CL You obviously haven’t gotten pen flinger from first day of school as libram paladin. With a full board, you fan potentially get 7 pen flinger attacks in 1 turn with just 1 libram of wisdom and then have it in hand again
Vocal-jority* no one is going to tell him to keep doing what he's doing, cuz that's a no-duh. so any amount saying change it looks like a majority. I liked it as it was... I feel like this will leave things just as "oh wow i wonder how he'll rate this one."
Dana Staples-Weyrauch That’s very true, but the comment suggesting the switch in the last video had over 1k likes, along with the majority of the replies being positive, so I feel like that must have some merit. If it was a bad idea, then most people would have disagreed. I’m honestly surprised an argument didn’t break out there, considering how easily internet arguments start. xd
Often only one or two cards in the review will be a 5/5 thus eliminating any guesswork. This new format is far superior even from an objective point of view.
I like how, while Trump was ROASTING that Moroes card, even though the screen was crammed full of stuff, he and Jens made sure to fit in the name of the poor sap who designed it.
They wouldn’t even need to do that, Trump doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Literally start up a game of Hearthstone on mobile and you’ll see that you can in fact have 10 cards shown 😂 Source: Mobile Hearthstone player
@@agr0nianTV Scroll bars are very clunky and not elegant. You can't see all the cards at once or quickly go back to other cards instantly. I've played card games with scroll bars and it doesn't feel good to use at all.
Bowmaster's assistant is set for grand tournament, and you've said that you'll take into account when the card is supposed to be set and so it would now be rotated out, therefore one of your two design weaknesses is nullified, right?
No, because the author clarified the card was not a beast because of Dire Frenzy, which is not a TGT Card, or anywhere near that. So, you either dock points for the balance of being unbalanced with Zul’Jin, or you dock more design, because designed this card based on a card that wouldn’t be printed for years...which one is it, I believe it is the first...
4:17 That's not that bad if they're forced to play their topdecked card. It's kind of like a worse Loatheb, but cheaper. It'd be useful to avoid certain combos or board wipes and the like.
Raging swordfish has the design of the Yu-Gi-Oh card named saber shark I remember it for my time playing Yu-Gi-Oh but raging swordfish does have a better affect even though it steals it’s artwork👍
Trump: Bowmaster assistant loses stars because it would have to be printed AFTER Zuljin Trump: *Fails fo recognize that it has the Grand Tournement stamp on it, thus printed before Zuljin and already out of standard rotation.*
For Prophet Zul you can replace your current hand with your opponents and you pick a card that way and just for a little more flavor they can have the shadow essence smoke aura around them
2:25 To everyone who is saying that Trump is missing the point of the doggo because the watermark was TGT, listen to what Trump said. He said the author didn’t make the dog a beast because of dire frenzy, you know, a card created years after TGT???
Back in the days of BlackRock mountain, flamewaker was OP if you just cast 2 spells and it dealt 4 damage. Spawn of ragnaros costs roughly the same/stats, but doesn’t need you to play spells, and auto-triggers every turn. It is insanely overpowered.
@@wormsblink2887 you realize flamewaker was good cuz you could proc it like 6 times in 1 turn and the spell condition is not a downside its a cap to the nuts power, and the minirags only get to shoot one time
hauntedxxshadow You want to know how busted they are? 3 Mini-Rags could cast Arcane Missiles at the end of your turn. You know how much casting an arcane missiles without “losing a card is”? Look at how Blizzard balanced it. They gave Arcane Missiles to a 3 mana 2/1...how is that supposed to be relatively balanced to 3 1/1s that, if you don’t kill them, will cast it again FOR FREE!
Prophet Zul is perfectly possible, You can just scroll along them, if you want to show 10 cards. there would be like 2-3 on screen at once and two buttons on the left and right to move along it, phone users would just swipe to move it along. Also the options for Prophet zul could include another option, something along the lines of "None of these cards", basically saying that they play the top deck, or a card they draw into.
Seriously, I have no clue what Trump is talking about when he says you can’t fit 10 cards on the UI lol. He probably has never played HS on mobile cause any mobile player can verify that yes you can in fact have 10 cards on the screen 😂
He’s mostly saying that the “Discover” look for cards, where they pop up on top of the play board, wouldn’t work on mobile for high amounts of cards. I still think he’s wrong for rating cards very low for this alone, since there are simple workarounds.
