The Mysterious Creature Of The Skull Cluster - 40K Theories

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 янв 2025

Комментарии • 645

  • @5680009
    @5680009 5 лет назад +1030

    "Surely the Imperium would not be so incompetent...".
    You underestimate the incompetence of the Imperium.

    • @robertnelson9599
      @robertnelson9599 5 лет назад +76

      The government is a "frozen sea of ineptitude".

    • @DharkDemonBlade
      @DharkDemonBlade 5 лет назад +119

      There is no such thing as efficiency, only varying degrees of incompetence.

    • @Tacoguy1000
      @Tacoguy1000 5 лет назад +15

      @@DharkDemonBladeI see what you did here...

    • @ridethetiger9092
      @ridethetiger9092 5 лет назад +12

      Dhark Angel The necrotic Empire of the False Corpse-Emperor of Mewling Mankind is barely able to distinguish it’s ass from a hole in the void.

    • @DISTurbedwaffle918
      @DISTurbedwaffle918 5 лет назад +29

      In the grim dariness of the far future, there is only debilitating bureaucracy.

  • @Sereze001
    @Sereze001 5 лет назад +266

    Whatever is in that hive it's either:
    A) Too dangerous to attack
    B) Too valuable to destroy

    • @CloseingStraw97
      @CloseingStraw97 4 года назад +32

      or C) all the above

    • @bobmilaplace3816
      @bobmilaplace3816 4 года назад +20

      I think its a Primarch, they are hoping he snaps out berserker rage.

    • @dinodude6992
      @dinodude6992 4 года назад +16

      Ahhhh....
      It be a toaster

    • @joelschneider4529
      @joelschneider4529 3 года назад +17

      Men of Iron Guarding a STC fragment?

    • @scottross5495
      @scottross5495 7 месяцев назад +1

      What happens on Necromunda stays on Necromunda.

  • @Warrior-Of-Virtue
    @Warrior-Of-Virtue 5 лет назад +437

    Maybe the Imperial Fists are covering up what's happening in the Skull Cluster because whatever they found would be considered grounds for exterminatus.

    • @commie4164
      @commie4164 5 лет назад +75

      anything and everything is grounds for exterminatus, including ork invasions. once a single ork lands on a world, that world will always have an ork population, as it is virtually impossible to fully exterminate them due to their physiology.
      so what determines if a planet gets sterilized or not, is the value the planet has to the imperium. necromunda is extremely valuable for its output of both manpower and material, so it is not a viable target for exterminatus.

    • @Rammkommando
      @Rammkommando 5 лет назад +30

      @@commie4164 come on come all the yearly ork hunt and defence is starting

    • @flense-x1z
      @flense-x1z 5 лет назад +24

      @@commie4164 I wouldn't say it's just the value of the planet that determines exterminatus, but the threat on the planet weighed in comparison to the value. So most likely whatever the Imperial Fists are covering up isn't dangerous enough to warrant further action let alone exterminatus. I can see why too, the planet is stacked with defenses and forces, it would take a serious threat taking them by surprise to make them even think about exterminatus.

    • @commie4164
      @commie4164 5 лет назад +16

      @@flense-x1z there are only two threats off the top of my head that would not be immediately considered great enough for exterminatus. a non chaotic anti imperial uprising, a peasants revolt that they could simply send in arbites or pdf forces to crush. and a non ork, non tyranid xenos invasion, that again they could simply deploy standard forces or some astartes to counter.
      literally anything else would result in the planet being glassed unless there is enough value on the planet in some form to warrant fighting for it in a conventional manner.
      hell when the planet vraks rebelled against the imperium, at the start it was just a peasants revolt, it became tainted by chaos later, but in the beginning there was nothing of the sort, at least as far as the imperium was aware.
      yet there were literally people advocating for the planet to be destroyed by exterminatus, for a simple peasants revolt, and the only reason they didnt was because it was determined that the stockpiles of ammunition, supplies, weapons, and vehicles were too valuable to waste.

    • @Sir_Bucket
      @Sir_Bucket 5 лет назад +7

      @@commie4164 dat's why we da best! Ya can nevar truly beat da orks! We'z alwayz win!

  • @dwreanchinotan
    @dwreanchinotan 5 лет назад +494

    perhaps something no one has seen yet. an unreleased entry into the "WHY DO PEOPLE LIVE HERE?!" book of necromunda

    • @jmagowan12
      @jmagowan12 5 лет назад +7

      Quite simply as they have na other choice.

    • @pauljohn4668
      @pauljohn4668 5 лет назад +8

      Perhaps it's something beyond Chaos, perhaps it's something older then existence itself and it's just waiting to strike.

    • @thatrandomconcript2640
      @thatrandomconcript2640 5 лет назад +3

      @@pauljohn4668 an overload of incompetence that not even the imperium has done before

    • @Ceenth
      @Ceenth 5 лет назад +3

      @@thatrandomconcript2640 Right. It's a C'Tan. XD

    • @Dadecorban
      @Dadecorban 5 лет назад +16

      @@pauljohn4668 It seems probably that if the Imperial Fists decided to just surround the place and leave it be that it is most certainly something that isn't a threat except to anyone that ventures into the hive. If it was a threat, and they have a first hand account, then they would be blasting the hive city into oblivion. When you have a hammer everything looks like nails. If Space Marines are just cordoning off a place and not attacking it it's because it's not a nail. Likely some sort of creature or monster that is likely to just hang out and leave everyone alone as long as they stay out.

  • @silvermarksman6834
    @silvermarksman6834 5 лет назад +276

    "The imperial fists would surely do more that build defenses if there was a chaos cult"
    Are you sure about that? These are Sons of Dorn after all...

    • @Ericshadowblade
      @Ericshadowblade 5 лет назад +80

      Kitten: dorn what are you doing?
      Dorn: i am fortifying this postion

    • @Ivandejanoski
      @Ivandejanoski 5 лет назад +61

      How dare you, as a son of Dorn I am deeply offended
      *builds a wall so he may never speak to you or see you

    • @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts
      @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts 5 лет назад +17

      Yet Dorn teaches that "the best offence is a good defence". So perhaps that would not be so unlikely.

