00:09 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है 01:54 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है 06:42 भारत को बॉटम-अप ग्रोथ की जरूरत है 09:03 भारत का विकास इसकी विरासत और गौरव के लिए महत्वपूर्ण है। 13:48 द्वितीय विश्व युद्ध के बाद जापान की आर्थिक वृद्धि 16:11 दक्षिण कोरिया द्वारा उपयोग की जाने वाली जापान की आर्थिक प्लेबुक 20:37 भारत में 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता 22:29 उच्च यातायात केंद्र और रहने योग्य क्षेत्र विकास के लिए महत्वपूर्ण हैं। 26:39 कमी की मानसिकता बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास को प्रभावित करती है 28:49 भारत को बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास के लिए सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है 32:34 एक मजबूत सांस्कृतिक नींव के निर्माण का महत्व 34:50 भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है 39:10 चीन को हराने के लिए भारत को व्यापक मानसिकता में बदलाव की जरूरत है 41:23 शहरों के बीच सुगम यात्रा के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे में सुधार और यातायात अनुशासन लागू करना 45:13 अन्य देशों की तुलना में भारत में सड़क बुनियादी ढांचा 47:06 निर्माण में मानकीकरण और गुणवत्ता नियंत्रण 51:27 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है 53:36 भारत को शिक्षा और अनुसंधान को प्राथमिकता देने के लिए एक सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की आवश्यकता है 57:54 भारत में विद्यालय स्थापित करने में चुनौतियाँ 59:56 भारत को गुणवत्तापूर्ण संस्थानों को प्रोत्साहित करने और शिक्षा क्षेत्र में उद्यमिता को बढ़ावा देने की आवश्यकता है। 1:04:09 आर्थिक विकास के लिए संस्थानों और शिक्षा को मजबूत किया जाना चाहिए 1:06:19 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है। 1:10:16 भारत को आर्थिक विकास के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे को उन्नत करने की जरूरत है 1:12:07 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को एक सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की आवश्यकता है। 1:15:44 भारत में कौशल विकास और नौकरी के अवसरों में सुधार 1:17:37 भारत को विकास के लिए कुशल जनशक्ति की आवश्यकता है। 1:21:30 यूटी के रूप में शीर्ष शहरों की केंद्रीकृत योजना और विकास। 1:23:21 भारत को अपने लिए उत्पादन पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है। 1:27:12 डिजिटल उपनिवेशीकरण में चीन को मात देने के लिए 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता 1:30:29 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है 1:34:41 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को बड़े बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास की जरूरत है 1:36:45 दिल्ली की तुलना में नोएडा का बुनियादी ढांचा और शासन 1:40:51 भारत को बेहतर शहर बनाने के लिए सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है 1:42:33 भारत को जनसंख्या केंद्रों के लिए ऊंची इमारतों के निर्माण पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है। 1:47:12 भारत को अधिक किफायती आवास बनाने की जरूरत है 1:49:10 भारत में रियल एस्टेट बुलबुला और चीन का अतिउत्पादन 1:53:00 भारत को तेज विकास के लिए निर्माण पर पुनर्विचार करने की जरूरत है 1:54:53 दिल्ली में रेल यात्रा की अक्षमता पर चर्चा 1:58:53 भारत को इस्पात आयात के मुद्दों का समाधान करने की जरूरत है 2:00:50 कानून का प्रवर्तन समाज के लिए महत्वपूर्ण है 2:04:48 कानून प्रवर्तन में भ्रष्टाचार और धार्मिक कारक 2:06:58 पुलिस सुधारों को लागू करने में चुनौतियाँ 2:11:16 न्यायपालिका में चुनौतियाँ और भ्रष्टाचार 2:13:24 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत में 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है 2:17:13 भारत को 10 ट्रिलियन की अर्थव्यवस्था के लिए योजना बनाने की जरूरत है 2:19:05 भारत में घटते अनुसंधान एवं विकास से विकास प्रभावित हो रहा है 2:23:01 भारत के भविष्य के लिए युवाओं का मार्गदर्शन और मार्गदर्शन महत्वपूर्ण है 2:24:55 भारत में भ्रष्टाचार व्यापक है और भ्रष्टाचार मुक्त समाज हासिल करना आसान नहीं है। 2:28:43 हार्ड कोर स्किल्स की बहुत जरूरत है 2:30:40 भारत को विनिर्माण को बढ़ावा देने के लिए 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता है 2:34:46 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को विनिर्माण और सॉफ्टवेयर विकास पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है। 2:37:02 बैंकों से धन प्राप्त करने में संपत्ति और मशीनरी का महत्व। 2:40:45 भारत को आर्थिक विकास के लिए अधिक हवाई अड्डों की आवश्यकता है 2:42:42 भारत को आर्थिक वृद्धि के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है। 2:46:40 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है 2:48:40 भारत में रक्षा उत्पादन चुनौतियाँ
I agree with him on lots of points but he does more rants rather than solutions bhai apana constitution ke preamble me aj bhi socialist hai aur tum private university pe baat kar rahe ho. Aur India ki development start hi 1998-2000 se Hui hai usme bhi 10 sal upa aur Rajan jaise log chala rahe the oh bhi globalization ke zamane ko waste kar diye. Sala Ek expressway nahi banaya upa walo ne.
@hj2711you are missing the point, it's not a skill issue, it's an everything issue. Anywhere bw 40-50% are always late, minimal hygiene, drunk and have behavioural issues but are skilled and independent. Another 40% has none of the behavioural problems but are not skilled or independent and need constant monitoring.
@@rutvikrs Bhai wo dono hi roads consistently ache bana lete hai. Unka basics bohot strong hai. Hamara basics exist hi nahi karta. Cities me roads bhi nahi hote aur footpaths bhi nahi hote. Bas kachra hi hota hai. We're easily 70-80 years behind China
@@yugmathakkar4023 I don't disagree with you on that. Unedited comment was bakwaas along the lines of China doesn't litter or has zero open defecation, so they are a superpower. Abhi edited comment is reasonable.
Without manufacturing India cannot grow at faster pace and pullout millions out of poverty. For the semi skilled and unskilled, manpower intensive manufacturing is essential. Ship building, auto ancillary, electronics, steel equipment, garment, food processing, agro tech have to be all pushed at massive scales.
Sir, As a housewife I have been telling my family since 2015 the same thing. We dont have any work force like plumber, carpenter, electrician, mason etc, with real skills . We need more state of the art vocational colleges teaching these skills . These guys could also be exported. 🙏
I agree with you ma’am, there is someone who is also thinking like me. Thanks for raising your voice. We don’t have this people cause we don’t have skill worker cause we don’t. Production than. And those want to learn they are experienced labor. But they are not skilled. For this we need more good education and with out license no one can work as a electrician, plumber or any XYZ job
@@SilentTraderview ya but they said in 2070 will be done 😂 😂 😂 any government comes and goes they have project on 3D maps but in reality it’s no where around. We need to progress faster, decision making should to be faster but like bullet train even Japan is giving money here we are so slow for decision making
But question is would you like to enroll your son in such course... And make him a plumber, carpentor etc... Society doesn't respect work but the nature of work.
Yes, and they're all fairly USELESS in the so called EDUCATION that they provide for $60,000+/year. There is ZERO critical thinking involved in anything Harvard, MIT and Stanford even teach at this point. You can be more experienced and get REAL WORLD experience from going to a charter school where you learn real life skills.
Try throwing opportunity to aspiring candidate I hv seen candidate passed bcom 😊 doing excellence in electric.. best factory manager/ engineer a bcom ??
Absolutely! Education must! But not just theory based practical training is necessary from the age of 14yrs. Civil etiquette, customer service, basic wood work, metal work, etc would also help. We lack basic manners, social interactions, interpersonal and communication skills all necessary for labour force
Cultural revolution of China was nothing more than a Chinese version of Japan's Meiji restoration, meiji too broke certain structures of old society which was resistant to modern industrial structure which is something China did as well. Indian govt historically was weak and did not destroy the conception of family cliques and neoptism although it did it better than Pakistan but still did not go far enough. All cultural products are created in cities, civilization itself requires conception of cities. Village is meant to be primitive which should be limited to agriculture activities. To expand up to 10 trillion industrialization will be required. Otherwise India might get stuck in 5-8 trillion.
British slavery (Ghulam)parliament democracy made India next Africa already.... ... American propaganda media, conspiracy theory and fakes news against China,Iran, Russia and North Korea is controlling and dictating 1.4 billion Indians minds now..... ......... ..........1 million American CIA agents in India now so India will never be next economic super power in history....... India will be next economic super power in American propaganda social media platforms ( You Tube, Facebook, Twitter only)
Dehatis are the most dangerous hindrance to industrialization. I always balk when ppl romanticize village life and villagers, rural folks are one of the casteist people with very low moral values. It's not any particular community, it's everyone else against anyone outside their group. Pure tribalistic agrarian low enterprise society
It's irrelevant what they did 100 years ago and they supplied opium through Britishers in line with the law of the land. So even didn't do anything illegal. Aaj koi daaru bechta hai kyuki wo legal hai. Kalko illegal hogai toh wo criminal thodi hogya
They (Parsees) were given special treatment by British at the behest of other Indians. This was done to create artificial divisions in the society under Divide and Rule policy.🧐
@@sanchitsharma6852 Please give me one Parsi name who went in jail or died for Bharat Freedom Fight. Those are very near and dears of looters colonials. Tata is main in 2G scam…..our people memory is very short and we didn’t connect dots.
Best podcast with Shashank among all. This conversation feels more real than those guys giving fake expression and interrupting all the time during podcast( Beer biceps and Prakhar k pravachan). They should learn.
