In case you missed it, my 30-minute Nebula Original video about Macau is out now. Sign up now to CuriosityStream to watch it: curiositystream.com/polymatter
Please come to Tibet and have a look. 99% of tibetans don't care about him except americans you never come to Tibet ？ruclips.net/video/Wvo8MXny5XI/видео.html
@Alex Mercer The Mongolian conquered Tibet, then it fell. Tibet was independent until the Manchurian conquered, then it fell. Tibet had become independent from 1912 to 1951 .Mao of China invaded Tibet 1951 .
China has stated that they will use the Golden Urn to choose the next dalai lama. the Golden Urn method was devised by Emperor QIanlong in 1792, and was already used to choose the 10th 11th and 12th dalai lama. It's funny how people are wiling to believe a fairy tale just to be anti-China, reincarnation is not real, it's simply a political tool for the theocratic lama class to stay in power in feudal tibet. The selection process for the Pope is much more logical and honest.
@Alex Mercer I am an atheist myself but as someone who is a lover of freedom and liberty I believe people should be free to practice their faith without the influence from political cults such as Communism and Fascism.
@@freeman10000 You should read history, or observe the middle east. When you loose control, the religious force will try to get their way with politics. Childish.
Ty YT no no, it's okay. Christians in their beliefs know he never reincarnated, as his body had the scars from the crucifix. If he ever returns back will be more complex that a simple new body.
to put it simply: the Fire Nation wants to control the reincarnation of the Avatar so that it doesn't arise from the Air Nomads again, but if the Fire Nation appoints a Pro-Fire Nation Avatar, a religious war could spark between the Fire Nation and The Air Nomads.
I think you forgot to mention about the 11th Panchen Lama, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, which according to the tradition is the one supposed to be choosing the next Dalai Lama. He was ‘protected’ by the CCP after chosen by the current Dalai Lama in 1989 and has been the youngest political prisoner in the world ever since. That is the reason why the next Dalai Lama may not be found/chosen/legitimate. The CCP may release him as the new ‘leader’ of Tibet after the current Dalai Lama though. After his ‘re-education’, of course. (For more you can look it up on wikipedia)
Yet... the Panchen Lama fought against the Dalai Lama during the 1930 Tibetan Civil War... Assuming those two are the same souls reincarnating... that's got to have started a recent grudge.
Actually the show only shows us how the Air Nomads identify the Avatar. I'd be willing to guess the Earth and Fire nations might do something similar to China's approach
In fact, some of the characters have their names based on the Dalai Lama. Both Tenzin, and monk Gyatso. The 14th (current) Dalai Lama's name _is_ Tenzin Gyatso.
i would love to read the CCP Bible pharaohs enslaved the jews, with approval from the CCP moses led jews from egypt and split the water, with approval from the CCP romans crucified jesus, with approval from the CCP
God: Jesus, my Son, You will reincarnate on the third day after Your act of salvation from the cross. Jesus: Why on the third day Father? God: Because we have to file an application of reincarnation first....
"a database of officially sanctioned Buddhas"... one must "submit an application for reincarnation to the government for approval"... "reincarnation must comply with Chinese laws"... man, the Chinese government really struggles to grasp some of the fundamental tenets of Buddhism, eh? Either that or they're trying to co-opt it.
Kind of important to mention that this isnt new by any means, the rulers have been meddeling in this process for a long time. This time it's just more coercive. Chinese emperors usually "helped" when the panchem or dalai lama couldnt do it on their own.
Yes! Rulers have struck the hands of Catholic School students since time immemorial. And the Nuns wielding them look so much alike, that they may be older without reincarnation than civlilizations. And Olympians have been medaling (note the spelling, before meddling further with your keyboard) since ancient Grease slipped away.
Why didn't you mention the Panchen Lama? It's kinda a huge part of the selection process and very relevant as the Chinese government kidnapped the child the Dalai Lama chose as the 11th Panchen Lama and have chosen their own one.
There is the Punchen Drunk, staggering around after boxing matches The And the Drunken Punch, which Jackie Chan popularized in an early movie. And Proof of Reincarnation, Louie Armstrong sung "Hello, Dalai" decades ago. Then there was the 1990s choice Fernando Lama on his motorcycle, a favorite of chix everywhere. And the Japanesew Lama, who since they couldn't pronounce the L, shares identity with India's Rama. Then there is of course, the chociolae-flavored cake, the Rama Lama Ding Dong, popularized in 1950s vocal pop music. Panchen Out right now, bye.
@@marczhu7473 keep telling yourself that. Fire Nation is China. China is called Red China for a reason. And since when did Japan attack Tibet? They didn't China did.
It really makes you appreciate the fragility of our generation when you realize that both the dalai lama and the queen of england have been around since before a lot of us were born and still going
Heinrich Harrer, a great Austrian Eiger climber of the late 1930s had escaped to Tibet, and was biden to teach the young Dalai. He wrote "Mein Leben am Hofe des Dalai Lama" before queen Lizzie- though she was a better looking reincarnation of Hank VIII's daughter back in 1500s. And Gilgamesh was also born before a lot of us. My brother is so fat that I don't give him a day after the Fall of Burger King, so don't gauge your lifetime as very long, until after that happens.
For those interested: this current reincarnation system was first introduced by Qing dynasty after seeing its troublesome nature during Yuan and Ming time and has been a tool for central government to control tibet since the day it was invented.
John Man’s biography of Kublai Khan states that the Yuan Dynasty created the position of Dalai Lama because of the infighting between regional Tibetan Lamas. They wanted one Lama to represent them all. The dates match up, and Dalai is the Mongol word for Ocean, used metaphorically as of the many. If that’s true, then there is a precedent for Chinese governments manipulating the appointment.
