DBZ vs DBKai - Vegetas Tournament Ring Speech

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 окт 2024

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @BranVR
    @BranVR  3 года назад +179

    Please stop commenting to me about the music. Im aware its not correct. I didnt vet out the sites i used,(this was made for my friend, not thousands of people :p) but the music in the scenario isnt relevant, its the speech. Ty
    Edit on 12/19/2022: yall acting like i personally went in there and removed and changed the music myself.....yall give me to much credit. If yall need some more context, this was made in the span of 5 minutes in a single take using obs studio and a screen capture XD again I DID NOT VET the sites i used at the time, i just did a google, and AGAIN, this was made for the sake of comparing the dubs, i didnt care nor pay attention to what score was being used as that wasnt relevant for the purpose that i made this. calm yourselves, faulconer isnt going to descend from the sky, pat you on the back, and give you the gawk gawk because you defended his score.....so chill lol.

    • @clavicusvile1328
      @clavicusvile1328 2 года назад +19

      Hey bro just wanted to ask if you're aware that the music in this scene is wrong?

    • @self4797
      @self4797 2 года назад +9

      make sure the put the right music next time

    • @BranVR
      @BranVR  2 года назад +15

      @@self4797 no u

    • @chrisbitm
      @chrisbitm 2 года назад +1

      ​@@self4797 Who cares about the music. This is a comparison video between DBZ and Kai with swapped BGM. Bran VR made it clear why he did it the way he did it. This is RUclips where videos are shared; even if it is intended for a specific individual, and this is a comparison video, like the title suggests. Given your comment was from two months ago, and Clavicus Vile from 3 months ago, , you can easily stream both with their respective versions, even buying the official release of such. There are other videos where both clips of this scene are intact on this platform. You shouldn't make these kind of statements on these kinds of vids. It makes you sound like an asshole. Sorry, I just have to give my two cents.

    • @amadorcortinas2749
      @amadorcortinas2749 2 года назад +4

      @@indepth9930 The music sets up the whole tone of the scenes it just as important!

  • @zabbaninja
    @zabbaninja 2 года назад +637

    Not only is Vegeta’s speech amazing, but Supreme Kai’s legitimate confusion when he says “WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE?!” He is genuinely shocked that they would put this fight over the universe and it is so awesome.

  • @Sonicfalcon16
    @Sonicfalcon16 3 года назад +2037

    The Z speach makes feel like I can get where Vegeta's coming from and KAI feels like he's just whining

    • @izukumidoriyaisssss3049
      @izukumidoriyaisssss3049 3 года назад +61

      Well yeah, he is whining. Vegeta might be a great character, but he's also kind of a bitch. I mean, in his first fight with Goku. He only lost his skirmishes with him, because he was throwing temper tantrums because he wasn't used to fair fights. I mean, Goku and him were extremely close in power, yet because he wasn't used to fighting someone on an equal level, he freaked the fuck out, lost his composure and got his ass kicked. And in his fight with freeza, he legit cried like a little bitch when he knew Freeza was about to fuck him up.
      And this next instance isn't canon but still. In the broly movie, the dude literally collapsed on his knees in fear, while everyone else was trying their damndest to beat broly. Again, he's a great character. But man is he a bitch sometimes.

    • @lordmonarch2995
      @lordmonarch2995 3 года назад +17

      The Broly movie you speak of isn’t canon.

    • @ConradMarbourg3635
      @ConradMarbourg3635 3 года назад +58

      @Sonicfalcon16 : fully agree with one big exception the "My foolish pride ... To a Saiyan pride is all" that line was awesome in addition to be true :)

    • @izukumidoriyaisssss3049
      @izukumidoriyaisssss3049 3 года назад +5

      @@lordmonarch2995 I know. I said that

    • @Sonicfalcon16
      @Sonicfalcon16 3 года назад +3

      @@izukumidoriyaisssss3049 also Cell, he had plenty of chances to kill him and chose not to when he was clearly able to in the moment

  • @SuperMasterJefe
    @SuperMasterJefe 2 года назад +349

    "WHAT DO YOU KNOW OF MEANINGLESS!?!?!?"
    Out of all the dubs, that is still my favorite Vegeta line

    • @sabre4382
      @sabre4382 9 месяцев назад +13

      Og dbz line was better here, honestly just made more sense

    • @victorsamsung2921
      @victorsamsung2921 7 месяцев назад +3

      @@sabre4382 True. Vegeta's speech in DBZ had more heart to it than that of DBZ Kai. In the sense that you could feel empathy for his frustration regarding his Saiyan origins, what happened to the Saiyans (destruction of planet Vegeta) and the importance of pride etc.

    • @goncalobaia1574
      @goncalobaia1574 4 месяца назад

      100% absolutely. For a moment there he really sounds like a completely real dude who's had enough and is about to snap

  • @spiralroad2327
    @spiralroad2327 3 года назад +675

    The Z dialogue is an eloquent summary of Vegeta's downward spiral. He walks you back through Freeza's reign, the destruction of Planet Vegeta, the Namek arc, everything he's been through leading up to his breaking point. I love that brief hesitation, when saying that Goku saved his life. It's like Goku being a nice guy just makes him that much angrier...

    • @slashs1318
      @slashs1318 2 года назад +4

      Are you high or mixing things up because the Kai dub clearly talked about the past way more than Z dub does here...

    • @TyphlosionGirl
      @TyphlosionGirl 2 года назад +41

      @@slashs1318 Bruh what are you talking about? You know the first clip is Z and the second is Kai right? In terms of Vegeta's speech (not everything in general just these couple of episodes) the dialogue is much more specific in Z then in Kai.

    • @slashs1318
      @slashs1318 2 года назад +7

      @@TyphlosionGirl yeah, No. Kai had the supreme Kioshin actually concerned about Vegeta murdering those people. If you want to look at just Vegeta, sure DBZ was more "I'm angry and also bad now". Yet Kai is way more consistent with characters interacting with each other and the world they live in. Kai vegeta reminisces on his past life and what was, while Z vegeta out of no where talks about some "ruined destiny" which makes no sense and is so corny. Kai makes you feel way more invested, Z is like WWE script.

    • @UncJah
      @UncJah 2 года назад +43

      @@slashs1318 dawg you got it completely backwards lmao

    • @slashs1318
      @slashs1318 2 года назад

      @@UncJah I bet you like Majin vegeta after he killed those innocent people. 🤦‍♂he is the bad guy here!!! no one should like majin vegeta, he is a prick. yall dont get fiction.

  • @ryubunny877
    @ryubunny877 3 года назад +1220

    i dont usually say this but dbz did this scene so much better, the music, the dialogue, the reasoning behind vegeta turning evil makes much more sense other than "I just want to fight kakarot arghh"

    • @UmbreonMessiah
      @UmbreonMessiah 3 года назад +164

      The reasons are the same, the motivations are the same....but Z communicates it better.

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад +21

      @@UmbreonMessiah Yeah like what is he talking about💀💀

    • @unholydiver1095
      @unholydiver1095 3 года назад +44

      I think Kai did better than Z with everything up to and including the Freeza/Namek saga. But everything after that I feel Z did better

    • @sheevpalpatine1741
      @sheevpalpatine1741 3 года назад +34

      @@unholydiver1095 Personally, I think kai did a wonderful job with the android saga but the cell saga is when it started to fall flat

    • @JeromeProductions
      @JeromeProductions 3 года назад

      Yup

  • @alexiavya722
    @alexiavya722 3 года назад +793

    DBZ did it 100x better The whole "and his debts, Must. Be. Paid." bit was so fucking badass that was on point with his character at this point.

