Listen people, she's a mother of two teenage kids, i'm sure the last thing she wants is to go viral again for a bad performance, cause that won't simply impact her anymore. It irritates my soul that Mariah's shows are always ignored if nothing bad happens. Think about the infamous christmas performance, she had amazing shows that followed, and showcased amazing vocals, but no one cares. Mariah probably knows at this point that everyone is waiting to see her fail, i remember seeing the comments on a video of her performance with Ariana and Jhud, the most liked comments were telling her to retire and that she sounds awful. Why would you want to bother singing live when people will constantly compare you to your 20 year old self and say you should stop doing what you love because you aren't the same? We know she can sing, she is using new prerecorded vocals, and she has posted little live rehearsal snippets for us. But her voice is unreliable, it always has been, but now she is pretty much gauranteed cracks and a nasal sounding tone when she sings for extended periods, and when everyone is watching you only to see your downfall, why would she give them the satisfaction? I don't think Mariah will ever get to the point where she's comfortable enough to give a completely live performance again. As a lamb, i'm completely fine with that, if she wants to be a 100% studio artist now, there's nothing wrong with it. She has given us a lot for the past 3 decades, and still has a lot more to give in the studio, i'm just happy she's still in the music scene. What i want from her now is to experiment vocally, try new genres and explore the lower register of her voice more. True lambs will continue to support all her endeavours!
I think if anything she'll do a song fully live but besides that I doubt we're getting 80% live shows also she's probably trying to preserve her voice so she can keep recording songs in the studio because she has been working on mc16 and the butterfly lounge and maybe some jazz songs
Very well said and I agree wholeheartedly with you. I am going to comment, mainly to others, because my Aries energy is burning fiercely right now. To all those that say Mariah needs to do this or that, she doesn't owe any of us anything. So, we get can get over ourselves and appreciate that we still have a wonderful legend still among us. Please allow me to provide some context. I saw Mariah perform her Xmas show at MSG, night 1. I paid a bit of money for the airfare, hotel, taxis, and that show. Vocally it was not a good show. Though she plowed through the performance, her phrasing was tense, broken up, and you can hear the pain in her throat. She still kept the ambiance of the holiday season very festive. So, I appreciated the show but I was very let down. It was WAY different from the night 2 prerecorded special that aired on CBS. Then, I got out of my head. How fortunate was I to have the opportunity to attend the show, to have musical greatness present before me, and to be at MSG at Christmas, a magical place at a magical time of year. I regrounded myself and thought that she had an off night. It's okay. Fast forward to last night, 4/13/24. I'm actually here in Vegas right now, for the weekend, celebrating my birthday. It was yesterday and I attended that performance. I absolutely enjoyed myself. There are some live parts and there are some prerecorded vocals. I'm happy that there are a lot more modern prerecorded vocals from the ones she used in years past. You could hear the crowd singing along to her songs and there was a great amount of applause after each performance. Vegas is very good for her. She is comfortable in her element here. I am happy to never see her be frightened again on awards shows or at festivals. She doesn't need to do those, it's okay. The colors used throughout the show were gorgeous. It definitely gave classic, old Hollywood vibes. I felt like I attended a very classy event. We had a great mix of songs, some of which were rare or obscure. I was also surprised that the show did not end on Hero or We Belong Together, as many have in the past. Throughout the show we are taken on a guided journey, narrated by Mariah. All in all, it was a great show! I fell asleep with a huge smile on my face and it was a great birthday (a cause for celebration). Sure, like many of you, I'd love a D5 in this part and a whistle there but it's not up to us to decide that. Whether sung live or prerecorded the vocals were strong, connected, and, most importantly, sounded very healthy. I'm very excited for this chapter in Mariah's life. The last few years were tough for her but she seems like she is in a good head space.
We all love her. But it’s disingenuous to have people pay hundreds of dollars to see you stand and mouth words to a song. She has all available resources to improve on her vocal condition, and if she chooses not to use them, that’s within her right but you can’t stop people from complaining.
