paradoxed I think it’s more he is himself.. but maybe was acting as a more exaggerated version the more fame he got. Like. XFM for example I don’t think he’s playing an actor.
The clone concept of not knowing who the original is, is a key aspect of some bad guys called the Mauler Twins in the Invincible comicbook series and it’s actually so interesting that Karl thought about that dilemma, I like Ricky Gervais at times but he really doesn’t give Karl enough credit for being intelligent in his own way
Surely you would know that you had been cloned though, therefore you would know you're the original? Unless you both have exactly the same memories, but then that isn't really a clone.
@@scerpalman Clones would never have the same memories. A clone is a normal person that just looks like you. How they are brought up and the choices they make will mold their personality so it will be completely different to the original person. It's like the butterfly effect, every different choice they make would lead to a different outcome.
gotta say, that "how would I know which one I was" is smarter then the other two guys got. he specifically asked "does he know what I know"; so basically asking "is it really and exact copy in that moment down to the knowledge and thoughts". in that case the question makes sense, because both versions would think they are the real one and both versions wouldn't want to end whatever that existence would be at the end of this one day.
the last one was philosophically genius, if the clone was made with the exact same memories and experiences, you wouldnt know if u were the clone all along or not
yeah makes sense, since there is a sort of neural duplication. so the clone would have the memory of creating a clone... unless of course your clone has no memories
I think you'd know who you are cause you're looking through your body's eyes. That's why they're laughing. There's no space for doubt there. I'm the one facing south, cause I'm facing south and I'm looking and the guy who's not. That's the point.
@samplexample Because he likely would have had to use a snorkel to begin the dive. I know it's animated, but they've obviously put some thought into it. If we were ignoring all the real life rules, then there'd be nothing stopping Karl from wearing a 3 piece suit and sandals while swimming.
The longer time passes, the more we appreciate how unique Karl actual is.Granted yes, he’s got some truly hilarious (dumb) moments, but he’s smarter than Ricky / Steve proceed him to be.
I don’t think I’ve seen cartoons that so perfectly capture the personality of the people they represent. Even down to Ricky looking like Fred Flintstone.
I strangely agree with him on the last one as the other exact replica would also have same memories thoughts and believe he was original Karl. So you would maybe think 🤔 Am I original me or are the memories there just because we are exact replicas. The other one would also have been told he’s meeting an exact replica of himself. His truth & the replicas truth would be exactly the same. So how could you say for definite to yourself that you are the original you🤔 if that makes sense 😬
I literally was about to post that.. karl has genuine gem thoughts if you watch his adventures.. theres quite a few beneath the jokes in idiot abroad 😂😂
Actually, on the last one, Karl has a point. If Karl knows that the other clone is like him in every way, how is he to know he is not the clone, because the clone will be thinking exactly the same. Karl, I'm with you on this one ! 👍
@@chattingesque372 No he's not. that's my point. Neither him or the clone will know they are the clone, because they are exactly identical. Both will suspect the other is the clone.
@@dereksawle no he's saying "which one I am/was" the I implies that there is someone there. Whichever I he is, is him. Otherwise you can ask yourself, "how do you know that you are real?" and not be able to answer. Decartes already covered this "I think therefore I am". If Karl was thinking about the clone, that means he can't be the clone because he is Karl. There is only one Karl. Otherwise any of us could be Karl.
"How would I know which one I was?" I simply didn't expect that. It came out so genuinely and profound, it blew my mind a little. The ultimate existential dilemma "Am I real, or am I the clone?" I'm not sure what show this is from, but I'm kinda infatuated by it, especially the 50's cartoon style, it's a fantastic touch!
@@squedex3164 They're not talking about a literal clone, they're talking about a replica which thinks the same, as they said, which would have the same memories.
Imagine cloning yourself, with all memories including the act of cloning, and you recorded it and tagged the clone to denote that it’s the clone, only to discover that you were the clone with the tag and the duplicated memories fooled you. You basically realized everything you ever knew was a lie and you’ve only existed for however long it took to clone you. How depressing would that be
I have always found Karl to be extremely profound with his thinking, its just he has no capability to put it into words other than breaking it down to its barest point, so in a way Ricky and Karl are the perfect fit, they are both extremes in that way.
