In my Parish you can receive the Eucharist in the hand, on the tongue, or at the rail if you wish. We do both Body (wafer) and Blood (wine) of Christ. One of our servers always receives it at the rail. I serve Masses with him and he is able to speak Latin. I have attended the Traditional Mass in Latin (1962 missal) which we have weekly at 2PM Sunday at St. Mary north of Ironton.
@@michaelblair5566 you’re so blessed you are able to attend a missal that’s not been corrupted. I only have NO available to us and I stopped going to mass because it’s invalid so there’s no point of going.
I am 51 years old. I became Catholic in 1987. I have only known the Norvus Ordo. In fact I've beem a Server in the Novus Ordo Mass from 1987-1991 and since 2022. It has improved drastically in my Parish over what it was when I was in school. I returned to Mass after two major strokes and an encounter with Jesus back in 2018. BTW, we have put the St. Michael Prayer back into EVERY ONE of our Masses in Ironton, OH. We even use some of the pre Vatican II responses (Kyrie Eleson, Christe Eleson), etc. When I was told to return to Mass, Jesus knew I'd be going to Mass in Ironton. I am named after St. Michael. He is the Saint I was named after. I didn't choose a Saints name at Confirmation, it is my birth name. Which is ironic because I am not a cradle Catholic, I am a RICA Catholic.
The Jewish Tribune newspaper, in 1927, in an editorial, stated: "Freemasonry is based on Judaism. Eliminate the teachings of Judaism from the Masonic ritual and what is left?"
I remember the change. Also remember walking into my Catholic school and seeing the nuns habits removed from their heads . All the students were shocked , and my heart sunk deep.
I just found your channel, so thankful to have been guided to it. I was Protestant and now a recent convert to the REAL church. It's been quite a learning curve! These videos are so important, the topics you choose pinpoint areas that need clarification. Thank you for making them.
Actually they are not getting stronger. They are falling apart little by little. And like Saint Athanasius said (They have the Buildings but we have the Faith of the Apostles) The average age of Novus Ordo attendees is 55 which is Unsustainable. The Novus Ordo will fade away in time.
You DO NOT want a council called by a Pope Francis. I pray for Francis every week, on the altar, as a server. Because that is what Jesus wants us to do. Will it change Francis? I don't think so. But I will persist.
I read Bella Dodds book 10 or more years ago. AA-1025 too. It all made sense. In the last 50-60 yrs it has all come to pass. There are small communities and good priests who are keeping the true faith. Pray, pray, pray! Practice devotions, make many Acts of Faith, Charity, Penance.
I love your view on this, most people I talk to seem to be completely against Vatican II to the point they see it as invalid and want it revoked, or completely for it but ignorant to the problems our Church is facing.
It's a shame we're on the cusp of losing the TLM. I grew up going to NO masses. I left the church for over a decade and started attending mass again. It's changed--and not for the better. They now do this beating on the chest, raising hands during the Our Father, extending arms for blessings like evangelicals. The canned responses feel so forced. The changes made everything feel "culty" and empty. I attended a TLM on Easter and it was so much better. There was a strong sense of authority and traditional. Everything commanded reverence. I would love to go every Sunday. But there's only one church that offers the TLM, and it's kinda hard to get to. I heard a growing proportion of younger people are embracing the TML. I think I understand this. We grew up in a world of the "latest and greatest" attitude. However, this leaves us kind of empty and desiring a traditional to tie ourselves to. The church has become too much like the modern world it seeks to be a refuge from.
@@orthocatsr.8723 TLM is the traditional Latin mass, which was how all masses were done before Vatican II. It was replaced by novus ordo (NO). There's usually a few churches in each region or major city that offer the TLM. Definitely check it out if you have the opportunity.
The people who defend V2 by saying “ read the documents, they’re beautiful”drives me crazy. Bishop Barron so invested in “ the council” has lost credibility.
I judge V2 by its fruits. Among my friends and relatives, all but one or two dropped away since 1970 and became, at best, C&E Catholics-In-Name-Only. Many of my relatives have already died outside the sacraments, which is the true disaster. How can they be saved, except by appealing to the Divine Mercy at the moment of their immediate judgment? Among boomers, I am sure there are millions upon millions of souls already lost, and many more among their children who are speeding towards their own damnation. All of this is directly the fault of the changes that resulted from V2.
recently a mass at a parish with no tabernacle to be found. perhaps somewhere off to the side, but not in plain view. the priest though was very happy about his 'evangelical' style worship and feel in the church. there you go.
I argued with a guy last week because he said Freemasons were the Templars and i told him you cant be Freemason and Catholic. He said his father and grandfather was.
Have you heard of La santa muerte? If you have, then you know they claim to be Catholic aswell. I'm protestant, but I know "folk catholics" aren't catholics. Freemason isn't Catholic
All Orthodox receive Holy Communion standing - except for the babies in their mothers/fathers arms.[ and the sick, of course] Christ has been with us all since the Last Supper. May He have mercy on us and our brothers in Him. +
Weak catechesis, changing cultural norms, world events, division and distraction, church of "me", and relativism are among the problems. Matthew 16 assures us the "gates of hell shall not prevail against (the Church)". If as you say, there are individuals in high places who are undermining the Church, don't you think Jesus would return and ensure that they not prevail?
Dee Original correct. Very weak teachings and even bisshops priests and religious teachers dont know the true faith. Even professors at the vatican two universities theology are in one way or the other heretics.
So, where do i go to receive the sacraments, then? Are NO priests/bishops doubtful? Is the local diocesan TLM valid? Should I go to the sedevacantists? Should i simply convert to Orthodoxy? Idk who to trust anymore.
Sacraments are valid in both NO and TLM masses. Sacraments do not depend on the holiness of the priest. If you go the route of sedevacantist or Orthodox you are denying Jesus Christ established Peter and his successors as head of his Church.
