“Scientific” Mesh Head Test
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 июл 2017
- The most accurate mesh head test on RUclips! Check out my comparison video of the Jobeky Try-Ply, drum-tec Basic, Design Series and real feel mesh head.
Find V-drum Tips on:
✭ Facebook: goo.gl/sW6z3S
✭ Webpage: www.v-drumtips.com
-- Mesh Heads --
1. drum-tec real feel (3 ply): goo.gl/cb6RPV
2. drum-tec Design Series (2 ply): goo.gl/wszHdD
3. Roland MH & PowerPly: amzn.to/2BZPAvY
4. Jobeky Try Ply: goo.gl/iJgam8
5. Drum-tec Pro (1ply): goo.gl/6oVtCF
6. drum-tec Basic (1 ply): goo.gl/zkzhTs
7. Remo Silentstroke (1ply): goo.gl/1k9ZfL
Music: www.davidhilliardmusic.com/
Related Videos:
► Mesh Head Test: • Mesh Head Test (E-drums)
► Jobeky Mesh Review: • Jobeky Mesh Head - Test
-----------------------------------------
1. drum-tec real feel (3 ply)
Rebound: 7/10
Noise: 6/10
Hot Spotting: 8/10
Quality: 9/10
The rebound is very good, especially when tensioned tighter. It is noisy in comparison to other mesh heads. It reduces hot spotting when tuned tight.
The quality is good, but not perfect, as there are sometimes treads at the hoop.
2. drum-tec Design Series (2 ply)
Rebound: 6/10
Noise: 7/10
Hot Spotting: 7/10
Quality: 9/10
The rebound is better than the Roland Powerply and Roland MH Series rebound. Therefore it is slightly noisier. How spotting is more reduced than with a Roland head, as the drum-tec mesh material is not as stretchy.
3. Roland MH & PowerPly (2 ply)
Rebound: 5/10
Noise: 8/10
Hot Spotting: 6/10
Quality: 10/10
The Roland PowerPly series mesh head is exactly the same head as the known Roland MH head, except that the PowerPly is offered in more sizes.
It is not too noisy but in terms of rebound and hot spotting, not as good as the drum-tec Design Series 2 ply head.
Quality Wise, it is the best mesh head but it comes at a price. (Very expensive)
4. Jobeky Try Ply
Rebound: 5/10
Noise: 9/10
Hot Spotting: 5/10
Quality: 6/10
The Jobeky Head is quieter than the Roland mesh with a similar rebound than Roland. Hot spotting can become an issue because the material is very stretchy.
Out of the box, the head does not really have the form of a drum head, it is very short and the hoop is very small. The material is smooth and feels like cloth.
5. Drum-tec Pro (1ply)
Rebound: 9/10
Noise: 2/10
Hot Spotting: 9/10
Quality: 10/10
This mesh head is a kind of hybrid between mesh and millar head. The mesh strings are really thick and make the head very loud. It is as realistic as a real head in terms of rebound. It is not stretchy, therefore reduces hot spotting. These heads are made for sets that are placed in a garage or somewhere where noise is no issue.
6. drum-tec Basic (1 ply)
Rebound: 3/10
Noise: 7/10
Hot Spotting: 4/10
Quality: 9/10
The best “normal” one ply head on the market, not as stretchy as the Remo Silent Stroke. It is really quiet if used with the right shells. 1 ply heads cannot be tuned well, so the hot spotting and rebound is an issue.
7. Remo Silentstroke (1ply)
Rebound: 2/10
Noise: 9/10
Hot Spotting: 3/10
Quality: 10/10
This head is the 1-ply version of the Roland mesh head. It is stretchy but very quiet. The quality is outstanding. The rebound is unrealistic.
8. Millenium QuieHead (2ply)
Rebound: 3/10
Noise: 7/10
Hot Spotting: 4/10
Quality: 5/10
This is by far the cheapest mesh head on the market (14” costs 15€). The material is not white, but transparent and logo is very ugly. The head is too short, meaning it is flat and does not have the form of a drum head out of the box. The rebound is not great and it is stretchy.
9. 682 XS Pro Mesh Head (2ply)
Rebound: 2/10
Noise: 9/10
Hot Spotting: 3/10
Quality: 5/10
Cloth style head that is too bouncy and stretchy but very quiet. I would not recommend buying it. Almost every other head is better. The only good thing about it is that you cannot look through.
Incredible!
This is what I have been looking for, you did a masterful job
Great work - very precise!!
great video, finally a proper test with accurate measurements
Fantastic video! great job.
Awesome testing :) thanks for sharing
This channel is pure gold!!!!
Very interesting. Well done video. Love the control of the variables. I recently replaced some very old but still functioning Roland heads that came on my TD9 with the drumtec real feels. Funnily when I cranked the snare as tight as I was willing to go I started to get some serious hot spotting issues, which I honestly never noticed with my roland two ply. I replaced the trigger cones a while back but the roland heads were still fine after that. I backed off the tightness of the real feels and it's made it better. Not sure why. I'd prefer to have it tighter. Anyway....I do like the feel of them, but to be honest I don't notice a huge difference. They are nice and white though! lol.
Man this is awsome. Good work.
At last a test that gives you the actual gap beetween every MH types. Thanks !! One that would show how loose the tension should be on the differents MH to approach a mylar rebound would be icing on the cake 😁
Very smart demonstration!
Great content! Congrats!!!
Excellent video. Thank you for taking the time to make it
Wow!!! Thank you very much! Great work.
Excellent video.
Well done!
You need to compare this to the yamaha silicone pad head, ask a store to collaborate with them. This will help the e-drum community
excellent job!!!!
Perfect test Thank you 🔥🔥🔥👌🤘
Amazing video! Love science!