The Long History of Survivor Quitters
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 дек 2019
- While many people pine to one day be on the show, what about those who actually made it on but then quit? Let's talk about them. It's a long and winding road to losers lodge, so here's a brief history covering the entirety of the Survivor "quitters" club.
Smuff my torch, Jeffery. I dare you.
If you'd like to support me, check out these links:
💎 / peridiam
💎 / peridiam
💎 / discord
💎 / billygiese
💎 / billywgiese
Seasons highlighted in this video:
Pearl Islands, All-Stars, Palau, Fiji, Micronesia, Gabon, Nicaragua, Philippines, Blood vs. Water, Cagayan, San Juan del Sur, David vs. Goliath, Edge of Extinction
SUBSCRIBE & FOLLOW FOR ALL THE SURVIVOR GOODNESS! :D 
Развлечения
![MAF Teeski - Whole Thing (feat. VonOff1700) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SHWEj-ndz6g/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine an all quitters season
StrapGod the Trap God watch the season end pre-merge bc every contestant quit
Starting petition
@@stellashanker5724 they can vote for someone to stay instead of leave the island every week xD
It could work if they tested them with something else. Like Big Brother season full of Survivor quitters
in challenges the winning tribe gets to vote someone off, and in the individual part the winner of each challenge goes home. at the end the jury votes for the biggest loser, who has to pay $500,000 to each alternate from their first season for taking away their chance to play
When you look up the word "quitter" in the dictionary, a photo of Colton comes up
Dylan Thomas Dawson lol
He quit twice I believe....
@@annamarie2849 serial quitter then ahaha
By far the WORST and most disgusting player in my opinion! ‘...or you can jump into that fire, whichever is more convenient for you’. ‘Ghetto trash’. ‘Munchkin’. ‘Oompaloompa’. The guy was horrible and whiny and it’s my belief that he quit his first season as well as we later learn that he did NOT have acute appendicitis as was stated. He was just a whiny bitch who fake cried as the medic was checking him over. Sorry for the rant, I just watched that season again and it’s all very fresh and maddening.
Anna Marie he quit once
Jenna's story is so sad, but sometimes you just KNOW when you need to go. She probably realised that her mother was weakening and that if she missed being there at the end, she'd never forgive herself.
I hope she's doing okay now.
I agree. Jenna did the right thing. When she knew she knew.
I agree. She definitely did the right thing
I hate that everyone except Boston Rob gave her shit for leaving. Even Jeff was like “it sounds like you have outside interference” like wtf
@@Heyimconnorespecially considering that production probably told her that they received a call from the family stating her mother's vitals were worsening. But Probst was kind of a dick through almost the entire series, so it tracks.
I think the Sue incident was the producers fault for letting Rich play naked. Survivors were climbing on small ledges and bumping into each other a lot. Had Rich had clothes on there would have been no problem
X.
Nah. Sue would probably still have an issue
Rich should have kept his clothes on, producers dropped the ball on that . I could see how torn up Sue was, Jeff’s flip attitude was wrong. Now have strict rules because of season 39. Which is why Richard Hatch was not on winners at war.
@@susanvega1590 all the years before that contestants took off their clothes. They changed the rules because they don't want to deal with whiny people talking about metoo
@@dwightmanne what are you talking about?? Me Too is definitely valid. Just because people only started talking about it now does not mean they are whiny. Its precisely what the essence of Me Too is. In the past, there were so few coverage about sexual harassment and no proper example of what is acceptable and how should females (and males) should react. As a result, everything got swept under the rug. It’s unfortunate.
You who don’t understand the Me Too movement means you lack basic level of compassion for your fellow human being, who feel sexually harassed.
Won’t you feel sexually harassed if Hatch rubbed his nuts on you? On public TV?
@@bakedtarts I get sexually harassed on a regular basis due to my job. But there isn't a mentoo movement. Many would say that I'm "lucky"
All these so-called "victims" turned out to be massive frauds and hypocrites who took advantage of their sexual prime to get into positions they could never have gotten on their own.
No metoo "victim" was legitimate. They all lied
Imagine taking a feast from a starving person who had no chance of real food for a week longer all while knowing you were less than 24 hours from all the food you could eat.
Ouch
Eh, she offered to sit out of the challenge & not get the reward but that old lady was bitter & made her do the challenge knowing she wanted to quit
its a game stupid.... a reality show...... they aren't really starving. santa clause isnt real, and your mom is the one that taking all your teeth.
As a total Bastard, imagining doing that feels me with malicious glee. Thank you for taking me on this thought exorcise.
@@nickmagill3604 you don't understand what people will do for fame, yes, they will starve in the wild for it
I honestly respected Bi’s decision to quit. I mean, SHE’S A PROFESSIONAL MMA FIGHTER, that’s her JOB. Just because she’s still cleared to play, it can only get worse, which could put her career in danger.
