드가 답이다..!
가이드도 죽여버리는 k-pop 패치
아이돌은 아이돌인듯 확실히 노래잘부르는사람이 불러야함
런데빌런 케샤버전도 들어보면 오짐
@@IncognitoOnezz 런데빌런은 애초에 케샤노래를 소시가 커버?한거아님?
난 완벽한 이 영상의 커버 중앙에 당당히 자리한 대원 치과가 너무 웃김.........
I can't wait to be frienzoned and sing that line 2:59 xD
Am dead 😂😂😂😭👌
This song makes me happy to be friendzoned
the instrumental sounds a lot lower and deeper than in the f(x) version, this is why i like it more, especially that more recognisable western house sounding synth at 2:00
Hey, love your pfp
I LUVV THAT PART
OMG SPOOKED RUclips WHAT U DOING HERE
@@ratoestelar1286 i have become devout kpop fan and listen to as many kpop artists as i can
@@SpookedYT truly admirable.
와,.,,,데모개오진다진짜.,...그냥 이대로나왔으면 지금까지 길거리에서 들렸을듯
데모가 뭔가 느낌이 진짜오짐...
약간 2002년 월드컵 주제곡 같음
숩 이게 주제곡이면 소울민국아니냐..
숩 그건아님ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이렇게 세련된 곡이 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이게데모?...와..
i dont know about yall but i be throwin my ass in a circle to this version
karla hernandez OML I'M CRYING RIGHT NOW XDDD
😂😂😂😂 yes
Same 😂😂😂
fat facts
fax no printer
데모랑 원곡이랑 느낌, 결이 다른데 너무 에펙 곡 깎아내리는 사람들이 많네.. 데모곡은 좀 더 팝적인 비트가 도드라지는 반면 에펙은 몽환적인 느낌 살리려고 창법도 공기 많이 섞고 맨 마지막 싸비 비트도 느낌을 더 가볍게 살려놨음 그니까 비교 그만하세요 약간 다른 장르니까
마자요 ㅠㅠ 함수도 좋구 데모도 좋아요
데모가 훨씬 퀄 좋음 이거 듣고 함수꺼 들으니까 애들 학예회 노래 듣는듯
맞아요 그냥 결이 다르지 데모가 함수 곡보다 퀼이 좋다는 표현은 대체 뭔지 ㅋㅋ
김신욱 진킴 이 두 댓글 아주 난독증들이 왔구나;; 결이 달라서 비교 대상이 아니라는 말에 또 좋네 어쩌네 되도 않을 평가질 하고 앉았네 거기에 좋아요 박은놈들은 또 뭐야? 그냥 에펙 곡 깎아내리고 싶으면 제대로 말을 할 것이지 으유,,
비교 대상이 왜 아님? 같은 곡을 다르게 불렀으니 충분히 비교할 수 있는거 아니냐?
1:00부터는 랩 보컬 원곡보다 더 좋다 …
Honestly LDN Noise have made some of my favourite songs
SM's EDM obsession is lowkey the best part of Kpop rn
Black people been making kpop cool since the 90s
official regina What does that mean?
official regina It’s your opinion but honestly I think it sounds better then the F(x) version
official regina why tf are you here then 😪 hypocrisy
@official regina what sounds stupid is how black people aint getting recognition for handing over demos to our fave songs and still be discriminated against in Korea
official regina I got news for you : you’re racially insensitive and we don’t need people like you in 2020
This version is more legit and logical than f(x) version lol....
Its because its lyric is english?
@@frost3193 no bc now these 4 walls got me in the friend zone literally means something. Love is 4 walls an interesting maze* doesnt mean shit
@@Sesamsesam59 you people really must not know that most lyrics that get retranslated arent gonna make sense due to certain words we just dont have that korean does.
@@azvrias im half-korean and understand korean 100%... i can confirmed that f(x)'s 4 walls doesnt make any sense. I can say that im confused at first but thats kpop.. especially idols song, they just want to have singable/catchy song and literally put no effort on the lyric... but still, its a bop.. cant be mad at that lol
@@azvrias lmao no the Korean lyrics are just lazy writing. They just wrote what rhymes with the beat in Korean but I really can't blame them
1:16 omg his voice is beautiful af!
Frr 😩
vocal smoothing
I’m mad this isn’t the official song that I could buy cause I would bop every day of my life
But I’d buy it to support them...
Me too!
Me too
then go stream 4 walls by f(x) tf
its not the same??
