If you meet my 11th great grandfather a you tell him tomorrow stop impregnating Italian servant girls, it’s making my 9th grand nephews task impossible to re-assimilate my DNA.
The reasons why it's unfit for either of these is because it's fake, computer-generated, and innaccurate. It's fun for us as viewers to watch, but we are learning nothing from it.
Difficult. That would add a fake component to our already heavily filtered and ultimately incomplete historical “knowledge”. On the other hand, we all know those documentaries in which historical events are portrayed by actors. In any case, we should avoid letting our young people think that omniscient AI can give us an exactly accurate picture of history. Greetings from Germany!🇩🇪🤝
@Gamba_with_Cigarette or could it be that more symmetrical and defined features we find attractive are simply easier for the a.i to compute. I'd imagine a stranger looking person with more unique asymmetries and strange head shapes would be harder to arrange than the standard views of beauty given there's more imperfections to articulate
Even when the resemblance is extraordinary, the difference between a painted likeness and a 3D representation is like day and night. Thank you for making some fascinating historical people seem real again, I'm sure they would love it.
probably because the painting are also stylized and sanitized . Also they are the elite so they have access to beautification products and services. They are the equivalent of Hollywood stars of that time as they are the elite and famous.
I enjoyed the entire video; we need more like it. The music was perfectly suited for the video, though it evoked a melancholic feeling. This feeling is commonly known as post-series depression or post-movie depression syndrome, which is a sense of sadness, emptiness, or grief that people may feel after concluding a movie, TV series, or book in which they were deeply engrossed. The emotional impact of a story can be heightened by melancholic music or poignant scenes that highlight the characters' fates after pivotal events. It's a common emotional response as audiences form deep connections with the characters and the narrative, making it difficult to part with the story upon its conclusion. Although I realize stories cannot continue indefinitely, I often struggle with their endings. This is just who I am; it was difficult to bid farewell to the "Lost" TV series, and it's why I repeatedly watch the original "Dark Shadows" TV series whenever possible.
Truly outstanding work, and very lifelike. AI has come a long way in the last few years, but it takes someone with aesthetic awareness to produce this kind of art. Thank you!
When replicating portraits, we need to remember they didn't have cosmetics in common use until the 1600s, and then, mostly in the French court. Elizabeth I wore makeup to cover her smallpox scars, but it wasn't used by members of her court.
Close enough. All this complaining, it’s kind of frustrating. So what if it’s not perfectly accurate. The fact that this is even possible is a gift in itself. Of course AI isn’t perfectly accurate. It’s AI. And I’ve learned that the more details you try to use, the more the AI messes up.
Artists historically followed popular trends in schools of painting by more prominent artists in different countries depending on which one was most popular at the time. Artists also depicted their subjects according to their personal perspective and not as they actually were. That's why portraits painted by diffrrent artists at different time periods can look very different
Doesn’t take into account for skin shade, pimples, uneven skin colouration, or other imperfections that would be present but the painter politely left out. Most of the women painted in ancient times were teenagers. And a painter who wanted favour would flatter his subject.
más bien al revés, en el pasado las personas de europa tenían la piel más blanca, todavía es posible verlo en mi propio país de españa en las zonas del norte sobre todo zonas rurales, donde la gente es literalmente tan blanca como una pared, esos rostros bronceados de la ai no son muy representativos de como se veía la gente de esa época
These really are a stunning achievement. Mary of Guise’s lips are a bit thinner and more pursed and not so full and pretty as you have made them…but I’m sure she wouldn’t complain! Please please do Lettice Knollys, Countess of Essex and Elizabeth the 1st’s hated love rival and also Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, the man they fell-out over.
Elizabeth Báthory, also known as the 'Blood Countess,' is a figure enveloped in a mix of historical fact and myth. The charges against her are serious, but it's vital to examine the context and the available evidence, or its absence, that surrounds her story. First, many testimonies against her were extracted under torture, which casts doubt on their veracity. Furthermore, there was no solid physical evidence to directly connect her to the purported crimes. The political environment of the era is also key. As a wealthy and influential noblewoman, Báthory was vulnerable to attacks from political adversaries who could benefit from her misfortune. Some scholars suggest that the charges were the result of a politically charged defamation campaign. Additionally, the trial was notably unconventional, with Báthory being denied essential legal rights, including the use of torture to force confessions from her servants. Recent scholarly work has added layers of complexity to her story, indicating that many tales about Báthory, like her alleged virgin blood baths, are more mythic than factual. These considerations don't exonerate her but offer a more layered perspective on her case. Distinguishing between the established facts and the myths is crucial, taking into account the wider historical and political milieu.
