BOEING 727 vs. TUPOLEV TU-154 - LANDING + DEPARTURE - Which one do you like more? (4K)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 янв 2025

Комментарии • 195

  • @alexp5138
    @alexp5138 4 года назад +76

    727 looks like a plane with 3 engines strapped to the back. TU-154 looks like 3 engines with a plane strapped to the front

    • @CarolLynnWilliams
      @CarolLynnWilliams 4 года назад +4

      @Alex P - - good description...

    • @stevez6499
      @stevez6499 4 года назад

      Three underpowered engines on the TU-154 also. I’ve seen enough of them at various airports in Russia use all the runway up. And I’ve never seen any with as little black raw fuel smoke coming from them on departure as the one in the video. Normally it’s a lasting trail of smoke. Extremely noisy also.

    • @alexp5138
      @alexp5138 4 года назад +5

      Steve Z Well they have a much faster cruising speed than nearly all commercial airliners still in use

    • @larsx8662
      @larsx8662 4 года назад +9

      @@stevez6499 The Tu-154 has engines with around 100kN of Thrust with a maximum takeoff weight of around 100 tons, the 727 has engines producing about 72 kN of thrust with a takeoff weight of nearly 95 tons(727-200). The Tu-154 is absolutely not underpowered, the takeoff speed is just rather high.

    • @adeldassy5559
      @adeldassy5559 4 года назад +2

      @@stevez6499 Les moteurs du tupolev sont surpuissants par rapport à la messe au decollage 3 x 12 tonnes pour 90 tonnes !!!

  • @Kevin_747
    @Kevin_747 4 года назад +13

    I favor the 727 since I flew them a long time. TU-154's are interesting to watch. Seeing a 727 now is like seeing a DC3. 727's taught me a lot in 7900 hours.

  • @user-ld6is4ni3d
    @user-ld6is4ni3d 4 года назад +14

    Nice camerawork as always. Not that I'm saying the 727 is bad, no, it's an amazing plane and a legend, but it think the tu 154 has just a bit more personality and is a bit more beautiful

  • @2201Duluth
    @2201Duluth 4 года назад +36

    The unique way the landing gear retracts on the 154 is fascinating.

    • @rhodium1096
      @rhodium1096 4 года назад

      They sold the Design to Boeing for 777 landing gear six wheels

    • @EricIrl
      @EricIrl 4 года назад +1

      @@rhodium1096 The Tu154 main undercarriage design is based on the system they had originally fitted to their early jet bombers. Having the main wheels out on the wings means you can have an unobstructed bomb bay in the fuselage. It is not ideal for an airliner as it puts a lot of strain on the wing fuselage joint and can cause these areas to fail in a heavy landing. The Tu154 was the last Russian airliner to feature that undercarriage arrangement.

  • @nightbot8526
    @nightbot8526 4 года назад +46

    Difficult decision, but I think I'll stay with tu154

  • @microRiZu
    @microRiZu 4 года назад +51

    That russian plane is wild, first it screams then it opens up reverse thrusters midair before touchdown LMAO

    • @REFEREEMOUSE
      @REFEREEMOUSE 4 года назад +1

      microRiZu I was thinking the same thing

    • @goto8438
      @goto8438 4 года назад +3

      This was standard operating procedure for soviet pilots, especially provincial airports.

    • @luisf4077
      @luisf4077 4 года назад +2

      Those guys are risk takers. You couldn't pay me to fly with them on a Tupolev.

  • @Miftahjaya96
    @Miftahjaya96 4 года назад +11

    sound engine from the Tupolev TU-154 when departure is so amazing..i like it

  • @kilasracingfactory
    @kilasracingfactory 4 года назад +21

    That Tupolev screams man!

  • @captainharvey7527
    @captainharvey7527 4 года назад +12

    Tupolev - 154B2/M beautiful plane!

  • @Qboro66
    @Qboro66 4 года назад +5

    I've only flown in the B727 and not the Tu154. Except for the shallow takeoff, I enjoyed the flight on the B727. It's the closest I came to flying in a B707. The B757 was another beauty.

