ASK THE ARTIST: Who Is The Best Drummer In Metal? | Metal Injection
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- We ask members of Anthrax, Motorsister, Dethklok, Meshuggah, Honeybee, and Incite who the best drummer in metal is!
---------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe to Metal Injection on RUclips: bit.ly/ZhpTbA
FOLLOW US:
/ metalinjection
/ metalinjection
/ metalinjection
metalinjection.net
Eloy Casagrande, Matt Garstka, Mario Duplantier and Tomas Haake are definetely on my top. These guys are the peak of drumming for me.
Baard Kolstad is also amazing, if you haven't checked him out.
you forgot Matt Halpern
@@MassholeDrums Periphery is my favorite band, I love Matt but I don't think he is necesseraly as good as all of these guys I mentioned, I feel like he holds back a little bit.
@@feliperibeiro463 that doesn't mean he's not better but i think you need to listen to P1 more because that album shows his true potential while a lot of their newer stuff i get why youd say "holding back". He can play everything they can but not necessarily vice versa. Matt's tasteful understated playing is probably why he's so underrated but p1 stands up with any album drumming wise.
Matt makes it look what he's doing much easier than it is.
Eloy is sick. I need to hear more of his stuff. Halpern, Jay Postones, and Chris Allison all belong on any list of great metal drummers. I'd take em all over the rest anyday, but especially halpern.
Guys don't forget, like he said it's HIS top stop with the "you forgot this one" thing, everyone has his own favorites
So glad that Gene immediately says Bill Ward. That man doesn't get nearly enough credit for his role in the history of drumming. Such an amazing feel.
you got that right
Genes too humble to say himself
Tomas Haake is just unreal. He gets my vote.
Yeah Tomas haake for sure
Tomas Haake, Chris Pennie, Sean Reinert. These guys created new ways of playing Metal.
Elliot Hoffman?
YES to Sean! All 3 are great.
You. Nailed. It.
I'd add Ken Schalk though.
The holy trinity of the best of the best:
Mario Duplantier, Thomas Haake, Danny Carrey
Not ranked in order. They are all the best
Im with you ...
Replace Carrey with Eloy Casagrande and now we’re talking.
1. Tomas
2. Mario
3. Eloy
@@iambrsmith Can we replace someone with *Chris Adler* ❓ 🤔
The band Haake mentions is C.B Murdoc and the drummer is Carl Bäckström
Thanks for giving his name, I have to check him out.
Carl is an absolutely superb drummer. His syncopation on CB Murdoc is mind boggling and his drums on Sectu just blistering
I feel like Richard Christy doesn’t get the credit he deserves. Such a monster on drums.
Yo his drumming on The Sound of Perseverance was crazy
Richard is a ducking mutant
I didn't think anyone could step-in and fill the shoes of Hoglan, but Christy did an amazing job.
Yup and he smoked dream theater's drummer at that drum event.
Totally agree
Tomas Haake is the correct answer.
A. The guy from Meshuggah B. The guy that plays bleed C. The polyrhythms master D. Thomas
True
Absolutely
Gene hoglan
@@Spiritcr1jsher Gene is a legend, but he’s not that great of a drummer compared to others.
I'd say Gene Hoglan. Just look at all bands he was in and the amazing drumming he did in all of them. Dark Angel, Death, Fear Factory, Strapping Young Lad, Testament, Dethlok just to name the big ones I can think of off hand.
One of Gene's lesser known projects was called The Almighty Punchdrunk. The album is on RUclips.
@@the6ig6adwolf Big thanks! Had not heard of them before, and they sound right up my alley!
I'd say Gene Hoglan for Death Metal and Hellhammer for Black Metal, the body of work of Hellhammer speaks for itself also.
Mike Smith of Suffocation, Dave Lombardo of Slayer, and bill Ward of sabbath.
Sean Reinert, Gene Hoglan, Gar Samuelson and Alex Rüdinger
Elliot Hoffman?
I though that after naming Sean, that some more good taste in drummers would follow. I was very wrong.
Tomas Haake
Morgan Agren
Elliot Hoffman
Matt Gartska
Toby Wright
Alex Rudinger
Abe Cunningham
probably the best list in here. Only missing Sebastian Lanser and Travis Orbin.
I’ve always said Gar Samuelson’s work on the Peace Sells album is the greatest metal drumming performance of all time. Amazing feel, technique and groove. Like Buddy Rich plays metal! And all done pre Pro-Tools!