NO and TLM are still valid. He simply just explained the problems in the Church today as a result fo vatican ii, but that doesn't mean that the sacraments aren't still valid
The Vatican 2 documents explained : Without understanding the following you will never be able to understand the documents. I will list here, what the documents consist of, by name and by title. But you will never find the list of these names inside the documents this is deliberate. For the purpose of concealment. But what you will find in every paragraph of every page the “definition” of the terms listed. Therefore the Vatican two documents consist of “definition” only: Without understanding the following you will never be able to understand the documents. I will list here, what the documents consist of, by name and by title. But you will never find the list of these names inside the documents this is deliberate. For the purpose of concealment. But what you will find in every paragraph of every page the “definition” of the terms listed. Therefore the Vatican two documents consist of “definition” only: 1) Indifferentism 2) Syncretism and Synthesis 3) Immanent 4) Transcendentalism 5) Individualism 6) Existentialism, naturalism 7) Stoicism 8) Pantheism 9) Evolution 10) The Sciences such as historian sociology psychology critic… If you look up Saint Pope Pius 10 Encyclical “ Pascendi Dominici Gregis” you will find he new about Vatican 2 and wrote a detailed comprehensive explanation of Vatican 2, listing in detail more than half of the items above listed, and he even explains, in example, how it is meant to diminish Jesus Christ and the one true church and desecrate all seven sacraments and to leave the door open for more of modernism and Progressive changes in the future. He is not alone !!! Pius 10 on the Errors of Modernism, Pius 9 his Syllabus of Errors and Pope Gregory 16 in his Encyclical “Mirari Vos” see #19 on the waldensians,the Beghards,the Wycliffites, and all the popes condemned the documents of Vatican 2 and the Synod of Pistoia and warned the faithful with excommunication, anathema if you don't reject the Vatican two documents, and church, and embrace the one true traditional Catholic Church, the depository of faith, before the end of your life. As you examine these terms and then read the Vatican two documents you can clearly see the “definition” of all the above listed terms, but not the terms themselves, and the evil,and that it is no longer Catholic but a new religion that will lead you straight to hell !!! The Vatican II documents : briefly 1) Christ is united with each man in the Incarnation before Jesus was even born (Gaudium et Spes #22) 2) Protestant religions are a means of salvation and all other denominations. (Unitatis Redintegratio #3) 3) non-catholics made lawfully receive Holy Communion and the sacraments of the church.(Orientalium Ecclesiarum #27) 4) Muslims and Catholics together worship the same God (Lumen Gentium #16) 5) the Catholic church is united with those who don't accept the Catholic faith or the papacy. Lumen Gentium #15) 6) some people above the Age of Reason don't believe in God through no fault of their own. Lumen Gentium #16) 7) and the Buddhism man search the highest illumination. (Nostra Aetate #2) 8) all things on earth should be related to man as their Center and Crown. (Gaudium et Spes #12). Then what are we to do you ask ? If you are a true Traditional Catholic then you are supposed to do what the Blessed Virgin Mary told us to do, in these evil times, that she described at Fatima, in the “Third Secret”. Not the fake phony Third Secret that John Paul II falsified and Rewritten, along with the fake Lucia !!! But the real true Third Secret of Fatima. You are also to do what the Blessed Virgin Mary told us to do at La Salette, France and again at Our Lady of Good Success, who described in great detail what is to happen to the Catholic church at the end of the 20th century and she was 100% right !!! What do we do then ? what did she say to do ? She said, to say the Traditional Rosary, not the rosary of John Paul II, the Traditional Rosary !! 15 decades, everyday or 5 decades on Monday, 5 decades on Tuesday, and 5 decades, on Wednesday. Since the Mass is the greatest prayer of all !!! you get the Saint Andrews missile (and no other missile) but the St Andrews missile, and you say Mass every Sunday (you're not able to consecrate) but you can still say the prayers of the Mass !!! From only the Saint Andrew's missile!! You can say the rosary, the Seven Sorrows of Mary, the Stations of the Cross, all at home. Have nothing to do with today's fake Catholic Church!!! NOTHING !!! This means all Vatican 2 priests and parishioners also the sspx, sspv, cmri, fssps… It will be a mortal sin and send you straight to hell if you go to any of these groups who support and embrace “Invincible ignorance” and also “baptism of desire and blood” that the Traditional Catholic church teaches against !!! Subjective v.s Objective heresy !!! OR, You can be in the soul of the church and not be a member heresy, these groups, the sspx and others Embrace these heresies !!! along with using the St Joseph's missile (THIS IS A Condemned Missile) if anyone, even the Pope, tells you that it's not a condemned missile they are - A - Liar !! don't believe them, they're a liar and a Heretic !!! Heretics will send you to Hell !!! You say your prayers at home, you stay at home, and you say your prayers at home, the Traditional prayers of the church and you say them every day. You read the Bible the Catholic Bible and no other since all other Bibles have been Rewritten with attacks againt Mary !!! and study the lives of the Saints of the church, and stay away from newly written or revised books on the market today !!! Don't buy any books on the market after 1960 !!!! What about confession and all that ? You confess your sins to God the Father, Son and Holy Ghost using the prayers in the St Andrews missile, in the confessional which is in the back of the book, or you say one of the seven penitential Psalms along with the act of contrition. That's your confession, at home where you are safe both in body and soul !! For baptism you do the same at home with the proper, Matter, Form and Intent !!! But whatever you do have nothing to do with the Vatican 2 Church sspx, sspv, fssp…. even if it's empty do not go in it !!! Judgment day is almost here. P.S.- the Most Holy Family Monastery is a good resource me and my colleagues have kept a close eye on them for over 20 years I highly recommend them. Also the web site - God's Catholic Dogma. They are the only 2 sources of Catholic Teachings on earth. And Vatican 2 doc. Are binding if anyone tells you there not their lying God Love You
so do i or don't i join the Church? i have grown up IFB but by our Lord's Grace and goodness was led out of that falsehood. i want so, so badly to join the Church: The True Church. but, having watched some of these videos about vatican 2, i'm concerned the true church isn't here anymore. can i still join the true Church? i have spent my life to this point in error and apostasy. i have hope the Lord will forgive me but i'm terrified of the idea of offending Him further. please forgive my ignorance. i appreciate any answers. please pray for me. thank you.
The answer is yes, you join the church. With all its problems its still Gods church. I would suggest the latin mass preferably sspx. But if all you have is novus ordo your still in the church by joining. Join the church and God will fix it eventually. But woe to you if you have knowledge and dont join. Council of Florence The holy Roman church] firmly believes, professes, and preaches that all those who are outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans but also Jews or heretics and schismatics, cannot share in eternal life and will go into the everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless they are joined to the Catholic Church before the end of their lives; that the unity of the ecclesiastical body is of such importance that only for those who abide in it do the Church’s sacraments contribute to salvation and do fasts, almsgiving and other works of piety and practices of the Christian militia produce eternal rewards; and that nobody can be saved, no matter how much he has given away in alms and even if he has shed his blood in the name of Christ, unless he has persevered in the bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church (Session 11 - Feb. 4, 1442) .2nd vatican council Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it” And woe to me if my videos caused you not to join. Even though I am telling the truth.
@@imisschristendom5293 thank you. this answer eases me. it's my belief that God has truly been directing me, as i've perceived the latin tradition is most appropriate. there is also one nearby (within an hour). again, thank you.
I became a fan of your channel because you produce your videos well and have a unique insight on things. Mentioning the relation between the state of the church vs the world, and popular Catholic movies of the 1950s are good examples of that. But then later one, this video switches to you just repeating a lot of common narratives in the trad community without really digging into the data. For example - at one point you say that the vocations crisis was the result of the Mass released in 1970. However, if you look at the numbers, vocations were already dropping throughout the 1960s. There was a lot going on in 1960s, such as a sexual revolution (in part) triggered by the normalization of birth control in the 1950s...wouldn't that have a massive effect on celibate vocations with or without Vatican 2? Another thing I noticed is the narrative that the Council was non-infallible. This is innacurate. Yes, Paul VI gave a talk once where he said something like that - but it doesn't matter because within the Council itself he promulgated the documents officially and infallibly. Official promulgations are what matter in regards to infallibility, not what The Pope says in a talk to some group or on an airplane or whatever. I guess what I'm saying is to be careful. One of the reasons The Church is in crisis is because of confusion. Please be careful not to add to that confusion and keep up the good work on your channel.
I agree with you on most of these points. However, I would argue that Vatican II made things go from bad to worse. Concerning the infallibility of the council, I agree that as a council it is infallible, but I believe that the church stated that since the council was pastoral, and not convened to resolve a dogmatic matter, that its edicts were non-binding. Now, concerning confusion, you can't blame faithful catholic communities i.e. "trad cads" for the confusion in the church, most of the confusion has come from the hierarchy, none more so than from Pope Francis himself.
there were bad trends in the church before vatican 2 no doubt, but what came out of vatican 2 didn't help any of it. it compounded the problems to the point where now there are church closures throughout the Western world. how is that possible with a council that was supposed to be so great and infuse Holy Spirit into the life of the church?
Well, my first response would be: where is your proof that Vatican 2 made things worse? You point to trends but trends tell a different story. The trends for church attendance fell throughout the 50s, 60s, 70s, 80s but so did attendance of bowling leagues, supper clubs and ALL types of community groups. This reveals the issue was social change outside The Church, and actually, although the pews were emptying, this is evidence that those people were primarily there for SOCIAL reasons, i.e. they liked going to mass to see people, not because they had faith. Thus the "loss" of these numbers is not actually a loss in number of believers. But also, the trends for all these things fell at different rates. Attendence of ALL churches fell during this time, including Protestant services. That obviously had nothing to do with Vatican 2. But what you see in the trends is that some fell more quickly and some fell more slowly. Following Vatican 2, attendence for Catholic mass fell more slowly than attendence at Protestant services. This could be seen as the protection of The Holy Spirit. But at the same time, the promise of Christ has never been that The Church is constantly growing in numbers. There have been times in the history of The Church that numbers have fallen. Have a blessed Easter!