I find it kind of sad and irritating that she still gets lumped in as “quitter”. Yes, it’s technically true, but in context it’s closer to Med-Evac. She didn’t want to quit, it was just the only reasonable choice she could’ve made.
I agree as well, and supported her choice since I watched it as the season aired. If I remember correctly, it looked like she could play just fine at first, but then she injured herself further and that's why she was so worried? Definitely don't want players to put their career in jeopardy because of a show.
Yeah, and since Survivor has that 'quitters don't return' rule, we won't even get to see her get a second chance to really play.
@@JurzGarz A lot of these times, it's basically a "Soft med-evac". Yeah, they weren't sick/injured enough to be evaced, would have been asked to be voted out at the next tribal council because of it, but they knew "It could probably get worse, so I shouldn't risk it".
Osten had multiple staph infections (Which we didn't know until after the fact)
Dana was in pretty bad pain
Kathy was having withdrawal symptoms
"We brought back a quitter, and we got a quit." That pretty much sums up Colton. He has to be my least favority Survivor ever!
Dude. Colton faked appendicitis. He shouldn’t have ever been brought back, he was a whiny complaining bitch.
Dude, where’s the medical evidence? Colton clearly faked appendicitis. Probst is the host of the show, and if he says something happened, guess what, it fuckin happened. Read reports on the doctors saying there was nothing wrong with him. Don’t come into the comments spewing bullshit for a reaction if you won’t get your facts straight.
Find one report stating this outside of Colton himself claiming that. I see no doctorate proof.
Here’s my question to you: why is Jeff’s word not to be believed over Colton’s, who has proved himself to be a whiny piece of shit who quit (definitely) the second time and in my opinion the first time as well? CBS can not file a lawsuit for something Colton says because it is his quote and that’s not how lawsuits work, so why is Jeff’s word “not trustworthy” in this case but I’m supposed to blindly follow Colton because he said it to a single reporter?
My g I don’t think you understand how much of a fallacy that is, just because Probst didn’t object doesn’t mean what Colton said was true. It probably means Probst didn’t want to get into it with Colton on live TV and take away from the actual fucking reunion
One season I would still love to see is Quitters vs MedEvacs
Thats an amazijg idea
buragarawa Jeff would tear into them
in that case they should build ponderosa on edge of extinction
buragarawa maybe for redemption, they don’t have to if they don’t want to 🤷♀️
Caylee I’d root for the medevacs.
The burning of the camp was one of the funniest things i've ever seen because how do you SURROUND A FIRE WITH WOODEN CHESTS LMAOOOOOOO
Oh millennials!!!
George Fitzgerald ok boomer
Gen Z loser
@@morganfreeman8390 haha you tell him! Boomers are superior at being racist, homophobic, sexist, and creating a bad housing market.
Don’t diss the millennials, one day they could be keeping you alive in a hospital. Then they are like, “hey I remember how he called racist, sexist, and homophobic! I hate him/her. “ Then they pull the plug. Ok that sucks but seriously that’s rude and mean so rn you’re b in just as bad as the millennials you ar talking about. Don’t be agist
Probably an unpopular opinion but I can actually somewhat respect most of these quits. Most of them were basically med evacs and Hatch from a publicity point of view is lucky he did what he did in like 2003. If he does that on a modern season he gets hated more than Dan. Never once blamed Sue for that quit. Colton and Naonka were the worst.
yeah, +1 on sue; it makes me really upset when people talk about that like a "normal quit" when it was clear she genuinely felt upset and violated and it didn't seem to matter to probst or anyone else. has probst ever acknowledged that he...casually...kinda made fun of someone who was sexually harassed?
meeseinoddplaces I think people had that reaction because it took her a while to actually get pissed about it and immediately started talking about suing people.
@@FuhrerHeisen sexual assault/harrassment's just complicated, you know? people who are mentally fatigued, younger, etc might not have the emotional capacity to process everything at once. :/ see: Larry Nasser case - people who came out mentioned not realizing they had been assaulted until they thought more about the situations they were in
@@meeseinoddplaces But... ain't Hatch gay?
@@oneofthe12sionmains70 it doesn't matter if he was gay or not, an assault is an assault. Supposedly straight men assault other men. It's about power not about actual attraction.
I realllly don’t like quitters, but the ones I actually do understand are:
Osten (it was reported that he had like 2 or 3 staph infections and had dropped a huge amount of weight, so I have come to understand his reasons)
Jenna (her mother had cancer, so no questioning her decision)
Sue (that incident would make anyone uncomfortable)
Gary ( I have had vertigo and it is awful.)
Kathy (in way over her head, and as stated, was off of her medication)
Dana (in a lot of pain, don’t blame her at all)
Bi - (her career involves being an athlete, so it’s completely valid)
i agree, but id add purple kelly to the list. production literally gave everyone jackets and stuff besides her. she had nothing but a bikini and a skimpy sundress
Medical and family emergencies aren't really quits, they're more of player-discretionary pulls (like Terry when his son was hospitalized).
