SPOILERS (Just my interpretation of course) First time I watched I thought the mother was crazy, ruling her household with a narcissistic and obsessive compulsive world view that she projects onto her daughter. However, a second look reveals that the mother is just as much a victim as the daughter. A victim of the father’s constant paranoia and psychosis. Their home is filled with disturbing artwork and grotesque Frankenstein taxidermy projects. A sign on the door demanding to keep it locked, and a glance at a page in his journal reveals a paranoia under which he demands everyone in the house live. He’s taught Rachel many things, like throwing a bone in the forest to see where it leads to, picking up dead pieces of hair and flesh in the forest and holding them to her ear to listen. We know she didn’t learn this from her mother who wouldn’t dare go into the woods for fear of mud and dirt. Her father was out of his mind, and clues in the film point to Rachel possessing the same mental illness as her father. She seems to hear and see things that aren’t there, and as the film progresses and the imagery of the millions of bugs crawling gets more and more frenzied, that’s Rachel slowly succumbing to her psychosis. That moment in the woods, staring into the goats dead eye, is the moment her mind left the “in-between” and her inherited insanity rose to the surface. She then goes home and bludgeons her mother, ties her up, vacuum seals her father, and recites a poem about how she found the “in between” in the woods. Even after his death, the father is an ominous presence in the house. The women are afraid of offending him, worried he’s pretending and that he’ll overhear something he doesn’t like and won’t come back. They’re convinced he’s testing them so they must be on their best behavior, doting on him, bringing him gifts and reciting poems and making sure the house is clean to his liking because as the mother says “you know what your father is like”. She is insistent on carrying on as normal and pretending like nothing bad is happening, because that is how she copes, and perhaps how he expects the household to cope. And if she follows his rules, he’ll notice and come back. This film is Intuitive and clever and grim, the imagery is spot on but the symbolism is not overbearing. The actress playing the mother is so fantastic she really makes this story what it is. I’m so impressed. Serious dogtooth vibes!!
Dolce Luxe thank you for this! You are bang on - the father and daughter are indeed similar in a way the mother isn't, and your interpretations are very true. This should be a top comment!
I thought the daughter's facial expressions were spot on hilarious. Especially when she was in the woods with her 🦴 bone! "Rachael, go get your bone"! 😂🤣😂🤣
Somewhere in Glasgow England lies a little cottage in the woods, and in the Attic are 2 vacuum sealed corpses and a 95 year old woman reading them poetry waiting for them to wake up from their sleep to congratulate her on passing their test on rot.
5:01 I just love the little bit of detail where for the book titled "Grammar and Spelling", "Spelling" is spelt as "Speling", further showing how not particularly well educated the family is on top of the other insane things.
I love these films because unlike most horror films, where it's just jump scares, these are actually suspenseful and creepy. I love this. It's like Creepypasta for RUclips
I couldn't agree more! This was the scariest one I've seen so far. The edgy madness of mother and quiet insanity of this whole situation is sheer terror, and it is literally right up in your face silently screaming at you, and you just cannot look away. I felt like I was going mad by the end of it. This was brilliant! Poor Rachel...
The actress who does the crazy abusive mother does a spot on job! Perfect! The clipped words,the shrill voice, and the obsession with cleanliness. Does a very good imitation of the abusive mother.
This sentence is of major importance and actually easy to comprehend. But it is horrible that it has to be explained. I fear people when they act as a mass.
This film deserves more appreciation. Clever plot, really! Dealing with the loss of a loved one (through death or them leaving)... denial... discovery (courage to overcome boundaries and explore... the truth)... and even acceptance... of the inevitable... death... and the reality of this world. Bravo!
Chickenlegs41 There were flies IN his flesh... Idk much about science but thye’re probably sucking his blood or something. That and they said he smelt horrible.
I feel connected to this short film, it reminds me of when I was home-schooling, there is gaslighting and there is indoctrination and bullying. It takes courage to tell the truth to someone who was in denial. I applauded Rachel for accepting that her father is dead and he is no longer with her.
She didn’t come to realization that her father is dead. She’s just as crazy as the mother. She said that they need to be here when he returns so they can open the bag and give him air. The whole family was delusional
@@mikurusagawa6897 😯 A couple of seconds ago I've posted this to another comment: This sentence is of major importance and actually easy to comprehend. But it is horrible that it has to be explained. I fear people when they act as a mass. Now I read your lines ... Gives me some hope.
I was thinking the same thing lol, maybe its a better way of summing everything up that she doesnt care about to make her daughter focus on the fathers past down paranoia idk lolol
i feel like whenever i watch an odd kind of cryptic start of an ALTER short film, my brain automatically thinks to open the comments as the absolute saints in the comments always explain the well thought out plots of the story perfectly. Thank you to ALTER and those amazing people in the comments who explain the amazing storylines and their well thought out and directed short films
@@yourformeranxiousstubbornb5195 Did your mother use to call you "anxious stubborn brat" and the like? But now you've progressed in finding your own identity, and that's why you add the word "former"? Gosh, if this is true, I really wish you a lot of inner strength and supportive friends to help you heal from those insults, so that your past won't drag you down anymore ☺🤗
@dani cali why does it have to be one country vs the other? With 7 billion people on this planet I'm sure anyone from anywhere can come up with a harrowing horror idea. It doesn't matter where you're from. Horror is universal.
Both of these actresses do a fantastic job in their roles, from the way the mother is set in her opinion despite having evidence she's wrong, to the way Rachel wants to question things she doesn't know given she's only ever been told things from one source, I love it
A lobotomy is a surgery of sorts where part of a person's brain is removed, usually to help fix chronic nightmares and things like that. I don't know what this girl was on about.