The struggle against Sinocization in Tibet goes back centuries. Basically Tibet is the Poland of Asia, disappearing from the map in 1720, reappearing in 1912 and again disappearing in 1951 In 1720 the Imperial Qing government launched an expedition into Tibet under the pretext of defending it from a common enemy. Tibet was soon annexed afterwards. But Tibet didn't accept Qing rule resulting in a revolt in Lahsa in 1750 which the Qing brutally put down. Tibet struggled with Qing rule off and on until the fall of the Qing. Tibet was able to recover it's national sovereignty with the assistance of the world's strongest military at the time, the British Empire. Who utilized it's geo strategic position as a buffer state. Despite the security guarntee from the British Empire Tibet never became a colony. Likewise it also never achieved de jure status of international recognition instead being able to achieve the de facto status. This would severely limit the Tibetan struggle in the future. After WW2 the UK couldn't continue with its security commitment to Tibet and recalled its troops. Tibet was left without any international recognition but the Chinese were still occupied with their civil war however the Tibetan government knew it was only a matter of time as both the Communists and the KMT claimed Tibet as part of China. Tibet attempted to reach out to both the United Nations and the Chinese government to gain it's legal status as a sovereign territory but the UN was focused on the European rebuilding effort and the establishment of Israel it couldn't focus on the Tibetan cause who in 1946 wasn't a UN member. Tibet then approached the government of China in 1946 but the Chinese civil war had outlasted WW2 was still ongoing so no response was received to grant Tibet it's full legal status. With the victory over the KMT in 1949 Mao and the communist forces moved west to "reclaim" Tibet and 1951 Tibet was returned to its second period of Chinese rule. Tibet has since tried to wither the erosion of Tibetan customs and traditions as best it can.
Sending good vibes to everyone in China and in other countries who are affected by the Corona virus. May you all be immune to any form of sickness and may those who are sick be well again. Peace and love from India
As a person who has a nebula account and hardly uses it due to the convenience of youtube, this tibet teaser for a macau main course is genius. I hope your fellow nebulans start doing more, cause youtube is getting worse and worse, and i feel i need prodding to actually move to greener pastures
This is great. I'm super interested in the history of the Tibet, the Dalia Lama and the Potola Palace, and I've been begging for someone to cover it. Thank you so much for not cowtowing to the algorithm.
His title is the Dalai Lama and his winter palace was the Potala Palace. Don't worry compadre, Tibet has always existed, just like any other major culture like China or India. By that very nature, Tibet as a topic will continue to exist.
you forgot about the penchen lama, a pretty significant figure who identifies the next dalai lama and who is identified himself by the former dalai lama
Thank you for doing a video on this topic. This is extremely important stuff to even Western Vajrayana Buddhists. His Holiness, and his predecessors have been amazing, important historical figures even outside the tradition. The CCP's stance is, of course, dangerous and oppressive. All awareness on the topic, especially as thorough as this, is positive.
Great video but I can't help but be a little disappointed that Taiwan was just glossed over as if China's claim to it might actually be legitimate. At least it wasn't included in the map as a part of China.
@@eugeneng7064 I don't think there's any "legitimate" claim to be made at all. Taiwan has operated as an independent, sovereign nation since the Japanese gave up the island in 1945. The Qing Dynasty claims over the island (which is not to be confused with modern China) ended in 1895. If China has a claim to Taiwan than it absolutely does not have a claim to Tibet... simply put Taiwan is an independent nation and doesn't need to claim as such because it already is...
@@JohnnyStrides The Japanese gave up Taiwan, to which the KMT took in 1945, so they have been ruled from Nanjing for about four years after the war ended. The Taiwanese government also still recognises the One China Policy, therefore by their own admission affirms they are a part of China. So long as that stands, Taiwan to me is a part of China. As for Tibet, the Qing government that held it passed power to the Empire of China which was replaced by the Republic which was replaced by the People's Republic. Therefore continuity of government holds. If that wasn't enough they took it back, which cements it. If you haven't noticed, official standing of the concerned parties and actual control are what I care about. In which case, Taiwan's official stance is that they are a part of China and Tibet has been a part of China since the mid-Qing at the most conservative with a shirt interregnum after 1911.
@@JohnnyStrides What an easy way to dismiss someone you disagree with. Go ahead, point out which bits are fake. I'll provide all the citations (non-Chinese) necessary.
The map that you are showing is only the Chinese so called "AUTONOMOUS REGION", and it's not the full picture of Tibet. Tibet is much larger than that, it includes Kham and Amdo too(place where the 14th Dalai Lama was born)
You're referring to Greater or Historical Tibet, which the Tibetan Government-in-Exile lays claim to. Author Patrick French in his book _Tibet, Tibet: A Personal History of a Lost Land_ wrote that he found it curious the TGIE would make such a claim given that even from 1913-1951, Tibet exercised no power over the region beyond historical U-Tsang (which is roughly today's Tibet Autonomous Region). Amdo and Kham had basically been under Chinese control since the Qing Dynasty, and even further back than that, Lhasa never really had much control over those regions for extended periods of time.
@@ZhangtheGreat Tibetan Emperor, Chinese Emperor, and Mongolian Emperor. Asia three most famous Emperor in the early time. King Songtsen Gampo's Queen was came from China. She is only Chinese and no one or nothing else.
@@ZhangtheGreat During king Songtsen Gampo, He ruled whole Asia, so no doubt of unified Utsang, Kham and Amdo. It got disconnected for a while after king passed away, so that doesn't mean no related between three province region of Tibet.
Nickle in gadgets is mined from Tibet. The Tibetan population is about 6 million. 3 million Tibetans live in Tibet aka Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR). Half of the Tibetan population and half of the Tibetan landmass is merged with Chinese province such as Qinghai (where the current Dalai Lama was born), Sichuan, Yunan, Gansu. While TAR was occupied by China in 1950 the ones merged with Chinese provinces were occupied much before 1949.
@@noritos7648 well yes it was awful before but any improvement is obviously just a side effect british colonial rule also had proper improvements, a bit of an unfair comparison yeah, but times have also changed and how bad you can treat colonies have some limits now, and now china is more than excited to be fully on the edge of whats acceptable with it wringing out all its peoples value .