0:58 That's my card! Hehe You're analysis is fair but it's literally just intended as pack filler, thanks for noticing me I've been waiting for this episode to come out for a while now! :)
@@dragonfruit7236 i actually disagree with you there. If our care not about power level of your design at least you can run wild with new and interesting things and someone like Trump could balance it out, or someone else, or sometimes it might not even be that bad etc etc etc. When you commit into being bland from the start that's what you get, being bland and boring. No one wants pack fillers they are literally made to milk money out of players, you have this amazing chance to let your creativity go wild away from greedy corporations and what do you do? Imitate the very same bland money milking corporations. If you don't see a problem with that there's something wrong with your world view.
I think it is balanced card because of spirit of frog. And it works well with the buffed 3/6 minion that summon two 1/1 on overload too. This card might make some kind of new deck like nomi sudderlock overload sharman viable.
1. Kind of disagree on Spawn of Rag. The Echo is obviously too good, but it will probably live a turn very rarely and thus will most often be a worse Elven Archer 2. Sea Guard seems kinda weak. You will rarely want the freeze (as there are usually better options for that effect) and otherwise it is just a conditional Saronite Chain Gang with 1 more attack (and this isn't that great). It might just be playable in a defensive mage though
@Trump There is an easy way to salvage cards like ‘Prophet Zul’ that shows your opponents hand: The opponent’s cards appear in your hand maybe even blurred like mage’s shifting scroll. Done ;)
I can't believe you looked at a card where the creator said they made it for fun knowing it was broken and docked it points for them not trying to balance it
@@NightKev I mean Yeah, basically. If his review system is explicitly based around if cards are standard ready, don't review cards that aren't even trying to appeal to your standards, especially when you and the creator both admit that you shouldn't be reviewing the card in the first place
Illuvial Ok? I’d argue it isn’t fun or creative enough to be a meme card. The boards don’t make enough sense and it wouldn’t make sense to have a card do this. Maybe a tavern brawl where you discover I could possibly see, with this card not included, but then the problem is, who chooses the board?
@@rickhaavisto9023 And clearly your idea of fun just differs from the card creator's idea of fun. If someone comes out and says "Hey here is a card that obviously has design issues and wouldn't be balanced but I think its fun and cool" Don't try reviewing it under your standards of "Card has to be standard capable and have genuine chance of being printed to get a good score"
he said if it were already frozen you would get 6-6 worth of power but could you not just target the same frozen minion again? the text needs to say "with only taunt" or am I missing something?
I think Demetrius the Dastardly would have been a great release in Knights of the Frozen Throne when Treachery was still in standard. (Treachery: Give a minion to your opponent)
there's another problem with Maroes, what the hell will happen if both players have Maroes? Who's board would it be? I can grasp that both player's affects can happen at the same time, but the board is the flavor right? It's a bit of a hit on my personally though. I started playing Hearthstone right when One Night At Karazhan came out. I was a foolish ftp who purchased the first wing, and I used every card I could obtain in a ftp mage deck with Fireland's Portal, Pantry Spiders, Arcanosmiths, and of course Moroes. I used to get so hyped up when Barnes summons Moroes and I go "Wow the intended combo the designers intended! Dang I'm a genius!" I'm sad that non-competitive legendaries are forgotten. I can imagine someone having nostalgia towards making horrible decks with their first legendaries in the form of Splitergraft or Flark's Boomzooka
Its very basic one Maroes is played the board changes, the second is played the board changes again. They dont get instantly played when you draw it...
Prophet zul could hidden counter 1 card in their hand for next turn. So if the card was played it would be counterspelled or burned. You can show 10 cards by the same visual as your hand and after you pick one the hand disappears
The Design Problem you had with Prophet Zul didn´t prevent blizzard from making Ghastly Gravedigger - it also says "choose a card in your opponent's hand" even tho it only shows 3 cards of there hand ;)
Apart from the obvious issue of showing all the cards, Prophet Zul could be very interesting as you can pick a card that would otherwise harm your gameplan. You could distrupt/delay their combo by 1 turn.
4:30 its really easy to fix that, the game can let you see his entire hand by simply replacing it with yours until you select your option (by "playing" the card) or they can simply put a side scrolling to the choose one thing... its not that hard.
Something not mention in the Spawn of Rag is that with a 2 mana 1/1 shaman card you can make it 0 mana, for a small mana cheat. Doesnt seem like much, but it gets you 1 more spawn easier. Plus there is a legendary from ungoro that loves of the idea of +35 hp to go with his taunt.
You can fit your own ten card hand on the screen as well as the opponents . You could simply flip the opponents hand to make it visible . Wouldn’t even take up any extra space .
With prophet Zul, you could just have the opponents hand replace your own hand after you play it, and you play your choice from the hand. And yes, they could play their topdecked card but then you made it so they couldn't make their optimal play, with a fairly ok body alongside it.
