The problem with that is... it would be even more confusing for everyone should the card ever be generated randomly. I feel HS need to steal from LoR the fact that if you right click on a card, you can see all the card/thing it can generate/trigger, if there is a finite list anyway.
I feel like the Malevolent Shapeshifter could be a neat mechanic, where there are several different Malevolent Shapeshifter Cards, and they only disguise as another random shapeshifter.
People who make custom cards take art from pretty much anywhere (as long as it is sfw) If anything, some people tend to take art from the same source, so maybe someone who makes a lot of custom cards take a lot of artwork from smite
Mysterious btw, and I think that would be dope. Although my question is what does Mysterious shadow do and how many or what type of cards do you need though?
Honestly malevolent shapeshifter reminded me of the Rogue secret Bamboozle. I don't think it's nearly as unbalanced as Trump feels it is. However I get and probably agree with the design issues it would pose.
So like Magic’s morph- where you don’t know which hidden card it is? That mechanic worked like Secrets where they’re only good if there’s enough other good cards so you don’t instantly know which one was played. Like YuGiOh trap cards. So you’d need to make a handful of these cardsfor the classes that can play them in order to get the surprise affect when you find out which one it was. Maybe make it have effects similar to the “Battlecry: chose secretly”? A cycle of those guys could be fun if Hearthstone visits a sneaky setting.
If its text is true then it would stay hidden. Which makes little sense since it would basically reveal itself if it suddenly kills something with poison. In most cases it probably dies anyway, though.
Probably if it survives the poisonous effect goes off and you might be confused but knowledgeable players would then know it's the MS And if it dies it would probably poof and reveal itself
when trump laboratories invents time travel, invented time travel, has invented time travel... will invent time travel, decks are not bad, it just isn't the right time yet. Prepare for the magtheridon meta
Deathwing Worldbreaker is just TESL in a card, I guess. If Worldbreaker's effect is deemed too dramatic to be sustained by one card, they could make Worldbreaker support cards (similar to C'thun support cards) with Empire mechanics and print Lydia as an anti-Worldbreaker card to fit a certain good vs evil theme.
Perhaps Deathwing can tear the battlefield apart but give a card that restores the battlefield to it's original state. Perhaps a 5 or 6 mana spell or another 10 mana minion (maybe 12/12 as well, or a 5/15 taunt as to be playable against deathwing himself).
Please enlighten me: why is Vision in a Box not useless? It takes up a spot in the hand, which is used for knowing what the next card in the deck is- but you could have just not included Vision in a Box in your deck, and instead have another card in your hand, which you would know the identity of AND be able to play?
You're right, in a way, but its a little more subtle than that. Let's say you have a deck of 29 cards and you don't want to put in any more than that. Vision allows you to put in that 30th card without watering down your deck. For example, let's say you draw visions as your 10th draw from your deck. Now let's say the "perfect answer" card you need is the 12th draw from your deck. The next turn, you'll draw your 11th card, and be bummed that you're about to lose.... until you see your vision show you that your next draw is your perfect answer. If visions were any other card, you wouldn't have that kind of information, and could possibly make a sub-par play because you lacked information.
You're right that it is useless in most decks, for the reasons you gave. The only decks that would run it are combo decks that only care about drawing a few specific cards, the same kinds of decks that run Novice Engineer. They would prefer to cut it and just have a smaller deck, but they include more card draw since they need to have 30 cards in the deck.
Been binging all of these videos and they’re super entertaining and also have helped me to understand all aspects of the game better!! Thank you mr Trump
Malevolent Shapeshifter however could probably pretty much be printed as is in Magic the Gathering. Morph when involved in combat (Alternatively: Morph when blocked or declared as blocker) Deathtouch Interesting just not good for Hearthstone for the reasons trump stated. For everyone who doesn't know morph from MtG: Morph: You can play this card face down as a 2/2 and turn it face up for it's morph cost In this case it would be morph on trigger which shouldn't be a problem when i doubt just still give it morph cost and just have it be irrelevant most of the time. edit2: I think you can morph any time so probably could just be morph 0 and then don't even neccesserely need the trigger.
