Catherine the Great - Not Quite Catherine Yet - Extra History - Part 1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 янв 2025

Комментарии • 3 тыс.

  • @extrahistory
    @extrahistory  5 лет назад +718

    Listen to this Extra History series as a podcast! becausegamesmatter.com/podcast

    • @FanFicnic
      @FanFicnic 5 лет назад +7

      Do you link or list your sources?

    • @daelen.cclark
      @daelen.cclark 5 лет назад +3

      Extra Credits
      Have you ever watched the mysterious mr enter?

    • @alialharthi8390
      @alialharthi8390 4 года назад +2

      دقدا دقدا

    • @linuswelch1173
      @linuswelch1173 4 года назад

      Would you like a Sprite cranberry

    • @jessiemac9226
      @jessiemac9226 4 года назад

      Normies: "5 years older"
      Extra Credits (an intellectual): " Half a decade older "

  • @AYVYN
    @AYVYN 2 года назад +1027

    Frederick had the rarest skill any leader can have. An accurate judgment of character.

    • @jaydenliberty9536
      @jaydenliberty9536 Год назад +47

      I think one of the only other people in history who *maybe* had such a grasp was Justinian, given the effectiveness of the people he put in charge of various things that most others would have ignored or actively sent to prison
      But there, we have doubt. With Fredrick, there is certainty

    • @Vodka6329
      @Vodka6329 Год назад +23

      @@jaydenliberty9536 Justinian was an smart, yes. But he was paranoid. He was so anxious about one of his trusted generals, Belisarius, revolting and coming into power that he effectively shot himself on the foot by hindering Belisarius' campaigns just to make sure he wouldn't be more popular with the people... Which undoubtedly just had the opposite effect.

    • @cchiborak
      @cchiborak 6 месяцев назад +2

      😂😂😂

  • @m.h.7364
    @m.h.7364 3 года назад +4198

    At least Catherine and Frederick could relate to each other about the whole 'having terrible parents' thing

    • @williamstocker584
      @williamstocker584 3 года назад +18

      Yea Frederick dad was definitely a piece of crap

    • @m.h.7364
      @m.h.7364 3 года назад +79

      @@williamstocker584 That's an understatement lmao

    • @bram61
      @bram61 3 года назад +135

      @@m.h.7364 ye he executed and exiled Fredericks boyfriends

    • @operleutnant7235
      @operleutnant7235 3 года назад +163

      @@bram61 that and his near constant beatings, his father trying to stop his enjoyment of music and the arts, his father waking up him with artillery drills…
      Yeah. Pretty shitty.

    • @arcaneTempest1
      @arcaneTempest1 2 года назад +60

      sophias mother was a karen before karens were a thing

  • @poopa854
    @poopa854 5 лет назад +5353

    Normies: "5 years older"
    Extra Credits (an intellectual): " *Half a decade older* "

  • @facey2965
    @facey2965 6 лет назад +2396

    It’s been on my recommended for five moths YOU WIN RUclips OK?!

  • @connormclernon26
    @connormclernon26 8 лет назад +1491

    For all that it was realpolitik, it's nice that Frederick treated Sophia with kindness. Perhaps he saw a bit of his own situation in her.

    • @hilkmeister1382
      @hilkmeister1382 8 лет назад +64

      Victor Mapping power is the most addicting drug in existence

    • @Mercure250
      @Mercure250 8 лет назад +75

      I think Frederick II's father was waking him each morning with the noise of a canon shooting

    • @connormclernon26
      @connormclernon26 8 лет назад +142

      Mercure250 yeah, his father considered him an effeminate pansy that needed to have the love of art and culture literally beaten out of him

    • @marxel4444
      @marxel4444 7 лет назад +10

      was old fritz the one probaly get a hard one seeing tall soldiers lines up?

    • @MalaysianChopsticks
      @MalaysianChopsticks 6 лет назад +54

      marxel4444 that would be his father. “The most beautiful girl or woman in the world would be a matter of indifference to me, but tall soldiers-they are my weakness”

  • @weirddude928
    @weirddude928 5 лет назад +2746

    Oversimplified: GO FOR JOKES
    Simple history: GO ALL ON HISTORY
    Extra credits: Eh lets do both!

    • @goyonman9655
      @goyonman9655 5 лет назад +159

      Extra credits: Aims to emotionally manipulate audiences

    • @Hectopath2006
      @Hectopath2006 5 лет назад +57

      Simple History does have joke references though.

    • @Nebula644
      @Nebula644 4 года назад +14

      Goyon Man how

    • @malikdespanie4344
      @malikdespanie4344 4 года назад +26

      To the guillotine!!!!!!!

    • @koolmckool7039
      @koolmckool7039 4 года назад +31

      @@malikdespanie4344 OoOoOoOh NoOoOoOo

  • @tummywubs5071
    @tummywubs5071 6 лет назад +5173

    Was her mother the inspiration for Cinderella's stepmother?

    • @danielkiciak9899
      @danielkiciak9899 6 лет назад +253

      Je ne pense pas, car la princesse Joanna Elisabeth de Holstein-Gottorp est née en 1712, tandis que Charles Perrault, auteur de "Cendrillon", la version la plus célèbre du conte de fées "Cendrillon", mourut en 1703, neuf ans avant sa naissance.
      (I think not, because Princess Joanna Elisabeth of Holstein-Gottorp was born in 1712, while Charles Perrault, the Autor of "Cendrillon", the most famous version of the fairy tale "Cinderella", died in 1703, nine years before her birth.)

    • @trailblaze6734
      @trailblaze6734 6 лет назад +53

      @@danielkiciak9899 English pls?

    • @maxbuster1508
      @maxbuster1508 6 лет назад +280

      @@trailblaze6734 basically, the author died earlier than Sophia's birth

    • @Necrocracy
      @Necrocracy 6 лет назад +34

      Bryant Sarmiento What’s there to be r/woooosh for?

    • @bigredmed
      @bigredmed 6 лет назад +11

      Cinderella’s root fairy tales far predate her.