Out of the entire show, she’s actually singing for a grand total of 52 seconds. And given her history of cutting and pitching up studio vocals (not to mention AI nowadays) we can’t even be sure that the new prerecords are genuine 😬
I don’t know about y’all, but her voice is in a really good place, just like it was during Christmas concerts last year. It makes me so sad to see 99% (literally) of the concert being lip-synched. I completely understand lip syncing hard parts of the songs, but all of it? 🥺 In the tiny moments that we’ve got to hear her voice live (the end of “I’ll be there”, or the pause in “Vision of love”), she sounded absolutely gorgeous and the notes sounded very reach and easy for her to produce. That’s the magic of live concerts, which, at the moment, is taken away from us. I’d rather hear her not making any big tricks with her voice, than not hearing her live at all. 😞
@@vladmihai66 it's just so mind boggling to me. Her voice seems to be in a very healthy place right now. It's very resonant and solid despite her not even pushing very much at all. If she was actually trying I could see her doing some pretty powerful and full belts reminiscent of 2016 or 2010. It's just such a waste to barely even use it at all and resort to lipping everything even the easy parts on songs that never even lipped before. What's even crazier is she sang more live at lovers and friends when her voice was in terrible condition.
I just miss watching her improve night after night and doing different notes and stuff and being creative😭imagine her singing circles and your girl I remember that video she uploaded of her singing snippets TEOM songs and it was actually amazing. The heavy playback makes watching the concert so boring and predictable
They are live… singing in her whisper tone is one of her strengths and great tools in her current voice. Saying those songs are lipped is beyond ridiculous. It’s belting where she might struggle not in these songs you mentioned.
@andrewgarfield9898 I have seen you commenting on Mariah posts since I fell in love with Mariah back in 2017 and you like myself seem to be some of the few that are actually prepared to call out the delusional fans that will lie through their teeth saying Mariah sings live lmaooo. This show is great and i'm happy she is back out there but she is singing about 3% of the show - one line in VOL / I'll be there and that's about it rlly
@@joshbarnes8562 it just really gets on my nerves constantly being told I'm not a reel fan just because I'm being rational and realistic. She will always be a legend and I'll always love her......but I'm also not delusional
@@andrewgarfield9898 because who gives a fuck.... if people think something's live, just let them be. i used to be like you in like 2017, but it's just so obnoxious raining on people's parade, especially on videos that end up going viral! i hate seeing lambs expose mariah for lipsyncing on viral clips that regular ass people are impressed by! it's fine to discuss if you're genuinely unsure, but just wagging your finger in people's faces is ridiculous
@maybe i could be wrong but i promise you she doesnt care about live performances at all. she only does it for the fans. she probably wouldnt do any. she's always said that she feels ans does her best at the studio, and thats where she feels the most comfortable at
@Thank you! Fans are always saying she’s preserving her voice because she’s recording for her next album or saving it for a session. They’ve been using this excuse for like 6 years. If she’s preserving her voice then why is she scheduling live performances??