Samsung from commodity trading to basic manufacturing like textile and chemicals to transistors to a complete turn towards(started 1990-95)display,memory chip,dram to led tech to consumer mobiles and items to fabless semi. Aur bhi banate hai samsung c and t(construction),chemicals(ev batteries and all) to big container and petroleum ships. I was like kuch to chhodh dete. Aur Haan family batware mein retail business kisi aur mil gaya. Start kaise hua tha after retirement i guess toshiba founder came to korea just one year before death aur Samsung ke founder ko mentor kiya idea diya ki beta transistor aur radio mein upgrade karo apne manufacturing ko
Honestly I am a little disappointed by the podcast. While I agree with his overall message of India requiring a cultural revolution, infrastructure creation, reducing petty crimes and the need for public order to be restored, many other arguments are either fallacious, incorrect or not apt for India. 1. India cannot follow the east Asian countries' playbook on manufacturing. America was still growing as an economy when east Asian countries ramped up manufacturing prowess. As of today, growth is stagnant in the broader West. India can hope to take a pie from the east Asian countries but cannot replicate their strategy. It needs to manufacture for its own population to begin with instead of copy-pasting mercantilist manufacturing models. 2. American cities are horribly planned (and Japanese cities are not all grid layout type except for small portions). There are limited walking areas and the requirement of a car is a must to commute between different parts of a city except for NY, Boston. Moreover, America can afford this expansive car-centric city planning because of the huge land mass, we need to create cities that encourage public transport, cycling and walking leaving the car capacity to a few vehicles or LCVs. This is not a scarcity mindset but a policy implication for India. 3. America is the only country in the world that has an abundance mindset because that was the basis of its creation and the American Dream. Enormous land and natural resources have enabled this mindset. Bharat has always been one of the most densely populated regions in the world since time immemorial. Conservation of resources has been deeply ingrained into our culture and psyche. There is nothing wrong with having such an approach. Finally, I feel his long time in the US clouds his judgement and makes him observe things from an Americentric perspective. Bharat will have its own model of development. The government should create infra on mission mode and devolve more powers (and create accountability) for cities to make them liveable. The rest Bharatiyas will take care of.
भारत के विकास में सबसे बड़ा रोड़ा हमारे देश की सरकारी मशीनरी है सरकारी कर्मचारी अपने को सेवक नहीं शाशक समझते हैं । हर काम में टांग अड़ाने की आदत । समस्या को सुलझाने के बजाय उलझाने की महारत हासिल है सरकारी कर्मचारियों को ।😭😭
Good discussion. The need for 10x thinking is a good suggestion and worth noting 👍 However, I disagree with Shashank's hypothesis that progress in India can be bottom-up. Historically, India has been top-down in terms of progress and bottom-up in terms of resistance - Examples of top-down progress - 1. Economic Liberalization in 1991 2. India becoming a nuclear power in 1998 3. Ram Mandir Movement planned by the BJP, culminating in creation of Ram Mandir in 2023 Examples of bottom-up resistance - 1. Rebellion of 1857 2. J.P. Narayan movement of 1975 against Indira Gandhi's Emergency 3. Anti Farm Laws Movement from 2020 - 2021 Also, Shashank's statement that hardware / manufactured product startups require less funds than software startups is incorrect. Software startups (unlike in 2021) normally raise big money after some product traction. And getting to that part (product traction) in a hardware product requires a significant investment. If a young person wants to get funded via a loan from an Indian Bank for a hardware / manufactured product startup, that is just not going to happen!
Let Mumbai-Delhi Expressway get completed you'll need even less time to cover the same time... We needed an expressway chain long back... But no Khangress government paid heed to infra boom...Most of such projects have seen the light of day in the last 1 decade... And in the next 5 years, many of them will find their place in the list of the world's best infra projects...
Sir, Railway is a corruption of Mount Everest. My friend designed a machine for railway and railway minister demanded two crores without any advance order. He lost his life savings and filed bankruptcy. Railway imported the same machine from Germany at ten times cost. Corruption is the only bottle neck.
I've learnt so many perspectives that I've never even think off and we need more such discussion amongst our youth... let's go boys, only we can bring change 🙅
Jabardast. I congratulate you both for laying out a detailed analysis of the root causes of problems India has been facing. We need more such debates so that we can propel towards some actions and tangible work.
We Indians always find a problem to follow the rules. Our mindset is the person next to me is not following why i should follow. No sense of responsibility to be clean as well . We follow corruption to the core . Our big cities are run by corporations who are working life mafias . Our city roads are not world class at all. Lack of planning , lack of quality and no standardization . Forget about the village roads . We spit on the roads and everynow and then dig up the existing roads because our different departments are not coordinated . Long way to go folks.
Kya baat chit thi 🙏. We need more of such deep conversation focusing on Bharat's real problems.Thank you so very much .Looking forward to more such content.
.....China is 30 years ahead of USA and 150 years ahead of India now in infrastructure development now.....China bullet train railways 40,000 kilometres and India still zero....USA still zero.....China total expressway 1,68,000 kilometers, USA 1,48,000 kilometres and India still 5,000 kilometres , Check. Google.....China skyscraper 4,000.....USA skyscraper 1,800 and India skyscraper 330 only....
Overall good discussion, but some comments were naive. Core issues were not properly understood. 1) china is 5 times bigger than us GDP wise so most indicators will be 5-8 times bigger, thats not a surprise 2) things like why we cant build HSR over eway etc is pointless as its mostly function of money. When we have enough money things will happen 3) metro all over world are like that. Stations cant be skipped as there are only 2 tracks unlike normal railway where it exapnds to 10s of tracks near stations. 4) petty crimes cannot be easily stopped at this level as we have lot of poor people. Cant vacate encroachment or slums as its not fair to poor people. Thailand is 7k per capita which is 2-3 times bigger than India. 5) there are many companies that make fans in India. What is different abt atomberg is that they introduced BLDC fans which was innovation 6) there are many more vehicle manf companies like TVS, eicher, Ashok Leyland, force, hero etc so that will also grow naturally, no real information or insight there even when you talked about it for 10min In nutshell many of these will be solved when we reach similar income levels. Real problem we have is lack of planning and quality control over execution, horrible police and slow judiciary, very poor urban infra. these things are bad even when compared to similar GDP per capita levels countries. Many of these are related to excess democracy which cant be corrected now.
Hindu apne school college nahi khol sakte agar kholte hai to vo govt control rahenge christian kholte hai par bahot kam kyonki vo sankhaya me kam or muslmano ko keval madarsa kholna hai bas or majhabi shiksha leni hai
Mai programming seekh raha tha software Engineering banne ke liye lekin saath saath mai massive layoffs ko bhi dekh raha hun, hiring bahut kum ho rahi hai software Engineers ka, isilye maine ye decide kiya hai ki aage chalke mai hardware design(jaise electronic circuit design, Embedded systems design etc) aur programming bhi sikunga kyonki mujhe electronics ka Thora bahut idea aur usme interest hai . Abhi Shashank Dixit ji ko sunke lag raha hai ki mera hardware design (including electronic circuit design) aur programming ko sikhne ka decision sahi hai. Mai jaanta hun electronic circuit design , Embedded systems and programming seekhna mere liye challenging hoga lekin iska matlab ye nhi ki main naa karun.
Kuch Challenging nhi hai, you can learn whatever you want. There are lot of companies in Electronics too. Keep skilling one thing to another. If you like software then also it is fine.
This guy has no idea what he is talking about. Very superficial knowledge and poor analysis on most of the topics. He diverged from answering the core question as well.
Arihant, please update your Spotify playlists. That's where I discovered your podcast properly and been listening off and on. RUclips isn't convenient for audio only play in the background.
Shashaank dikshit sir achha sapna dikha rhe hain i have seen 2-3 friends having family business of manufacturing in basic electrical material and plastic housekeeping system and their life is destroyed almost, as demand hi ni hai. local kharidta hi koi ni hai. So kehdena ki manufacturing kro manufacturing kro se kuch ni hoga.. Carpenter chahiye electrician chahiye 15k ki job milti hai unko tabhi na wo dubai jate hain. Paisa dena hai ni, demand bnani hai ni aur sabko experience wala hi chahiye new ko sikhane wala bhi koi hai to wo bhi lut rha hai.. Aur sapne dekho😂
Shashank is founder of software company. He made millions in software sector. He is enjoying his wealthy life. Travelling in luxury car, living in luxury house, travelling all over the world. He expects other to do hardware manufacturing and not go after money. Manufacturing is hard ,more risky, less rewarding.
@@guptasagar694Are bhai jb Infrastructure he ghatiya hai to kya bologe? Ayodhya ka vikas pe khub majak bn gya hai news wale godi media jise khte h unhone he tamasha bna diya....Fir railway station ka ghatna Train accident ka ghatna Mandir me pani bharna aur chat se tapak tapak girna Hawai adde ka chat he gir Jana Mathura me pani ka tnki girna Bihar me 7-8 pool 1 hafte me girna Rajasthan me hawai adde ka chat girna Ahemdabad me sadak me gaddha hona Lucknow me bhi same....kya hai bhai ye sb? Ghatiya vikas hai khokla vikas h bolte h karwayi karenge are kispe karoge jb khud usme sanlipt hoge to🤣🤣
Pura suna hain sir ..... thank god this man is adddressing all the core and real problems ..... thank you ...... gov should restructure all systems in politics and judiciary rethink and rebuild ❤❤❤❤❤
British slavery(Ghulam )feudalism parliament democracy made India already next Africa............ American propaganda media, conspiracy theory and fakes news against China,Iran, Russia and North Korea is controlling and dictating 1.4 billion Indians minds now..... ......... ..........1 million American CIA agents in India now so India will never be next economic super power in history....... India will be next economic super power in American propaganda social media platforms ( You Tube, Facebook, Twitter only)
I have worked in one of the top corporate firm of India, and now appearing in civil services interviews; i want to say that, bhai, ye angreji me chahe kitna bhi libir libir kar lo, ye Bharat hai, India nahi, yahan ki pitch slow hai, bade bade khiladi spin me bold ho jate hain. Ye jo videsh ke tamam jhandu balm bata rhe hain Dixit ji, yahan kuchh nahi chalega. Yaha Bose aur Bhagat Singh jaise log side kar diye jate hain aur Nehru jaise chaplus kursi pe baith jate hain. I am telling you bhai, sirf Modi ji bakaiti de rhe hain upar se, andar aaj bhi wahi sab hai...the Medieval "Samnti" Bharat !!
@@cloudboiz dekh bhai...podcast-baji, aur twitter campaign...aur AC office me baith ke youtube me Rashtriya Samasya ki Charcha sunne se kachhu nahi hota...civil services gives you the authority to bring social change. A civil servant is a bonafide social reformer. Haan, aur bhi better ways ho sakte hain, I respect them, par ye Dixit sahab jo bol rhe hain, wo AC ki hawa me baith ke sunne ke liye achha hai, yha zamin pe aake execute karne ke liye this Indian society is too rigid. Aur aapko bata dein sir, ki ye rigidity corporate sector me rehke to katai door nahi ho sakti. Its only civil services that can break this rigidity, aur prayas jari hai. To sahab, is podcast me gyaan to bahut hai, lekin implementation kaise hoga Indian setup me, uspe input "ZERO" hai....haan, interviewer sir ne prayas zaruru kiye ki Dixit sahab ground pe kaise reforms laenge uspe baat karein, par Dixit ji could not explain it. AC ki hawa me baith ke colourful excel sheets me solution dena Corporate DRM me chal jaega....yhan nahi. Sorry.
