The last game uses a marketplace horror template called horror engine and probably a marketplace map. The seller most likely sells the same project to each customer if he's just using templates. Terrible. If he's offering source files on the fiver website, which many game developer posts do, then that is illegal as it violates marketplace tos. As the developer didn't even make what he sold you that one is worse than the first one. Edit: I checked and he does sell source files which is illegal as he is not allowed to redistribute the asset packs he purchased. That seller is practically scamming buyers and marketplace sellers. It's crazy that crap like this is allowed on fiver. He charges minimum 100 for the basic pack. People need to so more research before buying into this.
i mean actual game development is difficult, complicated, and very time consuming so 100 dollars or less for a full game is definitely not going to be original and will most likely not have original code or assets, or if it does it will not be of a very high quality for that price, people just need to understand real game development cant be done that quickly or cheaply with the expectations of quality original works
@@pablovaldes2397 The originality isnt really the problem the problem is the redistribution of source files to buyers. That is entirely illegal. Sell copycat games if people will buy them. Just don't redistribute other people's work.
@@arxci9402 i mean like original code, like they made it themselves, because they clearly just copied another person's work, and i dont mean a lookalike, i mean line after line of code and source files for that game, because there is no way he could make that in a short time frame, but im no expert tbh
If this youtuber “Bad Gamedev” is including the source files on his patreon in addition to the compiled game, he too, is in violation of the marketplace TOS. Even if he doesn’t include them, kind of shady that he’s reselling other peoples work through patreon.
Are you saying people don't deserve money in their lives? Also, I'm sure even who made the shitty 10$ one had to spend time drawing and writing stuff to complete it
7:28 as a game developer my self I assure u they used unreal engine asset called "horror engine " to make this game in which 98 percent of work is done by this assets and it's free anyone can make these kinda game if u have some bit of knowledge about unreal engine
I’m a unity dev but it was very obvious to me that they did not make all that themselves. Especially the art, that must have been a pack at least. This engine is tempting me, the watermark at the beginning of my games is starting to become a problem.
With some more development and polishing, the last one could be made into a full game Edit: Everyone stop telling me this is an asset flip, I have been told that more times than I can count and it's getting annoying!
To everyone, even you BadGameDev, thinking the third one was a real game, sorry to disappoint you. I now worked with UE4 for nearly 6 years, sadly all the assets, even the mechanics, were an asset flip. The bunker is basically a five dollar package while the mechanics are a template called "Horror Engine", this template is available for free and anyone can play with it. All you have seen is already included in the template, it is basically drag-n-drop and that's it. Sorry guys...
@@Dazai_200 Don't know why this is a point of interest but definitely old enough to grow up with UE3 back then when it was called UDK. Care to elaborate?
My favorite game is the second game the dev was so creatively creative the mechanics of it and all ,.mind blowing ps:I like the last game too but I felt that it was already made before or he just reused everything from his previous horror game unless he really was committed to the job
Am I missing the part where you mention how much you paid for each game? It would just be nice from a critique perspective to know how much you paid and how much time they had. Otherwise it's just you running around 3 random games. Why does this matter? Well, if you paid me $10 and I had 1 day to make a game, you'd probably get the first game. If you paid me $1000 and a month of time to work with, you'd probably get the third game. It's unfair to judge sellers based on radically different conditions.
Thank you! I came to the comments to basically say the same thing. And considering the thumbnail had prices on it, I was assuming that’d be part of the video 🥺
@@motoscafopazzo1144 I’m looking at the description on my phone and some of it is being cut off. But all I can see is links to the artists Fiverr page. No prices 🤷
This horror game idea i had a few years ago was called "forgotten" is was a third person horror game where you played a 19yr street smart, street teen named alison smith, who wakes up in a strange place and doesn't remember a thing, while being hunted down by "mr smiley" a tall and slender figure with a mask craves with a smile on it and empty eye sockets, its a survival horror where you have run, hide, stay quite, use stealth and noise to continue farther, alison has blond hair with black dye at the edges, a torn lather jacket, grey hoodie, a white faded shirt with a skull, dark blue jeans with a hole in the left knee, sneakers, and a dark grey beanie and a smallish backpack. While trying to avoid the monsters, alison has to manage her stamina, sanity, hunger, inventory, and rest, few places where alison can restock and feel well rested and save progress in her diary in the her "safe spot", alison can arm herself in different weapons she finds the way and they will break over time, knifes, axes, bats, pipes, ETC.