Nothing happened w/ Sue, she literally went out of her way to have that incident.
Nersius Exactly she went out of her way to walk into Richard I understand why she was uncomfortable but it was easily avoidable
Nersius from what i can tell no she did not,he intentionally did that
@@leighannvanderford2550 ruclips.net/video/6Xq6GuQTzyM/видео.html&feature=emb_title Other paths available, people rushing behind her and on the same platform, yet "gotta take this one" against Hatch.
Jenna’s exit was so sad.
Yeah it was. :'(
Only time I ever cried for a reality show, only was verklempt for certain American Idol boots.
@@HeavyMetal-jy4vj if this is the only time you cried while watching a reality show, you probably dont watch that much
Definitely, the most appropriate self-removal ever. Most of the others were selfish choices, often ruining other players’ possibilities of winning.
maggie198333 just finished a re-watch of All-Stars last night and actually got a bit teary when she left.
You could feel the disrespect radiating from Probst in that scene (I read his body language as ‘why the hell did you come on the show in the first place and take up a spot that could’ve gone to someone else?’) but I’m sure everyone realized after the news hit that she did the right thing and simply made a mistake in agreeing to participate.
Man, if I got public scrutiny for every bad decision I made in my 20s, I’d crawl into a hole and not come out!
I have a genius idea about next season after winners at war... Survivor: Back to the Basics... no twists, no idols, bringing back auctions, bringing back two people final tribal councils, the rite of passage, and an all new but likeable cast, and a traditional jury final tribal council where individual jurors give speeches. Also mutiny (ability to switch tribes) offered, and ability to give immunity necklace to another person. Most importantly, we should bring back the theme song with each person disappearing from the theme after their elimination. SURVIVOR AND PERDIAM, if you see this please like it
They can still give away immunity necklace just no one wants too
Bring back the SOS challenge
Baki but if Jeff asks about it, it would be used more. And could create more drama like erik’s infamous giving up of his necklace
Noah Roberts definetly, there’s so many classic challenges they need to bring back that makes it more fun and intense, challenges these days are boring compared to classics
@@justin.e.s4121 not really, other than the time burton won immunity despite already being immune, theres only been 2 times the immunity was given away, one where jeff said it (erik), and one where he didnt(brandon)
Currently watching Pearl Islands for the first time since I was little and the way they treat Osten is super unfair. He had multiple staph infections and had lost 40 pounds already. Because he was so physically strong and had such little body fat, he had very little fat to lose. Therefore, all of the weight he was losing other than water weight was pure muscle, making him way weaker. They should've at least mentioned the staph infections. From what I've read, he likely would've been medically evacuated if he kept going.
He also sold off all of his clothing on the first day which also harmed him a lot physically.
I wonder - did Jeff even know that Osten have such staph infections?
@@Terestrasz Judging by his reaction and how hostile he was, I don't think he knew, because if he did know, then he would be a straight A-hole.
I wish the survivor community was bigger on RUclips so your channel could get the boost it deserves. I’m sure that these videos aren’t exactly easy to make with the upload frequency and shear quality of each video. Just here to say thank you for all the videos and effort you put into making them. Keep up the good work
Also happy new year
Jeff said:
"You're quitting? 😑😐"
she was spent
I don't mind if people want to quit. This show isn't a torture experiment, it is a consensual competition. If they've weighed their options and want to leave, then that should be acceptable. Even if the only explanation they provide is that they "aren't enjoying it," who are we to tell them their happiness or comfort is unimportant?
Ya it sucks when there thousands of people that would give anything to have a chance to be on the show and you take there spot just to quit because your unhappy like you know what your sighed up for
If Jeff doesn't approve, I don't approve.
The first season i watched was Nicaragua with naionka and purple kelly so i thought that them quiting like that was normal for a while 😂
wait same😂
same! nicaragua is one of the only seasons i have seen so i was expecting to see a lot more quitters in this video
Elena Hammonds yea but i’ve streamed every season except for the past two i’ve watched those love
N L yea but i’ve streamed every season except for the past two i’ve watched those love
Spencer Peterson i’ve watched every other season after it and then went to the early season so..
Can I just say I feel so bad for Jenna? She leaves on the journey of a lifetime and her mom contracts cancer... and she dies 8 days later when Jenna returns...that’s just so sad... can we get a prayer for her mother, and we can just hope she is in a better place.
Not gonna' lie, seeing Sue's facial expressions as she's lying on the beach, reflecting on what happened, I saw the face of a woman struggling with the idea that she'd been sexually harrassed/assaulted on national television, and no one in the challenge - not her teammates, not the other team, not Jeff, and not the producers - said anything. I would've supported her if she decided to sue the show and demand that Hatch get arrested for sexual assault.
Why didn’t she sue
they have to sign a waver that says they wont sue.
I wish Richard Hatch wore clothes during that challenge.
@@teamsteed1 I wonder if the producers would even allow nakedness nowadays.