@@nealkriesterer Happy Easter. After Vatican 2 millions of faithful left. some due to societal changes, some due to abrupt changes that followed the council - Mass changing from Latin to Novus Ordo, overnight with all the craziness that came with it. it was too much to bear for some. results - the church has lost its influence over culture resulting in loss of vocations, married life, priesthood, etc. all the trends are down across all metrics. so if the council was supposed to somehow make the church better, it didn't.
@@TheCoachsCoach933 No you didn’t study the docs can’t help you some people are sheeple. Watch Fr. Joseph Noonan please the heresy of Modernism is wicked.
I really want to become a Catholic but the biggest reason I haven’t is because of Vatican 2 I don’t see how Muslims worship the same God as Christians I also don’t think a pope should ever kiss a Quran to me that’s a bad look
WELL, from ALLthe Cathoic Church, OK; but from the 'Roman'Catholic Church, not ,by it's count, since 1054 when it seceded from The Church through the singular action of the Patriarch of the West - who called himself Pope - and First in authourity, not just honour.[He was not] And grace from The Holy Spirit, through His Anointing of His Apostolic Bishops - as recognized by Rome!!!
How can you possibly interpret Matthew 15 as meaning only through the catholic church does grace come into the world? It was meant to show that Jesus came first to reconcile the Father with His people, (the Jews) and then to the Gentiles. It also showed Jesus's compassion for people who, in that day, somebody of His standing would have normally not bothered to even speak to. Romans 1:16: I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew, then to the Gentile. Luke 24:47: Repentance for the forgiveness of sins will be preached in his name to all nations, beginning at Jerusalem. Look at the parable of the grand banquet in Luke 14, it screams that God's intention was to originally reconcile His people to Himself first, but because of their disobedience, the Gentile was then invited, only after the Jew. The catholic church is not the table of grace as you think it is. Jesus coming into the world was, in part, to fulfil God's promise to Israel, but gentiles were permitted to become children of God as well. At that point in Jesus's ministry, he was mostly focused on the people of Israel. Using that to justify the catholic church hoarding the grace of God is hubris in it's worst form. Grace comes into the world through the Holy Spirit, period.
I’m a big fan of yours, and I know this is an older video being a year old. We don’t have to agree on everything, and I enjoy almost everything you publish. But, I think you are wrong on Vatican II. I believe it was a work of the Holy Spirit and great things came out of it. Unfortunately, it coincided with the unleashing of some great evils in society. So I feel Vatican II gets unfairly blamed for things beyond the Church’s control. Additionally, there are a lot of calumnies surrounding the Bishops involved, accusing them of unfounded freemasonry and other things. In my opinion, the entire conference could be Freemasons, but because of the charism the Pope has the result would still be good despite all the devils efforts. Before Vatican II a lot of Mass abuses also occurred, and it sought to eliminate them. Unfortunately new abuses have popped up, but having traveled around the US and having attended foreign Masses, I can say I have never seen a bad Mass. Some are better than others, but I haven’t never come across anything resembling a “clown Mass.”
Maybe you can do a video on all of the fake annulments since Vatican II. Everyone gets one now. I know of many in my own family. I don’t have one so I get to be alone since 1999. I know someone that was annulled from two marriages and is married for a third time. This makes me so mad I can chew through a nail! No one is really serious when it comes to this. There’s an excuse for everybody because no one really wants to follow the teaching on remarriage. After all of these years I should just apply for my fake annulment too. God can”t hold me responsible then since the modernist church says it’s ok Phonies! Our Lord isn’t going to let this abuse slide.
I feel you are headed the right direction but your theories aren't connecting.... Maybe you should contact the Dimonds of most holy family monastery to get a better view of the end times
Does the byzantine catholics have the original Vatican 01 rite in Greek? If not I'm probably going orthodox from cradle protestant Edit* I meant Orthodox
@@imisschristendom5293 Yes, that is correct. There is a byzantine catholic church near me, and it's the same as EO. The only difference is that they are in communion with the holy see.
@David Phillips haha one prot sect to another 🤣 What I'm more scared of the Orthodox seem very national and rigid and I would miss the Rosary and Memorale... My issue is I don't know what God rather me be. There's so many signs for both and God bless ✝️
@@orthocatsr.8723 Do not judge the workers in the Catholic (universal) church as the faith itself. You know what Jesus taught and He also said in Matthew 16 that the "gates of hell shall not prevail against it." We go to mass to hear God's Word, see Our Lord's sacrifice re-presented and to receive His Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. It is our act of worship. No council, no pope, no opinion will change my mind that the Catholic church IS the church that Jesus founded. Peter being the first authority (pope) and an unbroken change of ordained priests since have served as popes, all of them sinners just like you and me. Pray for conversion of sinners!
@@donnarichert5627 amen. I have maybe 99 percent the same belief ... I would ask You for a certain prayer about a particular conversion too! - I'm actually very interested in some very catholic things like that much more than anyone can comprehend albeit I look like hell. God bless and thank U
@@dan_m7774 Angelicans embraced trans lgbt and their churches are dying for it. And Orthodox are our brothers which we can receieve communions with them Also it doesnt matter the TLM is Growing
Your teaching about the passage on scripture that involves the woman who was a gentile Is absolutely wrong. The passage is about Jesus showing that his kingdom is for everyone who believes in him and the gospel. He knew her faith was grate!
The document of the Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae, word-for-word contradicts the infallible condemnation of religious liberty found in Pope Pius IX's encyclical, Quanta Cura. In Nostra Aetate, false religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism were praised. Lumen Gentium attempted to change the constitution of the Church (which is immutable) and also teaches a newly invented heretical ecclesiology whereby other 'Christian communities' can be considered part of the 'Church of Christ' or 'People of God'. This flatly contradicts Pius XII's Mystici Corporis and all traditional teaching on the matter. The plain meaning of the words of these documents is vindicated due to the interpretation of them given by the putative Popes and also by their practice. For example, in the document, Dominus Jesus, Cardinal Ratzinger, the future Benedict XVI, confirmed the new heretical ecclesiology of Lumen Gentium. There is no way out by appealing to interpreting the documents in light of tradition for the putative Popes sabotage the endeavour through their words and actions. There is no getting around it: the council taught heresy. It was a robber council ratified by a false Pope who founded a conciliar sect which masquerades as the Catholic Church.
The night before He died, Jesus prayed that we would all be one as He and the Father are one. Some unity! I've lost count of all of the different denominations. I have decided to believe that worshiping in the Church founded by Jesus and his apostles is right for me. You can call us names all day long but I will not leave the Eucharist. For those who don't know, catholic means universal.
@@donnarichert5627 I don't believe I called anyone names. Perhaps you could point out how I did that? I would certainly never tell anyone to leave the Most Holy Catholic Church founded by Our Lord, Jesus Christ, so you must have misunderstood me there. Nor am I advocating the establishment of yet another denomination. The problem is that the post-Conciliar Popes do not believe in the Catholic religion, which is easily confirmed through the comparison of their teaching and traditional Catholic teaching, which cannot change.
@@donnarichert5627 I gave several examples in my first comment. Did you read it properly? Nevertheless, Francis has taught that the death penalty is intrinsically evil, that God wills the diversity of religions, and that Luther was right about justification. All of those are heretical statements.
@@augustinepinnock7740 Sorry, I don't see every comment. The death penalty is and always has been intrinsically evil. Only God has the power of life and death. God wills the free will of man. If man has to get to God through a different path, who is Pope Francis to judge that path? Judgment is God's and His alone. If the Pope said Luther was right about justification and it wasn't a media soundbite or a misquote, it is not necessary for a person to belong to Christ's church to be saved. God will judge us on our own path, even if one has never known of God. Sincerely Mr. Pinnock, you might consider reading portions of The Catechism of the Catholic Church or the writings of the early Church Fathers. Thankful you're engaged, truly. Prayers and peace, brother.