    • @Nerozard
      @Nerozard 5 лет назад +11

      @PJ Rivera SIEGE

  • @sasmo6515
    @sasmo6515 5 лет назад +484

    It could be men of iron. They could have been in deep storage when something reactivated them. It would lend itself to the hulking figures, the bestial cries could have been confused for that of ancient machinery, and we've seen what happens when astarts go against a well developed hive of men of iron. It would also explain why they redacted the information as well being that AI is strictly prohibited. But thats just a thought.

    • @mattkennedy9308
      @mattkennedy9308 5 лет назад +55

      I was thinking two normal enemies fighting each other but an Ork infestation fighting Men of Iron would be cool.
      Strike force shows up, fights some Orks then both sides get wrecked by the Men of Iron so the Fists set up and watch for intelligence on how they operate.

    • @Yingyanglord1
      @Yingyanglord1 5 лет назад +24

      That makes alot if sense

    • @sasmo6515
      @sasmo6515 5 лет назад +21

      @@Yingyanglord1 It's only speculation. I'm a bit of a nerd when it comes to lore but I feel like I'm lacking a lot of knowledge. 40k kind of helps fill in some of those gaps but I'm still sometimes lacking, sadly.

    • @doomguy9049
      @doomguy9049 5 лет назад +11

      this would be the coolest possibility

    • @sasmo6515
      @sasmo6515 5 лет назад +13

      @@mattkennedy9308 Yo, that would be sick actually. Just the amount of carnage. Im sure Special K would have the biggest stiffy at that fight. I already know The Big S already has a both figurative and literal female boner so just addressing the obvious at that point.

  • @greenlightertothe4th
    @greenlightertothe4th 5 лет назад +273

    Anything as mundane as Orks, Genestealers, or even Chaos would be attacked until eradicated, not blockaded.

    • @ericvaroli9895
      @ericvaroli9895 5 лет назад +15

      Sevedris not unless they still don’t know what it is, could be old one eye and no one would know

    • @matenzo
      @matenzo 5 лет назад +38

      Men of Iron have been blockaded and burried by the imperium before.

    • @mrbreck1
      @mrbreck1 5 лет назад +10

      Burning figure makes me think of a c'tan shard. No doubt there is probably various zenos and gene stealers as well.

    • @informationyes
      @informationyes 5 лет назад +2

      @@matenzo If the emchanicus found out they would lose their sh*t BIG TIME

    • @lunabee1313
      @lunabee1313 5 лет назад +11

      Maybe the skaven

  • @paule.vanamburgh8028
    @paule.vanamburgh8028 5 лет назад +140

    I vote Necrons. A flayer coven could easily shred a strike team and no one may know what to do with Necromunda if it turns out to be a tomb world

    • @Sam-er6up
      @Sam-er6up 4 года назад +24

      I know I'm replying to a one year old comment but the name is Necromunda just think about that, hell yeah it might be a tomb world.

    • @midgetydeath
      @midgetydeath 3 года назад +16

      Honestly, if Necromunda turns out to be a Tomb World I'd almost pity the Necrons. If any world has such a violent, armed, and experience population that it could probably fight off a Tyranid invasion with just its roid-raging citizens, that world is *Necromunda.* The Necrons would be up shit creek.

    • @LinkieNecronLore
      @LinkieNecronLore 2 года назад +5

      With it being flayed ones, they could take any form; but another bit of evidence is, Flayed ones just kinda… happen. They pop out of their personal pocket dimension where ever the smell flesh appears. Normally battlefields, but with high crime, and gang wars in Hive cities, there would be a load of dead for the flayed ones to… well.. flay. And seeing that there was living meat, would have an absolute field day.

  • @walterlopez5054
    @walterlopez5054 5 лет назад +245

    it's where they're keeping the Squats.

    • @negativezero8174
      @negativezero8174 5 лет назад +13

      B L A M

    • @verilyveronica8430
      @verilyveronica8430 4 года назад +9

      The squats have been hiding wearing High Heels.

    • @aguspuig6615
      @aguspuig6615 4 года назад +3

      for the 5th time Rogal, they are called dwarf

    • @CallieYote
      @CallieYote 4 года назад +3

      @WASDLeftClick it's a horrifying unified Squat/Skaven coalition

    • @essexclass8168
      @essexclass8168 3 года назад

      @@CallieYote led by the Daemon primarch of Malal: Gilles de Breton

  • @Asmith218
    @Asmith218 5 лет назад +106

    Zoat infestation, imperial fists sealed the records so GW doesn't have to recognize their existence.

  • @Jacl11
    @Jacl11 5 лет назад +167

    Why? I have a planet to invade at 7am tomorrow, an Exterminatus 8, fending off Eldar Corsairs at 9, and stopping a Black Crusade at 10, but I have to watch your videos. They are too good not to watch.

    • @mercenarygundam1487
      @mercenarygundam1487 5 лет назад +4

      We all need some respite once in a while.

    • @salahberjawi3945
      @salahberjawi3945 5 лет назад +6

      Ahem, the inquisition wants to know why you are being derelict in your duties.... You have executions to conduct at 5am, once the heretics are disposed of you may pursue the rest of your duties..... No more shirking...... The inquisition is watching you....... VERY CLOSELY!!!!

    • @grievouslytired7886
      @grievouslytired7886 5 лет назад +7

      The Admiral is shirking his duty for personal leisure. Ahem.....Inquistor!?

    • @salahberjawi3945
      @salahberjawi3945 5 лет назад +6

      @@grievouslytired7886 Personal Leisure........ Sounds like HERESY to me!

    • @NoobNoob-ss5hs
      @NoobNoob-ss5hs 5 лет назад +1

      Don't forget to boop the snoot.

