Rocky Handsome vs The Man From Nowhere | Fight Scene Reaction | John Abraham vs Won Bin | PESHFlix
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- Here is our reaction and review to 'Rocky Handsome' vs 'The Man From Nowhere' Best End Climax Final Fight Scene.
John Abraham vs Won Bin Fight Scene.
'Rocky Handsome' is a Bollywood action film starring John Abraham.
'The Man From Nowhere' is a Korean action film starring Won Bin.
'Rocky Handsome' (2016) Hindi Full Movie
'The Man From Nowhere' (2010) Korean Full Movie
Korean Movie Scene Reaction
Subscribe to PESH Entertainment: / peshentertainment
Twitter: / peshflix
Instagram: / peshflix
#RockyHandsome #TheManFromNowhere #JohnAbraham
The Man From Nowhere is fluid and smooth. It feels like a secret agent killing quickly and efficiently. Rocky Handsome feels like a Terminator fight. It is a big guy playing with sharp toys.
Yes.
*TMFN shows emotions, fatigue, and/or desperation on the people's faces. Both of good guy's and bad guys'.*
Every hit from TMFN is vital, in the organs, or in arteries. The good guy was getting swarmed by a bunch of bad guys but he kept using one of them as a meatshield to make them hesitate. It's not about just the good guy's acting, but the bad guys who are gangsters who never trained in the military like the good guy, you can see from their movements that they are very scared of the good guy and when they lash out with their knives, they swear profanity and swing large strokes which all feel desperate and sloppy, reciprocating the suspension of disbelief that the good guy is scary. That's why this feels more realistic. When sometimes there was too much violence they smartly cut out and had blood splatters off screen.
*Rocky is like a terminator, he doesn't show emotions.* He is a beautiful statue. Maybe Abraham is better for movies that play to this strength. I know Arnold would have been a terrible choice for movies like, Shawshank Redemption. They are just not his style. Maybe this movie should have gotten someone else instead of Abaraham.
In RH, where is all the blood? Even when they did show you the ppl getting shot and stabbed on screen, all they leave is a little hole and no blood splatters. Did you see that bad guy with a hammer holding a sledgehammer with an unrealistically large head? When he let it go he was holding it with one hand and still holding it upright. If you ever held a sledgehammer in real life you know how stubborn the heavy head is, you can never hold it like that. As it fell on the floor it clattered like a light piece of wood. :P
I do like how the final fight was more evenly matched though, and Rocky got more wounds. But maybe too much. He should not be able to shrug off a wound to the heart at the end.
You want realistic action then watch a war documentary. Nobody not even the most highly trained commando can kill 10-20 guys with guns in an open fight with knifes. The base of the action scene itself is unrealistic.
@@mrinal8169 I've seen your comment copied and pasted...I think people claim the fight in the Korean version just simply looks real I don't think they think that is how it actually works so I think telling them to watch a war documentary is just unnecessary
Right brother
@Ankit Debbarma Korean version is better than Bollywood
Indian version is so "Indian" exaggerated as usual. Man from nowhere is more realistic n skilled fighting! Indian one just copied the fight scene but couldn't copy the actual actor's skills.
That's a big man with no martial arts background being mentioned in the same conversation as a lifetime trained guy at least show some respect
A little bit biased I think the man from nowhere is way better 😂
korean version = reality
Indian version = fantasy
well said!
Indian one gives me john wick vibes
Indian version= way better than korean!!!
@@comrade3186 the indian version is trash
@Jason Duarte Man from nowhere is different from john wick of course john wick took some inspirations from a man from nowhere (It is very realistic even better than john wick when it comes to realism) but Indian one gives me those Hollywoodish vibes that I got from john wick
To address one thing, the reason why he didn't get injured in the last knife fight (MFN) is because of the fact that it was meant to be far more realistic and therefore any serious injury would mean almost certain death while in Rocky Handsome it was meant to be over-the-top and the main characters could sustain far more
I prefer realistic fight from man from nowhere
Seriously. Casually walking away from a knife fight with two chest wounds is not realistic. Pulling a knife out of your chest with your teeth and then, with it still in your teeth, using it to slit the throat of a guy who is holding a knife in your chest is not realistic. None of that silly shyte happened in MFNW which makes it more realistic with just that.
Lazarus Long
The perfect physique of John and his endurance along with his lots of training can do that. I'm talking about that uniqueness. This is not exaggerated, but perfectly balanced.
Lazarus Long
Also, ****From my opinion, this movie scene is far better than the original one 'A Man From Nowhere'.****
****I'm not a big fan of Indian movies, I'm actually a fan of 'Hollywood' movies and Asian (especially Chinese) movies. But this movie is exceptional. Because, people say certain Indian movies are made near equal/above/below Hollywood, but this one certainly and appreciably equaled Hollywood and the makers of this should be definitely proud where they should be awarded (including Oscar and others) for their 💯% proper research and hardwork for this movie! (A special note: Blood don't splash at the instance in these kind of fast and very technical cuts on the human body. This fight scene is at the most practical. This Indian movie actor name is 'John Abraham'! Some people are confusing and misspelling his name😒...) My claps with 'hats-off' for the decent and originality of this stunt coordination and entire movie team work ☝👌👍👏👏👏🙋🙌😎!****
(By the way, those people who are all saying that this 'Rocky Handsome' (Indian-Hindi) movie is a copy of a 'Korean' movie, you must understand this👉 ****It's not a copy. It's an official remake! There is a difference.****
****REMAKE and this is perfect!**** )
(On the contrary, John professionally trained many things for this scene itself and more in various countries! He's a daredevil in real life. If you have doubt, make your first move in front of him (closer) and then comment if you survived after that impact. A truck smash straight to anywhere of your body! Combat it is☝!)
