China's Catastrophic Oil Problem | Hasanabi Reacts to RealLifeLore ft. Boy Boy and I did a thing
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Hasan is joined by the Aussies to watch Real Life Lore's analysis of China's biggest weakness and what it means for both the country and the world!
Edited By: / hasanreactions
Intro Animation By: / hasanreactions
Outro Animation By: / hasanreactions
Music Composition By: / hasanreactions
(Yes, right now it's just me making everything)
Editor's Note: My edits were all made to keep the video on one, central topic by editing together relevant commentary from many parts of Hasan's streams to create a storyline that is still followable by the viewer. I also edited in commentary of my own in places, in addition to relevant external information that improves the viewing experience. A lot of edits were made for comedy purposes, or to enhance the comedic timing of certain beats, but never to misrepresent Hasan's point of view.
If you like my edits, leave a Comment, Like, and Subscribe. It helps a lot, thank you :)
Discussion Video: • China's Catastrophic O...
Unless otherwise stated, all visuals, audio, and commentary added during the editing process is created and owned by Hasan Reactions.
Find Hasan Live at: / hasanabi
#hasanabi #reallifelore #China #HasanReactions #reacts
About Hasan:
Hasan Piker is Political Commentator turned Twitch Streamer (#13) known for his Turkish heritage and leftist takes, often speaking on topics like Socialism, Communism, Capitalism, and Marxism (and occasionally 9/11). He loves reacting to political news, and occasionally goes on IRL adventures with his friends. He likes to react to popular media content with his audience as well, such as Jubilee, JCS (Jim Can't Swim), Joe Rogan, Andrew Tate, Ben Shapiro, Steven Crowder, True Crime, trending Twitter posts or TikToks, and other creative videos.
Hey everyone, if you want more of Boy Boy or I did a thing, you can find their channels here:
www.youtube.com/@Boy_Boy
www.youtube.com/@Ididathing
😂
I can tell Hasanabi will be fine to travel to china, maybe shanghai first. they won't ban people because of speaking bad things on the CN gov. the only thing is you won't get any sponsor from any chinese. But I don't think Hasanabi care that
When you EMPHASIZE every other WORD you DEFEAT the PURPOSE.
Honestly can't stand listening to this guy, the emphasis is so damn annoying
I hate his delivery so much
CHINA imports 80% OF all THEIR oil, this MEANS they PRODUCE 20% DOMESTICALLY.
Thanks for the math lesson Mr. Reallifelore.
It's so annoying
You should emphasize only THE most important word - THE
People don’t realize the modernization that China has gone through even in young peoples lifetimes. My ex was from China and came to the US when she was 10 (2008). Her city she was from had dirt roads and little infrastructure (she compared it to a old west ghost town we visited once) she went back to her city to visit in 2017 and all the roads were paved and it had better modernization and infrastructure than most US cites. That kind of change in peoples lives is going to buy a lot of loyalty from the citizens. When you went from dirt roads and sewage in the streets to a standard of living equal to and sometimes better than first world countries you’re probably going to not feel like not criticizing the government is a hugely negative trade off.
The internet in China essentially started in 2005
love how neither malaysia nor indonesia ever enter the chat when the strait is literally between the two countries lmao
We made sure Indonesia toes the american party line back in the 60s. We showed Sukarno what happens when you have a mild disagreement with the US status quo.🔫
Indonesia chat here
Damn Hasan getting stun-locked while boy boy and I did a thing just have a thousand yards stare like wtf is happening is hilarious 😂
Lmao Hasan always runs his stream as if there were no guests
Timestamp?
@@DanRec1312 I'm gay Dan. Please give me timestamp
@@StopItGarrisonha gay
@@danielomar9712 How many dans are there? I'm gay.
As a Malaysian who has lived in Brunei for almost half my life before moving back to Malaysia (I'm in my late 20s now), that one Brunei mention and Hasan and co's reaction made me unreasonably happy XD I also feel a natural sense of camaraderie with the Aussie boys because of Milo.