@@superswagmimi4237 Yes. Home-schooling is limited to the knowledge of one's parents, and god forbid that person should have such a dummkopf for a mum.
if you're talking about in the woods, then I can tell you that it isn't far from the truth. If you look for dead stuff in the woods, you're almost certain to find some. If you're talking about in the house, well, it's pretty heavily hinted that this is a family of witches. so like. spook
The tension in this film is palpable. It felt like it was bleeding out of my screen with every shot. The composition is gorgeous and edited well. The soundtrack really cranks it up. Really hope to see the actress who played Rachel in more things to come.
Ooooo somebody's been watching RUclips "horror story" channels. There's a law that if you put a horror story on RUclips, it MUST include the word "palpable". Without that word, the video will not be allowed to be published.
I know, right? She's brilliant! I hope she'll be given new opportunities to be an actress again, she was so natural and convincing! I found out she took part to another short movie ("Our Broken Heart"), and in that one she was soooo good, too! She plays a dramatic role, and she kills it! Lovely and very talented!
I said she ALSO, not BECAUSE. Her having depths and her, looking like Anne Hathaway, are 2 UNRELATED/UNRELATED observations. BTW, If you don't agree with any of those 2 DIFFERENT/UNRELATED feedback, fine :) @@littleleah310
It's not just copy and pasting, the video did not make me laughbut this person's comment did. You calling someone brainless for making a joke is very rude and insensitive
OMG....no need to be so rude !!! Keep your hateful comments to yourself...the world would be a more peaceful and happy place if it weren't for people like you, Ben
The acting, the cinematography, the not traditional set up, it's so good and so refreshing. It's not cheap horror with jump scares, it's horror that makes you think and the best part (or actually worst), you can sort of see this sort of thing in real life.
There are...SOOO many half-truths in what the mother is teaching. She's not an intentional liar and she loves her family...she's just a zealot and in denial. This is SUPER well written.
Its true that if a thing is being constantly told, one believes it and accept it as it was told. I totally hate how this mother who is lacking in education herself, makes her daughter believe his dad is gonna comeback. He's dead bruh just accept it.
The sad thing is there are people like this. They become convinced that what they believe is true, get offended when someone says something different, and when everyone else says the same thing the incorrect person t he ows a fit and cuts themselves off from everyone else. There totally are people who would home educate their children because they are convinced the school systems are teaching wrong info.
It goes both way with the school systems. There are really bad school and there are also very good ones. It depends where you go to school. It's the location, the neivhborhood, which makes the school good or bad.
I homeschool my kids and honestly most of the other mom's sound like this woman. Science curriculum should be monitored and knowledge tested just like math and language arts.
I was homeschooled and yeah there were no exams. Luckily, I didn't need them. Now I am a Computer Science senior in uni with a gpa of 3.70 out of 4. So it worked out for me.
In my country, homeschooled kids aren't even registered. It's really sad because for kids with severe anxiety or special educational needs, homeschooling could be really useful, but it's often used by weird people like this woman, and they teach their children that schooling is bad so wrong information is passed down through generations.
I find your comment very interesting. I was homeschooled, and I met some of the craziest and most backwards family from it. There is no doubt that homeschooling certainly has some major downsides, I feel like I suffer from some issues that worsened due to being homeschooled. Now as a college student, i feel free from it all though
Yeah because this is an accurate representation of home education.... I guess they should now make a horror video about governmental school education and show you how great that is, maybe something like Nazi Germany governmental school education.
Mom: He must be proud. It's not easy making rhymes like that. The Girl: Oh dad, you the best dad I've had. I'm glad. But you're dead and that's bad, and makes me sad.
Rather... incorrect, perverse, erroneous, psychopathic, horrific , sick and evil home education. Wonder what the final exam entails? What kind of school did lovely mom attend? Great job Alter. Thanks.
I have this WIERD fascination with horror shorts. Half of my mind fears that I will see something I wanna unsee, and the other half doesn't care and loves this.
A beautifully disturbing film about two people grappling with the idea of mortality and grief, the mother with denial and the need to control and the daughter with naïvety yet curiosity and creativity.
Did anyone else thought about what these guys were doing before the man died? Like was the whole family crazy? And what was that thing that was shown in dark anyway?
Everyone is making smartass comments for the laughs, but I actually wanted to congratulate this short movie : it was INCREDIBLE. The lightning, aesthetic, the actor's way of playing, the theme that reminds us a little bit of ''Stranger Things'' with the whole upside down concept and this very suffocating atmosphere that we can have in ''huit clos'' type of movies. I would have love to see an actual, 1h30 long movie with these actresses and concept. Thank you so much for making me discover new short films that develop my creativity ^-^
This short was brilliant, and I love how it unfolded. There is definitely abuse going on here and my perception is that both the mother and the daughter were abused in this home by the father. I think that there was possibly violence and emotional abuse towards the mother first by her domineering husband and that when she domestically instructs her daughter and slaps her for being out of line, it is so the girl can navigate around her father and avoid more serious violence from him towards her and possibly back to the mother for not doing enough to educate her daughter "right". The mother was probably already broken when her daughter was born and appears to be obsessive compulsive and is clearly uneducated in matters of science, which is kind of funny if the situation was not so serious. The only way to get her to listen was to tape up her mouth, and as we leave her tied up in the chair, she will now be a victim of all the faulty education she has imparted in this years-long tyranny. Couldn't happen shiver a nicer person!
Why are all of you so averse to the idea of a woman (especially a white woman) being an evil, manipulative abuser? Isn't there enough evidence in the video suggesting that that is so?
hey damn that makes so much sense- i didn't even consider that. Thats why she couldn't let go of her stubborn behavior- people experiencing abuse are still often suffering the consequences even if the abuser isn't around anymore.