    • @slashs1318
      @slashs1318 2 года назад +12

      yeah, No. Kai had the supreme Kioshin actually concerned about Vegeta murdering those people. If you want to look at just Vegeta, sure DBZ was more "I'm angry and also bad now". Yet Kai is way more consistent with characters interacting with each other and the world they live in. Kai vegeta reminisces on his past life and what was, while Z vegeta out of no where talks about some "ruined destiny" which makes no sense and is so corny. Kai makes you feel way more invested, Z is like WWE script.

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад +63

      @@slashs1318 You mixed up badly, it's kai which feels like a wwe script and it's Z that makes you feel invensted. In kai He just seems to whining just for the sake of whining. But Z add so much more to the scene, it's like the way Vegeta talks makes you understand where he is coming. Z clearly slaughters Kai in this scene.

    • @slashs1318
      @slashs1318 2 года назад

      @@theguy3129 Clearly you dont understand the fact that Vegeta is actually a whiney bitch for going Majin in the first place. At this point in the series, Vegeta reverts back to the hateful sayain that we first met in the show and that over saw the slaughter of our beloved Z warriors and almost Gohan and Krillin. So, I absolutely love the Kai dub because it paints Majin Vegeta as the unsympathetic LITERAL villain he is at this point!!! You are really not supposed to sympathize with him, considering he just murdered innocent people. Cringy Z dub, as always. I love Vegeta post majin, but not so much anytime before that.

    • @doniarts
      @doniarts 2 года назад +3

      @@theguy3129 no.

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад +1

      @@slashs1318 Vegeta is whiny bitch but Z executes the scene way better with way better dialogue and delivery. Vegeta's dialogue from 0:14 to 0:22 in Z sounds like he's literally lost his shit. That alone demolishes anything Kai has to offer in this entire scene. As I said, you're clearly mixed up. It's Z that paints Vegeta as a cold hearted unsympathetic villain (especially in this scene). Kai, well, the dialogue and delivery are fucking cringe.

  • @itv4713
    @itv4713 4 года назад +413

    Z murders Kai in this scene, Kai's dialogue is really juvenile and they just make Vegeta sound whiny.

    • @yeetnessthegreater1298
      @yeetnessthegreater1298 3 года назад +16

      Uh..so does Dbz pal don't get it twisted

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад +16

      @@yeetnessthegreater1298 deadass just with a deep voice💀💀Canonically that means Vegeta is whiny because Kai is more similar to the actual dub

    • @genorem
      @genorem 3 года назад +13

      As good as the dialogue was, it all literally boils down to vegeta whining.
      Kai: Earth's in danger!
      Vegeta: I want my rematch!!

    • @xrstevenson
      @xrstevenson 3 года назад +50

      @@genorem seriously, that's all it is. There isn't a difference: "His debts must be paid" = "Fuck Earth and the universe, this dude insulted me by saving my life and you want him to do it again!?!?" Like, people, this is Vegeta's character. There is no "Vegeta sounds whiny in Kai" because he's whining in both, THAT'S WHY THE FIGHT STARTS IN THE FIRST PLACE

    • @PatLund
      @PatLund 3 года назад +20

      Vegeta is supposed to be whiny in this scene. That's the whole point.

  • @bigtommy9715
    @bigtommy9715 3 года назад +192

    The way he used to voice vegeta just fits majin vegeta 100x better

  • @deaj8450
    @deaj8450 5 лет назад +428

    The difference between Z and Kai here is so huge and it makes Kai looks so bad. In Kai Vegeta is literally just narrating what we already know about how he feels in the situation. We know as the audience he doesn't care about Buu, we know he is into it simply for Goku. Even Goku knows that. Z is wracked with emotion. We get to hear much more of what Vegeta really cares about in terms of values, motivation, goals. We get to hear him admit how much Frieza's rule obviously psychologically destroyed him to the point of only caring about his own strength.
    "Spend most of your life ruled by another, watch your race dwindle to a handful, then tell me what has more meaning than your own strength."
    vs
    "All I want is my fight with Kakarot! Here and now! I shall emerge the victor!"
    It's not that Kai's portrayal is out of character or incorrect, but it is worse because it is lacking the depth the OG Funi dub had. In Z we see into his soul, in Kai he acts like a one-dimensional character. This problem applies to a lot of Kai and the entirety of DBS in my opinion.

    • @vit968
      @vit968 4 года назад +69

      *This is why I'm don't like modern dubs' slavish devotion to a 100 percent exact literally translated Japanese script. If Z was dubbed back then like Kai was today, we would've never have gotten the masterfully crafted improvised Woolsey-ism dialogue of*
      _"Spend most of your life ruled by another, watch your race dwindle to a handful, then tell me what has more meaning than your own strength."_
      *I want Eng dubs to feel free to do whatever they want with the script if it results in a more memorable and better overall performance in their own language. I don't want them to just copy every way the Japanese version did. I want them to do their own thing.*

    • @CapsuleGraph11
      @CapsuleGraph11 4 года назад +14

      Kai is so much better

    • @deaj8450
      @deaj8450 4 года назад +54

      @@CapsuleGraph11In terms of production value I would agree, but I would have to disagree on basically everything else. Especially the differences in writing between Kai and the OG dub, Kai might be more accurate to the manga but it also is missing a ton of soul the funi dub had.

    • @justinlynch3
      @justinlynch3 4 года назад +13

      @Cole MacGrath Except for Android 18, completely the wrong voice for that character in Kai, it was terrible. Thankfully Super brought back the original Z voice actor to play 18.

    • @beach2550
      @beach2550 4 года назад +27

      @Cole MacGrath I don't actually agree that it had better voice acting, at least for the Buu saga Vegeta clips I've been watching. Chris Sabat seems like he is just trying to get it over with in Kai, and he seems obviously detached from Vegeta in his performance. In Z, he really feels like Vegeta, going all in with the performance and making it believable. Kai is more of a vocal showcase of their improved technical skills as voice actors, but Z had the conviction and emotion behind the voice. That means much in this show to me

  • @Sizifus
    @Sizifus 3 года назад +505

    For most of Z, Kai really excels in dialogue. This however is not one of those instances

    • @Aikuran
      @Aikuran 3 года назад +6

      Fact

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад +54

      you must not have seen all those instances where z is way better than kai.

    • @kyleh1494
      @kyleh1494 2 года назад +5

      @@theguy3129 like?

    • @DarkClassicGamer
      @DarkClassicGamer 2 года назад +44

      Honestly I think that dbz Kai handled everything better from the saiyan arc to the cell arc. The buu saga was handled worse In kai

    • @joshgauve9044
      @joshgauve9044 2 года назад +11

      @@theguy3129 Typical stubborn Z fanboy, Always mouthing trash to spite other series, But don’t have the sources with them in regards to back up their babbling.

  • @MuteLung
    @MuteLung 3 года назад +68

    Kai's more accurate in tone to the manga, but it fumbles the actual wording of it so hard. Quick transcription for those who don't want to look it up.
    GOKU: Vegeta... You surrendered to Bobbidi's spell on purpose... to make me fight. Am I right?
    VEGETA: If I hadn't, I'd never get to fight you. After today, you're leaving this world forever.
    SHIN: Just... to fight him...? Are you that insane...?!
    VEGETA: "Insane"...?! You think this is "insane"?! Who cares about Buu?!! This is what I live for! ...He... surpassed me...!! He's Saiyan just like me, but he far outstripped me!! Me--the prince!! The strongest of them all!!! Once... he even saved my life!!! I can't stand it!!!! ...I can't...!!!!
    Between this and the famous 'I wanted to go back to the way I was before' speech, there's an edge of desperation for closure and understanding that's absent in Kai's reading of it. As far as Vegeta knows, this is the very last chance he'll ever have to discover why Goku is so powerful despite being so gentle--which is something Vegeta views as a weakness. I could say more but this is an essay already.
    Z completely demolishes Kai here though, holy shit.

