If people were only fans of Milli Vanilli for the voices and lyrics they were doing it wrong. Milli Vanilli was about the performance and energy. Anyone can have a good voice but not everyone had the star quality Rob and Fab had.
I don’t care if they were singing the songs or not, what a performance! Milli vanilli had an amazing stage presence and you can actually feel the music through their energy, I simply love this.
They had so much talent. Look at those steps, dances and performances... It's a spectacle. It's a great spectacle. So what if they didn't sing? Look at that show, the audience certainly loved it. Even if I had been there I would have enjoyed it a lot!
I don't think people understood the hard work they had to put in to pull this off so flawlessly. Singing (although the most important part) was still just a part. They had a right to make their portion of the money they received for their performances.
This footage is amazing!! This show, even if partially pre-recorded, is still better than many live shows I've seen. And that dancing. It was real and it was fantastic. I can watch Rob & Fab dancing all day. They were so talented.
I met them back in 91 back when they did the club MTV tour with downtown julie brown they were really cool dudes & yes me & rob are german descent miss you rob thankx for your time & fab your music is really amazing 🎸🎙
Most performers that have high energy dancing like this don't sing live. Try singing good in the middle of your cardio workout. I'm aware that these guys didn't sing on the recorded album.
@@michaelmarama-de4gx Yeah man, compared to a guy like you, who possessed the wisdom of the universe, we are only simple stupid people. Be proud of you man.
Que hermosa presentación bailaban hermoso y también cantaba que triste todo lo que paso con ellos. Ellos si querían cantar pero el estúpido manager que tenían era una mala persona ami me encantaban hermosos para mi siempre serán Milli Vanilli ❤❤❤💋💋💋
You must be kidding... can't be called singing. They sound horrible. They're only jumping and jumping and screaming (the ladies at the back are the ones that are trying to sing).
Que raro yo vi un vídeo de un recital de Fab con el verdadero cantante . Fue en 2019 y dan tiene un programa en un canal en You Tube y se lo vio bien el intérprete original un poco agitado pero la vos la sigue teniendo casi igual . Y Fab mejoró en su vos
El engaño más hermoso del mundo, no le perdonaría una infidelidad a mí mujer, pero a estos weyes, les perdono TODOOOO, que carisma, que energía, una gran época, ojalá viviera ROB y volver a verlos JUNTOS...."5 minutos a ese ritmo y energía la neta yo si tiraba la toalla, si les digo: raza esto es un engaño, hay muere yo me largo aaahhh y no hay reembolso" 😅...MV FOREVER 🤟☝. Gracias x el video, es una joya. Papapapa baby....
There's something to be said about that. If the public could have actually seen footage like this they might have stood a chance. These guys were literally doing BACKFLIPS, entertaining thousands of people. Frank should have went to prison for fraud.
amazing. i LOVED MV as a kid and watching this as a 42 year old it takes me back to when 12 years old meant a walkman, vhs, baseball and Milli Vanilli and Linear on Cassette singles meant happiness. For years after November 1990 i couldn't get over the visuals and ear candy i had grown to love.... Now as a musician myself, i LOVE the instrumentals and musicians that toured with MV... that bass player and guitar player are PURE FUNKING AWESOME! love the funk.... the drummer is really Good also but Mikky was the best. RIP Rob Pilatus and Mikky Byron!
holy smokes, are you ME?? Ha. Same age, same EVERYTHING here. ;) - also, the bass player Keith Yoni Yon is a real estate agent in Las Vegas nowadays. Cray cray.
@@MoonLanta 🤣 hahaha, we just have great taste 😆 Have you met, Keith Yoni Yon? I really like and admire him in his interviews and how well he talked about "the boys". Have a Merry Christmas!
@christianaguayo6756 😎 haven't met Keith...just did a ton of research after the documentary, mainly trying to find out what sampler or dat machine 'malfunctioned'. I personally think someone behind the scenes sabatoged them. Ive reached out to Keith here on youtube, nothing. I've hunted down sound techs from their tours, nothing. Happy Holidays!
Ésto es oro puro!!!!!!nunca pense que iba a lograr ver algo así de Milli Vanilli!!!!! gracias por compartir ésto con la gente!!!! te pone la piel de gallina!!!!
exelente!!!. su musica se adelanto a su tiempo...gran talento de Rob&Fab para mi ellos son el alma de MV..., ojala la pelicula de sus vidas se haga realidad algún dia
@ Raul P.😊If they were going to come out with a movie i don't think I can bring myself to go see it because of what they endure the lying , bullying and broken proimses.😘 I Cannot hear Robert 🎩 died again it's to painful 😥😪😘.
@@lorettaquerry2814 Va a ser muy doloroso ver eso pelicula, y más cuando pasen la muerte de rob, no lo voy a soportar, si ahorita me duele mucho su partida, y eso que solo es figura publica, siento mucha tristeza, que ya no este ese hermoso hombre.