  • @Ok-yn9uo
    @Ok-yn9uo 6 лет назад +6527

    How to abuse and neglect your child 101

    • @God-yb2cg
      @God-yb2cg 6 лет назад +100

      Could be worse, at least she wasn't hit with a whip on daily basis and forced to carry heavy books over her head risking damaging the structure of the back and neck during her "etiquette training" lessons.
      Or maybe she was idk

    • @stardustlover8446
      @stardustlover8446 6 лет назад +5

      Yup

    • @loafgaming9381
      @loafgaming9381 6 лет назад +3

      Hi friendly boi

    • @jasonfields2845
      @jasonfields2845 5 лет назад +7

      911 what’s your emergency

    • @pandacherry8288
      @pandacherry8288 5 лет назад +12

      How my parents treat me 101

  • @jesseberg3271
    @jesseberg3271 Год назад +409

    Just a thought, people weren't staring at Fredrick making conversation with a child, they were staring at Fredrick making conversation with *a woman,* something he was not well known for doing.

    • @kalibronx
      @kalibronx 11 месяцев назад +18

      jail 😭😭😭

    • @purpleheadedhedgehog3821
      @purpleheadedhedgehog3821 9 месяцев назад +7

      @@kalibronxit’s dodgy but it was a different time at the end of the day

    • @jorgesagredo1186
      @jorgesagredo1186 8 месяцев назад +19

      I always have this weird imagen of they speaking meanwhile the rest of the court screaming, running, loosing their heads because the king are talking with a woman that Is a violation against the laws of nature himself and that means the end of the world

    • @PashkenS.
      @PashkenS. Месяц назад +3

      He went *straight* to the conversation.

  • @VulcanTrekkie45
    @VulcanTrekkie45 8 лет назад +832

    Damn, the only thing keeping Johanna from being a complete wicked stepmother is the fact that she was Sophia's actual mother.

    • @Thraim.
      @Thraim. 8 лет назад +127

      Fun fact: In the original folk stories there were no stepmothers. The brothers Grimm changed it because they considered real mothers doing all this shit to their own children as too dark.
      As per usual reality turns out worse than fiction.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 6 лет назад +14

      Damn, I'm glad they changed it because that is too dark. Doing that shit to your own daughter sucks major ass for kids to hear about.

    • @ElizabethMcCormick-s2n
      @ElizabethMcCormick-s2n 6 месяцев назад +2

      @@Thraim.Johanna is the kind of mother that you don't want to have!

  • @chichi77tim
    @chichi77tim 6 лет назад +670

    "She could memorize things with ease, but she frequently infuriated her tutors by BEING SMART."
    Short version. 😂💓

  • @paulnash6944
    @paulnash6944 5 лет назад +3890

    Sophie: *Despised by her mother for being a girl.*
    Me: Does anyone else detect a slight hint of hypocrisy?

    • @StukovM1g
      @StukovM1g 5 лет назад +528

      In deeply sexist and patriarchal societies, many women feel pressured to have a son and this internalise contempt towards their daughters. Observe modern day India and female infanticide.

    • @paulnash6944
      @paulnash6944 5 лет назад +54

      StukovM1g I know, I was just putting down my thoughts.

    • @AnhThuNguyen-zz2hm
      @AnhThuNguyen-zz2hm 4 года назад +13

      seriouslywhatthe

    • @whytfbuddy4118
      @whytfbuddy4118 4 года назад +56

      Paulfuss Entertainment Nah, this was olden ages when having a son was more important than life itself

    • @Klaaism
      @Klaaism 4 года назад +85

      @@StukovM1g Its even worse when the mother wants to use a son as a tool for their own gain.

  • @jakubgawronski3203
    @jakubgawronski3203 8 лет назад +2460

    Man, her mother sounds like an stereotypical Crusader kings 2 player.

    • @edisonmichael6345
      @edisonmichael6345 8 лет назад +19

      Something between that and a Miss' mother.

    • @Gothic7876
      @Gothic7876 7 лет назад +136

      Ehhh as CK2 player that’s tame.
      I have had my own Son KILLED because his culture switch to German. And my current character was next in line for the title of the Holy Roman Empire...

    • @fyedoravna7569
      @fyedoravna7569 6 лет назад +44

      My husband has claim on Holy Roman Empire and I was in prision, without heir. I assasinated 12 prince before him and get killed after a day. I became Empror

    • @hudasheta2002
      @hudasheta2002 6 лет назад

      Jakub Gawroński هلن

    • @jacques3148
      @jacques3148 6 лет назад

      ;)

  • @stablernose7203
    @stablernose7203 6 лет назад +7859

    When I was young I asked "what happened before the universe" and questioned religion but I didn't become a russian queen life is unfair

    • @theworldoverheavan560
      @theworldoverheavan560 6 лет назад +106

      Same here

    • @dinodude7290
      @dinodude7290 6 лет назад +287

      you guys are lucky!
      you know how hard you will be judged if you ask these questions in a muslim socity? even tho i was a child!

    • @lamestar9382
      @lamestar9382 6 лет назад +118

      Also did the same.
      I questioned religion too much when i was a child because i thought i doesn't make sense and focused on science i do think i became naughty because of that way of thinking cause i never wanted to go to church nor pray because i think its stupid.

    • @danielkiciak9899
      @danielkiciak9899 6 лет назад +39

      StablerNose 720 That's because the Russian throne has been disabled after the Bolshevik Coup d'etat in 1917, and I doubt, that Vladimir Putin would simply allow a relative of the former royal family (or any of their allies) to take away his contol over the Russian Federation.

    • @amirhanabishev8868
      @amirhanabishev8868 6 лет назад +93

      @@danielkiciak9899 That moment when you try to push propaganda in a joke.

  • @roeggleston2863
    @roeggleston2863 5 лет назад +3724

    Is it just me or would Catherine's story be good as a musical? Like Hamilton.

  • @pugperson6129
    @pugperson6129 6 лет назад +1571

    “16 pug dogs.” Awww pugs are the best why would that be bad?
    “That did everything dogs do.” Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh...

    • @paulnash6944
      @paulnash6944 5 лет назад +33

      PugPerson Yeah, we forget these things.

    • @lowleypeasentmr.l8836
      @lowleypeasentmr.l8836 4 года назад

      @BatCatShipper they could have been taken out regularly

    • @wareagle4206
      @wareagle4206 4 года назад +7

      It’s also unhealthy for the women with the 16 pug dogs that do every thing a dog dose

    • @kamanashiskar9203
      @kamanashiskar9203 3 года назад +8

      @@wareagle4206 Well, the aunt was a spinster. So her life was ruined. The pugs were her coping mechanism.

