Best Cordless Framing Nailer? DeWalt, HiKoki or Milwaukee? Who makes the best? Nail Gun Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2024
- I couldn't wait for Makita any longer, so here are the battery only framing nailers from Dewalt, Hikoki and Milwaukee.
TTI Nailer Showdown - Ryobi VS AEG/Ridgid VS Milwaukee • TTI Framing Nailer Sho...
ALL MILWAUKEE M18 NAILERS AND STAPLERS • ALL Milwaukee M18 Nail...
HiKOKI (Metabo HPT) Metal Connector Nailer • 36v HiKOKI Metal Conne...
AEG / Ridgid Framing Nailer Review • Is the AEG / Ridgid Fr...
Buy Nailers Here US homedepot.sjv....
Patreon / toolsandstuff
My Other Channel / buildsstuff
And I'm on Instagram now too / toolsandstuff
DeWALT Nailer amzn.to/3bqltOi
Metabo HPT Nailer (HiKOKI) amzn.to/3y14dIW
Milwaukee Nailer amzn.to/3bnnL0A
NAILS amzn.to/2RMRnxw
4 Top Multi-tools • Best 18v Multi-Tool. D...
4 Top Impact Drivers • DeWalt VS HiKOKI VS Ma...
4 Top Angle Grinders • Best Cordless Angle Gr...
4 Top Hammer Drills • Top 4 Cordless Hammer ...
4 Top Routers • 18v Router Comparison ...
If this description contains links to Amazon or Ebay, as an Amazon Associate and EPN Associate I may earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn't cost you a thing! But it means I can make more videos for you.
►►►Handy Hardware www.handywareho... 1/79 Wairau Rd Auckland
►►Get some 40v tools in the UK & Europe amzn.to/3306Htf
►Makita 40v finally available in the US! amzn.to/3tszyAP
More Makita XGT 40v Videos
40v MITRE SAW • Makita 40v 216mm Mitre...
40v 2.5Ah Battery VS 4.0Ah Battery • Makita 40v Battery Com...
Makita 40v Max XGT 6 piece Kit MEGA REVIEW • Makita XGT 40v Max MEG...
40V IMPACT DRIVER • Makita 40v Impact Driv...
40V ROTARY HAMMER DRILL • Makita 40v Rotary Hamm...
40V RECIPROCATING SAW (SAWZALL) • Makita 40v Reciprocati...
40V COMBI DRILL (HAMMER DRILL) • Makita 40v Hammer Dril...
40V GRINDER REVIEW • Makita 40v grinder Vs ...
40V CHARGER & BATTERIES • Makita 40v Batteries a...
40V CIRCULAR SAW • Makita 40v Circular Sa...
40V DRILL CLUTCH SETTINGS • Makita 40v Hammer Dril...
PURPLE MAKITA IMPACT DRIVERS (& OTHER COLOURS)
NEW 18v Makita TD172D in all available colours ebay.us/HADzgU
18v Makita TD171D in all available colours ebay.us/b7erGy
40v Makita TD001G in all available colours ebay.us/kzI7Uq
MORE VIDS
My Top 5 18v Makita • My TOP 5 Makita 18v Co...
My Top 5 36v (18v x2) Makita • My TOP 5 Makita 36v Co...
Homemade Hot Tub • How to Build a Hot Tub...
MY AMAZON STORE www.amazon.com...
ToolsContactNZ@Gmail.com
If this description contains links to Amazon, as an Amazon Associate I may earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn't cost you a thing! But it means I can make more videos for you.
Check out my other videos for reviews of Makita, Hilti, DeWalt, Bosch, Hitachi, Ryobi and more... As well as build projects and the odd random thing.
#Nailer
#ToolsandStuff
#BuildsandStuff
#KiwiToolReviews
New Zealand
TTI Nailer Showdown - Ryobi VS AEG/Ridgid VS Milwaukee ruclips.net/video/vmigX1PeQFM/видео.html
I have the Dewalt and love it. Built a 12x16 shed 100% solo and didn't have any issue with jammed nails despite going thru nearly 1500 nails. Great battery life as well, only went thru about 1 5ah battery for the entire project.
1500 nails 😂 that’s nothing. You should be able to shoot 10’s of thousands of nails before a nailer jams.
@@TCSwizz2he said he didn’t have a jam😂😂😂
I shoot 1500 nails a day!