The struggle against Sinocization in Tibet goes back centuries. Basically Tibet is the Poland of Asia, disappearing from the map in 1720, reappearing in 1912 and again disappearing in 1951 In 1720 the Imperial Qing government launched an expedition into Tibet under the pretext of defending it from a common enemy. Tibet was soon annexed afterwards. But Tibet didn't accept Qing rule resulting in a revolt in Lahsa in 1750 which the Qing brutally put down. Tibet struggled with Qing rule off and on until the fall of the Qing. Tibet was able to recover it's national sovereignty with the assistance of the world's strongest military at the time, the British Empire. Who utilized it's geo strategic position as a buffer state. Despite the security guarntee from the British Empire Tibet never became a colony. Likewise it also never achieved de jure status of international recognition instead being able to achieve the de facto status. This would severely limit the Tibetan struggle in the future. After WW2 the UK couldn't continue with its security commitment to Tibet and recalled its troops. Tibet was left without any international recognition but the Chinese were still occupied with their civil war however the Tibetan government knew it was only a matter of time as both the Communists and the KMT claimed Tibet as part of China. Tibet attempted to reach out to both the United Nations and the Chinese government to gain it's legal status as a sovereign territory but the UN was focused on the European rebuilding effort and the establishment of Israel it couldn't focus on the Tibetan cause who in 1946 wasn't a UN member. Tibet then approached the government of China in 1946 but the Chinese civil war had outlasted WW2 was still ongoing so no response was received to grant Tibet it's full legal status. With the victory over the KMT in 1949 Mao and the communist forces moved west to "reclaim" Tibet and 1951 Tibet was returned to its second period of Chinese rule. Tibet has since tried to wither the erosion of Tibetan customs and traditions as best it can.
I have faith in Tibet as one of the most remarkably loyal civilizations humanity has created. Loyalty to the three jewels of refuge (AKA Buddhism), loyalty to its doctrine of compassion for all sentient beings, and loyalty for its Buddha-King His Holiness the Dalai Lama. They'll find a way. There's nothing but more blood, sweat, and tears for Tibet to re-attain its basic liberties or even acknowledgement of existence, but it will come no doubt.
@Alex Mercer Please elaborate, you're extremely vague with what you're claiming. When did Tibet become Chinese territory and how? Also, no one said they wanted to be a "poor slave of the Dalai Lama," that's only a strawman you created.
If Tibet is independent and ruled by Dalailama: your skin gets peeled,skull gets cut and Dalailama makes a drum with your skin and skulls.They use your bones to make flutes and hold a giant party using hundreds of drums and flutes just to memorize their 'God'.
I really like your videos man. They are informative, well-researched and cover a lot of stuff that others don't cover on RUclips. I noticed you're trying to read the way news anchors read. IMHO it sounds monotone, it's distracting and it causes the video to appear boring. I really like they way David Attenborough narrates documentaries and Derek Perkins reads audiobooks (he reads Yuval Noah Harari's books). Just food for thought. Keep up the great work!
Legislate reincarnation =) I remember when my mom told me about this and we both had a good chuckle...pinnacle of absurdity especially given they were "suppose" to be atheistic. My grandpa would be turning in his grave. Anything for power I guess.
This Dalai lama enslaved 98% of population in Tibet and he is an icon in the west. Guardian "Until 1959, when China cracked down on Tibetan rebels and the Dalai Lama fled to northern India, around 98% of the population was enslaved in serfdom. Drepung monastery, on the outskirts of Lhasa, was one of the world's largest landowners with 185 manors, 25,000 serfs, 300 pastures, and 16,000 herdsmen. High-ranking lamas and secular landowners imposed crippling taxes, forced boys into monastic slavery and pilfered most of the country's wealth - torturing disobedient serfs by gouging out their eyes or severing their hamstrings." www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2009/feb/10/tibet-china-feudalism
When the Panchen Lama died, the Chinese imprisoned the real new Panchen Lama, and had monks select one acceptable to the Chinese government to be trained by them. So that they will do the same for a new Dalai Lama is not surprising.
I felt like I was in a fantasy novel listening to this...I had no idea the Chinese government approached theology this way but it makes sense when you realize it's not so different from the Western politico religious pursuits of my ancestors.
The Dalai Lama is sort of like the Doctor, having several incarnations. Anyway, I think that independently finding a new one without china's influence will be difficult, as China controls the entire area. There could possibly be 2 auccessors. A Chinese picked one that is loyal to china, and an internationally picked and recognised one probably based in India or Nepal.
Fo the record, sequence between 3:32 - 3:47 is not in China, it is in Ladakh, India. I understand that it serves as a visual imagery of Tibetan water sources, but I think it makes sense to point out the factual correctness too!
Ya know, I’m a man of science. Religions don’t really hold weight in my life. However the process of picking a new Dalai Lama, and the religion of Buddhism really do interest me. Edit: I do hope that in my life I can spend more than a few weeks in Tibet. I’ve always wanted to ask monks in Tibet, on some far off sanctuary, if I could sit quietly in the corner and observe. No notes, no recordings, but just be there. Utterly fascinating honestly.
Would you were a man of silence- then you would already have studied Buddhism and so not sat your tubby Buddha weight so Pestiferously upon the Hungary. Pinch a Loaf. Fish. Hang out on the Crossroads to observe. Oh, man of science, give us a scien.
Wha? I'm in china right now and I have to say you left out some important stuff. Especially the Panchan lama (spelled wrong I think). Around the age of 26 the dalilama choose a young boy as the Panchan lama because they are spiritually connected. Counterparts, so they can know where they are when brought back to life. China might still have the real Panchan alive somewhere. (My info might not be accurate, but this should be really important).
The clip at 3:39 is ladakh(very far from china claimed area in ladakh), india I know because I went wild water rafting here. Please don't pollute our land with reference of China..
no offense and being brutally honest, the last thing China wants is to deal with more overpopulation and poor people. just no, they rather give you loans and see whether you sink or swim.
Hey man. I've been living in China for the last two years. I've met people who grew up in XinJiang. I can tell you some first-hand stories if you'd like. Just a little thing, people in XinJiang are required by law to wake up in the morning and pledge allegiance to the Chinese flag in a group ceremony. I'm not sure how widespread this is, but my friend is from a town on the border with Kyrgyzstan. When she visited for Chinese new year (This January) she said that was happening.
@@delphinidin Ever heard of the American Civil War? That was what happens when the citizenry was NOT loyal to the country (the Confederates were loyal to their particular state).
Corona Virus: I have infected almost 80 thousand people in your country and I am a threat to humanity, don't you think you should be looking for a cure. China: Nah I am just going to try to reincarnate the Dalai Lama.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
In case you missed it, my 30-minute Nebula Original video about Macau is out now. Sign up now to CuriosityStream to watch it: curiositystream.com/polymatter
I'm sorry but i can't watch it
PolyMatter ok
Can you do a vid on covid-19
Tibetans look down on tibetans in India and the United States. They refused to become the dalai lama's slave society
Please come to Tibet and have a look. 99% of tibetans don't care about him except americans
you never come to Tibet ？ruclips.net/video/Wvo8MXny5XI/видео.html
Buddhists: *Reincarnates*
China: *You got a licence for that?*
India making joke FUNNY
@Alex Mercer The Mongolian conquered Tibet, then it fell. Tibet was independent until the Manchurian conquered, then it fell. Tibet had become independent from 1912 to 1951 .Mao of China invaded Tibet 1951 .