  • @ponysrule101
    @ponysrule101 5 лет назад +199

    How do we know that The Skull Cluster wasn't just filled with giant spiders and the Imperial Fists just decided NOPE.

    • @Oliolli3
      @Oliolli3 5 лет назад +31

      HOW DID THE MEGARACHNIDS GET HERE!? I THOUGHT THEY WERE EXTERMINATED ON MURDER!

    • @LocalHeretic-ck1kd
      @LocalHeretic-ck1kd 5 лет назад +30

      Can you imagine Astartes in power armor armed to the teeth and he is like:
      "Eww spiders! I wont gonna go there! Have you ever seen them? They are THIS big and gross!"

    • @randallb84
      @randallb84 5 лет назад +17

      Oh dear God Emperor that made me laugh, the mental image of an Asartes on a chair because of a spider is so ridiculous its funny

    • @AnimeSunglasses
      @AnimeSunglasses 5 лет назад +6

      @@randallb84 QUICK, somebody get Lutherniel to DRAW THAT!
      (They're the artist behind Bolter to Kokoro, for the uninitiated...: www.deviantart.com/lutherniel )

    • @silent_stalker3687
      @silent_stalker3687 Год назад +1

      @@randallb84wait until you find one of them destroyed a oven and a rack by falling over because he didn’t know what a lobster was when he entered the room.
      He almost stepped on it and moved back, bumping into the oven and slide it against the wall to the rack of the stuff for cooking
      He then saw a bowl of living shrimp just bunch of bug things ‘wriggling and writhing around with beady bug eyes some ruptured from decompression’
      When a paradise world is too much of a paradise and space marines have seen too many bugs.
      Jk jk

  • @Antlion1001
    @Antlion1001 5 лет назад +121

    What about necrons?
    Good luck purging a Tombworld with a hive world built on top of it.

    • @jacobfreeman5444
      @jacobfreeman5444 5 лет назад +6

      @@centuri.trader9194 I...I...hmmmmm. This needs to be canon.

    • @VespiansGrace
      @VespiansGrace 5 лет назад +15

      And if the skull was the entry to the tomb world it would make sense to fortifying the hell out of it.

    • @truegregthompson
      @truegregthompson 5 лет назад +16

      Could even be the survivor was allowed to leave after the Lord of the tomb decided a messenger was needed to let the planet know that they all needed to fuck off and let them sleep

    • @Liminal.Headspace
      @Liminal.Headspace 5 лет назад +5

      That's a good theory, they might be Destroyers, whom are REALLY not liked by any still sentient Necron and usually banished unless someone needs an epic atom flayer buttfuck

  • @absalomdraconis
    @absalomdraconis 5 лет назад +49

    Probably something highly dangerous if encountered, but slow to expand. The guarding marines are to kill any that try to expand out. They aren't mounting a purge because it isn't worth the bother (noone was using the place anyways), or the infestation might even be useful (some rogue archeo-tech semi-living mining machine).
    Regardless, it's not a continental or even hive-cluster threat at all, but it's a massive in-hive threat, and if lots of folks knew then they'd make a massive nuisance of themselves: perfect for an RPG campaign.

  • @spartana1116
    @spartana1116 5 лет назад +123

    Maybe a lost dark age or early imperium experiment

    • @Ballagorn_Ironblood
      @Ballagorn_Ironblood 5 лет назад +5

      Like in that funny book called Death Zone, short story "Descend"?

    • @spartana1116
      @spartana1116 5 лет назад

      Idk because i never read the books

    • @wizard0313
      @wizard0313 5 лет назад

      @@Ballagorn_Ironblood What was it?

    • @Ballagorn_Ironblood
      @Ballagorn_Ironblood 5 лет назад +10

      @@wizard0313 There was a nanobots with program to gatter and combine all organic material and peoples consciousness into one. Long lost creation from dark age of technology
      If i remember it right. I read that book long time ago

    • @alexanderzhmurov9624
      @alexanderzhmurov9624 4 года назад

      @@Ballagorn_Ironblood Will need to look into it

  • @mrbearbear83
    @mrbearbear83 5 лет назад +219

    Was I the only one who heard:
    Burying the cannibals and the population to starve and thought:
    Locking the cannibals in with a food supply?

    • @40KTheories
      @40KTheories  5 лет назад +59

      The food, and cannibals, run out eventually ;)

    • @tylerdunn9683
      @tylerdunn9683 5 лет назад +11

      @@40KTheories but the cannibals still have food. They have each other

    • @22BCMF
      @22BCMF 5 лет назад +12

      Tyler Dunn they’re not gonna be able to have kids quick enough to outpace their need for food

    • @tylerdunn9683
      @tylerdunn9683 5 лет назад +1

      @@22BCMF your right theyd just eat them the second their born.

    • @tylerdunn9683
      @tylerdunn9683 5 лет назад +3

      @@40KTheories hey if you had to choose between hyperspace travel from Star Wars or warp travel/ Eldar webway travel to we'll move across the galaxy

  • @TeamOneDay
    @TeamOneDay 5 лет назад +107

    Necromunda, what happens when you allow Karl The Deranged to get bored.

  • @Folgore.202
    @Folgore.202 5 лет назад +43

    More importantly however, why didn't the Adeptus Mechanicus strip the hive clean of industrial machinery after its decimation? Surely the machines could have been repurposed elsewhere on Necromunda.

  • @lokiorin5520
    @lokiorin5520 5 лет назад +28

    All 3 options (Orks, Tyranids and Chaos Cult) seem pretty unlikely purely because there hasn’t been a more significant response. Those 3 options all require immediate responses, and are known quantities in the universe. Even if they couldn’t eradicate the infestation entirely, regular purges of the Skull would be required to keep things from escalating. Otherwise we’d be expecting a Waaagh, or some flavor of rebellion.

    • @dilophosaurussk4333
      @dilophosaurussk4333 4 года назад +5

      Yep, those are all too proactive. They would have attacked already.