I've had the hikoki one since it seems out. Still going strong. I've worked with teams and when paslodes fail they all end up borrowing my gun. It only failed once in 3 1/2 years. They sent it back fixed been good ever since. Its heavy but powerful and reliable.
It was fixed for free?
The Dewalt, consistantly sinks nails near 100% over a year of regular use, after the run in period. During run in period had a few false fires and two jams, since then no issues. Fast
Production framer here. We switched to milwaukee from paslode air nailers. We have run into problems with them in the summer heat. They stop shooting all together and we are left wishing we still had a compressor to hook up. Also sheeting goes slower. I don't think it's because it shoots much slower but the weight of it slows you down. Wall framing? Very similar speed to air nailer and no hose.
Good input, I was thinking about going all cordless on all my tools
But even the best cordless nailers in the market right now can’t keep up with old pneumatic nailers.
A combo air/cordless will be okay
did it make that clicking/grinding sound??
My Milwaukee framers were great… for the first 12 months, now I’m returning them every couple months. I picked one up yesterday from repairs and it lasted an hour. I’m currently have 3 framers, 3 15ga and 1x 18ga. 1 of each is in for repair at all times
+1 extra point to milwaukee for having an extended magazine. I've owned both the hikoki and milwaukee. The hikoki was sent back for repairs several times for example shooting two nails at a time. Also -1 point for hikokis terrible customer service. Brought the milwaukee have shot 13000 nails and could count on one hand how many times it's jammed or left a nail proud. Very impressed. Coming from a makita user.
Big makita fan myself just can't understand why they can't make a good nailer
Just invested in whole stock of tools for Makita and their pneumatic an924. I would love to an 18v setup
I’m into Makita’s lxt & xgt lines and still use a bosch air nailer. Waiting on the xgt but if it isn’t great, I’ll lean into team red for it.
Bought
I'm looking into milwaukee can you tell me best of 23. 24 please don't like hoses I'm old almost 70 years old I've learned enough, so rather keep it around 500$ unless a 800$ is better its not for me so much it's for my son it's longevity thing please and thank you
I'm in ireland, bought a hikoki in February , my rafter hook is 4", it's on the right hand side of the tool and will swing right around to the other side, it does have the bump fire mode but I dont use it, the power button is in a weird position but the tool will stay on for adleast a half hour without touching it so ,and that's rare to not need it for so long
I have the hikoki framing nailer. I find it a good nailer with sufficient power with standards North American framing lumber. But one huge pet peeve that probably every nailer should have - an audible warning for an empty clip.
Why? Trying to shoot without the recoil is hard on the wrist. A simple sound/beep to let you know your out would avoid unnecessary wrist pain.
I hate it when you are holding some wood for the first shot
O shit no nails start again
i hate putting the heavy thing in an awkward position to finish the job and ... empty!
Metabo i bought will put over 1k nails per charge on larger battery. The small battery it came with about 400. But for sure is a great buy. We have built several decks with it and did not need to have a standard nailer for our jobs. One metabo 2 batteries i can build about anything!! I was very impressed with it!! And yes it will drive 3in nails in pressure treated lumber.! First charge out the box we drove over 1k nails on a single charge! Only set back for me was that it does not like to shoot on an angle very well. And if your paper nailing if paper is damaged at all mine won't fire.
Milwaukee has extended mag available very handy for capacity
Yea thats why im getting milwaukiee
I had the DeWalt 21* Framing Nailer for about a year, and just wasn’t happy with the ‘Fisher-Price’ kinda sounds of its flywheel whirring, and so, I sold it and got into the Metabo HPT (formerly Hitachi and Hikoki(?)) Framing Nailers (and specialty 36V Nailers, too) and love them all! I have every model except for the 16ga, as the 15ga and 18ga Nailers can handle whatever the 16ga was meant for, IMHO! Thanks for posting another great comp video, brother!
m18, milwaukee is awesome, i got the extended mag, 96 nails. what a game changer!
We put a couple thousand nails a day through a DeWalt. It works great 99% of the time and has great battery life. The only problem I have with it is if you hit a nail or bad knot occasionally a nail will get stuck in the end.
One of the best cordless framing nailer comparisons I've seen. Thanks
Cheers
I love my dewalt first fix. It’s the type 3 and I think it’s as powerful as a paslode
The hikoki is a great nail gun. Bought one because I was sick and tired of my paslode only ever driving nails 3/4 of the way. The Hikoki nails home 99% of the time (even in LVL where the paslode is a waste of time). I also use the small 3ah battery to save weight and the large rafter hook which can hook over 90mm plates.