Trump sometimes complains about some really easy to solve stuff, like with Prophet Zul: just replace your hand with your opponent's hand and pick the card you guessed. I'm not saying he is, but sometimes it feels like he is reaching for some arbitrary reason to dock points from a card and sound smart from pointing it out, like with that "Battlecry: Gamble!" legendary card.
@Kyle Dunnell You could just add a "Swap Between Hands" button onscreen, it could even replace the End Turn button since you would never realistically play this card and immediatly end your turn
You can only pull that off turn 1 if you're going second and also have Ray of Frost in hand. Thats a 4 card combo you have to get on the mulligan to pull off. Too inconsistent to be a real problem. Plus your opponent would also have to play a minion turn 1, which isn't a guarantee either.
4:15 they allready do this when spectating both friends in a casual map, it should not be that hard to make. just make so you can hover over them like normally.
Party Planner Maroes is actually balanced. If you consider the randomness of discovering from a pool of 24 different boards you have a very slim chance of getting what you want and even then considering that you have no knowledge of what deck your opponent is running you could benefit them far more than yourself. It's a very risky card with a high reward up to RNG.
Delay could be crazy strong with right overload synergy because it overloads you again for free. Potential for game breaking aggro or OTK applications.
Now that mini rag is more balanced than priestess of fury by a mile so why the heck not. I mean at least mini rag goes away when you cast arcane explosion or any other one damage board clear. It's really easy to get rid of.
I don't get how the mini-rags would be better elven archers they have 1 health they don't ever shoot twice unless your opponent has literally no hand and no minions, and the turn they're played they're just worse since you can't pick the target. I think the card is op but I don't get why trump acted like its the unstoppable god card of doom, people don't run elven archer in fact no one has ever run elven archer since like GvG (not counting that one tox monger synergy but quest hunter sucked anyways) so it just kinda seems like the normal amount of OP I guess?
To Prophet Zul: The hand of the enemys card will be shown to u like this: Its shown like its ur own hand but they have the same particles like the curse in the enemys hand. So instead of ur own hand you have the enemys hand and like play one card to choose it. After you choose the card you get ur own hand Back
4:10 For the showing of cards, i think maybe it can replace ur hand with the cards in your opponent's hand and when you play the card, it counts as u guessed dat card and u get back ur hand
Counter argument to the idea that you can’t fit 10 cards on a screen in hearthstone. Your hand can have up to ten cards in it and you can see it just fine by using your finger or your cursor to scroll over cards. Not saying Prophet Zul is designed well but I think it’d be possible if you replaced what is usually your hand with your opponents hand and the card you “played” would be your guess to try and counter their card.
The design of Party Planer is off because if you play it on turn 1 your opponent then counters itself with a new board from your opponent. I like the idea but it does too much. Even if you drop the "start of game draw this" and make it "start of game "animate" the board" just feels weird
Honestly if it just changed to "Start of Game: Select a different board to play on" with no other effect, itd be fine as a fun card. Maybe make it a 1/2 so its not completely powercreeped by most other 1 drops.
8:44 Trump you should remember that it may be a good card in wild to discover because it has taunt and can be picked up on stonehill defender wich is gonna be huge in odd pali
1:00 the card is actually insane. Being a 0 mana spell it draws a 1 cost spell for free with spirit of the frog which starts that whole drawing chain. Its like a situationally better innervate in a deck that runs 3-cost "auctioneers". A 0 mana spell with no text would be run in shaman, its just free cycle
Best way to view tiny Rags is as 1 Mana 1/1 Divine Shield, Echo, Rush. They will attack at the end of your turn => rush They won't take damage => Divine Shield They will be cleared immediately => nothing else Make it 2 mana, should be legit for a legendary.
Most of the time they will be cleared before your next turn starts but there are some decks where if your play a couple of these on an empty board (or luck out the rolls clearing the board) you basically win the game. It should be fine at 2 mana but you need to be very careful when designing cards with such high ceiling.
Except targeting is a huge deal. Your card might just get played on 2 mana, this wouldn't, even though this has the advantage of a continuing effect, it still should lose due to the lack of targeting. If it was 2 mana it should be at least 1/2 or something, the exact properties would get figured out by balancing it in game, but no matter how much trump hyped it up, it wouldn't get played as it is on 2 mana by anyone but the most devout memers out there. Despite the small inaccuary I do like your analogy.
"Imagine an Elven Archer with Echo... That would be insane"
"Hey, Loser! Wasn't meeee... Hey, Loser! Wasn't meeee... Hey, Loser!"
i hate that card so much, so annoying
still weaker than echo elven archer
CL You obviously haven’t gotten pen flinger from first day of school as libram paladin. With a full board, you fan potentially get 7 pen flinger attacks in 1 turn with just 1 libram of wisdom and then have it in hand again
@@jerrylin6756 so a card in a fringe deck against a card that is good in almost every deck. Not to mention you don't get 7 1/1 on the board.