@@rt66vintage16 No I don't think so regarding the "metoo" movement.
I hate that Sue had to go through that. I think a lot of women understand the feeling of not initially reacting to something and feeling the trauma set in later too:( She deserved better
I don't despise quiters like most people do. Yes, some of them have pathetic (ex. Colton, NaOnka) excuses but some still have good reason to quit the game. Each person has different threshold or tolerance. If their physical or mental can't take it anymore. I think it's best to quit.
Some of you may argue "But you play for money!!!" 'You take somebody's place who deserve to play more!!!". Well, they didn't know or predict in advance that they couldn't take it, did they? Sometimes things were harsher than they thought and for their own sake, quitting is the best solution.
Thank you for saying that
You never know what goes on in someone’s life until you truly see it
I love her but you didn't mind Kyle purple quitting HYPOCRITE
Ya it’s not like other competitions like big brother where it’s literally just living in a house, this game is 39 days of torture it’s impressive that more people haven’t quit
I'm so glad you said that, and more fans seem to be coming around on the idea of quitting=bad. There have been quits that I hated, like Colton, but I feel most of them had an absolutely valid reason to leave, especially for mental or physical health reasons or family emergency. If someone signed up knowing they'll probably quit, sure, those people shouldn't be cast, but I also believe the majority of players that come onto the show don't have any intention to quit.
Maybe it's because I'm from the Netherlands, and I'm not eligible to apply, but I just don't see it as someone "taking the spot of someone who really wanted it!!".
Don't group NaOnka in with Colton. She had legitimate health issues, as she is anemic, which is an absolutely brutal condition to have when it's raining so much. Colton quit because he was a salty baby.
Amber is resilient. She didn’t want to play WaW, she only went for rob. And she was on EoE for a lot of the time. She didn’t quit at all! Amber is amazing.
The 20 year long evolution of the game I feel like definitely justifies both Jenna Morasca’s and Sue’s quit. Terry Dietz was considered medically evacuated due to a family emegency, and Dan Spilo was kicked out because of innappropriate sexual conduct, both in recent seasons. I feel like had Jennas and Sues situations happened in later seasons, Jeff and the production crew would’ve handled it better, Hatch’s behavior especially, but maybe only in Jennas case if someone back in the states tried to reach out to her and wanted her to come home. But her’s was completely out of instinct but even then I can imagine Jeff would have more compassion.
True Fact: Richard Hatch was supposed to be on Winners at War, but after the Dan Spilo incident during Island of the Idols, they didn't want Hatch back because of what happened on All Stars.
its so funny about how silently mad Jeff gets when players quit, but I cant blame him, I would get really mad if someone quit.
I can. Especially how he treated Sue and Jenna. Disgusting behavior on Jeff’s part. He should be ashamed
@@spacecadet2172 he treated sue and henna with respect
@@heizousbabygirl4972 and Bi
@@spacecadet2172 I get the feeling you didn’t watch either of those moments because Jeff handled them about as well as anybody
@@SonicGlitchmaster1 excuse me? Sue was sexually assaulted under his watch, on a show he produces and not only did Jeff not properly address the issue, but he belittled the victim and made her out to be a quitter. Jenna left to see her dying mother one last time, which turned out to be completely the right decision and again Jeff maligned her unfairly and treated her with disgust and disdain. It’s disturbing that you consider that “handling well”.
I read an entire piece on purple kelly and how they duped her into only having about 5 pieces of clothing and no protection. Production did not let her bring anything else. I would not be able to handle being cold with no source of warmth for 30 days straight so I respect how long she lasted.
Angelina: "Quitting is such a tough decision"
Also Angelina: "Did you know I got rice for my tribe?"
She was such a cringe goddess.
Jesus Christ that dude who violated Sue should have been kicked off the show immediately. So much respect for her for telling Jack off.
Richard Hatch really should've been shown the door right there, the second he decided to do that challenge naked. And Sue's right, even if Jeff didn't see it, there are 50 different cameras at these challenges. He could have found out after and he and other producers could have tossed him. So I don't see Sue's quit or the others linked to injuries as legitimate quits.
It absolutely shouldn't have been allowed to happen. The people who try to defend the producer's actions or say that Sue overreacted are disgusting.
I hope that there will be a Survivor: Quitters
There will be no tribal councils, just quitters.
but there must be rule: if no one decides to quit, the tribe gets penalized by destroying shelter, taking away food and fire-starter to get them motivated to quit...
@@911madza This is genius. lol
@@Kim-xs2yw In Survivor: Quitters edition Immunity challenges would be used for quitting.
Jeff: Come on in guys!
_Tribes come in and take their marks_
Jeff: Wanna know what you are playing for?
Tribes: Yes, Jeff, Yes!!!! _Everyone's jumping around_
Jeff: An opportunity to leave this island before others. _Points to boat in the shore_
Tribes: _Everyone screaming in excitement_
Jeff: Alright, I'll give you a minute to strategize and lets get started!