I still listen their songs and when I listen them I think about these two guys! Especially as I see so much stupidity going on in Tik Tok or bad bunny music type... I miss these guys
THANK YOU 4 POSTING THIS... NEVER WAS ABLE TO SEE MILLI VANILLI LIVE BACK IN THE DAY, SO THIS WAS A NICE SURPRISE!! ROB & FAB ARE SO FUN 2 WATCH... 😎💕🎩 HOPE MORE FOOTAGE OF THEM SURFACES 1 DAY!! R.I.P. 😇 ROB MISS U SOO MUCH IT HURTS...
Poor Rob,he felt bad himself but continued to work. Maybe because of drugs? Thanks for footage,Rob & Fab were really unsurprassed performers. Thousands kisses💋 & much love💗 for them both.
Remember the original singers were anonymous at this point. No one knew who they were. If it wasn't for Rob and Fab they might never have been known, and certainly would never have reached this level. Mr John Davis was the exception. He did big things. May he RIP, too.
Estupendo video mucha energía y talento muy buena presentación sobre el escenario y esos cabellos la locura , gracias por compartir tan bello recuerdo de Milli Vanilli.
Exactly - I wish more people back then could have watched footage like this. They were literally doing *back flips* - This is more entertaining than anything going on now. Also the live band was incredible 🥂
Hasta después de muertos seguirán para la historia cómo milli vainilla los primeros en doblar canciones porque su mánager no los dejaba cantar...los tenía para lucir el escenario y ellos daban para mucho más...Ya Rob Pilatus falleció muy joven con apenas 33 años ...se cansó de intentar salir adelante con la música y no les dieron oportunidad...para la humanidad era un fraude y un fracaso cuando el egoísmo cegó al mundo y fue más fácil juzgar y ya. SIGUEN SIENDO PARA LA HISTORIA MILLI VANILLI
Thank you! Meadowlands arena, e Rutherford, N.J - club MTV tour, 23rd July 1989. This concert only 2 days after tape skipped incident at Lake Compounce ...
They always have incident and even worse than that, but people never cared until Frank had his conference, ..there was several incidents they still in the dressing rooms and the music already being played with vocals people laughed when they appeared on stage but when they started to perform people just forget about it because people enjoy when they started to dance...they are not the one lipsynching with someone else vocals most european dance act like Black Box, Technotronic, Milli Vanilli that huge at that time they are not English native speaker they even have intrepreter when doing interviews it was common practice they use model as frontman to sing English songs...in US they did the same thing but more covert ...by mixing vocals...but people have no idea..
Madonna & many others have lip synched to save their voices. Only difference is these guys were just beginning & signed bad contracts but I believe they would be still around (Fab is & hes doing awesome) unfortunately Rob didn't make it:(
Rob real voice is handsome than the recorded voice. If only Farian give them a chance to record their own voice maybe they are more popular than Backstreet Boys.
They definitely used "tape". Their mics are live (so they can talk to the audience and ad-lib) but the main songs were pretty much all pre-recorded. Still great performers ♥️🎤🎵
It doesn’t sound like the songs from the music videos but it sounds like the real singers pre-recorded a live version of the songs. With that heavy accent, it was a gamble for Rob to be yelling out in the crowd.
Thank u so much, this is a dream come true, I was too young to see them when they came to NZ (but I got the autographed record from my Dad who was police)
I watched one of their live concerts.. they talked and sang.. so, they were not lip syncing.. I know they were caught, but they did sing live converts and sounded awesome !!
They weren't caught. Frank Farian pulled the plug in 1990 by revealed the truth on a press conference that they actually did not sing (on the record) after receiving the Grammy Award as they seemed to go bananas, they wanted to do their own thing coz they thought to be above all and their producer who created them - started to condemn rules they had to follow. Frank gave them first the opportunity to sing but they weren't good enough, at least not in production terms. BUT apparenty not live where they seemed to rock the audience what we can experience here... ;) And it wasn't all about singing, the performance was the second important point that was underestimated.
Away with your lies they did not sing live its not there voices in the studio or in this clip if you seen a concert after 1990 that you never did then they may have sang live but during the milli group absolutely never live so stop with your sad lies and i am a massive milli frank farian collector.