Have you serviced the paslode? It loses power over time as it gets dirtier and doesen't seal as well anymore. I haven't used the hikoki but that dewalt was just pain in the ass to deal with compared to paslode im90. I have shot around 10k 90mm nails with paslode and around 4k with dewalt
@@MrAggezzz It’s just the Paslode, unfortunately. They’re horrrrrible on LVL’s, goes 3/4 and then you need to hammer them in manually. The Hikoki blasts them in! The hook as atrocious though. I don’t know who decided that design was the best. It’s far too large and I guess that’s not too bad, bro it’s spring mechanism is trash. It’s like a swivel, and doesn’t lock out.
@@MrAggezzz I have the dewalt at the moment as my ex partner decided to get it as the dickhead behind the counter at the tool centre told him what an amazing gun it was like he used one every day.
As soon as I have some more money together im going to send him a film of me launching it of the scaffold.
Diyer gun
@@CryptikStudios I love the big hook. Folds out of the way when you don't need it and can als hook it on triple lams
I love my Milwaukee framer. So ridiculously powerful and always consistent. Doing a reno recently using oak framing through the entire house and not once did i have to tap in the heads something we had to do a lot with our old porter cable air. Bump fire it just never runs out of breath. It's very impressive. I use it with a cp 3.0 to minimize the weight without sacrificing the performance. Thing is still a pig tho.
I am a lightweight and it is a bit heavy at times. Would not trade it for anything.
@@MrTHEBRITINWA same here 5'4" manlet. But I would probably trade it for another milwaukee if this one dies out of warranty and there is a newer one that is lighter but offers the same consistent performance.
@@khoatran9482 I run one with 8’s and an extended rack on the other for 16’s.
Oak framing?
Got tired of waiting for Makita to get one on the market, so I got the Milwaukee.
1) as someone said, the Milwaukee has the extended mag. I got it and it's great having the capacity.
2) I got the bare tool, and a battery adapter so my Milwaukee nailer uses my Makita batteries. It's a really great solution and I've had 0 issues.
In the same situation like you were. Been looking at the Hikoki all this time but after this review and reading you set up I'm now thinking Milwaukee. Got plenty Makita batteries to use.👍
@@johnmackay7789 do it! I love Makita, but the Milwaukee nailers are awesome. I also got the gen 2 Milwaukee Brad nailer, and I actually have the Makita one as well.
@@travis7500 do you find any issues with the battery being attached to an adaptor, does it make the gun cumbersome?
I've used both dewalt and hikoki and I prefer the dewalt simply because of the fact the hikoki turns off so quickly! Nothing more annoying that getting something in place above your head and then having to take it back down to turn the hikoki on!
mine turns off after about 15 mins, thats ok to me.
Quickly? How long do you take between nails?
Hopefully Makita can get in the game soon. I mean heck they finally have a grease gun, so there is hope!
Makita have quite a few framing nailers pal, shit tho
I’ve used all 3 and own the Milwaukee because I’m on that platform, the Milwaukee is awesome! Yes it’s heavy but you get used to it quickly. I could happily use the hikoki but the dewalt just doesn’t hold up. I had a paslode for years before moving over and will never go back, no gas, no constant servicing and no bang.
What happened to the dewalt ? Gen 3?
The Bump Mode on the De Walt is actually very good by the way.
Shut tf up
@@antoniononame3037 you shut tf up
I like the bump mode too
I got the dewalt gen 3 great gun, the spring takes minute to change if breaks good being able to change on-site, better if you have the bump fire on these guns
I know from shooting the Milwaukee I started with charged 5AH battery and started nailing in bump mode. 14 minutes in and I had it stopping from overheating of both battery and tool. Just a fact here I shot 300 nails in that time frame. Gonna be putting my own Dewalt against it tomorrow. I am firing 3 inch nails into hardwood, mainly oak, 2x4 and 3x4s. What needs improved is heat dissipation on the Milwaukee. Shooting blasts of compressed air into the vents seems to cool it.
300 nails in 14 minutes? I would be using a pneumatic for that. I use my milwaukee for remodeling only,...and 300 nails in 14 minutes isn't required.