Elizabeth Bathory was probably wrongfully accused. She was a wealthy land-owner who refused to give up her land to men who wanted it, so they found a way to take it from her.
@@helbraheals I knew I would find "women did not do evil things; it was men's fault' comments like yours regarding Bethory, as women in the comment section always do about historical women. So modern women are capable of serial killing, but historical women are not? It's always the men's fault, huh?
Kublai Khan, the only man in known history who could teach his warhorses to gallop backwards. Seriously though this is stunning work. Imagine them comprehending that half a millenium later they'd be brought to life using AI tech.
Would be more interesting if the women weren't automatically given modern mascara and eye shadow... and were made up with more authentic white makeup of the period. This is just pointless.
Anyone that's against ai should see this. We can bring history to life and make it relatable. I know people will say 'Why not get actors to play them in videos". Not everyone can afford actors or accurate costumes. This can be a great teaching tool for students.
How do we know these women didn’t have zits, uneven skin tone, dark or yellow complexions? Skin is essential for true beauty. No painter who cared about his career wouldn’t flatter his subjects by making them appear better than they were. Queen Elizabeth 1 had horrible small pox scars, yet not one painting shows this. Not much different than the tic toc filters heh ..?
Rather impressive!! Thanks for animating the people too! Can other paintings, say, of battles or other events "come to life"? The music you are using almost sounds like Lantz & Speers!
Why does AI insist on making the women smile but not the men, when most were not smiling in the painting? It feeds the rhetoric that women need to be seen as pleasing and welcoming. Even the serial killer was made to smile at the end!! Women do not have to smile to be acceptable.
Keep in mind it could also be the “prompter” injecting that into the details. Other wise they could make sure they don’t. But paintings often never captured smiles. In reality the real person smiled from time to time.
this is very biased no WAY do these people look like AI is making it its pretty neat but notice they make everyone look way MORE attractive then they actually looked if someone was attractive then they would look that way in the painting but dont forget that the times back in the day they didnt clean themselves and it was very dirty everywhere so they would be looking so nice and clean but i get it you wanna believe so bad that your able to bring stuff to life but its nonsense
This is terrible the faces completely change into several different people as soon as they move and they don’t even resemble any of the source images anymore…
Let me get this straight. You take an old painting, mix in some AI and present it as bringing an historical figure to life. And people are supposed to be in awe?
This is great. Of course it is not perfect and everybody looks a lot better than the probably looked like, but it nevertheless brings them to life and pushes them closer to us today. Although being an artist myself, I always find it hard to relate to painted people (I hope this somehow makes sense). Beautiful music as well, not too distracting. If you allow me one question: what AI do you use for the different tasks of creating and animating these portraits? I would love to try that with some old photos of my long dead grandparents.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks, this makes it a lot easier to identify the people on my time travels
What! You too?
Damn!
Are you the one met on the slipstream in 1234 AD? Good times!
If you meet my 11th great grandfather a you tell him tomorrow stop impregnating Italian servant girls, it’s making my 9th grand nephews task impossible to re-assimilate my DNA.
Before you go, be sure to watch the video on tips for medieval time travel. Just type it in, it'll pop right up.
🤣🤣🤣
This would be good for museums and history classes, it really makes history alive.
Yeah, ai makes such lessons interesting for contemporary students
Great idea!
The reasons why it's unfit for either of these is because it's fake, computer-generated, and innaccurate. It's fun for us as viewers to watch, but we are learning nothing from it.
@@jaguwa4816 yet interesting!
Difficult. That would add a fake component to our already heavily filtered and ultimately incomplete historical “knowledge”. On the other hand, we all know those documentaries in which historical events are portrayed by actors. In any case, we should avoid letting our young people think that omniscient AI can give us an exactly accurate picture of history. Greetings from Germany!🇩🇪🤝
AI is making them all 20 per cent better looking
AI learns from photos on the internet. Beautiful people are more likely to appear in mass media. AI thinks that’s what average looks like.
@Gamba_with_Cigarette or could it be that more symmetrical and defined features we find attractive are simply easier for the a.i to compute. I'd imagine a stranger looking person with more unique asymmetries and strange head shapes would be harder to arrange than the standard views of beauty given there's more imperfections to articulate
Yes, I noticed that. Considering that most of these portraits would have flattered the sitter, it should err in the other direction.
@@Gamba_with_Cigarette I'll put a picture of myself up there. That should bring the average down!
On top of the original artist that probably had to make them 80% more beautiful.
Even when the resemblance is extraordinary, the difference between a painted likeness and a 3D representation is like day and night.