I'm an Indian and I like Korean version wayyyy better.. in Indian version it's like bad guys are waiting for their turn to fight.. it's not realistic..
The man from nowhere is the best!!!
The Man From Nowhere is much better, more stylish and the choreography is superior. In Rocky Handsome there are too many unnecessary moves, plus, while in the Korean movie we have few one shot segments, here every scene and movement is cut into so many pieces that it displeases the eye and gives the impression that the fight is not real.
o6ina u clearly are biased and can't appreciate the art , Any unbiased person would say Those knife stabs are much more cooler and Badass
True, I'm biased by good cinema. I know art when I see it, dude. The rest is eye gum for blockbusters' lovers.
o6ina are u talking about the movie ?? I haven't seen either of them , I was just talking abt the Fight scene
I've seen "The Man From Nowhere" and liked it a lot. One of my personal top 10 action movies. I've tried "Rocky Handsome", but it didn't like it much. Maybe because the plot was already too familiar I don't know. About this particular fight scene, in RH it is over exaggerated. They aimed to make it more brutal, but there are so many cuts, that it is just not believable. To me, that means mediocre fight choreography and camera work.
o6ina I don't care about about the movie , haven't seen them but if I have to choose on fight scene , I'll go with Rocky handsome , it's much more cool and badass , I don't get why u being insecure abt TMFN , it's not about Comparison ,it's awesome too , I just liked this one more and I am a guy who likes Raid movies , Ip man and such movies so yeah for me RH is more interesting and that last Mouth kill is Epic 👌👌 ,
I am laughing at all these comments saying Rocky Handsome is better than The man from nowhere. What drugs are you on people?
@Umair Tallat My dear fellow if Rocky Handsome was an original Indian movie, nobody will say anything against, it but is a stupid copy to the dot and comma of the Korean hit "Ajeossi"or "The man from nowhere",which brings to surface what people without imagination and of low quality are there at the Bollywood studios,which is not really news to anybody outside India.
@Umair Tallat My dear fellow you have answer to me exactly as I would have expected you too,so your answer is not news to me ,sorry for being so cliche but you if know one Indian ,you know all of them,because you are such predictable losers.Take care buddy.
@Umair Tallat My dear fellow honestly if stupidity was a disease you would have died long a ago ,what is it with you are you a a parrot repeating back my words and what language are you using hinglish because it isn't English,I think you are spending much too much watching Bollywood third rate movies and you begin to think that you are one of their characters,is it really empty space or void between your ears?
@@MarianDiaconu-uk5cd It was an official remake.
Even "The Departed" starring Leonardo DiCaprio was a remake of a Hong Kong movie. The Departed even went to win multiple Oscars. Making Remakes is OKay
You want realistic action then watch a war documentary. Nobody not even the most highly trained commando can kill 10-20 guys with guns in an open fight with knifes. The base of the action scene itself is unrealistic.
I'm going to have to agree to disagree. Indian version may have more eye candy, but fight looked more like dancing and unrealistic. Korean version had better realism in tactics. It had no huge moves and super kicks nor posing between fights to look cool but every slash and stab was efficient. Korean actor's moves isolated other combatants to create 1vs1 by getting bad guys in the way to prevent them from overpowering him with numbers. Did I enjoy both? Yes. Indian version made me seat back and relax laughing with brutal violence, but Korean version had me on the edge of the seat with thrilling excitement. Personally, I would take Korean version since posing between fights and unrealistic fantasy like fight/dancing scenes are so 90s.
I agree with you.
Brother you need not explain what u like everyone have different taste
What dancing it's martial arts, a professional Indonesian martial artist was called to create the fight scenes in Rocky handsome so it's in every way realistic. And what's wrong with using kicks huh
@@smilekumar9002 STFU bollywood version is trash 🤮
@@smilekumar9002 Lol, have actually taken martial arts? Fight choreography for movies made by martial artist is nothing like real life. Rocky Handsome proves it. It’s pure Bollywood BS fantasy.
Korean version is the best one. Nobody could replace won bin. Won bin did legendary work. Infact every actor/actress of this korean version did marvelous acting.
Won Bin is a terrific Actor. If i dare say, one of the best Asian Actors out there. I have yet to watch a Movie where he isn`t outstanding. You should definitfly check out his other Work. I promise you, you won`t be dissapointed.
if you good looking you see jhon abraham acting is better
Won bin is a terrific actor??
In Korea now for my knowledge ji chang wook,, n Lee min ho ,
@@jaskiran-vb5zl John Abraham? A good actor? My wall can act better than him 🤣
Korean movie is better by the way can you pls comment other movies of Won Bin please
The Man From Nowhere is better because of the chemistry between the guy and the little girl plus the action isn't over the top like Rocky Handsome! Rocky Hamdsome looks like a remake
Walter Legrand
It is remake and he is muscular!