It’s not as unbalanced as he says, just a whirlwind clears it all which is why it’s not that great.
Yeah saving the best for last makes Trump's pick much more exciting since he's not just repeating what he said 5 minutes ago
I disagree, I'd rather guess his card of the week from the cards shown this new format just strips that away :/
agr0nianTV a lot of people were complaining about it, which is why Trumo decided to switch to this format to satisfy the majority
Vocal-jority* no one is going to tell him to keep doing what he's doing, cuz that's a no-duh. so any amount saying change it looks like a majority. I liked it as it was... I feel like this will leave things just as "oh wow i wonder how he'll rate this one."
Dana Staples-Weyrauch That’s very true, but the comment suggesting the switch in the last video had over 1k likes, along with the majority of the replies being positive, so I feel like that must have some merit. If it was a bad idea, then most people would have disagreed. I’m honestly surprised an argument didn’t break out there, considering how easily internet arguments start. xd
Often only one or two cards in the review will be a 5/5 thus eliminating any guesswork. This new format is far superior even from an objective point of view.
The Raging Swordfish card is the most simple yet perfect custom card I've seen in a while
Cyclonix good arena card
It was printed in the end
I like how, while Trump was ROASTING that Moroes card, even though the screen was crammed full of stuff, he and Jens made sure to fit in the name of the poor sap who designed it.
It's like he doesn't remember a meta of turn 1 firefly or dire mole.
Well, he did misspell moroes somehow.
I highly believe the "poor sap" is somewhat incapable of thinking whatsoever
@@EricHareSkol 29 card deck with a guaranteed 1 mana minion OMEGALUL
Note how he didn't say a card that is affected by the board shouldn't be in the game
But by having the TGT tag, the doggo wouldn't be playable in Standard witl Zul'jin by default.
Fernando Cabana Porto That’s what I was saying to myself too, this is a completely missed detail that changes the card’s balance.
b
haHAA
Playing wild 4head
And i think rarely he notices the expansion tag when he review a card. It's clearly something he should give attention to.
Idea for showing 10 cards: temporary replacing your hand with the wanted cards and "playing" the chosen card.
and them add a button to see your card while you chose
How about a simple scroll bar :P
They wouldn’t even need to do that, Trump doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Literally start up a game of Hearthstone on mobile and you’ll see that you can in fact have 10 cards shown 😂 Source: Mobile Hearthstone player
still actually bad game design, should never happen
@@agr0nianTV Scroll bars are very clunky and not elegant. You can't see all the cards at once or quickly go back to other cards instantly. I've played card games with scroll bars and it doesn't feel good to use at all.
My biggest problem with the Moroes card was the disgusting misspelling of his name.
Diego A oh dear they made a terrible mess
0:13 5 star in both design and balance makes me happy. I'm glad you liked my card!
Is that alice in AOV?
@@rinakumala7593 idk, just found it and it fit the card flavor
Derio simple, but really nice. Good job
Rina Kumala yeah it’s Alice from AOV lol with the explorer skin
@@Ipejuan2000 I literally have no idea who that is.
How can he possibly not call his card of the week the "Trump card of the week"? What a missed opportunity.
Spawn of Ragnaros is also terrifying with Spirit Echoes.
holy shit
You can even trade him back in to your hand so it's a little op.
0:07 Congrats to Derio_Games. Almost predicted todays new card reveal - Jar Dealer. Same, but deathrattle not battlecry.
Demetrius the Dastardly would be absolutely busted in wild, Renolock vs midrange...
To be fair wild is already pretty wild
@@PuffPound nah it's just a bunch of fucking big priests.
Succ God I mean of course it’s super strong but with the right counter cards it’s a winnable match up
@@PuffPound you're right it's just god do I hate big priest. Ive been scarred for life since Barnes release.
Succ God i feel you the whole game has been scarred since Barnes, Baku and death knights but I guess that’s what standard is for
Bowmaster's assistant is set for grand tournament, and you've said that you'll take into account when the card is supposed to be set and so it would now be rotated out, therefore one of your two design weaknesses is nullified, right?
No, because the author clarified the card was not a beast because of Dire Frenzy, which is not a TGT Card, or anywhere near that. So, you either dock points for the balance of being unbalanced with Zul’Jin, or you dock more design, because designed this card based on a card that wouldn’t be printed for years...which one is it, I believe it is the first...
