haven't seen anyone talk about development at such an essential level. most are busy talking about landing on mars while not even talking about the terrible quality of life fueled by uninspiring infrastructure. huge props to shashank.
Different sort of development. Landing on Mars, or developing missiles, gives you a strategic deterrence. One is not related to other. While the points are very much true. Our standard of living (in our mindset) & planning is just so low. Also, we have too many 2-wheelers. We can’t even restrict buying of 2-wheelers. What govt can do, is restrict buying of 2/3 vehicles per household in metro cities (unless the person/owner can show parking space). Removing street/cart vendors & providing vending zones for them. + lot of other steps. Basic stuff that they can implement , they never pay attention to. Like enforcing strict regulation on commodity carrying vehicles. I see open loads of cement on tractors in B’lore. Proper paved roads + road-edges matching with dust laden pavements/tracks on the side. These all are basic stuff. Again, nobody cares for this stuff. These can be taken care of.
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions Things we should ask from government:- ? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field ? What now about semiconductor plant ? ? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities. ? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean. ? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara") ? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting. ? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes ? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit) ? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea) ? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to . We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India ?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
@@D__Ujjwal you have raised good points, i have a response for each and every one of those points. Govt can't solve all those things, certain things, yes. But regardless a good list of things to ask ourselves.
Indian politicians SP, RJD, Baspa, NCP congress, TMC, Shiv Sena waley koi padhey likhey kam hi haijadatar BA, BCOM, LLB waley dhacchar hai joe student union leader gang sey ayey huay hsi, wo kya desh ka development ka khak karengey. Jebey bgarengey, daroo piyengey khatam.
@@6732VKWhy are you after Modi ji's Degree? He holds BA and Masters Degree. He is a visionary leader and has a foresight and within last 10 years, he transformed india to a next level, the BJP government is far better than previous crooked governments in the past. But sadly some people mindset is not ready to accept change and develop . They still don't want to see India change. Chalta hai na kind of attitude, greediness and lack of civic sense too. They just want to game the system, avoid paying taxes, cheating, adulteration, indulge in fraud and corruption. These are impediments that nedd to be weed out.
39:27 I saw my friend who was in Germany putting trash on designated bins. When we landed in India, he started throwing trash in open even when bin is available. I never understood the mentality. Only when I spoke, he noticed. He said, it was an unconscious action. I think when everyone in your immediate surrounding is following rule, people have no choice but to follow it too. No one wants to be the odd one in the group. Group behavior has positive/negative impact on individual behavior.
Its not "Thrash" but Trash.. Well Your friend is not behaving strange..When my uncle comes from Singapore, he advises us not to throw Kachra on the road as we'll be fined heavily and himself follow suit..!
We can't progress without a basic foundation and this explains the foundation of Singapore , we need to work on our foundations , Great video Vaad and Shanshak , really needed this , this won't get much of views but this definitely has created a category which I am sure other's will also take intrest in
Idhar foundation banane ke liye aadmi poori life nikaal deta hai. And Jo kuch bhi school me seekha, sab paani me jaata hai. Ameer log ke ladke aur ladkiyan khaana waste karti hain restaurants me.
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions Things we should ask from government:- ? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field ? What now about semiconductor plant ? ? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities. ? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean. ? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara") ? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting. ? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes ? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit) ? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea) ? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to . We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India ?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Bhai...India has been like this from 1947. we are actually getting better. Stop being cynical after watching such videos. mein 40 saal ke upar hoon. Ye kahaniyan maine pichle 30 saal se suni hai. ignore maro inko. India has its own path. "We can't progress" is a strong assertion to make based on one Video on Singapore. Singapore cant progress. u know why? Coz its tiny and is finite in everything.
@@atulborkar3504 Even countries under-developed than India have cleaner and better managed cities. Hiding behind the facade of all is well is the key reason for us not learning from our mistakes or from the successes of others.
We are still struck with feudal mentality where government & its bureaucracy are the elite and citizens are its subjects. There is a dire need for mentality change in how we view our public services.
Citizens of India are the biggest problem. In the first example of Delhi, where vehicles are merging due to unauthorized encroachments, if the government or bureaucrats start to clear these encroachments, people will start protesting, claiming that the poor are being wronged ("garibo ke sath galat ho raha hai"). I went trekking in HP and found it littered with alcohol and beer bottles, as well as chip packets. No government in the world can do anything if its citizens simply don't care and conveniently shift blame onto others. All government interventions will fail unless people reciprocate and understand their responsibilities.
@@Me7eOrmEmO1r2 true bhai Yogi govt in UP issued an order for teachers to do attendance digitally. Teacher union protested as if they were asked by govt to walk on burning coal. Teacher absenteeism in govt school is the biggest contributor in lower learning outcome and school dropouts
make a rule all government officials kids must get health services in govt. hospital, education in govt. school and colleges and see the impact after it. all govt. services suddenly become world class
Feeling very low after watching this video. Our officers and politicians don't seem to care about anything. I'm sure they are aware of these issues, but they will never implement the necessary changes. As long as problems exist, they continue to profit. It's not a lack of talent we suffer from, but a lack of intent. Our greatest achievements begin and end with UPI. It's hard to accept this reality. I know I will never see such roads, infrastructure, or cleanliness in my lifetime in India. That's how much trust I have in our officers and politicians. This video is heartbreaking.
Obviously but we can do our part by maintaining civic discipline and spreading this discipline, don't forget the north-east has this well established already, just videos from mizoram ... Just need to spread this ❤❤
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions Things we should ask from government:- ? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field ? What now about semiconductor plant ? ? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities. ? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean. ? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara") ? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting. ? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes ? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit) ? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea) ? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to . We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India ?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Inspirational video... I've visited singapore many times and whn i convey all this to our people.,.. But our people are not in a position to accept this kind of honest concept.
Excellent excellent excellent. Have been thinking about this for a long time. Dixit sahab hamesha mudde ki baat karte hai. Kudos to Arihant for covering this topic.
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions Things we should ask from government:- ? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field ? What now about semiconductor plant ? ? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities. ? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean. ? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara") ? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting. ? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes ? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit) ? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea) ? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to . We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India ?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
I always say this. Infact indian politicians are not that bad at all everybody is trying their best to do something. It's careless self entitled selfish people that is the problem.
The simplest thing to ask is good education for all which makes this primate into a thinking human being . No one asks for this and the man who provided this just spent 17 months in jail without trial.
Singapore's low corruption levels stem from a strong legal framework, an effective anti-corruption agency (CPIB), and a meritocratic public service. The government enforces strict anti-corruption laws with severe penalties, maintains transparency, and ensures public officials are well-compensated to reduce temptation. Strong political will, an efficient bureaucracy, public education, and an independent judiciary further reinforce a zero-tolerance culture toward corruption.
Hi, I'm a Tamil-speaking Singaporean who has never been to India. I think Indian cities CAN learn from Singapore, but it takes political will. After Deng Xiaoping's landmark visit to Singapore in 1978, Chinese leaders made a conscious decision to model their cities after Singapore. Look at Chinese cities today, clean, modern, well-maintained, and well-planned. India is full of brilliant minds, there is nothing the country cannot achieve if the people are united.
Kishore Mahbubani said indian politicians lacks accountability. Both Chinese and India sent officials to learn from Singapore. One country learns and adopt and tweak policies to suit their country and it prosper. The other? I think the officials wants a nice holiday or add another prestigious line in their CV without doing anything to improve the country
In a country where: - Over 70% of the population has been denied access to education and has lived in sub-human conditions for centuries, - The destiny of its people was controlled by foreign invaders and colonizers for over a thousand years, - Cleaning was viewed as the duty of a particular caste rather than a shared responsibility, After gaining independence, the country faced stark realities: -A society fragmented by over 5,000 castes, -Divided by more than 25,000 sub-castes, -Speaking over 800 languages, -Representing over 2,000 ethnic groups, -And six major religions, including one that locks its followers into a mindset from the 7th century. With such fragmentation and no strong sense of unity, true development remains elusive. Comparing this to a country like China is futile: - Over 90% of China’s population belongs to a single ethnicity, - China was ruled by its own dynasties until the 20th century, avoiding the depth of colonial poverty. Its people were educated, and its streets were clean. With no unifying sense of identity, this country has little hope for true development.
Bhai this is a clear example of what can be done if you put some effort and mind to it. Our ministers have always gone to these places. Modi himself has visited many countries and only thing that we hear is how people are singing praises about him. But there is no technology transfer no knowledge transfer nothing will change in this country of ours and amazing thing is people are proud of it. Amazing that we are actually accustomed to the way India is now.