  • @NarfoOnTheNet
    @NarfoOnTheNet 8 лет назад +1157

    Am I the only one who enjoyed learning how flabbergasted Sophia's mom was when the King of Germany wanted to see Sophia over her?

    • @Hersatz
      @Hersatz 6 лет назад +45

      Sweet Karma is sweet.

    • @fissionabledolphin
      @fissionabledolphin 3 года назад +10

      When was there a ‘king of germany’

    • @ntfoperative9432
      @ntfoperative9432 3 года назад +47

      @@fissionabledolphin king of Prussia, is that better

    • @operleutnant7235
      @operleutnant7235 2 года назад +10

      @@ntfoperative9432 yes. Yes it is

    • @ntfoperative9432
      @ntfoperative9432 2 года назад +12

      @@fissionabledolphin oh and there was a king of Germany, called the Kaiser

  • @gale1243
    @gale1243 2 года назад +171

    Coming back to this after the first episode about Frederick the Great...no wonder the two got along.

    • @MURPHYCHACHO
      @MURPHYCHACHO Год назад +32

      He took one look Sophia's awful mother and was like "You too, huh?"

  • @LaZodiac
    @LaZodiac 8 лет назад +1288

    It's a shame Catherine and Frederick never met again, I feel like they would of made great friends.

    • @HxH2011DRA
      @HxH2011DRA 8 лет назад +19

      LaZodiac Indeed

    • @monkofdarktimes
      @monkofdarktimes 8 лет назад +12

      LaZodiac so ture

    • @christianweibrecht6555
      @christianweibrecht6555 8 лет назад +161

      LaZodiac
      together they would of conquered Europe without breaking a sweat

    • @gavinsmith9871
      @gavinsmith9871 8 лет назад +8

      dont they go to war at some point?

    • @rinzzler366
      @rinzzler366 8 лет назад +20

      and then civ 4 happened, those two rulers are nigh inseparable, unless they both founded a religion.

  • @CitanulsPumpkin
    @CitanulsPumpkin 8 лет назад +1714

    Questions asked by Frederick the Great:
    "Where's your daughter?"
    "No, Seriously! Where's your daughter?"
    "Oh come on! Don't you get that we're doing a thing here? Get your daughter in here now so I can make sure the girl we put on the armrest of Russia's throne isn't a total idiot!"

    • @Mercure250
      @Mercure250 8 лет назад +88

      More like "Wo ist Ihre Tochter?"
      Wait, they may have spoken in French : "Où est votre fille?"

    • @shontaia07
      @shontaia07 8 лет назад +5

      XD lol

    • @kevinli1438
      @kevinli1438 6 лет назад +30

      Ohhhhhhhhhh Who knew Frederick The Great was a Yo Mama Roaster?

    • @GumSkyloard
      @GumSkyloard 6 лет назад +71

      "Ugh, just give her a goddamn dress already."

    • @ThomasJefferson-xc8wg
      @ThomasJefferson-xc8wg 6 лет назад +56

      @@GumSkyloard "Here Child,Let Us Speak Of Things That Your Mom Doesn't Agree With"

  • @brucejedilee5290
    @brucejedilee5290 4 года назад +233

    Sophie (Catherine): *Exists*
    Joanna Elisabeth: How dare you?

    • @AOSABS
      @AOSABS 4 года назад +8

      I love how people still comment on this video 3 YEARS LATER

    • @koathekid8255
      @koathekid8255 10 месяцев назад

      @@AOSABSmake that 6

    • @Straws_in_Berries
      @Straws_in_Berries 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@koathekid8255 Make that 7

  • @mestre12
    @mestre12 8 лет назад +3037

    One the greatess Monarch of Russia, and, people are demanding her back in Civ 6.

    • @leotseng4139
      @leotseng4139 7 лет назад +63

      mestre12 what is wrong with peter the great?

    • @Andreych95
      @Andreych95 6 лет назад +129

      Nothing wrong with him, but civs can have more than 1 leader (Gorgo and Pericles for Greece)

    • @jackblair9668
      @jackblair9668 6 лет назад +117

      I would rather Ivan the Terrible
      strapping heretical apostles to gunpowder barrels sounds fun
      *The sheep need their shepard*

    • @principetnomusic
      @principetnomusic 6 лет назад +20

      I actually want a Soviet leader again.

    • @swishswish3611
      @swishswish3611 6 лет назад +56

      Peter for culture and science, Catherine for war and expansion?

  • @victorconway444
    @victorconway444 7 лет назад +587

    Catherine the Great's early life sounds very familiar. Almost like Cinderella. You know, if Cinderella grew up to be an iconic, brutal enlightened despot of an enormous multi-continental empire.

    • @irrelevant_noob
      @irrelevant_noob 6 лет назад +27

      well, that's just the way stories end: on a high, without revealing what would actually happen behind that "happily ever after". ;-)

    • @lenny9672
      @lenny9672 2 года назад +1

      My dad forced me to read the book and sophia, uhh, she will grow up to be a ⛏

  • @alastorparker7529
    @alastorparker7529 5 лет назад +990

    "Visiting Relatives to find a match"
    SWEET HOME ALABAMA

  • @Friedrich687
    @Friedrich687 6 лет назад +397

    *Friedrich Der Große comes up.*
    Me: *Inner German intensifies.*

    • @ilosttehlegs4517
      @ilosttehlegs4517 5 лет назад +5

      What do you mean, FDG the dark mom war ship? Or you mean the well disciplined figure of history

  • @Sylocat
    @Sylocat 8 лет назад +738

    Yay! This one's been in the polls for eons but it always got beat. I'm glad it's finally here.

    • @extrahistory
      @extrahistory  8 лет назад +135

      Catherine was never a woman to suffer setbacks meekly.

    • @JarroHood
      @JarroHood 8 лет назад +30

      I feel I'm about to understand a certain ERB video much better by the end of this.

    • @paulpeterson4216
      @paulpeterson4216 8 лет назад

      I've been hoping you would do Kate the Great! \o/

    • @brandtlucasbrandt
      @brandtlucasbrandt 8 лет назад

      Rabbit Cube what's in the pills now?

    • @S3rp3nte
      @S3rp3nte 8 лет назад

      Me too.