  • @VinneyPooooh
    @VinneyPooooh 4 года назад +21

    Of course, TU-154!

  • @pavwgn
    @pavwgn 4 года назад +3

    Memories, memories you are turning us older but what a great sight. Thanks Cargo, another great video

  • @ukaviationtransport9441
    @ukaviationtransport9441 4 года назад +9

    I’ve actually heard there’s 2 727s in the U.K. current serving 2 excel aviation in Doncaster. I do hope I get the chance to record one there after lockdown. Hard choice to be fair but the 727’s design just stands out to me especially the way it uses its reverse thrust. Nice video :D

  • @IsegrimSTP
    @IsegrimSTP 4 года назад +12

    154 :) for the UUUUltra wide main gears but i do like both.

  • @akindudeerada5840
    @akindudeerada5840 4 года назад +13

    Definitely Tupolev for me.

  • @exfa7094
    @exfa7094 4 года назад +3

    TU-154 Is like a beast,love it

  • @CarolLynnWilliams
    @CarolLynnWilliams 4 года назад +6

    The tail engine S-ducting as engineered on most tri-jets is such an elegant design when compared to the tail mounted engine on a DC-10, which was a comfortable and serviceable (but externally ugly) plane.
    The target-type "bucket" thrust reversers are an amazing marvel to watch.
    I wonder if the fuselage airstairs are still in use on the cargo 727s and DC-9s.

    • @featherstone5838
      @featherstone5838 4 года назад +1

      I fully agree with you. The DC-10 looks as if the designers had forgotten an engine. The L-1011, B-727 and TU-154 are all beauties. Even though I heard that the S-duct was problematic.

  • @АндрейА-я2г
    @АндрейА-я2г 4 года назад +15

    Tupolev handsome, elegant diplomat! Boeing as a tired businessman)))

  • @james78ish
    @james78ish 4 года назад +13

    got to be the 154 different beast altogether.

  • @mylosairplanefan
    @mylosairplanefan 4 года назад +1

    Two of my favorite planes.. Love their classic sound :) Nice shots mate!

  • @ghtrcvb
    @ghtrcvb 4 года назад +7

    ту154 красавец самолет..

  • @e.2412
    @e.2412 4 года назад +1

    Tupolev , cause is massive ! The 727 is surely a nice plane , but that old style , the screaming sound and those thrust reversers...I fell in love ahah

  • @lanalaz6723
    @lanalaz6723 4 года назад +10

    Реверс в воздухе 🔥

  • @f-btsc9944
    @f-btsc9944 4 года назад +16

    Awesome video ! 😃👍👍
    Did you noticed than the TU-154 deployed his reversers above the runway ? :)

    • @Ljet600
      @Ljet600 4 года назад +6

      It's allowed and confirm AFM for the Tu-154M.

    • @hakan737
      @hakan737 4 года назад +1

      as far as i know, the only plane capable of doing this is TU 154. Great on both planes, but TU154 is different from B727 with this feature.

    • @stevez6499
      @stevez6499 4 года назад

      hakan737 DC-8’s can deploy the inboard reversers in flight to act as a spoiler. No where near the runway either.

    • @323bas
      @323bas 4 года назад

      @@hakan737 Ilyushin IL-62 as well: ruclips.net/video/T-yJ4jru6Ig/видео.html

  • @peterschumann1490
    @peterschumann1490 4 года назад +2

    The TU-154 is the most beautiful Civil airliner in the world ...

  • @parispanagiotou8201
    @parispanagiotou8201 4 года назад +1

    Both are nice . TU 154 has a massive wild beauty , B-727 has a delicate gentle beauty . I feel lucky that , I worked on both of them ( mostly B-727 )

  • @DolleHengst
    @DolleHengst 10 месяцев назад

    The take-off in a TU-154 is the craziest flight experience i ever had. The sheer noise, the immense thrust. Terrifying and glorious at the same time.