Just google India send official to study Singapore. There are knowledge transfer. Did Indian official came here for holiday or the system is making it hard for them to implement improvement?
Waha ke authorities loose hogaye tho dekhlo ki kitne civilized rahenge... It's mostly about strict applications of rules and regulation and a bit of peoples discipline...
Kyun jhut bol rhe ho delh lia election main people dont want good train they want bailgadi tnat myst be free, they dont want roads they want mitti ka sadak toll free, thye dont want developed indian they want muftkhor india@@Vaad
Summarizing few takeaways from the video. 1. Not setting Accountability for individuals and Organizations. 2. Leaders focusing on short term fixes.Focussing on Prize rather than the process. 3. Public having holier than thou attitude towards "blue collar jobs". These are often critical for the support infrastructure. 4. Authority for urban planning not working properly/ or completely missing ? 5. Not Incentivizing good behavior and eliminating the bad behavior by harsh punishments by right legislation. 6. Not Embracing Technology enough. 7. Creation of Jobs/Industries is not enough. The ecosystem that comes along with it is often missing.
Can't praise this content enough. Kudos! Arihant bhai.....Your best podcast till date. Btw...I've shared this in all the Uncles', Aunties' Family whatsapp groups.....jahan din raat yahi baatcheet hoti rehti hai ki "iss desh ka kuch nahin ho sakta." It would be a pleasant change if we start talking about What's stopping us from achieving greatness and what needs to be done?
@@6732VK from education , critical thinking , understanding , adapting and improving . Our country elects the unworthy , at this world transformation era . we must rethink and revolve. ❤
a sugarcane juice wala in my town madhubani, bihar uses similar machine. he brought that from gujarat. was very proud of him when i got to know about it.
As Amjad khan in interview said, complete system change is necessary in India. Don't expect any change from current politicians of India from any political party. India still awaits great leadership like Singapore.
Singapore prime minister really loves modi ..... He clearly said it's only modi that thought about changing the system........ Modi bss 5 saal aur h bsss .....fir khtm fir jaati jaaati no development ....bss free bies appeasement
Singapore as it looks today is solely because of the vision of the leader like Lee Kwan Yu, he was a mild dictat or he imprisoned critics, banned Unionists, invited plane loads of private players and let the Singaporean markets be free from government interference while keeping it under the strict government watch in case the rights of Singaporeans don't get trampled over by private players, all in all for the sole intention of making Singapore a top class Nation on Par with those of the west and even ahead of them in many cases, and it worked because Lee Kwan Yu actually had a genuine motivation to make Singapore a great nation and not just grab as many capital as he could in the end to flee to a first world country like actual dictat ors from Africa or Latin America or just live a lavish lifestyle while his people live a peasant's life like under Gaddafi, Saddam, Khomeini etc. I personally love Lee Kwan Yu and i actually believe his mild dictat orial policies were totally justified as he foresaw the hindrances that would come in the garb of proponents of freedom of speech, labour unionists, sociàlists and dealt with them accordingly, something Modi can't do because it's a duckin democracy with a bunch of bureaucrats married to the families of activists journalists celebrities and politicians running the country and all of whom have common goal of being everything but a capitalistic country absolutely out of touch with the realities of the streets and the people that walk on it.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Vishwagurum Punah tabh hoga jabh caste based reservation se bahar aayenge but wait nahi jaat toh Sata paksha aur vipaksh dono ko chaiye toh enjoy Civic Sense Reservation se nahi aayegi
आम बोलचाल में हम भारतीय कहते हैं, "देश को साफ-सुथरा और व्यवस्थित रखना हम नागरिकों की जिम्मेदारी है; हम इसके लिए अकेले सरकार को दोषी नहीं ठहरा सकते।" शायद हमारे देश की सरकारों और सरकारी एजेंसियों ने इस तथ्य को बहुत सहजता से स्वीकार कर लिया है कि देश के नागरिक और जनसंख्या ही सारी अव्यवस्था की जड़ हैं। चूंकि वे अपनी जिम्मेदारियों को पूरी तरह से नहीं निभाते, इसलिए सरकार व्यवस्थाओं में कितना सुधार ला सकती हैं? तो जब सरकारें पब्लिक-प्राइवेट भागीदारी को बढ़ावा देना चाहती हैं और "सबका साथ सबका विकास" और "स्वच्छ भारत" जैसे नारे और अभियान चलाना चाहती हैं, तो क्यों न सार्वजनिक भागीदारी को सिर्फ़ एक अभियान तक सीमित न कर दिया जाए, बल्कि पब्लिक-प्राइवेट मॉडल अपनाकर एक "इंसेंटिव सिस्टम" शुरू की जाए जिस से स्वच्छता और व्यवस्था लाने के लिए सहयोग करने, भाग लेने और स्वयं सेवा प्रदान करने के लिए हम भारतीयों को प्रेरित किया जाए? हमारी सरकारें पब्लिक-प्राइवेट मॉडल के माध्यम से देश की सबसे बड़ी ताकतों में से एक - प्रचुर और गुणवत्तापूर्ण हमारे “तकनीकी संसाधनों” - का लाभ क्यों नहीं उठा सकतीं और मौजूदा प्रणालियों को मजबूत करने और हमारे देश की कानूनी प्रणाली में बदलाव का एक ऐसा मॉडल लाने के लिए AI जैसी अत्याधुनिक तकनीकों का उपयोग क्यों नहीं कर सकतीं जो भारत जैसे बड़े और विविधतापूर्ण देश के लिए उपयुक्त हो? इसके आधार पर सरकार मौजूदा कानूनों का पालन सुनिश्चित कर सकती है और नए नियम भी बनाकर लागू किए जा सकते हैं। साथ ही उनका विनियमन भी? तो, जैसे ही मौजूदा और नई व्यवस्थाएं और कानून लागू होंगे और देश के नागरिकों को उनका पालन करने के लिए प्रोत्साहन और उल्लंघन करने पर दंडित किया जाएगा, सकारात्मक बदलाव आने लगेंगे। ऐसे बदलावों के लिए देशव्यापी बुनियादी ढांचे के निर्माण के लिए इंतजार करने की जरूरत नहीं है। सरकारें बिना किसी देरी के ऐसे कामों को लागू कर सकती हैं, खासकर अब जब हमारे देश में "UID आधार" जैसी व्यवस्था उपलब्ध है। साथ ही, हमारी सरकारों को सिंगापुर जैसे देशों से प्रेरित होकर भारत के लिए उपयुक्त सुविचारित, नए और आधुनिक बुनियादी ढांचे और प्रणालियों पर काम करना चाहिए। और मौजूदा व नए बुनियादी ढांचे में समन्वय लाकर उन्हें भी मजबूत करना चाहिए। कहने की जरूरत नहीं है कि हमारे देश के शिक्षा, स्वास्थ्य, मानव संसाधन, रोजगार और मानवाधिकारों जैसे क्षेत्रों में रणनीतिक रूप से समानांतर बदलाव किए जाने चाहिए। इस तरह, हम 2047 में भारत को विकसित करने के लक्ष्य को बहुत पहले प्राप्त कर सकते हैं। बस हमें एक-जुटता और दृढ़निश्चय के साथ क्रियान्वयन की आवश्यकता है। हमें याद रखना चाहिए कि हमारे देश की जनसंख्या ही हमारी परम शक्ति है।
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions Things we should ask from government:- ? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field ? What now about semiconductor plant ? ? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities. ? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean. ? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara") ? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting. ? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes ? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit) ? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea) ? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to . We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India ?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Our primary problem is our multi level multi parties democratic system which is against any kind of central level planning for development . Secondary problem is our fixed method of bureaucratic system where we hire mostly inexperienced, bookworm type manpower after a bookish knowledge based examination and keeping them until their retirement without proper evaluation of their performance or practical knowledge promoting them only basis of seniority. And another problem is critical and contradictory laws and rules with slow judiciary system .
Singapore is a well planned country. India has a lot to learn from them. The subject you have taken up is very interesting and informative. One of the most intelligent programme I have come across so far. Thank you for the content.