@@cloudboiz aur ek baat aur sir...India is not held back because yha civil services ka craze hai...India is held because yahan Problems dekhne wale Crore hain, lekin unko actually zamin pe utar ke solve karne wale bahut kam...jo utar bhi rhe hain unko marginalise kr rakha hai society ne...jaise abhi aap comment kr rhe hain. AC chamber me baith ke UNIBIC cookies khate hue, EURO CUP ka schedule discuss krke India ki socio-economic problems pe bhasan dena bahut easy hai....koi bhi kar lega jo 10 country ghoom le aur India ko compare kar le....the major challange is to solve the complex problems, aur uspe Dixit ji khare nahi utre hain. Wahi mai keh rha hun. To mujhpe tippani karne se better hai aap Dixit ji se request kijiye ki koi solid ground-work plan bataen, ki kaise ek already existing socio-economic structure ko totally revolutionise kar denge ye. India me +70% population aaj bhi Medieval setup me ji rhi hai, usko kaise transform karenge ye, Korea, Japan aur Vietnam ka model laga ke, aur exactly kya steps follow kiye jane chahiye. Warna ye criticism aur 4 desh ghum ke wapas aake India ko gali dena is very easy, aajkal har 4tha aadmi dikh jaega ye karte hue. So i hope, aap meri bhawnaein samajh pa rhe honge sir. Thanks
Aa gaye hamare left ke krantikari... Bharat ka kuch nahibho sakta, Sirf bat karne se kuch nahi hoga, sab dhong hai..... khali problem ginana hai, solution kuch nahi hai... Civil services me mat ja bhai, khali opportunity kharab karega tu...
@@indiboy7 are babaji, wahi keh rha hu mai...ye video me Dixit bhi yahi bol rha hai ki India me kuch sambhav nahi...japan aur korea ne hi badhiya kiya hai.....thik se video dekh le bhai pehle...hamesha bhakti thik nahi. Leftist rightist chhod, jamin pe policy kaise execute karna hai ye bata, baki kahani har koi bol deta hai youtube pe aake.
What you call petty crime by the contractors is actually executed by politicians and that makes it not petty. This is quite a simplistic solution being provided that 'just stop the petty crime' without thinking abt the real cause.
😮 We expect a series of discussions with scholers on Anti philosophies : against Sanatan Vedic Hindu Dharma and Science Virodhi galat philosophies ka parda fash karne wali series Atheist Rationalist Agnostic Socialist Communist : Science varces all above philosophies on the basis Spiritual science Spiritual Philosophy Parapsychology Metaphysics Cosmology Theology Spiritual science and philosophy Towards the Truth for peaceful bright future of human and world. 😮
2:28:24 obviously so government do need to start a basic unemployment benefit on the bases of the potential of that person , so that he can leave zomato, also government need to start free skill enhancement programs which give lean management and similar kind of work compatibility courses . In west government do these courses for free and place the candidate for related jobs themselves.
Indian Parsi Industralist got preference treatment from British in government contract compare to Hindu businessman during 1850 to 1945 and these Industralist did not invested in factory worker housing in Mumbai due to this there is slum problem in Mumbai. This is one of best example of how homegenous culture like in UK USA Industralist spend some money on creating institution to prepare future work force of technitian but parsi ignored in India. Nothing against Parsi but this is fact. Bullet train is not a solution for big country like India. Maintaining track and track barrification is costly for bullet train. Bullet train is OK for country size like Japan, Germany to connect few high traffic centre. Same money can be spend for high acceleration train with overall Average speed of 125km/h compare to 200km/h average speed of bullet train and cost increase by 4 times..
This is mindset of scarcity . Abundance mindset is : Not building something is not the solution, it's always good to have as many transport alternatives as possible. You can't cry about something which you don't even have , those who value their time will pay for quick, noiseless, hassle-free transport. 2nd important point is we can't increase speed on current railway tracks beyond 150-160 km/hr as train operating above this speed require proper barricaded tracks, with low curves Semi-highspeed and high-speed trains can run only on new separate lines that is why we have to build RRTS and Bullet trains 😊
20 years behind?. India has almost Zero infrastructure, , most roads are very badly maintained, in the last 10 years most roads have been repaired, new roads are made very less,
Look at the roads?? Fake material are used, no pavements for pedestrians, no proper road policy, no implementation, fake driving license, no traffic rule. Then you build high rise in posh areas, walk round the corner and Kachra everywhere, then you'll find 😮some muddy corners? Holistic development of the site is never done.
56:47 well I can understand what you are saying , but you see in USA how the social security is fixed from a very long time , so when a person in USA work on a risky big project ( it can be university) his mind has no worries of his basic survival or any kinda worry of his family survival , Also minimum wage and equality in the society is there , so a risk taker have a peace of mind that if his project fails , he can grab an odd job which is capable of giving him a basic civilised life (and society doesn’t look down to any job) so there is not that kinda society pressure which one can face in India 😊😊, I mean I hate when they start calling people freebie , how cruel it is , the people are innocent and they are already suffering from great discriminations and poverty, and if you giving them lil help of free electricity, people start calling it freebie, lol 😂 They have no clue how human being works. You give respect and dignity to a human being , you ll then see a great difference in them . Which west understands.
Bhai kis gadhe ko laaye ho. Apartment ki price kam hone se nahi hua evergrande barbaad. Ek project ka paisa doosri jagah lagane se hua. India mein bhi builders yahi karte the, RERA ne rok diya. (IBFC and RERA are 2 of thr most important protections given to indian consumers) US mein bhi aise laws hain builders ke liye. I agree vocational education (higher education in general) ki shortage hai India mein, badi companies bhi kam hain. Aur hume apna haal South Korea jaisa nahi karna jahaan kisi ko job nahi milti. Lekin uska solution Chinese aur Japanese way nahi hai (all these 'tiger' economies with the exception of Singapore are full of Zombie corporations with a negligible start up culture). India, like the US ,needs to chart its own course.
India ke andar agar retired trained log apne apne gaon guhand (kshetra) me workshop level par logon ko train karna suru kar den besarte thora payment par ho to desh ko bahut aage le jaya ja sakta
You are right young generation White collar job vo bhi sarkari ki khawahish rakhti hai lekin usko kaise achieve kiya jaye iska koi idea nehi hai dusre opposition ke chakkar me parkar apna time sarkaar ko gaali dene me barbaad kar rahe hain
In case of import of steel from China- one is Cheaper electricity and energy in China, In our country govts charges higher rate of electricity tariffs to factories than to consumers. (again mindset of treating producers as golden goose) seconnd - subsidies given by chinese govt
It is an irony that India is a collective society but in driving it has an individualistic attitude while Americans society has an Individualistic mentality yet their rule following is considerate of the collective.
अगर भारत को बदलना है तो हमे बदलना होगा हमारे attitude को बदलना होगा, ये नही की कोई भी बिल या रिफॉर्म्स किए जाए तो उसका विरोध शुरू कर दे। भारत में अगर कोई नई ट्रेन भी चले तो उसे पैसों की बरबादी कहते है।
we want such frequent videos on this topic. china specific make a series and do podcast on this topic with different people. with this vieo movementum has begun. Thanks for doing this podcast.
Do not agree with Europe didn’t take benefit of manufacturing, Germany has the most advanced and strongest manufacturing. UK has very advanced manufacturers like Rolls Royce, Prett and Whitney, BAE and many more.
You are missing the point, these are legacy players running on patents, trade secrets or brand value. Europe hasn't been able to sustain a factory since the early 2000's because they don't do "scale". The Chinese need just half a day of server access and 20 nappingkids(YT filter sorry) to shut down ASML.
@@rl1900 Nokia, Siemens, IKEA, ASML holdings, Airbus, Areva, Eurofighter, most of the robotic companies, sensor companies, Oral-b, medical devices, implants and even the advanced pumps. There are certain companies in Europe who are so advanced that any company in the world could not make comparable product such as ASML( this company technology is backbone of all the chip industry). Europe has advanced tech companies which create backbone of most of the industries that most people are not aware. China make low quality and low tech products, mostly assembled in China with the parts procured from all over the world. China can’t even make the SS ball that is used in ball point pen, they have to get it from Japan. In last 10 years China became pioneer in stealing the technology 😄.
Heard the entire podcast. Superb topic, I am working as an NRI and see how entire cities here are build around public transport. When I move between my workplace and home, there is so less friction compared to what I used to face in India. Pls continue on this topic, enlightening 😊
Jyadatar wo Galat hi kehte hai. Raghuram Rajan jo pichli Congress aur UPA ki sarkar ka ravaiya tha usko jayaz thehrane ki koshish kar rahe hai. Pichle sarkar ye nhi chahti thi bharat manufacturing ko jyada tawajjo de. Yaad hai , pehle hindu devi devtaon ke murtiyan China se aati thi, jabki China me to koi hindu dharm ko mante nhi. Lekin Chinese unko manufacture karke bharat me export kar dete the. Wo murtiyan to bharat me banne chahiye the(Murti Pooja karne ka ek fayeda ye bhi hai ki economy ko support karta hai , murtikaron ki murtiyon ki demand bani rahti hai aur employment generate hoti hai, ye prachin hinduon ko pata chali thi, ye Tantra darshan se nikla hai) Lekin pichli sarkaron ko isse koi problem nhi thi. Humare yahan kanoon aise bane hai ki aap saste me koi cheej bana hi nhi sakte ,lekin China ye kar sakta tha, bharat me 80% se jyada log Gareeb pichde hone ke bawajood aap saste me koi cheez banake Market me bech nhi sakte the. Ab chunki modi manufacturing par jor de rahe hai jo ki pichle sarkar ne nhi kiya to unhen darr hai ki Modi ko postmodern Indian economy ke nirmata ka khitab na mil jaye.
The quality of infrastructure currently constructed is poor, and most of the money is siphoned off by politicians, and bureaucrats in the form of commissions, and consultancy fees. Construction contracts are offered to contractors close to political parties and subcontracted to the families of bureaucrats. I can only hope that Modi is made aware of the same or else the damage to his reputation will be irreversible.
Bhai ji 30 lakh banake kaha bechta hai, abhi kya hal hai chaina ka Bhai ji Ghar ki bat pe hi Ghar banane ke chakkar me lage pade hai chahiye I think aap logo thoda aur padhna chahiye
Sir I have friends and colleagues from ASEAN countries, amongst them Korean people are the most hard working people. But overall people from East Asia are very hardworking and for them their work is their pride. They will die for their work. India needs to learn from these countries. Don’t follow them but copy their good habits.
Japanese work to death. Even in India, companies exploit people and overwork them. It's not an attitude problem but a skill issue. We don't have a lot of skilled people in India. Everyone tries to make big bucks in an industry which they are not even interested in.