@@Gojira_Wins the evil within, slender, and other survival horror game gave me the inspiration, the hunger and sanity can easily be manage but should never be neglected or forgotten about, it also adds the challenges to keep track of what's in hand.
@@gotanypain3083 i didnt realise that my comment rhymes until now note, this was an starting idea i had a long time ago, Awhile back i came up with another idea, a bunch of idea to put together so far about a teenage girl named brianna William, a 17 year old who and her classmates get taken by a sadistic cult on a remount fictional island with no easy escape
The first game sucks. Its just bad... Im a begginer when it comes to unity C# but I can still make that game in 30 mins or less. No character animations, no maze artwork, no "horror" feeling. Basically a waste of money and time. People might get triggred by me saying that but I still think this game is just bad. Even adding a bit of darkness around the player wouldve helped. 20$ wasted.
The third seller is distributing Source Code, which is illegal. I submitted a Report through Fiverr about this Seller and I would suggest everyone else does the same. It's fine to sell a game you make but don't fuck over Developers trying to sell their Assets.
The last one I have a feeling game was already made and just changed it a little to what you want it for. As 3d dev is not cheap i mean like 100k+ for simple game
How can you call a overly simple maze game a success? And what does it have to do with horror?????? I get you can't bad mouth a dev but seriously? Pure madness.
this guy.s business model is insane. He pays people probably an extremely low amount of money from how the game look so that he can both use it as monitzable youtube videos and also post them on patreon and make money from people wanting to play them too. He doesn't even do what the thumbnail said of using different prices
i hate people who goes like "the third one should be a full game". Like come on it looks like a game only made of assets with no work. The one that seemed the most interesting was clearly the second one.
Thank you for linking the sellers this time. You should go back and do so for the other Fiverr vids. Also, why are the prices not given? And you keep reusing the same clickbait thumbnail that falsely suggests you paid someone $1k. Not cool.
can you do a video on trying to make LingLong Incarnation Anime into a shooter game and i think it will actually be a good game if you spend time. hell if i know you might get a award
Makes me wonder if some of these people have games sitting around and sell the same game to multiple people, perhaps changing things only slightly eg., the name. Not saying they do, just wondering.
The second one is just a free horror template from Unreal Engine marketplace, ahhahhahaha. He took your money and delivered basically a free stuff. Haha.
99% of that last game was just the free horror engine asset for Unreal Engine. But yes, using it can allow you to spend most of your time actually building a good game. The guy in the last video should've had a lot more done within a week.
The last game uses a marketplace horror template called horror engine and probably a marketplace map. The seller most likely sells the same project to each customer if he's just using templates. Terrible. If he's offering source files on the fiver website, which many game developer posts do, then that is illegal as it violates marketplace tos. As the developer didn't even make what he sold you that one is worse than the first one.
Edit: I checked and he does sell source files which is illegal as he is not allowed to redistribute the asset packs he purchased. That seller is practically scamming buyers and marketplace sellers. It's crazy that crap like this is allowed on fiver. He charges minimum 100 for the basic pack. People need to so more research before buying into this.
i mean actual game development is difficult, complicated, and very time consuming so 100 dollars or less for a full game is definitely not going to be original and will most likely not have original code or assets, or if it does it will not be of a very high quality for that price, people just need to understand real game development cant be done that quickly or cheaply with the expectations of quality original works
@@pablovaldes2397 The originality isnt really the problem the problem is the redistribution of source files to buyers. That is entirely illegal. Sell copycat games if people will buy them. Just don't redistribute other people's work.
@@arxci9402 i mean like original code, like they made it themselves, because they clearly just copied another person's work, and i dont mean a lookalike, i mean line after line of code and source files for that game, because there is no way he could make that in a short time frame, but im no expert tbh
If this youtuber “Bad Gamedev” is including the source files on his patreon in addition to the compiled game, he too, is in violation of the marketplace TOS.
Even if he doesn’t include them, kind of shady that he’s reselling other peoples work through patreon.
@@Nebulaoblivion Actually fiverr let's you know that if you sell something to someone it's now your property
The 2nd fiverr Dev really cares about his craft. You can tell how much time he spent on it and it wasn’t even a really serious job
I would really like to see the third game made into a full game. The second one too because I really like its style and concept.
The third one was just the free horror engine in unreal engine 😂🤣
@@comebackguy8892 really ?
@@Nico-oj8oq Yes, really.