Amazing facts, it's true, when I share these with my friends and relatives in india they try to defend india instead of try to learn and change their attitude, keep up your good work
The reason why they don't allow people to buy multiple house is that , govt expect people to work and earn rather than just buy and sell and buy and sell. The govt expect people to work of any age and do the efforts in earning, Along with this they are giving opportunity for middle class to get chance. Great video and good perspective. Expecting more such videos
Singapore ki population 60 lakhs hai aur wahan pe 9 lakhs vehicles hain, India mein it’s the other way round and the issue is with the heavy population with various class of people. Singapore is also filled with health conscious and fit people, you look fat and obese, follow their healthy ways of life also if you’re so inspired.
You're constantly comparing with Delhi, which has one of the best transport infra than other Indian cities. Try small Indian cities and towns. You will be traumatised.
This video should be taught in all schools. RTO department needs to be scrapped, even Nitin Gadkari wants to get rid of it. Driving tests should be privatised. Driving education should be a 1 month course, to bridge the huge gap that we have now. Later it can be a 5 day course with an exam and practical exam. Give power to beurocracy and they always use it to do corruption. Never for country's greater good. I'm fed up with all this mismanagement by beurocracy.
A very good effort to introspect. However, after viewing the video, it's very clear that such planning would need atleast a century to take place in India. The interviewer was so casual when he was telling that it is not a rocket science and we can do it in two years. I think it's only a wishful thinking. We have been able to provide the most basic things to our citizens in the last 75 yrs.
Hope India will improve… we Indian also deserve quality life like other countries’ citizens enjoying… whereas Indians are struggling for basics in this century this is horrible even after paying hefty amount of taxes on everything
As an Indian we take pride in breaking rules.We keep lamenting the corrupt system but no body takes the responsibility of following rules........how many of us have gone to proper driving school to learn driving or learned the driving instructions? Hygiene is not followed at home let alone outside food outlets. How many Indian houses have clean toilets ? Cleanliness begins at home.😂
I can say this is the best content I have even seen in RUclips. Thank you very much for this content. Now I am thinking to write a mail to PMO & CMO so that they can think on this. Kindly share more this type of content so that people can watch, learn & act.
Superb video.. I live in dubai and dubai authorities openly say they are following Singapore model of development... The problem in India is corruption
China and Hawaii political party also said the same thing following Singapore model on how to fix the housing crisis issue and build affordable public housing for their people. Dubai also requested Singapore to build them the NeWater system that collect sea water and turn them into safe drinking water for every household
Lol.. Indian beraucratic mindset is that you give them one innovative idea they'll make you count 100 ways and reasons it cannot be done. This tour should be given to beraucratic trainees..
I am a 2nd generation born Singaporean from India origin. My family and I have visited India from the early 2000s frequently. India has come a long way. As an outsider India today is at major crossroads which will shape India’s future in the next 20-30 years. India's strength is its democracy and diversity but it’s crucial for the nation to know when to put aside differences and act as one. In 1978, China's key leader Deng Xiaoping and others visited Singapore and made a conscious decision to model their cities after Singapore and they achieved it. There is nothing India cannot achieve if the people are united!!
@@daydaystudydaydayup there can be an infinite scenarios based on "if" but with no evidence to prove it, then why wonder? Good governance can be looked and studied upon based on a nation's history, the decision the government chooses to make based on today's reality which will shape a nation's future.
Are bhai... mai jaha rehata hu, vo Block ke samne vala signal pass kiya aapne abhi, Boundary Road, Serangoon Avenue 4, Blk 211😂, 2:01... 2:25 ke bich me, felt very happy as I watch your podcasts 🥰
Stupendous.❤❤❤❤.. This is really CONTENT which we want to see and discuss further instead of wasting time on celebrities interview or similar kind of unnecessary discussion on YT.
The best part of Singapore is the ruthless punishments, once you are in jail, they beat your bum until you can't walk straight - everyone knows you got beat in jail like a dog. So when you come out of jail, there is no bad boy glamor or bad girl glamor attached. Hence, people are shit scared to go to prison, purely because of the beating & the humiliation EVERYONE knows you got there.
I am a cyclist and biker in Singapore and cycled across Singapore roads for 6+ years. There are pot holes occasionally. You have to be careful otherwise you have to take the road jerk. Unlike India,Singapore used to be a rainforest and it is easy to clear the forest to create a city.
Hi Ganesh, Singapore is a mix of greenfield and brownfield development. While some vegetation was cleared, A lot of villages were converted to HDB and city area. Existing CBD was also converted to modernity, what we see now.
Please tell me where are these potholes good sir. I am a PCN cyclist of all the East - ECP, Tanah Merah Coastal Express Way, pasir ris, loyang, Tampines etc I detect something else
@@6732VK you missed the point. I talk about Roads, not PCN. Also, I said "occasional" pot holes, meaning pot holes can appear after heavy rains and cyclists taking Roads must be careful at all times.
Singapore is definitely great. Most workers working on road construction in Singapore are from India. So Indian workers can make same quality roads in India too if companies want to. But I think road construction in India has a different model, focus is on making more roads at a lower cost. If govt prioritise even higher cost of road construction in India, then lot of road projects will never be implemented. There have been road markings in India too, especially on NH its good. But within cities , falling under state govt , that aspect is poor.
I have a point on housing in india when you operate free market in highly unequal society most of assets prices are bid up by high income individuals, prices of home skyrocketed in metros but income of mid wage earners not vis-a-vis. Therefore, rent increases to cover cost of acquisition of house. So basically what happens one might ended up with so many home might unoccupied others have nothing. Singaporean gov. is smart enough to understand that it did not allowed to operate private players in housing bcuz it know how market distributes it fruits.
Arihant - Extremely important video. We'll scale this conversation to an unprecedented level. Thanks and you should replicate this format .. walk / background based. Refreshingly different yet important.
यहां तो smart card license बनवाया ओर जब renew करने को दिया तो वो लाइसेंस online register ही नही किया गया जिसकी वजह से दोबारा learner license से apply करना पड़ा। ये efficiency है।
In India A) plastic needs to be banned and plastic in circulation needs to be retrieved destroyed B) Sanitization needs overhaul C) People need to be co opted in the upkeep of cities and towns.
Its an ecosystem. We need to have federalism not state wise but city wise aka give more power to elected city officials who can work with local colleges, collect taxes and build that city.
@@dhari-rl6su Yes thats the problem. But why doesnt same corruption happen in US or China? Because it does happen. Heck it happens even in a society where Chanda is collected. Corruption can be yeeted out only via reducing govt. But here I am talking about taking power from states to city and making them accountable. Governance will be better.
you are right the mixture is nearly same, except in very hot and very cold climate, inindia and pak we use very little bitumin and heat it too much so it can coat the aggregates very well, as with high tempm it get thin, but then bitumin looses its power of gluing, and when rain comes it disintegrate the road.
Good content. Talking about oneself taking the responsibility of change: that has not happened in India yet. Talking about planning: people don't have macro level decision capability yet. They can take micro decisions but they are independent of each other and does not take the whole into account. Talking about cleanliness: I hoped the swatchh bharat campaign had taken the drive to its final conclusion (to make whole of India clean like Singapore by changing people's mindset).
It’s not about the Government in India. It is about the people who don’t care for rules and regulations. When they visit Singapore or other developed countries, they go out of the way to follow rules. But the moment they are in an Indian environment, the will not miss even a second to flaunt the rules and make their priority the most important one by neglecting basic human rights or rules of the road. If even all people who have traveled abroad and seen the traffic rules and follow the same in India, I am sure there will be a minimum 20% change in road user attitude. It all starts with us. Not the government. Government already had the laws and rules in place. It’s for us to follow and believe in those rules and regulations. Till then India will not change. Agree?
Wrong. People will follow only when rules are strict. In India people don't follow because rules are not the same for all. People who escape either havecontacts with officials or pay money to authority. How can you make rules same when your system is corrupt?
@themotorcyclechronicles2812. Righly said & completely agree on what you mentioned. Our expectations are so much on the others, be it the people or govt. Why we dont start with us. If others are not following traffic signal you follow. If others are throwing waste in the open you start using the dustbin. Should't it start from small and then grow big as a revolution. Spread the words to your neighbors / friends / relatives and who ever who can listen to you in a positive way. I know its difficult but not impossible
@@merabharatmahan9621 Thanks! That’s the way it has to be.. it should start with us… rather than simply push it on Govt and complain on roads (of course roads need improvement in many cities). On the other hand I must say that it’s been about 20 years since the last time I drove / rode in India. The roads are somuch better (highways). And the traffic sense of highway users has really really “Improved”. But it’s still a long way before we actually start hearing zero honking anywhere;)
Such in-depth conversation is necessary. If the people in charge of India are genuinely interested, I don't see anything in Singapore that can't be implemented here. These are all available best practises and technologies.