I had the bostitch 20v (basically a first gen dewalt, just bought a new dewalt) and my boss has the Milwaukee. The mil definitely has more power. It can drive a nail deeper. The fan noise is something I got used to and actually prefer. With the mil when you run out of nails or have a jam or something you won’t know until you put the nailer up and pull the trigger a couple times. With my bostitch and dewalt when something Like that happens it won’t make the noise and you know before you even try to do something. (I’m in US and use bump fire so you might not get to experience that)Also know kind of a “hey I’m live and am about to shoot a nail”. Don’t get that warning with the mil. With that being said I prefer mine for framing up walls and just simple stuff. But when it comes to putting nails in harder woods it’s nice having the Milwaukee around. Great review man!
I moved over to cordless nailers early on. I got both the dewalt 21degree and 30 degree nailers as well as the 16ga angles and 18ga.
They’re all more or less garbage in my opinion. The 21 degree framer is dog shit, doesn’t drive nails and jams all the time. The 30 is much better but there are still more jams than what’s acceptable, I still use it when I only need a few nails, but hand banging 16 pennies are almost more efficient at this point… all guns got feeding issues.
I’ve moved back to air lately, gotten myself more compact high pressure air compressors and I feel like a fool for wasting time and money on all these cordless nailers… they don’t hold up… air tools are cheaper, preform better an will last a lot longer if you oil them every time you use them.
Hate the noice of dewalt
Who wants to hear that fan running all the time? Definitely something I don't miss from my Paslode.
I have used all major players when it comes to framing guns , and quite honestly i love the hikoki and the milwaukee , but I keep going back to the paslode, I am not a huge guy and just overly prefer how light weight the paslode is compared to its gasless counter parts
i just wish that milwaukee and hikoki manage to shed some of the weight off their guns on their gen 2 models, they have the better power but at a sacrifice to weight, which isnt a big deal but paslode always takes the cake when it comes to comfort of use for me
The dewalt one has soo much recoil like it was going to the moon when you shot it through the 3 layers
The dewalt recoil in the review was quite exadurated because the dewalt is much lighter. and.... in bump mode does it even less. I am not a PRO, I own it, love it and would buy it again.
I'm not a framer anymore but I waited so long for Milwaukee, I might just grab one anyway..
Thanks heaps. Enjoyed your video. I have the DeWalt combo (both the framing and finishing nailers). I use the finishing nailer all the time doing insurance work. The framing nailer not so much. Being in Australia, I do have bump function on both tools, which I think helps because of how light the framer is. You can cut down on recoil by bump firing. It does make an annoying sound but compared with my work buddy’s Paslode, it is much quieter which is great in insurance work because the client is usually at home while we’re working. Other than that, I think your comparison was pretty fair.
I have the Hitachi (bought it just before they changed their name) and love it...
Hitachi made the best nailer for roofing since i can remember, this are battery now so not sure anymore
Quality and technology is just as good
Very impressed , especially the 36V guns
I have had two of the dewalts and returned both of them. I typically tend to frame something in then switch to ring shank to sheet and the dewalt will not sink any type if ring shank. I have also had the same thing happen when trying to shoot regular framing nails into different materials. Like shooting osb into a laminated beam. Just not versitile and powerful enough for me.
I’m a makita fan boy... but I couldn’t wait so I bought the hikoki.
Not in the building trade so it’s for my weeks projects and I love it
Also have the 16g brad nailer also
Finally someone did proper comparison between them.
Thank you! Well done! Has helped me a great deal in making my decision.
You're welcome, glad it helped.
I can't wait for Makita's framing nailer. Hopefully, soon they'll have compact 21700 cell batteries to go with it!
They have small compact 2ah xgt 40v batteries in europe.
How could one possibly make smaller cell? 2170 literally mean 21mm diameter 70mm length fyi
@@joemooney366 They are a larger cell however they have a higher energy density per cell.
@@joemooney366 He's not talking about making the cells smaller hes talking about making low ah batteries witn the larger cells.
Their new release xgt 40v brad cannot even sink on hardwood despite its only 40mm length capaticy. Milwaukee is 54mm and sinks into hardwood fast with no problem
I had Paslode nailers ( framing and finish) for years, so happy to have Hikoki guns that use no gas and just a battery, on top of that they are much quieter to use that the Paslode
Man, I wish you could have done the bump tests, I’ve used all 3, the Milwaukee bump fire is absolute lightning, I shoot flooring with it it’s that quick, glad I settled on it and bought it, has been absolutely bulletproof, our hikoki has already had to go back for servicing with issues,
I have the Milwaukee and the dewalt. I like them both.
