Why Chasiv Yar is so important to Ukraine & analysing the battle for Donbas, Ukraine: The Latest
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 май 2024
- Day 797.
Today, we discuss the heavy fighting in the East as Russia approaches Chasiv Yar, we report on the inauguration of Vladimir Putin in Moscow and analyse Ukraine’s manpower crisis.
David Knowles (Head of Audio Development). @djknowles22 on X.
Dominic Nicholls (Associate Editor, Defence). @DomNicholls on X.
Francis Dearnley (Assistant Comment Editor) @FrancisDearnley on X.
Fabrice Deprez (French Foreign Correspondent). @fabrice_deprez on X.
Articles / Episode Referenced:
'Putin renews oath for fifth term with Russia under firm control' (BBC)
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-euro...
'Under Putin, a militarized new Russia rises to challenge U.S. and the West' (Washington Post)
www.washingtonpost.com/world/...
Episode feat. interview with Evgenia Kara-Murza:
www.audible.co.uk/podcast/Vla...
Subscribe to The Telegraph: telegraph.co.uk/ukrainethelatest
Email: ukrainepod@telegraph.co.uk
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information. - Хобби
The telegraph will declare chasiv yar as "strategically unimportant" in a few weeks. 😊
They will say it is all destroyed and worthless. But help is on the way. The wonder weapon will arrive soon or Putin is dying or something like that....
Because it is; it's current narrative that is pumped up drama to motivate further help.
Ukraine as a whole is soon strategically unimportant.
of course...this channel hasnt gotten a single thing correct...all of his info comes from Uk which sides...arms and even has sent troops into Ukraine...yet Russia continues to take land and inflict massive damage to troops and equipment....They have even gone as far as stating Russia was out of ammo and missiles back in December 2023 and Russian troops where fleeing back to Moscow.
@@Slimedog1963because they got all their info from UK ministry of defense LOL
We should commend the Russians for achieving significant gains in Ukraine despite using shovels in combat. It's puzzling why Ukrainians haven't embraced this traditional method of warfare.
never bring 61 billions of USD to a shovel fight.
sticks < stones < wooden spears < metal swords < guns < assault rifles < tanks < bombs < nukes < shovels
It was the British MoD that told us Russians had run out of missiles 2 years ago and that they had resorted to shovels...
No, it was Prighozin who gave shovels to his convicts because he wanted them to dig trenches under fire.
U wudnt be well 🤣
@@16252imagine that..yet afu lost thousands of soldiers and still LOST BAHKMUT😂😂...Plus serski got a new name from it "THE BUTCHER" 😂😂😂 his own troops hate him
@@16252lol Russia always had shovels 😅😅
@@16252 Ah. No army ever has to dig trenches under fire. Except the Russian. I understand now.
Industrial production in the German manufacturing sector dropped by 0.4% on a monthly basis in March, the country's Federal Statistical Office Destatis said in a provisional report released on Wednesday. The reading was higher than expected.
Output in the industry fell 3.3% in comparison to March last year. The decrease in production was largely driven by the 4.2% decline in energy production, followed by the 1.4% drop in the production of consumer goods. However, the production of capital goods climbed by 0.1%.
Excluding energy and construction, Germany's industrial production declined by 3.4% year-on-year.
Germany is de-industrializing
tldr
Its vitally important only until liberated. Then it becomes unimportant.
Which means it will be indefinitely important for Ukraine
@@gdiwolverinemale4thjust like Bakhmut and Avdiivka famously still being held by the AFU .. Wait a moment
@Gustav-yi2nr and Russia lost 15% of their military taking them. Russia is pathetic at war just stop 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Then why are they winning? 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
@@darrenwhitaker1015winning? That’s funny! They wanted to take Kiev and overthrow the Ukrainian government, yet they struggle to take the East of Ukraine with a 10-1 manpower and ammo advantage. Let’s see this Russian win when F-16s are in the skies and Ukraine gets better long range missiles. Russia has lost a third of its navy to Ukraine which doesn’t even have a navy😂
AFU Ground Forces chief Pavlyuk, "The loss of Chasov Yar in Donetsk region would not have "decisive significance", it is "an ordinary urban settlement"...