4:02 you could just make it appear as your hand with a shadow-y effect on it. Works even on mobile.
4:17 That's not that bad if they're forced to play their topdecked card. It's kind of like a worse Loatheb, but cheaper. It'd be useful to avoid certain combos or board wipes and the like.
4:54 Hey! Art from Yu-Gi-Oh for a hearthstone card!
4:15 They could replace your hand with opponent's for battlecry's duration
or add a scroll affect to the original 3 card being shown
Raging swordfish has the design of the Yu-Gi-Oh card named saber shark I remember it for my time playing Yu-Gi-Oh but raging swordfish does have a better affect even though it steals it’s artwork👍
Trump: Bowmaster assistant loses stars because it would have to be printed AFTER Zuljin
Trump: *Fails fo recognize that it has the Grand Tournement stamp on it, thus printed before Zuljin and already out of standard rotation.*
*ChakraX2-Fails to recognize that the author used cards in the same rotation as Zul’Jin to decide against the card being a beast*
2:24
For Prophet Zul you can replace your current hand with your opponents and you pick a card that way and just for a little more flavor they can have the shadow essence smoke aura around them
whats with the raging swordfish text? what does charge mean whats this ancient word i can only understand rush
It's like Rush. But with guns!
its like rush, but better.
2:25
To everyone who is saying that Trump is missing the point of the doggo because the watermark was TGT, listen to what Trump said. He said the author didn’t make the dog a beast because of dire frenzy, you know, a card created years after TGT???
Spawn of Rag is not a repeateble Elven Archer. That completely ignores "random" and "can't attack", which are pretty huge.
Yeah he was a little off base with that card. It is a fun little card, but I don't think it would be nearly as good as he thinks it would be.
Back in the days of BlackRock mountain, flamewaker was OP if you just cast 2 spells and it dealt 4 damage. Spawn of ragnaros costs roughly the same/stats, but doesn’t need you to play spells, and auto-triggers every turn. It is insanely overpowered.
@@wormsblink2887 Flamewalker had 4 hp, spawn of rag has 1. it's insanely easy to get rid of a 1 health minion, especially after turn 4.
@@wormsblink2887 you realize flamewaker was good cuz you could proc it like 6 times in 1 turn and the spell condition is not a downside its a cap to the nuts power, and the minirags only get to shoot one time
hauntedxxshadow You want to know how busted they are? 3 Mini-Rags could cast Arcane Missiles at the end of your turn. You know how much casting an arcane missiles without “losing a card is”? Look at how Blizzard balanced it. They gave Arcane Missiles to a 3 mana 2/1...how is that supposed to be relatively balanced to 3 1/1s that, if you don’t kill them, will cast it again FOR FREE!
That Moroes might just be really good as a Brawl card.
Bowmasters assistant actually came out, after rahstakhan rotated out too. Would you look at that
You CAN show 5 cards on the screen. You must have forgotten already about Elise and Ungoro pack...
Prophet Zul is perfectly possible, You can just scroll along them, if you want to show 10 cards. there would be like 2-3 on screen at once and two buttons on the left and right to move along it, phone users would just swipe to move it along. Also the options for Prophet zul could include another option, something along the lines of "None of these cards", basically saying that they play the top deck, or a card they draw into.
6:51
It's somehow even worse with Odd decks. Imagine an Odd deck getting Grand Tournament.
Make it upgrade and cost 1 then lol
Reddit told me my 4 mana loyal companion was trash - discover and summon an animal companion - RIP top cards of the week for me lol
Honestly, I probably like that better than the real card animal companion...
Thats almost broken, Reddit is stupid
4:25 yea I wonder how would the hearthstone team ever add a ui for 10 cards, that's why I never draw past 5 cards
Seriously, I have no clue what Trump is talking about when he says you can’t fit 10 cards on the UI lol. He probably has never played HS on mobile cause any mobile player can verify that yes you can in fact have 10 cards on the screen 😂
He’s mostly saying that the “Discover” look for cards, where they pop up on top of the play board, wouldn’t work on mobile for high amounts of cards.
I still think he’s wrong for rating cards very low for this alone, since there are simple workarounds.
@@matthewmills2944 yea like showing a simple animation and replacing your hand with the opponents
Bowmaster Assistant is a TGT card(look at the logo behind the text), the author probably intended it to be printed in TGT
Osprey Talon then why did he say he removed the beast rage because if dire frenzy and masters call
Thanks for putting pick of the week at the end.
Demetrius' art made it to the game
Looked at newest comments first to find a comment talking about this
0:58 That's my card! Hehe
You're analysis is fair but it's literally just intended as pack filler, thanks for noticing me I've been waiting for this episode to come out for a while now! :)
We're literally running to custom HS so we don't see pack fillers and yet here you are, making them.