_Tribes make a circle and decide who would be most fit to quit_
Jeff: Alright, its time to quit! Who is it gonna to be?
_Selected survivor takes a step forward_
_Jeff raises both hands as he does on winning_ You win the quit! You must leave immediately!
Jeff: As for the others, I have nothing for you! Enjoy the night out!
Truly heartbreaking for Jenna, but I am so glad she trusted her gut feeling.
Same here. You always gotta go with your gut
I kind of understood Lindsey’s quit. She seemed to be on the verge of hurting Trish. As someone who’s friend has bad anger issues, it was pretty mature to take herself out.(she probably shouldn’t have signed up in the first place)
John Debate I really respect her for doing that. She knew her limits and she knew she would do something she would regret if she didn’t quit and that was really mature of her. She gave up a chance for $1,000,000 because she didn’t want to hurt trish
David Basa agreed. She handled herself like a mature woman.
idk i feel like she sort of used that as an excuse bc she didn’t want to play without cliff
No it was very immature. If you can’t handle anger don’t fucking sign up. I can’t believe people are actually excusing this behavior valid. “I have poor emotional maturity” is not a valid excuse
@@liminalcriminal_ if you think that the entire situation is summed up to emotional maturity then you might be lacking it yourself
HAPPY NEW YEAR PERIDIAM
Jeff HATES quitters and cannot hide it for his life!!! lol
Cast members don't get equal clothing. They get what casting wants to let them keep to support their character role.
I respect Sue so much. She had to know everyone was going to criticize, even make fun of her, for quitting. Rich unquestionably assaulted her, yet she’s supposed to laugh it off and pretend it wasn’t a literal crime. Years later and I’m still so proud of Sue for standing her ground.
So Rich sexually harassed/molested Sue and everyone just expected her to be ok with that. I totally understand her feeling violated and disrespected and dehumanized. Jesus Christ.
This was long time ago people didn't make a big deal of it like they do now
DX- DRAGON, As someone that was already an adult in 2003, I can assure you that people made a big deal about sexual harassment in 2003.
@@brawndothethirstmutilator9848 Not like they do nowadays... No they didn't and I was also an adult in 2003.
Things are different now.
Petty Kitty, “Things” are always “different”. The one constant of reality is change.
One of the things that are different is that now we have people recording themselves at the gym and trying to publicly shame other people who barely look at them or talk to them as “harassers”. It’s quite fashionable on TikTok at the moment. That behavior wasn’t happening in 2003. Apparently our society no longer understands normal public social interactions. So yes, things are different.
Let's not forget that Colton is a two-time quitter. Pathetic. His first quit is labelled a medical evacuation but Probst told us that he faked the illness. That's 100% a quit in my book.
Yeah Colton should of never played
Honestly....I really hoped that Colton was gonna have a story that he had changed. I was disappointed when he quit. It would have been redemption for him...but he IS also a terrible person so I don’t feel as strongly as I did back when it aired.
No he corrected himself in the reunion it was a medevac
As much as I hate to admit it, Colton’s pain in One World was very real. As a person who’s had a bacterial infection, they feel a lot like an appendicitis and are incredibly painful
You really just gonna believe Probst like that? I mean, he clearly hated Colton (which is fair), so I wouldn't be surprised if he just made that up for more anti-Colton ammo (which is not fair).
Sue’s quit was totally valid. The producers in general and Jeff in particular majorly fucked up by letting Richard compete naked and then make light of Sue’s feelings.
The likes of Colton and Na’onka deserved the roasting they got from Jeff
I think a good twist would be that if there's ever a quit, the person voted out previously should have the chance to come back. Especially with Nicuagua...
yeah ikr. Marty and Brenda were the best people that season and them coming back would've made the season far better in my opinion.
I really like that idea not just a free return but a -chance-
I agree if it’s a Medical evac then yes, but quitters should not have another chance
As someone with a disability/chronic illness, I sympathize with the quits for medical reasons (this includes mental health, like with Kathy and Sue). It's hard to really know how far you can push yourself and when it's genuinely time to stop trying, so I can relate. With quite a few of them, it looked like they would've been medevaced soon anyway, I'd rather see players get proper treatment.
I'm also not from America, so maybe this is a cultural difference (though in my personal environment, not so much). I was SHOCKED at how angry fans would get over quits when I just got into the show. And started reading social media and message boards. To me it feels like a lot of them have a valid reason to leave and did try for as long as they could?
I sympathize with Katy as well. I suffer from anxiety and I take meds for it. I probably would’ve had a similar reaction if I was off my meds and dealing with the harsh conditions
the main issue people have with quits is that they take up the spot of somebody who would have gone the distance, also in modern seasons they fully know what they are signing up for
@@esinger23 Yeah, Kathy is like... the textbook example of why quitting your meds cold turkey, without consulting a doctor, can be a bad idea. The game is mentally taxing even without the need for medication and/or mental illness. Probst was pretty understanding about it, too, which I liked.