Your pfp is so ugly
@CrazyX Yeah, he truly is a bad game dev...
the real horror is actually having to pay someone
Lmao
especially the first one lol
Are you saying people don't deserve money in their lives?
Also, I'm sure even who made the shitty 10$ one had to spend time drawing and writing stuff to complete it
@@InnerEagle dude it's a joke
@@professorcube5104 I wanted to r/whoosh myself, it's 10 yrs I'm trying, ok?
7:28 as a game developer my self I assure u they used unreal engine asset called "horror engine " to make this game in which 98 percent of work is done by this assets and it's free anyone can make these kinda game if u have some bit of knowledge about unreal engine
I'm sure it is, recognised it immediately
I thought so too and I am not even a game developer!
I belive they added some colorgrading aswell, which makes it kinda stand out a bit, I am not sure if horror engine has that
I’m a unity dev but it was very obvious to me that they did not make all that themselves. Especially the art, that must have been a pack at least. This engine is tempting me, the watermark at the beginning of my games is starting to become a problem.
@@immortalhamster1645 u can change water mark btw if u have to
I really liked that “skillcheck” struggle mechanic in the second game. It looks like a cool idea.
With some more development and polishing, the last one could be made into a full game
Edit: Everyone stop telling me this is an asset flip, I have been told that more times than I can count and it's getting annoying!
Maybe it will get to be one in the future? :>
Not polishing
It needs months of building😅
I agree
@@osamashokry4524 ofcourde but it is still great
i'm a fiverr game dev too!
I have been searching for more “hiring fiver game dev” videos and there aren’t many videos related to that. Finally a new video
Last seller is a complete scam. Using a pre-made horror engine for unreal which I myself have used, and charging that price.
i said it too
To everyone, even you BadGameDev, thinking the third one was a real game, sorry to disappoint you.
I now worked with UE4 for nearly 6 years, sadly all the assets, even the mechanics, were an asset flip.
The bunker is basically a five dollar package while the mechanics are a template called "Horror Engine", this template is available for free and anyone can play with it. All you have seen is already included in the template, it is basically drag-n-drop and that's it.
Sorry guys...
It's literally copy paste
@@Dazai_200 Exactly
@@jandosk1586 how old r u dude
@@Dazai_200 Don't know why this is a point of interest but definitely old enough to grow up with UE3 back then when it was called UDK.
Care to elaborate?
Third one was just a Unreal engine marketplace template , seller didn't even bother to make slight change.
The common person will be wowed by that last 3D game but in my opinion the second was the best/most intricate
No
@@dillandoesthedo1813you’re 5 years old and get wowed because someone spammed free assets with shitty pbr lighting
My profilepic what you see now is made on fivr.
He was so happy because it was his first job. I told him it was also my first order 🤗
that’s wholesome 😄
@@Shibu-069 the emoji is creepy
My favorite game is the second game the dev was so creatively creative the mechanics of it and all ,.mind blowing
ps:I like the last game too but I felt that it was already made before or he just reused everything from his previous horror game unless he really was committed to the job
Yeah no way he made that 3d game for the video. Thats why the title is so specific.
Yea the third game is just an unreal engine asset so not much work i suppose
The game looked identical to the photo on his profile page so it's clearly from a pre-existing template.
Why you don't try make a multiplayer game ( Or you can't do that )
dani style
He can't obviously
Whattup BONER?
Wow that was really cool
@@_Mooshroom Wanted to say that 😄
Pog, you finally gave credit to who made the Gunner Runner game
Yet still hasn't added any credits to that vid, despite the comment section filled with people calling for that...
The one at 7:43 was made in ue4 and it uses the horror engine asset
Always really enjoy these videos! Great work!
Am I missing the part where you mention how much you paid for each game?
It would just be nice from a critique perspective to know how much you paid and how much time they had. Otherwise it's just you running around 3 random games. Why does this matter? Well, if you paid me $10 and I had 1 day to make a game, you'd probably get the first game. If you paid me $1000 and a month of time to work with, you'd probably get the third game. It's unfair to judge sellers based on radically different conditions.
Thank you! I came to the comments to basically say the same thing. And considering the thumbnail had prices on it, I was assuming that’d be part of the video 🥺
@@JamieDunbar the links of the various sellers are in the description with their price and working days
@@motoscafopazzo1144 I’m looking at the description on my phone and some of it is being cut off. But all I can see is links to the artists Fiverr page. No prices 🤷
@@JamieDunbar Right?
