I dont know people if you knew that Joseph Williams is the son of great composer John Williams winner of 5 Iscars 25 Granmys and on million nominatios for all kind of awards. Always loved this song.
I’m 50!! Seventh One is still one of my favorite records! I went through 3 tapes and 2 CDs of this record!! Probably my favorite Jeff Porcaro groove!! I’m a drummer today because of this song!!
He's still incredible, however, he's dodging the chorus completely and some higher tones here and there. Still a great performance considering his age and the amount of touring these guys do
@@xanderguldie He's not singing the first half of the chorus, which is the smart move to do here. He's avoiding straining and tiring out his voice and gets to rest it and prepare for a stronger delivery on the second half. Besides he got an amazing backing vocal band with him there is no need for him to sing in the first half as the backing vocals are covering the really high vocals too. Why expend yourself unnecessarily when you need the voice to be intact for the rest of the gig?
@SAJ Music & Production First of all, it wasn't criticism. As you explained, he's looking out for his voice, which was damaged, and it took a long time for him to recover. I just wanted to point out that although he's still incredible, he can't sing as he used to be. Nor should people expect him to.
@@xanderguldie never criticed your comment I was helping clarify why Wiilliams did not sing in certain parts of the song. And I agree with everything you said was just making an addition comment.
This song didn't make it in the U.S in 1987/88 because at the time Totos popularity was declining , though the songs were good "Isolation" their first album after TOTO IV flopped, and people need to be honest, a record that sold massive and garnered 6 to 8 grammys like TOTO IV and add the departure of Kimballs voice (I know how and why he was fired) It would be difficult to damn near impossible to repeat that success again, especially with a change in personnel. The Eagles were under pressure to duplicate that success following "Hotel California" with the "Long Run" and "Heart ache tonight" their fastest song to get to no.1 and the pressure to repeat still broke the band up in 1980 till 1995 "When hell freezes over" the very words they said about ever regrouping after the break up. Lukather should be grateful to still have an audience.
One of the rare bands that still perform on their original key - and still deliver big time! I'm only 29 years old but I grew up with TOTO songs after playing Vice City and this brings a tear to my eye hearing Joseph and Steve perform like they've never aged! Amazing!
What an AMAZING vocalist he is even as he ages! Few can carry that kind of presence. His tones are perfect, and the backup vocals are off the charts phenomenal!!
@@JureJerebic on some live shows, I guess depending how tired he is as they do it towards the end, he'll either sing a bit lower in the chorus or he'll go all in.
Love that Joe and Steve are keeping live Toto going. Shame that David Paich and Steve Porcaro can’t be with them, but the musicians they have filling out the band are awesome.
With all due respect to Joseph Williams and other vocalists, I enjoyed listening Africa from Bobby Kimball more than anyone else. TOTO is the Master Class...
YES!!! I'm not familiar with Robert, but he had some seriously big shoes to fill, and he totally held his own. Nothing but respect! He deserves a ton of credit for this!
I was introduced to Joe on star search in the days before Fergie Ferguson joined Toto and after the 1st Kimbell exodus. We were fans back then. In later years, I learned why Joe was outside the band and the infamous Past to Present experiment had occurred. The fact that his voice was I tatters from drugs and oversinging, he did what he needed to and got that amazing instrument back. Google 35th anniversary live, Joe was in peak form over the next 5 years. He earned the right to succeed Bobby Kimbell the 2nd time. This is why Joe remains one of my vocal heroes to this day. Bless ya , brother Joe. Thanks to Luke for giving a brother a 2nd chance too.
What a hidden Gem for US Toto fans: one of my favorites. Performed impeccably some 30 years later! Who does this? That voice has not, yet, seen better days. Keep belting out memories!
It is a real shame that this song wasn't released as a single here in America. It would've not only be a hit single, but also would've helped improve the sales of "The Seventh One" album on Billboard 200. This is forever hands-down one of my top favorite songs by Toto of all time! Thank you Toto for this amazing song!
