Is Sumo Deadlifting Cheating?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 окт 2024
- Help SUPPORT the channel by checking out:
Our Powerlifting Programs
➢calgarybarbell...
Our Apparel
➢www.calgarybar...
Our Website
➢www.calgarybar...
Our Sponsors
➢Use "KRABSHARK" for 5% off your supplement order!
eformulations.co/
➢Use THEKRABSHARK for 15% off obsidian ammonia!
hypedust.com/
Follow us on social media:
TWITCH
➢ / calgarybarbell
DISCORD
➢ / discord
INSTAGRAM
➢ / calgarybarbell
➢ / bryce_cbb
➢ / dillon_cbb
Want us to critique one of your lifts? READ BELOW
Submission guideline video
➢ • FREE POWERLIFTING FORM...
Email for lifting critique:
➢FORMCHECKFRIDAY@GMAIL.COM
How can it be wrong if it feels so right!?!
OmarIsuf eat butt, it's the "dark side"
Although Omar is memeing, it does feel very right
More power to the sumo 💪
But it looks wrong
@Jeeses99 I mean that it looks unpleasant
Do you tell your parents you pull sumo?
I’m working up the courage... 😕
Have you tried praying the sumo away?
Nick T 😆
Nick T I actually tried sending my kid to a conventional camp once and I found him pulling sumo 2 weeks after coming home
If sumo is respectable then put it in your resume.
love the extra burn with the metric system
throwing hella shade at the us
I mean, Canadurp is part of the civilized west!
@@taunokekkonen5733 are we really though?
🤣🤣
The metric was a burn?
Deadlifting is cheating altogether: have some proper range of motion and snatch that barbell right above your head! :D
Snatch is cheating, as you're using momentum and jumping under the bar for extra benefit. Be a man and do a combined deadlift + bicep curl + overhead press in one motion :)
VortechBand lmao bicep curl into a slow and control strict over headpress, then do some tricep extensions while the weight is up there for a few good reps before putting it back down.
@@MrInzombia after you tricep extend it, put it on your back and start squatting it
@@takodafreeman1668 after you done squatting, do some good mornings.
You better stop now
"he's super long and gangly and weird" hahah.... crease!!
Long time ago when I was in physics we went to a weight room and measured the Joules (energy) required in a lift and how it was affected by things like RoM. It'd be interesting to see something similar done to this test.
Work (in joules ) = force * distance.
So yes a sumo pull will require less energy than a conventional one of the same weight, since the barbell moves a shorter distance.
Energy requirement isn’t the limiting factor of lift though, but rather the maximum torque requirements at the joints involved. Sumo has been shown to require the same torque requirement as conventional.
@@finnconroy2668 energy is also torque*angle traveled. The angle traveled is less insumo, so less work
@@Grutzai
Yes but the amount of work done still isn’t what makes a lift harder.
so unless sumo requires less torque requirements at the joints, it isn’t easier.
@@finnconroy2668 Force is subjective because of lever actions.
Depending on where your fulcrum is, you can move the lever more or less, with the same force .
0------------^-------------1
0----^---------------------1
0---------------------^----1
If the fulcrum is close to the load, you'll move the load less distance.
If the fulcrum is close to the puller, you'll move the load more distance.
With the same amount of effort required.
I mean.. If it takes 10-15 cm from the rom regardless of the lifter and it has different leverages and joint angles, shouldn't it be considered a different movement?
true
so should benchers with a wide grip and a naturally large arch compete in a different fed?
Should lowbar be in a different fed?
If the ROM is different regardless of the lifter then they should just switch to sumo. Simple as that.
Yet some people dont, why?
Oh that's right because it's not like that for everybody you dumb fuck.
@@ZugZug99 jesus calm down
Liu Kang that's an empty opinion
Interesting, I got mad respect from my Bros who wouldn't lie and kiss my ass after I pulled 550 at 160 be...maybe speaking for yourself
Even though i exclusively do conv, i don't get why it would be cheating when the stance is legal in competition. It would be like saying a runner is cheating because he has longer legs. And if used for hypertrophy purposes it's just a matter of what muscles you want to work more, and hence doesn't apply.
no it's not like saying a runner is cheating because he has longer legs, like at all ; we never talked about physique, but technique
Im merely speaking in terms of utilizing an advantage.
you should be merely talking about technique, but you just were speaking about physique with your "runners with longer legs"
Considering that people often utilize on or the other(sumo vs conv), depending on their physique, then how are they not related?
I don't considerate this in that debate, I mean : in competition based debate
I don't understand why people hate on the sumo deadlift so much. For me personally, I'm 6 foot 4, arms are pretty short and my legs are long af. It feels more comfortable on my body to do sumo deadlifts. I can do conventional deadlifts, but not comfortably. The sumo deadlift is more technical in nature and I know guys that can conventional deadlift 495 but can't sumo deadlift 225 for reps. In the end, do what works for you! who tf cares if people say you're "cheating. Chances are they probably can't lift nearly as much as you can. Am I right?