You'll never take me alive!
China has stated that they will use the Golden Urn to choose the next dalai lama. the Golden Urn method was devised by Emperor QIanlong in 1792, and was already used to choose the 10th 11th and 12th dalai lama. It's funny how people are wiling to believe a fairy tale just to be anti-China, reincarnation is not real, it's simply a political tool for the theocratic lama class to stay in power in feudal tibet. The selection process for the Pope is much more logical and honest.
caesaropapism with chinese characteristics
So this would be the equivalent of Italy trying to regulate Catholicism, appointing the Pope by the Congress, and so on.
Pope above the country? Italy, no more.
Better than the Vatican trying to regulate Italy.
@Alex Mercer I am an atheist myself but as someone who is a lover of freedom and liberty I believe people should be free to practice their faith without the influence from political cults such as Communism and Fascism.
@@freeman10000 You should read history, or observe the middle east. When you loose control, the religious force will try to get their way with politics. Childish.
@Alex Mercer *tips fedora*
Why Jesus has not returned: he forgot to apply for reincarnation.
Keeps getting born in China.
*RASPUTIN*
Ty YT no no, it's okay. Christians in their beliefs know he never reincarnated, as his body had the scars from the crucifix.
If he ever returns back will be more complex that a simple new body.
Mmmmm. Nah he can stay chilling in heaven. I’m not tryna go to hell right now
There's no such thing as reincarnation in Abrahamic religions only in Eastern civilization. Christ is Christ he doesn't reincarnate.
Just imagine an undercover Chinese agent being elected as the Dalai-lama.
never imagine a traitor acting as a covert puppet of the CIA and other western's secret services
@@fitobarcelona7542 This comment is APPROVED by the PRC, China numba one!
@@fitobarcelona7542 *someone mentions China*
NPCs: something something westerners reee
@@birbies Every time.
@@randomstuff3413 someone should make a bingo of PRC shill terms, like "western", "imperialist", "whataboutism"
to put it simply:
the Fire Nation wants to control the reincarnation of the Avatar so that it doesn't arise from the Air Nomads again, but if the Fire Nation appoints a Pro-Fire Nation Avatar, a religious war could spark between the Fire Nation and The Air Nomads.
The air nomads dont fight wars tho
hahahaha :D
@@ethanmcfarland8240 no because China raped and killed most of Tibet and its culture. Exactly like the air nation
The similarity is astounding!!!
Hey I never thought of avatar as an allegory. Thanks.
PolyMatter's Mandarin pronunciation has improved!
He did fuck up the pronunciation of "sichuan"
@@Daniel-ht4wr the Rick and Morty sauce?
To that end it was still confusing for some... I find his pronunciation of “Chen Kuiyuan” particularly difficult to understand...
zah fares the place in China
ya ofc it'd improve, the guy only talks about china lmfao
not that there's anything wrong with that
Polymatter's topic range:
China
China
China
Apple
China
China
Asia
Apple
China
Chinese Companies
China
Startups
China
Just like wendover productions with planes
PaperTronics north korea
Simply because USA is no longer relevant
He did Sweden once I think!
lol, solid evidence of propaganda against China. haha
I think you forgot to mention about the 11th Panchen Lama, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, which according to the tradition is the one supposed to be choosing the next Dalai Lama. He was ‘protected’ by the CCP after chosen by the current Dalai Lama in 1989 and has been the youngest political prisoner in the world ever since.
That is the reason why the next Dalai Lama may not be found/chosen/legitimate.
The CCP may release him as the new ‘leader’ of Tibet after the current Dalai Lama though. After his ‘re-education’, of course.
(For more you can look it up on wikipedia)
He forgot the most important part...
The Panchen Lama is what he called “ the second most important lama” in video. So he have mentioned it
from what I've heard, they've assigned their own Panchen Lama
Yet... the Panchen Lama fought against the Dalai Lama during the 1930 Tibetan Civil War...
Assuming those two are the same souls reincarnating... that's got to have started a recent grudge.
Day Y. Lol you got the people all wrong and mixed up
This video: exists
Ozai and Sozin : why TF didn't I think of that before !!??
Because there are obvious physical indicators of whom the Avatar is, while the Lamas are physically ordinary human beings.
In theory DLs can be interrogated and cross-referenced, which they do. But the guys doing this can be coerced
10:11 looooool " application for reincarnation to the government for approval " this is a whole new level of oppression.
8:45 this is literally how the Avatar was found.
The writers were probably inspired by the Dali Lama
@Dayne64 he is so powerful that he ripped off a show from the future
@Dayne64 hope it's a joke. Otherwise it's just plain stupid
Actually the show only shows us how the Air Nomads identify the Avatar. I'd be willing to guess the Earth and Fire nations might do something similar to China's approach
And we all know who the fire nation is
Who else thought about “Avatar: The Last Airbender” when hearing about the reinkarnationen of Dalia Lama?
ATLA was based on Dalai Lama, so that checks out lol
Edit: not fully, but they do take the Dalai Lama as reference
"But everything changed when the People's Republic of China attacked..."
In fact, some of the characters have their names based on the Dalai Lama. Both Tenzin, and monk Gyatso. The 14th (current) Dalai Lama's name _is_ Tenzin Gyatso.
5aye
@@Novenae_CCG Can confirm this fact. No cap!!!! To add, Pema, Tenzin's wife is also another tibetan name.
China: We -
Polymatter: WRITE THAT DOWN GOD DAMMIT
Huh?
Hhhhh this comment is funnnnny
10:00 "You need to apply for reincarnation."
10:55 "Reincarnation must apply to Chinese laws."
I totally LOLed at these parts.
If religious people wanna play silly games. We Chinese will indulge the silliness as long as it keeps things moving 😎
@@levelazn Winnie the Pooh
@@thevideoclub8562 maga?
@@levelazn pooh = maga = nazi
@@thevideoclub8562 nazi ? did NAzi save thousands of jews during wwii in shanghai? and fight the japanese ?