Gar Samuelson has always been one of my favorite drummers. He sounds great on Peace Sells but his speed and technicality on Killing is my business.. is pure insanity. RIP Gar 🥁
I likes Gar..but he was not in the ballpark of Gene and Richard.I agree though style, and taste is more important than techinical ability
@@jasondixon6760 Richard Christy & Gene are both excellent but I do believe Richard is a bit smoother behind the kit. I've heard Gene mess up a few times live & even on records. In my opinion "the atomic clock" is a bit overrated. No drummers are perfect and Gene is a fuckin beast. Out of the Death drummers I think Richard was the best, Sean Reinert was 2nd & Gene Hoglan was 3rd.
By far not
@@kayvan671 i Agree i think it would be Sean..Gene ...Richard.I commend Richard for over reaching the entire time and having the balls to do it.Now i by no means mean myself or much people coukd play most he left on tracks...Sone of it sounds confusing and doesnt fit.It happens frequently on sound
100% agree with Gandalf. Speak friend and enter
XD XD XD
When your nicknames are "The Atomic Clock" and "The human drum machine" you're one of the best. Add to that the fact that he plays the way he does wearing ankle weights and combat boots, Gene Hoglan takes it for me.
Uncle Gene is always so cool and modest.. lots of knowledge in his response.. Besides he is on my top 3 as well.
My personal faves in no particular order: Ian Paice, Dave Lombardo, Eloy Casagrande, Tomas Haake, George Kollias, Trym, Nick Barker, Gene Hoglan
... special mentions for various reasons outside metal: Jet Black (The Stranglers), Boris Williams (The Cure), Evelyn Glennie, Louie Bellson & Simon Phillips 👍
Elliot Hoffman definitely needs to be mentioned.
HELL YES. I would put Elliot up against any drummer in the genre. He's criminally underrated, as are Carbomb.
I must say Thomas Haake is very humble and kind soul, for being one of the best drummers in metal to mention all those others and not himself, what a guy and he got the atomic clock's name in there. m these are my two votes and Gene(Atomic Clock) Hoglan is an insanely impossible-to-imitate drumming god and such a good soul, to mention Bill Ward, one of the most underrated and not mentioned a lot. like i said my two no three top votes
I'm so glad one of my GOAT's (Gene Hoglan) said my all time GOAT (Bill Ward)
Dirk Verbeuren, Tomas Haake, Mario Duplantier, and lastly Neil Peart, cause he's your favorite drummers favorite drummer, even outside of metal, major influence on any scene of music
Ummm
@@Red-Brick-Dream you're so cool. I wish I could be like you
Imagine namedropping neil peart in 2022
I would put Tomas Haake up against anyone in Metal. After the drum cam video of Clockworks and my lifelong pursuit of trying to learn Bleed, I can’t think of anyone I’d rather pick.
Same here but very disappointed meg white isn't there.i know she's not metal but still
Still Thomas Haake himself claims someone else to the the best. I think Thomas is the closest to the real answer. It’s impossible to name THE best drummer in metal since there are so many and very few get to show their full ability when playing, since a good drummer only does what he need to do for the music he is playing. If Thomas himself would name a drummer in general, not just a metal drummer, I’m sure his jazz drumming friend Morgan Ågren world be up there. That’s also who I would name to the the best drummer I’ve ever seen.
Ever heard of Jamie Saint Merat from Ulcerate? I personaly prefer his drumming over Haake.
Correct
@@bhic4wow finally someone here with some wisdom. Jamie is easily the BEST BEST in metal. Dude has mastered the style from every angle.
Brann Dailor is a good name for a list like this too
Super underrated drummer
Gene Hoglan with Phantasm!! Back in the day!!
kenny grohowski clears most of the guys people are saying people need to pay more attention to him
yep. to be fair, some of these names were surely influential on him (though I think he said Thomas Haake and Chris Penney were the metal drummers who really took him into heavy music), but I think he's an easy choice for "best" in the sense of not just being technically amazing, but super well-rounded and musical - the guy can play basically anything.
My favorites Lombardo, Steve Asheim, Donald Tardy, Nicko Mcbrain , Hoglan, and Richard Chrisy because I was listening to Sounds of Perserverance earlier today, I had to add that in
Gene is probably the most wholesome person in metal. He's also an absolute beast behind the kit.
You know how the Powerpuff Girls were made out of sugar, spice and everything nice?
