I want the player that will most likely get on the court to spell Luka and/or Kyrie. We have got to find a way to get them more rest in the regular season.
@@bervicksimien2848 And that's all he had to say was that he was from LA and always dreamed of playing for the Lakers. No one would've took issue with that but he tried to funny and/or sound smart with the whole "mom and dad" analogy and made a fool of himself while unnecessarily pissing off a fanbase that was nothing but good to him.
@@badongjunior1261 Spencer ? is that you ? Well if you want some basketball reasons then I don’t want you here because you’re an inefficient shot chucker that is going to hinder Hardy’s development. Stay where you belong.
It really just depends on what kind of guard this team needs. Do we need a guard that can come off the bench who’ll give us shotmaking & playmaking off the 2nd unit, if so then Dinwiddie should be the target. Or do we need a true POA, pesky guard defender that we can put on a some of the good PGs in the league to make it difficult for them, if so then DSJ should be the target. If you ask me I’m going with DSJ. We are already going to have Hardy (Who I’m high on) that’ll be the main scorer off the bench. Also one of Luka, Kyrie or Klay will always play with the 2nd unit. I don’t worry about scoring on this team. This team doesn’t have a true defensive minded PG, and it’s clear that is DSJ’s main calling card. Also he would give us some much needed athleticism that we’ve lost with DJJ & Green gone.
@@cashwalker9512 I don’t get this notion that we need to get a 4. PJ is a 4 and will be playing 30+ minutes a night, Maxi is a 4 and wether ppl like it or not will still get solid minutes. OMax is built like a 4 and Kidd will find a way to get him regular minutes, then there’s Naji who is big enough at 6’7; 220Ibs to give us some minutes at the 4 as well. We are well stocked at the PF spot.
We need a 6th man that can generate some offense when either or even both Kyrie and Luka are off the court. Just sucks the name I’m hearing is Dinwiddie
Dinwiddie would be the better choice, guy is bigger, a better scorer and is experienced in playoffs playing with Luka. Imagine if it was him instead of Exum (who disappeared) in the playoffs.
So did Luka, if I remember correctly. If I'm not mistaken, whatever Rick said ( i believe it was Rick accusing DSJ of being jealous) left a bad taste in Lukas mouth.
@@dmoney7165 DSJ talked about Carslile trying to embarrass him in front of everyone in the locker room, essentially bringing him down. He actively treated DSJ poorly, but again that’s just what I heard from DSJ.
@@NoTime4NoHoyou are talking about a player that went from Carlisle’s star to a player that wasn’t passing to Luka on plays he was supposed to pass it to him out of time outs That’s what started all that Dsj was jealous and quit on the team Nick mentions some of that here but left out what I just said.
DSJ is my choice. He wants to be here. He constantly is working on his game, he could easily take another step up w Mavs this year. He is the guy. I’m not opposed to Morris either.
@@a.puerto5667 just recent comment about how he really likes him. Jeez. I just gave my opinion as far as “fit. / chemistry. I believe DSJ is a better defender? Klay makes a huge dent in the shooter deficiency along with the two new pick ups. We lost our best defender (according to stats). Sooo. …IMO. DSJ would be a better fit. Spencer can still fit adding another offensive 3 point threat. But I think he’s kinda soft on D?
@@Jorlaxe I would like to go see that comment. I can’t find it when I search it up. I believe Jones was a very good defensive wing, better than what the Mavs have had in a while. But let’s not act as if he was Kawhi Leanard out there. The Defense was already good before he started playing more minutes and starting in the playoffs. I can’t say he was our best defender when the defense got better once PJ and Gafford started getting chemistry with the rest of the team. Jones will be missed, but I have high hopes for Grimes, who can easily take minutes away from Hardy and even Klay if he’s struggling like last season. Grimes can Defend as good as Jones. Jones was not known as some defensive stopper before coming here, you never know, maybe Klay becomes himself again on defense as he was when he was younger under Kidds defensive scheme. Or maybe Naji is a better Jones defensively next season. That’s to be determined obviously, but we haven’t seen these players play under Kidd, so we’ll see. DSJ won’t play much here because he can’t shoot, or is big enough to defend 6’6” wing players. I doubt he would take minutes from Hardy or Exum. Kidd likes tall players on the floor. I honestly only think he’s ok with Kyrie because it’s Kyrie and he’s gifted offensively.
As much as i love dsj but with his 3pt shoot he is almost unplayable beside kyrie or luka. He is no long enough to be switchable aswell. He just doesn't fit at all into our system. Widdie though would actually be a great addition. He showed he can play the perfekt 3. Guard role from the bench and is big enough on Defens. He would be the only player from the bench which can create his own shot and still pass out of this situations. That's so valuable. ... winwiddie is a nobrainer for the last spot to me, even with what he said last season.