Why even return to MY, got nothing here sadge
I cant ever stop thinking about Brunei. The sole reason is, despite having a terrible memory, I cant get the capital name out of my head. "The capital of Brunei is Bandar Seri Begawan" is a phrase that will never leave my mind till the end of time. The capital of Washington? Nope cant tell you. The capital of a random Asian country that rivals Monaco in size? Sign me up.
Sorry, I needed an excuse to vent about it.
@@AlphaAceEX It happened around the global financial crash (2015? I can't remember). Situation went down for non locals to be able to earn more money because the ministry started pushing the whole 'blame them for stealing local jobs' shit. I was pretty much a kid so didn't really understand it, but we were pretty much forced to move back to Sabah. Family and I legit went through some hard times for a year or so especially mentally, but we're okay now at least. I went and graduated college in KL and made the best of friends so it's all good XD
@@Kimmie6772 Haha yes. Always abbreviated it as 'BSB'. I myself even as a Malaysian can't remember the national anthem, but if you ask me to sing the Brunei anthem, I can do it immediately despite not hearing it for almost a decade 😂
@@shahs1221 oh damn, hope all is well
I find real life lore delivery so pedantic and condescending it’s almost comedic
he needs to follow in the footsteps of second thought
Who else just tuned in to see Boy_Boy ? Love those guys!🎉
Tbh I've been loving the Boy Boy x Hasan content this past week
I love Hasan but it’s always better when he has guests. Just bouncing stuff off of chat gets repetitive.
@@simplicitylost*arguing with chat lol
Yeah definitely not…. He gets on my nerves not gonna lie
I Did a thing and boy boy
I love when the Aussies hang at Hassan's place. let them move in permanently
It’s all fun and games until your ceiling fans are mysteriously replaced by machetes one day…
@@musicdev 😆😆😆
I love that hasan is as fed up as I am with the audio quality perverts haha. like we get it, you have special little ears & only the most pristine, gilded tones are allowed in
The most controversial take 😎
man real life lore is so much like the dark version of second thought
more like a cheaper and more neoliberal version of wendover productions lol
@@jakestar121isn’t wendover like center-right to begin with?
@@AwesometownUSA"more"
@@jakestar121 Wait how is real life lore neolib
@@jakestar121i have watched countless of his videos but his titles and explanations are so surface level it feels like he's making videos for children.
In many ways, Chinese inner mongolia is more mongolian than outer mongolia, which is in effect Russian Mongolia. There are twice as many Mongolians in China as Mongolia and the ones in China continue to read and write in traditional Mongolian script wheras outer Mongolians have been converted to the cyrillic alphabet.
From what I remember, in china, mongolians have also started largely using chinese language and letters
Hasan will have a guest on who makes a great point and he’ll just be like “anyway…” and completely disregard what his guest said 😂
😂 he's so baybiegurl
While the strait of malaka (malay spelling) is important, its not like there isnt multiple other waterways (like the sunda strait) that also work and would maybe be a few days slower. All china needs to do is be on good terms with indonesia (and to a lesser extent malaysia) and this would be less of a problem.
"American demand for peace" lmao
Real Life Lore recycles so many talking points in all his videos. It's all basically the same content with slightly different focal points
The Aussie lads: mention they have enjoyed Chipotle
chat: "Oh my God that's literally food poisoning, Chipotle is so bad, why would you eat that??"
Just be normal chat jfc
One commenter said something I found funny "they hate Winnie the Pooh so I have them"
Which is funny for several reasons
1. its false, Winnie the Pooh is viewed favorably in China, they even have a whole park
2. the ones using the image of Winnie the Pooh as some sort of insult when talking about China online are the ones who have negative associations with the bear, so yes, they have Winnie the Pooh, so I hate them.
Except Winnie the Pooh has been banned in China since 2017 due to people calling President Xi "Winnie the Pooh"
49:10
It doesn't matter that Hasan criticized China, he can still go there with no problem at all.