Well, the ultimate metal drummer is made out of Chris Adler's hands, Tomas Haake's feet, Bran Dailor's fills and chemical X is Gene Hoglan.
I believe that makes Seth Davis
Tomas Haake brought about a huge transformation in metal drumming. His playing was a game changer, a crucial reference for modern drummers. It's comparable to what Sean Reinert did with "Human" back then.
Dan Presland from Ne Obliviscaris. 🤯
Sebastian lanser, Brody Taylor smith, ash Pearson are prolly my top 3, mainly stylistically, the way they play just feels good. Menza got me into drums for real tho.
Mario Duplantier and Tomas Haake are the best in my opinion. Bill Ward and Mitch Mitchell come to mind from the old days.
Bill ward70s,Dave Lombardo 80s,Gene hoglan 90s,Hellhammer 00s.
Alex Bent, Matt Garstka, Navene Koperweis, Mario Duplantier damn there are so many monsters :)
Gar Samuelson
That shout-out to Bill Ward!!
Trey Williams
Tomas Haake.. what a humble dude and amazing drummer. I agree Bill Ward is the Godfather. I can't pick just one.
Tomas Haake
John Longstreth, David Diepold, Kevin Paradis, Sébastien Lancer.
Watching Haake like... um, no YOU'RE the guy. lol
There's a lot of great drummers in metal, but Spencer Prewett from Archspire is my personal favorite drummer.
Spencer is the gold standard for tech metal, man is insane.
@@psychotictactoe Definitely!
thats fair. In terms of straight technical ability I would say Thomas Haake is better, but its close
Tomas Haake is a genious of groove and detail. He can't play as fast as some others not anymore anyway but he does so many things at the same time with the kit that it's mindblowing to watch.
The three most influential drummers for me were Sean Reinart, Gene Hoglan, and Alex Marquez. I feel like these guys were doing things that nobody else was and that current metal drumming monsters would not exist had it not been for their influence
It was so cool to hear Thomas Haake pull out Kenny G as his first name! I've been a huge fan of Kenny since he first started playing with Secret Chiefs 3 and they guy is such a master and sooooo versatile. coming from jazz and latin music gave him an edge in musicality that when he discovered metal (quite late, apparently) he carried through. he's so, so good on the kit, and one of the nicest and most humble guys. he deserves a lot of attention but don't stop as Imperial Triumphant, and don't miss the HOLY VEHM when it finally comes!
I went to school with the drummer Tomas Haake mentions "Calle Bäckström" in CB murdock, and he was INSANE in school, like unique... and i can just imagen he got better, if you have never seen him drum, you should.
Impossible to name just 1. But top 5 has to be Gene Hoglan, Tomas Haake, Danny Carey, Dave Lombardo, Nils Dominator
For me the all timers are
Eloy casagrande, Sean reinert, Tomas haake, kai hahto, mario duplantier, matt Garstka, gene hoglan, Vitek from decapitated
for sure mario duplantier
Garstka beats them all, may not have the blast beats but technically he is a monster!
Marco Minneman would be another worthy mention.
@@hyetrwesmelvin8167garstka beats them all in terms of “regular” drumming but he’s barely a metal drummer. He’s a gospel drummer playing with a metal band. No shade though, he’s a monster for sure.
What about Mike Portnoy?!)
Take it from our drummer Puff.
Being good it gets you stuff.
Lars Ulrich of course!
Lmao
These 2 gents for a start followed by MARIO
thomas haake...hes just humble
Humble is the best way to act
Gene Hogland, Raymond Herrera, Dave Lombardo, anyone in Opeth.
Eloy Casagrande
Rings Starr did that one really sick drum fill/solo in that one song.
Def Benante for early metal!!
My favorites are Darkside, George Kollias, Nils Fjellström, Faust and Hellhammer 🤘
Trym from Emperor is pretty sick too.
Derek Roddy
Darkside is awesome
Finally some love for the black metal drummers... Americans simply aren't into BM for some reason...
I’m not saying he’s the absolute best but one of my favorite drummers is Steve Shelton from Confessor. He’s definitely worth checking out.
Yes yes and yes. Insanely underrated
Just checked, tasty fills man whew
I rehearse next-door to Steve. What a MONSTER he is!
Hell yeah! He's awesome! Isn't he drumming for Loincloth too? That's a great band also.
Pete Webber from Havok
Eloy Casagrande and it's not even close. Greetings from FR!
Carey, Ward, Tommy A, Cozy Powell…I love Vinnie Appice’s feel.