Thank you for making some fascinating historical people seem real again, I'm sure they would love it.
This is so amazing to see these historical figures come to life.
Not so amazing though when some feel the need to act like an ass for no other reason to be one.
Beware of the last serial killer chick though..😂
But everything other than their frontal visage is entirely estimated. Really all you're seeing is an unpaid actor/actress dressing up like a painting
yes. ❤
its not though. It's seeing them through an ai stolen-image box to serve up what is mainstream.
I'm a grown man, in my early70s's tears have come to my eyes seeing theses beautiful come to life.
Pretty sure Donatello was a turtle
A ninja turtle 😂
😆
You’re thinking about Michaelangelo my man
Yes, and there are four of them 😁
Cuwabunga...! 🐢
Best Comment Ever 🤣
Beautiful! Actually it’s more than beautiful, knowing that these figures were real before has made it much more moving and heartwarming..
Not bad, but they look like Hollywood actors rather than real people. Its too styliszed and pretty.
💯
probably because the painting are also stylized and sanitized . Also they are the elite so they have access to beautification products and services. They are the equivalent of Hollywood stars of that time as they are the elite and famous.
They’re literal royalty. Of course they were beautified more than the average citizen.
This is probably what they really look like since portraits rarely do them justice.
Yeah the women have got modern western makeup.
I think a lot of renaissance European women had very pale makeup and heavily plucked eyebrows.
I find it beautiful to see those characters almost like living, thank you!
I think these renditions are amazing and beautiful artwork. I could watch your work for hrs
its not their works its the ai's
I enjoyed the entire video; we need more like it. The music was perfectly suited for the video, though it evoked a melancholic feeling. This feeling is commonly known as post-series depression or post-movie depression syndrome, which is a sense of sadness, emptiness, or grief that people may feel after concluding a movie, TV series, or book in which they were deeply engrossed.
The emotional impact of a story can be heightened by melancholic music or poignant scenes that highlight the characters' fates after pivotal events. It's a common emotional response as audiences form deep connections with the characters and the narrative, making it difficult to part with the story upon its conclusion. Although I realize stories cannot continue indefinitely, I often struggle with their endings. This is just who I am; it was difficult to bid farewell to the "Lost" TV series, and it's why I repeatedly watch the original "Dark Shadows" TV series whenever possible.
Brilliant! and the music sets the mood. Thank you!
Can't believe my eyes. Looks wonderful.
Truly outstanding work, and very lifelike. AI has come a long way in the last few years, but it takes someone with aesthetic awareness to produce this kind of art. Thank you!
Quite well done. Keep ‘em coming!
When replicating portraits, we need to remember they didn't have cosmetics in common use until the 1600s, and then, mostly in the French court. Elizabeth I wore makeup to cover her smallpox scars, but it wasn't used by members of her court.
naah
@@apriliashinta6075 What's even the point of your reply?
Close enough. All this complaining, it’s kind of frustrating. So what if it’s not perfectly accurate. The fact that this is even possible is a gift in itself.
Of course AI isn’t perfectly accurate. It’s AI. And I’ve learned that the more details you try to use, the more the AI messes up.
How come animated versions are always much more beautiful than their portraits?
AI can generate more lifelike versions than paintings.
Artists historically followed popular trends in schools of painting by more prominent artists in different countries depending on which one was most popular at the time. Artists also depicted their subjects according to their personal perspective and not as they actually were. That's why portraits painted by diffrrent artists at different time periods can look very different
Because those portraits r mostly paintings, tools of the time weren't offering fidelity.
The women in particular are generally given more generous mouths, reflective of more contemporary beauty ideals?
More uncanny, you mean
So so beautiful. Thankyou ❤❤❤🏴
Wow, just WOW!
Doesn’t take into account for skin shade, pimples, uneven skin colouration, or other imperfections that would be present but the painter politely left out. Most of the women painted in ancient times were teenagers. And a painter who wanted favour would flatter his subject.
among that most of them where covered with scars from ospa
Já lí em algum lugar que em alguns casos faziam um verdadeiro fotoshop,senão poderiam ficar com má fama ou ainda ,cabeças rolavam!!!
@@mariaizabeldealvarenga3907photoshop in the renaissance?
más bien al revés, en el pasado las personas de europa tenían la piel más blanca, todavía es posible verlo en mi propio país de españa en las zonas del norte sobre todo zonas rurales, donde la gente es literalmente tan blanca como una pared, esos rostros bronceados de la ai no son muy representativos de como se veía la gente de esa época
That "Elizabeth Bathory" looks happy, I'm sure she was a nice person!