    • @adams3560
      @adams3560 2 года назад +12

      So basically neither of them is fully accurate, but Z’s version sounds cooler.

    • @MuteLung
      @MuteLung 2 года назад +6

      @@adams3560 that's anime for ya.

    • @nelson_rebel3907
      @nelson_rebel3907 2 года назад +3

      @@adams3560 sounds more realistic and has the weight of real desperation and rage in it. It makes the conlfict feel like its believable and not just wasteful filler.
      Delivery and wording matters in these

  • @yhwhfearingguy646
    @yhwhfearingguy646 4 года назад +521

    One of the few times I'll honestly say Z wins by a mile. Kai was good but Z is on a different level in terms of dialogue

    • @Sqautter
      @Sqautter 4 года назад +36

      To me kai did better with the frieza saga but I prefer z for the other arcs

    • @0vern9K
      @0vern9K 4 года назад +27

      Z is on a different level when it comes to almost everything

    • @yhwhfearingguy646
      @yhwhfearingguy646 4 года назад +17

      @@Sqautter Yeah Kai killed the frieza saga especially with the original score, Z was only just getting into the game with funimation in that saga so you could tell the acting wasn't nearly as good back then.

    • @necessaryevil2560
      @necessaryevil2560 3 года назад +6

      @@Sqautter most of the dialogue in Kai is better other than most of the Majin vegeta speeches. The original dub was really good with majin vegeta

    • @steffondoyle8071
      @steffondoyle8071 3 года назад +5

      Personally I like the Kai dub better because it’s less cheesy and more realistic. But of course, Z dialogue has moments that can never truly be bested. Like this.

  • @TBAG
    @TBAG 3 года назад +468

    like always, Z wins by a LANDSLIDE

    • @heythereimkike
      @heythereimkike 3 года назад +33

      Dbz kai was just bad with the buu saga

    • @thetrader5235
      @thetrader5235 3 года назад +108

      Definitely not “ like always “ but ok

    • @westong9082
      @westong9082 3 года назад +49

      @@thetrader5235 ikr the old dub sucks balls except for the buu arc

    • @justajobro1266
      @justajobro1266 3 года назад

      Wow you are here yes!!

    • @jamespuso1627
      @jamespuso1627 3 года назад +12

      @@westong9082 I swear to God, even with the Buu sagas improvement a year or so ago a friend of mine who was kinda getting into anime but didn't remember DBZ wanted to rewatch it. I sent him the original Funimation Super Saiyan 3 scene and his response was "damn that voice acting is awful" lol

  • @j062
    @j062 4 года назад +497

    I'm always on Kai's side, but the z dub did this much better.

    • @notisttt1240
      @notisttt1240 3 года назад +57

      @DeeCee 1.Accuracy doesn't mean decent show. If I wrote a decent comic and someone made a series (with my permission of course) that actually perfects any flaws in what I started, then what is better? The half made decent comic, or the perfected series? Your point makes no sense, it's just an obsession over the source material.
      2.No one denied that toriyama started it all with his manga. Noone denied that it's one of the greatest manga out there. Noone denied that the anime came from it. But that doesn't mean it had no room for improvement. A little more emotion here, a filler scene to fill in a huge time gap there (db had a lot of great filler throughout db and dbz, unlike other shows). Improving a show isn't an insult to the source material, it's just an improvement. And obsessive purists like you might be the reason they barely try with this show anymore. As long as it has toriyama in it, you obsess over it.

    • @ZenKrio
      @ZenKrio 3 года назад +24

      The Kai Dub in the Lost Chapters/The Buu Arc felt too much like they were just reading a script. OG DBZ they had no clue what they were doing but made up for it in effort and passion, the script wasn't up to par but they clearly believed and were invested in the acting to make up for it.

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад +4

      @@notisttt1240 No he's right here tho. Kai is a better dub cause it's actually what they said in canonically. Accuracy to the original source does make Kai better. Z dub is barely any different from a fanmade abridged. Unless this argument isn't about Z vs Kai then Kai is the clear winner.

    • @notisttt1240
      @notisttt1240 3 года назад +16

      @@youravictim38 my comment had answers against the 1 point you made, but here you are, repeating the exact same thing the previous guy did, as if constantly repeating the same point is gonna make it right

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад

      @@notisttt1240 You're comment literally doesn't prove that Z is better💀👎 Z dub is only good Cell saga and up with Vegeta with most of the emotional or great lines. while Kai doesn't everything better. Example: Gohan transforming to SSJ2. Instead of him monologuing with himself he build more tension staying silent and then proceeds to give a way better scream than Z dub Gohan. Original Japanese dub was even better than Z dub. SO the fact Kai was more accurate to the original dub is even better. This futher proves why Accuracy means a lot when it comes to dubbing plus false dub can cause a lot of misinformation when talking about series. and many other problems. You're point about a you making a comic is a entirely different situation then people dubbing a show. So you're point was already bad form the start.💀

  • @mg682
    @mg682 3 года назад +191

    A prime example of changing the story a bit that actually enhances it. I don't think everything has to be manga-accurate

    • @fupalover
      @fupalover 2 года назад +2

      Yup

    • @digizilla164
      @digizilla164 2 года назад +6

      @Mordecai Maxwell The super anime made Goku dumb as bricks and regressed him. Super manga Goku isnt really dumb but more of a continuation of how he was in Z.

    • @Sayajin3321
      @Sayajin3321 Год назад

      ​@@digizilla164Yea, the past few arcs were awesome, even compare the scene from Superhero where Goku doesn't know what meditation is to the manga where he's just shocked that Vegeta knows how to meditate.

    • @blueflare3848
      @blueflare3848 3 месяца назад

      Completely agree. This is exactly why. Some changes actually improve the overall scene.

    • @NeoConker626
      @NeoConker626 6 дней назад

      I like both scenes, I'll just say the Z scene IMO wouldn't have fit Kai. Z dub made changes all over the place that make Vegeta less evil at core, more a product of upbringing under Freeza. The manga doesn't really ever "excuse" Vegeta, and his goal for going into the ROSAT was to gain power and kill Goku after the androids. So him being a whiny brat in this scene fits the original depiction of an evil guy forced to settle down, who only came out today for a chance to fight his dead rival lol.

  • @DaSheepKiller
    @DaSheepKiller 3 года назад +93

    I usually prefer Kai, but Z has the better dialogue here. His dialogue in Z actually shows his inner struggles, meanwhile in Kai he's just complaining that Goku beat him (even though the fight was a draw lol).

    • @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World.
      @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World. 3 года назад

      Same

    • @ruturajshiralkar5566
      @ruturajshiralkar5566 3 года назад +3

      Nope Vegeta beat Goku

    • @DaSheepKiller
      @DaSheepKiller 3 года назад +2

      @@ruturajshiralkar5566 That would've been the case if Goku didn't get help, yes.

    • @ruturajshiralkar5566
      @ruturajshiralkar5566 3 года назад +3

      @@DaSheepKiller In their first encounter, Goku was beaten to a pulp. Although Vegeta was forced to retreat, he still won against Goku in their fight.
      In their 2nd Encounter, Vegeta cheated and played Dirty, but still won.