  • @Xer0sama
    @Xer0sama 5 лет назад +190

    "Why would it take over nine thousand years to notice a burgeoning Ork population?"
    WHAT? OVER 9000?

    • @TheGenXGeek
      @TheGenXGeek 5 лет назад +21

      Perfect example of government at work...

    • @kieranh2005
      @kieranh2005 5 лет назад +10

      Stelf orks?

    • @tiggerbane4325
      @tiggerbane4325 5 лет назад +10

      Dey be purple then do they?

    • @phreakazoith2237
      @phreakazoith2237 5 лет назад +7

      how long did it take for the imperium to notice the fact that a planet of ape smurfs with flintlock guns forged their own empire with space travel, AI, battle suits and stuff? 4000 years?

    • @ragnerschwarzmane3412
      @ragnerschwarzmane3412 5 лет назад +4

      Tigger Bane no, if they were purple, the imperium still wouldn’t have noticed.

  • @christopherg2347
    @christopherg2347 5 лет назад +60

    It has to be a few creaturs tops. Stuff like Cults can be easily dislodged via miltiary action, so the empire would not hesitate to send in forces. Or they would quickly starve.
    A strong creature with a homefield advantage however, could be "too much trouble" to try to smoke out. It is better to guard the exits so it does not wander around and just wait for it to die of old age.
    It can also be helpfull not to antagonize it via further attacks. A single, strong creature could be very dangerous if antagonized.
    And not burying the hive might be better, as it might be needed as real estate later.
    Keeping the existence a secret is also a good idea, as something that the Emperors Angels of Death fear would disrupt the local morale.
    It might even be a interesting training scenario for the Imperial Fist Recruits and to keep all those other things out of there.
    So it is just the right combination of:
    - too troublesome to attack at home or rile up
    - too troublesome to admit it existing
    - not troublesome enough to waste force on smoking it out or wasting a good hive to burry it
    - to usefull (as cult deterent or sparing partner) to remove
    If they ever do need the hive, they propably have the manpower to spare to take it out. But until then it is just not worth the effort.

  • @knowplay
    @knowplay 5 лет назад +28

    It's simple: A Man of Iron. A surviving member of the Men of Iron that had been buried in the ash....and eventually awoken by a massive storm. His years of burial have driven him mad...almost feral. Now, he claims the Skull as his kingdom.

  • @KristofKristoferos
    @KristofKristoferos 5 лет назад +68

    Matt Ward lives within it. He is loosed upon the materium once more, Throne save us all

    • @LocalHeretic-ck1kd
      @LocalHeretic-ck1kd 5 лет назад +6

      Nice. Matt Ward doesnt like Fists that much. They end up killed or they sacrifice themselves in his books.
      So it adds up.

  • @littlebubulle
    @littlebubulle 5 лет назад +10

    - Skavens
    - nothing. The IF sent there just tripped on their own feet and fell down a long set of stairs. The defenses are to save face.

  • @Frotopoto
    @Frotopoto Год назад +2

    Well, I have now the beginning of my Skaven's lore in 40K. Thank you 🐀

  • @Venneroth
    @Venneroth 5 лет назад +46

    It’s a Lost Primarch. He likes his privacy, that’s all.

    • @GregoryElliott1973
      @GregoryElliott1973 5 лет назад +2

      I was going to say that. Lol

    • @kingjulian7045
      @kingjulian7045 5 лет назад +3

      Yeah..... the primarch of the second legion. I.E the rainbow warriors

  • @MeepChangeling
    @MeepChangeling 5 лет назад +10

    It's just Sly Marbo's house. The Marines are there to keep the kids off his lawn.

  • @TheMemphisxlr8
    @TheMemphisxlr8 5 лет назад +9

    It's actually Karl: He has a vacation house beneath the Skull, where he likes to practice his singing.

  • @nexviro8987
    @nexviro8987 5 лет назад +24

    When i heard the discription I though a band of thunderwarriors

  • @bluestormpony
    @bluestormpony 5 лет назад +12

    my guess is either men of iron, or dark eldar. if they were dark eldar it could be a contact for below board mutually beneficial transactions. as the imperium and space marines Have on occasion turned a reletively blind eye to aeldari activity before. the imperial fists increasing their numbers is just a precaution for the eventuality of the dark eldar betraying them

  • @jaqdraco
    @jaqdraco 3 года назад +7

    I'm throwing the theory in that it is Dorn.
    We will find out eventually that Dorn is also a perpetual, his last battle much like one of Vulkans deaths, was so intense and complete that his regeneration has left him violent, incoherent and crazed.
    the three holes in the hive could be the remnants of his reentry among debris from a ship.
    This is why the Fists can't simply destroy the location, and going in is too dangerous. I think there is a storyline there that while the fists have been unable to bring his mind back, think when the World Eaters tried to get Angron on side, so much so the Fists seek an audience with the returned Roboutimus Prime he goes in has a bit of a fistycuffs with the deranged brother trying to bring his mind back, whispers 'Martha...' wait sorry wrong storyline, eventually gets through to Dorn maybe by him seeing the Emperors Swords (sounds wrong) trips his memory back.
    This would then reinforce my belief all the Primarchs are perpetuals, because it's way to useful an ability to give to just one of them.

    • @ianharrison5758
      @ianharrison5758 2 года назад

      I very highly doubt that. If the imperial fists knew that their own primarch was down there, they’d stop at nothing to retrieve him by any means necessary. Any means necessary.
      As for the perpetual part, we know for a fact not all of the primarchs could possibly be perpetuals bc we know of several that are deader than dead.
      Horus, Ferrus Manus, Konrad Curze, sanginius, and most likely both lost primarchs are dead. If any of them were perpetuals they’d have respawned or healed by now.

  • @Kay_Drechsler
    @Kay_Drechsler 5 лет назад +1

    I just want to tell how many countless hours of pure pleasure you gave me with your content.
    Your work is done so very well that I'm struggling to find appropriate words for it.