4:20 I get where's he coming from. How would you know if you're the clone or not? If the clone have all of your memories and experiences, then how could you ever be sure that you weren't the clone? Unless you saw the clone being made. But if a clone just came into your life and claim he was the real you could never find out who was the real
No cause if you saw the clone being made that would still count as one of your memories that the clone would be imbued with. So either way there’s no way to really tell which one you are
What he is trying to say about jellyfish and octopi is that they appear, move and act alien compared to most other living species, which is true. The Clive Warren idea was part of S04 E06 Black Museum in the Black Mirror series. When he tried to "see" his toe without using his eyes he was trying to do a type of meditation. I also understand his questions regarding our consciousness and the awareness of our own existence. The way he expresses it though is utterly hilarious and no one in the world takes the mick out of someone like Ricky Gervais. And Stephen Merchant really increases the overall average height of the show.
The last point is quite a genuine stance in philosophy. I mean both you and your clone will claim to have experienced your past, but only one was physically there. If the clone were physically identical, there would be no way to distinguish the original!
Everyone in the comments is saying karl is a genius askinghow would he know if he was the clone, but that's not at all what he asked he asked "how'd I know which one is me?" Which is implying karl meets his clone and then goes 3rd person.
realistically the clone would know they are the clone, and you would know you are the original, because only one of you would have the memory of getting out of the cloning pod or walking out of the cloning facility etc
Tbh I have to agree with Karl on the Clone one. If you were put to sleep at a random Time, cloned and you then you walked out of the 'cloning facility'. Because you and the clone are exactly the same person. You wouldn't know which one you were. Are you the original? The one who was cloned or are you the clone? Neither would know the truth because they are thinking the exact same thing.
That totally makes sense, actually. If one of the versions of you is fake but has all the same memories, you wouldn’t be able to tell if you were the original or the copy.
Karl is 100% correct on the clone dilemma. If the clone was created with the exact same memories, you’d have no way of knowing if you were the original or the clone. It’s actually very insightful.
The clone dilemma has many versions. Blade Runner, BNHA's Double, even Naruto's clone jutsu can be considered in this discussion, and each one works in an individual manner to its environment.
Karl is one of the funniest human beings to ever live.
Amanuel Kassa not intensionally
@@MajinJuice intentionally you mong, play a record
Bee Mail no
Bee Mail Bravo.
THE funniest
Dumb? Not at all, he’s just got a different vocabulary.
I admire him so much that I subconsciously have started slowly copying his hairstyle
He’s a uneducated idiot. I wouldn’t have it any other way.
Isn’t this all pre-written? He’s playing a character.
@@checkeredcheese where did you hear that?
paradoxed I think it’s more he is himself.. but maybe was acting as a more exaggerated version the more fame he got. Like. XFM for example I don’t think he’s playing an actor.
paradoxed I think one of those is true. He’s definitely playing a character but I still think it is improvised.
The clone concept of not knowing who the original is, is a key aspect of some bad guys called the Mauler Twins in the Invincible comicbook series and it’s actually so interesting that Karl thought about that dilemma, I like Ricky Gervais at times but he really doesn’t give Karl enough credit for being intelligent in his own way
Gervais has said on a number of occasions that he loves the way Karl's mind works and that he's very bright in his own way.
@@kalibos "enough" pay attention to what he wrote
Surely you would know that you had been cloned though, therefore you would know you're the original? Unless you both have exactly the same memories, but then that isn't really a clone.
@@scerpalman Clones would never have the same memories. A clone is a normal person that just looks like you. How they are brought up and the choices they make will mold their personality so it will be completely different to the original person. It's like the butterfly effect, every different choice they make would lead to a different outcome.
@@TheDeepState2001 yeah that's what I thought
The only HD version I’ve ever seen!
I wonder how you can get the HD version
Jake Wellens same! I didn’t know Ricky Gervais show was this HD
@@simoneastwood7583 buy it
Right? My eyesight feels amazing.
They’re re airing episodes on Comedy Central HD soooo
If the clone has the same memory how would u know your not the clone, karl makes perfect sense in that.