    • @dukinuki9959
      @dukinuki9959 3 года назад +3

      @@ruturajshiralkar5566 He didnt though they both agreed it was a draw

  • @justinlynch3
    @justinlynch3 4 года назад +79

    Between the two easily Z in this one.

  • @YungJaime73
    @YungJaime73 3 года назад +34

    Z portrayed Vegeta like a human being struggling with feelings of anxiety, inadequacy, and frustration. Kai portrayed Vegeta like a collection of tropes. Kai has many things over the original dub but the Majin Vegeta stuff was one of the few things that was gold the first time around.

    • @JSmoothSoul
      @JSmoothSoul Год назад +4

      By this time they were almost on the level of Kai while doing their Funimation adding thing. So in the Buu saga they outdo Kai because they added the right things for a change

  • @thekuriboh275
    @thekuriboh275 2 года назад +25

    Here’s my take in the dubbing; anyone is more than welcome to discuss this with me too:
    Z: In Z, i feel like Funi got more in depth with Vegeta’s emotions rather than his pride, which is what honestly made this scene and character so iconic for the amount of years Z has been out for.
    Kai: Of course, Kai is going to be accurate with the manga/original japanese broadcast. Vegeta’s pride was the main focus: both as a Saiyan and as a fighter. He had always seemed more focused on both his title as the Saiyan Prince as well as his pride as a Saiyan Warrior.
    To kind of sum up what i’m trying to say, I think Z getting into depth with Vegeta’s character was very surprising but also a very nice touch, which is why it takes the win for me in this scene. (I love kai too btw)

    • @NeoConker626
      @NeoConker626 6 дней назад

      Pretty spot on. It's worth pointing out, Z kept adding lines for Vegeta to make him seem a little softer. In the manga, man was ruthless until he had a kid, then he was forced to chill until he snapped here.

  • @themercilesself2898
    @themercilesself2898 4 года назад +237

    imagine the kai animation with Z’s dialog. that would be perfection.

    • @keenan2x19
      @keenan2x19 3 года назад +1

      Facts

    • @konondayo5397
      @konondayo5397 3 года назад +54

      they have the same animation the difference is kai has different colors and saturation and less filler

    • @youthfulgreenbeast3851
      @youthfulgreenbeast3851 3 года назад +34

      Depends on the dialogue. Vast majority of z dialogue sucks

    • @Mr.Nyongo
      @Mr.Nyongo 3 года назад +20

      The fuck?? It's the same animation.

    • @eccentricDuelist
      @eccentricDuelist 3 года назад +6

      Chris Ayres is a way better Frieza but other than that Z beats Kai on the music alone

  • @jamespuso1627
    @jamespuso1627 3 года назад +26

    It's so weird seeing the Kikuchi score on Z and then the Falconer score on Kai lol

    • @randomshiba779
      @randomshiba779 6 месяцев назад +1

      DBZ Kai Faulconer edition slaps. It's on internet archive

  • @the-aspiring-creator4249
    @the-aspiring-creator4249 Год назад +11

    Here's my thing about this, I think the Z dub itself gives Vegeta certainly a much better reason for why he allows Babidi to control him. I like that it actually delves a bit into his anger over having the Saiyan race being nearly extinct, his anger over Freeza ruling over him and his rage over ultimately watching what he views to be trash ascending the food chain... but there are shades of a character here that just isn't what Vegeta is, especially at this point. Vegeta is supposed to be this prideful, petty baby who clearly was raised into believing that he's the top dog, that he is the greatest warrior in this universe. He's raised to believe that those with low power levels are pathetic and not worth considering... and Goku completely shattered those ideas and because of it, he's in a mad dash to try and find out why he's so strong, why "Kakarrot", the low-class trash is just better than him with him never stopping to consider that it's because whereas that man trains every day and fights only to defeat himself, he has been given shortcuts, he was born into power and only thinks about what he thinks he's owed and not what's actually important and just when one thinks he has put all that bullshit behind him with Goku's sacrifice, he comes back and it reopens that old wound. This is not intended to be a high point for Vegeta, not a moment of understandable rage brought out by his internalized agony over the miserable life he led... it's meant to be the sad low of what is basically his midlife crisis. His realization that in the years he has spent since Goku's death that he actually liked living the quiet life and how he so desperately wants to prove he isn't. To me it's what makes a line like "To a Saiyan, PRIDE IS ALL!" hit harder than "What do you know of meaningless?!". Because it more clearly conveys how Vegeta is in a way trying to force himself to regress back into his old ways of thinking.
    The dub's still solid to be fair, this was the point where vocal delivery was much better among the dub cast and I'll grant that there are issues that might be keeping the Kai dub from reaching its full potential but personally? I think for the accuracy and the delivery the Kai dub is great here. It gets to the core of what this scene is supposed to be instead of trying to make Vegeta come off as this sympathetic character.

    • @NeoConker626
      @NeoConker626 6 дней назад

      One weird thing for me with the old Z dub was it never could decide if Vegeta cared about the destruction of his planet lol. In the sub he literally says more than once that he doesn't, so it's kinda odd that he's crying about the race "dwindling" here.

  • @YungandRekless545
    @YungandRekless545 4 года назад +50

    I feel like Kai was a vast improvement on the original until the Buu saga. I don't know how, but Kai just dropped the ball so badly after all those years of anticipation. The soundtrack got worse, the pacing of certain scenes was so rushed that the voice acting almost overlapped different takes, even the dialogue which really improved characters like Frieza took a drop in quality. Just feels like they took a small step backward.

    • @xxstealerxx
      @xxstealerxx 3 года назад +3

      yeah it was good up until the buu saga then it went to shit in both japanese and english. Unfortunate

    • @darling..............
      @darling.............. 2 года назад

      Atleast kai got a sick soundtrack that it only it got in the kid buu vs ss2 goku part

    • @zenitsuthunder3946
      @zenitsuthunder3946 2 года назад +1

      or maybe the FUNI dub in buu saga was just really good.

    • @kaiocrap6965
      @kaiocrap6965 2 года назад

      Lol

    • @rorschach1985ify
      @rorschach1985ify 2 года назад +2

      @@zenitsuthunder3946 This mostly. Say what you want about the early Funi days, but the Buu saga was where they really improved and got a handle of both the characters they voiced and their dialogue to the point they did it close close to perfect and even expanded on the characters in ways the original manga and Japanese version did not. When they had to do it again they really could not improve on what they already did better with.

  • @aaronhigh1923
    @aaronhigh1923 4 года назад +54

    When it comes down to it, Script and Voice acting go to Z. Coming from a voice actor (and this isn’t a stab a Chris Sabat, he’s played vegeta for multiple years, vegeta has a gritty voice so it’s normal over that course of time his voice would change and certain things will be harder to do) But you can really feel Vegeta’s emotion through his Z speech and really pin point the things that are bothering him, angering him and Infuriating him just by how he emphasized some of his words. “I” have in me the blood of a Saiyan Prince “HE” is nothing but a “JOKE” “MY” destiny “THROWN TO THE WAY SIDE”, when stating that goku even saved him like a helpless child he pauses and flinches in his voice indicating how hard it is for him to even say what he’s saying out of possible embarrassment and then the final “He has stolen my honor” and “his debt...MUST BE PAID” it’s almost like with his first line he said it with his breath like he got everything off his chest in one sentence, all the pain and anguish he’s been feeling and once he’s turns to Goku he infuriatingly states he will pay for what he’s done, mix all that with Chris Sabats young and fresh dark and grottle fried voice, the amazing original script and Bruce Faulconers always enjoyable music score this scene is almost enough to make you stop breathing for a second, like you feel everything. Plus Vegeta literally sounds like a possessed maniac which is exactly what he’s supposed to sound like. On the ship Vegeta sounded calm, cool, collected and very confident in himself but after his possession which was to give him the strength and drive he yearned for to kill goku, he got exactly that and it almost sounds like he can’t even control himself anymore. Kai just doesn’t hit that mark, the music definitely helps set the tone but it just falls short, sounds more like a child complaining about wanting a rematch on fortnite, it doesn’t feel like a speech given by a man who’s lost it all, clawed his way to where he is and standing before the only other man that’s keeping him from reaching the top. Z will ALWAYS be legendary for doing it all right the first time