  • @chrisfloyd9204
    @chrisfloyd9204 5 лет назад +556

    Toxic mothers don't get talked about enough

  • @extrahistory
    @extrahistory  8 лет назад +2492

    Before she became Catherine the Great, legendary empress of Russia, she was a smart but lonely girl called Sophia.
    PLUS! Vote for Extra Credits in the Shorty Awards up to 3 times per day: shortyawards.com/9th/extracreditz

    • @Loadlng
      @Loadlng 8 лет назад

      Notification squad!

    • @javepadolina2383
      @javepadolina2383 8 лет назад +4

      Ok... not to sound ignorant,but wasn't she the one rumored to have had relations with a horse?

    • @montymonty5040
      @montymonty5040 8 лет назад +1

      Could you please do San Martín next?

    • @raymondz999
      @raymondz999 8 лет назад +3

      Rex Master It is just a myth

    • @petercevallos258
      @petercevallos258 8 лет назад

      Really happy to see the great Russian empress brought into light. How about Lenin?

  • @AndyG94
    @AndyG94 8 лет назад +583

    Catherine the Great and Frederick the Great, two of my favorite monarchs ever.
    I had often wonder what would have happened if Catherine and Frederick had been married, oh history, so full of what if's.
    We need to put in the polls Frederick the Great, he was such an interesting character!

    • @fipse
      @fipse 8 лет назад +87

      It would have been horrible. Fredrick the Great was not known to be very fond of women at his court.

    • @w.a.r4856
      @w.a.r4856 8 лет назад +10

      Fipse True, that's why he didn't have an heir.

    • @Xerxesjc28
      @Xerxesjc28 8 лет назад +18

      Why did he not like women? Was he gay?

    • @w.a.r4856
      @w.a.r4856 8 лет назад +117

      Xerxesjc28 He hated his father, and out of spite, swore an oath to never have an heir.

    • @dragon12234
      @dragon12234 8 лет назад +107

      It was also quite possible that he was gay yes

  • @durrangodsgrief6503
    @durrangodsgrief6503 3 года назад +101

    I would love to see a series based around Catherine's life

    • @magibersok3681
      @magibersok3681 3 года назад +5

      Watch the show.
      What's stopping you?

    • @playwars3037
      @playwars3037 Год назад +1

      There is one ! It's called The Great.

    • @danisprettygay
      @danisprettygay Год назад +1

      ​@@playwars3037
      It's fun and raunchy and dramatic and almost completely fictional.

  • @kingcat6084
    @kingcat6084 7 лет назад +214

    "showing his affections" aka how to creep 101 XD

  • @imperatorcaesardivifiliusa2158
    @imperatorcaesardivifiliusa2158 8 лет назад +737

    I want a series on Roman von Ungern-Sternberg, a man that tried to restore the Mongol Empire, and was definitely insane.

    • @docslastname2711
      @docslastname2711 8 лет назад +47

      Imperator Caesar Divi Filius Augustus You saw isorrow productions.

    • @gavinsmith9871
      @gavinsmith9871 8 лет назад +5

      I want to play as him in Kaiserrigh(spelled that wrong...)

    • @kochkochkoch
      @kochkochkoch 8 лет назад +20

      Gavin Smith Do you mean Kaiserreich?

    • @fattshea8085
      @fattshea8085 8 лет назад +1

      Kaiserriech?

    • @joluoto
      @joluoto 8 лет назад +14

      Meh, Kaiserreich takes some serious liberties with the character. He was a crazy monarchist who wanted to restore the Romanovs and the Qing throne, something that actually made him severely disliked in Mongolia. His rule was short and he never liked the Mongols, seeing them as just savages. Even his conquest of Mongolia was a mistake. He was leading a fleeing White army band from the advancing Red Army, and crossed the border to get away, then attacking and removing the Chinese warlord who had been sent to Mongolia to pacify the breakaway province.

  • @건-r7c
    @건-r7c 5 лет назад +720

    5:58 Well, thinking that she could seduce Frederick with her beauty would be a great mistake, given the historical fact that he was much more interested in dudes rather than ladies.

    • @dorkfish1275
      @dorkfish1275 4 года назад +69

      implying he was interested in ladies at all

    • @fandemusique4693
      @fandemusique4693 4 года назад +85

      I read somewhere than actually, Joanna and Frederick were very good friends, so, i don't think than it's was the intention, even more because Frederick was helping Elizabeth Romanov for check for how good as a bride for Peter Sophia/Catherine was.

    • @theanjanamarandy
      @theanjanamarandy 3 года назад +6

      @@fandemusique4693 ohhhh

    • @persediaanbcbitung989
      @persediaanbcbitung989 2 года назад +27

      I believe Frederick is also interested with genuine intellect person regardless the gender. Perhaps he just fulled with daughter affection love

    • @thedaringdarson2659
      @thedaringdarson2659 Год назад +6

      @@persediaanbcbitung989 no he just likes intelligent men

  • @simozu7072
    @simozu7072 6 лет назад +24

    The intro warmed my heart and i felt like i was sitting on a sofa in front of the fireplace during a full moon night with my parents telling me a wonderful and true story

  • @JoshIdstein
    @JoshIdstein 8 лет назад +239

    Yes! Frederick the Great finally got mentioned in one of these episodes!
    One of the coolest monarchs in German history, who apart from being a military genius, was a great philosopher and advanced the freedom of speech and religion in Prussia, coining the awesome phrase: "Everyone shall be happy by his own fashion in my country" (or something similiar, basically: go live whatever way you want).
    Okay, I don't want to paint an 18th century monarch as a saint here, but he was pretty open-minded and progressive for his time. Let's not forget the fact that for evey good monarch you get three dozen appaling ones.

    • @MalaysianChopsticks
      @MalaysianChopsticks 6 лет назад +18

      Aaron Idstein I missed this a year ago and I wholeheartedly agree. Frederick The Great is one of the most selfless and progressive monarch of his time. Always the first servant to his people and very under appreciated having very little content about him on RUclips. Waiting for the day that he’ll have his very own series on Extra History. But till that day comes Kings and Generals will keep me entertain with the Silesian wars.

    • @anoukori316
      @anoukori316 6 лет назад

      You're right, he is a saint?

    • @adrikristian5958
      @adrikristian5958 Год назад +2

      @@MalaysianChopsticks hello sir, that day finally comes!