@@haritt-mh2synot possible in india for sure the discipline in citizens not there special poor states like Bihar up jharkhand bengal odisha are too unhygienic
When I visited Singapore, I was absolutely stunned to see how well managed everything is and how beautifully and aesthetically people take care of everything. Noticed the same in some other countries too. He said the correct thing about climate.
This video should be seen by all Indians especially those responsible in charge of development including those in bureaucracy, politicians. These things are very easy to implement as seen in this video.
Bahaar hawkers mai sasta khana mai nipta diya. Iske ghar pe lunch karne ko bolte toh batata ki singapore mai bohot rarely ghar pe khana banana allowed hota hai.
Both man have different reactions on everything especially white shirt sir he feel bad due to continuous recalling of his own country conditions. Although I am indian living in india feel literally bad.
Never seen anyone who is this much concerned about infrastructure, urban planning and basic human needs. Hat's off to you buddy🙋🏻♂️ this is much needed. Indian's are just one step behind to do this they just have to think about it ❤
लोगों ने केजरीवाल को बाड़ की तरह लगाया पर बाड़ ही खेत को खाने लगी।आजतक पर सुधीर चौधरी ने बताया कि आईएस करने वाले बच्चों की तकलीफ़ कैसी हालत में हैं। कोई प्लानिंग नहीं है।
Indian municipalities need to recruit more town planners and architects for city planning and space planning rather than just civil engineers. Then only aesthetics and infrastructure development will go hand in hand. Also this channel must try to cover the 2030 development plan of Singapore wherein how future planning of the city is taken care of will be evident. Moral of the story is the civic sense of common Singaporeans and their governments will power is commendable.
I really hope that videos on this type of framework will be more frequent, realllllyyyyy liked the content, I'll give my suggestion on last question by more research on this ❤❤❤ love you team
Problem is system level enforcement, if actors in the system know that everybody is following rules, then all will follow. We haven't moved to post industrialised standards
haven't seen anyone talk about development at such an essential level. most are busy talking about landing on mars while not even talking about the terrible quality of life fueled by uninspiring infrastructure. huge props to shashank.
Different sort of development.
Landing on Mars, or developing missiles, gives you a strategic deterrence.
One is not related to other.
While the points are very much true. Our standard of living (in our mindset) & planning is just so low.
Also, we have too many 2-wheelers. We can’t even restrict buying of 2-wheelers.
What govt can do, is restrict buying of 2/3 vehicles per household in metro cities (unless the person/owner can show parking space).
Removing street/cart vendors & providing vending zones for them.
+ lot of other steps.
Basic stuff that they can implement , they never pay attention to.
Like enforcing strict regulation on commodity carrying vehicles.
I see open loads of cement on tractors in B’lore.
Proper paved roads + road-edges matching with dust laden pavements/tracks on the side.
These all are basic stuff.
Again, nobody cares for this stuff.
These can be taken care of.
both are different things , work can be done on so many things at once
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions
Things we should ask from government:-
? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field
? What now about semiconductor plant ?
? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities.
? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean.
? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara")
? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting.
? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes
? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit)
? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea)
? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to .
We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India
?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Mars landing is just as important to d growth. Those leaps have ripple effects in many parts of society
@@D__Ujjwal you have raised good points, i have a response for each and every one of those points. Govt can't solve all those things, certain things, yes. But regardless a good list of things to ask ourselves.
This is why Lee Kwan Yew was so disappointed with our indian politicians.. He had great hopes for our countries to cooperate and develop together
Indian politicians SP, RJD, Baspa, NCP congress, TMC, Shiv Sena waley koi padhey likhey kam hi haijadatar BA, BCOM, LLB waley dhacchar hai joe student union leader gang sey ayey huay hsi, wo kya desh ka development ka khak karengey. Jebey bgarengey, daroo piyengey khatam.
@@AB-cw7gl you forgot our beloved Modiji with his invisible degree
@@6732VKWhy are you after Modi ji's Degree? He holds BA and Masters Degree. He is a visionary leader and has a foresight and within last 10 years, he transformed india to a next level, the BJP government is far better than previous crooked governments in the past. But sadly some people mindset is not ready to accept change and develop . They still don't want to see India change. Chalta hai na kind of attitude, greediness and lack of civic sense too. They just want to game the system, avoid paying taxes, cheating, adulteration, indulge in fraud and corruption. These are impediments that nedd to be weed out.
@@AB-cw7gl uneducated comments need not be answered. I also apologise now that we are a developed country and wishwaguru.
@@AB-cw7gl
Lol
39:27 I saw my friend who was in Germany putting trash on designated bins. When we landed in India, he started throwing trash in open even when bin is available. I never understood the mentality. Only when I spoke, he noticed. He said, it was an unconscious action. I think when everyone in your immediate surrounding is following rule, people have no choice but to follow it too. No one wants to be the odd one in the group. Group behavior has positive/negative impact on individual behavior.
"Environment shapes behavior"
Its not "Thrash" but Trash.. Well Your friend is not behaving strange..When my uncle comes from Singapore, he advises us not to throw Kachra on the road as we'll be fined heavily and himself follow suit..!
Sahi baath, group behavior makes impact. 👍
@@RamchandraSwamy Thank you for pointing out. It was typo error.
@@RamchandraSwamy Is he Singaporean or residing in Singapore for a long time. Behavioural changes take time. My friend moved to Germany recently.
We can't progress without a basic foundation and this explains the foundation of Singapore , we need to work on our foundations , Great video Vaad and Shanshak , really needed this , this won't get much of views but this definitely has created a category which I am sure other's will also take intrest in
Idhar foundation banane ke liye aadmi poori life nikaal deta hai. And Jo kuch bhi school me seekha, sab paani me jaata hai. Ameer log ke ladke aur ladkiyan khaana waste karti hain restaurants me.
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions
Things we should ask from government:-
? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field
? What now about semiconductor plant ?
? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities.
? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean.
? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara")
? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting.
? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes
? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit)
? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea)
? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to .
We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India
?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Wese bhi kuch nahi hoga, too much corruption and too much concentration of power.
Bhai...India has been like this from 1947. we are actually getting better. Stop being cynical after watching such videos. mein 40 saal ke upar hoon. Ye kahaniyan maine pichle 30 saal se suni hai. ignore maro inko. India has its own path. "We can't progress" is a strong assertion to make based on one Video on Singapore. Singapore cant progress. u know why? Coz its tiny and is finite in everything.
@@atulborkar3504 Even countries under-developed than India have cleaner and better managed cities. Hiding behind the facade of all is well is the key reason for us not learning from our mistakes or from the successes of others.
lack of accountability is main problem here, bureaucracy here work for big elites and suppress citizens
We are still struck with feudal mentality where government & its bureaucracy are the elite and citizens are its subjects. There is a dire need for mentality change in how we view our public services.
Accountability that's the main culprit in India
Citizens of India are the biggest problem. In the first example of Delhi, where vehicles are merging due to unauthorized encroachments, if the government or bureaucrats start to clear these encroachments, people will start protesting, claiming that the poor are being wronged ("garibo ke sath galat ho raha hai").
I went trekking in HP and found it littered with alcohol and beer bottles, as well as chip packets. No government in the world can do anything if its citizens simply don't care and conveniently shift blame onto others.
All government interventions will fail unless people reciprocate and understand their responsibilities.
@@Me7eOrmEmO1r2 true bhai
Yogi govt in UP issued an order for teachers to do attendance digitally. Teacher union protested as if they were asked by govt to walk on burning coal. Teacher absenteeism in govt school is the biggest contributor in lower learning outcome and school dropouts
@@Me7eOrmEmO1r2 People of India have forgotten that constitution has also provided fundamental duties along with fundamental rights.
Scrap UPSC. If India wants to grow!
Reservation system too
Why don’t we provide high quality and free primary and secondary education so that our population is made up of capable people
make a rule all government officials kids must get health services in govt. hospital, education in govt. school and colleges and see the impact after it. all govt. services suddenly become world class
@@prantosarathy386 all religions & caste too &
@@param888 the most ridiculous suggestion. Do it the other way around . Make the schools so excellent that everyone will want to send their children.
Feeling very low after watching this video. Our officers and politicians don't seem to care about anything. I'm sure they are aware of these issues, but they will never implement the necessary changes. As long as problems exist, they continue to profit. It's not a lack of talent we suffer from, but a lack of intent. Our greatest achievements begin and end with UPI. It's hard to accept this reality. I know I will never see such roads, infrastructure, or cleanliness in my lifetime in India. That's how much trust I have in our officers and politicians. This video is heartbreaking.