I wish I could accept your via media. I am currently converting to the Catholic Church. Part of this process is reading from the ancients up to V2 as well as a very careful reading of the V2 documents and post Conciliar encyclicals etc. If we accept the V2 documents as validly promulgated by a valid Pope, then we must accept the changes that have come as the positive will of Christ in the Church. This means that Christ contradicts himself however, as there are statements in the Council documents that would have earned chastisement from any pre council Pope and excommunication if the error was persisted in.
Vatican 2 is valid and the Pope was valid. Some interpretations of V2 were not promulgated by the council. They claim they did so in the "spirit" of V2.
Pope Paul VI stated at the close of the Council, "This council defined nothing". It was a pastoral council. The first of its kind. However, there are heresies within the documents, and they were written in an ambiguous way in order to allow differing interpretations going forward.
@@soldier8304 every pope after the Council has shown their interpretation of the documents through radical ecumenical actions, and statements. Yours is not a realistic interpretation, and if those were/are valid popes, their interpretation is the rule of faith.
I agree what you said except when you said that the vatican ii council is valid & you seem to belive that Montini is valid Pope. He is definetely invalid & anti-pope because he killed the sacraments.
It was one of the prayers to the Sacred Heart. I used to see it all the time on the non mainstream Catholic websites. But since they Purged the internet a few years ago I can't find it anymore
@@imisschristendom5293 Dang I tried finding it to but to no avail. Hopefully the church comes back in greater glory in our life times (likely not but after our lifetimes it is guranteed).
@@imisschristendom5293 Hopefully it can be found, Europe needs protection from the Saracens more than ever. The recent waves of migration have been more successful bringing Europe under the yoke Islam than all the Jihads of the last 1500 years combined.
Who are you to judge? Jesus did not say that the vatican 2 ruined everything. Becareful jesus say in luke 6:45 - "the good man out of the good treasure of his heart produces good, and evil man out of his evil treasure produces evil; for out of the abundance of the heart his mouth speaks". Luke 6:37 - jesus say "judge not and you will not be judged; and condemn not and you will not be condemnef; forgivr and you will be forgiven".
Hear me good--I am old enough to remember Latin Masses, communion rails and Communion on the tongue only. I do NOT to ever, ever, EVER go back to medieval-style Masses. Traditionalists who are too young (that is, the vast majority of them) to have been alive during the "Golden Age of Catholicism" do not know what they are asking. The TLM is a "fad Mass" and a curiosity. I do not want to be stuck with a medieval Mass in a dead language once the TLM fad Mass is reinstated as THE Mass.
That's pride talking and remember pride is what made lucifer fall. You can't obtain salvation without Christ's church and the Sacramental of Confession.
Liz, I pray for you and all who have left the Catholic church. Have you considered just going to RCIA classes and listening in? No decisions, just inquiry.
I too, sadly, stopped going to mass .. it was before Covid started. The words just felt .. wrong to me. And when the Churches started to shut down because of State's Mandates.. I knew it was wrong too. How did the state become more powerful than the church of God?? What's going on?
Ruined everything? Dramatic. Be grateful for the Holy Eucharist. Would you prefer a world of Saints in novus ordo or a world of the wicked in tlm? I suggest we go to work and have faith
A lot of this is nostalgia for a world and church past, like the maga, only it’s MOCGA, make our church great again, with devotionalism, Latin, retribution,…….
The proof is in the pudding. Go to any traditionalist catholic parish and you will see a church full of families, with lots of children, with veiled women and girls silently praying. The girls and women will be dressed modestly not showing any cleavage or skin above their knees or mid arms, nor will their clothes be provocative in any way. The Fathers and sons will be impeccably dressed wearing suits and ties. Now contrast that to the Novus Ordo parishes, they will be mostly filled with adults or elderly, there will be hardly any children. The younger women will be immodestly dressed, and half the men will be dressed like they're headed to the beach afterward. The church will be noisy before mass because everyone is chatting it up with their neighbor instead of praying.
When you attend a NO you are, in essence, attending a Protestant service. If you don't believe me, start attending Anglican services for awhile and, then, compare it with the current NO Catholic Mass. The words are the same. I grew up Catholic in the '80's - NO, but I didn't know any different and the Mass had a lot of the traditional elements intact. Then, I left the Church and attended Protestant services for most of my adult life. I converted back to Catholicism a few years ago. So much of what I'm experiencing in Catholic Mass now if just like the Protestant churches I went to. I feel empty inside. I feel I'm being called to attend TLM going forward.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
I dunno why some priest find it offensive if you receive The Lord kneeling. This is absolutely disappointing
In my Parish you can receive the Eucharist in the hand, on the tongue, or at the rail if you wish. We do both Body (wafer) and Blood (wine) of Christ. One of our servers always receives it at the rail. I serve Masses with him and he is able to speak Latin. I have attended the Traditional Mass in Latin (1962 missal) which we have weekly at 2PM Sunday at St. Mary north of Ironton.
@@michaelblair5566 you’re so blessed you are able to attend a missal that’s not been corrupted. I only have NO available to us and I stopped going to mass because it’s invalid so there’s no point of going.
@@Maya-yp2ey Try your nearest Orthodox Church
becuse they have been TOLD to.
I am 51 years old. I became Catholic in 1987. I have only known the Norvus Ordo. In fact I've beem a Server in the Novus Ordo Mass from 1987-1991 and since 2022. It has improved drastically in my Parish over what it was when I was in school. I returned to Mass after two major strokes and an encounter with Jesus back in 2018.
BTW, we have put the St. Michael Prayer back into EVERY ONE of our Masses in Ironton, OH. We even use some of the pre Vatican II responses (Kyrie Eleson, Christe Eleson), etc. When I was told to return to Mass, Jesus knew I'd be going to Mass in Ironton.
I am named after St. Michael. He is the Saint I was named after. I didn't choose a Saints name at Confirmation, it is my birth name. Which is ironic because I am not a cradle Catholic, I am a RICA Catholic.
i feel like there was a lot of weaponised ambiguity in vatican 2
Thats how you know the devil was involved
"weaponised ambiguity" A very good description!
The Jewish Tribune newspaper, in 1927, in an editorial, stated: "Freemasonry is based on Judaism. Eliminate the teachings of Judaism from the Masonic ritual and what is left?"
I remember the change. Also remember walking into my Catholic school and seeing the nuns habits removed from their heads . All the students were shocked , and my heart sunk deep.
This is exactly what the reformers said about the council of Trent.
I just found your channel, so thankful to have been guided to it. I was Protestant and now a recent convert to the REAL church. It's been quite a learning curve! These videos are so important, the topics you choose pinpoint areas that need clarification. Thank you for making them.
Your welcome
If you want the REAL Church, look to the Orthodox
The Real Church? You're Orthodox? welcome!
I think that the analysis here is SPOT ON. Unfortunately, they are getting stronger and stronger. But Our Lord will only let it go so far.
Actually they are not getting stronger. They are falling apart little by little. And like Saint Athanasius said (They have the Buildings but we have the Faith of the Apostles)
The average age of Novus Ordo attendees is 55 which is Unsustainable. The Novus Ordo will fade away in time.
If Vatican 2 ruined Everything,I if I was Pope would call Vatican 3.I would
make sure that Everything is put Right.❤️🙏🏻❤️.
You DO NOT want a council called by a Pope Francis. I pray for Francis every week, on the altar, as a server. Because that is what Jesus wants us to do. Will it change Francis? I don't think so. But I will persist.
Hehehehehe how ironic... The pope through his synod on synodality wants to make it even worse than Vatican 2
Come back home to 1054AD; before the Schism
Ambiguity = the wickedness and snares of the devil. Therfore we must make corrections and remove the ambiguity, it is not of God.
I read Bella Dodds book 10 or more years ago. AA-1025 too. It all made sense. In the last 50-60 yrs it has all come to pass. There are small communities and good priests who are keeping the true faith. Pray, pray, pray! Practice devotions, make many Acts of Faith, Charity, Penance.