Dalai Lama: You can’t regulate the afterlife!
China: Hold my beer.
They can regulate anything if they have the will. ^^
God: Let there be light
CCP: approved
So there's light...
@刘传 玉皇帝在文化大革命中已被杀死了
😂
This is something every atheist Chinese agrees
Atheists rise up!
i would love to read the CCP Bible
pharaohs enslaved the jews, with approval from the CCP
moses led jews from egypt and split the water, with approval from the CCP
romans crucified jesus, with approval from the CCP
im impressed by your Chinese pronunciation. better than that plane channel lol
jie gao wendover gone mad
Damn. 😂😂😂
If that is plane channel, this is China channel.
😂😂😂😂😂
'That Plane Channel' :D ♥
He makes mistakes deliberately which increases angry comments in comments sections which the RUclips algorithms to recommend the video more.
Dude's the Avatar
Other way around.
Avatar was inspired from this.
I know it's if the avatar was actually inspired based on other real-life cultures.. oh wait, it was.
We Indians are so close to Tibetans. They have communities all over northern India hope so Tibet is free one day.
Yes. Hope India is free from fascism too 🙏
@@dan5974 based
@@dan5974 wut?
@@TheArijitBanerjee India has a fascist government which oppresses minorities.
@@dan5974 Lol I’m a Buddhist(minority) in India and perfectly fine
You forgot to mention that "Legislation on Reincarnation" not something first started by PRC. The previous dynasty Qing also legislated that
We all know what will happen, quote:”China was whole again, then it broke again.”, end quote.
The empire
Long divided must unite
Long united must divide
*or simply China is whole again, then it broke again*
Bill Wurtz needs to make more history videos.
@@captain_code last time I checked he was learning 3d stuff to make better videos
cmon guys, the CCP is REALLY trying here, at least A for effort? lol
What every westerner power hopes for.
Yet for anyone who actually travels China -- no sign of it happening.
God: Jesus, my Son, You will reincarnate on the third day after Your act of salvation from the cross.
Jesus: Why on the third day Father?
God: Because we have to file an application of reincarnation first....
Jesus is not reincarnated, he is rejuvenated since it is the same body. Just saying.
@@Maya-sv1pz Well the most accurate term would be 'ressurection'. My point is he died and lived again
we'll that seems true there are millions of gods waiting to reincarnations....so they must have to wait for a while..
Amy Ee nah same thing
Allah is the only truth
"a database of officially sanctioned Buddhas"... one must "submit an application for reincarnation to the government for approval"... "reincarnation must comply with Chinese laws"... man, the Chinese government really struggles to grasp some of the fundamental tenets of Buddhism, eh? Either that or they're trying to co-opt it.
So would Dio have to apply? he is a vampire and he already re"incarnated" into another man's body outside of China.
That's Tibet tradition for over 500 years now, just that it's beneficial to the central government, so they just really like it, 😂
not only ccp.the son of heaver or past Chinese emperor is like the pope in the west who give legitimacy to regional spiritual leader .
Kly yo is that a Chinese government reference?
Kind of important to mention that this isnt new by any means, the rulers have been meddeling in this process for a long time. This time it's just more coercive. Chinese emperors usually "helped" when the panchem or dalai lama couldnt do it on their own.
Yes! Rulers have struck the hands of Catholic School students since time immemorial. And the Nuns wielding them look so much alike, that they may be older without reincarnation than civlilizations. And Olympians have been medaling (note the spelling, before meddling further with your keyboard) since ancient Grease slipped away.
Why didn't you mention the Panchen Lama? It's kinda a huge part of the selection process and very relevant as the Chinese government kidnapped the child the Dalai Lama chose as the 11th Panchen Lama and have chosen their own one.
There is the Punchen Drunk, staggering around after boxing matches
The And the Drunken Punch, which Jackie Chan popularized in an early movie.
And Proof of Reincarnation, Louie Armstrong sung "Hello, Dalai" decades ago.
Then there was the 1990s choice Fernando Lama on his motorcycle, a favorite of chix everywhere.
And the Japanesew Lama, who since they couldn't pronounce the L, shares identity with India's Rama.
Then there is of course, the chociolae-flavored cake, the Rama Lama Ding Dong, popularized in 1950s vocal pop music.
Panchen Out right now, bye.
It would be hilarious if it wasn't so sad
Hey thanks for commenting that, I was honestly starting to think people thought the whole thing was more funny than anything because of sheer irony
"When the Fire Nation attacked"
Attach what, themselves to the Communist Party?
you know fire nation was japan ,earth nation china , wind nation is tibet, and inuit is water nation
*attacked
Ants Canada
@@marczhu7473 keep telling yourself that. Fire Nation is China. China is called Red China for a reason. And since when did Japan attack Tibet? They didn't China did.
wow the avatar was so good they made him in real life
We also have a real life fire nation that wants to take over the world but the question is which country will end up like the air nation
@@werty21100 taiwan
@@tannen3339 lichtenstein
@@werty21100 we have quite a few real life firenations.
Air nation = tibet
It really makes you appreciate the fragility of our generation when you realize that both the dalai lama and the queen of england have been around since before a lot of us were born and still going
@Richard Higsalih the repetitive nature of this alignment would indicate god does exist and has been trying to fix this over loop
What a time to read this comment.
Heinrich Harrer, a great Austrian Eiger climber of the late 1930s had escaped to Tibet, and was biden to teach the young Dalai. He wrote "Mein Leben am Hofe des Dalai Lama" before queen Lizzie- though she was a better looking reincarnation of Hank VIII's daughter back in 1500s.
And Gilgamesh was also born before a lot of us. My brother is so fat that I don't give him a day after the Fall of Burger King, so don't gauge your lifetime as very long, until after that happens.
For those interested: this current reincarnation system was first introduced by Qing dynasty after seeing its troublesome nature during Yuan and Ming time and has been a tool for central government to control tibet since the day it was invented.
Do you have any book where i can read about that?
John Man’s biography of Kublai Khan states that the Yuan Dynasty created the position of Dalai Lama because of the infighting between regional Tibetan Lamas. They wanted one Lama to represent them all. The dates match up, and Dalai is the Mongol word for Ocean, used metaphorically as of the many. If that’s true, then there is a precedent for Chinese governments manipulating the appointment.