Is it just me, or is Murloc Witch doctor a card that Trump reviewed early early on into doing Trump reviewing custom cards? I recall this specific effect which is unlikely to be a coincidence due to how unique it is.
Malevolent Shapeshifter should be a Hunter card and should just transform into any 3-cost minion. "Poisonous. Each turn, transform into a random 3-cost minion that transform back when attacked"
Do you think tearing the battlefield apart could be an envisageable mechanic if you limited its active uptime? Like, ''Tear the battlefield apart for 1-2 turns'', or even delay it like ''Tear the battlefield apart in 2-3 turns''
Fun fact! SMITE splash arts are used pretty often by the custom Hearthstone community. (I'm talking about the "Honey Bear" card being a Bacchus skin splash. It's not the first time people use those artworks)
The point on Ill-Fated Morti about people not knowing what old cards do is applicable to current cards too (like things that summon boom bots), but i think its just a part of learning the game
Bashing helm has an issue. Durability is lost after the attack (after damage calculation), which means u actually can’t just hero power and attack for free. The attack will reduced your armour and then lose your weapon.
The cards Vision-in-a-Box revels would have been in hand if the Vision-in-a-Box card was removed from the deck before drawn. This is because drawing Vision-in-a-Box means you're effectively one draw behind on your deck (with reduces information). Without cards like Far Sight and Holy Wrath, Vision-in-a-Box is useless
What if Shapeshifter worked something like MTG morph, or like a Secret, where the opponent could tell that it was a hidden minion but not which one until they interacted with it? Of course, then it would either have to be fixed p/t until revealed, reveal itself upon dealing (or taking?) any damage, or all hidden minions would need to have the same statline. That way, though, you could have different ones which reveal under different conditions.
Vision-in-a-box would be a huge buff to Flame Leviathan, possibly even making the combo worth playing.(7 mana 7/7 when you draw, then deal 2 dmg to all minions.)
Old video but still gonna mention. "Vision-in-a-box" being in shaman should just be a 0 cost overload 3, at that point it fulfills the role of emergency draw 1. The 3 overload would hurt you later, as per an emergency answer.
8:55 Bashing Helm + Upgrade = permanent Stormhammer in warrior for a 2 mana maintanence cost each swing. When looked at this way, this card becomes a lot scarier.
Sounds like a terrible card to me. A specific 2 card combo whose only pay out is a 3/2 weapon that cost 2 mana and your hero power to maintain? It's infinitely shittier than stormhammer, which is 1 card that simply require you to have a dragon in play to maintain.
@@NestedQuantifier Except it doesn't have to cost 2 mana to maintain. It only costs 2 mana if you don't have armor. It isn't unreasonable for enrage warrior to get over 20 armor right now with armorsmith skipper shenanigans and then not lose that armor for several turns. This is especially going to be true when you have an "infinite" 3 attack weapon to keep the opponent off the board.
There is an issue with honey bear and cult master. Playing cult master and then honey bear, it will result in a two card, 8 mana, 8/7 draw 4 cards. which is a bit on the strong side imo.
Wouldn't Anako the Dragon at 6:57 also negate the "secret" part of your secrets, since your opponent always sees what Spell is cast when drawn? I think that's interesting, but Trump didn't mention it.
They see that you draw a secret with cast when drawn. There's no reason for it to reveal. Every other spell in the game is revealed when it's played... other than secrets. It shouldn't be different for casts when drawn.
The thing with libram of kings is that.... the more libram there is, the more powerful all of them becomes. I mean if they just print 5 additional different copies (for 12 total in deck) of libram of hope, you would just make hard core libram+cycle deck to dig for the discounts then spam 3 mana 8/8 divine shield heals. I wonder if people are gonna run libram for the 3-shooter brawl... it's probably not fast enough but would be funny.... As such, every libram printed need to be ever slightly weaker, I feel 9 mana would be the most it can go down to, and that's only because as a legendary and therefore only adds one libram to deck.