Excelente concierto de verdad que Rob & Fab se esforzaron por dar el mejor espectáculo, aunque no estaban cantando en verdad, pero hay que reconocer que dieron lo mejor de ellos. Lastima que eran otros tiempo y tal vez el publico era mas exigente y les afecto el saber que ellos no cantaban, yo tenia 18 años para ese momento y no me importo sino cantaban, y mas porque eso ya ocurría con otros grupo de la época. Pero también había que reconocer todo el esfuerzo que ellos hicieron, y mas que a la final las circunstancia difíciles por las que pasaban, fue lo que los llevo aceptar ese trato con Farian quien salió ileso de todo el escandalo. Bueno seguiremos disfrutando de lo que nos dejaron musicalmente. Saludos desde Venezuela 😊
Andaikan Rob masih hidup, tentu ia tidak perlu merasa sedih karena para penggemar mencintai nya tulus seperti apa adanya ia, Padahal ia bisa merubah imagenya dan menunjukkan jati dirinya yang sebenarnya seperti yang dilakukan Fab sekarang sungguh sangat disayangkan rob mengakhiri hidupnya dalam kesedihan
Llevo siendo fan de MV desde 2013. En 2014 subi un pequeño fragmento del concierto y alcance los 4M de visitas, pero tuve que borrar el video por motivos de copyright. Me hace muy feliz verlo de nuevo. Muchisimas gracias por subir este video!! :')
@@ios332 No, por supuesto que no. Era el concierto de MTV donde se descubrió que MV hacían playback, era sacado del documental de behind the music. Este concierto será grabado por un fan seguramente.
@@ios332 Estaba prohibido hasta hace unos años por motivos de copyright y era imposible de encontrar. Yo subi solo las partes donde salia el concierto de MV y lo edité. Ahora se puede encontrar en YT y agradezco que la gente vaya subiendo material de MV en internet. Mi video gneró 4 millones de visitas porque no podía encontrarse en ninguna parte. Ojalá algun dia poder ver el concierto completo, daría lo que fuera.
Some kind soul sent me a bootleg tape of this concert months ago when I had recently come out of my surgeries in Boston. God bless you. I had expressed a strong liking to this duo. Every once in a while you meet someone decent which is now a rare treasure, a lost art almost like handwritten letters.
All that extreme aerobics, they would have had to lip sync to a track anyway!. Just the pure physicality of their show! They were constantly moving....huge kudos to these two!
These guys are real performers. Regardless of their singing, it didn’t matter. You don’t see anything like this today. At the time tickets were always sold out. I supposed to get 3 tickets, one for myself, my girlfriend and her best friend. Came up one short and knew the girls wanted to go so I wanted them to have a good time so I took a back seat and let the go. Came back with ear to ear smiles. I was happy that they enjoyed it. I was told it was one of the best concerts they ever went to.
Amazing! Gonna tell it like it is. These men SWEAT. The real singers stood in an air-conditioned room and recorded. They deserved the credit they got, but so did Rob and Fab. This was only possible because of them. And let's face it. A lot of the vitriol that came from the U.S. was from jealous African Americans who saw these guys blow in from Europe taking center stage in minutes. Eg. Arsenio Hall, the Wayans Bros., et al. Their attacks were merciless and all based on jealousy and envy. Think about it. American and global audiences - mostly females - were CRAZY for these "Euro brothas." No one had EVER seen anything like this; not here. They could not compete with this. Tell me they weren't pissed and out to destroy them from the beginning. You can't tell me otherwise.
eu tenho tanta saudade do Rob pilatus descanse en paz querido nos ti amar todos os dias eu vejo os vídeos deles e choro muito não enporto ser já faz 24 anos que Rob partiu
El video se ve tan bien que parece grabado directamente a digital actual... Muy bien por Rob y Fab ... solo necesitaban una oportunidad para desarrollar su talento y parece que FranK no se los permitió...
This DUO were bad-ass!..Their energy,charisma,dynamics...Outside of the obvious synch ordeal,Concertgoers got a stellar performance and an unforgettable experience!..Hell,I'd went to the concert then and NOW..R.I.H ROB P..and My prayers/best wishes to all affected by that sorry ass producer!
They say their backing track malfunctioned too in a Vegas show. That time they actually tried to sing live and it was a disaster. But the audience was so loud that they didn't care.
honestly itd be hard to tell this was fake. their hype and performance is on point. Imagine if they didnt when any rewards and had time to transition to using their own voices. We'd still have Rob with us to keep this magic alive
This is quite an entertaining show. From a technical point of view, it's interesting to hear how they mixed playback and live elements together. You have to admit these guys rocked the stage, but did anyone in the audience really believe they would sing live? Obviously it's pre-recorded, but even if you think the guys sang live, the vocals would sound way too clean and proper and they danced too.
Eu era muito fã deles!!!! Pra mim sempre serão ícones! Creio que se não fossem por eles, especialmente a performance que apresentavam, a música não faria tanto sucesso ... foi uma união mágica
Si estuvieras vivo mi Rob, haría lo que fuera por tal de ir , a unos de esos conciertos y yo ser esa muchacha con la que bailaste., en verdad eras el hombre mas hermoso del mundo.❤❤❤
![Fab Morvan (Milli Vanilli) in the Markus Lanz Show [2015 Full Interview]](/img/1.gif)
If people were only fans of Milli Vanilli for the voices and lyrics they were doing it wrong. Milli Vanilli was about the performance and energy. Anyone can have a good voice but not everyone had the star quality Rob and Fab had.
even the backvocals where stomping the hell out of this stage … pressure was high this evening
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
@@bustaroqz Facts!