Obviously but we can do our part by maintaining civic discipline and spreading this discipline, don't forget the north-east has this well established already, just videos from mizoram ... Just need to spread this ❤❤
Welp keep voting same people in power, again and again.
Don't worry god choose us we do it so our kids will get benifits.
@@chocolatemilkshake9168im from southern Assam and have seen traffic in mizoram and manipur but they are almost as same as rest of indian bullshii
Lol come to my city 😂
This is great effort Arihant. A much needed blackpill to our society, politicians and bureaucrats.
lekin black pill hazam nhi hogi hamare logon ko, they will fall in despair.
It's a whitepill though! See how such small but smart efforts make all the difference in making a city liveable.
Was in Singapore in May this year with family on vacation, Really Hats off to all Singaporeans they are So disciplined!!!!
East Asian mentality. Very disciplined
India with discipline....I keep hoping there will be a day when people follow rules
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions
Things we should ask from government:-
? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field
? What now about semiconductor plant ?
? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities.
? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean.
? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara")
? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting.
? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes
? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit)
? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea)
? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to .
We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India
?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Indians won't be disciplined untill we are beaten to do so. We have taken democracy as freedom to do anything@@askinc102
39:27 Discipline is not not inherent and can easily be cultivated as said in the truck driver example
Inspirational video... I've visited singapore many times and whn i convey all this to our people.,.. But our people are not in a position to accept this kind of honest concept.
Who have said one correct word - honest
Excellent excellent excellent. Have been thinking about this for a long time. Dixit sahab hamesha mudde ki baat karte hai. Kudos to Arihant for covering this topic.
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions
Things we should ask from government:-
? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field
? What now about semiconductor plant ?
? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities.
? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean.
? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara")
? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting.
? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes
? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit)
? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea)
? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to .
We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India
?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
It's not Indian cities or Indian politics.
It's Indians 😅
Old saying in business:
it's not a business problem, it's a human problem.
I always say this. Infact indian politicians are not that bad at all everybody is trying their best to do something. It's careless self entitled selfish people that is the problem.
@@lantherpagdi I include politicians in people,
I don't blame only politicians, or only one political party or one community of people, I include all
KAMU，BE丅0L，SEKAL|，😁😁😁😁😁😁😀😀😀😀😀
I hope this becomes the most watched vlog in india and people start demanding such simple things from the government.
The simplest thing to ask is good education for all which makes this primate into a thinking human being . No one asks for this and the man who provided this just spent 17 months in jail without trial.
@@makrandpalkar1192 please no. What a waste of time
Singapore's low corruption levels stem from a strong legal framework, an effective anti-corruption agency (CPIB), and a meritocratic public service. The government enforces strict anti-corruption laws with severe penalties, maintains transparency, and ensures public officials are well-compensated to reduce temptation. Strong political will, an efficient bureaucracy, public education, and an independent judiciary further reinforce a zero-tolerance culture toward corruption.
Salute to the president lee kuan yew,who built this wonderful country from the scratch
I agree he was a great guy and he deeply respectfull to Hindus and india too..
LKY sg ke pm the bhai president nahi
He was our PM, not president bro. LOL
Bro Singapore is half the size of Delhi
Hi, I'm a Tamil-speaking Singaporean who has never been to India. I think Indian cities CAN learn from Singapore, but it takes political will. After Deng Xiaoping's landmark visit to Singapore in 1978, Chinese leaders made a conscious decision to model their cities after Singapore. Look at Chinese cities today, clean, modern, well-maintained, and well-planned. India is full of brilliant minds, there is nothing the country cannot achieve if the people are united.
Kishore Mahbubani said indian politicians lacks accountability.
Both Chinese and India sent officials to learn from Singapore.
One country learns and adopt and tweak policies to suit their country and it prosper.
The other? I think the officials wants a nice holiday or add another prestigious line in their CV without doing anything to improve the country
In a country where:
- Over 70% of the population has been denied access to education and has lived in sub-human conditions for centuries,
- The destiny of its people was controlled by foreign invaders and colonizers for over a thousand years,
- Cleaning was viewed as the duty of a particular caste rather than a shared responsibility,
After gaining independence, the country faced stark realities:
-A society fragmented by over 5,000 castes,
-Divided by more than 25,000 sub-castes,
-Speaking over 800 languages,
-Representing over 2,000 ethnic groups,
-And six major religions, including one that locks its followers into a mindset from the 7th century.
With such fragmentation and no strong sense of unity, true development remains elusive. Comparing this to a country like China is futile:
- Over 90% of China’s population belongs to a single ethnicity,
- China was ruled by its own dynasties until the 20th century, avoiding the depth of colonial poverty. Its people were educated, and its streets were clean.
With no unifying sense of identity, this country has little hope for true development.
Bhai this is a clear example of what can be done if you put some effort and mind to it. Our ministers have always gone to these places. Modi himself has visited many countries and only thing that we hear is how people are singing praises about him. But there is no technology transfer no knowledge transfer nothing will change in this country of ours and amazing thing is people are proud of it. Amazing that we are actually accustomed to the way India is now.
Just google India send official to study Singapore. There are knowledge transfer.
Did Indian official came here for holiday or the system is making it hard for them to implement improvement?
Hey Bhagwan hum log toh ekdum uncivilized hain. Great program. Thank you Arihant bhai.
U missed the point it is not how uncivilized but apathy from the road authorities for not painting the roads which discipline the traffic
Waha ke authorities loose hogaye tho dekhlo ki kitne civilized rahenge...
It's mostly about strict applications of rules and regulation and a bit of peoples discipline...
Thanks. But the point of the video is that systems drive behavior and we can bring a transformative change by doing the small things right.
Kyun jhut bol rhe ho delh lia election main people dont want good train they want bailgadi tnat myst be free, they dont want roads they want mitti ka sadak toll free, thye dont want developed indian they want muftkhor india@@Vaad
@@Ekanth_the_01 Waha pe koi danda nahi maartey to keep things civil. Wahan indians jaise gawaar nahi hai zyada.
Summarizing few takeaways from the video.
1. Not setting Accountability for individuals and Organizations.
2. Leaders focusing on short term fixes.Focussing on Prize rather than the process.
3. Public having holier than thou attitude towards "blue collar jobs". These are often critical for the support infrastructure.
4. Authority for urban planning not working properly/ or completely missing ?
5. Not Incentivizing good behavior and eliminating the bad behavior by harsh punishments by right legislation.
6. Not Embracing Technology enough.
7. Creation of Jobs/Industries is not enough. The ecosystem that comes along with it is often missing.
@@ashishsrivastav8956 I would give you only 2% marks for font and numbering. Content shows lack of thought, reading and understanding of the world
@@6732VK Then you get off your high horse and enlighten us buddy.
@@ashishsrivastav8956 no can do
Huge uneducated population, corruption at all levels, tax evasion, improper use of miniscule taxes collected, and lack of right skills and management.
Can't praise this content enough. Kudos! Arihant bhai.....Your best podcast till date.
Btw...I've shared this in all the Uncles', Aunties' Family whatsapp groups.....jahan din raat yahi baatcheet hoti rehti hai ki "iss desh ka kuch nahin ho sakta." It would be a pleasant change if we start talking about What's stopping us from achieving greatness and what needs to be done?
@gauravawasthi6212. I wish we had all the people like you in India, would really have been a much greater place.
Haha. Thanks Gaurav.
These uncle aunties will all say "iss desh ka kuch nhi hoga" and they are the first to break rules, not follow civic rules and discipline
Civic sense is all we need in India 🇮🇳
@@Mukesh_Singh91 where does it come from ?
@@6732VK from education , critical thinking , understanding , adapting and improving .
Our country elects the unworthy , at this world transformation era . we must rethink and revolve. ❤
Bring it in the mainstream education.
Arihant bhai, this was a refreshing change of pace from the standard sitting podcast format. Would love to see more of such content in future.
@@vaibhavsharma6831 no we wouldn’t. Go make videos on education or the lack of it in India
a sugarcane juice wala in my town madhubani, bihar uses similar machine. he brought that from gujarat. was very proud of him when i got to know about it.
As Amjad khan in interview said, complete system change is necessary in India. Don't expect any change from current politicians of India from any political party. India still awaits great leadership like Singapore.