My views on sumo are the same as much views on the contortionist bench press. It's legal in competition, but not so impressive for the observer.
as grand daddy Boris Sheiko would say, "it's an empty discussion, only weak people think sumo is cheating"
Or maybe people who see that more often than not a person will sumo more than they do conventional think sumo is cheating and it has nothing to do with them being weak
@Gore4ever FulciLives you sound like a weak lifter lol
Gore4ever FulciLives you should tell that to Ed Coan
Jordan You clearly don’t see the joke in that dudes comment
Jordan that Gore4Ever dude, the things he says are worded so ridiculously he’s 100% satire
You need to let the measuring tape hang to get an accurate result. In some cases, you measured at a steep angle like at 4:52
Sumo doesn't tax my back and allows me to fully use my legs, it's the only way to fully enjoy deadlifting for me without feeling like SHIT afterwards
Yeah but your literally killing your back! And your not getting as much of a pull!!!
4:55 Lmao he measured like 3cm away from where directly below the plate was
Yeah, that was some major parallax error.
If you use trigonometry that's not even a 0.5cm difference.
tan^-1(3/34)= 5.6 degrees
34cm*cos(5.6) ≃ 33.9cm
So 🤷♂️
Sumo is cheating in strongman competitions. Besides that, it's just another way to lift.
I would agree fully! It’s against the rules!
I dont think its cheating its just not allowed
Sebastian Tyler *facepalm* and the Darwin Award for Biggest Dunce goes to you, my good sir! Conglaturation! How does it feel to know you’re leading the way in human de-evolution?
Ryan Newton how is that human de-evolotion? sumo and "cheating" is a discussion. and I wasnt wrong, I just didn't comply to the way you want it. which is ignorant and arrogant.
Sebastian Tyler Go back and read your own comment first buddy. I said what I said because you clearly contradicted yourself in the statement that sumo “isn’t cheating, it’s just not allowed (in strongman)”. When referring to the legality of the subject in question, “cheating” and “not allowed” are synonymous. Hence, I made a (slightly) low ball joke about your stupidity being a part of the reason humans are “de-evolving”.
Congrats, you’re 0 for 2 on comments today. Better luck next time
I think sumo and conventional are 2 different lifts and shouldnt be compared. Change my mind.
Should high bar and low bar squats not be compared aswell? Both use very different muscle groups
@@atruescotsmanuth2481 i would say it would be more like comparing a front squat to a back squat
@@UltraWhale No its not. Nobody ever front squats more than they back squat. Its not gonna happen, whereas many people do in fact deadlift conventional more than sumo.
@@atruescotsmanuth2481 ye thats a good point tbh
I personally pull sumo deadlift and I don't think it gives me any advantage. The reason I do it, is because it anatomically suits me. Convensional makes my back feel pain and i do not feel comfortable with it. I think you should choose the one, you enjoy most. Only a group of people can lift both effectively and they probably can DL more in sumo, since it is more leg focused.
Just fix your form lmfao
So how do you explain more records being pulled by sumo than conventional? Because it’s shorter ROM, easier to recover from, and not a true hip hinge. Less core.
The list goes on and on.
@@rickywagner6990 what is heavier? Convencional WR or Sumo WR? Sumo allow some people, that are able to perform both styles, an advantage. But they are people, not even a small amount to be honest, that cannot pull differently. Bitching that it is cheating is just lame.
anatomically dumbass
But muh rounded thoracic narrow stance Konstantinovs record tho
Effin Bruce Krawfish.
I train both honestly, I've heard it said, that Sumo is a performance move whereas conventional is a developmental movement. My Sumo deadlift is about 40 lb higher than my conventional.
Sumo is also easier on the back, and works the quads and upper traps more.
That’s why I do sumo on 100+ only, I had a back injury so I use it so that I have less stress
@@shemshem9998 same. I'm also kind of small so it feels easiest for me. Sumo is usually easier for smaller people and conventional is easier for larger people.
Ok good for you to put your health first but they are 2 different movement.That means that you cant do the one instead or the other expecting to train your muscle groups the same way.Its that simply.
Sumo has way better carry over to squat, because i used to do both and when i began sumo my squat always went up fast and almost stalled when I went back to conventional. My glutes get hit hard with sumo, not the case with conventional either. If you love deadlifting - for some reason - do both... Like Jamal
@@Dr.WhetFarts deadlift is traditionally a back exercise.I dont get doing a variation of it to improve your legs.And sumo isnt even a great leg exercise.I mean better do Jefferson squats, barbell hack squat or wide stance squats.All of them engage the quad more than sumo.
So, you just prove it’s a different movement. Perhaps it should get its own category.
ever heard of mv0.5v^2=mgh in high school physics? what is the h I wonder.