@@l-SlimReaper-I I never said that he played the three. We played a lot of three guard lineups back then though. He was our 3. guard coming of the bench for Brunson or Luka and he actually was part of the finishing five a lot of times aswell. look it up bro ... not that long ago in 22. The fit was perfekt because he is big enough to gaurd 2s and some 3s. so Brunson could Guard the smallest player on the court. He was a great fit back then and still would be a great fit now. Tall for his position, good enough of a shooter when open, can create his own shot, can pass out of his own creation, awesome finisher around the rim, was clutch back then. I would be so happy knowing he would come of the bench and get some pressure of of Kai and Luka while still playing the same system with him.
@@TheBleistift123 you just said he was the “perfekt 3” first off that’s not how you spell perfect. Secondly, he’s not a 3 once again… he’s a guard. Also key word “back then” can’t be living in the past he’s washed
@@l-SlimReaper-I i`m sorry if my english isn't perfect enough to pealse u, I´m german and in our language a 3 plus a "." as I have written "3." translates to "third". So If u read it again it means "perfect third guard". Which he is. and boy he ain´t washed at 31 ...he just played for the lakers. Came to a disfunctional Team late in the season.
Spence can’t return after that statement. He could’ve thought of any analogy in the world and that’s what he came up with?!? That backfired right in his face, so I’m rolling with DSJ.
@@VVVY777 if giving your opinion on a person is feminine and emotional, it applies to you because you’re giving your opinion on me. They call that a hypocrite.
One thing people dont seem to recognize is DSJ isnt only a defender and nothing else. Also good at being disturbition PG who can challenge the rim. You wont need much shooting of him considering he will end up 5-10 minutes, will play with Hardy-Exum-Naji-Maxi-Klay most of the time. I was leaning on Dinwiddie but overall fit, chemistry, no difference on playmake on both side really makes DSJ a better option. My ideal scenario would be prove it vet min deal with Tyus Jones. Hell, if Tyus are sooo desperate, i rather send Maxi to sign him and bank on Omax which is a bad gamble but a guy like Tyus would make us second favorite to win a title.
I understand the case for DSJ,but this is the thing tho, this is your 13th - 15th guy. And Spencer is just more talented, he was a 6th man his first half a year and he was a really good player in his 2nd year who was valuable enough to be a piece in the Kyrie trade(they picked him over Chris Paul). We don’t have a “need” that we have to fulfill, you need someone who MIGHT have some use and raise your ceiling and that’s Spencer because hey just more talented, also having a reliable 3rd ball handler is a bigger “need” than another defender
So far I think it is 14. Lawson 13. Powell 12. OMAX 11. Hardy 10. Exum 9. Maxi 8. Grimes 7. Naji 6. Gafford 5. Lively 4. PJ 3. Klay 2. Kyrie 1. Luka Hardy and Exum are interchangeable based on whether you need Exum ball handling and defense or Hardy scoring and shot creation. Everyone commenting will say Maxi is to high and although I would agree, this is what I think Kidd will do not what fans think he should do. We have to face facts that Kidd loves Maxi and unless Lively becomes an really good perimeter defender for a big and an occasional 3 point threat Maxi will play. He was 6th on MPG for both regular season and playoffs last season of the guys left on the team. The 3 guys we added will be above him but no one else. A good OMAX season could see him end up in Maxi's spot but to start with he will not play much.
My votes for Dennis Smith Jr, even though he asked to be traded. He's built himself into a solid defensive guard now and I think he can help the current Mavs squad moreso than Dinwiddie.
I don't think so... he'd rather play for his daddy and lose, than win and go to the finals with his mommy... We needed a 3rd ball handler off the bench before the playoffs and the Lakers needed shooting, and genius went to the Lakers lol
Dinwiddie, not even a question. He is a proven good fit with Luka, essentially carried us through a number of games, multiple game winners, is ~6'6", and has playoff experience. Look at how we lost and what we currently need.
As far as DSJ requesting a trade years ago, he was young and hadn't been humbled. Dinwiddie scorned us a few months ago as a grown ass man, so DSJ is my pick 😂
The correct call got to be Devonte Graham, who is more capable to make play or bucket than the other 2. Since guys has been praising Grimes as solid defensive addition, then a third guy that able to generate action is what we need
DJJ was a liability in the finals, couldn't hit the broad side of a barn, and his defense was less effective against bigger guards/forwards. Klay is a massive upgrade.
I would say Spencer, need another guard that will be effective offensively and create so the usage rate of Luka & Kyrie isn't so high in the regular season. Spencer can easily get the Mavs 8-10 PPG with some assists. I like Hardy but he's not a PG, he's a scorer first, let him score. DSJ plays solid defense, but after that he can't shoot the 3 or space the floor to inconsistent offensively, & defensively has no kind of wingspan, with DJJ he could at least give you about 33-35% from 3. Spencer was solid on the Mavs. Fans need to remember he played perfectly behind 2 guards in Brunson & Luka. Im looking at guards out their and not much, so to me Spencer is the most comfortable and good option to me, to put the Mavs over. Then if they have another spot go after the other Morris, and roster is complete, good balance.