Please make a video on the book the beautiful tree by historian Dharampal ji it's about indigenous Indian education system and dalit and women education system and because of casteism people defame and leave Hinduism please 😢
About education sector analysis , however , you are spot right but now the things are changing. Present government has started 150 new medical colleges ( govt. Funded ) so that they will be sufficient doctors in future . And in west health sector is not easily affordable to poor.
That isn't a problem, it's a tradeoff. They "earn" through basic services like healthcare, food, water and "invest the profit" into R&D, HDI and operational excellence. For all the talk of cost, the US has the best hospitals, best Pharma cos, best doctors and best medico-industrial base. I am not saying that it is the only path, the US needs a limited phase of cheap Medicare, with limited being the operative word.
Loved the podcast as always. But for some reason Arihant seemed a bit too pessimistic in this one (and I can understand why…) Hopefully the last 10 years have laid the foundation for a boost that the country really needs…
Yes the host got emotionally involved. But the guest is a guy with a very limited world view and outdated info and economic models which are completely unsustainable in today and tomorrow's economy.
What is different now from 50 years ago is that the application of automation in factories is getting higher and higher, a large number of jobs that used to require a lot of people are replaced by robots or automated equipment, fewer people are needed, cheap labor has less impact on the cost of production, and the technical requirements for factory operators are much higher than before. It often takes several years of vocational and technical training to become competent, and the capital, technical threshold and commercial risk of investing in factories are much higher than before. Until now, China is still in short of skilled workers who can be skilled in CNC equipment. Fortunately for China, 50 years ago, a large number of rural labor can be easily trained to work in factories, and factories at that time need far more cheap labor than now, and the large population at that time just meet the needs of industrialization. Unfortunately, India does not have such good luck now.
I think your analysis is completely wrong , India is 432 years ahead of Singapore/China/Japan/USA, we have smart cities not only on India but Modi ji built multiple smart cities on planet Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. also we have bullet trains running from India to Mars and Mercury, also Indians have 10000000 crore in their account so they are the richest in the world, India is also the cleanest country on planet earth that there is no garbage on the garbage collection center itself. India not only has make in India program but it also has make in mars and Pluto program where India built smart cities and smart colonies.India is so smart that USA,China and other 3rd world European countries learn from India on how to manage garbage collection center and how to run their own country.
There are many drawbacks in his analysis. 1. Germany is a huge manufacturing hub. 2. Which is the most productive locality in the US? It is San Francisco bay area. That is definitely not a high-traffic area. One can't generalise such things. There are different ways of development geographically.
It is a one sided analysis . . at many points in depth analysis was required going upto the root cause of the problems and the solution would have been practical and workable then . . It is easier to compare with other countries but we should take into consideration a couple of points like low 'density' of population in other countries as compared to India . . It should also be taken into consideration that China opened up its economy (in seventies) way before India did in 1992 . . China got guarantee of heavy investments from the USA and EU in lieu . . and thus it flourished . . Whereas India didn't get any such guarantee beforehand before opening up of our economy before our economy being opened up in 1992. Moreover the infrastructure development was very slow due to lack of funds, finance and investments (during UPA regim it was only around $ 250 billion) and abundance of 'babudoms' . . Gradually things are moving for better now as is visible from the increasing forex reserves and good investments from foreign funding agencies coupled by solid government support planing and actions . . Just have patience and wait for some time . . We are moving in the right direction now overcoming all the hurdels that are throwing spanner in our wheels of development . . It will take some time to change the mindset of the people and bringing in workaholic mindset . . Just wait and watch . . India is arriving . . Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Hi Arihant India’s civilisational edge and future progress would be underpinned by her strives and achievements in scientific research, innovation, R & D and academia-industry convergence. Your interaction with Sanjay Dixit has very rightly brought this to fore, he was right in considering this an imperative. Human development, prosperity and wellbeing of any society would be critically dependant on its achievements in scientific research and innovation. For the last few years, I am working towards inspiring young minds for future engagements in science through the multilingual platform, Scientific European, which I founded few years ago. I expose them to latest research & scientific and technological developments in their mother tounges for easy comprehension and appreciation. This eases language barriers faced by non-English and non-native English speakers. The translations, when read with original article in English, make comprehension and appreciation of the idea easy. You are very good in your work, great service to the country. Congratulations!
This is good information, but the basic premise is that you are comparing yourself to a completely different economic and demographic model. Singapore, Korea Japan have piddling populations and so export is the only choice for them to grow. Also their growth was fuelled by the massive influx of cheap dollars (cheap for the US) where they exported natural resources, labour and depended upon the economic engine of the US. That's exactly why, after growing to the point where Japan threatened to become the world no 1 economy, overtaking the US, all the US has to do was tweak a few levers and they've not recovered from the stagflation they went into in the 1980s. Today China is realising the same thing. They've mined their resources, polluted their air, waters with heavy chemicals and metals and all this export for paper money - it takes the US 17 cents to print 100 dollars and then give it to China for 100 dollars worth of real goods. I feel that our growth was and will be fuelled by our domestic markets first and then exports to reach attainable and sustainable levels of prosperity. India is looking at mass transport using waterways, rail and creating tier 3,4 cities. We have enormous potential for growth by moving production to these cities. Please look at our purchasing power parity. We are third in the world currently. So i feel that this interview is helpful but we must drive our own growth story, not use a "playbook" cookie cutter plan.
Search for China tofu dreg constructions, ghost cities to show growth in GDP, drainage sewer cooking oil. systemic corruption is rampant, which makes our babus look like angels. GDP as the mantra is the reason for this.
We will leap frog interim technologies and adopt the latest tech at scale. You can see this in our upgradation of 95% trains to electric in a decade. UPI skipped all the interim tech moving directly to mobile based payments. Stock exchanges have had T+1 day trade settlement for last 20 years where the US still has T+3 to T+5 day trade settlement. India is building roads at a world record pace. All this while de dollarisation is decimating the economies of Japan, South Korea, China etc.
China used highly questionable trade policies and propping up one company in a sector with other competitor companies providing resources, marketing, sales to one company till they became world leaders. Then that company helped the others grow larger. This is possible in a dictatorship, not in a democracy. But all this was propped up by printing currency, reverse engineering and copycatting foreign technology. Shortcuts which have led to a bad reputation in the world. We can achieve similar growth without sharp tactics.
00:09 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है
01:54 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है
06:42 भारत को बॉटम-अप ग्रोथ की जरूरत है
09:03 भारत का विकास इसकी विरासत और गौरव के लिए महत्वपूर्ण है।
13:48 द्वितीय विश्व युद्ध के बाद जापान की आर्थिक वृद्धि
16:11 दक्षिण कोरिया द्वारा उपयोग की जाने वाली जापान की आर्थिक प्लेबुक
20:37 भारत में 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता
22:29 उच्च यातायात केंद्र और रहने योग्य क्षेत्र विकास के लिए महत्वपूर्ण हैं।
26:39 कमी की मानसिकता बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास को प्रभावित करती है
28:49 भारत को बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास के लिए सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है
32:34 एक मजबूत सांस्कृतिक नींव के निर्माण का महत्व
34:50 भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है
39:10 चीन को हराने के लिए भारत को व्यापक मानसिकता में बदलाव की जरूरत है
41:23 शहरों के बीच सुगम यात्रा के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे में सुधार और यातायात अनुशासन लागू करना
45:13 अन्य देशों की तुलना में भारत में सड़क बुनियादी ढांचा
47:06 निर्माण में मानकीकरण और गुणवत्ता नियंत्रण
51:27 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है
53:36 भारत को शिक्षा और अनुसंधान को प्राथमिकता देने के लिए एक सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की आवश्यकता है
57:54 भारत में विद्यालय स्थापित करने में चुनौतियाँ
59:56 भारत को गुणवत्तापूर्ण संस्थानों को प्रोत्साहित करने और शिक्षा क्षेत्र में उद्यमिता को बढ़ावा देने की आवश्यकता है।
1:04:09 आर्थिक विकास के लिए संस्थानों और शिक्षा को मजबूत किया जाना चाहिए
1:06:19 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है।
1:10:16 भारत को आर्थिक विकास के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे को उन्नत करने की जरूरत है
1:12:07 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को एक सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की आवश्यकता है।
1:15:44 भारत में कौशल विकास और नौकरी के अवसरों में सुधार
1:17:37 भारत को विकास के लिए कुशल जनशक्ति की आवश्यकता है।
1:21:30 यूटी के रूप में शीर्ष शहरों की केंद्रीकृत योजना और विकास।
1:23:21 भारत को अपने लिए उत्पादन पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है।
1:27:12 डिजिटल उपनिवेशीकरण में चीन को मात देने के लिए 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता
1:30:29 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है
1:34:41 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को बड़े बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास की जरूरत है
1:36:45 दिल्ली की तुलना में नोएडा का बुनियादी ढांचा और शासन
1:40:51 भारत को बेहतर शहर बनाने के लिए सांस्कृतिक क्रांति की जरूरत है
1:42:33 भारत को जनसंख्या केंद्रों के लिए ऊंची इमारतों के निर्माण पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है।
1:47:12 भारत को अधिक किफायती आवास बनाने की जरूरत है
1:49:10 भारत में रियल एस्टेट बुलबुला और चीन का अतिउत्पादन
1:53:00 भारत को तेज विकास के लिए निर्माण पर पुनर्विचार करने की जरूरत है
1:54:53 दिल्ली में रेल यात्रा की अक्षमता पर चर्चा
1:58:53 भारत को इस्पात आयात के मुद्दों का समाधान करने की जरूरत है
2:00:50 कानून का प्रवर्तन समाज के लिए महत्वपूर्ण है
2:04:48 कानून प्रवर्तन में भ्रष्टाचार और धार्मिक कारक
2:06:58 पुलिस सुधारों को लागू करने में चुनौतियाँ
2:11:16 न्यायपालिका में चुनौतियाँ और भ्रष्टाचार
2:13:24 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत में 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है
2:17:13 भारत को 10 ट्रिलियन की अर्थव्यवस्था के लिए योजना बनाने की जरूरत है
2:19:05 भारत में घटते अनुसंधान एवं विकास से विकास प्रभावित हो रहा है
2:23:01 भारत के भविष्य के लिए युवाओं का मार्गदर्शन और मार्गदर्शन महत्वपूर्ण है
2:24:55 भारत में भ्रष्टाचार व्यापक है और भ्रष्टाचार मुक्त समाज हासिल करना आसान नहीं है।
2:28:43 हार्ड कोर स्किल्स की बहुत जरूरत है
2:30:40 भारत को विनिर्माण को बढ़ावा देने के लिए 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की आवश्यकता है
2:34:46 चीन से मुकाबला करने के लिए भारत को विनिर्माण और सॉफ्टवेयर विकास पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है।
2:37:02 बैंकों से धन प्राप्त करने में संपत्ति और मशीनरी का महत्व।
2:40:45 भारत को आर्थिक विकास के लिए अधिक हवाई अड्डों की आवश्यकता है
2:42:42 भारत को आर्थिक वृद्धि के लिए बुनियादी ढांचे के विकास पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है।
2:46:40 चीन को मात देने के लिए भारत को 'सांस्कृतिक क्रांति' की जरूरत है
2:48:40 भारत में रक्षा उत्पादन चुनौतियाँ
Bottom up growth me inspector Raj sabse bari badha hai
आपके इस अनुपम कर्म के लिए धयंवाद ❤
Thank you bhai ❤
Best Conversation on Real Problem Of Bharat, no Time Waste , No fake fiction , Pure reality.