Here in Brazil we have a youtuber called Felipe Durante, he's very left-wing and lives in China for five years now (I think) but he criticized the CPC in a lot of his videos, and there's nothing wrong with it really, the goverment knows that he criticizes them and even congratulated him by saying "good videos".
People are spreading falsehoods about that place.
The government really welcomes constructive criticism from people, but they're just extra wary about foreign influences that want to top the central government or secession on the internet (famous colour revolutions staged by the USA and so on...).
Heck, the infamous antichina youtuber Laowhy86 said he "escaped" China, yet a year later he came back to sell some land properties from his wife.
@@yiluis1316stop lying no it doesn’t
@@SolitaryLarkbasically a "no u" Counter
@@RyuKyu.77 sure 🤷♂️. It’s rather clear it’s a lie.
@@yiluis1316 even Hasan realizes that china is an authoritarian state, Stop kidding yourself.
Real Life Lore cherry picks his "facts" so hard and presents it AS absolute WITH no OTHER alterantive.
Also on his American geography being OP the comments are filled with people saying stuff like: "it should be a civic duty for everyone to watch this".
OK I thought I was the only one that picked up on that. Reading his comment section was painful because I wanted to point out the things he's ignoring
Nothing inspires white rage more than a non-white country rising, western countries did the same to Japan when Japan was rising in the 80s, there is a reason why "evil Chinese" don't enlist the same kind of emotional response out of non-white communities.
His voice is annoying, but well.... what did he get wrong? And about American geography being OP, it kinda is...
@@ecnalms851 In this vid he tried to make it seem like China's military is "catching up" to ours because they recently started spending more. Even if we stopped funding new operations today, it would take decades for any country to catch up. As for the OP vid: I never said America wasn't. The problem with it is bringing up all these stats and not addressing the fact that we spend way too much on our military (he does the opposite in fact and thinks it's a good thing when the whole vid is about how it would be impossible for anyone to invade). He then disregards how our economic system contributes to the US having one of the largest wealth gaps in any developed nation. You'd think the richest nation with the best land would be able to support its own citizens but here we are.
@@bigchilling420How to spot propaganda:
Enemy does something-bad
We do the exact samething-good
China spend on military bad, US spend on military good.
Islamic fundamentalisms was an issue in Afghanistan and in Xinjiang.
The US tried their method, China tried theirs.
One involved bombs the other involved education.
I dont think the education method was aimed at destroying culture, although it is still worthy of criticism for being draconic.
Today we see two regions, Afghanistan and Xinjiang, the results speak for themselves, Afghanistan is controlled by the Taliban, Xinjiang has experienced poverty alleviation and is now a top tourist destination in China.
I don't see how you're blaming muslims for the poverty in that area or how you're claiming poverty has now decreased as a result of subjugating muslims. Care to elaborate? How has tourism increased? Was there a boom in the entertainment industry like bars, brothels and gambling spots?
@@Just_another_menace Im not, its simple.
Poverty has decreased because of good governance.
yknow at the start I was actually really disagreeing with Hasan, Which is weird, But after watching for a few more minutes and letting him explain and fact checking what he said. Damn, the man is right! I cant argue facts. Learned something today.
Hey so how come Taiwan/ROC's territorial claim isn't included on the map? Perhaps because they make the same claim to own the entire South China Sea (plus extra dashes in the Gulf of Tonkin). Also interesting how he focuses so exclusively on the Straight of Malacca when it is not remotely claimed in the 9 dash line.
Well you see, because rll's stupid
48:50 Would love to see Hank Pecker's reaction to this lol
There wasn't a genocide or 'cultural genocide' in Xinjiang. The UN report is probably the most fair in saying that crimes against humanity, not genocide, were likely committed, related to the mass detention of a lot of people who were unfairly sent to reeducation camps during China's sweeping anti-terrorism/ anti-secession / anti-extremism campaign in Xinjiang from 2017 to 2019.
A shutdown in trade with China would suck absolute balls, but dealing with industrial supply chain for a living, we would have 6 months before we felt it in earnest.