Singapore prime minister really loves modi ..... He clearly said it's only modi that thought about changing the system........ Modi bss 5 saal aur h bsss .....fir khtm fir jaati jaaati no development ....bss free bies appeasement
Singapore as it looks today is solely because of the vision of the leader like Lee Kwan Yu, he was a mild dictat or he imprisoned critics, banned Unionists, invited plane loads of private players and let the Singaporean markets be free from government interference while keeping it under the strict government watch in case the rights of Singaporeans don't get trampled over by private players, all in all for the sole intention of making Singapore a top class Nation on Par with those of the west and even ahead of them in many cases, and it worked because Lee Kwan Yu actually had a genuine motivation to make Singapore a great nation and not just grab as many capital as he could in the end to flee to a first world country like actual dictat ors from Africa or Latin America or just live a lavish lifestyle while his people live a peasant's life like under Gaddafi, Saddam, Khomeini etc.
I personally love Lee Kwan Yu and i actually believe his mild dictat orial policies were totally justified as he foresaw the hindrances that would come in the garb of proponents of freedom of speech, labour unionists, sociàlists and dealt with them accordingly, something Modi can't do because it's a duckin democracy with a bunch of bureaucrats married to the families of activists journalists celebrities and politicians running the country and all of whom have common goal of being everything but a capitalistic country absolutely out of touch with the realities of the streets and the people that walk on it.
@@z.h.farooqui2608 all but 1 party
Aboo Kejriwal has already done that to Delhi where are you sleeping
All this development came from japbese help cause japan colonised Singapore ..
India me logo ko ego problem jyada hai..
Sab apne aap ko seth ji samjhte hai ..
Arey hum toh vishwaguru superpower hai😂
India me har caste ke apne groups hain, we like to pull others down.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 comment delete hojarahe warna batata hun tereko.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 har jagah mat aaya kar bhai tu chaa mudwaane..
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Vishwagurum Punah tabh hoga jabh caste based reservation se bahar aayenge but wait nahi jaat toh Sata paksha aur vipaksh dono ko chaiye toh enjoy Civic Sense Reservation se nahi aayegi
आम बोलचाल में हम भारतीय कहते हैं, "देश को साफ-सुथरा और व्यवस्थित रखना हम नागरिकों की जिम्मेदारी है; हम इसके लिए अकेले सरकार को दोषी नहीं ठहरा सकते।" शायद हमारे देश की सरकारों और सरकारी एजेंसियों ने इस तथ्य को बहुत सहजता से स्वीकार कर लिया है कि देश के नागरिक और जनसंख्या ही सारी अव्यवस्था की जड़ हैं। चूंकि वे अपनी जिम्मेदारियों को पूरी तरह से नहीं निभाते, इसलिए सरकार व्यवस्थाओं में कितना सुधार ला सकती हैं?
तो जब सरकारें पब्लिक-प्राइवेट भागीदारी को बढ़ावा देना चाहती हैं और "सबका साथ सबका विकास" और "स्वच्छ भारत" जैसे नारे और अभियान चलाना चाहती हैं, तो क्यों न सार्वजनिक भागीदारी को सिर्फ़ एक अभियान तक सीमित न कर दिया जाए, बल्कि पब्लिक-प्राइवेट मॉडल अपनाकर एक "इंसेंटिव सिस्टम" शुरू की जाए जिस से स्वच्छता और व्यवस्था लाने के लिए सहयोग करने, भाग लेने और स्वयं सेवा प्रदान करने के लिए हम भारतीयों को प्रेरित किया जाए?
हमारी सरकारें पब्लिक-प्राइवेट मॉडल के माध्यम से देश की सबसे बड़ी ताकतों में से एक - प्रचुर और गुणवत्तापूर्ण हमारे “तकनीकी संसाधनों” - का लाभ क्यों नहीं उठा सकतीं और मौजूदा प्रणालियों को मजबूत करने और हमारे देश की कानूनी प्रणाली में बदलाव का एक ऐसा मॉडल लाने के लिए AI जैसी अत्याधुनिक तकनीकों का उपयोग क्यों नहीं कर सकतीं जो भारत जैसे बड़े और विविधतापूर्ण देश के लिए उपयुक्त हो? इसके आधार पर सरकार मौजूदा कानूनों का पालन सुनिश्चित कर सकती है और नए नियम भी बनाकर लागू किए जा सकते हैं। साथ ही उनका विनियमन भी?
तो, जैसे ही मौजूदा और नई व्यवस्थाएं और कानून लागू होंगे और देश के नागरिकों को उनका पालन करने के लिए प्रोत्साहन और उल्लंघन करने पर दंडित किया जाएगा, सकारात्मक बदलाव आने लगेंगे। ऐसे बदलावों के लिए देशव्यापी बुनियादी ढांचे के निर्माण के लिए इंतजार करने की जरूरत नहीं है। सरकारें बिना किसी देरी के ऐसे कामों को लागू कर सकती हैं, खासकर अब जब हमारे देश में "UID आधार" जैसी व्यवस्था उपलब्ध है।
साथ ही, हमारी सरकारों को सिंगापुर जैसे देशों से प्रेरित होकर भारत के लिए उपयुक्त सुविचारित, नए और आधुनिक बुनियादी ढांचे और प्रणालियों पर काम करना चाहिए। और मौजूदा व नए बुनियादी ढांचे में समन्वय लाकर उन्हें भी मजबूत करना चाहिए।
कहने की जरूरत नहीं है कि हमारे देश के शिक्षा, स्वास्थ्य, मानव संसाधन, रोजगार और मानवाधिकारों जैसे क्षेत्रों में रणनीतिक रूप से समानांतर बदलाव किए जाने चाहिए।
इस तरह, हम 2047 में भारत को विकसित करने के लक्ष्य को बहुत पहले प्राप्त कर सकते हैं।
बस हमें एक-जुटता और दृढ़निश्चय के साथ क्रियान्वयन की आवश्यकता है।
हमें याद रखना चाहिए कि हमारे देश की जनसंख्या ही हमारी परम शक्ति है।
What we immediately need is implementation of CAA NRC, 2 child policy in states like Bihar, UCC, abolition of waqf board, all temples to be free, no reservation to Muslims or other religions
Things we should ask from government:-
? Why "make in India" have become slow? Especially in technological and defence fields . Also in small scale, Not everybody can become labour so if there are plants for earphones, toys,(things which we import from china) then people from Bihar and others can go into that field
? What now about semiconductor plant ?
? How will Modi government plant to restructure our cities? Traffic lights , cycle tracks, footpath are basic necessities.
? Cleanliness? We need movement like "ugly Indian" in every part of India to make it clean.
? Why India has failed to become a tourist hub despite its diversity(not just people but also geographical {plains, Himalayas, beaches, north east, deserts},monumental Heritage and ancient culture(people in China's South province wear dress like Indian clothes, even they are capitalising on Indian culture saying that it's thiers and increasing thier soft power, just search "flying Apsara")
? When a foreigner say India is chaotic, it means lawlessness like traffic, footpath stalls, people spitting.
? When is government passing law to strict movement of cows on roads. Cow owners should provide shelter to cows and if found on roads then it should be seized just like bikes
? Pollution. A good public transport system of buses(Jakarta bus transit)
? Why government not promotes Indian brands. Police cars should be of Indian brands, public phones should be of Indian brands(just like South korea)
? Why don't we have app like "WhatsApp" , only South Asians use it , we South Asians are 2 billion people so we deserve our own app instead of American, if we start using some it then rest of the south aisans will have to .
We also need our own RUclips , people like puneet, chapris and others are maligning the image of India
?education? India has more temples and mosques than government schools. According to me, ann organisation should be given contract to make government school for 20 years lease. Conversational sankrit(not necessarily written) compulsory from young age, hindi is not much use. Social should be taught in local language. History shouldn't be taught from invader perspective
Our primary problem is our multi level multi parties democratic system which is against any kind of central level planning for development . Secondary problem is our fixed method of bureaucratic system where we hire mostly inexperienced, bookworm type manpower after a bookish knowledge based examination and keeping them until their retirement without proper evaluation of their performance or practical knowledge promoting them only basis of seniority. And another problem is critical and contradictory laws and rules with slow judiciary system .
Oh my god. So democracy holds us back is it. Not the quality of the leaders? The sort of comment which is written by class 8 students
Singapore is a well planned country. India has a lot to learn from them. The subject you have taken up is very interesting and informative. One of the most intelligent programme I have come across so far. Thank you for the content.
Amazing facts, it's true, when I share these with my friends and relatives in india they try to defend india instead of try to learn and change their attitude, keep up your good work
The reason why they don't allow people to buy multiple house is that , govt expect people to work and earn rather than just buy and sell and buy and sell.