Absolutely brilliant, the film oscillates in perfect balance between art and horror, creating this intelligent movie of poetic angst. And the young woman is such a genuine talented actress.
bacteria aren't mammals cuz bacteria use asexual reproduction instead of well yeah and don't blame me blame mi science teacher Ms.magard PLS hlp mi I hate school
white wolfy _12234 That really doesn’t classify bacteria or mammals. A better example would be that all mammals are eukaryotes, while all bacteria are prokaryotes.
20:13 : “Hi” 😂😂😂😂😂 she just said Hi like nothing has happened. Lol. She is an awesome actress. ALTER u never cease to amaze me!!!! Thank u for always making videos to share to horror lovers like me❤️
HOLY SHIT @ HOME EDUCATION. been binging horror shorts for some creative inspo for the last 2 hours and this one absolutely blew me away. Writing is so beyond clever and love how it circles back and evolves without feeling redundant. Acting performances are SO, so good and genuinely FUNNY and relevant all at the same time. Wardrobe & HMU are so perfect for characters they are maintained yet still flawed enough to make us feel there with them. The fly montage, ohmygod. The sound design with this in particular was *gorgeous*. Shots are incredible, extra crispy and intelligently stitched together with such wonderfully unflattering lighting in the best way. Excellent job to everyone on this short, I just had to share how much I truly enjoyed this project. Been an Alter fan for years but this one rlly blew me away. The overall message was felt without being forced, and personally something I fixate on in the spoon-fed media age. This team accomplished comments on censorship and mental health in a way that felt actually original and not overexaggerated. We tend to define horror with very graphic, visual imagery; but Home Education really makes you wonder; maybe the scariest thing for us humans is anything unknown/the result of, or in this case, literal lack of knowledge.
Mother is grieving & is in complete denial of her husband's passing. She's putting it off on the daughter for not doing things in "order." Blaming her daughter for him not waking up. Odd & uncanny, but I LOVE it!
"In the woods" In the woods is where i go Whenever i am free And when i go into the woods I see the in-between We dont know how the place works But we do know that its there We all know its the door That opens here to there Because that is where there is the space That crosses in between The things we see right here And the ones we havent seen And when we all go through that place The world will turn around There foxes fly water is dry And trees are upside down The flies are in the sky And the sky is on the ground So we must keep on exploring Until the day we doubt That the way into the nightmare Is our only way out Love this so muchhh
Thank you for the transcription - I was looking to see if anyone had done that. I'm using this film with my students and the poem (which I love too) is an important part of that. You've saved me some time transcribing it myself :))
One slight mistake. If he was rotten enough for flies then the fathers body would really smell the whole house out, not just when the blankets were pulled back: the flies would be the least of their concerns. Apologies if said before but otherwise a great film.
I love looking for horror shorts late at night and then ending up watching films from a new channel all night, Alter has some great content, lots of unexpected endings
Well... I have to say... the actors were amazing.... especially the young lady... she outperformed the other two and the other guy was dead... seriously though... both ladies were amazing and it was an outstanding performance.
Who loves alter?! I LOVE ALTER ❤️ 💕
Me too
Me too!
me three!
The Dog me four!
I FUCKING LOVE ALTER!
SPOILERS (Just my interpretation of course)
First time I watched I thought the mother was crazy, ruling her household with a narcissistic and obsessive compulsive world view that she projects onto her daughter.
However, a second look reveals that the mother is just as much a victim as the daughter. A victim of the father’s constant paranoia and psychosis. Their home is filled with disturbing artwork and grotesque Frankenstein taxidermy projects. A sign on the door demanding to keep it locked, and a glance at a page in his journal reveals a paranoia under which he demands everyone in the house live.
He’s taught Rachel many things, like throwing a bone in the forest to see where it leads to, picking up dead pieces of hair and flesh in the forest and holding them to her ear to listen. We know she didn’t learn this from her mother who wouldn’t dare go into the woods for fear of mud and dirt. Her father was out of his mind, and clues in the film point to Rachel possessing the same mental illness as her father. She seems to hear and see things that aren’t there, and as the film progresses and the imagery of the millions of bugs crawling gets more and more frenzied, that’s Rachel slowly succumbing to her psychosis.
That moment in the woods, staring into the goats dead eye, is the moment her mind left the “in-between” and her inherited insanity rose to the surface. She then goes home and bludgeons her mother, ties her up, vacuum seals her father, and recites a poem about how she found the “in between” in the woods.
Even after his death, the father is an ominous presence in the house. The women are afraid of offending him, worried he’s pretending and that he’ll overhear something he doesn’t like and won’t come back. They’re convinced he’s testing them so they must be on their best behavior, doting on him, bringing him gifts and reciting poems and making sure the house is clean to his liking because as the mother says “you know what your father is like”. She is insistent on carrying on as normal and pretending like nothing bad is happening, because that is how she copes, and perhaps how he expects the household to cope. And if she follows his rules, he’ll notice and come back.
This film is Intuitive and clever and grim, the imagery is spot on but the symbolism is not overbearing. The actress playing the mother is so fantastic she really makes this story what it is. I’m so impressed. Serious dogtooth vibes!!
Dolce Luxe thank you for this! You are bang on - the father and daughter are indeed similar in a way the mother isn't, and your interpretations are very true. This should be a top comment!
Good gracious thank you for explaining lol.. I couldn't quite figure out what was going on
Your spot on!
@rutituti678. Me either lol. I still have no clue
I wish I was your type of smarts.
I always rot a bit to test people around me
Mikuru Sagawa
Lmao
As long as it’s only a little bit, that’s fine.
People around me rot to test me
Ah same, so relatable
Same here man
Honestly the daughters performance is great. Absolutely heartbreaking
And yet.. u start an argument
Honestly...