DSJr showed me massive growth last time I saw him vs DAL. He went from (pardon me) dumb AF/ like Westbrook, to a true PG- He's smart and distributes on offense now. But Mavs lost a ton of above the rim athleticism from Green/Jones. I mean, prob the 2 best high-flying dunkers at SG in the NBA- Huge! DSJr is that, then some. Need some of that back. Note, if Kyrie goes down, we'll need that extra PG and since Exum plays Point, id like the defensive counterpart option in the backcourt. Also, Kidd plays a kinda 3rd bench unit look too. He'll go with Hardy 3rd unit, with a 2 Biggs/ 3 Guards look. Something to consider.
If we really want to try and test Luka at the start of the year you may need a vet like Spencer to run the game more. I prefer DSJ but just looking at it objectively.
Spence is tall enough to play wing as well as guard. Its obviously him over DSJ that isn't even a debate but getting another guard isn't the main need for the Mavs right now. Got plenty from Kyrie, Klay, Exum, Hardy, etc. The issue is Forward depth as Maxi isn't good enough as a 3pt shooter and isn't reliable on defense without Gaff or Lively out there. Not to mention health concerns. We need depth behind PJ Washington.
I could go with either Dennis Smith Jr or Spencer Dinwiddie - so… the answer is something I don’t know the answer to, which is “which one fits best in terms of personality and compatibility with teammates”?
Question - Don't the Mavs have 1 non-guaranteed spot? If the answer is that it would be great to have both DSJ and Spencer Dinwiddie and we value having that flexibility, could the Mavs waive the non-guaranteed player?
We need someone faster that can leave players behind with his speed. I remember Barea even tho he was small, he was fast kind like TJ McConnell fron IND and I saw him disrupting BOS defense squeezing through defenders and creating for others while putting up points
People tht say he’s washed now are full of it. He was “washed” in Washington and then went crazy with us. The stats and highlights speak for themselves.
The question is “what players will play in all four quarters and have significant minutes in the fourth”? I only see eight guys now. Lively/Gafford PJ Klay Luka Kyrie And Marshal and Grimes……not that Grimes will be great but that he’s proven with his playoff experience to be more ready than Exum, Hardy AND MAXI. But it’s a long season and who knows if any of these guys will stay healthy. All have shown a propensity to get nicked up. As always it’s who wants it the most And who we inevitably trade for at the deadline. No one can predict the future.
1st team: Luka, Ky, Klay, PJ, Lively/Gaff 2nd team: Hardy, Grimes, Naji, Maxi, Lively/Gaff Stash: Exum, Omax Team is set. I don't know why Dallas is enamored at trying to get guards every freaking free agency. Dallas hasn't needed to get a guard, much less a high profile one, ever since 2018. Since Luka was drafted, the team has always needed athletic defenders and/or shooters rather than guards. If for some quirky reason they REALLY need to get a guard this season, might as well trade Hardy coz every guard signing has been holding and will continue to hold him back. Maybe trade him and then get Tyus Jones or something. Otherwise, if the Mavs use the roster spot for vet presence, how about Taj, Lowry, Patty Mills, PatBev, Thad Young, or even Tristan Thompson. Or they could pick up KJ Martin as some sort of a project. Given Maxi's injury history, he can probably even compete for minutes as a backup PF.
DSJ did get treated like dogwater by Rick Carlisle, he was young, talented and developing, don't blame him one bit for asking to get traded. Carlisle tried to pit DSJ against Luka, which was completely unfair because we all knew what Luka was even as a rookie. Pretty sure he's grown and matured since then. He deserves a second chance. Dinwiddie can stay in LA.
If i was dsj I be excited but wouldn't come back as kyrie irving basically is doing what dsj role would be, if they kept him and let him develop a bit more and figure it out.
DSJ > Dinwiddie IMO. More of a dawg, I think he would be motivated to produce at a high level within his role the 2nd time around. His athleticism is needed not to mention the fanbase would welcome him w/open arms. Aside from his contributions on the floor, it would be a good PR move with that roster spot.
I'm leaning towards Dinwiddie. We know what he brings and would be more of an offensive threat. Also, waive AJ. We don't need him on the roster. Open up another roster spot
Kyrie is not a slouch defensively. Mavs got to take Spencer to spell Luka and Kyrie. Luka was fine defensively prior to injuries. Pick the player that makes the regular season easier for the stars. You sign Dinwiddie and he’s the first guard off the bench for Kyrie. DSJ will not save this team come playoff time. I think they’ll play Omax because they need Maxi replacement. Maybe not as a big man but PJ backup.
are you unfamiliar of the concept of roleplayers standing up for the stars because they cant afford to get T'd up? but yeah thats a problem thats long gone for luka so idk why its still being brought up
Luka can handle himself.. he is just smart about it. Balkan guys are hardcore. . But Naji is also a baaadd man too. Dont need Marcus really. But i like his shooting.
ppl forgot that we need pg who can playmake when luka sits on the bench. dinwiddie is a big upgrade for exum, you can't play ky and dsj at the same time. I don't get why people bring up dsj and ky prolly don't like him.
