Mini-Q Metal Gear Servo Tests: Centering, Speed, Resolution

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 дек 2024

Комментарии • 76

  • @RedwoodRc
    @RedwoodRc 4 месяца назад +1

    Nice! Just started watching your older k989 videos. It's nice to know that alternative parts from kyosho can be used. Thank you for the content you post. Very informative

  • @thomasbuser6975
    @thomasbuser6975 4 года назад +1

    Your tests are very useful, thank you Beaver 👍👍👍

  • @bananabread3630
    @bananabread3630 5 месяцев назад

    I miss this type of videos

  • @BlitzWorks
    @BlitzWorks 4 года назад +1

    Have been playing with servos at a larger scale as of late and found the real issues with centering are when moving a large load and when there is bind or resistance. analog vs ditigal appears to play a bit of a role here. while some servos looked good on the bench, when installed in a car and placed on carpet (adding bind) they would get close but not fully center. seems its a bit easier at this scale but something i have been paying more attention to after i noted some servos where not working as well under high speed braking+turning

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад +1

      It's exactly centre in drift car but that doesn't mean much since there's low resistance. I'll try to put it in my TC soon.

    • @BlitzWorks
      @BlitzWorks 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby based off your original servo latency video i went off and bought a proper servo tester and have been amazed at what i have found, i wont put a servo in a car until i have gone off and tested it fully now. so many dont meet specs

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@BlitzWorks Just tried it in my Q7 TC. It pulls really well. Centre is perfect. Not as good as A11CLS but at this price, I'm not complaining. I'm getting another one for my WLtoys.

    • @BlitzWorks
      @BlitzWorks 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby Nice to hear, i have been wondering during this conversation if i need to establish a testing methodology for better comparison. the one thing i noticed with the new tester is peak current draw which has lead me to believe that with one or two of my servos adding a capacitor may improve performance
      it does make latency testing much easier as it can go from nothing to full lock in a single step. i should really look at recording those videos

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      ​@@BlitzWorks Now that I think about it, if you want to see how fast it can do and eliminate the human error then you can use Arduino to command it. just write the pulse you want and it'll output that without delay.

  • @DerperyPooslinger
    @DerperyPooslinger 4 года назад +1

    Have you ever tried the HGD1 RWD kit from Banggood? Would like to see a video on it

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад +1

      It's on the way. There will be build video and review as usual.
      ps. At first I didn't think I'd buy it because I was saving up for a GL car but then I decided, yep, I should have one.

    • @DerperyPooslinger
      @DerperyPooslinger 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby Awesome, I look forward to see this, always enjoy your videos!

    • @DerperyPooslinger
      @DerperyPooslinger 4 года назад

      @@BeaversHobby Not sure if this is useful, but there is a YT called Sunrise Garage, and they have a video about this turning radius mod for a 1/28 scale, it's available via this website called CRD R/C. I'll attach links below for both
      CRD: www.tokopedia.com/crd
      Sunrise Garage video: ruclips.net/video/oss-wnJNCBA/видео.html

  • @trevorc6793
    @trevorc6793 3 года назад +1

    Hi Beaver, is this still a good option (when back in stock) or is there now something newer/better that you've found? **edit** just found the wltoys upgraded 5g version..

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  3 года назад

      Yes, it's still good and it's practically the same as WLtoys metal gear version so pick whichever you can get the cheapest.

  • @paulettesaunders6003
    @paulettesaunders6003 3 года назад +1

    I have a SCX24 with a bad 3 wire servo! I have a HBX that don't work but it has rite size servo but 5 wire can it be used in SCX

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  3 года назад

      Yes, you can try swapping the board and see. I don't know what servo SCX24 uses but you should be able to find a similar size with metal gear.

  • @olafschermann1592
    @olafschermann1592 4 года назад +2

    Great mini-q servo! I wish they would still produce the gears for cs-mod. 😞

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      Yes, such a shame they dropped it.