@ Rohan Q no one can dance like Rob 🥰🍒 and fab🥰🌹they are. 🌟bs
Concordo
I don’t care if they were singing the songs or not, what a performance! Milli vanilli had an amazing stage presence and you can actually feel the music through their energy, I simply love this.
now today that what he does its a shit
Ich nehme nichts übel, die waren toll...
Noone singing at concerts. Madonna, Gaga, Pink, Katy Perry just dancing and licking balls of black agressive dancers.
FAKE...SINGERS,,,,,,,,,,,,!!!!
TRASH--------------------!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
They had so much talent. Look at those steps, dances and performances... It's a spectacle. It's a great spectacle. So what if they didn't sing? Look at that show, the audience certainly loved it. Even if I had been there I would have enjoyed it a lot!
Here I am in 2024. I play Girl You Know Its True at every single one of my gigs. If there is a highlight all night at all, this song is one of them!!!
Yes you love a song that’s sung by black Americans and also written by Kevin Lyles for head of Def Jam records
I don't think people understood the hard work they had to put in to pull this off so flawlessly. Singing (although the most important part) was still just a part. They had a right to make their portion of the money they received for their performances.
Rarely ever seen such original dance moves and iconic signature styles.
Most entertaining and energetic duo I have ever seen. Gotta still love them
Yes same
true,love them both.
🤣 😂 🤣 😂 It's a pity they didn't sing THEM......🤣😂
If you you're on as much drugs that they were on back then, you to would very super energetic. 😅
@@choc0077 and they don't need to worry about singing so they can focus solely on dancing and jumping around.
This footage is amazing!! This show, even if partially pre-recorded, is still better than many live shows I've seen. And that dancing. It was real and it was fantastic. I can watch Rob & Fab dancing all day. They were so talented.
And this is true! ^^
ABSOLUTELY
God bless the person who recorded this on their camera
Unglaublich diese tolle Show. Ich liebe Milli Vanilli immer noch❤❤❤❤
I saw them on tour that year, these dudes were a huge deal...probably most popular artist that year
I mean for them to put this much life and energy and make the whole world dance, that is talent
Sadly, people are always appreciated after tragedy. They were definitely the moment I was there.❤
Saw them live in Greenville SC. Was actually a great show. The were real performers even if they didn't sing.
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
lucky!
I met them back in 91 back when they did the club MTV tour with downtown julie brown they were really cool dudes & yes me & rob are german descent miss you rob thankx for your time & fab your music is really amazing 🎸🎙
@@karlfortuin5794club mtv tour was summer 1989..you sure you met them then?
FAKE...SINGERS,,,,,,,,,,,,!!!!
TRASH--------------------!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I was there that night.I was 12 at the time. Good old time
Lucky!
@@alessandrabongiovi Yes sir.I still remember that night until this day..I also seen Paula Abdul, tome loc and temptations that night.
Какой город?
RIP Rob. Glad to see Fab doing his thing still these days. He looks great!
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Fab sings even better than the original singers at this point.
The sound engineers deserve an Oscar for the job they did to make it seem as though they are singing live
Haha....
And than later they can bring it back!
All the behind-the-scenes crew!
That was a big effort for entertainment
Most performers that have high energy dancing like this don't sing live. Try singing good in the middle of your cardio workout. I'm aware that these guys didn't sing on the recorded album.
@@dewitp I don't dance while performing live.
@@denverberry sounds good, I was replying to doc b though
I love MilliVanilli great performers
Who cares about singing or not. They gave us a good time. This is what matters.
What a load of nonsens
@@michaelmarama-de4gx Yeah man, compared to a guy like you, who possessed the wisdom of the universe, we are only simple stupid people. Be proud of you man.
@@michaelmarama-de4gx Yeah, man. For a guy like you who owns the wisdom of the universe, we are just some stupid, simple people. Be proud of you, man.
If the aim was to create magic this vid is proof they accomplished it!
Que hermosa presentación bailaban hermoso y también cantaba que triste todo lo que paso con ellos. Ellos si querían cantar pero el estúpido manager que tenían era una mala persona ami me encantaban hermosos para mi siempre serán Milli Vanilli ❤❤❤💋💋💋
@Davis N I glad someone sees what I'm talking about ty.😊
Verídico
Siempre Milli Vanilli
Vi un reportaje donde a seguraban que no cantaban y por lo que vi si cantaban y muy bien. Y ellos son y serán los Milli Vanilli.
These guys have so much energy.this show is not lips sing. They are singing lives. I love them.
You would be able to dance like that too if you weren't wasting energy from singing at the same time lol.