The struggle against Sinocization in Tibet goes back centuries.
Basically Tibet is the Poland of Asia, disappearing from the map in 1720, reappearing in 1912 and again disappearing in 1951
In 1720 the Imperial Qing government launched an expedition into Tibet under the pretext of defending it from a common enemy. Tibet was soon annexed afterwards. But Tibet didn't accept Qing rule resulting in a revolt in Lahsa in 1750 which the Qing brutally put down.
Tibet struggled with Qing rule off and on until the fall of the Qing. Tibet was able to recover it's national sovereignty with the assistance of the world's strongest military at the time, the British Empire. Who utilized it's geo strategic position as a buffer state. Despite the security guarntee from the British Empire Tibet never became a colony.
Likewise it also never achieved de jure status of international recognition instead being able to achieve the de facto status. This would severely limit the Tibetan struggle in the future.
After WW2 the UK couldn't continue with its security commitment to Tibet and recalled its troops. Tibet was left without any international recognition but the Chinese were still occupied with their civil war however the Tibetan government knew it was only a matter of time as both the Communists and the KMT claimed Tibet as part of China.
Tibet attempted to reach out to both the United Nations and the Chinese government to gain it's legal status as a sovereign territory but the UN was focused on the European rebuilding effort and the establishment of Israel it couldn't focus on the Tibetan cause who in 1946 wasn't a UN member.
Tibet then approached the government of China in 1946 but the Chinese civil war had outlasted WW2 was still ongoing so no response was received to grant Tibet it's full legal status.
With the victory over the KMT in 1949 Mao and the communist forces moved west to "reclaim" Tibet and 1951 Tibet was returned to its second period of Chinese rule.
Tibet has since tried to wither the erosion of Tibetan customs and traditions as best it can.
Sending good vibes to everyone in China and in other countries who are affected by the Corona virus. May you all be immune to any form of sickness and may those who are sick be well again. Peace and love from India
Rejoy Panakkal thank you. Wish you and your country the same.
Thank you my friend. Well wishes and blessing to you and your family as well
How are things for you now?
As a person who has a nebula account and hardly uses it due to the convenience of youtube, this tibet teaser for a macau main course is genius. I hope your fellow nebulans start doing more, cause youtube is getting worse and worse, and i feel i need prodding to actually move to greener pastures
The whole process feels like the search for the Avatar
The Air nomads culture in Avatar is heavily inspired by Tibet.
During the Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties, the Dalai Lama had to be recognised by the emperor.
This is great. I'm super interested in the history of the Tibet, the Dalia Lama and the Potola Palace, and I've been begging for someone to cover it. Thank you so much for not cowtowing to the algorithm.
His title is the Dalai Lama and his winter palace was the Potala Palace. Don't worry compadre, Tibet has always existed, just like any other major culture like China or India. By that very nature, Tibet as a topic will continue to exist.
This video made me appreciate the Tibetan influences to the Air Nomads in ATLA
Your social credit score has been lowered for the following reason(s) :
he put glory to hong kong at the end of his documentary so his social credit score is -1
ruclips.net/video/Wvo8MXny5XI/видео.html
*Man spits on elevator during coronavirus outbreak
*Yeet skeet your social credit is deleted*
Reincarnation without party approval.
*Reincarnation without party approval, into a different ethnic group, in order to abuse ethnic group privileges.*
3:14
I never noticed how weird camels look from above omg
When you realize it's the same way the airbenders in the last air bender finds the avatar
They really copied television for their religion smh
I love how aang is basically just a animated Dali lama
*EDIT Dalai lama
Then the fire nation attacked
As a Tibetan American I watched knowing that Aang is the The Dalia lama.
you forgot about the penchen lama, a pretty significant figure who identifies the next dalai lama and who is identified himself by the former dalai lama
A leader not judged by its attributes to lead but what objects they pick during infancy. Sounds like a solid plan.
Thank you for doing a video on this topic. This is extremely important stuff to even Western Vajrayana Buddhists. His Holiness, and his predecessors have been amazing, important historical figures even outside the tradition. The CCP's stance is, of course, dangerous and oppressive. All awareness on the topic, especially as thorough as this, is positive.
It is interesting how people can have such different views of life while all living together in the same world
Great video but I can't help but be a little disappointed that Taiwan was just glossed over as if China's claim to it might actually be legitimate. At least it wasn't included in the map as a part of China.
Depends on how you view it. China's claim is legitimate based on continuity of government and the One China Policy. Otherwise no.
@@eugeneng7064 I don't think there's any "legitimate" claim to be made at all. Taiwan has operated as an independent, sovereign nation since the Japanese gave up the island in 1945. The Qing Dynasty claims over the island (which is not to be confused with modern China) ended in 1895. If China has a claim to Taiwan than it absolutely does not have a claim to Tibet... simply put Taiwan is an independent nation and doesn't need to claim as such because it already is...
@@JohnnyStrides The Japanese gave up Taiwan, to which the KMT took in 1945, so they have been ruled from Nanjing for about four years after the war ended. The Taiwanese government also still recognises the One China Policy, therefore by their own admission affirms they are a part of China. So long as that stands, Taiwan to me is a part of China.
As for Tibet, the Qing government that held it passed power to the Empire of China which was replaced by the Republic which was replaced by the People's Republic. Therefore continuity of government holds. If that wasn't enough they took it back, which cements it.
If you haven't noticed, official standing of the concerned parties and actual control are what I care about. In which case, Taiwan's official stance is that they are a part of China and Tibet has been a part of China since the mid-Qing at the most conservative with a shirt interregnum after 1911.
@@eugeneng7064 Wow, you're brainwashed. Have a nice life sir, I'm done with your misinformation.
@@JohnnyStrides What an easy way to dismiss someone you disagree with. Go ahead, point out which bits are fake. I'll provide all the citations (non-Chinese)
necessary.
Reincarnation passports... We need you to come back ASAP, Jesus!
Respect to the pronunciation of the Chinese words
Allah hu akbar
The map that you are showing is only the Chinese so called "AUTONOMOUS REGION", and it's not the full picture of Tibet. Tibet is much larger than that, it includes Kham and Amdo too(place where the 14th Dalai Lama was born)
You're referring to Greater or Historical Tibet, which the Tibetan Government-in-Exile lays claim to. Author Patrick French in his book _Tibet, Tibet: A Personal History of a Lost Land_ wrote that he found it curious the TGIE would make such a claim given that even from 1913-1951, Tibet exercised no power over the region beyond historical U-Tsang (which is roughly today's Tibet Autonomous Region). Amdo and Kham had basically been under Chinese control since the Qing Dynasty, and even further back than that, Lhasa never really had much control over those regions for extended periods of time.
and vast is non-human area.