Oh my God! JOSEPH WILLIAMS IS INSANE here! Killing voice ! Amazing band.. great tune, great stuff. I love it!.. I love TOTO. STOP LOVING YOU, A NUMBER ONE RECORD!
I think Toto is more famous in Mexico than the United States. We loved Toto since we were kids, and through the decades their music has been and still is relevant.
Honestly, TOTO should have more recognition than their sudden spike with Africa, all of IV is good, Isolation has some of my most favorite songs of the band, TOTO (album) is really good and has the most of my favorites despite being their first studio album.
This may have been Joe’s first big hit with him on vocals. He fit in perfectly with this band. Saw them at The Gorge circa 1988 and it was the first time I heard a band sound as good live as the studio recording. Crazy talent!
So much groove and talent... Luke, Williams... And the "Porcaro-ish" feeling... Back to a time when record companies were not deaf and ignorant regarding TALENT.
I've been to see Toto a lot here in the UK but when I heard of the new line up I thought..nope ,this could be the end but having watched these new live songs I am very happy to be proved completely wrong. The harmonies sound incredibly full and the addition of the sax is awesome too. The band sounds so full and alive, I can't wait to see them again. Absolutely top notch 👌
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5tppmuRLNkc/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. Joseph Williams, one and only man who can sing this song perfectly on earth.
Tonny was good toooooo
@@grokur9714 Yes, Mr. Tony Spinner and Mr. John James have sung this song very well too but I do love Joseph's singing!
Totally agree
Sir, Warren Ham is right behind him
Joe sings this song perfectly! I love his voice!! ❤️❤️
I dont know people if you knew that Joseph Williams is the son of great composer John Williams winner of 5 Iscars 25 Granmys and on million nominatios for all kind of awards.
Always loved this song.
I’m 50!! Seventh One is still one of my favorite records! I went through 3 tapes and 2 CDs of this record!! Probably my favorite Jeff Porcaro groove!! I’m a drummer today because of this song!!
Joseph Williams is incredible. What a voice! Honestly his vocals have gotten better with age!
He spent three years getting g lessons on how to improve, stengthen and sustain it.
He's still incredible, however, he's dodging the chorus completely and some higher tones here and there. Still a great performance considering his age and the amount of touring these guys do
@@xanderguldie He's not singing the first half of the chorus, which is the smart move to do here. He's avoiding straining and tiring out his voice and gets to rest it and prepare for a stronger delivery on the second half. Besides he got an amazing backing vocal band with him there is no need for him to sing in the first half as the backing vocals are covering the really high vocals too. Why expend yourself unnecessarily when you need the voice to be intact for the rest of the gig?
@SAJ Music & Production First of all, it wasn't criticism. As you explained, he's looking out for his voice, which was damaged, and it took a long time for him to recover. I just wanted to point out that although he's still incredible, he can't sing as he used to be. Nor should people expect him to.
@@xanderguldie never criticed your comment I was helping clarify why Wiilliams did not sing in certain parts of the song. And I agree with everything you said was just making an addition comment.
Joseph Williams! What?! What a voice! Wow. I’m so impressed 👏🏽
And the other great voices, sounds incredible.
Timeless singer jw..👍👍👍👍
@@marisolfraga1317 especially with this setup..... what voices....!!!
This song didn't make it in the U.S in 1987/88 because at the time Totos popularity was declining , though the songs were good "Isolation" their first album after TOTO IV flopped, and people need to be honest, a record that sold massive and garnered 6 to 8 grammys like TOTO IV and add the departure of Kimballs voice (I know how and why he was fired) It would be difficult to damn near impossible to repeat that success again, especially with a change in personnel. The Eagles were under pressure to duplicate that success following "Hotel California" with the "Long Run" and "Heart ache tonight" their fastest song to get to no.1 and the pressure to repeat still broke the band up in 1980 till 1995 "When hell freezes over" the very words they said about ever regrouping after the break up. Lukather should be grateful to still have an audience.
the sax player is a GOAT
One of the rare bands that still perform on their original key - and still deliver big time! I'm only 29 years old but I grew up with TOTO songs after playing Vice City and this brings a tear to my eye hearing Joseph and Steve perform like they've never aged! Amazing!