  • @MayorMcCheese47
    @MayorMcCheese47 4 года назад +1

    Love the 27, had hands on experience with an ex-FedEx -100 at my maintenance school. Haven't seen many flying in my lifetime but when I do its a treat. But DAMN I wanna see a tu154 in person one day! Being from the US the chances of seeing one are basically zero, but maybe one day I'll visit Europe and have a chance

  • @gerardolramos
    @gerardolramos 4 года назад +1

    TU-154 is beautiful in overall design.

  • @pretjenr1127
    @pretjenr1127 4 года назад +1

    727 all day, don't you ever ask again! Nice video

  • @alexberro5376
    @alexberro5376 4 года назад +2

    My vote goes to the TUPOLEV TU-154. It's more attractive

  • @jowenjv4463
    @jowenjv4463 4 года назад +8

    Noticed how different their take off are. Tu-154 just jump as soon as the pilot pulls the yoke.. It seems that the 727 needs to generate a little more lift with angle of attack to get off the ground.
    Choice is difficult, if not impossible. 727 for the elegance, 154 for the exception.

    • @olegdc10
      @olegdc10 4 года назад

      Johan G.Bruère-Dawson Tu-154 pilot uses take off thrust. 727 pilot uses climb thrust for take off. Procedure depends on actual take off weight, runway length and actual outside temperature

    • @jowenjv4463
      @jowenjv4463 4 года назад

      @@olegdc10 Really ? The 727 manuals i had clearly show different EPR settings between take off and climb if I remember correctly (need to confirm though). How do you know that the 727 pilots use climb thrust ? I though about noise reduction, engine wear... ?
      Thanks.

    • @olegdc10
      @olegdc10 4 года назад +1

      Johan G.Bruère-Dawson It depends on runway length, field elevation, ambient temperature, pressure altitude and actual take off weight. Actually you always use reduced thrust for take off and it is really climb thrust or little bit more than climb thrust. Of cause, you have to set max power when you take off from Denver with max take off weight. And you always set “climb thrust with zero payload in LAX. No matter which Boeing you fly. 727 or 747.
      As example. Today is warm day in California, 25 degrees. Max take off EPR in LAX is 1,54. But today you have empty aircraft and fuel to LAS and to alternate airport. You will set EPR 1,44 and your climb thrust is 1,44, and may be more. You remember, TAT at 1500 ft is almost 30 today. But there’s no such procedure in Tu-154 manual. Take off is take off and you have always set max thrust, no matter if it is LAX or DEN. And Tu-154 climbs to FL300 after 12-13 minutes after rotate when 727 needs 25 minutes. But this is her only single advantage.

  • @DRPadmologist
    @DRPadmologist 4 года назад +2

    Tu is a far superior, wide undercarriage for rougher landings on less prepared strips and plenty of power, aesthetically more attractive and a really high cruising speed

  • @cbwplanespotting2599
    @cbwplanespotting2599 4 года назад +3

    I would have to go with the TU-154.

  • @SergiosBurinskas
    @SergiosBurinskas 4 года назад +18

    Ту - 154

  • @ThomasSteffien
    @ThomasSteffien 4 года назад +4

    to me the B727 looks more elegant, but the TU154 has some interesting details - as with girls - sometimes i like this, sometimes that ;)

  • @Rasscasse
    @Rasscasse 4 года назад

    I gotta say Cargospotter, that beautiful dusk backdrop at around 4m25 is stunning!
    A beautiful plane against a fiery sky. Excellent work sir 👍

  • @kevinholm2794
    @kevinholm2794 4 года назад +2

    Tolles Video TU154 und B727 Tolle Flugzeuge

  • @bojanglesthewizard8875
    @bojanglesthewizard8875 4 года назад +1

    I love how the gear goes up on the 154s

  • @saxonlight
    @saxonlight 4 года назад +1

    The 727 went into service in the early 1960s nearly 10-years before the 154. Since I have only flow on the 727 between Houston and Los Angeles in the late 70s on National Airlines I give it the thumbs up. It was a good flight. The 154 looks like something from the Thunderbirds TV series.... unconventional.

  • @WysteriaGuitar
    @WysteriaGuitar 4 года назад +3

    727 for sure as I grew up flying in these...