I love your view on this, most people I talk to seem to be completely against Vatican II to the point they see it as invalid and want it revoked, or completely for it but ignorant to the problems our Church is facing.
Great video as always. I especially like the accounts of St. Maximillian Kolbe and the former American communist
I love your presentations, you sum up everything so precisely and in an adequate timeframe!!
It's a shame we're on the cusp of losing the TLM.
I grew up going to NO masses. I left the church for over a decade and started attending mass again. It's changed--and not for the better.
They now do this beating on the chest, raising hands during the Our Father, extending arms for blessings like evangelicals. The canned responses feel so forced. The changes made everything feel "culty" and empty.
I attended a TLM on Easter and it was so much better. There was a strong sense of authority and traditional. Everything commanded reverence. I would love to go every Sunday. But there's only one church that offers the TLM, and it's kinda hard to get to.
I heard a growing proportion of younger people are embracing the TML. I think I understand this. We grew up in a world of the "latest and greatest" attitude. However, this leaves us kind of empty and desiring a traditional to tie ourselves to. The church has become too much like the modern world it seeks to be a refuge from.
What is TML brother? Thanks
@@orthocatsr.8723 TLM is the traditional Latin mass, which was how all masses were done before Vatican II. It was replaced by novus ordo (NO). There's usually a few churches in each region or major city that offer the TLM. Definitely check it out if you have the opportunity.
@@Patrick_919- thought so Bro, does the byzantine catholics do the traditional Latin mass but in Greek?
@@orthocatsr.8723 I'm not sure to be honest. It's possible that they do.
@@Patrick_919 - God bless Your whole house bro ✝️
I never gave it much thought, but now I realize that you are 100 % right. Looking at the consequences, its fruits, it cannot be denied.
Here is where the next Lutherans are forming.
Our Lady of Sorrows, pray for us.
Just now came across your channel........looks really good so far !!!.......thanks for your effort and knowledge !!
Thank you
@@imisschristendom5293The Church is only declining in the West. It's growing everywhere else. Viva Christo Rey. My western brother.
The people who defend V2 by saying “ read the documents, they’re beautiful”drives me crazy. Bishop Barron so invested in “ the council” has lost credibility.
Has he read the Creed?
i have to give credit to Dr Taylor Marshall for introducing me to the TLM which eventually brought me back to my Catholic faith🙏🏻🇻🇦✝️
I judge V2 by its fruits. Among my friends and relatives, all but one or two dropped away since 1970 and became, at best, C&E Catholics-In-Name-Only. Many of my relatives have already died outside the sacraments, which is the true disaster. How can they be saved, except by appealing to the Divine Mercy at the moment of their immediate judgment?
Among boomers, I am sure there are millions upon millions of souls already lost, and many more among their children who are speeding towards their own damnation. All of this is directly the fault of the changes that resulted from V2.
Pray, got to mass, receive the sacrament, and up hold the Law.
A deacon at Mass last Sunday swore during the homily, I was appalled, but should I be? Was it ok for him to do that?
Probably not good for him to sware
Yeah, probably not good. Vulgarity has no place in the mass.
NO!
recently a mass at a parish with no tabernacle to be found. perhaps somewhere off to the side, but not in plain view. the priest though was very happy about his 'evangelical' style worship and feel in the church. there you go.
No
I argued with a guy last week because he said Freemasons were the Templars and i told him you cant be Freemason and Catholic. He said his father and grandfather was.
Have you heard of La santa muerte? If you have, then you know they claim to be Catholic aswell. I'm protestant, but I know "folk catholics" aren't catholics. Freemason isn't Catholic
All Orthodox receive Holy Communion standing - except for the babies in their mothers/fathers arms.[ and the sick, of course] Christ has been with us all since the Last Supper. May He have mercy on us and our brothers in Him. +
Weak catechesis, changing cultural norms, world events, division and distraction, church of "me", and relativism are among the problems. Matthew 16 assures us the "gates of hell shall not prevail against (the Church)". If as you say, there are individuals in high places who are undermining the Church, don't you think Jesus would return and ensure that they not prevail?
Dee Original correct. Very weak teachings and even bisshops priests and religious teachers dont know the true faith. Even professors at the vatican two universities theology are in one way or the other heretics.
Excellent video thank you
So, where do i go to receive the sacraments, then? Are NO priests/bishops doubtful? Is the local diocesan TLM valid? Should I go to the sedevacantists? Should i simply convert to Orthodoxy? Idk who to trust anymore.
Sacraments are valid in both NO and TLM masses. Sacraments do not depend on the holiness of the priest. If you go the route of sedevacantist or Orthodox you are denying Jesus Christ established Peter and his successors as head of his Church.
NO and TLM are still valid. He simply just explained the problems in the Church today as a result fo vatican ii, but that doesn't mean that the sacraments aren't still valid
@@joziahchama2735The Church is only declining in the West. It's growing everywhere else. Peace. Viva Christo Rey.
A masterful summary!
Very astute observations, thank you.
Paul VI cried? Why didn't he just reverse Vat 2?
because the freemasons and the CIA have infected the church since the 1950s. Basically he had his hands twisted
The Vatican 2 documents explained :
Without understanding the following you will never be able to understand the documents. I will list here, what the documents consist of, by name and by title. But you will never find the list of these names inside the documents this is deliberate. For the purpose of concealment. But what you will find in every paragraph of every page the “definition” of the terms listed. Therefore the Vatican two documents consist of “definition” only:
Without understanding the following you will never be able to understand the documents. I will list here, what the documents consist of, by name and by title. But you will never find the list of these names inside the documents this is deliberate. For the purpose of concealment. But what you will find in every paragraph of every page the “definition” of the terms listed. Therefore the Vatican two documents consist of “definition” only:
1) Indifferentism
2) Syncretism and Synthesis
3) Immanent
4) Transcendentalism
5) Individualism
6) Existentialism, naturalism
7) Stoicism
8) Pantheism
9) Evolution
10) The Sciences such as historian sociology psychology critic…
If you look up Saint Pope Pius 10 Encyclical
“ Pascendi Dominici Gregis” you will find he new about Vatican 2 and wrote a detailed comprehensive explanation of Vatican 2, listing in detail more than half of the items above listed, and he even explains, in example, how it is meant to diminish Jesus Christ and the one true church and desecrate all seven sacraments and to leave the door open for more of modernism and Progressive changes in the future. He is not alone !!! Pius 10 on the Errors of Modernism, Pius 9 his Syllabus of Errors and Pope Gregory 16 in his Encyclical “Mirari Vos” see #19 on the waldensians,the Beghards,the Wycliffites, and all the popes condemned the documents of Vatican 2 and the Synod of Pistoia and warned the faithful with excommunication, anathema if you don't reject the Vatican two documents, and church, and embrace the one true traditional Catholic Church, the depository of faith, before the end of your life.
As you examine these terms and then read the Vatican two documents you can clearly see the “definition” of all the above listed terms, but not the terms themselves, and the evil,and that it is no longer Catholic but a new religion that will lead you straight to hell !!!
The Vatican II documents : briefly
1) Christ is united with each man in the Incarnation before Jesus was even born (Gaudium et Spes #22)
2) Protestant religions are a means of salvation and all other denominations. (Unitatis Redintegratio #3)
3) non-catholics made lawfully receive Holy Communion and the sacraments of the church.(Orientalium Ecclesiarum #27)
4) Muslims and Catholics together worship the same God (Lumen Gentium #16)
5) the Catholic church is united with those who don't accept the Catholic faith or the papacy. Lumen Gentium #15)
6) some people above the Age of Reason don't believe in God through no fault of their own. Lumen Gentium #16)
7) and the Buddhism man search the highest illumination. (Nostra Aetate #2)
8) all things on earth should be related to man as their Center and Crown. (Gaudium et Spes #12).
Then what are we to do you ask ?