  • @AreEia
    @AreEia 5 лет назад +13

    To my mind the most feasible creature(s) would be some sort of mutated animal strain. As Necromunda is well known for its high level of mutation and deadly creatures. It would have to be an extremely deadly creature(s) as it killed so many Imperial Fists but also one that is not too likely to spread to other Hives quickly. Since all they did was shore up their defenses.
    This to me also says that it is a creature(s) that must have a great advantage in the deep dark hive, but probably is not as deadly in the ash wastes. So maybe either some "shoggoth-like" super organism, or a new species of especially cordinated and deadly hive creatures...or both?
    Whatever it is I would love to see a BL novel where some dumb off worlders try to get into the Hive for some convoluted reason or another, only to meet the wrecthed thing that dwells in the Skull. Other than that, great video as always :)

  • @Eldor-117
    @Eldor-117 4 года назад +5

    Imperial fists during attack: *fortification*
    Imperial fists during defense: *heavy fortification*

  • @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts
    @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts 5 лет назад +5

    "Have been known to be highly zealous"
    Oh, the understatement.

  • @josetrujillo2394
    @josetrujillo2394 5 лет назад

    Thunder Warriors? Maybe they made some kinda deal with the Imperial Fists which is why they just build some barricades instead of clearing them out (although being Imperial Fists, do they really need a reason to build defenses?)

  • @ostangvulkahn1875
    @ostangvulkahn1875 5 лет назад +11

    I think it's Kitten's half Tau children

  • @MalachiteDragon1
    @MalachiteDragon1 3 года назад +1

    Meanwhile, in the High Lords' room...
    "I AM THE LAWN!!!... uh... say, you fellas get the feelin' we forgot about somethin' important?"

  • @MrMortull
    @MrMortull 5 лет назад +1

    Mutants. My guess is regular, common-or-garden Mutants in *massive* numbers that the Administratum and Fists simply don't consider the costs necessary to purge The Skull as being worth it.

  • @Glaaki13
    @Glaaki13 5 лет назад +11

    well the only thing the Imperium leave alone of the big factions are Necrons -thay just hope they sleep forever, but a lot of lesser things could hold them back

  • @Rastek19
    @Rastek19 5 лет назад +7

    The imperial fist?
    Reinforcing a perimeter?
    What an unlikely event

  • @matenzo
    @matenzo 5 лет назад +6

    Men of Iron. There have been instances of Men of Iron being entombed and sealed off by the imperium before.

  • @AwsmChimera
    @AwsmChimera 5 лет назад +3

    They're probably just Squats standing on one-another. Easily why there'd be such secrecy.
    "Yo, why we building this wall?"
    "Dunno, but... I just _feel_ like it's something we *desperately* need to do for this one, y'know?"

  • @lord_duckian9521
    @lord_duckian9521 3 года назад +1

    I believe it's just sump monsters, growing much much larger from being released from the sump and being able to expand their territory to the rest of the hive

  • @internetzenmaster8952
    @internetzenmaster8952 5 лет назад +19

    Obviously it's a cluster... _filled with Orks and Digganobz. Or one very, VERY big Ork._

    • @jonathandavies1716
      @jonathandavies1716 5 лет назад +11

      One massive ork wearing The Skull as a hat.

    • @Rammkommando
      @Rammkommando 5 лет назад +1

      @Steve Campbell "Imperial fists i am so happy to see you, Come GIVE ME A HUG"
      Imperialfist : that is not necessary

  • @VissAViss
    @VissAViss 5 лет назад +10

    Maybe there is a old war machine or a group of man of iron robots in the hive

  • @EternalQuestion
    @EternalQuestion 5 лет назад +6

    "The imperium have been known to be highly zealous when dealing with the followers of chaos"
    Literal understatement of the millennium.

  • @cerdic6867
    @cerdic6867 5 лет назад +6

    I like the idea of it being some ancient malice from the dark age of technology

  • @gothicshark
    @gothicshark Год назад +1

    Probably ancient pre-imperium abominable intelligence. Or even Necrons (or what ever Xenos made the long lost warp gates). After all there are some big mysteries regarding the Araneus Continuity.

  • @owenbevt3
    @owenbevt3 5 лет назад +3

    the stand off approach makes int unlikely but I sooo hope its orks, the reactions of orks and Goliaths meeting each other would be precious.

  • @Nobility4U
    @Nobility4U 5 лет назад

    Could it be a small group of rak'gul? This may be the reason space marines would only reinforce the area and not send in a kill team. Rak'gul don't go down easy especially in a close quarters area such as a hive city.

  • @claypidgeon4807
    @claypidgeon4807 4 года назад +3

    I always assumed it was something new, or shall we say very, very old. Some darktech abomination from the Age of Strife that ought to have remained buried forever managed to claw its way back into life and has taken residence in a derelict old ruin.

  • @auraenchanted2503
    @auraenchanted2503 5 лет назад +11

    what about it being a base for the men of iron and that they are keeping it quiet because they simply have no effective counter to killing them and so they keep them hidden. the effigies are in place as a form of perpetuating superstition and that the imperium is content to keep them locked up because they see no reason to march on the men of iron and destroy them. possibly with the battle brother who survived the beatings he suffered believing them to be some kind of adeptus mechanicus project that he has disturbed

  • @Bloodchylde2012
    @Bloodchylde2012 5 лет назад +2

    With the Imperial First home base close by, an entire Strike Force wiped out when scouting, the Imperial Fists lock away the records of the engagement and fortify defences around the Skull... surely they would have the ordnance to level the hive city? To eradicate whatever dwells within that has them so spooked?

  • @vojtechpribyl7386
    @vojtechpribyl7386 5 лет назад +1

    What about Necrons? Their warriors are physically imposing and yet they are not particularly dangerous when they lack high tier commanders. If part of their tomb has been activated the Administratum could have decided that it would be better left alone and Adeptus Mechanicus not alerted so that they don't trigger any additional systems by nosing about. Surely the Necron tech could have some howling sounds and weird lights by running some of their systems.