Because the clone wouldn't have memory of seeing itself being created being
@@Charlie.c19 neither would you
Charles Obscure well it would be a clone so the memory would be implanted in it
@@Charlie.c19 if the cloned you it would have all the memories you had up to being cloned
Because you would know it from your own personal knowlegde. And nothing outside of it should matter at all
Karl is actually a genius
and he stands alone
We're not ready for his thoughts.
gotta say, that "how would I know which one I was" is smarter then the other two guys got. he specifically asked "does he know what I know"; so basically asking "is it really and exact copy in that moment down to the knowledge and thoughts". in that case the question makes sense, because both versions would think they are the real one and both versions wouldn't want to end whatever that existence would be at the end of this one day.
You're as dumb as Karl then
Karl always makes sense Ricky just has to sell it for laughs. It can be frustrating
@AnthonySanders-y2j well not always. He thought it would be much easier to cycle up Mount Everest than walk up it.
Nope, Karl is an idiot
And so are you
How do you not know the difference between “than” and “then” xd
YES! Lovely that people are still sharing Karl's lovely innocence, Stephen's quick wit and Ricky's infectious laughter
the last one was philosophically genius, if the clone was made with the exact same memories and experiences, you wouldnt know if u were the clone all along or not
The last one actually makes sense if the clone had all your memories up until present day. You wouldn't be able to tell of you're the clone or not.
yeah makes sense, since there is a sort of neural duplication. so the clone would have the memory of creating a clone... unless of course your clone has no memories
What if the clone was 6 inches tall
It would depend on whether you still exist as yourself or whether you're experiencing both existences at the same time
I think you'd know who you are cause you're looking through your body's eyes. That's why they're laughing. There's no space for doubt there. I'm the one facing south, cause I'm facing south and I'm looking and the guy who's not. That's the point.
2:00 why does spaceman Karl have the American flag on his spacesuit? American animators being cheeky
@samplexample Because he likely would have had to use a snorkel to begin the dive. I know it's animated, but they've obviously put some thought into it. If we were ignoring all the real life rules, then there'd be nothing stopping Karl from wearing a 3 piece suit and sandals while swimming.
Proper weird.
Only 5 min for dumb moments??? Seems too short
adam Seccombe it’s actually because he’s genuinely really smart without knowing it
@@MsJobbyjabber well on occasion, but there is far more than 5 minutes of beautiful idiocy on Karl's part haha
Look up the xfm days, you'll love it
Like Karl
This should be Karl's Most Interesting Moments. Karl is very introspective, absolutely philosophical on the clone part.
Karls onto it with the "how do you know which one you are"!
yes!
He was thinking of the plot of ‘The 6th Day’.
He’s not dumb black mirror is based on his theories
The longer time passes, the more we appreciate how unique Karl actual is.Granted yes, he’s got some truly hilarious (dumb) moments, but he’s smarter than Ricky / Steve proceed him to be.
If aliens ever visit, Karl is who I would send as an ambassador
I wish there was videos of them actually recording this live, their reactions etc
I don’t think I’ve seen cartoons that so perfectly capture the personality of the people they represent. Even down to Ricky looking like Fred Flintstone.
There's a British radio host called Clive Warren.
The last one is a legitimate philosophical debate, and he is pretty spot on in his thinking.
Netflix show "Living with yourself" is based on the same principle of cloning and not knowing who is the real one, exactly as Karl said. Mind blown!
netflix shows use alot of his ideas! black mirror episodes have used Karls ideas from this show and thats a british show
Also if you watch Ricky’s stand up it’s full of Karl’s jokes
I strangely agree with him on the last one as the other exact replica would also have same memories thoughts and believe he was original Karl. So you would maybe think 🤔 Am I original me or are the memories there just because we are exact replicas. The other one would also have been told he’s meeting an exact replica of himself. His truth & the replicas truth would be exactly the same. So how could you say for definite to yourself that you are the original you🤔 if that makes sense 😬
I literally was about to post that.. karl has genuine gem thoughts if you watch his adventures.. theres quite a few beneath the jokes in idiot abroad 😂😂
That makes complete sense.
agreed. Karl is actually completely right here.