Right
You know, back when weightlifters started squat snatching in the 50s and 60s the splitters never cried "cheating" because the rules don't say split (or squat). If you can lift more within the rule you win. Disagreeing about a legal win is called bad sportsmanship, as I understand it, and it isn't even up for debate except in their minds.
It is not the same thing. In weightlifting the bar still ends up at the same spot ROM isn't different just the way it gets there. Where as here Sumo has a shorter rom and as many people said just look at the IPF under 105kg how many pull sumo and how many pull conventional.
Victor Manin The range of motion of the first/second pull of a squat snatch is about 5cm shorter than the split. Everybody accepts the fact you need to pull the bar higher to get under it because the aft leg needs to go really far to reach final catch position and it takes a bit longer to get into position for the catch, so it needs to be higher. Because the range of motion from the floor to final position is the same (with the same lifter) doesn't mean the distance traveled was also the same...remember in WL the bar can change direction in a good lift and it does. Look at how much extra ROM there is when someone catches a clean too high and comes down 11cm to bottom before coming back up. You are certainly right about the comparison not being a terrific one about lifting mechanics; my comment is more about the fact the rules define what cheating is, not what technique is easiest for you. WLs also only started squatting (in competition) once the rules stopped specifying the grip width for the lift(1946) and squat snatching (with a wide grip) became a legal option: it was no longer 'cheating".
Going back further, classic snatches were not even allowed to touch the body.
I love it. The "sumo is cheating" crowd don't even lift, let's be honest.
Very articulate. Don’t go using all the big words you know at once.
Prob cause you can't pull sumo for shit. Am I right? You've tried and failed? Miserably?
what's with your homosexuality obsession? A little suspect if you ask me. Oh, and btw, I train both. So, all your failed attempts at sumo pulls have given you nightmares, ya? That's ok man, not everyone knows how to pull sumo. Don't beat yourself up.
You've gone and done it: used all the big words you know in one sentence. It's not a good look man. And I don't believe you deadlift weight, at all. But please! Please accept me, oh lord of the deadlift!
I don't care if you train for reps and pump lol I care if you can move weight, cause you're talking like you can. And you know Bryce has set records in both styles, ya? Have you set any records? I already know the answer to that....
bracing during lift is cheating, real lifters don't need to brace
Decreasing the ROM of a powerlift decreases the muscular involvement of the powerlift
Yes among many other things. But dont start arguing with these powerlifting junkies. You can see this guy doesn't have much longer in the game at this rate. He's already wearing himself down. Its his lower sciatic region now, but next will be his shoulder, etc...
I was arguing in favor of Sumo dumbass.
Mike Stoklasa You're the dumbass then.
Ethan Lewis Summo actually decreases range of motion. By spreading your legs apart like a stripper, youve already decreased the distance the bar has to travel by 3-4 inches
One thing you can do once you measure the difference is to lift with weights or blocks under the plates, raising the bar an equal amount to what you got by comparing both styles.
Imagine to lift conventional with the bar 16cm higher, it would definitely make it easier to lock the knees, but one thing has to be said about sumo, the force is not being applied in a straight line, but still, i would consider that the advantage in starting pulling position could make a bit of a difference, specially if the difference is that big.
I must say tho, the involvement of the muscles is totally different in each style, for which i believe they should be different lifts, but I'm just a nobody when it comes to powerlifting.
lol did Dillon just call himself "Big D" the whole video? I mean he edits these, right? Please say yes, that would be amazing
Yes, yes he did.
So if sumo is 'cheating' because of reduced rom, are short people cheating?
Sick vid. I reckon measuring hip and knee angle differences could also be cool for this experiment.
Honestly, it's not difficult to figure out the context of what people mean when they say that sumo is cheating; they're talking about how strength is regarded in the real world.
If you need to pick up an engine block or a chunk of concrete and move it somewhere, are you going to pick it up in a sumo position and waddle like a crab 20 meters across the shop? No, that would be the dumbest shit ever and you'll probably bust an abductor in the process. What would actually happen is that you would position yourself to get as much bend in the knees as possible and lift to a standing position so you can move the object in question, which is like a practical version of a conventional deadlift, since most heavy objects aren't bars.
It's two different lifts though, so not sure why people would compare them anyway. You don't compare conventional deadlift records with stiff legged deadlifts records, so why sumo and conventional?
If you were competing and you decided to pull stiff-legged, then you absolutely would be comparing the lifts. The difference is your training numbers vs max lifts in a meet. You wouldn’t consider your high bar PR equivalent with your low bar PR, but regardless of how you squat in a meet - it’s a squat.