****From my opinion, this movie scene is far better than the original one 'A Man From Nowhere'.****
****I'm not a big fan of Indian movies, I'm actually a fan of 'Hollywood' movies and Asian (especially Chinese) movies. But this movie is exceptional. Because, people say certain Indian movies are made near equal/above/below Hollywood, but this one certainly and appreciably equaled Hollywood and the makers of this should be definitely proud where they should be awarded (including Oscar and others) for their 💯% proper research and hardwork for this movie! (A special note: Blood don't splash at the instance in these kind of fast and very technical cuts on the human body. This fight scene is at the most practical. This Indian movie actor name is 'John Abraham'! Some people are confusing and misspelling his name😒...) My claps with 'hats-off' for the decent and originality of this stunt coordination and entire movie team work ☝👌👍👏👏👏🙋🙌😎!****
(By the way, those people who are all saying that this 'Rocky Handsome' (Indian-Hindi) movie is a copy of a 'Korean' movie, you must understand this👉 ****It's not a copy. It's an official remake! There is a difference.****
****REMAKE and this is perfect!**** )
(On the contrary, John professionally trained many things for this scene itself and more in various countries! He's a daredevil in real life. If you have doubt, make your first move in front of him (closer) and then comment if you survived after that impact. A truck smash straight to anywhere of your body! Combat it is☝!)
@@canonboom165 Not to take anything away from the actors or anything, but Rocky Handsome almost looks like a parody of the original...
@@canonboom165 Oscars? For this? 😂😂 You must be delusional. I mean, The Academy has lost its relevancy, but let's not reduce it to that level. Also, for someone who doesn't like Bollywood, you know a lot about it 😂 Just say, you are a Bollywood fanatic who can't digest the truth and leave..
Won Bin severed the artery of the goon, hence the splattering of the blood. Last time I checked, arteries carry blood directly from the heart. 😂
creation is hard, copy is more easy. that's it.
Hahaha but to make a copy better than the original and in some parts different also is not that easy but yes the root of idea will always be appreciated
अगर औरजिनल फिल्म दमदार हो तो कापी करने नीले।कभी उसकी बराबरी नहीं कर पाते
What about the action?
Won bin acting ia better than john,
@High on Acids yes
This is like comparing a Tarantino movie with a Marvel movie. The Korean version is the original from 2010 and it is IMO much better. It influenced many other similar movies such as "John Wick" and "Equalizer". The scene where Won Bin gets suited up all in black filmed from the back was replicated in "John Wick" frame by frame. Hollywood always steals from Asia, nothing new. Also, it is hilarious that one of the two dudes has an Indian accent saying how the Indian version is much better. lmao, I find the lack of knowledge and research a bit annoying, and I'm not even Korean. Won Bin is a very respected actor, who played in different types of movies such as "Mother", where he played a boy with a mental disorder, directed by Bong Joon-Ho, the director of "Parasyte", "Memories of a Murder" and many other great movies. I had absolutely no idea till this very moment who John Abraham is but he seems like an Indian version of The Rock. If you want to see a really good movie with great music watch "The man from nowhere". If you are on a high-protein diet watch "Rocky Handsome". lol
its like korea=UFC vrs bollywood =WWE. and i like the korean version.
Wow well said
India made much worse than that called ring ka king
@SAI KESHAV MAHANKALI Wrong. I'm Indian. Chutia
I like the real one and it’s Korean. not copied lol
Absolutely the man from nowhere because you can see how professional won bin's acting is and the storyline is inspiring just at the scene when tae sik cried and shouted after he saw his wife was killed tragically by the car crash, expressed his desperation, tried to commit suicide, and shed his tears after so mi hugged tae sik while crying
Are you two crazy? The remake is better? U two need more exposure to movies. That’s it.
I'm Indian and I find that
won Bin fight is smooth, convincing and surprising.
While in Indian version
Jhon Abraham is clearly big bear playing with wolfs so it's also eyes pleasuring ass whooping.
So it's depend upon choices of smooth fight or badass fight.
I couldn't help but laugh out loud when at 13:28 he stab that mans arms like a little girl chopping vegetables lmao
It's funny how some people say "Thin guy can't fight that many people that good"
Many Asians are generally thin physique. And it is true he is on the thin side but not on skinny chopstick thin where you really can't fight that many people that good.
He is thin compare to the other movie's actor but his physique is not how those people described to be "body that can't really fight that many people"...
I'm not sure if they watched the whole movie or not but... yeah.
And I've actually seen people with big physique and bulky body can't really fight that long and that good either and skinny people with really great strength so I hope those people start think little more before they just blurt out whatever
Then why are there weight categories in Boxing, Wrestling, Judo etc?
The original Korean movie received 100% on Rotten Tomatoes...where as the Indian remake received 0%. The Korean original version's cinematography of Lee Tae Yoon is still regarded as one of the best action sequence in action filming.
The Korean version is much better. See the whole movie before posting reviews.
I like both movies. But ... Yeahhh The korean one is the original and I like it more. The feeling is much better.
The original version (The man from nowhere) better than remake version
haha. what a joke. I can see their taste. The guy with the red shirt has no clue of what he is talking.He is just moving his mouth. Btw Korean version which is the original version is way much bettter than Indian version. Even the movie itself is way better.
He just moving his mouth! 🤣 damn true!