Our economy would crash from a speculative standpoint, but when I plan an order from China, I don't expect to see it for a minimum of 6 months.
I need my Fleshlight now not in 6 months 😢
Isn't this why their doing that silk road deal?
It's also why they are trying to be less dependent on oil.
We get it Hasan you love China
"im sick of lookin at these lines" killed me
Man he really just didn't mention the 11-dashed line of the ROC at all
Why would you mention a fake country's made up line?
24:38😭 a german exchange student came to arizona and he absolutely loved it too we literally got ts 3 times a week
why do chatters keep complaining about the audio?
I literally have a degree in audio production and I really don't mind that the audio is not perfect because it's a fucking TWITCH STREAM, not music or a movie
""it's echoing"
for me that's slap delay
Cool
Cuz they bought “audiophile gear” and now with their entry level Sennheisers or $5k Focals they are obligated to assert their dominance.
I'm glad to see I'm not the only who absolutely hates the way RLL talks. It's so fake.
You may not like the way he talks but his points are valid.
@@jamalihamilton7866you've got to stop taking him seriously as soon as he mentions Scottish independence will defeat Nato 🤣
The echo kinda hits different ngl
It feels like we're in the room
real life lore: my favourite source for chronically overexaggerated, factually incorrect, ideologically driven drivel presented as unbiased mini-documentaries.
Hasan - I moved to China and all you need is a VPN of which there are many. It's a very small price to pay for an awesome standard of life in this country. I will never return to the UK which looks like a shitshow right now.
I like how China expanding their economy is somehow evil.
The point of the video was to highlight a strategic weakness of china nobody said china having trade route disagreements are evil they have done evil shit but it has nothing to do with this
It is, but not in the way liberals think it is
Its evil because we know how US/UK expand their economy, they just projecting it onto China
Expanding the economy isn't the problem. The problem is that they are doing colonialism and taking the resources of other countries.
@@andrewgreenwood9068 They're taking Australia's resources by buying them. Truly terrifying
Barbie movie is banned in Vietnam because they showed 9 dash line aroumd that are for like 2 seconds
As opposed to ho china acts towards any media that acknowledges Taiwan.
As a Filipino, hearing people minimize China's aggressive posturing by saying "but the USA..." is really grating to the ears
Agreed
Yes. There is a reason all of China's neighbours don't like china and it isn't US influence.
*China sinks Filipino ship in the West Philippines sea for simply being there*
"It was a response to American military aggression!"
Like, vietnam, a nation the US had a war with for a decade, is very much pro US, which is funny, cause you'd think they'd prefer working with China, till you realize that vietnam has far more immediate grievances with China than the US.
Hasan isn't able to comprehend a worldview outside of "America bad." He has no clue how things actually work in the world.
Look, this territorial dispute has been going on for decades. I remember Fidel Ramos saber-rattling against the Chinese, and he served his 6-year term during the 90's.
I think the harsh reality is that China is extremely content with either bullying their neighbors, or as in the case of the Philippines, getting a president elected who favors trade with them over the Western powers. Under Duterte, we went from saber-rattling against China's rampant building of bases in the South China Sea to opening our gates to massive amounts of Chinese labor and cheap goods from the Alibaba-owned online store, Lazada.
Our national Sinophobia also morphed from perpetual fear of getting bombed during Noynoy Aquino's term, to getting pissed that the Chinese are taking all our good tech jobs under Duterte.
Decades? Brother people have fought for that trade route for centuries 😂
Is it Sinophobia or are they actually assholes on the seas?