NaOnka was the only quitter that upset me only because she should’ve had an amazing downfall. I also find it bs how Dana’s quit is excused but Purple Kelly isn’t, even though she was sick for even longer than Dana.
I think it has more so to do with the way it was portrayed. Dana was given the medical team's clearance, but they showed her in extreme pain. Editors made Purple Kelly infamous with her edit, which just makes her quit and the situation around it a lot more hidden for the mainstream fanbase.
@@funkycrawler619 Yeah, I definitely think they should've been more honest about Purple Kelly and how sick she was. This pretty much left it up to the rest of the cast to defend her choice, because they had seen how sick she'd been. Similar thing with Osten and his edit. Wish they'd been given a similar edit like Dana. While I've seen her situation debated as well, there's more people who are sympathetic to it because we got to see how bad it was.
Haha, I actually think NaOnka had a pretty damn good chance to win the game if she didn't quit. She was in a great position (she'd lose to Fabio, but she beats a lot of other people), and she had an idol.
I truly feel for Kathy, the main reason I would never agree to a show like this is that I rely on my high doses of medication to not off myself impulsively lmao
Survivor quitters as Jeff Probst says, "that no one remembers" is a good monologue for Survivor quitters but I think some quitters are better than others. Kathy from Micronesia, for example, I believe she really tried her best and she was just overly emotional from the elements and I felt for her. Colton's quit from B v W is probably one that I have no respect for. He quit because he couldn't get his way. He is just pathetic.
Happy New Year Peridiam. 😊❤❤
GamingFanactic911 this comment is an emotional roller coaster lmao
colton had several staph infections and they SUCK DUDE it hurts to move sometimes because if one little infection
@@thereses.9926 osten was the one with several staph infections. colton's the one who quit twice, and while you may believe he was genuinely sick the first time, the second time he literally, self-admittedly quit because he didn't immediately start off with a good place in the game, and he was too whiny and lazy to try playing from the bottom or accept being voted out normally. he's pathetic. i don't often get angry with quitters tbh but colton doesn't deserve any respect.
In my mind I can't justify calling Jemma a quitter.
I agree. If you’re going to leave, a dying loved one is certainly a good enough reason to. She had the intuition that something was going to happen and I’m positive the last 8 days she had with her mom are worth more to her than $1M
@Peter McGill and Gary and Dana
B.B. Anderson (RIP) from Survivor Borneo is technically the first mercy-kill quit. In episode 2, he asked his tribe to vote him out after Pagong lost the immunity challenge.
15:08 “never to be topped”
*Hannah:* wanna bet?
Omg Jeff getting at Colton for quitting is just amazing 👌
Ngl most survivor fans that'd be on the show would probably quit lmao
Man that stuff looks hard. Its supposed to look easy. But it looks hard💀
I quit before I even applied to be on the show. 🤷🏻♂️
How could that possibly be true? A lot of the people on the show were fans and the majority of them didnt quit
@@theyogaduck2532 The contestants are usually recruits anyway, hence why they probably aren't scared of the elements
Nova he’s just saying that being on survivor is harder than it seems. and a lot of fans can sit there and say they wouldn’t quit but in reality the difficulty of it would cause a lot to quit .
I think Dana's questionable quit is 100% more dignified and bad-ass than some of those mercy-kill quits that had happened before.
P.S. At least Winners at War should be quitter-proof. So that's good.
The 30s (seasons 30-39) have all been quitter free yet alone an all winner season
B C No. Bi quit in survivor 37, but it was a good reason to. But other than that, yeah no one else has quit.
pogodziej Sandra quit the edge which isn’t really that shameful tbh
I’d be curious to see a review of throwing challenges. Some have won the game for someone, others have doomed entire tribes.
Thank you very much for this video. My husband and I were just talking, the other day, about people that have quit. I appreciate the video. Very interesting and good editing.
I don’t consider this a quit however I felt it should have been mentioned. I’m referring to when Terry Dietz left the game in survivor Cambodia (second chance) to see his son in the hospital...
He was pulled
Clii Nt
He had a choice just as Jenna had a choice. He made the right decision but it still WAS a decision
@@nift_nift8474 ohhh okkkk
@@nift_nift8474 no he really was pulled, he had no choice, they just made it look like he had a choice
TheOscar401
The first person ever pulled from the game was Dan from this season Island of the Idols. He did not have a choice. Terry did.
I just had another thought! Thinking about Season 40, and previous seasons featuring winners, I would love to see you break down the history of returning winners, and why only one thus far has managed to win a second time!