@@ZhangtheGreat Tibetan Emperor, Chinese Emperor, and Mongolian Emperor. Asia three most famous Emperor in the early time. King Songtsen Gampo's Queen was came from China. She is only Chinese and no one or nothing else.
@@ZhangtheGreat During king Songtsen Gampo, He ruled whole Asia, so no doubt of unified Utsang, Kham and Amdo. It got disconnected for a while after king passed away, so that doesn't mean no related between three province region of Tibet.
@@hkwopczk1 70 percent of Russia are forest and jungle, that doesn't mean those are not Russian territory or part of Russian.
Nickle in gadgets is mined from Tibet. The Tibetan population is about 6 million. 3 million Tibetans live in Tibet aka Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR). Half of the Tibetan population and half of the Tibetan landmass is merged with Chinese province such as Qinghai (where the current Dalai Lama was born), Sichuan, Yunan, Gansu. While TAR was occupied by China in 1950 the ones merged with Chinese provinces were occupied much before 1949.
Dalai Lama: *reincarnates*
China: Wait, that's illegal
I followed the Dalai Lama on Twitter, but he didn’t follow me back
...
He’s very self centered.
Lol
Oh well then
Not funny
Sebastian Elytron bad joke
He has no time to wast his time like u🥱🥱🥱😷
THE VIDEO WE HAVE ALL BEEN WAITING FORR!!!!
To be honest, the process of looking for the new dalai sound SIMILAR to the avatar the last airbender
If I remembered right, the current dalai lama is the 14th one. Everyone before him was approved by the qing emperors.
We are witnessing the death of 900 year old culture
...shisui
@@noritos7648 they marketed it different to the western world
You mean an end of 900 year old slave system? do you know what is human skin drum?
@@noritos7648 well yes it was awful before but any improvement is obviously just a side effect
british colonial rule also had proper improvements, a bit of an unfair comparison yeah, but times have also changed and how bad you can treat colonies have some limits now, and now china is more than excited to be fully on the edge of whats acceptable with it wringing out all its peoples value .
@@noritos7648 >> Oh, great, let's kill and beat up monks and people and force them into our ways. That's actually better 😊
2:05
Well done for your hard work on pronunciation. It is respectful to try your best
Last time I was this early Dalai Llama was still in India.
The struggle against Sinocization in Tibet goes back centuries.
Basically Tibet is the Poland of Asia, disappearing from the map in 1720, reappearing in 1912 and again disappearing in 1951
In 1720 the Imperial Qing government launched an expedition into Tibet under the pretext of defending it from a common enemy. Tibet was soon annexed afterwards. But Tibet didn't accept Qing rule resulting in a revolt in Lahsa in 1750 which the Qing brutally put down.
Tibet struggled with Qing rule off and on until the fall of the Qing. Tibet was able to recover it's national sovereignty with the assistance of the world's strongest military at the time, the British Empire. Who utilized it's geo strategic position as a buffer state. Despite the security guarntee from the British Empire Tibet never became a colony.
Likewise it also never achieved de jure status of international recognition instead being able to achieve the de facto status. This would severely limit the Tibetan struggle in the future.
After WW2 the UK couldn't continue with its security commitment to Tibet and recalled its troops. Tibet was left without any international recognition but the Chinese were still occupied with their civil war however the Tibetan government knew it was only a matter of time as both the Communists and the KMT claimed Tibet as part of China.
Tibet attempted to reach out to both the United Nations and the Chinese government to gain it's legal status as a sovereign territory but the UN was focused on the European rebuilding effort and the establishment of Israel it couldn't focus on the Tibetan cause who in 1946 wasn't a UN member.
Tibet then approached the government of China in 1946 but the Chinese civil war had outlasted WW2 was still ongoing so no response was received to grant Tibet it's full legal status.
With the victory over the KMT in 1949 Mao and the communist forces moved west to "reclaim" Tibet and 1951 Tibet was returned to its second period of Chinese rule.
Tibet has since tried to wither the erosion of Tibetan customs and traditions as best it can.
This is depressing, reminds me of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth Partitions
I have faith in Tibet as one of the most remarkably loyal civilizations humanity has created. Loyalty to the three jewels of refuge (AKA Buddhism), loyalty to its doctrine of compassion for all sentient beings, and loyalty for its Buddha-King His Holiness the Dalai Lama. They'll find a way. There's nothing but more blood, sweat, and tears for Tibet to re-attain its basic liberties or even acknowledgement of existence, but it will come no doubt.
@Alex Mercer Please elaborate, you're extremely vague with what you're claiming. When did Tibet become Chinese territory and how? Also, no one said they wanted to be a "poor slave of the Dalai Lama," that's only a strawman you created.
If Tibet is independent and ruled by Dalailama: your skin gets peeled,skull gets cut and Dalailama makes a drum with your skin and skulls.They use your bones to make flutes and hold a giant party using hundreds of drums and flutes just to memorize their 'God'.
I really like your videos man. They are informative, well-researched and cover a lot of stuff that others don't cover on RUclips. I noticed you're trying to read the way news anchors read. IMHO it sounds monotone, it's distracting and it causes the video to appear boring. I really like they way David Attenborough narrates documentaries and Derek Perkins reads audiobooks (he reads Yuval Noah Harari's books). Just food for thought. Keep up the great work!
I visited little tibit in Delhi once where I saw posters of Panchen Lama a 11 year old spritiual leader who is kept as a political prisoner by CCP.
Illegal religious leader
@@jackl2257 yes as it doesn't like by CCP
Mayank Singh yes
I'm really curious how they plan to enforce their laws about reincarnation.
why the lamas keeps being born in a particular geographical region is beyond me. Apparently, the aatma also has deals signed with Tibet and China
Legislate reincarnation =) I remember when my mom told me about this and we both had a good chuckle...pinnacle of absurdity especially given they were "suppose" to be atheistic. My grandpa would be turning in his grave. Anything for power I guess.