I wish Hasan's commentary on anything China related was better. He usually substantiates his points, but whenever it is about something bad China does it's just "the US does it too!", strawmen and a bunch of sarcastic comments. Like these things are bad, Hasan correctly criticizes the US for doing it, but when China does it it's just these repeated comments over and over again. I would get if he did this as a realist, where a realist would believe that China needs to alleviate it's insecurities about the US in order to achieve longer lasting peace, therefor defending Chinese imperialism in this regard would be a good thing. But he isn't, I am pretty sure(?)
totally agree, i think his stance on the uyghur genocide is wayy too relaxed, any time it comes up he just says that "uhm acksthually its cultural genocide, theyre reeducation camps not death camps, also the US is doing the same thing at the border" so much deflection, he seems like a closeted tankie but is very agreeable on any other topic
@@binoculustf2he's expressly stated the reason why he does that is because him, and most of his audience lives in the U.S.A. not China...
@@Fleshdeficiency then why cover china at all if he's just going to be deflecting all the time?
@@binoculustf2 he is not deflecting he is showing western media's hypocrisy and bias when they cover anything about china. he literally says in the video that he criticizes china about their free speech laws and their treatment of uyghurs. i don't know why you people cant even stop and think for a second and listen what he actually says, instead of going crazy whenever he talks about china.
@@ragavanvijay8189 why the sudden hostility lol, you cant deny that most of his takes about china are deflection, in all the videos and streams ive heard of him talk about it, he is more positive of china than negative, he says "uhm why is the US there anyways" and says there would be no tension without the US which is just untrue, i hate america as much as the next guy but this sort of hatred blinds people to other evils
The echo makes it so much funnier
This would have been correct in 2019, but we get a lot of our “treats” from Mexico and Southeast Asia since the aftermath of the trade war.
You mean to tell me the most populous country on earth also consumes the most energy 😱 how dare they
Love seeing this after US response to Yemen's blockade of trade to Israel
I love when I have to sound important, so I right click thesaurus my script.
you cant compare chinas growth in the past 20 years to the us for several crucial reasons. primarily because chinas development was essentially at rock bottom during maos reign, so its unbelievable growth came from absolute rock bottom, which was almost the exact opposite of the us 20 years ago.
okay, then compare china's growth with other countries that are lesser developed? What did China do right. It was an accident and government played no part? In fact, if you are Chinese, you can compare China during ROC era vs. China during PRC era. Why couldn't ROC modernize China, in both industry and thought? I would also argue a lot of ROC's "modernizing" of Taiwan is due to Japan's post-colonial infrastructure, but same can be said about Shanghai.
China's recent growth has been extremely impressive however it is really important to recognise that it isn't going to continue at the same rate forever. China is a strong economy but it is by no means uniquely so.
@@o00o0o0o0o0o You also need to recognize different circumstances, the ROC era was iterally a big civil war, CCP unified China due to several factors. If CCP was incharge of the ROC in the same era, all that might happen is just slightly faster unification but still won't make China into a modernized industrial country.
@@o00o0o0o0o0oare you for real to comparing roc and prc ? The roc era was literally civil war followed by a japanese invasion and then a full scale invasion and civil war again. The prc not only had a more stable time(except the first few years) but had the US investment and special treatment that the roc era didn’t have
Jokes bro "Dream Team Of Racism" hilarious!!
Well, now I can't go to China and won't ever think about going again due to...
No p*rn noooooooooooooooooo
1:04 👈 best part of the video
49:40 explain to me again how you can have corruption 'in the interest of party and state'? Not that naughty corruption but the good kind.
Also America practically set up the interconnected world with obv being a primary founder of the un and protector of free trade, and there allies in southeast Asia are also a contributing factor behind what the us has the ability to do all that.
And if you look at how we got those 'allies' (particularly indonesia) you can see why everyone is gonna do exactly what we say to do there. Don't want to end up like the Indonesians in 1965.
Nice video, thanks for sharing.
I think you manage to keep a very objective view with the little information you have.
You might want to talk to Cyrus Jansen. He has a RUclips channel aimed at sharing his knowledge of China.
He's an American citizen who lives in China for a long time now. He could tell you what he knows about the Xingjiang province.
I mean, just to receive the viewpoint of someone from over there.
This is absolutely wilddd
Lot of China content today
Hasan needs to earn his CCP payment 😂
It’s like playing video games.