@@MrMrtvozornik Well it's better than making something blatantly overpowered
You could've remove that Overload part and still end up with a pack filler...
@@dragonfruit7236 i actually disagree with you there. If our care not about power level of your design at least you can run wild with new and interesting things and someone like Trump could balance it out, or someone else, or sometimes it might not even be that bad etc etc etc. When you commit into being bland from the start that's what you get, being bland and boring. No one wants pack fillers they are literally made to milk money out of players, you have this amazing chance to let your creativity go wild away from greedy corporations and what do you do? Imitate the very same bland money milking corporations. If you don't see a problem with that there's something wrong with your world view.
I think it is balanced card because of spirit of frog. And it works well with the buffed 3/6 minion that summon two 1/1 on overload too.
This card might make some kind of new deck like nomi sudderlock overload sharman viable.
1. Kind of disagree on Spawn of Rag. The Echo is obviously too good, but it will probably live a turn very rarely and thus will most often be a worse Elven Archer
2. Sea Guard seems kinda weak. You will rarely want the freeze (as there are usually better options for that effect) and otherwise it is just a conditional Saronite Chain Gang with 1 more attack (and this isn't that great). It might just be playable in a defensive mage though
idk man i feel like some of these 1 star balance cards are actually 5 star design... i love that lil Ragnaros
@Trump There is an easy way to salvage cards like ‘Prophet Zul’ that shows your opponents hand: The opponent’s cards appear in your hand maybe even blurred like mage’s shifting scroll. Done ;)
Anyone watching this after Pen Flinger?
Maybe show the entire opponent’s hand by using the same interface as opening a pack, then you can just scroll through the hand.
a pack's 5 cards doooooooood
Agreed a scroll bar/feature would be perfect
I can't believe you looked at a card where the creator said they made it for fun knowing it was broken and docked it points for them not trying to balance it
What do you want him to do instead, not rate it at all?
@@NightKev I mean
Yeah, basically. If his review system is explicitly based around if cards are standard ready, don't review cards that aren't even trying to appeal to your standards, especially when you and the creator both admit that you shouldn't be reviewing the card in the first place
Illuvial Ok? I’d argue it isn’t fun or creative enough to be a meme card. The boards don’t make enough sense and it wouldn’t make sense to have a card do this. Maybe a tavern brawl where you discover I could possibly see, with this card not included, but then the problem is, who chooses the board?
@@rickhaavisto9023 And clearly your idea of fun just differs from the card creator's idea of fun. If someone comes out and says "Hey here is a card that obviously has design issues and wouldn't be balanced but I think its fun and cool"
Don't try reviewing it under your standards of "Card has to be standard capable and have genuine chance of being printed to get a good score"
I LOVE sea guard, can easily see as an in-game card :)
he said if it were already frozen you would get 6-6 worth of power but could you not just target the same frozen minion again? the text needs to say "with only taunt" or am I missing something?
maroes should be a random board. That makes it a meme card and not overpowered. And start it in you hand like a quest.
4:45 I love it when there's yugioh art on the cards... Nostalgia
to show ten cards you could have the 4 cards and then a little next arrow thing on the right side of that line of cards to look at the other ones
Really appreciate Trump giving this subset of videos more love and taking the viewers’ opinions into account. I look forward to every one!
"0:05 lets start with a cutie" "trump shes 12! " *DOOR BREAKS DOWN*
*FBI Open up!*
I think Demetrius the Dastardly would have been a great release in Knights of the Frozen Throne when Treachery was still in standard. (Treachery: Give a minion to your opponent)
It would still work in wild! Some Reno lists run Treachery+Doomsayer.
Trump: "Spawn of Ragnaros OP, 1 star!"
Blizzard: "Hehe 7 Mana Priestess of Fury go pew pew pew"
Looking back from saviours of uldum the swordfish looks extremely close to restless mumy. Coincidence, i dont think so.
Wow, Bowmaster's Assistant is now a shaman card
there's another problem with Maroes, what the hell will happen if both players have Maroes? Who's board would it be? I can grasp that both player's affects can happen at the same time, but the board is the flavor right? It's a bit of a hit on my personally though. I started playing Hearthstone right when One Night At Karazhan came out. I was a foolish ftp who purchased the first wing, and I used every card I could obtain in a ftp mage deck with Fireland's Portal, Pantry Spiders, Arcanosmiths, and of course Moroes. I used to get so hyped up when Barnes summons Moroes and I go "Wow the intended combo the designers intended! Dang I'm a genius!" I'm sad that non-competitive legendaries are forgotten. I can imagine someone having nostalgia towards making horrible decks with their first legendaries in the form of Splitergraft or Flark's Boomzooka
was playing in rank 25 against a druid with a golden copy of floops glorious floop in his deck.