For me it’s Dinwiddie, Mavs are in Win now mode, I don’t care for the young guys like Prosper or Hardy. Luka and Kyrie need experience next to them. DSJ can’t shoot for shit and is short if he had to play with Luka and Kyrie in a guard lineup in a spot minutes. Dinwiddie shot the ball well in his last 15 games for the Lakers and is a big guard. Which Kidd likes. If the Mavs don’t get Dinwiddie, just resigne Bullock for another 3 and D wing. And if they do want another guard, then trade for Brogdon, who played well under Kidd and off the bench for the Celtics or give John Wall a chance.
@@p2pirate534 he’s an unrestricted free agent that nobody is talking about and idk why he’s way better than both options Mavs fans are obsessed with rn
Dinwiddie all day. Mavs fans need to forget the childish comments he made when he went to the Lakers. His skill set would be perfect off the bench. As much as i like exum and Hardy, they still don't seem ultra reliable. Dinwiddie can do it all
I want the player that will most likely get on the court to spell Luka and/or Kyrie. We have got to find a way to get them more rest in the regular season.
Luka could get rest in the game, all he has to do is get off the ball.
DSJ all day, Spencer Dinmiddie doesn’t want to be here. He’s begging the Lakers to open up a roster spot to bring him back. He can stay over there
Yeah, He would've fit in perfectly last year during the playoffs, but he got caught up in all that LeBron b.s. in L.A.
He's from LA so it makes sense.
@@bervicksimien2848 And that's all he had to say was that he was from LA and always dreamed of playing for the Lakers. No one would've took issue with that but he tried to funny and/or sound smart with the whole "mom and dad" analogy and made a fool of himself while unnecessarily pissing off a fanbase that was nothing but good to him.
Dumb comment with no basketball analysis whatsoever. Just pure hate.
@@badongjunior1261 Spencer ? is that you ? Well if you want some basketball reasons then I don’t want you here because you’re an inefficient shot chucker that is going to hinder Hardy’s development. Stay where you belong.
It really just depends on what kind of guard this team needs. Do we need a guard that can come off the bench who’ll give us shotmaking & playmaking off the 2nd unit, if so then Dinwiddie should be the target.
Or do we need a true POA, pesky guard defender that we can put on a some of the good PGs in the league to make it difficult for them, if so then DSJ should be the target.
If you ask me I’m going with DSJ. We are already going to have Hardy (Who I’m high on) that’ll be the main scorer off the bench. Also one of Luka, Kyrie or Klay will always play with the 2nd unit. I don’t worry about scoring on this team.
This team doesn’t have a true defensive minded PG, and it’s clear that is DSJ’s main calling card. Also he would give us some much needed athleticism that we’ve lost with DJJ & Green gone.
Need the biggest man they can get
@@cashwalker9512 I don’t get this notion that we need to get a 4. PJ is a 4 and will be playing 30+ minutes a night, Maxi is a 4 and wether ppl like it or not will still get solid minutes.
OMax is built like a 4 and Kidd will find a way to get him regular minutes, then there’s Naji who is big enough at 6’7; 220Ibs to give us some minutes at the 4 as well. We are well stocked at the PF spot.
@@victorakwaowo7998 we see how they do when kristaps is guarding them
We need a 6th man that can generate some offense when either or even both Kyrie and Luka are off the court. Just sucks the name I’m hearing is Dinwiddie
I think it’s DSJ way i see it we only have 2 other guard defenders.
Dinwiddie would be the better choice, guy is bigger, a better scorer and is experienced in playoffs playing with Luka. Imagine if it was him instead of Exum (who disappeared) in the playoffs.
Dinwiddie disappears all the time, not just the playoffs…
DSJ leaving was a Rick C issue, not a Mavs issue. DSJ has talked about it before.
So did Luka, if I remember correctly. If I'm not mistaken, whatever Rick said ( i believe it was Rick accusing DSJ of being jealous) left a bad taste in Lukas mouth.
@@dmoney7165 DSJ talked about Carslile trying to embarrass him in front of everyone in the locker room, essentially bringing him down. He actively treated DSJ poorly, but again that’s just what I heard from DSJ.
@@NoTime4NoHoyou are talking about a player that went from Carlisle’s star to a player that wasn’t passing to Luka on plays he was supposed to pass it to him out of time outs That’s what started all that Dsj was jealous and quit on the team Nick mentions some of that here but left out what I just said.
So very true
Spencer Dinwiddie would be the perfect fit.
DSJ similar to DJJ defensively
Haveen't been able to watch DSJ lately. Did he really blossom to a good defender?