The govt expect people to work of any age and do the efforts in earning,
Along with this they are giving opportunity for middle class to get chance.
Great video and good perspective.
Expecting more such videos
Singapore ki population 60 lakhs hai aur wahan pe 9 lakhs vehicles hain, India mein it’s the other way round and the issue is with the heavy population with various class of people.
Singapore is also filled with health conscious and fit people, you look fat and obese, follow their healthy ways of life also if you’re so inspired.
Irony Indian civil engineers are unemployed and forced to do other jobs and youtubers are busy in talking about road quality and design 😂😂😂
Those non tech engineers too ends up in doing corporate IT jobs or becomes youtubers themselves 😂😂😂
Ekhdam sahi bola
Tu bhookha hi rhega
भारतवर्ष उन UNEMPLOYABLE Civil Engineers का युगों-युगों तक आभारी रहेगा🙏
BTech paise deke karliye, kuch sikhe nahin, kaun naukri dega. Phir Jake sarkari Naukri dhundte hain aur coaching mafias ke ghar chalate hain.
We need tons of videos like this, much respect to the thoughts and efforts, we are with you.
You're constantly comparing with Delhi, which has one of the best transport infra than other Indian cities.
Try small Indian cities and towns. You will be traumatised.
Also, metro cities at least have some green cover. How many trees you see in Tier 2, Tier 3 and towns? Non existent.
Bro Delhi is the best we have.... Even that cant match with Singapore. Infact its atleast 25 years behind Singapore.
The combination of you too brings out the best. Optimism and criticism at the balance. Someone please pay heed to this
Damn this video is really informative kudos to Shashank sir for showing us Singapore in this depth.
This video should be taught in all schools. RTO department needs to be scrapped, even Nitin Gadkari wants to get rid of it.
Driving tests should be privatised. Driving education should be a 1 month course, to bridge the huge gap that we have now. Later it can be a 5 day course with an exam and practical exam.
Give power to beurocracy and they always use it to do corruption. Never for country's greater good. I'm fed up with all this mismanagement by beurocracy.
Another 6th class essay.
A very good effort to introspect. However, after viewing the video, it's very clear that such planning would need atleast a century to take place in India. The interviewer was so casual when he was telling that it is not a rocket science and we can do it in two years. I think it's only a wishful thinking. We have been able to provide the most basic things to our citizens in the last 75 yrs.
It is discipline of the people living there makes a country so beautiful.
Hope India will improve… we Indian also deserve quality life like other countries’ citizens enjoying… whereas Indians are struggling for basics in this century this is horrible even after paying hefty amount of taxes on everything
Awesome video by vaad. Shashank Bhai is amazing and passionate. Also awesome video quality and audio management. Crazy quality.
Whatever the traffic issues, the video of Delhi traffic is fascinating. Merging without lanes with heavy traffic.. is method to the madness.
that's what content is needed for india .hope we learn
came here from the YT shorts, and got to know so much about Singapore and its methods of doing things. Really liked your video 👍
As an Indian we take pride in breaking rules.We keep lamenting the corrupt system but no body takes the responsibility of following rules........how many of us have gone to proper driving school to learn driving or learned the driving instructions?
Hygiene is not followed at home let alone outside food outlets.
How many Indian houses have clean toilets ?
Cleanliness begins at home.😂
I can say this is the best content I have even seen in RUclips. Thank you very much for this content. Now I am thinking to write a mail to PMO & CMO so that they can think on this. Kindly share more this type of content so that people can watch, learn & act.
Superb video.. I live in dubai and dubai authorities openly say they are following Singapore model of development... The problem in India is corruption
Nope, food terrorism is the problem of India or Brahmavad is the problem.
Pork is delicious @@vinsin328
China and Hawaii political party also said the same thing following Singapore model on how to fix the housing crisis issue and build affordable public housing for their people. Dubai also requested Singapore to build them the NeWater system that collect sea water and turn them into safe drinking water for every household
Tum flight attendant ho na
Very good video. May we as fellow Indians pressurise our local municipalities and state govts to implement these in every cities and towns!
It starts with every one of us first.
Lol.. Indian beraucratic mindset is that you give them one innovative idea they'll make you count 100 ways and reasons it cannot be done.
This tour should be given to beraucratic trainees..
They do such tours.. it's called family trips.
At present bureaucrats are doing family trips in Paris Olympics
dont you know there are some bureaucratic tour or the other going on at any given time. The outcome will always be the same.
I am a 2nd generation born Singaporean from India origin. My family and I have visited India from the early 2000s frequently. India has come a long way. As an outsider India today is at major crossroads which will shape India’s future in the next 20-30 years. India's strength is its democracy and diversity but it’s crucial for the nation to know when to put aside differences and act as one. In 1978, China's key leader Deng Xiaoping and others visited Singapore and made a conscious decision to model their cities after Singapore and they achieved it. There is nothing India cannot achieve if the people are united!!
新加坡的优势是国民里大部分是华人。现实点，这世界只有中华文明和欧洲文明才有可能成为发达国家。
@@daydaystudydaydayup our founding father PM Lee Kuan Yew never saw it that way and that is exactly why Singapore is where it is at today. :)
@@Nisha-ik1ue If most of Singapore is African, can Lee Kuan Yew still develop Singapore into a developed country?
@@daydaystudydaydayup there can be an infinite scenarios based on "if" but with no evidence to prove it, then why wonder? Good governance can be looked and studied upon based on a nation's history, the decision the government chooses to make based on today's reality which will shape a nation's future.
@@Nisha-ik1ue请说出一个不属于东亚文明或者欧洲文明的发达国家或地区？李光耀确实很优秀也很有魄力，但中国有一句老话:巧妇难为无米之炊。
Are bhai... mai jaha rehata hu, vo Block ke samne vala signal pass kiya aapne abhi, Boundary Road, Serangoon Avenue 4, Blk 211😂, 2:01... 2:25 ke bich me, felt very happy as I watch your podcasts 🥰
Stupendous.❤❤❤❤.. This is really CONTENT which we want to see and discuss further instead of wasting time on celebrities interview or similar kind of unnecessary discussion on YT.
The best part of Singapore is the ruthless punishments, once you are in jail, they beat your bum until you can't walk straight - everyone knows you got beat in jail like a dog. So when you come out of jail, there is no bad boy glamor or bad girl glamor attached. Hence, people are shit scared to go to prison, purely because of the beating & the humiliation EVERYONE knows you got there.
By far, the best podcast channel, in my opinion.
World class Infrastructure 👏 👌 🙌
One correction: DMRC has always been profitable barring the covid year.
I am a cyclist and biker in Singapore and cycled across Singapore roads for 6+ years. There are pot holes occasionally. You have to be careful otherwise you have to take the road jerk. Unlike India,Singapore used to be a rainforest and it is easy to clear the forest to create a city.
Hi Ganesh, Singapore is a mix of greenfield and brownfield development. While some vegetation was cleared, A lot of villages were converted to HDB and city area. Existing CBD was also converted to modernity, what we see now.
At least you can cycle in Singapore, boss!
Please tell me where are these potholes good sir. I am a PCN cyclist of all the East - ECP, Tanah Merah Coastal Express Way, pasir ris, loyang, Tampines etc
I detect something else
@@6732VK you missed the point. I talk about Roads, not PCN. Also, I said "occasional" pot holes, meaning pot holes can appear after heavy rains and cyclists taking Roads must be careful at all times.
@@GhaneshPV I am focused on your roads comments. Tell me the areas were you saw these. Most curious
The difference is dedication. Transparency and clear conscience is important.
Singapore is definitely great. Most workers working on road construction in Singapore are from India. So Indian workers can make same quality roads in India too if companies want to. But I think road construction in India has a different model, focus is on making more roads at a lower cost. If govt prioritise even higher cost of road construction in India, then lot of road projects will never be implemented. There have been road markings in India too, especially on NH its good. But within cities , falling under state govt , that aspect is poor.
I have a point on housing in india when you operate free market in highly unequal society most of assets prices are bid up by high income individuals, prices of home skyrocketed in metros but income of mid wage earners not vis-a-vis. Therefore, rent increases to cover cost of acquisition of house. So basically what happens one might ended up with so many home might unoccupied others have nothing. Singaporean gov. is smart enough to understand that it did not allowed to operate private players in housing bcuz it know how market distributes it fruits.
Arihant - Extremely important video. We'll scale this conversation to an unprecedented level. Thanks and you should replicate this format .. walk / background based. Refreshingly different yet important.