How do their families feel about 889 deaths. Per day!
as soon as Russia takes Chasiv Yar, it'll be declared 'insignificant', just like every other town Russia takes ?
It will be insignificant for Ukraine because they won't be able to use the fortifications.
Considering that they only take about 1 town a year, their significance is how they underline that RU are moving too slow to "win".
@@lance9150 - what fortifications, the money was embezzled...
Bakhmut was insignificant, but was fought over because of Chasiv Yar's topography.
Avdiivka was significant because of the robust fortifications Ukraine had built since 2014
@@rmdomainer9042 the Russians are as successful as the Ukrainian counter offensive.
Thanks from the update from Canada
Haha that ending.
Presenter, David, your sound is coming across distorted. Might need to turn the mic down a bit? Thanks.
I'm amazed that Russia is doing so well in this conflict. I was assured by that nice man at The Telegraph that this wouldn't happen. He said that Ukraine has "defence in depth" while Russia doesn't. Has this changed now?
Chasiv Yar is 4 hours walk from Bakhmut. How is that "doing well"?
@@rmdomainer9042Ukraine is again advancing backwards, braverly? Lol, pathetic cope
Copeing well thanks
3 daays. Black Sea Fleet. 475,000 casualties. 7,000 turretless tanks. And the list goes on. And meanwhile Ruzzia has given up its soul and its future for putin's vanity.
The whole narrative here is tied to the idea of a Ukranian victory. The facts are used selectively to back that narrative so it becomes increasingly hard to make a coherent case for that narrative when the facts are clearly moving against it.
I swear these people talk like the truth isn't out there.
Yeah, Russkyi MIr is like an onion of lies.
there there Tovarich, don't fret.
The MOD in the UK estimate average April Russian losses as 899 per day. When even Western sources admit that the Russians have massive advantages in artillary & missile attacks, might I submit that he may have mixed up Ukrainian casualties for Russian ?
Grind on….😅
Ruschia is attacking, that generates more casualties. Ruschia is attacking with poorly trained and equipped soldiers, that generates even more casualties.
Ruschias advantage in artillery is large in quantity but as precision and recognisance is poor this advantage is not as large as it seems.
Ukraine has advantage in drone use and long range precision weapons as himars and stormshadows. Neither does ukraine waste rockets on schools, hospitals, residental buildings and kindergartens as ruschia does.
Ruschia is currently churning fast through its post soviet junkyards, it will be interesting to see how they perform when they are closer to the bottom.
Ruschia is attacking, that generates more casualties. Ruschia is attacking with poorly trained and equipped soldiers, that generates even more casualties.
Ruschias advantage in artillery is large in quantity but as precision and recognisance is poor this advantage is not as large as it seems.
Ukraine has advantage in drone use and long range precision weapons as himars and stormshadows. Neither does ukraine waste rockets on schools, hospitals, residental buildings and kindergartens as ruschia does.
Ruschia is currently churning fast through its post soviet junkyards, it will be interesting to see how they perform when they are closer to the bottom.
Superiority of firepower generates casualties… not who’s attacking.
@@brettonsmith8534 sitting in a dug out or fox hole is safer than running over fields or as ruschia transporting soldiers in chinese "golfcarts" to the zero line.
Its quite fascinating to see how poorly ruschia performs. Not a single western military adviser had dreamed about seing the kind of shitshow of a circus ruschia displays.
Who could have guessed? It looks like dictatorship, coruption and vodka not are the best ingredients to build an effective army after all.
TY
Well the nuke thing is different they called French and UK ambasadors in told them that an attack on russia main with weapons from those countries would allow them to strike mil bases abroad or in the home countries... pretty much war on a wider scale.
This was always going to end the same way the question is how many men will be killed to get there.
The question is how many more Russians will be sacrificed at the alter of Putinism? The despot's survival is clearly more important than the survival of half a million Russians. How many more Russians must be sacrificed before the Russian people say "enough"? What's the number? 5 million?
Meanwhile the females are scratching their fannies and sipping lattes
those 8 points actually make Putin look like a true patriotic leader
Quick, send in the French, they'll stop it.