i think at this point she doesn't need to sing live, we know who she is and that's it. i also think everybody who highlights her lip syncing needs to calm down and realize that ppl don't go to a mariah carey concerts just to hear her sing live (which she still does btw in segments of the concert) but because she is mariah carey, she's got the hits and she's a living legend. if anything i think that pre recorded tracks and lip sync just make her voice more precious cause she doesn't use it live as much as she used to but now whenever she does it's always so exciting and just beautiful to witness cause it is obvious that she still got it, a singer like THAT doesn't randomly lose the ability to sing even despite nodules and everything, just like regular people don't forget how to ride a bike after they learn, the comment might be kinda long but the concept is really simple tbh, i guess people are just dumb, jelous and frustrated
Erm yeah she does need to sing live it’s what you go to a concert for! I can’t believe people just accept it now. She’s trying to convince us she’s lipsymching and it’s not working. Also, she just stands there now and hardly moves, even her hands she looks scared to move and looks awkward - she’s lost all sense of being a performer. Also yes people do lose their voices over time. It can’t be used as an analogy for riding a bike it’s not the same. More like a carpenter constantly using their hands they will eventually get worn out - some quicker than others
@@scottmurphy6159 bro it's not that people accept lip syncing, I'll accept it for Mariah as an exception cause she's a legend and there are exceptions anyways. plus Mariah has never been a dancer what do you expect her to do? you guys are acting delirious 😂 more than half of her songs are ballads/chill songs do you expect her to dance like Beyoncé during babydoll, without you and we belong together? that's a you problem, plus if you just can't stand Mariah now just simply don't go to her concert, it's that simple
Somehow i know that she can do all basic note she lipped rn just look how comfortable she is with the ending of i'll be there that Bb4,C5 is so easy for her if were being honest rn, but i guess she is Perfectionist up to the point she has to do this kind of stuff......
She pre-recorded tracks for every song, that's why it sounds live
7 месяцев назад+11
True. The pre-recorded tracks really sync well with whatever live parts she add. However, her face and demeanor just aren't convincing, and she doesn't look like she's even trying to make it realistic. She keeps staring at the monitor for the lyrics or the lipsync timing.
And they used to be like 15 minutes long, no joking, previous videos of TDOMC/mariahxlambily Not even talking about her prime performances, where literally an entire concert is one huge vocal highlight But it is what it is
That kinda makes me sad. I get she's trying to preserve her voice and give us a consistent show, but, couldn't she have done at least one song partially live? Like Hero at the very least.
It’s sad that she lips syncs but oh well. I’m just happy every song sounds like she prerecorded it she working hard in that studio. All these new high notes are amazing all she is not doing it live.
@@scottmurphy6159 because she has a lovely tone, very suited to jazz. Whenever she did a jazz cover at her shows it was always live, and she smashed it cause jazz seems to be much easier on her voice.
I just don't understand why Mariah teases us w those acapella moments and then turns around and does this... It really makes no sense bc even in her harshest of voice she still got up on stage and gave everything she had *LIVE* I really miss the confidence she had in the 2015/16 #1 to infinity and 2020 Butterfly returns eras. I tried to wait it out but as a fan this is just disappointing, it goes against everything Mariah stands for as a premier vocalist... Hopefully she gets out of her head more as the residency continues smh
She has always stood for this, you were just in denial...This is not new. Her voice always had zero stamina and not a touring voice at all. She knew this even in her prime. As the year got on, the war and tear just made it even more and more impossible for her to sing live.She is not a live singer, never was.
@@odumosuolusegun2781 Being a live singer isn’t a natural thing. It just comes from practice. She just didn’t wanna tour like others. Her only real proper tours are Daydream and Charm, and those were great.
90% of this show was lipped (if not more). stop justifying her and start criticizing he or else she'll never give us a performance worth watching again
It is not hatred or a harsh opinion but always love that motivates people and keeps them going. It is obvious that something is going on in Mariah, and we all know that she can sing if she is in a good and safe condition. She has proven it over and over. If you are a lamb, the only thing you can do is trust, observe and support her, and if you are not, you do not have to follow her and you can just leave her alone.
If you don’t think she’s worth watching, don’t watch her and that’s all. Many of us appreciate her as the last standing member of the vocal trinity, and if she wants to keep her voice safe for other projects, we won’t criticize her for it. You all criticize the legends and then start appreciating when they’re gone.
![Kumamoto Masters Japan 2024 | Gregoria Mariska Tunjung (INA) [5] vs. Akane Yamaguchi (JPN) [2] | F](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EIjZybhsWqA/mqdefault.jpg)
youtube.com/@TheMrKingAlex?si=AMhaXtgcbnEYFBU- footage from Mralex. He came thu
Listen people, she's a mother of two teenage kids, i'm sure the last thing she wants is to go viral again for a bad performance, cause that won't simply impact her anymore.