@@calgarybarbell I see your point but I think if sumo is better (cheating) then why doesn’t everyone just deadlift sumo and then we can have a separate place for conventional I mean arching on bench makes sense, I’m talking about when powerlifters arch so much it pretty ridiculous when they arch so much it isn’t even really a rep but this just doesn’t make sense, if sumo is easier then pull sumo it’s not so bad to the point we’re it’s like not even a rep anymore as oppose to powerlifting bench’s
Cheating = of course not
More efficient = yes
I like conventional for hypertrophy and sumo for powerlifting. After all its all about moving maximal weight and as Chris Duffin said "I outlift guys that are stronger than me all the time". This is just my two cents, I like both (not trying to be diplomatic its just my experience). Love the video!
Easier = yes
Does range of motion actually matter? I think that measuring moment arms to the hip and back along the axes of their respective levers perpendicular to gravity in the start position (or wherever they're longest, if your knees drift back) would give you a much clearer picture of the differences for a sport of singles. We're not measuring mechanical work in powerlifting, we're measuring force output and torque.
This thought also sorta justifies the divide between powerlifting and strongman (also crossfit). If you're doing reps, range of motion matters a LOT, and strongman (also crossfit) frequently have max rep deadlifts as events. Powerlifters really shouldn't give a shit about ROM, since all that really matters is if you're producing enough force to keep the bar going at the mechanically weakest part of the range of motion, and sumo doesn't give you a favourable answer to that question.
I completely agree that a single measurement of N=2 lifters doesn’t give us even close to a full picture of anything really. The measurements were simply a curiosity for Dillon and I, and a decent talking point.
Senpai noticed me. :D Yeah, for sure an interesting start, especially given how close the percentage differences are. I'm afraid that just seeing ROM differences without any other analysis is more fuel for the "sumo is BS" crowd, though. :/
Nick Kastoris well, well, well.
Your comment has been reported. ROM is the end all and be all! Jk
Mr Cripples, in powerlifting, we measure a proxy for force output: pounds on a bar. Mechanical work matters a HUGE deal in training decisions, but the sport isn't about mechanical work. It's about pounds on a bar and whether or not you can move them within the constraints of the competitive movements. Distance is not a variable that you're scored on within the sport.
What about muscle recruitment? Might be a good topic to talk about and could tell us some interesting things like the difference in the muscle mass used in the performance.
I think pulling sumo is the deadlift equivalent of arching your back excessively on bench... there's no doubt it makes the movement easier in the sense that you're moving it less distance, but you also have a very different leverage that can work for or against you depending on your body type and training regimen. For example, I actually pull signigicantly less sumo than conventional despite less ROM. A possible solution would be categorizing conventional and sumo separately, but I think that would unnecessarily complicate things
This was a great video Mr Krawfish. Like the translation to cold numbers as opposed to opinions (which is great aswell, but this just gives a different feedback)
Is the “cheating” logic applied to narrow grip bench press vs wide grip bench press?
Nope narrower grip is harder cuz less pecs (big muscle) is engaged and more tricep is used (small muscle), guess it applies to everyone
I still respect conventional pullers more. It looks cooler and it requires more raw strength.
I dont know why, but my sumo dl isnt as strong as my conv dl. It feels really awkward deadlift in sumo stance for me. I think both has different cue and technique
Satya Pawitra Sumo isn’t easier for everyone. People with different leverages perform the one that they prefer personally. Anyone who says sumo is cheating just doesn’t understand how leverages work. Use the style that is most comfy for you 👍🏻
@@gabriellenicholls6712 wrong
Steffi Cohen’s range of motion is like 20cm. The bar is almost at her knees on the floor.
Not a powerlifter here but one version looks like it uses your back and the other looks like a wide stance squat , isn’t that two different lifts?
It's just a slightly different movement/option for people that might work for different builds. I know for sure that conventional is awkward as hell for me. Just can't reach my potential with that lifting technique.
I can't even physically get into conventional without lifting from blocks. My back is completely rounded at the start position with any weight. So sumo all the way.
How about we just have separate competitions for real dead lifts and competitions for short people that do sumo
Thank you for using metric measurements!
Big D’s conventional pull is my height.
Personally, my pr's are about the same for both, but I just feel more explosive when pulling conventional. My setup also feels significantly tighter.
If you don’t pull a deadlift the same way Eddie Hall does then it doesn’t count. The Beast is the deadlift master
Oh you mean with a whippy bar, straps, a deadlift suit, and hitching? Lol
It's not about how high the weight is at the peak of the rep, it's about how sharp the angles of your joints are and the torque applied to them. That's why you can lift more if the bar is at a higher starting height. In sumo, the angles are way more obtuse and there is less torque being applied so they are easier. I'm not saying they should be banned just different category than conventional. I personally do sumo because I have a long torso but also long femurs and it's much more ergonomic. But, yes, they are easier
Spoke the truth.