I have all of them plus matabo.. matabo is the best by FAR! My 2 dewalts absolutely suck they jam like crazy. Milwaukee doesn’t jam but extremely heavy and quits working when working in the rain also shoots way slower then matabo. My two matabo are about 3 years old used and abused by framing crew both still going strong
The Hikoki is Metabo HPT
Dewalt is third gen now and brushless Also ridgid (sister to Milwaukee)
@@ToolsAndStuffOFFICIAL yep
@@Dirtyharry70585 I will have to try one of the new ones👍 both of the dewalts I have now sit in the van and never get touched.
G'day mate, watched this a few weeks back and it helped me make my decision, which was the hikoki go figure! Seemed a bit more accessible price wise to start on a new battery platform than the milwaukee and I didn't want to wait any longer for Makita to get their act together. One thing you may find interesting though is that I managed to pick it up for $600 NZD through the mitre10 trade hub, with 2 batteries and charger. Absolutely bonkers! They've got a knockdown price on the main website down to 850ish and it must've upset something in the trade site which has made it glitch down to an incredibly low price! Just checked and it's still 520.87 plus GST, mental! Either it's a glitch or they want rid of them fast, but either way I jumped on it!
Sweet deal.
I have a Milwaukee, works really good, but it's so heavy to use!!..Otherwise I love it......Thanks for this fine video and objective review...
I'm super happy with my Hitachi. Ginormous hook and all. I have the 21° style for the full headed nails. Holds less nails. It also has a obscenely large hook. On/off buttons a pain. Comically oversized hook. Battery gauge, poo. And, AND, an overwhelming hook for the purpose of hanging the tool from the top of an entire house. I've never had a problem with this gun, or any of the other three Hitachi cordless nailers I own.
Large hook.
I like my metabo/hikoki nailers two just with they’d incorporate beep? To let you know the clip is out so you don’t keep trying to nail.
Great, but how's the hook?
We have a dewalt and the hikoki onsite aswell a paslode. The dewalt is definitely the best at getting into tight spots between joists and studs etc although not as powerful as the green one.
One annoying thing about the Hikoki is you have to turn it on and switchs off after a short time
14:20 Hikoki has an optional no-mark tip
26:50 Going to get the Hikoki
You keep telling me to complain, but I don’t have anything to complain about… Wait, does this mean I was complaining? 😂🤷🏽♂️
That means you're one of the good ones. 😉
on the dewalt its a fibre reinforced plastic so pretty tough and harder than 'regular' plastic
The dewalt short nail feature is abit useless but it was ment to save battery usage ithink. Very good review, nice to see a kiwi review
Considering all the other big brands have a battery nailer out, I’m hoping that Makita will bring one out within the next year or two. They wouldn’t want to miss the market for too long.
Man, I ve been hoping for a while. Im all Makita, but they need a table saw and a series of good trim and framing nailers… I’m actually trying to figure out what second battery platform to add for just those items…. I like the weight of the dewalt nailer, but it looks like Milwaukee might be better rounded
@@gregruopp4437 I have the milwaukee and the metabo and have used the dewalt. The metabo is absolutely the best one by a good disparity in my opinion. it’s a lot lighter and it’s a lot faster (i switched the spring in it to make it more sensitive) The only advantage of the milwaukee is that they offer the extended magazine
I’m with both of y’all I have all Makita tools and I wish Makita would come out with a gun or and I’m stock because I want to get to Milwaukee but then I wish Makita would come out with a gun
@@colekidd2 these are all junk. The dewalt is the worst. Then the metabo. Milwaukee is the best of the 3 but so far i like the Rigid. That may change all depending on how long it lasts. Now people may disagree with me but i do nothing but install metal roofs and i use these to install the 1x4s and i have never had 1 last more then 60 days. Less in the summer months. The Milwaukee will cool off and continue to work. The metabo then goes to the scrap heap. The last 1 I had Metabo would not even repair or replace. Saying they can't get parts anymore. I bought them from Lowes and paid for the extended warranty. Very disappointing. Rigid is pretty new. I will see how it holds up
@@allenbyler8210 I wouldn’t call any of them junk. for any pickup framing they’re way better than rolling out a compressor and in my opinion the weight is an even sacrifice for not having a cord running behind you everywhere especially when it’s just small work.