@@uncannylongarms
비트가 너무너무너무 좋아서 영어나 한국어나 다 너무 좋아... 스엠이 곡 하나 잘뽑는건 인정한다!!!
OMG!! This is liiiiit!
처절함이 느껴지는 원가사..ㅋㅋ 하지만 가려지지 않는 몽환을 끄집어내서 극몽환으로 간 작사가 대단..
See it doesn't take to much before
some feelings start to form
Everything began so perfect
wasn't tryna get involved
but the way you looked at me
girl I just knew you wanted more
Oh you fooled me
If I knew what I knew now
(wouldn't ever loved ya)
Girl ya heart so cold its blue
Got a soul as black as night
Lead me on,
lead me on,
let me loose
Now these 4 walls
Got me in a friend zone, friend zone
Now these 4 walls
Got me in a friend zone
Taking a backseat to being your lover
Gave you my heart girl
you threw in the gutter
So imma need answers
Would've sworn we had something but
you look at me like its nothing
Oh you gone get repercussions,
don't think that I'm bluffing
Quit tryna put me in the friend zone,
I thought we had something to stand on
Girl look how you doing the mans wrong
Took it personal
I opened up you give
me the cold shoulder
Girl what was that for
Always teasing me
So special every time you had me over
But tell me goodnight
If I knew what I knew now
(wouldn't ever loved ya)
Girl ya heart so cold its blue
Got a soul as black as night
Lead me on,
lead me on,
let me loose
Oh, dont do it some me girl
You let me take you out
You let me buy you things
I never asked for much
You turned your back on me
Why go and change it up
All of a suddenly
Fuck that baby
If I knew what I knew now
(wouldn't ever loved ya)
Girl ya heart so cold its blue
(you so blue~)
Got a soul as black as night
Lead me on,
lead me on,
let me loose
(let me loose)
Now these 4 walls
Got me in a friend zone, friend zone
Now these 4 walls
(our friend zone~~)
Got me in a friend zone, friend zone
You need to get on top so I don’t have to scroll through all of these comments to find you bro😔
Thx for the lyrics
Thnx man.i thought they were singing about nut is in the walls.
its in the description my guy
The lyrics r in the description too
finally I found my life's original soundtrack
Rizky Ayu Ryani Putri lmao
OMG MEEEEEE
this is not the original lyics
DUDE THIS LIT AMAGAD IM FREAKIN OUTT
RIIGHHTTT
NOW THESE FOUR WAWAWAWALLS GOT ME IN THE FRIENDZONE FRIENDZONEEE
This picture is so nice too, whenever I see it I get happy because it looks nostalgic for some reason🔥
i can’t be the only one thinking this is better than the f(x) version
This is the original
@@kleeblatt06 no this is the DEMO
@@bellabababooey1276 a demo is the original because it is the first version of a song.
Laila Diamond This is the alternate the F(x) version is the original
@@sayuri1003 no the demo is the original song
this is SO good why didn’t they just release it themselves
cause its a demo?
Sarodja Govindin regardless of it being a demo, it had the potential of becoming a hit in the us. let’s be honest, had they kept the rights to 4 walls, this song would have probably done well in the charts and with the overall pop culture of the us
ミルクティーMilkTea well, because thats not the content to the video... there are a lot of things i like about f(x)s version - the choreo, lunas vocals, and the lyrics make more sense. But we wont stop you from liking f(x)s version more either. Its all up to personal preference!
Because their Producer simple as that
So many producers have no interest in releasing things for themselves. They enjoy the stability of a regularly paying job that doesn’t hinge on public approval of their personalities. They don’t have to worry about the lack of privacy and constant backlash that comes with fame. They simply enjoy making music and know they’re good at it and want to get paid for their work, they don’t want to go on exhausting world tours or be hypervisible public figures. Producing is an entirely different art form from performing. Just like there are people who would rather be music teachers than singers, there are people who would rather be producers than celebrities.
Not everyone wants some big grand life in the public eye, many people just want a calm job they enjoy doing.
can SM get these guys to write SuperM's songs?
PERIODT!!!!
Lol they already have I think, they are the same people who made Jopping
They made "Jopping" which is a bop!!