    • @MalaysianChopsticks
      @MalaysianChopsticks Год назад +1

      @@adrikristian5958 i know right. 4 years later!

  • @DragoniteSpam
    @DragoniteSpam 8 лет назад +2276

    School version: something something something something something Russia something something,
    EH version: *emotional roller coaster
    Wonder which one I'm going to remember in five years.
    edit: wow you guys are seriously overanalyzing the meaning of this comment

    • @DLCSpider
      @DLCSpider 8 лет назад +136

      True. I never cared about history in school and I never thought I would like Extra History. Turns out I enjoy it quite a bit.

    • @DragoniteSpam
      @DragoniteSpam 8 лет назад +196

      "We want you to learn the concepts instead of memorizing the dates," they said. And then all I ever did in history class in school anyway was memorize a bunch of dates. (Apparently they're trying to change that nowadays, at least here in New Jersey.)

    • @pplluumm22
      @pplluumm22 8 лет назад +7

      I think you've already forgot one.

    • @krim7
      @krim7 8 лет назад +67

      You were taught history wrong, then. Sorry to say but date memorization went out of fashion a long, long time ago.

    • @awanderingmonk828
      @awanderingmonk828 8 лет назад +58

      DragoniteSpam That sucks. My world history teacher was a dynamic person and his lectures were very similar to how ECH does it.

  • @iansmith4702
    @iansmith4702 8 лет назад +21

    I, personally, am thrilled that you are doing Catherine the Great. Some of my ancestors moved to Russia from Germany because of her.

  • @turtlewater1895
    @turtlewater1895 6 лет назад +538

    *Be less sad*

  • @theuncannycharlatan3980
    @theuncannycharlatan3980 7 лет назад +285

    It’s ironic how the last living grandson of Peter the Great was originally the heir to Sweden.

    • @SanyaRy
      @SanyaRy 6 лет назад +43

      ​@Mysterious Stranger the irony is that one of the greatest achievements of Peter the Great was kicking Sweden's ass in the Great Northern War

    • @MrCubFan415
      @MrCubFan415 5 лет назад +5

      Alex Ry The real irony is that Peter the Great’s grandson was originally the heir to the very same country whose ass Peter had kicked in the Great Northern War. So basically a combination of the original comment and your reply.

    • @micah1397
      @micah1397 5 лет назад +1

      @@SanyaRy the irony

    • @caucasusmapper7098
      @caucasusmapper7098 5 лет назад +1

      Not surprising TBH. Marriages between rivaling dynasties did happen.

  • @008TheDen
    @008TheDen 8 лет назад +24

    I love learning more about Old Fritz ( Frederick the Great). First of all him being a master of tactics and lover of arts and hearing about how he struggled against his father's homophobia (Frederick's lover in the army was executed), but would go on to be one of the greatest of German rulers. It is an inspiring story.

    • @MalaysianChopsticks
      @MalaysianChopsticks 6 лет назад +1

      The Eyebrows still waiting for the day he’ll have his series and Honoured fully on RUclips.

  • @ARC9652
    @ARC9652 6 лет назад +40

    Catherine the Great and Frederick the Great are among my all-time favorite historical figures, learning that these two met and spoke to one another is like if it was fan-fiction, I literally squealed like a schoolgirl as it transpired.

  • @bottomtext
    @bottomtext 8 лет назад +9

    Finally an episode including one of my favourite historical characters, Frederick the Great. Just wish there would be a complete series on him.

  • @OriginalMokthol
    @OriginalMokthol 5 лет назад +13

    I dont know exactly what it is about the story of Catherine the Great, but I keep finding myself coming back here to rewatch it again and again.

  • @misti-step
    @misti-step 4 года назад +59

    quickly rewatching this series before "the great" comes out on hulu lol

  • @geekerama2415
    @geekerama2415 6 лет назад +1715

    Funny fact: Catherine The Great had a bastard son, a son outside her marriage with a militar guy, they had an affair. Unfortunatelly I don't know what happened to him, but her son lived, married a girl and started the Eckerman Family (my family btw); because of the jewish origin of the name, and the fear of being killed by their "royal blood" during the Revolution, they escaped to German, and after some time, escaped to other parts of the world. One of those parts was Brazil, my grand-grandma, Maria Eckerman was a lovely woman! I want the world to know her story! 💖 (Yes, we have evidences that this is true, my family contacted a guy who had the original documents signed by the court about the Eckermans)

    • @alexie832
      @alexie832 6 лет назад +222

      Wow! That's awesome! I should find out about my family history too!

    • @lolomo8864
      @lolomo8864 6 лет назад +8

      Coincidence? Or not? Lol

    • @Me-eb3wv
      @Me-eb3wv 6 лет назад +4

      o

    • @vickyyy2817
      @vickyyy2817 6 лет назад +3

      Cool

    • @moundhirmoundhirs6123
      @moundhirmoundhirs6123 6 лет назад +61

      You son of a bastard a dna test is all we need

  • @edim108
    @edim108 6 лет назад +370

    Sounds like a terrible parenting, even for the time. But from that troubled childhood came Woman who made Russia Great once more. The Woman of great character and brilliant mind.
    As Pole, I can't say I like her role in history- If not for Her and Frideric the Great, Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth could have possibly reformed and become the Europes Superpower once more- But I respect her and her great talents. You simply can't deny her role in the history of Russia and thus, the history of the World.

    • @kipkap7406
      @kipkap7406 6 лет назад +6

      Make Russia GreatAgain

    • @Flaccid_Child1
      @Flaccid_Child1 6 лет назад +4

      parenting was horrible throughout our living

    • @feldmarschallvonbraunschwe4463
      @feldmarschallvonbraunschwe4463 4 года назад

      Sorry about the partitions.

    • @Avghistorian77
      @Avghistorian77 3 года назад +2

      Catherine had a terrible mother, and became a terrible mother.

    • @spaghetti_warmer1024
      @spaghetti_warmer1024 3 года назад

      I or l which one is which (I or L and if you guess you get money and food) 🍚🍩🍩🌶🥨🥨🥨🥨🥨🥨🥨🥨

  • @thewafflegamer6152
    @thewafflegamer6152 Год назад +24

    its so weird that Fredrick whom interacted with Catherine and will be an important ally in the future, would not be talked about in extra history for another 6 years.