Only 31,000 Ukraine casualties.
When Zelenski was talking casualties he was referring to monthly casualties.
Chasiv Yar holds.
You'd think Ukrainians would be lined up for the army. People gotta eat.
Why is the British MoD so much interested in the Russian losses ? This is a Country that lost 27 million in WWII what is 470 k after 2 years in a war that is existential to them
It is not existential to them. It is existential to Putin. There is a difference.
Ask why Russia keeps violating UK air space.
WW2. No TV, no internet. No access to free press. Today - the internet gives Ruzzians access to the world's press.
It's 400.000+ dead UKRAINIANS, obviously. Oh wait, Zelensky said 31.000. It's 50.000+ dead russian troops.
Where are the west's battlefield nuclear weapons ?
Controlled by America. Like Europe. Which has none of them.
Cuban, Nepalese, Indian, Somali etc fighters vs European troops, well consistency isn't their strong side
It's very unlikely that RU will use nuclear weapons in Ukraine.
However, striking a nuclear powerplant is highly likely - diverting blame so that there won't be any repercussion
U can't handle an army with shovels why r u speaking?
When RU decides to use nukes, it will be on the main decision-making centers. And those are certainly *not* in Ukraine
It's highly likely that RU will use the nukes on the main decision-making centers. And those a certainly not in Ukraine
It's highly likely that RU will use the nukes on the main decision-making centers
It's highly likely that RU will use the nuclear weapons on the main decision-making centers. And those are certainly not in Ukraine
Only ten times. He's lucky.
quite bad sound quality ...
The Ukraine requires a leader that has real balls. Someone that doesn't believe in killing. The Russians would respect that. Vote for the Pope.
The Ukraine is winning. All they have to do is take chasiv yar, then Robotyne, then avdiivka, then bakhmut, then the land bridge, then didrupt the kursk bridge and they won.
Feels like the volume has been a bit up and down over the last few episodes.
The Ukies made such a big deal of changing Christmas to the Western date.whats up with Easter,?
Chinese President Xi Jinping and his Serbian counterpart Aleksandar Vucic formalized on Wednesday an agreement to reinforce a collaborative future between the two nations.
According to the Chinese government page, the signed statement looks for the "building of a China-Serbia community with a shared future in the new era" making the Balkan state "the first European country to build such a community" with Beijing.
The Serbian government said in a press release that "28 documents on cooperation were exchanged" between the two nations, on topics such as civil and commercial matters, green and sustainable development, digital economy, cooperation in the field of infrastructure, poverty reduction through science and technology, information and communication technologies, geology and mining.
more yawn from the truthbum
More copy and paste? Ok then 🫠
Can the British MOD be trusted any more? Propaganda seems to be overriding objective fact. Once trust is lost it won't be regained.
MOD= Ministry of Truth. Ie propaganda..
@@egoncorneliscallery9535 Orwell's bleak prophecies coming true ( apparently he had seen the way a certain dept in the BBC connected to Govt operated)
The Ukraine has gone south.
Sugar, spice and all things nice that's what the telegraph is made of
Reminds of my ex before she turned
More like spin, lies and porky pies
War distracts from poverty - that's about current UK situation.
This is all about keep this conflict going to keep dumb citizens from looking at real news that affects them.
Sacrifice Ukraines men for the sake of votes 8n USA, UK, EU.
Keep the Ukrainians buying it’s for the eu good.
Such an organic post.
ask putin,he wants your vote..
Especially compared to the lavish Russian lifestyle.
@@piseag458 I gave him my vote.
Mail in ballots… democracy is so inconvenient. Pausing democratic processes until the end of war, with a neighbor like Russia. Is like some mystical riddle paradox. Am I the only one seeing how bad an idea that is? Skipping elections is a hard habit to break. I really hope Zelenskyy understands how important it is to nurture his young democracy. Even a hasty gesture of an election to keep people in the habit and settle a few local issues would be worthwhile. I am so hopeful for Ukraine and I sincerely wish that they achieve all their goals in time.
it is written in some articles into the Ukrainian Constitution, not just by Zelenky.
its over..