Sir , aise ki series he shuru karlo ek .
यहां तो smart card license बनवाया ओर जब renew करने को दिया तो वो लाइसेंस online register ही नही किया गया जिसकी वजह से दोबारा learner license से apply करना पड़ा। ये efficiency है।
स्मार्ट कार्ड लाईसेंस क्या होता है?
Hahaha, Sanjay Ji, this is classic case of 'High IQ, low Akal'! But things will be better. One day!
Wow amazing video, really hope this reaches all the people in Civil engineering, such basic aspects which are 100% achievable in our country.
Inn desho ki achi foundation 1980's me rakhi gyi almost sabhi south east asia country me hamaari foundation hi nhi h
In India
A) plastic needs to be banned and plastic in circulation needs to be retrieved destroyed
B) Sanitization needs overhaul
C) People need to be co opted in the upkeep of cities and towns.
In india, they just add new layer of road over old layer, and all shops and homes go below ground level 😂 ingenious indian way 😅
Exactly 😅
😂
And why do they do that ? Why are they allowed to get away with that ?
@@6732VK kis ko bolenge, lack of accountability
Exactly, this is common all over India
I wish it was subtitled so I could understand what he is saying. Seems like an interesting video
i just love sphinx's voice
Inspirational video, thanks for your great effort
Its an ecosystem. We need to have federalism not state wise but city wise aka give more power to elected city officials who can work with local colleges, collect taxes and build that city.
Means more corruption !
Federalism in modern 21st century 😂😂😂😂 you are bluffing like those jingoistic babas😂
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Bhai akal vakal lagao kabhi, sirf suni sunai bate na idhar se udhar kara karo
@@dhari-rl6su Yes thats the problem. But why doesnt same corruption happen in US or China? Because it does happen. Heck it happens even in a society where Chanda is collected. Corruption can be yeeted out only via reducing govt. But here I am talking about taking power from states to city and making them accountable. Governance will be better.
@@deadlyninja8391 Oh...That will be better...Just like housing societies where we can keep a watch on.
you are right the mixture is nearly same, except in very hot and very cold climate, inindia and pak we use very little bitumin and heat it too much so it can coat the aggregates very well, as with high tempm it get thin, but then bitumin looses its power of gluing, and when rain comes it disintegrate the road.
Good content. Talking about oneself taking the responsibility of change: that has not happened in India yet. Talking about planning: people don't have macro level decision capability yet. They can take micro decisions but they are independent of each other and does not take the whole into account. Talking about cleanliness: I hoped the swatchh bharat campaign had taken the drive to its final conclusion (to make whole of India clean like Singapore by changing people's mindset).
It’s not about the Government in India. It is about the people who don’t care for rules and regulations. When they visit Singapore or other developed countries, they go out of the way to follow rules. But the moment they are in an Indian environment, the will not miss even a second to flaunt the rules and make their priority the most important one by neglecting basic human rights or rules of the road. If even all people who have traveled abroad and seen the traffic rules and follow the same in India, I am sure there will be a minimum 20% change in road user attitude. It all starts with us. Not the government. Government already had the laws and rules in place. It’s for us to follow and believe in those rules and regulations. Till then India will not change. Agree?
Exactly right but the mentality of the Indian people will never change even 1000 years from now.
Wrong. People will follow only when rules are strict. In India people don't follow because rules are not the same for all. People who escape either havecontacts with officials or pay money to authority. How can you make rules same when your system is corrupt?
@themotorcyclechronicles2812. Righly said & completely agree on what you mentioned. Our expectations are so much on the others, be it the people or govt. Why we dont start with us. If others are not following traffic signal you follow. If others are throwing waste in the open you start using the dustbin. Should't it start from small and then grow big as a revolution. Spread the words to your neighbors / friends / relatives and who ever who can listen to you in a positive way. I know its difficult but not impossible
@@merabharatmahan9621 Thanks! That’s the way it has to be.. it should start with us… rather than simply push it on Govt and complain on roads (of course roads need improvement in many cities). On the other hand I must say that it’s been about 20 years since the last time I drove / rode in India. The roads are somuch better (highways). And the traffic sense of highway users has really really “Improved”. But it’s still a long way before we actually start hearing zero honking anywhere;)
Change comes from the people. Pehle apne mohalle mai jaakar safaai karo.
First, in our construction site trucks leaving site should clean their four tyres before coming out to main road. Simple, but no one follows.
Driving in Singapore, ..you must be very very rich Shashank ji
Extremely detailed video on basics of development. Really good points and attention to details.
You will notice almost none hoardings,poster,hanging wire etc.
Such in-depth conversation is necessary. If the people in charge of India are genuinely interested, I don't see anything in Singapore that can't be implemented here. These are all available best practises and technologies.
@@sujoydutta6260 in depth ? What do you read? Even amar chitra katha has more depth than this
बहुत अच्छी वीडियो है और आपने बहुत अच्छे से समझाया है
We have more bikes than car hence issues with lean cutting. But if bikers follow lean system life will be easy in India 👍🏻
VERY INFORMATIVE ❤ GUY HAS A GREAT KNOWLEDGE ABOUT SINGAPORE AND INDIA AS WELL
WORTH IT!
SUBSCRIBED ✨️
Very interesting guest and thanks for showing what india can learn
Do you think india will learn?
@@haritt-mh2synot possible in india for sure the discipline in citizens not there special poor states like Bihar up jharkhand bengal odisha are too unhygienic
When I visited Singapore, I was absolutely stunned to see how well managed everything is and how beautifully and aesthetically people take care of everything. Noticed the same in some other countries too.
He said the correct thing about climate.
We r vishwaguru that's why we always teach others 😂
Poore comment tere jaise 🦧 bhare pade hain kon kin ko pakad ke gali du ab main.
Guru has specific strength. No single guru is expert at every single subject
Strength in what 😂
@@AbhinandanSingh-ir6wzbakchodi
Ab to vishwaguru shabd se bhi ghin aa jaati hai.
This video should be seen by all Indians especially those responsible in charge of development including those in bureaucracy, politicians. These things are very easy to implement as seen in this video.
Singapore Without Reservation 🦁
India With Reservation 😺
Amazing . Eye opener
Bahaar hawkers mai sasta khana mai nipta diya. Iske ghar pe lunch karne ko bolte toh batata ki singapore mai bohot rarely ghar pe khana banana allowed hota hai.
it was a much needed video. thanks'
Hit like for continuously watching over the seat belt handkerchief
LKY knew the dangers of western style freedom driven style of democracy for a young and poor country. Hats off to the guy!
@@piyush7700 he was much much more than that. He understood human nature
Can we first learn how to keep our places clean , stray dog & cattle free. Than we can expect that we’re moving in right direction 🇮🇳🙏
Singapore is a small island with high population but planning is so good it is marvelous architecture
Both man have different reactions on everything especially white shirt sir he feel bad due to continuous recalling of his own country conditions. Although I am indian living in india feel literally bad.
Never seen anyone who is this much concerned about infrastructure, urban planning and basic human needs. Hat's off to you buddy🙋🏻♂️ this is much needed. Indian's are just one step behind to do this they just have to think about it ❤
लोगों ने केजरीवाल को बाड़ की तरह लगाया पर बाड़ ही खेत को खाने लगी।आजतक पर सुधीर चौधरी ने बताया कि आईएस करने वाले बच्चों की तकलीफ़ कैसी हालत में हैं। कोई प्लानिंग नहीं है।
Nice to see vlog discussion video from singapore. I am also an Indian working in Singapore.
Indian municipalities need to recruit more town planners and architects for city planning and space planning rather than just civil engineers. Then only aesthetics and infrastructure development will go hand in hand. Also this channel must try to cover the 2030 development plan of Singapore wherein how future planning of the city is taken care of will be evident. Moral of the story is the civic sense of common Singaporeans and their governments will power is commendable.
Brahmins will oppose it, lacto vegetarians will oppose it, some will say that is against Indian culture, cow vigitalist will oppose it.
But Muslims will oppose it calling it against thier religion if we prevent namaz and prayers on streetrs
@@SwapnilSawant-nn2wg where does Civic sense come from. Go find the answer to this rather than grandiose 2030 planning
I really hope that videos on this type of framework will be more frequent, realllllyyyyy liked the content, I'll give my suggestion on last question by more research on this ❤❤❤ love you team
Problem is system level enforcement, if actors in the system know that everybody is following rules, then all will follow.
We haven't moved to post industrialised standards
You are on to something