Yes she was. Read the Hungarian wiki about here hu.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%A1thori_Erzs%C3%A9bet
Crazy, I always thought Donatello looked like a turtle
Yeah, and where’s his staff?
And Raphael and Michaelangelo and was there another one? I've forgotten, it was a long time ago and I'm 45 😂
@@UserUser-vo2ky Leonardo! That was my go to on Nintendo
kskksksk
Yes, I think you might be crazy.😄
These really are a stunning achievement. Mary of Guise’s lips are a bit thinner and more pursed and not so full and pretty as you have made them…but I’m sure she wouldn’t complain! Please please do Lettice Knollys, Countess of Essex and Elizabeth the 1st’s hated love rival and also Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, the man they fell-out over.
This was nice right up to Elizabeth Bathory. Then I got a chill down my spine.
Elizabeth Báthory, also known as the 'Blood Countess,' is a figure enveloped in a mix of historical fact and myth. The charges against her are serious, but it's vital to examine the context and the available evidence, or its absence, that surrounds her story.
First, many testimonies against her were extracted under torture, which casts doubt on their veracity. Furthermore, there was no solid physical evidence to directly connect her to the purported crimes.
The political environment of the era is also key. As a wealthy and influential noblewoman, Báthory was vulnerable to attacks from political adversaries who could benefit from her misfortune. Some scholars suggest that the charges were the result of a politically charged defamation campaign.
Additionally, the trial was notably unconventional, with Báthory being denied essential legal rights, including the use of torture to force confessions from her servants.
Recent scholarly work has added layers of complexity to her story, indicating that many tales about Báthory, like her alleged virgin blood baths, are more mythic than factual.
These considerations don't exonerate her but offer a more layered perspective on her case. Distinguishing between the established facts and the myths is crucial, taking into account the wider historical and political milieu.
And she looked so pleasant and dignified.
Elizabeth Bathory was probably wrongfully accused. She was a wealthy land-owner who refused to give up her land to men who wanted it, so they found a way to take it from her.
@@helbraheals I knew I would find "women did not do evil things; it was men's fault' comments like yours regarding Bethory, as women in the comment section always do about historical women. So modern women are capable of serial killing, but historical women are not? It's always the men's fault, huh?
Makes a lovely collection and ends it on an alleged serial killer.
That is incredible transformation into a beautiful realistic animation.
You brought Renaissance Master Donatello to life. The resemblance is amazing.
Kublai Khan, the only man in known history who could teach his warhorses to gallop backwards.
Seriously though this is stunning work. Imagine them comprehending that half a millenium later they'd be brought to life using AI tech.
I love Botticelli's art, I think I would have really fallen for him as a man.
He looks like the sort whom a man might fall for
These are amazing! In most cases, the AI seems to pretty much nail their likeness.
Thank you for making a series of this.
Don't know why but it made me cry
Maybe I missed something, or miss someone
thank you for love
Probably a past life.
perfect i love it.
Would be more interesting if the women weren't automatically given modern mascara and eye shadow... and were made up with more authentic white makeup of the period. This is just pointless.
Got you to view and comment, which was the point lol
I've always liked Mary of Guise. My wife looks just like her. The resemblance is uncanny 😊
That means your wife must be very pretty😊.
Wow that's so sweet 😁♥️
Anyone that's against ai should see this. We can bring history to life and make it relatable. I know people will say 'Why not get actors to play them in videos". Not everyone can afford actors or accurate costumes. This can be a great teaching tool for students.
These were idealised paintings. It's impossible to know what they really looked like
wow this is awesome! big fan!!
Incredible, it give a good general idea of what they very well could looked like.
Super fun to watch and learn something about each of them.
Absolutely amazing, seeing these people come to life. I thoroughly enjoyed watching, so beautiful to see !
Amazing thanks for giving a view into their appearances in real life. time Awesome
I always enjoy watching these. The only negative comment I have is that the recreations all have thicker and longer eyebrows.
I’m a history junkie and this is amazing. Subscribed 🤙
Very good, though could I suggest that next time you don't reverse the motion, as it breaks the illusion. Great, though!
Wow Thanks for this amazing video!! 😍📸❤❤❤❤❤ It was really good. The peoples was looking like they was really live in now!!
Absolutely amazing. Especially Marie de Guise and Agnes Sorel were so gorgeous ❤❤
How do we know these women didn’t have zits, uneven skin tone, dark or yellow complexions? Skin is essential for true beauty. No painter who cared about his career wouldn’t flatter his subjects by making them appear better than they were. Queen Elizabeth 1 had horrible small pox scars, yet not one painting shows this. Not much different than the tic toc filters heh ..?