Not even close
That's what your mum said.
❤Ukrainian ❤
Khokhol
❤️Russia❤️
@@darrenwhitaker1015 🍆
@@darrenwhitaker1015go live there Darren
@@anthonyhulse1248 Putin has just given France and the UK a good slap as their ambassadors have been called to Moscow, as a result France & UK have backed down. Turns out they aren't going to send troops to Ukraine after all.
Fun fact France's ambassador will be attending Putin's inauguration day....ha ha ha
So who's weak again
Strong Ukrainian heroes!,, stand , fight, get your land back!,,,
Люди в Україні тобі не раби привіт актори для твого геройського кіно
Приїджай до нас в Україну. Чого ти за закриті кордони та скасування прав людини. УКРАЇНА ЦЕ ХТО ДИКТАТУРА ЗЕЛЕНСЬКОГО, ЯКА ЖЕРТВУЄ ЛЮДЕЙ ДИКТАТУРІ ПУТІНА ДЛЯ ВАС. ЩОБ ВИ ЗМОГЛИ ПОЖИВИТИСЯ СВОЄ КРИВАВЕ ШОУ, ЯК ЗЕЛЕНСЬКИЙ З ЛЮДЕЙ РОБИТЬ РАБІВ, А З УКРАЇНИ ДИКТАТУРУ ДЛЯ ПУТІНА. ЗДОРОВОГО ГЛУЗДУ ВАМ. ВИ, ЩО ПРОТИ ПРАВ ТА ЖИТТІВ ІНШИХ.
There's none left soft lad
The territory and the people on it
@@nigelalanwood6781deluded
Naive Ukrainians. USA wants Ukrainian men dead so that there are more Ukrainian mail-order-brides. Hunter Biden loves Ukrainian 'women'.
Thanks, Telegraph.
Thanks for the update and the guests ….
NO ONE SURVIVED! Russian Missiles Wiped Out A Large BASE of US and Polish Mercenaries In KUPYANSK!
Against the background of the successful advance of the Russian army on the battlefield, Russian combat aviation, together with missile forces, continues to launch massive missile strikes throughout Ukraine. At the same time, it is worth noting that these missile strikes occur with a difference of one or two days. The main goal of these Russian massive missile strikes is to prevent the Ukrainian army from regrouping, replenishing its forces and completely depriving it of logistics chains through which the Armed Forces of Ukraine regularly receive various types of weapons and so-called mercenaries from NATO countries.- BORZZIKMAN
Slava ukraini
🔱Героям слава🔱
The gayest thing anyone can say 😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣👎👎👎
cringe
🤡🌈"slava🟥⬛geyям"🦄💩
I’ve heard that Russia hasn’t moved forward anywhere in the past 24 hours.
Shovel shortage?
@@stevepi1 sorry 48 hours now.
Berestovoe, Urozhainoe and not only.
Check the mappers; they continue moving forward.
Coeur d'Alene Idaho USA, Slava, Ukraine
lmao all the bots
Russian bot infestation today
Gotta repel the orcs!
Ukrainian orcs (the original orcs) are being decimated. But... there will be more Ukrainian mail-order-brides available. USA loves Ukrainian mail-order-brides.
Russia at this time has a major shoretage of flags, it keeps painting them in captured towns and villages .
Loved the Putin analysis. Tsarist Putin is a combination of Lenin and Stalin. ❤👌
Metropolitan Opera Orchestra - Wagner: Ride of the Valkyries - Ring (Official Video)
ruclips.net/video/xeRwBiu4wfQ/видео.html
Bs Russian dont omb Ortodox chearches the Ukraians Catolics do
Bravo Russia, keep going
Wonder why Russia is not told to give up the occupation of Königsberg and Karelia at the same time as they pull out of Belarus?
The day u dumb western pricks give up various overseas possessions u have tge russians will give up there's hows thar sound?......how does that fly?
Told by whom? Because at present Russia is giving U.S. led Nato the beating of it's life.
Great idea! 👍👍💪🏻
@@richardmarsden5610Nato has not arrived yet. What we have seen from ruschia so far is that it was not the military power we thought it was.