  • @AlRoderick
    @AlRoderick 8 лет назад +407

    Bad girls go to live in the pug box. Do you want to go live in the pug box?

    • @somedragonbastard
      @somedragonbastard 8 лет назад +13

      Alexander Roderick
      I like pugs, but I don't want to live in the pug box. It's small and dirty.

    • @cindchan
      @cindchan 6 лет назад

      A very late reply, but I had to say that this made me laugh! ^_^

    • @marie-vy4mc
      @marie-vy4mc 6 лет назад +3

      Me being the socially awkward dog lover, yes

    • @vbgvbg1133
      @vbgvbg1133 6 лет назад

      Now its the box.

    • @ms.rstake_1211
      @ms.rstake_1211 6 лет назад

      lol

  • @SonicRooncoPrime
    @SonicRooncoPrime 8 лет назад +37

    Sophia's mother makes me sick to think of her, but your narration and art are as amazing as ever, EC/ EH team!

  • @dhaz4455
    @dhaz4455 3 года назад +20

    Sophia's mother sounds like every step-mother Disney villain

  • @emiv592
    @emiv592 6 лет назад +139

    ... The Disney show..
    SOFIA THE FIRST "I'm finding out what being royal is all about".. Wow

    • @HyperzonMusicalies
      @HyperzonMusicalies 6 лет назад +6

      @Olivia SUN and then regret it

    • @jaded8578
      @jaded8578 6 лет назад +5

      *clears throat*
      SOFIA THE FIRST, MAKING MY WAY IT'S AN ADVENTURE EVERYDAY
      IT'S GONNA BE MY TIME TO SHOW THEM ALL THAT I'M SOFIA THE FIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRST
      (i used to watch that show when i was younger.. but i'm already pretty young, so)

  • @killerOfMoons
    @killerOfMoons 8 лет назад +368

    She better have Siberian riches or I'm not playing.

    • @nicholascooper945
      @nicholascooper945 8 лет назад +69

      (Gets to Atomic Era after long arduous slog) "NO URANIUM? OH HELL NO!" *quits out*

    • @kiwi4998
      @kiwi4998 8 лет назад +7

      haha, she had also get animal husbandry first in the world

    • @akrybion
      @akrybion 8 лет назад +27

      Nicholas Cooper *Russia has denounced you* Oh come in, I just punished warmongering Caesar and gave you back two of your cities! That's it. Fuck Cultural victory, Total War it is.

    • @monkofdarktimes
      @monkofdarktimes 8 лет назад

      Jaiden Cross I will send you there

    • @killerOfMoons
      @killerOfMoons 8 лет назад

      Workers CCCP no I only go there if Stalin sends me there!

  • @amsimsicle
    @amsimsicle 3 года назад +20

    0:08 Best intro ever. if you disagree then you’re wrong

  • @kendallcarter3491
    @kendallcarter3491 8 лет назад +5

    Words can't begin to describe how good this video was. Both the animation and narration where on point, I myself was very interested in the history of Catherine the Great. This is a very effective way of teaching history to people who actually want to learn it.

  • @nodeins1848
    @nodeins1848 Год назад +14

    I'm glad Fredrick got some episodes of his own.

  • @olgadzhydzhora1688
    @olgadzhydzhora1688 4 года назад +17

    Nobody:
    Not a single soul:
    Fredrick: WHERE THE CHILD

  • @theochasid8996
    @theochasid8996 6 лет назад +242

    Royal Drama sounds like a bunch of terrible people doing terrible things to each other. o0 So weird.

    • @SA2004YG
      @SA2004YG 6 лет назад +17

      Because the nice ones either get killed off or swept to the side

    • @wareagle4206
      @wareagle4206 4 года назад

      Most of the time that is not always though Catherine is a good example

    • @Kaiserboo1871
      @Kaiserboo1871 3 года назад +1

      @@SA2004YG Royal courts were some of the most Darwinian state institutions in history where in many cases losing favor meant death.

  • @CanterlotCrusader
    @CanterlotCrusader 8 лет назад +42

    Damn, her mom was such a spoiled brat. But even poor beginnings can leave a lasting legacy, looking forward to more!

  • @TerrierMartello
    @TerrierMartello 4 года назад +5

    This has been on my RUclips recommendation for 6 months, you win RUclips, ok, you win!

  • @runningarctic301
    @runningarctic301 8 лет назад +41

    Can I just say that you have had a perfect track record for answering every question I have ever thought of? I legitimately enjoy all of your videos.

    • @extrahistory
      @extrahistory  8 лет назад +29

      We try our best to have a suspiciously perfect track record with you.... er, it's not suspicious at all!
      Seriously though, thanks for the love!

  • @itschichi2211
    @itschichi2211 4 года назад +260

    Who else just finished watching "The Great" on Hulu?

    • @kanapotetakerngkeat3506
      @kanapotetakerngkeat3506 4 года назад +2

      ItsChiChi wth is that

    • @itschichi2211
      @itschichi2211 4 года назад +8

      @@kanapotetakerngkeat3506 it's a tv series abt Catherine the Great. Its rly funny.

    • @squiddadoll
      @squiddadoll 4 года назад +10

      Kanapote Takerngkeat It’s a show that’s very inaccurate but still good

    • @kanapotetakerngkeat3506
      @kanapotetakerngkeat3506 4 года назад +1

      Hi There oh ok? Just asking though but it’s kinda like a Mel Gibson type?

    • @saadwaqar3851
      @saadwaqar3851 4 года назад +2

      @@kanapotetakerngkeat3506 it's comedic completely barely and seriousness

  • @bigj1905
    @bigj1905 3 года назад +48

    Too think that the two greatest monarchs of the late 18th century only met once, and when Cathrine was a child no less, is shocking to me.

  • @TurlasThe6
    @TurlasThe6 8 лет назад +131

    Psst, guys...the video is amazing, but...double check the description before tomorrow. ;)
    Looks like another great series! :D

    • @extrahistory
      @extrahistory  8 лет назад +22

      No worries, just a placeholder! I don't always update the full video for early access. Thanks for looking out for us, though.

    • @Raspoutable
      @Raspoutable 8 лет назад +4

      Shh. Pretend it's someting good...

    • @MayraCma
      @MayraCma 8 лет назад +4

      scyx what? sorry, maybe they already made a correction, or maybe i just don't see what's wrong. could you pls tell me?