  • @uedc100
    @uedc100 4 года назад +1

    Chulada el TU-154 😍

  • @tk7107
    @tk7107 4 года назад

    Great to see the 154 still active. The open skies 154 was in CGN today again!

  • @electric7487
    @electric7487 4 года назад +1

    Note that the last 727 ever built was built in 1984, while the last Tu-154 was delivered in 2013. My vote goes to the Tu-154.

  • @rhodium1096
    @rhodium1096 4 года назад +1

    Tupolev among the reasons...Engines (sound) and landing Gear design

  • @Gtacarsgarage
    @Gtacarsgarage 4 года назад +1

    Amazing sound!

  • @AdamShaiken
    @AdamShaiken 4 года назад +5

    I've never seen a 727 landing from the rear...I also never realized that the thrust reversers can be deployed before touchdown !!!, though the spoilers/speed brakes did NOT get deployed until after the mains hit.

    • @FirstNameLastName-cu2tq
      @FirstNameLastName-cu2tq 4 года назад +2

      Not for each plane thrust reversers can be deployed before touchdown. For Tu-154 it is allowed.

    • @AdamShaiken
      @AdamShaiken 4 года назад

      @Vergolia Elcompa I stand corrected. That was, indeed, a Tu !!!

    • @aarondynamics1311
      @aarondynamics1311 4 года назад

      @@FirstNameLastName-cu2tq 737s can do it too

    • @FirstNameLastName-cu2tq
      @FirstNameLastName-cu2tq 4 года назад

      @@aarondynamics1311 , "CAN" and "ALLOWED in accordance with the flight manual" is not the same.
      Of course, this does not mean at all that this is some kind of great advantage, it is just a feature of this aircraft because the Tu-154 has a higher landing speed which must be reduced as soon as possible after landing. And the high landing speed is the price that had to be paid for the configuration of the aircraft that provides faster cruising speed. With a cruising speed of 975 kilometres per hour (606 mph), the Tu-154 is one of the fastest civilian aircrafts ever build.

  • @aviationlba747
    @aviationlba747 4 года назад +7

    Both are beautiful, but I’d go with the 727. Check out VP-BAP with the winglets at 7:12!

    • @blackmaiden3893
      @blackmaiden3893 4 года назад +5

      Yeah VP-BAP is owned by the ‘Malibu Consulting Corp.’ She is one of the last active 727’s, let alone 727-100’s.

    • @aviationlba747
      @aviationlba747 4 года назад +3

      Indeed Jack.

  • @John_Conor_BLR
    @John_Conor_BLR 4 года назад +2

    Красивые птички.)

  • @marcalleyne2582
    @marcalleyne2582 4 года назад

    Wow , nothing like a twilight take off.
    And never knew of this other aircraft w it's multiple landing gear but I've always loved the noisey 727s n DC 9s .. damn I miss them

  • @525iat
    @525iat 4 года назад +11

    Tupolev

  • @aviatorman8
    @aviatorman8 4 года назад

    Very nice. More videos of those two birds, please! I know it’s hard to find them around, and would appreciate any effort you can put into filming them.

  • @juliensvideography
    @juliensvideography 4 года назад +1

    awesome catches

  • @ronaldpetru
    @ronaldpetru 4 года назад +4

    Love the TU, robust and sturdy classic with a great sound too. Btw.: try to take off or land a B727 on an unpaved runway ;-)

    • @MayorMcCheese47
      @MayorMcCheese47 4 года назад +1

      Its definitely been done plenty on the 727s lol. The 154 is probably more suitable for unpaved runways but the 27s can definitely take a beating!

    • @DolleHengst
      @DolleHengst 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@MayorMcCheese47Sure the 727 is a legendary workhorse. Great airplane. And yes, it probably can land on grass, dirt, and be just fine. However, the TU-154 can land on those, and make you think you've landed on silk. Immense travel in the landing gear. Speaking from personal experience.