@@richardmarsden5610haven’t seen any Russian beating in any of our nations, Ukraine is definitely humiliating Russia the mighty teddy bear though.
I thought they said they were already at war with NATO, they need to make their minds up.
The gap between the BS emanating from these pundits and reality is gigantic.
The only thing that would make this podcast more pathetic is if they actually believed their own lies
They do believe! 😂😂 and so do I! 😅
They do believe it😂😂
Go get your eggs before they are all gone Vlad.
@@user-dq4he4pm4r baby girl!!!
I like "What is happening on the ground" from Dominic.
Always reminds me of the Iraqi Minister "Comical Ali" during the Iraq war.
Russian economic data does it for me.
The FFL lasted a whole two days.
Russia threatens anyone at any time that suits them, and they do so frequently, but if anyone dares to threaten them back even in a minor way then it's a major international scandal. Putin, like the schoolyard bully, can dish it out but can't take it. What a fragile little man. Slava Ukraini!
that's right the UK and France have had to back down, turns out it's the Europeans that are weak not Putin
@@stephenglover1818what did the UK back down from?
@@JonSmith-wg8mr putting troops on the ground in Ukraine
@@stephenglover1818 but the UK never said they were going to do that. Telling lies isn't a good look, everyone is entitled to an opinion but don't lie.
U wudnt be well
Zelenskyy regime is on its last legs and it can't be propped up even until November.
Lol because Russia is such a force 😅😅
riiight.
Ukraine's security equals Russia's insecurity
And vice versa
NATO expansion pushed this issue into conflict
Neutral Ukraine could have solved this problem
Minsk
Wrong
@@user-dq4he4pm4r explain
I wonder why there are trolls on almost every podd / video where we praise the heroes of Ukraine? There are many troll sites although the Master of Trolls Prigozhin was eliminated by Putler, the latter obviously wanted to be the Master of Trolls himself.
Slava Ukraini! They fight bravely for the freedom of Europe.
Now Strelkov is charged with "treason". Very useful. The guy that has testified that the entire Donbabwe/Luganda "resistance" is an FSB plant.
Controlled 🇷🇺
Anyone who says things I don't agree with is a Troll.
"Deepots"?
I come here to laugh at the reporting of this conflict. The telegraph really does think so little of its listeners.
Party in Crimea? 🤡
Puck Footin
Two Ukrainian alcoholics are still held up in one of the big buildings. They have lots of alcohol.
The statements made at the beginning of these videos are pure cringe.
Which videos are these?
@@SuperRosie123
Ukraine: The Latest. The two quotations from Zelensky and the one from Sunak, the British PM.
Give it months3these 🤡 will be saying Chasuv Yar is of "no strategic significance"
Free Julian Assange! Free Pablo Gonzales! Imprison Biden, Zelensky, Victoria Nouland, Netanyahu!!!
Free Gerasimov!
Free Russia!
If we give sergeant bumfrey the bums, then they will get bumed.
A bunch of lies. Dream on
The propgandist oh I mean telegraph
I thought it was only 20% of the Ukraine invaded. How's that 100% or full scale.
Finland opened its borders with Russia.
putin gotta be glad that France and Britain don't have any nuclear weapons 😉😉😉
They do have some crappy stuff. Perhaps an easy target for S500
@@gdiwolverinemale4th lol ok vatnik
@@gdiwolverinemale4th Showmuch? 🤣🤣 Is that a Benz?
They do.
Putin has just given France and the UK a good slap as their ambassadors have been called to Moscow, as a result France & UK have backed down. Turns out they aren't going to send troops to Ukraine after all.
Fun fact France's ambassador will be attending Putin's inauguration day....ha ha ha
So who's weak again
LoL - load of psyops 77th Brigade's propaganda
19:00 bye bye NWO
They've captured Drrobotnick
I have a fear on nuclear treat coming from Russia.
Take a look at these comments. Its easy to see who the Russian bots are.
Поясни по яких ознаках ти визначаєш, хто бот, а хто ні. Люди, які за права та конвенції та відкриті кордони, щоб люди могли вирішувати в Україні, що вони хочуть для тебе боти. Ти бот путіно зеленської диктатури проти свободи вибору людей?