The original is soooooo much better
@Cannabis Queen lol! rocky handsome is a shit u bollywood moron
@@tanimhasan4555 shut up saaaor🐷🐷🐷
@@tanimhasan4555 Rocky handsome is brutal and better that's why everyone is reacting to it... No one is reacting to korean version hahaa
@@zieus972 korean version is underrated and your bollywood version is overrated shit
@@tanimhasan4555 I m sure you are from Pakistan ha haa........ Lol
The man from nowhere is the best u feel the sadness to his face about that eye💔
TBH , 'The man from nowhere' is one of my favourite Korean movie, I was so scared hearing that Bollywood is making official remake of it, I probably thinking that they will ruined it and I didn't watch the Rocky Handsome.. but at least they tried .. hands down to 'The man from nowhere ' and is the only movie lead me to Korean movies.
korean version is better. look realistic, brutal, and emotional. rocky handsome is just like a martial art demo.
Syamsil Adri bcz in rocky handsome john is a trained martial assasain killer
Well the scene is average nonetheless lol
Shubham Bashera You do realize they’re both trained killers right?
@@KhiemNguyen-ly1wz man from nowhere he was military special force agent he learn to kill enemy without any sympathy and have special martial skill and everyone in military know that he is someone u should not joke around they keep his profile even police don't know him.. He the top killer in his military special force agent
Rocky Handsome is very Funny. There is no sorrow in the look of Abraham. It's like a martial arts demonstration.He stick a lot excess of swords at people, and the villains do not fight.
The villains open their arms and receive the sword whole body. I enjoyed it very much.
bb koobo you said what i exactly want to say
I feel ashamed of some Indian brothers barking here. So what if TMFN is better than RH? Indeed true that the Korean version is way better than RH. Just admit it guys. There is no reason to fight.
Honestly the Man from nowhere is way much better.... hands down!
I agree, but they did give it a good effort with the remake. I can't say it was great, but it wasn't a piece of junk that I thought it would be, a decent remake. So, yes Man from nowhere was better, but Rocky Handsome (dumb title) was pretty darn good.
Hi, Im Korean. in my opinion, both have good and weakness points so u guys dont need agressive debate.
In Korea, more than 90% male go to milliary service for more than 2 years, cuz we are fight vs North Korea. this situation is just stopping not finished. So if ballywood style like RH, we know that act is not specialist move. if u guys wanna to kill somebody you dont need to big weapon and body. many of special force milliary services crew dont much have big guys especally, top class agencts.
but many of Indian or other contries people dont have that information. so RH can feel much friendly and ez to understand better.
So i think that differences are cultural differences. and you guys have to think the main actor's job is not 'Rambo'. He is secret agency. that is main point of that act, realistic and why the actor's body is normal size.
InKwang Song you are a level-headed person.....and yes the difference is in the culture...
InKwang Song You make very good points. Thank you.
InKwang Song Great explaination brother, i also didn't know that much .So thanks for telling the whole thing. At last both were very nice, but the Korean one was little better than that. Love from India
InKwang Song 딱 내가 생각하던건데ㅋㅋ
The differences are not cultural. The thing is Indians when they go to watch movie they like pumped up and brutal shit. We believe that Films are a fantasy of ours. So our films the Actor is gonna do things that no man can coz those are our fantasies. Of course we know that it is less realistic but it gives us that special adrenaline rush.
We also know about Military. We are always at conflict with Pakistan and China. Just that Films are a way for us to go into the world of fantasy. They are our gateways to fantasies. Both Korean and Indian versions are good I believe.
The Man From No Where is definitely better, considering the main actors emotions and ofc the action scene. I was really upset about you guys watching it dubbed tho. Took so much from the experience. Also the blood actually wasn't overlydone. He was cutting their weins and organs not just cutting/ He knew where to it exactly. Plus he did get injured about 3-4 times.
I also found it so funny how in Rocky the enemies were showing up one by one. So unrealistic.😂😂😂 Actually the Bollywood version did not have better knife sequence. It was not technical but instead impactful (strength based no real technique but flashy) which again is not realistic but action acting. I mean they could have killed the main guy if it wasn't one by one 😂
Worldwide Handsome Jin's Flying Kiss 13:30 There you go. He's fighting with 2 guys simultaneously rendering your argument invalid. Also he's taking injury but being strong and highly trained in combat he fights through it. Man from nowhere was great but he took no injuries in it and the fight with the Karambit guy was very "meh"
Yea. Fought 2 guy *once* , complete invalid. Let's ignore the fact that they still come after another, just faster that time.
" he's taking injury but being strong and highly trained in combat he fights through it. "
Lol in real life. He's fucked right at the first shot taken.
"Man from nowhere was great but he took no injuries in it"
You're blind.
4:39 slight cut at his arm 4:55 bat hit his leg 5:30 that guy stabbed him and stuck his knife there for a while.
"fight with the Karambit guy was very meh"
holy shit opinion.
Making excuses to prove that original is better than remake won't change reality😂
@@nishanttripathi7209 true
Only thing I didn't like in man from nowhere is camera work that's all
The man from nowhere is much better..
The south korean is more realistic
the indian actor is a real martial artist
@Cannabis Queen original is way better.
I agree. Indian version has hero shooting people without even looking their way. Even though both scenes were improbable , Korean version felt real.
Also the music in the Korean version added a lot.