It’s an escape because reality sucks.
Your life is just working to make bare minimum.
@@matricci2256is this a diss? you are doing the state departments job for free 😹😹
25:40 in 1941 japan is in no way comparable to china in 2024
lotta rad libs and anarkiddies in this comment section eh?
If we blockade their exports we can just put all our children in the factories and make stuff here again! GOBLESS
28:18 china workers are a different mindset meeting them. We like to be treated like people and not tools here that the biggest gap
theres an echo coming off of the microphone
I don’t normally give a fuck about audio but omg that echo is unbearable.
I am convinced Chines make their defense dollar go further
I thought it said joy boy and hasi was back on one piece
Ccp stans
Real life lore is like just a jangoist propoganda dispenser. Total nonce
the US is just a boring version of the thalmor zzz
Hasans problem is that he only focuses on that the US does the same thing and ignores what China does
because the US is an overwhelming force of evil
Yeah he doesn't fucking realise how close Xi Jinping's China is to Mussolini's Fascist Italy
China does US shit but it does so in a less violent fashion. I don't think Hasan ignores this fact from what I've seen
Hasan is smart enough to understand that while he can be 100% sure of what the US is doing and the scale that its doing stuff he has to be more carefull about the info of "what china is doing" cause its usualy filtered and packaged by western media and we are in a state of new cold war. If Hasan knew Chinese and was able to consume more first hand coverages or a more diverce reporting on China then he would be more confident to focus on the bad and the good. But since the videos and articles he reacts too are by their nature flimsy and have inherent bias in their reporting he holds back on his critisism of China based on them in order to be safe
Yea
There’s definitely an echo
Even if China had an oil problem, which it doesn't, China is massively investing into green energy, public transit, and hydrogen infrastructure that would mean no more oil problem in 20-30 years, and maybe even no more oil in 50-70 years. Meanwhile, in the US....
In US corporations decide that Government won't create programs that will actually improve peoples lives, any decision is based on: it have to make small group of people evil rich. China doesn't have that problem.
How doesn't it have an oil problem? China's economy is still very heavily dependent on it and in the case of war, oil from Middle East can be blocked off. China does have Russia but I don't think Russia could cope with all China's demand and its rapid growth. It is investing in renewables, so in the long term in may not have as much as an oil problem but currently in the short and medium term it does.
@@ecnalms851 How would oil from the Middle East be able to be cut off, unless you are suggesting that the US would be willing to fire on Saudi or UAE oil tankers, or that the Saudis or UAE would not want to sell to China if the US declared war. Russia, Iran, and Central Asia could sustain China in the short term if every country in the Middle East for some reason were hit with a mind control beam and decided not to sell oil to China, combined with China's 3.5-4 *billion* metric tons of oil reserves (this is about a thousand times larger than the US oil reserves).
@@ecnalms851 stop dreaming about a war ok? Why do you wanna war with China so much?
@@therat1117 We're talking about a Chinese-American war so there is definitely a possibility yes. Although the likely outcome would be the fact that US wouldn't even need to fire upon the ships, just either physically block it but they could also use their influence in South East Asia with Malaysia/Indonesia but also they could also coerce Middle Eastern countries too.
Bear in mind, we are talking about the US which has been protecting trade routes to protect its own interests for a while now with their big navy. They don't really have a naval rival yet, or any military rival as of yet (China is still getting there obvs but still has not many international military bases).
But yeah we agree that in short term, yeah China is oil secure but long term no.
In any case, in an actual war it could just go nuclear and it obviously would be over quite quickly.
Bro really thinks America can shutdown Japan oil imports and all of the countries commodity imports for their own interests and china is the one that would be in trouble
46:00 is such a dumb argument. the gemans in nazi germany also, to a vast majority, didnt think it was bad to live in germany, so i guess nazi germany was fine, then
His voice sounds like Think Before you Sleep 😢
He sounds like a put-together 'think before you sleep'. Also, stop talking about that loser he deserves no attention.
Nah, Think Before You Sleep is five octaves higher.