Its very basic one Maroes is played the board changes, the second is played the board changes again. They dont get instantly played when you draw it...
@@asp_asp oh oops
The dog was meant for the grand tournament
2:24
Not according to the author, and I’m gonna take his word over yours.
@@rickhaavisto9023 you can see that the card has the shield from the grand tournament
Mr 121500 and you can hear that the author balanced this against Dire Frenzy, a card not existing in Grand Tournament.
Pick your poison.
bickflick Yup, either way it was a design problem
Mr 121500 There’s a reason I gave you the time stamp, listen to Trump...
Spawn of ragnaros targets random enemy, unlike the archer where you can choose
wow this ragnaros spawn is the idea behind demon hunter {priestess of fury} and that sucks
how is priestess of fury not removed yet
Prophet zul could hidden counter 1 card in their hand for next turn. So if the card was played it would be counterspelled or burned. You can show 10 cards by the same visual as your hand and after you pick one the hand disappears
When you were talking about a balanced version of Prophet Zul, it reminded me of a Rogue secret I made a while ago
The Design Problem you had with Prophet Zul didn´t prevent blizzard from making Ghastly Gravedigger - it also says "choose a card in your opponent's hand" even tho it only shows 3 cards of there hand ;)
I'm surprised Trump didn't touch on mage's critical mass of freeze cards when he talked about his pick of the week
There will always be a critical mass, at least when you see it as a critical mass. Maybe he changed his mind
Apart from the obvious issue of showing all the cards, Prophet Zul could be very interesting as you can pick a card that would otherwise harm your gameplan. You could distrupt/delay their combo by 1 turn.
4:30 its really easy to fix that, the game can let you see his entire hand by simply replacing it with yours until you select your option (by "playing" the card) or they can simply put a side scrolling to the choose one thing... its not that hard.
Enjoyed the final card reveal. Kept things interesting.
Something not mention in the Spawn of Rag is that with a 2 mana 1/1 shaman card you can make it 0 mana, for a small mana cheat. Doesnt seem like much, but it gets you 1 more spawn easier. Plus there is a legendary from ungoro that loves of the idea of +35 hp to go with his taunt.
I think that showing you the enemy's hand should be done by swapping your own hand with his and adding a little swap around button in the corner
You can fit your own ten card hand on the screen as well as the opponents . You could simply flip the opponents hand to make it visible . Wouldn’t even take up any extra space .
How would that work at all on mobile?
With prophet Zul, you could just have the opponents hand replace your own hand after you play it, and you play your choice from the hand. And yes, they could play their topdecked card but then you made it so they couldn't make their optimal play, with a fairly ok body alongside it.
de
If Demetriuses effect ever gets created I'm crafting whatever card that is instantly for shenanigans.
Trump sometimes complains about some really easy to solve stuff, like with Prophet Zul: just replace your hand with your opponent's hand and pick the card you guessed.
I'm not saying he is, but sometimes it feels like he is reaching for some arbitrary reason to dock points from a card and sound smart from pointing it out, like with that "Battlecry: Gamble!" legendary card.
@Kyle Dunnell You could just add a "Swap Between Hands" button onscreen, it could even replace the End Turn button since you would never realistically play this card and immediatly end your turn
Spawn of ragnaros can be used with bloodlust or any other card that can buff multiple minions
But it can't attack.
What about double elemental invocation and frrezze shard on turn one or two?
You can only pull that off turn 1 if you're going second and also have Ray of Frost in hand. Thats a 4 card combo you have to get on the mulligan to pull off. Too inconsistent to be a real problem. Plus your opponent would also have to play a minion turn 1, which isn't a guarantee either.
4:15 they allready do this when spectating both friends in a casual map, it should not be that hard to make.
just make so you can hover over them like normally.
How do you think that would work on mobile?
The tiny portalmancer is Alice from aov lmao
2:08 The day you can have 8 minions on a board is the day I get to legend.
Party Planner Maroes is actually balanced. If you consider the randomness of discovering from a pool of 24 different boards you have a very slim chance of getting what you want and even then considering that you have no knowledge of what deck your opponent is running you could benefit them far more than yourself. It's a very risky card with a high reward up to RNG.
Delay could be crazy strong with right overload synergy because it overloads you again for free. Potential for game breaking aggro or OTK applications.
Adding overload 1 on spawn of ragnaros I feel would help fix the balance issues
How? If you spam your board full of them, how is overload going to help with that?