Omg. I grew up with Vice City, but I don’t remember Toto being there. That’s amazing!
P.S and yes, couldn’t agree more. What a spectacularly good band
@@caprise-music6722 Africa was on Emotion
One of the strongest band
Matth, keep listening to toto..... it gets better and better.
Great duet Steve and josep..en la version original canta Anderson,vocalista de Yes..en los coros..te recomiendo la version original de todas maneras!!
What an AMAZING vocalist he is even as he ages! Few can carry that kind of presence. His tones are perfect, and the backup vocals are off the charts phenomenal!!
Dopo di loro il nulla ❤️
that's absolutely true
Daccordo
My favourite song of Toto. Look, the fight with "Africa" is hard, but "Stop Loving You" have a special place in my heart.
Finally someone who understands! I always get dirty looks when I place this above Africa!
I think this comment changed my mind. I will rank this song first from now on.
Hi, Joe, are you there? Joseph! ;)
Music video!
I'm 16 and Toto are my favourite band!
The fact that he can still sing the chorus in the original key blows my mind.
He doesn't though; most of it is sung by the backing vocalists
@@JureJerebic on some live shows, I guess depending how tired he is as they do it towards the end, he'll either sing a bit lower in the chorus or he'll go all in.
His technique seems pretty awesome. That’s some longevity! Beautiful❤
Exactly ❤️🙏
Love that Joe and Steve are keeping live Toto going. Shame that David Paich and Steve Porcaro can’t be with them, but the musicians they have filling out the band are awesome.
With all due respect to Joseph Williams and other vocalists, I enjoyed listening Africa from Bobby Kimball more than anyone else. TOTO is the Master Class...
4:45 touched me 😥
One of the best TOTO songs ever!
Love you all, best regards to David Paich, his's missing!
This is my favourite Toto song
David Paich pops in later in the Rosanna song. Paich hasn't been well.
@@wendyc7730 oh no. :(
@@betweentwohorizons Brand new interview with Lukather explains some of it
ruclips.net/video/YOXJcQ6kfdQ/видео.html
There's a few missing
TOTO, Steve lukather, Joseph Williams, 👏🏼👏🏼
Joseph Williams’ voice is like a great red wine, it gets better year after year! Still killing it!
Steve you're still No 1 in Europe! We love your Music. Joseph is just incredible!
A great song from toto. Joseph williams is fantastic. What a fantastic voice. Toto is one of the biggest bands for ever
Eddie Van Halen said: TOTO is the best Band of the World
Muy cierto....
Joe and Sput and all the other guy are on fire. Top notch performance.
This is the TOTO drum feeling that I have missed for so long. Thanks! Jeff would be happy, Robert!
YES!!! I'm not familiar with Robert, but he had some seriously big shoes to fill, and he totally held his own. Nothing but respect! He deserves a ton of credit for this!
The new members are killing it!
@@DavidDarrow Robert is quit a musician. Check Snarky Puppy.
@@cloremaemabida2018 They'er absolutely great!
Beautiful, I sing this song to my German Shepherd Puppy Mila every day, she loves it ♥️
Cool 👍 My cat is sitting here with me, listening
Absolutely awesome….not many groups can pull this off "LIVE" ….. EACH member of the group is specifically talented in ways that fits that "Toto Sound"
The reason why I am a musician today.. toto 🙌🏼♥️
me and three bandmates too
add me to the list brother! Heard them for the first when I played Vice City and Africa blew me away. I then pursued music.
FELICITACIONES..... A MIS 52 AÑOS ME ESPERA UNA GUITARRA QUE DEJO MI HIJA AL PARTIR DE CASA Y QUIZAS ES TIEMPO DE APRENDER ALGO NUEVO.....!!!!!!
Amazing like the original first recording on 80's.
This is Superband... never die... everlasting Toto...
*Yes*
The band Toto in my heart. Steve's guitar is the sound of heaven.