I thought the daughter's facial expressions were spot on hilarious. Especially when she was in the woods with her 🦴 bone! "Rachael, go get your bone"! 😂🤣😂🤣
@@neshaoinspopolk4417 wewedgwuuu
@@vitorribasboska6792 I'm sorry, did you mean wedgwood?
the actor who played the dad killed it
I quite agree, He gave a breath taking performance.
😂🤣
He was dead-set on doing a good job.
😂😂😂😜
This actor got one of the best roles ever. A role to die for
I think the casting of the girl was perfect, her big doeful eyes tell the most amazing story!
Omg yaaassss shes amazing she needs to be in more movies and series
She looks like Michael Jackson lol
Did you mean doleful or doe-eyed? Cuz either way you're not wrong
@@reachbean LMAO fr
i love her eyes they speak a thousands words...I love a woman with beautiful big eyes.
And that my friends...is how to raise a serial killer
Yes cap'n I am taking notes!
Yep
×)🔫😛
lmao xD
Dude your right the saddest part is that there are actually people like this in the world. This goes for the mom and the daughter.
Somewhere in Glasgow England lies a little cottage in the woods, and in the Attic are 2 vacuum sealed corpses and a 95 year old woman reading them poetry waiting for them to wake up from their sleep to congratulate her on passing their test on rot.
Why must you scare me in this way
Glasgow? England?
Glasgow is in Scotland
@@Billy69101Thank you. A true hero
but how does a family find meat, if they don't even know where dust comes from?
Mom: "Stop questioning things you know nothing about"
SO WHAT'S THE POINT OF QUESTIONING THEN?
L. Sousa Official exactly. We’d know nothing if we stopped questioning what we don’t know
It's code for "Shut up, I want to be right."
L. Sousa Official Yeah mom is damaged I think.
right?
I was just watching this part and i asked myself the same thing XD
That man is going to be bones in a bed and they're still gonna be saying "he'll be back soon" 🤦🏾♀️😂😂
For real
And the mother will keep on insisting that the father is only testing them
Ikr bloody hell
kitkatcoco67 its one word decomp
Delusions are lies that tell the truth
The scariest moment was when she said bacteria are mammals.
YUP
…And that air is “made of oxygen.” 😂
She ignores the 78% nitrogen.
Scariest part was when she made goat noises at a goat head
Also..y-your profile is kinda creepy ngl-
Also..y-your profile is kinda creepy ngl-
5:01 I just love the little bit of detail where for the book titled "Grammar and Spelling", "Spelling" is spelt as "Speling", further showing how not particularly well educated the family is on top of the other insane things.
*“he’s rotting a little bit to see how we react”* yeah sure hun whatever floats your boat
😂
Lol
ARMY is everywhere
The dad died , mother in denial, teaching her daughter that he would come back if they kept away the bacteria...... Yup... totally bonkers!!
Lmao
That just goes to show that the daughter is more grown up than her own mother. Lmao 😆
It took me a Hot Minute to realize the dad was dead, not in a Coma.
The mom was turning it into a religion too.
Thanks for explaining that for me. I was wondering what the hell was going on
SHE DIDN'T EVEN CRACK THE EGGS
SHE JUST PUT WHOLE, RAW EGGS WITH SHELLS IN HER FOOD
British cooking yo.
@@Quinn10 😂😂😂😂😂
Keiley Crother
And one was moving, bro
Hehehehe 🤣🤣😂😁
We didn’t even get to see what the final product looked like.
i love the casual misinformation that dust and bacteria are mammals
😂
For real had me googling to make sure I wasn't tripping 😂
Scariest part: The chicken, cauliflower and those whole eggs weren’t seasoned at all
Ikr?! An hour and a half of the mom cooking and you got yourself a horror movie.
The egg moved
@@Myp0tat0head oh thank god I'm not the only one that saw that I thought I was losing it
Fr she didn’t even put salt and pepper
ATLEAST ADD SALT 😫
“Foxes fly water is dry and trees are upside down”
Hey look at that she discovered Australia
Omg
Water is wet
Vortex597 lol
Australia isn't real
phoebe poh ok
I love these films because unlike most horror films, where it's just jump scares, these are actually suspenseful and creepy. I love this. It's like Creepypasta for RUclips
Sounds like you've been ALTERed. 🖤
@@WatchALTER Yup! And I'm so glad. Been binging all week.
I think they're thriller not horror
@@tasha3757 Can't deny the creepy aspect though
I couldn't agree more! This was the scariest one I've seen so far. The edgy madness of mother and quiet insanity of this whole situation is sheer terror, and it is literally right up in your face silently screaming at you, and you just cannot look away. I felt like I was going mad by the end of it. This was brilliant! Poor Rachel...
The actress who does the crazy abusive mother does a spot on job! Perfect! The clipped words,the shrill voice, and the obsession with cleanliness. Does a very good imitation of the abusive mother.
This mother and the mother from the other short horror flick who killed her children for being dirty should get together and have tea.
Omg sooo true!!
What one is that I wanna go watch it
@@sr4698 it's called Childer
@@berkleep9885 just watched that shit yesterday and then this =)))
YES
“Stop questioning things you know nothing about”
It’s that how you learn? I mean...
right like what
Yeah seriously
I think you meant "isn't"
This sentence is of major importance and actually easy to comprehend. But it is horrible that it has to be explained. I fear people when they act as a mass.
The family functions like a cult. Cults don’t want you to question. They want you to obey.
"He is rotting a little bit, to see how we react." .. WELL , we`ll see about that 🤣
I know right 😂
Is the mom crazy or what
@@iminneedofhelp5513 PSYKO MURDERER
277 likes 4 comments iluminati confirm
Hi cutie
This film deserves more appreciation. Clever plot, really!
Dealing with the loss of a loved one (through death or them leaving)... denial... discovery (courage to overcome boundaries and explore... the truth)... and even acceptance... of the inevitable... death... and the reality of this world. Bravo!