@@DocPerry He is able to get steals like cakework. There was some stat about his steals this year, but he baits and pokes. Kinda cool to watch
@@DocPerry from the highlights I’ve seen it looks like he’s become a really good defender. I’ve seen clips of him guarding one through four.
The only difference is that he’s 6’2 lol
@@DoggyMoon doesn’t matter, they’re both high flyers, same body type.
DSJ, but Shamet gives us another capable shooter and ball handler with decent size if the Mavs are truly interested.
DSJ is my choice. He wants to be here. He constantly is working on his game, he could easily take another step up w Mavs this year. He is the guy. I’m not opposed to Morris either.
Tough call. I like them both. But for fit? hmmmm DSJ would be my call.
How does he fit? He’s too small to play with Luka and Kyrie and terrible shooter
@@a.puerto5667 idk. Luka really likes him. So there’s that for fit.
@@Jorlaxe I know that they were friends when he was here, when did you find out that they’re still close?
@@a.puerto5667 just recent comment about how he really likes him. Jeez. I just gave my opinion as far as “fit. / chemistry. I believe DSJ is a better defender? Klay makes a huge dent in the shooter deficiency along with the two new pick ups. We lost our best defender (according to stats). Sooo. …IMO. DSJ would be a better fit. Spencer can still fit adding another offensive 3 point threat. But I think he’s kinda soft on D?
@@Jorlaxe I would like to go see that comment. I can’t find it when I search it up. I believe Jones was a very good defensive wing, better than what the Mavs have had in a while. But let’s not act as if he was Kawhi Leanard out there. The Defense was already good before he started playing more minutes and starting in the playoffs. I can’t say he was our best defender when the defense got better once PJ and Gafford started getting chemistry with the rest of the team. Jones will be missed, but I have high hopes for Grimes, who can easily take minutes away from Hardy and even Klay if he’s struggling like last season. Grimes can Defend as good as Jones. Jones was not known as some defensive stopper before coming here, you never know, maybe Klay becomes himself again on defense as he was when he was younger under Kidds defensive scheme. Or maybe Naji is a better Jones defensively next season. That’s to be determined obviously, but we haven’t seen these players play under Kidd, so we’ll see. DSJ won’t play much here because he can’t shoot, or is big enough to defend 6’6” wing players. I doubt he would take minutes from Hardy or Exum. Kidd likes tall players on the floor. I honestly only think he’s ok with Kyrie because it’s Kyrie and he’s gifted offensively.
Dallas needs someone at tHe 4 spot
As much as i love dsj but with his 3pt shoot he is almost unplayable beside kyrie or luka. He is no long enough to be switchable aswell. He just doesn't fit at all into our system. Widdie though would actually be a great addition. He showed he can play the perfekt 3. Guard role from the bench and is big enough on Defens. He would be the only player from the bench which can create his own shot and still pass out of this situations. That's so valuable. ... winwiddie is a nobrainer for the last spot to me, even with what he said last season.
Dinwiddie has never played the 3 you don’t even know what you’re talking about
@@l-SlimReaper-I I never said that he played the three. We played a lot of three guard lineups back then though. He was our 3. guard coming of the bench for Brunson or Luka and he actually was part of the finishing five a lot of times aswell. look it up bro ... not that long ago in 22. The fit was perfekt because he is big enough to gaurd 2s and some 3s. so Brunson could Guard the smallest player on the court. He was a great fit back then and still would be a great fit now. Tall for his position, good enough of a shooter when open, can create his own shot, can pass out of his own creation, awesome finisher around the rim, was clutch back then. I would be so happy knowing he would come of the bench and get some pressure of of Kai and Luka while still playing the same system with him.
@@TheBleistift123 you just said he was the “perfekt 3” first off that’s not how you spell perfect. Secondly, he’s not a 3 once again… he’s a guard. Also key word “back then” can’t be living in the past he’s washed
@@l-SlimReaper-I i`m sorry if my english isn't perfect enough to pealse u, I´m german and in our language a 3 plus a "." as I have written "3." translates to "third". So If u read it again it means "perfect third guard". Which he is. and boy he ain´t washed at 31 ...he just played for the lakers. Came to a disfunctional Team late in the season.
@@TheBleistift123 when you’re saying 3 that means small forward not 3rd guard for future reference
what a team wants what a team needs
I’m good with either one. I think injuries will give lots of opportunities, and we will see how it plays out in the regular season.
Spence can’t return after that statement. He could’ve thought of any analogy in the world and that’s what he came up with?!? That backfired right in his face, so I’m rolling with DSJ.
Don't be so feminine and emotional. He had game-winners, clutch shots and 30pt games in the Playoffs.
@@VVVY777 if giving your opinion on a person is feminine and emotional, it applies to you because you’re giving your opinion on me. They call that a hypocrite.
What is so bad to be comforting as you mother? I admit it was wired analogy.