- A male fan of Toto for 53 years living in Korea. -
I was introduced to Joe on star search in the days before Fergie Ferguson joined Toto and after the 1st Kimbell exodus. We were fans back then. In later years, I learned why Joe was outside the band and the infamous Past to Present experiment had occurred. The fact that his voice was I tatters from drugs and oversinging, he did what he needed to and got that amazing instrument back. Google 35th anniversary live, Joe was in peak form over the next 5 years. He earned the right to succeed Bobby Kimbell the 2nd time. This is why Joe remains one of my vocal heroes to this day. Bless ya , brother Joe. Thanks to Luke for giving a brother a 2nd chance too.
I'm glad Joe is back in Toto and better than ever.
What a hidden Gem for US Toto fans: one of my favorites. Performed impeccably some 30 years later! Who does this? That voice has not, yet, seen better days. Keep belting out memories!
Yes, I won't stop loving this band.
Hello how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
The greatest band of all time.
he is so happy playing with these guys their music. 2:34 actually all are smiling, Steve is just concentrated
It is a real shame that this song wasn't released as a single here in America. It would've not only be a hit single, but also would've helped improve the sales of "The Seventh One" album on Billboard 200. This is forever hands-down one of my top favorite songs by Toto of all time! Thank you Toto for this amazing song!
やっぱり、TOTOが好きだな！💜
Williams y Lukather, que duplaaa!
"Time passes quickly and chances are few" has influenced my decisions ever since this song was first released. This is a fabulous live version !
Oh my God! JOSEPH WILLIAMS IS INSANE here! Killing voice ! Amazing band.. great tune, great stuff. I love it!.. I love TOTO. STOP LOVING YOU, A NUMBER ONE RECORD!
The most incredible band of the history !
It's really weird with a TOTO without any Porcaro, but boy do they still sound great!
Jeff, Mike, and Steve P. So much talent in one family - and never forgetting their drummer dad! ❤️
Best, most unique sound from any drummer whoever sat behind the stretched skins…
All i wanna do is love this band forever
With this song I knew You My Dear JOSEPH Williams and I loved😍!! I'm your biggest FAN.Kisses from Lima,Perú 🇵🇪
TOTO IS FOREVER ❤️🤩
Joseph Williams🙌🙌🙌What a VOICE!!! beyond amazing!!!!
Joe's voice has really held up well. Love his singing! 🎶🎵
Amazing that song wasn't number 1 in USA. Is beautiful song.
Luke.... the greatest guitarist ever, from the daughter of one, and the mother of one.....
Hello how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
My absolute favorite Toto song (which is saying something) and Joe's voice is gorgeous as ever!
Mine too - I adore this song, listening it over and over 😍
still waiting for Straight for the Heart!
Yes, me too! It's one of my favourites 💗
Me too!!
Amazing. Toto reborn. Great work Luke, Joe and Warren.
one of the best band of the century . never gets old .❤️❤️❤️
Brought tears to my eyes it was so good
I use to wonder why some of these great early Joseph songs didn’t get airplay.
This is a Toto classic, and JW sounds like his younger self.
Joseph Williams still sounds the same. It's a good thing he still maintains his voice. Amazing
Hello how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
Timeless, roll on the European Tour!
I think Toto is more famous in Mexico than the United States. We loved Toto since we were kids, and through the decades their music has been and still is relevant.
awsome those guys and excited to see them next month in Tüsslin (Germany) hope the wheather likes us
This one of my fave versions aside from their 35th at Poland. And probably the best version!!!
These guys are really fantastic musicians. Fantastic, real musicians.
They can play any type of music...
0:07 Steve is not so sure about the front mans introduction here! ;-) great band, and one of the greatest songs ever written in my view.
How was this song not released in the USA? Toto was an absolutely AWESOME band. Amazing!!!
It's a cool ending with Warren Ham's saxophone performance!!
I like Toto, and not enough is said about them. Totally unique in their style and tempo 👌 😍 x
Still as good as when I was wearing out the Hydra 8 track tape some 40 years ago. Thanks for all you do guys.
Toto always delivers more than you expect...awesome!