They all sound like this...idk if they learned english from tiktok AI...
@@romxxii true 🤣
@@Drownedinbloodok yeah it’s rly likely they learned to speak from professor Rocket Raccoon AI
The Atlantic... great source lol
THE MOZZYMANS!
Never gonna happen.... That was the year 2000 answer when i asked this question... Permenent defense budget is my answer 23 years later.... This is hype.
RealLifeFiction
56:28 "have you heard about the Holocaust?" Oh, nice. A bit cheap, though, giggling, when you clearly can't remember the purges, the great leap forward, the Chinese famines, the hundred flowers campaign, the cultural revolution, the subsequent purges, tiananmen square. You know, that stuff
I mean you can call the state and usfg govts what you want. It diesnt matter hasnt changed anything fir the better in a long tine i reckon
We’re just gonna pretend that if China stopped selling Japan oil the US wouldn’t export oil to them 😂 Im guessing the reason they don’t currently is that it’s probably more expensive because it’s a longer route
I love watching hasan roast some of my favorite creators
You're slow to realize how much of the economy is changing (and how fast it's changing) to combat the issues you brought up about the supply chain. It's not that I disagree with your point, moreso that the problem you raise is being dealt with very very quickly based on what we're seeing in the data
Did they forgot strait of java?
This video could have said that China will drop a nuclear bomb on Taiwan and these guys would have said "but what about the US in Iraq". Their obsession with defending an authoritarian regime in China at every point is just disgusting
Wow, crazy how they never said that...
yeah i dont have anything to criticize them so i will create an entire fake scenario about them being wrong so i can destroy them in a debate.
Smartest dronie when someone says something not insanely negative about china.
@@ragavanvijay8189 Did you watch the video? They did keep saying "oh the US did this" as a way to defend China's authoritarian actions - 2 things can be bad at the same time!
@@Fleshdeficiency It was a hypothetical... Hasan and them 2 people defended China's regime but saying that the "US did this" when both things can be bad at the same time.
Did u notice the echo?
This dude keeps yapping about oil and gas as if china doesn't have a neighbour country to the north with enough oil and gas to sustain china forever, did they forget russia?? No ships needed baby
China's economy would collapse, the countries exporting the oil wouldn't because guess what, we all buy oil from the middle east as well, not just china thats a bit of a bad take honestly like china is the only one buying oil...
You know that China also manufactures other stuff too right?
@@guishenStreetB and Oil is a huge part of their economy at the present time. Hence the wanting to get away from it iniatives.
Okay these guys not understanding the political importance of these straits is baffling.
It's 100% a weapon for rivals.
And they were so bias coming into it that they actually just misunderstood stuff....
It’s pretty gross when China is continuously treated like a harmless innocent panda bear getting done wrong in the world by people know have to know better.
Do you think this man would have the same energy for a doc about America
No
90 days if they use oil normally. if they ration they could last up to 8 years. and taiwan on the other hand is much more energy dependent. blockading china effectively means blockading taiwan as well, because no way china will allow taiwan to import energy. taiwan falls long before china. also taiwan is much more food dependent than china. it's a flawed strategy.
You forget that the USA could directly import oil to Taiwan if they blocked the Straight of Malacca, they share an ocean. China will undoubtedly try and naval block Taiwan, and I imagine that a theoretical war between China and the USA other Taiwan would mostly take place at sea. As landing on Taiwan is outrageously difficult, due to its coast being mostly mountains and it's beaches being heavily fortified.
In WW2, it was estimated by a US general that to take the island of Taiwan from the Japanese, who were defending it with 50000 troops, they would need a land invasion force of nearly 200000 troops, and he expected that most of the 200000 would die. China couldn't invade Taiwan before the USA arrived to fight at sea. Which means most of the fighting would take place at sea
@@EchoAwakens that is such a hopelessly clueless response that i don't know if it's even worth putting effort into..