Yes true every day I've always listening thiers songs such a nice voice
You must be kidding... can't be called singing. They sound horrible. They're only jumping and jumping and screaming (the ladies at the back are the ones that are trying to sing).
It’s obvious that they were lip syncing. Their voices don’t sound like the track playing
Are you serious? They dont sing it's not their voice it's a recording
Impresionante!!! Milli Vanilli son explosivos en escena!!! Hicieron historia, excelente recuerdo ...
Que raro yo vi un vídeo de un recital de Fab con el verdadero cantante . Fue en 2019 y dan tiene un programa en un canal en You Tube y se lo vio bien el intérprete original un poco agitado pero la vos la sigue teniendo casi igual . Y Fab mejoró en su vos
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
@@east--westsounds5681 Gracias por estos dos conciertos ,son una joya ,no tienes más conciertos de ellos??
Love these guys........regardles..they are talented........
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Dont u know 5hey fake
Great energetic performers that are fun to watch and dance with. Their legacy lives on. Thanks Rob and keep on spreading the love and vibe Fab ⚡
If you are interested, Fab has his own YT channel. He is a cool guy.😊 Fab Morvan Channel
Amazing boys! They were singing or not.I don't care.Energy was real, great dancers great show
I Love Milli Vanilli 💖💖 and my big love Rob 💖💖💖 Forever only you my sweet angel 💋💓❤
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
El engaño más hermoso del mundo, no le perdonaría una infidelidad a mí mujer, pero a estos weyes, les perdono TODOOOO, que carisma, que energía, una gran época, ojalá viviera ROB y volver a verlos JUNTOS...."5 minutos a ese ritmo y energía la neta yo si tiraba la toalla, si les digo: raza esto es un engaño, hay muere yo me largo aaahhh y no hay reembolso" 😅...MV FOREVER 🤟☝.
Gracias x el video, es una joya.
Papapapa baby....
Thankyou very much for this piece of history! This is the first time in over 30 years I’ve seen a full live footage of Milli Vanilli. ❤️
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
There's something to be said about that. If the public could have actually seen footage like this they might have stood a chance. These guys were literally doing BACKFLIPS, entertaining thousands of people. Frank should have went to prison for fraud.
Very glad to see them in concert!!! Pure energy!!! Love them♥️
Thanks for sharing!!!!
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
😊
amazing. i LOVED MV as a kid and watching this as a 42 year old it takes me back to when 12 years old meant a walkman, vhs, baseball and Milli Vanilli and Linear on Cassette singles meant happiness. For years after November 1990 i couldn't get over the visuals and ear candy i had grown to love.... Now as a musician myself, i LOVE the instrumentals and musicians that toured with MV... that bass player and guitar player are PURE FUNKING AWESOME! love the funk.... the drummer is really Good also but Mikky was the best. RIP Rob Pilatus and Mikky Byron!
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Rob was a brother to him as Fabrice says he was a part of his life.
holy smokes, are you ME?? Ha. Same age, same EVERYTHING here. ;) - also, the bass player Keith Yoni Yon is a real estate agent in Las Vegas nowadays. Cray cray.
@@MoonLanta 🤣 hahaha, we just have great taste 😆 Have you met, Keith Yoni Yon? I really like and admire him in his interviews and how well he talked about "the boys". Have a Merry Christmas!
@christianaguayo6756 😎 haven't met Keith...just did a ton of research after the documentary, mainly trying to find out what sampler or dat machine 'malfunctioned'. I personally think someone behind the scenes sabatoged them. Ive reached out to Keith here on youtube, nothing. I've hunted down sound techs from their tours, nothing. Happy Holidays!
Holy shit, for a footage from a vhs recorder in 1989, it looks so fucking clear
Amazing
I’m sill sad Rob died, the industry fucked them over😔
Ésto es oro puro!!!!!!nunca pense que iba a lograr ver algo así de Milli Vanilli!!!!! gracias por compartir ésto con la gente!!!! te pone la piel de gallina!!!!
exelente!!!. su musica se adelanto a su tiempo...gran talento de Rob&Fab para mi ellos son el alma de MV..., ojala la pelicula de sus vidas se haga realidad algún dia
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Están en eso supuestamente harán una película
Ojalá , soy re fan !!
@ Raul P.😊If they were going to come out with a movie i don't think I can bring myself to go see it because of what they endure the lying , bullying and broken proimses.😘 I Cannot hear Robert 🎩 died again it's to painful 😥😪😘.
@@lorettaquerry2814 Va a ser muy doloroso ver eso pelicula, y más cuando pasen la muerte de rob, no lo voy a soportar, si ahorita me duele mucho su partida, y eso que solo es figura publica, siento mucha tristeza, que ya no este ese hermoso hombre.