Me: The daughter's personality is actually cute.
Her: BEEEEH
Me: We all make mistakes..
Luxyon 😂
Lmao 😂 😂😂😂
what
@@poppiinmaya2607 16:07 in the video
When?
*"he's rotting a little bit... to see how we react"*
random craft love that line 🥰
They are still believing he would come back but... He isn't coming back anymore...
It's only a flesh wound!?
Chickenlegs41
There were flies IN his flesh... Idk much about science but thye’re probably sucking his blood or something. That and they said he smelt horrible.
That girl is rebirth of Anne Hathaway!! A great actress is coming
Perizat Ismailova ya actually she is reminding me of Hathway
Ironclaw XII It’s like she’s acting like Anne Hathaway in real life, then?
I also thought about it too!
Perizat Ismailova that’s what I thought too!
Ironclaw XII Anne Hathaway is a Queen! Love her
I feel connected to this short film, it reminds me of when I was home-schooling, there is gaslighting and there is indoctrination and bullying. It takes courage to tell the truth to someone who was in denial. I applauded Rachel for accepting that her father is dead and he is no longer with her.
Woah. I never knew that’s what homeschooling is like. I hope it didn’t take too long for you to pull through.
@@FusedPixelz typically this is only when radical religious people home school I’ve been doing online school and I love it
Sure sure lol. Seems contrived
@@listlessdandelion3587I hope you and your loved ones are okay)❤
She didn’t come to realization that her father is dead. She’s just as crazy as the mother. She said that they need to be here when he returns so they can open the bag and give him air. The whole family was delusional
" He's testing us."
Yeah and you are failling miserably.
Oof 🥲
THANK YOU! oh my GOD I swear--
Stop dude you arleady kild her!
“I made sure to plaster your head so you won’t have a lobotomy” this film is breaking me
It's funny how the "grammar and speling" book isn't even spelled correctly, such irony
I thought I was the only one that noticed that 😂
Yes, and "Drawring" too
I think thats the point
I think its because of their accent, thats how they say spelling, with only one l.
they also use the wrong word in "Knitting and Sowing" lol sowing is for seeds, sewing is the thing with needles and thread
These two are in a psychotic state of mind. Grief does that.
"Stop questioning things you know nothing about" The irony of that statement
Worst thing about that is that I know (we probably all do) people in real life who state the same with the same lack of any knowledge
@@mikurusagawa6897 😯 A couple of seconds ago I've posted this to another comment: This sentence is of major importance and actually easy to comprehend. But it is horrible that it has to be explained. I fear people when they act as a mass.
Now I read your lines ... Gives me some hope.
“He’s just rotting to test us”
Me when having a breakdown
😂😂
I feel ya
:)
LMAO
LoL...huh...lol....left
Ok... did this lady just say bacteria are mammals...
I didn’t listen during taxonomy, but that ain’t it sis.
I was thinking the same thing lol, maybe its a better way of summing everything up that she doesnt care about to make her daughter focus on the fathers past down paranoia idk lolol
5:42
girl: can you make anything hard?
mom: yes
mom's brain: how the hell do u think you got here rachel
lololololol
underrated comment
LMAO I THOUGHT THAT WHEN I HEARD THAT AND CAME TO THE COMMENTS TO SEE IF ANYONE SAID THAT XDD
lol
cosmic rot I CANT
i feel like whenever i watch an odd kind of cryptic start of an ALTER short film, my brain automatically thinks to open the comments as the absolute saints in the comments always explain the well thought out plots of the story perfectly. Thank you to ALTER and those amazing people in the comments who explain the amazing storylines and their well thought out and directed short films
Kudos to the main actress who’s out there vibing with the worms and listening to death in some creepy ass forest for the sake of our enjoyment
this is the best comment lol
😂😂😂😂😂‼️ my kinda people
best comment ever
'vibing with the worms' will be engraved on my tombstone, thank you
Omg 😂
The way the mom treats her daughter kills me.
My mom is worse xD😭✨
Ikr
@@yourformeranxiousstubbornb5195
I feel bad for you ;(
was ist dein lieblingsfach?
@@yourformeranxiousstubbornb5195 Did your mother use to call you "anxious stubborn brat" and the like? But now you've progressed in finding your own identity, and that's why you add the word "former"? Gosh, if this is true, I really wish you a lot of inner strength and supportive friends to help you heal from those insults, so that your past won't drag you down anymore ☺🤗
rachel- how do you know he’s pretending?
mom- because, nobody actually WANTS to rot, Rachel 😂😂😂
lmao such a Karen
I mean....she's got a point👀
Best line in the flick
@dani cali why does it have to be one country vs the other? With 7 billion people on this planet I'm sure anyone from anywhere can come up with a harrowing horror idea. It doesn't matter where you're from. Horror is universal.
@dani cali u sound dumb
Both of these actresses do a fantastic job in their roles, from the way the mother is set in her opinion despite having evidence she's wrong, to the way Rachel wants to question things she doesn't know given she's only ever been told things from one source, I love it
"I made sure to plaster your head so you wouldn't have a Lobotomy"......GOD, I love this girl!
i dont even know what a labotomy is
A lobotomy is a surgery of sorts where part of a person's brain is removed, usually to help fix chronic nightmares and things like that. I don't know what this girl was on about.
@@gregthemerrow5306 i’m pretty sure it was meant to serve as another example of her mother’s twisted teachings.
@@superswagmimi4237 Yes. Home-schooling is limited to the knowledge of one's parents, and god forbid that person should have such a dummkopf for a mum.
@@gregthemerrow5306 Home schooling is never a good idea
"he's rotting a little bit..to see how we react." wtf kind of logic is that
h _ xsociety Possibly the most brilliant line in all of cinema!