@@LisaG442 In public they likely covered impurities up with lots of plaster.
Enjoyed thoroughly!
The women don’t resemble the portraits, they’re too glamorized
what do you think the portraits are?
Rather impressive!! Thanks for animating the people too! Can other paintings, say, of battles or other events "come to life"? The music you are using almost sounds like Lantz & Speers!
4:52 lol 😂no. No! 🤣
Excellent video.
Wow, the production is really beautiful. It would be the best if all the famous people in history, kings and emperors were all made into AI.❤
Absolutely Awesome
WOW ❤😊 Bravo 👏 Bravo 👏 on this 👏 you did an excellent job 👏 👍 on this. Words cannot do this post justice ❤ Wow Thanks for posting this 👏 ❤
2:52 they did her dirty 😅😅😅
How?
@@greysuit17 In the painting
@@kayannanorthover2888 but if that’s how she looked not really…. Your statement is funny.
So cool seeing these people brought to life probably the way they actually looked.
Agnès Sorel était blonde...aux yeux bleus...
mais le portait…
You have done very well with this video...Thank you.
Donatello is way off. AI even forgot the purple mask.
💀
@@MysticDivinerLJ is that because I'm dead funny?
Stunning!
Reducing the noise to almost zero, only then is this watchable.
Very well done 👍
I like Donatello!
Botticelli got them bedroom eyes! 😻
I'll be honest.
None of them look like their portraits, the AI only makes similar faces, and sometimes it doesn't respect skin color or lighting.
Yeah, but none of the portraits probably look like the real person either.
Agree. Smiliar clothes maybe but not face
Nicely done, BRAVO!💖
Why does AI insist on making the women smile but not the men, when most were not smiling in the painting? It feeds the rhetoric that women need to be seen as pleasing and welcoming. Even the serial killer was made to smile at the end!! Women do not have to smile to be acceptable.
AI is imitating who we are; “women should always smile”. We are a reflection of AI.
You should smile more sweetheart. No one likes a sour lady
So you’re a sourpuss feminist then?
@@jonthorson3997tf?
Keep in mind it could also be the “prompter” injecting that into the details. Other wise they could make sure they don’t. But paintings often never captured smiles. In reality the real person smiled from time to time.
Incredible! More please.
Bacana iii legal iii 😊😊😊❤❤❤
Nice faces👍
Thanks! I have seen wiith pleasure👍
AI really isn't helping our obsession with youth and unrealistic beauty
thank you. Truly amazing. Wow!
In my opinion, Donatello’s was the closest resemblance.
The other’s had slight nuances that didn’t quite match precisely.
the paintings are very old ' in some cases nothing to compare to
Pretty cool to see this though! Good work.
AI is so cool but creepy af
this is very biased no WAY do these people look like AI is making it its pretty neat but notice they make everyone look way MORE attractive then they actually looked if someone was attractive then they would look that way in the painting but dont forget that the times back in the day they didnt clean themselves and it was very dirty everywhere so they would be looking so nice and clean but i get it you wanna believe so bad that your able to bring stuff to life but its nonsense
words fall short to describe how amazing and thrilling theserenditions are; congratulations!
This is terrible the faces completely change into several different people as soon as they move and they don’t even resemble any of the source images anymore…
very good
wow this is amazing. what a great concept
Let me get this straight. You take an old painting, mix in some AI and present it as bringing an historical figure to life. And people are supposed to be in awe?
Great job!!!
AI WAS TOO KIND cause they was fuuugly in the paintings 😂
Incredible. . .if I didn't know any better I would think you're merely finding people who happen to look like those in the paintings.
technically did in a way, but they’re not real they’re made up
This looks great. Thank you
This is great. Of course it is not perfect and everybody looks a lot better than the probably looked like, but it nevertheless brings them to life and pushes them closer to us today. Although being an artist myself, I always find it hard to relate to painted people (I hope this somehow makes sense). Beautiful music as well, not too distracting.
If you allow me one question: what AI do you use for the different tasks of creating and animating these portraits? I would love to try that with some old photos of my long dead grandparents.
Bravo ! . Keep going the good work , mighty . Nice AI program ! .
Soooooooooooooperb ❤
Amazing 😮
Excellent video. I wikl watch more of your videos.
What a great work, bravo 👏
Your work is amazing
AI did it at least half but still
Amazing and absolute beautiful.
👏👏👏 Excelente.
The background music is so magical
So cool.
This is great, thanks!
This is actually really cool!
Brilliant, really enjoyed that
Amazing🤩