Two different lifts to me. If you say my Max deadlift is ___. I'd assume your are talking about your conventional. If your max on sumo is higher, which it probably is, you should say it's your sumo. They are different lifts because they stress different muscles. I have friends that prefer the sumo because they have had a back injury and it puts less stress on their lower backs.
I'm not a competition guy so I can't really comment on that. That's more of playing within the rules to be more effective.
Only differences one more quad dominant than hipfelxor dominant better quad and glute activation in shumo but some find shumo harder on heavier loads as people shot up legs to quick get nowere with lifting bar up and shumo can become bit of 2 part movement not a 1part like conventional
I want to preface this by saying that I agree with the core of your argument that sumo isn't "cheating and takes longer to master technically" and should be legal, especially on a stiff bar. However 2 data points does not a trend make and I think framing the discussion with such low hanging fruit wording like "is it cheating" takes away from the more nuanced observation that not all pulls are made equal, and people who point this out are often called haters. It definitely seems to make little difference on an Eleiko stiff bar which is stiffer and shorter, but imagine one of those 150-160lb guys we see pulling 6+ plates toes to plates on a deadlift bar. The range of motion after the slack is pulled is so small in that case (straps exaggerate this), that that sumo pull is in a different league entirely to the same guy pulling convy, especially since we know smaller guys almost always have to use a narrow convy stance, lengthening their convy ROM. In other words a 70kg guy pulling 260kg in that setup might struggle with 220 convy on a stiff bar. The difference in ROM there would be hooooge, and I'd like to see a measurement of the case described. TL:DR Yes sumo is and should be legal, especially on stiff bars, it's a much more technically demanding lift than convy, but i think the shorter/smaller you are the less you can say it's an equal lift to the convy. They're just different.
Oh we’re definitely not saying that our measurements mean anything. We know N=2 is not a statistically significant sample size. And the whole ‘is it cheating’ bit was just to open the conversation.
I just want to add that it really depends where are you stronger genetically. Somebody can actually be weaker on sumo how is that cheating....
Can someone answer me why have nearly all world record lifts been done conventional? If sumo is easier why dont those 6'6" giants pull sumo?
They don't answer you. Sumo is an advanced technique like front squat compared vs back squat. I know, PL is PL and that's ok, but in a non competitive scenario learning and doing sumo and front is far superior and safer. Really safer. And that's what is important.
Ah, chinup has more Rom then pullups, but they are easier. ROM means nothing.
Lower weight classes are using more sumo. When you are heavyweight than leverages are different and you lose mobility.
@@ivan_9386 people ask these questions because natural interest trends towards "WHAT IS THE BIGGEST NUMBER" for most people and they seem to forget that weight classes even exist or have records, so they just don't check
well that's easy.
1: Many records are in fact sumo, and every year a larger % of records are set sumo.
2: Sumo hasn't been populair for very long.
3: Sumo is banned in strongman, so you'll never see those guys do it.
Look at the percentage of lifters pulling sumo vs conventional at IPF worlds, especially all the weight classes up to 105kg/230lb.
Now answer this question "Is sumo easier for most of the population?" Spoiler alert: yes
Sure. I wouldn’t argue with you at all on that point.
How many IPF boiz and girls are max-width benchers? Same thing.
@@calgarybarbell So what do you think it is about Brett Gibbs that he seems to prefer, and do better pulling conventionally? I'm wondering if it's longer arms or short tibias or something, but I don't know, as I'm not an expert. Any thoughts?
Depends some people cannot do shumo well at heavier loads as it becomes more 2 part lift from after the bar gets past your shin going towards knee and regular restanceing after a rep some issues don't really come across on conventional
Thats the point.The arguement with sumo vs conventional isnt that sumo isnt a legit or good movement/exercise.The problem is that pulling sumo against conventional its not logical cause they 2 different movements.They hv different range of motion and the joints are on different angles.Meanimg that they use the muscle groups in different ways.Its like comparing you incline bench press with your dumbbell press.
4:54 it's even shorter since you didn't measure at a right angle
its cheating if you call it deadlifting. you must call it just 'sumo deadlift'. Like how you would call it 'behind the back deadlift" and not a "deadlift" that you did behind the back.
Hey Guys, nice vid on a still controversial topic.
I do Sumo, I am not great in Powerlifting, but i know a thing or two about mechanics.
If u just focus on lifting hight u r not geting the whole picture. u might ask a someone who can do physics or isn mechanical engineer and do another video considering the difference between "work" and "power". I dont want to go into detail but i think it can be another interessting followup-video for the upcoming hate against this pro-sumo-vid.