Their legs look amazing. 🦵❤🔥
Fab must be missing Rob so much in his life
Que tal energia de esta dupla, y para mi si cantaban no siempre pero si tenian talento para cantar y bailar
#metarkof 😊 it will be off the chain and explosive.😋😋
I still listen their songs and when I listen them I think about these two guys! Especially as I see so much stupidity going on in Tik Tok or bad bunny music type... I miss these guys
THANK YOU 4 POSTING THIS... NEVER WAS ABLE TO SEE MILLI VANILLI LIVE BACK IN THE DAY, SO THIS WAS A NICE SURPRISE!!
ROB & FAB ARE SO FUN 2 WATCH... 😎💕🎩
HOPE MORE FOOTAGE OF THEM SURFACES 1 DAY!!
R.I.P. 😇 ROB MISS U SOO MUCH IT HURTS...
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Poor Rob,he felt bad himself but continued to work. Maybe because of drugs?
Thanks for footage,Rob & Fab were really unsurprassed performers.
Thousands kisses💋 & much love💗 for them both.
They sing for real there most of the songs at this consert. Not lipsync and their real voices, damn! just listen carefully 😀
Wow incredible, love it
Que energía la de esos malditos. Nunca paraban de bailar, es increíble. Eran unos Duros.
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
@aGabriel C 😁 They are very good performers strong epecially fabrice 😍 gosh he looks really good he's toned etc.oh boy.🥰
@@lorettaquerry2814 Así es tienes toda la razón.
@@holagabriel Rob stopped with everything on the age of 33!
The back-up singers/dancers are killing it too!
Remember the original singers were anonymous at this point. No one knew who they were. If it wasn't for Rob and Fab they might never have been known, and certainly would never have reached this level. Mr John Davis was the exception. He did big things. May he RIP, too.
O show deles era pura energia. Gostaria que eles tivessem vindo para o Brasil, Brasil amava eles.
Estupendo video mucha
energía y talento muy buena
presentación sobre el
escenario y esos cabellos
la locura , gracias por compartir tan bello
recuerdo de Milli Vanilli.
Say what you want but they did a good show. In todays world everything is fake!
Exactly - I wish more people back then could have watched footage like this. They were literally doing *back flips* - This is more entertaining than anything going on now. Also the live band was incredible 🥂
The point was that it wasn't just about the lip syncing, it was that they weren't the ones singing the songs
These guys look more energetic than any modern performer I've seen!
Hasta después de muertos seguirán para la historia cómo milli vainilla los primeros en doblar canciones porque su mánager no los dejaba cantar...los tenía para lucir el escenario y ellos daban para mucho más...Ya Rob Pilatus falleció muy joven con apenas 33 años ...se cansó de intentar salir adelante con la música y no les dieron oportunidad...para la humanidad era un fraude y un fracaso cuando el egoísmo cegó al mundo y fue más fácil juzgar y ya.
SIGUEN SIENDO PARA LA HISTORIA MILLI VANILLI
Gracias por compartir este video inédito para muchos de nosotros ... cuanta energía de parte de este gran dúo mi adolescencia eran mis preferidos
Amazing performers. Pop stars don't sing live much, and they can't dance like this. The energy is amazing.
This is unique! Rob and Fab are singing. Thanks for sharing
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Sadly not
Don't care what they did . They were the best I still have their all the albums . Sadly did not get a chance to see them live.
Thank you! Meadowlands arena, e Rutherford, N.J - club MTV tour, 23rd July 1989. This concert only 2 days after tape skipped incident at Lake Compounce ...
Allegedly that backing track had also failed in Milwaukee weeks before. But it was a minor incident at the start of a song.
They always have incident and even worse than that, but people never cared until Frank had his conference, ..there was several incidents they still in the dressing rooms and the music already being played with vocals people laughed when they appeared on stage but when they started to perform people just forget about it because people enjoy when they started to dance...they are not the one lipsynching with someone else vocals most european dance act like Black Box, Technotronic, Milli Vanilli that huge at that time they are not English native speaker they even have intrepreter when doing interviews it was common practice they use model as frontman to sing English songs...in US they did the same thing but more covert ...by mixing vocals...but people have no idea..
Technotronic? Really?
Madonna & many others have lip synched to save their voices. Only difference is these guys were just beginning & signed bad contracts but I believe they would be still around (Fab is & hes doing awesome) unfortunately Rob didn't make it:(
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Rob real voice is handsome than the recorded voice. If only Farian give them a chance to record their own voice maybe they are more popular than Backstreet Boys.
The back up singers/dancers are Amazing🔥The bigger girl can move! ♥️🔥
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Thanks for posting an amazing show! Clearly, Milli Vanilli did not use "tape" for this live band tour -- nobody knows better than me. #RIP Rob Pilatus
They definitely used "tape". Their mics are live (so they can talk to the audience and ad-lib) but the main songs were pretty much all pre-recorded. Still great performers ♥️🎤🎵
Yes they used. They always sang playback. They are lipsyncing.