    • @johnmachter40
      @johnmachter40 8 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@BeaversHobbywhat's the cs mod?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  8 месяцев назад

      @@johnmachter40 It's the mod to make rear wheels spin faster than the front and force the car to hold counter steer (opposite lock) when drifting. Here's the video explanation of it. ruclips.net/video/N2D1rALTQPY/видео.html

  • @sk8rboi05
    @sk8rboi05 3 года назад +1

    sir do these metal servo still need springs?
    did you try using digital servo?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  3 года назад

      Yes, the spring is still needed. It's a part of servo saver that will bounce the horn when there's a collision. Although it's not entirely necessary with metal gear servo but having a bit of protection is still better for touring car.

  • @sontoshi25
    @sontoshi25 9 месяцев назад +1

    Hey beaver can you help me with my servo? I bought the servo and I was thinkering my rc, suddenly my receiver's steering is reversed, like when I turn the wheel to the left, it goes right and vice versa. I tested other servos but still the same so I think the receiver is the problem, can you give some advice to fix?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  9 месяцев назад

      That is the setup on the transmitter. You can go into the menu and find "REV" or "Reverse channel" select channel 1 then switch it off (or on, anyway, it's the opposite of what you have now).

    • @sontoshi25
      @sontoshi25 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby my rc is the wltoys 284161, it doesn't have switches besides throttle trim and steering trim.

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  9 месяцев назад

      @@sontoshi25 Do you remember what did you do exactly to have this effect? It's unusual for the servo to suddenly have reverse direction when there's no setting to do. Now you either have to change the servo and find one that works or open up the transmitter and swap 2 wires from the steering potentiometer. You'll have to experiment which 2 gives you the correct steering.

    • @sontoshi25
      @sontoshi25 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby I installed the aluminum parts and followed your steps on grinding some to fit and when I put everything back together, the steering suddenly became reversed. I bought another servo because I thought that was the issue, but lo and behold it's not. I think the transmitter is the problem or the esc? I guess i'll have to open up the transmitter and do what you said. Do you have any guide how to open up the transmitter for the 284161?
      (Really appreciate you taking the time and helping man)

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  8 месяцев назад

      @@sontoshi25 It's strange that the transmitter suddenly reverse the channel by itself. Unfortunately I don't have a tutorial to open up the transmitter bit it's just a few screws so you can slowly remove them and keep track of where they were. If you have the old version with red handle + flame then there might be some screws hidden behind the reflective sticker on the base.

  • @mridz7392
    @mridz7392 4 года назад +1

    Great servo for my future upgrade, btw can u show us how to put on metal die cast cover on K989 body? Thank.

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      I haven't found a metal die cast that fits on the car in my area yet but it is the same as using plastic model as a body. First you make 2 plates to put a magnet on between the body posts, one for the front and another on for the back. Then stick some magnets on the body, line them up with the magnets on the car and that's it.

  • @foxhoundra6444
    @foxhoundra6444 2 года назад +1

    I broke my stock servo on the 530 today haha :( This one is out of stock, which do you suggest?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  2 года назад +1

      This one. www.banggood.com/custlink/K3vWOjuf4W
      It's the same unit but with a different bag and label.

    • @foxhoundra6444
      @foxhoundra6444 2 года назад

      @@BeaversHobby thanks again, have you noticed there isn't a lot of other information out there aside from yourself?

  • @deadlockggwp
    @deadlockggwp 4 года назад +1

    Beaver if you use gyro on this servo you have shacking on servo?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад +1

      Not more than other servos. I do have slow shake in my HGD1 RWD drift if I crank up the gain too high. The car still drifts file but it might look strange from the outside but other than that, no, it's not shaking violently.