Furthermore u can consider the direction ur legs are pushing compared to conventional. Convy is more in line with gravity, sumo is less. U can feel the loss of force in the friction of your shoes to the ground (doesnt appear out of noware), which doesnt accure in convy.
just some nice things to think, talk and hate about :)
keep the work up guys
Thank you for using Metric system as rest of the world
If sumo is unfair then so is having short femurs
So far as I know, the specific rules and regulations for deadlift are simply to lift the weight off the ground the rules and regulations make no specific mention on stance or style as long as your feet don't go outside the circumference of the plates...in strongman competition I would like to believe sumo is not allowed but I'm not sure so feel free to correct me
Interested in how you'd feel about bench press where those ppl have that huge arch and barely move the bar a couple of inches if that. You can't tell me THATS not cheating...
Christopher Alvarez in DL bar plate width is the stopping factor. Can't put your feet past plates, right? In BP flexibility can be trained to achieve a sky high arch
I’ve had someone telling me that hook grip was cheating also
Then they have never tried it
I am 1.73 tall (hello from the rest of the world, hehehe) and with "normal" leverages and after some time I switched to sumo. Why? In conventional I just cannot place my back flat and brace properly, and I found that in sumo I get rock solid at the whole push/pull. Maybe I have hexbar every now and then, but not conventional for me. Sumo is safer for me. Period.
why isn't range of motion important in deadlifts if it is in squats? A quarter squat would not fly in a competition. so why should sumo be acceptable?
Because the range of motion is defined as “floor to lockout”. Which is anatomical in definition, just like “hip crease below the top of the knee”. If someone widens their stance in the squat, is that unacceptable because the absolute distance is shorter?
Calgary Barbell I’m not all that knowledgeable in this field nor will I pretend I am but man it does seem like the two should be in two completely different categories. I understand completely with what you replied and agree. It’s just in a competition that seeks out the “strongest” competitor and not the competitor that can most efficiently complete the motions required you’d think they’d look at that range of motion or lack of as a sneaky way to get a heads up over others.
I mean looking at the difference of the ROM between conventional and sumo most think that they have to be stronger at sumo. But they‘re missing that they need way more stability in the sumo deadlift then in the conventional deadlift. I believe that‘s the main reason some are not stronger in sumo than conventional (including me). Sorry if my grammar is a bit off and commas are missing everywhere but I‘m german and commas in english are hard af
Cody Sawyers
I agree, and therefore they should be competed seperately.
Cody Sawyers totally on your side. Everyone is allowed to pull sumo therefore there are no disadvantages for anyone. Same thing like with knee sleeves, belt, wrist wraps. You don‘t have to use them but you can. It‘s out of question to differ them.
Marwin Demisch theres actually a study on EMG activation on sumo and conventional and the only difference is more quad activation.
Correct me if I’m wrong… sumo works your back less by shifting focus to quads and glutes, it’s like adding another squat movement to the meet resulting in lifters with a strong lower body and shit upper body to dominate. If deadlifts were conventional only, winners would be more well rounded, stronger athletes
Sumo "vs" Conv is the age old question...its time for a new age; Sumo "&" Conv
Unless you are in worlds, get technically sound with both...imo
Great video as always!
It's interesting that your conventional rom was exactly the same as big d's sumo rom. Surely in this situation it can't be classed as cheating if all you're doing by pulling sumo is bringing the distance you have to move the weight in line with other competitors. Besides, I've never seen someone who benches with a wide grip be called a cheat because they're reducing their rom
Sumo isn't cheating...It's like seated military press vs standing. Ones harder and probably more accurately represents your press strength but we wouldn't say your cheating doing either
Uhmm. Terrible comparison. A standing military press is significantly harder than a seated military press. Based on this strength website. The intermediate seated military press is 158-160. The intermediate shoulder press or standing press is around 140-142. Compare the seating military press to the seating military press ONLY. Now, if you want my opinion on Sumo. It isn't cheating, but it does help guys with very good leverages. strengthlevel.com/
In the context that people say it? Yes,it is cheating. Thats why no one of the sumo haters is getting convinced that sumo isnt cheating just because the counter argument is "but its allowed to be used in comps". How you should be approaching this issue is telling people that the goal in competetive powerlifting is to demonstrate maximal strengh,not build it,at least not on stage. The conventional is better at building strength and its harder,but the sumo allows you to lift more and better show your maximal strengh,since the goal in powerlifting is to lift heavy ass weight.
If you want to judge overall strength look at strongmen competition. Oly/power is judging how strong you can be at three artificial lifts.
Yew Tewb powerlifting claims that it just wants to test maximal strengh output of the muscle fibers,which it does. However sumo and conventional recruit muscle fibers at very different points and angles. Powerlifting never claimed it was the most "functional"
ChallengingGravity I agree. It's synonymous to what I call the "contortionist bench press." Where the lift is more of a feat of flexibility rather than it is of pure strength.
J Ro most sumo lifters train a lot conventional and other variations in their off season. Look at Cailer Woolam or Dan Green.
"Errybody wanna be a bodybuilda! But ain't nobody wanna lift no heavy ass weight".
If two men are the same strength and have the same leverages, the one that pulls sumo will almost always deadlift more. It's not cheating because it's legal but it definitely is advantageous and that's undeniable.