First of all , Librum of Kings ? Why not Librum of Lords , so thats at least 3 points off design right there , secondly , Librum effects , bar one , are targeted effects and i believe as the sets go on and we get more librum cards this will become more evident , cool idea though all the same
Ill-fated morti could say "cast a misfortune on this minion" with 4 misfortunes that have the exact same effect as the spells.
Or maybe more balanced, very nice idea!
The problem with that is... it would be even more confusing for everyone should the card ever be generated randomly. I feel HS need to steal from LoR the fact that if you right click on a card, you can see all the card/thing it can generate/trigger, if there is a finite list anyway.
*DIFFERENT THREAD, PLEASE*
@@RealityMasterRogue It was only two messages lol
@@felixap9286 it was more, they were deleted
Looking back at this, Murloc Witchdoctor totally predicted School Teacher
I was looking for this comment glad I wasn't the only one who thought this
Looking back at this, Murloc Witchdoctor totally predicted School Teache
@@blaked.4571 Looking back at this, Murloc Witchdoctor totally predicted School Teache
11:11 Yo that's my card, such a blessing to get 5 stars from the mayor of value town himself
Nice Kevin
No it's my card :)
Nice Kevin
No, I made this :)
So you made that entire train mistery expansion? Props to you man
WE HAVE MUSIC!
Trump Nice
@@fallendeus ok
Pog !!!
10 Weeks without a card review? You've been slacking hard.
@@bobbinsthethird don't blame Jens its Trumps fault
Deathwing would make a cool Tavern Brawl!
Bobby B I’d call it a tired old boring tavern brawl if that was the only thing with it, but sure
@@kasra38s A tavern brawl that changes the core rules? Thatd absolutely be an interesting brawl
6:41 please put a warning before showing mysterious challenger on screen
WHO AM I? NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS! Did I just cause you PTSD? lol
Never seen a keemstar video before and after that clip am definitely not regretting it
You should watch the three newest videos on h3h3
@@pr3nzlb3rg3r No.
@@pr3nzlb3rg3r No views. No money.
@@starluigi767 yes
Little did you know it's a Keemstar video hosting Trump
I feel like the Malevolent Shapeshifter could be a neat mechanic, where there are several different Malevolent Shapeshifter Cards, and they only disguise as another random shapeshifter.
Something akin to morph from MtG?
Deathwing worldbreaker is literally just turn hearthstone in to elder scrolls legends lol.
rip
Rip
rip
I really enjoyed that game when it came out
14:23: Exactly what I was thinking when he said it! Nice one, Jens!
7:09 hey it's Bacchus. Smite artwork has a tendency to become custom hearthstone cards don't they?
To be fair, the smite card art does fit the hearthstone aesthetics pretty well.
Antonykun Indeed they do
People who make custom cards take art from pretty much anywhere (as long as it is sfw)
If anything, some people tend to take art from the same source, so maybe someone who makes a lot of custom cards take a lot of artwork from smite
I lol when I recognize art; usually from Magic.
5:13 Rogue laughing in the corner
The malevolent shapeshifter gave me an idea! A group of cards that when played appears as a "misterious shadow".
Mysterious btw, and I think that would be dope. Although my question is what does Mysterious shadow do and how many or what type of cards do you need though?
That sounds good, just a question of how to flavor that into classes that aren't rogue and how to differentiate it from stealth
Honestly malevolent shapeshifter reminded me of the Rogue secret Bamboozle. I don't think it's nearly as unbalanced as Trump feels it is. However I get and probably agree with the design issues it would pose.
So like Magic’s morph- where you don’t know which hidden card it is? That mechanic worked like Secrets where they’re only good if there’s enough other good cards so you don’t instantly know which one was played. Like YuGiOh trap cards.
So you’d need to make a handful of these cardsfor the classes that can play them in order to get the surprise affect when you find out which one it was.
Maybe make it have effects similar to the “Battlecry: chose secretly”? A cycle of those guys could be fun if Hearthstone visits a sneaky setting.
Malevolent Shapeshifter has a wording issue. It only says 'until attacked'... so what happens if it attacks first?