Yup! They wrote Jopping. In fact, Adrian wrote all my favourite parts-the harmonic parts and the bridge. I am a fan of his work.
they wrote jopping and a different song too
I want to know singer's name! 😄😄😄 This version is so good! 👍👍👍
+Phuong Anh Nguyen Tay Jasper & Adrian
+Phuong Anh Nguyen WOOW yes this is my jam now omg...but am i the only one who laughs when he say friendzooone hahahaha
+luch hau yes when I hear "friend zone" it sounds like a parody but it's a good version
that version is the original one
singers
Is it bad that I like the original better than fx 4 walls...?
Grandpa Min than*
Grandpa Min same
YESSS!
Almost as bad as your grammar
Sameeeeeeeee
IF I KNEW WHAT I KNEW NOW 🗣🗣🗣‼‼‼
GIRL YOUR HEART SO COLD ITS BLUE😫😫🔊🔊
GOT A SOUL AS BLACK AS NIGHT 🗣️🗣️🗣️!!!!!
LEAD ME ON, LEAD ME ON, LET ME LOOSE😣🗣️‼️‼️
NOW THESE 4 WALL-WALL-WALL WALLS 🗣️
@@arthurrodrigues6294 GOT ME IN THE FRIENDZONE, FRIENDZONE 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🎶🎶🎶
been here since fx 4 walls was released. there were rumour about this demo in twitter so i also listened alot around 2014.. currently this demo become popular again..
한국어 가사가 너무 예뻐서 가이드 버전도 좋지만 에프엑스 버전도 좋은듯..
업타운 펑크 까놓고 이건 또 찰떡같이 잘 사서 에프엑스 버전으로 재탄생 시켰네 하긴 데모가 이 정도면 나같아도 안 살 수가 없을듯ㅋㅋㅋ에프엑스 버전으로 다듬은 것도 그런게 작사가가 존나 대단
진짜 소울은 무시 못하네 아직도 듣는다..
This is a jam, seriously. Their voices are so nice to listen to and the lyrics are very direct, something I really like about songs.
Kinda better than original not gonna lie still love the original tho
it's the original demos are bases of songs
Demos are THE ORIGINALS mk good
I agree this is better
Dulce DIY no. This is a DEMO. The official song is 4 walls by fx.
human The Demo is what the official song is based off of. So technically this is is the original song then it was picked up or sold to F(x). Just like how Sia writes music for other artist and she’ll make a demo as a guideline for the actual song so they can hear what it’s SUPPOSED to be.
I love f(x) but bro… this demo hits wayy different I’m obsessed
This demo gave me another reason to love Adrian McKinnon and Tay Jasper. And seriously, did we need another? I love these guys! Thank you for contributing so much to kpop and SM music. There is till date no song in which Adrian has participated that I didn't like( most of them are my favourites) Shout-out to Umu from ReacttotheK for interviewing these guys and helping us to know about them!
those guys are awesome they 100% will make a fire ass track together no matter what
저 사진 뒷배경이 한국인거 삼 년만에 알았다 미친 대원치과
헐 나 계속 배경 외국인 줄 알고 들었는데ㅁㅊ 오늘 첨 알았다
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ이태원임 저기
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋ
이태원ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
뭔가 뜬금없긴함ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
i always knew there was something British about this song
1 Bang it’s the EDM vibes
the biscuits in the MV
lol
2:02 thats a sample. That pluck synth is a sample and i cant tell from where. Its on the tip of my tongue.
omg yes
@@booooostaaaaa-h5j Robin S - Show Me Love [1993]
I love the final version but I wish f(x) had kept more of the grittier/louder synths, especially at the end. The released version of "4 Walls" is just slightly too polished, but still one of my faves. Props to these guys for formulating a great demo!
damn, they managed to make such iconic song, and f(x) popularized it so much that this style even inspired other kpop songs such as GWSN - Puzzle Moon (and other gwsn song too, pinky star, red sun, and like it hot), ILLIT - Magnetic, AB6IX - Breathe
popularized garage and dnb?