One thing people dont seem to recognize is DSJ isnt only a defender and nothing else. Also good at being disturbition PG who can challenge the rim. You wont need much shooting of him considering he will end up 5-10 minutes, will play with Hardy-Exum-Naji-Maxi-Klay most of the time.
I was leaning on Dinwiddie but overall fit, chemistry, no difference on playmake on both side really makes DSJ a better option.
My ideal scenario would be prove it vet min deal with Tyus Jones. Hell, if Tyus are sooo desperate, i rather send Maxi to sign him and bank on Omax which is a bad gamble but a guy like Tyus would make us second favorite to win a title.
Teams often leave a roster spot open to start the season.
I understand the case for DSJ,but this is the thing tho, this is your 13th - 15th guy. And Spencer is just more talented, he was a 6th man his first half a year and he was a really good player in his 2nd year who was valuable enough to be a piece in the Kyrie trade(they picked him over Chris Paul). We don’t have a “need” that we have to fulfill, you need someone who MIGHT have some use and raise your ceiling and that’s Spencer because hey just more talented, also having a reliable 3rd ball handler is a bigger “need” than another defender
So far I think it is
14. Lawson
13. Powell
12. OMAX
11. Hardy
10. Exum
9. Maxi
8. Grimes
7. Naji
6. Gafford
5. Lively
4. PJ
3. Klay
2. Kyrie
1. Luka
Hardy and Exum are interchangeable based on whether you need Exum ball handling and defense or Hardy scoring and shot creation.
Everyone commenting will say Maxi is to high and although I would agree, this is what I think Kidd will do not what fans think he should do. We have to face facts that Kidd loves Maxi and unless Lively becomes an really good perimeter defender for a big and an occasional 3 point threat Maxi will play. He was 6th on MPG for both regular season and playoffs last season of the guys left on the team. The 3 guys we added will be above him but no one else.
A good OMAX season could see him end up in Maxi's spot but to start with he will not play much.
Neither of them fit I think. We need to trade Maxi for a good PF who is a consistent shooter and can start on some games too
Before maxi's shoulder injury we were high on him. He'll recover
@@crisdeugzman3711 Even before his injury he was very inconsistent on both shooting and defense
Kidd is going to play a 12 man rotation until February, and it’s going to piss every MFFL off.
My votes for Dennis Smith Jr, even though he asked to be traded. He's built himself into a solid defensive guard now and I think he can help the current Mavs squad moreso than Dinwiddie.
Is Spencer is interested in mavs? That's the question
I don't think so... he'd rather play for his daddy and lose, than win and go to the finals with his mommy...
We needed a 3rd ball handler off the bench before the playoffs and the Lakers needed shooting, and genius went to the Lakers lol
@@godspeedgideon9178
Can’t blame him…he from the LA area.
Dinwiddie, not even a question. He is a proven good fit with Luka, essentially carried us through a number of games, multiple game winners, is ~6'6", and has playoff experience. Look at how we lost and what we currently need.
I think their is a higher chance Dinwiddie gives you 15 off the bench a game then DSJ
As far as DSJ requesting a trade years ago, he was young and hadn't been humbled. Dinwiddie scorned us a few months ago as a grown ass man, so DSJ is my pick 😂
DJJ only played 20 MPG!! Great take, guys, it makes me feel so much better.
Dude! Didn’t realize Nick was a Cincy kid until recently…fellow Nati Native now in Texas and lifetime Mavs fan. There can’t be that many more of us 🤣🤣
Dinwiddie by a mile! Dinwiddie is a killer!
All the mess that went on in Dallas with DSJ was due to Rick Carlisle not liking him. DSJ loved Dallas and said many times he’d love to come back.
The correct call got to be Devonte Graham, who is more capable to make play or bucket than the other 2.
Since guys has been praising Grimes as solid defensive addition, then a third guy that able to generate action is what we need
DSJ brings some verticality to the team. That was fun with DJJ. If the others on the court provide some spacing, he'll be lob-available.
DJJ was a liability in the finals, couldn't hit the broad side of a barn, and his defense was less effective against bigger guards/forwards. Klay is a massive upgrade.
DSJ all the way
Pro(s)per OMax and Hardy minutes please!
DSJ watch was a special time for the podcast😭
WHEN IS THE CHOICE GOING TO BE MADE! It feels like forever and nothing is happening while every other team is STILL making moves & improving.
I would say Spencer, need another guard that will be effective offensively and create so the usage rate of Luka & Kyrie isn't so high in the regular season. Spencer can easily get the Mavs 8-10 PPG with some assists. I like Hardy but he's not a PG, he's a scorer first, let him score. DSJ plays solid defense, but after that he can't shoot the 3 or space the floor to inconsistent offensively, & defensively has no kind of wingspan, with DJJ he could at least give you about 33-35% from 3. Spencer was solid on the Mavs. Fans need to remember he played perfectly behind 2 guards in Brunson & Luka. Im looking at guards out their and not much, so to me Spencer is the most comfortable and good option to me, to put the Mavs over. Then if they have another spot go after the other Morris, and roster is complete, good balance.