I think it’s because you can see how they played in previous seasons and people are intimidated by them since they’ve already won, so they want to vote them out as soon as possible
I remember watching the Tribal Council in Pearl Islands when Osten had decided to leave. Jeff just verbally polled his tribe mates and they didn't even vote. I remember Jeff being mighty miffed about the whole thing, too. "Osten, for your wishes," snuffs torch, "go home." Then the torch gets laid down on the floor with dramatic music playing in the background and Jeff basically tells the rest of Morgan how pissed off he is. And as a final insult, when Lil, Sandra and Johnny Fairplay go through the Rites Of Passage at the final three they're not even given time to reflect on Osten's time in the game, because he quit.
Ouch.
But, Osten is also probably lucky to have quit since he almost drowned in a challenge and had to be rescued by Andrew Savage and Ryan O.
Probst at that tribal council made me so uncomfortable, I really hated how hard he went in on Osten (when it's been later confirmed by Savage that he had serious staph infections). Like, Probst just wouldn't believe that someone could be too sick to continue, or that not every player handles being sick the same way. I still don't get why he couldn't just let the tribe vote Osten out as normal, someone had to go and everyone was fine with it being him. I get that they wanted to scare off future players from quitting, but not that they picked this player to do that with.
Imagine if Jeff had taken Sue more seriously. Imagine how season 39 would’ve gone down after that
im glad jenna made the call to go, she really felt the need to, i respect her 🕊
Colton high key my least favorite player ever
@EN KVN No i don't "marginally like Dan" I just hate Colton even more. On the badness scale, they're both 100/100, but Colton was on the show twice. :/
@EN KVN No Colton is even worse
EN KVN no no that goes to that one guy I forget his name who outed Zeke for being trans in game changers
Helen Notestine that wasn’t even that bad, Cirie is the bottom of the barrel
Matthew Covert 😂
Thank you for posting the video. Can't wait for your "Survivor: Winners at War" review.
11:56 Dan's having fun there
Lindsey's quit I agree was pathetic. Yes, she thought she was in the majority and her ally got blindsided and after that she just quit when she didn't have the guts to fight from the bottom like most people that get blindsided. But at the same time, I think she was right to quit because she could have gotten physical with Trish but either way if she did do that, she would have been ejected from the show.
She had anger issues. She kept arguing with Trish, and was afraid of physically hurting her.
I am now convinced the only reason Colton was cast a second time is because they wanted Caleb on a season
Thanks for all you do Peridiam! Best wishes for 2020
as beautifully put by the best quitter of all time, "milk your own milk"
k lindsey quit bc she was scared she was going to hurt trish which i think is actually a pretty responsible thing to do
That just seems like bad emotional control. If youre so emotionally unstable that one woman disliking you and not seeing a friend, you probably shouldn't be on the show in the first place.
I find that Jeff's a LOT more sympathetic towards people who are quitting for reasons that are medical related - such as being off meds or injuries.
Happy New Year Peridiam I can't wait to see what work you come up with. Very famous
Happy New Year! Excited for Winners At War
Loving your work Peridiam! This may not be something you're interested in, but I'd love to see you explore something along the lines of "The Long History of Survivor Showmances". Could be an interesting change of pace? Discussing the OGs Colby and Jerri, through the iconic Rob and Amber, and incorporating the quickly smuffed such as Dean and Chelsea. In any case, I can not wait until the Season 40 coverage!
Jenna's quit is probably one of the few times I believe Jeff completely understood the reason for the quit and while it's known he gets very annoyed with quitters, saying they would not be asked back to the show, I remember seeing somewhere that Jenna was one of the exceptions he would make since her quit was for a very good reason. There are others yeah, but I'm sure Jenna is the main example of a quitter who likely would be asked to come back.
I hope so! Her quit was entirely justified in my opinion - I can't even imagine her devastation if she didn't listen to her gut and her mom passed away while she was still on the show. Heartbreaking situation, she made the right choice. I'd love to see her get another chance and I'd definitely be interested in seeing how she does on a modern season of Survivor
Happy New Year Peridiam! Keep up the awesome content in 2020
Funny enough i'm discovering this channel since yesterday ( i'm liking it very much :3 ) and i'm watching this now xD
Happy New Year Peridiam
Even though he was voted out, Brandon Hantz fell into this category with me, as a rage quit. Even if his tribe hadn't of voted him out, his actions and temper tantrum probably would have forced the producers to pull him from the game.
That dude had serious mental problems! I was honestly concerned he was going to kill someone in the camp as they slept.
Ngl I categorize it as a med evac. Not physically but just mentally he shouldn’t have ever played.
They did pull him from the game the players said after the season that the producers forced them to vote him out
Happy New Year! Hope everyone has a great year. Looking forward to an awesome year of Survivor!
Happy New Year, PERIDIAM!!! 🥳🎉🎊
Happy New Year Peridiam!
the fact that Na'Onka seriously could have won had she not quit... a disappointment
usually quitters are passive players that really don’t want to be there anyway, or don’t care much about the game, but naonka was such an active and powerful player and just.... quit. so close to the end. it was so disappointing
i hate na’onka.