It irritates my soul that Mariah's shows are always ignored if nothing bad happens.
Think about the infamous christmas performance, she had amazing shows that followed, and showcased amazing vocals, but no one cares.
Mariah probably knows at this point that everyone is waiting to see her fail, i remember seeing the comments on a video of her performance with Ariana and Jhud, the most liked comments were telling her to retire and that she sounds awful. Why would you want to bother singing live when people will constantly compare you to your 20 year old self and say you should stop doing what you love because you aren't the same?
We know she can sing, she is using new prerecorded vocals, and she has posted little live rehearsal snippets for us. But her voice is unreliable, it always has been, but now she is pretty much gauranteed cracks and a nasal sounding tone when she sings for extended periods, and when everyone is watching you only to see your downfall, why would she give them the satisfaction?
I don't think Mariah will ever get to the point where she's comfortable enough to give a completely live performance again. As a lamb, i'm completely fine with that, if she wants to be a 100% studio artist now, there's nothing wrong with it. She has given us a lot for the past 3 decades, and still has a lot more to give in the studio, i'm just happy she's still in the music scene. What i want from her now is to experiment vocally, try new genres and explore the lower register of her voice more. True lambs will continue to support all her endeavours!
I think if anything she'll do a song fully live but besides that I doubt we're getting 80% live shows also she's probably trying to preserve her voice so she can keep recording songs in the studio because she has been working on mc16 and the butterfly lounge and maybe some jazz songs
Very well said and I agree wholeheartedly with you.
I am going to comment, mainly to others, because my Aries energy is burning fiercely right now.
To all those that say Mariah needs to do this or that, she doesn't owe any of us anything. So, we get can get over ourselves and appreciate that we still have a wonderful legend still among us. Please allow me to provide some context.
I saw Mariah perform her Xmas show at MSG, night 1. I paid a bit of money for the airfare, hotel, taxis, and that show. Vocally it was not a good show. Though she plowed through the performance, her phrasing was tense, broken up, and you can hear the pain in her throat. She still kept the ambiance of the holiday season very festive. So, I appreciated the show but I was very let down. It was WAY different from the night 2 prerecorded special that aired on CBS. Then, I got out of my head. How fortunate was I to have the opportunity to attend the show, to have musical greatness present before me, and to be at MSG at Christmas, a magical place at a magical time of year. I regrounded myself and thought that she had an off night. It's okay.
Fast forward to last night, 4/13/24. I'm actually here in Vegas right now, for the weekend, celebrating my birthday. It was yesterday and I attended that performance. I absolutely enjoyed myself. There are some live parts and there are some prerecorded vocals. I'm happy that there are a lot more modern prerecorded vocals from the ones she used in years past. You could hear the crowd singing along to her songs and there was a great amount of applause after each performance. Vegas is very good for her. She is comfortable in her element here. I am happy to never see her be frightened again on awards shows or at festivals. She doesn't need to do those, it's okay. The colors used throughout the show were gorgeous. It definitely gave classic, old Hollywood vibes. I felt like I attended a very classy event. We had a great mix of songs, some of which were rare or obscure. I was also surprised that the show did not end on Hero or We Belong Together, as many have in the past. Throughout the show we are taken on a guided journey, narrated by Mariah. All in all, it was a great show! I fell asleep with a huge smile on my face and it was a great birthday (a cause for celebration).
Sure, like many of you, I'd love a D5 in this part and a whistle there but it's not up to us to decide that. Whether sung live or prerecorded the vocals were strong, connected, and, most importantly, sounded very healthy. I'm very excited for this chapter in Mariah's life. The last few years were tough for her but she seems like she is in a good head space.
you ate that
THIS
We all love her. But it’s disingenuous to have people pay hundreds of dollars to see you stand and mouth words to a song. She has all available resources to improve on her vocal condition, and if she chooses not to use them, that’s within her right but you can’t stop people from complaining.