It doesn’t sound like the songs from the music videos but it sounds like the real singers pre-recorded a live version of the songs. With that heavy accent, it was a gamble for Rob to be yelling out in the crowd.
@@navy4181 In the interviews you could notice that.
It was both, playback with voice over … most singers do it this way live on stage these days
Whatever the case, they were fantastic.
Un show de primera, felicidades, a eso se le llama vivr en el escenario
Great Performance wish to see this in a better quality!
Thank u so much, this is a dream come true, I was too young to see them when they came to NZ (but I got the autographed record from my Dad who was police)
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
@@east--westsounds5681 thanks!
I watched one of their live concerts.. they talked and sang.. so, they were not lip syncing.. I know they were caught, but they did sing live converts and sounded awesome !!
They weren't caught. Frank Farian pulled the plug in 1990 by revealed the truth on a press conference that they actually did not sing (on the record) after receiving the Grammy Award as they seemed to go bananas, they wanted to do their own thing coz they thought to be above all and their producer who created them - started to condemn rules they had to follow. Frank gave them first the opportunity to sing but they weren't good enough, at least not in production terms. BUT apparenty not live where they seemed to rock the audience what we can experience here... ;) And it wasn't all about singing, the performance was the second important point that was underestimated.
Away with your lies they did not sing live its not there voices in the studio or in this clip if you seen a concert after 1990 that you never did then they may have sang live but during the milli group absolutely never live so stop with your sad lies and i am a massive milli frank farian collector.
Excelente concierto de verdad que Rob & Fab se esforzaron por dar el mejor espectáculo, aunque no estaban cantando en verdad, pero hay que reconocer que dieron lo mejor de ellos. Lastima que eran otros tiempo y tal vez el publico era mas exigente y les afecto el saber que ellos no cantaban, yo tenia 18 años para ese momento y no me importo sino cantaban, y mas porque eso ya ocurría con otros grupo de la época. Pero también había que reconocer todo el esfuerzo que ellos hicieron, y mas que a la final las circunstancia difíciles por las que pasaban, fue lo que los llevo aceptar ese trato con Farian quien salió ileso de todo el escandalo. Bueno seguiremos disfrutando de lo que nos dejaron musicalmente. Saludos desde Venezuela 😊
Fab still has that energy today he's amazing💪🏾 RIP Rob😌 respect to the real singers more respect to the real performers Rob and Fab/milli vanilli 👏
Andaikan Rob masih hidup, tentu ia tidak perlu merasa sedih karena para penggemar mencintai nya tulus seperti apa adanya ia, Padahal ia bisa merubah imagenya dan menunjukkan jati dirinya yang sebenarnya seperti yang dilakukan Fab sekarang sungguh sangat disayangkan rob mengakhiri hidupnya dalam kesedihan
That energy level is insane. I’m pretty positive that cocaine did play a role in it.
Ye but still
Llevo siendo fan de MV desde 2013. En 2014 subi un pequeño fragmento del concierto y alcance los 4M de visitas, pero tuve que borrar el video por motivos de copyright. Me hace muy feliz verlo de nuevo. Muchisimas gracias por subir este video!! :')
Is that the same concert? Post it in private Milli Vanilli group...
@@ios332 No, por supuesto que no. Era el concierto de MTV donde se descubrió que MV hacían playback, era sacado del documental de behind the music. Este concierto será grabado por un fan seguramente.
Oh from behind the Music, they already uploaded that...just search in RUclips...
@@ios332 Estaba prohibido hasta hace unos años por motivos de copyright y era imposible de encontrar. Yo subi solo las partes donde salia el concierto de MV y lo edité. Ahora se puede encontrar en YT y agradezco que la gente vaya subiendo material de MV en internet. Mi video gneró 4 millones de visitas porque no podía encontrarse en ninguna parte. Ojalá algun dia poder ver el concierto completo, daría lo que fuera.
Not all uploaded the concert is a fan, but someone who attends all concert
Some kind soul sent me a bootleg tape of this concert months ago when I had recently come out of my surgeries in Boston. God bless you. I had expressed a strong liking to this duo. Every once in a while you meet someone decent which is now a rare treasure, a lost art almost like handwritten letters.
All that extreme aerobics, they would have had to lip sync to a track anyway!. Just the pure physicality of their show! They were constantly moving....huge kudos to these two!
This is amazing, thank you
Rob & Fab = Milli Vanilli!
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
no
These guys are real performers. Regardless of their singing, it didn’t matter. You don’t see anything like this today. At the time tickets were always sold out. I supposed to get 3 tickets, one for myself, my girlfriend and her best friend. Came up one short and knew the girls wanted to go so I wanted them to have a good time so I took a back seat and let the go. Came back with ear to ear smiles. I was happy that they enjoyed it. I was told it was one of the best concerts they ever went to.