Yeh Ricky and Steve aren’t fully grasping the concept and therefore appearing dumber than Karl
so the exact plot of living with yourself
Actually, on the last one, Karl has a point. If Karl knows that the other clone is like him in every way, how is he to know he is not the clone, because the clone will be thinking exactly the same. Karl, I'm with you on this one ! 👍
It's like the synths on fallout t
Because he's visualizing what the clone might be thinking, therefore he is an observer
@@chattingesque372 No he's not. that's my point. Neither him or the clone will know they are the clone, because they are exactly identical. Both will suspect the other is the clone.
@@dereksawle no he's saying "which one I am/was" the I implies that there is someone there. Whichever I he is, is him. Otherwise you can ask yourself, "how do you know that you are real?" and not be able to answer. Decartes already covered this "I think therefore I am". If Karl was thinking about the clone, that means he can't be the clone because he is Karl. There is only one Karl. Otherwise any of us could be Karl.
_Karl Pilkington: a modern day philosopher_
"How would I know which one I was?"
I simply didn't expect that. It came out so genuinely and profound, it blew my mind a little. The ultimate existential dilemma "Am I real, or am I the clone?"
I'm not sure what show this is from, but I'm kinda infatuated by it, especially the 50's cartoon style, it's a fantastic touch!
Karl’s right about the clone... if it is an exact replica neither will know who the original is.
No, the one with all the memories will know it's the original, a clone won't have the same memories as the person it was cloned from.
An exact copy would have all the same memories
@@seminoleboy96 that's not what a clone is, a clone is made from someone's DNA, it's not an exact copy in terms of consciousness
@@squedex3164 They're not talking about a literal clone, they're talking about a replica which thinks the same, as they said, which would have the same memories.
ShufflinRhino he hasn’t changed though he is still him
😂😂😂 Play a record!
Imagine cloning yourself, with all memories including the act of cloning, and you recorded it and tagged the clone to denote that it’s the clone, only to discover that you were the clone with the tag and the duplicated memories fooled you. You basically realized everything you ever knew was a lie and you’ve only existed for however long it took to clone you. How depressing would that be
I would be fine about it 😂
3:11 Focus on the toe
See how you go on
And we'll have you next time u come in
Let me know
Anyway I gave this a go
Focusin' on the toe
Awesome video. I need to watch every week to keep inspired, motivated and remember what others have done.
The last clip Karl basically describes the plot to the film enemy
Zak A-R Enemy is more about a split personality than a clone
Most of these are just Ricky missunderstanding
And bullying him for his own stupidity or ignorance.
Karl's a genius. I will not be taking questions at this time.
You know it’s a doozy when Steve leaves the table in a laughing fit 😂
I can see what he means on alot of these, they didn't give him the chance to speak
That's the whole show
How old I know which one I was, is one of the most intelligent answers possible from an existential perspective.
Stephens answer from the jump gave off some "call of the void" vibes
It takes a genius to act like a total fool.
Thank you.
He's not acting ...v
He definitely is, but you’re dumb for not getting it
Clive Warren bit absolutely has me dying! 🤣
That clone one was deep, and had me thinking.
4:49 Yeah, there has been someone who said dumber things than Karl:
Katie Perry to Neill Degrasse Tyson: “Is math related to science?”
Yes, my favorite is here and it's #1 "How would I know which one I was?"
When are you making eye to eye contact with a fish lool. I've never forget, Karl is undefeated
The last one is a deep philosophical thought with legitimacy
I have always found Karl to be extremely profound with his thinking, its just he has no capability to put it into words other than breaking it down to its barest point, so in a way Ricky and Karl are the perfect fit, they are both extremes in that way.
4:20 I get where's he coming from. How would you know if you're the clone or not? If the clone have all of your memories and experiences, then how could you ever be sure that you weren't the clone? Unless you saw the clone being made. But if a clone just came into your life and claim he was the real you could never find out who was the real
-until the end of the 24 hours when the Clone stops existing.
No cause if you saw the clone being made that would still count as one of your memories that the clone would be imbued with. So either way there’s no way to really tell which one you are
I loved watching the Karl Pilkington show
Karl is amazing. I could just watch these guys talk to each other for days at a time
I totally get what he meant by still using his eyes while they are shut.
Steve’s line, “I don’t care” 1:52 is a mood
Ricky's laugh is Amazing.