@@avinash_7x170 the korean actor is also real martial artist too. He doing his own stunts. He even jumped up from the building with glass on w/o stunt
My hubby is a neurosurgeon and we both love Man from Nowhere. We own it and watched several times. The last fight scenes at least 10 times.
In the last fight scene, I asked him the same question. Yes, it sqirts if you go after the arteries. The main character only cut the arteries of all the bad guys bc one it is deadly and second, you cannot recover unless you are in operation table within 10 mins. It is a painful way to die but very effective and efficient. The Korean guy knew exactly where to slash with his knife whereas in RH, he didn’t just go for the arteries like the Korean movie. I felt the RH was too showy than realistic
real knife fighting martial artists review and said the same that its real fighting and efficient way of killing. high level special ops learn this filipino knife fighting combat
is this even a topic of debate??what is world coming to!!
I mean Man From Nowhere was such a big hit in Korean industry that it was officially remade for indian audience with addition of songs.
I am totally against copying and remake....its like taking someone hardwork and credit away especially of that of writers who write scripts...I feel for them.
I liked rocky handsome but come'on it is no way better than MFN.
Best example is martial art is part of Korean culture ...this fight sequence somewhat reflects their culture.
Well thank you Arvin Yadav.
I think you are not hypocrate.
The man from nowhere is better. More realistic.
You have to watch the two movies first, personally the Korean is much better and it is in 2011
SS man from nowhere much much better... Realistic the acting was superb im not a korean but man from nowhere is one of my best film that ive ever watch👍👍👍💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
In 2010
Yes cos you haven't seen the remake.
It s 2010
@@elalamarr1166 I've watched both of them. And TMFN remains superior. Not saying RH was bad though.
I'm an Indian And I love Kpop and Kdrama a lot.
And yes!!! Original version is best 💜💜💜
The man from nowhere is the og. That get u in your feels for days
The rocky handsome one was very choreographed but the weakness was that you could see that the actors went slow so the entire sequence would not screw up. If they increased the tempo, it would look more "realistic".
In terms of the two, Man from Nowhere shows WOn Bin getting hit (1 slice and 1 bat to the leg) which brings into focus why he kept moving and forcing everyone to chase him. His attacks were also straight and to the point other than the guy he sliced on the wrist, which was an intimidation move.
Rocky handsome's issue was that the multiple stabs were of no real use because the final move was the one which was the fatal one.
In terms of pure brutality, Man from Nowhere wins because the fight doesn't try to extend itself and Won Bin's character is out to kill efficiently. The fight is short, to the point and the actors act much like what you would expect (the wild swings by the last guy alive before the one on one was good).
In terms of looking badass. Rocky Handome wins but Hollywood already has plenty of badass fights and posing, eg the Die Hard series
I like the fluidity of he guy from korean..the lead actor of india looks like a robot fighting scene
비교하지 마라.니가 좋아하는걸 그냥 즐겨라. 비교 자체가 오리지널에 대한 모독이다.
Every Indian in this comment section be like: rocky handsome is better!!
You guys should watch full version of the original one. Won bin's acting (korean actor) is not a joke. He even got award from this movie. I already watch it for several times and never fails to get me emotional.
The remake version better... Really ? The remake is a disgrace to a classic...
Nicholas Blanchard
STFU!
I agree with you nicholas the original one is one of my favourte movies because its really emotional and has better fight scene unlike rocky handsome where everyone flies around the one after one punch in the face
I agree with you
@@canonboom165 why?You can't digest the truth?
@@humayrafaizah1428 no because you can't digest the truth don't be biased and you will find the remake version lot better than the original one
So... Indians like Rocky, everyone else like The Man from Nowhere. Here you go.
Evgeniy Deus
Not all Indians. Just the ones who are a fan of John Abraham and Bollywood in general.
lol.. kid watch the other reactions of people from diff. country ull know which one is better xD
Indians don't care about the subject matter. Anything indian, they like it and think thats the best. They don't have any sense of judgement
Gyati Tako says the one who's fucking judgemental about a whole country
I like Rocky Hansome and I'm Asian. Nothing beat Bollywood fighting. Its just like watching a super hero movie. It have its own style. Like it when the main character can catch almost every punch from the bad guy before attacking him back. Its like the whole purpose of the bad guy was to let the hero catch or block his attack and get own in return. Its just like old school comic book fights. The only thing I don't like is the singing part. Its like there gotta be singing in every movie. In America, we call those musical. There is singing in war movie, love movie, crime movie, horror movie, and etc. I love it when the hero just got done killing bad guys and you feel pump up only sec later to see him singing and dancing. You be like ok tough guy nice going. I pay to see a war or bloody movie not a musical.
I like a man from no where.. looks realistic
Vikas Yadav what i know rocky handsome looks so bad comparing to the man from nowhere
Vikas Yadav whatever first is best in any situation... original one is feels better
alghoog can u explain how? or u r just one of those Indians who think anything foreign is way better than Indian things
I'm not saying this because I'm Korean but, even if I was Indian, I would still have to go with The Man from Nowhere. The realism in the execution of fight sequence is simply a level up over RH.... just damn too much to not notice it....
Korean version looks more real, RH is overboard
I am indian
The Man form nowhere better 🖤
I am genuinely concerned you actually thought the Indian version was better. HAHA good joke.
Cuz hes indian.