I think the msvs need another big forward, because maxi cant stay Healthy...
Paul reed is apparently good too?
Definitely dinwiddie. It’s always not a bad thing to make your team more flexible. With him on the team, the Mavs can even rest Luka or Kyrie more.
DSJr showed me massive growth last time I saw him vs DAL. He went from (pardon me) dumb AF/ like Westbrook, to a true PG- He's smart and distributes on offense now.
But Mavs lost a ton of above the rim athleticism from Green/Jones. I mean, prob the 2 best high-flying dunkers at SG in the NBA- Huge! DSJr is that, then some. Need some of that back.
Note, if Kyrie goes down, we'll need that extra PG and since Exum plays Point, id like the defensive counterpart option in the backcourt.
Also, Kidd plays a kinda 3rd bench unit look too. He'll go with Hardy 3rd unit, with a 2 Biggs/ 3 Guards look. Something to consider.
If we really want to try and test Luka at the start of the year you may need a vet like Spencer to run the game more.
I prefer DSJ but just looking at it objectively.
Spence is tall enough to play wing as well as guard. Its obviously him over DSJ that isn't even a debate but getting another guard isn't the main need for the Mavs right now. Got plenty from Kyrie, Klay, Exum, Hardy, etc. The issue is Forward depth as Maxi isn't good enough as a 3pt shooter and isn't reliable on defense without Gaff or Lively out there. Not to mention health concerns. We need depth behind PJ Washington.
If Thompson can still get 15-20 points per game, it would be a success.
We still need one more big man.
Now thats its offical. Issac Harris On the Pod!!!
I could go with either Dennis Smith Jr or Spencer Dinwiddie - so… the answer is something I don’t know the answer to, which is “which one fits best in terms of personality and compatibility with teammates”?
I guess what I’d be looking for is “chemistry”
Question - Don't the Mavs have 1 non-guaranteed spot? If the answer is that it would be great to have both DSJ and Spencer Dinwiddie and we value having that flexibility, could the Mavs waive the non-guaranteed player?
DSJ gives you upside and defense.
Dinwiddie just chose Lakers over Mavs a couple months ago because he doesn't want this 3rd PG role.
It was a different team and coach when DSJ asked for a trade. Spencer was with this team and coaches.
Gotta disagree Reggie ; kidd gave maxi and THJ minutes and they DID NOT earn it
Focusing on OMax's development early on this season may pay a ton of dividends
We need someone faster that can leave players behind with his speed. I remember Barea even tho he was small, he was fast kind like TJ McConnell fron IND and I saw him disrupting BOS defense squeezing through defenders and creating for others while putting up points
Are people forgetting Dinwiddie's clutch 3's, game-winners and 30pt games deep in the Playoffs?
People tht say he’s washed now are full of it. He was “washed” in Washington and then went crazy with us. The stats and highlights speak for themselves.
DSJ left cause of Carlisle, KP didn't work out cause of Carlisle... I'm not completely right, but am I wrong?
Shammet tho?
The question is “what players will play in all four quarters and have significant minutes in the fourth”?
I only see eight guys now.
Lively/Gafford
PJ
Klay
Luka
Kyrie
And Marshal and Grimes……not that Grimes will be great but that he’s proven with his playoff experience to be more ready than Exum, Hardy AND MAXI.
But it’s a long season and who knows if any of these guys will stay healthy. All have shown a propensity to get nicked up. As always it’s who wants it the most
And who we inevitably trade for at the deadline. No one can predict the future.
Great show
1st team: Luka, Ky, Klay, PJ, Lively/Gaff
2nd team: Hardy, Grimes, Naji, Maxi, Lively/Gaff
Stash: Exum, Omax
Team is set. I don't know why Dallas is enamored at trying to get guards every freaking free agency. Dallas hasn't needed to get a guard, much less a high profile one, ever since 2018. Since Luka was drafted, the team has always needed athletic defenders and/or shooters rather than guards. If for some quirky reason they REALLY need to get a guard this season, might as well trade Hardy coz every guard signing has been holding and will continue to hold him back. Maybe trade him and then get Tyus Jones or something. Otherwise, if the Mavs use the roster spot for vet presence, how about Taj, Lowry, Patty Mills, PatBev, Thad Young, or even Tristan Thompson. Or they could pick up KJ Martin as some sort of a project. Given Maxi's injury history, he can probably even compete for minutes as a backup PF.
Who would be more motivated? Probably DSJ. Better player now is probably Dinwiddie provided his health matches up with 2022
DSJ did get treated like dogwater by Rick Carlisle, he was young, talented and developing, don't blame him one bit for asking to get traded. Carlisle tried to pit DSJ against Luka, which was completely unfair because we all knew what Luka was even as a rookie. Pretty sure he's grown and matured since then. He deserves a second chance.
Dinwiddie can stay in LA.