    • @evan7337
      @evan7337 8 лет назад +3

      What was it?

  • @inakiaraquistain5731
    @inakiaraquistain5731 6 лет назад +9

    What a beautiful story! It's like a fairytale.

  • @TheIbney00
    @TheIbney00 8 лет назад +294

    No but seriously. Fredrick the Great series when?

    • @ThePublicDominion
      @ThePublicDominion 8 лет назад +11

      And as long as we're on the subject of monarchs nicknamed, "The Great," a series on Alfred the Great would also be awesome.

    • @MalaysianChopsticks
      @MalaysianChopsticks 6 лет назад +4

      Have you tried Kings and Generals? They just started a series for Frederick the Great.

    • @qwertyzxcvbn6929
      @qwertyzxcvbn6929 6 лет назад +2

      WE NEED MORE THE GREAT VIDEOS GODDAMMIT

    • @chizhang2765
      @chizhang2765 6 лет назад

      Can't wait to see EH's take on von Katte!

    • @dizthea4145
      @dizthea4145 6 лет назад

      Hamilton? Is that you?

  • @Konree
    @Konree 8 лет назад +58

    6:53 When you are so desperate in finding wife, that you tell her the Tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise...

  • @Rukai
    @Rukai 3 года назад +7

    My gosh, it's been 4 years already. I don't remember how much I miss this until the algorithm gods sent this video back in my playlist

  • @samleheny1429
    @samleheny1429 8 лет назад +198

    Why when looking at history are there so many sickly heirs? Was it all that keeping the blood "pure"?

    • @hilkmeister1382
      @hilkmeister1382 8 лет назад +27

      Sam Leheny yup they liked keeping it in the family

    • @latersatyr
      @latersatyr 8 лет назад +79

      Inbreeding yes, but also just bad medical knowledge. Many people died in childhood back then.

    • @rambard5599
      @rambard5599 8 лет назад +40

      I don't think the main purpose of the "inbreeding" was to keep the blood pure, but to ensure profitable marriages and connections to other monarchs. In essence, for them a child was an asset, and you don't want to throw away an asset.

    • @baranix3384
      @baranix3384 8 лет назад +6

      And since the royals always had access to the "latest advances in medicine"...

    • @adamthornton7880
      @adamthornton7880 8 лет назад +39

      This is a typical human population before the 19th century:
      Fertility rate: 6-7 children per women
      Population growth rate: close to zero

  • @lilguccigoku6426
    @lilguccigoku6426 6 лет назад +57

    I Can imagine Fredrick the great yelling where the heck is Sofia and then her mom says she has nothing to wear then Fredrick calms down is like my dear sister can u please lend Sofia a dress he just go 0 -100 real quick mad and then just calms down

    • @MURPHYCHACHO
      @MURPHYCHACHO Год назад +1

      I'm just picturing Fredrick letting out a massive exasperated sigh and then turning to his sister like:
      "Wilhelmina?"
      "I'm on it."

  • @jadehulse9535
    @jadehulse9535 6 лет назад

    When I was in school, I didn't like history classes much. Not that I didn't like history itself, because I loved documentaries and other media based on history. I figured out the way I was taught was not usually engaging enough or there were simply too many people being talked about and I had no visual representation of them. I discovered these Extra History videos a few days ago from the Genghis Khan series, and it was the first time I had ever learned about him! To go from knowing "Genghis Khan was this historic guy from Mongolia or whatever" to being able to comprehend his entire life's story in about an hour was great! Thank you so much for these videos! They make me want to seek out more interesting ways to self-study history lessons I missed when I was younger.

  • @saundramadespecial8056
    @saundramadespecial8056 6 лет назад +4

    This was so good I watch all of them I forgot I was even learning about history, I mean that in a good way. This was so informative and yet so fun to watch, I loved this, keep doing what you're doing and enjoy the process! Love you're vids!

  • @daggerdan12
    @daggerdan12 8 лет назад +23

    This looks like it's gonna be an interesting one. I love historical court intrigue.

  • @As_Silent_As_Forest
    @As_Silent_As_Forest 6 лет назад +65

    Well, but the capital of Russia was Saint-Petersburg, not Moscow

    • @restezlameme
      @restezlameme 6 лет назад +19

      I'm pretty sure that during that time, while Saint Petersburg was considered the "official" capital, it still wasn't a favorite among the noble elite. The ruling classes preferred Moscow as the cultural and religious center of Russia. (I read this in Massey's biography of Catherine the Great.)

  • @NonApplicable1983
    @NonApplicable1983 8 лет назад +11

    Woo! Fritz, my man! I hope we get to see more of him! Don't get me wrong, I'm also excited about Catherine but I just love Frederick so much.

  • @frogfireFantasy
    @frogfireFantasy 8 лет назад +13

    Omg I totally want to hug Sophia!!!!

    • @rileyrose5166
      @rileyrose5166 8 лет назад +1

      ? I don't see what's so cringy. ur just being dumb lol

    • @rileyrose5166
      @rileyrose5166 8 лет назад +1

      So? let them. It's not hurting anyone, if they're young (which they probably are), let them have fun instead of laughing at them. Hell, if they ARE young, then you're making fun of a CHILD. do you realize how pathetic that is?

    • @CSGhostAnimation
      @CSGhostAnimation 7 месяцев назад

      Oh wow no way, cool seeing a familiar face lol

  • @monroerobbins7551
    @monroerobbins7551 6 лет назад +3

    This was talked about in my history class, and one kid summed up Sophia and Fredrick’s chatter to ‘nerds being nerds.’ That was just funny to me.

  • @chickensangwich97
    @chickensangwich97 8 лет назад +8

    As someone who knows nothing about pre-Soviet Russian history, "Count Bestushev" is a fantastic villain name.

  • @lithop256
    @lithop256 6 лет назад +166

    You should have called it "Catherine the ok" for this video, "the alright", then the great for the next one

    • @Shadow-gc6le
      @Shadow-gc6le 5 лет назад +18

      What do you think this is? Overlysarcastic productions?

    • @MexiSword
      @MexiSword 5 лет назад +7

      "Some of us are trying to nail Catharine the Great.... Or should I say Catharine the So-so." --JKF

    • @mr.mirage3986
      @mr.mirage3986 3 года назад +2

      _"Historic titles don't exist."_
      -The country of Myanmar

  • @josephmariani732
    @josephmariani732 4 года назад +3

    This is my favorite Extra History series!