Grow up.
@@user-kr6ui1cd8f That is not the language used here.
@@richardmarsden5610 Says the copy-pasting shillpig.
@@rmdomainer9042go beg for more money
I wish Richard Nixon was still president when i hear how we should accommodate Russia's position on the war in Ukraine.
The Ukrainians should vote for the Pope. That would solve everything.
Russia has the entire region covered by non strategic nuclear weapons.
Putin learned from Liz. They often had tea. Putin has nothing in common with Charlie.
Walking on the moon.
The war sounds so aged; rockets, tanks, ground flanking movements, etc. A tsunami of Western technology would put this away in a few weeks. Seems the stagnation in initiation stems from the West eschewing the horror this would entail. As the carnage continues, and especially the nuclear threats, I expect there will be a breaking point and unimaginable destruction will ensue. The world often has changed tremendously due to aggression: Perhaps this is more nascent than we realize or will take a few more years, but I expect the world won’t let this continue quiescent. If it’s still a few years off, technologies stemming from AI and quantum computer advances will make quick work of Russia in my opinion.
Ukraine is losing. Stop the war.
Putin is the only one who can stop the war. Ukraine will keep fighting for their freedom and lives.
If Russia stops fighting, there will be no war.
If Ukraine stops fighting, there will be no Ukrainians.
@@badluck5647 If Ukraine stops fighting, there will be no Zelensky. Russia has no claims against Ukrainians
@@burritosls
The mass graves in Bucha say otherwise .
@badluck5647 Bucha fake, lol. No one sees a list of this "victims"
RU has no path to win, so do not stop it.
Nato helped create the most powerful land army the world has ever seen... The Russian Army.
Reported for misinformation. By what metric would it be that?
@@rmdomainer9042 - Reported for misinformation. By what metric wouldn't that be?
@@rmdomainer9042 By the defeating U.S.led Nato in Ukraine. As witnessed over 2 years of conflict. Pretending Nato isn't the not so star quarterback in this conflict is only self-delusion at it's worst btw.
@@richardmarsden5610 That is a non sequitur. Try to answer the question as an intellectual would.
@@rmdomainer9042 well a NATO backed counter offensive totally failed for one. Western economies are deindustrialising and demilitaritarizing
My dose of copium
The "Z" has become the new swastika.
Ur losing to a country fighting with shovels why ru speaking?
It has been all along
@@RyanBrown-nx8dwthree daaays!
@@anthonyhulse1248It would have been better for Ukraine had they surrendered in 3 days.
The 3 Day Mythos came from Gen.Miley
Like the Mythos US will be 3 years in Afghanistan,and Wasted 20 years For Nothing.@@anthonyhulse1248
Russia has done nuclear tests.
Russian Orcs going to battle the same number of soldiers they use in Ukraine ?
Not outnumbering the opposition ?
How unfair, we will be humiliated
Ukrianian orcs, The Original Orcs, are dying. But now there are more mail-order-brides available from Ukraine. USA loves Ukrainian mail-order-brides.
Have the orcs lost 500,000 ?
Russia is a nuclear superpower.
Long Live Mighty Putin. Long Live Mother Russia 🇷🇺 💙
"Mighty" Putin Poopinpants? That bunker grandpa? 🤡
I finally unsubscribed from this channel, should have done it days after mistakenly subbing it at the start of the SMO in '22. Haven't watched it since then. Complete utter propaganda tool.
Bye
SMO is not actually a thing. It is newspeak only employed by vatniks.
Bots don’t leave
Nobody real calls it "SMO" btw. Learn that for your next account.
@@stream2watchit didn't start off as a full mobilisation so SMO at the start but not now. Even the Russians no longer call it a SMO
Russia does not have the means to reach the UK
They have submarines and ICBM!
@@aac74 ... and underwater battleships.
What is that poseidon torp I've heard of
@@aac74I think he means the actual soldiers for them to be an invasion force.
So many Russian trolls on this channel. Trying just a little too hard.
Sounds like Ukraine is toast to me, unfortunately.
Slava Russia 🇷🇺