How would I know which one I am? Is actually genius when you think about it.
What he is trying to say about jellyfish and octopi is that they appear, move and act alien compared to most other living species, which is true. The Clive Warren idea was part of S04 E06 Black Museum in the Black Mirror series. When he tried to "see" his toe without using his eyes he was trying to do a type of meditation. I also understand his questions regarding our consciousness and the awareness of our own existence. The way he expresses it though is utterly hilarious and no one in the world takes the mick out of someone like Ricky Gervais. And Stephen Merchant really increases the overall average height of the show.
Reminder that Karl's movie concept with Clive Warren and Rebecca Demornay actually became a Black Mirror episode.
“Jellyfish are 97% water or something, so how much are they doing? Just give them another 3% and make them water”
The look on Rick's face at 4:34
That was also my expression
4:33 😂😂
4:46 ............YES!!!. "As me or as a worm 🪱"
"How do I know which one I was?" Is actually one of the smartest things he's ever said.
"How would I know which one I was?"
Tried to take a sip of water while watching this... big mistake
EEEEEEY, THERE YOU ARE WHEATLEY!
The biggest mystery is how this video is only 5 minutes long 🤔
that last one is just philosophical
I want this to come back
these 3 need a new podcast.
Roundheaded genius. 😂
Love this show, It's so funny but also annoying when you know exactly what Karl's on about yet the other two just don't get it l.
When Ricky says "That's incredible!" I was in shock that he'd be agreeing with Karl... then... nevermind
@4:33 predicts the Mauler twins from Invincible
Karls animation is perfect
Karl is a legend.
i definitely think if karl had reasoned by saying, 'how would i know if i was the original?' it would have been much better
Love Ricky and Steve, but Karl is just much more relatable and real
Can we please bring this back
I love this
Last day on earth and he wants to kick a duck up the arse, it took me 10mins to compose myself enough to watch the rest of the video, brilliant Karl 😂
The 1st one reminded me how insane Stephen was back then 😂
Ty for this cartoon video joy😂😂🤣🤣
Can't believe Karl predicted living with yourself the Paul Rudd netflix show
The last point is quite a genuine stance in philosophy. I mean both you and your clone will claim to have experienced your past, but only one was physically there. If the clone were physically identical, there would be no way to distinguish the original!
That last one wasn't dumb. Karl had just watched The 6th Day.
Everyone in the comments is saying karl is a genius askinghow would he know if he was the clone, but that's not at all what he asked he asked "how'd I know which one is me?" Which is implying karl meets his clone and then goes 3rd person.
that last bit is where Paul Rudd got the idea for Living With Yourself
realistically the clone would know they are the clone, and you would know you are the original, because only one of you would have the memory of getting out of the cloning pod or walking out of the cloning facility etc
Karl talks absolute sense
One of my greatest fears is that Karl will change as a person.
There were simple animals who developed into quality humans.
What has gone wrong is the bully humans
Tbh I have to agree with Karl on the Clone one. If you were put to sleep at a random Time, cloned and you then you walked out of the 'cloning facility'. Because you and the clone are exactly the same person. You wouldn't know which one you were. Are you the original? The one who was cloned or are you the clone? Neither would know the truth because they are thinking the exact same thing.
I love the cartoon I wish they made a cartoon for the entire shows
Karl is a genius.
That totally makes sense, actually. If one of the versions of you is fake but has all the same memories, you wouldn’t be able to tell if you were the original or the copy.
Karl is 100% correct on the clone dilemma. If the clone was created with the exact same memories, you’d have no way of knowing if you were the original or the clone. It’s actually very insightful.
That last clip was literally the plot of Moon
The last one wasn't dumb at all. If the clone has the exact same memories as you, it wouldn't be obvious at all which one is the clone.
Both would say "not bothered"..😂😂😂😂😂😂
I love Karl
The clone dilemma has many versions. Blade Runner, BNHA's Double, even Naruto's clone jutsu can be considered in this discussion, and each one works in an individual manner to its environment.
Cartoon Ricky looks so cool.
It's hilarious! He looks exactly like Fred Flintstone.
He's said in an interview before his Character is sort of a cross between Fred Flintstone and Barney Rubble
Brilliant!