HD had two dewalts kits on mark down from $399 to $100 3-10-22. Bought
one! Been using a 1996 Porter Cable framer and the last deck I wish I
had this guy! Had to drag all the air tools shit around back a condo by
hand, everyday no lock up.
I have the Hikoki and I think its good. So has everyone who has used it. Compared to a paslode it is ace. Never tried the Milwaukee, never seen one on site here. The Dewalt is just irritating. Not so awful nailing on a top plate or similar, but every time you pick it up....Whrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr bang Whrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr bang. The Hikoki is just bangbangbang, move bangbangbang
The recoil on the DeWalt looks brutal.
It is but av been using it everyday for the past 8 months on site everyday and it’s just started to missfire so would say pretty good going blasting 90mm nails all day
Me being a service tech for these brands (minus Hikoki) I have learned that when you buy one of these at full MSRP, the company can replace about 5 or 6 of them before they take a loss. And average repair for an electrical Dewaltout of warranty is about 260 bucks and a 6 week wait time . Hence why air tools will always dominate the field.
Not a bad comparison, thank you - one consideration you missed (unless I missed it day-dreaming); likelihood of serious damage if dropped. A bit tricky but an important point.
I had the DeWalt for about a year and then the Milwaukee came out with theirs and so I bought that, then the DeWalt just sat in my trailer until I sold it.
Edit: I also added the extended magazine. No brainier purchase.
Mines a slightly different model. The tips they made razor sharp sonit grips good. And they include a plastic cover to both protect you and the material your shooting if required. I brushed it woth my arm with the cover off and opened me up pretty good. Like a horribly deep cat scratch. So always store with the plastic cap cover.
My work colleague got one recently and noticed that too. It has made quite a big difference on how much easier it is to fire.
I have the Milwaukee and it’s the best. It’s also the fastest and most powerful when bumpfire is available.
I’m the only thing I want is the side fins on the contact tip to match the length of the top fin, like a standard one you would see on a metabo or hitachi pneumatic.
Considering getting some custom fins welded on the side
Sometimes its good to have adjusting depth. When nails are left visible they should be flush and when putting on temporary supports or braces. Its easier to pull out nails which already are few mm up.
You can by 6Ah third party batteries for Hikoki (at least in the UK), but whether they really are 6Ah, or last as long, might be another matter.
As I personally already have a raft of Hikoki tools and batteries, then the decision for me is essentially already made, but I'm interested to see the results of the tests.
When it comes to the tip, you can file it to the satisfying sharpness
I took a grinder to to nose on my dewalt, works like a dream. I prefer air nailers tho.
Just got the makita fn001g
Brilliant bit of kit... Hopefully 1st fix nailer is on the horizon now with the new 40v stuff
Don't hold your breath.
decision made milwaukee it is, loved my paslode but the nails plus gas for the im360 are to expensive and my local builders merchants dont stock them, thanks for the help choosing between the hikoki and milwaukee
Using the hikoki and having one gun shoot around 2000 nails a week, they do wear out very quick and it does require servicing, weight and delay to fire is also annoying.
If it was more cost effective I would choose a paslode without a doubt.
But I’m really leaning towards getting myself a Milwaukee gun. The rafter clip and the tool belt clamp seem a lot better than the hikoki, I think I could live with the extra weight.
I’ve rounded out the dewalt, mainly because that noise it makes pisses me off haha
The only other contributing factor is what saw is best, to see if I can get some value out of the purchase,but that’s another topic
the red, don't last. They rushed to market too soon, I am on my third one, and finally have to give up, move to another color.
@@tallcook37 for price and reliability, I’m going to stick with hikoki. Once the guns have nolathane bushes to replace the rubber ones (from what my repair/service guy has done) they shoot twice the amount before needing another service, that also depends on the age of the nailer/ how hard a life it’s had.
Thanks for the extra assurance though!
Cheers from the US. Great vid! I had the Dewalt 21* and 30*. My boss thought my new 21 nailer needed oil before use... needless to say it didn’t make it long after and now that whirring sound triggers my anxiety pretty fierce. Took it back and tried the 30 and they just don’t seem to have enough power to frame efficiently. Milwaukee seems to be the leader again
Thanks for the test. Purchased the DeWalt and fired approximately 200 nails and sold it. No my cup of tea. The spring reset switch is a pain in the butt. The Milwaukee looks great but already purchased a paslode before I seen this clip. Thank you for the test comparison.