Someone show the lady at 1:20 their tickets..
😭😭😭😭
I WAS WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO SAY THAT THE VOL WHISTLE WAS DIFF 😢😢😢
Yup it is diff it is live and I don't care if she lipped or what as long as she use new vocals I do understand singing live can be messed sometimes
Yea it’s shorter me thinks
It is different!!!
Someone should do a video comparing the nights.. Somehow I miss mariahxlambily videos, no lamb channel equals the quality of his videos yet
Wow a honest vocal showcase 🎉👏♥️
Slaythelivevocalsriah lives up to her name indeed ❤❤❤
I love this new version of looking in
0:47 this didn’t sound out of key/tune to me at all
It was for like a second
Dang it sound literally sloppy and like --____~~~
The ill be there bb4 sounds like it came right out of 2016
That's bc it prob did
Out of the entire show, she’s actually singing for a grand total of 52 seconds. And given her history of cutting and pitching up studio vocals (not to mention AI nowadays) we can’t even be sure that the new prerecords are genuine 😬
Amazing Mariah
include also the first night "don't you know gonna be that way" of I'll be there. thank youuu
I don’t know about y’all, but her voice is in a really good place, just like it was during Christmas concerts last year.
It makes me so sad to see 99% (literally) of the concert being lip-synched.
I completely understand lip syncing hard parts of the songs, but all of it? 🥺 In the tiny moments that we’ve got to hear her voice live (the end of “I’ll be there”, or the pause in “Vision of love”), she sounded absolutely gorgeous and the notes sounded very reach and easy for her to produce. That’s the magic of live concerts, which, at the moment, is taken away from us.
I’d rather hear her not making any big tricks with her voice, than not hearing her live at all. 😞
it’s not 99% lipped, stop preaching what you don’t know.
@@pianotips2623 It is, darling… I’m sorry.
@@vladmihai66 it's just so mind boggling to me. Her voice seems to be in a very healthy place right now. It's very resonant and solid despite her not even pushing very much at all. If she was actually trying I could see her doing some pretty powerful and full belts reminiscent of 2016 or 2010. It's just such a waste to barely even use it at all and resort to lipping everything even the easy parts on songs that never even lipped before. What's even crazier is she sang more live at lovers and friends when her voice was in terrible condition.
I just miss watching her improve night after night and doing different notes and stuff and being creative😭imagine her singing circles and your girl I remember that video she uploaded of her singing snippets TEOM songs and it was actually amazing. The heavy playback makes watching the concert so boring and predictable
@@andrewgarfield9898 exactly…
She seems so on day 2 like something bad happened before she went on stage
I know you can slay the upper register better than that! Stop it! You have to keep going. Show them what musicians are.
Love this
0:25 ooh I forgot about the F5 version! am I delulu to think she might attempt it again as an Eb5💀
She could sing up to C#5 like she always did if she wanted
Okay vol climax change
There’s no logical reason, for me, why songs like Looking In, Babydoll, or even Emotions can’t be sung live. She sounds fine on I’ll Be There.
They are live… singing in her whisper tone is one of her strengths and great tools in her current voice. Saying those songs are lipped is beyond ridiculous. It’s belting where she might struggle not in these songs you mentioned.
@@bigbof6527 delusional much? I'm sure you think she's also hitting the F5 live on ABMB as well?
@andrewgarfield9898 I have seen you commenting on Mariah posts since I fell in love with Mariah back in 2017 and you like myself seem to be some of the few that are actually prepared to call out the delusional fans that will lie through their teeth saying Mariah sings live lmaooo. This show is great and i'm happy she is back out there but she is singing about 3% of the show - one line in VOL / I'll be there and that's about it rlly
@@joshbarnes8562 it just really gets on my nerves constantly being told I'm not a reel fan just because I'm being rational and realistic. She will always be a legend and I'll always love her......but I'm also not delusional
@@andrewgarfield9898 because who gives a fuck.... if people think something's live, just let them be. i used to be like you in like 2017, but it's just so obnoxious raining on people's parade, especially on videos that end up going viral! i hate seeing lambs expose mariah for lipsyncing on viral clips that regular ass people are impressed by! it's fine to discuss if you're genuinely unsure, but just wagging your finger in people's faces is ridiculous
I need her to hit more low note... praying for G2 & F2 with a peak E2...