Please bring Sanjeev Sanyal or someone from government and pass them these critical feedbacks which you guys discussed 🙂.
Bro have the guts to bear criticism
Bhai, they know it all. Discussion me yhi bola gaya ki ground up krna giga development. Log sudhrenge to desh sudhrega.
Sanjeev Sanyal knows everything in this world!!!!
I agree with him on lots of points but he does more rants rather than solutions bhai apana constitution ke preamble me aj bhi socialist hai aur tum private university pe baat kar rahe ho. Aur India ki development start hi 1998-2000 se Hui hai usme bhi 10 sal upa aur Rajan jaise log chala rahe the oh bhi globalization ke zamane ko waste kar diye. Sala Ek expressway nahi banaya upa walo ne.
really man, mujhe to lagta hai independence 1991 se mila india ko
@@sg042it's not a joke when people say 2014 was our year of independence.
@@rutvikrsno one says that except bjp politician
And of course they will say that
@@MriKum-wr6ks not here to change anyone's mind.
@@MriKum-wr6ks And they have a point in that argument
I have ran factory at Shenzhen 18 years with 600+ team. Now moved to all setup Japan. We are missing pragmatic attitude and low skill 🙏🏾
Hi. Can you please explain this in more detail for the benefit of others? Thanks.
@@Vaad please share your email address and contact window 🙏🏾
@@Vaad Hello please share contact window 🙏🏾
Traitor not moving to India?
@hj2711you are missing the point, it's not a skill issue, it's an everything issue.
Anywhere bw 40-50% are always late, minimal hygiene, drunk and have behavioural issues but are skilled and independent.
Another 40% has none of the behavioural problems but are not skilled or independent and need constant monitoring.
It’s the best Indian podcast I have ever seen. These are the problems I have always thought about. Thanks for giving voice to it
How many times you have written that 😂😂😂
@@pradeep-qu9wt twice . Once here on YT and second on Twitter. Purpose was to increase the audience base
@@maheshbabbar07 👍
jEsE ki baat boli gyi yhan sirf baat hoti action 0
My opinion
China is 50 years ahead of India
China has
own space station
Own astronauts
Clean roads
Good infrastructure
Surface level analysis ho gaya bhai. I can show instances of littering in Japan. No one will claim Japan is underdeveloped.
China has 186000 km of expressways in the end of 2023 45000 km of high speed railway 10500 km of underground metro network in more than 60 cities
China is known for dictatorship but Indian democracy creates hurdles restrains in many projects
@@rutvikrs Bhai wo dono hi roads consistently ache bana lete hai. Unka basics bohot strong hai. Hamara basics exist hi nahi karta. Cities me roads bhi nahi hote aur footpaths bhi nahi hote. Bas kachra hi hota hai. We're easily 70-80 years behind China
@@yugmathakkar4023 I don't disagree with you on that. Unedited comment was bakwaas along the lines of China doesn't litter or has zero open defecation, so they are a superpower. Abhi edited comment is reasonable.
Without manufacturing India cannot grow at faster pace and pullout millions out of poverty. For the semi skilled and unskilled, manpower intensive manufacturing is essential. Ship building, auto ancillary, electronics, steel equipment, garment, food processing, agro tech have to be all pushed at massive scales.
Sir, As a housewife I have been telling my family since 2015 the same thing.
We dont have any work force like plumber, carpenter, electrician, mason etc, with real skills .
We need more state of the art vocational colleges teaching these skills .
These guys could also be exported. 🙏
I agree with you ma’am, there is someone who is also thinking like me. Thanks for raising your voice. We don’t have this people cause we don’t have skill worker cause we don’t. Production than. And those want to learn they are experienced labor. But they are not skilled. For this we need more good education and with out license no one can work as a electrician, plumber or any XYZ job
skill INDIA ka name suna wahi ho raha ha...
@@SilentTraderview ya but they said in 2070 will be done 😂 😂 😂 any government comes and goes they have project on 3D maps but in reality it’s no where around. We need to progress faster, decision making should to be faster but like bullet train even Japan is giving money here we are so slow for decision making
But question is would you like to enroll your son in such course... And make him a plumber, carpentor etc... Society doesn't respect work but the nature of work.
⁰⁰0⁰0⁰⁰00⁰⁰00
❤🔥 aag laga di bhaion.. excellent topic! please continue this series on manufacturing. main apne sab bhaion ko bhej rha hu.
Harvard has assets worth 51 billion dollars. Stanford, MIT etc have huge assets.
Yes, and they're all fairly USELESS in the so called EDUCATION that they provide for $60,000+/year. There is ZERO critical thinking involved in anything Harvard, MIT and Stanford even teach at this point. You can be more experienced and get REAL WORLD experience from going to a charter school where you learn real life skills.
Deta kaun hai? Alumni...
They have Trust and from student fees but matter of the fact is they do solve countries problem.
We have personally experienced the skill gap, the scarecity of skilled and semi skilled people is real.
Try throwing opportunity to aspiring candidate
I hv seen candidate passed bcom 😊 doing excellence in electric.. best factory manager/ engineer a bcom ??
@@YashSharma-sp4bcworks in close circles, not at scale.
Education is the only key to success, we need to open training centers for skilled workers, our labor is just a traffic nothing else
Absolutely! Education must! But not just theory based practical training is necessary from the age of 14yrs. Civil etiquette, customer service, basic wood work, metal work, etc would also help. We lack basic manners, social interactions, interpersonal and communication skills all necessary for labour force
Cultural revolution of China was nothing more than a Chinese version of Japan's Meiji restoration, meiji too broke certain structures of old society which was resistant to modern industrial structure which is something China did as well. Indian govt historically was weak and did not destroy the conception of family cliques and neoptism although it did it better than Pakistan but still did not go far enough. All cultural products are created in cities, civilization itself requires conception of cities. Village is meant to be primitive which should be limited to agriculture activities. To expand up to 10 trillion industrialization will be required. Otherwise India might get stuck in 5-8 trillion.
And we have someone in the comment section who wants to preserve joint families 😂
British slavery (Ghulam)parliament democracy made India next Africa already....
... American propaganda media, conspiracy theory and fakes news against China,Iran, Russia and North Korea is controlling and dictating 1.4 billion Indians minds now.....
.........
..........1 million American CIA agents in India now so India will never be next economic super power in history.......
India will be next economic super power in American propaganda social media platforms ( You Tube, Facebook, Twitter only)
Dehatis are the most dangerous hindrance to industrialization. I always balk when ppl romanticize village life and villagers, rural folks are one of the casteist people with very low moral values. It's not any particular community, it's everyone else against anyone outside their group. Pure tribalistic agrarian low enterprise society
@@rutvikrsThat's previlege for those who can afford to live comfortably.
Whats the problem with that?? I genuinely want to know@@rutvikrs
Tata made his fortune selling Opium. They have quota at Hong Kong from colonial looters 😂 we are just fool and believed Tata clean image 😂😂😂
100% True
TATA and Teresa have become Holy Cows.
Their andhbhakts can not hear anything critical about them.
It's irrelevant what they did 100 years ago and they supplied opium through Britishers in line with the law of the land. So even didn't do anything illegal.
Aaj koi daaru bechta hai kyuki wo legal hai. Kalko illegal hogai toh wo criminal thodi hogya
They (Parsees) were given special treatment by British at the behest of other Indians. This was done to create artificial divisions in the society under Divide and Rule policy.🧐
@@sanchitsharma6852 Please give me one Parsi name who went in jail or died for Bharat Freedom Fight. Those are very near and dears of looters colonials. Tata is main in 2G scam…..our people memory is very short and we didn’t connect dots.
Best podcast with Shashank among all.
This conversation feels more real than those guys giving fake expression and interrupting all the time during podcast( Beer biceps and Prakhar k pravachan).
They should learn.
Samsung from commodity trading to basic manufacturing like textile and chemicals to transistors to a complete turn towards(started 1990-95)display,memory chip,dram to led tech to consumer mobiles and items to fabless semi.
Aur bhi banate hai samsung c and t(construction),chemicals(ev batteries and all) to big container and petroleum ships.
I was like kuch to chhodh dete.
Aur Haan family batware mein retail business kisi aur mil gaya.
Start kaise hua tha after retirement i guess toshiba founder came to korea just one year before death aur Samsung ke founder ko mentor kiya idea diya ki beta transistor aur radio mein upgrade karo apne manufacturing ko
Honestly I am a little disappointed by the podcast. While I agree with his overall message of India requiring a cultural revolution, infrastructure creation, reducing petty crimes and the need for public order to be restored, many other arguments are either fallacious, incorrect or not apt for India.
1. India cannot follow the east Asian countries' playbook on manufacturing. America was still growing as an economy when east Asian countries ramped up manufacturing prowess. As of today, growth is stagnant in the broader West. India can hope to take a pie from the east Asian countries but cannot replicate their strategy. It needs to manufacture for its own population to begin with instead of copy-pasting mercantilist manufacturing models.
2. American cities are horribly planned (and Japanese cities are not all grid layout type except for small portions). There are limited walking areas and the requirement of a car is a must to commute between different parts of a city except for NY, Boston. Moreover, America can afford this expansive car-centric city planning because of the huge land mass, we need to create cities that encourage public transport, cycling and walking leaving the car capacity to a few vehicles or LCVs. This is not a scarcity mindset but a policy implication for India.
3. America is the only country in the world that has an abundance mindset because that was the basis of its creation and the American Dream. Enormous land and natural resources have enabled this mindset. Bharat has always been one of the most densely populated regions in the world since time immemorial. Conservation of resources has been deeply ingrained into our culture and psyche. There is nothing wrong with having such an approach.
Finally, I feel his long time in the US clouds his judgement and makes him observe things from an Americentric perspective. Bharat will have its own model of development. The government should create infra on mission mode and devolve more powers (and create accountability) for cities to make them liveable. The rest Bharatiyas will take care of.
Yes. US further it's growth with cheap printed money. Money press go brrr.. now it's on its last legs.