Dinwiddie is the big combo guard the mavs need. He shot 3s great in dallas and would be another guy that can handle and guard 1-3
If i was dsj I be excited but wouldn't come back as kyrie irving basically is doing what dsj role would be, if they kept him and let him develop a bit more and figure it out.
Who needs to worry about this -- I trust Nico.
DSJ > Dinwiddie IMO. More of a dawg, I think he would be motivated to produce at a high level within his role the 2nd time around. His athleticism is needed not to mention the fanbase would welcome him w/open arms. Aside from his contributions on the floor, it would be a good PR move with that roster spot.
LET
IT
RIIIIIIIIIIIDE!!
I'm leaning towards Dinwiddie. We know what he brings and would be more of an offensive threat. Also, waive AJ. We don't need him on the roster. Open up another roster spot
Mavs need DSJ's point of attack defense but they need Dinwiddie's size - to play together with Kyrie - and his playmaking.
Im on the rare train it seems for bringing back Dinwiddie over DSJ. Hes just the better talent at the end of the day
Kyrie is not a slouch defensively. Mavs got to take Spencer to spell Luka and Kyrie.
Luka was fine defensively prior to injuries. Pick the player that makes the regular season easier for the stars.
You sign Dinwiddie and he’s the first guard off the bench for Kyrie.
DSJ will not save this team come playoff time.
I think they’ll play Omax because they need Maxi replacement. Maybe not as a big man but PJ backup.
Just sign the twins Markief n Marcus. No more bullying Luka lol
Luka is a grown man with a child. If he’s being bullied he’s less than a man.
If they would even see any PT. 😂
Ummmm did you not see Naji choke Jimmy Butler?
are you unfamiliar of the concept of roleplayers standing up for the stars because they cant afford to get T'd up? but yeah thats a problem thats long gone for luka so idk why its still being brought up
Luka can handle himself.. he is just smart about it. Balkan guys are hardcore. . But Naji is also a baaadd man too. Dont need Marcus really. But i like his shooting.
None of these players, please, and thank you!
Spencer had his chance he went to LA remember... Let's go MAVS 🎉🎉🎉
Windiddie! All the way!!!
ppl forgot that we need pg who can playmake when luka sits on the bench. dinwiddie is a big upgrade for exum, you can't play ky and dsj at the same time. I don't get why people bring up dsj and ky prolly don't like him.
I think the pros outweigh the cons with dinwiddie, but only if he wants to be here
Neither I would rather have a big to back up, Derek, lively, and Daniel Gafford
I’d take DSJ over Dinwiddie. I think DSJ can handle the ball good enough
Kyrie and luka hardy are PG we. Need forward shooter defender
They can't play 48'/game. Mavs need a trustwothy PG. I like Dante but he is not a pure PG...
Hardy cannot play PG!
Marcus Morris Sr or JT Thor
It’s funny to me you don’t think Dsj can create when he averaged more points than Dan witty Dsj would be a exum upgrade/replacement
For me it’s Dinwiddie, Mavs are in Win now mode, I don’t care for the young guys like Prosper or Hardy. Luka and Kyrie need experience next to them. DSJ can’t shoot for shit and is short if he had to play with Luka and Kyrie in a guard lineup in a spot minutes. Dinwiddie shot the ball well in his last 15 games for the Lakers and is a big guard. Which Kidd likes. If the Mavs don’t get Dinwiddie, just resigne Bullock for another 3 and D wing. And if they do want another guard, then trade for Brogdon, who played well under Kidd and off the bench for the Celtics or give John Wall a chance.
Odd man out is DPowell.
There’s no need for him, unless he somehow develops a respectable jump shot.
Spencer hands down because he’s more talented and proven.
Neither of them. I want Pat Bev!!!!!
DSJ.....he's a dawg on defense
Dinwiddie more experience, better playmaking, shooting and his defense isn’t that too far off
bring dennis for the vibes
If bottom 5 guys don't play, then fill them with min salary players.
Dinwiddle, could help win alot of games when you rest a 32 yr old Kyrie or Luka at times
LONZOOOOOO
DSJ all the way!
i will die on the lonnie walker hill, i think hes the best of both worlds between dinwiddie and DSJ
I agree, I didn’t know he was an option
@@p2pirate534 he’s an unrestricted free agent that nobody is talking about and idk why he’s way better than both options Mavs fans are obsessed with rn
Dinwiddie all day. Mavs fans need to forget the childish comments he made when he went to the Lakers. His skill set would be perfect off the bench. As much as i like exum and Hardy, they still don't seem ultra reliable. Dinwiddie can do it all
Kennard is a better 3 point shooter than klay is now and has more to his game at this point in klays game. Just to pint this out
What ya got for us Reggie?
Theo pinson for the final spot please and thank you
If we're the Boston and dinwiddie said that sht, he'll be booed for the rest of his life when he appears in the city.
Dinwiddie will fit better
We need defense.... DSJ pls
Media member and channel manager *