The cake in fridge ate itself cause everybody likes cake
@@bichen-up-ur I just can’t😂😂This made me laugh way too hard
I always rot just a lil bit to test my loved ones... you don't? 👀
Seriously, what is up with all the dead things lying around
I See it Everyday when I go to grab a Lunch
Simbå Sàmá lol
they are animal hunters
if you're talking about in the woods, then I can tell you that it isn't far from the truth. If you look for dead stuff in the woods, you're almost certain to find some. If you're talking about in the house, well, it's pretty heavily hinted that this is a family of witches. so like. spook
I think the Mom is Homicidal?? Maybe idk tho
The Actor playing the mother is fucking fantastic, she sold every emotion, especially the denial.
"Get your bone and go find your father something special in the woods" LMFAO
Lmfaoo I wonder wtf was the purpose of the bone
@@enrique8190 what did it come from?
@@julieboys8194 who knows
do you think the bone and the "can you make anything hard?" is all some complex fertility symbol?
*i readed that comment at the moment she said that*
*Obsesses over things being clean*
Rachel:*crawls near dead things and bugs on the forest floor*
Nice profile.
BAAAAAAAH
Obsessed over dust and bacteria but has a huge collection of stuffed dead animals... and she doesn’t wash her hands after touching the raw meat
@@lissasue6241 Maybe mum's cooking killed dad?
*centuries later*
~the dad is just bones now~
“He’ll come back soon”
Mother: he just dried up a bit to see how we react.
😂
Just testing us
Rachel : And look mom, you're rotten just like me.
Mom : Oh, we're also testing him.
Spooky scary dad
@@umikayumi2690 To see how he reacts
The tension in this film is palpable. It felt like it was bleeding out of my screen with every shot. The composition is gorgeous and edited well. The soundtrack really cranks it up. Really hope to see the actress who played Rachel in more things to come.
it was really well at building a world that sucked me in and i wanted to somehow see or know more from those characters
Ooooo somebody's been watching RUclips "horror story" channels. There's a law that if you put a horror story on RUclips, it MUST include the word "palpable". Without that word, the video will not be allowed to be published.
I can't believe that the girl, Kate Reed, career didn't just rocket. She is amazing.
I know, right? She's brilliant! I hope she'll be given new opportunities to be an actress again, she was so natural and convincing! I found out she took part to another short movie ("Our Broken Heart"), and in that one she was soooo good, too! She plays a dramatic role, and she kills it! Lovely and very talented!
She has depths not all actors can reach. She also looks like Anne Hathaway ❤
@@divinearellano7019so her looks is her depth?!
I said she ALSO, not BECAUSE. Her having depths and her, looking like Anne Hathaway, are 2 UNRELATED/UNRELATED observations. BTW, If you don't agree with any of those 2 DIFFERENT/UNRELATED feedback, fine :) @@littleleah310
"He's rotting a little.. to see how we react"
Him: *dead*
Flies: *buzz buzz*
Them: 👀👀
Hotel: trivago
@Justin Trudeau because I thought it was funny enough to comment fym move on lmao I could say the same thing about your reply
It's not just copy and pasting, the video did not make me laughbut this person's comment did. You calling someone brainless for making a joke is very rude and insensitive
@Justin Trudeau I didn’t but thank you
OMG....no need to be so rude !!! Keep your hateful comments to yourself...the world would be a more peaceful and happy place if it weren't for people like you, Ben
The acting, the cinematography, the not traditional set up, it's so good and so refreshing. It's not cheap horror with jump scares, it's horror that makes you think and the best part (or actually worst), you can sort of see this sort of thing in real life.
There are...SOOO many half-truths in what the mother is teaching. She's not an intentional liar and she loves her family...she's just a zealot and in denial. This is SUPER well written.
Its true that if a thing is being constantly told, one believes it and accept it as it was told. I totally hate how this mother who is lacking in education herself, makes her daughter believe his dad is gonna comeback. He's dead bruh just accept it.
You figure a lot of people tend to go a little crazy after they’ve lost someone they loved
@@applestobuttercups6035 correct. This woman gone too far.😂
@Brandon Greco I know it's wrong but my whole life has been a lie bruh😂 don't know what's real anymore just saying.
The sad thing is there are people like this. They become convinced that what they believe is true, get offended when someone says something different, and when everyone else says the same thing the incorrect person t he ows a fit and cuts themselves off from everyone else. There totally are people who would home educate their children because they are convinced the school systems are teaching wrong info.
It goes both way with the school systems. There are really bad school and there are also very good ones. It depends where you go to school. It's the location, the neivhborhood, which makes the school good or bad.
I need to see the finished result of that meal she was cooking though 😂
Right? Who the fuck uses eggs in shell?
g kkkwar it hardboils them lol
For real tho-
I thought it was cauliflower
8)
Them: “he’ll come back”
The dad: anyway I start rotting
hes just testing them
What I don’t get is how them being there equates him to coming back with air…
699th like
@@ellaelliott4415 Basically they would be there when he wakes up to let him out of the plastic so he doesn't suffocate
Literally one of the best short stories I’ve ever seen! The ending was absolutely fantastic!!
I homeschool my kids and honestly most of the other mom's sound like this woman. Science curriculum should be monitored and knowledge tested just like math and language arts.
I was homeschooled and yeah there were no exams. Luckily, I didn't need them. Now I am a Computer Science senior in uni with a gpa of 3.70 out of 4. So it worked out for me.
In my country, homeschooled kids aren't even registered. It's really sad because for kids with severe anxiety or special educational needs, homeschooling could be really useful, but it's often used by weird people like this woman, and they teach their children that schooling is bad so wrong information is passed down through generations.