  • @idigamstudios7463
    @idigamstudios7463 2 года назад

    Possibility: it's nothing so typical. There are many strange xenos, warp beings, and such. It could even be a full integrated halo device user for example. In which case keeping it bottled up would be easier than trying to dig it out and launch it into a star.

  • @-Bile-
    @-Bile- 3 года назад +1

    The fists response stongly suggests necron tomb world. Hulking shadowy figures are tomb constructs. Imperial forces cant take offensive action for fear of waking up the tomb, especially not so close to terra.

  • @brigandboy1425
    @brigandboy1425 5 лет назад +19

    Or perhaps the skull is the repository of Cawl's misbegotten failed experiments.
    Wouldn't do for the reality of his vaunted Primaris origins to be released to the public.

  • @VoiceOfTheEmperor
    @VoiceOfTheEmperor 5 лет назад +5

    It's like trying to root out a lazy terrorist cell in Baltimore. Especially if it's in a VERY bad area. People aren't going to trust the National Guard coming in and raiding a large block just to deal with some outside threat. Especially if it's not a major one AND the entire area knows the consequences for letting things "get out of hand". Plus it's a recruiting world for a major Space Marine chapter. The conditions on Necromunda keep the Imperial Fists sharp and the imperium able to fight off pretty much anything. In other words, the risk outweighs the reward.

    • @Ponkan45
      @Ponkan45 3 месяца назад

      So instead of bothering people tolerate terrorists? Gotcha lol

  • @MrMysticphantom
    @MrMysticphantom 5 лет назад +4

    Maybe it's Dorn, just in a maddened form, slowly recovering while having psychic backlashes

  • @jotarokujo5305
    @jotarokujo5305 4 года назад

    Ima add like one view to all your videos real quick over the next week

  • @zarektheinsane6656
    @zarektheinsane6656 5 лет назад +16

    So they finally found Conrad Curze and his emo den

    • @malcadorthesigillite5847
      @malcadorthesigillite5847 5 лет назад +1

      @Corvus Andrathi
      In 'light' of that purest edge I'm calling him knock-off Corax until the sun explodes.

    • @Eisenwulf666
      @Eisenwulf666 5 лет назад

      Isn't he dead tho? Like 100%,boyscout's honor, we have proof, we promise never to bring him back, dead? Or am i missing a bit of the lore?

    • @johnathanblackwell9960
      @johnathanblackwell9960 5 лет назад +2

      @@Eisenwulf666 Well, his soul is in a spirit stone as far as I know.

  • @Bullet-ve2it
    @Bullet-ve2it 5 лет назад +8

    Those things that wrecked necromunda right after the imperium took the empire!

  • @ffejpsycho
    @ffejpsycho 5 лет назад

    My idea for who this group is...
    A group of "renegade" Thunder Warriors... they are invoking some rituals or 'warp'ish shenanigans in order to void their built in expiry date and extend their lives indefinitely....
    They aren't full chaos, just to keep from dying naturally... they were hulking, and plenty unstable...
    What do you think?

  • @GreatChickenGod
    @GreatChickenGod 5 лет назад +9

    it could be a nest of Ambulls

  • @patricksmith7626
    @patricksmith7626 5 лет назад +1

    Uh ... Necrons? There have been some indications of Necro tombs activating because of investigation. In the Soulstorm video game, if the Imperial Guard wins, the general scours the world with Necrons, and then orders it never to be surveyed again. The Imperial Fist might (maaaybe) ignore some minor Necron activity if they believed engaging would result in a full scale activation.
    Plus, and I'm not sure I remember this rightly, but isn't there a feral human tribe that fights beside low teir necron units? I think you did a video on them. Were they based on Necromunda?
    Plus ... "Necro" munda? Far from conclusive, but an interesting detail. Sceretly a Tomb world, perhaps?

    • @patricksmith7626
      @patricksmith7626 5 лет назад

      Plus plus plus ... "the SKULL cluster?" Yet again we see death imagery ... not conclusive, but I could see 40K creatives laying a bread crumb trail through such hints.

  • @TK199999
    @TK199999 5 лет назад +1

    This is 40K we are talking about, what would be the worst possible situation in the Skull hive? Everything. Meaning there is feral Orks, Gene stealers/Gene stealer cults and Chaos cults/warp spawn infestation. But why then would the IoM fortify and not annihilate. At first I thought maybe Necrons, but they would be too powerful a foe to risk leaving in place. So what Xeno race could bottle up all these horrors, to the point the IoM would rather leave it be? Then it hit me, Hrud. If there is a Hrud infestation along with all the others, then the best thing would be to leave it be. If its just Hrud, then either way Hrud tend to stay in place and not venture out. Since the Hrud ability to mess with time, may mean time passes much faster in the Skull than the rest of the planet. This effect is two fold, it makes assaulting untenable and it effectively bottle's up anything or everything fighting in there. But if any group would win and move out to attack the rest of Necromunda, those fortifications would annihilate them.

  • @Shawass
    @Shawass 5 лет назад +5

    it's Karl the Deranged down there, I'm calling it

  • @mattkennedy9308
    @mattkennedy9308 5 лет назад +5

    I'm sort of inclined to think it may be a minor force of Orks that the Imperial Fists are using as practice due to the previous abandonment of the cluster.
    If a basic strike force was able to cleanse or severely cripple it, sealing records and waiting for a respawn to practice Ork fighting wouldn't be unbelievable.
    Especially if there's enough Fists to crush it in future.
    Either that or multiple forces are active and they're waiting to see who wins and take out the weakened victor.
    Orks fighting Genestealer cults with no clear advantage would also explain why they'd reinforce defences but not raid in force until a clear winner emerged as a threat to the Hives and Production.