  • @JoakimEwenson
    @JoakimEwenson 4 года назад +2

    That Tu-154 is nothing but a truly hideous beast, but it’s still one impressive beast! 😍

  • @ravivijay2741
    @ravivijay2741 4 года назад +1

    Most of Aeroflot's were Tu154.
    After lift off, nice to see the landing gear folds & closes. Ive seen it taking off in Moscow. Fast & with roaring sound.
    Nevertheless both Tu154 & B727 are good airworthy planes.

  • @ANAMELESSGUYAFACELESSMAN
    @ANAMELESSGUYAFACELESSMAN 4 года назад +1

    I have the great fortune to work with the always majestic B727, here in Colombia, there are still 7 flying 727's with LAS Cargo(the company where I work), Aerosucre and Colombian Air Force. So, I think Colombia is one of the countries with more still flying 727's all over the world, nonetheless, long live the Boeing 727

  • @kento1390
    @kento1390 4 года назад +1

    Tu-154 is a very rare sight nowadays. Hoping to see one before it says goodbye to the skies.

    • @nightbot8526
      @nightbot8526 4 года назад +1

      both are, and to think that out of more than 1000 units have won the skies almost none currently fly

  • @saifanibnetanbir6144
    @saifanibnetanbir6144 4 года назад +1

    i love both bc Soviet planes are interesting and Boeing models are my favorite both seems to be good

  • @sanel1068
    @sanel1068 4 года назад +1

    I like the gear of the TU154

  • @gabrielzayas5913
    @gabrielzayas5913 4 года назад +3

    Amerijet from SXM!!!!! Just awsome

  • @maddoc68
    @maddoc68 4 года назад +1

    Love the tupolev‘s sound. Used to see them a lot in the 90s in haj. And they deploy the reversers before touchdown! And she’s a beauty. 727= 😕

  • @2바이오
    @2바이오 4 года назад

    김해공항에서티웨이 가이륙중입니다.?

  • @trucktalkvideosandy8185
    @trucktalkvideosandy8185 4 года назад

    727 anyday how many are still flying?

  • @АлександрБольшаков-т6т

    VP-BAP👍👍👍👏👏👏!

  • @leesmith8366
    @leesmith8366 4 года назад +1

    Cannot decide both great aircraft wish a trident was flying still even a taxi run would be good trident 3 zm at wroughton could possibly do this

  • @flygwada971
    @flygwada971 4 года назад

    Nice trijet action. The Antonov is a highlight.. activating reverse before touchdown.. ...

    • @2Vit2
      @2Vit2 4 года назад

      flygwada971 Tupolev )

  • @MrTruth73
    @MrTruth73 4 года назад +1

    The Russians just make the planes look Better, RV thrust before wheels down too! TU takes the 🍰

  • @johndouglas5712
    @johndouglas5712 4 года назад

    All magnificent planes . Gotta go with that Amerijet 727 . I was so sad to hear that it was retired

  • @LC-qs8ti
    @LC-qs8ti 4 года назад

    The first landing... reverse thrust engages before touchdown, i'm surprised it didn't land sooner with the weight of the pilot's balls of steel.

  • @blackgrinders
    @blackgrinders 4 года назад +1

    Туполев!!! TUPOLEV, MIGHTY TUSHKA, TU-154M MOST BEAUTIFUL PLANE IN THE WORLD!🤘

  • @will891410
    @will891410 4 года назад +4

    Boeing is safer, but the Tupolev engines sound is awesome.

  • @carlossuavemente379
    @carlossuavemente379 4 года назад +2

    The AmeriJet took off from St Maarten airport. Been there.

  • @ananthasrikara1167
    @ananthasrikara1167 4 года назад +1

    i really like tu-154

  • @jimpowell1802
    @jimpowell1802 4 года назад +1

    I have to pick the 727 for two reasons. 1. It just looks good. 2. I flew on a couple back in the 70's.

  • @RedArrow73
    @RedArrow73 4 года назад

    The 7-2 is actually sleeker with the longer fuselage, more conical nose, and cleaner wing. It also has the wing dihedral one expects in a large jetliner.
    Truth be told , the 7-2 looks like it also carries more, as evidenced by the longer takeoff roll.
    Operators like bigger payload capacities.