I find your comment very interesting. I was homeschooled, and I met some of the craziest and most backwards family from it. There is no doubt that homeschooling certainly has some major downsides, I feel like I suffer from some issues that worsened due to being homeschooled. Now as a college student, i feel free from it all though
Yet you spelt "moms" wrong.
In my country if you are home schooled you should be registered in a normal school so teachers can come to your house and help you learn
“Air...AIR IS MADE OF OXYGEN” oml why is she even a mom
“StaWp qUeStiOniNg tHiNgs YoU dOnT kNoW aBoUt” then how da heckz are we gonna learn
Those people don't want you to learn freely, only the stuff they are teaching you. The core concept of indoctrination.
It's a short film it's not real pls calm down
"The way into the nightmare is our only way out"
Oh, that hit different.
Legitimately see a lot of potential with this channel. You guys totally deserve a RUclips Red show or Netflix show
@@tapsi6928 they get permision and promote them on the description just like omelleto?
Wow, thanks for all the likes!
i would totally watch a short creepy stories show on netflix like this
“Just because you know something, doesn’t mean you know everything!”
This woman could learn a thing or two
She does have a point, she knows a little, but not how to make an egg
@@randomuser5443 she had no point lmfaoo. She even referred to bacteria as mammals💀💀.
Nah...She is stupid. Remember Dunning Kruger effect.
The only thing that I understood is that home education is terrific
Thank you! That means a lot :)
well it is. Think about what the hell happens when parents decide to go full woke by "teaching" their flat earth BS to their non vaccinated kid
Yeah because this is an accurate representation of home education....
I guess they should now make a horror video about governmental school education and show you how great that is, maybe something like Nazi Germany governmental school education.
@@arav13 - Yeah, everyone should go to public education to learn that sex is an illusion and there is no difference between a man and a woman.
@@NielsenWill I don't get you buddy, but as long as there is no home schooling I'm fine with that
I know people are talking about the "no one wants to rot" line, but I burst out laughing when Rachel finished vacuuming her dad with "hi"
The scariest thing about this short film is that it perpetuates the myth that poetry needs to rhyme
Thats what i thought LMFAO
Mom: He must be proud. It's not easy making rhymes like that.
The Girl: Oh dad, you the best dad I've had. I'm glad. But you're dead and that's bad, and makes me sad.
LMFAOOOOOO
And that bacteria are mammals
@@Jakamo2323PLSSSS💀
Rather... incorrect, perverse, erroneous, psychopathic, horrific , sick and evil home education. Wonder what the final exam entails? What kind of school did lovely mom attend? Great job Alter. Thanks.
I have this WIERD fascination with horror shorts. Half of my mind fears that I will see something I wanna unsee, and the other half doesn't care and loves this.
That’s everyone including me lol
Sammee
I know right!
A beautifully disturbing film about two people grappling with the idea of mortality and grief, the mother with denial and the need to control and the daughter with naïvety yet curiosity and creativity.
Did anyone else thought about what these guys were doing before the man died? Like was the whole family crazy? And what was that thing that was shown in dark anyway?
I wonder what context clues are, it's not like we where taught this in 8th grade English 🙄
Mum is "complicated and dangerous" for her daughter. It's sick to want to live with a dead person.
The mother might be a victim of a supressive husband and be totally lost without his guidance, she probably really believes he will come back.
"It prevents mould bacteria WHICH ARE ALSO MAMMALS!!"
My brain: *"One gram of diamond weighs something like fifteen grams."*
beetlejuice’s logic is being passed on 😌
As soon as this was said I was like "hold up! That isn't true" and then the logic went downhill from there. Lol
Everyone is making smartass comments for the laughs, but I actually wanted to congratulate this short movie : it was INCREDIBLE.
The lightning, aesthetic, the actor's way of playing, the theme that reminds us a little bit of ''Stranger Things'' with the whole upside down concept and this very suffocating atmosphere that we can have in ''huit clos'' type of movies.
I would have love to see an actual, 1h30 long movie with these actresses and concept.
Thank you so much for making me discover new short films that develop my creativity ^-^
This short was brilliant, and I love how it unfolded. There is definitely abuse going on here and my perception is that both the mother and the daughter were abused in this home by the father. I think that there was possibly violence and emotional abuse towards the mother first by her domineering husband and that when she domestically instructs her daughter and slaps her for being out of line, it is so the girl can navigate around her father and avoid more serious violence from him towards her and possibly back to the mother for not doing enough to educate her daughter "right". The mother was probably already broken when her daughter was born and appears to be obsessive compulsive and is clearly uneducated in matters of science, which is kind of funny if the situation was not so serious. The only way to get her to listen was to tape up her mouth, and as we leave her tied up in the chair, she will now be a victim of all the faulty education she has imparted in this years-long tyranny. Couldn't happen shiver a nicer person!
Excellent analysis 👌🏼
Why are all of you so averse to the idea of a woman (especially a white woman) being an evil, manipulative abuser? Isn't there enough evidence in the video suggesting that that is so?
hey damn that makes so much sense- i didn't even consider that. Thats why she couldn't let go of her stubborn behavior- people experiencing abuse are still often suffering the consequences even if the abuser isn't around anymore.
"Can you make anything hard?"
Me and my mature brain: that's what she said lololol
Just get into a freezer, or rope
Sheconds I laughed at that bit too lol 😂
Same😆
NO STOP YOU CANT DO THAT TO ME
Michael Scott has entered the chat
I thought the goat head was going to scream
Same 😂
Ikr
MEEEEEHHHHHHH lol
🤣🤣Me too
same here lmao
Im sitting here on second watch through wondering what the hell the mother was making in the kitchen
OrabitsMadness ikr
Something inedible
Imma go and try making sum of that
Right!
Chicken, cauliflower, and uncracked eggs. Tasty.