@@akadxniel in kpop? yeah this and view by shinee were the first deep house kpop tracks and made it insanely popular
damn i love gwsn's music they got me house-style music
@@akadxniel 4 Walls and View are the reasons why Garage and DnB are popular in Kpop lmao
@@knightenchanter7908lmao y’all are delusional. They did not have impact
"Now these 4 walls..." I heard "nariz for walls" Nariz means nose in Spanish... anyone else heard that? it's ok if I'm the only one haha
Thanks for sharing 😊
SAME
i didn't hear it until i read this comment now i cant unhear it 😫
same here hahaha xDD
I didn't hear it until you said it lol
Me too haha i'm brazilian so its the same word in portuguese
These guys shoulda kept the song. They would've made it big and become huge. Though, with a record this big it could easily overshadow them as artists. I can also see Justin Bieber releasing it with the lyrics tweaked here and there. Anyway, glad f(x) released it, but I would really like it if they ever released an English version. They did record the song in Japanese after all.... I'm sure it'd be a piece of cake for Krystal and Amber to write English lyrics.
the song isn't theirs though. LDN composed it for f(x) and then had them write some lyrics for the melody guide
Producers and songwriters probably make more (guaranteed) money by sending the song to a big company.
It was a choice between them releasing the song on their own, as relatively unknown artists, and hoping it made it big; or giving it to SM so they could use it for an idol group with a guaranteed fanbase.
laracroftvideos They're probably making a lot more money through some form of royalties. Releasing on their own would've been risky.
데모가 이렇게 넘사벽으로 좋은 곡은 처음이네. 딱 내 취향이다
still can’t get over how good this demo is omg
i actual wished that they kept this song to thereselfs :c its suits there voices alot.
The song was never theirs as it happens. Composed at SM by LDN for f(x) and these guys (Tay & Adrian) wrote and sang the lyrics as a melody guide for f(x) :)
I like this version better because of their voices and their attitude :D
솔직히 .. fx 버전도 좋은데 이버전은 훨씬 좋음..
never delete please, I love F(x) don't get me wrong but it's nice to hear the English version, once in a while.
sm은 항상 가이드 버전들 좋은거같음 하지만 에펙스 포월즈가 충격적으로 좋았기때문에 아쉬운 마음 1도 안들어...
ㄹㅇ인 듯... 레드벨벳도 데모 버전이 훨씬 좋음
ㅈㄴ아쉬운데
지리네 이 가이드곡 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
굳이 남 의견에 딴지는 왜 거냐 취존 좀 해라..;
후스온 으이구 고집은
if it didn't say "friend zone" and instead had a more clever phrase there, this would be amazing. It's really well done.
I hate the word friend zone like dude you got rejected like just called it that
JuFro743 maybe something like “these four walls, got me feeling hollow hollow” or “learning how to let go let go” idfk, just anything but friend zone 😅
I think is because she said something like “Sorry, just friends” or something like that idk, but well the song is really good
I heard it as 'Prison' wtf 😳
Y'all don't get it
This would of been a hit in America if they kept the rights to the song. Lol especially since electronic songs are getting really popular
This is an amazing demo and the singer’s range is incredible.
if this got mixed better & released i think this wouldve charted in the us 😭 like i could see this being popular alongside that rihanna and calvin harris song
둘 다 매력있는 노래. 몇년이 지나도 세련된 건 변하지 않는다
The demo is actually dope.
This song is such a masterpiece, even as a demo. Feels like it would have been a hit with these guys and the right promotion, but I'm glad f(x) got it, being one of the most artistic kpop groups and probably the best one to handle it
This is really good! I never really liked any of f(x)'s original demo songs but this is really good!!
샤월 미유인데 원래 샤이니가 4walls , 에프엑스가 View 부를 뻔 했다는 거 이제 알았음!! ㅠㅠㅠ 둘 다 딥하우스라 바꿔도 전혀 안 어색했을 듯 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 포월즈랑 뷰 덕분에 음악 취향 중심부에 자리 잡은 딥하우스,,,💕💕
this could easily be a #10 on hot 100 if were dropped today on their voices
it would be a huge flop.
@@uncannylongarmsyou have 9 comments on this video, go outside
@@uncannylongarmsthen compose there sis
@@uncannylongarmsracist SM stans. Whats new
@@uncannylongarmsgirl don't lie you know they sound just as good, if not better
와….. 아니 진짜 개좋다..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 4walls의 숨겨진 멜로디를 듣는 느낌..
I think the reason this demo sounds very lit is how nice and powerful the vocals flow ,f(x) version is addictive in its own right too with the soothing female vocals and enchanting forest vibes
Hate to admit it but I like this better than f(x) version. 😭 like there’s just this vibe they give to it. Black people really have influenced so much of kpop.
이 노래 만들어주셔서 감사합니다...개좋네
not me being 9 years late, but I just noticed the 4 in the logo is literally made of 4 rectangular walls😭
I actually really like this! After hearing this I went back and listened to a few of his songs and he's really good! Got a new fan :)