If you are a true Traditional Catholic then you are supposed to do what the Blessed Virgin Mary told us to do, in these evil times, that she described at Fatima, in the “Third Secret”. Not the fake phony Third Secret that John Paul II falsified and Rewritten, along with the fake Lucia !!! But the real true Third Secret of Fatima. You are also to do what the Blessed Virgin Mary told us to do at La Salette, France and again at Our Lady of Good Success, who described in great detail what is to happen to the Catholic church at the end of the 20th century and she was 100% right !!!
What do we do then ? what did she say to do ? She said, to say the Traditional Rosary, not the rosary of John Paul II, the Traditional Rosary !! 15 decades, everyday or 5 decades on Monday, 5 decades on Tuesday, and 5 decades, on Wednesday. Since the Mass is the greatest prayer of all !!! you get the Saint Andrews missile (and no other missile) but the St Andrews missile, and you say Mass every Sunday (you're not able to consecrate) but you can still say the prayers of the Mass !!! From only the Saint Andrew's missile!! You can say the rosary, the Seven Sorrows of Mary, the Stations of the Cross, all at home. Have nothing to do with today's fake Catholic Church!!! NOTHING !!! This means all Vatican 2 priests and parishioners also the sspx, sspv, cmri, fssps… It will be a mortal sin and send you straight to hell if you go to any of these groups who support and embrace “Invincible ignorance” and also “baptism of desire and blood” that the Traditional Catholic church teaches against !!! Subjective v.s Objective heresy !!! OR, You can be in the soul of the church and not be a member heresy, these groups, the sspx and others Embrace these heresies !!! along with using the St Joseph's missile (THIS IS A Condemned Missile) if anyone, even the Pope, tells you that it's not a condemned missile they are - A - Liar !! don't believe them, they're a liar and a Heretic !!! Heretics will send you to Hell !!!
You say your prayers at home, you stay at home, and you say your prayers at home, the Traditional prayers of the church and you say them every day. You read the Bible the Catholic Bible and no other since all other Bibles have been Rewritten with attacks againt Mary !!! and study the lives of the Saints of the church, and stay away from newly written or revised books on the market today !!! Don't buy any books on the market after 1960 !!!!
What about confession and all that ? You confess your sins to God the Father, Son and Holy Ghost using the prayers in the St Andrews missile, in the confessional which is in the back of the book, or you say one of the seven penitential Psalms along with the act of contrition. That's your confession, at home where you are safe both in body and soul !! For baptism you do the same at home with the proper, Matter, Form and Intent !!!
But whatever you do have nothing to do with the Vatican 2 Church sspx, sspv, fssp…. even if it's empty do not go in it !!! Judgment day is almost here.
P.S.- the Most Holy Family Monastery is a good resource me and my colleagues have kept a close eye on them for over 20 years I highly recommend them. Also the web site - God's Catholic Dogma. They are the only 2 sources of Catholic Teachings on earth.
And Vatican 2 doc. Are binding if anyone tells you there not their lying
God Love You
so do i or don't i join the Church? i have grown up IFB but by our Lord's Grace and goodness was led out of that falsehood. i want so, so badly to join the Church: The True Church. but, having watched some of these videos about vatican 2, i'm concerned the true church isn't here anymore. can i still join the true Church? i have spent my life to this point in error and apostasy. i have hope the Lord will forgive me but i'm terrified of the idea of offending Him further. please forgive my ignorance. i appreciate any answers. please pray for me. thank you.
The answer is yes, you join the church. With all its problems its still Gods church.
I would suggest the latin mass preferably sspx. But if all you have is novus ordo your still in the church by joining.
Join the church and God will fix it eventually.
But woe to you if you have knowledge and dont join.
Council of Florence
The holy Roman church] firmly believes, professes, and preaches that all those who are outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans but also Jews or heretics and schismatics, cannot share in eternal life and will go into the everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless they are joined to the Catholic Church before the end of their lives; that the unity of the ecclesiastical body is of such importance that only for those who abide in it do the Church’s sacraments contribute to salvation and do fasts, almsgiving and other works of piety and practices of the Christian militia produce eternal rewards; and that nobody can be saved, no matter how much he has given away in alms and even if he has shed his blood in the name of Christ, unless he has persevered in the bosom and the unity of the Catholic Church (Session 11 - Feb. 4, 1442)
.2nd vatican council
Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it”
And woe to me if my videos caused you not to join. Even though I am telling the truth.
@@imisschristendom5293 thank you. this answer eases me. it's my belief that God has truly been directing me, as i've perceived the latin tradition is most appropriate. there is also one nearby (within an hour). again, thank you.
Is Holy Water (that you can get in a Novus Ordo church) still effective against demons/islam/lust and other sins?
I became a fan of your channel because you produce your videos well and have a unique insight on things. Mentioning the relation between the state of the church vs the world, and popular Catholic movies of the 1950s are good examples of that.
But then later one, this video switches to you just repeating a lot of common narratives in the trad community without really digging into the data. For example - at one point you say that the vocations crisis was the result of the Mass released in 1970. However, if you look at the numbers, vocations were already dropping throughout the 1960s. There was a lot going on in 1960s, such as a sexual revolution (in part) triggered by the normalization of birth control in the 1950s...wouldn't that have a massive effect on celibate vocations with or without Vatican 2?
Another thing I noticed is the narrative that the Council was non-infallible. This is innacurate. Yes, Paul VI gave a talk once where he said something like that - but it doesn't matter because within the Council itself he promulgated the documents officially and infallibly. Official promulgations are what matter in regards to infallibility, not what The Pope says in a talk to some group or on an airplane or whatever.
I guess what I'm saying is to be careful. One of the reasons The Church is in crisis is because of confusion. Please be careful not to add to that confusion and keep up the good work on your channel.
I agree with you on most of these points. However, I would argue that Vatican II made things go from bad to worse.
Concerning the infallibility of the council, I agree that as a council it is infallible, but I believe that the church stated that since the council was pastoral, and not convened to resolve a dogmatic matter, that its edicts were non-binding.
Now, concerning confusion, you can't blame faithful catholic communities i.e. "trad cads" for the confusion in the church, most of the confusion has come from the hierarchy, none more so than from Pope Francis himself.
there were bad trends in the church before vatican 2 no doubt, but what came out of vatican 2 didn't help any of it. it compounded the problems to the point where now there are church closures throughout the Western world. how is that possible with a council that was supposed to be so great and infuse Holy Spirit into the life of the church?
Well, my first response would be: where is your proof that Vatican 2 made things worse?
You point to trends but trends tell a different story. The trends for church attendance fell throughout the 50s, 60s, 70s, 80s but so did attendance of bowling leagues, supper clubs and ALL types of community groups. This reveals the issue was social change outside The Church, and actually, although the pews were emptying, this is evidence that those people were primarily there for SOCIAL reasons, i.e. they liked going to mass to see people, not because they had faith. Thus the "loss" of these numbers is not actually a loss in number of believers.
But also, the trends for all these things fell at different rates. Attendence of ALL churches fell during this time, including Protestant services. That obviously had nothing to do with Vatican 2.
But what you see in the trends is that some fell more quickly and some fell more slowly. Following Vatican 2, attendence for Catholic mass fell more slowly than attendence at Protestant services. This could be seen as the protection of The Holy Spirit.
But at the same time, the promise of Christ has never been that The Church is constantly growing in numbers. There have been times in the history of The Church that numbers have fallen.
Have a blessed Easter!
@@nealkriesterer Happy Easter. After Vatican 2 millions of faithful left. some due to societal changes, some due to abrupt changes that followed the council - Mass changing from Latin to Novus Ordo, overnight with all the craziness that came with it. it was too much to bear for some. results - the church has lost its influence over culture resulting in loss of vocations, married life, priesthood, etc. all the trends are down across all metrics. so if the council was supposed to somehow make the church better, it didn't.
@Ave Crux Spes Unica you think so? vatican 2 caused many of the problems seen today, so how is that a fallacy?
Have you done a video on what these prophets of the Church have said about future chastisement? If not, you should please cover them 🙏
All prelates had taken the Oath Against Modernism. "Pope" John XXIII led them in breaking their oaths.