I have a feeling she's lipsyncing to preserve her voice. Either that, or she's been hitting the studio a lot
For what is she always "preserving" her voice if not for the actual live performance??
@maybe i could be wrong but i promise you she doesnt care about live performances at all. she only does it for the fans. she probably wouldnt do any.
she's always said that she feels ans does her best at the studio, and thats where she feels the most comfortable at
@ Probably to take care of an issue. Her voice has deteriorated completely since 2022
@@issamoodissavibe
The fans would prefer new studio music then rather than 99% lipsynced shows...
@Thank you! Fans are always saying she’s preserving her voice because she’s recording for her next album or saving it for a session. They’ve been using this excuse for like 6 years. If she’s preserving her voice then why is she scheduling live performances??
Estas partes pueden estar cantadas en vivo o sobre una pista, pero esta cantando!!!
i think at this point she doesn't need to sing live, we know who she is and that's it. i also think everybody who highlights her lip syncing needs to calm down and realize that ppl don't go to a mariah carey concerts just to hear her sing live (which she still does btw in segments of the concert) but because she is mariah carey, she's got the hits and she's a living legend. if anything i think that pre recorded tracks and lip sync just make her voice more precious cause she doesn't use it live as much as she used to but now whenever she does it's always so exciting and just beautiful to witness cause it is obvious that she still got it, a singer like THAT doesn't randomly lose the ability to sing even despite nodules and everything, just like regular people don't forget how to ride a bike after they learn, the comment might be kinda long but the concept is really simple tbh, i guess people are just dumb, jelous and frustrated
Erm yeah she does need to sing live it’s what you go to a concert for! I can’t believe people just accept it now. She’s trying to convince us she’s lipsymching and it’s not working. Also, she just stands there now and hardly moves, even her hands she looks scared to move and looks awkward - she’s lost all sense of being a performer.
Also yes people do lose their voices over time. It can’t be used as an analogy for riding a bike it’s not the same. More like a carpenter constantly using their hands they will eventually get worn out - some quicker than others
@@scottmurphy6159 bro it's not that people accept lip syncing, I'll accept it for Mariah as an exception cause she's a legend and there are exceptions anyways. plus Mariah has never been a dancer what do you expect her to do? you guys are acting delirious 😂 more than half of her songs are ballads/chill songs do you expect her to dance like Beyoncé during babydoll, without you and we belong together? that's a you problem, plus if you just can't stand Mariah now just simply don't go to her concert, it's that simple
Somehow i know that she can do all basic note she lipped rn just look how comfortable she is with the ending of i'll be there that Bb4,C5 is so easy for her if were being honest rn, but i guess she is Perfectionist up to the point she has to do this kind of stuff......
En la última canción ella tiene sus ojos llorosos 🥹 está más triste en el segundo show 😢
This show and the level of lip synching is something that any MC fan would’ve been horrified at 15 years ago
everythings changed already people accept the fact the she cant belt those notes anymore. and you should appreciate also 🙂🙂🙂
@@ohmylambily She’s adapted VOL for decades to meet the needs of her changing voice tho.
Is this whole show actually lip syncing? a lot of parts sound live tho, maybe her audio engineer did a really good job mixing everything this time
She pre-recorded tracks for every song, that's why it sounds live
True. The pre-recorded tracks really sync well with whatever live parts she add. However, her face and demeanor just aren't convincing, and she doesn't look like she's even trying to make it realistic.
She keeps staring at the monitor for the lyrics or the lipsync timing.