AWWWWWWWW LOOK AT THE LITTLE PUPPYYY WITH THE ARROW OMG
Now that mini rag is more balanced than priestess of fury by a mile so why the heck not. I mean at least mini rag goes away when you cast arcane explosion or any other one damage board clear. It's really easy to get rid of.
The shaman card would be play in shaman aggro its not that weak since its a 0 mana spell with overload in shaman.
I think delay may work as a card that something gives you 2 or 3 free copies of.
pretty easy to show opponents hand, just code for the hand to flip and you can scroll through the cards like it was your own hand
is nobody gonna point out that the artwork in "raging swordfish" is legit just copied off "Saber Shark" from yugioh?
Im glad i wasnt the only one lol
people dont make their own art
Wow that card at the end would fit right into freeze shaman
Funny how we basically have mini rag in one minion
I don't get how the mini-rags would be better elven archers they have 1 health they don't ever shoot twice unless your opponent has literally no hand and no minions, and the turn they're played they're just worse since you can't pick the target. I think the card is op but I don't get why trump acted like its the unstoppable god card of doom, people don't run elven archer in fact no one has ever run elven archer since like GvG (not counting that one tox monger synergy but quest hunter sucked anyways) so it just kinda seems like the normal amount of OP I guess?
That raging swordfish is awesome.
To Prophet Zul:
The hand of the enemys card will be shown to u like this:
Its shown like its ur own hand but they have the same particles like the curse in the enemys hand. So instead of ur own hand you have the enemys hand and like play one card to choose it. After you choose the card you get ur own hand Back
4:10 For the showing of cards, i think maybe it can replace ur hand with the cards in your opponent's hand and when you play the card, it counts as u guessed dat card and u get back ur hand
This probably isn't gonna be seen, but it should be pointed out Bowmaster's Assistant has the grand tournament insignia behind the text.
Party Planner Moroes would be a fun card if the special effect was removed. And it would be usable because it would enable Transfer Student.
i havent been watching HS channels in a while but dude...whats that endings its actually so good
Counter argument to the idea that you can’t fit 10 cards on a screen in hearthstone. Your hand can have up to ten cards in it and you can see it just fine by using your finger or your cursor to scroll over cards. Not saying Prophet Zul is designed well but I think it’d be possible if you replaced what is usually your hand with your opponents hand and the card you “played” would be your guess to try and counter their card.
In wild you can totally spawn tons of recruits...
And recruit buffadin is now insanely fast.
The design of Party Planer is off because if you play it on turn 1 your opponent then counters itself with a new board from your opponent. I like the idea but it does too much. Even if you drop the "start of game draw this" and make it "start of game "animate" the board" just feels weird
Honestly if it just changed to "Start of Game: Select a different board to play on" with no other effect, itd be fine as a fun card. Maybe make it a 1/2 so its not completely powercreeped by most other 1 drops.
8:44 Trump you should remember that it may be a good card in wild to discover because it has taunt and can be picked up on stonehill defender wich is gonna be huge in odd pali
honestly id love to see party planner where each player picks a board and it randomly chooses which one
Spawn of Rag into "BREAK YOURSELF UPON MY BODY"
@@travelkingable lol
1:00 the card is actually insane. Being a 0 mana spell it draws a 1 cost spell for free with spirit of the frog which starts that whole drawing chain. Its like a situationally better innervate in a deck that runs 3-cost "auctioneers". A 0 mana spell with no text would be run in shaman, its just free cycle
totemic might isn't played, so I doubt this would be either
Delay could be broken in wild with Tunnel Trogg to get him up to like a 8/3 by turn 2 or 3
The Party Planner would be a really fun Tavern Brawl, thats about it.
Best way to view tiny Rags is as 1 Mana 1/1 Divine Shield, Echo, Rush.
They will attack at the end of your turn => rush
They won't take damage => Divine Shield
They will be cleared immediately => nothing else
Make it 2 mana, should be legit for a legendary.
Most of the time they will be cleared before your next turn starts but there are some decks where if your play a couple of these on an empty board (or luck out the rolls clearing the board) you basically win the game.
It should be fine at 2 mana but you need to be very careful when designing cards with such high ceiling.
Except targeting is a huge deal. Your card might just get played on 2 mana, this wouldn't, even though this has the advantage of a continuing effect, it still should lose due to the lack of targeting.
If it was 2 mana it should be at least 1/2 or something, the exact properties would get figured out by balancing it in game, but no matter how much trump hyped it up, it wouldn't get played as it is on 2 mana by anyone but the most devout memers out there.
Despite the small inaccuary I do like your analogy.