भारत के विकास में सबसे बड़ा रोड़ा हमारे देश की सरकारी मशीनरी है सरकारी कर्मचारी अपने को सेवक नहीं शाशक समझते हैं । हर काम में टांग अड़ाने की आदत । समस्या को सुलझाने के बजाय उलझाने की महारत हासिल है सरकारी कर्मचारियों को ।😭😭
सरकार भि कर्मचारितन्त्रही चलाती हे
India needs to soften labour laws,land laws ..... setting up factories is hard...change factories act😂😂
Good discussion. The need for 10x thinking is a good suggestion and worth noting 👍
However, I disagree with Shashank's hypothesis that progress in India can be bottom-up. Historically, India has been top-down in terms of progress and bottom-up in terms of resistance -
Examples of top-down progress -
1. Economic Liberalization in 1991
2. India becoming a nuclear power in 1998
3. Ram Mandir Movement planned by the BJP, culminating in creation of Ram Mandir in 2023
Examples of bottom-up resistance -
1. Rebellion of 1857
2. J.P. Narayan movement of 1975 against Indira Gandhi's Emergency
3. Anti Farm Laws Movement from 2020 - 2021
Also, Shashank's statement that hardware / manufactured product startups require less funds than software startups is incorrect. Software startups (unlike in 2021) normally raise big money after some product traction. And getting to that part (product traction) in a hardware product requires a significant investment. If a young person wants to get funded via a loan from an Indian Bank for a hardware / manufactured product startup, that is just not going to happen!
41 hr (3,815.1 km)-Jilin-Xinjiang.
62 hr (3,089.8 km)Mumbai-Manipur.
Look at coatal routes.....you chose very offbeat location....Xinjiang is not mainstream in China....
Let Mumbai-Delhi Expressway get completed you'll need even less time to cover the same time...
We needed an expressway chain long back... But no Khangress government paid heed to infra boom...Most of such projects have seen the light of day in the last 1 decade... And in the next 5 years, many of them will find their place in the list of the world's best infra projects...
Sir, Railway is a corruption of Mount Everest. My friend designed a machine for railway and railway minister demanded two crores without any advance order. He lost his life savings and filed bankruptcy. Railway imported the same machine from Germany at ten times cost.
Corruption is the only bottle neck.
I've learnt so many perspectives that I've never even think off and we need more such discussion amongst our youth...
let's go boys, only we can bring change 🙅
Massive bull.....
Young have to join politics for that
Jabardast. I congratulate you both for laying out a detailed analysis of the root causes of problems India has been facing. We need more such debates so that we can propel towards some actions and tangible work.
Listen to Abhijit Iyer Mitra's blackpill at IIT-(K?). Why India won't be a superpower.
University of California, is totally publicly funded. All 50 states have public universities with world class education.
Ten point charter दीजिए, क्या क्या कैसे कैसे करा जाय
One point चार्टर, जातपत बंद करो 😂😂😂
We Indians always find a problem to follow the rules. Our mindset is the person next to me is not following why i should follow. No sense of responsibility to be clean as well . We follow corruption to the core . Our big cities are run by corporations who are working life mafias . Our city roads are not world class at all. Lack of planning , lack of quality and no standardization . Forget about the village roads . We spit on the roads and everynow and then dig up the existing roads because our different departments are not coordinated . Long way to go folks.
we need more episodes like this . hope you start a new series with him . discussing all of these topics. thanks for this episode
Kya baat chit thi 🙏. We need more of such deep conversation focusing on Bharat's real problems.Thank you so very much .Looking forward to more such content.
China is way ahead of India. I have been seeing Indian backpacker blogs and been observing that china seems more developed that US too.
.....China is 30 years ahead of USA and 150 years ahead of India now in infrastructure development now.....China bullet train railways 40,000 kilometres and India still zero....USA still zero.....China total expressway 1,68,000 kilometers, USA 1,48,000 kilometres and India still 5,000 kilometres , Check. Google.....China skyscraper 4,000.....USA skyscraper 1,800 and India skyscraper 330 only....
😂 no it's not watch videos at china insight and china observer
china has developed big cities. but america is developed as whole . village and small towns in china are poor.
why watch news outlets from cult falun gong with fake buddha impersonator. Where is your allegiance to Dalai lama? Backpackers are fine- no politics.
I also watch backpacker vlog to know how china is infra too good compare to India. tunnel are much more you ever think of it
Very very rightly said - Raasta hii nahi pata hai hume
Manufacturing business thought doesn’t even cross our minds when brainstorming
i am listening your podcast since 1 am at night and the best conversation i have listen to insure our country growth
Overall good discussion, but some comments were naive. Core issues were not properly understood.
1) china is 5 times bigger than us GDP wise so most indicators will be 5-8 times bigger, thats not a surprise
2) things like why we cant build HSR over eway etc is pointless as its mostly function of money. When we have enough money things will happen
3) metro all over world are like that. Stations cant be skipped as there are only 2 tracks unlike normal railway where it exapnds to 10s of tracks near stations.
4) petty crimes cannot be easily stopped at this level as we have lot of poor people. Cant vacate encroachment or slums as its not fair to poor people. Thailand is 7k per capita which is 2-3 times bigger than India.
5) there are many companies that make fans in India. What is different abt atomberg is that they introduced BLDC fans which was innovation
6) there are many more vehicle manf companies like TVS, eicher, Ashok Leyland, force, hero etc so that will also grow naturally, no real information or insight there even when you talked about it for 10min
In nutshell many of these will be solved when we reach similar income levels.
Real problem we have is lack of planning and quality control over execution, horrible police and slow judiciary, very poor urban infra.
these things are bad even when compared to similar GDP per capita levels countries. Many of these are related to excess democracy which cant be corrected now.
Yar....ye Indian backpacker China ghum raha hai....yar....look at those infrastructure.... cities....they doing very well!!!
Hindu apne school college nahi khol sakte agar kholte hai to vo govt control rahenge christian kholte hai par bahot kam kyonki vo sankhaya me kam or muslmano ko keval madarsa kholna hai bas or majhabi shiksha leni hai
😂 mullah ko education se koi Lena Dena nahi , sirf Quran . Asli power Christian missionary ke pass he , which is education .
Finally the indians had beaten china in population growth. I am sure they can compete china in other fields as well😂
Mai programming seekh raha tha software Engineering banne ke liye lekin saath saath mai massive layoffs ko bhi dekh raha hun, hiring bahut kum ho rahi hai software Engineers ka, isilye maine ye decide kiya hai ki aage chalke mai hardware design(jaise electronic circuit design, Embedded systems design etc) aur programming bhi sikunga kyonki mujhe electronics ka Thora bahut idea aur usme interest hai . Abhi Shashank Dixit ji ko sunke lag raha hai ki mera hardware design (including electronic circuit design) aur programming ko sikhne ka decision sahi hai. Mai jaanta hun electronic circuit design , Embedded systems and programming seekhna mere liye challenging hoga lekin iska matlab ye nhi ki main naa karun.
Kuch Challenging nhi hai, you can learn whatever you want. There are lot of companies in Electronics too. Keep skilling one thing to another. If you like software then also it is fine.
And there's scarcity of workers in that sector so its better to jump there.
This guy has no idea what he is talking about. Very superficial knowledge and poor analysis on most of the topics. He diverged from answering the core question as well.
Arihant, please update your Spotify playlists. That's where I discovered your podcast properly and been listening off and on. RUclips isn't convenient for audio only play in the background.
If you have a premium subscription your issue will be resolved...
Shashaank dikshit sir achha sapna dikha rhe hain i have seen 2-3 friends having family business of manufacturing in basic electrical material and plastic housekeeping system and their life is destroyed almost, as demand hi ni hai. local kharidta hi koi ni hai. So kehdena ki manufacturing kro manufacturing kro se kuch ni hoga.. Carpenter chahiye electrician chahiye 15k ki job milti hai unko tabhi na wo dubai jate hain. Paisa dena hai ni, demand bnani hai ni aur sabko experience wala hi chahiye new ko sikhane wala bhi koi hai to wo bhi lut rha hai.. Aur sapne dekho😂
Bilkul sahi bola...Mechanical, Civil, Infra jaise sectors me ekdum ghatiya 2 kodi ke jobs he...Sirf IT / CS hi best he as per jobs
Shashank is founder of software company. He made millions in software sector. He is enjoying his wealthy life. Travelling in luxury car, living in luxury house, travelling all over the world.
He expects other to do hardware manufacturing and not go after money. Manufacturing is hard ,more risky, less rewarding.
@@guptasagar694Are bhai jb Infrastructure he ghatiya hai to kya bologe? Ayodhya ka vikas pe khub majak bn gya hai news wale godi media jise khte h unhone he tamasha bna diya....Fir railway station ka ghatna Train accident ka ghatna Mandir me pani bharna aur chat se tapak tapak girna Hawai adde ka chat he gir Jana Mathura me pani ka tnki girna Bihar me 7-8 pool 1 hafte me girna Rajasthan me hawai adde ka chat girna Ahemdabad me sadak me gaddha hona Lucknow me bhi same....kya hai bhai ye sb? Ghatiya vikas hai khokla vikas h bolte h karwayi karenge are kispe karoge jb khud usme sanlipt hoge to🤣🤣
Pura suna hain sir ..... thank god this man is adddressing all the core and real problems ..... thank you ...... gov should restructure all systems in politics and judiciary rethink and rebuild ❤❤❤❤❤
I m sorry but nyc traffic is horrible. So is Boston
Family ke saath ya dosto ke saath aise 2 3 ghante baat ki na ...to bohot saare problem solve ho jayenge......hum log aaj kal sab mobile pr chipke hain
Shashank Dixit is Original Gangster of 🇮🇳/acc
British slavery(Ghulam )feudalism parliament democracy made India already next Africa............ American propaganda media, conspiracy theory and fakes news against China,Iran, Russia and North Korea is controlling and dictating 1.4 billion Indians minds now.....
.........
..........1 million American CIA agents in India now so India will never be next economic super power in history.......
India will be next economic super power in American propaganda social media platforms ( You Tube, Facebook, Twitter only)
I have worked in one of the top corporate firm of India, and now appearing in civil services interviews; i want to say that, bhai, ye angreji me chahe kitna bhi libir libir kar lo, ye Bharat hai, India nahi, yahan ki pitch slow hai, bade bade khiladi spin me bold ho jate hain. Ye jo videsh ke tamam jhandu balm bata rhe hain Dixit ji, yahan kuchh nahi chalega. Yaha Bose aur Bhagat Singh jaise log side kar diye jate hain aur Nehru jaise chaplus kursi pe baith jate hain. I am telling you bhai, sirf Modi ji bakaiti de rhe hain upar se, andar aaj bhi wahi sab hai...the Medieval "Samnti" Bharat !!