    • @deadlockggwp
      @deadlockggwp 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby thank you beaver, maybe i will try this servo. Because now i use wltoys 5g servo metal gear but if i use gain more than 40 its shacking violently

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@deadlockggwp I don't think this would be any different than WLtoys metal gear though, they look exactly the same and probably from the same manufacture. Which car are you using it with? Check the steering for slop and binding first, it might help.

  • @Chromie21
    @Chromie21 4 года назад +1

    What AAA batteries do you recommend for the miniq? Should I run a lipo? Buy a rechargeable battery pack?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      A set of too rechargeable AAA is good. Something like Eneloop or IKEA Ladda are easy to find and performance is good.
      If you want use Lipo, 1S works best with the original board. Capacity is whatever fits the tray.

  • @jamesklark7307
    @jamesklark7307 4 года назад +1

    Comparing with Gening D561MG whichone is better?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад +1

      This one has better centering and the unit is shorter. Overall this is better. But you need your own horn because it's not included.

    • @jamesklark7307
      @jamesklark7307 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby Thank you very match~

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      My pleasure.

  • @orange1248
    @orange1248 4 года назад +1

    would this go well with micro crawlers?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      Yes, it will. Check the size of your servo first. This is 5g size. I normally see 9g on micro crawler.

  • @IYNGAME
    @IYNGAME 4 года назад +1

    Where i can buy solid for thi car,

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      Um... I guess you meant servo? Here's the link for this exact one. bit.ly/2PfUtWJ
      Here's another one. It's the same just with a different badge. bit.ly/3k0CrWb

    • @IYNGAME
      @IYNGAME 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby no i meant i have buy solid exle for miniq 1 you no place can i buy.

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@IYNGAME Oh, sorry. In that case you can just buy a standard diff from Mini-Q or Min-Z and then glue the inside to lock it.
      Mini-Z standard diff bit.ly/2M9hSrv
      Mini-Q ball diff bit.ly/2Wm6puF

    • @IYNGAME
      @IYNGAME 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby thankyou

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@IYNGAME My pleasure.

  • @goingcrazy00
    @goingcrazy00 4 года назад +1

    This direct swap into the 989 servo mount?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      Yes. Same spline for servo saver too.

    • @goingcrazy00
      @goingcrazy00 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby what's a spline for a servo saver? Lol

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@goingcrazy00 Spline is where you put the servo horn in. Servo saver is mechanism that has spring with a bit of give so when you crash the impact to servo mechanism will be lessen, hence the name.

    • @goingcrazy00
      @goingcrazy00 4 года назад +1

      @@BeaversHobby thanks again.

  • @xgeo88
    @xgeo88 4 года назад +1

    Is it compatible with atomic DRZ?

  • @anggasetiawan7988
    @anggasetiawan7988 4 года назад +1

    hai beaver..saya baru membeli esc brushed 20a..baru pertama di pakai sudah terbakar..apa penyebabnya?..saya menggunakan motor dan baterai stock k989..receiver r6fg

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      There are many ways things could have gone wrong, defective ESC, wrong wiring like put battery in to motor, plugged the receiver in the wrong way, etc. If your receiver survived then just get a new ESC to try out.

    • @anggasetiawan7988
      @anggasetiawan7988 4 года назад +1

      receiver ku baik baik saja..apakah ada esc yg kuat..

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@anggasetiawan7988 If you don't mind the weight and size, Hobbywing 1625. The other one is Dumbo RC 10A bit.ly/2qPpisf .

    • @anggasetiawan7988
      @anggasetiawan7988 4 года назад +1

      saya mencoba memakai receiver stock wltoys..lalu motor jadi sangat panas dan baterai cepat sekali habis..saya merubah posisi motor jadi di tengah dan menggunakan pinion yang besar untuk motornya..apakah itu penyebabnya?

    • @BeaversHobby
      @BeaversHobby  4 года назад

      @@anggasetiawan7988 Could be. If the gear mesh is too tight it'll heat up the motor very quickly. ruclips.net/video/bQiR-cfBnvw/видео.html