It dies because it has 2 health
If its text is true then it would stay hidden. Which makes little sense since it would basically reveal itself if it suddenly kills something with poison. In most cases it probably dies anyway, though.
Probably if it survives the poisonous effect goes off and you might be confused but knowledgeable players would then know it's the MS
And if it dies it would probably poof and reveal itself
7:15 Art is from SMITE, it is bacchus’ bear skin
If I remember correctly Trump has shown a couple Custom Hearthstone cards that use SMITE skin artwork
Bruh I have that skin and I didn’t notice lol
@@VergilsApprentice yes, I've seen Cabrakan and Chronos.
Trump: Evocation isn't run.
Wild quest mage: am I a joke to you?
Murloc witch doctor is basically in the game now cool!
naga school teacher?
when trump laboratories invents time travel, invented time travel, has invented time travel... will invent time travel, decks are not bad, it just isn't the right time yet. Prepare for the magtheridon meta
Magtheridon has always been/is always/will always be good
Wastes opportunity, could have called it “Libram of Lords”
Oh there wasnt music. I thought you just wanted to emphasize the sound effects.
Deathwing Worldbreaker is just TESL in a card, I guess.
If Worldbreaker's effect is deemed too dramatic to be sustained by one card, they could make Worldbreaker support cards (similar to C'thun support cards) with Empire mechanics and print Lydia as an anti-Worldbreaker card to fit a certain good vs evil theme.
Perhaps Deathwing can tear the battlefield apart but give a card that restores the battlefield to it's original state. Perhaps a 5 or 6 mana spell or another 10 mana minion (maybe 12/12 as well, or a 5/15 taunt as to be playable against deathwing himself).
GOD i love this series. Please make more, definitely my favorite series on youtube
murloc witchdoctor is school teacher wow
Hey trump, amazing to see custom cards of the week come back! It would be amazing to see it coming weekly, I hope you can make that possible! ^^
this episode was a 10 week summary, so much for weekly
@@bobbinsthethird bro that was 2 years ago
I gotta love his visualizations, makes me see what they can do
“The game activity lying to the player would take it too far.”
Well this aged well
OMG. LOLOL. Trump getting in on the Keem drama action. Love it.
8:40
But Trump! You forgot the best part! A Murloc with a witch's hat is adorable!
Long have we waited and Finally the time has come
We Are Now PREPARED!!!
8:18 bro this is literally the 4 mana naga dude 2 years before its relase this dude knows something we dont
I feel like WorldBreaker works a lot better as a Quest Reward, preferably one that isn't too hard to fullfil
Hope to have custom cards every week now! This format is too good Trump!
Lanes are great idea, mechanically. Even as a mechanic with synergies
Deathwing here is way too insane for HS but it’s a very interesting idea for alternative modes
Busted for sure. Good sleuthing! Fantastic editing as always Jens.
Man your outros are outrageous!
And awesome.
Please enlighten me: why is Vision in a Box not useless? It takes up a spot in the hand, which is used for knowing what the next card in the deck is- but you could have just not included Vision in a Box in your deck, and instead have another card in your hand, which you would know the identity of AND be able to play?
You're right, in a way, but its a little more subtle than that. Let's say you have a deck of 29 cards and you don't want to put in any more than that. Vision allows you to put in that 30th card without watering down your deck. For example, let's say you draw visions as your 10th draw from your deck. Now let's say the "perfect answer" card you need is the 12th draw from your deck. The next turn, you'll draw your 11th card, and be bummed that you're about to lose.... until you see your vision show you that your next draw is your perfect answer. If visions were any other card, you wouldn't have that kind of information, and could possibly make a sub-par play because you lacked information.
You're right that it is useless in most decks, for the reasons you gave. The only decks that would run it are combo decks that only care about drawing a few specific cards, the same kinds of decks that run Novice Engineer. They would prefer to cut it and just have a smaller deck, but they include more card draw since they need to have 30 cards in the deck.