    • @triiodide7762
      @triiodide7762 3 года назад +5

      For this scene maybe. But overall, Kai has miles better voice acting and dialogue. Z had a lot of weird acting and dialogue choices that made scenes feel like they weren't serious

    • @aaronhigh1923
      @aaronhigh1923 3 года назад +6

      Very subjective but I have to disagree. As a matter of fact I deal it’s the complete opposite. I’m not saying each doesn’t have their personal flaws but overall, in my opinion, the script and acting for some characters was done way better in Z than Kai. I even think the “polish” they put in the show kinda killed its overall vibe. Again, me personally.

    • @TheShockVox
      @TheShockVox 3 года назад

      @@aaronhigh1923 Chris: “I’m not gonna pretend that wasn’t a really crappy dub” (referring to Z)

    • @sprtsfanatic1
      @sprtsfanatic1 3 года назад +1

      💯 agree to your points on this scene breakdown. I do really enjoy Chris Ayers, RIP, take on Frieza though. But I don’t dislike Linda Young’s version either. They’re very different personalities with their respective voices. For me, personally, and this is def due to nostalgia, not hearing the gritty 90s-early 2000s Faulconer tracks on Kai also is a big letdown. I know that they kept it much more akin to the manga, even adding the Japanese music, but I’m just not a huge fan of it. I did enjoy the music for SSJ2 Gohan in Japanese but I prefer Faulconer’s score for all of Z

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад

      @@TheShockVox Form your own reasons and opinions. Don't worry about what Sabat said.

  • @powdereyes2210
    @powdereyes2210 3 года назад +220

    dragon ball Z understoond Vegeta's character more than Kai did

    • @cyberianknight19yearsago25
      @cyberianknight19yearsago25 3 года назад +35

      Yep, and Ironically in terms of dialogue Kai was more faithful towards the original manga

    • @powdereyes2210
      @powdereyes2210 3 года назад

      @@cyberianknight19yearsago25 sorry for not seeing this comment for 2 weeks

    • @PatLund
      @PatLund 3 года назад +41

      That's actually not true. What Vegeta says in the Kai dub is much closer to what he says in the original Japanese and the manga. So that means the Kai dub understands his character better.

    • @matthieu21mm20
      @matthieu21mm20 3 года назад +4

      I mean Sabat directed the voice acting for both and he’s the voice of Vegeta...

    • @fridaynightnicktoons6885
      @fridaynightnicktoons6885 3 года назад +3

      @@PatLund I really drew manga and Kai is NOT closer. That’s a myth funimation made to sel dvds. Just like the orange bricks Kai is a false advertisement

  • @thaddeuscheeleyjr.369
    @thaddeuscheeleyjr.369 3 года назад +12

    Kai makes this sound more petty than it is. Revenge for someone beating you or succeeding where you don't is already petty, but Z at least makes it seem like Vegeta has relatable reasons. Kai makes Vegeta sound like, "waahh, I'm a saiyan too, why can't I be as strong as Kakarot?! Its not fair!"
    Like, this is a grown mad who's killed thousands and is a survivor of a mass extinction we're talking about here, and he sounds like my cousin when he was 6 and he would complain to my mom when I wouldn't let him play my Xbox when he was over.

    • @NeoConker626
      @NeoConker626 6 дней назад

      That's actually the point. And it's more than thousands, man was a genocider by trade. But this is rock bottom for him, a complete ego tantrum. He saw Goku exceed him in power, and he also felt Goku's time slipping away as they pursued Babidi, and he just had a petty af snap. He's not supposed to be relatable here lol

  • @jaredsterling1302
    @jaredsterling1302 2 года назад +16

    “That is an indignity I CANNOT BEAR” saves the scene at the end for Kai but I think I feel that way because I have context with the original. I’ve been watching both and there truly are many scenes/episodes where each show does better than the other. Watching both is truly the way to go if u have the time.

    • @lookie4448
      @lookie4448 Год назад

      that line fits so much better, the debts must be paid sounds way too cheesy, even if i like the original dub in this scene more than kai, overall.

    • @kedryckjames2021
      @kedryckjames2021 6 месяцев назад

      I also agree because "his debt must be paid" sounds silly considering this line usually means the debt paid is taking his opponents life, and Goku is already dead.

    • @kedryckjames2021
      @kedryckjames2021 6 месяцев назад

      I also agree because "his debt must be paid" sounds silly considering this line usually means the debt paid is taking his opponents life, and Goku is already dead.

  • @claymournesden8705
    @claymournesden8705 3 года назад +25

    Wow, they really did Vegeta DIRTY in Kai. Almost every speech of his I see is almost always more heartfelt and emotional in dbz.

  • @theguy3129
    @theguy3129 2 года назад +18

    0:14 - 0:17 this exact dialogue and the line delivery shows Vegeta has literally lost his shit. Completely demolishes anything Kai has to offer in the entire scene.

  • @hyperionsf3220
    @hyperionsf3220 2 года назад +8

    I like how Goku keeps coming back to life in random scenes, then dying again. Like.....oh a halo! Oh! Where'd it go? Oh! It's back! Oh, there it goes again...

    • @lokcoadv
      @lokcoadv 29 дней назад

      Foreshadowing...

  • @metalfury123
    @metalfury123 4 года назад +22

    Voice: Kai
    Script: z
    If you put them together you get a masterpiece but yeah i think z wins.

    • @fridaynightnicktoons6885
      @fridaynightnicktoons6885 4 года назад +4

      Kai's voice is wierd. It's so forced

    • @metalfury123
      @metalfury123 4 года назад +3

      @@fridaynightnicktoons6885 I'd argue it's the opposite chris sabat has said that when he was dubbing dbz for the first time everyone loved brian drummond so he tried his best to make it sound like him whereas in kai and super it's more natural to him.

    • @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World.
      @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World. 3 года назад

      @@fridaynightnicktoons6885 It sounds the opposite

    • @fridaynightnicktoons6885
      @fridaynightnicktoons6885 3 года назад

      @@The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World. I’m trying to have a legit discussion and ya’ll just wanna troll and say kid better when it’s objectively phoned in. My god. Nobody argue with them they’re probably 13 or some shit.

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад +1

      @@fridaynightnicktoons6885 yep. Z's voice seems more natural.

  • @infamoushiphop7943
    @infamoushiphop7943 2 года назад +9

    Kai makes him seem really 1 dimensional. While the original u can hear the pain in vegetas voice and suits the animation perfectly.

  • @ToonfieldAnimations
    @ToonfieldAnimations Год назад +6

    0:06 vegeta is so intimidating goku lost his halo

  • @vegaswithdrawal4132
    @vegaswithdrawal4132 4 года назад +49

    How come Faulconers music plays in Kai but not in the original Z version? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Anyway, Z definitely was more captivating. The Kai version either feels phoned in or trying too hard at times.

    • @JinzoFiter
      @JinzoFiter 4 года назад +11

      The Kai clip in this vid is a fan edit with Faulconer's music. The actual episode has the Sumitomo score they used for the Buu Saga.