Did you split the chuckle? And where can we purchase one?
But why map of Tibet is shown wrong?
Tibet is larger in size than shown in video here.
Those were the borders set by china when it invaded
@@anemu3819 Set by the Republic of China, not the People's Republic of China
Everyone gangsta until china walks in with their reincarnate paperwork!
I have seen so many polymatter videos that I could smell the sponsor spot before it even started...
I just found out that in this year's Bill (U.S) there is funding to reincarnate the Dali Lama
I never knew reincarnation cycle of the Dalai Lama influenced the avatar cycle lol
what happened to your pronunciation? did you start taking chinese lessons? it's pretty good
Disadvantage of being so early is that i dont get good jokes in comment section.
It's all dipshit comments about avatar the last airbender
Dalai Lama: Oh boy, time to reincarnate!
State: _do you have an appointment?_
This Dalai lama enslaved 98% of population in Tibet and he is an icon in the west.
Guardian "Until 1959, when China cracked down on Tibetan rebels and the Dalai Lama fled to northern India, around 98% of the population was enslaved in serfdom. Drepung monastery, on the outskirts of Lhasa, was one of the world's largest landowners with 185 manors, 25,000 serfs, 300 pastures, and 16,000 herdsmen. High-ranking lamas and secular landowners imposed crippling taxes, forced boys into monastic slavery and pilfered most of the country's wealth - torturing disobedient serfs by gouging out their eyes or severing their hamstrings." www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2009/feb/10/tibet-china-feudalism
When the Panchen Lama died, the Chinese imprisoned the real new Panchen Lama, and had monks select one acceptable to the Chinese government to be trained by them. So that they will do the same for a new Dalai Lama is not surprising.
3:33 this is in Ladakh, India not in Tibet.
Your pronunciation of the Chinese words is outstanding 👏👏👏
They can never touch a reincarnating spirit. He could be reborn anywhere across time and space
How they find the reincarnated baby is probably the inspiration for Avatar
I AM SO DISAPPOINTED. TAIWAN IS A SEPARATE, DEMOCRATIC STATE WITH NO AFFILIATION TO CHINA. DO YOUR RESEARCH.
098765 Craper No affiliation to the country that’s commonly referred to as China by most humans. I.e. with China op referred to the CCP.
Well if Taiwan didn't had such a close relationship with US, then maybe China would have left y'all alone. Anyway, good luck
I felt like I was in a fantasy novel listening to this...I had no idea the Chinese government approached theology this way but it makes sense when you realize it's not so different from the Western politico religious pursuits of my ancestors.
The Dalai Lama is sort of like the Doctor, having several incarnations. Anyway, I think that independently finding a new one without china's influence will be difficult, as China controls the entire area. There could possibly be 2 auccessors. A Chinese picked one that is loyal to china, and an internationally picked and recognised one probably based in India or Nepal.
Is it just me or is ATLA'S process of choosing an Avatar based off of this.
Fo the record, sequence between 3:32 - 3:47 is not in China, it is in Ladakh, India. I understand that it serves as a visual imagery of Tibetan water sources, but I think it makes sense to point out the factual correctness too!
Ya know, I’m a man of science. Religions don’t really hold weight in my life. However the process of picking a new Dalai Lama, and the religion of Buddhism really do interest me.
Edit: I do hope that in my life I can spend more than a few weeks in Tibet. I’ve always wanted to ask monks in Tibet, on some far off sanctuary, if I could sit quietly in the corner and observe. No notes, no recordings, but just be there.
Utterly fascinating honestly.
Your concept of religion is very narrow I think christianity or Islam.
Would you were a man of silence- then you would already have studied Buddhism and so not sat your tubby Buddha weight so Pestiferously upon the Hungary. Pinch a Loaf. Fish. Hang out on the Crossroads to observe.
Oh, man of science, give us a scien.
🤣😂 reincarnation must comply with Chinese laws and regulations
Wha? I'm in china right now and I have to say you left out some important stuff. Especially the Panchan lama (spelled wrong I think). Around the age of 26 the dalilama choose a young boy as the Panchan lama because they are spiritually connected. Counterparts, so they can know where they are when brought back to life. China might still have the real Panchan alive somewhere. (My info might not be accurate, but this should be really important).
Thank you. I remembered Dalai Lama have chosen a boy but he was kidnapped by the chinese gov.
The clip at 3:39 is ladakh(very far from china claimed area in ladakh), india I know because I went wild water rafting here. Please don't pollute our land with reference of China..
Never ever think about it...
TAIWAN IS AN INDEPENDENT COUNTRY WITH ITS OWN GOVERNMENT, CURRENCY, AND MILITARY!
You forget the latest addition to its provinces, Province of Philippines.
no offense and being brutally honest, the last thing China wants is to deal with more overpopulation and poor people. just no, they rather give you loans and see whether you sink or swim.
@@kugelblitzingularity304 you wouldn't get the reference, mate. So you can't offend me. Cheers.
More like Pu Li Pin Zhou, the next province...
0:26 bruh I used to live in those apartments
real life avatar vs the fire nation
Honestly, this video just showed me how much of the Avatar from Avatar: The Last Airbender was based on Tibetan Buddhism
Wow, China is back.
Now you know why Trump kept saying *China.*
Stellvia Hoenheim that’s not cool bro
Hey man. I've been living in China for the last two years. I've met people who grew up in XinJiang. I can tell you some first-hand stories if you'd like.
Just a little thing, people in XinJiang are required by law to wake up in the morning and pledge allegiance to the Chinese flag in a group ceremony. I'm not sure how widespread this is, but my friend is from a town on the border with Kyrgyzstan. When she visited for Chinese new year (This January) she said that was happening.
Pledge to the national flag. Isn't it happening in every American school every freaking day? Including kindergartens.
@@DY-fy2jh Yep, and most of the rest of the world thinks the US is nuts for doing so!
@@delphinidin Ever heard of the American Civil War? That was what happens when the citizenry was NOT loyal to the country (the Confederates were loyal to their particular state).
Wow, I actually knew about this already!
11:08 This statement implies that the US congress recognizes any Dalai Lamas, or that it's recognitionis at all relevant.
Corona Virus: I have infected almost 80 thousand people in your country and I am a threat to humanity, don't you think you should be looking for a cure.
China: Nah I am just going to try to reincarnate the Dalai Lama.