Underrated song and one of my fav by you guys... my growing years and memories would not be same without Toto... thank you.
Saw all these same guys save the drummer in Lincoln, Ne. They brought the house down! It was like being back in my 80's youth. Knew EVERY song!
Joseph’s back and better than ever! Now let’s talk about sput on the drums 🔥🔥🔥
Sput's approach is phantastic! Love his groove and feel. He doesn't copy, he is himself, authentic and enjoys it. Great fit! ❤🔥👍🙏
Sput is brilliant. Great find by Toto. He plays awesome. Can't wait to see him in concert
He is amazing
Simon is the one and only Percussion God in a Toto Universe ! All others are just a weak Copy
@@AudiV8RS Agee to disagree 🙂
40 plus years, and you guys are still the best!
Perfect voice absolutely Good
I despair when I hear most of today's tuneless, soul-less, melody-less pop-crap....then I hear Toto and I have hope again. Simply the best
I freaking love all of these old Toto songs….and I’m 21 haha. It’s just soooo much better than all this pop stuff that’s out now.
Nostalgia isn't what it used to be.
Honestly, TOTO should have more recognition than their sudden spike with Africa, all of IV is good, Isolation has some of my most favorite songs of the band, TOTO (album) is really good and has the most of my favorites despite being their first studio album.
Musician communication at its finest! When each musician looks at each other, giving each other ques or waiting for the ques.
again..sensible..Joe pulls out of the chorus lines.... he realises his range........ bravo sir........ awesome
LOVE THIS SONG such great memories from 70's & 80"s..
The guy can sing!! Totally impressed after all these years.
Hello how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
Share, this GOAT band. Toto, I can`t stop loving you.
I can't stop lovin' this.......just beyond.......
Wow, Joseph still sounds great!
ONE OF MY FAVOURITE SONGS! STILL SOUNDS SO AMAZING!💚
The basist looks so kind... Just smiling all the time 😊
This may have been Joe’s first big hit with him on vocals. He fit in perfectly with this band. Saw them at The Gorge circa 1988 and it was the first time I heard a band sound as good live as the studio recording. Crazy talent!
So much groove and talent... Luke, Williams... And the "Porcaro-ish" feeling... Back to a time when record companies were not deaf and ignorant regarding TALENT.
Use to be *talent,* *musicianship* and *songwriting skills* were essential requirements..
Now? 😂
"hey, where do you want these wardrobe changes"
@@rg2027x Wardrobe changes were common practice even in the '70s, which doesn't mean that every musician had them, just like today.
Toto forever!!!
How did this band recapture the magic of the original performance?? This is lights out amazing!!!
One of my favorite TOTO songs! I never knew how Steve felt about it. Joe is still great but boy do I miss Jeff.
Awesome drummer
That was magical. Brings me back to better days.
I seem to remember this playing on Canadian radio. Great song.
A record industry crime not releasing this as a single in 1988 (in the US). Perfect blend of pop sensibility and musicianship!
I've been to see Toto a lot here in the UK but when I heard of the new line up I thought..nope ,this could be the end but having watched these new live songs I am very happy to be proved completely wrong. The harmonies sound incredibly full and the addition of the sax is awesome too. The band sounds so full and alive, I can't wait to see them again. Absolutely top notch 👌
We are blessed that we have them😙
Absolutely....yes
Very grateful 🙏🏼
Wow. Live performance with studio version quality.
Now if they can do a tour playing all of Fahrenheit and Seventh One back to back we'd have the ultimate tour of a lifetime!! 🙏
Yes sir!!!
A hit everywhere except over here in the US? That doesn't surprise me .
What's the reason for this?
Love this song. Always gives me tingles. Joseph's vocals always get to me.
Awesome! And the amazing Warren Ham on sax and vocals! Love him
Hello how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
Wishing you all a long and healthy life so I may keep enjoy your music 🎶
I love Toto!!! 💜💙🤍
Mr. Lukather remains a superb talent! Hope you will always continue to share your amazing talent with the world! Thank you!
Another timeless masterpiece
WOW!!!!!