@@donderstorm1845 Solid take of "I don't know what to say, so you're wrong" love to see it. Just point out to me where I'm wrong, should be very easy
@@EchoAwakens no, it's just so mindbogglingly dumb and ignorant that it's hard to take you seriously. it's like a mentally handicapped person came up to me and spoke confidently about something he very clearly has no clue about, and is unsulted when i don't react to him.
@@EchoAwakens for one, if you're even remotely aware of the modernizations and the growth of the PLA, especially the PLAN, you'd know that there is a high probability that the US would not be able to defeat them near taiwan. that means they can't "directly import oil to Taiwan if they blocked the Straight of Malacca".
secondly, taiwan is not "mostly mountains and its beaches being heavily fortified."
its east coast is mountainous, the west coast is not. and it's definitely not heavily forfitied, taiwan hasn't been taking their own defense seriously enough for that.
thirdly, china would not attempt an invasion until taiwan is completely cripplied by missiles, and the PLA has completely air and sea domination around taiwan. so your numbers about a japanese invasion are irrelevant. china would also not attempt an invasion until the US has either been defeated, or backed off somewhere where it can't help taiwan.
radical leftist alternative instead of RealLifeLore? especially the history of revolutions and power going back to tsarist Russia/Ottoman empire era to present day ideally...? please help! thank you!
Would I trade free speech for universal healthcare? I mean I’m not sure but it’s a tempting offer.
What a terrible and privileged take to have...
We have free speech in the West, until the CIA targets us. 💀
Keffals need to watch this
Times and time again we’ve cared about geopolitics first, principles second. Sometimes principles can manage to take priority but many times it doesn’t. For instance, our long time military support of the Saudis, who are about the same level of bad as we claim China is being today.
The Saudis engage in massive censorship, anti LGBTQ+ practices, anti-women’s rights, autocracy, and partially caused the literal starving of at least a hundred thousand Yemenis, yet all that can be brushed aside due to their oil which helps the US dollar to remain the reserve currency.
If the US and China go to war what leads you to believe trade would just be business as usual?
Because if not then the economy of both nations would collapse. Neither Xi Jinping or Biden want that.
A lot of US corporations kept trading with the USSR for example whilst shit like Vietnam was going on and thousands of Soviets were fighting Americans in Vietnam.
China, and the US going to war, would be the end of life as we know it.
Real life lore's Japan take is historically erroneous to the extreme. How much is he getting paid to spout this BS?
Why not like. Go around?
That’s what the Chinese are trying to do now by building ports in Myanmar and with climate change trade route from above Russia are becoming more and more accessible. These things take decades tho so it’s just the short term that might be a problem
Its seem u also have a wrong assumption about free speech or u only see that issue in ur own cultural perspective. There have free speech in china, they just dont have a rights to make lies and speak everything without consequences. Free speech in china give people a right to take on issues in a right and consractive ways ( like as demostrations or reclamating the corrupt official or have an openion in social media and address it to a right person, not to blaim the whole sociaty and country or whole goverment, and not try to break the harmonius of sociaty like in american where people can tell lies about the other side and cause shooting, distruptions, riots etc.). Not like in the west, in china duty come first before freedom. Thats why u are bound to take the consiqueces that u had made either fysically or semantically. That why china still stay in stable while there have 500 protests/demostrations.
Hi
Hello
26+6=1
broooo. the echoo is anoin
Bro all US allies are not CLIENT STATES
Japan and Taiwan are
@@HydratedBeansTaiwan kinda Japan not so much
@@moustachio05 Most of their military presence are US forces and they never defy us on the international stage. Their decency laws were written by us after WW2 and we designed their government. At the very least they're a protectorate.
@@HydratedBeansactually if you go by this logic Taiwan is less a client state of the US than Japan they are only protected by the US
@@HydratedBeansalso I was talking about what Hasan said that we shouldn't care about the 9 dash line cuz all the other countries that have claims are US client states like wtf no. I am not saying that the US is doing this for the right cause (ofc they just want to cut off china) but they are helping other SOVEREIGN countries keep their waters.