  • @unknownpasserby1431
    @unknownpasserby1431 4 года назад +1

    I cheer for Tu-154✈️✈️✈️

  • @geoffpickard9186
    @geoffpickard9186 4 года назад

    There's just something about the Careless stance!

  • @alejandrorocha9377
    @alejandrorocha9377 4 года назад +2

    727!

  • @jamesgovett3225
    @jamesgovett3225 Год назад

    Interesting 154’s seem to deploy their Clamshell reversers before the mains touch the runway unlike the Boeings, but the 727’s are definitely more aesthetically pleasing and symmetrical, my opinion only

  • @Glideslopes
    @Glideslopes 4 года назад +1

    The nice thing with the TU-154 was you could track it up to FL 100 by the exhaust trails. 😂😂

  • @emmab.2146
    @emmab.2146 4 года назад

    Tupolev Tu-154 is mine! +1

  • @Aleksey_Morozov
    @Aleksey_Morozov 4 года назад +1

    Мне кажется, что у Боинга 727 больше схожести не с Ту-154, а с Як-42!!
    Чисто моё мнение!!)

  • @wriker36
    @wriker36 4 года назад +2

    727 is way sexier.

  • @cpsfarm4126
    @cpsfarm4126 4 года назад

    Mantap,,👏👏

  • @marcalleyne2582
    @marcalleyne2582 4 года назад

    And watching those reversing engines makes the 727 my favorite.
    Too bad it had so many crashes

    • @river_salmon
      @river_salmon 3 года назад

      bad maintenance, dude. it's not easy to maintain decent stats while being operated by poor African airlines

  • @featherstone5838
    @featherstone5838 4 года назад

    The first time I flew in a TU-154, I actually thought it was a B-727. I was surprised to see Cubana using US made planes in the 80s - well, they were not. I had to look twice to see the difference.

  • @michellearrington4846
    @michellearrington4846 4 года назад

    Well I like the 727 more, not just because its American and I am American. But because the 727 is an extremely safe and reliable airliner and I have flown on many many 727's over the years. For decades the 727 was the most powerful airliner on the market. (Power to weight ratio) Every video I've seen of the interior of a tu-154 in flight, the passengers look like they're completely sedated on barbiturates, or they look like they're scared crapless, right along with the flight crew who shouldn't be sedated.

  • @utfgamingyt8294
    @utfgamingyt8294 3 года назад

    The difference between the aircraft are they have different cockpits and the tu154 does not have winglets and the 727 does

  • @CGSIDDLE
    @CGSIDDLE 4 года назад

    The TU-154 screeches the 727 sounds like a fighter jet at times

  • @Shadoe0716
    @Shadoe0716 2 года назад +1

    2:01 Sounds like those Airbuses A319 and A320.

  • @AlpineTerrier
    @AlpineTerrier 4 года назад

    I’ve been on both aircraft and I used to service both. In simple terms I would happily fly again in a 737 but not a 154.

  • @luisf4077
    @luisf4077 4 года назад +1

    727 all the way

  • @jaafarzaidi3390
    @jaafarzaidi3390 4 года назад

    8:22 thats the cleanest 727 I've ever seen, there isn't a single black mark or stain visible anywhere next to the engines or the fuesalage.... noice!!!

  • @scooterboy787
    @scooterboy787 Год назад

    This is a rather new comment but, I'm not saying the Tu-154 is bad but, I love the 727's personality more and think It's better.

  • @Shadoe0716
    @Shadoe0716 2 года назад

    I drew the AmeriJet International in Procreate Yesterday.

  • @Shadoe0716
    @Shadoe0716 2 года назад

    Is TU-154 the Russian Clone of Boeing 727?

  • @ЕвгенийХрущев-ч8в
    @ЕвгенийХрущев-ч8в 4 года назад +4

    154 ВНЕ КОНКУРЕНЦИИ

  • @RUSGrus
    @RUSGrus 4 года назад +2

    Huge

  • @aimarquejidogomara
    @aimarquejidogomara 4 года назад +1

    The tu-154 looks better