Vatican did not ruin any thing, it was the Bishops going back and misinterpreting much of it to suit their agender.
It is ambiguous which means it is meant to be misinterpreted
@@edwinkubena9944it is not ambiguous. It is people’s inability to comprehend what they read.
@@TheCoachsCoach933 No you didn’t study the docs can’t help you some people are sheeple. Watch Fr. Joseph Noonan please the heresy of Modernism is wicked.
@@TheCoachsCoach933 typical pope splainer puppeteer
Thank you for this very informative. video.
I really want to become a Catholic but the biggest reason I haven’t is because of Vatican 2 I don’t see how Muslims worship the same God as Christians I also don’t think a pope should ever kiss a Quran to me that’s a bad look
Sometimes I wonder what if all the religious had kids. It’d be a better world today.
no
Definitely not.
@@mariepaukowits1709 I think so. Less evil atheists
Things are only ruined if the TLM was your idol. Repent
So Vatican 2 and the N.O. Mass has been a great success then! 😅
@@michaelgibbons7281 Are you claiming the real presence of Christ is a failure?
Is it our fault, our enemies stormed the gate and attacked us?
Agreed. Mother Angelica agrees it was poor implementation of Vat 2. So sad😢
WELL, from ALLthe Cathoic Church, OK; but from the 'Roman'Catholic Church, not ,by it's count, since 1054 when it seceded from The Church through the singular action of the
Patriarch of the West - who called himself Pope - and First in authourity, not just honour.[He was not]
And grace from The Holy Spirit, through His Anointing of His Apostolic Bishops - as recognized by Rome!!!
How can you possibly interpret Matthew 15 as meaning only through the catholic church does grace come into the world? It was meant to show that Jesus came first to reconcile the Father with His people, (the Jews) and then to the Gentiles. It also showed Jesus's compassion for people who, in that day, somebody of His standing would have normally not bothered to even speak to.
Romans 1:16: I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew, then to the Gentile.
Luke 24:47: Repentance for the forgiveness of sins will be preached in his name to all nations, beginning at Jerusalem.
Look at the parable of the grand banquet in Luke 14, it screams that God's intention was to originally reconcile His people to Himself first, but because of their disobedience, the Gentile was then invited, only after the Jew. The catholic church is not the table of grace as you think it is. Jesus coming into the world was, in part, to fulfil God's promise to Israel, but gentiles were permitted to become children of God as well. At that point in Jesus's ministry, he was mostly focused on the people of Israel.
Using that to justify the catholic church hoarding the grace of God is hubris in it's worst form. Grace comes into the world through the Holy Spirit, period.
Yes, who established the Catholic Church as His vehicle of Grace
Vatican ll Council is heretical and need to anathema
Denying Vatican II is denying the entire claim of the RCC
I’m a big fan of yours, and I know this is an older video being a year old. We don’t have to agree on everything, and I enjoy almost everything you publish. But, I think you are wrong on Vatican II. I believe it was a work of the Holy Spirit and great things came out of it. Unfortunately, it coincided with the unleashing of some great evils in society. So I feel Vatican II gets unfairly blamed for things beyond the Church’s control. Additionally, there are a lot of calumnies surrounding the Bishops involved, accusing them of unfounded freemasonry and other things. In my opinion, the entire conference could be Freemasons, but because of the charism the Pope has the result would still be good despite all the devils efforts. Before Vatican II a lot of Mass abuses also occurred, and it sought to eliminate them. Unfortunately new abuses have popped up, but having traveled around the US and having attended foreign Masses, I can say I have never seen a bad Mass. Some are better than others, but I haven’t never come across anything resembling a “clown Mass.”
Maybe you can do a video on all of the fake annulments since Vatican II. Everyone gets one now. I know of many in my own family. I don’t have one so I get to be alone since 1999. I know someone that was annulled from two marriages and is married for a third time. This makes me so mad I can chew through a nail! No one is really serious when it comes to this. There’s an excuse for everybody because no one really wants to follow the teaching on remarriage. After all of these years I should just apply for my fake annulment too. God can”t hold me responsible then since the modernist church says it’s ok Phonies! Our Lord isn’t going to let this abuse slide.
Where did you find the 34 directives? Anybody have a link? Great video, also.
Is your last name Luther by any chance?
big fan
I feel you are headed the right direction but your theories aren't connecting.... Maybe you should contact the Dimonds of most holy family monastery to get a better view of the end times
As the church goes so goes the world. We had Two Popes and two Presidents.
Now we have one Pope.... keep watching
Truth.
Does the byzantine catholics have the original Vatican 01 rite in Greek?
If not I'm probably going orthodox from cradle protestant
Edit* I meant Orthodox
My understanding is that eastern Catholic have the same Rite as their Orthodox counterpart
@@imisschristendom5293 Yes, that is correct. There is a byzantine catholic church near me, and it's the same as EO. The only difference is that they are in communion with the holy see.
@David Phillips haha one prot sect to another 🤣
What I'm more scared of the Orthodox seem very national and rigid and I would miss the Rosary and Memorale...
My issue is I don't know what God rather me be.
There's so many signs for both and God bless ✝️
@@orthocatsr.8723 Do not judge the workers in the Catholic (universal) church as the faith itself. You know what Jesus taught and He also said in Matthew 16 that the "gates of hell shall not prevail against it." We go to mass to hear God's Word, see Our Lord's sacrifice re-presented and to receive His Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. It is our act of worship. No council, no pope, no opinion will change my mind that the Catholic church IS the church that Jesus founded. Peter being the first authority (pope) and an unbroken change of ordained priests since have served as popes, all of them sinners just like you and me. Pray for conversion of sinners!
@@donnarichert5627 amen. I have maybe 99 percent the same belief ... I would ask You for a certain prayer about a particular conversion too!
-
I'm actually very interested in some very catholic things like that much more than anyone can comprehend albeit I look like hell.
God bless and thank U
What an utter disappointment the last supper is to those who make the TLM their idol.
guard your forked tounge, Novus Order Churches are dying TLM is attracting the young and the next generation.
@@PabloVelasco-hr3ko Wishful thinking.
@@dan_m7774 it is true tho, TLM are growing and are filled with Young. Novus Order is filled with the Older Generation. TLM is the future
@@PabloVelasco-hr3ko Are the young as likely to go Orthodox or Angelican because of the visuals and not because of the teachings?
@@dan_m7774 Angelicans embraced trans lgbt and their churches are dying for it. And Orthodox are our brothers which we can receieve communions with them
Also it doesnt matter the TLM is Growing
Your teaching about the passage on scripture that involves the woman who was a gentile Is absolutely wrong. The passage is about Jesus showing that his kingdom is for everyone who believes in him and the gospel. He knew her faith was grate!
One good thing. I don't have heretics at my mass
IT’S INVALID
NOT Vatican II, but the INTERPRETATION of Vatican II !!!
‘Interpretation’ which was ready even before the Council started…
@@tubaceous Thanks to the LGBTPQ etc. infiltrators!!!!!
@@tubaceous They are now destroying of what's left of the Catholic Church and not even pope Benedict could stop them. ....😖
@@arnoeeuwigheid4499 not only LGBT… also masons, communists and one world government types.
@@arnoeeuwigheid4499 amen!
The document of the Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae, word-for-word contradicts the infallible condemnation of religious liberty found in Pope Pius IX's encyclical, Quanta Cura. In Nostra Aetate, false religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism were praised. Lumen Gentium attempted to change the constitution of the Church (which is immutable) and also teaches a newly invented heretical ecclesiology whereby other 'Christian communities' can be considered part of the 'Church of Christ' or 'People of God'. This flatly contradicts Pius XII's Mystici Corporis and all traditional teaching on the matter. The plain meaning of the words of these documents is vindicated due to the interpretation of them given by the putative Popes and also by their practice. For example, in the document, Dominus Jesus, Cardinal Ratzinger, the future Benedict XVI, confirmed the new heretical ecclesiology of Lumen Gentium. There is no way out by appealing to interpreting the documents in light of tradition for the putative Popes sabotage the endeavour through their words and actions. There is no getting around it: the council taught heresy. It was a robber council ratified by a false Pope who founded a conciliar sect which masquerades as the Catholic Church.