♥️💞♥️ they brought us unbelievable excitement and happiness ♥️💞♥️they will be loved and remembered forever ♥️💞♥️RIP ROB 💞🙏💞
Amazing! Gonna tell it like it is. These men SWEAT. The real singers stood in an air-conditioned room and recorded. They deserved the credit they got, but so did Rob and Fab. This was only possible because of them.
And let's face it. A lot of the vitriol that came from the U.S. was from jealous African Americans who saw these guys blow in from Europe taking center stage in minutes. Eg. Arsenio Hall, the Wayans Bros., et al. Their attacks were merciless and all based on jealousy and envy. Think about it. American and global audiences - mostly females - were CRAZY for these "Euro brothas." No one had EVER seen anything like this; not here. They could not compete with this. Tell me they weren't pissed and out to destroy them from the beginning. You can't tell me otherwise.
Damn, you’re right. Great observation. American blacks can be the worse bullies. This is a fact.
Que suerte los que tuvieron la oportunidad de estar ahí yo en ese tiempo ni nacía
eu tenho tanta saudade do Rob pilatus descanse en paz querido nos ti amar todos os dias eu vejo os vídeos deles e choro muito não enporto ser já faz 24 anos que Rob partiu
O seu comentário me emocionou🥲
Thank you
El video se ve tan bien que parece grabado directamente a digital actual... Muy bien por Rob y Fab ... solo necesitaban una oportunidad para desarrollar su talento y parece que FranK no se los permitió...
@ Luis R, That evil troll someday he will get his.💀☠️
They were good looking, were high energy, put on a real show. What is wrong with that?
This is such a treat! Bless you for sharing.
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
succes to conten. Miss you baby freind fab morfan and mili vanili amoooo baby freind everting nextlaaaahh........
Incredible perfomance; you can really feel how much they enjoy being there.
Wow...the footage is fantastic!
Thank you for sharing💙💙
Simplemente los amo mis chicos hermosos
Great Concert More Please 😊
This DUO were bad-ass!..Their energy,charisma,dynamics...Outside of the obvious synch ordeal,Concertgoers got a stellar performance and an unforgettable experience!..Hell,I'd went to the concert then and NOW..R.I.H ROB P..and My prayers/best wishes to all affected by that sorry ass producer!
Finally a semi "pro" shot video of MV live. Always wanted to see one. Who cares if they were't really singing. MV wasn't about great vocals anyway.
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Still a MILLI VANILLI Fan. I do not blame Fab and Rob for the Scandal, and I don't blame the rain either. I BLAME THE PRODUCERS!
wowww love them
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
Estos chicos talentoso están tan buenotes asi como para mi
Poor Robert Pilatus RIP
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
@@east--westsounds5681 😃
They are trully a superstar 👍
excellent dancers! awesome!
They say their backing track malfunctioned too in a Vegas show. That time they actually tried to sing live and it was a disaster. But the audience was so loud that they didn't care.
Rob said that they had to do a few songs without backing track on a few different occasions but the audience didn’t really seem to notice.
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
honestly itd be hard to tell this was fake. their hype and performance is on point. Imagine if they didnt when any rewards and had time to transition to using their own voices. We'd still have Rob with us to keep this magic alive
Now that we know it was lip synced, it looks pretty obvious that it was
ruclips.net/video/u3Rm9fFYx5s/видео.html
I agree we still have him 😍
I wish i was there in 1989...OMG😍😍😍💓
This is quite an entertaining show. From a technical point of view, it's interesting to hear how they mixed playback and live elements together. You have to admit these guys rocked the stage, but did anyone in the audience really believe they would sing live? Obviously it's pre-recorded, but even if you think the guys sang live, the vocals would sound way too clean and proper and they danced too.
I totally agree. I've scoured the web for what possible sampler/playback system that was used, to no avail.
Eu era muito fã deles!!!! Pra mim sempre serão ícones! Creio que se não fossem por eles, especialmente a performance que apresentavam, a música não faria tanto sucesso ... foi uma união mágica
OMG I wish I saw them live!!
Si estuvieras vivo mi Rob, haría lo que fuera por tal de ir , a unos de esos conciertos y yo ser esa muchacha con la que bailaste., en verdad eras el hombre mas hermoso del mundo.❤❤❤
Em 2:34 Rob like MJ?😁 EM 18:00 parece que ele passa mal? Os shows deles tinham uma grande energia, os cantores de hoje parecem um zumbis 🥱perto deles.
Em 11:34 chama a gordinha para dançar 😀que privilégio dela!
Como te entiendo me pasa lo mismo ROB es hermoso como ninguno nadie como el
Great performers/dancers & singers too! (They proved they could really sing & sing good too!)
Rob and Fab looks so entertaining. Very energetic performances