☝️this is exactly the reason why india is held back! Le de kar sirf civil services exam! Poora podcast sun kar bhi zero bata zero!
@@cloudboiz dekh bhai...podcast-baji, aur twitter campaign...aur AC office me baith ke youtube me Rashtriya Samasya ki Charcha sunne se kachhu nahi hota...civil services gives you the authority to bring social change. A civil servant is a bonafide social reformer. Haan, aur bhi better ways ho sakte hain, I respect them, par ye Dixit sahab jo bol rhe hain, wo AC ki hawa me baith ke sunne ke liye achha hai, yha zamin pe aake execute karne ke liye this Indian society is too rigid. Aur aapko bata dein sir, ki ye rigidity corporate sector me rehke to katai door nahi ho sakti. Its only civil services that can break this rigidity, aur prayas jari hai. To sahab, is podcast me gyaan to bahut hai, lekin implementation kaise hoga Indian setup me, uspe input "ZERO" hai....haan, interviewer sir ne prayas zaruru kiye ki Dixit sahab ground pe kaise reforms laenge uspe baat karein, par Dixit ji could not explain it. AC ki hawa me baith ke colourful excel sheets me solution dena Corporate DRM me chal jaega....yhan nahi. Sorry.
@@cloudboiz aur ek baat aur sir...India is not held back because yha civil services ka craze hai...India is held because yahan Problems dekhne wale Crore hain, lekin unko actually zamin pe utar ke solve karne wale bahut kam...jo utar bhi rhe hain unko marginalise kr rakha hai society ne...jaise abhi aap comment kr rhe hain. AC chamber me baith ke UNIBIC cookies khate hue, EURO CUP ka schedule discuss krke India ki socio-economic problems pe bhasan dena bahut easy hai....koi bhi kar lega jo 10 country ghoom le aur India ko compare kar le....the major challange is to solve the complex problems, aur uspe Dixit ji khare nahi utre hain. Wahi mai keh rha hun. To mujhpe tippani karne se better hai aap Dixit ji se request kijiye ki koi solid ground-work plan bataen, ki kaise ek already existing socio-economic structure ko totally revolutionise kar denge ye. India me +70% population aaj bhi Medieval setup me ji rhi hai, usko kaise transform karenge ye, Korea, Japan aur Vietnam ka model laga ke, aur exactly kya steps follow kiye jane chahiye. Warna ye criticism aur 4 desh ghum ke wapas aake India ko gali dena is very easy, aajkal har 4tha aadmi dikh jaega ye karte hue. So i hope, aap meri bhawnaein samajh pa rhe honge sir. Thanks
Aa gaye hamare left ke krantikari... Bharat ka kuch nahibho sakta, Sirf bat karne se kuch nahi hoga, sab dhong hai..... khali problem ginana hai, solution kuch nahi hai... Civil services me mat ja bhai, khali opportunity kharab karega tu...
@@indiboy7 are babaji, wahi keh rha hu mai...ye video me Dixit bhi yahi bol rha hai ki India me kuch sambhav nahi...japan aur korea ne hi badhiya kiya hai.....thik se video dekh le bhai pehle...hamesha bhakti thik nahi. Leftist rightist chhod, jamin pe policy kaise execute karna hai ye bata, baki kahani har koi bol deta hai youtube pe aake.
Aisa lag rha h 2 log jinko bhot zyada knowledge nhi h hawa me baate kr rhe h
Not a quality podcast
Haan aap hi ko ab pata hai. AAP kab aa rahe hai?
vaad is doing what i always wanted hindu organizations to do a hold on education
What you call petty crime by the contractors is actually executed by politicians and that makes it not petty. This is quite a simplistic solution being provided that 'just stop the petty crime' without thinking abt the real cause.
X pe jaake unko reply karde factually
😮
We expect a series of discussions with scholers on
Anti philosophies : against
Sanatan Vedic Hindu Dharma
and
Science
Virodhi galat philosophies ka parda fash karne wali series
Atheist
Rationalist
Agnostic
Socialist
Communist
:
Science varces all above philosophies
on the basis
Spiritual science
Spiritual Philosophy
Parapsychology
Metaphysics
Cosmology
Theology
Spiritual science and philosophy
Towards the Truth
for peaceful bright future of human and world.
😮
2:28:24 obviously so government do need to start a basic unemployment benefit on the bases of the potential of that person , so that he can leave zomato, also government need to start free skill enhancement programs which give lean management and similar kind of work compatibility courses . In west government do these courses for free and place the candidate for related jobs themselves.
Indian Parsi Industralist got preference treatment from British in government contract compare to Hindu businessman during 1850 to 1945 and these Industralist did not invested in factory worker housing in Mumbai due to this there is slum problem in Mumbai. This is one of best example of how homegenous culture like in UK USA Industralist spend some money on creating institution to prepare future work force of technitian but parsi ignored in India. Nothing against Parsi but this is fact.
Bullet train is not a solution for big country like India. Maintaining track and track barrification is costly for bullet train. Bullet train is OK for country size like Japan, Germany to connect few high traffic centre. Same money can be spend for high acceleration train with overall Average speed of 125km/h compare to 200km/h average speed of bullet train and cost increase by 4 times..
China high speed train line is 😂😂😂
This is mindset of scarcity .
Abundance mindset is :
Not building something is not the solution, it's always good to have as many transport alternatives as possible.
You can't cry about something which you don't even have , those who value their time will pay for quick, noiseless, hassle-free transport.
2nd important point is we can't increase speed on current railway tracks beyond 150-160 km/hr as train operating above this speed require proper barricaded tracks, with low curves
Semi-highspeed and high-speed trains can run only on new separate lines that is why we have to build RRTS and Bullet trains 😊
Appreciate you guys for this episode
आउटस्टैंडिंग बर्तालाप् हम भारत को इलेक्ट्रॉनिक हब बनाएंगे......
A sincere request to you. Pls introduce your guests. I've heard many podcasts of yours but I seldom know the guests.
See description
20 years behind?. India has almost Zero infrastructure, , most roads are very badly maintained, in the last 10 years most roads have been repaired, new roads are made very less,
I don't agree with his thoughts.
Look at the roads?? Fake material are used, no pavements for pedestrians, no proper road policy, no implementation, fake driving license, no traffic rule.
Then you build high rise in posh areas, walk round the corner and Kachra everywhere, then you'll find 😮some muddy corners? Holistic development of the site is never done.
56:47 well I can understand what you are saying , but you see in USA how the social security is fixed from a very long time , so when a person in USA work on a risky big project ( it can be university) his mind has no worries of his basic survival or any kinda worry of his family survival ,
Also minimum wage and equality in the society is there , so a risk taker have a peace of mind that if his project fails , he can grab an odd job which is capable of giving him a basic civilised life (and society doesn’t look down to any job) so there is not that kinda society pressure which one can face in India 😊😊,
I mean I hate when they start calling people freebie , how cruel it is , the people are innocent and they are already suffering from great discriminations and poverty, and if you giving them lil help of free electricity, people start calling it freebie, lol 😂
They have no clue how human being works.
You give respect and dignity to a human being , you ll then see a great difference in them .
Which west understands.
Bhai kis gadhe ko laaye ho. Apartment ki price kam hone se nahi hua evergrande barbaad. Ek project ka paisa doosri jagah lagane se hua. India mein bhi builders yahi karte the, RERA ne rok diya. (IBFC and RERA are 2 of thr most important protections given to indian consumers)
US mein bhi aise laws hain builders ke liye.
I agree vocational education (higher education in general) ki shortage hai India mein, badi companies bhi kam hain. Aur hume apna haal South Korea jaisa nahi karna jahaan kisi ko job nahi milti. Lekin uska solution Chinese aur Japanese way nahi hai (all these 'tiger' economies with the exception of Singapore are full of Zombie corporations with a negligible start up culture).
India, like the US ,needs to chart its own course.
क्या china में डेमोक्रेसी है
India ke andar agar retired trained log apne apne gaon guhand (kshetra) me workshop level par logon ko train karna suru kar den besarte thora payment par ho to desh ko bahut aage le jaya ja sakta
Yeh tiktokiya generation hai bhaisaheb. Nahi hoga unse kasrat.
You are right young generation White collar job vo bhi sarkari ki khawahish rakhti hai lekin usko kaise achieve kiya jaye iska koi idea nehi hai dusre opposition ke chakkar me parkar apna time sarkaar ko gaali dene me barbaad kar rahe hain
In case of import of steel from China-
one is Cheaper electricity and energy in China, In our country govts charges higher rate of electricity tariffs to factories than to consumers. (again mindset of treating producers as golden goose)
seconnd - subsidies given by chinese govt
It is an irony that India is a collective society but in driving it has an individualistic attitude while Americans society has an Individualistic mentality yet their rule following is considerate of the collective.
That's an excellent observation and this is one of the ultimate extreme level pain filled daily suffering problem of us Indians 😢
अगर भारत को बदलना है तो हमे बदलना होगा हमारे attitude को बदलना होगा, ये नही की कोई भी बिल या रिफॉर्म्स किए जाए तो उसका विरोध शुरू कर दे। भारत में अगर कोई नई ट्रेन भी चले तो उसे पैसों की बरबादी कहते है।
In daily life, no Chinese think of India。
So?? We need to think about it, nobody in Europe thought about china 30 years ago
Dare to be Naive - Buckminster fuller
Great work @vaad, this podcast is an honest piece. One must listen to it with a lens of pragmatic and practical intuitiveness. Kudos to team.
Please comment on population
we want such frequent videos on this topic. china specific make a series and do podcast on this topic with different people. with this vieo movementum has begun. Thanks for doing this podcast.
Do not agree with Europe didn’t take benefit of manufacturing, Germany has the most advanced and strongest manufacturing. UK has very advanced manufacturers like Rolls Royce, Prett and Whitney, BAE and many more.
All these are pre-ww2 and these are not mass goods except for BMW cars
You are missing the point, these are legacy players running on patents, trade secrets or brand value. Europe hasn't been able to sustain a factory since the early 2000's because they don't do "scale".
The Chinese need just half a day of server access and 20 nappingkids(YT filter sorry) to shut down ASML.
@@rl1900 Nokia, Siemens, IKEA, ASML holdings, Airbus, Areva, Eurofighter, most of the robotic companies, sensor companies, Oral-b, medical devices, implants and even the advanced pumps. There are certain companies in Europe who are so advanced that any company in the world could not make comparable product such as ASML( this company technology is backbone of all the chip industry). Europe has advanced tech companies which create backbone of most of the industries that most people are not aware. China make low quality and low tech products, mostly assembled in China with the parts procured from all over the world. China can’t even make the SS ball that is used in ball point pen, they have to get it from Japan. In last 10 years China became pioneer in stealing the technology 😄.
commenting so that this video could reach people
Heard the entire podcast. Superb topic, I am working as an NRI and see how entire cities here are build around public transport. When I move between my workplace and home, there is so less friction compared to what I used to face in India. Pls continue on this topic, enlightening 😊
Where are u ?