  • @Costin_Gaming
    @Costin_Gaming 8 лет назад +8

    You gotta give Friedrick the Great a round of applause of reaching out to Catherine the Great even before she was wed.
    That boys and girls is REAL politics.

  • @roykennedy
    @roykennedy 6 лет назад +164

    Fun Fact: What catherine said in latin was just placeholder latin text as Lorem Ipsum is basically a fake latin word to make you seem smart

    • @zayyanabbas4958
      @zayyanabbas4958 6 лет назад

      Wasn't it a secret language developed by Da Vinci, where no one could find the meaning, so they just used it as placeholder text?

    • @irrelevant_noob
      @irrelevant_noob 6 лет назад +3

      roy kennedy it's not quite "fake" fake, it's a tweaked version of a 1st-century BC real-Latin text by Cicero. :-B

  • @laceystar4759
    @laceystar4759 6 лет назад

    Whenever I come to this channel this series about Cathrine the Great is something I always watch. I love listening to how you explain the history of many people.

  • @KumaKaori
    @KumaKaori 8 лет назад +7

    Almost spit-took the milk foam of my latte at Sophie's Lorem Ipsum. THANKS EC. XD.
    The ill fit of Sophie's dress comes across wonderfully. Huge Props to y'alls Artist!

    • @fictionfan0
      @fictionfan0 8 лет назад

      Should I even ask what that means?

    • @KumaKaori
      @KumaKaori 8 лет назад +2

      Lorem Ipsum? Sure, from wikipedia -- "In publishing and graphic design, lorem ipsum (derived from Latin dolorem ipsum, translated as "pain itself") is a filler text commonly used to demonstrate the graphic elements of a document or visual presentation. Replacing meaningful content with placeholder text allows designers to design the form of the content before the content itself has been produced."
      tl:dr; Filler Text, often used in publishing/graphic design. Latin in origin.

  • @AndyG94
    @AndyG94 8 лет назад +115

    Hmm, the ill treatment from her mother explains A LOT of Catherine's future relationship with her own offspring...

  • @mediocreman6323
    @mediocreman6323 5 лет назад +5

    2:11 - these drawings really made me laugh :-D Great job on the art work, as usual :-)

  • @ChrisKrunchy
    @ChrisKrunchy 6 лет назад +77

    They went to Petersburg not Moscow...

    • @kamanashiskar9203
      @kamanashiskar9203 3 года назад +1

      Yes. In 1721, Emperor Peter I of the Russian Empire founded St. Petersburg as the capital of the Empire.

  • @aarynminyard6446
    @aarynminyard6446 8 лет назад +7

    Frederick the Great needs a full series. He is bae.

  • @AgarthasKnightCrusader
    @AgarthasKnightCrusader 2 года назад

    Hey dude! Thanks for these AMAZING history. This really helped me out with my History homework. I may or not used 4 pictures were Friedrich the Great and Catherine the Great talking 6:50 start end 6:53. But these really helped me out Thanks and your Content is AMAZING!

  • @UnprofessionalProfessor
    @UnprofessionalProfessor 5 лет назад +3

    History is a million times more entertaining than fiction.

  • @breezv
    @breezv 6 лет назад +3

    this was just randomly in my recommended, and i am SO EMOTIONALLY INVESTED

  • @izzyfloof1083
    @izzyfloof1083 4 года назад +1

    The only person that can get me to enjoy learning about 17th century aristocracy

  • @willrogers3793
    @willrogers3793 6 лет назад +18

    I’m kind of surprised at how much I like Freddy, even though I know very little about him. But considering that many nobles from what would become Germany had done their absolute best to be the stereotype of “nobility purely of the flesh, with none of the spirit” just a century before (Dat 30 Years War, tho. Feels bad, man.), it’s kind of remarkable that someone as well-liked and respected as Frederick managed to emerge from the same lineage.
    Srsly tho, I need to learn more about him so I can justify having him share “favorite king” status with Gustav Adolf II of Sweden.

  • @CoachJohnMcGuirk
    @CoachJohnMcGuirk 8 лет назад +6

    I just wanted you guys to know that this is my favorite content in the world. not just on the medium of youtube, but in general. from the bottom of my heart, thank you for making these. I plan on supporting the channel when I get my tax refund!

  • @zairusan7344
    @zairusan7344 2 года назад

    Whenever I get overwhelmed with life, this channel has been my go-to channel to calm my nerves a bit. And this video has been by far my favorite. Thank you, EC 🥰

  • @myohmy9000
    @myohmy9000 8 лет назад +103

    And we all know who arranged this meeting with Catherine and Fredrick, Walpole

    • @mxsdrago
      @mxsdrago 8 лет назад +9

      Chris Ramsey goddamnit

    • @hilkmeister1382
      @hilkmeister1382 8 лет назад +12

      Chris Ramsey I think this 6 degrees of Walpole has gotten out of hand

    • @based_prophet
      @based_prophet 8 лет назад +1

      Chris Ramsey fuck u mate

    • @drosso4956
      @drosso4956 7 лет назад +1

      Bebop The Robot calm down mate jeez

  • @catesmommy2006
    @catesmommy2006 6 лет назад +17

    I am proud to say my name is Catherine!! =D

    • @moutan100
      @moutan100 6 лет назад +4

      But Her name is sophie not catherine

    • @warriorcat4301
      @warriorcat4301 6 лет назад

      She maybe named Sophie but she is also named Catherine.

    • @moutan100
      @moutan100 6 лет назад

      Idk ,something is wrong here. her real name is Sophie as I know not Catherine sorry.

  • @Dedelblute3
    @Dedelblute3 5 месяцев назад

    It’s honestly pretty cool to see you reminding people of older series through Shorts. It also shows that EH videos are pretty timeless, still being just as good as ones years more recent.

  • @maskmaster8898
    @maskmaster8898 8 лет назад +12

    I'm having flashbacks to the epic rap battle of history between Alexander the Great and Ivan the Terrible.

  • @joshbray5036
    @joshbray5036 5 лет назад +19

    Lmao
    What if HBO used Extra Credits as their source for their show "Catherine the Great"?