The whole Show !
1:19 you’re not here, show me your ticket lol 😂😂😂
It’s lip synced so night 2 and night 1 will have the very same highlights
There were some variants on the tracks tho
@@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242 will, that’s good I guess. So she’s not so bored lip syncing
Next vocal highlights video 3 seconds long 🤦🏻♂️
And they used to be like 15 minutes long, no joking, previous videos of TDOMC/mariahxlambily
Not even talking about her prime performances, where literally an entire concert is one huge vocal highlight
But it is what it is
Is looking in at -2?
Wdym
@@yeetvocals3786 the key😭 is it -2 semitones?
@@Fishriah_Ari oh lol, it appears so.
Second 😢❤❤❤
can you do a vocal range of her prerecorded songs
I did, my previous video was that
@@yeetvocals3786 i know but u missed some songs sorry haha
@@MC-wd7jc they weren't that interesting imo.
Not me and other people like you being attacked for telling people that the show is mostly lipped if not 100% lipped...
literally
Yeah it's lipped
Everybody knows that it’s completely pre-recorded
That kinda makes me sad. I get she's trying to preserve her voice and give us a consistent show, but, couldn't she have done at least one song partially live? Like Hero at the very least.
Right I was confused cause some vocals were weirdly consistent and clean... And then it clicked
whats the name of last song ?
It’s sad that she lips syncs but oh well. I’m just happy every song sounds like she prerecorded it she working hard in that studio. All these new high notes are amazing all she is not doing it live.
i still think the vol whistle and run up to it from yesterday and today is live since it has a different sound in the belts
no
I wish that was the case.
Delulu
1:23 help 😭
1:53 not ominous- but i seee
naurrrr was she crying during looking in ?
Yes
Just a jazz album please
Why does everyone want a jazz album please?? Because it’s in low notes?
@@scottmurphy6159 because she has a lovely tone, very suited to jazz. Whenever she did a jazz cover at her shows it was always live, and she smashed it cause jazz seems to be much easier on her voice.
Try Lozenge has gotten too big. It's sad Luther Vandross meets Klumps meets poor Randy Jackson territory.
I just don't understand why Mariah teases us w those acapella moments and then turns around and does this... It really makes no sense bc even in her harshest of voice she still got up on stage and gave everything she had *LIVE* I really miss the confidence she had in the 2015/16 #1 to infinity and 2020 Butterfly returns eras. I tried to wait it out but as a fan this is just disappointing, it goes against everything Mariah stands for as a premier vocalist... Hopefully she gets out of her head more as the residency continues smh
She has always stood for this, you were just in denial...This is not new. Her voice always had zero stamina and not a touring voice at all. She knew this even in her prime. As the year got on, the war and tear just made it even more and more impossible for her to sing live.She is not a live singer, never was.
@@odumosuolusegun2781 Being a live singer isn’t a natural thing. It just comes from practice. She just didn’t wanna tour like others. Her only real proper tours are Daydream and Charm, and those were great.
It hurted my ears. Come on: she can't sing anymore
I think “looking in” is lip synched
Ik
90% of this show was lipped (if not more). stop justifying her and start criticizing he or else she'll never give us a performance worth watching again
It is not hatred or a harsh opinion but always love that motivates people and keeps them going. It is obvious that something is going on in Mariah, and we all know that she can sing if she is in a good and safe condition. She has proven it over and over. If you are a lamb, the only thing you can do is trust, observe and support her, and if you are not, you do not have to follow her and you can just leave her alone.
@@commentary2122 you're part of the problem
@@MP_Guzyou're also part of the problem
It’s because of people like you that she’s afraid of being vulnerable and afraid of failing and yall don’t even notice.
If you don’t think she’s worth watching, don’t watch her and that’s all. Many of us appreciate her as the last standing member of the vocal trinity, and if she wants to keep her voice safe for other projects, we won’t criticize her for it. You all criticize the legends and then start appreciating when they’re gone.