    • @vegaswithdrawal4132
      @vegaswithdrawal4132 4 года назад +5

      @@JinzoFiter I'm just pointing out the irony.

    • @Mauri2rawww
      @Mauri2rawww 3 года назад

      @@vegaswithdrawal4132 but Original Dbz clip is a true clip, I don’t know why but when I rewatched dbz it had the Japanese ost I think it’s a remaster or something, and I don’t think dbz kai uses the Japanese music at least for the dub

    • @cameronoverton5717
      @cameronoverton5717 2 года назад

      He likely switched the OSTs around in order to give people a better perspective on the voice acting, in case they were biased in favor of the Faulconer score.

    • @kaiocrap6965
      @kaiocrap6965 2 года назад

      True

  • @MusicLover-my6fo
    @MusicLover-my6fo 3 года назад +13

    Despite Kai having more touched/fixed animation, neither Z nor Kai noticed that Goku's halo is missing at 1:15

  • @frupunrounin738
    @frupunrounin738 Год назад +4

    DBZ's dub, Vegeta has a lot to prove. From a young age he'd been told that he would be the one to rule Planet Vegeta, that he'd be the strongest and most powerful among their people. The planet and most of their people were destroyed. He was then placed under Freeza's rule. His role as a prince no longer mattered. Now he was a simple underling. The only thing he could cling onto was his strength and then he was bested in that by someone who he views as infinitely lower than him. Now he has nothing to cling onto. His destiny as a prince and the strongest Saiyan was thrown to the wayside. Now he must prove that he is the strongest by beating the one who took the only thing he had left to cling onto.
    DBZ Kai's speech on the other hand refers to Vegeta's pride being shattered. He believed himself to be the strongest among the Saiyans only to be greatly outshined by someone infinitely lower than him. "Even a low class can beat an elite, if he trains hard enough": Vegeta is constantly trying to prove that statement to be false by trying to outshine Kakarot, to prove that he is ELITE and that a LOW CLASS WARRIOR can never beat him but the simple fact is, Goku is just better than him. But Vegeta can never accept this fact thus his tantrum here.
    I don't believe Toriyama's original intention for this scene was for it to be a deep look at Vegeta's past and what it's built up to till this point, like DBZ's dub, but simply Vegeta holding a childish grudge.

  • @Yung94Man
    @Yung94Man 2 года назад +8

    Both speeches show vegetas selfishness to go to such extreme lengths to attain more power but the z version makes it more justified and you sympathize with him more because if you stop and think about it he has been through so much

  • @kyrian7600
    @kyrian7600 13 дней назад +1

    “He has stolen my honor and his debt must be paid” 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @clintongillespie9895
    @clintongillespie9895 4 года назад +15

    To a SAYAIN pride is everything

  • @Fonz128
    @Fonz128 3 года назад +7

    "You killed countless innocents to try and repair your foolish pride."
    Whoa Supreme Kai is BASED!

  • @விஷ்ணு_கார்த்திக்

    Virgin Kai Vegeta: *"ThAt iS aN InDiGniTy I CaNnOt BeAr"*
    CHAD Z Vegeta: *"And his debts MUST BE PAID!"*

  • @ChiChoo29
    @ChiChoo29 4 года назад +35

    I love Kai, but I agree that Z owns this scene

    • @dripgoku1174
      @dripgoku1174 3 года назад +1

      Z is the best in my opinion

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 2 года назад

      @@dripgoku1174 Literally is.

    • @kaiocrap6965
      @kaiocrap6965 2 года назад

      @@dripgoku1174 facts

  • @DanielLopes-dh2hv
    @DanielLopes-dh2hv 3 года назад +6

    The DBZ one is WAY better, you can understand what vegeta is feelling and he explains it in a way I can't explain. In the Kai version he's just acting like a baby or kid when looses

  • @Articade-oi3nt
    @Articade-oi3nt Месяц назад +1

    Not going to lie, both dialogs are great here, but "His debts... must be paid!" Hits way harder in DBZ

  • @illsologamer
    @illsologamer 2 года назад +3

    "What has more meaning than your own strength?" That alone is a giant FU to the Kai's simple version.

  • @riveraharper8166
    @riveraharper8166 6 месяцев назад +1

    OG Sabbat: I'll show to that japanese version!
    Kai Sabbat: let's get this over with.

  • @clintongillespie9895
    @clintongillespie9895 4 года назад +10

    He has stolen my honor and I want it back

  • @Koohai
    @Koohai 2 года назад +4

    I prefer Kai over Z overall but I love the Buu saga in the original DBZ dub more more than Final Chapters. Especially with scenes like this one.

  • @hyperbolicathletes
    @hyperbolicathletes 3 года назад +7

    The dbz scene didn’t even have the music with it and yet it still beat Kai by a landslide

  • @vanillabeans32087
    @vanillabeans32087 2 года назад +2

    Supreme Kai's 'Who ARE you people?!' in Z is perfect, haha. It's so.. flabbergasted

  • @GeteMachine
    @GeteMachine Год назад +4

    This is the one scene I think is better in the original. The wording sounds smoother, more personal for Vegeta. Because he is referencing things that happened prior in the series, sounded contemplative, where as Kai he just sounds like hes only mad because Goku just got stronger first.

  • @calebkent6706
    @calebkent6706 3 месяца назад +1

    Heres what kais shouldve been (small tweaks go a long way)
    Gohan : Vegeta Stop! This isnt you-
    Vegeta : [knocks away Gohan] SILENCE! This does not concern you! This is between me and Kakarot!
    Goku : i wont fight you vegeta not now!.
    Vegeta : [blasts the arena] You'll fight with me, Kakarot! Unless of course, you'd like more blood on your hands.
    Goku : Vegeta! Certainly you wouldnt!... How sad. I didn't think you were weak enough to be controlled.
    Gohan : Dad, don't!
    Goku : vegeta, answer me! Do you let yourself be a slave?
    [Vegeta blasts the arena again]
    Vegeta : Tell me... Is it slavery when you get what you want?
    (Goku goes ssj)
    Supreme Kai : No, Goku! You cant fight Vegeta……if you fight him. The injuries he gives you will mean provide more power to babadis ship and Majin Buu will be revived!
    Goku : Tell me, Vegeta. Was that stamp on your head worth it, I know Babidi's been the one giving you orders. Is this one of them? or is this all go back the same old story between you and me?
    Gohan : Does it really matter right now Dad?
    Vegeta : Not to you, Gohan. But to a warrior, it matters greatly. And you know this as well as I do, Kakarot. In a day, you'll be back to the dead, and I will not miss this opportunity!
    Supreme Kai : That was your plan!? To kill countless people in hopes to fight goku and satisfy your meaningless pride?
    Vegeta : (growls)………MEANINGLESS, HUH? WHAT DO YOU KNOW OF MEANINGLESS? Spend most of your life ruled by another! Watch your race dwindle to a handful! AND THEN, tell me what has more meaning than your own strength! I have in me the blood of a Saiyan prince. He is nothing but a peasant! Yet I've had to watch him surpass me in strength, my destiny thrown to the wayside! He's... he's even saved my life like I were helpless. He has stolen my honor, and his debts... must be paid!

  • @rassilontdavros3004
    @rassilontdavros3004 4 года назад +24

    I can't believe that _I'm_ saying this, but I actually like the original dub better here. Which almost _never_ happens, in my case at least. Neither one is perfect, but Sabat showed a lot of raw emotion that is nowhere to be found in Kai's version. Weird, since for the most part people seemed to refine their portrayals over the years.