The Dewalt does get better once you have fired 500+ nails. But I know what you mean.
Every comparison I have ever watched I believe has put Milwaukee first so like a lot of their tools it is no doubt the most powerful and in all reality the best gun. But again like a lot of their tools it drastically falls down on ergonomics. All battery framers are way too heavy but they go one better and make theirs a boat anchor for a container ship. Terrible balance and stupidly heavy. I wrote to them and expressed this plus added if they could be first to make a decent light framer they wouldn't keep up with demand. I will probably be long retired before that happens so not for me.
The problem we have is the cold, at -20C the Milwaukee nailer just does not perform well at all. Even as it warms up still lots of stoppages, and it's a pain when your trying to keep 5 guys going.
Really enjoying this series Tools! Makita nailer will go at the top of the Tools I Don't Need But Want list ;)
Glad you like them!
I had thought things through and ended up getting the DeWalt
Own 2 x Milwaukee guns. Great tool. Bit heavy but already in the environment so not changing.
I have the Metabo 👍👍, it's heavy , but it's a beast 💪. So far ...so good . Can definitely sink the nails
From my understanding, the dewalt is at least serviceable whereas the gas cylinder guns (Milwaukee, hikoki) are throw away items when that cylinder is depleted. Please correct me if I am wrong though. Also, being able to access the Dewalt in a kit with a 5ah battery & charger for about $400 less than the opposition has to be worth considering in your decision.
My god the Milwaukee with the 12ah must have been HEAVY 😂
What a monster of a gun it is though 💪
Great video though mate, I've just found your channel and have been binge watching!
Dewalt takes about 5 minutes at most to service, its 2 springs and retaining clips, quite easy tbf
The internal cylinder on the metabo can be refilled, at home. The tool is avail on amaz. Hook up to compressor and refill
I'm still waiting for Makita to make a nail gun... I shall not fall to temptation I will wait!!!
I'm a DeWalt guy and I recently bought the Milwaukee to replace my whore out DeWalt. The thing is a monster it hasn't misfired or Jammed. What it does do is overheat rather quickly. If it's not the gun it's the silly battery. Still the best one out there ATM. DeWalt needs to go with a 60v version and upgrade those weak ass springs on the inside.
I would go for dewalt if it had an nails extension like the milwaukiee, thats why im going for milwaukiee
@@contessa.adella actually I forgot the d at the end. We all took a turn nailing her.
@@ferndogg4427 go for the Milwaukee. Way heavier but much better. You won't like the extended mag. This thing will overheat rather quickly. I own 2 so the other one has a chance to cool off 🤣 no joke.
Still beats dragging a hose in the mud.
I like my Milwaukee framing and Angled 15ga. Finish nailers I don’t care how much more it weighs because it beats swinging a hammer all day long
I know I'm a little late to the game here, but Hikoki/Metabo HPT (for us yanks) has released a 36v version as well as a strap and one other 36v......still no MAKITA!!!!!!!
Got the metabo. It’s solid but It tends to misfire in colder temperatures.
Want a bump fire function? You can order one from Australia mate.
The dewalt springs only seem to go when you push them past what they can do, lots of nailing on stuff that’s too hard breaks the gun. Softwood to softwood just keeps going - and I mean going - for years.
Never ever had any issue with the flywheel bit wearing out either.
Agreed, I've got the 1st gen gun which I bought in 2013 and I have absolutely abused it on a daily basis and it's never been in for a repair!!
I reckon I'm on the 3rd set of springs in that time, I find that if the gun gets wet the springs tend to rust and that is the likely cause that will give you trouble. When it eventually dies I'll have no hesitation in buying a 3rd gen dewalt gun.
I gave up waiting for a Makita nailer so got the Hikoki. Decent gun, same issues you had, power button is in a stupid place and the tip isn’t long enough but apart from that I’d definitely recommend it.
Metoo in 2017 👍 Slowkita
Also the hikoki belt hook is so dumb
@@kizzjd9578 I think they supply different clips in different regions. Mine just has a massive rafter hook. Which I removed as I find them annoying.
@@deanripley2875 yea same, i had to order the hook off the finish nailer and swapped it over. They are still a shit design though. They should've made one like the paslode.