If the movements are so different, they should be competed seperately.
The ROM is quite different, but I don’t think the movements are. Should wide grip/narrow grip bench be competed separately? What about wide stance vs narrow stance squats?
I think I'ma do conventional, deficit conventional (with and without bands), conventional off blocks (2"), sumo. And... ass-to-grass (ie. weightlifting) squats, 45 degree weighted hyperextensions, barbell rows, T-bar rows. That just about covers it all.
Sumo is to conventional as an ATG narrow-stance squat is to a wide-stance PL depth squat. Yeah, the distance the bar travels changes. Good point that it has nothing to do with "cheating."
Conventional is hard on the back and when some people start getting back issues they switch to Sumo. Some do Sumo since they think they won't get back issue and get the height leverage. I don't think IPF is gonna change their rule as they did for bench press recently.
love this instuctive video. so i was feeling guilty for being a cheater again just like how iam on a regular basis. but thanks i dont feel bad but rather feeling great. and i absolutely learned how to pull sumo from ur videos u posted in the past
Actually, I'd tend to say that sump benefits more to taller guys than shorter : taller dudes tend to have some long limbs, and being able to pull sumo allows to have so much better leverages such as lower hip hinge, and this multiplicates the advantage that is having long arms since they're not counteracted by the long legs
Could someone please explain to me the difference between a "stiff bar" and a "deadlift bar" and how a deadlift bar reduces range of motion? Never knew there different types of bars like this.
Deadlift bars are generally longer, whippier and have no center knurling.
Tried sumo 10 days ago definitely requires more mobility and felt harder than conventional maybe cause im not used to it idk
Yep !
I was a conventional puller, 260kg at 19 years old. Switched to sumo 3 months ago, I was struggling with 200kg. Yesterday I did 8 reps at 220kg sumo.
It just needs some time for your body to addapt
im 10 and pull 360kg but when I was 7 I pulled 420kg for tripple.
@@top3anythingrandomstuff98 lmao
@@frankytanky5076 i have a guy in my gym whos pulling 220 age 18. He is natty. By far his best lift. 115 bench and 165 squat. I dont say its likely to pull 260 but maybe its possible?
@@frankytanky5076 Hell yeah I did it. I am in the national team of my country.
260 isn't that great, especially taking the fact that I was 105kg+, lots of guys are pulling way more in my weightclass...
If you don't believe it to be possible tcheck out my friend David Alvarez on instagram, we are in the same team (you can see me spoting him in some videos :D), he did 200kg squat, 120 bench, 210kg deads at 16...
We are both being trained by Adrien Poinson, multiple times world record holder in the bench.
The Sumo Deadlift is generally easier for women because they have better mobility and stronger legs and hips relative to their back. You've seen women with big quads and glutes, but you've probably never seen a women with big traps and lats.
It is of note that the Straddle Deadlift and the Behind the Back Deadlift are currently banned in all federations.
And if those same women have short backs, which means erector strength becomes less of an issue, they set records conventional. See: Kim Walford, Marisa Inda, Jessica Buettner. Traps and lats don't move weight in the deadlift. Hips do, regardless of stance.
I've never tried sum deadlift before, but I feel like I would lose a lot of power through my legs if I had to stretch my legs that wide apart.
Personally I consider them different lifts, and I think that they should be judged differently.
It's within the the rules, as is getting an absurdly large arch in the bench, or a super hip hinged LB squat, however it violates the spirit of the sport, and are completely different motions. The super exaggerated arched bench transforms a lift from primarily being a feat of strength, to a feat flexibility. And the exaggerated sumo, and LB super hip-hinged squat, make them almost the same motion. This type of manipulation of the the rules create completely different motion patterns, and is one of the reasons the clean and press was discontinued as an Olympic lift in 1972, and why power lifting will never be an Olympic sport.
Actually, there wasn't any discussion in this video ... Just a defensive talk
Haha yes, my opinion is definitely slanted. But mostly because I think it’s kind of a non-issue. And yes, I do sometimes get triggered when people act silly about sumo deadlifting. I realize I was being snarky.
Great video:) I wanna know why i can pull more doing conventional than i can sumo. For some reason i find the initial pull really hard to get off the floor. I even take my stance in quite a bit n make sure my joints r stacked.
Relatively weaker quads and stronger posterior chain. The hardest part of the Sumo is of the floor, so if your quad strength is insufficient to break it of the floor. Therefor shorter range of motion doesn't matter, and the back and hamstrings never really get a chance to engage and contribute significantly to the lift.
What is a guide you recommend for people trying to decide between sumo and conventional based on their proportions/leverages?
The first thing you usually hear from coaches/experienced lifters is to pull sumo if it is geometrically impossible for you to hold a maximum of 90 degrees back angle while pulling conventional. That said, there are a bunch of really tall guys pulling conventional with a rounded back who seem to be doing ok.