Last time he did that people got so angry in the comments so I guess he didn't want that aagin?
This horror game idea i had a few years ago was called "forgotten" is was a third person horror game where you played a 19yr street smart, street teen named alison smith, who wakes up in a strange place and doesn't remember a thing, while being hunted down by "mr smiley" a tall and slender figure with a mask craves with a smile on it and empty eye sockets, its a survival horror where you have run, hide, stay quite, use stealth and noise to continue farther, alison has blond hair with black dye at the edges, a torn lather jacket, grey hoodie, a white faded shirt with a skull, dark blue jeans with a hole in the left knee, sneakers, and a dark grey beanie and a smallish backpack. While trying to avoid the monsters, alison has to manage her stamina, sanity, hunger, inventory, and rest, few places where alison can restock and feel well rested and save progress in her diary in the her "safe spot", alison can arm herself in different weapons she finds the way and they will break over time, knifes, axes, bats, pipes, ETC.
Thanks for the idea 😊
That's just Alien Isolation but reskinned as being on Earth with Slenderman.
Also, Gamers really hate hunger mechanics.
@@Gojira_Wins the evil within, slender, and other survival horror game gave me the inspiration, the hunger and sanity can easily be manage but should never be neglected or forgotten about, it also adds the challenges to keep track of what's in hand.
I weirdly started rapping your comment when words started rhyming.
@@gotanypain3083 i didnt realise that my comment rhymes until now
note, this was an starting idea i had a long time ago,
Awhile back i came up with another idea, a bunch of idea to put together so far about a teenage girl named brianna William, a 17 year old who and her classmates get taken by a sadistic cult on a remount fictional island with no easy escape
I’m so happy I discovered your channel
The last one was just the free horror engine in unreal engine...
The last game was based on Horror Engine, so it's kinda cheating...
Kinda smart tho
@@JC00PER-08 no?
@@BitterJoyXx anime 🤓🤓
@@JC00PER-08 huh
@@JC00PER-08 he is scamming
That second game was really cool!
BadGameDev: "and here is what we got"
Supercell ad: "SUpERCElL iNTro"
First game was insane!
I would love to see it updated further
The first game sucks. Its just bad... Im a begginer when it comes to unity C# but I can still make that game in 30 mins or less. No character animations, no maze artwork, no "horror" feeling. Basically a waste of money and time. People might get triggred by me saying that but I still think this game is just bad. Even adding a bit of darkness around the player wouldve helped. 20$ wasted.
No way bro said fleshlight instead of flashlight☠️
.the 2nd one which you hired several times now is really creative !!!
man, i love your channel so much lol. every time i get a notification you posted i click asap, keep up the fun work
The third seller is distributing Source Code, which is illegal.
I submitted a Report through Fiverr about this Seller and I would suggest everyone else does the same. It's fine to sell a game you make but don't fuck over Developers trying to sell their Assets.
Agreed, I just checked and he is still on Fiverr. I feel bad for the other people who went through him for game dev.
The 2nd and 3rd game were good, that 3rd game was super good looking. I wish we could have seen the monster
Honestly, I could probably make the first one with the little experience I have with the Construct 3 engine.
Third game is a paid asset reused and put on sale which is well.. pretty illegal its called something like horror engine on ue4 store
I don't think it's illegal to sell a game using premade assets from ue4.
Idk if it's illegal, but I think it's pretty lame when someone just passes someone else's work off as their own
@@TheUltimateNavigator1he used a template scene according to others. So bassicly he did nothing
you should add some features to captain explosion, and if you do, make the knife troughable
My idea for a video:
Ask gamedevs if they can make a strategic map game or just a strategic game
Even bad gamedev has scamers damn
@@Boba_fett327 IKR!
The last one I have a feeling game was already made and just changed it a little to what you want it for. As 3d dev is not cheap i mean like 100k+ for simple game
Dbd players when they see the second game: *its my time.*
You read my mind
I thought no one would know the skill check was a Dead By Daylight thing
Hi badgamedev keep up the good work :)
5:45 maybe use the roll mechanic
What I would like to see is what these devs would give if you asked for a Sim Tower like game.
The sound effects in the last one, definitely the beeping, sounds so familiar, what were they from?
There was the audio from cod 6 the beeping in the beginning
I make games with GameMaker, It's just my side hobby and it's FUN :)
I love your videos man, completely chill and awesome
I loved the third game alarm, it was the best :) I love alarms specially in games.