  • @roberttew6073
    @roberttew6073 5 лет назад +1

    I have a suggestion for a theory; at the same time, a question: What is the Pale Wasting? I heard on the lexicanum that it is an event in the Ghoul Stars that wiped out eleven Astartes Chapters, with the Novamarines being the notable surviving chapter. Listed with what are called, "Nightmare-Engines". Sounds like Necrons, or something worse. Were it not for the fact that the region is in the Ultima Segmentum, I would think it part of the Haunted Segmentum Obscurus. What do you think?

  • @mercenarygundam1487
    @mercenarygundam1487 5 лет назад +23

    Well it is called the skull.
    Khorne owns it and other non Khornate Chaos members pay rent in blood.
    Now imagine TTS doing a sjetch on that.

  • @TK199999
    @TK199999 4 года назад +2

    It could be a minor Necron stasis tomb, with the Fists and the Imperium deciding to leave it be and not disturb it.

  • @Zephyrbaby1
    @Zephyrbaby1 5 лет назад +1

    Ash ganger 1 - “hey did you hear that howl, it sounded like it came from the skull hive city?”
    Ash ganger 2 - “only howling I heard was your mum! Hey! Imma right guys?”

  • @Ezael
    @Ezael 5 лет назад +3

    It could also be a dangerous piece of archeotech still functioning/malfunctioning

  • @screamingcactus1753
    @screamingcactus1753 5 лет назад

    I could imagine that it's an Eldar outpost, to keep an eye on what is essentially a pressure bomb for chaos worship in the under hives, and the hulking figures are actually war walkers or wraith lords on patrol. Or perhaps it's an outpost for the Dark Eldar, and they're using it to kidnap people from the lower and underhives, and the hulking figures are the twisted creations of the haemonculous sent out for the same reason.

  • @spencerschaepman7239
    @spencerschaepman7239 5 лет назад +1

    Perhaps the Imperial Fists are maintaining a defensive cordon while the Grey Knights are, in fact, purging the cluster. Imperial Fists keep people out and the threat contained, Grey Knights stay out of sight. Easy day, job well done.

  • @seannorthern8854
    @seannorthern8854 5 лет назад +7

    Just a thought: Perhaps the Imperial Fists discovered an enclave of ex-Thunder Warriors. They were the ultimate terror force (Cruz was a wet sausage wallet by comparison), they were physically massive, and any news of their existence would directly contradict the Emperor.
    Oh... and they could •each• easily turn a squad of Astartes into crimson mist and bone chips using a pool noodle.

    • @Eisenwulf666
      @Eisenwulf666 5 лет назад

      Well then why not Exterminatus the planet? Seems like the sensible choice. But ,you are probably right in that it is of imperium origin,too precious/dangerous to be disposed of,but not enough of a treat to exterminate the planet

    • @kingjulian7045
      @kingjulian7045 5 лет назад +1

      I mean, if there's a group of warriors that can beat a custodes with a soup spoon, your gonna leave them alone

  • @Abdega
    @Abdega 5 лет назад +3

    It is a new Chaos God of bureaucracy and incompetence

    • @ProfDCoy
      @ProfDCoy 5 лет назад

      And it has occupied the whole Hive structure, suffusing its every wall, room, machine and computer terminal. Entrants are coldly informed through every vox-caster within the Hive of the forms they must fill out (in triplicate of course) in order to conduct the most basic activities. They must work through mountains and mountains of paperwork just to requisition a meal, or open a locked door to the next room, or go to the toilet.
      After weeks of maddening paperwork, running low on supplies, members of the Imperial Fists squad began arguing with each other over how to correctly complete the forms, who still had a working black pen, who had ticked the box marked "F" instead of "M" on their AFG 582 - Request for Investigation of Need for Approval of Evening Sustenance - and other grave matters. Soldiers accused each other, took sides, angrily checked and re-checked paperwork. At length, one man drew his bolter and fired, and the whole room erupted in a confused cacophony of bolter fire. Finally, only one of the fratricidal maniacs stood alive, pathetically mourning his own wicked actions.
      Having successfully defended itself and even fed and grown stronger on the Space Marines' feelings of confusion and frustration, the God let the last soldier leave the way he came. This sad, broken man, once a proud and strong Astartes, would serve as a last witness to what happened - to the tale of what happens to all who defy Cycifeern, God of Red Tape, He Who Files.

  • @gigatwin5298
    @gigatwin5298 5 лет назад +4

    perhaps the last surviving Thunder Warriors live with in The Skull after all there much stronger, faster and tougher warriors then the Space Marines while being similarly equipped which would explain why only one heavily injured Imperial Fist made it out of the Skull and why the Fist's simply fortified the perimeter in order to cage what ever was inside as well as explaining why the information was put under seal people after all aren't suppose to know that some of the Thunder Warriors survived there last battle.
    It would also explain the "hulking forms' seen within the Skull as Thunder Warriors are vary large humanoids and are fairly brutish by nature, so the "burning effigies" maybe them burning icons of the emperor of man that maybe where left over within the city out of spite.

    • @invaderHUNK
      @invaderHUNK 5 лет назад

      Gigatwin This. This is a really cool idea. The Thunder Warriors did get their hands on a cure for their condition, and Necromunda is close to Terra.

  • @Rain..._
    @Rain..._ 5 лет назад +3

    good ol classic 40 theory

  • @icecold1805
    @icecold1805 5 лет назад +2

    I imagine it is Chaos, but the Imperial Fists are keeping this hidden from the Inquisition to avoid it launching an Exterminatus on one of their recruitment worlds. I mean, this isn't unprecedented, if I remember correctly.