Having struggled with this question myself, all I can say is try them both (starting with conventional if you are a novice lifter) and stick with the one that allows you to pull more weight and recover better.
yeah i pull conventional right now and have a meet in 4 weeks. After that, i was going to take a semi-extended off season and play around with sumo a bit just to see how it goes. Thanks for the reply
Aeklypsis yup taller people just can't sumo I still have no idea why. I can't sumo for shit either. Alot of the u93+ lifters tend to pull conventional
When you say 90 degrees, 90 degrees from where?
the angle your upper body forms with the vertical plane (the plane where the bar moves). It essentially means that your hips are higher than your shoulders, which is not uncommon for really tall people.
If you deadlift from your knees, the distance you cover in contrast to deadlifting from the floor is a lot more, so naturally you will hav ean easier time lifting from your knees. same with sumo. less distance to cover, so bigger lifts. sumo deadlifts are easier to execute and easier to finish. but strongmen dont sumo deadlift. they conventionallydeadlift, but if they all started sumo deadlifting their prs would be much much higher than that. then everyone should sumo deadlift and lift 5x to 6x his own bw, but thats easy to do, its the easy way of lifting, similar to the inch bench press some powerlifters perform. all you need to is juice up just a bit and all your numbers go up the roof. in modern times, powerlfters tried the same with the squat and miraculously it works. its not what you call a cheat lift, but in powerlfiting it is. how am i suppose to measure your strength if youlift 400kg a few inches from the floor, inch press 250kg at 70kg bw and in no time break the deadlift record by putting your feet far far wide. its cheating for competitions but not the exercise its self. its funny
YESSSS
I'd be interested in seeing a video about how to start using hook grip. By that I mean the process of how a beginner to hook grip would start getting used to it enough to pull near maximal loads.
I don't honestly know who's weirder: the people who think sumo is cheating or the people upset about centimetres
Bryce,
whats the actual difference in range of motion between stiff and deadlift bar without significant whip on the deadlift bar (which is there I guess around 250 kg+, but there is almost 0 with one plate on each side)? I think the whole difference between range of motion of both bars it showed is because you used wider stance with the deadlift bar, which obviously decreases range of motion.
thanks for clarification
There's a clear pattern that USUALLY more weight can be pulled sumo. Regardless, I wouldn't consider it a cheat any more than I'd begrudge another lifter for having longer arms than me. If I, as a strictly conventional puller, set out to best another lifter who pulls sumo, my M.O. is to pull more weight, full stop. No excuses about technique or leverages, just pull more weight. Or don't, accept defeat and give due credit.
You could have just taken the difference between length of the leg times the cosine of the angle from neutral for each stance. This is because the difference in stances would affect lockout height of the legs or arms. 85.9 cm leg * (cos of 1.5° conventional stance- cos of 25.5° sumo stance) = 8.22 cm difference between stances. I also got these numbers based on the video, measuring pixels for height (proportioning them out with the known tape measure) and using an on screen protractor.
Well, I guess you may grab the bar differently for each stance, which changes the lockout height too, but the same equation would work too: 63.0 cm arm * (cos of 3.8° conventional grip - cos of 1.2° sumo grip) = -0.1 cm difference (this formal assumes a bigger angle is better, but for arms, the smaller angle is better, so the answer is negative), so the difference is minimal in grip width.
For the people saying conventional is "harder": straight leg deadlifts are harder too. Why don't you use them as your main movement?
My main point is always that deadlift in some way represents a functional lift for being strong in "real life". If I pick a log or a heavy object I'm certainly not lifting it sumo style. Sumo deadlift is clearly taking advantage of mechanics but is in no way "cheating " in regards to power lifting competitions.
Rules need to change, same with bench width rules
I often pick up heavy objects in "real life", sumo style.
Finally! Someone is talking in cm and not in inches... Liked & Subscribed!
I literally only hear people crying when metric isn't being used ... never the other way around.
I don't know why some people say it's cheating, it's all about your structure. I am 6ft.1' tall but I lift more conventional because of my legs and torso length.
Whats harder? A wide grip pullup or a shoulder grip pullup?
5:06 there's no way Dillon's normal deadlift stance is that narrow...
It’s not even ROM, there’s just so much less torque on the lower back that it’s easier for most people. It’s cheating in Strongman and not cheating in powerlifting. The question is whether it ought to be allowed or not, in either sport. There is a similar debate about wether jerking instead of pushpressing or excessive hitching on the deadlift should be allowed in Strongman or not, and whether those things are “cheating”.
Which DL form is better for an average person who just wants to get stronger ?
The answer, it will probably help you lift more but it will take you years to master it and in that time your strength has increased from all that practice. Sooo yes lifting more weights for a significant amount of time makes you stronger.... Shocker.