    • @xxstealerxx
      @xxstealerxx 3 года назад +2

      Kai Buu saga was dogshit all around tbh. The dialogue seemed much worse than Z and Kai for the cell saga

    • @lapplandkun9273
      @lapplandkun9273 3 года назад +1

      I mean it did. Kai improved the voicing in Frieza saga

    • @EnoYaka
      @EnoYaka 2 года назад +1

      I feel like all of Kai's voice actors have gotten worse.. yeah some of the dialogue is better, but the voice acting and feeling is better in Z

    • @fridaynightnicktoons6885
      @fridaynightnicktoons6885 2 года назад

      @@EnoYaka yeah Kai just sounds like they’re talking faster,but less natural

  • @cloudsz4743
    @cloudsz4743 4 года назад +17

    hail z

  • @lightning116
    @lightning116 5 месяцев назад +1

    "I don't like the Kai version. It makes Vegeta sound whiny."
    Uh, YES? Cause Vegeta _was_ being a whiny little man-child.
    That was the point.

  • @kyleh1494
    @kyleh1494 2 года назад +12

    Even as someone who prefers Kai, Z really nailed this scene. Sure, Kai’s more accurate to the original dialogue, but it’s much more emotional in Z

  • @NaturalStateDepths
    @NaturalStateDepths 4 месяца назад +1

    Z makes you see where Vegeta is coming from, but Kai just makes Vegeta sound like an entitled brat.

  • @brianlaureus
    @brianlaureus 2 года назад +3

    The original dub gets so much hate when a lot of the changes they made at least in later seasons weren’t that bad. Damn near all of vegetas speeches were better in the original in my opinion.

  • @MelonGrace
    @MelonGrace 2 года назад +2

    "Vegeta just comes off as a jealous baby in kai"
    Toriyama : Shush.

  • @hahaimasian
    @hahaimasian 2 года назад +3

    I like both. And japanese version. I can rewatch them all.

  • @camacaze199
    @camacaze199 3 месяца назад +1

    Z: A tortured anti-hero desperately searching for power any way he can
    Kai: A petulant child
    The original dub has a bit more of a grand opera vibe to it which I prefer

  • @HygorBH
    @HygorBH 3 года назад +16

    People say that the DBZ speech was better and Kai's was "Vegeta is just bitching", but that's just it. Vegeta was _just_ bitching. That was the biggest flaw of his during that time. His thirst to defeat Goku was so big, he allowed himself to be "controlled" just to become stronger and fight him. While the Z dub can make fans see where he's coming from, the "right way" is not to make fans feel bad for Vegeta, but actively hate him like Kai did.

  • @Haymdahl
    @Haymdahl 4 месяца назад +1

    'Pride is all' - Vegeta backing Pride month.

  • @okay6703
    @okay6703 3 года назад +3

    I never thought about the fact that since Goku was still dead, powering up to ssj3 to fight vegeta would’ve probably wasted the rest of his time he had left

  • @Montesama314
    @Montesama314 6 месяцев назад +1

    The Kai speech focuses on pettier, individualized grievance, focusing more on Vegeta's personal pride. The Z speech reflects more on how LIFE seems to beat him up, not just Goku, affecting his pride as a Saiyan turned "endangered species".
    He loses his birthright, his home, and any freedom from dictatorial edict, but scrapes out an existence anyway... And then some total reject leftover of his race not only survives too, but continues to outpace him, making his life of struggle and his Saiyan super-elite status (one of the only things he has left) seemingly be treated like a joke!
    The slights dealt upon him by Goku and his life in general would equally make a prideful man like Vegeta want to lash out. If Vegeta sounds like he's just being a petty bitch, I think that's the point.

  • @Lordecai
    @Lordecai 3 года назад +3

    Vegeta forgetting he killed 1/3rd of the remaining saiyans on Earth

  • @fellowninja
    @fellowninja 5 месяцев назад +1

    People like to poopoo on the OG series because of how long they spent building things up, sometimes over several episodes. What they don't realize is it's deliberate, and without the build up it makes things just worse. Best example is Vegeta's Final Flash. It's called Final Flash because it's final. It's all his energy focused into a single beam. It's super impractical because of how long it takes, and it's Vegeta abusing his cocky genes that are in Cell. Kai and Super turned it into just any old move, and it misses the point.

  • @theimprovedbore550
    @theimprovedbore550 3 года назад +4

    if kai merged what they had in the og dub with the manga it wouldve been perfect

  • @tishoostars
    @tishoostars 2 месяца назад +1

    A very, VERY rare instance of the original dub having better timing and emotion than Kai imo. "WHAT DO YOU KNOW OF MEANINGLESS" and the speech that follows was accidentally hard af

  • @4iss.22
    @4iss.22 3 года назад +9

    Kai: Better dub work
    Z: Better dialog

  • @SamsarasArt
    @SamsarasArt 3 года назад +6

    The original speech was far superior. The words used and especially how they were said exuded passion. You get a good look at vegeta's psyche when listening. The kai version just seems off, it doesn't feel as believable. It's like they were trying to top z by being more dramatic but it didn't work. It came off as hokey.

  • @thewhiteknight9923
    @thewhiteknight9923 3 года назад +3

    Dbz gave more emotion while dbz kai gave more depth to how hard the power gap hit him

  • @jae3276
    @jae3276 2 месяца назад +1

    Since when did Kai have faulconer music lol. Love it tho

  • @SrMatheusMartins
    @SrMatheusMartins 2 года назад +6

    "My foolish pride? To a sayan pride is all!!!"
    That scene is amazing!

    • @theguy3129
      @theguy3129 Год назад +3

      It sounds cringe af. Z did this scene way better.

    • @IsaiahStickman
      @IsaiahStickman Год назад

      @@theguy3129 nah fam

    • @george721gr
      @george721gr Год назад +1

      ​@@IsaiahStickman yes fam

    • @IsaiahStickman
      @IsaiahStickman Год назад

      @@george721gr bruh no

    • @george721gr
      @george721gr Год назад +1

      @@IsaiahStickmanhe sounds much more annoying in Kai

  • @kcawks8585
    @kcawks8585 7 месяцев назад +1

    DBZ showed the more tragic side of Vegeta. While the Kai version focused more on Vegeta’s pride of himself. Kai in my opinion is more accurate to his character, but DBZ just feels so raw.

  • @ThatBoiDarius_
    @ThatBoiDarius_ 3 года назад +3

    What’s the Theme that plays in Kais version I know it’s Vegetas Theme but which version is it?