  • @callumbignall1877
    @callumbignall1877 5 лет назад

    I think for the info to be kept secret & have the area secured it has to be something that can't be easily dealt with that is also already a secret like either The Rak-Gol or a missing Primarch

  • @drdresapinkbunny
    @drdresapinkbunny 5 лет назад +2

    There is absolutely no way the IOM would let a Chaos Infestation slide. Necromunda was basically founded upon the rotting corpse of Araneus Prime after a Chaos incursion. The Imperial Fists "E-specially" know this.
    And like the video said. The Grey Knights are right around the galactic corner. Neromunda is within striking distance of Holy Terra itself. If there was so much as a turd of Chaos from a long dead chaos bunny lying somewhere in the Skull. They would find it. And they would obliterate it. In fact, they would most likely obliterate the entire structure. .
    After that was done, I am sure there would be a permanent quarantine zone set up, and around the hilariously deep crater that used to be the skull. Around this Quarantine Zone I would imagine would be permanently garrisoned troops. A whole fuck ton of Imperial Guard. Lots of Fists. Mechanicum, and Sororitas Elements as well. You'd probably see a Titan Legion or two.
    At any rate, if there were Chaos, Genestealers, or Orcs, I just can't see the IOM reacting with anything but extreme prejudice. It is an interesting piece of lore. I wonder if GW has even thought about what might be lurking down there? It would be cool if they expanded upon the lore. Great video as always BTW.

  • @warrenlamb2655
    @warrenlamb2655 5 лет назад +1

    They walked in on Rogal Dorn during a magic pain glove session.

  • @doomguy19931
    @doomguy19931 5 лет назад

    "Surely the Imperium would not be so incompetent as to let such a threat run rampant without taking the appropriate counter measures... would they?"
    *that's a fucking loaded question there, bucko*

  • @Xarcht
    @Xarcht 5 лет назад +5

    OOOOOOHHHHHHH a large hive of men of iron that follow the emporer

  • @sanuku535
    @sanuku535 4 года назад +1

    "relatively near galactically speaking"

  • @dogmeat7486
    @dogmeat7486 4 года назад

    The problem around trying to figure this out is based on the fact that it is both serious and secret but not serious enough to warrant a purge.

  • @Verse_Jumper
    @Verse_Jumper 5 лет назад +1

    Strange shit going down in front of the imperial fists?
    Fortify

  • @Saphels
    @Saphels 4 года назад

    >Imperial Fists fortified positions around Skull and did nothing else
    What else should be done? They're IMPERIAL FISTS. THEY FORTIFY.

  • @steelwolf8853
    @steelwolf8853 5 лет назад

    I think this would make a good game.
    : You'd play as a member of the Imperial Fists Legion, tasked with investigating the disturbances on Necromunda. You fight through the enemies(as the video stated Orks being a likely choice, but other variables making other enemy choices possible), the Imperium is attempting to cover up the event(maybe they have your character assassinated after the mission to assist in the cutting of loose ends, or sends you to a isolated planet far away from Necromunda?...)
    -As the style of game, I think Deathwing Space Hulk could be a viable choice(although expanded abit more, and developed more efficiently).

    • @Rammkommando
      @Rammkommando 5 лет назад

      Yes i agree metallic wolf, the fact there is no such game makes me......ANGRY

  • @Fuerto203
    @Fuerto203 Год назад

    Could be a chaos cult that summoned demons. The Imperial Fist strike force were successful in wiping it out with the last Imperial Fist being the only one to stagger out of the meatgrinder, but seeing hive as tainted by chaotic corruption the chapter decided to quarantine the area

  • @roganzar
    @roganzar 5 лет назад +1

    It's Conrad Curze. Now here me out. He was killed but the Ruinous Powers brought him back. His use and grudging acceptance of his precognitive abilities was enough to link him to a Chaos God. Probably Tzeentch. Being brought back would be an immense torment that it's possible Tzeentch and the rest would have found mildly entertaining.
    Curze took up residence in the Skull hive and has set it up in such a way that everyone should leave him alone. All while his precognition constantly torments him. When the Imperial Fists investigated they ultimately found a traitor Primarch. Curze let the one go to tell the Chapter what was there. Slaughter all but one to convey a message is the Night Haunter's M.O. This would be of such great danger that the Fists would seal this information away.
    There are probably both Orks and Genestealer Cultists in parts of the hivenat this point. Due to Curze allowing them to be there but using them to get out his more violent urges when his visions get to be too much. Also using them as a distraction from his presence.

  • @hughgedney3393
    @hughgedney3393 5 лет назад

    Great video 40k Theories

  • @FelrinKirla
    @FelrinKirla 5 лет назад

    My vote is the Imperial Fists did something horrendously embarrassing while fighting against Orks in there, and the Imperium wants to keep it locked away like the Unforgiven keep the Fallen a highly secretive topic.

  • @dansmachine9360
    @dansmachine9360 5 лет назад +2

    It is an ancient xeno abomination left over from the system's previous occupant before the arrival of the Emperor's fleets.

  • @kenju2268
    @kenju2268 5 лет назад

    I find it odd that nobody has brought up the possibility of Dark Eldar as being the culprits here, after all the Imperial Fist strike force never called for backup or extraction, so something hit them hard, and fast. My thinking is they LET the one go after they were finished playing with him as a messenger and warning to keep out and they'll keep to themselves in turn. This would also explain the 'lumbering hulking figures' as they could be Grotesques.

  • @stephenbond1990
    @stephenbond1990 5 лет назад

    Have you done the Bhein morr monster? Gothic sector, mentioned in the rulebook for battlefleet Gothic as responsible for several ships disappearing

  • @adinocc2042
    @adinocc2042 5 лет назад

    40k has more intriguing mysteries than any 10 franchises combined!

  • @mattkennedy9308
    @mattkennedy9308 5 лет назад +4

    Is Necromunda still supported or playable?
    I haven't seen resources for that game in years

    • @TheJesus_Christ
      @TheJesus_Christ 5 лет назад +4

      IIRC it actually had a massive rework back in late 2017

    • @dominusbalial835
      @dominusbalial835 5 лет назад +2

      Yeah it's still playable in fact I remember hearing about major updates within the past year at least

    • @mattkennedy9308
      @mattkennedy9308 5 лет назад +3

      Cool.
      I always liked the concept but I could never find much happening locally so I never got into it properly.
      Same as the larger model game with the Inquisition