The night before He died, Jesus prayed that we would all be one as He and the Father are one. Some unity! I've lost count of all of the different denominations. I have decided to believe that worshiping in the Church founded by Jesus and his apostles is right for me. You can call us names all day long but I will not leave the Eucharist. For those who don't know, catholic means universal.
@@donnarichert5627 I don't believe I called anyone names. Perhaps you could point out how I did that? I would certainly never tell anyone to leave the Most Holy Catholic Church founded by Our Lord, Jesus Christ, so you must have misunderstood me there. Nor am I advocating the establishment of yet another denomination. The problem is that the post-Conciliar Popes do not believe in the Catholic religion, which is easily confirmed through the comparison of their teaching and traditional Catholic teaching, which cannot change.
@@augustinepinnock7740 For example?
@@donnarichert5627 I gave several examples in my first comment. Did you read it properly? Nevertheless, Francis has taught that the death penalty is intrinsically evil, that God wills the diversity of religions, and that Luther was right about justification. All of those are heretical statements.
@@augustinepinnock7740 Sorry, I don't see every comment. The death penalty is and always has been intrinsically evil. Only God has the power of life and death. God wills the free will of man. If man has to get to God through a different path, who is Pope Francis to judge that path? Judgment is God's and His alone. If the Pope said Luther was right about justification and it wasn't a media soundbite or a misquote, it is not necessary for a person to belong to Christ's church to be saved. God will judge us on our own path, even if one has never known of God. Sincerely Mr. Pinnock, you might consider reading portions of The Catechism of the Catholic Church or the writings of the early Church Fathers. Thankful you're engaged, truly. Prayers and peace, brother.
I wish I could accept your via media. I am currently converting to the Catholic Church. Part of this process is reading from the ancients up to V2 as well as a very careful reading of the V2 documents and post Conciliar encyclicals etc. If we accept the V2 documents as validly promulgated by a valid Pope, then we must accept the changes that have come as the positive will of Christ in the Church. This means that Christ contradicts himself however, as there are statements in the Council documents that would have earned chastisement from any pre council Pope and excommunication if the error was persisted in.
Vatican 2 is valid and the Pope was valid. Some interpretations of V2 were not promulgated by the council. They claim they did so in the "spirit" of V2.
Pope Paul VI stated at the close of the Council, "This council defined nothing". It was a pastoral council. The first of its kind. However, there are heresies within the documents, and they were written in an ambiguous way in order to allow differing interpretations going forward.
@@soldier8304 every pope after the Council has shown their interpretation of the documents through radical ecumenical actions, and statements.
Yours is not a realistic interpretation, and if those were/are valid popes, their interpretation is the rule of faith.
@@twoody9760 These interpretations were made by papal actions and pronouncements. There is disruption not continuity after V2.
I don't know about everything, but can't say it didn't ruin something.
Oh stay far away from me Vatican
The 1950s was not the height. It must been pre ww2.
this isn't right, don't you know that Michael Lofton "nuanced" (gaslighted..) all this away...
Haha, i just cringe when I hear him talk. Its so obvious what he's doing.
I cringe also when I hear lofton voice
I agree what you said except when you said that the vatican ii council is valid & you seem to belive that Montini is valid Pope. He is definetely invalid & anti-pope because he killed the sacraments.
What is the mohammedon prayer?
It was one of the prayers to the Sacred Heart. I used to see it all the time on the non mainstream Catholic websites. But since they Purged the internet a few years ago I can't find it anymore
@@imisschristendom5293 Dang I tried finding it to but to no avail.
Hopefully the church comes back in greater glory in our life times (likely not but after our lifetimes it is guranteed).
@@imisschristendom5293 Hopefully it can be found, Europe needs protection from the Saracens more than ever. The recent waves of migration have been more successful bringing Europe under the yoke Islam than all the Jihads of the last 1500 years combined.
@@vaderkurt7848 Never lose your hope! Jesus will return and the new heaven and the new earth will mean the choices are behind us.
@@imisschristendom5293The Church is only declining in the West. It's growing everywhere else.
2 Thessaloniki 2:3 ??
Listen carefully to monseigneur lefevre.
Who are you to judge? Jesus did not say that the vatican 2 ruined everything. Becareful jesus say in luke 6:45 - "the good man out of the good treasure of his heart produces good, and evil man out of his evil treasure produces evil; for out of the abundance of the heart his mouth speaks".
Luke 6:37 - jesus say "judge not and you will not be judged; and condemn not and you will not be condemnef; forgivr and you will be forgiven".
you shall know them by their fruits
and the Vatican 2 is destroying the faith of millions of Catholics
100 ,% it did .
Dogs 🙄😶🌫️🧐
Hear me good--I am old enough to remember Latin Masses, communion rails and Communion on the tongue only. I do NOT to ever, ever, EVER go back to medieval-style Masses. Traditionalists who are too young (that is, the vast majority of them) to have been alive during the "Golden Age of Catholicism" do not know what they are asking. The TLM is a "fad Mass" and a curiosity. I do not want to be stuck with a medieval Mass in a dead language once the TLM fad Mass is reinstated as THE Mass.
This is part why I don’t go to mass. My sin, I get it. I have to find my way back
That's pride talking and remember pride is what made lucifer fall. You can't obtain salvation without Christ's church and the Sacramental of Confession.
You need to suck it up bro.
We all need to suck it up regardless of the crisis or era we live in.
Just go to confession, it's difficult to get in the confessional, but once you've confessed your sin and know your forgiven, it's a very liberating.
Liz, I pray for you and all who have left the Catholic church. Have you considered just going to RCIA classes and listening in? No decisions, just inquiry.
I too, sadly, stopped going to mass .. it was before Covid started. The words just felt .. wrong to me. And when the Churches started to shut down because of State's Mandates.. I knew it was wrong too. How did the state become more powerful than the church of God?? What's going on?
Ruined everything? Dramatic. Be grateful for the Holy Eucharist. Would you prefer a world of Saints in novus ordo or a world of the wicked in tlm? I suggest we go to work and have faith
First of all, the word is correctly translated as DEVIL,
and second of all, that is a devilish bible thou art quoting
A lot of this is nostalgia for a world and church past, like the maga, only it’s MOCGA, make our church great again, with devotionalism, Latin, retribution,…….
The Church is a reflection of the body of Christ, the people of God, and we're all sinners.
No it didn't. sigh There's no limit to traditionalists' hyperbole.
Yes it can, sigh. But only for those open to God's grace.
The proof is in the pudding.
Go to any traditionalist catholic parish and you will see a church full of families, with lots of children, with veiled women and girls silently praying. The girls and women will be dressed modestly not showing any cleavage or skin above their knees or mid arms, nor will their clothes be provocative in any way. The Fathers and sons will be impeccably dressed wearing suits and ties.
Now contrast that to the Novus Ordo parishes, they will be mostly filled with adults or elderly, there will be hardly any children. The younger women will be immodestly dressed, and half the men will be dressed like they're headed to the beach afterward. The church will be noisy before mass because everyone is chatting it up with their neighbor instead of praying.
@@richardditty5318this ‘European oho …’ is likely a paid Vatican facilitator. I learned to smell them, and there is no point opening discussion there…
You are blind
When you attend a NO you are, in essence, attending a Protestant service. If you don't believe me, start attending Anglican services for awhile and, then, compare it with the current NO Catholic Mass. The words are the same. I grew up Catholic in the '80's - NO, but I didn't know any different and the Mass had a lot of the traditional elements intact. Then, I left the Church and attended Protestant services for most of my adult life. I converted back to Catholicism a few years ago. So much of what I'm experiencing in Catholic Mass now if just like the Protestant churches I went to. I feel empty inside. I feel I'm being called to attend TLM going forward.