Oh and of course , my washing machine on fast spin !
I’m the best drummer.
Alex bent trivium. They guy has brought so much to the band and the way he plays with such intensity but at the same time looking so effortless.
The dude is in cruise control evetytime I watch him lol. Too many attributes to mention!!
I love Trivium but I feel like Alex is too talented for his own good like he will just throw down a blast on stuff that doesnt need it sometimes
Hell no LOL he's not even Triviums best drummer. Travis was much better
@@Goose21 which means he's not actually a good drummer lol
Bill ward
Mario Duplantier!
I can’t believe that they didn’t mention Vinnie Paul !!!
Charlie Benante
Dave Lombardo
Gene hoglan
Tom hunting, just to name a few
I love how Gene Hoglan, the best drummer in metal, is in this video.
Mr Vinnie Paul himself. Taking into consideration that he also created a lot of those classic pantera songs. Him and Dime were musical genius. And I'm biased for anything that comes out of my city.
Edit: Dallas Texas. RIP Abbott brothers. Heavy metal misses you
They came from MY city! Arlington.
Will Farrell from red hot chili peppers. Or Bill Burr from meshuggah
Pete Sandoval .
dayum, how's pete sandoval NOT mentioned 😒
Tomas Haake, Aaron Kitcher, Gene Hoglan, Mario Duplantier, Marco Minnemann.
How do you unironically put Aaron Kitcher in a list with ACTUAL great drummers?
Seriously, though…Kenny is insane. And he plays all of that intricate music IN A MASK! Just watch him play ONE song live and I promise you’ll be blown away.
Darkside is sick too and plays with a mask as well!
@@dftns no. He’s not even close to Kenny, if you think he is even remotely close to Kenny, then you don’t know why Kenny is good. Lol.
I get to see them next month! 🤘🏼👊🏼
Atomic Age playthrough, I watch it so often. He's such a sick drummer \m/
If your band inspires tool, you know the answer must be Tomas haake of meshuggah.
Tomas Haake and Joey Jordison 👍👍👍
Alex Rudinger
Chris Turner
Matt Garstka
Danny Walker
John Merryman
Chris Pennie
Sean Reinert
Thomas Haake
Ken Schalk
Blake Richardson
Flo Mouiner
Mario Duplantier
Matt Halpern
James Stewart
Navene Koperweis
Aric importa
Blake Richardson to me maybe
Some of The best in metal
Gene Hoglan, Nick Barker, Ken Bedene, John Longstreth, Vinnie Paul, Jalomah, Tomas Haake, Jorg Michael, Inferno, James Payne, Dominator, Daray, Sean Reinert, George Kollias
It's Ringo...JK. The Double-bassinator from Get In The Flask. Hands down.
For me it’s spencer prewett from archspire.
John Longstreth
Sean Cynic,Pete Sandoval,Gene Holgan,Buddy Rich then Flo from Cryptopsy in 96 then of course the machine himself John damn Longstreth in 2002 informis
Blake Richardson says hello!
For my money Vinnie Paul was in a league of his own. The man could play any genre of music and was such a beast behind the kit. Rest In Peace Brick Wall!! 🤘
Vinnie was the perfect drummer for Dime, they clicked into something that couldn't be replicated
I completely agree, Vinnie Paul and Dimebag on the same stage or studio was just something that was a perfect match.
I found Vinnie to be very overrated
@@Nall412 me too, never blown away by his playing like i have been with so many others
@@danielweissel2366 yea. I mean no disrespect er anything. Obviously he knew what he was doing. I just find alota ppl hype him up
What about Thomas haake??
Sebastian Lanser, David Diepold, Simon Schilling, Bobby Jarzombek, Tomas Haake, Eloy Casagrande...
not many people will agree with me but my top drummers would be trym torson, inferno and kai hahto. i wouldnt call them the best most technical drummers out there but they are my favorite
Shannon Lucas
Ken Owen - Carcass
Jamie Saint Merat deserves a mention.
Sean Reinert!
i agree with Gene
Jamie Saint Merat of Ulcerate
Vlad should be mentioned
Chris Turner of Oceans Ate Alaska, Austin Archey of Lorna Shore, Jimmy Pino of Signs of the Swarm, Matt Greiner of August Burns Red and David McGraw of Cattle Decapitation
Bill is the GOAT... simples
Respect & Peace
🤘
Ward, hoglan, haake... Those are my faves