Been binging all of these videos and they’re super entertaining and also have helped me to understand all aspects of the game better!! Thank you mr Trump
Wait, FilTheFalcon predicted "Evocation"?
good job Fil
Nice to see this come back
Aww if this was just one week I might have gotten on it, I wanted to see what his reaction to collassol dreadmaw remade one in hs
Malevolent Shapeshifter however could probably pretty much be printed as is in Magic the Gathering.
Morph when involved in combat (Alternatively: Morph when blocked or declared as blocker)
Deathtouch
Interesting just not good for Hearthstone for the reasons trump stated.
For everyone who doesn't know morph from MtG:
Morph: You can play this card face down as a 2/2 and turn it face up for it's morph cost
In this case it would be morph on trigger which shouldn't be a problem when i doubt just still give it morph cost and just have it be irrelevant most of the time.
edit2: I think you can morph any time so probably could just be morph 0 and then don't even neccesserely need the trigger.
YES, I don't even play Hearthstone anymore but I still follow Trump's custom card series. So glad it's back.
The malevolent shapeshifter is a card of the board game Seasons they copy it the image, if don't know it search it and see all the cards
It's malevolent dice, I think.
Wouldn’t the deathwing just kill themself the moment they were played? Or do you have to pick a lane before you play it
Lol youre right.
Damn we time skipped to the past here
Is it just me, or is Murloc Witch doctor a card that Trump reviewed early early on into doing Trump reviewing custom cards? I recall this specific effect which is unlikely to be a coincidence due to how unique it is.
Love the Bacchus skin art used for Honeybear.
It's Funny that he says "the gaming liying on your behalf is a bad idea" and today we have 'Maestra of the Masquerade'
Honeybear has a strong upside if your board is nearly full such as if you have a bunch of tokens already on board.
that murloc guy literally got printed lol
Is it going to be 10 more weeks before next episode once again?
I always knew Trump was a 1/1 minion.
8:54 *cries in Wild mode*
Why did he Repost?
Music
was a murloc
who smelled of elderberries
you smell
12:41 nice rick&morty reference
its interesting to see the different power levels in games. When trump says something is to op for HS i look and say that's a staple card in mtg.
Nice episode. See you again in 2 months!
I love honeybear
Malevolent Shapeshifter should be a Hunter card and should just transform into any 3-cost minion.
"Poisonous. Each turn, transform into a random 3-cost minion that transform back when attacked"
Do you think tearing the battlefield apart could be an envisageable mechanic if you limited its active uptime? Like, ''Tear the battlefield apart for 1-2 turns'', or even delay it like ''Tear the battlefield apart in 2-3 turns''
2 ”lanes” is just like the Elder Scrolls Card Game! Its fun and new for HS and id like to see that in the game, even as a brawl!
Fun fact!
SMITE splash arts are used pretty often by the custom Hearthstone community. (I'm talking about the "Honey Bear" card being a Bacchus skin splash. It's not the first time people use those artworks)
The artwork really fits Hearthstone
The point on Ill-Fated Morti about people not knowing what old cards do is applicable to current cards too (like things that summon boom bots), but i think its just a part of learning the game
Woo I helped! His other vid was set to private or hidden, so he uploaded it public, so subs could see it not just notifications
Bashing helm has an issue. Durability is lost after the attack (after damage calculation), which means u actually can’t just hero power and attack for free. The attack will reduced your armour and then lose your weapon.
Haha the Abrakadabra by Kripparian got me :)
What is Trump's little trumpet doot? Does anyone have the sound?
It’s the hearthstone play-card-sound for the *spare part* card “rusty horn”
the end credit scene is beautiful
12:46 missed the oppotunity to call this "Libram of Lords"
The cards Vision-in-a-Box revels would have been in hand if the Vision-in-a-Box card was removed from the deck before drawn. This is because drawing Vision-in-a-Box means you're effectively one draw behind on your deck (with reduces information). Without cards like Far Sight and Holy Wrath, Vision-in-a-Box is useless
What if Shapeshifter worked something like MTG morph, or like a Secret, where the opponent could tell that it was a hidden minion but not which one until they interacted with it? Of course, then it would either have to be fixed p/t until revealed, reveal itself upon dealing (or taking?) any damage, or all hidden minions would need to have the same statline. That way, though, you could have different ones which reveal under different conditions.