We're seeing some quite split opinions on this. Although the setting feels a bit different, atmosphere different, the actors are different, to my eyes at least, the Korean version delivers better emotional depth on that scene. I don't know about the overall movie, but if we were to critique on this scene only, I think The Man from Nowhere was directed better, the actor delivered better sentiments on this scene which is absolutely necessary in this movie as this is part of the climax leading into the end of the movie. I think this shares the same genre in the action film category with the Bourne series just action-wise. Scenario-wise, it would be closer to the Taken series. What I'm trying to say is that although the film primarily provides pleasure through its action scenes, it provided much more than just visual pleasure because of its scenario well directed throughout the movie as well as the depth of emotions the main character was able to play.
the Korean version is better one. won bin is awesome👍
Ramjith Babu in youf dreams
@@noseopm I agree the Korean version adds more suspense and thriller to the movie compared to the fuck you that is rocky handsome opening scene I want to sing you a song about how I love I mean who does that?!
Myself personally, Man from nowhere hands down! Reason being is that that the fight sequence kept moving and was fluid. Rocky Handsome, when one person would attack, he'd block their strike and just stand there for him to jab them with his knife as if it was too convenient for him. Even when they were shooting at him, he walked casually to take cover rather than the Man from Nowhere where he still kept a tactical approach to taking cover.
Yes...He was walking normally....that's called being badass..lol
unrealistic
Yeah man thats was badass totally..I like that too. That's how u fight when u have muscle power
Sammy Mackletraveranderson
Muscle practicality💪💪💪☝👍!
Hector Acuna
Yes. True. Badass it is💪☝👏👏👏👍!
****From my opinion, this movie scene is far better than the original one 'A Man From Nowhere'.****
****I'm not a big fan of Indian movies, I'm actually a fan of 'Hollywood' movies and Asian (especially Chinese) movies. But this movie is exceptional. Because, people say certain Indian movies are made near equal/above/below Hollywood, but this one certainly and appreciably equaled Hollywood and the makers of this should be definitely proud where they should be awarded (including Oscar and others) for their 💯% proper research and hardwork for this movie! (A special note: Blood don't splash at the instance in these kind of fast and very technical cuts on the human body. This fight scene is at the most practical. This Indian movie actor name is 'John Abraham'! Some people are confusing and misspelling his name😒...) My claps with 'hats-off' for the decent and originality of this stunt coordination and entire movie team work ☝👌👍👏👏👏🙋🙌😎!****
(By the way, those people who are all saying that this 'Rocky Handsome' (Indian-Hindi) movie is a copy of a 'Korean' movie, you must understand this👉 ****It's not a copy. It's an official remake! There is a difference.****
****REMAKE and this is perfect!**** )
Rocky Handsome's fight scenes look like actors practicing their choreography. It's also just cheesy as fuck and totally lacking in realism. It's one of the many reasons it has a 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. Meanwhile, The Man From Nowhere has a perfect 100%.
won Bin is life💖💖
Korean version way better and more believable. Bolly wood version sucks trying to do spin kicks and all these extra move, not realistic. Remember, the character is suppose to be special forces or cia of some sort. They teach realistic self defense not that bullshit in the Bollywood version. The knife play was ok but over done. The Korean version shows where he slices...its all on the tendons to handicap someone and arteries to kill. the Bollywood one show him stabbing these guys more then three times. not believable at all...just to make ppl say the scene was cool.
The man from nowhere is better
😯😯😯
For people who prefer RH, more is more. RH has a bigger hero, the movements are bigger, there are more bad guys, each bad guy gets stabbed more times, and the fight lasts longer. For people who like MFN, less is more. Won Bin is smaller, he moves faster, his movements are efficient and economized, and he kills the baddies with only a couple of stabs each. It's not surprising that Bollywood audiences who grew up on 3+ hour long movies with song and dance numbers like RH for being over-the-top. Meanwhile, western and asian action flicks are undergoing a transformation from the explosions and bullet-fests of Die Hard and John Woo, to tight fight choreography and proper gun discipline (e.g. compare the James Bond of Daniel Craig to that of Pierce Brosnan). So it's also not surprising that western and asian audiences tend to favor MFN. In the end, your preferences are largely based on the aesthetics that you are used to.
The Man From Nowhere English dubbed is weird lol
Ventus Tarango tot agree. Too high and too energetic voice compared to original ver.
I like both, the Bollywood style and Korean cinema style are different, some people like one more than the other. "The Man From Nowhere" (the original) is fluid and smooth, Wu Bin is not only a great actor but also a legit Martial artist. In "Rocky Handsome" (the remake), John Abraham is a great action actor, fit and big but not a Martial artist, so the scenes have more cuts and choreography is gory to make up for the fact he's not as quick and natural in the moves as Wu Bin. In "The Man from Nowhere" it is a former Special Ops killing quickly and efficiently. "Rocky Handsome" feels like a Terminator fight: a big guy playing with sharp weapons.