TheMurrmursonbottle wdym she was so annoying. I feel so bad for fabio whenever she talked he would get so frustrated ahah
@@elenaistoocool4928 even if you found her annoying you can't deny that she was a powerful player and was definitely playing the game
-robert- she couldn’t win. even if she decided not to quit. literally everyone hated her
I pointed this out last time but someone quit like 2 seconds into the game of Fiji
EN KVN I feel like if they tried they would find someone who would drop their entire life to go on survivor but ya that’s hard...
So's sister got medevac'd before San Juan Del Sur
RC's father did too in Blood vs Water
I don’t care how many times I watch this but I love this video
Just realized I wasn’t subbed to you and I’ve watched like 15 of your vids. Keep up the great content buddy!
You’re the best. I like that you weren’t included people on EOE.
Sue had a very valid reason, she was sexually harrased and she was probably too shooken to actually play
LOL
Sweet Scribblez I think it was more of an accident but I see why she left.
It’s like she never felt a peepee before
"Shooken"??
"Shaken"
Camille Anderson she saw too shooketh sorry
Love these long videos
Great content!!
Brenda deserves more on her formerly season if two quitter s gone previously.
Anthon Metropolis I saw a comment where if someone quits the person should get a CHANCE to come back not a guarantee but a chance
Video idea:
Is the era of the survivor villain over?
Your video about splitting up survivor into eras and my love of Russel Hantz inspires this. I ultimately think that in this day and age of plentiful advantages and idols, the villain is a more risky way to play. Someone like Russel or Randy would not make it far in a modern season, imo.
The idea that villains in Survivor are gone is ridiculous. Here are Villains of all the last seasons:
IoI: Missy
EoE: Rick Devens
DvG: Angelina
GI: Dom
HvHvH: Crissy and Ryan
GC: Sarah and Brad
MvGx: Jay
KR: Scott and Jason
SC: Spencer
WA: Rodney
SJDS: Natalie A.
BvBvB: Tony and Kass
If you're wondering why there aren't any legitimately awful people like Russell playing Survivor anymore, it's because people know they CAN'T do that shit anymore if they want to have a chance at actually winning. Russell proved that himself by losing twice in a row.
I mean yes, every season there will be players who may play a “villain role” but I feel as if that may just be the people that they are. More aggressive, etc. I do agree that Tony, Kass, and I would say Abi-Maria are some of the only true villains in seasons past, as their underhanded gameplay was ultimately their life or death in the game.
@@jacobmiller8786 I honestly don't know what you are asking for. Missy, in just the last season, was a pretty spiteful and underhanded player, and perfect proof of why you don't see a lot of people actually playing like that. Because it doesn't work. You either get found out and voted off mid way through the merge (like Missy), or you make it to the finals as an asshole that noone wants to give a million dollars (like what would have ultimately happened to Dan if he didn't get pulled).
Most effective villains in modern seasons know they have to be more subtle. A Russell-type player cannot exist and be successful in Modern Survivor, because he technically was never successful to begin with.
There are still villans
i LOVE your videos so much.
Happy New Year!
Is it me or right after the Richard and Sue incident in All Stars, they prohibited the contestants from competing naked?
I remember that before that, some contestants would go naked in some challenges (Jenna and Heidi in the Amazon, or Savage, Ryan and Osten in Pearl Islands) but after that situation, that never happened again. Correct me if I am wrong.
Thank you for sparing us all of Coltons most cringey moments. You aced that, because I was ready to fast forward and didn't need to.
Love this channel
thank you my friend
Honestly, Purple Kelly's quit was understandable- and her doing so led to the producers changing some rules and giving other women cast in her role a chance to get more clothing in the future. She had to wear a bikini and little else and she's not a big girl- she's going to get cold faster. Interviews with her teammates have said that she hardly got any sleep most of the time. Shivering and being cold saps energy, so she's going to be even weaker from there. Like, the fact that this girl made it as far as she did is incredible, considering what she was facing. She managed to make her way onto each majority alliance and despite ridiculous conditions considering what she was allowed to wear, made it deep into the game.
If she had stayed in the game much longer, there was a solid chance she would have had to be medevac'd at some point, imo.
I don't really understand the vilification of people who retract their consent to do something. Sure, maybe the thing they don't want to do is something other people might want to do or think they could handle better, but that doesn't mean that someone's ability to retract consent should be mocked. No means no, and the decision to say no shouldn't be villainized.
the intro gives me goosebumps 🤍
Peridiam, you should do a cast assessment of Survivor 40: Winners at War!
Can you please do a video comparing Big Brother, Amazing Race, adn Survivor? Comparing winners, ratings, twist, entertainment, and stuff like that.
Keith and wendy played survivor, got voted off, tried to get back in, didn’t, and stopped their survivor journey. They aren’t quitters and they both have said they had a positive experience on survivor which is what matters
Colton got medically evacuated in One World
He faked it
You have to mention the quitters from exile Island. They accepted the terms again, once they chose to reenter the game...