Amazing editing by Jenz
Please don't skip the bad cards. Garbo gives me life
I like monthly-ish card reviews as well. Do them whenever you feel like it :)
1:56
Oh, so it turns Hearthstone into Elder Scrolls Legends? Neat!
For the americans out there: the span from March 7 to March 21 is 14 days which is considered to be called "HALF A MONTH"
Couldn't Vision in a box also slide into warlock as 1 Mana take 2 damage draw a card?
Vision-in-a-box would be a huge buff to Flame Leviathan, possibly even making the combo worth playing.(7 mana 7/7 when you draw, then deal 2 dmg to all minions.)
Old video but still gonna mention. "Vision-in-a-box" being in shaman should just be a 0 cost overload 3, at that point it fulfills the role of emergency draw 1.
The 3 overload would hurt you later, as per an emergency answer.
8:55 Bashing Helm + Upgrade = permanent Stormhammer in warrior for a 2 mana maintanence cost each swing. When looked at this way, this card becomes a lot scarier.
Sounds like a terrible card to me. A specific 2 card combo whose only pay out is a 3/2 weapon that cost 2 mana and your hero power to maintain? It's infinitely shittier than stormhammer, which is 1 card that simply require you to have a dragon in play to maintain.
@@NestedQuantifier Except it doesn't have to cost 2 mana to maintain. It only costs 2 mana if you don't have armor. It isn't unreasonable for enrage warrior to get over 20 armor right now with armorsmith skipper shenanigans and then not lose that armor for several turns. This is especially going to be true when you have an "infinite" 3 attack weapon to keep the opponent off the board.
Maybe to help with Malevolent Shapeshifting it could have: Start of game: reavel this card to your opponent
Lmao rogues now get the game to actively lie on your behalf
Honey bear would be insane with infuse lol
There is an issue with honey bear and cult master. Playing cult master and then honey bear, it will result in a two card, 8 mana, 8/7 draw 4 cards. which is a bit on the strong side imo.
Wouldn't Anako the Dragon at 6:57 also negate the "secret" part of your secrets, since your opponent always sees what Spell is cast when drawn? I think that's interesting, but Trump didn't mention it.
They see that you draw a secret with cast when drawn. There's no reason for it to reveal. Every other spell in the game is revealed when it's played... other than secrets. It shouldn't be different for casts when drawn.
I really like this videos,they are always super fun to watch
That worldbreaker looks like it'd be an AWESOME CARD
The thing with libram of kings is that.... the more libram there is, the more powerful all of them becomes. I mean if they just print 5 additional different copies (for 12 total in deck) of libram of hope, you would just make hard core libram+cycle deck to dig for the discounts then spam 3 mana 8/8 divine shield heals.
I wonder if people are gonna run libram for the 3-shooter brawl... it's probably not fast enough but would be funny....
As such, every libram printed need to be ever slightly weaker, I feel 9 mana would be the most it can go down to, and that's only because as a legendary and therefore only adds one libram to deck.
"the game lying to a player is going too far", then they released maestra of the masquerade
You have just reminded me that Ragnaros the Lightlord should have exsisted in WoW at some point. WE ALL WANT IT
@0:55 Utgarde Grapplesniper into Malygos + cheap damage spells. Boom EZ Legend.
What happens with anako if u draw a secret that is already played tho
Punchline at the end, oh you joker Trump!
I really like the malevolent shapeshifter.
Scavenging Hyena + Honey Bear combo would be cool.
So if you only control Deathwing it will suicide since you place it in the middle zone ?
How is Libram of *Kings* exactly flavorful to summon a Ragnaros? You have some weird ratings sometimes.
1:12 ah yes bad card always fits in shaman
First of all , Librum of Kings ? Why not Librum of Lords , so thats at least 3 points off design right there , secondly , Librum effects , bar one , are targeted effects and i believe as the sets go on and we get more librum cards this will become more evident , cool idea though all the same