The Indian version looks Cringey, Cheesy, and Corny as hell, starting from the title, no offence. Bollywood, the copycats, no creativity, no originality. And no wonder both of you are bollywood fans. 😂🤣😂🤣😂 Masala level 101.😂🤣😂
The Man From Nowhere was the masterpiece and more realistic than Rocky Handsome... I like John Abrahams movies but compared to Korean movies... Indians still need improvements
factfeeder777 actually indian movies are more grossing and yeah they need to improve
factfeeder777 I think john did good for a model turned actor and the korean guy did two years in military and he knows martial arts
ibrahim chy you fool what do you know about john.He is undergone rough, hardcore and brutal training of Silat (Indonesian-Malaysian martial arts) and Yong Chung (a Chinese Martial Art) in thailand for 3 months(14-16 hours daily) see the level of hardwork he put forth only for seen of 10 minutes in a movie,could that korean guy do that.
factfeeder777 they r both okay indian they don't need an inprovement that wat they r
factfeeder777 India film industry don't need improvement that much.... They have the best movies and musics
I like the Korean version better
hummm, The Man From Nowhere is the best
Rocky moves like robocop LOL😂😂
that rocky handsome was so extra. lols
im fan of both but ill go with A MAN FROM NOWHERE
Ofcourse Bollywood version is fine tuned and John did a great job. But the Korean version was like a raw fight.
Bhanu Prakash
Yep👍!
Bhanu Prakash
****From my opinion, this movie scene is far better than the original one 'A Man From Nowhere'.****
****I'm not a big fan of Indian movies, I'm actually a fan of 'Hollywood' movies and Asian (especially Chinese) movies. But this movie is exceptional. Because, people say certain Indian movies are made near equal/above/below Hollywood, but this one certainly and appreciably equaled Hollywood and the makers of this should be definitely proud where they should be awarded (including Oscar and others) for their 💯% proper research and hardwork for this movie! (A special note: Blood don't splash at the instance in these kind of fast and very technical cuts on the human body. This fight scene is at the most practical. This Indian movie actor name is 'John Abraham'! Some people are confusing and misspelling his name😒...) My claps with 'hats-off' for the decent and originality of this stunt coordination and entire movie team work ☝👌👍👏👏👏🙋🙌😎!****
(By the way, those people who are all saying that this 'Rocky Handsome' (Indian-Hindi) movie is a copy of a 'Korean' movie, you must understand this👉 ****It's not a copy. It's an official remake! There is a difference.****
****REMAKE and this is perfect!**** )
(On the contrary, John professionally trained many things for this scene itself and more in various countries! He's a daredevil in real life. If you have doubt, make your first move in front of him (closer) and then comment if you survived after that impact. A truck smash straight to anywhere of your body! Combat it is☝!)
Korean version=UFC=real
Indian version=WWE=fake
Which is better? Up to your preference.
The man from nowhere is stunning visual visceral treat .
the man from no where is much better than RH
this is so unfair decision ...korean version is too much better than indian version
Madan Limbu
It's a fair and fact based decision on both levels.
Abraham already put his forearm up to protect enemies’ attack even they didn’t attack him. XD
This was nuts to say the remake is better. THE ORIGINAL IS BETTER. End of story.
I like Rocky handsome fight scene❤️❤️❤️
The director of the Korean version, 아저씨(The Man from Nowhere), used to be an amateur Taekwondo player, but there is no kicks in the film because the director persued a REALISTIC movie.
Even one of the martial arts in the scene, Krav Maga, is one of the killing skills officially adopted by South Korean special forces tier 1(HID, UDU, AISU) and tier 2(SWC, UDT, CCT).
Man from nowhere is more realistic in fighting while other one is just more violent and not realistic. There is no comparison in cinematography or music. I like original so much better, but this is better version of knockoff from Bollywood.
korean movie is better and more stylish...but why bollywood actor,director everything so boring make your own movie come on.
Korean version is so much better than indian one👏👏👏👏
That dwarf will not survive one proper punch and the director wants me to believe he can every man in that room
In action, too much cut scene is not good to watch like Rocky Handsome . I like Korean version is more look nature and realistic. And in martial arts, size of body or muscle is not means that he can fight better.
Then why do have weight categories in Wrestling, Judo, Boxing etc ?
Well its a sport, fair game.. anyways killing people is not about size.. its about speed and mind, strong imagination is a weapon itself
The original is good for solid and realistic fights, the remake is great for seeing a power fantasy. I like them both
They didn’t like the Original cause the actor has smaller build than the ripoff. What?!?!?!! They watch rocky the handsome in its OG language but not The Man From Nowhere.
Korean version is wayyyy better because it's realistic and original....
Lavi Taufoa ...okay so...Blood coming out of a wrist like tap water...looks more realistic to you.....😅😅😅
Holy fuck. You are everywhere nitpicking stupid stuff.
Sammy Mackletraveranderson ...okay just forget it
RahulMcLaren Lazarus Yes because that’s generally what happens when you cut an artery.
Lavi Taufoa
Man from nowhere way better much more realistic Koreans make amazing action movies
Rocky Handsome has only one advantage.
The advantage is not to dance while fighting.
i thought that rocky handsome was comedy genre film like 'scary movie'.
In this movie, Most murder skills are learned from Korean Special Forces.
the man from no where is the best because they created this movie 2010
Rocky handsome is kinda unrealistic how everyone waits for him to do his cool kill on one dude and after he kills then they wanna go
if your saying Rocky Handsome is unrealistic then have you even watched other bollywood movies like dabang baaghi etc. they are totally unrealistic. Bollywoodwas never very good at action. But yeah i agree the man from nowhere is better than the remake
bigger doesn't mean stronger just look more stronger
Ikon kim the korean actor looks gay in front of john abraham lol
Jc L but in real life john would beat the shit out of him
Emere Mor
I doubt it, John doesn't know ho2 to fight in real life.