    • @BranVR
      @BranVR  3 года назад

      idk sorry, from what everyone is screaming in the comments, the site i nabbed these clips from didnt use correct scores for either, but idk, i wasnt paying attention to that kind of thing when i threw this together years ago

    • @BeholdMyStrength
      @BeholdMyStrength 3 года назад +1

      It's an unreleased track from the Faulconer score, that first played when Vegeta wakes up from his nap on Namek and finds Gohan and Krillin using the dragonballs. Coycoy88 did a rip of the song and named it "Vegeta's Anger". Here's a link for ya.
      ruclips.net/video/v6apdmz38W0/видео.html&ab_channel=coycoy88

  • @MR_DUALITY
    @MR_DUALITY 2 года назад +1

    I grew up watching Z on tv pand this scene still feels so real. Feels like everything built up for this very moment

  • @SGCentral
    @SGCentral 4 года назад +13

    The voice acting in Kai is better, but the script is way more interesting in Z.
    You feel why Goku’s superior strength haunts Vegeta in Z, whereas Kai’s dialogue kinda sounds like a generic bad guy, which is far from how I would categorize Vegeta

    • @TBAG
      @TBAG 4 года назад +3

      The voice acting in Kai sounds like the actors have done this a million times already and can't wait to leave the studio and go home. Sounds like they are bored as hell. Especially piccolo lol

    • @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World.
      @The_Man_Who_Sold_the_World. 3 года назад +1

      @@TBAG Fr

  • @callmemrd1
    @callmemrd1 2 месяца назад

    This is absolute peak writing, why newer versions of the show(second half of this episode) change iconic lines is beyond me. This is my favorite moment in the entire series

  • @bassettehound
    @bassettehound 3 года назад +4

    Gotta give this one to z

  • @steffondoyle8071
    @steffondoyle8071 3 года назад +1

    “WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE!? DON’T YOU SEE THE UNIVERSE MATTERS MORE THAN YOUR MEANINGLESS SQUABBLE!?”
    “THAT was your reasoning!? You killed countless innocents to try and repair your foolish pride!?”
    Can’t decide which one I like better. Never been a fan of Supreme Kai’s, but it’s kinda hard to not feel for him here. He just trying to do his job and keep the universe safe, which is the most logical thing to do in their situation. Yet, he has to work with powerful, but incredibly shortsighted fools who can’t man up and set their pride aside and pull together.

  • @Josh-di3zo
    @Josh-di3zo 4 года назад +4

    If you believe Kai did it better check yourself into a mental institution

  • @semihtv6004
    @semihtv6004 Год назад +1

    I myself would go with the original Version, but the Kai Version is not weak either. To fully understand it, stick with me for a moment + let's just twist a little bit and say that Vegeta did all that to safe his son Trunks. (It is a very human thing to do - doing bad things to protects something like your baby child. We humans can understand this because we value familiy bonds more then anything less.)
    Now imagine the Kaioshin says something like "What? You did all that for your foolish son?" - if you watch the scene again with that in mind you could completely understand Vegetas reaction right?
    How pissed would you be in this moment in Vegetas shoes? That is how Vegeta reacts when Kaioshin tells him"What? You did all that to repair your foolish pride?" -> He is extremely pissed, because he values Pride more than anything else. THAT is what Sayajin Pride is and the Kai Version explains it perfectly with that scene.

  • @BballNintendo3
    @BballNintendo3 3 года назад +11

    Kai is overall the better version of the story but there are some scenes including this one where Z is by far superior

  • @blueflare3848
    @blueflare3848 3 месяца назад +1

    Man, they really butchered his speech in Kai, huh? In Kai he sounds like a whiny child. In DBZ you actually understand where he’s coming from and why he’s so resentful.

  • @E2000-o5n
    @E2000-o5n 3 года назад +3

    For someone who liked kai more than z even I have to agree z did better in the buu arc

  • @The_Isaiahnator
    @The_Isaiahnator Год назад

    It's cool that you swapped the music (presumably to get a fairer opinion of the dialogue).

    • @BranVR
      @BranVR  Год назад +1

      ......you should really read the pinned comment.

    • @The_Isaiahnator
      @The_Isaiahnator Год назад

      @@BranVR
      Haha, thanks.

  • @DemetriusPooleJr
    @DemetriusPooleJr 4 года назад +3

    As a fan of dragonball
    Z wins the dialog for vegeta sounds good but Kai its meh but hey Kai looks good tho
    I mean ay you like what you like if you like Kai kool and if you like Z kool.

  • @TyTurner1996
    @TyTurner1996 2 года назад +2

    I'll stick with Z. "And his DEBTS... MUST BE PAAAID!"

  • @dwdw781
    @dwdw781 2 года назад +3

    I'm sorry to anybody that like the kai version but how the hell can you compare.

  • @waveythoughtsandtalks6432
    @waveythoughtsandtalks6432 Год назад +2

    I’m currently rewatching kai cuz it’s shorter and I don’t feel like waiting 5 episodes for Goku to throw a spirit bomb buuuut I came to this video cuz when I got to this scene I didn’t remember him saying any of this… the dragon ball Z version of this scene is infinitely better. I was let down when he never says “WHAT DO YOU KNOW OF MEANINGLESS????”

  • @jaytrillzz5110
    @jaytrillzz5110 3 года назад +13

    Dialogue is something funimation just doesnt understand anymore.

    • @ZenKrio
      @ZenKrio 3 года назад +6

      Theyre matching the sub more closely, in the original dub their translations were off and it was more about filling mouth flaps, but because of this they were a lot more passionate and made up for their lack of skill with raw emotion.

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад +5

      The only person who had great dialogue in Z was Vegeta💀Goku and everyone else sucked in Z. Kai was far better in voice acting

    • @ZenKrio
      @ZenKrio 3 года назад +4

      @@youravictim38 Z Kai I'd agree with you for sure but watching clips of what they called the Lost Chapters or Buu Saga Kai there was a lot less passion there. Like, it's so bad compared to the OG dub, likely because by now they just don't care as much.

    • @youravictim38
      @youravictim38 3 года назад

      @@ZenKrio That's true

    • @awsomeboy360
      @awsomeboy360 3 года назад

      @@ZenKrio They do care lmfao.

  • @alexanderthered5603
    @alexanderthered5603 2 года назад +1

    I mean... I literally just read this in the manga a few days ago, and Kai is far closer than Z in regards to dialogue. I get why people like the Z one better and thought that Kai Vegeta was whiny but... yeah, he was whiny in the Canon source. He had to work through some crap, and that was part of it. It wasn't about being oppressed or any of the reasoning Z created, but simply wanting to surpass Goku. He could not stand that Goku was better than him, hence why he accepted Bobbity's control. It's what made his dialogue at the end of the arc so impactful, when he acknowledged and accepted that Goku was better and the champ.

  • @RenoDantres
    @RenoDantres 3 года назад +9

    These scenes are so hard to watch without the Faulconer score.

    • @RenoDantres
      @RenoDantres 3 года назад +1

      @Kid Synthesize I hope you're joking.

  • @mxgross
    @mxgross 11 месяцев назад

    I still remember when Vegeta cared only about proving that he was the strongest fighter in the universe. Even as a kid, his status as the heir to the throne of Planet Vegeta, along with the praise he received when ever he succeeded at completing a mission, served to bolster his ego, to the point where he believed that he alone was entitled to be ruler of the Universe. It wasn't until the final battle with Kid Buu that the cocky prince finally accepted that there will always be someone better.

  • @W_C_M_III
    @W_C_M_III 4 года назад +3

    I can say z Is way better then kai. The way vegeta gives his speech is better makes it more interesting and invested instead. But the voice actors of kai is better z hands down

    • @andrewvincent7299
      @andrewvincent7299 3 года назад +1

      The voices of kid Gohan and 18 in Kai were awful and really hurt the show.

  • @andrewgarfield9898
    @andrewgarfield9898 3 месяца назад

    What a plot twist. You play the Kai scene with the falconer score but the original doesn’t have it💀💀💀

  • @simphiwe4930
    @simphiwe4930 4 года назад +8

    Did Kai actually use Faulconer music in that scene... Damn💭 Still Z.

    • @JinzoFiter
      @JinzoFiter 3 года назад +6

      They didn't. The clip in this video is a fan edit.

    • @ok6114
      @ok6114 3 года назад

      Yes exactly what I was wondering

    • @robertisham5279
      @robertisham5279 3 года назад

      @@JinzoFiter Yeah I thought so

  • @SMABackup
    @SMABackup 4 года назад +1

    Vegeta was a prince whose honour was taken from him when a pauper saved and surpassed him