Bring abjith iyer and talk about how Indian food and tourism can bring income of a 1 trillion dollor for economy, if created awareness.
Or Ankit Shah
bhai poadcaster sahab itta beech mai mat bola karo apki interuptions ke vajah sai shashank dixit sir kise bhi topic mai deep dive nahi kar paye
Raghu Ram Rajan to kehta hai we should not go for make In India
We should be only service based economy
Jyadatar wo Galat hi kehte hai. Raghuram Rajan jo pichli Congress aur UPA ki sarkar ka ravaiya tha usko jayaz thehrane ki koshish kar rahe hai. Pichle sarkar ye nhi chahti thi bharat manufacturing ko jyada tawajjo de. Yaad hai , pehle hindu devi devtaon ke murtiyan China se aati thi, jabki China me to koi hindu dharm ko mante nhi. Lekin Chinese unko manufacture karke bharat me export kar dete the. Wo murtiyan to bharat me banne chahiye the(Murti Pooja karne ka ek fayeda ye bhi hai ki economy ko support karta hai , murtikaron ki murtiyon ki demand bani rahti hai aur employment generate hoti hai, ye prachin hinduon ko pata chali thi, ye Tantra darshan se nikla hai) Lekin pichli sarkaron ko isse koi problem nhi thi. Humare yahan kanoon aise bane hai ki aap saste me koi cheej bana hi nhi sakte ,lekin China ye kar sakta tha, bharat me 80% se jyada log Gareeb pichde hone ke bawajood aap saste me koi cheez banake Market me bech nhi sakte the. Ab chunki modi manufacturing par jor de rahe hai jo ki pichle sarkar ne nhi kiya to unhen darr hai ki Modi ko postmodern Indian economy ke nirmata ka khitab na mil jaye.
Bahut acha podcast hai sir people's must think and talk about these issue..baat kana jaruri hai baat se hi baat banti hai
In India metro station are build based on how near it's to MP houses 😄
The quality of infrastructure currently constructed is poor, and most of the money is siphoned off by politicians, and bureaucrats in the form of commissions, and consultancy fees. Construction contracts are offered to contractors close to political parties and subcontracted to the families of bureaucrats. I can only hope that Modi is made aware of the same or else the damage to his reputation will be irreversible.
China is more than 100 year ago from us will be until next 50 years.
Why can’t we do copy paste like China?
I agree on them for cultural development need so strongly in india.
1:26:51 With out removing missionary madarsa culture from India this revolution is not possible by any kind of media
They are unknown about this problem ,because they are corporate guys ,,,,its not their fault
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂why is this host is crying and talking
क्या china ज्यादा खुश है
Bhai ji 30 lakh banake kaha bechta hai, abhi kya hal hai chaina ka Bhai ji Ghar ki bat pe hi Ghar banane ke chakkar me lage pade hai chahiye
I think aap logo thoda aur padhna chahiye
Sir I have friends and colleagues from ASEAN countries, amongst them Korean people are the most hard working people. But overall people from East Asia are very hardworking and for them their work is their pride. They will die for their work. India needs to learn from these countries. Don’t follow them but copy their good habits.
Japanese work to death. Even in India, companies exploit people and overwork them. It's not an attitude problem but a skill issue. We don't have a lot of skilled people in India. Everyone tries to make big bucks in an industry which they are not even interested in.
Please make a video on the book the beautiful tree by historian Dharampal ji it's about indigenous Indian education system and dalit and women education system and because of casteism people defame and leave Hinduism please 😢
About education sector analysis , however , you are spot right but now the things are changing. Present government has started 150 new medical colleges ( govt. Funded ) so that they will be sufficient doctors in future . And in west health sector is not easily affordable to poor.
That isn't a problem, it's a tradeoff. They "earn" through basic services like healthcare, food, water and "invest the profit" into R&D, HDI and operational excellence. For all the talk of cost, the US has the best hospitals, best Pharma cos, best doctors and best medico-industrial base.
I am not saying that it is the only path, the US needs a limited phase of cheap Medicare, with limited being the operative word.
A couple of medical colleges and IITs/IIMs do not solve the problem. We need to make grassroot level changes in our education system.
Loved the podcast as always. But for some reason Arihant seemed a bit too pessimistic in this one (and I can understand why…) Hopefully the last 10 years have laid the foundation for a boost that the country really needs…
Yes the host got emotionally involved. But the guest is a guy with a very limited world view and outdated info and economic models which are completely unsustainable in today and tomorrow's economy.
L&T also said that skilled manpower is in shortage in india
Everything can be done, It depends on the will and reduction of populationl
What is different now from 50 years ago is that the application of automation in factories is getting higher and higher, a large number of jobs that used to require a lot of people are replaced by robots or automated equipment, fewer people are needed, cheap labor has less impact on the cost of production, and the technical requirements for factory operators are much higher than before. It often takes several years of vocational and technical training to become competent, and the capital, technical threshold and commercial risk of investing in factories are much higher than before. Until now, China is still in short of skilled workers who can be skilled in CNC equipment. Fortunately for China, 50 years ago, a large number of rural labor can be easily trained to work in factories, and factories at that time need far more cheap labor than now, and the large population at that time just meet the needs of industrialization. Unfortunately, India does not have such good luck now.
Very important and knowledgeable podcast ❤😊
I think your analysis is completely wrong , India is 432 years ahead of Singapore/China/Japan/USA, we have smart cities not only on India but Modi ji built multiple smart cities on planet Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. also we have bullet trains running from India to Mars and Mercury, also Indians have 10000000 crore in their account so they are the richest in the world, India is also the cleanest country on planet earth that there is no garbage on the garbage collection center itself. India not only has make in India program but it also has make in mars and Pluto program where India built smart cities and smart colonies.India is so smart that USA,China and other 3rd world European countries learn from India on how to manage garbage collection center and how to run their own country.
There are many drawbacks in his analysis.
1. Germany is a huge manufacturing hub.
2. Which is the most productive locality in the US?
It is San Francisco bay area. That is definitely not a high-traffic area. One can't generalise such things. There are different ways of development geographically.
It is a one sided analysis . . at many points in depth analysis was required going upto the root cause of the problems and the solution would have been practical and workable then . . It is easier to compare with other countries but we should take into consideration a couple of points like low 'density' of population in other countries as compared to India . . It should also be taken into consideration that China opened up its economy (in seventies) way before India did in 1992 . . China got guarantee of heavy investments from the USA and EU in lieu . . and thus it flourished . . Whereas India didn't get any such guarantee beforehand before opening up of our economy before our economy being opened up in 1992. Moreover the infrastructure development was very slow due to lack of funds, finance and investments (during UPA regim it was only around $ 250 billion) and abundance of 'babudoms' . . Gradually things are moving for better now as is visible from the increasing forex reserves and good investments from foreign funding agencies coupled by solid government support planing and actions . . Just have patience and wait for some time . . We are moving in the right direction now overcoming all the hurdels that are throwing spanner in our wheels of development . . It will take some time to change the mindset of the people and bringing in workaholic mindset . . Just wait and watch . . India is arriving . . Jai Hind 🇮🇳
why India always talks the talk but does not walk the walk. Talk is cheap. Try get 10 Olympic gold medals first!
Sir maaza aagaya
Will do sometimes near future
Hi Arihant
India’s civilisational edge and future progress would be underpinned by her strives and achievements in scientific research, innovation, R & D and academia-industry convergence. Your interaction with Sanjay Dixit has very rightly brought this to fore, he was right in considering this an imperative. Human development, prosperity and wellbeing of any society would be critically dependant on its achievements in scientific research and innovation.
For the last few years, I am working towards inspiring young minds for future engagements in science through the multilingual platform, Scientific European, which I founded few years ago. I expose them to latest research & scientific and technological developments in their mother tounges for easy comprehension and appreciation. This eases language barriers faced by non-English and non-native English speakers. The translations, when read with original article in English, make comprehension and appreciation of the idea easy.
You are very good in your work, great service to the country. Congratulations!
This is good information, but the basic premise is that you are comparing yourself to a completely different economic and demographic model.
Singapore, Korea Japan have piddling populations and so export is the only choice for them to grow. Also their growth was fuelled by the massive influx of cheap dollars (cheap for the US) where they exported natural resources, labour and depended upon the economic engine of the US. That's exactly why, after growing to the point where Japan threatened to become the world no 1 economy, overtaking the US, all the US has to do was tweak a few levers and they've not recovered from the stagflation they went into in the 1980s.
Today China is realising the same thing. They've mined their resources, polluted their air, waters with heavy chemicals and metals and all this export for paper money - it takes the US 17 cents to print 100 dollars and then give it to China for 100 dollars worth of real goods.
I feel that our growth was and will be fuelled by our domestic markets first and then exports to reach attainable and sustainable levels of prosperity.
India is looking at mass transport using waterways, rail and creating tier 3,4 cities. We have enormous potential for growth by moving production to these cities.
Please look at our purchasing power parity. We are third in the world currently.
So i feel that this interview is helpful but we must drive our own growth story, not use a "playbook" cookie cutter plan.
Search for China tofu dreg constructions, ghost cities to show growth in GDP, drainage sewer cooking oil. systemic corruption is rampant, which makes our babus look like angels. GDP as the mantra is the reason for this.
We will leap frog interim technologies and adopt the latest tech at scale. You can see this in our upgradation of 95% trains to electric in a decade. UPI skipped all the interim tech moving directly to mobile based payments. Stock exchanges have had T+1 day trade settlement for last 20 years where the US still has T+3 to T+5 day trade settlement.
India is building roads at a world record pace.
All this while de dollarisation is decimating the economies of Japan, South Korea, China etc.
What I'm trying to say isn't that we blindly chant "India is great" but that we understand that the are multiple ways to achieve strength and growth.
China used highly questionable trade policies and propping up one company in a sector with other competitor companies providing resources, marketing, sales to one company till they became world leaders. Then that company helped the others grow larger. This is possible in a dictatorship, not in a democracy. But all this was propped up by printing currency, reverse engineering and copycatting foreign technology. Shortcuts which have led to a bad reputation in the world.
We can achieve similar growth without sharp tactics.
बाप के कंधे पर पैर रखकर, नाचनेवाले Aamul boy कि दिमाग में आजब सोच निकल आते है ।
उसमे दो product आप दोनो आते है ।