That last one had the time splitters 2 sound love it
that last game alarm sound is the alarm sound from N64 Goldeneye
YES I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
GoldenEye alarm at 8:30?! I know alarms often sound alike, but I think that's the GoldenEye 007 (from the N64) alarm? Maybe?
You should host a game jam
the first one was honestly just bad, it wasn't even a horror game tbh
I wont even call it a complete game
Pretty sure that 3rd one has been made for awhile and is just reused.
The first game is like a Sprite game
guess you could say that last games.... UNREAL
7:46 "Oh and there's a fleshlight, cool"
me: O.o
The thumbnail was a bit misleading but otherwise nice vid 👍🏻
Very Nice Bro Keep It Up
0:39 dog bark
That last game was very cool. Should make something out of it.
It was a UE4 Template there scamming ppl
@@ESparkAsterbadGameDev just said "make a horror game" with such an unspecific command, the dev can do whatever they want.
How can you call a overly simple maze game a success? And what does it have to do with horror?????? I get you can't bad mouth a dev but seriously? Pure madness.
this guy.s business model is insane. He pays people probably an extremely low amount of money from how the game look so that he can both use it as monitzable youtube videos and also post them on patreon and make money from people wanting to play them too. He doesn't even do what the thumbnail said of using different prices
The Last game used Horror engine
I wish I could get the patreon I would totaly get it even just to support you!
i hate people who goes like "the third one should be a full game". Like come on it looks like a game only made of assets with no work. The one that seemed the most interesting was clearly the second one.
Those are siren head sound effects in the last one
Or at least that’s the only place I’ve heard them
the last developer you paid, did you receive your order on time cause mines is late, im not sure if he’s scamming or not
wait 7:42 "Z is the forward" ? A french game developer?! im not alone ?!
The real horror was the last game you wouldn’t shut the f up so we could hear the emergency brodcast
8:01 “there is no any key in inventory”
Thank you for linking the sellers this time. You should go back and do so for the other Fiverr vids.
Also, why are the prices not given? And you keep reusing the same clickbait thumbnail that falsely suggests you paid someone $1k. Not cool.
3rd game just use the free asset “Horror Engine”
maybe i should make a fiver account, with unreal's content with megascans i could make games 8000x better looking than this x)
the last is a legend
the 1st game there was a X in the beginning at the top right guessing that thats another way to play
I was just going to hire a dev on fivver. DAMN YOU!!!1
Yeah i love this series
can you do a video on trying to make LingLong Incarnation Anime into a shooter game and i think it will actually be a good game if you spend time. hell if i know you might get a award
2nd and 3rd game were nice
in the last game you were freaking your life out 😂 love it
would have been cool to see jumpscares but its ok
the last game has audio that sounds very similar to scp?
Bro getting scammed and still says "thanks good job"
Upload game development series... please
Ahhhh skill checks gotta love them
Makes me wonder if some of these people have games sitting around and sell the same game to multiple people, perhaps changing things only slightly eg., the name. Not saying they do, just wondering.
This. I heard that the 2nd game was actually a unity template that the creator took and delivered so I wouldn't doubt that
unreal engine template@@TheUltimateNavigator1
Where is you probably won’t survive?
lmao is that the timesplitters alarm sound i hear
Next pay game developers to make gta 6:)
I wanna see more scared BadGameDev
you didnt pay them different amounts like the thumbnail said
Wish you would have played them a bit more lol.. the last one especially
What was the turn around time for each of the games?
Can u play more horror games cuz u so funny😂😂😂 jk I know you wownt hahahah
do you also own the creative rights to sell these as your own product?
Yeh since he paid for them
Ask fivver developers to make an scp game!
The second one is just a free horror template from Unreal Engine marketplace, ahhahhahaha. He took your money and delivered basically a free stuff. Haha.
The only thing this video taught me was never to pay someone on fiverr to make a horror game
tbf we have no idea how much he paid them
“i didn’t like the games so the devs who worked hard shouldn’t be paid for their work 🤓”
@@super8bitable`` redistributing a free asset illegaly and charging people a lot of money is hard work 🤓``
I could really see the third game turning into a full game. It has a lot of potential!
99% of that last game was just the free horror engine asset for Unreal Engine. But yes, using it can allow you to spend most of your time actually building a good game. The guy in the last video should've had a lot more done within a week.
Finally a horror game 🎉
Maybe.
whyyyy the last is made with ue4 but he used the open source horror game engine