+Emere Mor lol That gay ass guy literally went through 2 years of military service, you fucking idiot.
I kinda agree, his Voice sounds kinda gay in the english synchro. Watch the korean version, at least this scene. Much better.
so these two think that obviously fake looking stabbing action scenes are better than the original honestly WHAT? RH action scenes are joke when dudes are simply being shot, stabbed, and kicked, there is no pain in any of the scenes aaaaaaand to say the remake is better cuz it's slower are these guys even aware of the fact that the man is a former special force soldier?
john park they dont care because they're part hindu 😂
Man from nowhere is original. and of course it's better
rocky handsome is more fantastic but not realistic. Just it like show. They acted big too much unnecessary and played each other. I think someone likes this, other likes that as their favor. but ya i acknowledge a man from no where is more cruel. And then we can not say which is better. It just depends on watcher.
wow!! the man from nowhere is one reference from John wick while the Indian version just remake it is distinctly different. creographically, the Korean version of fighting is more natural and this reality this is like comparing the action of Bruce Lee vs. vin diesel very clearly different class
man from nowhere is better IMO :/ indian remake look so unrealistic
aniket Sharma your opinion is shit to me... just keep you fucking shitty opinion to yourself... Man from nowhere is better!!!!!!
Grevexx Vexxon why dont we meet fair and square instead of being a key board warrior let go me and u
Sarpanch Bai only pistol lmao... come to Jacksonville ,Florida... i am waiting for you ;) i don't have Facebook btw
The Rocky Hansome version looked like it was poorly choreographed by someone used to choreographing Bollywood dances. Some sequences felt as if he was about to start dancing and singing.
While in the Korean version, it seemed the girlish actor will start doing pole dancing 🤣🤣🤣
@@mrinal8169 …girlish actor?? what exactly about him is girly??
There's no realism in Indian version that's the problem. And choreography looks very choreographed. It's like counting steps. And Abraham's acting is so wooden.
That's exactly what I thought. I swear I could literally see the guy in the Indian version counting steps and stabs lol 1,2,3 duck...his movements did not flow together at all and all those cuts had my eyes hurting lol
hallie i didn't knw that u were the flash
so blood flowing out like fountain seems realistic to u? and most of the fight scenes with actors like jackie chan,jet li,tom yung gong etc look choreographed so according to u those are also "unrealistic" according to u
Go ask special force person who done knife fighting. This scene there is by far one of the most realistic knife fighting portrayed in the movies. And the flow is much more natural whereas in Rocky Handsome you can see hits not connecting and Abraham counting the steps. If you can't see that, something wrong with your sensibility and you've been watching way too many exaggerated fights to not see the diff.. Outside Bollywood, that sequence in Rocky Handsome isn't special at all. Yes, the blood flow may be exageration but not the fight sequences.
Xentradi97 u must be stupid to not realise that the attitude and way of fighting of both the actors were different,in Korean version the actors was mostly slashing his enemies with a few stabbing too just to give them a painful death while in RH John was mostly stabbing and his acting looked wooden cause that's what he was supposed to do i.e. act emotionless and that counting thing is plain stupid point which u got from that dickhead's comment who thinks he is either a flash or some stunt expert and by d way many stunt expert have seen this sequence and thought of it as genuine
The Indian version is so robotic and the fake looking. The remake just looked so corny.
I really miss Cybertron...
Indian version of Terminator. Watch out!
I really miss Cybertron...
****From my opinion, this movie scene is far better than the original one 'A Man From Nowhere'.****
****I'm not a big fan of Indian movies, I'm actually a fan of 'Hollywood' movies and Asian (especially Chinese) movies. But this movie is exceptional. Because, people say certain Indian movies are made near equal/above/below Hollywood, but this one certainly and appreciably equaled Hollywood and the makers of this should be definitely proud where they should be awarded (including Oscar and others) for their 💯% proper research and hardwork for this movie! (A special note: Blood don't splash at the instance in these kind of fast and very technical cuts on the human body. This fight scene is at the most practical. This Indian movie actor name is 'John Abraham'! Some people are confusing and misspelling his name😒...) My claps with 'hats-off' for the decent and originality of this stunt coordination and entire movie team work ☝👌👍👏👏👏🙋🙌😎!****
(By the way, those people who are all saying that this 'Rocky Handsome' (Indian-Hindi) movie is a copy of a 'Korean' movie, you must understand this👉 ****It's not a copy. It's an official remake! There is a difference.****
****REMAKE and this is perfect!**** )
(On the contrary, John professionally trained many things for this scene itself and more in various countries! He's a daredevil in real life. If you have doubt, make your first move in front of him (closer) and then comment if you survived after that impact. A truck smash straight to anywhere of your body! Combat it is☝!)
Agree with you..and damn the reaction, The man from nowhere is an originality works, looks real and more important theres the emotional things goin on.. whats with all the dissaproving sign..and i thought they might have the same type of mindset with the RH director..bunch of amateurs giving off the reaction without knowing a damn real fights
True but the John Abraham one iz still better despite the corny ness
It's OK man, epic things are out of your understanding levels😅😅😅😂😂