I have the Milwaukee and I love how powerful it is, but dang that weight tho. Glad to see your thorough test on all those aspects of them. I also can’t wait for Makita to bring one out, and for Milwaukee to hopefully do a gen 2 that is lighter weight!
Milwaukee makes stuff to last, definitely the the Estwing of the 3.
I have the dewalt and like in the video it is really terrible. Refuses to put the nail in all the way and constantly jams. Just got the Milwaukee and it is awesome so far.
The weight of the gun is probably pretty important for penetration? Heavier guns have less kick which means more power is transferred into the nail. It would be really cool to do a test where you add some weights to the head of the Dewalt and Hikoki to make them as heavy as the Milwaukee, and then compare depth. The Milwaukee would probably still win, but it could be a lot closer - maybe you *don't* want Milwaukee to make their gun lighter... Thanks for the vids, I've been enjoying them!
For a while I had the dewalt. It was worthless very soon after getting it. Was not even usable driving framing nails into doug fir framing lumber. I wasted a lot of time talking to people on the phone. After getting the biggest battery I could for it,..there was no change,. It would not set nails at all,..Usually you had them proud about 1/2 inch or so. I sold it and bought the milwaukee and have been very surprized. I can use a small battery with the milwaukee and it still does OK, although I'm sure if I had a super large battery I would notice a difference. I usually use 5ah batteries,..and sometimes a 2 ah..
Something missing 🤔 yes the Lumberjack with the 4amp battery 😊
Hikoki for me £389
Milwaukee was £500 in UK
Got 3300 free nails to in deal
what about deck framing? the video reviews Don't seem to address that. framing material looks beat up using these nailer. words I ld be using 21 degree stainless 3.25. thank you
What a great comparison! Despite its brutality, I like your scoring system ;) I'd suggest that the availability of the extended magazine for Milwaukee would have merited a point, but obviously wouldn't have affected the outcome here. I put the Milwaukee in my Messy Garage (I was already on the M18 platform, and had/loved the 18ga brad nailer, so wasn't a hard choice). The DeWalt noise would drive me absolutely crazy - oof...
You should have added an ordinary hammer to the test. It is lightest cheapest sinks ALL nails, pulls them OUT! and so on.
😂
Dewalt has a forward assist lol, the Milwaukee light made my day. I love these head to heads.
That that annoys you would be the setting that allows you to not go at so much death so you can keep it from going through your sheeting But I’m sure you figure that out
2nd fix nailers .. head to (heed ) 🤣
Bring it 👍🏼
I'm saving up for that... could take a while...
My experience with Dewalt is they are not reliable and iam a Dewalt guy,I went through 4 of them framing my house this past winter the place I take all my tools to be fixed won't even look at them they say they are not worth fixing.
I've got the Milwaukee, and it's been amazing so far. I'm really a Makita girl, but I doubt they'd made a good nailer. The reason? Their patents are based on the DeWalt design with the flywheel. But yea, my Milwaukee nailer has been great. No jams as of yet, and haven't needed to reset the striker.
Im dewalt guy but 3 things why im getting milqaukiee, less noice and u can add a nail extension
I totally agree makita made me buy milwaukee tools
theres 2 missing now ryobi has just came out with 1. ive been waiting for it for too long. but they say it will be released first of 2023
I also like lighter tools. However, as a tool like this lightens, it will ultimately have more recoil.
I got the hikoki cause I got a free 15g finish gun and 18v trim router and was cheaper then the Milwaukee
Sweet deal
Makita guy , have the Milwaukee 21 with the extended clip. Got the battery adapter so I can use my Makita batteries.
Where you get the adapter?
@@PropaStuff eBay.
How’s the milkwaukee holding out ok still not sure on paslode or getting Milwaukee
@@PropaStuff I have no regrets. The features on the magazine are identical to my pneumatic porter cable. It’s hefty, but I knew that before my purchase.
My clutch parts are abs plastic. Lots of high intensity car parts are.
I've got the dewalt and I totally agree with the result of this test I can tell you first hand that it's shit. I think that makita has a patent for a framing gun and it's a flywheel driven system like the dewalt so now that there is better technology makita have probably gone back to the drawing board because I don't think it would be as good as the Milwaukee or the hikoki it would probably be better than the dewalt though.
I have the extend clip for my milwaukee and it does great, only issue I have is when I use the bump fire mode it shuts down due to over heating.
These aren't made for continuous use. If you want longevity you need an air powered nailer.