Absolutely brilliant, the film oscillates in perfect balance between art and horror, creating this intelligent movie of poetic angst. And the young woman is such a genuine talented actress.
Alter is the heccin best
That dumbass is... well a dumbass
And that nobody knows where dust comes from, and that air is made entirely of oxygen, that the reason some stuff decays is because its hard, etc, etc,
bacteria aren't mammals cuz bacteria use asexual reproduction instead of well yeah and don't blame me blame mi science teacher Ms.magard PLS hlp mi I hate school
white wolfy _12234 That really doesn’t classify bacteria or mammals. A better example would be that all mammals are eukaryotes, while all bacteria are prokaryotes.
Woooooooosh
When the fox said “🥺” I felt that
Melody Lilac same 😔
Can relate
Lol
What does that, ⒨⒠⒜⒩
Im a germaphobe and this just gives me bad anxiety.
I love rotting a little bit to test my loved ones💀
But forreal, this was my first Alter short horror, and I absolutely fell in love 😩👏🏾
ALTER do a full horror film that lasts 2 hours already. I want to see it in a cinema
We're almost there. Keep a 👀 out.
@@WatchALTER now i just hope that it will be all over the world
I’d be the first in line !
@@laurenmorales6241 i think that spot is reserved for me
20:13 : “Hi”
😂😂😂😂😂 she just said Hi like nothing has happened. Lol.
She is an awesome actress.
ALTER u never cease to amaze me!!!!
Thank u for always making videos to share to horror lovers like me❤️
Is it just me or does the daughter look alot like Anne Hathaway, sorry if I spelt her name wrong
No you spelt it right
OliVIA U but she does thoo
I think so.
I thought she did to!
More like michael jackson lol
"That the way into the nightmare is our only way out" my favorite phase, this was amaizng
The two actresses here both sold it amazingly, some of the best acting I've seen in a horror short.
The way they believe he will be back, is like my kids telling me they will clean their room soon .
Cuz no one wants to . Saying that from a kids heart (I'm am a kid)
😂😂
I'm curious how the family makes money?
Taxidermy?
Serveys!!!
go on ebay and look at taxidermy, it gets exspensive
Actors for this film 😂
Yeah, could be from taxidermy, the father could be a taxidermist
HOLY SHIT @ HOME EDUCATION. been binging horror shorts for some creative inspo for the last 2 hours and this one absolutely blew me away. Writing is so beyond clever and love how it circles back and evolves without feeling redundant. Acting performances are SO, so good and genuinely FUNNY and relevant all at the same time. Wardrobe & HMU are so perfect for characters they are maintained yet still flawed enough to make us feel there with them. The fly montage, ohmygod. The sound design with this in particular was *gorgeous*. Shots are incredible, extra crispy and intelligently stitched together with such wonderfully unflattering lighting in the best way. Excellent job to everyone on this short, I just had to share how much I truly enjoyed this project. Been an Alter fan for years but this one rlly blew me away. The overall message was felt without being forced, and personally something I fixate on in the spoon-fed media age. This team accomplished comments on censorship and mental health in a way that felt actually original and not overexaggerated. We tend to define horror with very graphic, visual imagery; but Home Education really makes you wonder; maybe the scariest thing for us humans is anything unknown/the result of, or in this case, literal lack of knowledge.
Also WTF IS THE MOTHER COOKING AND WHERE DID THOSE EGGS COME FROM
Mother is grieving & is in complete denial of her husband's passing. She's putting it off on the daughter for not doing things in "order." Blaming her daughter for him not waking up. Odd & uncanny, but I LOVE it!
Did anyone notice how “spelling” was spelled “speling” when they show the shots of all the books
Home education must actually be one of the best horror movies I have ever seen in a few months! You are literally amazing
"In the woods"
In the woods is where i go
Whenever i am free
And when i go into the woods
I see the in-between
We dont know how the place works
But we do know that its there
We all know its the door
That opens here to there
Because that is where there is the space
That crosses in between
The things we see right here
And the ones we havent seen
And when we all go through that place
The world will turn around
There foxes fly water is dry
And trees are upside down
The flies are in the sky
And the sky is on the ground
So we must keep on exploring
Until the day we doubt
That the way into the nightmare
Is our only way out
Love this so muchhh
Thank you for the transcription - I was looking to see if anyone had done that. I'm using this film with my students and the poem (which I love too) is an important part of that. You've saved me some time transcribing it myself :))
One slight mistake. If he was rotten enough for flies then the fathers body would really smell the whole house out, not just when the blankets were pulled back: the flies would be the least of their concerns. Apologies if said before but otherwise a great film.
MrCrisp yes and if there were flies there would probably be maggots which would happen after around 2-3 weeks of rotting.
MrCrisp thanks will try. 👍
He’s been taxidermied at least somewhat.
Don’t forget nose blindness will prevent them from smelling.
Mrs G No it won’t, it really won’t
"Mold bacterias, which are also mammals"
I burst out laughing harder than I should have ^^
I love looking for horror shorts late at night and then ending up watching films from a new channel all night, Alter has some great content, lots of unexpected endings
Damn, she’s beautiful. Looks like a young Anne Hathaway.
Lol that's what exactly popped up in my mind the second I saw her lol
Didn’t see your comment until now but YES
Thought she looked more like Michael Jackson, post surgeries.
true
@@chadellis8294 😂😂😂
I lost her as soon as she said, “it rhymes so it’s a poem”.
What about raps? And poems don’t all rhyme.
"He's rotting a little bit, too see how we react".This movie was so well written, I loved it.Both actresses were brilliant.One if your best Alter.
Well... I have to say... the actors were amazing.... especially the young lady... she outperformed the other two and the other guy was dead... seriously though... both ladies were amazing and it was an outstanding performance.